We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Tourism, Culture, Arts, Sport and Media

Expert Advisory Committee Reports into RTÉ: Raidió Teilifís Éireann

Contributions 1–172 of 521. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Colleagues and guests are all welcome here this evening. It is a late shift. We call this the graveyard shift in Leinster House, but I am sure attendees do not mind being here with us this hour of the evening. We have received apologies from Deputy Christopher O'Sullivan and Senators Shane Cassells and Fintan Warfield. Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh is substituting for Deputy Chris Andrews - she is very welcome - and Senator Timmy Dooley is substituting for Senator Cassells.

The committee is meeting tonight with representatives of RTÉ to discuss the reports of the expert advisory committee commissioned by the Minister, Deputy Catherine Martin, on governance and culture in RTÉ, contract fees, human resources and other matters in RTÉ; the recommendations made therein; and RTÉ’s implementation plans for the recommendations made. We have many new things to talk about as well.

I warmly welcome RTÉ’s interim leadership team. With us this evening are Kevin Bakhurst, director general; Adrian Lynch, director of audiences, channels and marketing and deputy director general; Mr. Mike Fives, group financial controller; Mr. Richard Waghorn, director of operations and technology; Ms Vivienne Flood, head of public affairs, who is no stranger to this room either; Ms Niamh O’Connor, deputy director of content; Mr. Gavin Deans, director of commercial; Ms Deirdre McCarthy, director of news and current affairs; Ms Eimear Cusack, director of human resources; and Mr. Daniel Coady, director of legal affairs.

The committee welcomes all the witnesses and we look forward to discussing the recommendations made by the expert advisory committee and to hear from RTÉ how it will seek to address the recommendations made on the foot of the recent publication and its implementation plan. The format of the meeting is that I will invite the director general to deliver an opening statement, which is limited to three minutes. This will then be followed by questions from members of committee. As witnesses are probably aware, the committee may publish the opening statement on its web page.

Before we proceed to the opening statements, I wish to explain some limitations in relation to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. Witnesses are again reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

With all the housekeeping out of the way, which I am sure attendees could ream off themselves at this stage, I propose we proceed to Mr. Bakhurst to deliver his opening statement. The floor is his.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I thank the committee for its invitation to attend this evening. After a challenging year for the organisation, in which we continued to deal with the fallout from the events of last year, we welcome the opportunity to discuss RTÉ’s future. Having previously explored the various issues of the last year in depth, I know the committee is especially focused on how RTÉ will reform, in particular our implementation of the recommendations of the expert advisory committee. As the committee members are aware, last week we published a comprehensive outline of the various ways in which RTÉ will address the 90 recommendations arising from these two reports.

Our progress will be monitored by an oversight group set up by the Department of Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media. I assure the committee that this work will build on a wide-ranging and comprehensive programme of governance and cultural reform which is already well under way.

Since July 2023, there have been substantial changes to the leadership team. We have made a number of new appointments to key roles following several public competitions. There have also been changes to the composition of the board, and there are new protocols in place to ensure the leadership team properly apprise the board of all relevant information. As director general, I now provide a full written monthly report to the board; all minutes from the meetings of the interim leadership team are now submitted for review by the team; and there is increased and regular communication between the board and the leadership team on all corporate activity. I have provided the committee with a more comprehensive list of the actions taken since my appointment.

We have published a new governance framework, which will we continue to review and develop. We have also given due priority to better standards of engagement with our colleagues. Since July 2023, the director general and representatives from the interim leadership team have maintained an ongoing dialogue with representatives from the trade union group, TUG. I hold monthly town hall briefings on a range of key organisational issues. RTÉ is embarking on a substantial programme of change, and we are resolved that this will happen in a collaborative and open manner with the various staff groups, including the newly formed staff engagement group. Our staff will play a key role in our transformation. I again put on record my thanks to them for their work and commitment to the organisation over the past year. It is thanks to the efforts of our people that RTÉ has continued to deliver a high-quality public media service for Ireland, and achieved exceptional impacts and audience connection over the past year.

In early June, coverage of the 2024 elections drew significant engagement with RTÉ radio, television and online services. Total news traffic online hit 16.4 million page views over the election weekend, significantly higher than the previous elections in 2019. Enjoyment of RTÉ's free-to-air sports coverage continues to be exceptionally strong, be that the GAA, the coverage of the Euros, or Ireland's performance in the European Athletics Championships in Rome. RTÉ Player has this month seen some of the highest viewing figures ever on the platform. The UEFA European Football Championship 2024 began on Friday, 14 June, and there have been more than 3 million streams across 32 games on RTÉ Player. That is approximately 3.5 times higher than the equivalent average in the previous European Football Championship in 2021. It is proof that, in this digital era of public broadcasting, RTÉ is not only relevant, but highly sought.

