We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport and Communications

Departure of High Performance Unit Head Coach: IABA and Sport Ireland

Contributions 174–366 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Joe Christle

No, it was not secured for the other employees.

Comment on this

We are only talking about Billy Walsh.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

No. The effect on the others is that there is an inevitable right for somebody to match any of the other coaches, to have a similar increase.

Comment on this

On a fixed contract?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

No. What was being offered to him in the agreement in August was that he would remain as a permanent employee with his remuneration going up at the levels that I am talking about. What I am trying to convey to the committee is that the IABA did not want him to go. Firstly, we never asked him to leave or change his employment status. I have already put it on the record that even at the very last deal he shook my hand and said "These terms are acceptable to me". We said: "There is always the choice to remain as a permanent employee. That is the choice that you can always make and we will fight for increases of the more modest 5% or 10% and bonuses for you." The choice was made because he was comparing the offer that was there in terms of the length of time of the employment of contract with his offer in America.

He is not here, nor does anybody in the room actually know what he was offered in America - none of the terms and conditions of that offer.

The IABA is not entitled to know and would never have asked what those terms and conditions were. We have to respect his right to negotiate on his own behalf and then try to fight to retain him. If we come up with various propositions, such as acting as a contractor, as a fixed term employee or waiving his exclusivity of service, they are all ideas to try to find another way to keep him in Ireland and keep him involved, not only as the high performance unit’s head coach but also in sport, and lending his expertise to the other sports, that indicates the IABA wants him to stay.

Comment on this

Mr. Christle has focused only on the financial issues and has not really addressed the non-financial issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I would like to ask our president, Mr. Pat Ryan, to deal with the direct question do we resent the high performance unit’s success.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Ryan

Absolutely not. The inception of the high performance unit in the IABA was one of the greatest happenings in its history. Naturally, in its infancy there were many misconceptions about what was involved in high performance, who would run it and all kinds of questions.

When the position came up, Gary Keegan, who is a personal friend of mine, and I, discussed it at length. He and I are directly involved in co-ordinating training at national level. Gary was fortunate and successful in his role. We then identified a coach and Billy Walsh was identified at that time as a very young, ambitious and well-established coach and he was appointed.

It is necessary to take a broader view of the high performance unit. It is the jigsaw for success. Part of the jigsaw was to try to source a technical coach. This job was given to Dan O’Connell from Cork, who was one of our top international referees and judges. In Georgia Dan found Zuar Antia, who was brought to this country and we employed him. He is probably reputed to be one of the finest technical coaches in the world. His contribution to this jigsaw is huge. Also at the time, Jim Moore, whose son won a bronze medal in 2001 in Belfast, was part of the coaching staff. The Irish Sports Council supplied the necessary support staff in sport psychology and eventually came on board with Gerry Hussey, a remarkable sports psychologist. His contribution was also huge. We had dieticians, and a strength and conditioning coach, John Cleary, an exceptional guy. His work ethic and contribution to the entire programme, from youth to senior level, have been phenomenal. We absolutely do not resent the high performance unit. I am sure the CEO of Sport Ireland, John Treacy, would be aware that my endeavour to be president of this organisation goes back many years, with a good struggle.

However, I succeeded. It would have been mooted around the country, because Billy Walsh and I spent ten years together in the high performance unit. I was involved in coaching many teams under Billy's stewardship. I know the value of Billy Walsh and never was his professionalism or expertise questioned by anybody.

What is more important for me, as president of the organisation, is the tears that come after. There has been a huge discussion here about what happened with regard to Billy's position and the parties involved. However, it is important that we are very much aware that the high performance unit is one element of our organisation. To take it a stage further and say that we are dysfunctional would be a misrepresentation of how the organisation functions. We have more clubs, more coaches and more boxers, both boys and girls, at present. We have an excellent level 1 and level 2 coaching programme that is implemented and delivered by established master tutors. We also have a referee and judges programme that has enabled some of our referees and judges to officiate at the three pathways that are now available to the Olympic podium, which are AOB - Olympic, WSB - World Series Boxing, and APB - the AIBA professional programme. The same coaching staff is involved with that. I am concerned that we need more coaches to function at this high level. The high performance unit has been fantastic for the IABA but to develop the sport further, it is now a requirement for us to move forward to establish these centre-of-excellence boxing academies in the four units so we can continue the pipeline or conveyor belt and produce boxers from all 32 counties, and so the coaches working in these areas get an opportunity to learn high performance systems and, therefore, continue to produce the conveyor belt of boxers coming to high performance.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

I wish to respond to Deputy Griffin, who asked a specific question about our remuneration. It related to the article in The Sunday Business Post and the Deputy asked whether the directors sought anything. For absolute clarity, the directors receive no remuneration whatever, nor do we claim any expenses for attending board meetings or any other meetings anywhere in the country.

Comment on this

Perhaps the witness will clarify the quote in the newspaper, which states that a review of salaries for all staff in the IABA should be undertaken on behalf of the ISC before any contracts are signed.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

John Treacy, the CEO of Sport Ireland dealt with that, or perhaps it was the chairman.

Comment on this

Can the witness clarify that? Was that on the document?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

As our chairman stated, we said there would be a relativity knock-on effect or a benchmarking for our other employees. We are in a situation here where our most prized asset and coach has come to us stating that he has received a very attractive offer. We were never privy to what that offer was, nor should we be. That is a matter for himself. If we accede to all his financial requests we know, with certainty, that his assistant coach, our other coaches and, indeed, our boxers - not only do we know, it has already happened to us-----

Comment on this

Was it all staff?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

All staff.

