We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Justice and Equality

Access to Justice and Legal Costs: Discussion (Resumed)

Contributions 159–336 of 336. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Fergal O'Leary

It is difficult to find out who is operating in the market. With any competition assessment we do, we would normally start out by assessing what is the concentration level in a particular market, who is operating year-on-year and who is coming into or leaving the market here. It is difficult to find that data for this market on its own so the analysis we do subsequent to that is made more difficult.

Comment on this

The analysis will be very limited if the CCPC does not have the data.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal O'Leary

That is correct. The crux of this matter is how much time we spend trying to collect data versus making recommendations on which the Government and the State can act. As I said, we are in the middle of the study at the moment and our resources are going towards trying to figure out that key part of getting enough evidence while not spending too much time on it. While I say this in a way that is not critical of the Central Bank, it is about three and a half years since the cost of insurance working group started and the report was published this week. I do not think anybody wants us to be a year or two working on this public liability insurance study.

Comment on this

Did the CCPC consider publishing an interim report highlighting the difficulties it has in collecting data?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal O'Leary

We did not. The issues around transparency are already accepted. As our colleagues from Insurance Ireland said, the Central Bank plans to publish data on public liability next year, so I think that point is well accepted. Again, we are not trying to replicate the work that is being done by either the cost of insurance working group or the Personal Injuries Commission. We feel we can do that. We are confident in terms of our ability to look at this market from the point of view of an analysis around theories of harm and to make evidence-based recommendations on that point. However, we do not plan to make an interim report simply because that would slow down the publication of the final report.

Comment on this

The CCPC should perhaps consider doing that if the difficulties continue in regard to collecting data. This would let us know the information. Information belongs to us and it is powerful to have it so we all can be part of the analysis.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal O'Leary

That is accepted and, as a commission, we always keep these things under review. If it looks like the timelines are going too long, we will reconsider that decision.

Comment on this

Of course, we all make comments in the context of insurance difficulties everywhere, including in regard to crèches. On my desk is a reference to the Galway community services which are part of the much lauded Galway 2020. They had a scheme of events and they cannot do it because their insurance literally jumped in one year from €10,000 to €24,000. That happened without explanation and not based on any claims, alleged fraud or anything like that - it was a complete jump. In addition to legal costs, there appear to be many problems in the narrative that is being given as to why premiums are high.

The Legal Services Regulatory Authority has been taking complaints in regard to solicitors and barristers since October.

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

That is correct.

Comment on this

Dr. Doherty has given us the numbers. Has it been difficult in that short while since October to detect trends or to draw conclusions?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

We must produce our first report by 7 April, but even within that short timeframe there are key trends it could outline. As I said earlier, communication is the general theme of the report.

Comment on this

My apologies, I was not here earlier.

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

In effect, where legal practitioners may have failed to properly inform customers in regard to cost and the risk of taking-----

Comment on this

I have read the submission in detail. Does Dr. Doherty have anything further to add?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

Another theme is probate, which seems to be attracting a large number of complaints. We have received complaints in regard to a number of parties who may be putting themselves forward as barristers but who are not on the roll of practising barristers and may be exploiting members of the immigrant community who are very vulnerable. We have also received complaints in regard to the non-payment of barristers. I would caveat all of that with the point that all of this is based on data since 7 October. We will report in full on 7 April.

Comment on this

In regard to the review committee, am I correct that the complaint is made to a board?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

The complaint is made to the authority and processed by authority staff. There are three categories of complaint, including inadequate service, excessive fees and misconduct. The LSRA staff can attempt to informally resolve complaints of inadequate service or excessive fees. There are circumstances in which they can determine those complaints and those determinations can be reviewed by an independent review committee.

Comment on this

What is the role of the authority?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

The authority is involved in establishing the review committee but its decision-making is independent of authority.

Comment on this

Has the review committee been established?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

It will be established early in the new year. It will be comprised of lay members and nominees from the Bar Council of Ireland and the Law Society of Ireland.

Comment on this

How many decisions have been determined by authority staff?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

Under the scheme of the Act we first have to attempt to informally resolve those complaints. The complaints that have been admitted are in the process of being informally resolved. It is only where that resolution process fails that we then move to determination.

Comment on this

Can Dr. Doherty provide us with the number of complaints that have been resolved informally?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

I regret, I cannot. We have had very encouraging engagement from both legal practitioners and complainants such that complaints are being resolved prior to the admissibility decision.

