National Fare Structure for Public Service Obligation Services: National Transport Authority
The NTA defended the new national fare structure as necessary to address falling fare recovery, rising operating costs and support further investment in PSO services, including 140 proposed initiatives. Members criticised the increases, particularly their impact on commuters, questioned the transparency and timing of the decision, and highlighted possible inefficiencies, inadequate services and the risk of reducing passenger numbers. The NTA said the changes could generate approximately €70 million in 2027, alongside increased Exchequer funding, but could not guarantee specific new routes until the budget process concluded. It agreed to provide further information on operating costs and discuss with the Department whether the list of proposed service improvements could be published.
Contributions 204–409 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Technically, I do not know how easy it would be to do that in the first place. I have not seen it in other jurisdictions. However, we are certainly providing much more data and more up-to-date data on both passenger numbers and performance on our website than we did in the past.
Comment on this
It is not that I am trying to crack the whip; it is about trying to build public confidence in the services. We had a whole litany of ghost buses over two years where data was not showing. Ghost buses were being reflected. We need to do an element of confidence building so I urge the NTA to think about how to make that data accessible to be analysed by other parties.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Moynihan and call Senator Clifford-Lee, who agreed to switch with Deputy O'Gorman.
Comment on this
Like all my colleagues on this committee, I was dismayed by the announcement of these fare increases. The communication was poor. We had no indication beforehand that it would happen. We have had a lot of engagement as individuals and as a committee with the NTA and there was no indication that this was coming. I would like the NTA to reflect on that and maybe give an indication today as to whether this will be a yearly process.
Commuters on the northern commuter line are on the most overcrowded train service in the country. As has been outlined, particularly the commuters in Balbriggan and Skerries are facing a 50% increase in a short period. When the NTA says there have been no increases to fares since 2018, it falls hollow on the ears of people from Balbriggan and Skerries. It is disappointing that, as was outlined today, that there is no budging on this. It is fixed and the NTA is just informing the committee of it. There has been no consultation with the public representatives or commuters in a particular area.
I was concerned when the NTA said it expects a 2% reduction in passenger numbers and that every time the fares go up, there is a corresponding 2% reduction. Where does the NTA think these commuters will go? Will they just stay at home? No, they will move onto the roads. Dublin is already one of the most overcrowded and congested cities in Europe. Our road network cannot take any more passengers. They have to use rail. The residents of north County Dublin have no other option but to use rail, and they are distressed.
What additional capacity will there be on the northern commuter line as a result of these fare increases? We were led to believe in the communications, as has been outlined by colleagues, that these increases would be ring-fenced and used to increase services and that there would be 140 services. It is disappointing that this has not been published in line with the NTA's determination. Can the witnesses give the committee any specific information about the northern commuter line? What additional capacity will there be? Analysis of the 2027 timetable does not indicate to me there will be any additional capacity on the northern commuter line.
Comment on this
Fare changes do not create capacity. We are not for one minute saying that. What does create capacity is changes to the train system. Next year, we will introduce a battery-electric DART fleet on the northern line and the trains have a higher capacity than those in current fleet. They have a capacity that is approximately 50% higher than the current fleet on that line, so they will provide additional capacity. Simply swapping one train for another will immediately provide an uplift in capacity. Then our intention is to improve the frequency on the northern line by adding additional train services. That is our intention. It will not be next year, but we wish to follow through on that.
Comment on this
When will the frequency increase?
Comment on this
I do not want to lock in a date, but I hope that the following year we will be able to do something on adding an additional service, certainly at peak hours.
Comment on this
The language Mr. Creegan is using is not very encouraging. He hopes that the NTA will be able to do something. Why should people pay huge increases in rail fares when there will maybe, the NTA hopes, be a bit of an increase in a few years' time.
Comment on this
Going back to the starting point, the fares increase, along with additional Exchequer funding, allows us to invest further in public transport services, I hope, for everyone. That does not-----
Comment on this
I will just interrupt Mr. Creegan there because I am tight on time. Why should commuters in north County Dublin, who are on the most overcrowded rail service in the country, pay higher fares to improve services in the rest of the country when they have no other option but to use the rail? They are coming into Dublin city to work. They have no option to drive. They are in a congested city. They will not see any benefit.
Comment on this
They will. We are spending hundreds of millions on the DART+ project, including DART+ Coastal North, on that line. Three fleet orders are on the go, one of which will start to come in next year which will immediately change the fleet on the northern line to newer DART fleet with additional capacity.
Comment on this
That has already been announced. There will be no benefit basically for the commuters in north County Dublin relating to these fare increases because what Mr. Creegan outlined was already decided upon and factored in previously.
Comment on this
The fares increase contributes to the new services and the running of the existing system. We need two things to run-----
Comment on this
Mr. Creegan has not said there will be any new services. He said that maybe, he hopes there might be additional capacity in 2028.
