Dublin Port and the Fisher Report: Presentations.
Contributions 129–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
In regard to expansion, where exactly are the 50 acres? I believe the north-east corner of the port was mentioned. More importantly, will Mr. Connellan tell us where that is in relation to the other side of the inlet, whether Dollymount, Clontarf or Fairview? Will he use local landmarks to let us know about what he is talking?
Mr. Connellan said that the application for a foreshore licence has not been processed by the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources. He said that essentially the Department has indicated that it will not deal with a foreshore application until planning permission has been obtained and that the city council has made it clear it will not deal with a planning application until the foreshore permissions are in place. He went on to say that the matter is now being advanced by the establishment by Dublin City Council of a study into Dublin Bay, including the port area, but that this study is not due to produce a report until June 2007 following which changes are likely to be required to the Dublin city development plan before any application can be submitted to the city council.
It seems that not only has the Dublin Port Company being going around in a circle for the past number of years but that when the new process, that is, the study into Dublin Bay is concluded, it will have to resubmit itself into that circular process in that it will go back into the planning process. The planning authority has already said it is not prepared to deal with the matter until there is a foreshore licence. In light of the recent assumption of powers in regard to transport at the port by the Department of Transport, is there a role for that Department in terms of banging the heads of the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources and the city council together to come up with some appropriate process? While this is a very important project not only for the city but for the country, there must be other foreshore projects in the same situation in the city council's area. It strikes me as the height of the "Yes Minister" syndrome if this is what we are dealing with. We must be in a position to come up with some realistic solution to this problem.
In regard to the expansion, Mr. Connellan said in response to a question that if the 50 acres were to take what I consider a most unlikely course and be developed into a port complex, that would deal with the needs of the Dublin Port Company for the foreseeable future. Is that the foreseeable future in the context of Mr. Connellan's time in the Dublin Port Company or is it the foreseeable future for generations living in Clontarf? Will he give us a slightly more definitive answer than simply saying it will deal with the needs of the Dublin Port Company for the foreseeable future?
Is it not the case that there is very limited scope for development in the port and that the only hope for development is the area about which we are talking? I fully understand Mr. Connellan's reluctance to get involved in the debate about the relocation of the port and he has done an extremely fine "hands free" job of not getting involved in it. Will he confirm that he has basically said the relocation of Dublin Port, as far as he is concerned, is a non-runner?
Comment on this
I express my delight at the presence of these esteemed gentlemen who could not find the time to attend a conference, even though some were invited as keynote speakers. All the organisations were invited as guests. We have been told there is a crisis in this area.
Comment on this
I was the chairman of that conference and I am independent. I was asked to chair it on the basis that it was independent. The point was made by a number of the speakers that it was independent.
Comment on this
It comprises me, Senator Tom Morrissey, and Gerry Kiersey. It has been the subject of parliamentary questions and so on.
I am delighted these gentlemen are here given that there is a crisis. I presume very little will be learned today except that the gentlemen opposite must realise the 50 acres is an unworkable proposition. I say that because I have met the city council. I would like a direct answer from the gentlemen from the Dublin Port Company about when they last discussed the planning permission they must get with Dublin City Council. What relationship, if any, do they have with the city authority? How does the relationship they have with the city authority compare with those other port authorities in this country and elsewhere in the world have with their city councils?
The Dublin Port Company has been thinking inside the box but it is time to start to think outside it. European best practice has shown that rundown port areas suffering from capacity problems should relocate. I am well aware of what Mr. McCabe has written about this and I understand the frown on his face.
Deputy Glennon said Mr. Connellan has operated a "hands free" policy in regard to why the port cannot move. Mr. Connellan has done this committee a fantastic service by asking questions about the port move. All the questions he has asked are very easily answered. On the question of where there is an adequate scale of land available, we are speaking here about possibly adding 50 acres to the 660 acres in Dublin Port. The Bremore proposal involves circa 1,000 acres with the total support of the local authority concerned, all but a business partner.
Comment on this
On the attitude of local communities, it was put into the county development plan with the unanimous support of the 24 local councillors.
Comment on this
Senator Morrissey, we are discussing Dublin Port, not this famous north Dublin port of which you speak.
