We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport, Tourism and Sport

Fáilte Ireland, Shannon Group and Port of Waterford Company: Chairpersons Designate

Contributions 118–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am talking about capital.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We cannot do that.

On the Deputy's point about Coillte, we now have a strategic partnership with that company. Our biggest capital investment over the next three or fours years will be a development with Coillte - our first - near its headquarters in Rathdrum, which is a phenomenal development. We talked about Lough Key, which was given grant aid in 2012.

Comment on this

That is the development to which I was referring.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We are happy to look at Lough Key again when we get a project proposal from Coillte on it.

Comment on this

I call it Forest Park, but I was referring to Lough Key. What prohibits Fáilte Ireland from assisting or resourcing capital expenditure for accommodation providers?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

In the private sector?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I suspect it is state aid rules.

Comment on this

It could also be the public sector. Let us say-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Is the Deputy referring to a publicly-owned hotel?

Comment on this

Perhaps a community might get together and decide to develop 50 glamping pads in a field in Manorhamilton because they do not have a hotel. Could Fáilte Ireland support such a project with capital investment?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I do not know the answer to that. Philosophically, we want to assist anything that helps tourism, provided it fits into what customers want and what they are telling us they want.

I will give the Deputy an example. We have deliberately stopped supporting distilleries because we believe there are enough of them. We researched the experience of distilleries in Scotland and found that only the top five or six were successful. We have an input in terms of our research as to what can help people locally. If finance is an issue, if we are allowed to do it and if it falls within our definition, we are very happy to look at it. There is no religious objection to this.

Comment on this

I respectfully ask that Fáilte Ireland examine this on the accommodation side because by Mr. Cawley's own admission there are capacity issues in some parts of the country and we want weddings, not domestic tours.

I am nearly there, I promise the Chairman. The tourism strategy 2019-24 does not include one mention of the word "China". With 130 million journeys and €277 billion in expenditure per annum, the Chinese are by a distant mile the biggest spenders, so it is unusual that we would develop a five-year strategy without a single mention of the biggest market in the world.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Numerically, it is not in our top ten markets at the moment, but the Deputy is right that China is the biggest single market in the world. Before he came in, I talked about one of the key projects we have just finished and will be developing further, namely, our China Ready programme. We have 130,000 visitors from China or of Chinese origin into the country, as the Deputy mentioned, and-----

Comment on this

I do not think the figure is that high.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I think it is.

Comment on this

I was referring to 130 million journeys from Chinese people. What is the actual number of Chinese visitors?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I believe it is 130,000 people visiting the country.

Comment on this

Is it that many?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

That is the figure for visits from people originating in China and Chinese people living in Europe. There are customer expectations and personal interactions here which are different from the European or American experience. The Chinese definition of customer service is different from ours. We have carried out a very elaborate training programme with key hotels and restaurants right across the country-----

Comment on this

How many staff-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

-----and then gone out with programmes to Chinese tour operators. We have been quite successful in this, assisted by the direct flights from China and Hong Kong, and we hope it will develop. The omission of the Chinese market from the strategy is therefore not reflective of the work on the ground.

Comment on this

We will not know unless reference is made to the Chinese market in the strategy. If we have a website not prioritising domestic tourism-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I am not responsible for the Department's website.

Comment on this

That is the issue, is it not? We are all inside our own little pigeonholes and it is a case of "this is their job and that is their job".

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

No.

Comment on this

Perhaps that is one of the problems. We need a little more integration.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I have more important things to do in Fáilte Ireland than to correct the Department's website.

Comment on this

There was a peculiar line in one of the publications I read. It must have been the strategy. It stated that the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport "will report to the tourism leadership group".

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

That is true.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Cawley tell us, for the benefit of the committee, who is on the tourism leadership group?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I am not on it.

Comment on this

I am only interested in who is on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

The chief executive of Fáilte Ireland, the chief executive of Tourism Ireland, the Minister, the Secretary General of the Department and the assistant secretary with responsibility for tourism. They are the core of the group. There may be one or two other people-----

Comment on this

The Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport will report to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I did not know that either.