RTÉ's most recent investigative report into horse welfare standards garnered significant reaction, including at an international level, and it is likely this important programme will prompt further action. The annual Reuters "Digital News Report 2024" for Ireland revealed that public trust in RTÉ news coverage has increased by 1% since last year, despite what the report described as recent turbulence within RTÉ. At 72%, the report said that RTÉ News and The Irish Times remain the two most trusted media outlets in Ireland. These successes and our commitment to reform reflect a much broader ambition: that RTÉ's delivery for the people is strengthened and reimagined. Across almost 100 years, RTÉ has played an invaluable role in the evolution of Ireland's national identity, language and culture. RTÉ has empowered the public and the public discourse through debate, discussion and the provision of independent, essential information. RTÉ has built a broader sense of connection and community. All these elements are at the core of our new strategy, and our focus on digital transformation and financial sustainability is there to ensure these vital roles for Ireland's national public service media are not only maintained but thrive.

It is very important to be clear what this new strategy is, and also what it is not. I am aware there are some allegations that our increased commitment to commissioned content is some form of privatisation of a public good. That is simply untrue. Working in partnership with the creative sector has been a long-standing obligation in the provision of public service media, both for RTÉ and TG4. Our intention to do more with the sector is reflective of national policy, our statutory obligations, and the recommendations of the Future of Media Commission report. Many of our most-watched programmes, be they factual documentaries such as "Birdsong" or popular programmes such as "Dancing with the Stars", are made in partnership with the independent sector. We are focused on delivering more of the kind of content our audiences most value through a blend of in-house and commissioned content. This will allow us to strengthen Ireland's creative production sector while protecting the unique public service that is RTÉ. The prohibitive cost of maintaining RTÉ's significant existing ageing infrastructure means RTÉ will be a smaller organisation by the end of the strategy period. However, RTÉ will remain the largest content creator in the country by far and will continue to produce tens of thousands of in-house hours of live and recorded audio and video programming. We will retain 1,400 roles within the organisation, and there will be opportunities for staff to explore new roles and opportunities, supported by training and development where necessary. The reduction in staff numbers over the five years ahead will be achieved through a voluntary exit programme, with all relevant approvals. RTÉ has been operating with deficits for many years at this point, long before the licence fee crisis in 2023. With an aged building stock in need of large-scale investment and a workforce of a significant scale, the need to take corrective action has become very clear. We also urgently need to invest in digital products such as upgrading the RTÉ Player, the news app and a new audio app.

Some previous strategic plans have failed because they did not go far enough in terms of the reforms needed structurally to achieve sustainability into the future. This plan does go further because it must to secure the future of the 1,400 people who will still be here; to secure our services; and to protect public service media for the audiences of the future. I am confident the New Direction plan is the best way forward for RTÉ and offers not only the best value for money for our audience but also the most effective way RTÉ can remain viable, relevant and thrive. The New Direction strategy is about ensuring the future and the relevance of a transformed RTÉ. It is about delivering a strong and independent public service, available to everyone. It is about creating a trusted organisation delivering for Irish audiences. It is about backing creative ambition and digital innovation, supporting Irish culture, and bringing people together. It is about reflecting Ireland and supporting the creative industry across the island. It is a plan based on the core values of public service. We are determined to build a strong, modern RTÉ that will play a defining role in Irish life, an RTÉ that Ireland will be proud of, and one that will deliver a better outcome for the public we serve.

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. Bakhurst very much. My colleagues have been furnished with a speaking rota. First, we have Senator Carrigy. The floor is his. He has ten minutes.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. Following the publication of the report, we understand the Department released the first tranche of interim funding, in the region of €20 million, ultimately of taxpayers' money. Will Mr. Bakhurst tell us what exactly that is for?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Is that the €20 million?

Comment on this

Yes. What will it be spent on?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We can confirm we received that money yesterday. It is to make up the shortfall in TV licences which help fund our range of services across the organisation. The funding is used for current affairs, drama, and continued investment in technology. We are already investing in the RTÉ Player this year. We are also rolling out training and development opportunities to staff. It is about funding business as usual and making sure we can maintain our public commitments in terms of the delivery of programming.

Comment on this

Corporate governance has been at the core of our interaction with RTÉ and it is the reason we are here, 15 months later, following numerous meetings. The word "new" is in the name of the plan, and we see a lot of new faces here that were not here 15 months ago. What measures have been put in place to guarantee to the public, us, the taxpayer, and the licence payers that the corporate governance structure in RTÉ is fit for purpose going forward?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We put a range of measures in place. They are all listed in the annexe. The key changes are that, first, we have, as the Senator says, new leadership at the top of the organisation. Second, we have a much more transparent and open relationship between the interim leadership team and the board. I speak to the new chair extremely regularly - several times a week. We discuss everything. There is nothing left to discuss. We have a new company secretary in place who makes sure everything that is discussed at the leadership team is reported to the board. I furnish the board with a written report from the DG for every board meeting, which did not happen before I arrived. It is a comprehensive view of what has been going on and the significant events across the organisation, both the corporate events but also financial and programming, and content highlights as well.

Those are the main changes that have been brought in, but there is a list of about 70 or 80 smaller changes that have been brought in across the organisation to make it more transparent and more robust and to make us more accountable.

