LAND BILL, 1923 (REPORT STAGE).
Contributions 1–129 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 24 of 1923 ›
I beg to move:—
Section 19, Sub-Section (2): To add after the word "year" in line 22 the words "save that in a case where payment of the yearly rent in one annual sum after the second gale day of the year is customary, one half-year's rent out of the amount paid after the second gale day in the year 1920 shall not be so appropriated."
This amendment was one which the Minister I think said he would accept but he did suggest that we might disturb the whole of the arrears Clauses by inserting it. I understand, however, that the Dáil cannot re-open the whole Section and can only deal with this amendment. As I see no danger in that I hope the Minister will accept it and that the Seanad will press him to accept it.
Comment on this
This is a question I would like to leave absolutely free to the Seanad. I will just put the case as I see it quite frankly. The proviso which Senator Sir J. Keane seeks to amend reads: "Provided that any payments made by the tenant after the second gale day in the year 1920, shall be appropriated to the rent which accrued since the first gale day in that year."
That might be looked at from two points of view. One point of view is this: a tenant is paying his rent half-yearly, regularly for 10 or 15 years. Some 6 or 7 years ago he got into two or three years' arrears. The landlord might not have pressed him for one reason or another. The receipts given on the basis of the arrears showed that the rent was anti-dated by 3 years. It would be hardly fair that such a man should be asked to pay the three years' arrears now. He would have to pay if the Section remains as it is.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. That was one point of view from which this proviso might be looked at. The other is that any rent paid within three years should be appropriated to the three years. It was argued from both points of view. This proviso was carried, and I am sure was supported both from the first and second points of view. From the point of view of the people who voted, that any rent paid within a three years' period should be appropriated to that period, the amendment would not carry out their wishes. I am not saying whether that is right or wrong, but I say that different reasons actuated different people for leaving the arrears clause as it stands. If a man voted for this proviso: "Provided that any payment made by the tenant after the second gale day in the year 1920, shall be appropriated to the rent which accrued since the first gale day in that year," on the ground that any rent paid within the three years should be appropriated to the three years' period he would say that a man who paid a year's rent in November should get a receipt up to the following May, I will be quite frank and say that was not my meaning. I know there was the other point of view, but I did not anticipate the case which Senator Sir John Keane quoted to me afterwards. Under all these circumstances, and in view of the fact that agreements about arrears are always agreements based on expediency and could be attacked, from a great many points of view, and in view of the fact that there are all sorts and conditions of people, who want to open up the arrears question for all sorts and conditions of reasons, I put it to the Seanad to consider whether it would be good business to re-open the arrears question, for the sake of the comparatively few cases where the loss of a half-year's rent in three will be suffered as a result of the proviso. If the Seanad approves of Senator Sir John Keane's amendment I will do my best to have it carried in the Dáil. I will put the question before the Dáil as strongly as I can. If the Seanad on the other hand thinks the other thing should be done, it is a matter for them.
Comment on this
I would like the feeling of the Seanad on this question.
Amendment put and declared lost on a show of hands, 8 voting for and 11 against.
Comment on this
I move: Section 24, Sub-Section (2) to insert after the word "or" in line 8 the words "town park used solely for dairying purposes or." The object I wish to attain in this amendment is to enable people in the country towns and also in the big towns, if possible, to obtain pure milk close to where they live. My reason for wishing to have this amendment added to the Sub-Section is that it is almost impossible for the poor people in poor parts of a country town to obtain milk easily and with dispatch. The result is that children are not attended to properly. They do not get proper nourishment, and in many cases they are often given the most extraordinary liquid. I mentioned this case to the Minister, and I wish to mention it to the Seanad. In a town in my part of the country a young mother was in a bar attached to a grocer's shop. It was a place where women of the country very often drink. She had a puling infant in her arms. She was drinking porter and put the porter to the infant's lips and the infant drank some of it. Someone said to her, "Why did you do that," and the mother answered, "Sure it would not do any harm." Later someone told the district nurse of this as the child was getting thinner and thinner. There are funds to deal with this sort of case and a bottle and milk were got for the child and it is now living and well. I know the difficulties that attach to the Minister in regard to this. He will say in some cases that the town parks are wanted to increase the size of the town and in other cases it might interfere with the tenancies of tenanted or untenanted land. I should like to hear what he says to my amendment before I answer him.