Comment on this

It sounds a bit strange.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

It does.

Comment on this

It is like saying, "Fáilte Ireland will report to Fáilte Ireland north west", is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

One could characterise it like that.

Comment on this

Absolutely. I just feel like there are gaps in the integration of our approach. I started by praising Fáilte Ireland and all the great work being done.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I thank the Deputy. It is all down to the staff in Fáilte Ireland.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about that. Going back to the issue of China for a second, how many permanent staff speak Cantonese or Mandarin?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Permanent staff in Fáilte Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

None that I am aware of.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Cawley know how many there are in Tourism Ireland? I know it is not his-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

No, I do not know.

Comment on this

What about the office in Beijing? That is an office of Tourism Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We do not have an office in Beijing.

Comment on this

No. Tourism Ireland does.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Yes, I believe so.

Comment on this

There are 12 people in the office. Presumably, they all speak Cantonese or Mandarin.

Regarding Fáilte Ireland's China Ready programme, which we spoke about in the Dáil just a moment ago, is funding available in support of hoteliers and other accommodation providers-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Let me finish the question. Is funding available in support of them to learn Cantonese and Mandarin?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Yes.

Comment on this

How many are doing so?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I do not know the answer to that.

Comment on this

It would be good to know the answers to these questions.

I will move on. I really am getting near the end - I promise. Is Mr. Cawley familiar with the term "place bonding"?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Not particularly, no.

Comment on this

From my research on international tourism, it seems to be among the new buzz terms. Place bonding is what leads to repeat tourism. Our rate of repeat tourism is 31%, apparently. What are we doing to increase this? In Britain the rate of repeat tourism is 63%. What we have when people exit the country is a satisfaction questionnaire, which asks them whether they had a nice time, where they stayed, how they got on and so on. At the end of a holiday, unless they have had a really bad meal or stayed in a really bad hotel, people are in reasonably good form so will say everything was tickety-boo and that they had a tip-top holiday in Galway, Kerry, Sligo or wherever they were. I think the satisfaction rating is a flawed metric and that we need to take a different approach to ascertain and build place bonding because there is no question but that we can build our repeat tourism rate. We will never get everybody back because some people want to travel the world and they go everywhere once. Other people have place bonds and will say, for example, "I really loved visiting Senator Ó Céidigh in Connemara and I am going to go there every year because I love the people and they know when my birthday is and what I like to drink and eat and so on." There is certainly scope to build our rate up to 40% or 45%. What are we doing about that?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We want to give people the best experience possible. We emphasise retention of business to a lot to people. For example, one of the things we emphasise to all the stakeholders in the tourism industry is responding to ratings on TripAdvisor, booking.com and other rating websites. They are a key not only to getting visitors back but also to reaching the people who read and use those websites. They are highly instructive and highly informative to people travelling. Fortunately or unfortunately, we have to work them - that is the way the world is - and the communication there through social media is very important. I am surprised by the Deputy's numbers because my information is that only 14% of British people have ever visited this country. I see that as an opportunity. Those who come, however, come frequently. I am very familiar with west Cork, for example, and the south. There is huge repeat business there from people from Britain in particular, probably less so from Americans because it is such a big journey and a once in a lifetime experience for them. I am therefore surprised by the Deputy's figure, but the whole experience-----

Comment on this

I assure Mr. Cawley that my figures are accurate. I asked Fáilte Ireland and Tourism Ireland for them. They were derived from international research, and I can provide them to him.

I promise I am concluding. This is my very last question. Is there an opportunity to build place bonding and repeat visiting through the excellent work Fáilte Ireland does? However, is it trying to do a little too much? Are we missing out on having a local structure that reflects the umbrella branding and the overall mission of Fáilte Ireland and Tourism Ireland? Perhaps, supported by local authorities and industry, we could have local bodies like, going back to the 1960s, the regional tourism organisations envisaged by Lemass, which evolved into Bord Fáilte and Fáilte Ireland but have broadly disappeared apart from private community-run groups, which are very successful in some areas but not in others. Do we need a structure around that which could enhance it?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

My preference would be to see more community involvement rather than institutionalising anything. I was in the west last week and we had feedback from community involvement on the Aran Islands and out in Clifden. Our visit coincided with an arts festival in Clifden. There was incredible activity, all run voluntarily. One could put a bureaucracy down on top of that and kill it, in my view. We will work with any community, whether on a voluntary or institutional basis. We do not discriminate. However, it is much better if the community owns the undertaking. The Gathering, for example, was essentially community-based and rose up from the bottom. If people own the project, it gives the customer and the visitor a much better experience.

