Remit of Iarnród Éireann: Discussion
Iarnród Éireann outlined strong passenger growth and major rail investment plans, including DART+ expansion, new stations and fleet upgrades, while also highlighting freight and regional projects. The main focus was the severe failure of the national train control centre traffic management system contract with Indra: despite repeated warnings, missed deadlines and escalating costs, the software has still not been delivered and the asset was impaired in 2025. Members criticised governance, procurement assumptions and continued spending, asking why a formal stop-review was not triggered sooner. Iarnród Éireann said it remains in contract, is reviewing options with the NTA, and will bring a recommendation to its board.
Contributions 151–315 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
What we have done is to have been very transparent. We have gone through a very rigorous process looking at all the costs incurred to date, as approved by our board.
Comment on this
All of that, everything we are aware of, has been written down. If we remain in contract, however, there will be additional costs accruing from here on.
Comment on this
Okay. This means that the level of impairment of €50.3 million can, potentially, increase.
Comment on this
It could increase to cover the current running costs.
Comment on this
If we revoke the contract with Indra and move to an alternative, what is the scope of the increased impairment?
Comment on this
I have to be very careful; we are in contract with it. We have not gone to our board with any options so I am really not in a position-----
Comment on this
We could look at a greater level of impairment or additional costs. It will all depend on the options.
Comment on this
To come back to the financial briefing, I mentioned in my opening comment the extent to which the change orders exploded. The original contract with Indra increased by 65% but in particular with the change orders, there was an increase of 235% in the Turas contract and 342% for Ricardo Rail on the original contract value. Were any of these change orders linked to delays caused by Indra, in particular the change order as it applied to Turas and Ricardo Rail?
Comment on this
Some was work we had to do to support our SET division but the majority of the growth in the Turas and Ricardo contracts was having to lean in and bring in more temporary staff than was envisaged to support Indra and for longer than was envisaged.
Comment on this
Deputy Shane Moynihan raised commercial reset 2. In terms of the ongoing delays and the commercial reset in 2024, were any penalties waived?
Comment on this
There is a liquidated damages mechanism in the contract with penalties for performance. They were all retained in the contract when we did the reset. We still have liquidated damages-----
Comment on this
When we did the reset, we reset the programme and the contract. It resets when the liquidated damages apply. They are not waived but the point in time when they apply is reset and moved.
Comment on this
In essence, the support costs exceed the value of the contract itself. What specific services were purchased under those support costs of €31.4 million? I highlight again that is greater than the value of the contract with Indra.
Comment on this
I assume the Chair has the sheet; the expenditure is significant. In the expenditure column, Turas is €15 million and Ricardo Rail is about €11.5 million. Those services provide support to the client project team to manage the contract with Indra. We have a contract manager supporting us in managing the financial mechanism of this contract.
Comment on this
Some were necessary to manage the project and were preplanned to bring in subject matter expertise to help us in what we knew was going to be a difficult and challenging project. A lot of those costs were brought in to support the difficulties Indra was facing. As I said, there was prolongation; we had it for longer than we expected. We expected to taper down those resources much earlier in the project. They have ended up being there longer because of the programme delays.
Comment on this
It is important I give Irish Rail representatives the opportunity to comment on the safety of the existing rail network given what they said in their opening statement regarding existing systems and end of life. Will they comment on the safety of our rail network given that this may drag on for a significant period? How safe is our rail network?
Comment on this
Safety is absolutely paramount on the railway. It is the first thing we look at in every meeting. As Mr. Hendrick explained, we started this project in 2015 because the train control system technology was no longer supported. We were expecting to have this in 2024 but we will not have it in the foreseeable future because of the delays. As a result, through funding from the Department of Transport through the multi-annual contract, we are putting additional resilience into the heavier used parts of the network around the GDA. That is to de-risk it but that is more from an operational perspective to make sure we do not have faults and breakdowns. From a safety perspective, if there are any issues, it is a fail-safe system so we just shut it down. There would be interruptions to services but safety would not be compromised. It impedes further development of the railway network. Any new projects will require a new train control system. That is where we have capacity constraints on the system as well. To give further assurance to the committee-----
Comment on this
This has a significant impact on the vision and ambition and the review of the national development plan in the context of Irish Rail 2050.