Comment on this

What happens to the complaints that do not come within the remit of the authority? Is it the role of the authority to decide if a complaint is admissible?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

A decision is made as to whether the complaint is admissible under the scheme of the LSRA Act. The complaints that we can informally resolve and determine are those related to inadequate service or excessive costs. Complaints of misconduct are dealt with by the complaints committee but if they are determined to be of a serious nature they are sent to the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal.

Comment on this

It will be interesting to see the report in due course. When will it be published?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

We are required to report every six months. The first report will be published before 7 April.

Comment on this

Will it be a public report?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

Yes.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Doherty.

I will now move to questions to Insurance Ireland. I have read Mr. Hassett's submission in detail. I like to deal in facts. There is an absence of fact generally in the Insurance Ireland submission. Reference is made in the submission to there being a "suspicion" that very often seeking leave to adjourn may be used as lever in negotiation. I do not believe the word "suspicion" should be referenced in a submission. It should be based on facts. I have some questions for Mr. Hassett in regard to the narrative of Insurance Ireland. Does that narrative change following the publication of the Central Bank's report? I agree there are many nuances in the report such that it requires a second reading and that I have read it only once.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Not particularly. There are changes of detail, I will accept that, but we still believe the cost of claims in Ireland are too high and that without structural reform normality will not return to the market.

Comment on this

On what basis does Mr. Hassett believe the cost of claims are too high?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I am not 100% sure of that. We have seen significant inflation in that area in the past number of years. For example, the report from the National Claims Information Database, NCID, shows a drift from €31,000 to an average of €47,000, which is approximately 40%. I am not 100% sure why that is, but I know it seems to be a fact.

Comment on this

In regard to premiums and dual pricing, with which I was not familiar until recently, what direction has Insurance Ireland given in this regard? This is about an existing policyholder being treated differently from a new customer in that the latter can get a cheaper premium. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The Central Bank has instigated a review of dual pricing and the extent of it. Dual pricing is a common practice across many markets. There are positives and negatives to dual pricing. Encouraging people to switch creates value in the market. It is a sign of a healthy market. However, if loyal customers are being penalised for their loyalty then that is a problem.

Comment on this

What has Insurance Ireland done about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

As an industry body, Insurance Ireland does not have a line of sight into the commercial practices of its members. Under competition law, we cannot do that. While I am aware from an anecdotal point of view that this practice is going on I do not have any data around the extent of it or how it is applied in various markets.

Comment on this

Would it not be important to have that data?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I am not allowed to have that data.

Comment on this

The insurance companies can provide the data.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The insurance companies are currently engaged in a review with the Central Bank on sharing that data with the Central Bank. Insurance Ireland is not the appropriate authority to do that.

Comment on this

I understand that, but Mr. Hassett can have an opinion on the matter. He can comment on the absence of data.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

We welcome the Central Bank review but we have no line of sight on the commercial activity of our members.

Comment on this

Okay. In regard to the current European Commission investigation, is it an investigation under the anti-trust legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Yes.

Comment on this

Was Insurance Ireland previously investigated by the European Commission?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I do not believe so.

Comment on this

The current investigation is a first for Insurance Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Yes, I do believe that to be the case.

Comment on this

The Central Bank report is interesting. Mr. Hassett quoted figures from it. It is difficult in the limited time I have available to me to question him on all of those figures. On page 14 of the Central Bank report it states that the average premium per policy was €706 in 2018, which was 42% higher than in 2019. The report provides a breakdown, including a period during which there was falling premiums for a period, followed by increasing premiums, with premiums increasing by 62% between 2013 and 2018. Would Mr. Hassett agree that is a huge increase?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Yes.

Comment on this

Mr. Hassett thinks that is okay?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I do not think it is okay. It is a reflection of several factors. If the Deputy looks at the loss ratios contained in the report she will see the industry sustained significant losses which peaked in 2014. In that period, we had-----

Comment on this

Can Mr. Hassett quote the losses?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Yes. They are set out in graphic form on page 19.

Comment on this

It is page 45.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

There is a table on page 45.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Hassett clarify what is set out on page 45?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Essentially, the long-term loss ratio across the period is 75%. Typically, in addition to that there is 20% related to management expenses and commissions. Taking 2014, where the losses peaked, and one adds the-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

It was 94%. When one adds the management expenses and the commissions at 20%, the 94% increases to 114%.

Comment on this

The highest point was 94%. What was the lowest point?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The lowest point was in 2017 at 59%.