Comment on this

That is administrative staff and everybody.

Comment on this

It looks to me as if this position and the situation the witnesses found themselves in with Mr. Walsh was used as a bargaining chip for the witnesses and the staff as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

Not ourselves. I have already explained that we sought nothing for ourselves.

Comment on this

It was a review of salaries for all staff of the IABA.

Comment on this

That is the coaches perhaps.

Comment on this

I know that. I am just saying about the staff.

Comment on this

I am trying to help. Is it a knock-on effect for the coaches?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Just coaches and high performance staff Deputy Griffin.

Comment on this

Would that include Mr. Carruth?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Pardon me, Deputy Griffin. I wish to have it on the record here that the chief executive, Mr. Fergal Carruth, has put himself on record as saying that even if there was any review he feels he is adequately paid and that he did not seek, nor has he ever sought during his time, to leverage his own position. He is a very modestly salaried CEO.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Christle not think that by including these terms, the IABA was playing with fire and that it jeopardised the retention of Mr. Walsh? With hindsight, does Mr. Christle regret that?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

The terms that are there were the terms put in place by the Minister of State, Deputy Michael Ring, on 11 September. There was a pathway to success, the first part of which was to offer to Mr. Walsh a fixed-term contract along with a severance package. The IABA did not know what the severance package was going to be - it was to be ring-fenced and proposed by the Irish Sports Council, at the invitation of the Minister. On the day on which we conducted the negotiations, I was on the phone to the Irish Sports Council to find out exactly what we could offer Mr. Walsh in order to fix the deal.

Comment on this

Can the witness indicate whether the description of the proposal from the IABA reported in The Sunday Business Post is accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

What the Deputy is referring to is the letter-----

Comment on this

At the 14 October meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes, in the October meeting - which was called by the IABA to bring the Minister of State up to date with everything that had happened since the Athlone meeting - we set out what we had already done. These are the other matters that were agreed in Athlone and we were seeing what had happened regarding those other matters. At the 14 October meeting, it was clear that the most important thing for the Minister of State, the Irish Sports Council and the IABA was to get Mr. Walsh's signature on a contract. We all agreed on that and we all left the room saying "That is what we will get done." That was on the Wednesday before Mr. Walsh's resignation letter on the Monday.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

We were tasked to get that done by the Friday.

Comment on this

In the interests of clarity, the minutes of the meeting of 14 October were circulated to members this morning.

Comment on this

I just wanted to know if that was accurate because that is what was reported.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Christle explain why he felt that a review of all salaries should be undertaken on behalf of the ISC before any contracts were signed. The IABA was standing on the edge of a cliff and it was still seeking to impose these conditions. Why was this done when we were on the verge of losing this highly valued coach? Why did the IABA complicate the situation so much and why did it include those conditions? Was it just a bad game of poker that the witness was playing?

Comment on this

Deputy Griffin has had a fair crack at the whip and I want to go back-----

Comment on this

I just want to establish if Mr. Christle regrets having included those conditions before Mr. Wash's signature was obtained. Does Mr. Christle regret that?

Comment on this

I remind Deputy Griffin that we have a procedure and he has put his questions to the witness. The Deputy will get the chance of a supplementary question if his question is not answered. I invite Mr. Christle to answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

The board of directors was happy to set that aside and follow the proposal or the urging of the Minister.

The Sports Council and the IABA, at the meeting on 14 October, were happy to set it aside and fully concentrate on getting the contract and getting the deal that had been agreed on 14 September signed and sealed. That was the week in which the world championship finals took place on the Wednesday and Thursday and Billy Walsh was back on the Friday and coming up for a meeting on the following Tuesday. The IABA expected contracts to come back from the solicitors because it was at the exchange of contract stage and we had given our word to the Minister that we would finish this by the following Friday. It did not matter what was coming back from the solicitors, it was going to be done. The Minister indicated in the strongest possible terms that he wanted it done and we said that we would get it done.

Comment on this

Did Senator Brennan have questions?

Comment on this

Are there any other issues that we should know about? Does Mr. Christle believe that Billy Walsh got the recognition and respect that I feel he was due? Is Mr. Treacy aware of any other issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I am not aware of any other issues. In regard to the recognition of Billy Walsh, the IABA could not have put it more clearly in the statement that was read into the record, he is the most successful Olympic coach in any sport in Irish sporting history. We are extremely grateful for all the work that he has done. These are not platitudes. This is real. That is why for eight long months we battled to try to find a way to hold on to him.

Comment on this

What contract would have held on to Billy Walsh, in Mr. Christle's opinion?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Sadly, because I never saw the contract from America, I have no idea what was on the other side.

Comment on this

He wanted to stay in Ireland. What offer would have held him?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I cannot answer for Billy Walsh. Perhaps that is a question for him. I can reassure the committee that we fought long and hard over eight months. The irony is that the length of time for which we fought to retain him and secure the exact right deal is now-----

Comment on this

Mr. Christle must have gotten an idea of what he wanted. That is all I say.

Comment on this

Does Sport Ireland want to come back in?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

Deputy Bruton asked if any other clubs applied for the OSCAR grant and why some clubs did not. The answer to that is yes. A lot of clubs benefitted from the OSCAR grant to the tune of almost €600,000. For the ones that did not, we have, with the assistance of the Irish Sports Council, employed two development officers to go directly into clubs and, amongst other things, help them to fill out application forms for various grants and local sports partnership funding that may be available to them. They have already started with the association and are now visiting clubs.

