Anti-Discrimination Within Traveller Employment: Discussion
Pavee Point highlighted severe Traveller employment gaps, widespread workplace discrimination, and barriers linked to education and the loss of traditional livelihoods. It called for a co-designed national employment, training and enterprise strategy, measurable recruitment targets, expanded public-sector programmes, and stronger support for Traveller businesses. Witnesses also urged sustained funding and fair pay, benefits and career paths for Traveller primary healthcare workers. The committee welcomed the evidence and indicated these issues would inform its report, with targeted recruitment seen as essential.
I welcome everyone to this meeting of the Joint Committee on Key Issues affecting the Traveller Community. No apologies have been received. This meeting is our first hearing to discuss anti-discrimination within Traveller employment. Our witnesses today are from Pavee Point Traveller and Roma Centre, Mr. Martin Collins, co-director, and Ms Winnie McDonnell, training co-ordinator. They are both very welcome.
I ask anyone attending remotely to mute their microphone when not contributing so that we do not pick up any background noise or feedback. As usual, I remind all those in attendance to ensure their mobile phones are on silent or switched off.
As the witnesses are within the precincts of Leinster House, they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure it is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person or entity outside of the Houses, or an official of the Houses, either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable.
I now invite Mr. Collins to make his opening statement, followed by Ms McDonnell. We will then proceed with a question and answer session.
Comment on this
We thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee. Pavee Point is delighted to have this important opportunity to speak to members on this issue. We will highlight some of the issues and challenges in relation to Traveller employment. In parallel, we will also highlight potential solutions for how the unemployment rate among the Traveller community can be addressed. We will also highlight recent positive initiatives.
To begin, I would like to acknowledge that there are a number of Travellers employed in the Oireachtas, which is a welcome development and can be built on further. We need the Oireachtas, as our national Parliament, to lead by example. While we have seen some modest improvements in Traveller employment outcomes in recent years, significant and persistent structural inequalities continue to restrict Travellers' access to employment in Ireland. Data sets, for example, census 2022, and the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, or FRA, report in 2025 show that 22% of Travellers in Ireland are in paid employment compared with approximately 79% of the general population. This figure has increased from 15% in 2019. There was a 61% Traveller unemployment rate in census 2022 among the age group 15 to 65 compared with an unemployment rate of just 5% in the general community. These numbers have not appeared in a vacuum and are due to structural barriers from a young age, historical inequality and discrimination and racism prevalent in the labour market. We know that 65% of young Travellers are not in employment, education or training compared with just 7% of young people in the general population.
Some 75% of Travellers experienced discrimination in the previous year according to the FRA research. We have provided a case study to exemplify the incidence and prevalence of discrimination in the labour market. In a case at the WRC in April 2026, it adjudicated in favour of a young Traveller man who worked for a sales company in solar panels. A marketing strategist was invited in to increase their sales. He said, "You are not like a pack of knackers going door to door selling tarmac". This is not an isolated incident; it is just an indication of the prevalent discrimination and racism within the labour market.
Some 84% of Travellers have experienced discrimination when looking for work and 34% have experienced discrimination in the workplace so it is not just about accessing employment but when they gain employment, discrimination can occur in the workplace. Of that 34% who experienced discrimination, only 11% reported it to the appropriate authority. This demonstrates a lack of confidence in the relevant bodies to adjudicate and deliver justice. Some 68% of Traveller children attend early childhood education compared with 95% of children in the settled community while 27% of young Travellers completed at least upper secondary school education compared with 97% in the general community. There is a clear link between educational inequality and unemployment inequality. I will leave the gender dimension to Ms McDonnell.
There are a couple of positive developments I would like to bring to the committee's attention. To date, under the apprenticeship programme managed and co-ordinated by the Irish Traveller Movement, 215 bursaries were awarded. This is a really important initiative. It needs to be supported and further sustained. Pavee Point also wants to acknowledge the placement programme initiated by the Department of justice. To date, approximately 25 Travellers and Roma have gained employment across eight Government Departments at clerical officer and executive officer level. This is an important development. We need to build and develop this further. I also acknowledge the Department of Children, Disability and Equality in expanding the Traveller and Roma employment initiative from six projects to 14. We now have 14 local offices across the country offering mentoring supports and help writing CVs for Travellers and Roma looking for employment. We also acknowledge the inclusivity employer toolkit developed by Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission.