Comment on this
It will impede development if we do not address this. That is why it is paramount. From an infrastructure perspective, significant funding has been made available in recent years to address a lot of the deficits that were there heretofore.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before our committee. There are a number of issues to get through. I came up on the 7.45 a.m. train from Limerick today. As always, I found the staff outstanding at the station and on board. It is important that be reflected as much as possible at these meetings. They have always been brilliant. There are very few-late night trains out of the capital to other parts of the country. If I want to leave Dublin to go to Limerick, Clare or Cork, I can get a train every hour but not at 8 p.m. for some reason. The last one is at 9 p.m. If someone has come up for a match or concert, it confines them to having to stay at extortionately priced hotels in the city centre. Why are there no late-night trains? Where is there none at 8 p.m. leaving the capital?
Comment on this
We will pass on the Deputy's appreciation to the team. It is always nice to hear that. I will deal with the 8 p.m. gap in the Cork service at the moment. It is subject to funding. If we had additional funding, we would be in a position to provide that additional service.
Comment on this
Yes. A PSO fund. We provide an hourly service to Cork and there are connections from the junction to Limerick, Ennis and Galway. They run all the way through to 7 p.m. There is gap at 8 p.m. and a service again at 9 p.m. That is a funding issue. Beyond 9 p.m., beyond funding, there is a maintenance issue. We need that window at night, the possession period, to do essential maintenance on the network. If we were to run later trains, it would impede that very narrow window for maintaining the infrastructure. I hear the Deputy's concerns; indeed, we get them form a number of areas all over the country but there is a balance to maintain.
Comment on this
Does it require double tracking to allow the train to be run on one line with the other is maintained? Is that what will fix this?
Comment on this
We have double tracking to the junction already I believe but it is the maintenance window really. It is having the fleet in the right position for a very important service.
Comment on this
Does Irish Rail apply to the NTA for the PSO?
Comment on this
We are on a ten-year contract. The baseline contract was, I believe, in 2019. There was a mid-contract review last year. We have set funding. We timetable and provide our services annually to the NTA and they are funded accordingly. There are always constraints on funding and a desire to run more services. It is about trying to manage within the funding envelope we have. We also have fleet constraints. It is a combination of both issues.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. There is an on-board text facility if there is trouble on a train. It is on the Luas as well. It seems to work far better on the Luas because are security staff at different stops and they can get on board. It does not work so well on the train. I travel on the train. I make five or six journeys a week. It is usually so nice and train etiquette has improved hugely. People are very nice to travel alongside and the staff are excellent but on 13 April I sent a text on board the train.
There is just a kind of automated acknowledgement. Nothing happens to it. That was a fairly minor incident, but about three years ago, coming from Limerick Junction to Limerick, there was a guy on board talking about what he was going to do with a knife when he got off at the other end. People cannot exactly make a 999 call even though they are told to by the bot, when they are in the same carriage as the guy. They rely on the text facility, but I do not know how plugged in it is. I do not know what is happening with that behind the scenes, but it does not seem to be very connected to where it needs to be.
Comment on this
Let me address that. It is monitored live at all times of service. It does not go into the ether. An agent in the central security centre will see it and will liaise with traffic control and colleagues around the country to report it. If a serious issue comes through that, it will be actioned. They can contact An Garda Síochána as well.
On the intercity network, we have established, with An Garda Síochána, 20 rapid response hubs around the country. That has direct contact with our on-board teams. If an issue requires Garda intervention, it goes directly to An Garda Síochána, which has been fantastic in proactively working with us to develop these and giving the kind of response we need to those incidents. We have a lot of joint patrols for prevention, but response to incidents goes through the hub.
Comment on this
I want to ask Ms. Considine about improvements planned along the Limerick to Ennis train line. There are proposals to have a rail spur to Shannon in the future. In Ballycar, where there is an incessant problem with flooding, there is an idea to have some double tracking and to elongate platforms. What is planned along that line? Will we see the service improve from a slow-moving commuter train to an intercity service from Limerick to Ennis and on to Galway? Will Ms Considine address those points?
Comment on this
One of the earlier projects is already in phase 3 - appointing a multidisciplinary team to look at a preliminary design - for the double tracking from Limerick Junction to Limerick. We are also, through our early works, looking at platform extensions along the line between Limerick and Ennis and on to Galway, a static loop in Sixmilebridge and a platform extension that will provide additional capacity there. I hope, with those infrastructure modifications, we will be able to take larger trains. Then, as we procure more fleet, we will be able to add capacity to the service. There is growing demand. In the first phase of the western rail corridor, the demand has surpassed the projections so we know people want to use the service. There is demand from students and workers commuting and, particularly as we are in a housing crisis-----
Comment on this
Will Ms Considine comment on the rail spur to Shannon? It is an essential piece of infrastructure to realise the airports she did a lot to lead on over the years.