Comment on this

It is cyclical, is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

It is cyclical.

Comment on this

Does the Central Bank acknowledge that?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

It does.

Comment on this

Insurance companies are making very healthy profits. Is that right?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Looking at these numbers, there were profits in 2017 and 2018, with significant losses in some earlier years.

Comment on this

Okay. The premiums did not go down when the profit went up.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

No. As I explained previously, it is not an exact science. A premium is collected in a single year and losses or claims are sustained in future periods. This report is very clear. It is probably much more accurate about earlier years than later years because the claims data for earlier years are much more accurate. We have been able to count up all the claims with the passing of time. We have seen for litigative cases that companies typically reserve four to six years ahead. When a premium is set, one is not always aware of what the claims experience will be. That is why it is cyclical. Sometimes one overshoots and sometimes one undershoots. That is the nature of it.

Comment on this

The plain English on page 18 is very helpful information from the Central Bank. It states:

Between 2009 and 2018, the average annual gross earned premium increased by 42%; the average cost of claims per policy reduced by 2.5% over this time.

To recap on Part 2, 2013 was the lowest point for average premiums over this ten year period, having decreased by 13% from €498 in 2009 to €435 in 2013. Premiums started to increase again in 2013, increasing by 62%

It recaps again for us after that. It is very helpful. What is really jumping out for me is a healthy profit, premiums going up and a narrative that is not reflective, partly because the narrative is not based on fact from anybody, even the no foal, no fee basis. I have a difficulty with the narrative from insurance companies. I was in the Chair in the Dáil lately and heard a narrative about fraud, lying and cases that were not right. Are the figures for fraud not in fact extremely low?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Can I provide some context for the figures?

Comment on this

Please. That would be helpful.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

It is a tale of two halves. From 2009 to 2013, claims costs and premiums came down. That is clearly the side that the Deputy wants to see.

Comment on this

They came down a little bit but the difference between the cost of the premiums and the profit-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

That is my point. The year 2013 was the period of peak losses in the sector. Companies such as Setanta and Enterprise collapsed, with a major multinational company here having to recapitalise itself to the tune of hundreds of millions. To put this in context, with average premium levels, we collect approximately €1.5 billion a year and pay out in the order of €1.1 billion or €1.2 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The primary objective of an insurance company is to have enough money to pay its claims. In 2013 and 2014, there were questions about whether companies would have enough money to pay their claims. From a prudential point of view, if one has those issues, the only outcome is to increase the premium.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Connolly comes in with her next question, prior to her arrival I cautioned about this matter a couple of times. I fully appreciate the context of the Deputy's line of questioning and its appropriateness, but it is important for the questioner to contextualise it himself or herself and not to rely on my understanding of it. I need the Deputy to reflect that it is in the context of legal costs. We are not a different committee.

Comment on this

I understand that. I probably will not have time to get to the State Claims Agency. It is in the context of the submission from Insurance Ireland and the report published yesterday. That is why I asked my questions at the beginning. I have a final question for Insurance Ireland, and if I am allowed, I will go back to the State Claims Agency, or if my time is up, so be it. Does Insurance Ireland have a view on premiums and how they are calculated? Should there be more openness?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I understand that this database is going to be published every year. This is the first year that we have seen it and we are all coming to terms with the data in it. We will see it annually. Much of the debate will be about the changes from one year to another. I think that level of transparency is helpful. Typically an insurance company will price to achieve a 5% margin in a year. The reality of it is that it rarely achieves that. It will either overshoot or undershoot. The Deputy can see that it fluctuated wildly over the ten years. There were years of losses and years of profits. I accept that 2018 seems to have been a pretty profitable year. It is hoped that marks the top of a cycle and it may move in a different direction. I do not know. As the Central Bank says, it ebbs and flows.

Comment on this

Could I ask one question of the State Claims Agency? I am not asking questions that are for the Joint Committee on Health or the Committee of Public Accounts. Does the State Claims Agency have a policy about confidentiality clauses? Does it take its direction from the Minister or where does it take its direction from?

Comment on this
Mr. David Mack

The function that I perform is purely head of legal costs for third-party legal costs. I do not believe that we have a policy on confidentiality for legal costs agreements or bills of costs coming in. From time to time, we promote mediation and we try to stay within the parameters of mediation. I have said to colleagues that we cannot contract out of obligations that are consistent with public service. I do not believe there is any policy about third-party legal costs management that involves confidentiality.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Connolly. Our final contributor is Deputy Pearse Doherty. He is very welcome to the Joint Committee on Justice and Equality.

