We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport

Long-term Strategy and Plans for the Future Development of Irish Ports: Discussion

Summary

Port companies urged a coordinated national approach to expanding and protecting port capacity, with ports recognised as critical infrastructure, strategic land safeguarded, consenting streamlined and a clear framework for State co-investment. Cork, Shannon Foynes and Waterford highlighted offshore wind and future freight needs, while Dublin stressed its near-capacity operations and the importance of protecting its trade role. Witnesses also cited rail links and maintenance dredging as essential to resilience and regional development. The draft ports policy was welcomed, but companies called for stronger practical commitments; questions on Port of Cork governance were curtailed as outside the session’s main focus.

Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are back in public session. This engagement is with port companies to discuss the long-term strategy and plans for the future development of Irish ports. On behalf of the committee, I am pleased to welcome representatives from the port companies. From the Port of Cork, I welcome Ms Ann Doherty, chief executive officer. From the Shannon Foynes Port Company, I welcome Mr. Pat Keating, chief executive officer. From the Dublin Port Company, I welcome Mr. Barry O’Connell, chief executive officer, and Mr. Eamonn O’Leary, chief financial officer. From the Port of Waterford, I welcome Mr. David Sinnott, chief executive officer.

The format of the meeting is that we will hear the opening statements first, followed by a question-and-answer session with the members of the committee. I ask members to be concise in their questions to allow witnesses the opportunity to participate. I propose seven minutes per member for the question-and-answer session. We will proceed according to the speaking order.

I am required to read to the witnesses a note on privilege. They are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside of the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

I invite Ms Doherty to make her opening statement on behalf of the Port of Cork.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

Good morning. I thank the Cathaoirleach and members for the opportunity to address the committee. My message today is straightforward. Ireland must plan port infrastructure, strategic land investment and consenting as one national programme. Without an integrated approach, we will not have the capacity Ireland needs for future trade, offshore renewable energy, ORE, or resilient international supply chains, nor will we be able to realise strategically located urban lands for regeneration.

I will make the case for four actions: to protect strategic port land and future capacity, to establish a national port infrastructure investment framework, to co-ordinate the delivery of nationally significant port projects and to recognise ports as critical national infrastructure.

The Port of Cork is a tier 1 port of national significance and a core port on the EU trans-European transport network, TEN-T. It is also one of only two ports in Ireland capable of handling all six principal modes of port traffic. Its role extends well beyond Cork Harbour. The port provides essential capacity for Irish trade, connects the southern region to international markets, supports energy security and strengthens national supply chain resilience.

In 2025, Irish lo-lo traffic reached a record 1.3 million TEUs, which was an increase of 7%. More than half of Irish port traffic is now unitised, yet it is concentrated in only four ports in the Republic, with approximately three quarters moving through Dublin. That is why capacity at alternative gateways, such as Cork, is a national resilience requirement. The 2024 incident at Holyhead demonstrated the consequences of relying on a limited number of critical routes and facilities.

Our masterplan 2050 provides the long-term framework for our river-to-sea strategy, with the phased movement of activities from the city quays and Tivoli to modern deepwater facilities in the lower harbour. This replacement capacity must be delivered before strategically located urban lands can be released for housing-led and mixed-use regeneration. Port investment and urban regeneration are therefore not competing objectives; the first is a prerequisite for the second.

The Port of Cork is already delivering. The €94 million Cork container terminal opened at Ringaskiddy in 2022. The €100 million CORE-1 multi-purpose berth is now under construction. Together with the proposed €70 million deepwater berth extension, these projects have secured €38 million in EU CINEA funding. They will strengthen deepwater capacity and support offshore renewable energy.

Two constraints now require national action. First, land at Ringaskiddy is finite. The immediate offshore renewable energy programme requires 32.5 acres for storage, marshalling and related activity, while future trade growth will also require terminal, logistics and waterside capacity. Second, major infrastructure must compete for limited balance-sheet and borrowing capacity.

The next phase at Ringaskiddy would provide a 400 m berth and 45 acres of lay-down space, all on reclaimed land, at a current estimated cost of €439 million. It would deliver substantial national value, but its direct commercial return would not support the scale and risk of the investment through the port’s balance sheet alone. This is not an argument for general subsidy. It is a case for addressing a specific market limitation. Nationally necessary infrastructure generates public and wider economic benefits that cannot be captured fully through port charges.

There are four priorities. The first is to protect strategic port land and future capacity. The final national ports policy should require existing and future port lands to be identified and safeguarded for trade growth, offshore renewable energy, logistics, energy security and industrial development. For Cork, this means protecting Ringaskiddy and planning now for subsequent phases of the masterplan 2050.

The second is to establish a national port infrastructure investment framework. The State should be able to co-invest, case by case, where wider public value exceeds direct commercial return. The framework should complement port investment and combine port equity, commercial borrowing, EU grants, State investment and proportionate risk sharing.

The third is to co-ordinate delivery of nationally significant port projects. Strategic projects should not have to navigate disconnected planning, marine, environmental, road, utility and funding processes. The Government should establish one co-ordinated delivery approach across the relevant Departments, agencies, local authorities and port companies while maintaining environmental protections and statutory scrutiny.

The fourth is to recognise ports as critical national infrastructure. Ireland needs a long-term national port capacity and resilience programme that assesses future trade, energy and supply-chain requirements across the port network, recognises the complementary roles of ports of national significance and identifies infrastructure needs ahead of demand.

The Port of Cork has a distinct and complementary role within the national port system. We have invested, secured planning approval, attracted EU support and demonstrated our ability to deliver. We are ready to invest further, maintain commercial discipline, work with Government and other Irish ports, and remain accountable for delivery. The choice is clear: Ireland can plan and build port capacity ahead of demand, or it can react after constraints emerge, and trade, investment and energy opportunities have moved elsewhere. I ask the committee to support these four priorities and to advance them through the final national ports policy.

I also invite the committee to visit our port to see our operations across six sites in Cork Harbour, the world’s second-largest natural deepwater harbour.

I thank the committee and look forward to members' questions.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Ms Doherty. We note her invitation.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

I thank the committee for inviting me to discuss the long-term strategy and plans for the future development of Irish ports.

Shannon Foynes Port Company is Ireland’s largest bulk port company and has statutory jurisdiction on the Shannon Estuary covering 500 sq. km. With channel depths of up to 32 m, we handle the largest vessels entering Irish waters and our activities have a trade value of circa €8.5 billion per annum supporting 3,900 jobs. Both EU and national policies endorse the strategic importance of Shannon Foynes by including it at the top of their respective policy hierarchies. Importantly, there are several sites adjoining the estuary, extending to 1,200 ha, that are zoned for maritime development, making Shannon Foynes ideally suited for future national port infrastructure of scale for this country. To fully realise its comparative advantages, the development of the port is led by its 30-year master plan, Vision 2041.

Our plans are consistent with Government policy in areas such as the national planning framework, NPF, regional development and climate action and take account of freight market dynamics due to population growth. Accordingly, our master plan, Vision 2041, focuses on the following four themes: deployment of offshore wind at scale; required port expansion to meet expanded, diversified and more sustainable logistics services; positioning the Shannon Estuary as a green energy park by integrating energy supply and demand; and implementation of the Limerick docklands framework strategy

Our port master planning identified the development of a new port terminal on Foynes Island as essential for its implementation. We have made substantial progress in the pre-planning phase of Foynes Island with, for example, the marine area consent, MAC, received last July. This new 700 m jetty, with 18 m alongside and over 25 ha of quay set-down, is on track for submission to planning in early 2027. This new jetty will be multifunctional and will provide capacity for both future offshore renewable demands and national freight and logistics growth. Furthermore, it will be situated at an uncongested point in the national road and rail network, assuming completion of the Vision 2041 transport objectives.

The Limerick-Foynes rail and road schemes are key transport requirements of Vision 2041. Encouragingly, these projects are under way and together with the port infrastructure planned for Foynes will transform it into a major national energy, freight and logistics hub. Successful implementation of our plans will be transformational for the country. Developments at Foynes will provide substantial port capacity and resilience for the national freight sector. The Atlantic’s renewables resources could assist national energy independence. Freight transport could be considerably decarbonised by reducing tonne per kilometre travelled and introducing a modal shift to rail. Resulting economic impacts will be in the order of tens of thousands of jobs created and billions of euro invested in supply chain and route-to-market infrastructure and facilities along the entire western seaboard.