In conclusion, we will continue to advocate for universal anti-racism training for employers and the need to have clear equality statements in order to demonstrate they are fair and inclusive employers. Affirmative action measures are needed to tackle the above-mentioned disadvantages and racism experienced by Travellers in seeking and retaining employment. We will continue to advocate for data collection systems to include ethnic identifiers to ensure specific outcomes for Travellers. In terms of creating inclusive workplaces, too many Travellers are forced to hide their ethnicity in the workplace due to discrimination. The price they pay for that manifests in mental health issues. We need greater recognition of and support should be given to Traveller entrepreneurship and self-employment. Supporting Traveller-owned businesses through targeted enterprise programmes would create additional pathways to economic participation and financial independence.
The scale of disparity between Traveller employment rates and unemployment rates among the general population remains unacceptable, especially given that the Irish labour market is currently performing well. It is regrettable that the untapped potential of Travellers in the labour market is not being realised. We need continued investment in these initiatives and in anti-racism training among employers. This is the key to better opportunities for Travellers seeking and retaining employment and progressing in the labour market.
For many years Pavee Point and other Traveller organisations have been advocating for the development of a national Traveller and Roma training, employment and enterprise strategy, and for this to be developed and co-designed with Traveller organisations. There is an absence of a coherent strategy to create the conditions whereby Travellers can access employment opportunities in the labour market and formalise or set up a business. We would like the committee, in its final report, to make a very clear and explicit recommendation that such a strategy is of the utmost importance.
Comment on this
I will give some background on how we have got here. For a number of years, Pavee Point, alongside local Traveller organisations, has been very concerned about the recruitment and retention of Traveller primary healthcare workers. One of the key issues was the pay and conditions of Traveller workers and particularly their lack of basic entitlements. In 2017, we developed a paper documenting these problems. Through the National Traveller Health Network and working with Traveller organisations on the ground, we decided to update this analysis. We commissioned a consultant to carry out the work, which was undertaken and published in 2025 as Beyond the Poverty Trap. This showed a significant pay gap, with workers earning an average of just €150 per week. This is a very nominal amount and it does not reflect the value or demands of the work.
At the same time, the Department of Health requested a review of these projects to see whether they were fit for purpose. For the projects, this added insult to injury but we engaged fully with the process. The review was completed and published this year and it gave a very strong endorsement of these projects. Its key recommendations were to address pay and conditions, recruitment and retention, workforce planning and career progression. Following this, the CEO of the HSE committed to implementing the findings of the report. Work began on standardising the job specification for these workers and on workforce planning for the sector. This exercise has now been completed and we are delighted that the recent budget allocated €1 million to address the pay deficit.
This is a starting point and not an end point. If we are serious about the workers that the State, the HSE and other statutory agencies rely so heavily on, we need meaningful and sustained investment. Beyond the Poverty Trap documented the pay gap and the lack of entitlements facing Traveller primary health care workers. The Department of Health’s review of the projects then demonstrated their value to the health of Travellers and to the health system itself. Projects led by the community and staffed by members of the community reach people that mainstream services too often do not.
Beyond the Poverty Trap also highlights the lack of professional progression routes for workers in these projects. Many project workers are paid very little yet carry enormous workloads on the ground. They do not have the same benefits as HSE staff doing comparable work. They have no clear career ladder and no recognised pathway from community roles into higher grade positions. At the same time, there is a heavy over-reliance on the services these workers deliver. Statutory services depend on their trust, their knowledge and their reach. This dependence should be matched with fair pay, proper terms and a future in the work. It is also important to understand that these workers do not switch off at 5 p.m. They work in the community they live in. When the working day ends, they are still neighbours, relatives and the first person people turn to when someone is sick, bereaved or in a crisis. The work follows them home.
Maternity and paternity leave is a stark example of the gap. Access to this depends entirely on whether the organisation someone works for allows it and can afford to provide it. The majority of local projects do not have the resources to do so. In practice, workers delivering vital health services to their own community may not have the family supports others take for granted. To take the pension auto-enrolment scheme as another example, many projects have not yet received the funding needed to meet their obligations under this scheme. Some projects simply do not have the resources to sustain these costs if they are not funded. Without this funding, workers will be left out of the system the rest of the workforce is entering and projects will be forced to make impossible choices. This matters deeply for our community. Only 3% of Travellers live beyond the age of 65. For generations, many Travellers would never have seen the value of a pension because they did not live long enough to draw one. Today, thanks in large part to the work of these projects, many members of our community live into their 80s and 90s. Many of them have worked for years, often in community roles, and now have no pension at all. A community that is finally living longer must not be left to age in poverty.
Health inequalities do not discriminate. A Traveller in a paid role is still a Traveller. Having a job does not remove the dire statistics attached to our community, which makes us one of the most vulnerable groups in Irish society. Our workers carry the same risks, the same shorter life expectancy and the same exposure to poor outcomes as the people they support. We must also be honest about the conditions in which many Traveller workers are living. Travellers who are in work are experiencing food poverty and energy poverty at a far higher rate than the settled population. Many are living in unsuitable conditions, including mobile homes that are not fit for purpose. Working for very low wages while living in these conditions brings constant stress and this stress harms health, family life and the ability to keep working.