Comment on this
A key part of the all-Ireland strategic rail review is the ambition for all our major airports and ports to be connected by rail. I am keen for that to happen. In the first instance, a feasibility study is required to determine the appropriate line for that route. The Deputy will be aware that TII is already working to lodge a planning application to upgrade the N19 to the airport. The original line spur goes back to an early plan from 2007, so that needs to be updated now. Subject to funding, that will be the first piece of work. We are anxious to do it. It is subject to funding though.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. I was following their presentation remotely. I missed some of the back and forth because I was required in the Seanad Chamber, but I thank them for coming before us today and answering these important questions.
In Ms Considine's opening statement, she made reference to the northern commuter line and the electrification work that is ongoing there. She also made reference to it being completed in the first half of next year. That is a six-month window. Is there any clarity on when exactly it will happen? Will it be in the first half or at the latter end of the first half of next year?
I will also ask about the capacity of the carriages. What practical difference will it make to commuters on the northern line? Will there be greater capacity on the line? Will there be greater frequency?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. What I referred to in my opening statement was that the new fleet is in testing at the moment and we hope, once it has gone through the safety assurance process, that it will start to come into service from the middle of next year. We hope from mid-summer next year we will start to see that new fleet come into service. As I said in the statement, some of those carriages will add capacity and some will replace older fleet. On that particular line, we will be replacing older fleet. The new fleet will be much more accessible. The trains are flush with the platform. It will be a significantly enhanced customer experience and we are looking forward to them coming into service. What that will do in the rest of the country is that we will be able to deploy some of our older fleet and some of our intercity fleet - the ICRs we are currently using on that network - in other parts of the country.
Comment on this
I previously heard the internal capacity of the carriages is greater than the old carriages so that more people would be able to get on the train. Is that the case?
Comment on this
I do not have the exact figures, but they are quite similar in capacity. The difference is that there are no breaks. It is a continuous through-train so there will definitely be more standing room and it should be a more comfortable experience for passengers.
Comment on this
Ms Considine also spoke about the capacity on the northern line between Malahide and Connolly Station. Will it be possible to increase the frequency of the train service on the northern commuter line north of Malahide?
Comment on this
At the moment, there is significant congestion coming out of Connolly Station. In truth, we are probably operating above capacity or where we would ideally like to be. There is a critical project in our plan for tracking north of Connolly Station and, until we deliver that, there will continue to be congestion on that line. I do not know whether Mr. Kenny has anything to add to that.
Comment on this
We will be starting public consultation on that project this year, towards the end of the summer, to start to detail what the options are and how we will develop the programme. DART+ Coastal North gives capacity benefits in the interim, but ultimately, we want more Enterprise trains, more services from Drogheda and from nearer to Dublin, and if they are all competing for the same two tracks, that has an impact on the capacity. On the approaches to Heuston Station, the existing four-tracking and the planned four-tracking for the DART+ South West allows us to separate so the intercity express trains can overtake the stopping commuter services. For an alignment as busy as north of Connolly Station, that is where we want to be.
Comment on this
I understand that project is there. We have heard about it for a long time, but I heard Mr. Kenny refer to the capacity between Malahide and Connolly. I am talking about north of Malahide.
Comment on this
It will give the wider network that capacity because everything starts to converge there. It will benefit the services further out. It is just that the physical work will be on that section.
Comment on this
I understand. The frequency from Malahide to Connolly Station is quite good but the issue is north of Malahide. That is where I am concerned about so I wanted to flag that it is not from Malahide onwards. It is from Drogheda to Malahide.
Comment on this
The physical works in that area will have a benefit all the way up the route.
Comment on this
I will move on to bank holiday weekend closures on the northern commuter line. I understand why they had to take place. It was to upgrade the line for electrification. Do we have any clarity on when it will be finished? The August bank holiday weekend is coming up. Will the line be out of service for that weekend?