The successful implementation of our plans requires a collaborative and co-operative approach with all stakeholders. In that regard, the following areas are relevant. Regarding ports policy, Shannon Foynes broadly supports the direction of the draft policy. However, the final ports policy could provide stronger commitments and greater certainty in five critical areas. These are: support for the delivery and realisation of strategic projects within existing port master plans and specifically our Vision 2041 master plan; the Shannon Estuary should be recognised as a nationally strategic Atlantic energy and industrial platform, with Foynes Island deep-water port as a critical enabling investment; a more balanced policy approach to biodiversity protection and strategic infrastructure delivery; alignment with the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026; the identification of a west coast offshore energy pathway is required and should include designated maritime area plan, DMAP, route-to-market, grid and port capacity; and the revised funding position should be turned into a practical funding toolkit outlining funding access and governance requirements.

On offshore renewable energy policy, Atlantic renewable energy requires a proximate deep-water port.

Accordingly, the scheduled publication of the national DMAP will provide further certainty to the sector and further certainty for enabling infrastructure such as grid and ports. We welcome the significant progress being made to date on the national DMAP. We note that the focus to date has been on the identification of broad areas and that future phases will also concentrate on the delivery of offshore renewables, ORE, from these areas. We believe an integrated approach is essential for Atlantic offshore renewables to materialise in the next decade.

On hinterland connectivity, the completion of the Limerick to Foynes road scheme is strongly emphasised in our plans. While construction for phase 1 has commenced, we urge that procurement and construction for the remaining sections would commence as soon as possible. The reopening of the 35 km Foynes to Limerick rail line is due early next year. We would like to take this opportunity to thank Irish Rail and the Department of Transport for their work in reopening this vital connectivity link to Foynes Port. Similarly, the reinstatement of the western rail corridor will add significant synergies to this line and to rail freight generally.

I look forward to discussing the aforementioned with the committee. There is also an open invitation to the committee to visit Foynes Port as well.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. Keating. We note that invitation as well. I invite Mr. O'Connell to make his opening statement on behalf of the Dublin Port Company.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

I thank members for the invitation to appear before the committee.

Dublin Port is the State’s most significant trading gateway and a key part of Ireland’s national economic infrastructure. Dublin Port handles almost half of all goods moving through Irish ports and 78% of all containers or trailers, which are unitised freight. According to the Irish Maritime Development Office, IMDO, around €165 billion worth of trade passes through the port every year, which accounts for around 46% by value of Ireland's total goods, imports and exports.

Dublin Port’s scale is due to several factors, including location, connectivity and an established role at the centre of Ireland’s freight and logistics networks. The port is close to the greater Dublin area, which is Ireland’s largest concentration of population and economic activity, and 61% of heavy goods vehicles using Dublin Port have their origin or destination within 40 km of the port, which rises to 73% within 90 km. The port also has direct access, via the Dublin Port Tunnel, to the M50 and national motorway network and benefits from a naturally sheltered location at the mouth of the River Liffey. Trade through Dublin Port includes food, medicines, fuels, clothes, cars, animal feed, cement, steel and raw materials for manufacturing, to mention but a few. It is also the primary hub for our high-value exports that pay for so much of what we consume.

It is therefore of vital importance to the national economy that Dublin Port can operate efficiently, and maintain and build sufficient capacity to meet growing demand. An IMDO study of capacity across the Irish port system highlights the limited ability of other ports to accommodate Dublin’s volumes. In a scenario where Dublin’s traffic had to be displaced, other ports could at best accommodate about 40% of its roll-on, roll-off or ro-ro traffic and 60% of its container freight, dependent on additional yard space being available. Diversion would also impose additional transport and logistics costs given Dublin Port primarily serves a market within 90 km of it. This concentration of trade means that maintaining sufficient capacity and resilience at Dublin Port is a national rather than simply a port issue. In every practical sense, therefore, Dublin Port is critical national infrastructure.

Ensuring this critical national infrastructure has enough capacity to meet Ireland’s needs, before demand arrives, is core to what we do. Since 2017, we have delivered 80 construction projects, with a combined budget of €557 million, all on or under budget within Ireland’s busiest working port and without central Exchequer funding. Along the way the port has absorbed Brexit, Covid, the Ukraine war, increasing storm severity, climate change and the closure of Holyhead.

That track record of delivery is important because we have a detailed and carefully considered master plan, which is a multibillion capital programme to 2044. This forward planning is crucial because our container terminals are already running at close to 100% utilisation leaving no headroom for recovery from future disruptions or growth in demand. Our building programme will keep port capacity ahead of demand, provided the planning and consenting system keeps apace and the scarce land we have is protected for port use. The reality, however, has become more complex over the years.

In terms of what we ask, we welcome the draft revised national ports policy, which closes the debate around relocating Dublin Port and puts port capacity at the centre of national policy. We believe it can go further in supporting ports to deliver their national mandate.

We particularly draw the committee’s attention to four areas where further action could have a transformative impact on Irish ports.

First, it is imperative that port infrastructure projects are designated as critical national infrastructure under the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026, with a seat for ports on the accelerating infrastructure task force. This is not about ports competing for priority with other sectors. Ports are critical enablers to the delivery of infrastructure projects. The priority should be to ensure that nationally important port developments are not delayed or deprioritised at the expense of the national economy.

Second, service standards should be set for consenting bodies, just as ports are held to service standards. The process for securing consent for port infrastructure has become significantly more complex since the last national ports policy was introduced in 2013. New planning legislation, the introduction of the maritime area consent process and additional requirements, involving multiple agencies, have added stages to the development process. For projects in the maritime area, for example, a maritime area consent is required before a formal planning application can proceed. That means important elements of the consenting process must be undertaken sequentially rather than in parallel. The final policy should provide for statutory timelines for consenting bodies and enable processes to run in parallel, wherever possible.

Third, there is a need to protect and preserve port lands for port purposes. Operational port land should be recognised as strategic national infrastructure in the national planning framework, with a dedicated port infrastructure zoning, so that decisions about its use are made nationally and consistently, rather than locally or case by case. For example, we acknowledge that it is expected that State bodies play a part in delivering solutions to the housing crisis, but scarce port lands ought not to be rezoned for housing, with our role being to ensure that there is sufficient capacity for all the building materials the State will need.

There is also an immediate opportunity to put this principle into practice. One tangible benefit from engagement with this committee would be, based on an engagement with the Office of Public Works, the return to port use of under-used State agency-held land by the end of this year. For example, 14.6 ha of core port land at Dublin Port was made available to the State to manage the consequences of Brexit. The Comptroller and Auditor General recently indicated that this land was under-used and much of it idle. It needs to be returned for core port use, not kept idle.

Fourth, a long-term financing framework to support future investment should be agreed. Our annual capital investment is set to grow from an average of €60 million to €175 million per annum for the foreseeable future, with net debt rising to around €1 billion. As a self-financing commercial entity, we will finance this through debt and from our own revenues. A long-term investment programme needs an equally long-term financing strategy, agreed with the Department of Transport, NewERA and the Department of public expenditure. This should cover borrowing, pricing, a multi-year dividend framework and funding for public amenities that generate no commercial return, such as roads, greenways and dredging.

Dublin Port is critical national infrastructure. It carries nearly half of the State’s international goods trade each year. It keeps our shelves stocked, fuel flowing and factories supplied and it has done so through Brexit, Covid and the closure of Holyhead. We have a record of delivering major construction projects under budget and inside Ireland’s largest and busiest working port, and a detailed plan to continue building the capacity Ireland needs up to 2044, but we need active State support to allow us to deliver that plan. Our request is simple: enable Dublin Port, as a commercial semi-State company, to continue facilitating international trade and to build the resilience this country needs. This means the following: recognising nationally important port projects as critical national infrastructure under the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026; protecting operational port land through the national planning framework; making consenting processes work more efficiently; and putting in place a long-term financing framework for investment.