Comment on this
On the question of related infrastructure, has Mr. Connellan heard of the outer ring road? Does he seriously suggest that the Port tunnel, even with an upgraded M50, is the infrastructure that will cater for an increased Dublin Port when his submission states that the larger vessels coming to this new enlarged Dublin Port will require deeper berths? Will Mr. Connellan state what is on those larger vessels? Do they not contain larger containers? As those larger containers cannot fit through the Dublin Port tunnel, how will they leave the port? The constraint on the development of Dublin Port is the tunnel, the size of which Dublin Port Authority did not help increase.
Mr. Connellan asks about Dublin Port's business users and the environmental concerns. I have met hauliers who have told me that they can make the round trip from Rush to Larne quicker than the trip from Rush to Dublin Port, that on the M50 their trucks travel a half-mile per gallon. Mr. Connellan speaks of environmental concerns. Is he suggesting that Dublin Port's offering is better? Mr. Connellan has given a two-year horizon to produce a 50-acre addition to his port. Deputy Glennon has shown that Mr. Connellan cannot even commence it for two years, following which he will be off to Europe to fight the habitats directive which Bremore need not do.
Mr. Connellan must now start thinking outside the box. If he cannot read the signals from Dublin City Council, can he confirm whether Dublin Port has a relationship with Dublin City Council and when he last met the council? Has he met the new city manager? When last did he meet the retired city manager to discuss Dublin Port's proposals? Let us have this discussion in broad daylight, not carry on the way Mr. Connellan has in not answering other Deputies' questions clearly and precisely. I am asking Mr. Connellan simple questions. When last did he meet the former city manager? Has he met the new city manager? What is the city manager's reaction and what has he told Mr. Connellan about Dublin Port's proposition involving 50 acres?
Is it not simply the case that no Government, since Senator Daly was Minister for the marine in the early 1980s, will ever allow Dublin Port to develop further? If that will not happen, Mr. Connellan is back to square one and we then start commencing the de-industrialisation of Dublin Port. The planner for Dublin Port who attended our recent conference stated that the port is the backyard of our country, while we want make it the front door.
What are the infrastructure costs for key development for the existing port, never mind the new 50 acres? What are Dublin Port's capital investment requirements over the next five years to make it a more safe and workable area?
Comment on this
I will commence by answering Senator Norris's question. The first time Dublin Port made the application was in 1988 and it might not be quite fair to state that we precipitated a crisis.
Comment on this
My point is we have been at this for 18 years.
On the issue of silting, especially on the east coast, it might help us all if the committee visited Dublin Port because one can see how we have dealt with it. Silting is not a problem in Dublin Port, but it is quite a problem in some ports further up the east coast.
Although it is a couple of years since I have been to Hamburg, I was not aware that the port had moved. I had spent some time there.
Comment on this
It has not moved. I am quite certain it has not.
Comment on this
I did not mention Helsinki. I can remember the name of Helsinki; I could not remember the name of the port.
Comment on this
The record should show that the man who designed the new port attended the conference.
Comment on this
Deputy Glennon asked me to go back to the capacity issue. I wish that any of my terminals was operating at 60%. The best example I can give is this. People have not quite defined what they mean by capacity in various places. If one is operating at 75% or 80% of theoretical capacity, then one is full. Like any broom cupboard, if it is full one will not be able to choose a broom.
The location of the area for expansion of which we speak is a small area, which is visible because it is marked by buoys. It is 600 m. by 350 m. at the north-eastern corner of the port, alongside what would be called the Norfolk Ferries terminal. I am quite happy to show it to the committee, if it would be helpful.
I am not so sure about the "hands-on" and "non-runner" references. My role as the chief executive officer of Dublin Port Company is to manage the operation of the port. The issues of the location of the port are matters for the shareholder, which is the Government, and they are outside my remit. If the shareholder decides that we should operate in Timbuktu, then I will not be saying we will not. I am glad, from Senator Morrissey's point of view, that I have been helpful in raising some of the questions that could be asked with regard to Bremore, in particular. Of course Bremore is a project belonging to the port of Drogheda, which itself has serious constraints, but I am sure they will be able to speak for themselves and I do not purport to speak for them.
