We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport

Engagement with the Minister for Transport

Summary

The Minister outlined €24.3 billion in transport capital investment to 2030, record public transport funding for about 140 new or improved services in 2027, and continued investment in roads, walking and cycling. He acknowledged serious procurement failings in Irish Rail’s train-control project, which has incurred an impairment exceeding €50 million, and said lessons would be acted on; next-generation ticketing remains on track for a pilot next year under close scrutiny. Members raised safety concerns about e-scooters, and the Minister said a ban was not ruled out, while defending new restrictions and enforcement measures. He backed a greenway on the western rail corridor section not expected to carry rail services before 2050, with land retained for possible future rail use, and said compulsory purchase should be a last resort.

Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Today's engagement is with the Minister for Transport to discuss all areas within his remit. On behalf of the committee, I welcome him and his officials. We really appreciate their time this afternoon. I hope we will see the Minister again before the end of the year with regard to the Estimates.

Comment on this
Darragh O'Brien Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage. Fianna Fáil

You will.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I hope he will not delegate that to a Minister of State.

Comment on this

No, I will be here.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Minister. We will note that commitment.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make changes against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members will have six minutes today for questions and answers. I will not allow speaking time for any other member outside of the key members of the committee. I ask members to keep their questions short and ask one question at a time. I invite the Minister to make his opening statement.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis an gCathaoirleach agus leis na Teachtaí agus Seanadóirí as an gcuireadh teacht os comhair an choiste. I thank the committee for the opportunity to update members on the Department of Transport’s progress over the last year and to discuss some of the key projects and programmes being undertaken now and for the next 12 months.

Since I became Minister for Transport in 2025, we have focused on the efficient delivery of transport infrastructure and services, not only to help meet the needs of today but also to future-proof the transport sector, which is a key foundation for the further growth and prosperity for our country. As we approach two years into this programme for Government and over a year since the review of the national development plan, I am pleased to be able to discuss with the committee some of the significant delivery achievements of the Department over that time, as well as outline our ongoing and future plans for expanding and improving transport at all levels and in all regions of the country.

I should first mention the significant investment secured during that review of the national development plan, with some €24.3 billion being allocated to capital investment in the transport sector between now and 2030. That is about one euro in every four allocated for that period. The NDP sectoral investment plan for transport, published shortly after the review, details the various projects under way or planned in the sector and provides the timelines and expected deliverables of each programme.

As Minister, I am proud to be pushing forward with this programme of investment in the sector. We recognise more than ever the important role that integrated, effective transport networks play in enabling other priorities under the programme for Government. Transport-oriented development will enable us to deliver more housing, increase access to health and educational facilities and reduce our reliance on private transport. This is attained by moving people closer to the services they need and ensuring that more communities than ever will have access to safe, reliable public transport and active travel options.

It is important to note the scale of our programmes at present, as well as the future-orientated approach to the roll-out of new infrastructure. It is significant that three major transport projects - MetroLink, the Cork area commuter rail and the Galway ring road – have been designated as critical infrastructure under the Critical Infrastructure Act 2026, to ensure their delivery is fast-tracked and approval timelines reduced. As well as the major capital investments ongoing and planned for urban areas, we are committed to providing better services and access to regional and rural communities, making sure that transport options deliver real benefits to users.

Some of the larger programmes in progress are in public transport.

Projects like MetroLink, DART+, Cork commuter rail and BusConnects will fundamentally change how public transport operates in our urban areas, while the Connecting Ireland plan and Local Link programmes will continue to link those living outside urban areas with both their regional partner communities and the urban networks around the five cities.

Developing those projects alongside sustainable mobility options such as an expanded cycling network and safer walking infrastructure will not only increase the appeal of multimodal transport but also create significant health benefits and tourism opportunities as people can commute or undertake leisure activities on greenways or using designated active travel routes.

This is typified by our approach to projects like MetroLink, which will provide a major public transport spine for Dublin, integrating the surrounding road, rail and light rail network, and will add a much-needed rail link to Dublin Airport. This is an example of the joined-up approach we are taking to delivery, and I believe it will reap significant benefits.

I am delighted that the Government committed an extra €6 billion in funding in budget 2027 towards MetroLink construction up to 2030. Works on that project will start on site in Dublin next year as we ramp up to deliver this transformative piece of infrastructure for our people. This is more than a transport project; it is a quality-of-life project, a housing project and a decarbonisation project and will deliver major benefits for the region.

As we deliver major public transport projects and grow the network, the benefits do not just scale across; they compound with network effects. People newly connected to a particular service or piece of infrastructure gain access to both that service and the wider, integrated network as a whole. Under budget 2027, over €1 billion, the highest amount ever, has been allocated to public transport services. This will support the delivery of approximately 140 new or enhanced services throughout the country, which is the biggest expansion in a single year in many years.

In addition, we will invest €360 million in walking and cycling projects across all local authorities, building on over 1,000 km of new and upgraded infrastructure we have delivered to date, with a further 1,000 km planned before the end of this decade.

For each person who makes use of our expanded public transport or active travel options, we have the opportunity to reduce congestion on our roads while simultaneously expanding and upgrading the network.

While we are constructing new major roads such as the Adare bypass and the M28 Cork-to-Ringaskiddy project, we are also ensuring that the regional and local roads network is both maintained and upgraded through the regional and local roads grant programme.

It is important to acknowledge that this investment in roads infrastructure is making our roads safer. Our framework is the Government's road safety strategy. It aims to halve road deaths and serious injuries by 2030 and move towards Vision Zero by 2050. Every single road user is entitled to feel safe on our roads. We are at the halfway point in delivering the phase 2 action plan of the strategy. Like the committee members, I am extremely concerned about the upward trend in fatalities and serious injuries on our roads.

However, progress has been made this year: stronger oversight arrangements are in place; practical reforms to learner licensing are moving forward; the learning-to-drive curriculum is being reviewed; road safety education is reaching young people from primary school through to third level; and new investment is supporting public awareness work. For 2027, the budget for public awareness and expanded education has increased to €20 million. Legislation and enforcement have also been strengthened. Together, these actions show a shared determination to turn commitments into visible results. There will be further legislation, as members know, before the end of this Dáil session.

Turning to aviation, we are focused on addressing the passenger cap at Dublin Airport and we have invested in the wider sector while developing a new regional airports programme. Some of the other investments to date over the past two years include Cork Airport's security screening project and ensuring the continuation of the Dublin-Donegal public service obligation, PSO, air services contract.