Comment on this

Did the IABA apply for regional elements of the programme?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

It did.

Comment on this

It was not successful.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

No.

Comment on this

What did it apply for?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

It applied for €210,000.

Comment on this

What was that in respect of?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

Capital work for the national stadium.

Comment on this

We will go to Senator Brennan.

Comment on this

I have a question on the boxing side and concerns that out boxers are now more vulnerable in the ring as a result of losing our head coach to another country - someone who would have known their weaknesses. Is that a consideration?

Comment on this

Is that the miracle of inside information?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I will hand over to Pat Ryan, because he was a coach in high performance for ten years with Billy Walsh so he knows both Zaur Antia and Billy Walsh.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Ryan

To answer Deputy Brendan Griffin's question, it will be difficult to fill the void Billy has left. If we could do it all over again, we might possibly prefer it if he had not walked into the office. We have a very successful coaching team that operates within the high performance unit. It is important to emphasis that it is the system which is in place that justifies the success we have seen. Billy played the lead role and did a remarkable job, absolutely. However, his experience will now be passed on. Zaur Antia has been beside him all the way for the past 13 years. John Conlan who is the Ulster high performance coach and also contributes to the national high performance coaching team is a very accomplished coach in his own right. He is the father of Michael Conlan who recently won a gold medal in Doha. In addition, we have Eddie Bolger, another valued member whom we appointed in the past 12 months. He took over responsibility for Joe Ward at youth stage because his club coach, Seamus Dorrington, was not in a position to continue with him at the time. Eddie took over coaching responsibilities for Joe for a number of years and is now a member of the high performance coaching staff. Joe is the current World Championships silver medalist.

As members can see, we have developed coaches who have grown within the system which was headed up by Billy. It is very important that we have additional coaches who have spent a number of years working in the high performance area.

Comment on this

I apologise for interrupting. My interpretation of Deputy Brendan Griffin's question was that he was seeking Mr. Ryan's view on whether Ireland's boxers would be negatively affected by the fact that Mr. Walsh would effectively be coaching our opponents. If I understand him correctly, Mr. Ryan is saying we have a good coaching structure to carry on the work.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Ryan

My understanding was that Deputy Brendan Griffin was asking whether our boxers would be affected by the void Billy had left.

Comment on this

My question was related to the flight of specific information on our boxers' individual weaknesses and so on.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

We cannot speak directly for our boxers on this issue because they really would have to answer the question themselves. We can, however, speak for those who have given their view on it, one of whom is Katie Taylor. Referring to her opponents, she has observed that one can tell boxers what to do, but it does not necessarily mean that they will be able to do it. That reflects the degree of confidence boxers have in our high performance unit and programme. Comments have been attributed to a number of other boxers and Deputy Tom Fleming noted that he was not particularly happy with what had been said in one instance. It is not a case of their feeling any badness towards anybody leaving; the boxers regret Billy's departure, but they ultimately have confidence in their own abilities and try not to let themselves be distracted in any way, shape or form.

Comment on this

I welcome the delegates. My question is to the delegates from the Irish Sports Council. The minutes of the meeting of 14 October refer to remuneration for Billy Walsh of €115,000, plus a bonus of €10,000. Is that the delegates' recollection of the agreement?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

No, we put forward a different structure on 22 August. However, in fairness to both the IABA and us, we did put a parameter of about €125,000 on the package.

In fairness to the IABA, it was restructured around this.

Comment on this

Supposing it had not worked, which is a concern I have, and its successes were not entirely due to Billy Walsh. He is 52 years of age and he could have run out of ideas. Would the organisation have been stuck with the arrangement or would it have been able to renegotiate it if it had not worked out?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

My understanding is that a three-year deal was put to Mr. Walsh because he was leaving his full-time employment with the IABA. I believe it was €115,000 plus a bonus of €10,000 for three years only.

Comment on this

Mr. Treacy felt the taxpayer was protected.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

We must be careful. I am uncomfortable with any suggestion that age determines competence, ability or talent. We do have laws on this matter.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Mulvey. In his statement, Mr. Walsh indicated that the new fixed-term contract gave him very few legal protections and prevented him from having any contact with the Irish Sports Council or the Olympic Council of Ireland. He further indicated that he was also prevented from having contact with the Irish Sports Council or the Olympic Council of Ireland without written permission of the CEO and that this stipulation also related to any contact with the media. Is this a normal relationship for a sports organisation to have with a person of Mr. Walsh's stature?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

No, it is not. Sport Ireland deals with performance directors on a regular basis because they are the main contact when it comes to high-performance sport. From our perspective, having this in the contract of someone dealing with us on a regular basis is unworkable.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Treacy value the media role played by individuals such as Seán Boylan and Mick O'Dwyer in promoting sport, rather than having them bound by contracts which mean they are not allowed to talk to the media?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Perhaps the Senator should address his question to the IABA. Any person dealing in high-performance sport needs to talk to the media on a regular basis. This is very clear. It is part and parcel of what these people do. They are on the edge of performance. Mr. Sheedy could tell the Senator exactly what his role was when he managed Tipperary.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Sheedy

It is par for the course. One regularly engages with the media because there are always questions. Understanding what is happening in sport is a national interest. It is the norm.

