We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan Delivery

Business of Joint Committee

Summary

The committee accepted Glenveagh’s invitation to visit its Carlow factory on 7 December and noted or agreed to publish departmental correspondence. Members unanimously condemned inadequate and delayed responses on the Midlands hospice and Birr water treatment plant, called for the agencies to return, and raised concerns about accountability and the credibility of National Development Plan cost estimates.

Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

There are two items of correspondence for today’s meeting. The first concerns the Glenveagh Homebuilding Horizons 2026 Report and the invitation to visit the NUA Manufacturing factory in Carlow. The email was circulated. It was originally received from Kevin Dillon of Glenveagh Properties, who issued an invitation to the committee. We have been in contact with him about the appropriate date. The committee secretariat has been in contact with the company to arrange a visit and it has proposed Monday, 7 December 2026. We have no start time but a morning to midday start is likely. It will take place in Carlow town.

Comment on this

What is the date?

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

It is Monday, 7 December. It will be in the morning. I take it that we will agree to accept that invitation because we went looking for it. That is the suitable date, which is good. The company wants to assemble the appropriate people to be on site to meet us. That is the date. We will agree with that.

Moving to the next item, we have received a letter from the Department regarding Uisce Éireann and the further information sought by Deputy Clendennen on Birr water treatment plant. The letter was from Mr. Towey, the assistant secretary of the Department. It was agreed at the last meeting that the information provided was unsatisfactory. It was also agreed to seek a substantial supplementary response from Uisce Éireann addressing the six specific matters that had been mentioned. They have been circulated. I propose that we note that correspondence and members will be free to use the documentation. They have all received it. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Item No. 62 is follow-up correspondence from the Department of Health. The email was from Fiona Kelly, private secretary to the Secretary General, and it follows on the Department’s response to the 16 questions raised during the committee meeting. The different tables were also attached, including the number of completions in 2025, the 2025 national programme and the 2026 national development plan project. Do members wish to discuss this correspondence, or will we note it, publish it and people will be free to use the documentation? We will note and publish that correspondence.

Did someone indicate to speak at this early stage?

Comment on this

No. I was seeking to get my name in early for the next section.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Okay. The Deputy will get his chance. Two other Deputies are indicating.

Comment on this

In fairness, the three boys were here first.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Okay. We will work down the line-----

Comment on this

Bhí mise anseo-----

Comment on this

Deputy Clendennen was in before me and the two boys were-----

Comment on this

-----ar dtús. The early worm.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Before we move to the next item on the agenda, we will suspend briefly-----

Comment on this

Sorry, Chair. I want to come in on the correspondence and the inadequacy of the responses. That is probably the best way to put it. I clearly outlined, both to the HSE and Uisce Éireann, the specific answers I sought on the different projects I raised and they have not been forthcoming.

The midlands hospice is a particular example in this regard. I asked when a shovel would be in the ground. At the time, I also asked about the value engineering exercise. I was given the impression that it had been completed and a sum of €40 million and a shortfall of €12 million were identified. However, looking at the correspondence received, it says that as such, a value engineering exercise is currently being undertaken on the project to reduce costs in line with the budget expectations. That does not fit with the response we received from the witnesses on the day. It goes on to say that it would be premature, at this time, to confirm a constructive commencement date until the value engineering exercise has been completed. We have no indication as to when that is going to be completed. We are just supposed to let this float into the ether and pick it up again in 12 months’ time. That is totally unacceptable.

I am on this committee from the perspective of infrastructure delivery and accountability. I do not feel we are getting the respect we deserve as a committee from some of the witnesses when they come in to answer our questions. I understood that there was a two-week standing order process in relation to responses. This response took four or five weeks to come back. I am a little bit frustrated as to how the work of this committee is being treated. We need to send a message to all witnesses that we are serious about delivery and that we need them to be too. There is an emergency when it comes housing and capital infrastructure development across health, education, transport and every other public sector area. I do not get the same sense of urgency that we are bringing to the table when it takes a delayed timeframe to get a response. When we get a response, it is basically buying time. That is not the purpose of this committee.

Comment on this

I support my colleague, Deputy Clendennen, on that. To be honest, it is completely ridiculous that such a reply has been sent back, considering what was said here on the day. It is inadequate to go back and remodel what has already been designed to fit the €24.5 million already ring-fenced for the project. When the initial plans came out with regard to the hospice on the site on Arden Lane, there was no talk even at that stage about having to pay for a road. The road is an extra €2.5 million. The longer we leave this, the more it is going to cost because building inflation is not going to stop. It is going to ratchet up higher and higher. It is probably going to increase in speed over the next 12 months, considering what is happening on the world stage. We should go back to the HSE straight away and request that it comes back to us with proper information, instead of what looks to me to be just a fudge to try to quieten us down so that it can carry on. To be totally honest, the HSE’s performance that day was absolutely disgraceful. They are the people in charge of billions of euro regarding the infrastructure for the HSE. It is a joke. We are in an awful place if that is who is looking after the money for our infrastructure.

With regard to Uisce Éireann and the response it provided, it has already spent money on the project in Birr but came back to us with a wishy-washy answer. Its witnesses gave us more information on the day they were before the committee. What Uisce Éireann has come back with is worse. We need to go back to it as well to say we are not prepared to take that as answer and we want a follow-up on it.

Comment on this

We need to invite both groups back to the committee. If we are going to be serious about this, and if we are going to receive inadequate and insufficient responses, we will just have to bring them back in.

Comment on this

I support the contributions of my colleagues. Ultimately, the word “delivery” is in both the title of this committee and is its remit. If the view of committee members and colleagues, which I agree with, is that there is not sufficient delivery being driven by the people who we are entrusting with the execution of billions of euro of taxpayers’ money, then I will support and second the call for them to be brought back before the committee. It should be made very clear what the committee’s standing orders are and the level of respect we would appreciate being afforded.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

There is a unanimous view on that. We had asked specifically about delivery, including what was done last year and what will be done by 31 December 2026 and each subsequent year. From listening to the witnesses who have been referred to, my concern is that we could get to the end of the national development plan with only 40%, 50% or 60% of it implemented. Who knows how much will be implemented? Our job is to get to the bottom of that because it is a wish list. That is all it is in a lot of cases.

Comment on this

It is also not value for money for the taxpayer. What is happening in a lot of cases is that a project gets to a certain stage at a cost of millions of euro - it could cost €50 or €60 million for a small project and more for a larger project - and then it is just dropped.

The public are getting no value whatsoever for it.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

A question we have not addressed yet is how the figure was put in the national development plan as an estimate in the first place. None of us have ever seen anything coming in below the estimate. We will be told two thirds of the way along that an estimate of the final cost cannot be given until the final tender is received and a contract appointed, and that is four years down the road in a lot of cases. Regarding the mechanism of where these figures came from, I think we have to-----

Comment on this

Nobody is held accountable, and that is a huge problem.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Yes. I also suggest, although we will not decide this today, that we need to invite in the senior officials from the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation to see if they stand over the figures, whether they are realistic and the basis on which they were calculated.

The figures may have been based on 2024 costs, even though it was well known the project will not be finished for ten years, in some cases. That means the cost estimate is meaningless. Some of the figures we have got so far are meaningless, and our job is to get on top of that. I would prefer to know we are delivering 60% of projects within the timescale and that the remainder will be delivered whenever down the road. More projects are included than can ever be completed within the timescale of the national development plan, NDP, period.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Sean Fleming An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We will suspend for a moment while we bring in our witnesses.

Comment on this