The other changes we have brought in relate to staff engagement. As Senator Carrigy will know, there was a criticism before that we did not properly engage with staff. As outlined in my opening statement, there is considerable staff engagement. That includes regular town halls, which the team and I go to and at which we discuss the main events with staff and take questions. Those are normally once a month or once every six weeks. There are regular communications from me via email; I think some members of staff might say too regular. We have surveyed staff to get their feedback on what it is like to work at RTÉ and we will repeat that survey to make sure we are improving. I set up a new staff engagement group, which was open to anybody in the organisation to join. It meets with me approximately once a month. Actually, whenever it wants to meet, it asks to meet and we arrange that. Everything is potentially on the agenda for those meetings. We have new people in place in key roles. We have a new head of commercial. As the Senator can see, Mr. Deans is here. We have just appointed a new CFO, who will arrive in September after serving out her period of notice. Mike Fives has been standing in as the CFO until Mari Hurley arrives.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst mentioned staff engagement. Probably all our members here have received a significant number of emails over the past 24 hours from staff and people representing various elements of the staff and the organisation. There does not seem to be a lot of staff engagement there with regard to some of the proposals. Quite drastic proposals are being put forward, for example, a 50% increase in commissioning spend and new regional commitments. On the latter, Mr. Bakhurst mentions commitments to Limerick and Galway, but does that include the other studios? I refer to Athlone and Sligo. They do not seem to be mentioned. Mr. Bakhurst might flesh out the commitment to those studios. As regards the reduction in the number of staff by up to 400, it is very difficult in any organisation to achieve figures like that if there is not going to be staff engagement, so Mr. Bakhurst might flesh out what staff engagement means and what amount of staff engagement took place in putting this report together.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

There has been extensive staff engagement, as the Senator will be aware. First of all, we published the framework for the strategy in November. That was available to everyone, and the key pillars of the strategy were in that framework and were made publicly available. We had a town hall at that point to discuss it with staff and take feedback. We then did a very wide consultation which involved not only members of the public and key stakeholders but also, for the first time ever, all members of staff, so we got their feedback. The feedback in that consultation from the public, the stakeholders and the staff was extremely positive about the main pillars of the strategy. In the document we published this week, those pillars are still there. The document gave a lot more detail and a timeline but, between publishing in November and this timeline, a significant number of staff have been involved in specific areas in developing the strategy. There has therefore been extensive staff engagement. Obviously, we are aware of some of the comments made in particular by some of the unions about that. We met with the unions before we published the strategy document and we met with the managers' association and with a new group we have set up of senior managers, about 90 managers, across the organisation. That was all on the day before we published the strategy. There has therefore been very extensive staff engagement.

I realise this will be a really important part of delivering this strategy because this is about ensuring the future of the organisation and the futures of 1,400 people who will be there. We understand that 400 people will be leaving, but I should emphasise that, first, we have said repeatedly that that will be through voluntary exits; second, it will be done over a period of five years; and third, we have about 186 people due to retire in that period to start with. The previous two voluntary exit schemes we opened up saw in excess of 400 applications and we let many fewer than that go. People have a high level of interest in taking the opportunity to leave the organisation because there are a lot of opportunities outside that they want.

Lastly, we made it very clear that part of the strategy is about investing in staff and providing training and learning for people in order that they can choose to move around if there are appropriate alternative jobs inside the organisation.

Comment on this

In a one-word answer, is Mr. Bakhurst confident those 400 exits can be achieved through the voluntary measures?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes, we are confident. It will not be easy, but we are pretty confident, looking at the time period and the numbers as I have just set them out.

Comment on this

I mentioned that we have been discussing this here for 15 months. There are probably still some unanswered questions because individuals who should be able to answer those questions are not here and have not appeared here, despite having been written to by the committee. I will ask about one in particular. Is Jim Jennings still on official sick leave as an employee of the organisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

He has been on sick leave for most of the year and is still employed by us at the moment.

Comment on this

Is there any reason he cannot come to an Oireachtas committee meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

He has had clear medical advice from his consultant. I have spoken to him about this. I do not want to go into personal things. I am happy to do that privately but he has had very significant and very clear medical advice about stress being an important issue as far as his medical condition is concerned. I do not hesitate to believe him because it is not a new thing. He is, however, very apologetic. He would like to come before a committee - he has said that - but he has had really clear medical advice. I was supportive of him in following that medical advice.

Comment on this

That is understandable, but why should we be offering a very generous exit package? Mr. Bakhurst might say something on that. I do not think we should to somebody whom we, as an Oireachtas committee, have asked to come here to discuss an important part of what we have spent the past 15 months talking about. He has not come in, notwithstanding medical advice. Should RTÉ, as an organisation, be offering him a generous exit package? Figures I have heard bandied about include €400,000. Mr. Bakhurst might confirm what it is. Is it his view that it is correct that that should be paid while that individual has not come in here to the Oireachtas committee to answer questions from us, the representatives of the people, the taxpayer?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

As regards the details the Senator talks about, I do not think it has been confirmed whom that package is for. I know Terence O'Rourke was asked about it at a previous committee hearing. I think he said as much as he could. All I can say about that process, which is still ongoing with the individual, is that it has ended up in the WRC because we were unable to do a deal early on. They went to the WRC and, as the Senator will understand, because it has gone to the WRC, I am very limited in what I can say about it. I sorry about that.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst is under privilege here, so-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes, but that privilege does not override potential criminal prosecution as regards confidentiality of the WRC, unfortunately.