Comment on this

It is normal also that when a person achieves international success, he or she receives kudos for his or her performance. When Shane Long scored a goal against the world champions, people in Tipperary could have said they washed the jerseys and pumped up the footballs when he was playing as an under ten but, for better or worse, it was Martin O'Neill, the manager of the team - who sent Shane Long onto the pitch as a substitute just before he scored - who was recognised. Is this not the nature of sport, that success at the highest level gets media attention and reward? We need the under tens in boxing and football because their efforts inevitably feed in to international success.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Sheedy

Absolutely, any sport starts with participation, which is clear. Participation is built and out of this, the strong ones come through. The bigger the pool at the bottom the greater the potential but 80% or 90% of the talent will operate in the participation pool. The cream will rise to the top and we need to ensure they can walk into a world-class high-performance structure. Billy Walsh oversaw that high-performance operation in boxing and what has been achieved in the ring has made us all stand up and take notice. It is phenomenal. It is unfortunate that we have ended up in here today speaking about what has happened over the past eight months. Mr. Walsh is more than a coach. He made an emotional connection with boxers and only over time will we understand whether this can be replaced.

It is great to hear that support structures are in place but he is a major loss to Irish boxing and sport.

Comment on this

I wish to make a number of observations and put some questions but I will defer to committee members first. I am conscious that we have been meeting for three and a half hours. Would the witnesses or members like to suspend for 15 minutes before concluding? We are close enough to the end but I do not want-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

Keep going.

Comment on this

Is that unanimous?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

Just keep going.

Comment on this

That is fine. I just wished to give people the opportunity. I will be able to make my observations at the end of the meeting but I will turn to members now. I ask each to remain brief. We have given everyone a fair crack of the whip and I do not want long speeches, only supplementary questions.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for this open engagement. It has been helpful, although whether it gets us to where we need to be is another question. From what we have heard over the course of today and what we have read in recent days, Mr. Walsh was head coach and the de facto high performance director even though he had never been appointed to the latter role. Something was stated that I was not aware of and that I must have missed when researching this situation, namely, that he had gone for the position and had not been successful and that someone else had been appointed. One of the witnesses indicated that the person who was successful in the competition did not take up the position because he or she was not acceptable to Mr. Walsh or the ISC. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes.

Comment on this

Who was that person? I presume that it is a matter of record.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

It was Mr. Dominic O'Rourke.

Comment on this

He did not take up the position. It could be inferred from that that Mr. Walsh felt out of sorts because he was not the chosen one. He was offered another position. This sets the context in which he began his discussions with the IABA following an offer that he would have had to consider, given that the IABA was never going to make him the high performance director. In February, he got an offer from the US. I presume that he made contact with either Mr. Christle or Mr. Carruth or both?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes.

Comment on this

What was the IABA's initial reaction?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

The initial reaction was one of "Oh my God" at the prospect of losing the head coach so close to the Rio Olympics. We immediately set about trying to secure the funds that would keep him in place. In a number of responses, I went through-----

Comment on this

Yes, we have covered that.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

-----everything that we tried to do.

Comment on this

I asked the question because I read of an indication that Mr. Christle and Mr. Carruth's initial reaction was to manage the situation and issue a joint press statement. Is that true?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

That is not my recollection of it at all.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Carruth-----

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

It was all I could think of, even if I were falling down those steep stairs. I expressed to Mr. Treacy and Mr. Mulvey that I had a deep pain in the pit of my stomach at the prospect of Mr. Walsh leaving Irish boxing. All that I wanted to do was to try to put together a package to retain him. Not for even one second did I decide to wish him all the best and say that I would see him around and not do anything to keep him. That never crossed my mind and it was never discussed. The only thing-----

Comment on this

Then, just one final-----

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

-----that was ever discussed, when it was brought to the board, was how do we retain him and minimise the knock-on effects in order that the funding would not go askew.

Comment on this

I will conclude on this point. On the premise that Billy Walsh had proven himself time out of number and was worthy of the title of high performance director, was consideration given to going with that and all that flows from the position of director, in terms of answerability and being able to decide himself? I do not wish to nit-pick but Mr. Christle made a point earlier in which he characterised the relationship between Mr. Walsh and Mr. Carruth as being on good terms on the basis that Mr. Walsh was able to admit there had been a mix-up and to get a ticket to travel wherever. It is ludicrous for someone at that level not to have such autonomy within his or her own unit or that there was even a requirement to approach Mr. Carruth to seek approval to resolve something so minor. It is clear there was conflict on what was his role and his autonomy. Without going back over it, there is voluminous coverage in various different statements he has issued and in reports that ultimately, it came down to autonomy and a sense of recognition by the Irish Amateur Boxing Association, IABA, that this man was fit to run his own unit, within certain constraints. The directors of the association of course have responsibilities and they devolve certain powers and responsibilities to a director in charge of a particular function and I would have thought that is the normal way. It then goes back to what Mr. Kirwan has said about the capacity within his contract to be changed without reference to himself. While that point has been covered, in looking at all of this, it appears to me to be a relationship that was not self-respecting. It is clear from everything Mr. Walsh has said that he did not believe he had the autonomy or the respect of the association. If anything emerges from today's meeting, it is clear to me he did not and some of what has been said by its representatives leads me to assume or believe this is the case.