Comment on this

My first question is about legal costs for claims that are made and settlements that are not accepted by an individual at PIAB who goes on to make a claim in the courts and where the court does not award a higher payment. Dr. Doherty might be able to answer this. Is there any evidence of the sections in the 2007 Act being enforced by the courts, which means that the legal fees would not be payable to that individual?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

Sorry, Deputy, I do not have that information. I apologise.

Comment on this

Does Insurance Ireland have any knowledge of or insight into this?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

No major insight.

Comment on this

Do the witnesses have any insight about the number of settlements that are not accepted by a claimant that go on to be litigated in the courts? What percentage of those receive a higher payment than was on offer?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

We do not have any hard data on that. We know that insurance companies tend to accept more than 90% of the recommendations of PIAB and the acceptance rates on the claimant side have been in the mid 60s, though they have fallen slightly.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

We would have no sight of what happens to individual claims that are not accepted. If they go through PIAB, we would not have line of sight all the way through.

Comment on this

The companies that make up Insurance Ireland are the ones that are defending these cases in the main. Legislation was passed here in 2007. It was suggested by PIAB at the time that it would result in fewer people going to the courts. The trend has been the opposite because it allowed the courts to ensure that no legal costs would be paid if the award was not paid. What are Insurance Ireland's affiliated insurance companies doing? Do they press that? Do they bring it to the judges' attention in these cases? Is it the case that all of these claims get a higher payment than PIAB had offered? I would find that surprising given that PIAB's payments and the court payments are quite in line when one excludes payments of more than €100,000.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

The comment on the amounts is borne out in the settlement channels, PIAB and the courts.

On the Deputy's specific question on insurance company activity, I do not have an answer for him today but I can ask about it and we can come back to him on that.

Comment on this

I have heard Insurance Ireland banging on about this for quite a while and it has a fantastic propaganda machine and, indeed, captured many of the political parties in here and much of the media in terms of its spin. There is a section of the Act that allows for legal costs not to be paid out and, at this point, Insurance Ireland does not know if any of the 100-plus companies that make up Insurance Ireland actually press this in any of the court cases it is dealing with, yet it continues to raise the issue of legal costs as a major issue in terms of the cost of claims overall.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

What would often happen is that an insurance company would make a lodgement, and that puts the claimant on risk for costs. If the award does not beat the amount of the lodgement, the person is liable for part of the costs of the claim. There are tactics that people can use to put the claimant on risk for cost if they are not behaving reasonably, if you like.

Comment on this

That is why I am raising the issue of the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (Amendment) Act 2007, which specifically deals with this issue. My question is how often that is happening. How often are the courts not awarding costs and is there any indication from Insurance Ireland in this regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

One of the problems in the past was that people would sometimes make a claim to PIAB, reject the award and then, effectively, almost make a different claim or add other things into the claim at the litigation stage. Now, thanks to the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (Amendment) Act 2019, there are provisions for the courts to take a view from a costs perspective. That is something the insurers are very alive to and very keen to push.

Comment on this

If I can put it this way, does Insurance Ireland know of any court case in regard to somebody who did not accept a PIAB settlement award, which went to the High Court and where section 51A of the legislation, which means the individual would not be paid their costs, was effected?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

We cannot talk about individual cases but we can come back to the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

I am not talking about individual cases. I am trying to figure out Insurance Ireland's knowledge in regard to any of this. Is it aware this is happening or not?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

We can come back to the Deputy with more information on that.

Comment on this

We do not want to know about individual cases, nor is the question seeking that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

What we would do in a situation like that is poll our members and seek the information. We can revert to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. Insurance Ireland makes the point about PIAB and suggests the level of cases that are not being accepted has increased as a percentage over the last period. We know from the Central Bank report that PIAB is probably the most effective way of keeping costs down and, indeed, is more effective than the insurance companies settling the claims themselves. How many claims have the insurance companies rejected annually? What does 10% look like?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

Based on an acceptance rate of 90%, and given the figures in the PIAB annual report for 2017, we are talking about 12,663 total cases, so 10% of that is about 1,200.