Comment on this
I am waiting to hear when Mr. Connellan met the former city manager and the current city manager.
Comment on this
Chairman, I do not think I should discuss my business with the committee.
Comment on this
I am asking a specific question. When did Mr. Connellan last discuss with Dublin City Council his proposals for the infill of 50 acres?
Comment on this
It is not in the realm of this committee to go into the discussions between Dublin Port and the local authority because we did not ask them to come in to discuss their meetings with Dublin City Council. I ask Mr. Connellan to continue.
Comment on this
Mr. Connellan's submission includes the difficulties in getting planning permission and a foreshore licence. We are entitled to ask what discussions have taken place over the years in seeking that permission and that is what I am asking.
Comment on this
Some people would say that business plans should not be for more than five years. In my opinion, the foreseeable future relates to a period of 20 years.
Comment on this
It is depressing that we came here today to discuss national ports policy, while members are focusing almost exclusively on the needs of and issues relating to Dublin Port. The latter is important but, with respect——
Comment on this
With respect, the purpose of the meeting is to deal with matters relating to Dublin Port.
Comment on this
Also the Fisher report and issues connected with national ports policy.
I wish to make a comment on behalf of the organisation I represent. A number of queries were made about a conference. Conferences relating to transport in Dublin city probably take place on every day of the week. If I were to attend all these, I would end up doing nothing.
On the specific issue of the movement of Dublin Port to Bremore or another location, from the perspective of IBEC, this is an abstraction. We cannot afford to spend our time discussing abstractions; we need to deal with real issues. I remind members that the issues connected with developing ports and their capacity are on the agenda for practically every port city in the world. I cannot think of another major international port that is attempting to deal with its capacity problems and growth issues by taking a simple exit strategy and relocating. I refer here to Antwerp, Hamburg, Rotterdam, Liverpool and even Belfast. These cities recognise that their ports add value, generate employment and contribute to the dynamism of their economies. Ireland is a trading economy and it is critically important that Dublin Port, as an existing facility, be provided with room to grow. That was the tenor of our presentation.
It is not only Dublin. There are issues in respect of Cork and other ports as well. Our view is that it is all about risk factors. One must consider Bremore either in the guise of a development of Drogheda Port — which I would call a small-scale proposal — or as a large-scale development involving the relocation of Dublin Port and take into account the risk factors involved. Anyone involved with ports who is well informed with regard to the industry and the risk factors to which I refer would allocate a probability of something less than 5% in respect of the Bremore project proceeding. For us to put our eggs into that basket, would, from the point of view of my organisation, be irresponsible. It is just not the way to deal with the real and current issue of capacity.
We can spend the afternoon dealing with how long it is likely to take to redevelop or proceed with existing proposals for Dublin. However, in my view we could be getting involved in a process that would last decades if we were to advance a large-scale proposal along the lines of a so-called relocation.
Comment on this
Mr. McCabe has raised a key point. It is impossible for members of the committee or anyone else to reach a view on the future needs of the Dublin Port Company in respect of capacity without having some clear idea of the impact of developments at Drogheda and Bremore. There is a view that has been circulating at political level that this is the obvious eventuality, namely, that a new port will be created and that Dublin Port will relocate. There is political motivation behind that proposal. However, I am not clear about the Government's position on the Bremore proposal. Where stands the Government in that regard at present? When, if ever, will the Bremore proposal be given the go-ahead? What would be the implications for that in respect of taking business away from Dublin? If he is in a position to do so, I would like Mr. Lumsden to outline Government policy in that regard. I would also like Mr. Connellan to indicate his view on what is likely to happen.
Comment on this
In a reply to a parliamentary question tabled to the Department of Transport — this was already referred to in a submission from one of the other groups present — a clear reference was made to the fact that the Drogheda Port Company has made a submission regarding a separate proposal to build a new, multi-purpose port at Bremore in north County Dublin. The Bremore proposal is being advanced by the Drogheda Port Company as a stand-alone project and is not dependent on or linked to any relocation of activities from Dublin Port. We must wait to see whether that remains the position.