As Mr. Walsh is not coming back, we are now past that. How can the IABA prove to members, who represent the taxpayer, that it will be able to move beyond this and will be able to put in place a high performance director who will have the autonomy and wherewithal to get on with the task required of that person to run the unit? The representatives from either the IABA or Sport Ireland mentioned the necessity to have a memorandum of understanding between the two bodies. Is the IABA prepared to enter into that discussion? Would the association be prepared to come back to the joint committee or to send it a communication within a month or whatever to the effect that it has signed off on such a memorandum and now knows what is meant by a high performance unit within the boxing association, what are the director's role and responsibilities and whether everybody is happy with that?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

As I outlined previously, we will have a board meeting on Wednesday and they are exactly the terms upon which we will be considering this. We do not simply wish to appoint another head coach as what we want to get is a director of high performance. If that turns out to be a significant front-line coach as well, who has all the attributes, then two positions will have been filled. In all the appointments to which Mr. Fergal Carruth alluded since I have become chairman, it has always been the case that somebody from the Irish Sports Council has sat in on the process, on the interview panel and on the drawing up of the terms of employment, the duties and so on. On the appointment of Mr. Fergal Carruth, I worked with Gary Keegan to whittle down a list from 22 to eight. We were asked to bring it down to six but we could only get it down to eight.

I absented myself from consideration of anything to do with Fergal Carruth's application simply because he had acted as secretary to the board and I had had previous contact with him, so I said I could not be involved. There was an instance in which Gary Keegan had to say the same to me about one of the applicants.

We want to move forward in a way that is not only in tandem with but in agreement with the Irish Sports Council and the Department. I hate to use the much-bandied-about word "dysfunctional," but this dysfunctional communication or understanding involving the single most successful national governing body in the history of Irish sport must be repaired. I would like to be able to say both for myself and as a legacy to whoever comes after me that I assisted in the facilitation of that. The Deputy's words are well understood and taken on board.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Allen

A comment was made about the filling of the position of chief executive officer. I was on the interview panel and I must say that I was not happy with the process. I expressed my reservations at the time. Certain changes had to be made to the process. I do not think it was as smooth and as clear as has been portrayed to the committee today.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Allen unhappy with the process or the outcome?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Allen

I was unhappy with the process. I was present at what was to be the final round of interviews and was given inadequate explanation about how the weeding-out process had taken place. Gary Keegan was present at the first meeting and was subjected to such a level of treatment that I had to intervene and say "Look, this isn't on." I would not agree with the statement that this process was clear-cut and clean.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I went through that process with Gary Keegan. I was asked by the board to whittle down 22 candidates. I suggested that it should be done with somebody from the Irish Sports Council. I know where that process happened. It was very open and clear and we got it down to eight candidates, although we could not get down any further. I said that this was the end of their involvement and my involvement in that process, so I am a bit mystified as to why this is now being called into question. I have a copy of a report drawn up by Gary Keegan and that I signed off on. We were both extremely happy with the process. I am only talking about this little part of the process - the whittling-down process. If I can dig it out, that report would put to bed any fear that there was some kind of-----

Comment on this

Could Mr. Christle make this report available? What I must say as Chairman is that there are obviously different interpretations of the process.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Allen

Information about the total number of applicants for the job, how the applicants were reduced to a certain number and how the final number was arrived at needs to be supplied.

I did not intend to speak but I cannot let that statement go that the filling of the chief executive officer's post was clean and smooth and with the impression being given to the committee that it was clear cut. In fact, we had to have a second round of interviews because a person who I deemed to be adequately suitable for the position did not even get to the final round of interviews. That is a matter of public record. It was signed off on and there was a majority decision made. Quite rightly, the Irish Sports Council went with the majority. However, I did express reservations at the time and reported back accordingly to the Irish Sports Council on the matter.

Comment on this

We will park that issue. It is clear there are different interpretations.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Senator Eamonn Coghlan will have to ask the Irish Sports Council about those ulterior motives, if they exist at all. I believe there is a history of miscommunication, which I spoke about earlier. We have inherited a legacy of that mistrust.

With regard to the statements made last week, when everyone was in shock - including us, as has been acknowledged - threats were made and language was used that put the coaches and boxers in fear as to where their money would come from. The IABA had to react to that, not only because we have had this conversation and engagement but also because the reality is that we all volunteer to try to promote sport. The sport we are passionate about is boxing. We must keep asking ourselves, as I do, what is in the best interest of the boxers themselves. The ones on the line are the ones who have already qualified for the Olympic Games and the others in the elite programme who are on the way to qualification events in 2016. We must ask whether it in their interest that we try to draw a line under this and get rid of the history of the non-filling of Gary Keegan's role as director of the high performance unit from 2008 to the present day. I have not had the discussion with the board of directors but I understand that is the line we will be moving towards. We have to put together a plan of action that will satisfy not only the boxers but also, and ultimately, the people of Ireland who give the money to the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport and the Irish Sports Council. In my view, they are the most important stakeholders in this after the athletes and coaches in the high performance category and all the volunteers and boxers underneath them. We cannot concentrate on one and not on the other.

Is it in our interest to have some sort of battle between the IABA and the Irish Sports Council or any other funding organisation? I cannot see that it is. Lessons have to be learned by all sides, including the IABA and the Irish Sports Council. I look forward to engaging in dialogue with both the Minister and Irish Sports Council on constructing a pathway that will mean the work towards Rio de Janeiro will not be as affected as it might be by the departure of our head coach.

Comment on this

From talking to people involved in boxing, I have learned the consensus seems to be that, for the next 37 weeks leading up to the Olympic Games in Rio de Janeiro, what has occurred will not have the impact that some people might believe it will have. It is the period after the Olympic Games that many people are worried about.