Finally, we would very much welcome the opportunity to invite the committee to visit Dublin Port and tour the port estate from both land and sea because that is the only way to get a full appreciation of it.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Mr. O'Connell and we note the invitation. I invite Mr. Sinnott to make his opening statement on behalf of the Port of Waterford.

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach, Deputies and Senators for the opportunity to appear before the committee and contribute to its consideration of the long-term strategy and future development of Irish ports. I am very proud to be the CEO for the Port of Waterford. At the outset, I will give some information on the port.

The Port of Waterford is one of Ireland's oldest ports in the State and last year we celebrated 1,111 years of existence.

Currently, our principal commercial operations are at Belview on the River Suir, approximately 8 km downstream from Waterford city. Belview has a kilometre of quays and we use these quays to handle lo-lo containers, bulk and other project cargo. We are strategically located on Ireland's south-east coast and our facilities complement the ro-ro and passenger facilities at Rosslare.

A particularly important feature of Waterford is our connectivity. The port has uncongested access to the motorway network via the M9. It is one of a small number of Irish ports with a rail line directly onto the quayside. There is an existing scheduled rail freight service to Ballina and capacity for additional services. This combination of maritime, road and rail tells our connectivity story.

Our location is also significant. We provide a maritime gateway for the south east but our catchment extends well beyond that region. The port trades with our European neighbours and much further afield. Importantly, there is capacity at Waterford to do more.

In the recent draft national ports policy document, we were pleased to see our proposed designation as a port of national significance. This designation properly recognises not simply what Waterford does today, but the contribution it can make to Ireland’s future supply-chain resilience, regional development and energy transition. We welcome the designation but there must be practical consequences. Our port has lo-lo capacity, bulk capacity, strong road and rail connections and the potential to accommodate additional freight. At a time when capacity pressures are emerging elsewhere, particularly on the east coast, that represents an opportunity to properly realise the value of existing port infrastructure. We hope the final ports policy will examine how improved rail freight connectivity could allow ports such as Waterford to play a greater role in serving the national market.

In our submission to the national ports policy, we suggested a practical initiative bringing together the port, road hauliers and other participants to optimise port capacity and freight flows. As I am sure committee members appreciate, hauliers understand better than almost anyone the practical factors determining freight movements, be they customer requirements, route choice, cost, port access or journey times. Bringing that expertise together with the port and the Government could identify practical measures needed to move additional freight through Waterford and, potentially, alleviate pressures elsewhere.

Dredging the navigation channel in Waterford Harbour is not an optional commercial activity for us. It is what keeps the port open and vessels moving safely. There needs to be a much clearer distinction between capital dredging, which creates new infrastructure, and maintenance dredging, which maintains existing infrastructure. Maintaining Waterford's navigation channel is, in principle, not different from maintaining an important road or rail corridor, yet the substantial recurring cost is borne by the port and it reduces our capacity to build reserves and invest in future infrastructure. The cost of dredging accounts for 15% of our turnover. It is a substantial burden and one that can never be deferred or postponed.

Other European countries recognise the distinction between maintenance and capital dredging. In Germany, the Federal Government funds navigation-channel dredging and we believe Ireland should examine a similar approach. We also need a simpler and more predictable consenting system for recurring maintenance dredging. It should not take years to secure permission to continue maintaining an established navigation channel.

Coming to investment in ports, the ambition in the new ports policy is substantial. Ports are expected to contribute to freight capacity, offshore renewable energy, decarbonisation, supply-chain security, regional development, international connectivity, energy security and, increasingly, national defence – all of which are national public-policy objectives. Transformational investment to deliver them cannot always be funded solely from the retained earnings and commercial borrowing capacity of individual ports. We therefore welcome the proposed relaxation of restrictions on Exchequer support for commercial ports. The final policy should go further and establish a clear framework setting out when the State will participate in important port investment.

Waterford is well positioned to contribute to developments in offshore renewable energy, ORE, particularly those associated with tonn nua and the south coast DMAP. There are opportunities for Waterford to support ancillary activities for these wind farms at the construction phase and the operations phase. State investment in ports will be needed to provide the facilities for ORE projects that might otherwise be handled at ports outside the State.

On the regulatory environment, we fully support robust environmental, planning and marine regulation but regulation needs to be proportionate, predictable and timely. Too often, infrastructure projects encounter sequential processes involving different State bodies, adding years to delivery without necessarily improving the regulatory or environmental outcome. For important port infrastructure, Ireland should move towards co-ordinated and, where legally possible, parallel processing of State consents.

Our message to the committee is a straightforward one. The new national ports policy represents an important opportunity. Its success will ultimately be judged not by the designations it creates or the ambitions it expresses, but by whether it enables ports to deliver. For Waterford, that means making better use of existing capacity, maintaining safe access to the port, creating a realistic framework for strategic investment, reforming slow and complex consenting processes, enabling our contribution to offshore renewable energy and recognising resilience as a national objective. If we get those things right, the Port of Waterford can make a greater contribution to Ireland's freight system and energy transition, the economy of the south east and the resilience of the State as a whole.

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I look forward to discussing these issues with the committee and would also like to extend an invitation to the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee to visit us at the Port of Waterford to see the current facilities and have further discussion about the potential of our port.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Thank you, Mr. Sinnott, and we note your invitation. I will now invite questions from members.

Comment on this

Profits at Port of Cork rose by almost half in 2025, so the company is not under any financial pressure, but a lot of questions have to be answered about corporate governance failures. They are a little bit harder to explain, I suspect.

I want to talk about Port of Cork's legal spend. It went from €165,000 in 2023 to over €1 million in 2024. Was that million spent? How much of it was related to disputes and how much to current staff and directors and to former chief executives?

I will also ask about the Cobh situation. After seven years, the port has conceded a right of way to the people of Cobh. The court directed the Port of Cork bear the costs. What was the total cost of that bill? Who in Port of Cork authorised taking residents to court? Why was the decision taken? Out of that million euro-plus spent on legal advice, was there any time the board was told that this could fail? It got a tremendous amount of legal advice and I find it amazing that nobody would advise it that that action would fail.

I also question the internal controls of Port of Cork. In 2024, a report was carried out and it confirmed there were no weaknesses causing material losses in those controls, but there were.

When did the board learn of arrangements concerning a company storing containers free of charge? What was known about that? Who signed off on that? How much revenue was lost?

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I remind the Deputy the purpose of the meeting is to discuss the long-term strategy for the development of Irish ports. That was clarified at the start of the meeting.

Comment on this

I am aware of that.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am not immediately clear what links what the Deputy is raising with the long-term strategy. Maybe he will give that clarification to the witnesses.

Comment on this

No problem. If there is a corporate governance problem or there are questions around the operations of Port of Cork, the long-term strategy of the port is compromised. It is very simple.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

It sounds very simple and I thank the Deputy for that clarification. Let us also be clear we invited the witnesses here to speak about the long-term strategy for the ports in question. I ask the Deputy to direct his questions to the themes raised under that topic for the remainder of his time.

Comment on this

Navigo and Governance Ireland had nine recommendations for Port of Cork in October 2024.

How many of those have been implemented by the Port of Cork as it stands? Additionally, there is Samskip. There is an email going around about anti-competitiveness. We have seen that email. That led to the €380,000 in charges being manually deleted from the Port of Cork. I ask the witnesses to give us the information on who deleted it and why it was deleted. Are there other companies having their charges deleted by the Port of Cork?

I wish to talk about the Tivoli housing statement. There was a statement made previously that the Port of Cork will be in Tivoli until 2045. Was that discussed with Cork City Council? Was it agreed with Cork City Council? Was it agreed with the Department of housing before it was announced?

Regarding Ms Doherty's appointment, freedom of information records show that the board members raised concerns when she was hired. How many directors objected to Ms Doherty being hired? Are those objections minuted? Was the Department------

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Deputy, that is-----

Comment on this

Was the Minister consulted?

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Deputy, I am speaking.

Comment on this

I am hearing the Leas-Chathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Yes, then you stop speaking when I speak. That is how the Chair operates at this committee.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

This might be the Deputy's first time here. This is how we operate. I am not really clear how the appointment of an officer of the company relates to the long-term strategy of the port. I ask the Deputy to desist from that questioning. Any remaining questions the Deputy has on-----

Comment on this

I am just asking was the Minister-----

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

-----the long-term strategy of the port-----

Comment on this

I am asking was the Minister-----

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Please, do not talk over me. I ask the Deputy to direct his remaining time to questions on the long-term strategy for the Port of Cork.