Comment on this
I said there will be new fleet on the northern line next year, which will increase the capacity. It is an uplift in capacity for the northern line for the-----
Comment on this
That has already been announced, factored in and decided upon. I want to talk about the fare increase the NTA announced last week. There will be no benefit for users of the northern commuter line. None of the increase in capacity, the 140 improvements, will be for the northern commuter line.
Comment on this
To the rest of the country.
Comment on this
No. It contributes to operating all of the public transport services, which has to include-----
Comment on this
There will be no direct benefit for the people of north County Dublin.
Comment on this
Mr. Creegan has not outlined it. He talked about DART+. That is welcome and we are looking forward to that, but it has nothing to do with this fare increase, if Mr. Creegan gets what I am saying.
Comment on this
I get what the Senator is saying, but the fares increase goes into an overall pot that pays for the public transport service across the country, which includes the northern line, south-east line, west line and so on.
Comment on this
That is what we are worried about. It is going into an overall pot and will disappear away from north County Dublin. We are not going to get an increased service. Similar to my colleague, Deputy Moynihan, we have areas with huge increases in population and we are not seeing an improved service. While the extra capacity that will be there with the new carriages will be welcome, that is going to be a drop in the ocean. There have been huge concerns, particularly lately, that the trains are shorter and there are only four carriages on trains in the morning. The trains are full at Balbriggan and they still have to go to several other stations after that. There will be no additional benefit for the commuters of north County Dublin. That is clear from Mr. Creegan's answer there.
Comment on this
May I come in on that point? We are going to be introducing, subject to funding, further bus services as part of the BusConnects programme. That is in the ask.
Comment on this
I do not think we have enough time to outline our issues with the BusConnects programme in north County Dublin. I have additional questions for the NTA. I will be in contact with it.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their time today. It is fair to say that the fare increases are disappointing, especially when many people have to rely on often overcrowded services. The justification being given is that the fare increases will go toward funding new services, but the reality is that the only assurance that commuters have at the moment is that the fare increases are going up because those discussions on the new services are all subject to funding. Is there any timeline for when there will be an outcome from those funding discussions?
Comment on this
Funding discussions get settled as part of the budget 2027 process. I am presuming that shortly after budget 2027 is decided, we will be told what our allocation is for next year, which then allows us to put together a final delivery plan for next year, which we hope will include 140 services, but it is dependent upon what funding we get.
Comment on this
Okay. How much does the PSO budget need to be raised by just to maintain services going forward?
Comment on this
We got a €940 million allocation in 2026 for PSO services. The total cost in 2026 of operating the existing services is about €1.5 billion. I am doing a little bit of maths now. I think it will be around €1.65 billion or thereabouts in 2027 to operate the existing services.
Comment on this
How much is required to deliver the additional 140 services?
Comment on this
We have asked for a total of €45 million in 2027.
Comment on this
That is the cost of introducing those new services.
Comment on this
That is the cost of new and enhanced services during 2027.
Comment on this
That includes maintaining those services as well.
Comment on this
To maintain the existing services is included in the previous number.
Comment on this
I think I gave the figure to the Deputy. It is around €1.65 billion. I can come back and confirm that number with the Deputy.
Comment on this
That is fine. Mr. Creegan said more fare increases were expected in the years ahead. What percentage annual increase in fares is expected?
Comment on this
That has to be decided on a year-by-year basis. All we are flagging is that there will be future fare increases. Zero decisions have been made on what they might be.
Comment on this
On the basis that inflation keeps going upward, we are expecting that there will need to be fare increases on a periodic basis.
Comment on this
It is disappointing to hear and signals a lack of commitment from the Department when it comes to the funding of public transport services in the context of a cost-of-living crisis and so on. People are having to rely on overcrowded services. It is very disappointing. I will give one example. I have raised the 7.49 a.m. train to Athenry with the NTA multiple times. It is dangerously overcrowded. People are pushing to get on. They are having to stand face to face with nothing to hold onto. I got an email about this morning's service telling me that a person had fainted due to the heat and the lack of air. This is a problem every single morning. There are only two carriages on that service and we have been told that it will be 2027 at the earliest before additional carriages can be provided. This situation is not sustainable. Can anything be done in the short term to alleviate this problem? That is the question I am getting from the people who have to travel on this train every morning. It is highly dangerous at the moment.
Comment on this
We have raised this directly with Irish Rail on several occasions because we are aware of those kinds of report. The reality is this service is at peak hours, which is when it says there are no spare carriages at all. As I said earlier, next year when we introduce DART services on the northern line from Dublin, that will release other fleet, which is capable of being cascaded. I know that this is one that will be considered for augmentation of the existing train service.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Creegan give a commitment that it will be prioritised for those carriages that come from Dublin? The situation is unacceptable at the moment.
Comment on this
I can give a commitment that we will look at it, knowing its importance, but I do not want to go any further than that here.