Comment on this

I wish all three witnesses the very best and thank them for their time and their answers to the questioning. I apologise to my good friend here, Senator Kieran O'Donnell, who has been waiting for some time.

Comment on this

I acknowledge that our guests have been here for two hours.

Comment on this

I will just come in for a quick minute.

Comment on this

Please do. From now on, members are to avoid repetition in their questions.

Comment on this

I welcome all the witnesses. I would like to put a specific question to Ms Hynes. The script she furnished to the joint committee refers to the impact that a hard Brexit would have and to European hub connectivity for Shannon Airport. I ask her to elaborate on those matters. Along with members of the Shannon Group's management team, I met the Minister, Deputy Ross, on 6 February last. I understand that at the end of March, the Shannon Group sent a submission into the Department about the establishment of European hub connectivity. How has that been received? The 2014 guidelines on state aid to airports and airlines facilitate the State in being able to support start-up aids to airlines where they are of common interest. It requires airlines to establish that they will be viable within three years, will increase the mobility of EU citizens and will increase the connectivity of the regions by opening new routes. I am mentioning this in the context of Brexit. I ask Ms Hynes to update me on this matter. Will she indicate when she expects the Shannon Group to have a new CEO in place?

I ask Mr. Cawley, in light of his knowledge of the airline industry, to set out how important he considers it to be that Shannon Airport has European hub connectivity. It is excellent that we have connectivity with Heathrow Airport. We had connectivity with Charles de Gaulle Airport for a brief period when Aer Lingus pulled out of Heathrow Airport. When the Heathrow Airport service came back, the Charles de Gaulle Airport service ceased. I believe Shannon Airport is absolutely critical for our region. For the last year, I have been pushing the issue of the establishment of European hub connectivity. I appreciate that a submission has been placed before the Department. What is the current position in that regard? Having studied the European guidelines, it appears to me that the mobility of EU citizens and the connectivity of the regions can be increased by opening new routes, in line with section 5.2 of the 2014 guidelines under the heading of "Start-up aid to airlines". I think the State would be able to facilitate route support through public funds over a three-year period on the basis that these routes would not be opened without such support and that such routes would be viable within three years.

More particularly, Limerick and the mid-west region has a disproportionately large number of multinational industries. Tourism is vital to the region. We must have that connectivity. For me, anything to do with Brexit contingencies must involve Shannon Airport having major European hub connectivity. Frankfurt Airport is being mentioned, but I am not particularly precious about the exact location as long as there is connectivity. I ask Ms Hynes and Mr. Cawley to give us a quick update in this regard.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

I completely agree with the Senator that Shannon Airport is absolutely vital. Connectivity is vital. It is vital to have an additional connection. We have a connection with Heathrow Airport at the moment. The question of Brexit comes into play in that context. We have worked for quite some time to try to achieve connectivity with locations like Frankfurt, Amsterdam and Paris. That takes time, effort and funding. Our submission is still before the Department. That is the update. We are still waiting. We have lobbied hard.

Comment on this

Does Ms Hynes believe there is scope under the 2014 guidelines, as communicated from the Commission, which refer to airports with fewer than 3 million passengers?

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

Yes.

Comment on this

Does she agree that the document in question could apply to Shannon Airport?

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

Yes. It is possible to do it from a state aid perspective under the original airports programme, as long as the passenger numbers are between 1 million and 3 million. We have been lobbying under that heading. We are positively awaiting a response.

Comment on this

If such approval is forthcoming, does Ms Hynes believe that Shannon Airport will get an airline to fly-----

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

Yes, I do.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

Very much so. We have made a very strong case. We have pushed it and we will continue to push it. We are waiting for the answer.