Today there are Travellers working as doctors, nurses, solicitors and members of An Garda Síochána. These achievements should be celebrated. They should not be seen as exceptions or anomalies. They show what is possible when barriers are removed and they must become the norm. This is why the Traveller and Roma Civil Service employment programme matters. We want to see it rolled out to more Government Departments and extended into local government. It is one tool in a toolbox. It will not solve everything but it is a practical, proven way to open doors and it needs to be supported and expanded as part of the wider approach.
We do acknowledge that progress has been made and we are grateful for it but we cannot ignore the discrimination and racism Travellers continue to face or the persistent failures by local authorities to implement Traveller accommodation programmes. These are not separate issues. They are directly connected to low pay, poor conditions and health inequalities that our projects exist to address. We are asking the committee to ensure that committed funding reaches projects without delay, including the resources needed for the pension auto-enrolment. We also ask for funding to sustain projects that cannot otherwise continue. We ask the committee to support clear progression routes and pay parity with comparable HSE roles, making family-related leave, including maternity and paternity leave, a funded reality for project workers, rolling out the Traveller and Roma Civil Service employment programme to more Government Departments and to local government, fully implementing Traveller accommodation programmes and tackling the racism and discrimination that underpin these inequalities. The budget allocation is a start. With continued commitment it can be a foundation for lasting change. Gralti for sunni and gloryin to us. I thank the committee for seeing and listening to us.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for the presentations and I ask Mr. Collins to clarify something. He stated that 215 apprenticeship bursaries were awarded by June 2026. Was that in 2026 or is that altogether until 2026?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Collins have the numbers per year?
Comment on this
No, I do not have that information but we can supply it.
Comment on this
Yes, it is the total over a period of years.
Comment on this
It looked interesting until I figured that out. It is not as many as I thought. This is a very important issue to deal with. Employment, not just for Travellers but for everybody, can be life changing and I do not have to tell people this. With a decent job and decent pay, people can start raising their family properly. It is up to us, if possible, to figure out what barriers are there and the witnesses have outlined some of them and how to remove them. The State is a huge employer itself, with a lot of State Departments and what we refer to as semi-State bodies, such as Iarnród Éireann, Bus Éireann and others like this. Do these bodies have any particular engagement with Ms McDonnell with regard to the activation of Travellers?
Comment on this
I am not aware of any. I know there are Travellers employed in the likes of An Post, Bus Éireann and other bodies but they do not have any direct engagement with us in Pavee Point.
Comment on this
Perhaps this is a recommendation we might make with regard to having a scheme.
The State is one of the biggest employers and it would be good if it could reach out in that way.
The witnesses might also explain something else to me. I have heard in different presentations before and from Travellers I have met that when Travellers get a job, it is sometimes very difficult for them to maintain the job because of what they might experience in it. Some of them said they can survive, for want of a better word, in the job if another Traveller is working with them. Could the witnesses give us an example of one or two instances where that has happened?
Comment on this
To go back to the earlier question, it is important that we acknowledge there have been some important targeted measures to increase Traveller and Roma employment in the labour market. We are talking about Travellers in this case. This concerns the local authorities and Government Departments. I know the ESB has initiated recruitment strategies targeting Travellers. I also know that Dublin Bus has reached out. It already has a number of Travellers employed but it is looking to expand that number. Some really important initiatives are happening.
I also remember that a good few years ago, South Dublin County Council developed a targeted intervention to employ Travellers within the council as clerical officers and general operatives. That was a huge success. I think 14 Travellers secured long-term, pensionable jobs. This is actually a very interesting case study because many Traveller sites are located very close to the South Dublin County Council buildings. The manager at the time, the late Joe Horan, Lord rest him, did an audit of the composition of the council's workforce to capture ethnicity and gender. Through that audit, the council discovered that nobody identified as a member of the Traveller community despite Travellers being a significant population in close proximity to the council's buildings. The council put in place this affirmative action recruitment measure and it was quite successful.
What I am trying to say is that there are a number of examples and case studies which have proved that targeted, proactive measures aimed at Travellers, and other groups under-represented in the labour market, do work. Adopting a mainstreaming approach and saying our doors are open to everybody does not recognise that not everybody is starting from the same point because of disadvantage, racism and discrimination. Additional targeted measures are needed to address the inequality experienced by Travellers and Roma within the labour market. I gave just one example of those affirmative action measures.