In maritime affairs, I must mention the completion of the Coast Guard aviation contract earlier this year, with all our bases now fully operational, including the new fixed-wing support, which helps not only to save lives but to monitor our maritime environment, which is so important to us as an island nation.

Important work to update our national ports policy is ongoing. As an island nation with an open economy, we always come back to the importance of the ports as our trading links to international partners. The investment and diversification of the port companies to facilitate our other investments in offshore renewable energy are a policy that once again underpins the potential that lies here in securing our future energy needs.

While I have touched on many of the external programmes under way in the Department, I will finish with a nod to the strategic research and corporate work under way in the Department. We operate in a very challenging environment, with competing demands and, more than ever, a need to deliver efficiently, responsibly and effectively. We rely on a robust governance and assurance framework to ensure we keep things like value for money, measurable benefits and fiscal responsibility at the very heart of all our efforts. While we are undertaking major projects like DART+ and BusConnects, we always keep in mind not only our responsibilities to deliver benefits for citizens but also our responsibility to protect their investments in our work.

I again thank you, a Chathaoirligh, and the committee for the invitation. I would be pleased to discuss any matters the committee would like to raise.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you, Minister. I am conscious that time is of the essence. We will follow our speaking rota. I will allocate each member six minutes, with interventions today confined to members of the committee. I myself am first on the speaking rota today.

I go back to the Minister's opening statement, in which he referred to robust governance, value for money, timely delivery and fiscal responsibility. Yesterday we heard further evidence from Irish Rail about the failed train management system, originally budgeted for in 2020 at €19 million, which has now resulted in an impairment of more than €50 million in the 2025 accounts of Irish Rail. The CEO of Irish Rail was unable to provide this committee with a consolidated assessment of the final financial exposure or, indeed, a delivery date for this project as the National Transport Authority, NTA, has yet to sign off on the alternative proposal. In addition, while the Alstom trains were initially supposed to be delivered in 2025, we are now told that the earliest delivery date for them is quarter 2 of 2027. Minister, from the points of view of governance, value for money and fiscal responsibility, do you have confidence in the governance structures of Irish Rail?

Comment on this

Those are two very good points. I will deal first with the Alstom trains, which are a very important part of our fleet upgrade. We have purchased 285 carriages. We have received the first batch of carriages, which are being tested right now. I have visited them myself. The sole reason for the delay in their deployment was an issue found in another jurisdiction with a similar train that had a battery issue. Just out of an abundance of caution, and rightly so, for certification of the new rolling stock, that has to go through a further testing regime. That testing regime is under way, and then we will submit that to the European rail safety-----

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Minister, I am conscious of my time.

Comment on this

But I will just be quick.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Do you have confidence in the governance structures of Irish Rail?

Comment on this

The trains will be delivered in quarter 2 of next year. That delay was, in fairness, outside of Irish Rail's control. It was a safety issue.

I too am very concerned about the national train control centre, NTCC. I refer to the way in which this was managed prior to my coming into the Department and when it was brought to our attention. I am still awaiting the details, most importantly about how we move forward with this. To say I am very disappointed with Indra and the way in which this has been managed is an understatement. I do not have the-----

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Do you have confidence in the governance structures? Would you commit to a review of the governance structures? Surely this raises serious questions about oversight in Irish Rail. I believe it raises serious questions for the NTA as well.

Comment on this

Yes, I agree with you, and that is part of our work programme. It raises questions in particular with this project. The actual physical building was delivered on schedule. As regards the IT system, I think it goes back to the awarding of the contract, if I am honest, from what I have looked into. It appears to me that the contract for the system was awarded to a company that had not delivered a system and did not own the IP. That is crazy. I think the procurement was fundamentally where the issue was, and that is being addressed very seriously.

I take seriously my responsibilities and managing Exchequer money, the people's money, for investment across the board and this will be dealt with. I do not have the final figure on it. We are waiting on the NTA to see how we will proceed with this because the project is needed. It is needed for efficiency across our train services and our train network.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Just to ask the question again, are you comfortable with the current governance structures in Irish Rail that have seen this impairment of more than €50 million?

Comment on this

I am comfortable with the governance arrangements that are in place. Absolutely, learnings have to be made. I do not have the final report. I assure you that when I do, we will action it. I would welcome the input of the committee into that as well.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you. My final question is on e-scooters and the regulation of them. It is well known I believe we are just tying ourselves up in knots. We cannot ignore the evidence from Children's Health Ireland. You are very familiar with that evidence. The Garda Commissioner was very clear in his evidence before this committee that he fully supports an outright ban. There is huge public support for such a ban. Who checks the registration? Who checks compliance with the 20 km/h speed limit? Who checks whether an e-scooter has been modified? Who checks whether the rider is over 18? It is the same with insurance. I crossed the city this morning and the extent to which people are not wearing helmets or high-visibility jackets is alarming. People are still selling scooters online that are illegal on Irish public roads. Will you commit to keeping on the table the concept of an outright ban on e-scooters?

Comment on this

I reject any assertion we are not taking this matter seriously. We are, and we have acted in a very swift way. E-scooters are now banned for people under 18. Helmets and high-visibility garments must be worn. Those regulations have come in just over the last number of weeks and we have increased the penalties just this week, so that suite of measures has been brought forward.

I will say two quick things. Many use micro-mobility and e-scooters appropriately. People use them to go about their work or to go to college and we have to be aware of that too. I have not ignored the health issues, especially the reports that have come from CHI. They are extremely concerning. That is why those scooters are banned for under-18s. Families have responsibility here as well. The registration piece is being worked on by me and the Minister of State, Deputy Canney. If the question is whether anything is off the table, it is not.

This issue is not unique to Ireland, by the way. I attended the UN road safety summit in New York in July. There was a whole session on micro-mobility. This is an issue many countries are grappling with. Nothing is off the table, but I want people to abide by the regulations that are there. The enforcement is given to An Garda Síochána and its members are clear on that. I have met Justin Kelly on that very matter.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you.

Comment on this

The Minister is very welcome. The first thing I want to ask him about is the budget a few weeks ago and the PSO. When the NTA was before the committee, its officials said €1.65 billion was the estimated cost of running existing services in 2027 and that it would need an additional €45 million to introduce new services and enhancements to existing services. There has been a commitment to implement 145 new routes as part of the-----

Comment on this

It is about 140.

Comment on this

-----budget. Will the Minister confirm whether, in budget 2027, he now has enough funding to address capacity issues on bus services and introduce the new services we have been waiting on? He will be very aware, for instance, of the airport bus from Blanchardstown, the N8.