Comment on this
We dealt with these questions very fully on Colonel Hutcheson Poe's amendment. Tenanted land near a town will not vest as such if it has any potential or actual value as building ground. That disposes, I think, of the question of public policy about town parks. There is then the question of tenanted land that has no potential value as building ground and on which cows are grazing. The fact that we vest the holding in the tenant under the Act will not prevent him from keeping cows. Now if there is untenanted land near a town which is of any potential or actual value as building ground and which has been used by the landlords for the use of cows in order to sell milk to the towns people the Land Commission has power to take land invested in Trustees including the public authorities for pasturage.
Comment on this
I beg to move: In Section 24, Sub-section 3 "to add at the end of the Sub-section the words ‘there shall be an appeal to the Court of Appeal from any decision of the Judicial Commissioner under this Sub-section and the decision of the Court of Appeal shall be final.'"
This amendment opens up the question that has been debated for some time with regard to appeals from the decision of the Judicial Commissioner. That is to say he is a judge and we know who he is and this is an appeal to that Judicial Commissioner under this Sub-section. This was debated over and over again, and there is a feeling amongst those who hold land in this country that there should be some sort of appeal because—I do not wish to state it but it has been stated—the Judicial Commissioner will be judge, jury and general decider upon everything connected with the Bill. We want a Court of Appeal, a superior Court, and I myself have every confidence in the Court of Appeal of this country, and therefore that is the reason I wish for this appeal. I hope the Minister will inform me what he is prepared to do with regard to this question which I consider an important question and which I heard argued in another place across the water many a time on many and many a Land Bill.
Comment on this
I will accept that amendment. We debated the question of price yesterday, and I do not propose to debate it again, as I gave my reasons showing that it was impossible for me, as it was impossible for the people concerned with the 1907 and 1909 Acts, to give an appeal. We accept the appeal with the exception of "save on the question of price."
Comment on this
Would the Minister give an appeal to some superior Court on the question of law arising as distinct from a question of fact and price? That would go a long way to meet us.
Comment on this
I am sorry Sir John Keane did not make that suggestion before, because it is rather difficult to give an answer to that off-hand. A suggestion was made to me some time ago and I had not time to consider it. I suggest that we just pass on and come back to it later when I have had time to consider it.
Comment on this
I think that is a reasonable suggestion. It is a new suggestion and the Minister should have an opportunity of considering it.
Comment on this
I desire to say that the Minister's answer to the question would affect our attitude towards this Bill very considerably.
Comment on this
If the Minister ultimately thinks that it would be better to fall in with the suggestion to make the Judicial Commissioner sole judge of the question of fact which would, of course, include the question of price, and to give the Court of Appeal jurisdiction on the questions of law then this amendment would be out of place. Is it not wiser to leave it until the end of the Report Stage?
Comment on this
The words are the same as those you have accepted "save on a question of price." That is after the Sub-section. I think it is better to leave the matter over at present. Is that agreed?
Agreed.
Comment on this
I beg to move in Sub-Section (2), Section 25, "to delete in line 52 the words ‘the Land Commission and' and the word ‘respectively' in line 52-3."
Comment on this
This amendment was already debated in principle in three amendments in Committee. I do not know whether you, An Cathaoirleach, consider it right, but the same question debated and decided on three amendments should not be debated again.
Comment on this
We have not Standing Orders on that. Objection was taken to amendments to the Public Safety Bill, 1923, coming from the Labour side on the ground that they had already been disposed of. I ruled then, more particularly in view of the conditions under which we are discussing this Bill, that I would not exclude on the Report Stage any amendment put forward. The ruling I have given is in conformity with the practice of the House of Commons.
Comment on this
From what the Minister stated I believe it is useless further to debate the question. Still I, representing a certain class of farmers, appeal, and I think I am justified in entering a protest, against the arbitrary manner in which they have been treated. This amendment proposes to delete the words dictating to the Judge as to how the price is to be fixed. I leave it to he good sense of the House. Under the Bill any man's land can be taken from him compulsorily. Is it not right then he should get the full market value even if he is paid in bonds?