Comment on this
I am just trying to explain that we keep in contact with the Drogheda Port Company regarding the status of its Bremore project. The company spent the past few months involved in a serious selection process in respect of a joint venture partner that would commit, in conjunction with it, to take the project on to another level. Our arrangements with the various port companies require ministerial approval for joint venture arrangements of that sort. I would like to be more specific but we anticipate that, in the coming months, the next part of the presentation by the Drogheda Port Company regarding the status of its Bremore project will be forwarded to the Department of Transport. The Department takes the view that it would be right and proper to allow the Drogheda Port Company to develop to the point where it needs to make a clear submission to the Minister for Transport in respect of what it regards as a proposal that is viable, bankable, environmentally sound, etc. We have not demanded premature exposition or submission from the company on the many dimensions to which the Deputy refers. She is correct in that these must all be demonstrated. We expect to receive a significant submission early in 2007, particularly because we have been keeping in contact with the company and are aware that it was involved in a serious selection process. However, the current status of the proposal is that it is not linked to a relocation or movement of business from Dublin Port.
Comment on this
I accept what Mr. Lumsden says and it is, perhaps, unfair for us to put questions of this nature to him in respect of political matters. The Minister should really be present to comment on policy. In the context of the Government eventually giving the go-ahead to the proposal for the Bremore development, is Mr. Lumsden in a position to indicate what would be the implications of such a move for Dublin Port in terms of the likely level of business that would relocate to Bremore?
Comment on this
The short answer is "No". I cannot provide such information today. However, when a proposition emerges from any port company in respect of what it regards as viable on a business case basis, it has been normal that such companies will indicate that they want to pursue further business, both new business for Ireland Inc. and business that is currently going to a neighbouring port. There is nothing unusual about that.
Comment on this
Is this not central to the expansion of Dublin Port? Does not that issue have to be decided first?
Comment on this
Have we not heard that the ports seek significant "overhangs" or whatever expression Mr. McCabe used and that we are not trying to fine-tune the supply of port capacity so that it just happens to meet demand?
Comment on this
Mr. McCabe stated that at least 30% to 40% extra capacity would be required and that it is not possible to run to 100% because otherwise there would be chaos.
Comment on this
When we are examining, as we will in due course, a case relating to Bremore — we hope such cases will be put forward in respect of Cork, Rosslare and other ports — we will do so not just in narrow terms as regards its viability but also in the context of ports policy. We had an exchange earlier as to the meaning of this. It certainly means more than simply looking at the effects on a port of a significant expansion. I cannot predict what the outcome will be.
Comment on this
This is an area where I am probably happiest. We were established as competing entities by the State ten years ago. The Deputy asked about the impact of Bremore on Dublin Port and about the impact of Dublin Port on Drogheda, which might be more significant because Drogheda had a trade of approximately 50,000 TEUs up to a few months ago, but all that trade now comes to Dublin and Drogheda has none. This is due to competition. One of the reasons is that Dublin Port can better cater for the ships than Drogheda and provide better satisfaction to the customer. That is what competition is about.
Comment on this
May I add some further information. The Department heard from Drogheda just yesterday that it anticipates a new service that is imminent. That is good news from our perspective, if from no other.
Comment on this
I cannot let pass Mr. McCabe's comment that there is only a 5% chance that Bremore Port will materialise. I work closely with Drogheda Port and Fingal County Council with regard to this project, as do a number of colleagues. Perhaps Mr. McCabe has a rabbit in the hat, but as Mr. Lumsden has outlined, Bremore Port is due to go ahead according to the schedule he mentioned. It has a better than even chance of materialising.
Comment on this
Can I clarify what I said because I may have misrepresented it. Bearing in mind there are two versions of Bremore before us, ——
Comment on this
What Mr. Lumsden referred to is a proposal before the Department from the port of Drogheda to shift to Bremore. However, what Senator Morrissey espouses is a completely different set of proposals which entails the movement of the country's primary port facility and relocating it to Bremore. The footprint for the latter is in order of magnitude bigger than what Drogheda Port proposes. Do we accept that?
Comment on this
I agree with Mr. McCabe absolutely. There is only one proposal and that is the proposal for the relocation of Drogheda Port, as Mr. Lumsden has outlined. Nothing of substance or any material significance has emerged with regard to Dublin Port moving to Bremore and the Bremore project is on track.