Comment on this

We are really keen to see that implemented, but new services are also required in Tyrellstown. We have engaged extensively on this and I thank the Minister again for that engagement on addressing capacity issues on existing bus services. He really listened to me about that and about how commuters were suffering because of ghost buses and disappearing buses, and he put more funding towards those capacity issues. Is the Minister in a good place to be able to deliver on both the capacity issues and implementing new routes?

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. We are in a much better place. I outlined in my opening statement that we have targeted about 140 new and expanded services to be rolled out over the course of 2027 because of the increase in the PSO and the fare determination made by the NTA. We have a growing population and growing public transport use, with 365 million public transport journeys in the last full year we have data for, 2025, and that is continuing to increase this year.

In areas like the Deputy's own, Dublin West, and in all of our constituencies, thankfully, populations are growing and there is more demand on public transport services. I am meeting the CEO of the NTA the week after next to go through the authority's draft programme, and I say very clearly it is the authority's draft programme. I met Dublin Bus yesterday and I will be meeting Iarnród Éireann to look at the proposed extension and new services for 2027. I also want to go through the timelines for delivery of those within the course of that year. The additional funding in the PSO is going to new services. We are in a much better place for 2027 than we were this year insofar as this year was a stabilisation year. We got a big uplift in the PSO. I wanted to get it back onto a sustainable footing. Under the previous regime, supplementaries were added every year. There was a great expansion in services - we were all involved in that and it is something I welcomed - but you could not plan.

To answer the Deputy's question directly, we are in a much better space right now. I got an 11% increase in the PSO in the budget, from a much higher base as well, and we have targeted approximately 140 new and improved services for the very areas the members represent. In fairness, all the committee members here are very active in advocating for additional services or additional capacity across bus, rail and light rail networks. That is why we are pointing this additional funding to that.

Comment on this

I am sorry to rush the Minister but I have only two minutes. Does he have an update on the N8?

Comment on this

When we spoke about this in the Chamber, he said he hoped, with the best intentions, that it would be in late 2026 to early 2027.

Comment on this

I am aware of how important that service is for Dublin West and for connectivity to the airport. We will get the full draft programme. I want to agree that draft programme with the NTA. I want to test what is on it too. The Deputy can be assured that her input and that of other Members advocating on behalf of their constituents is very much taken into account. We are a number of weeks away from being able to do that but I want to be confident about what is put to me. I have already started again to engage with our operators about new services and about the capacity they have. That is my focus.

Comment on this

There was understandable outcry about the fare increase and it does not seem to shut the door on annual increases. Can the Minister give people any comfort about fare increases and assure them they will not be an annual occurrence? How does he feel about value for money in general when it comes to the PSO obligation and how much money we are now spending on public transport compared with 2019? Are we getting value for money?

Comment on this

First, fare determinations are made by the NTA. It will review them annually. Obviously, that is in consultation with the Department. Public transport fares in Ireland compare very favourably in relation to affordability with all EU peers and with Britain. Fares are 8% lower than they were prior to 2020. There was a 20% reduction in fares over the Covid period. I am aware of affordability for people. On whether we are getting value for money, I think in broad terms the answer is "Yes" when you look at transport surveys, but reliability and frequency are big issues for commuters. I assure people the additional funds will be focused directly at those new services and at improving frequency and services.

Comment on this

Good afternoon. Indra failed to deliver the traffic management system for Irish Rail and that will cost the taxpayer around €50 million. It also has the contract for next generation ticketing – the tag-on, tag-off with a bank card – which is an even bigger contract in terms of value. I have consistently been asking what additional scrutiny is being put on Indra’s delivery of next generation ticketing considering it failed so spectacularly with the traffic management system. I have received replies from the Minister’s colleague the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, and from the NTA. They have told me about the existing oversight system, but I want to know what extra scrutiny is being put on this particular company in its delivery of next generation ticketing, considering it failed so badly on the traffic management system.

Comment on this

I have addressed the traffic management system and I do not disagree with the Deputy. I have myself met Indra about next generation ticketing on at least two occasions. It has opened a full-time office in Dublin. I met its chief executive and senior management team, who came over from Spain. I was given assurances by them that the team working on next generation ticketing is solely working on that and has established a permanent footprint here in Dublin. I have visited that and met the team charged with delivering next generation ticketing. It is being watched extremely closely, by both my team and me. We want to roll this out in testing mode, which will happen in Dublin first, as the Deputy knows, in a pilot manner across our different modes of transport. That will happen towards the end of next year. Based on how that testing goes, it will lead to the next phase of the roll-out of the system. This will be transformational for the public and the customer experience.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. I am sure assurances were given by Indra about the traffic management system. Indeed, we read about them in our engagements with Irish Rail, and those assurances did not turn out to be the case. The Minister has described a personal, hands-on involvement between himself and Indra, which is good and I welcome it. In terms of the wider processes, however, is anything being done differently or is it just a case of the Minister having individual engagements with the company?

Comment on this

Fair point. Indra is also co-located with the NTA on next generation ticketing. They are in the same building, working hand in glove on this. We have boots on the ground, for want of a better phrase, with regard to the delivery of this.

Comment on this

Again, I welcome that but what does being in the same office----

Comment on this

It is not just being in the same office. They are working with them daily. I do not have to send someone every month just to check on them. They are actually there.

Comment on this

Was this always the process for the roll-out of next generation ticketing, or is this a changed process in light of the problem with the other contract?

Comment on this

The establishment of Indra's office in Dublin was very much a response to the Department's concerns around the control centre. Our worry at the time was that it would impact on the delivery of next generation ticketing. Its team is working solely on next generation ticketing.

Comment on this

I would like to move on to new and improved bus services. I will start with the N8 orbital bus route, linking Blanchardstown and Dublin Airport. We have discussed it a number of times in the Dáil this year and last year. The Minister told me the route would be delivered by the end of this year. Is that going to happen?

Comment on this

I am not going to tell the Deputy exactly. As I said in reply to Deputy Currie, in the case of all the routes we are going to be adding, I want to do them in a co-ordinated way in the next few weeks. The N8 is a really important one. I have answered Deputy O'Gorman directly in the Dáil, as I have answered Deputy Currie. It is a route that I want to see established. As for whether it will be up and running before the end of this year, I do not know. I will have to sit down with the chief executive of the NTA the week after next to go through the draft programme, which I am going to do. If I am satisfied with that, I will want to balance what they are bringing forward with feedback many Deputies and Senators have relayed about the demands in their own constituencies. What they bring forward may be exactly what I want but I doubt it. That is why I want to test it. That will done over the course of the next few weeks, and then we will be able to expand public transport services in a really significant way. I am not going to answer the Deputy directly about the N8 route because I do not have that draft list yet.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's sense that it is ready to go and is just dependent on the Minister giving approval?