Comment on this
I also want to raise the 350 and 351 bus routes. There have been improvements in recent years, which are welcome, but there are still capacity issues and people being left at the side of the road because the buses are full when they come. There are also issues with gaps in the existing timetable. There is no bus between 5.10 p.m. and 7.30 p.m. toward Galway and no bus between 6.15 p.m. and 8.30 p.m. from Galway. That makes it difficult for people attending work or appointments as well as students. It makes it difficult for them to get home at a reasonable time. I know the NTA will have received quite a bit of feedback from passengers and people in the local community about these issues on the service in recent times. Is there any prospect of the timetable being reviewed for that service to make it work a little bit better for commuters? When we are talking about additional services coming forward in years to come, is that something that can be considered as part of that?
Comment on this
We will certainly take that back to the service planning team in relation to the service gap mentioned by the Deputy. Any additional service would, as ever, be subject to funding availability.
Comment on this
Does the NTA review timetables on an ongoing basis? If gaps and issues are identified, is that something the NTA will be willing to respond to?
Comment on this
Yes. If we see them ourselves or if they are raised with us, we will always consider whether something needs to be done or can be done to improve the service.
Comment on this
I hope the NTA will take a look at this. I will continue to correspond with it on that.
Is the NTA disappointed with the failure of the Department to provide the necessary funding? I think it was mentioned earlier that insufficient funding had been provided. I am sure the NTA would like to be able to roll out as many public transport services as it can.
Comment on this
It is important to acknowledge that record funding is already being provided. Almost €1 billion - €940 million - is being provided this year to support the public transport service. More is needed-----
Comment on this
Is it disappointing that the NTA cannot provide new routes?
Comment on this
More is needed to invest at the level we want to invest at.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Creegan and Mr. Ryan for coming in. I know coming before committees is not easy, and I appreciate it. According to the opening statement, operating costs have risen from €971 million in 2019 to €1.379 billion in 2025. That is an increase of €408 million. Can they share with us where that money is going? We have record passenger numbers and record Exchequer support, as Mr. Creegan has just said. We now have a 15% fare increase. Earlier on, before I was here, I think it was said that it would raise approximately €70 million.
That is still not going to be enough to address the capacity issues and the new services that are required. Where is that money going?
Comment on this
Earlier on, we took an action to provide a detailed breakdown. We will do that. As an overview, as the Deputy will know, there has been a big increase in services across the country. That means extra drivers, mechanics, staff, depots and so on. That is part of it. There has been a major increase in the cost of fuel and in operating costs. That is part of it. There are several other factors like that. We will put down a clear list of what that uplift is made up of but it is those kinds of things. It is staff costs, an enlarged network, additional fuel costs and a variety of other related items.
Comment on this
This has to come back to value for money and what people get from paying their taxes. There is now a fare increase. That level of detail is really important. The amount of money being invested is beginning to sound like Monopoly money. It is not unreasonable for people to want to know where that additional money has gone. In 2019, the PSO subvention was around €300 million. In 2022-23, that went up to about €600 million when you take into account the Revised Estimates. It is now at €940 million. We are now adding another €70 million out of commuters' pockets and we are still not meeting the operating costs the NTA has said we need to meet. We are still not there. It could be as high as €1.65 billion. Does that take into consideration the €45 million the NTA is seeking for new services?
Comment on this
No. That is the cost of existing services in 2027. To go back to the point on value for money, we have done some analysis on this, as I said earlier. From 2018 to 2025, taking account of inflation, the cost per kilometre and cost per passenger have stayed around the same and, in some cases, have decreased. We think we are getting value for money. Could we get better value for money? We are certainly working with the operators on that to see where we can get efficiencies but, as I have said, there has not been an overall decline in efficiency and there is evidence of some improvements in efficiency since 2018.
Comment on this
We might need to talk about value for money specifically in the later session. What happened to the Government compensation for cheaper fares? The NTA has said that fare revenue has fallen from €667 million in 2019 to €576 million in 2025. That is part of the case for increasing the fares. However, when the Government introduced the 20% fare reduction in 2022, did it not explicitly provide additional Exchequer funding to compensate for that fare reduction?
Comment on this
We got a PSO increase that compensated us for that.
Comment on this
We got an increase in PSO funding that did recognise the reduced fare revenue and that compensated for that, balancing income and expenditure. However, as the Deputy will know, PSO funding is dealt with on an annual basis. Each year, the sum granted for the following year is part of the budgetary process. In terms of planning services, we would very much welcome a multi-annual viewpoint, allowing us to plan more solidly into the future.
Comment on this
Many people's reaction to the fare increase comes down to the principle of it. In areas like mine in Dublin West, they are being asked to pay more but they do not feel they have had any dividend from the massive increase to €940 million in PSO funding from the Exchequer. There were 75 Dublin to Maynooth weekday services on the Maynooth line in 2019 and there are 74 today. People could not get on the train yesterday morning because it was too packed. We have also seen the impact of ghost buses. What does the NTA say to those commuters who have not seen the benefits of an increase in the Exchequer funding? What are they actually going to get out of this increase of 15% in their fares? What precise improvement is the NTA committing to so that they feel they are getting value for money?