Comment on this
I would like to have some figures. If Senator Counihan happens to have purchased a farm under any Land Act I would like to know what the 4½ per cent. annuity would be.
Comment on this
Exactly, that is what I am talking about. If Mr. Counihan knows some farm which was purchased under the Land Act say, of 150 acres, in any county, I would like to have his views as to what the market value is. I would like to ask him to compute what 4½ per cent. on the market value would be, what the annuity would be like. Would it be in the nature of anything like from £3 to £5 an acre? And then I will go on and ask him if there were a single perch of land bought under any Land Act at the price resulting in such an annuity, would land purchase have been possible at all? The claim he is putting forward now scarcely ever was argued by the most determined enemy of land purchase in the English House of Lords.
Comment on this
A man buys a farm under some Purchase Act and he thinks fit in his wisdom to redeem the annuity, I take it, he then occupies untenanted land.
Comment on this
The land on which the annuity has been redeemed and which I take it is held in fee-simple, is, under a definition of this Bill, untenanted land. That fact, that it is untenanted land, attached to that land in the possession of whomever it may be.
Comment on this
I do not see why, that being so, land that has never been through the furnace of land purchase should merely by reason of that fact be acquired at a different price from land which is retained as tenanted land under this Bill. I cannot see the justice of that case. The Minister has pointed out the difficulties of financing any scheme of settlement if he pays the market price, but he will have to do so in the case of any holdings that are resumed and he will also have to do so in the case of equivalent holdings, presumably, purchased at a market price, and in the case of any holdings which may be acquired for the relief of congestion. If that objection applies in those two cases surely it should apply also to the third case.
Comment on this
Strictly speaking, there is something to be said for Sir John Keane's point of view in an academic way. But remember now he is just arguing against land purchase since the Ashbourne Acts were first passed, for some reason or another. I do not propose to cover the whole period of Irish history since 1885. For some reason or another it has been decided and is a closed issue that as a matter of public policy all untenanted land should be transferred from the land-owners to the tenants. That is an issue that has been before the public for 30 years, and it is accepted now by all parties. You do not expect me to argue the whole general question of Land Purchase and the reasons which actuated the various English Governments since 1885, in adopting a policy of the transferring of land from the land-owners to the tenants and congests. That is exactly the case. The reasons he opposes it now are reasons that are equally potent against every Land Purchase Act that was ever considered.
Comment on this
I do not accept that point of view. In the case of land purchase it is admitted that the tenant has acquired the tenant-right, and the basis of purchase is quite different. The landlord's right is only limited by virtue of the fact that the tenant has been given tenant-right. There is also the equivalent of tenant-right attaching to untenanted land. The owner of untenanted land has effected improvements which are in equity similar to those put into the land by the tenant. For that reason I would argue that the two cases are not in any way comparable.
Comment on this
Estates including tenanted and untenanted land were bought under the Land Purchase Act.
Comment on this
Would I be in order in moving an amendment to the amendment that Senator Counihan has moved?
Comment on this
Perhaps before moving the amendment, you would allow me to state that I do not think that the Minister has fairly met the case that was made yesterday, that a man ought to be a judge and jury in his own case. It is perfectly idle to say that the Judicial Commissioner of the Land Commission—I know that in the present holder we have the greatest confidence—but he will not always be there, and it is perfectly idle to say that he as head of the Land Commission is not responsible for the efficient carrying out of its policy. Like Senator Jameson, I cannot agree with the Minister when he said that the Bill would be wrecked if an appeal were allowed. I do not care to whom the appeal is. All I want is an appeal to some other person than the head of the Land Commission. That is absolutely essential. I have already said this, but even at the danger of reiterating things I say it again. I would like to point out that there would be no more use in going to the head of a body of that sort and asking for a revision of what had been done by subordinate officials, than there would be in going to the chair-man of a company asking him to reverse the decision already arrived at by his own officials.
I think it is a most unjust thing and from the view point of the Free State it would be a most injurious thing for the credit of the Free State if it went out to the public and the people outside Ireland that we were prepared to do an injustice to anybody. Undoubtedly an injustice under this section might arise. I told you of a case yesterday of which I was aware in which the Congested Districts Board had power to take certain lands. They proposed to take these lands and they proposed to take them at a price which was fixed by an inspector of their own. Now the returns of what that land had yielded were available for 30 years. The price suggested was utterly inadequate having regard to those returns which were unimpeachable. When they found that they would have to face a petition to some independent party they abandoned the purchase altogether. On the question of compulsory purchase I have never known of a case in which any Public Department was given power to expatriate compulsorily a person at an infinitely less price than the property was worth.