Comment on this

The N8 is well advanced and needs to be delivered.

Comment on this

The Minister is proposing 140 new services next year and that is one of the key justifications for the fare increase in January. Over the last three years, 188 new or improved services have been introduced. The most done in a year was 72. The least, this year, was 11 new or improved services. How can we have confidence that the public transport companies can deliver such an increased level of services across one year? Is there an additional capital budget as well as the current budget? Many new routes will require new buses and so on. How can we be confident all of that will be delivered? How confident is the Minister that if he is here in December of next year, he will be able to say he has delivered 140 services?

Comment on this

That is my absolute plan. It is approximately 140. It might be slightly more or one or two fewer. It is on the basis of what I go through with the draft programme. We have sufficient funding to do it. I was at pains to say the budget negotiations, the increased PSO and the fare determination are all going into the new and improved services. I met just yesterday with the board and chief executive of Dublin Bus, whom I meet regularly. It is the largest public transport operator in the country. The meeting was to assess Dublin Bus's readiness for the delivery of new services. The operators are ready. If we had the money, some of these services would have been delivered earlier. Many of them are well advanced in their planning. I will come back to the committee when we have that. I have taken on board the feedback from Members in the Dáil and committee members.

Comment on this

I wrote to the Minister recently about a very serious incident at Shannon Airport on 25 August. A potentially viable improvised explosive device was discovered at US customs at the airport. Airport personnel who were present have told me that this device was not dealt with correctly and in accordance with standard operating procedures, and that the device was transported by airport staff through a passenger area of the airport before it was made safe, putting both staff and passengers at risk. In the Minister's response, he outlined that the Irish Aviation Authority is investigating the incident. I have been contacted by some of the personnel who raised this. They have written to the IAA but have not received any response or acknowledgement. Following questions I put to the IAA, it appears that the onus is on those who were present that day to reach out to the authority.

This is very serious. It is known that airports are going to have to deal with incidents like this from time to time. That is why strict regulations and security protocols are in place. However, it is alleged they were not followed in this instance and that a number of people were put at serious risk. Has the Minister engaged with the IAA and the Shannon Airport Group on this and is he satisfied it is being properly investigated?

Comment on this

We take it very seriously. The Deputy wrote to me and I wrote back to him quite promptly on it. Any alleged incident that could potentially affect passenger or public safety is taken extremely seriously. The IAA is an extremely competent body, very highly respected both here and abroad. It is charged with carrying out this investigation, which is done independently of me. I have not received even an interim report on that yet. Nothing leads me to believe that it will not do its job properly and discharge its duties properly and professionally. The IAA is an excellent organisation and I do engage with it. The matter that has been raised is being taken very seriously. We will seek a further update for the Deputy. That file is open and I responded to the Deputy when he wrote to me. Any matters like that are taken very seriously. It is being investigated by the IAA.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear it is being taken very seriously.

I will move on to the western rail corridor. It is very welcome that we have moved towards reopening the Athenry to Claremorris section of the track. The Irish Rail CEO was before the committee yesterday and told us that section of the line could be up and running by 2031. We also heard from her about the next section of the line from Claremorris up to Collooney. It is very important that rail line is completed to ensure there is connectivity right along the west coast. Irish Rail has said previously that it is viable and could form part of future iterations of the all-island rail review. We also heard from the CEO that following political intervention, permission has been given for development of a greenway on that section of the line within County Sligo. That is very disappointing. It is going to make it much more difficult, ultimately, to restore that rail line if a greenway is placed on the track. The CEO specifically mentioned that the Department of Taoiseach intervened in respect of that. Was the Minister similarly involved in that decision?

Comment on this

I am the Minister for Transport. I outlined in my opening statement the importance of active travel and greenways as well. We are investing €360 million a year. There are no plans to open that section of the Sligo line until about 2050. Do we want to leave the line derelict or do we want to develop a greenway there that would be really good for residents and visitors alike, to drive economic investment and jobs? That would be my view.

Comment on this

The Minister is suggesting that a temporary greenway would be placed on the track. Greenways are very expensive. Is he suggesting a temporary greenway should be put down and ultimately be ripped up when the rail line is restored?

For me, the sensible solution would be for a greenway to be delivered alongside the infrastructure to ensure the rail line is protected for rail development. Would the Minister not agree that would be a much more sensible approach?

Comment on this

I do not design every scheme, as the Deputy knows. The reality is any greenway that is delivered on a disused rail line is generally licensed by CIÉ as the property owner. It is on licence. It is not disposed of, for the most part, so it can be taken back into use as a rail line in the future. That is the licensing arrangement.

Comment on this

I am asking whether that is a sensible way to approach this-----

Comment on this

-----when a much more sensible solution would be to develop a greenway alongside at a safe distance from the track, so both pieces of infrastructure can complement each other.

Comment on this

To be fair, there are conflicting views on this in the area. There are many who are for it and many who are against it. I do not tend to get involved in the local politics of it but there are well-held views. From our perspective, I want to deliver active travel. We have delivered over 1,000 km of active travel across the country already and we are going to deliver another 1,000 km. Communities derive incredible benefits from this right across the country, particularly in rural areas. The reality is there are no plans for a rail service on that section of the line until at least 2050. If people are saying to me that they want to just leave it vacant for 25 years, I do not think that makes sense.

Comment on this

Was the Minister involved in that decision? Did he discuss that matter with Irish Rail?

Comment on this

I have discussed that matter with Irish Rail. I am entitled to discuss matters like that, of course.

Comment on this

Was the Minister involved in this decision? That is what I am asking.

Comment on this

No, the decision was made by Irish Rail.

Comment on this

It said quite clearly yesterday that this was a Government decision.

Comment on this

When Deputies or Senators raise issues with me, I should be able to raise them with the relevant authorities and I do. There is no issue with that.

Comment on this

The Minister was involved in it.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for being with us today. We emailed him this morning to let him know that I would be talking about greenways in order to give him some bit of foresight as to what we would be talking about. I would love to go on about roads, the lack of funding in west Cork and rail. I will say one thing. The Minister said he is meeting with the NTA. We had a meeting with the NTA yesterday. We do not have any rail link from Cork city to west Cork, which is 130 km. The whole landscape of west Cork is without rail. We could have a bus connection to rail, and it has been proposed, but there is no movement on it. If we cannot get rail, and it looks like it is never going to happen, why can we not get a bus connection? I would appreciate it if the Minister can look into that when he meets the NTA.