Comment on this

As we are probably talking about a ten-year period, there would be some 12,000 cases over that period. Has Insurance Ireland done any analysis of those? Once it rejects a case or rejects a settlement, it is more than likely that it goes into litigation or else the insurance company settles, which is unlikely if it is the one rejecting the settlement. When the case goes into litigation, that is adding the extra €20,000 or €30,000. For those 1,200 cases the companies have rejected per annum, has Insurance Ireland done any analysis as to whether it was cost effective for them to do so, that is, that there would have been a reduced cost in the courts?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

No, we have not. The reason we would not do that is because how companies settle and manage claims is a competitive issue. How they price is a competitive issue and how they manage the expense line of settling claims is a competitive issue for them as well. We have not done anything individually or at an aggregate level in that regard.

Comment on this

I find that shocking. Has Insurance Ireland done any analysis of the 1,200 claims it rejects each year from PIAB with regard to how many of them fall into the different categories, for example, €1 to €10,000, €10,000 to €20,000, €20,000 to €30,000, and those above €100,000?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

We have not done any analysis of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I would have thought it would be a matter for PIAB to provide those data. We are not privy to the data that PIAB has. We get the same sort of data the Deputy gets in regard to PIAB.

Comment on this

We can ask PIAB in that regard. The point I am making is that it is likely the 1,200 claims that Insurance Ireland is rejecting are claims that have higher costs, that is, those that are at the higher end of perhaps €90,000 or €100,000. We know the cost of these claims when they are litigated makes up over 50% of total costs, even though they are a small proportion, given some 7% of claims are above €100,000. The reality is Insurance Ireland could have rejected every single one of them and, therefore, Insurance Ireland or the insurance companies could be the reason 50% of the legal costs are being paid out through the courts because they did not accept the settlements from PIAB.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

There are two points. Insurance Ireland does not accept or reject any claims.

Comment on this

Yes, I meant the insurance companies.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

Second, the case could actually settle for less than the PIAB determination and it may not go to litigation, so the converse could also be true.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

The other point is that PIAB only deals with cases where liability is not at issue. A lot of cases would involve disputes on liability and there would be complexity involved in the case and maybe high value involved in the case as well. PIAB only deals with the cases where there is no issue on liability and we are just talking about quantum. That takes a lot of the complexity out of the debate.

Comment on this

I understand that. When they settle on a quantum, when they settle on a figure to pay a claimant who may have serious bodily injuries, insurance companies affiliated to Insurance Ireland reject 1,200 of the cases based on the quantum. They go to court and if they are at the higher end, they could make up in excess of 53% of the entire legal costs of all litigated claims in the courts. Let me make this point. The courts pay out, on average, the same compensation as PIAB for claims less than €100,000. It is extremely likely that what is happening here is that insurance companies are rejecting claims that are on the higher end, towards €100,000, which make up some 53% of all legal costs when they go into litigation. The real issue is that it is insurance companies that are putting this bill upon themselves and, really, upon their consumers as a result. I am fully aware the witnesses do not have any of that knowledge.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

One headline number would be that, in 2018, there were 22,000 injuries cases filed in the courts. Let us take the 1,200 figure, the PIAB figure. That is 5%. It may be they are proportionately higher - I do not know - but we are certainly not flooding the courts with lots of cases. In the Central Bank report, the annual filing went from 14,000 to 18,000 over the past five years. At 1,200 per year, even if they all went into court, I do not see how it is the insurance companies that are clogging up the courts.

Comment on this

That takes me to the next point. We are just dealing with PIAB at the minute and I did not suggest the insurance companies are clogging up the courts. I am trying to find out, for the cases they have rejected, whether it has been the case that they have been at the higher end.

Have they resulted in significant legal fees? For cases above €100,000 the legal fees are significantly more. Yet, Insurance Ireland has not polled any of its members or collected any data on that. Is that what Mr. Hassett is telling me?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Yes.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Hassett explain one thing to the committee? The figure for settlements between insurance companies is above 90% of all claimants. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Is that direct settlements?

Comment on this

Yes, direct settlements.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

The figure is 53%.

Comment on this

I do not mean the value of cost but rather the number of claims.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

A total of 53% settled directly, some 16% settled through PIAB and 31% settled through litigation. The details are on page 8.

Comment on this

I am looking at page 22, which has details on settlement of claims. Under all claim types, it states 94% are directly settled, while 2% are resolved under PIAB and 4% are litigated.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

What is the page number?

Comment on this

It is page 22. Anyway, that takes in all claims. Let us move on to personal injury claims.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

That is damage as well as injury.