Comment on this

Obviously-----

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

It would make a huge difference. It would be a game-changer for us. Who knows what is going to happen with Brexit? We will need another European hub in any event, Brexit or no Brexit. If Brexit happens, absolutely we will need a European hub.

Comment on this

Why have airlines been reluctant to take up this route? Why am I asking for Government support? I believe state support can be provided on the basis that the airport has less than 3 million passengers. That section of the document is clear. In the context of Brexit, we are seeking to increase the mobility of EU citizens and the connectivity of the regions by opening new routes. Mr. Cawley might want to respond to this question as well. Why are airlines not flying to European hubs from Shannon Airport? In light of the presence of a large multinational sector in the region, given that Shannon Airport offers access to the whole western seaboard and considering that there is excess capacity at the airport, why are we not seeing it?

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

I think it is tough. As I said, there is tough competition from Dublin Airport. It is an easier sell for Dublin Airport to get a route into a European hub than it is for Shannon Airport. In the case of Shannon Airport, the viability of the route for the first three years has to be proven, which necessitates a serious marketing fund. In the case of Dublin Airport, it is a much more straightforward proposition. I agree with the Deputy that it is a tough space.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I am not an expert on airline hubs. The basic reason airlines do not start routes is that they would lose money on those routes. Money can fix that. The commitment involved in giving an expensive slot to a regional airport like Shannon Airport, as Lufthansa might do in the case of Frankfurt Airport, is an opportunity cost for those involved. When they look around Europe, they see the potential of linking in with a Polish city, a Swedish city or another city of 500,000 people and attracting the associated long-haul business traffic which would pay them money. Frankly, that is a big gap for an airport like Shannon Airport to bridge when promises are being made in respect of passengers. I am not sure where the foreign multinationals in Shannon want to fly to. The reality is that not enough of them have shown up to provide a level of demand for flights that would justify these increased services. I am sure the Shannon Group has prepared a proposition for the various airlines to which it talks. I do not know.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

We have huge support.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We are not in that business in Ryanair. We never have been.

Comment on this

There is huge support.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

There is huge support in the region.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Yes. The customers have to show up too.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

All of the stakeholders-----

Comment on this

There is a demand from the multinational sector.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

There is.

Comment on this

They are asking for it.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

They are.

Comment on this

I asked when the CEO will be put in place.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

They can fly to New York and go on from there. That is another hub. I do not know. I am not an expert on it.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

There is huge demand in the region from business and everybody else for that additional hub. I think it would be very successful.

Comment on this

When will the CEO be in place?

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

The CEO process is under way. I expect that a decision will possibly be made during this month. Then it will depend on notice periods and so on. A decision will certainly be made on foot of the successful campaign that has been run.

Comment on this

I ask Senator Ó Céidigh to remember that our guests have been here for over two hours.

Comment on this

This is the last time I will let someone who is not a member of the committee speak before me. Sin scéal eile. All of the witnesses are welcome. I congratulate Mr. Whelan on the work he has been doing. He mentioned that the company recently paid its first dividend in 200 years to the State, which is some feat. He spoke about the reduction in the pension liability as well. I wish the company continued success. Obviously, it is being managed very well.

Comment on this
Mr. Des Whelan

It is very little to do with me, to be fair.

Comment on this
Mr. Des Whelan

The credit must go to the executive and the staff.

Comment on this

I remind Mr. Cawley that I sat on the board of Fáilte Ireland for a number of years. I was very encouraged to hear him speaking about the staff. I say "well done" to him in that regard. The experience I had in Fáilte Ireland was that the staff are second to none. I was blown away by their passion and commitment.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Yes.

Comment on this

They go over and above the call of duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I have a couple of questions for Ms Hynes. Shannon Airport is my favourite airport, particularly for its ease of access. I can get in and out very quickly. We have been discussing why airlines may or may not use the airport. As Mr. Cawley rightly said, it comes down to economics. If airlines make money by serving a particular airport, they will go there. If they make more money elsewhere, they will go there. An airport cannot be moved. It is a fixed space. One can move an aeroplane wherever one wants, whereas an airport is a fixed, structured asset that cannot be moved around. That is the difficulty for those who manage airports. They depend on airlines and they are in competition with other airports for those airlines. I assure the committee that aviation is a serious and tough business to struggle in. That was my experience, although it might not be the case with Ryanair. If one makes €1 of profit per passenger, one is in seventh heaven.