Comment on this
It is fair to say there have been a number of improvements over the years. There has definitely been an uplift in various services in the Deputy's constituency, as she will be aware. However, there is a lot more to do. We accept that. The reality is that, over the past 12 months, we have not been able to introduce any new services. We have just kept the existing ones going. We want to see a return to where we were a few years ago. We want to invest more in putting in new services, where needed, and enhancing existing services. This fare determination facilitates that. We also need additional Exchequer funding to facilitate it. For us it is all about investing in public transport and trying to improve what exists to bring it to a higher level.
Comment on this
I will finish on this. I know Mr. Creegan is saying that he wants to introduce new services. We were introducing new services but it was at the expense of additional capacity. It is a zero-sum approach to say you can either have new services or fix the capacity issues. We need both. The overall picture here is that we and the commuters need to understand what value we are getting for our money because record levels of money are being invested in public transport. We need to understand where that money is going.
Comment on this
First of all, I acknowledge that both witnesses have been sent in here this morning to get lumps kicked out of them. They are being used as a fig leaf for the person who is responsible for this-----
Comment on this
-----which is the Minister for Transport.
Comment on this
I would cite that they have had lumps kicked out of them.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy to reflect on those comments. They do not reflect the spirit of this meeting so far.
Comment on this
We have not seen the Minister before us in a very long time. We have to be clear that the decision to allow fare increases of this magnitude is a political call by Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Independent Members who back them. If €70 million was found in the budget - a budget that has not been agreed yet and that there is still time to change or influence - this big hike that commuters are facing would not have to go ahead. I just wanted to acknowledge that this is not the witnesses' fault.
As well as this 15% average fare increase that has been announced - we know that it is much worse in certain areas and that it is 33% for some central Dublin services - the NTA has also indicated that there will be yearly fare increases in the future. Can the witnesses give me any indication of what those fare increases will be?
Comment on this
The honest answer is "No". It will be determined at a given point depending on the circumstances at that point in time. The biggest determinant is going to be inflation.
Comment on this
I will come back to the point regarding inflation. Has the NTA received any indication from the Department of Transport as regards a formula for fare increases? Has the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, indicated that, if the NTA brings in an extra €70 million in fares in a year, he will go to Deputy Jack Chambers and get an extra €70 million in Exchequer funding? Has any formula been suggested?
Comment on this
Mr. Creegan made the point that inflation drives the fare determination. The level of inflation in the country is now 3.4% while the average fare increase is 15%. Did the Department direct the NTA to increase fares not only based on the current rate of inflation but also to make up for the absence of fare increases in previous years?
Comment on this
No. We have to put our hands up and say that the NTA made this decision. As I have said, we had discussion sessions with the Department through that group.
This was an NTA decision. We were not instructed in the way in which Deputy O'Gorman asked about.
Comment on this
That is the PSO oversight group, of which the Department of public expenditure is a visiting member.
Comment on this
An additional 140 services for next year were mentioned in the submission, and they have come up a lot in the defence of this fare hike. Has funding for any of those additional services agreed yet?
Comment on this
So every one of these will be subject to the conclusion of budget negotiations over the next couple of weeks.
Comment on this
These 140 services are, in my view, being used as a sweetener. There is the stick of the fare increase and the carrot of the 140 extra services. It is very important to establish that these 140 services are not agreed. They are the NTA's request, at a time when the Minister for public expenditure is saying that trade-offs have to be made across Departments. There is every chance that these 140 services could be part of the trade-off the Department of Transport has to make in respect of its final budget.
Comment on this
We have put forward our request which, as Deputy O'Gorman knows, is what is normally done. He is correct, in that we have to await the outcome of the budgetary process before we can be clear. I hope we will be able to do all of what we intend to do. We will not know whether it will be anything less until the budgetary process is finished.
Comment on this
Has the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, given any indication that these services are a priority for him in his budget negotiations? When the NTA made its submission, did he give the NTA a little wink to say that he would get them over the line for it?
Comment on this
We do not operate like that. He is as aware, as Deputy O'Gorman is, of the importance of public transport and of investing in public transport services.
Comment on this
When the fare hike was announced, the article in The Irish Times cited either a spokesperson or a document from the Department of public expenditure stating that it felt that even though passenger numbers have increased in recent years, that increase had not been equal to the increase in overall population levels. Is this a calculation, analysis or metric that the Department of public expenditure is asking the NTA to use?
Comment on this
Did Mr. Ryan see the article in The Irish Times that I am referring to?
Comment on this
I did. I am not familiar with it, but I note that since 2019 our passenger numbers have gone up by 23% overall.
Comment on this
That is well in advance of the population increase in that time.
Comment on this
Was the NTA a bit perplexed on seeing that particular figure or metric?
Comment on this
It was a media article, so we took it no further.
Comment on this
On the issue of growth, we have seen a 23% increase over the intervening period. Mr. Ryan gave a figure earlier regarding an estimation that for every 10% fare rise, we see a 3% reduction in passenger use. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, that is a broad estimate. Local circumstances will always differ, but it is the rule of thumb we use.