I am perfectly certain that if a clause of that sort is allowed to go through in this Land Bill that the effect of it on the credit of the Saorstát is this: We have enemies elsewhere who will argue, "Oh what is the use of lending money to a country that is prepared to confiscate the property of individuals? Here in their own Acts which they have just passed they take power to do so and what security can they offer for a further loan?" That argument will be used and in the interests of the Free State, as in the interests of justice which is a thing that this Seanad holds very dearly. I am perfectly satisfied and certain that it would be inadvisable to allow a Bill of this kind to go through without allowing an appeal from the decision of the Judicial Commissioner, to somebody else. I do not care who that somebody else is so long as he is independent. I do not care if it is a Judge of the High Court, a valuer, or whatever he may be, or if it is the Court of Appeal. But I want to be able to appeal to an independent umpire, and I am perfectly certain that by allowing that appeal, confidence will be increased in the fair dealings of the Free State by the introduction of such a clause. My amendment is that an appeal should be allowed from the decision of the Judicial Commissioner to the Court of Appeal.
Comment on this
Is that to be a general appeal both on law and on fact?
Comment on this
I do not know whether I am really going out of my way in saying what I am going to say. But I am very anxious that the Seanad should realise the difficulty of the position in which the Minister is placed, and at the same time I would like to press upon him a suggestion which I think would meet all the legitimate suggestions to be urged by this Seanad, and which would be a distinct and substantial improvement in the Bill. I have had for my good or evil fortune to take part in administration from the point of view of the lawyer in all these Land Purchase Appeals since 1881, and I must say this that I never knew or heard of any just cause of complaint against the Judicial Head of the Land Commission in regard to the fixing and ascertaining of compensation. I can well understand the advantage the Ministry will see in having a judicial personage who, by daily contact with this question will be able to lay down certain principles of valuation and compensation and not leaving the thing to be largely a matter of haphazard decision of a different judge to-day and another to-morrow.
On the other hand, I also find that as a result of practical experience and with the very best intentions a Judicial Commissioner, like any other judge, would go wrong in considering the question whether certain elements of property that the owner alleged had a value, and where questions of that kind involving matters of law would come up, it is inevitable that the Judicial Commissioner's opinion would be from time to time, as it turned out to be on investigation by the Court of Appeal, erroneous. In all the interests of justice, I suggest all the difficulties in this matter, that have surrounded this complicated question, would be met if the Minister was prepared to accept an amendment which could be put in at the end of the Bill to the effect that the Judicial Commissioner should be the sole Judge of all questions of fact, and that an appeal should be allowed to the Court of Appeal on pure questions of law. Again, I want to point out that the Minister is considering that, and he ought not to be rushed. He will have full opportunity to consider it before the Report Stage is over.
Comment on this
What was suggested by the Cathaoirleach would certainly be a strong improvement. Senator Barrington referred to depreciation of security by confiscation. I think, from the concessions which the Minister made and promised to us, that any person who is disturbed from his holding is to get an equivalent holding elsewhere, and that will delete any possible chance of confiscation. On that point I take issue with Senator Barrington. I do not think there can be confiscation, and I do not think the security of the country, once we get the amendments promised by the Minister, will be affected.
Comment on this
Even though I cannot say without a little consideration what I have to say on the very important question which the Cathaoirleach has raised, I do want to say that it is nothing short of absurd for a responsible Senator like Senator Barrington to stand up and say that if this Bill passes in its present form people outside Ireland will say "What is the use of lending Ireland money when over there they are confiscating the people's land?"