It is about scalability, as well as everything else.

I have a couple of questions which are mainly for Mr. Cawley. I authored a Seanad public consultation report which represented approximately two years' work. It is the only comprehensive report which has ever been produced on SMEs in Ireland. It looks at industries on an industry basis and, separately, on a geographic basis. It is very interesting. We had engagement, for example, with Fáilte Ireland and many others. We engaged in public consultation and representations were made. In the hospitality and tourism sector key successes were mentioned. It employs approximately 280,000 people and 68% of the jobs are outside Dublin, which is of great importance. Of the people in question, 180,000 are engaged in the accommodation and food sectors, while 89% of the businesses involved are SMEs. That is from where I am coming on SMEs. I am going to connect it with Shannon Airport in a second. For some regions, tourism is the most significant industry. It helps to support local authority incomes. For example, if Donegal County Council did not have its current level of income from tourism, it would not be able to provide the community in the county the infrastructure it has provided. When I spoke to the county manager, he affirmed this. The tourism industry contributed approximately €2 billion to the economy in 2017.

I would like to hear Mr. Cawley's views on the key challenges which include currency volatility and the overuse of Dublin as a tourism destination. What can Fáilte Ireland to do with Ms Hynes and those like her in that regard? There were 32 million passengers at Dublin Airport in 2019, which is 18 to 20 times the number using Cork Airport, the second largest airport in the State which is in Mr. Cawley's home town.

Rising business costs are also a challenge, particularly when the unemployment rate is 4.5%. Issues in finding professional chefs and so on are mentioned. What is Mr. Cawley's experience in that regard?

Another issue is one that is dear to my heart, namely, the myriad agencies and supports in place for tourism. We are all over the place. Local authorities are involved in tourism. In my area we have Údarás na Gaeltachta. One has LEADER programmes and LEO involvement in tourism. There are approximately 12 to 14 organisations in the west with some involvement in tourism. From a policy perspective, it would be useful to co-ordinate that involvement in a structured way through Fáilte Ireland. What is Mr. Cawley's view? The work should not be splintered, with things getting lost all over the place. In former days one had one aeroplane type and a pilot could fly any aeroplane. There was a clear and simple model. It appears that in tourism, however, we are scattered all over the place, while people seek to hold onto their own peg for a sense of control and so on. I would value Mr. Cawley's opinion and like the Minister to listen when I say the activity should be co-ordinated centrally through Fáilte Ireland.

The report contains a number of recommendations, including on China. It also refers to SMEs. The Chairman is welcome to a copy of the report, albeit he probably has one. I have met perhaps 30 organisations in the past six months to discuss it, including IBEC, ISME, the Small Firms Association and various people involved in tourism. It includes statistics for the percentages of SMEs engaged in tourism. In County Kerry, for example, 20% of all SMEs are involved in tourism. One might not be surprised by that figure, but if something hits the fan in tourism, SMEs in County Kerry will be decimated. In Dublin, however, the figure is less than one third of that figure, at 7% of SMEs being involved in tourism. Therefore, the regional nature of tourism is critical. That is why Cork Airport, Waterford Airport and Shannon Airport have a critical role to play. We have to have the tourism industry and those airports on the same page. We also need strong and focused Government policy on facilitating regional development. It is not in Dublin's interests that the airport has 32 million passengers. It is in its interests that people can flow and find accommodation or housing reasonably easily. It is in the interests of the regions that there be some balance.