Comment on this

I am asking if the Minister was consulted, who was consulted and who was on the interview panel.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I ask the Deputy to justify to me how that relates to the long-term strategy of the Port of Cork, please.

Comment on this

If there is a conflict in the board and if the board is taking legal advice and over six members of the board are in conflict, then it has an effect on the long-term strategy.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

For the remainder of the Deputy's questions, I am going to ask him for context on how this relates the long-term strategy.

Comment on this

The seven minutes includes time for answers as well

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

It is up to the Deputy how he wants to spend his time. If we are going to spend it this way, that is his decision. I ask the Deputy to give context for the remainder of his questions.

Comment on this

I ask the chief executive to send to this committee in writing, within two weeks, a breakdown of the €1 million legal bill and the total cost of the Cobh case. I would also like to see information regarding the free storage deal and that a register of interest and a copy of the Governance Ireland report be made available not only to this committee, but also to the Minister for Transport also.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The witnesses have one minute and 25 seconds to give their answers. I will ask them to cease answering when the time expires. If the witnesses feel comfortable, I ask them to answer the questions on the matters on which they were invited to attend the committee.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I appreciate the Deputy's questions but I am mindful of the subject matter that committee has today and the time available to the ports. Therefore, I am not sure how it will take up the business of the committee. I am very happy to address whatever the committee would like me to. I can answer some of the questions. In relation to the legal spend, predominantly the legal spend is in relation to the development of our ORE facility. As he knows, we have a subsidy company that has been established. We have a commercial loan with ISIF. A lot of the spend is in relation to the legals around that, but I can provide the committee with the relevant information.

In relation to the Cobh right of way, the most important thing for the port authority is to operate its services and facilities safely. Safety is my number one priority. The case has been going on for a very long time. I was in court. I cannot give the Deputy a breakdown of the costs because that is before the courts. It is for noting today and the apportionment of costs.

I am very satisfied that we have a very robust system of governance in our company. I have a very competent board of members who have been appointed through the State boards process. All appointments have been through the rigour of that process. We work within a very strong governance framework. Our board oversees the activities of the company.

Some of the other matters that the Deputy has raised are confidential matters. I am very satisfied that any deal with any customer was subject to a legal commercial agreement. That is very important. All our customer relationships are guided through commercial agreements. That might be the most important.

However, I would be concerned if the committee felt that the Port of Cork was not capable of delivering what is required for Ireland because it is. We have a proven track record. We are building infrastructure. We are delivering services. Our company is growing. Our earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, EBITDA, has improved significantly. We are providing a service and employment to the communities of Cork and the wider area.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Ms Doherty. The facility remains available to Ms Doherty if there is any follow-up information she wants to share with us, particularly regarding the long-term position within the port. I will give Ms Doherty that opportunity.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I call Deputy Daly.

Comment on this

I thank all of the witnesses for their opening statements. I also thank them for the invites. We have already visited the port of Foynes. I will direct one or two questions to Mr. Keating first. He said that he was looking for greater certainty in some critical areas and that he wanted support for the delivery of the strategic projects. Are there particular challenges there?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Like any large-scale investment, certainty is key, particularly for the funding of projects. Regarding our policies, we have referred a lot to the planning system and critical infrastructure. It is about ports being recognised as critical infrastructure of the State, which they are. The ports policy recognises that. We now have critical infrastructure legislation. Regarding the port projects that we are all speaking of here today, we currently have nine projects designated as critical infrastructure. Ports should be included in that envelope because-----

Comment on this

That was mentioned by Mr. O'Connell as well. Has Mr. Keating had engagement with the Department in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

We have been making the point about that. We certainly made it very strongly in our submission to the port's policy. The consultation period just closed. Other areas for us would include the likes of ORE. We have the national DMAPs on the way for the west coast. Areas are being identified currently. It is a two-stage process where there is the identification piece, in which one identifies areas, and then the delivery criteria around that, which requires ports, grid and all of that. That needs to be part of the one. The Department of climate is undertaking that process currently. It published the areas about two weeks ago in Galway. There is going to be a further refinement exercise, but-----

Comment on this

Are there any particular challenges that this committee can-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Number one is that the programme that the DMAP is following be adhered to. It is committed to by the Department. It is important that it does happen. What these DMAPs do is build momentum - we have seen it with the south coast DMAP - for the entire industry, which can mobilise around the DMAP and that area. We speak about offshore energy in terms of just the electricity produced, which is important, but there is a whole ecosystem around it, including an economic activity development supply chain in terms of building out the requirements for the wind farms. When we bring that power ashore, we have a demand piece and can locate large users within the region. The Shannon Estuary region is unique, in that we can integrate energy generation with energy demand and create that regional development benefit.

Comment on this

Mr. Sinnott from Waterford mentioned rail connectivity. There is the new freight rail. However, there is no passenger availability on that. Does Mr. Keating think a trick has been missed there?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The rail has been developed initially for freight. The good thing about that in a way is that rail freight is much heavier than passenger, so the signalisation can be upgraded in time, but the main capital expenditure, capex, infrastructure is complete because rail freight is so much heavier. As the opportunities develop in time, that opportunity is there. The main thing for us is that the rail is up-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Keating think that should be pushed on as quickly as possible with the number of jobs we are talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Shannon Foynes Port is more supply chain freight. We would see the freight as being the precursor. Elements like the western rail corridor are important as well so that we have more of an expanded rail freight network. For cruise traffic, for example, which is developing, we could potentially have extensive passenger use from Foynes to Shannon Airport for turnaround vessels and that kind of thing. That is strategic, though. That is 15 to 20 years away.

Comment on this

There has been a lot of money spent without any access for passengers.

There is a temporary platform being built for the Ryder Cup-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Correct.

Comment on this

-----that will be redundant immediately afterwards.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The Department of Transport and Irish Rail are best placed to answer that question.

Comment on this

Is there maybe a lack of long-term thinking in the way it was developed?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

I think there is a very strong policy there. We have the Irish Rail 2040 policy on rail strategy. Then we have the all-Ireland joint strategy as well.

Comment on this

I am kind of caught for time. Mr. Keating mentioned biodiversity protection and that he wanted a more balanced policy approach. What exactly did he mean by that?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

We have a lot, and rightly so, on environmental protection but what we are asking for is that the strategic importance of the ports be brought up to balance and that this committee and the ports policy would equally realise that ports are strategic national infrastructure. Some 90% of our trade in and out of this country goes through ports. Trade is going to increase in volume. Our population is going to increase by 20% by 2040. Freight will go the same way. We are looking at an extra ten to 15 million tonnes of freight by 2040. For our economy to function, freight is the blood of the system. We need to be able to move that around.

Comment on this

When Mr. Keating says "more balanced", what does he mean by that?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

We call out strongly the requirement for environmental protections and so forth, which we all agree with, by the way. However, the strategic development of ports and the critical infrastructure piece needs to be called out as well. There is an imbalance at the moment from a planning and evaluation perspective.

Comment on this

Mr. Keating wants ports to be aligned or included with critical infrastructure.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The recognition of the importance of ports as strategic instruments of the State is really important.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Keating. Mr. O'Connell mentioned the issue of the return of lands to core port use. Has there been engagement with the Government or the Department about that?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

Over the past number of weeks, there has been more constructive engagement. Of the 14.5 ha, we have already received one of them back. It is called terminal 7. Discussions are ongoing with the Office of Public Works, OPW, about the return of some of the other lands. Some of them will continue to be required but there is a specific plan we are working with the OPW on to return what we feel is now required.

Comment on this

When did the engagement first commence?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

Three years ago.

Comment on this

So there was very little progress until a few weeks ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

Correct. I think the OPW and other State agencies commissioned a report by a consultant to look at the land use. The results of that should be out and we are now in a position where we can look to move forward with the correct allocation.

Comment on this

There is no concern that it is going to be delivered over to private use.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

No. In effect, it is our land. It is Dublin Port land that is leased to the various State agencies.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I will call Deputy O'Gorman next. I will go to the end on this rotation.