Obviously, the delegates have been involved in boxing all their lives. Did Mr. Keegan resign? This has not been answered. He was refused access to the boxers by the IABA. If I am involved the GAA, I know what is going down in every county. What is the story? The story proceeds from Mr. Keegan to Mr. O'Rourke. Did Mr. O'Rourke get a job?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes.

Comment on this

What was his job when he did not get the other one?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

That is already on the record, because I said it earlier.

Comment on this

We talked about Mr. O'Rourke being appointed for a job and that some body did not like him, be it the Irish Sports Council or another body.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

His title was changed.

Comment on this

So he got a different job?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

Yes. He is the director-----

Comment on this

I know he has left. What I am saying is that when he did not get one job, he was given another one.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

His title was changed from the director of boxing development.

Comment on this

That was handy enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

He got a four-year contract and at the end of those four years, which was in July last year, the funding ceased and that was the end of his job.

Comment on this

I want to be clear on an issue. I have been led to believe Mr. Walsh contacted Mr. Carruth on several occasions to arrange meetings. Perhaps something will emerge within the next week to prove what I am saying, be it a text or an e-mail. Did Mr. Carruth refuse or cancel any meeting with Billy Walsh in the past three months? Is he putting on record that he did not do so?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

To the best of my knowledge.

Comment on this

I am asking Mr. Carruth a straight question.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

I am giving the Deputy a straight answer - to the best of my knowledge.

Comment on this

"To the best of my knowledge" is not a straight answer. Mr. Carruth would know whether he received an e-mail or a text, whether he told someone he could meet and whether he met that person. It is a simple question to ask.

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

"To the best of my knowledge" is all I can say at this particular juncture. I would have to go through my records but to the best of my knowledge, I do not remember cancelling any meetings with Billy Walsh. I am being as upfront and open as possible.

Comment on this

If something crops up in the next week, would it make Mr. Carruth's position untenable? If information were to emerge that Mr. Carruth had refused or cancelled a meeting, would it put him in a difficult position?

Comment on this
Mr. Fergal Carruth

Absolutely not.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

The Deputy's question is not acceptable. Mr. Carruth has answered the question on a number of occasions.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzmaurice put a question and, as far as I am concerned, he was given an answer.

Comment on this

The boxing world and the Irish Sports Council have known since 2008 what has been going on. Mr. Allen, in his statement, dropped another bombshell. We do not know what sort of in-house arrangements are in place regarding appointments. Sport Ireland is the diesel in the engine that keeps the car rolling because it has the money. Why did someone not clean up this fiasco in the past eight years? Many people have many questions to answer for this hoodwink job or whatever it is because we do not know what is going on. At this stage, we have lost a person who everyone, on both sides of the argument, recognises was top class. Why did someone not foresee this development? Mr. Treacy has been in his position for a good few years and is experienced at his game. Why did someone not move in and turn off the flow of diesel? That is the only way something could have been sorted out.

Comment on this

The medals kept coming.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

In 2008, Gary Keegan came over and worked for the Irish Institute of Sport. We put our foot down and stepped in when a candidate was picked who we believed did not have the ability to do the job of director of high performance. I am not quite sure what the circumstances were in terms of what offer was made to the candidate in question but he went off and did another job. Billy Walsh essentially did two jobs. In 2012, we were told that Mr. Walsh's terms were to be enhanced and I believe he was promised enhanced terms. I also believe, however, that his terms were never enhanced. It must be remembered that Sport Ireland is not the employer.

Comment on this

It is the diesel.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We are the diesel. We have a high performance programme that is winning medals and one does not want to cut off the diesel to it. Therefore, we were caught in a bit of a bind. We worked closely with Billy Walsh to ensure the boxers were well catered for and we increased the money for high performance, where it was needed. A new board was also coming in and we placed our faith in it.

We were delighted to see a new chairman coming in.

Our reaction last week was not over the top; rather, we put our foot down. We could not take any more. We were extremely disappointed.

Comment on this

Had Mr. Allen informed Mr. Treacy of what he said here today before this?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

It was reported to our board.

Comment on this

Was anything done about it or was anything said?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Allen

Let me clarify the situation. I was unhappy with the procedures. We accepted the majority decision of the interview panel and that is as far as we could go without interfering in the internal workings of the association. I was extremely unhappy about what I saw there. It is no exaggeration to say that I experienced rough words being spoken to Gary Keegan. I was challenged about whether I was calling people dishonest when I questioned certain things. As I said, I was unhappy about a very experienced administrator not even getting the benefit of an interview. I insisted that the person be interviewed but, naturally enough, the person did not get the job.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I want to add one last thing. We are very reluctant to issue threats of withholding funding. We saw some of the reaction this week, in terms of the misinterpretation of the chairman's comments. We do not threaten organisations; rather, we try to work with them. This has brought the situation to a head.

Comment on this

I return to my original question. Can the public who fund the organisation have confidence in it, given everything we have heard from Mr . Allen and Mr. Treacy, what we heard Mr. Mulvey say last week, everything that has happened with Billy Walsh, the reports about Mr. Keegan and as far back as Mr. Cruz?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I believe the answer is "Yes". How can I convince the committee or the Deputy that is the case? Throughout the process with Billy Walsh I believe I can stand over my efforts and those of the board of directors to try to retain the services of Billy Walsh. The only way to demonstrate that those efforts were real and thorough is for an independent review on this whole process, from February to today, to be carried out. I would welcome that because of the words of the chairman and chief executive of the Irish Sports Council in regard to the competence or efforts of the board of directors, directed at me as chairman of the board of directors.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Christle concerned about their concern?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

This is something that could only be established by an independent inquiry into the process.