Comment on this
That is a cheap thing to say, in view of the fact that at least five times it was stated here that thirteen millions out of the twenty million acres of land in Ireland are purchased. It is also being repeatedly stated that it is mandatory on us under the Bill, in the event of our touching any of that thirteen million acres, to give an equally suitable and not less valuable substitute holding. In face of that you will have a responsible Senator stating here that outsiders will say we are confiscat- the land. Confiscation is a word that has been bandied about. I had to use it myself, and I did so, I may claim, with effect when I was preparing the Bill. I was faced with it definitely, or with something approaching it. Now we have Senators coming along and talking about confiscation in view of what has been said. All that I have to say is that Senator Barrington is living in a fool's paradise, and he is actually asking for it. I pointed out to Senator Counihan that he was making a demand which was never made by the most conservative landlord in the House of Lords at any time.
Comment on this
I wish to say that the definition of untenanted land never had such a wide meaning under any Act.
Comment on this
I may say on that question that the Senator's price was scarcely approached by that of the most conservative and relentless enemy of land purchase since the Act of 1885. There is just one other point. Apparently all the difference between confiscation and something that is not confiscation is an appeal from one High Court Judge to another. Senator Barrington's speech comes to that. I am not going to waste the time of the Seanad in saying what Senator Barrington is unable to contradict, except by making general statements, that the Judicial Commissioner's position has been carefully safeguarded by every Act that referred to him, and that his functions as an arbitrator between the Land Commission and the vendor are being carefully safeguarded and carefully defined with a view to leaving him as impartial as possible. If Senator Barrington thinks that human nature is so weak that because a man lives in the Land Commission, and because he happens to be called a Judicial Commissioner—I invite him to state any other reason that he may have—even though he is a Judge of the High Court, he will not be so impartial as any other High Court Judge. If that is the suggestion, then I cannot get next any man who holds that opinion, and consequently I cannot argue against it.
Comment on this
With reference to the Minister's imputation that I should explain matters, I should like to say that if I wanted to make a cheap point against him I might say very much more. He says he is astonished that a man in the responsible position of Senator Barrington should make certain statements, and that apparently I have not read certain Bills. If I wanted to make a cheap point I might say very much against a Minister in his responsible position who is so unaware of the criticisms that are abroad all over the world. I have just come back from another country, where I have had to take up the cudgels in favour of the Free State over and over again, and I have had to answer criticisms of the very sort that the Minister is astonished at.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I pointed out to the Senator that he had made certain statements without adducing some facts, and merely on the hearsay of friends in America.
Comment on this
Has this amendment been seconded, or is this the Report Stage of the Bill? Some of us are getting a little bit tired of the discussion now.
Comment on this
These criticisms are being made every day. The rest of the world does not think with us, and it does not think with us on this point especially. There are allegations that we are confiscating, and there is no doubt whatsoever about that. I gave a concrete case, which the Minister up to this has failed to reply to. In that case, if an appeal did not exist, some more of the land would have been confiscated. There is another point. In any of these large undertakings the provision of capital has to be provided for. No sane man would provide capital when he knows that next day the Minister might come in and deprive him of half, or almost the whole, of that capital, and the only protection that exists against that being done is the provision of an umpire. I do not care who that umpire may be, but there should be an appeal to somebody else on the question of price. That is absolutely essential. There should be an appeal to somebody else on the question of price if the Bill is not to be a confiscatory Bill.
Comment on this
I venture to suggest that the Judicial Commissioner himself might not be unwilling to have somebody behind him who might give an opinion on these matters. Surely he is being put in an extremely difficult position. With every desire that he naturally would have to do justice, he would be confronted in many cases with what might very properly, from the office point of view, be a conservative and rather low valuation of the land in question. On the other hand, he would, no doubt, get from the owner probably an inflated idea of the value of the land. There would be thousands of cases, and it would be quite impossible for him to go into all the details. He would naturally be very unwilling to let down those who are under him in the office. If he felt that his opinion might not always be absolutely right, and that there was somebody behind him to whom an appeal could be made, I should think it would be rather a comfort to him.