Local Link is a serious issue. Tenders were put out for Clonakilty, Grange, Timoleague, Kealkill to Bantry, Macroom, Caher and Drinagh, but those tenders went into a bin and nothing happened. We would appreciate it if the Minister could look at that.

I need to concentrate on the greenways. I only have five minutes and I need five hours. I am going to ask a number of questions and the Minister may get a chance to answer them, rather than going through them one by one and we do not get to them all. The code of best practice was being reviewed. Has that been finalised? Will we be looking at a situation where CPOs are taken off the table? It is very important for landowners to know that they are not going to have a CPO waved in front of them. Why is private land being favoured over State land?

I will just give one instance of the crisis situation that a lot of landowners and farmers find themselves in. I know the O’Leary family in Ballinascarty. They attended the meetings in relation to the roll-out of the walkways going through their area. They explained that the walkway cannot go through their farmyard, shed or parlour. The answer they got was that they should not worry about that; it will be shoved sideways. This is not Lego we are dealing with. This concerns real farm buildings, farm livelihoods and people’s livelihoods. They are in a crisis situation and stressed. It is difficult enough at the moment because farming is not going through a very easy time, but that is beside the point. It is the same with the Oldcourt route where, again, farmers do not want it going through their lands and they are saying “No”. They are being told in no uncertain terms that this is the route being taken and nobody seems to want to listen to them. They do not want it. It is the same on the “quiet road” in Belgooly on the Cork to Kinsale route.

As I always say, this should have been run by the communities. When it was run by the communities, it was delivered by the communities. The TII has taken it over. They are like a shower of dictators. They seem to have a fortune of bloody money. It does not matter if the building costs €1 million, €10 million, €50 million or €100 million – they will deliver. We cannot get a road fixed, but we can give money for this.

Is there a budget this year for greenways and what kind of budget is it? Is it going to be railroaded through landowners' land without their consent? Will there be CPOs? Where is the code of practice review? These are the questions I would like answered.

Comment on this

I think all of us see the benefits of greenways and active travel across the country, although there are some that are more contentious than others. I have been directly involved in this. To answer the question, the budget this year is €360 million. We have a very significant pipeline. We committed in the programme for Government to invest a minimum of €360 million per year over the course of the Government and that is being done.

I and my team have engaged directly with TII, the NTA and active travel, but let us stay on the greenways. I have met with them. The greenway strategy itself will go out to public consultation early next year. That strategy was published in 2018, so it was time to review it. The review has been done insofar as there was a comprehensive round of public engagement and market research was undertaken. A lot of stakeholders engaged, including those who are for greenways and those who have issues with them. As the Deputy knows, I have met residents from Cork who had issues with the manner in which they felt they were engaged with and that is absolutely valid. The new strategy will go for public consultation early next year.

On the review of the code of practice, TII has committed to reviewing that code and because the code is due to expire at the end of this year, it has to come back to me. I have insisted that I want to see it, so it has to come back and we will look at it. A lot of really good work has been done on greenways and active travel. What I do not want is some specific cases having an impact on the good work and the positivity around greenways and active travel. Good market research has been done in relation to how communities feel the greenways have added to their communities once they are delivered.

In relation to CPOs, b’fhearr liom comhaontú - I much prefer agreement. CPOs are a line of absolute last resort and are not entered into lightly. It is not something that should be used as a go-to in any way, shape or form.

Over the course of the next few weeks, because I want to conclude this work this year, I will be looking at prioritisation of the pipeline of projects that are there, looking at which ones can be delivered in the short, medium and long term, and providing funding in that regard. Where communities are implacably opposed to it, I can allocate the money somewhere else to communities that want it. I think we have to be practical about it. Sometimes those who shout loudest get heard, whereas there is a whole middle ground of people who are quite content. However, I have no difficulty in reallocating moneys from a project and giving it to a community that wants it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that if a landowner or landowners are totally opposed to a walkway going through the area, it will not happen?

Comment on this

I am not going to spend ten years trying to fight with a landowner, and I do not think anyone wants to do that when we have many communities-----

Comment on this

Will CPOs be taken off the table completely for recreational projects?

Comment on this

I am really clear on this. TII is going to come back to me with the review of the code. That is due to come back to me this year. A CPO should be a last resort and it should not be used as a go-to. I will engage on that.

Regarding Local Link, with the new service, there will be a significant amount of additional Local Link services for 2027.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is good to hear that.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for being here. I have a couple of questions on the temporary train station that is going into Adare in County Limerick. Between Irish Rail and the NTA, they have bought back the old train station. It was sold just over ten years ago for €200,000 and they bought it back for €2 million. It will cost €3 million to put in a temporary platform that is only going to be for the Ryder Cup. The train is going to be a passenger train going from Adare to Limerick Junction and then it can either go to Cork or Dublin. The way it is being viewed, the cost is €5 million between buying back the building and providing the platform. It is specifically for the Ryder Cup and for American tourists. It will not service Limerick city because it will not go to Colbert Station, as it is going straight to the junction. It will not service Kerry. Anybody living in the vicinity will not be able to use this station or use the rail. From what I am hearing, it is €5 million for American tourists for the sake of a week.

Comment on this

Is there a question?

Comment on this

Does the Minister think it is value for money?

Comment on this

The station itself has been defined as temporary. It is obvious that there are opportunities post the Ryder Cup for the station and the services there.

What I would say is that the Ryder Cup itself is a major international event.

Comment on this

I do not doubt that. I am not for one minute saying it is not. It is going to be fantastic for the entire country.

Comment on this

Does the Senator want infrastructure to be able to support a major international event that is going to bring in significant investment and significant funds for communities and businesses?

Comment on this

What I would like to see is permanent infrastructure, not something that is temporary for the sake of a week or two and is only going to benefit tourists coming in. It is not going to benefit anybody living in Kerry, Limerick city or County Clare. They will never get to use this and it will be gone because the bridge has to be raised for a permanent rail line.

Comment on this

Could we not have got that done? We have known for a long time that the Ryder Cup is coming to Adare. There was foresight to see the need for a rail line, but those concerned are saying they were too late going with the planning submission. Could that not have been fast-tracked to make it permanent?

I am all for a rail line. I want to see the Foynes-Limerick rail line turned into a passenger line. It would be fantastic and serve so many people. When there is a lack of public transport in an area, putting in a rail line like that for passengers would be fantastic, but I feel like it is €5 million for the sake of a week or two.