Comment on this

As a matter of public confidence, I refer to the CEO being asked by my colleague whether a meeting was refused or cancelled. I acknowledge that Mr. Carruth is a busy man as the CEO, but surely someone of the stature of Billy Walsh asking for a meeting to be arranged would be acknowledged. Can he give a "Yes" or "No" answer to that question? I would like something more substantive than "To the best of my recollection".

Comment on this

Mr. Carruth says that to his knowledge he did not refuse a meeting. If some new information comes to hand - perhaps that he inadvertently refused a meeting or did not contact Billy Walsh - would he please supply that? We have to accept that for now, and if something else shows up we will have more questions.

Comment on this

It would be extraordinary for him not to remember such an incident.

Comment on this

The question has been answered, and if we get some different information we will certainly follow it up.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Christle for his answer. Would the four members of the IABA agree that the public can have confidence in the IABA?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Ryan

Absolutely, yes.

Comment on this

I am glad that Mr. Treacy referred to the overt threats from the IABA, because the threat of the withdrawal of funding has come up time and again in this discussion. I was present at the meeting last week with Mr. Mulvey, and Mr. Treacy is perfectly right. I left here totally convinced that there was no threat to the funding of the IABA’s boxers. What Mr. Mulvey explored - he has answered already on this and can answer again - was the possibility, because of all that had happened following Billy Walsh’s departure, of adopting the United Kingdom model of funding for the high performance unit, which is a separate issue. That was not a question of withdrawal of funding but of perhaps redirecting funding.

I can understand his frustration, which he made quite plain, considering Mr. Christle's statement last week. According to Malachy Clerkin in The Irish Times, “They are standing up for boxing against a meddling Government agency, one they described yesterday as having [and this is a quote from Mr. Christle] ‘absolutely no experience, knowledge or credibility in this sport’.” If I was sitting on the Irish Sports Council I would have had a much less restrained response than Mr. Mulvey’s to that sort of allegation. That was an outrageous thing to say. I appreciate that people said things in the heat of the moment, but in the context of what Mr. Christle said, and what Mr. Mulvey said about the possibility of exploring the issue, I can understand Mr. Mulvey's point of view. I left here under no illusion but that there was no threat to withdraw funding. I raise this only because Mr. Christle said it sent shock waves through the organisation, from coaches down to boxers. It was good and proper to clarify that here again.

Can Mr. Christle clarify for me whether at the meeting on 14 September it was the Minister of State, Deputy Ring, who proposed the financial package and the remuneration to Mr. Christle, or was it the Irish Sports Council?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

The Minister of State.

Comment on this

I find that surprising because I would have thought it was the purview of the Irish Sports Council to decide on funding. The money comes from the taxpayer to the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport. There is then a legal process under which the council operates in the disbursal of those funds. I find it a little surprising that the Minister of State intervened and was proposing a financial package, which seemed to raise questions about his relationship with the council. That is a separate issue. I just wanted to clarify that it was not the Irish Sports Council that put forward the proposal but the Minister of State.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

It did agree with it.

Comment on this

I am not saying it did not. What else would it do? It would, would it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

We all agreed with it because we wanted to get it done.

Comment on this

In terms of what has been outlined about the statutory obligations and responsibilities of the Irish Sports Council, I would have thought that was an issue for it to put forward in its dialogue with the IABA as a governing body, rather than for the Minister of State to intervene at that point.

Comment on this

The Minister of State was trying to be of assistance.

Comment on this

We all agree that the Minister of State, Deputy Ring, has given an inordinate amount of time to trying to resolve this issue. I compliment him on that. The role of the Irish Sports Council and how it decides on its funding under its statutory obligations might arise in the future. That is why I raised it.

My next question relates specifically to the meeting of 14 September and what happened afterwards.

I am sorry, but I ask the Chairman to just bear with me for one moment because I want to find the particular reference made to it by Billy Walsh. He said the new fixed contract would give him very few legal protections. I think Senator Sean D. Barrett referred to this. Mr. Walsh said he was under significant time pressures to sign. Instead of rejecting the contract outright and walking away, he said:

I went through the proposed fixed-term contract with my solicitor and a HR professional and identified up to 60 changes that were required to make this a fair and acceptable contract document for me. We submitted these changes through my solicitor to the IABA solicitor on 21 September and no response came from the IABA until 8 October. From 21 September to 8 October it seemed that they were deliberately dragging this out.

He went on to say: "The IABA had merely agreed to a few stylistic changes and one or two elements of limited substance." I am going to direct the question to Mr. Kirwan because he seems to have come across as the person who was directly involved in the issue of contract employment law. Does he have any response?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

No, that is not quite correct. The organisation has its own independent solicitors who, in fact, were dealing with the matter. The impression the Chairman gave is that because of my experience in the area, obviously I was asked for an input.