Comment on this

What is Mr. Bakhurst's view? Is it correct that someone who is on sick leave and has been called in to us should-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I am not going to talk about that. It would not be fair to talk about it. The Senator is trying to align the two things. All I will say is that the process we are going through has been through the exact proper process as outlined and recommended in the expert reports. We have taken legal advice. The matter has gone through the remuneration committee. It has gone through the board. We tried to arrive at a settlement but could not. The matter ended up in the WRC. We took legal advice throughout on it. As I think I said before, I personally do not like making payouts to people. However, the Senator will see from the new members of this team, and more new members are joining it, that there was an expectation I would change the senior team at RTÉ. I cannot deliver change to the organisation with the same team that was in place before. If you are to exit people from any organisation, as we have seen frequently recently in the newspapers across many organisations, public sector and commercial, there is no alternative. If you just try to get rid of them with the wrong process, you end up paying more in legal fees and costing the taxpayer more. I do not like paying out large sums of money but I have to live within Irish law in trying to change the organisation.

Comment on this

There are two people, I understand, now covering the role Mr. Jennings covered. What remuneration are they receiving individually or between the two, and are we getting better value for money, in Mr. Bakhurst's opinion?

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is your final question, Senator.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We will publish those salaries in the annual report. They are on similar money to the other people on the leadership team. As the Senator will know, we did not replace the head of strategy, so the leadership team has stayed the same size. I wanted to split that content role into two halves because the content area of RTÉ is significant in size - 800-plus - and I did not feel that one person was able to manage TV and radio and the player and the audio app and manage people properly and communicate with people properly.

This is going to be key to delivering the strategy for the future of the organisation. We needed to have two people driving those two areas, audio and video, so that we can deliver for audiences properly over the course of this strategy and drive forward into the future in an ambitious way.

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We will conclude that because we need to move on. Senator Malcolm Byrne has the floor for ten minutes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. It is fair to say that it has been a very difficult 12 months for everybody at RTÉ, but critical as part of this process is that we have a stronger RTÉ at the end of all of this, and I have confidence that we will. When Mr. Bakhurst first came before us, he said to judge him on results. With regard to the general direction of the organisation, I say well done to Mr. Bakhurst and his team. This does not mean we necessarily agree on everything, but I appreciate that it is a process of transformation in an organisation, and it is critical to involve all staff, as well as the audiences.

We cannot lose sight of the bigger picture in a digital age, and I welcome the greater commitment to digital. Having public service broadcasting will be important, and indeed that Irish voices and Irish stories continue to be told. The recent election coverage by RTÉ deserves praise. At this committee we have sometimes criticised the lack of coverage of minority sports. I have full praise for RTÉ's coverage of the European Athletics Championships in Rome. Speaking on international coverage and maintaining it, I welcome the appointment today of Tommy Meskill as London correspondent. He has been an excellent journalist around here and the fact that there is still a commitment to maintain a London correspondent is important.

We are obviously here to talk about the strategy, because this is ultimately how RTÉ will be judged. It cannot just be a report; there must also be implementation of that. I welcome the statement that was made regarding having a very vibrant content creation industry in Ireland. Ultimately, it is all about the content. Given what is going on within the Irish content creation sector more generally, do the witnesses believe that we will see a much bigger and stronger content creation sector in Ireland? I refer to pumping out content in terms of film, TV and drama, as well as public service broadcasting and being able to engage in the digital space.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes, I do. That is core to this strategy. I welcomed today the endorsement by Screen Producers Ireland, which is very important to us. I am very aware that we are building on great foundations. We work with many fantastic independent production companies already, as I have set out. More of our content is already produced by the independent sector around the island that people do not recognise, because we do not necessarily shout about it loudly enough. I have no doubt that an increase in spend in the independent sector, particularly if public funding is sorted out and we have a predictability of public funding, we can make multi-year deals with independents. It is very hard at present with them, because we have been living year to year. We are only able to sign a contract for a year on many of the programmes, which causes issues for the independents' abilities to make commitments to the people they employ or to find the right people.

Comment on this

Would it be fair to say that the numbers employed within the industry more generally will be up at the end of this period?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Mr. Lynch might like to answer that.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

There are two things about that. First, we need to talk about the creative sector in the context of inside and outside of RTÉ. RTÉ at the end of this period, in five years, will still be one of the biggest creators of television content in Ireland. We probably produce up to 2,000 hours. When it comes to the independent sector, for example, if we look at the average cost of a television drama hour, which Senator Byrne will be familiar with, it is about €1.2 million. We would be putting out a portion of that, but producers are also able to access money from the international market. It means from an audience point of view, for example, if €10 million is put in, with the quality that is delivered at an international level, it is probably €40 million that is returned to the audience.