Comment on this

I am not dismissing what the Senator is saying. She is perfectly entitled to her point of view. To operate and manage major international sporting events like this, sometimes changes to permanent infrastructure are necessary. The Adare bypass, for example, is not just for the Ryder Cup. It is permanent. It is part of the motorway upgrade scheme, which is badly needed. I have visited the site on a couple of occasions. The provision of temporary facilities is also important to be able to deal with not just American tourists but visitors from all over Europe and from Ireland who are going to be at the event. There will be long-term benefits from the hosting of the Ryder Cup.

On the station itself, the Senator knows there are some flood risks there that would require permanent changes. Unquestionably, there is a line there. The Senator mentioned Foynes. Foynes absolutely should have a passenger line. I have visited it and seen the track being commissioned. For a permanent passenger service, signalling upgrades and such things would also be required. The week, and the weekend in particular, over the course of the tournament can be managed because it is just a very specific timeframe. It was appropriate that work was done to facilitate the tournament but it is clear, and the Senator has raised this as well, there are opportunities for further upgrades in the area that would be permanent. However, they would require planning permission and amendments.

Comment on this

Perfect. I thank the Minister.

I will ask about funding for rural roads. The Road Safety Authority had a report out that states 73% of deaths happen on rural and local roads, not motorways, and 47% of serious injuries happen on those roads. I know an extra €5 million was allocated this year to councils for rural roads. How much of that is going towards maintenance and how much is going to be put into other plans for rural roads, whether they are for upgrades of bridges or what-not?

I see issues when I am driving around rural roads, even with hedging. Is the Minister considering anything in this regard? Hedges are being cut only to a certain height. It is more for cars and vans, but trucks and buses are going outside the white line because the hedges up higher are still out too far. Drivers are protecting their mirrors. As the Minister knows, mirrors on trucks and buses cost an awful lot more than car mirrors. Are there any plans to address the problem? I would love to know how much is going into the maintenance of the roads.

Comment on this

On rural roads, we all know that the local authorities are the road authorities. They manage the budgets that we give them. We will make the allocations for rural roads very early in the new year, probably in January. We have other allocations later this year. I cannot give the Senator the exact figure because we are working it through at the moment.

The local authorities do send submissions to us. Regarding the Senator's own area, the submission will come to us and set out the work that needs to be done. There is a maintenance element to the funding. There is funding from the local authorities themselves as well. The Senator is looking at January for those allocations. They will be publicised.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire. I too am going to ask about the western rail corridor. In the Minister's opening address, which was welcome, he spoke about our reliance, or trying to reduce our reliance, on private cars. Most of what he spoke about here relates to wanting to increase people's use of public transport. I got confirmation last year from the chief executive officer of Irish Rail that the part of the western rail corridor from Claremorris to Collooney was to be used only for rail infrastructure. Suddenly, there was a reversal of that decision, which we had confirmed. There were rumours that the Department of the Taoiseach had intervened. Was it the Department of Transport itself that intervened and said that this was going to be used instead for a greenway? The Minister said that he believes the vast majority of people in our area would support the greenway.

Comment on this

If the Senator looks at the record, she will see that I said there are conflicting views in the area.

Comment on this

There are conflicting views but I am wondering whether the Minister has consulted. First of all, is what happened normal? Often, we hear that there is a hands-off approach from the Department of Transport in that it says things are the responsibility of the NTA or Irish Rail, which is fair enough regarding the operational structure. I do not expect the Minister to be involved in everything. However, is it commonplace for there to be political interference in decisions like this when Irish Rail has clearly set out that it wants to see the line retained only for rail infrastructure? Irish Rail has said that part of the line connecting it will be rails on track between Athenry and Claremorris by 2031. It has said there will be a new all-island rail review in 2034, which is only eight years away. Is it common, first of all, to have political interference in decisions like this? Second, has the Minister consulted? We have had so many different people before the transport committee, and so many bodies under the Minister's remit, saying they agree on the western rail corridor, including regional airports like Knock Airport. They have said it would transform the region, which has been designated a lagging region in terms of transport infrastructure.

The Port of Foynes representatives were with us two weeks ago. They confirmed that it would be of massive benefit to connect Sligo Port to the Port of Foynes, and that the western rail corridor would play a significant part in this and would be seen as a key infrastructure project. We then find out that there has been political interference and a temporary structure will be put in. I am not sure where the Minister is getting his information from. Atlantic Technological University college is in Sligo. The president of ATU has said that the university wants to see the western rail corridor opened. As far as I can see, the only people who do not are those involved in some kind of political interference. Even senior members of the Minister's own party in Mayo and Galway are astounded by the overturning of the decision by Irish Rail, a respected body. I am wondering whether interference is commonplace and whether the Minister has consulted other agencies within his Department.

Comment on this

First, I would say "political oversight" not "political interference".

Comment on this

The Minister said "political interference" a minute ago.

Comment on this

No, the Senator said "political interference". I do not want to split hairs.

Comment on this

I have a role. If I am asked by Deputy Collins or any of the many other Deputies across the House, such as Deputy Boland, about issues raised in areas, I look into them. It is better that I do. I am the Minister for Transport.

Comment on this

On this issue, what I did say earlier is that there are conflicting views. I have never had so much commentary in relation to a potential greenway. That is being honest. It shows the level of feeling on the ground. I get that.

We were talking earlier about Iarnród Éireann. It is a body that I have immense regard for. The Senator will note from what we were talking about earlier, from the chairman's address, that it is not without fault.

Comment on this

I have no doubt about that.

Comment on this

The reason I say that is I think it is appropriate that decisions be tested as well. The reality is that the section of the western rail corridor from Athenry to Claremorris, which is a priority for us, will be reopened and construction is going to be under way next year. We are looking at the phasing of this but the reality of this section of line, as I answered Deputy O'Hara earlier, is that we are probably looking at 2050, at best.

Comment on this

Not according to Irish Rail. It suggests that there will be a review in 2034.

Comment on this

The decision is taken. Iarnród Éireann has confirmed that in writing to Sligo County Council. Where any greenway is developed on Iarnród Éireann property and track, the land is made available under a leasing arrangement.

Comment on this

Sorry to cut across the Minister, but if there is a review in eight years' time, will the temporary greenway structure have to be lifted to accommodate railway infrastructure? An essential, key infrastructural project in our region will be taken up.

Comment on this

The decision has been taken on this.

Comment on this

Can it be reversed?