Comment on this
It was to the latter that I was assigning the 5% viability.
Comment on this
It would be irresponsible if we gave the impression that we do not foresee any difficulties in setting up the Drogheda facility in Bremore because there are challenges involved in establishing a port on a greenfield site
Comment on this
I would like clarification from Mr. McCabe, who represents IBEC. He said he regards the Bremore proposal as an abstraction.
Comment on this
Yes, and specifically for the transport and logistics area.
Comment on this
I am asking the question because it is important we know to whom we are speaking. I met the IBEC council in the presence of Mr. Connellan and Mr. McLaughlin.
Comment on this
Yes, the Dublin executive of IBEC. I met them in Jury's in March-April. Mr. Connellan was present for that meeting, was he not?
Comment on this
I have been at so many meetings with the Senator that I cannot remember.
Comment on this
I am delighted he acknowledges he has been at so many meetings. Would he confirm that at that meeting the almost unanimous view, except for him, was to wonder why this had not happened?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator is confused about his diary.
Comment on this
We are an open, transparent and democratic organisation and are set up on a regional level. There is a Dublin region, a region for the west, the mid-west and the north west, etc.
Comment on this
Some of the time the regional entities are empowered to take policy positions that vary. In other words, IBEC is not a command and control organisation. The various regions are quite free to debate with the Senator or anybody else investment proposals that fit into their regional perspective. The Dublin regional group is about to produce a strategy document and it will be interesting to see its formal statement on these matters. Perhaps we should wait until that is published.
Comment on this
Will Mr. McCabe clarify whether he is speaking in his capacity as chairman of the transport group or as spokesperson for IBEC?
Comment on this
I would like to complete my response to Deputy Shortall's question. If the proposal is for Drogheda to move to Bremore, we will continue to compete vigorously with them.
Comment on this
There is an issue with regard to the State investing heavily in infrastructure to allow this kind of competition. Mr. Connellan said Dublin Port had managed to take all the business from Drogheda. That is great for Dublin Port, but it does not make sense from the national perspective that we should have unused capacity.
Comment on this
That is the policy and the law. All nine ports are set up to compete with each other.
Comment on this
Many ports compete against each other and like the truckers that enter them, the fittest will survive.
Comment on this
I am trying to establish the position. The public view currently is that if the Government gives the go-ahead to Bremore, that will be the end of Dublin Port.
Comment on this
That view exists and is promoted politically. In terms of capacity, will Bremore have a similar capacity to Dublin Port. Are there relative figures available?
Comment on this
I will provide the Deputy with relative figures.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Connellan imply that he would not see Bremore having a serious impact on the level of business in Dublin Port?
Comment on this
I expect there will be competition. However, I think the Deputy wants me to put it in perspective. Dublin Port handles approximately 1.5 million TEUs. At best, Drogheda handled approximately 50,000 TEUs.
Comment on this
About four times the capacity for Drogheda currently, which is probably only one seventh or one eighth of Dublin Port's capacity.
Comment on this
We are not dealing with airports today. Before we finish, we will take up Mr. Connellan's invitation to visit Dublin Port to see the set up. Also, in the new year we should look at the port situation overall around the country. Perhaps we should seek submissions from the relevant authorities, such as Foynes and the proposed new port in Killybegs. We must also consider Warrenpoint as a competitor to the others.
Comment on this
I wish to repeat my request for the committee members to be provided with a map before we go.
Comment on this
I have a final comment. This is the first time that the ports groups have been before the committee. It is important that the dialogue is continued on an ongoing basis and that it is not allowed to become issue-driven. We need to keep an ongoing review of the issues relating to the ports all over the country. We concentrated on Dublin Port today but there are wider issues to be considered.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Connellan and his staff, and Mr. McCabe and Mr. Lumsden and their support staff, for coming here today and being frank and open with the committee. It is not easy for three different groups who are competing from different angles to come here and try to keep everyone happy. I know we did not keep everyone happy. Members of the press have left so I can say that. This discussion opens up a dialogue, as Deputy Glennon said, that needs to take place more than many people outside may realise. If we are going to have growth in our economy, everybody here will be under more pressure.