Comment on this
So with an average fare increase of 15%, which is the fare increase we are facing at the moment, the NTA would expect a 4.5% reduction in passenger numbers.
Comment on this
Roughly, but I did caveat this earlier by noting that we are at capacity on many parts of our network and that people simply cannot get on board the services. The number that declines is likely to be less than that in reality.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether it will provide reassurance to anybody that people not being able to get on a service will reduce that figure.
Regarding the PSO oversight group, was the impact of the reduction in the number of people using public transport discussed. In particular, was it discussed with the Department of public expenditure?
Comment on this
They were included in our forecasts of impacts of any fare change.
Comment on this
I have three members still to participate and there has been a lot of interest in the committee from committee members. I propose to give other members two minutes each and let the members back in for a second two-minute round. We have ten members in the room and we have 20 minutes, which means two minutes each. I will stick strictly to the two minutes.
Comment on this
Will members of the committee go first within that rotation?
Comment on this
To be fair, the other Members have been here. I have always had respect for those who have been in the room since the beginning of the meeting. Is that agreed? Agreed. There will be two minutes for Deputies Ó Muirí, Toole and Ahern, and I will then go back to the rota. It will be a strict two minutes.
Comment on this
I will have to be quick. Has the NTA ever consulted on a fare determination?
Comment on this
Why does it not consult on fare determinations? This is a huge issue for commuters in particular. They need fare certainty and good quality services. The NTA could bring them with it on that journey if it were to consult. It is a huge decision. Why does the NTA not consult with them?
Comment on this
In my experience, general consultation on price increases usually leads to one outcome. It is not the same as consulting on other things. If we ask somebody whether we should increase something we know what the answer is always going to be.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Creegan not accept that if the NTA engaged with commuters, they would at least see where it is coming from and it could bring them with it rather than the information appearing after the fact?
Comment on this
Price increases are really hard to manage. I take Deputy Ó Muirí's point. We can bring people along a pathway if we can inform them accordingly but there is a certain sensitivity about how we do this and how we announce it, and it makes it very difficult to do this type of consultation.
Comment on this
The Chair has put me on a really short leash. In terms of fare certainty and services, there are services in my area such as the 15 bus route. It is meant to be a workhorse coming from Clongriffin but it is full leaving Clarehall. People have given up on the 27 bus route. I thank the NTA for its correspondence on the 73 bus route, which is under review. I look forward to the output of that review. The 130 bus route is also problematic. These are all existing services that are really struggling in terms of capacity. What split of the new revenue will go into existing services? Everyone is talking about the 140 additional services, but I want to know what will be the split percentage wise that will go into trying to resolve these existing service issues vis-à-vis new services?
Comment on this
I do not have the exact split, but I can say very briefly that we will always try to prioritise capacity issues first, above new services, because we do not want-----
Comment on this
Will the NTA get us a percentage split after this meeting?
Comment on this
The funding we seek for new and enhanced capacity.
Comment on this
Just to clarify is that one quarter into new services or one quarter into existing services?
Comment on this
One quarter of the total funding request for new and existing services will go into capacity and enhanced existing services.
Comment on this
I have calmed down after being 38 minutes late this morning because I used public transport. I understand business, especially small business, and the cost of doing business. The very last thing someone does is pass on the cost of business to their customers in the absence of optimum customer service. Regarding capacity on the 103, 105 and 109 bus services from County Meath, we met in February, seven months ago. We sat in a meeting room and identified capacity issues in Meath East. Can the electric fleet for Dublin Bus be transferred? Can this asset be transferred to Bus Éireann and used on the shorter journeys from the city centre to commuter zone 2 in County Meath to cover these services for commuters? What forward planning and capacity planning does the NTA do and what interaction does it have with Meath County Council? We are seeing massive housebuilding in County Meath. How does the NTA measure efficiency internally? What sort of key performance indicators, KPIs, does it used to measure efficiency? The costs cannot be carried by consumers who are getting a suboptimal service currently. I am not worried about new services, I am worried about current capacity.
Comment on this
To answer those questions briefly, because I am conscious of time, I do not think the electric fleet can be transferred in the manner Deputy Toole suggests. We have not been using the electric fleet for these kinds of longer distances. In terms of forward planning we do have extensive engagement with Meath County Council. We have a strategic planning unit and a network planning unit in the NTA and we are pretty aware of the relevant development plans and of the delivery that is ongoing in Meath. We try to be prepared for it. In terms of KPIs we have an extensive portfolio of KPIs, which we publish on a regular basis.
Comment on this
Yes. We talked earlier about some of those, including operating cost per kilometre and per passenger. As I said, they have been very sustainable over the past few years in real terms.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for attending. Honestly, I was absolutely floored by this decision and the inherent unfairness at the heart of it, particularly given that a week previously, the Government was able to find €400 million behind the back of the couch to subsidise the cost of petrol for people who can afford to own cars. I do not know whether the witnesses would acknowledge that this decision will disproportionately affect people who are lower earners and who are less well off than people who can afford cars. Did the NTA think about that when making this decision?
