Decisions on Public Petitions Received
The committee agreed to publish petitions and official replies, close petitions on Common Travel Area travel and learner-driver accompaniment, and seek HIQA and Children’s Department input on section 19 safeguards. Replies on communications-data retention, fuel tax and dog-breeding caps will be sent to petitioners for comment within 14 days. It also agreed to hear views on a cap on female breeding dogs, with the aim of informing forthcoming legislation.
The committee is now in public session. I now have to read some formal notices. I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the place where Parliament has chosen to sit, namely, Leinster House, in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting.
I propose that the petitions considered by the committee at this meeting and previous meetings will be published and that the replies from Departments and other bodies will also be published. Is that agreed? Agreed.
P00005/25 relates to a travel grievance for short stay and tourism purposes within the common travel area, CTA, for residents. We have correspondence from the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration. Based on the correspondence from the Department, the manner in which it has confirmed that this matter cannot be progressed, and the fact it has no plans to make alterations along the lines suggested by the petitioner, I propose we close that petition. Is that agreed? Agreed.
P00065/25 relates to safeguards for section 19 supervision orders. It has been submitted by Mr. Stephen Bernard McElligott. We have correspondence from the petitioner. The proposal is that we will forward that to HIQA for comment as requested by the petitioner. We will make our decision on how to proceed on the basis of the response from HIQA, along with the petition that was submitted. I know Senator McCarthy had raised an issue with regard to children in family hubs and whether they are covered. I invite him to ask his question.
Comment on this
The issue is that section 19 allows Tusla to monitor children within their home environments. Through my work with Tiglin, we deal with many families in family hubs, and one or two of the parents might have addiction issues. I am wondering if section 19 allows Tusla to engage through family hubs. The petitioner does not cover that aspect, but I think there is a strong basis for supporting that.
Comment on this
On the basis that there is a question and we are not sure, we will get the answer to that. That will form part of our deliberations and, going forward, will inform us as to the extent to which we will proceed with this. Apparently, it covers those children who are living in emergency accommodation and family hubs, but we might get something specific in writing just to make it clear. Is that okay?
Comment on this
The petition is for HIQA. Can the Department of children also be brought before the committee so we can add it to the petition?
Comment on this
The Senator is right. The Department of children is definitely a party to this. That is agreed.
P00072/25 relates to extending communications data retention for critical evidence. We have a response from the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration. The proposal is that we will publish that response, and it will be forwarded to the petitioner for her comment within 14 days. Is that agreed? Agreed.
P00016/26 relates to amending learner driver accompaniment requirements. It comes from Ms Samantha Smith. The response from the Department of Transport states that having regard to the legislative framework, the available road safety evidence and the importance of maintaining high driver licensing standards, the Department does not propose to amend the current policy at this time. The Department has said it is not looking at this and that it is not an area about which it intends to make any changes. On that basis and because the reply from the Department was unequivocal, I propose we close this petition. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
What happens with learner drivers in other jurisdictions? It would be good to compare what is happening in other jurisdictions regarding learner drivers and if there is a precedent for that.
Comment on this
We can certainly ask the Department for its views on that.
P00048/26 relates to the immediate reduction of fuel tax to protect workers and families. It has been submitted by Mr. Manoj Panda. The response from the Department of Finance outlines in detail what the Department believes it is doing in terms of helping workers and families, specifically around the fuel tax. I am not sure if that response is going to be enough for the petitioner. Having said that, he is entitled to receive the response and come back to us within 14 days. That response from the Department of Finance will be sent on to the petitioner, and we will be available to receive his comments within a fortnight. Is that agreed? Agreed.
P000055/26 relates to a cap on the number of female dogs legally kept in dog breeding establishments. It has been submitted by Mairín Ní Chonghaile. We have a response from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. The proposal is that we would publish this and get a response from the petitioner within 14 days.
Comment on this
This is an important issue because it goes to the heart of dog and animal welfare. We had the Department of agriculture before us last week. It admitted that its figures were all over the place and inaccurate. The Department had never visited a dog breeding establishment, which is extraordinary for people who are planning to prepare legislation on this issue. Science and international research have determined that puppies born in mass production, non-domestic environments are statistically more likely to develop moderate and severe behavioural issues. If a puppy has been kept in a dark shed for the first eight weeks of its life and fed by trough, it is not going to develop in the way it would develop if it was born and brought up in a caring, warm family setting. They are family pets, and they should be treated like that. I have been speaking to behaviourists. There is a big increase in resource guarding in puppies that come from these large puppy farms. There is a dog breeding establishment in Cavan that has a licence for 300 breeding females in one dog breeding establishment, or as many would say, a puppy farm. That puppy farm-----
Comment on this
Sorry, Senator. I am going to stop you there because I am reasonably confident that the person who runs the establishment would not use that term. I accept that is your term. I want to be fair to people who are not here.