Comment on this
It will not. We do not have any works affecting the DART on the August bank holiday weekend this year. We do have works on the October bank holiday weekend. A lot of these works are quite cyclical in nature. The works in the DART area will affect people travelling further north. We are one third of the way through a renewal of our entire overhead line system and it is something that will happen on a cyclical basis. There are track renewal works and grid renewal works and they are the types of works for which, while we can do small sections overnight, to get the significant renewal needed, particularly dealing with crossovers at key junctions, we need the bank holiday weekends when there are 76 hours of continuous work. Our teams go in just after midnight and work around the clock until 4 a.m. or 4.30 a.m. on the Tuesday and they get a lot more return. If, for example, we were to-----
Comment on this
I understand that, but it is very disruptive for people-----
Comment on this
-----and we are looking forward to that finishing. I am talking about towns like Balbriggan, Skerries, Rush and Lusk, which have very limited public transport beyond the train. Is there any clarity as to when the bank holiday closures will finish?
Comment on this
We need to maintain our asset and bank holidays will always play a role in that. We look at what events are going on. There are more events than every before as well and that poses a challenge. For example, on the June bank holiday weekend just gone, we worked on the southside because on the northside, the St Anne's Park concerts were on and we take huge numbers to those.
On maintenance, we came through eras in the pre-1990s and during the 2010s, post the recession, where we were not funded and the asset degrades and that impacts on service quality. These works are done to maintain service quality. If we stop maintaining it appropriately, the customer suffers at the end of the day.
Comment on this
I understand but what I am trying to get clarity on is whether the bank holiday closures will continue beyond the electrification of the northern commuter line. Is it more of a maintenance issue rather than the upgrading of the line for the DART+?
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their information. What impact will the new train management system, which is supposed to be the new brain of the rail system, have on the modernisation of the rail service and specifically the DART+ West programme? What needs to happen in the meantime in relation to our signalling system?
Comment on this
To give some assurance to the Deputy and the committee, the resilience measures that we spoke about earlier on, which are being funded through the MAC to work with one of our existing signalling and technical specialists, will provide resilience in the greater Dublin area, and that will include facilitating the expansion of the DART programme. That is a critical intervention that we hope to be able to start working on in the immediate future and that will provide resilience. We are doing that because of the delays in the TMS system. It is a consequence of it but it will provide that resilience, which is really important. It does not, however, negate the requirement to have a new traffic management system or new train control system for the entire country. We still need to work on solutions for the broader network.
Comment on this
Is there a cost implication for that on top of the €50 million writedown?
Comment on this
Will Ms Considine give me some information on that?
Comment on this
I do not have an exact figure at this stage. We have a quantum but we are in commercial discussions, so I cannot give the figure at this stage.
Comment on this
That is okay. I am looking at the appendix that Iarnród Éireann provided and even back in 2015, market research was undertaken by Ricardo Rail, and the Indra Group's Da Vinci product was identified as being one of the commercially in-service products being provided in the TMS market at the time.
Later, during the development of the tender documents in 2018 and 2019, there was the stage where bidders could provide commentary on the contracts related to the process. Were there blinkers in relation to this product and Indra? Were its references from Lithuania scrutinised? Was due diligence undertaken to make sure that we were getting what we were supposed to be getting?
Comment on this
From the engagement I have had with my team, there was extensive market engagement. As the Deputy referred to, there were external experts appointed to assist our team in that and there was also an independent review of the tender documents by our approving authority, so a lot of due diligence went into this procurement process.
The criteria were 50% weighted towards qualitative and 50% towards price. I know procurement processes have evolved in the meantime and in later projects there is a higher weighting given to qualitative, but that was quite progressive at the time. The form of contract, an NEC contract, was again quite progressive at the time.
We fundamentally-----
Comment on this
I apologise but we are so tight on time. Did the due diligence go into the process rather than the delivery? Was Indra's delivery in Lithuania checked because at a later stage, it was said that Iarnród Éireann believed that the Indra Group had a mature developed product, Da Vinci 2.0, which was ready for deployment in Ireland? However, the issues were nearly immediate. Back in 2020 or 2021, it was stated that the system in Lithuania would not be supportable over the life of the maintenance contract and it too had to be upgraded to a Da Vinci 3.0 system. During the procurement process, was there enough oversight into the delivery of the products that Indra was basing its references on?
Comment on this
The procurement was based on the product that it put forward, namely, the Da Vinci 2.0. As part of that, and I referred to it in my opening statement, it signed a compliance matrix, which had, I think, over 240 line items, and provided an independent safety assurance. So there was a robust procurement process and that system was in operation in Lithuania and it pointed to a history of deployment of services over a previous 15-year period.