I ask Ms Hynes to set out some of the key challenges she will face in the coming three years. She has done an excellent job at Shannon Airport where capital expenditure was a significant issue. There was a problem with the runway which was uneven and cracked. I am particularly interested in her vision for non-core airline work in and around Shannon Airport. She has done some work on that issue. It would be useful if the committee could hear about the latest developments as to where she is with that strategy.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

I agree with the Senator on the co-ordination of a number of agencies. Fáilte Ireland has always and continues to carry out constant research on customers. With Tourism Ireland approximately four or five years ago we co-sponsored some major research work which we are constantly updating. It tells us what domestic and overseas customers want. We do not necessarily need to control funds locally, but we would like to advise people on spending, whether it is under the LEADER programme or by some other organisation. Money can be misspent and have a detrimental, rather than a motivating, impact. One of the good news stories on that front relates to the Department of Rural and Community Development under the Minister, Deputy Ring. We have been embedded in it to advise the Department on the importance of tourism to the regions, to which the Minister is completely wedded. He was previously a Minister of State at the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport under two Ministers and is personally very interested in the development of tourism. I had a meeting with him on the issue this morning. We are, therefore, central to how the Department disposes of its funds, the policy it applies and the emphasis of spending. We leverage the large amount of funding of the Department, which is a multiple of the funding available to us. We are designing the approach specifically to have the best impact in the regions. Therefore, I agree with the Senator on the need for co-ordination and to have myriad agencies brought together with one focus. Let them support individual projects and get the credit for it, but let us also pull in the same direction.

The Senator is absolutely right on the question of SMEs. A lot of tourism businesses, in particular, activity centres, are run by people whose hobbies, in essence, got out of hand and developed into businesses. Their enthusiasm for their customers is infectious and their expertise, important. The major decision for these businesses is employing the next person. It is a major decision. Thankfully, many of them are successful and grow to having five, ten and 20 employees. However, they do not have the range of expertise they require across marketing, revenue management, finance and communications, including in the area of social media. One bad rating can kill a business. Therefore, we teach them how to respond to TripAdvisor and Booking.com ratings and support them in other ways. More than 25,000 people attended Fáilte Ireland-sponsored courses this year, including courses on revenue management and customer greeting. We train tourism guides and provide for certification and so on. They are very important in the added value they provide for customers and the expertise they can imbed in their own businesses to make a profit. Many of them are fantastic at generating revenue and providing good customer experiences, but if they do not control their costs and are surprised by unexpected expenses, the business will fail.

The major challenge for us is wedded to the issue of regionality. It is to extend the season and have regional dispersion. I agree that it should not be at the expense of Dublin. Members might have seen on the news recently the spectacular development of the casino in Marino. There are parts of Dublin which need to be developed too, particularly on the north side. The concentration of business in the city centre is also a problem for Dublin. The DART offers us a fantastic opportunity to get people to Howth and Greystones, for example, as well as to towns such as Balbriggan, Skerries and so on. The development in Marino which is spectacular and has been assisted with Fáilte Ireland funding, in conjunction with the OPW, is something I commend to members.

It is our attempt, even within Dublin, to regionalise out from the centre. In the country as a whole, the Senator is correct that given the percentage of SME involvement in the tourism industry in County Kerry and elsewhere in the country is a risk in the context of any prospective downturn. We hope there will not be a downturn in tourism. This should concentrate our minds on ensuring this business and sector are properly funded and resourced, not necessarily only with money but also from an expertise point of view. We should support those SMEs which, as I said, do not have the expertise to run every element of their business.

Regional access, as the Senator pointed out, is a critical ingredient of success. Before the Senator arrived, we were discussing a review the Department is carrying out on regional airports, specifically Kerry, Knock, Waterford and possibly Derry airports. These airports must be supported and their performance must not be judged solely on their own profit and loss account. The capital expenditure that airports like Knock require to meet safety regulations, as is absolutely right-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

-----is a huge burden for a small airport. The contribution these airports make locally in Mayo, Galway, Sligo and so on should be the true measure of their performance. Joe Gilmore, whom I know personally, has done a phenomenal job to grow Knock Airport, through thick and thin, every year for the past 15 years.

Comment on this

I could not agree more.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

He is symptomatic. The guys in Kerry Airport have a huge burden as well. Management at the airport, which is vital to the region, changed recently. We need to support these airports and get more throughput to keep them growing.