Comment on this
The real difficulty in this case is, as Senator MacLysaght has put it, that we are debating a question which the Minister has given his opinion on. He has told us how far he is inclined to meet this question of appeal. I take it that matter is now before his Legal Adviser, and the Chairman has stated that, in his opinion, the question of law is the one thing that would really check iniquities. What Senator Barrington is forcing a decision on now is on the question of whether we will oppose the Minister on this matter of an appeal on price. The difficulty there seems to be this. If a decision was given one way by the Judicial Commissioner one class would at once begin appealing against every decision of the Commissioner. If a decision was given the other way, another class would rush in with appeals. I admit that when speaking on the subject before I did not think there would be many of those appeals, but I recognise now that if a decision was given on appeal, one way or the other, it would entail at once a large number of appeals, and it would interfere with the working of the Bill. I was trying to find out whether we would be injuring the working of the Bill if we adopted amendments such as this, and I am convinced now, if an appeal is allowed on the question of price, that quite a small decision may lead to an interminable amount of law and delay. Therefore, I am not prepared to vote against the Minister on this amendment. We have debated it so completely and absolutely that I do not think we are helping matters by discussing it any further.
Comment on this
Do I understand that the Minister is willing, at all events, to consider the subject raised by the Cathaoirleach? I quite understand that price is not a matter of fact. It is a matter of the principles upon which the price is based, and that is the point he raised. If the Minister is willing to concede that, I think there would not be very much more to discuss. Once you know the principles on which you base the price you can arrive at it rapidly.
Comment on this
My position on the question of price is exactly as stated by Senator Jameson. On the other hand, the Chairman has thrown out a certain suggestion, and I am prepared to say what I have to say on that later on.
Comment on this
A surprising statement has been made by Senator Barrington that people in other countries are considerably agitated by the confiscatory principles contained in this Bill. I do not know whether copies of the Bill have been circulated to all classes all over the world or even in the neighbouring countries, or how this confiscatory idea came to be so generally discussed. We have now got to the point as to whether there should be an appeal on the matter of price from the decision of the Judicial Commissioner. Anybody having any practical experience of Land Court business—I have had a slight experience— will know that there is everything to be said for the view taken by the Minister, and endorsed by the Chairman, who has had a very lengthy experience of the matter, that it is the man who is brought into touch daily with the fixing of prices who is the most competent. The evidence given by valuers on one side or the other in these land cases is very puzzling indeed to the casual listener, and makes him wonder whether, under any circumstances, any Judge, no matter how astute he might be, could arrive at a fair decision in the matter.
Time and again I have heard evidence given by the valuer for the tenant that the land had only a prairie value—no value at all—and, on the other hand, the valuer on the other side giving what he considered to be a fair value. The wide difference between the two baffles the ordinary man and makes him wonder how any Judge could arrive at anything like an equitable decision. So that it becomes a sort of intuitive thing on the part of the Judge in assessing the value and weight to be attached to evidence of that kind. The human element comes into the consideration of it. It is only by being in constant touch with these matters and sizing up the weight to be attached to witnesses, that a Judge arrives at something like a fair decision. That particular equipment and experience does not come within the range of the Court of Appeal Judge, who, five days in the week, is engaged on Probate and other matters of law. He would be confronted with this sort of impossible evidence, and that is the only evidence he has to go upon. He has not got the training of the Judicial Commissioner, and the intuitive instinct born of dealing with these matters daily. I think that an appeal to a Judge less equipped than the Judicial Commissioner would entirely dislocate the whole structure of the Bill.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with the last speaker on the question of appeal. Personally I do not see that a great deal is to be gained by an appeal on the question. The amendment does not remove my objection. What I object to is the definition and the direction to the Judge as to how the price is to be assessed. I have been trying to put myself in the position of the Judicial Commissioner. The matter depends upon what the proposals of the Government are with regard to financing the transaction. We have had no indication of that. If the Government say to the Land Commissioners, "We are prepared to finance the buildings or any additional expenditure on the land out of the taxpayer's pocket," the position of the Judicial Commissioner would be altogether different to what it would be if the Government say, "You have got to fix a price that will enable the tenant to pay an annuity and interest which will not only cover the price paid to the vendor, but also the price to cover perhaps a house or buildings." That is a very important point, as to which we have had no indication of the policy of the Government. If the Government say, "Our intention is not in any way to finance housing or stock-in-trade for the incoming settler," I do not see how that can be done when it is the intention to put on these lands landless men. Unless the Government are to place an intolerable imposition on the taxpayer they will have to fix such a price on the land as will enable them to finance it, as the Minister said, like a Stock Exchange transaction. That is left in the hands of the Executive. We have no indication of the policy of the Government in the matter, and for that reason I have a great apprehension that the direction to the Judge will create apprehension in the minds of people who are accommodated by banks and other accommodating houses.