The challenge came, as the Deputy correctly pointed out, post signing of the contract where Indra highlighted that the product we thought we were procuring would not be supported over the lifetime of the maintenance agreement, which was 15 years plus an option for five more, so it was over an extensive 20-year period.
It advised us that it was going to upgrade the software. That would not be terribly unusual that software would be upgraded. However, as it transpired, as the members can see in the sequence of events in the detailed appendix, it missed several deadlines. It was due to deliver that upgraded product to us in 2022, so we could start to deploy it onto the rail network for it to come into operation by 2024. As members can see from what we set out in the appendix, Indra missed a number of key deadlines.
Comment on this
How much went into checking references? Why go ahead when the proposed system, which was checked as part of the procurement process, was changed?
Comment on this
I might bring my colleague in on this but we got significant assurances from both our external experts that we had contracted to provide that expertise to us and from Indra. Ultimately, it was still providing us with a product that would have met the contractual obligations, but I might bring Mr. Hendrick in to get more detail.
Comment on this
In the time remaining, will the witnesses comment on the third parties, Turas and Ricardo Rail? They have worked with Iarnród Éireann for ten years. Were their contracts ever retendered in that time as well?
Comment on this
Turas has been working with us since 2020. Ricardo Rail worked with us under a couple of contracts before 2020, so its contract was retendered from 2020 onwards.
Going back to Ms Considine's point, the due diligence done was that the Da Vinci 2.0 product was verified, in existence and working. It contracted with us on that basis, and then what it said to us was that it was updating that product both for the historic client, which was Lithuania in this case, and that it was going to do likewise for its current customers. We were not just the only one at that particular point in time. The assurance that it gave was that the product would still meet the 96% compliance that it submitted and that was endorsed by Ricardo Rail as our subject matter expert in that area.
Comment on this
We have the national train control centre the total cost of which was going to be €150 million. Is that correct? It turned out that €50 million of that was in effect wasted. We do have the building. As an aside, there are 100 gardaí working in there at the moment. What are they doing? Does Iarnród Éireann have a lease with An Garda Síochána?
Comment on this
We have a lease with the Office of Public Works, OPW, because it manages all of An Garda Síochána's facilities.
Comment on this
I will have to come back to the Deputy on that. It would be a nominal rent. It would not be-----
Comment on this
I do not think it is significant. We will have to come back to the Deputy with the details.
Comment on this
I will have to come back to the Deputy. I am not aware of it being a major part of the project.
Comment on this
Is it a one-year lease or a two-year lease? How long is it for?
Comment on this
Again, I will have to come back to the Deputy. It is longer than that. He was asking me what is done in there. The whole of Dublin traffic control is in there. All the 999 calls that come in are dealt with there. The Dublin metropolitan region is controlled from there. Those staff were previously in Harcourt Street.
Comment on this
Mr. Hendrick does not know how long the lease is. How long is that unit expected to use the building?
Comment on this
From a technical point of view, it is expected to be used in perpetuity but the lease arrangements and actual contract will have a renewal clause. We will come back to the Deputy on the term.
Comment on this
When this whole debacle is eventually sorted out, will staff be moved in there?
Comment on this
We actually have staff in there as we speak.
Comment on this
There are some there but will the centre be going in there?
Comment on this
Yes, 100%. Effectively, the whole of the rail network will be controlled from Heuston. Everything will be brought under one roof.
Comment on this
When the project was started, was it intended that the 100 gardaí would be going in there?
Comment on this
It was not when we started developing the project but the-----
Comment on this
As things went along, the opportunity arose.
Comment on this
The NTA brought it to us before we applied for planning permission. It was brought forward because An Garda Síochána is moving from Harcourt Street and was looking at its space arrangements. It was introduced before we applied.
Comment on this
To go back to the initial stages, Indra provided a 242-page document. There was then an independent review and external experts were brought in to future-proof the tender document. Who were the experts who carried out this review at the initial stages?
Comment on this
Iarnród Éireann had been working with Ricardo Rail for a number of years. It had been working with the company for 15 years prior to this contract being signed. There was an existing arrangement with Ricardo Rail.
Comment on this
Ricardo Rail worked with us on the pre-contract phase with Indra under a particular support contract.
Comment on this
Had Iarnród Éireann been working with it for a while?
Comment on this
Had it recommended this new system or Indra?