For Ireland, look at the Future of Media Commission and think about the four things it pointed out that public service media does - independent journalism and bringing the nation together. The fourth one, being a platform as a public service media company, to provide a platform to export Irish culture to the world is a really important thing as well. When we think about the success of the animation companies in Ireland and Oscar nominees like Element Films, that kind of soft power in the world is very important.

Comment on this

It is fair to say that RTÉ is moving towards a publisher-broadcaster model. This is in the same way as we have seen Channel 4 and TG4 invest in partnership, as well as maintaining a lot of the core function.

Comment on this
Mr. Adrian Lynch

We are hybrid in that we will still be producing nearly 2,000 hours in RTÉ, between news and current affairs, sport and so on. For the hybrid model, it is working with our partners as we do now and expanding our spend as per the Future of Media Commission.

Comment on this

I want to ask about two specific programmes, which have obviously garnered a lot of attention, which are "Fair City" and "The Late Late Show". From the point of view of the viewing public, will they notice any difference? I appreciate it is still at an early stage, but where does RTÉ see those programmes being produced? It does not have to be a physical location, but how does it see the partnership working in both of those?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I should start by saying in both cases, this is part of a holistic strategy. We said we would not come to this committee and ask for €300 million to invest in the buildings that we would not potentially need. That is the figure we would need if we were to renovate all buildings on the site in order to do those programmes on-site. In the end, there was no choice about moving some of those big programmes off-site if we are not going to spend that kind of money on the infrastructure there.

The answer is that we said to both staff and in the strategy, that we will be moving those two programmes off-site at some point over the five years. They will be made in studios in and around Dublin. We have not settled on what exactly the arrangement will be. We said it the other day at the town hall and subsequently that we need to find out what the best model is. On "Fair City", for example, we did not want to start talking to the independents until we had first made a decision and then until we had told the staff and cast about it. We did not want it leaking out, as it so often does. I think the staff understood that.

In respect of audiences, it is important to say that "Fair City", for example, is critical to RTÉ. It is one of those unique programmes that performs well on RTÉ One and the RTÉ player. "Fair City" on its own, drives approximately 5% of the audience on the RTÉ player currently. It delivers for us and for audiences across platforms. Ms O'Connor and I met the "Fair City" cast last week straight after the announcement. They were on a day off, but approximately 30 people came in. We talked through why we were doing this, what the plans were and said that we would keep them fully involved and consulted throughout the process, which we will do. We also stated that we were ambitious for the programme. If there is a bespoke studio and lot for the programme, and if it is potentially being done with an independent, it is possible to sell it to other broadcasters and invest more money in it for production and so on. English language soaps do quite well. We are committed to the programme, and the audience may end up getting a better product in the long run.

It is different for "The Late Late Show". There is a much smaller team working on it and who rotate through it. There is the operations team in the studio, and a smaller production team also. Again, we will end up with a bigger studio that is able to accommodate more people for "The Late Late Show" and for "The Late Late Toy Show", which will be welcome. Audiences will get a better product, because that studio is too small and quite old. We have not invested in it enough over the years and the crew do an incredible job, against the odds, in making the show look great.

Comment on this

Key to implementation of this strategy is resolution on the funding issue. That seems to be written right throughout the report. There are no other reasons, aside from the funding, that RTÉ believes we cannot see implementation of this strategy.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We have tested this very thoroughly and behind what we have published, there are hundreds of pages of strategy. If there are any particular areas, this is the team that can talk about it. We have all been involved in drawing it up.

Comment on this

Let us talk about the funding strategy. By how much is licence fee income down in the 12-month period? We have seen a full-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

It is down 14%. That is the latest figure across the last six months.

Comment on this

Is RTÉ noticing any change in the trend?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

It goes up and down from week to week. Sometimes, it is dependent on how many committee hearings are held. If the committee makes this a good one, it will go up again next week.

Comment on this

Obviously, Mr. Bakhurst will be aware that our committee is this week publishing our report on the future of media. It is more than just a report on RTÉ. As Mr. Bakhurst will also be aware, we have been addressing this issue for a year and we will be talking in more general terms about the bigger picture in this regard. The Government will be moving to make a decision soon. Mr. Bakhurst has already expressed a view in respect of multiannual funding and our committee will be supporting a move towards the provision of such funding, which is critical for the sector. Is Mr. Bakhurst prepared to express a preference regarding the model that should be used?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

That would mean getting between the Tánaiste and the Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media, so I do not think so.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I am sorry, the serious answer is-----

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Senator has two more minutes. I am giving latitude.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I will try to be quick. The really important thing for us is the right level of funding. Our strategy is based on the recommendations of the Future of Media Commission in terms of funding and multiannual funding. Alongside this, it is important that our independence is guaranteed. In the context of these three factors, we genuinely do not have a preference. It is a matter for the Government and the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Without pre-empting our report, there may be an indication in it regarding a move to multiannual and increased funding when it is published tomorrow. Combined with RTÉ's strategy, does Mr. Bakhurst think it will be possible to leverage further funding, particularly through partnering with the independent sector?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes. I am totally sure of it. As Mr. Lynch said, drama is a great example of that. Irish drama is flying now, especially on the back of the success of "Kin" in the UK and "The Dry". There is a lot of demand. Dermot Horan, who represents us at international conferences, has been getting an extremely high level of investors looking to see if we are going to make the next "Kin" and if more dramas are available.