Comment on this
Many people would refer to it as a puppy farm. With 300 female dogs breeding, it is very hard to see it as anything else. Those puppies are being born into battery production, and there are obviously going to be behavioural issues. The Department of agriculture is undertaking to introduce legislation and is putting together a report. If we heard from the petitioner, it would be a good way of informing that report.
I know that a lot of the groups that were here spoke about introducing a cap. Some are opposed to a cap, but there has to be alignment with the policy and legislation north of the Border and with the EU directives coming in. I did not get any sense from the Department of agriculture officials who were here that they had any sense of the problems that will come from poor legislation. I think a cap is essential. There has to be a cap, and it has to be in line with the cap that will be introduced north of the Border. Here in the South, there is a plan for a 25:1 dog-to-staff ratio, whereas in the North, it is going to be a 10:1 ratio. We are going to be a pull or an attraction for an increasing number of dog breeding establishments, puppy farms or whatever we want to call them. It would be a good opportunity to hear from the petitioner and then, whatever happens with the petition, we can feed that back into the Department of agriculture, which is undertaking really important legislation.
Comment on this
Senator Andrews makes a good point, notwithstanding the intervention that I had to make, so long as what we are doing can reasonably feed into that legislation. We do not want to lead the petitioner down a path where there is not going to be any productive value. The Senator is right. If we have that session, we can use it to feed into what is going on in the Department of agriculture. I am also mindful that we are awaiting a hearing with the Minister for justice. We have corresponded with him to provide a range of dates on which that hearing can happen.
I think it is important that it does happen. It is a separate but related matter. While the petition is to put a cap in place, I am aware there are views among people that a cap would be counterproductive, and we need to hear from those people as well. I note Senator Andrews' contention that officials have not visited dog breeding establishments. There might be scope for us, as a committee, to do that. That is something we can pursue at a later date. I take the Senator's point on board, and the committee would be happy to hear from the petitioner, but on the understanding that we can feed into that legislation and send information to the Department of agriculture and the committee specifically handling the pre-legislative scrutiny on this, because if we cannot, I do not see much point in it. I do think it would be useful to join up those things.
Comment on this
I agree with my colleague, Senator Andrews. I know that the committee on agriculture said that a hard cap on dog breeding was left out of the draft heads and terms. I wonder whether there is a legal issue there. I know it is still under consideration. Any right-minded person would want some form of a cap. The petitioner also put in a second request that there should be mandatory behavioural welfare oversight. What is the committee's view on that? It was not addressed here today.
Comment on this
No, and the main thrust of the petition is around the cap. The request for the cap comes from a place of welfare and concern. Nobody who has read the petition could dispute that it is a concern for animal welfare that is driving it. We also have to be mindful that there are people who do hold a contrary view. We have to hear from both sides of this.
Comment on this
I agree it is important we hear the other side. There is an opportunity. We heard a different view at the agriculture committee. The Department officials said they were working on best practice and research from other jurisdictions. The difficulty is that their view is not backed up with science. They said they had done research. The research was actually wrong in relation to the country. I think they said people in Australia had done research and that they were following that example. In Australia, they have changed the legislation since the time the Department was referring to. We can talk about scientists and science, but nobody will convince me or, I imagine, the vast majority of people, that any dog breeding establishment that has 20, 30, 40 or 50 breeding females is good for animal welfare. You do not need to be a scientist to realise that is complete nonsense. People will talk about science. Ordinary people and the vast majority of people know that being brought up in a shed in the dark and being trough-fed is not good for any pup that is then going to have to come into a home with all sorts of attractions. One does not need to be a scientist to know large dog breeding establishments are bad for animal welfare and bad for dog welfare.
Comment on this
I am going to stop Senator Andrews there. He knows not every establishment is necessarily working against the interests of animal welfare, and I know he is not inferring that. I appreciate this is an issue he is very passionate about. I absolutely respect that but we have to be fair to people who are not here and, in my job as Cathaoirleach, I want to make sure we are fair to people. I completely respect Senator Andrews' experience and passion on this issue, but we also need to be careful that we do not let the issue get hijacked by people who may have a contrary view, which they are perfectly entitled to. That is the purpose of the hearing. It will ventilate that. That is why it is important.
Comment on this
It is good to have an alternative point of view heard. I personally believe that anybody with 30 or 40 breeding females on site is not good. There is no alternative view or science that can suggest that is good. Anybody with ten, 15 or 20 females is only interested in money. That is my personal view.
Comment on this
That is, indeed, your personal view, and on that basis, we will be issuing an invitation. Everyone is entitled to their personal view. Invitations will issue so we can get a full and clear picture, which is important, and only on the proviso that we can reasonably make a contribution to the good work being done at the agriculture committee. Are we agreed on that? Agreed.
That concludes our consideration of public petitions for this morning. I invite members of the public to submit petitions via our online portal, which is available at petitions.oireachtas.ie. A petition may be addressed to the Houses of the Oireachtas on a matter of general public concern or interest or an issue of public policy. Do members have any further issues they wish to raise? No. There being no further issues, the committee is adjourned until Tuesday, 20 October at 11 a.m.