Comment on this
As I said in my opening statement, we are very conscious of affordability issues and the effect that these decisions have on commuters. We try to balance that against the need to improve the services because that is what we need to do. We do need to improve the services, and that will take additional investment. This is a component part of it.
Comment on this
I understand that but even by the NTA's own metrics, passenger numbers are up 23%, given low fares, since 2019. The NTA is reducing the number of people on public transport by increasing fares. I do not, by the way, blame the NTA for this. This is a political decision, and Mr. Creegan said himself that the NTA got a PSO increase in 2022, when fares were reduced in the first place. Is the PSO just not keeping pace, and is this Government not willing to fund the PSO to the level the NTA needs?
Comment on this
I think I said several times there have been big investment increases in PSO funding over recent years. I think it has almost quadrupled since about ten years ago. It is now at nearly €1 billion, but that is because we have a bigger network and higher operating costs, and that is what is needed. There has been a serious investment by the Government in our services.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but what has changed? The Government has changed. Has investment not kept up at the pace of the previous Government? Why is it necessary to increase fares now when it was not previously? That is what I need to know.
Comment on this
I think I covered that in the opening statement. There has been a change in the contribution level from fares, a dramatic change from what it was a number of years ago. Fares contributed 69% back in 2016; now that is 38%. We are below our European peers in that respect so-----
Comment on this
That does not butter any turnips.
Comment on this
Comparing us to our European peers is disingenuous when we do not offer anywhere near the public transport our European peers do, so I will not over-concentrate on that.
I want to go back to the question I asked the witnesses earlier about Balbriggan and the cost of services. As they know, I have been asking for the analysis of the fare determination of 2025. First, I find it incredible that that analysis has not been done before the NTA comes out with a second determination. Second is the heavy rail census, which was supposed to be published in the first half of this year but which still has not been published. I asked for this and I repeatedly followed up over the summer. I have had to put in an FOI request because I am just not getting any of the analysis or data I have sought. Mr. Creegan did finally send me some information late last night and that indicates that, actually, passengers decreased in Balbriggan by 5% from 2024 to 2025. Now, the reality is that north County Dublin, Balbriggan in particular, is increasing delivery of houses. There is an estimate of at least 1,000, if not 1,500, new people living in Balbriggan in that same period, yet public transport usage has decreased. The NTA has to accept that the public transport fares increase has to be part of that and I really implore Mr. Creegan to look at it. This further increase is only going to disproportionately impact those people living in Balbriggan.
Comment on this
The Deputy will also see that just north of Balbriggan, at Gormanston, there is a big increase, so I-----
Comment on this
From 120 to 220. It is not quite the same thing. We are talking about a much denser area when we are talking about Balbriggan. Also, Gormanston fares decreased, unlike the fares in Balbriggan, which had increased.
Comment on this
We have not had time to do an analysis on the-----
Comment on this
But that is also part of my problem, which is that the NTA came out with a new fare determination without doing an analysis of the previous one.
Comment on this
Thank you. We touched earlier, Mr. Creegan, on next-generation ticketing. Originally, back in 2022, I think the estimated cost was somewhere around €150 million but there was contingency of maybe 50% or 55% built into that figure. I think your most recent evidence to the PAC was that that was somewhere between €220 million and €260 million. I presume there is contingency built into that as well. What is the up-to-date estimated cost for next-generation ticketing? I ask you to comment as well on the July 2028 delivery. What can we expect in July 2028? Is it just for the Dublin metropolitan region and when can we expect a wider roll-out of next-generation ticketing?
Comment on this
In terms of the cost estimate and the figures around, as you say, €220 million-odd to €269 million, there is a cost range there and we are still within that cost range. That cost range has not changed, so the project is being delivered on budget. It is going to plan at the moment. There will be an initial test phase of the new validators early next year, and then we are targeting the roll-out in 2028, and that roll-out will cover the Dublin network in terms of bus, rail and tram, and then we have to look at further expansions beyond that. They are follow-on projects.
Comment on this
Are you familiar with an app that is available to the Local Link network called Metric and, particularly, the benefit of that for those who avail of the door-to-door service, whereby they can get real-time information as to how far the bus is away rather than standing outside their door for 15, 20 or 30 minutes? Is it possible that we could roll out Metric at the local level in the context of the door-to-door services? Are you familiar with that? My understanding is that there is some barrier in terms of IT at the NTA to allowing it-----
Comment on this
I think there is just a concern that data quality is up to the requirements that we would need to provide accurate passenger information-----
Comment on this
It has been looked into, but we will continue to-----
Comment on this
Somebody might come back to me on that. Sorry, it is just I am conscious of time. I call Deputy Cathal Crowe.