Comment on this

I might put two broad questions out and take the views of all of the ports to begin with. On the revised national ports strategy, is it the witnesses' view that it is drafted sufficiently strongly as regards the need for the Government to direct support, particularly financial support, to the ports in respect of the delivery of capacity to support offshore renewable projects? Are there any particular types of Exchequer funding mechanism that the witnesses feel would be effective to support the building and extension work that the ports need to undertake to enhance that offshore renewable capacity?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

There is a step change in policy in respect of Government support where, for the first time, the draft policy recognises the potential for the Government to support and fund ports. That is a major step change and we very much welcome that. It will be very helpful but, of course, the devil will be in the detail. To be fair, the process and the toolkit of how we might access those funds definitely needs to be further refined.

Comment on this

Is there engagement between the ports and the Department on how the refinement of those funding mechanisms are developed and put in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

With the statement and consultation, which has just closed, that has started. We all have our own individual sessions with the Department and I think there are very good relationships between the ports and the Department of Transport.

We would see that process as evolving but it does need to be more defined. With respect, the State cannot step in for every single project here. There needs to be a funding framework identified that provides both sides with certainty on what will and will not be eligible and the various strands of funding that could be available, whether it is direct Exchequer guarantees, European Investment Bank, EIB, support or whatever. As the Deputy knows, there is no shortage of potential streams to fund some of this infrastructure but we would certainly welcome more dialogue on it. That is an open door with the way the draft policy is shaping up.

Comment on this

Does anyone else want to come in on that point?

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

We are building ORE infrastructure and we are funding that through a commercial loan as a company. The scale of the investment is significant and our own balance sheet cannot do it on its own. There is also the commerciality of being able to borrow against that infrastructure in the short term, so we really welcome the statement in the draft ports policy. We look forward to the commitment to look on a case-by-case basis at how we can create a framework to get that investment in advance to build the infrastructure, which will return with the delivery of ORE services. We very much welcome it.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

We in Dublin Port are not involved directly in ORE, as the Deputy may know.

On a more general point, we have long-term master plans. We have ten-year strategies with detailed financial projections. Engagement with NewERA and the Department of public expenditure and reform on a long-term financing framework would be very instructive and helpful for all concerned. The decisions we make as a self-financing port have implications in regard to our market pricing, dividends, borrowings and so on and so forth. Those analyses are there. It would be good to have alignment on a long-term financial framework as we have with our master plan.

Comment on this

I wish to follow up on the point Mr. O'Connell made there around the fact that Dublin Port was not involved in ORE. Is that a medium-to-long-term position that Dublin Port is going to maintain or might it change with the new ports strategy and the increased need for capacity with new sites coming online off the coast?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

No, I do not think it is going to change because the simple fact of the matter is we do not have space. We are currently running at close to 90%, depending on mode, in terms of our capacity for freight. That is our business, plus fuels and so on. There is no space to accommodate an ORE facility.

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

Like my colleagues, I support the fact that there is an opportunity to access funding and I look forward to seeing how the framework develops. It is going to be quite important in the Port of Waterford. Tonn Nua is very close to our coast. We have identified that if we can build a particular type of facility, it will add value over its lifetime. The challenge, much like has been said of Cork, is in trying to get the funding to get it up and running so that it will add value when the wind farms and opportunities come. It is quite important that we have a route to getting some funding.

Comment on this

As we have many of the major ports here that are interested in offshore wind and supporting that, I wish to ask whether they talk among themselves about any degree of specialisation. Do they support what is happening at the moment, where certain ports specialise in certain areas, be that the operation and maintenance or the initial marshalling, or are they each rowing their own boat on the issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

To answer that question, we have to be cognisant of the fact that we are also competing. We have the Irish Ports Association. In such forums, we look to share best practice on occasion. In particular, we share ideas on policy, which is fairly consistent with regard to the messaging we are giving today.

On the specialisation, it is determined to a large extent by the location of a port and what it has been doing for many years. Our specialisation is effectively freight. That is what we do.

We do not have the capacity for ORE whereas Cork and Shannon Foynes have more flexibility in that regard.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

It is almost self-selecting. For example, offshore floating is probably very suitable for Shannon Foynes. Then there is Cork and fixed-bottom turbines, due to Cork's location and the shape of its harbour. One of the things for the committee to be mindful of is that this particular sector is moving very quickly from monopiles to suction pad jackets, so the infrastructure needs to move as quickly. There is a dilemma about getting that infrastructure in place.

We also need to remember that anything we are building at the moment is there to build to support the long-term economic viability of this island nation that we live in. It is not just for ORE. Yes, ORE is an opportunity and is a great way to start building infrastructure, but that infrastructure will there for population growth and to support all of the other economic activities. That is important to note.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before us. I am a Mayo-based Senator with a particular interest in the western rail corridor, which has been referred to in different contributions. In Shannon Foynes, there is probably a particular opportunity that exists. Will Mr. Keating speak a bit more about that economic opportunity for the west with the reopening of the western rail corridor between Claremorris and Athenry?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Of the 55 million tonnes that transit through ports at the moment, much less than 1% of that is moved by rail. There is an opportunity to increase that, but rail is a niche market because of our size. However, there are opportunities to go from 0.5% to maybe 3%, 4% or 5% in the medium term. That means a couple of million tonnes, which is not a small number. With the scale of infrastructure that we are building at port side and with the Limerick-Foynes railway set to be handed over in quarter 1 of next year, our rail hinterland will extend with the western rail corridor, so there is a synergy there straight away. We have a deep-water port on the western seaboard that might be able to collect freight all up along the western seaboard as far as Mayo, for example. The western rail corridor is enabling infrastructure. Foreign direct companies, FDI, companies are mindful of their sustainability requirements, so it is becoming increasingly more important to decarbonise the supply chain.

Comment on this

What was Shannon Foynes Port Company's reaction to the decision to not prioritise rail in Sligo?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

From our point of view, the rail should be let go as far as it can go. We are respectful of any decisions, but I think that-----

Comment on this

I am interested in the company's economic reaction, not its own point of view. Does that decision limit the economic potential of both Sligo and Shannon Foynes?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

It would limit the reach of the rail from Foynes, so it potentially does, but to be fair, we have not done a full economic assessment on the rail benefits around Sligo. When we look at rail, it is like a motorway project. If it extends the hinterland to our port, it is good for our port. From a port perspective, we are looking at it through the lens of what is good for the port in terms of trade and trade volumes. That is our mandate, alongside handling trade efficiently. However, there is no doubt that rail and road are enabling infrastructure that the economy needs to build success on. It is no different than housing, the grid or whatever. We need that baseload of infrastructure. It is the same with ports. If we do not have it, we are going suffer because we will have a deficit in our infrastructure.

From our perspective, the western rail corridor extends the rail reach. It will be important for us and will provide a good synergy with the existing investment in rail freight in the country.

Some of the issues around it need to be assessed via an economic appraisal. It is a "go" or "no go" decision at the end of the day.

Comment on this

That is perfect. I am based in Ballina. We are proud of our rail and freight links. Does Mr. Sinnott believe that the line is at capacity? Is there are lot of congestion on the line? What can be done to improve the movements on the line from Waterford to Mayo?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

There are two Ballina-Waterford trains a week at the moment. They are full in both directions. It is an increase on where it was in the last couple of years. We are working with different logistics providers to see if there is a merit to putting a third train on the service. It is great to see that they are full and have been filling up. We are happy to engage with logistics providers and Iarnród Éireann to see if there is a chance to put on a third train and enable more goods to move between Mayo and our port.

Comment on this

Are there ongoing discussions with foreign direct investment, FDI, companies looking to decarbonise and move to freight? Is that a lot of what the port is seeing in terms of rail freight changes?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

It is a very purposeful decision on the part of the ones that are opting for rail freight as they are reflecting on their sustainability ambitions. The challenge will be to point out the benefits to others. I think it particularly works in that long distance from Mayo to Waterford. It is probably the longest possible rail journey that can be made in the country.