Comment on this
It is easy to propound dilemmas. One would think we were legislating in a vaccum, or playing draughts, and could bring in any sort of ideal scheme that would be without any defects. It comes to this, must land purchase be completed? In all the circumstances of the case, and in view of the influences that are likely to be brought to bear on that question, not to-day or to-morrow, but for the next three or four years, can this question be left unsettled? Must certain land be bought for the relief of congestion? Do you think we can afford to leave things as they are; in other words, to let things drift? As business men, do you think that the situation can be left as it is? Must we do something to complete land purchase and buy a certain amount of untenanted land to relieve congestion? If you think we must, and that we cannot stop and say, "That is the sort of thing the English Government would do, but an Irish Government is not going to do anything of the kind," I think you would have to admit that we must make some attempt to buy some untenanted land for the purpose of relieving congestion. We have to buy land. You know perfectly well that even if this Bill is not passed, another Bill will be passed, and that some other Land Commission or some other Government or Dáil will deal with the question. What is the price? Senator Sir John Keane put me in a dilemma. I will put him in another. He wants to know if it is the market price, and shows how the landlord will not get exactly the price he might get under other circumstances. He wants to know what will be taken into account and what will not be taken into account.
Comment on this
I ask clearly what is the policy of the Government with regard to financing landless men proposed to be settled on the holdings.
Comment on this
The Senator stated that the whole thing depended upon the price we could give for the land. I want to ask the Senator this question. Does he remember what happened all during last year, and the agitation about the price of tenanted land? Even within the last fortnight, much to my surprise, certain people changed their minds on the question of price very radically who formerly thought that the tenants should buy their holdings for half their value or for next to nothing. We stood up to that tendency with some success, and put certain figures in the Bill with regard to price. I suppose if we examined it very carefully we could put figures in the Bill saying what should be the price of untenanted land. It would be difficult to do it. I want to ask Senator John Keane does he think he will get a fair do from the Land Commission presided over by a High Court Judge called in as arbitrator in a dispute that must be settled, as to the price of a certain acreage of untenanted land, and told to fix a price which should be fair to the landlord and fair to the tenant in all the circumstances. That is what we are doing now. I do not know any other way of doing it, if I might say it, that would be fair to the vendor. I make no secret that we did try to protect the vendor's interest, and we tried to give him fair play. The best arrangement that could be made was to leave it not between the landlord and the Unpurchased Tenants' Association, or some other body, but between the landlord and a tenant who wants the holding, with the High Court Judge as arbitrator.
Comment on this
The Minister asked if a Judge could give a fair do What I say is that, as the direction is drafted, in my opinion, the Judge could be fair to neither party.
Comment on this
These interchanges between Ministers and Senators are not seemly.
Comment on this
Having made my case as strongly as I could, and as I see very little hope of carrying the amendment, and not wishing to delay the Seanad, I desire by consent to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move:—In Section 25, Sub-section (2), to delete in line 52 the words "the Land Commission and" and the word "respectively" in lines 52 and 53.
Comment on this
I have an amendment here: "To delete Section 29." I merely put it down to ask the Minister, after all that has been said, and the great injustice that some people believe will ensue if the section is allowed to operate, whether he could meet us on the point.
Comment on this
This section has been before the country for three years. I do not believe that any injustice will arise under it, and the section is vital to the Bill.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:—Section 29, Sub-section (3), to delete in lines 49 and 50 the words "in fixing the compensation payable to the tenant under the said section" and to substitute therefor the words "the compensation payable to the tenant shall be fixed on the basis on which resumption prices have heretofore been fixed under the said section, and in fixing the price."
Comment on this
The next amendment is merely a drafting amendment, and I will ask somebody to move it. It is: "To delete in line 63, Sub-section (1), Section 31, the letter ‘ (g).’”
Comment on this
I beg to move Amendment No. 8, which is as follows: In Section 34 to insert after the section a new section 35 as follows:—
Where the Land Commission have acquired any land from an owner under this Act they may purchase from him any demesne or other land in his occupation adjacent thereto at a price which in their opinion represents the selling value thereof and in such case may resell the whole or any portion of that land to him as if he were a person to whom advances might be made for the purchase of a parcel of land under this Act.