Comment on this
To be clear, Ricardo Rail does not recommend a supplier.
Comment on this
It endorsed the compliance matrix from Indra.
Comment on this
It endorsed the 242-page document. From the papers Iarnród Éireann has given us, it seems Ricardo Rail has received in and around €12 million over the years for that. Has it provided value for money for the €12 million it has received?
Comment on this
It is important to say that it has been providing us with temporary staff to support us with subject matter expertise to assist us in managing the technical aspects of this contract with Indra. It has provided us with the supports it was asked to provide during delivery of the contract.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Hendrick still happy enough with its initial assessment endorsing this deal?
Comment on this
The evidence Indra provided was assessed by both our project team and Ricardo Rail's technical experts. Based on the evidence provided, their view was that-----
Comment on this
Of course, Indra itself had assured Iarnród Éireann but that assurance quickly went off track, as the witnesses have said. Difficulties arose and there were six missed deadlines. In November 2022, it was indicated that the software needed to be upgraded. It was outdated by the time Iarnród Éireann got into the nuts and bolts of it. It was quickly outdated.
Comment on this
At the early stages, as we were saying earlier, it moved its DaVinci product to a next-generation platform. That is what it was delivering. In doing that, it was reliant on a generic product, a product development process it was doing centrally as a company. It was outside the project, if that makes sense, but the project then became dependent on that generic product being delivered.
Comment on this
There was assurance that it was being used in two other countries, apart from Lithuania.
Comment on this
As it was going to do for us, it was going to roll it out in other countries as well.
Comment on this
In addition to Lithuania, it was Estonia and Spain.
Comment on this
It was to be rolled out in its own country. At the end of 2024, the board approved an extra €22 million for the project even though there were big problems with it.
Comment on this
In 2023, we flagged a risk that the €150 million budget was going to be exceeded by tens of millions of euro. We notified the National Transport Authority and the Department of Transport of that risk. As it moved forward, it came to a point where we had to seek additional budget because the €150 million budget was all we had approval for. We had to seek further approval for an uplift.
Comment on this
Yes. We have only spent €150 million as we sit here today. We have not reached the €170 million mark.
Comment on this
There are a number of options. One is to get rid of Indra. The second is to get a new company to take it up and run it. Am I correct that a third option is to hire scaffolders or assistants to help Indra continue with the project? Are they the three options?
Comment on this
They are among a number of options that are being considered.
Comment on this
Are other options in addition to those three?
Comment on this
There is some variance but they are part of the options analysis.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Hendrick for that. There were a number of mentions of the project portfolio. The first trains are to be on the Drogheda route. There was mention of the railway orders for Ceannt Station and Foynes. There does not seem to be any new services this year, apart from those for the Ryder Cup. Mr. Hendrick mentioned the 8 a.m. service from Heuston. There was also mention of DART+ west and the catering service. I assume any catering service that would be provided would start on the longest route, which is the Tralee-Dublin route. No additional services are being provided, however. It was also mentioned-----
Comment on this
I will finish with this. It was also mentioned that Iarnród Éireann sought funding for additional services. Has that request been refused by the Government? Was funding not provided for two of those services, including that 8 a.m. service? Is it the case that, although the track is there, Iarnród Éireann is short of funding?
Comment on this
In some instances, we are constrained by the funding envelope. The Deputy is correct in that. In other instances, we are constrained by the availability of fleet. We also have infrastructure constraints. It all goes back to funding and trying to deliver the programme.
Comment on this
There has been a shortage of operational funding.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. I will address my questions to Mr. Kenny. At a meeting of Kerry County Council held on 17 January 2022, Mr. Kenny announced to councillors in attendance that Irish Rail planned to add up to 90 additional car parking spaces at Farranfore train station. Speaking at the time, he said that works would commence by the end of 2022. Mr. Kenny also said that the statutory processes would be carried out between April and June of 2022. To let him know what has happened in Farranfore since 2022, there has been no sign of the 90 car parking spaces. Work did not commence by the end of 2022, as he said it would. The statutory processes he said would be engaged in between April and June 2022 never happened. To top it all off, the bus, which he will know about because the majority of people in this country know about this bus at this stage, is still stopping in the middle of the N22, the main road going through Farranfore, multiple times a day because there is no joined-up thinking between Irish Rail and Bus Éireann. The bus should stop at the train station rather than in the middle of the road, blocking traffic. Will Mr. Kenny explain how he could go before the members of Kerry County Council and say what he said about all of this work that was going to happen with such certainty when it was never going to materialise? Council members have not been able to get a hold of him to have him answer for himself since that famous day in the council chamber. Before I say any more, will he give me a brief response, keeping within the time for the Chairman?