Comment on this
I want to go back over some of the figures from this morning. Mr. Creegan stated that fare revenue fell from €667 million in 2019 back to €576 million, yet public transport journeys are at an all-time record high of 343 million. There is a climb in the number of people using transport and there is a drop-off in revenue. Mr. Creegan spoke about modelling and elasticity. There is a point here at which the NTA hopes this will intersect and the costs will get covered. How many months out from that are we, does Mr. Creegan think?
In all the conversations that happened here, as regards the immediate position to go to fare increase, at any point was it suggested that operational costs need to be looked at? Were these KPIs that everyone is subjected to now, certainly in the private sector, looked at? I am thinking of my local bus service, which, when it arrives, is incredible. Some mornings it runs so fluidly; other days people are left in the rain with no bus stops. The bus timetables are not there. You would need a crystal ball to know when the bus is coming. There has to be a quality of service at the other end. Was there any pushback here where the NTA said in the Minister's office, "The NTA will consider this"? There has to be some change operationally. When does the NTA expect these two to intersect and costs to get covered, and did the NTA push back and say "Change your operational costs" at any point?
Comment on this
Fare revenue will never cover the operating cost. This is the public service obligation, PSO, service. It is-----
Comment on this
So how much of the gap will it plug, does Mr. Creegan think?
Comment on this
The intention is that there is a bit of rebalancing from where it is now and-----
Comment on this
But there must be figures. This is bound in figures and stats, so what are those stats? We need to hear them today.
Comment on this
We are at 38% fare contribution at the moment. The European average is 44%. We think we need to go in that direction.
Comment on this
The NTA has modelled this, so how much revenue will it bring in in the coming months?
Comment on this
In the full year this fares increase will bring in about €70 million in fare revenue.
Comment on this
Assuming that passengers keep coming at this level. There will be a drop-off, unfortunately.
Comment on this
It takes account of the drop-off that may occur-----
Comment on this
What percentage drop-off is the NTA expecting? This is key to-----
Comment on this
We have used the rule of thumb of 3% decline for 10% increase.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their contribution. Following up on Knock Airport, I asked Anne Shaw to ask the question of the Minister for it to be funded. Do the witnesses know if that question was asked?
Comment on this
My understanding is that yes, it was, but it is in the same position as all the other services in 2026. We do not have the funding for it.
Comment on this
"Yet", but it may be included in the ask of the 140 routes.
Comment on this
Mr. Ryan mentioned that the 140 routes are in Connecting Ireland. Which phase is that?
Comment on this
The 140 routes, to be clear, cover Connecting Ireland, BusConnects Dublin, BusConnects Cork and town services.
Comment on this
Does it include all of Connecting Ireland-----
Comment on this
The ask is for funding to complete the roll-out of the Connecting Ireland programme.
Comment on this
So that ask, which would include the route that was proposed to me by the NTA team, has been made.
Comment on this
If that is in the Connecting Ireland programme. As I say, I am not 100% sure.
Comment on this
I looked at it on a map there. It is the 444 route proposed in a purple line.
Comment on this
That is positive. Hopefully, it can be funded. One of the things I would like to put on record is the ask to make sure other towns and villages, including Kilkelly, Kiltimagh, Balla, Manulla and Breaffy, along the route are included. The proposal is positive and I hope that it is enacted. It will generate economies of scale. It will connect lots of different routes across the county. It is well done. As I have said, I have always complimented NTA's team on the proposal that it has made which will help create value for money from a taxpayer point of view on all the different public transport routes that will connect, including the airport.
Comment on this
I will return to the question on the trains. I appreciate that there is work ongoing with Irish Rail on looking at the capacity issue but for commuters who are watching this or listening to this or have been in contact with me, waiting a few months when they are terrified somebody is going to faint in the carriage really is not where we need to be. I will ask Mr. Creegan to take that away and see if something can be done more immediately in the short term around additional capacity. I take the point on carriages, but it is in terms of expediting and showing that there is an urgency felt. Mr. Creegan will appreciate that when commuters hear of a fare increase such as this and they do not see the same quality delivered on the rail line they use regularly, whether that be through the delivery of the extra bus service in Adamstown and Clonburris or additional capacity on the rail line, this is where it hurts most. Can I get a commitment from Mr. Creegan that he will try to expedite that and we will get a more immediate solution in the short term to deal with these capacity issues on the trains, whether that be in additional bus capacity or looking at the trains?
Comment on this
On the train side, we cannot magic up fleets. We have to wait until the fleet becomes available next year. On the bus side, that is something we can look at. We will take away that request.
Comment on this
I might ask for an update back to the committee on that.
Comment on this
Returning to the data question, I accept the NTA has not thought about making it open source. In terms of making the granular data available to providers who want to make improvements for customers, is that something the NTA will do and is that part of the overall plan for the deployment of that data? The NTA will have a massive resource when the next generation ticketing is introduced in terms of travel patterns, transport patterns, etc. Will the NTA make that available to operators so that they can make customer improvements as well and allow for innovation from the providers about how they provide public transport services too?