Comment on this

As an export product in terms of Irish content created, how large a market share or what sort of growth can be anticipated as a result of this strategic plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

It is hard to predict because it depends on the creative success. There is, though, an appetite now and programme sales are going very well for us now. People are keen to work with us, which is great.

Comment on this

The test will be if "Fair City" starts to be broadcast in Melbourne in the same way that "Neighbours" and "Home and Away" have been broadcast over here.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

That is what we are aiming for.

Comment on this

I welcome it. Turning to the external reports produced, I do not doubt the challenges these have presented to the organisation. Mr. Bakhurst is pretty confident that RTÉ will be able to meet all the recommendations. Does he have specific concerns about any of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No. Some are more complicated than others, as will be seen from the two reports. We are pretty confident about the vast majority of the recommendations. I think we said in our response that some of them need to be worked through. This is particularly the case concerning the recommendations relating to risk and compliance officers in the organisation. We want to do this properly and to be the best in class, so we have gone out and are engaging one of the big five accounting firms to advise on what implementing best practice looks like. We are confident we will do it but it may take a little time.

Comment on this

I have one final query.

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Senator has three seconds.

Comment on this

No exit packages exist other than the one for €400,000 we discussed previously. No other such exit packages are being negotiated or discussed.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

There are no others and I do not intend for there to be any. I have got to finish clearing out the old guard and bringing in the new guard. I am confident in the people I have appointed and retained.

Comment on this

Great. I thank Mr. Bakhurst.

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Senator Byrne. I am moving on to Deputy Munster, to whom I am giving 12 minutes.

Comment on this

A view has been expressed by many staff at RTÉ and by commentators that the New Direction strategy disproportionately affects workers on lower pay grades rather than those responsible for the mismanagement we have seen at RTÉ. Would Mr. Bakhurst like to comment on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I point out the number of departures of senior staff from the organisation in one way or another as a result of what happened last year. In terms of the strategy itself-----

Comment on this

In fairness, many of those senior staff left with big, hefty packages.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

In fairness, they did. That was the only way they could exit, but they did not want to exit, in most cases. Regarding the strategy itself, the view outlined by the Deputy is not the case. We have been in talks about the nature of the voluntary exit scheme and ensuring we can make it fair so people at all levels can leave the organisation as we reshape it. The impact will absolutely not all fall on lower-paid people. In fact, I think several senior people would be part of the plan to exit.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I return to the fact that this is entirely voluntary. I cannot emphasise this enough to the people in the organisation. It is important.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Bakhurst to explain the intention to privatise two flagship programmes, namely, "Fair City" and "The Late Late Show". For my own knowledge, what would it cost to dismantle the set of "Fair City" and rebuild it?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Ms O'Connor may wish to comment on this, but we will not be dismantling the set. We will have to rebuild a new one. We have already done it once and we would have to do it again in due course anyway.

Comment on this

If we are privatising the programme and it is going to be outsourced to a private independent company, will the set be left in situ and unused in RTÉ while another is built? What would the cost of this approach be?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh O'Connor

It would depend on the site secured. Some of the set would be able to be moved to the new site. Obviously, however, depending on that new site and the ambition of the programme, we would be looking at building a new set on that new site.

Comment on this

If that is the plan, then it would have been worked out where the savings would be in doing it. In fairness, this is public service media and these are two flagship programmes. Can Ms O'Connor tell us where the saving is in doing this?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh O'Connor

It is not just about saving in terms of moving both these products out. Picking up on the point made by Mr. Bakhurst, the sets in RTÉ sit within the television building. Bringing those buildings up to the standard required by 2030 was going to cost €300 million. It was a prohibitive amount for us because we do not have that kind of money, so we were going to have to move off-site anyway. Additionally, Cairn Homes, which has bought some of the land to the left of the television building, is going to begin its construction work within the next year to 18 months, so we were going to have to move off-site for that reason too.

Comment on this

If these programmes are being moved off-site for those reasons and the building would cost an extraordinary amount of money to bring up to standard, what will happen with that building?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Well, it is not just the television building involved but the set of buildings as a whole, including the radio, administration and canteen buildings, because these are all listed. As soon as we have moved back to one end of the site and consolidated into the most modern building there, and we have to invest in there as well, those buildings will be available. We have already had one discussion on this, but we will need to talk to the Land Development Agency. We will also need to talk to the Government because my view, and I think that of the board too, is that if we get proper public funding to enable us to transform the organisation and move out of many of those buildings, it may well be that there will be a public or social use for them. We would like to discuss that with the Government in due course.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst means outside of RTÉ.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes, outside of RTÉ, potentially, or in a partnership. It could be one or the other.