Comment on this
Those statements were made in absolute good faith and in the expectation that we would have the funding to do those works. Ultimately, there was an NTA review of the funding to be made available for the wider car park programme. That ultimately removed the Farranfore works.
Comment on this
I would have to check whether it was a reduction in funding or a reallocation. We have been doing a major programme with the NTA to look at our total car park programme around the network. There are lots of pressures on various stations. This is something we are hoping to confirm. I appreciate the frustration. I assure the Deputy that I was not seeking to mislead. I hope he accepts that. At the time, it was our expectation but ultimately funding-----
Comment on this
A very definite commitment was given.
Comment on this
Could we look at it again and could we please let the members of the council know, let me know and, most importantly, let the people who will be using the car park know?
Comment on this
I will be very happy to provide the update.
Comment on this
Would Irish Rail consider, as was suggested by councillor Jackie Healy-Rae, relocating the Farranfore train station further up the track adjacent to Kerry Airport? This is now an objective of Kerry County Council's development plan, under the Castleisland variation that was recently adopted. It is a very sensible suggestion. If the train station were moved nearer, to the airport it would enhance both services. It is an objective of the duly elected members. Will Irish Rail please look at this?
Comment on this
Certainly, and particularly if it is something the council has supported, we will examine it. Does Deputy Healy-Rae happen to know specifically whether it is the location of the station on the existing line or a realignment also to bring the line nearer to the airport?
Comment on this
A variation will have to be made to accommodate both but looking at the long term it would be very sensible to have the two joined together.
Why can Irish Rail not establish a pedestrian link between Killarney train station and Killarney bus station? This has been long raised, it has been costed and it would make great common sense.
Comment on this
I believe one of my colleagues has recently engaged with Kerry County Council on this.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Kenny give a commitment before the committee that Irish Rail will seriously look at it?
Comment on this
There is existing access. I appreciate that people want to see it improved. All of these things are in the funding envelope. We have discussed this with Kerry County Council recently.
Comment on this
At Farranfore and Minish railway gates, two cameras are being installed. We all know it is proper and right that cameras should be there in case people try to jump the gates and all this type of nonsense. Are they also being operationally used for speed monitoring?
Comment on this
They will be the Garda GoSafe cameras and they will catch speeding and breaking lights.
Comment on this
A long time ago when you left County Kerry and wanted breakfast on the train to Dublin, you could get it. When we did not have much else, we could get a very nice breakfast from very nice people, and I compliment the staff who operate out of Kerry on Irish Rail's service every day. I thank them for the good and nice service. Could we look at bringing back the food please? It is an issue of money and service. It would only be good for the service and the users of it. Will Irish Rail seriously look at this? If we could do it long ago, why can we not do it now?
Comment on this
As the chief executive said earlier, we are looking at having a pilot very soon.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for allowing me in. I have to say, having sat here for the past two hours listening to all of my colleagues speak about delays and money being wasted, I am very concerned about what could potentially happen with the Navan rail line. I am here to speak about the Navan rail line in the hope that nothing like this happens when it comes to delivering the service. It is desperately needed for the people of Navan. The last time we had a rail line between Navan and Dublin was 1947.
Will Irish Rail provide an exact timeline from the consultation stage that is going on now to procurement, construction and opening day? What milestones must be reached between now and the railway order application? How will Irish Rail keep the public informed? Given the history of delays surrounding the project, what makes this attempt different to previous commitments made to the people of Meath? I have done so much on this since I was elected and people still do not believe it is coming. Even though we are holding public consultations and chatting to people, they do not believe it because they have heard it before. I want to assure people that the project is going to happen.
Will there be sufficient train capacity to avoid overcrowding from day one given Meath's rapidly growing population? We are the largest commuter county to Dublin. Why was the decision made to provide only two stations in Navan? What analysis supports this? I do not know why we did not think of putting a train station in Johnstown. The fastest growing population area in Navan is in Johnstown. How are people there supposed to get to the central Navan station? Will there be public transport to get them there? At the central Navan station, we are talking about having no car park spaces, which completely baffles me. I do not know how that has even been considered.