Comment on this
Mr. Collins spoke about a dedicated Traveller and Roma training, employment and enterprise plan. How would Mr. Collins see that working and what needs to be in it?
Comment on this
We have strategies dealing with other issues. I am not suggesting for one minute that it is a panacea or working effectively but at least we have a framework in place to address Traveller accommodation. We have plans and strategies available in that context. We have the national Traveller and Roma Education Strategy, TRES, the national Traveller health action plan and the national action plan against racism. We do have strategies which offer a framework to address those issues but we do not have a strategy or a framework designed to address Traveller unemployment in the labour market or to offer support for Travellers who want to formalise or set up a new business.
Bits and pieces are happening. Some of this work is really positive and there are benefits from it but we need a bit more of a co-ordinated and coherent approach. We need an all-systems, integrated approach rather than silos. At the moment, different Departments and agencies are operating in silos and not speaking to each other. I think a strategy could potentially offer a framework for better co-ordination and coherence among all the different State agencies.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Collins. Turning back to Ms McDonnell and the healthcare workers she spoke about, what needs to be done in the very short term to improve their conditions and to retain the staff we have working there? We have heard before about the conditions, including the low pay and, as Ms McDonnell referred to, the lack of pensions. These workers often live close to their clients, so it is not a nine-to-five job. When there is a crisis in the community, they are often the first people there. Will Ms McDonnell explain what needs to be done? What would her priority be if she could get it done?
Comment on this
In the recent budget, we were allocated €1 million to address the pay deficit. As I said, that is only a start. A lot of work is happening behind the scenes to develop standardised job descriptions and a data-hub app that community health workers would be able to upload all their information to. Lots of work is happening with that, and on standardised job descriptions and workforce planning. The €1 million is great but, in reality, to sustain these projects, we need the funding to be continued. I do not want to put out a begging hand but we need much more funding.
We have seen the value of the primary healthcare projects for Travellers on the ground. We know the great work they do and how they bridge the gap between the services and the members of the Traveller community. We also know, however, that there are areas that do not have primary healthcare projects for Travellers. We would like to see support for getting these projects up and running in the local areas that do not have one because the amount of work they do without receiving credit is amazing.
Comment on this
I welcome our witnesses. If we do not solve this problem now, with full employment, there will be no hope when recessions inevitably hit, as they do. The optimum time to achieve something has to be now. In that context, I welcome the green shoots and the good news about the HSE, Bus Éireann and others. I believe we need to expand the approach to all public service Departments and local authorities. Perhaps the witnesses might elaborate on where we are at and tell the committee which bodies are not doing it now.
A former member of this committee, former Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, was a great champion of the rural social schemes. There should certainly be quotas within the community employment schemes, the rural social schemes and similar programmes to get a number of Travellers there as a transitional exercise towards absorption into other jobs. The public service could respond by every Department and local authority adopting a quota. Local authorities provide a great range of jobs. There are also the various social and community employment schemes. That is my first question. If the witnesses will respond, I will then move to two other matters. By the way, in relation to my question, Deputy Quinlivan raised the question of whether the €1 million was adequate. I was going to ask the witnesses the same question. I presume they hope there will be another €1 million or €2 million in every budget.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Collins want to take this question?
Comment on this
From our perspective in Pavee Point, while I acknowledged and said there were some really positive and important developments, they are insufficient. We cannot be complacent. We need to build on those initiatives to create further employment opportunities for Travellers and Roma. Nothing is off limits, of course. There is an ambition within the community to gain meaningful employment in all domains, whether in local authorities, Government Departments, the media or even in politics. Right across the board, we should not contain or restrict ourselves in any way.
We agree that there should be targets. We should be setting targets.
Comment on this
We should be setting very clear, realistic and achievable targets for the recruitment of Travellers into the labour market. If we have targets in place, we will be in a better position to monitor and benchmark what progress, if any, is being made against them. Pavee Point will always say it is very important to set targets. As someone once said, if you cannot measure something, it is very difficult to manage it.
In terms of measuring it, the analysis has been done and documented. That analysis points to ongoing exclusion, inequality and racism in the labour market. It is reflected in 65% of Travellers being unemployed. It is now time to use that evidence and that analysis to inform a strategy, as I said earlier. That is what is absent. What is needed is an overall coherent co-ordinated interagency strategy to address the issues. We have moved beyond the analysis and research. It has been well documented ad nauseam.
Comment on this
I can answer the Senator's question on what was given to Traveller health in the budget, which is welcome. However, we suffer from very poor health inequality and it is only a stepping stone to where we need to be in this day and age.
Comment on this
However, it establishes the principle.