Comment on this

Of course. Iarnród Éireann is not disposing of the land.

Comment on this

Taxpayers' money is being wasted by putting temporary infrastructure on a pre-existing railway line.

Comment on this

Sorry, if the Senator is saying 2050-----

Comment on this

I am not; I am saying 2034.

Comment on this

The Senator might let me answer because we are just going back and forth.

The reality of it , and I said this earlier, that my view and from the information I have is that the earliest we will have something on that section of the line is 2050, so if the Deputy wants to leave that line derelict for the next 24 years, fair enough. I do not think that is good for the local community either.

Comment on this

However, I got confirmation yesterday on this. Their agency, which is a semi-State commercial body, has been tasked to look at the all-island strategic rail review, which is a strategic plan that changes.

Comment on this

That is the whole point of having a strategy. It changes by internal and external factors.

Comment on this

We can see the population is increasing in the west. We can see that there is remote working. We want to encourage people to live-----

Comment on this

-----and work in the rest of Ireland. If that is the case, they confirmed yesterday that there is going to be a review of this strategy in 2034. What happens then if it says yes-----

Comment on this

However, if there is a review-----

Comment on this

Are we are going to have this temporary structure that is going to be there for eight years and wasting all that money?

Comment on this

I think I have answered it. That is fair enough.

Comment on this

I am delighted the Minister could make it.

Comment on this

It is very good to see him. In terms of next-generation ticketing, I had another e-mail this morning from a constituent who was going to get a late night 101 bus to Balbriggan and a taxi to Skerries. She did not have a Leap card and did not have cash so she could not get on the bus. It is absolutely essential that next-generation ticketing is implemented and as quickly as possible.

I was pretty alarmed at a recent Committee of Public Accounts meeting to hear that the RAG status of the project had been red and maybe then moved to amber, which was completely contrary to the indications I was getting from the NTA when I raised that with it earlier this year. Given all of the issues with Indra on the train control centre - we have been over them at length - it is essential that the project stays green, it really is, and that the governance and control, both of the Minister's Department and the oversight group, make sure this stays on track. The Minister might please confirm to me the current RAG status of the project and that the contractual arrangements include remedies for compensation for delays on the part of the supplier.

Comment on this

I am going to agree with the Deputy completely. Next-generation ticketing for passengers is a critical project. I mentioned earlier that I am watching really closely. I will not go over that in the interests of time. The Deputy will know that our colleagues are basically co-located with Indra. That project status is green. It is on track to deliver the pilot next year. The pilot will bring it into testing across bus, rail and light rail, and that is why we are doing that in Dublin. That is a small pilot so we can test how the system works in real time and with real usage. That will then inform the further roll-out. As I talk to the Deputy right now, however, we are watching it and it is green. It is on track for us to deliver the pilot next year and get it out into testing. We have a lot of work to do in relation to the terminals and so forth that have to be replaced. I have seen them. That is where we are at.

Comment on this

That is great. I urge the Minister to make sure it stays green and, if it moves into amber, that the Department steps in.

I know the Minister is seriously concerned about congestion in Dublin, as I am. I very much welcome the €1 billion PSO levy. I am very much looking forward to the announcement of the 140 new and enhanced services. I would again emphasise the need for the 33X to have increased services. However, one of the issues, which I have raised with the Minister several times and with the NTA, is that we need to make sure that the first mile is easy for people to get to. As the Minister knows, in Fingal we are building houses at pace, but we have a real issue at Rush and Lusk train station. The road itself, as the Minister knows well, is a very rural road. It needs to be resurfaced, there is no safe pathway, it is crumbling and it is not safe. It is very narrow on that road, particularly from the Lusk side where it is slightly easier to walk to because it is only 1 km on that side. There are no lights. I am going around in circles in relation to a feeder bus. The NTA says one thing me but in writing says the complete opposite.

Comment on this

In the interest of the 33X, I get the point; the Deputy has made that loud clear.

She is right about the provision of housing in Fingal. There are more homes being delivered in Fingal now under construction than there is in the greater London area. That just shows us the scale of development that is happening there. The services, therefore, need to be expanded to support the growth in population. With regard to physical infrastructure, the Deputy used a really good example of Rush and Lusk train station. There needs to be joined-up thinking in relation to access to those areas.

I mentioned that, the week after next, I am meeting with the chief executive of the NTA and I will be going through this. I can assure the Deputy that the points she raises with me regularly, and I appreciate that too, and all that feedback will be taken into account. Am I going to be able to deliver every service everyone wants all next year? No, I am not, but we have to look at our growth areas and areas with a growth in population where people want to use public transport. The first mile piece is really important. I get the Deputy on that. I note the earlier provision of a bus stop in the Deputy's own area, which seems like a very trivial thing but is not.

Comment on this

It took years.

Comment on this

Actually, when we look at the service users in that area - Prosper Fingal and various others - we need to be quicker. We have a good bus stop and upgrade service and we devolve money to the local authorities now for them to do it. There is a lot of that happening in Fingal, so that is pretty good.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. I am going to very briefly advocate for a feeder bus for the Skerries and Loughshinny area as well because, again, it is that first mile. The town is sprawling but it is very difficult to connect with the train station.

Comment on this

In that meeting the Deputy and I had with the NTA some time ago around the design of particular routes and how that might mop up some of those areas, that certainly was taken on board.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. Finally, I wish to raise the issue of fare determinations. I am very disappointed that the NTA came out with a new fare determination without analysing the impact of the fare determination of 2025. I am absolutely aghast that is how a State body can work. It is simply not good enough. We know from the heavy rail census that there was a 5% decrease in commuters in Balbriggan, a town the Minister knows has hugely expanded in a few years. There should not be any kind of decrease in the travel from Balbriggan. I urge the Minister to urge the NTA to make sure it is making fare determinations on an evidence base and that it has to analyse the impacts of previous fare determinations without coming out with new ones.

Comment on this

What the Deputy was referencing was the fair fares initiative.

Comment on this

Or unfair fares if people are in Balbriggan and Skerries.

Comment on this

I know, and it did have specific impacts on Balbriggan and Skerries. That point has been well made it has been fed back to the NTA.

Comment on this

It has, but it has not listened.