Comment on this

What is the plan for the staff who work on both programmes?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Taking "The Late Late Show" as an example, there is a small production team. What I said was that we are going to move the programme off the land but we have not decided how we are going to do this yet. Basically, there are two options. One of them is to put the programmes out to the independent sector, while the other is to do a hybrid model by working with the independent sector and some of our staff as well. Those are the options we need to explore.

Where people go, therefore, will depend on the outcome of the model we choose. Many operations people involved work across both programmes. I think there will be opportunities for them, potentially, to work in other areas. We will still be producing a significant amount of other coverage from RTÉ, as Mr. Lynch touched on, in respect of radio, television and sport. There will be opportunities for staff to retrain within RTÉ.

There may be opportunities for people to choose to take an exit package, leave and work for one of the independents. I touched on the previous voluntary exit schemes. A high number of people from operations applied to the last exit scheme who we were unable to let go because the organisation was not changing. There was a significant appetite last time around – I think it was in 2021 – for people to go.

Comment on this

That is a lot of uncertainty for the staff involved in that. No clear decisions have been made. A decision was made to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

To move off-site.

Comment on this

-----privatise the two flagship programmes, but there was no thought to how that will operate and where the savings would be as such. Normally, when you outsource to private sector, it is automatically more expensive. The outside broadcast unit was sold some years ago. It was a good deal initially, but when they realised they had a monopoly, the price rocketed. Are we making the same mistake again this time around?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, and I would dispute that it is outsourcing or privatising because we have not taken a decision on how we will do them yet. The one thing is-----

Comment on this

If that decision is taken, it would be privatising it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, it would be commissioning it for the independent sector, which we do with the vast majority of our TV programmes already.

Comment on this

But not these two.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

It is important to say that in respect of all the programmes RTÉ commissions for the independent sector - whether it is "Dancing with the Stars", the documentaries, "Birdsong", whatever it is - it still maintains overall editorial control and control of those productions. We would have oversight of this with the independent sector. With "The Late Late Show", there is a very good chance that whatever the solution is, we will end up with a senior editorial team from RTÉ involved in that programme because I am not sure the skills are out there. There is a very particular-----

Comment on this

As it stands, Mr. Bakhurst cannot give any guarantees to any of the staff involved in those two flagship programmes.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I can give a guarantee, which is there are no compulsory redundancies. That is the bottom line.

Comment on this

Yes but there is no guarantee their job as it is will not be outsourced or privatised.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, I cannot give a guarantee their job will not be outsourced, but we are not talking about that. We are talking about finding other opportunities within RTÉ or allowing them, as many of them want to, to leave if they want to take the exit package.

Comment on this

Will all drama be outsourced going into the future?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Apart from "Fair City", all drama is outsourced.

Comment on this

Everything apart from those two is outsourced, so this is the final one - the flagship, "Fair City". It is gone now, if that is the decision taken.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

All our drama is made by independent production companies. People would think these are RTÉ programmes and a high quality, which they are. Regarding the independents, there has been a bit of a characterisation of them in a way, which is unfair. We have a fantastic independent sector here. We have brilliant production companies that create incredible content.

Comment on this

I agree with Mr. Bakhurst that there are. However, it is public service media and this is the one last flagship programme, and that is now being-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I would dispute that because it depends what one characterises as flagship programmes. I would say "Prime Time", the "Nine O'Clock News" and all our sports programmes are flagship programmes.

Comment on this

Current affairs and sports. However, as regards drama, "Fair City" and "The Late Late Show" are synonymous with RTÉ. That goes without saying.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

For sure. That is why-----

Comment on this

They could be gone - out.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

They are absolutely treasures of RTÉ and we would not and will not do this unless we think we will get a superior product, which we will.

Comment on this

Okay, but we are scant on the detail of all of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

On that, we said this when the "Fair City" cast came to see us. We explained to them that we did not have all the detail because we did not want to start talking to people outside RTÉ about this before we talked to our own staff about it. This is over a period of years. They were very accepting of that. We also guaranteed to them, as we will do to all staff, that everyone involved will be fully consulted with and all those opportunities I set out, whether it is inside RTÉ or outside, will be fully tested with them.

Comment on this

In talking about the funding decision that has yet to be made about future funding for RTÉ, whether it is direct Exchequer funding, I think Mr. Bakhurst said he did not have preference. I do not know if I picked him up right or wrong on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

The Deputy did.