Comment on this

I come from a location in north Cork, which is the central point between Limerick, Waterford and Cork city. Recently, I attended a business meeting and it was acknowledged that the Waterford and Limerick regions were fast catching up and competing with Cork. One of the big benefits has been the infrastructure that has been in place. The tunnel under the River Shannon in Limerick has been a big boost to Shannon Airport and the companies in the region. A major bypass in Waterford is facilitating infrastructure in the port. I commend Mr. Whelan on bringing the port from the position it was in some years by reducing its debt and developing the container side of the business. With Brexit, would a roll-on, roll-off ferry be a possible option in Waterford Port?

Given the historical nature of Waterford port, are cruise liners making use of the port? They are an attractive option now that Dublin Port is seeking to reduce the number of cruise liner berthings there. Could Waterford Port use this opportunity and fill that void?

I am delighted to note the good occupancy rates of the commercial premises in the Shannon Group. Ms Hynes mentioned that 43% of properties were vacant in 2014. I was touring recently in the general Shannon Airport catchment area and I was amazed at the amount of industry and the number of industrial units in the area. Are the new jobs split 50-50 between foreign direct investment and indigenous companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Des Whelan

On the question of all roll-on, roll-off, Belview Port is seven or eight miles - Mr. Doyle may correct me as he is the harbourmaster - up the estuary. The larger ships need to go up with the tide. We have investigated in our master plan the potential for roll-on, roll-off traffic and it is not viable given the time restriction on a roll-on, roll-off vessel going up Waterford Estuary. The passage from the UK or from mainland Europe would add to costs and it would not be competitive against other services. We have looked hard at that and consulted a number of experts in our master plan and this was the general agreement. That is a fair summation of the position.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren Doyle

To be fair, Rosslare is not too far away from us either, and it is another State-owned asset. With value for money and cost-benefit analysis, this idea would not be effective.

Comment on this

What about attracting cruise liners?

Comment on this
Mr. Des Whelan

How long is a piece of string? People are very concerned about this issue, particularly in the tourism industry. We have about 25 cruise liners coming in to Waterford every year. The liners that are 200 m long can come up as far as Belview Port. They account for about ten of the 25. Three or four can go the whole way up the river into the quays at Waterford. The others, the very large ones with 2,000 or 3,000 passengers on board, dock off Dunmore East. They are then tendered into the harbour in Dunmore East, weather permitting. Quite a number of the cruise liner passengers are elderly, in the 50 plus bracket. One cannot always take that number of people on to a tender.

This week, for example, we turned away a very large cruiser because it was not suitable to take people off. To put a cruise facility in Dunmore East would be a multimillion euro investment. That is the reality of it. We are vulnerable to the weather for those ten or 15 cruise liners, that is, the very large ones. The other cruise liners can go up to Great Island or to Belview Port but we are restricted unless a massive amount of money is put into the infrastructure to cater for the very large cruise liners at Dunmore East, or something along that estuary, between there and Woodstown. Mr. Doyle is a harbourmaster and is far more used to dealing with the problems of cruise liners but it is important to say that we welcome them and would like more of them. The infrastructure and what we can offer, however, is a problem.

Comment on this
Mr. Darren Doyle

That is a fair comment. Significant investment in Dunmore East would be required to construct a cruise terminal there. The south east region as a whole is very attractive to cruise business and passengers and there are very favourable responses to Waterford from companies. The tendering is a challenge, particularly with some of the weather we have in Ireland.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

We are very proud of what we have achieved, particularly in the Shannon free zone. As I said, occupancy stood at 43% when we took over the zone and many of the buildings were not fit for purpose. That has completely changed now. We have spent over €40 million since 2015. We have built new buildings and demolished some of the unsuitable ones and we have refurbished other buildings. We have brought in new tenants, like Jaguar Land Rover, which have two buildings there as one drives into the airport. That is phenomenal for Shannon and is a game changer. Edwards Lifesciences are new tenants as well.

We have set up a brand called the International Aviation Services Centre, IASC, which attempts to cluster the aviation activity in and around Shannon. That has gone from having 40 members in the cluster to 83 now. There are two new aircraft leasing companies in Shannon, which is very dear to my heart as I came from GPA, the first of those leasing companies. These are two new small companies also and that is big for Shannon. Having the IASC brand to cluster the aviation activity is proving to be very successful because various companies feed off one another. That has been really good.