Comment on this

I understand that. Let us move on to personal injury claims. The figure is 53%. Then 14% of claims are settled through PIAB and 33% of claims are litigated. I do not have the figure before me but we know close to 50% of PIAB awards are not accepted either by the insurance company or the claimant. This corresponds to approximately 6,000 cases per year. It should correspond to 14%. What makes up the other 17% that are litigated?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

Can Deputy Doherty repeat the question?

Comment on this

Please look at page 24. In 2018, some 53% of personal injury claims were settled directly by the company while 14% were settled by PIAB. This means approximately 14% of those PIAB settlements were rejected and litigated, but 33% of claims are actually settled through the courts.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Certain claims are not eligible for PIAB. A claimant cannot go to PIAB with certain claim types in the first place. A claimant can elect not to go to PIAB as well. It is a claimant decision whether to go to PIAB.

Comment on this

How many cases did the insurance companies refuse eligibility for PIAB to deal with? That is one of the provisions insurance companies have.

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

That is the consent number. I do not know the consent number but I imagine PIAB could give that figure to the committee. I do not know the figure for consent for determination to happen.

Comment on this

Would that arise where insurance companies do not admit liability?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

There can be a number of reasons PIAB cannot make a determination. It could be if liability is in question. Certain claims are deemed to be outside the scope of PIAB. For example, if psychological injuries are attached to a claim, that would fall outside the scope of PIAB to make a determination. There are several other technical reasons as well.

Comment on this

I want to ask about a report done by the Central Bank and the data that Insurance Ireland releases in its annual report and fact file. Is this data the same data?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

No, it is swings and roundabouts. We are comparing different data sources. I would have thought the broad direction of travel is similar, but there are clearly differences in the data and how we interpret the data. It is a question of apples and oranges.

Comment on this

Why would there be differences? For private motor insurance, does Insurance Ireland deal with all private motor when it reports? Does Insurance Ireland have an insight only into a certain section of the insurance industry?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

More companies are captured in the Central Bank than would be captured in ours.

Comment on this

What is the proportion?

Comment on this
Dr. Declan Jackson

The legislation for the Central Bank report states that if a company writes any motor business it must make a return to the national claims information database. I am subject to correction, but I understand we have approximately nine or ten-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

We need to put some context on this.

Comment on this

Sorry, nine or ten what?

Comment on this
Dr. Brian Doherty

There are nine or ten companies I would recognise as members on the Central Bank report, whereas the Motor Insurers Bureau of Ireland list has 44 companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Some of those are specialist companies. I imagine the big market share players are represented in the Insurance Ireland fact file. The Insurance Ireland fact file replaced the blue book, which was a repository. It was an attempt to keep tabs on what was going on in the industry. I imagine everyone would agree that a centralised data source is a better source.

Comment on this

I am trying to get a handle on this. We were always relying on the Insurance Ireland fact file. I am seeking an estimate from the Insurance Ireland representatives. What percentage of private motor insurance is covered under the Insurance Ireland fact file compared to the Central Bank report?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

Off the top of my head, I would give a figure of 90%.

Comment on this

I am talking about market share.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The top eight players all have a market share of more than 7%. One has a share in above 20%. The arithmetic suggests it is up near 90%. The other players tend to be specialist players for classic cars or particular market niches.

Comment on this

Okay, let us say the figure is 90%. Does Mr. Hassett wish to correct the record of a previous committee meeting? Mr. Hassett was before me recently. He stated that his information was that premiums were coming down and had come down. He said they peaked in 2016 and had come down significantly. I challenged him and asked him to produce the facts. He went on to say his understanding was that prices had been coming down since the middle of 2016. He then went on to say that prices were falling. Mr. Horan intervened and defended the statement from Mr. Hassett. Mr. Horan said that the fall in recent years meant that motor claims costs had stabilised. Does Mr. Hassett accept that was not true?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I do accept that. Based on the Central Bank report, which I accept, I accept that is not true. I want to put some context on this - I think I placed the same context at the time. Actually, I was relying on data that had been shared in the market. It was third party data. Insurance Ireland has no access to price information. We should not have access to price information from any of our member companies either. The only data source we had at that time was the Central Statistics Office data. The data we quoted relating to 2017 were CSO data. One could look at the CSO data and the Central Bank report and question it because they do not line up.