Comment on this

What I will say is that my big focus is on additional new services for next year for our commuters across rail and road. I will continue to engage with the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are constrained by time and I apologise to Deputy Toole. We are only allowing in members of the committee today because of that time constraint. Deputy Toole does actively engage with the committee. I want to read a question on behalf of Deputy Toole into the record and I ask the Minister's officials to reply directly to her, if that is in order. In light of the European Court of Justice ruling last Thursday on the passenger cap at Dublin airport of 32 million and the subsequent referral to the High Court, will the independent review of runway operations at Dublin Airport now take place as a matter of urgency and what is the timeline? I am not asking the Minister to respond now. I would just ask that his officials respond directly to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I will respond in writing directly to the Deputy. To be fair to her, she has raised this matter on an ongoing basis.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I appreciate that. We have a few minutes before I bring the meeting to a conclusion. I have spoken to the Minister privately and I wrote to him back in March about this issue of horse-drawn vehicles on public roads, especially the use of sulkies. It is an issue that intersects not just with the Department of Transport but also with the Department of justice from an enforcement perspective and, in particular, the Department of agriculture from a welfare perspective. I welcome that the interdepartmental working group has been set up. I have very good engagement with Keith Walsh in the Minister’s Department. It is possible that group even met this week as well. I did ask that the group look at issues like welfare, obviously, enforcement and minimum age to explore a licensing and regulatory framework. Could the Minister provide any update on that interdepartmental working group?

I know there is a lot of legislation coming from the Minister’s Department in the next number of months. I acknowledge some of that key information, particularly around the National Vehicle and Driver File, Road Traffic and Roads Bill 2026. There is the proposed emergency road safety Bill, which everybody in this committee will welcome, and separate to that, obviously, updates to or perhaps a new traffic and roads Bill. Section 74 of the 1993 Act currently does allow for this. I accept it is under specific conditions, but we have roads legislation currently that does allow for the racing of horse-drawn vehicles or sulkies on Irish roads.

The racing of sulkies has no place on Irish public roads. Will the Minister commit to looking at section 74 of the Road Traffic Act in the opportunities that arise in upcoming and immediate legislation? A road closure licence is needed from the local authority and, more importantly, to prosecute someone in that regard you have to identify the organiser of the event. I appeal to the Minister to look at section 74 of the Roads Act 1993 in the context of the racing. I do not know whether he wants to comment on that. He could give his general view on the road racing of sulkies.

Comment on this

I commend you, Chairman, on the work you have put into highlighting this. There is a lot of really dangerous activity with the racing of horses and sulky racing across our roads, particularly with juveniles. I am sure we have all seen the videos of that too. The interdepartmental group is set up and it is working. The committee has engaged with it. I thank the Chairman for that. What we are working towards is to develop a scheme for a horse-drawn carriages Bill for hire or reward by late this year or early 2027. I do not have the details of section 74 of the 1993 Act as the Chairman has articulated here, but I give him a commitment now that we will bring that in. We will have a look at it. This is a really important piece of work. Originally, in December 2019, there was a decision to develop a Bill on that. It is not good enough that it has taken this long. There are other things we need to do in that regard but we are aiming for the development of that Bill late this year or in early 2027. I just got a note from the team here. I know the Chairman is engaged on this. The 1993 Act is being reviewed for the next road traffic and roads Bill. I thank the Chair for raising that.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I really appreciate that. There are a couple of final points. All members of the committee are very frustrated with the replies to parliamentary questions from the National Transport Authority, NTA. From my own experience and from speaking to members, it can take up to six, seven or even eight months to get a reply from the NTA. I have spoken to the leadership team in the NTA but unfortunately there has been no improvement. I accept the volume of questions but I do not think there is any excuse for an average of six to seven months for a reply from the NTA. Will the Minister speak to the NTA about the structures it has in place to deal with parliamentary questions?

Finally, I will come back to road safety. We have been full-on dealing with it since February or March of this year. We have met with many stakeholders - vulnerable road users, academics and all the key agencies - the RSA and local authorities. We met the assistant Garda commissioner. We are currently at draft report stage. We are going to look at a lot of different areas such as governance, enforcement, legislative reform and emergency response. We really look forward to working closely with the Minister, and in particular with the road safety leadership team established under the Minister of State, Deputy Canney. We all agree on the need for action. We talk about record numbers but of course behind each one of those statistics is a family and a community absolutely devastated. I think we are going in the wrong direction. Our targets in the context of 2030 will be very difficult to achieve, and that is notwithstanding the many thousands of serious injuries. We really look forward to engagement on it. I welcome the Minister's comments. I know it is a key priority for him.

Comment on this

The committee has done a lot of work on it and I look forward to getting the report. I met with members of the Irish Road Victims Association the week before last as well and they share our concern. I know the committee has engaged with them as well on the uptick in numbers. Those numbers are people; we get that. We must do a lot more collectively, both here in the Oireachtas but also in enforcement, education and personal responsibility, so that people know any time they get behind the wheel of a car they have a responsibility to others as well and that they do it appropriately.

On the NTA responses to parliamentary questions, I have already met with the chief executive on that. I discussed it with Ms Shaw. She is aware of it. I know the Chair has also spoken to her. It is not good enough for Deputies who are elected by the people to wait six, seven or eight months for responses. I know there is a high volume but it needs to be managed better. It is on my agenda and I have already spoken to the chief executive. I will speak to her again the week after next when I meet her with regard to the new bus programme. I will make sure that is on the agenda as well.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

In the context of our road safety report and recommendations, which we hope to launch in the coming weeks, it would be great if the Minister were possibly available. I hope to do the launch and to bring all stakeholders, including the representative body for victims, and the PARC Road Safety Group. It is a really good organisation headed up by Susan Gray.

Comment on this

We can work it out.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I promised the Minister he would be out by 1.15 p.m.

Comment on this

Gabhaim míle buíochas leis an gCathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is 1.13 p.m. or 1.14 p.m. I welcome the Minister's commitment. It is on the record that he will appear in person for the Estimates.

Comment on this

I will. I responded to that.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister did but I think there was a revision. A couple of weeks in a row, we saw a couple of Ministers of State.

Comment on this

I missed you guys. I will be back.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I do not want to put it on the record, but one particular member has referred to the Minister as the Scarlet Pimpernel.

Comment on this

That was Roderic O'Gorman.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I cannot divulge the name.

Comment on this

The Chair will note that he is not here now. A lot of the time I am here, he is not here.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I cannot divulge details about members. I really appreciate the number of members of the Minister's team who are here today. We have really good engagement. I just want to mention Keith Walsh, who is very good to me in terms of his ongoing engagement, especially on matters of road safety and the horse issue we just discussed. The meeting now stands adjourned until 9.30 a.m. on Wednesday, 4 November when the joint committee will again meet in public session. I thank all.

Comment on this