Comment on this
I agree. Mr. Collins's point about targets is absolutely correct. That is needed to start. If we got to a certain number, it would have a domino effect. It needs to break the glass ceiling at a certain statistical point and it will develop a norm. There are many jobs unfilled. I spoke to the owners of a small coffee shop recently which is closing because they cannot get staff. That is their only reason for closing. It was clear the shop was really busy but they said they could not get staff. With that background, there should be something doable here.
This has to be led by the public sector and then move to the private sector. I ask the witnesses to elaborate on how Traveller business and indigenous Traveller activities could be supported as a source of employment. Mr. Collins raised that earlier. Can he suggest strategies to get the private sector involved? All the public representatives in this room are meeting private sector people every day who are telling us that they have labour shortages. How do we break that glass ceiling? How do we square that circle?
Comment on this
The Senator's first point is absolutely correct. Pavee Point and other Traveller organisations have stated publicly that the State needs to lead by example. If the State does not demonstrate any leadership or ambition around Traveller employment, it is very unlikely that the private sector will step up. That is very important.
There is a gender dimension to this conversation which often gets overlooked or forgotten about. That is the role of Traveller men. Over the years, the role of Traveller men has changed drastically and profoundly. My community has gone through more change in the last 30 years than it did in the previous 100 years. Some people are struggling to cope with that adjustment and that change, in particular Traveller men.
That has been compounded by the State introducing various laws and policies. For example, the Casual Trading Act has effectively excluded or certainly restricted Travellers from participating in markets and fairs. There was a big trade among Travellers buying and selling horses at fairs and then we had the Control of Horses Act introduced. Other legislation has been introduced around recycling which was traditionally an economic activity that many Travellers engaged in. We have had a range of policies and laws introduced which have had negative consequences, in this case primarily for Traveller men around making an income and supporting their families. That has been closed off to them and nothing has been put in place to replace it.
As I have said to my colleagues, Traveller men are struggling to adjust to the new context and are receiving very little support in making that adjustment. Traveller men are struggling to redefine their role within the family and the community. I can see the manifestations of that in terms of mental health issues, drug dependency, alcohol dependency and even feuding. These are some of the manifestations of the drastic change that has taken place in our community. I am not saying that it has not impacted women but, on the face of it, it seems that women have adjusted and adapted better than men. I am not saying that change was not needed in the community in terms of patriarchy and gender inequality; of course, change was needed. However, we need to find a way of supporting people to adjust and adapt to the changing context. I do not think Traveller men are getting that support.
Comment on this
I wish to reiterate what Mr. Collins has said about the State taking the lead-----
Comment on this
-----and addressing the issue of low employment within the Traveller community. We need to be honest. The biggest barriers facing Travellers in accessing employment in the private sector are racism and discrimination. There are plenty of young Travellers who are willing to work. I have worked in local organisations over the years and I know from helping and supporting young people on the ground in filling in CVs that if they are living in a halting site, they have to change their address because they know if they put in a halting site address, they will not even get invited for an interview. The issues of racism and discrimination within the private sector are huge.
From personal experience I have listened to my own tell me how if their employer or somebody hits their hand against an inanimate object or something, the word "knacker" - I hate saying it - will come out. A tin of paint could become a "knacker". A young Traveller, man or woman, in an environment where they are trying to get on with life and having to listen to comments like this, will not stay in work in areas like that. Therefore, these initiatives that the public sector is doing for Traveller and Roma people are what is needed. The targeted approach Mr. Collins spoke about is definitely needed. However, that needs to be expanded out to local government. If I am accessing a local authority or a health service, I need to see people of my own kin there. To be it, you need to see it. Therefore, we need to be visible within all of this.
Comment on this
Ms McDonnell is right on that last point. It is probably the most significant barrier to employment all members of the Travelling community - the private sector. I would be reluctant to think it is the same in the public sector but, according to the data, it is. One of the things that disappoints me is that, as Mr. Collins said in his contribution, only 11% of members of the Travelling community who suffered that report it to an official body. That is where we are failing. There may be an historical mistrust of the State as well. The State is making formal efforts to overcome that. Why is it that only 11% of members of the Travelling community who suffer racism or discrimination in employment are willing to report it to an authoritative body?
Comment on this
I suppose there is a fear that if they report something that is happening or being said, they might lose their job. It might not necessarily mean that they would lose it over that but the employer might find a different excuse. There is a fear of losing their job. As the Deputy said, there is also mistrust. What happens if I do report it? Will anything change?
Comment on this
How can we reassure people around that?
Comment on this
I think you need to lead out. For the 11% who report it, hopefully it will be more as time goes on, they need to see clear action and people being held accountable for their racism and discrimination towards the ethnic minority group of Travellers in Ireland.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy has actually nailed it. Historically, there has been a lack of trust and confidence between our community and the State for a host of very obvious reasons.