Comment on this

We had a team of unions and other reps in a couple months ago and I asked each of them at the end their preference of funding, and all of them said direct Exchequer funding. Given the Future of Media Commission report, that was the one recommendation left sitting on the shelf, if you like. Would Mr. Bakhurst favour direct Exchequer funding? Is he frustrated that no decision has been made? As he referred to, the decision has not been made yet because no decision has been made. I would imagine they are like ferrets in a sack behind the door, fighting over it. The Minister for media has publicly expressed that she would prefer direct Exchequer funding, in line with the Future of Media Commission. Does Mr. Bakhurst have any comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No. I have spoken about this with the Deputy's party leadership as well, who I know are in favour of direct taxation. There are distinct advantages to direct funding, so long as the appropriate safeguards are in place. A number of the Nordic countries have introduced it with those safeguards, like multi-annual five to seven years, with safeguards about how the level of funding is decided with annual increase of 2%. There are schemes that work but there are schemes where it can lead to political interference if the safeguards are not in place. The key, as I said before, for us is a decision where - I welcome the Taoiseach saying they will make that decision by the end of the month - it is at the right level, it is multi-annual and it provides sustainability for us.

Comment on this

If it was direct Exchequer funding with those safeguards, would Mr. Bakhurst then be in favour?

Comment on this
Niamh Smyth An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

In an answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

So long as it met the criteria I just outlined.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst would be favour of the safeguards.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for joining us. I will ask Mr. Bakhurst a direct question. Is the person responsible for a €75,000 journal, which would have brought "Toy Show The Musical" losses below €2 million, still employed by RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I am sorry. I do not know who exactly the Deputy is pointing the finger at.

Comment on this

I do not either, but I want to know whether Mr. Bakhurst knows.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Sorry. Can the Deputy ask the question again?

Comment on this

I refer to the €75,000 misaccounting issue that arose in the musical report. Is the person responsible for that still employed by RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, not that I am aware of.

Comment on this

Was the person dismissed as a result of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

To the best of my knowledge, the individuals involved in that are not still employed at RTÉ.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Bakhurst consider that particular measure taken as accounting fraud?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, because the company lost no money. It was just misrepresented internally. That is the advice I have been given.

Comment on this

How many people have been dismissed by RTÉ arising from the scandals we have seen over the past 12 months?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I think five people have exited.

Comment on this

I asked Mr. Bakhurst how many had been dismissed by RTÉ.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Five people have left the organisation, all in different ways.

Comment on this

I refer to dismissal. It is a clear, simple question. How many people have been dismissed by RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

All I can say is five people have left.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I know what the Deputy is trying to get me to say. Because of Irish law, you cannot dismiss someone. There is a very high bar of evidence to dismiss people.

Comment on this

So nobody has been dismissed.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Nobody has been dismissed.

Comment on this

That is what I asked. What does someone have to do to get dismissed from RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Because of Irish law, there is quite a high threshold. We have looked at dismissing people and we have taken external legal advice, because believe me, there was some appetite in some cases. However, the legal advice was that there is an extremely high threshold and if you go down this route, you could end up costing the company an awful lot of money and end up in a position that other public organisations have recently ended up with - someone fighting it through the courts, being paid for a very long time while you do it.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Bakhurst believe that being an instigator or complicit in the loss of €30 million from the licence fee would be enough to warrant dismissal?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

If someone had done it directly and deliberately, yes. However, I do not think anyone has done that.

Comment on this

There is no one to blame.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

There are loads of people to blame. Many people had a part in this.

Comment on this

But none of those people was dismissed.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I have answered the Deputy's question on it.

Comment on this

Some €30 million has been lost in 12 months.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Yes, and some public comments about people not wanting to pay their licence fee have not helped either.

Comment on this

How many legal cases has RTÉ taken against formerly bogus self-employed workers?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Ms Cusack can answer that. It is about ten in-----

Comment on this
Ms Eimear Cusack

Can the Deputy repeat the question?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Did the Deputy ask about cases against individual workers?

Comment on this

Against formerly bogus self-employed workers.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

We have taken none against individuals. We have taken some against scope decisions.

Comment on this

RTÉ brought people to the courts.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, we have taken the Department-----

Comment on this

Ultimately it leads to former workers or some present workers having to go before the courts and go through that system.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

They may have to, but some of them agree with us. It is not all against the will of the individuals involved.

Comment on this

RTÉ almost routinely take cases against those workers but-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No.

Comment on this

-----is not prepared to risk being taken to court by a former executive.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No. Where the legal advice is that the Department of Social Protection or its scope section has made a mistake in law or in fact, those are the only cases we have taken. They are not against workers but against the Department for making what we view on the basis of legal advice as incorrect decisions.

Comment on this

Mr. Bakhurst understands how people will see double standards there.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

No, I do not.

Comment on this

He does not see that.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I do not.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I have just explained the situation. I know the Deputy sees double standards but I do not.

Comment on this

One can see how those workers feel they are getting different treatment to former executives. How many former executives have taken legal proceedings against RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I do not want to give the wrong answer. Is the Deputy asking how many have taken proceedings or how many have threatened to do so?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

I would say that everyone who has left has taken legal advice. It has never got so far as proceedings because we have handled it in the correct way.

Comment on this

There are no cases pending.

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

There are not, to my understanding.

Comment on this

Has the former director general initiated legal proceedings against RTÉ?

Comment on this
Mr. Kevin Bakhurst

Is the question whether the former director general is taking legal proceedings?

Comment on this