Comment on this

I put the facts about the CSO data to Mr. Hassett at the meeting. I am sick to my teeth of telling people this, including those in the Government. Mr. Hassett knows this better than anyone. The CSO data come from a CSO official telephoning an insurance company and stating that he or she is from the CSO and the office is looking for a price on a particular insurance policy. Then, the insurance company gives the price and the CSO reports on the change of that policy. Insurance Ireland provides information to the European authority, which compiles a report on insurance. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

We provide statistics.

Comment on this

One of those figures is the average cost of insurance per motorised vehicle. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

I do not recall providing that.

Comment on this

Insurance Ireland does so. Actually, the figure shows in 2017 that insurance premiums went up. Anyway, let us forget about that.

Is Mr. Hassett seriously telling me that he claimed repeatedly that insurance premiums went down from 2016 to 2017? They did not go up a little; they went up 15%. Is Mr. Hassett telling me that he is so completely unconnected with the industry that he has no clue what is happening? This is despite the fact that 90% of the motor market falls under Insurance Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

As a trade association we have no access to price information. We should not have such access either.

Comment on this

Mr. Hassett continued to claim at an Oireachtas committee that it was going down.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

We quoted CSO data.

Comment on this

Deputy Doherty, I am sorry but it is likely that if that is to be followed up you will have to revert to the other committee business. I wish to emphasise that access to justice and legal costs has to be the determinant in questioning here today.

Comment on this

My final question relates to the data.

When we have data, we need to know they are valid and accurate. Sinn Féin had reservations in regard to the legislation that underpins this report in terms of the Central Bank because we know that insurance companies transfer moneys to their headquarters. One insurance company transferred a significant amount of money to its headquarters and, therefore, was able to record a loss in this jurisdiction. This practice is legal but, therefore, the data are distorted.

On the Insurance Ireland fact file, in responses to me at a meeting of another committee Mr. Hassett, backed up by Mr. Horan, stated that the claims ratio for 2017 was 71.5%, which they reiterated to other members here today. We now know the claims ratio for 2017 was 59%, which means the insurance companies were more profitable than was suggested. At the aforementioned meeting, Mr. Hassett also made the point that the loss ratio for 2016 was 82%. We now know it was 69%, which, again, means the insurance companies were more profitable than was disclosed. He also made the point that in the three years prior to 2016 the loss ratio was in the mid-90s, but it was not. It fell into the mid-90s only in one year and it was in the mid-80s in the other two years. Again, this means the insurance companies were more profitable than was suggested.

The Insurance Ireland fact file covers 90% of the motor market. Is it nothing more than a propaganda tool given the information we now have in terms of the 100%, which could in no way allow for the type of discrepancies in the figures which Insurance Ireland present compared to what is now presented to us by the Central Bank?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I think the data in the Central Bank report are highly consistent with the fact file. There may be variations on a year-by-year basis and we can discuss how they may occur. In terms of the cycle, a claims ratio of 75% is highly consistent.

Comment on this

The Insurance Ireland fact file references a claims ratio of 71.5%. This means that for every euro taken in 71.05 cent is paid out in claims. The Central Bank reports states that the amount paid out is 59 cent, which is a significant reduction. For the previous year, Mr. Hassett claimed it was 82 cent, but the Central Bank report states it was 69 cent. They are not small margins of error.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

I refer the Deputy to the graph on page 19 of the report, which shows that the ten year average claims ratio is 75%.

Comment on this

I am not disputing that. What I am disputing is that the statistics provided in Insurance Ireland's annual fact file are completely at odds with the statistics provided in the Central Bank report. Legally, companies are required to report accurate, verifiable information to the Central Bank. There is a massive discrepancy in regard to how much of every euro taken in by Insurance Ireland is paid out in claims. Insurance Ireland claims that last year it paid out 71.5 cent of every euro it took in but the Central Bank report indicates that the actual amount paid out is as low as 59 cent. For the previous year, the discrepancy was massive as well, at 82 cent versus 69 cent. Insurance Ireland claimed that in two previous years it was in the mid-90s but it was 84. How could there be such a discrepancy?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

There are differences in the methodology. I will ask my colleague, Mr. Horan, to elaborate.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Horan

The NCID report is done on an accident year basis. This is explained on page 6. It is the year in which the accident occurred. It may take several years for all claims to be fully paid, etc. That is the basis of the NCID report. On page 7, it references the financial year, which is the year for which financial accounts are stated. When stating the claims incurred in a financial year insurers include claims which were paid in the year, reserves they set aside for claims that happened that year and changes to the reserves set aside for claims that happened in previous years. The fact file is done on a financial year basis. In the National Claims information Database report many of the chapters are on an accident year basis such that the figures will not stack up exactly. For example, the financial year stated accounts for, say, 2016 are a snapshot as at year end 2016 and the NCID report is a snapshot as at year end 2018, looking back at all of the accident years, such that it can see that in many of the earlier years in particular the claims were fully settled. There is an element-----