Comment on this

In relation to Mayo and the western rail corridor, do the other witnesses have any thoughts on the positive economic impact it could have for their ports?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

From the Dublin Port Company's point of view, we remain supportive of rail freight, and it is not just in the statements that we have been consistent in making over the years. We have also invested €9 million of our own money in Irish Rail's North Wall freight depot, which is adjacent to the port. It will continue to have access to Dublin Port. The question will be whether the demand will come.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

I have a rail-enabled site in Cork. It is called Marino Point. It is on the way to Cobh. That site has not enjoyed a positive planning history, which is maybe linked to Deputy O'Flynn's question in relation to Tivoli. It is part of the move of the port from the city to the lower harbour. It is a rail-enabled site, but we cannot get planning permission for any port-related activity at the moment because of the road.

Comment on this

If the Port of Cork could get planning, would it unlock-----

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

Absolutely. We have railheads there and we would be open to-----

Comment on this

Would that then connect freight to all of those different options, such as from Mayo to Shannon Foynes to Cork?

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

I presume that would be a question for Irish Rail, but we have a site that is rail-enabled. I cannot use it at the moment, and it has a direct impact on the port's relocation because of the Seveso sites in Tivoli.

Comment on this

I welcome all of our witnesses. It will be no surprise that I am going to Mr. Sinnott. I have a few questions about Waterford Port. I have been at the port a number of times over the last number of years and I have been blown away by the ambition the port has. It is not just Mr. Sinnott's ambition but that of all the staff and everybody involved in the port. I have seen lots of PowerPoint presentations on all the possibilities that exist for the port.

I will start with offshore renewable energy. We all want Ireland to reach its climate action targets, and for that to happen, we have to make sure that we are investing in renewable energies, and offshore wind has huge potential. Mr. Sinnott mentioned Tonn Nua as one of those opportunities off the coast of the south east. What is his own view on the potential of offshore renewable energy off that coast and what possibilities exist for the port? He talked about construction and operation, but what broader contribution could be made? What value would it add to the city and county of Waterford and the wider south east if we were to succeed in this area and the port was to play a role?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

A number of potential values will come from it. There is an economic one, which I will come back to, and there is also a societal one. It is a real levelling-up opportunity for the south east. We have had a brain drain in that area for quite some time. We now have a new technological university. This will be a real levelling-up opportunity to provide opportunities for children in primary school, secondary school and third level, and to provide good jobs in this particular area. Then there is the carbon benefit that would come from it.

Specifically on the economic side, everybody seems to think of long sea voyages, but whether someone is going 12 km or 15 km offshore or going to the other end of the world, the only place a ship can leave from is a port. There are a couple of opportunities that we could reflect on here. The first is that the larger ports will be doing the staging and marshalling. Our geography does not make that possible, but there is so much more to it. There are many of what I call the brown bits. The white bits and the yellow bits could be handled by the larger ports, but the only way that this will happen is if there is a loading dock to get them out to the wind farm. That loading dock is very much a dock; it is very much a port. Our ambition is to create a facility so that the smaller components can be brought out to the wind farm and to provide facilities that would support the construction. Potentially, there is also an argument that businesses in the south east of Ireland could actually create and make some of the infrastructure. Somebody once asked me to imagine how many kilometres of handrail and ladders there are out at sea and asked whether they could be made locally.

Comment on this

On the facility Mr. Sinnott is talking about for the Port of Waterford, what kind of timeframe does he envisage? Obviously, there are many contingencies. There are also the matters of planning and funding and all the rest of it, but, from his own perspective, what is the time horizon we should be aiming towards?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

We are currently in planning and, hopefully, will be able to get out of it. The next challenge will be funding. I believe we should be looking to have something around the year 2030 so that it will be ready when Tonn Nua is-----

Comment on this

Mr. Sinnott talked about collaboration with research and development interests, the university and the business community. All of that is important. What collaboration exists with Rosslare Europort? Obviously, it will have a role to play. I imagine Waterford will be carving out its own unique selling point. What collaboration is there between the two ports on this particular project?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

As Mr. O'Connell mentioned, we are actually set up to compete with each other but, when it comes to policy and things like that, we can have very good conversations. The absolute reality is that the Rosslare developments they are thinking of doing will absolutely be ready to do the staging and marshalling. We are not able to do that. We commissioned a small piece of work to understand whether there would be value in us constructing a renewables quay. The outcome was that, absolutely, over its lifetime there would be value, and that specifically it would be in the area of providing construction support. When it comes to operations and maintenance, the operators will just opt for the port nearest to the wind farm because that is the one that makes most sense.

Comment on this

Maybe, in the time we have left, for those who may not have had enough time themselves to get their heads around offshore renewable energy, what is happening off the coast of the south east and the opportunities for the port, bearing in mind that we are dealing with so many issues in every county or region, could Mr. Sinnott quantify the value, including the economic value, if we were to succeed in this space? If he were selling this to the people of Waterford and the south east, what are the big opportunities that would arise for people in Waterford and the south east if we can ensure the port has a really important role to play in offshore renewable energy and its plans are implemented?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

Tonn Nua is potentially one of four sites. If they were all developed, we would be talking about 5 GW. Ireland uses about 7 GW. All of that energy being very close to us would be very important. From what I understand, wind farms are quite expensive. They cost a lot of money, €3 billion or €4 billion each. Four of them could be €16 billion, potentially. Even if only 10% or 20% of that were to land locally, there would be a huge economic impact and a huge opportunity for local people to get involved.

Comment on this

I have a final question. The cranes have caused problems in the past. Is it still the case that those cranes need to be replaced?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

Ideally, we should be looking to replace the gantry cranes. They are near the end of their life at the container terminal.

Comment on this

Has the port requested funding for those?

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

Not specifically for those, but we have shared our corporate plan, which is seeking to make an investment in what I call the superstructure. We have to consider ways to fund that.

Comment on this

I thank all our witnesses. I wish all of them well and all of the ports because they play such a valuable role in all of the regional economies. I thank the Chair for the opportunity to put questions.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank the Deputy. It is my turn now.

My first questions are for Dublin Port. Mr. O'Connell mentioned service standards from individual consenting bodies. Could he say a little more about what he means and give some examples of agencies where things are not where they should be?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

The principal issue that springs to mind would be the consents from the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority, MARA, and how they tally with the consent that we require from An Coimisiún Pleanála. Rather than those happening in parallel, they happen sequentially. We need to wait for the approval of a maritime area consent, MAC, licence, as it is called, and that could take 12 to 18 months, sometimes even two years. Then we begin the application process with An Coimisiún Pleanála. The ask is to look at minimum requirements in terms of delivery of a decision, but also to run those processes in parallel with each other. A good practical example at the moment is that we have put probably the largest maritime infrastructure programme to An Coimisiún Pleanála and we are 120 weeks in and have not received a decision yet. It was five years in the making, with a 10,000-page submission, and we believe that national infrastructure of strategic importance should receive decisions within 48 weeks. We are 120 weeks in.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is that a concern of all port companies with regard to the service standards?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

Yes.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

With regard to the definition of installations as critical infrastructure, is Dublin Port being heard or is there still space for more movement?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

We are being heard on it, but it is a question of prioritisation. The decision has been made to prioritise other services first. While the importance of the ports is recognised, I do not think it is fully appreciated just how close to capacity we are and how we need to bring those concerned into the fold so we do not have to incur delays, such as 120 weeks for the approval of a major infrastructure project.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Can each port company state, in terms of its medium- to long-term horizon, the key risk it envisages at the moment? I will start with Shannon Foynes Port Company.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Planning risk is the big one, and timing. The State has introduced a workaround for that in terms of critical infrastructure. Once projects are designated under the Act as critical infrastructure, that helps because the timeframes involved in the strategic infrastructure application process are what they are. That is well known. The critical infrastructure approach is the solution the Government has introduced. Then there is the accelerating infrastructure committee. There is an apparatus of State that the current Government has introduced as a solution, but we are not part of it yet. It is key that we get under that umbrella.

The next aspect is funding. If we look at planning risk and the funding element, which we discussed earlier, we note that it is a matter of addressing the framework in conjunction with the Department and identifying where it needs to be fine-tuned and developed so that we can all see where we stand. That is important. At the front end of that is the policy that supports ports. For us, it is about the national designated maritime area plans, DMAPs, as well, and the follow-on route to market. All of that policy can give certainty not just to the ports as enabling infrastructure but to the developers as well. Planning is pretty onerous but funding is even more onerous.