We need to address that and develop trust, confidence and positive relationship building between the community and the State institutions. At the moment, I would say one of the reasons it is only 11% of that 34% reported is a lack of confidence that anything would be done and that they would get an effective remedy. Looking at access to justice and having an effective remedy can be a bit difficult and cumbersome and it might even be bureaucratic. It is about access to justice. Certainly, Pavee Point and other Traveller groups would encourage and support, where we have capacity, Travellers to make formal complaints. It really is important that they make a formal complaint if they feel they have been unlawfully treated or discriminated against. It is an ongoing process. As time goes on, we will increasingly see a lot more Travellers making formal complaints to the WRC under the Employment Equality Act but we might need to look at the process and how it can be made less cumbersome, simplified and much more accessible. That is one of the issues. I think the fundamental issue is the lack of confidence that something meaningful will be done to address the situation.
Comment on this
Mr. Collins spoke at length about the role of men in the Travelling community and how they find it difficult to define the role as it has evolved and changed. Has that had an impact on participation in the workforce or employment? He went through some of the data about the economic performance of the country and rising employment levels. There has always been discrimination against members of the Travelling community in employment but in the past, was there greater level of participation in employment by men in the Travelling community?
Comment on this
There were different roles within the community. Mr. Collins is a little older than me so he might be better able to speak on this. Traditionally, Travellers would have been involved in recycling. I always say we were the first in recycling until it became popular and was taken away from us in a sense. They would have been in that kind of role with the recycling of scrap or whatever else. There were very gender-specific roles in the community for Traveller men, whether they were doing physical work outside, such as landscaping. There were different roles in the community. Over time, there has been the development of primary healthcare programmes, which are seen as providing more of a role for women. That is starting to change and we really welcome that. We have a number of men in primary healthcare programmes right across the country. If we were to get extra funding, we could employ more. We do need to look at this because there is something there. There is a gap, I suppose, where men who might traditionally have been the recyclers or doing physical work have not been allowed to continue.
Comment on this
It has to a certain extent but it is not about that. It is the access to supports for the men who were involved in that. Being able to access supports which would get them formally up and running-----
Comment on this
Mr. Collins was making the point about the challenge that men in the Travelling community are finding in defining their role and participation in the wider community and society. I am just speculating but was it easier because the type of work Ms McDonnell was talking about was nearly formal ad hoc and they did not have direct employment?
Comment on this
Has regulation and so on harmed the participation on the Travelling community in those types of employment sectors?
Comment on this
Historically, that is exactly how it operated. What we dubbed the Traveller economy, and there was a lot of research on this, was very informal in nature. You would engage in recycling, selling a horse or doing a bit of market trading as a way of supplementing your social welfare payments which are not sufficient to live on, and even more so now than in previous years because of the cost of living and inflation. That was the mindset and the culture. It was very informal. It was to supplement your social welfare payments. The context has changed because of regulation, policies and so forth. Travellers are struggling to adjust to that and will need support to do that. Some Travellers have transitioned from the so-called informal economy to formalising their business with public liability insurance, making tax returns and have an accountant doing their paperwork. Some Travellers are running really successful businesses. That shows it is possible.
However, I think there is something really interesting and profound. I am not a sociologist, far from it, but for other men, because it has been passed down and become intergenerational, it is difficult to break that kind of mindset and culture to make that transition, particularly in the early days of setting up a business where you might lose your secondary benefits like medical cards. If that is taken away, then there are medical expenses. There needs to be incentives to make that transition incremental and as smooth as it possibly can so that people do not fall off a cliff edge. Stopping informal activity that is supplementing social welfare and setting up a formal business with everything that is associated with that can be quite intimidating especially when, as I said, it is intergenerational.
I operated in the informal economy with my father. We did the markets - we called it hawking - and went door-to-door selling goods. My father got that from his father. That culture and mindset becomes embedded and perhaps almost stagnant and it is hard to make the transition but it is possible and some Traveller families have done it and are running very successful businesses.
Comment on this
We are also seeing a transition of the younger men within the community. A lot of them are involved in apprenticeships now. We have got plumbers, carpenters, painters and whatever else. There is that switch among the younger generation but, as Mr. Collins said, the cohort in the middle is kind of-----
Comment on this
On that point, we have asked the Department of further and higher education about that. I believe that Traveller apprenticeship programme is still in a pilot phase. It should be mainstreamed and it should be guaranteed funding annually. Hopefully, it will get to that point soon.