Has Irish Rail co-ordinated with the Meath County Council to ensure housing development is concentrated around the stations? How many new homes does Irish Rail believe the project could unlock around Navan, Dunshaughlin and Kilmessan? Irish Rail is looking at putting 400 car parking spaces in Kilmessan so there will obviously be massive population growth there. Given recent concerns about major rail project delivery and technology programmes, what governance structures will be there for the Navan line project? For 25 years, the people of Navan have heard promises about a railway. Will Irish Rail state clearly what specific event or decision would have to occur for this project not to proceed? If there is no such obstacle, when can the people of Meath realistically expect to board the first train?
Comment on this
I will run through Senator Nelson Murray's queries and give an overview of the timeline of the project. As she has referred to, we have started the non-statutory public consultation on the emerging preferred route and we are having a number of open evenings. We had an open evening yesterday in Navan and we will have one next week in Kilmessan. The goal of this process is to take on board all of the feedback from everybody, including landowners along the route, with a view to finalising our preferred route. We will consider feedback on the stations, as Senator Nelson Murray mentioned. We will have a preferred route locked down by the end of the year. We will need to get it approved by the Government because the next stage will be to develop the design of the preferred route.
We will work towards railway order lodgement by the end of 2028. One of the key milestones by the end of 2027 will be to have a preliminary business case, which will be based on a much more detailed estimate of the construction costs based on the preferred route. We will be looking to submit the preliminary business case to the Government by the end of next year. This will be essential to get approval, which will allow us to enter the planning permission process with An Coimisiún Pleanála by the end of 2028. We will look to the procurement process between 2028 and 2030, to be ready to start construction from 2031 onwards, in line with the greater Dublin area transport strategy.
Comment on this
I presume Irish Rail cannot start on procurement without the railway order.
Comment on this
That is the default but we can look at it.
Comment on this
Can they be done in line with each other?
Comment on this
We will look at it in terms of what options are available to us.
Comment on this
At the moment, the process is sequential in terms of how the infrastructure guidelines work.
It is important to say that our goal is to deliver a DART+ style service, which could offer 15-minute frequency at peak times with a ten-car full train set. These are the new train sets that are in manufacture at present. We hope to get to tender for DART+ West at the end of this year and sign the construction contract within the next year. DART+ West is the first phase of the Navan line because it will bring the DART to Dunboyne in the south of the county. Ultimately, the Navan line will be an extension of this DART line to Dunboyne.
Comment on this
If the good people of Navan are watching this now, can we assure them that there will be a train line in Navan in the next eight, nine or ten years?
Comment on this
Yes, subject to funding. The main issue for all of our projects is getting the funding support.
Comment on this
Irish Rail is moving along on this as though it is definitely going to happen.
Comment on this
We are going on the basis that we will not be constrained.
Comment on this
More than any other project in the past.
Comment on this
It is time for me to bring today's meeting to a conclusion. I did not get a chance to raise any local issue pertinent to Clonmel or the Limerick Junction to Waterford line but there will be another day for that. I know the witnesses are always available outside of the committee structure to engage and I appreciate that. In terms of the options being considered for how we move forward with the TMS, do we have a timeline for a decision on the option?
Comment on this
We are working on it and we will bring a proposal to our board at the end of this month. That will then be subject to the approval of the NTA, which is our approving authority.
Comment on this
I accept that the NTA is a key actor in all of this in terms of it being the primary funder and auditor. I have seen some of the conclusions of its audit reports up until 2023, and we will continue further analysis and scrutiny with the NTA when it comes before the committee on 1 July. More than likely, we will ask the witnesses to come before the committee again in the autumn. I stand over my comments that it is not just a software issue and questions remain about governance and oversight.
The overwhelming message I want to give in my conclusion is to the more than 5,300 employees working in Irish Rail who do a fantastic job. There is always the odd occurrence when somebody is not happy but in the main they provide a fantastic service to more than 1 million passengers on a weekly basis. It is great to see passenger growth and the expected passenger growth between now and 2030. On average, there are 350,000 rail journeys every week with 147 stations. I welcome the upcoming investment in Clonmel. I thank the witnesses for today. I also thank them for the supporting documents provided, the significant financial briefing and the overall briefing. This level of transparency has been provided by Irish Rail, notwithstanding the many various issues, all of which have been discussed today and will be discussed further with the NTA. I thank the witnesses for today and I appreciate their time.