The funders will potentially put a much stricter rule over a project. For example, the customers for our Foynes island deepwater jetty offshore renewables project will come from the areas identified in the Atlantic region. There are 15 GW being spoken about. That is our future customer for that project. We need that type of certainty so that when we are putting our revenue assumptions into the business case, they are solid. It is all connected. It is cross-cutting across various Departments, including the Departments of the Environment, Climate and Communications; Transport; and Enterprise, Tourism and Employment.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I will allow the other companies the chance to come in. I will go to the Port of Waterford.

Comment on this
Mr. David Sinnott

We could make the planning and consenting processes run in parallel. The earlier question was interesting. We are self-funding and must try to do it all out of our retained earnings. We will have to make decisions about whether to invest in cranes, which are superstructures in the port, or look to address something such as the renewable energy opportunity. It is going to be hard to make the balance sheet work for both. If you look at the other list I mentioned earlier, there are other expectations, including onshore power and decarbonisation. The list of expectations is long and the funding is coming from our retained earnings. That is a particular challenge. We have a relatively small turnover and the challenge is getting the funding in place. Consenting is needed for that because if we are to look to Europe, the first thing that Europeans will look for is whether we have consent to maturity. I cannot even go looking for money until I have a consent.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

I will say, "All of the above." In particular for the Port of Cork, it is both on-dock and off-dock land in Ringaskiddy. The plan is to move all the activity to the lower harbour. That will release a significant 162-acre site in Tivoli for homes, businesses and all of that. However, there must be the replacement infrastructure in Ringaskiddy. There is both an opportunity and a major challenge in trying to secure that land in Ringaskiddy, both on-dock and off-dock.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

What are the biggest risks in Dublin?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry O'Connell

I would have to mirror what others have said. I have given a specific example of planning. It is funding. We are less susceptible because we have a much bigger volume. However, we are still self-financing, so we must constantly make the decision as to how we balance the levers of our economic model, including market pricing, because we need to maintain our competitiveness in that regard. We must keep pricing as low as possible for the greater good, so to speak, while also generating enough earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, EBITDA, to finance our borrowings.

We spoke about planning approval, but there is also the protection of lands which are already within the port of State. We have an instance, for example, whereby a particular plot has been redesignated for potential future rezoning. That places considerable pressure on us in the context of a port where capacity is already constrained. Whatever about the introduction of new lands or new planning applications to expand berth space, we also need to ensure that our existing lands are protected.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I missed some of the meeting. I was watching it online. I live in Sligo. I would be looking at the benefits - this is probably for Mr. Keating - of extending the western rail corridor to Sligo. We know it will be extended to Mayo. Many of us would argue that it should be extended to Sligo. Would Mr. Keating see potential in that? Because Sligo has a working port, can Mr. Keating see that there would be economic benefit were it to be connected to Foynes?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The more infrastructure a region has, the more benefits there are. It becomes more attractive to foreign investment. As I keep saying, ports are enabling infrastructure. The same is true of rail, road and the full gamut. The more you have in your region, the more attractive you are to industry. It makes the IDA's job easier. The answer to the question as to whether the western rail corridor would help Sligo is that it absolutely would. There is no doubt about that. It would give that further option. It would make for a more sustainable supply chain to move traffic. Irish Rail figures are something like 0.83 of a cent per tonne-kilometre travelled.

There is substantial carbon. There are costs associated. Generally speaking, and as I keep saying, any enabling infrastructure enhances a region's ability to be attractive and potentially more competitive.

Comment on this

Connectivity between the two ports would be an important part.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

To be fair, there are no direct business links today, but it is a changing economy-----

Comment on this

That is absolutely the case.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

-----and who knows what is going to happen in the future? There are two types of ports for offshore renewable energy, ORE. There are the marshalling ports, where all the heavy lifting is done, as Mr. Sinnott pointed out, and then you have the operations and maintenance business. You can absolutely have complementary activities going on in ports.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Keating talking about offshore wind and renewables?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Yes. Sligo Port would probably be an ideal operations and maintenance port. It does not have the deep water. You need certain physical characteristics to be able to do the marshalling, including deep water-----

Comment on this

That is a big thing in Sligo.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Sligo would absolutely have a role in operations and maintenance. Once the farms are built, you need access and the ability to serve and monitor all of that and get crews in and out. That is absolutely the case. There are considerable traffic numbers in that type of activity under ORE. Across Europe, some ports that were more or less extinct are now vibrant. The amount of economic activity it has brought to those regions is phenomenal. Look, for example, at Ostend in Belgium. Esbjerg in Denmark is absolutely massive. It has both. The operations and maintenance piece is huge. That is the function.

Comment on this

That is great to hear. That is fantastic. There is a policy. I open this question to any of the witnesses. Would they say they are getting enough guidance on the ports policy and strategy from the Government? Is Sligo Port getting enough guidance?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The Government has clearly set out its objectives. It wants 20 GW by 2040 and 37 GW and net zero by 2050. Those are very clear Government targets.

Comment on this

Are there actions put in to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The actions are coming in the form of designated maritime area plans, DMAPs, and the route to market. The Government announced €18 billion in investment for the grid. Ports are also enabling. That is where we are coming from with the ports. If we are talking about ORE, the two big enablers are ports and the grid. The grid is being funded, or is about to be funded. Projects need to be rolled out. There will be challenges, as we know. Ports are in the same enabling category. We are talking about the funding piece. The Department of Transport has recognised the need for funding for ports through its policy. We are saying that we must work together to refine that and consider what kinds of projects will be eligible and how much money needs to be spent.

Comment on this

Are the ports getting that support from the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The ports policy has opened the door. The grid is going to cost a lot more than the ports. We are not looking for €18 billion, in case people think we are.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

However, ours is a big ask, at the same time. It is not of that scale, but it is of a scale.

Comment on this

That is great. I thank Mr. Keating. Would any of the other witnesses like to say anything about whether they are getting enough support or guidance from the Government? That was all I wanted to ask. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I apologise that I had to run up to the Seanad and back down. I am so glad the witnesses are still here. I will direct the majority of my questions to Mr. Keating. I am from Limerick. I have been in Foynes Port. I was there for the first time in 2024 and must say that I was blown away by the project plan for offshore wind development. Back then, the representatives were talking about the fact that the DMAP had to be done within a certain timeframe to get EU funding. We still do not have that. Is there a timeline? I know there has been a start on the east coast.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The national DMAP is well under way. There has been a lot of progress.

Comment on this

Is there a timeline for when it might hit?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

The programme has been published. The Oireachtas is due to sign off on the final national DMAP in December next year. To date, it has issued identification areas off the west coast. They are going to be further refined by the end of this year. There will then be a further public consultation on the refined areas, which will be roughly 7,500 sq. km offshore over roughly the three areas of Donegal, west of the Shannon Estuary and south of Cork. The broad areas are currently 25,000 sq. km and they need to be reduced to 7,500 sq. km to get 15 GW by 2040. That is the direction of travel. A lot of progress has been made on that side, which is important for us because, as I said, our base customers are going to come out of that for the ORE piece.

What we are saying about the potential of this is that it is one thing to produce power and have the supply chain but we must also look at the other side of it, which is who is going to use the power. Earlier we had a discussion about the power landing ashore. We can then bring industry to the power and create an integrated supply, energy generation and energy user demand all in the one place. This creates massive opportunities for the regions. To be honest, at all of the ports represented at the meeting today, we can have very big new industrial green parks popping up under the LEAP strategy. If we go back to the industrial revolution, industry started with the coal mines. Because of this energy source we had big industries. This is the same; if we bring this power ashore, we can have big industry. IDA Ireland needs to do a better job and start identifying green energy parks where the energy lands ashore. We do not need as much investment as for the onshore grid and the transmission side. From our point of view, the policy is due in 2027. Mr. Sinnott can speak about how the south coast DMAP mobilises the whole supply chain and how it is so important.