Comment on this
If the committee has not done so already, I am sure it will be inviting in the other Traveller organisations and the Irish Traveller Movement which co-ordinates and runs that project. It will be in a better position to answer some of the questions with the detail the Deputy is looking for. On the face of it, it is a very promising and successful initiative and it could be replicated and built upon.
Comment on this
I have two more questions, if that is okay with the Chair. The difference in completion levels of secondary education among the general population and members of the Travelling community is stark. It is 97% in the general population and 27% of the Travelling community. How are we going to challenge that? I think it is important to challenge it. Everyone benefits from completing second level education. I wonder how we can challenge that.
Comment on this
We definitely need to challenge it. We are seeing slight improvements in retention of Traveller children in school but we need to see more. We should not be sitting here and talking about 27% in comparison with 97% of a population. It is a community that is very educated in a sense, whether that is with life learning, but the most important thing for us is, as Mr. Collins said, that there is a strategy there with the Traveller and Roma education strategy. It is midway, so it is actually very new. That will go towards looking at how we can address some of the challenges faced by Travellers in staying in school but we have to be realistic. Travellers, while at school, can face a lot of discrimination and racism. I have experienced it first hand. A family member of mine was received a very racist comment while she was in school from a teacher, and it was not that long ago. We have to be realistic about it. We have teachers who go through years of training who should not be coming out with derogatory comments in any way. As Mr. Collins said, we are seeing improvements. The Traveller and Roma education strategy will some way to addressing that and removing the barriers.
A lot of Travellers are seeing the benefit of staying on in education but we need to seriously address it.
Comment on this
I have one last question. I do not think we have seen the Department of Health report on the Traveller health projects. When was it published?
Comment on this
It was published in 2026. I can get a copy sent.
Comment on this
I am not sure if we have seen it. We have done a lot of sessions on the health inequalities and what the determinants of poor outcomes for the Travelling community are.
Comment on this
Two things about the service concern me. On where it is not functioning, do the witnesses have any idea how many locations or where in the country this is the case? My other concern, among all the witnesses have listed, is the aspect that it is nearly a 24-7 job and you are only paid for 15 hours a week.
Comment on this
It is a 24-7 job. The community health workers are all Travellers. As I said, we have a very small minority of men within it and we would welcome more but these workers do not switch off. When you go home you are living in the community and you are part of the community. We do not have to talk about the suicide rate as we know how high it is. When a crisis like the one we recently saw happens the community health workers are the first on the scene to try to support the families, especially if something happens over a weekend when we do not have access to HSE staff or whatever. Traveller community health workers do not switch off. It is a 24-7 job. You could be in a supermarket and somebody might ask you if they can come down to you so you can help them fill out a form.
Comment on this
Yes. If any group of people should have an appreciation of the challenge of that it is public representatives.
Comment on this
It is something we should look into more.
Comment on this
There have been improvements, which are welcome, like what has happened recently in relation to work progression and planning for the workforce, but acknowledgement of the work community health workers do is something that is vital to them.
Comment on this
I thank Ms McDonnell and Mr. Collins for their input. It is very important that we increase the number of people who are getting educated. The key to improving the employment prospects of everyone is starting at a young age, developing people and getting people into employment. Education is going to be so important and it is something that needs to be concentrated on. It is so disappointing that while the employment figure for Travellers has gone up, it has gone up so slowly. At this rate we will be here for a long time. Entrepreneurship and people working for themselves need to be concentrated on more, especially in the Traveller community. There are a lot of people who have skills and they need to be identified and targeted. It is very important.
We talk about the State and the different State bodies and their approach. They are supposedly promoting - and in a lot of cases they are - getting Travellers into those bodies. I wonder though about the Googles and Ryanairs of this world. Are all these big companies being targeted enough? There is the likes of the pharmaceutical industry. All of these are huge employers in different areas but are they being targeted enough? Is it being left to the State bodies? Someone needs to be targeting these big companies to see whether there is any scope for them to take on people. If they do not, they should give an explanation. The companies should be questioned on whether they have members of the Traveller community working in them. We should highlight that if they are not. It is very important.
There was talk about the number of people employed, with 25% being women and 19% being men, but how many people with disabilities are being looked after? If we are struggling with ordinary people in the Traveller community, then those with disabilities must be really struggling and I do not know whether we have any idea what that entails.
We have been talking about Travellers. The Roma community are discriminated against in an awful way, even more so than the Traveller community. I do not know if we have any idea how many from the Roma community are employed. It just seems we are in the dark a bit about that. I am not sure whether Ms McDonnell and Mr. Collins can comment on some of those things I have just said.