We have focused on turning Shannon free zone around and I believe that we are well on the way in doing that. We have done this in a very short period and I am very proud of that.

Comment on this

That is very good.

Comment on this
Ms Rose Hynes

We are also building the first wide bodied aircraft hangar just off the runway. It is due to be completed by the end of December. It is the first to be built in Ireland in the past 20 years. The development will further drive activity in and around the airfield zone.

Comment on this

Very good. I welcome Mr. Cawley. We acknowledge the tremendous work done by Fáilte Ireland during the years, particularly in recent years under the chairmanship of Mr. Cawley, as shown in the revenue figure of €8 billion. Previous questioners have asked questions about issues ranging from the Wild Atlantic Way to ancient Ireland and back roads. What about sport which is a big topic? Fáilte Ireland has a role to play in bringing more people to the country to participate in sports and attend sports events. The delegation might know why I have raised the issue. There has been publicity recently about greyhound racing. The Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport has asked Fáilte Ireland to remove references to it in its brochures. Fáilte Ireland promotes the country. How much of a role does it play in the overall promotion of sports when it is involved in trade delegations or at business stands abroad?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Cawley

We were not asked by the Minister to do that. He asked us to meet Bord na gCon, with Tourism Ireland. We met the board and made the decision. The Minister did not ask us to make it. He just asked us to meet the board.

On the issue of sport promotion generally, we entirely supported the bid to host the Rugby World Cup. We provided the administrative support. The Government, through Fáilte Ireland, put up €1 million for the bid which, sadly, was unsuccessful.

We initiated a cycle race on the Wild Atlantic Way. The event was held for two years and we are trying to restart it because cycling is huge as both a leisure and competition activity.

I will not go into too much detail, but we promote a broad range of sports in many ways. For example, we work with Mr. Peter McKenna in Croke Park to fill the empty seats at the hurling semi-finals. In the past there was capacity for 40,000, but that figure has now bee increased to 70,000 owing to a change in the pricing structure. I do not care who goes to Croke Park, whether it is visitors or Irish people. It is a fantastic spectacle and a shame to see empty seats at some of the big games. Croke Park has fixed the attendance issue in a certain way and we have worked with it in promoting events abroad. The television coverage of GAA games by Sky Sports in the past couple of years has helped a lot to promote the product. We work with all sports bodies, but in the past few years we have worked in particular with the GAA and the Irish Rugby Football Union. We are also involved with Union of European Football Associations in supporting the Nations Cup games that will take place in 2020 or 2021. We are assisting in providing the expertise it needs to maximise the impact of the games for us as a country in terms of the visitor experience.

Golf promotion is a major area of activity for us. With Sport Ireland, Fáilte Ireland has sponsored the Irish Open for the past few years. That sponsorship will finish this year, but Sport Ireland will keep the event going. We have leveraged our sponsorship to help smaller golf clubs which are the ones that really need to attract tourists. The Killarneys and Ballybunions of this world are full. We have used the exposure on television to market golf in Ireland. We received massive coverage in working with the European Tour. We also help smaller golf clubs in a practical way to join us. We have developed the Links Alliance in Dublin. We have also developed the North West Alliance which includes Belmullet Golf Club in County Mayo, Enniscrone, Strandhill and Rosses Point golf clubs in County Sligo and all of the golf courses in County Donegal. There is a common website on which one can book accommodation. Economically, the initiative is very good for the clubs and the regions because visiting golfers spend between €300 and €400 on green fees and another €700 or €800 on accommodation, food and so on. Fáilte Ireland has taken a keen interest in the sector. We have a special manager in the organisation who is dedicated to golf promotion and has done fantastic work in that regard.

Fáilte Ireland is involved across the entire spectrum of sport promotion.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Hynes, Mr. Cawley, Mr. Whelan, Ms Mosse and Captain Darren Doyle for their time. I apologise that the meeting lasted longer than expected.

Comment on this