Comment on this
We will certainly use the data. Of course, in service planning, it will be vital.
Comment on this
Will the NTA make it available to providers?
Comment on this
The Deputy must remember the NTA plans services. We will make available to providers data that they require for their operational needs but the NTA does the service planning for the networks and TFI.
Comment on this
The innovation piece is important here. To encourage innovation from providers, it is important for the NTA to make that data available to them too.
Comment on this
On budget day, when the Department of Transport puts out its press release announcing the budget allocation, will we know how many of the 140 additional and new services will have been funded?
Comment on this
At what point will we know that?
Comment on this
The process is that the Department of Transport is told what its allocations are - they may have to do some subdivisions within the Department and I am not privy to that - and at some point, then we get told, "The PSO amount in respect of transport is this". At that stage, we can put that to our estimates of fare revenue and then we can confirm what we are able to do for next year.
Comment on this
When will Mr. Creegan expect to be able to do that?
Comment on this
It is dependant upon the start point - when we are told what our money is. It will take us a few weeks after that.
Comment on this
By December, Mr. Creegan would hope.
Comment on this
The Deputy is assuming we get told on a certain date. Three weeks after the date we are told, we should know.
Comment on this
I ask because when the budget was announced last year there was a big celebration about the amount allocated to the Department of Transport but there was no line saying, "By the way, there will be no new services introduced in 2026." That is something I and other Deputies and Senators had to find out, parliamentary question by parliamentary question and committee hearing by committee hearing. Mr. Creegan set out this ambition - an ambition we all support - to get 140 services. I am trying to understand when we will know what proportion of that will be delivered and what those services will be. Can Mr. Creegan tell me when he thinks that will be?
Comment on this
I repeat that after the funding is confirmed to us - I do not know when exactly that will be because I do not know what distributions may have to occur within the Department of Transport - depending on the level of change there might have been from our ask, it will take us a few weeks to work out what our service will be.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses remind me what is the overall figure the NTA is seeking for extra services for next year? What is that universal figure?
Comment on this
For enhancements to existing services and new services, the total ask is €45 million.
Comment on this
Exchequer funding is up at record levels, the NTA said. It has quadrupled in recent years. Usage is up. The NTA is saying this fare increase would provide €70 million. What is in it for commuters of Dublin West when our train services are down, our bus services on average are at walking speed, and we have had a 17% population increase and over 8,000 homes?
I would like if Mr. Creegan could also give me an update on the N8 airport bus. The Minister said that was the one service he wanted to see introduced in 2026.
I seek one clarification on the Government compensation for cheaper fares. Some €54 million went towards that in 2022. Was there not compensation or a level of compensation provided in 2023, 2024 and 2025?
Comment on this
My understanding is it just gets rolled up into the overall PSO funding. The first year there may have been a separate heading. I stand to be corrected, but I think it is rolled up into the overall PSO funding for the subsequent years. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes. Some of the cost would have been covered by the budget allocation and then, later, Supplementary Estimates during the year. In effect, all the costs of fare schemes were covered over those years.
Comment on this
In terms of what Dublin West is getting out of this, it is the big picture we are looking at here. We are improving public transport services everywhere. This allows us to roll out the next phase of BusConnects, which presumably will allow a further phase after that. All of that eventually will improve transport in the Deputy's area and in other areas. There are benefits in this but, without additional investment, we cannot do those things.
Comment on this
If the NTA is asking people for a specific 15% fare increase, they are entitled to know what they are getting back specifically as well.
Comment on this
In the Dublin area, I would say they are getting back the BusConnects programme. In terms of the rail, they are getting back the DART programme. They will not all come in one year, but that is what we are investing in and the services that are going to be delivered under this.
Comment on this
The N8 is being worked on. That is my understanding.
Comment on this
Yes. We hope, subject to funding, we will be able to introduce the N8 in 2027.
Comment on this
Time is against me and I want to bring this meeting to a conclusion. I thank Mr. Creegan and Mr. Ryan for attending today. I do not think anyone dragged them in here kicking and screaming, nor do I think anybody tore lumps out of them today. This is not a Colosseum or an episode of "The Hunger Games", as long as I am Chair. While I have been in the Chair over the past 18 months, we have always operated in a respectful manner, obviously, demanding accountability. It is important that we scrutinise these decisions. In essence, today's discussions demonstrated the difficult balance involved. Like all committee hearings, with stakeholders that may be looking in, we will carefully reflect on today's evidence.
There are a number of follow-ups. I asked for details of that significant increase in operating costs. The NTA has committed to engaging with the Department. It is important that we publish that list at the earliest opportunity. I do not see how it undermines the budgetary process, but I will leave that to Mr. Creegan. There was a number of other asks as well but I will ask the clerk to the committee to follow up directly with Mr. Creegan's office.
I again thank the witnesses for appearing before us. The joint committee stands adjourned until 9.30 a.m. on Wednesday, 23 September, when we will meet with representatives from the Road Safety Authority and Transport Infrastructure Ireland.