Comment on this

I am glad that Mr. Kirwan has clarified that matter. Would he have a response to Billy Walsh's statement on the manner in which the contract was dealt with?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

Yes. I understand from our own solicitor that the timelines involved resulted in our solicitor taking annual leave and Billy Walsh's appointed solicitor also taking annual leave, as well as the difficulty of clearly getting instructions from Billy Walsh when he was, in fact, head coach in Doha with our team during that period.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Kirwan surprised that there were 60 amendments to the original contract on which hands were supposed to have been shook?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

No. What I would say - I would say this against my own profession - is that once lawyers get involved. there tends to be-----

Comment on this

Yes, I was thinking the same.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

There you go. I am open to correction, but I think there were approximately 60 amendments. Incidentally, they were referenced by Billy Walsh's solicitors as suggestions. They were not red flag items; they were suggested for consideration. That was the terminology used, if the Senator really wants me to be specific.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

I was not directly involved, but I believe over 30 of the amendments were, in fact, agreed to. It was at that point, as a solicitor, that one would usually expect the other solicitor to come back and look for a few more, but that did not happen. The next communication we actually received on was the resignation.

Comment on this

I asked the question to get this response and have clarity.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

I am giving it to the Senator.

Comment on this

Therefore, there was no ulterior motive in it at all-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

Absolutely none.

Comment on this

-----because it was contained in a statement and seemed to have been a breaking point for him.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

I am giving it to the Senator as clearly as I can, as I understand the facts.

Comment on this

Does Senator Sean D. Barrett wish to come back in?

Comment on this

I hope the parties, in paying tribute on the loss of a great servant to Irish sport, will belatedly reach agreement. The other thought I had was that over the weekend the Irish hockey team qualified for the Olympic games for the first time since 1908. I hope what we have heard in the past four hours will not set a precedent. It has been very sad to listen to it.

Comment on this

I think everybody will agree - I meant to say this earlier - that I have huge admiration for the manner in which the IABA has maintained unity in boxing on this island and particularly how it has managed time and again to cross the sectarian divide in the North. I only wish the soccer authorities would take a leaf out of its book. It has done a tremendous service for the country in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Christle

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

I will draw our proceedings to a conclusion with a couple of final questions and observations. Having listened to the discussion for the past four hours, I have a simple question. What would both organisations do differently in the future than they did not do in the past few weeks and months?

To tidy up, I have another question, but perhaps the answer was given earlier. I understand the administrative assistant of Billy Walsh was moved or changed. Why did that happen? That question is for the IABA.

To be as positive as I can - this is an observation, having listened to the discussion for the past four hours - the financial issues were addressed by the IABA in terms of the knock-on effects of a new contract and also by the Irish Sports Council.

Financial issues were addressed by the IABA, in the sense of the knock-on effect from a new contract and all of that, and were then addressed by Sport Ireland. That would be my observation. I am still puzzled by two things, the first of which is the contract. I am not a legal expert and I know Mr. Kirwan answered my previous question. I am puzzled that one side can change a contract but the other side cannot do so unless it breaks the terms or walks away from it. I may be making a wrong interpretation. I refer to term "the reasonable changes without ..." in this regard. The second thing that puzzles me is the requirement for Billy Walsh to have written permission. I want to move away from all the legal stuff for a moment. Mr. Pat Ryan, manager of the Portlaoise team, is present. I congratulate him on his win at the weekend. If he, as a team manager, had to get written permission to give interviews to the Laois media after a game, how would he feel about that? As somebody who has been involved in this situation along with Mr. Liam Sheedy and others, forgetting about the finance for a second, I would not be five minutes in the job if those conditions were imposed. While the IABA wanted to do everything to keep Mr. Walsh, I do not believe the non-financial conditions were credible. That is my genuine observation. I respect if the IABA has a different view on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

The Chairman is perfectly entitled to his observation. However, we are reluctant to draw analogies to other sports. When addressing the Oireachtas committee, I believe the chairman of Sport Ireland drew the analogy to Joe Schmidt and rugby. I could draw the analogy to rugby and the incident with Matt O'Connor, the former Leinster coach. I am not privy to the exact clauses in his contract but we know that when he complained about the condition of his players on returning from international duty and their lack of availability for Leinster matches, he was, in fact, called in to a disciplinary hearing by the IRFU, as I understand it. We all know what happened to Matt O'Connor.

Comment on this

Yes, I agree with Mr. Kirwan in the sense that if a coach says something derogatory of the people who employ him, obviously he must live with the consequences. However, we are talking about preventing him from actually speaking. He realises that he deals with the victory or the defeat that happens and if he deals with something else or goes outside his remit then he is answerable, of course, to his board or whatever.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

I think the answer to the Chairman's question is that it was included in his contract long before this board was involved; it was in his original contract back in 2003, as I understand it. If we consider the high profile he has had in the media, clearly we were not restricting him.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciaran Kirwan

That is the reality and one has to deal in realities.

Comment on this

There is only one reality; Billy Walsh is gone. That is the sad reality.

Comment on this

I wish finish on a positive note. I welcome the observations of the IABA and Sport Ireland to the effect that they want to get this matter resolved and ensure that nothing similar ever happens again and also that the preparation for Rio and other boxing tournaments will not be affected. It is incumbent on both organisations to deal with the issues rather than the personalities. I hope we might be here for a review after the Rio Olympic Games and that we will be discussing our athletes winning another bucket-load of medals.

I thank Mr. Joe Christle, Mr. Pat Ryan, Mr. Fergal Carruth, Mr. Ciaran Kirwan, Mr. John Treacy, Mr. Kieran Mulvey, Mr. Liam Sheedy and Mr. Bernard Allen for engaging with us today. It was important for the public that the issues raised in the media in recent weeks were articulated here. This has been a useful exercise. As there is no other business, I hereby adjourn the meeting.

Comment on this