Comment on this

The NCID found that the expected claims loss that Insurance Ireland had identified did not materialise, which is another serious issue in terms of what the insurance industry is doing. The industry is over-compensating in regard to future losses. It has to identify the claims settled in a particular year and make provision for the following years such that it is cooking the books and over-estimating only to find on look-back that that level of claims was not paid. When the Central Bank carries out the exercise which Mr. Horan spoke about, the actual claims ratio drops dramatically.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerry Hassett

The Central Bank report shows that Insurance Ireland paid out a higher percentage of premium in claims over the ten year period than is shown in its fact file. I reject the Deputy's comment.

Comment on this

I must ask Deputy Doherty to bring this particular line of questioning to a close as it is stretching the relevance to the overriding subject. I am not in any way challenging the legitimacy of the Deputy's questions but it is my responsibility to ensure the committee addresses the matter before it. Has the Deputy concluded his questions?

Comment on this

Yes. I would welcome if the information requested could be forwarded to the committee.

Comment on this

I will be referencing that in a moment.

Deputy Doherty's final engagement aside, it is fair to say that there has been a certain dominance of attention to Insurance Ireland. The Central Bank report is most likely the reason for it. As I have emphasised repeatedly, the committee's business is the address of access to justice and legal costs. It is important to point out the that views of members' expressed during the course of today's hearing are the views of members. They do not have the imprimatur of the Joint Committee on Justice and Equality. The committee will deliberate on all of the evidence presented to it over a number of hearings, and others received in written submissions and, ultimately, publish a report with recommendations. This is always a compromise. The committee is comprised of 11 members coming from disparate positions, as evidenced today, so for the report to have the imprimatur of the committee there will be a degree of give and take.

As in the case of committee members the expressed views of the Chairman are the views of the occupant of the Chair of the Joint Committee on Justice and Equality. I take a very different view in regard to the line of questioning posed to Dr. Doherty regarding "no win, no fee" and "no foal, no fee". I want to make it abundantly clear that the theme of these hearings is access to justice. Anything that would in any way inhibit or prevent any citizen having access to justice would run utterly and absolutely contrary to everything that I would believe in. In regard to the particular question posed to Dr. Doherty, in my view, he was correct in not responding to it. We must ensure that access to justice is not the preserve of those who can afford it or those who can afford to take the risk. Every citizen has the right to access justice. I believe strongly in that view.

In regard to the data requests, of which there were a number and Dr. Jackson indicated it will be possible to provide, I do not expect him to provide PIAB data but if he can we would welcome it. With no disrespect to any of the witnesses, there is a dearth of data as evidenced in questioning by colleagues from across the political spectrum. This is regrettable because data inform.

They help to formulate ideas and, it is hoped, effective and efficient change in the workings of the system. Where requests have been made, including by Deputy Pearse Doherty, the previous contributor, any information should be furnished to the clerk to the committee and not to the individual members who have presented. The clerk will circulate information to all members, who will have equal access to the information that the witnesses or any of the representative groups will share. Though Deputy Doherty is not a member of this committee, it will be shared with him equally, as it will be with members who have presented or who have not been able to attend today. I had some questions but I think we have all been exhausted, and the questions have been touched on in different ways. We have a significant job once we resume. We are anxious to conclude this report. We do not know how long we have in these Houses, so we will endeavour to get the report concluded as quickly as possible and published before the Taoiseach blows the whistle for a rematch for everybody concerned. I will vacate my position at that time.

It remains only for me to thank the witnesses. I will not reference the organisations but call the witnesses by their Christian names, if I may. I thank Isolde, Fergal, David, David eile - two together; snap - Brian, Ultan, Gerry, Michael and Declan for their attendance today.

This is the last sitting of the Joint Committee on Justice and Equality in 2019. I thank members for their participation throughout the year. It has been very productive. We hope that whatever duration the Thirty-second Dáil has into 2020, we will continue to be an important contributing body within the Houses of the Oireachtas. I invite witnesses to join us for a photograph. Pat will show us outside. We publish the photograph of all our witnesses with the reports.

Comment on this