Comment on this

Yes, it will be. I have seen the projected figures for increased employment in the area. It is going to be fantastic. I do not know Waterford, Cork or Dublin as well as I know Limerick. I know about losing companies such as Wyeth Nutritionals, and to get a boost of employment into an area would be fantastic.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

There is another important part of all of this. We have spoken about rail but there is also the Limerick to Foynes road scheme. The Adare section is under way and it is due to finish for the Ryder Cup. The next two sections are critical for us as a port, to connect the region and the Shannon Estuary to what we are talking about. I understand the entire road is committed to under the NDP.

Comment on this

It is just the Adare section to start with.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

I understand it is at the gate 2 approval process. It has been lodged with the Department by TII. The sooner that gate 2 decision is handed down, the sooner the contracts can be procured for the next phase.

Comment on this

On the critical infrastructure Bill, I assume all of the witnesses have submitted for ports to be included as critical infrastructure. I am in complete agreement with that. We live on an island so, between our ports and our airports, it is very important that we have connectivity. I am not by any means giving out about Dublin, so it should not be taken as a criticism, but I am always on about balanced regional development and investment. Dublin Port is massive and brings in so much and is so needed, but I would love to see more funding being redistributed. I always give out and say Shannon needs investment. Obviously it does not need what Dublin Airport needs but it needs the right amount for the area.

I can see this from the hauliers' viewpoint also. My husband is a HGV driver and I can say with 100% confidence that the difference between the ports is the same as the difference between going for a flight from Shannon Airport and Dublin Airport. People are in and out very quickly from Shannon. When taking a flight from Dublin people have to allow three hours. My husband much prefers to bring something from Foynes than from Dublin. The reason is not the port but the congestion and traffic. If we push everything into one place, we end up with this problem of congestion. We have Cork, Waterford, Sligo and Limerick with Shannon Foynes. It should be divvied out a little so that we have investment and employment in each of the areas and ensure that one port is not overloaded. Everybody says I am always criticising Dublin but I am not for one minute. I am just speaking about regional development and resilience. In her opening statement, Ms Doherty spoke about having resilience throughout the country through having investment in all of the ports.

I have another question for Mr. Keating on the timelines and the DMAPs. Where will this leave funding? I know the ports were looking at the EU funding but I think it will dry up at the end of this year.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

With the DMAPs we have to go into planning. We have received maritime area consent for Foynes Island and we hope to go to planning in the next number of months. In parallel with that, we have been looking at the funding potential. We have completed a preliminary business case consistent with the infrastructure guidelines. The outcome of that is very positive in terms of the project viability. If there has been a block up to this point, it is that the old ports policy prevented any Government funding for ports.

This door has now been opened with the new draft policy. The planning process will take the amount of time that it takes. Hopefully it will not take the 120 weeks Mr. O'Connell is experiencing but it will take a long time. There is no doubt about that.

In parallel we will be looking at the funding of the project. As I said, the preliminary business case findings are very promising but there are, obviously, contingencies such as policy supports, including DMAPs. We must market the road being built so our assumptions are valid. At this stage it is a twin-track process.

On funding and critical infrastructure, the big message from me to the committee today is that ports are critical infrastructure and need to be designated as such. We also need to define the funding.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I propose that for the second round members will have three minutes each, starting with Deputy O'Flynn. I remind members to direct their questions at the topic being addressed by the witnesses.

Comment on this

My question is for the chief executive of the Port of Cork. Will she confirm that she will give a breakdown of the €1 million legal fees and advice, a breakdown of the Cobh costs, the container arrangement and the register of interests?

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I will interrupt Deputy O'Flynn again-----

Comment on this

Excuse me, I am just confirming-----

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Excuse me. I am speaking.

Comment on this

-----what I said earlier-----

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am speaking.

Comment on this

-----and asking Ms Doherty to confirm on that.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am speaking.

Comment on this

I am speaking and it is on my time. You are on my time.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am speaking.

Comment on this

I am speaking and I am confirming what I said earlier and asking for it to be confirmed-----

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I have clarified for Deputy O'Flynn already-----

Comment on this

-----before I speak at all. The Chair is jumping in continuously before I speak at all.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

If Deputy O'Flynn speaks over me again-----

Comment on this

You are speaking over me. You are interfering with my questions.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

If Deputy O'Flynn speaks over me again, I will ask him to withdraw from the meeting.

Comment on this

There is no point in speaking at this meeting if you are going to speak over me.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I have already requested that Deputy O'Flynn direct his questions at the matter being discussed at the meeting. The confirmation he has outlined there is not in line with the topic being discussed at the meeting and Ms Doherty is under no obligation to give a response to it. That is the clarification I want to make. Deputy O'Flynn may continue.

Comment on this

If you do not want me to put questions to the Port of Cork about the future of the Port of Cork, there is no point in my asking questions.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Flynn's questions are not about the Port of Cork.

Comment on this

They are about the future of the Port of Cork.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

They are not.

Comment on this

They are about the governance of the Port of Cork. There are serious questions that need to come before the Oireachtas committee.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I suggest-----

Comment on this

There is a register of interests that needs to come before the Oireachtas committee. I have put down parliamentary questions. I have not had receipt of all the answers back yet.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Deputy-----

Comment on this

I am waiting to get those answers back. That is what I am worried about. I am worried about the Port of Cork and I am worried about the future of the Port of Cork because I am a representative from Cork, the same as you should be concerned about the Port of Dublin.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Deputy-----

Comment on this

If you are not going to leave me speak and ask my questions, I will withdraw from the committee.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

If I may respond, if Deputy O'Flynn wants to make a request to the committee to consider governance at the Port of Cork-----

Comment on this

I have already written to the committee. If you were on top of your brief, you would know I have already written. Thank you and well done.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The time has expired so we will move on now to Deputy O'Gorman.

Comment on this

We have ambitious targets for the delivery of offshore wind, of 5 GW by 2030 and 20 GW by 2040. For those ports that see themselves involved in the marshalling side of things and the initial construction, I would like a sense of what capacity they can support per year in terms of the delivery. Maybe I am not phrasing this well. How much can the ports deliver? Is it one project per year at a time?

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

We are in the process of building a 200 m quay wall with a lay-down area behind it of about 4.5 acres. We also have a 25 acre space for the storage. The assembly will be on the quayside. This would be one project at a time and it would be about scheduling these projects over time. It would be one project rolling on to another project. Our plan for the additional infrastructure, which I made reference to in my opening statement and which would be another project of €400 million plus, would give us an extra 42.5 acres of reclaimed land and additional quay wall, which would obviously change this.

Comment on this

It would change the capacity.

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

Yes, and at the moment our capacity is one project at a time.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

Our first phase would hit a run rate of about 500 MW per annum build-out of wind farms. For a 1 GW wind farm, we are talking about two years.

The challenges will arise where there is a multitude of developers. The State can control that by how it schedules route-to-market auctions. That will be important because we do not want it to become like buses, with everything coming online together.

Comment on this

Five projects went through offshore renewable electricity support scheme, ORESS, 1 and four of those are in the planning process now. I know they will not all come out together but there is probably not the capacity in Ireland to do those four right now. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

Not unless we build more infrastructure.

Comment on this

Not unless we build, yes. That itself takes time. That is an obvious constraint. Are some of these companies looking to base their marshalling in the UK? Is that an option or is that too far a distance? Do they just not happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Keating

From the perspective of floating turbines, which are different from fixed-bottom turbines, as the Deputy knows, you have to be proximate to the wind because of the towing and weather windows. Those are the constraints. Weather windows are good for maybe 48 hours and the tow speed might be 2.5 knots per hour to 3 knots per hour. That accounts for the limit of between 70 and 100 miles.

Comment on this

What about the fixed turbines?

Comment on this
Ms Ann Doherty

With the fixed turbines, what we are seeing at the moment in our engagement with the market is that it will probably emerge sequentially. There is time to get that infrastructure in place, however. We envisage the first Irish project happening in 2031 from a fixed turbine perspective. Notwithstanding the issues we have identified, they are all problems that can be addressed and solved. There is time to get that additional infrastructure in. We cannot miss the economic opportunity for the island associated with all of the benefits my colleagues have articulated.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this
Shane Moynihan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank all of the witnesses for their time and invitations. I thank them for answering the questions today and wish them well. The meeting will now adjourn until 9.30 a.m on 21 October, when we will meet in public session with Irish Rail.

Comment on this