Comment on this
Earlier I made reference to the Fundamental Rights Agency report on the experience of discrimination and racism. I have not got it with me but it gives some statistics on the experience of racism by the Roma community in Ireland. The scale of that racism is huge and that is of great concern. There is no doubt they experience discrimination in education and in trying to access employment, just like Travellers do.
On the high-tech companies, in the past Pavee Point did some anti-racism and diversity and inclusion training with the HR people in some of these companies. The issue here really is the lack of resources and capacity to drive this forward. We have the primary healthcare workers and the education community development workers, though not as many as we would like. However, we do not have employment community development workers whose full-time job would be pushing the doors to create employment opportunities for Travellers and Roma. To make this happen and happen effectively, the capacity of the Traveller organisations would need to be increased to have more of a focus on driving this. The Galway Traveller Movement has been very successful in setting up Bounce Back Recycling, which is a very successful recycling project as a social enterprise. It really is flying. ITM has secured some resources around the apprenticeship programme. Other than that I am not aware of any Traveller organisation getting dedicated supports to employ somebody, so that needs to happen just like we have done in the arenas of accommodation, health, education and so forth. If the committee was minded to make a conclusion or recommendation in that regard it would be important.
Was there another question there?
Comment on this
I was also wondering about people who have disabilities in the Traveller community.
Comment on this
That is a really good point because the rate of disability in the community is very high. I spoke about the development of a national Traveller employment training enterprise strategy. It needs to adopt, as the Deputy rightly pointed out, an intersectional approach in terms of gender, age and disability and how these interact and relate to each other. It is an important point.
Comment on this
Pavee Point has received some funding from the National Disability Authority to do some research on Travellers and disability. It will be interesting to see. It is only happening now so we probably will not have the results until some time next year, but it will be interesting to see what comes out of that, depending on the uptake we get on the research.
Comment on this
Yes. I just feel there is a gap. We have the State companies that are taking on apprentices and different groups looking at doing that.
It is great to see that a number of apprenticeships are being created. However, the gap between the private sector and the State is huge and needs to be addressed. We need something dedicated to deal with that. We have all these big companies like IKEA and the pharmaceuticals that are not being brought to task over employment in terms of the Traveller community or minority communities. It should be the case that they are.
Comment on this
This has been a very good first meeting on the employment module of the committee's work. Not just having targets but actually targeting is crucial, particularly in the public service. We can tell local authorities that it must be within their remit to target young people, in particular, within the Traveller community in terms of employment. They should go out and deliberately look for people to enter and be part of the workforce in local authorities and Government Departments that are spread throughout the country. Years ago, all the Departments were in Dublin but then we had decentralisation. We now have agencies, bodies and groups across every town and in many villages.
Mr. Collins made a very valuable and obvious point when he spoke about the number of regulations and measures brought in that have had a disproportionate impact on the Traveller community in terms of casual trading, control of horses and recycling. He spoke about hawking. I remember as a young lad going to school that there was not a week when a Traveller family was not visiting the houses in my estate selling stuff. I do not think there was a suite a furniture in our house that was not purchased from the Traveller community. All that is gone now, all that door-to-door stuff. It had another, social impact. We built up a relationship with the Traveller community and Traveller people that is removed now. We would meet them after matches and there was a much closer link and bond as a result. The social aspect of the relationship has also been impacted. On casual trading and control of horses, the town I come from was not particularly a place for horse-trading but I can see where Mr. Collins is coming from and how that impacted on the Traveller community. Of course, we are all recycling now but the Traveller community was doing it for decades. This has been a really good start to the module. I thank our guests for coming in and sharing their views. Their points will certainly form part of our report. It has been most welcome.
Comment on this
As a final point on the whole area of role modelling, Travellers who gain employment through targeted initiatives have an obligation back to the community. Pavee Point has always maintained this. As Ms McDonnell said earlier, if you cannot see it, you cannot be it. It is about role modelling and visibility of those who access employment through a targeted, affirmative action measure. There are many Travellers who I am sure have gained employment of their own volition and do not need the support or assistance of a Traveller organisation, and fair dues to them. They get employment in the mainstream labour force and good luck to them. However, for Travellers and Roma who do avail of a positive action measure, inherently in that measure, in my opinion, there is an obligation back to the community in terms of role modelling and visibility to encourage and inspire the next generation that is coming through.
I note that the committee will be inviting the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, IHREC, in at some stage. There is a legal framework around public sector duty, whereby publicly-funded bodies have a legal obligation to promote human rights and equality of opportunity in how they deliver services, and also in their composition as institutions. I am sure IHREC will speak more about that. There is not just a moral obligation to make sure our workplaces are much more inclusive and diverse, and that we get fresh ideas and perspectives from a range of people, there is also a legal obligation.