The provisions of Sub-sections (4) and (5) of Section 3 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, shall apply to any resale under this section.
Comment on this
My next amendment is as follows:—In Section 32, to insert after the word "shall" in line 36 the words "if the tenant so requires and". I think the Minister said he would accept that.
Comment on this
I think the word "shall" should be put into the bottom line to make it consistent. The "may" should be "shall."
Comment on this
In paragraph (a), Section 32, the words are “the Land Commission shall”.
Comment on this
I do not think it is desirable to put these words in here until the concluding words of the section are put right.
Comment on this
I beg to propose Section 29, Sub-section (3), to insert after the word "final" in line 43 the words "save where in this Act otherwise provided". This is a consequential amendment on the former one regarding the question of appeal, which the Government have to consider.
Comment on this
Then it would be better to let it stand. As regards the amendment on the paper standing in the name of Sir Thomas Esmonde in regard to Section 45, he has drafted a new clause, which the Government are prepared to accept.
Comment on this
In the absence of Sir Thomas Esmonde I desire to move the following amendment:—To insert before Section 46 a new Section as follows:—
The definition of ancient monuments contained in Section 14 of the Irish Land Act of 1903 shall include any monument which in the opinion of the Land Commission is of archaeological interest and shall where the Land Commission so declares also include the site for the monument and such portion of the land adjoining it as is necessary to prevent injury and afford access.
I think it will be unnecessary for me to waste the time of the Seanad in dealing with the subject. I had something to do with the insertion of a somewhat similar clause in the Land Act of 1903. I understand now that the Inspector of the Land Commission himself reports on these monuments, and I hope the Government will see that he does so thoroughly, for I know cases where admirable monuments have not been inspected.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Yeats for assisting me on this matter, and I also thank the Government for the reception they have been good enough to give to the proposal I recently put forward before them. I beg to second this motion. There is no doubt our ancient monuments are amongst our most precious national possessions. Heretofore efforts have been made to preserve such monuments, and we have not altogether been unsuccessful, because the Board of Works have done valuable service to Irish antiquity, and, thanks to them, we have succeeded in preserving our chief monuments of antiquity. There are a number of extremely interesting minor monuments, which, however, have escaped the notice of the public.
The Ordnance Survey for many years have consistently and persistently done what they could to inform us as to the position of our ancient monuments, and in the revised sheets of the Ordnance Survey there is a splendid index to a great deal of our archaeological possessions. It is our duty, and that of the Oireachtas, to preserve our historical monuments, and we cannot afford to lose any chance we have of promoting their preservation. This Land Bill gives us an opportunity of which naturally we are bound to take advantage, and what we are trying to do is more or less in the nature of a temporary expedient. What should happen is, there ought to be a comprehensive Act passed for the purpose of preserving our national monuments. Until such time as the Oireachtas can devote attention to this I think we should do the best we can, and take advantage of the opportunities before us. This proposition goes somewhat further than anything up to the present that has been attempted. It enables the Land Commission, with the assistance of the Board of Works, to take steps for the preservation of our minor antiquities, and to take further steps for the preservation of our greater antiquities that stand in need of repair and protection. Whatever cost is entailed in the protecting of our monuments or the scheduling of them, or making easier access to those monuments, will be borne by the Commission of Public Works. When the Irish Government controls the Board of Works we expect they will be generous.
Comment on this
In the last few lines there is a congestion of "its," and I would suggest that you change the last part to read "as is necessary to prevent injury and fair access."
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment, and suggest to the Minister that later on, when he has more time, a Bill should be introduced for the safeguarding for some of our monuments. Contrary to what Sir Thomas Esmonde has said, I feel it is a subject to which sufficient attention has not been given. Take one of the most ancient monuments in our city of Dublin, the refectory of Mary's Abbey. That refectory some five hundred years ago witnessed the historic scene when Silken Thomas, the Deputy of the day, relinquished office by throwing down his sword in front of the Privy Council. The last time I saw that building it was used as a lime store.
Comment on this
I understand the Min ister for Education has a Bill practically prepared with regard to that subject.
Comment on this
I am President of the Archaeological Society of Kildare, and I heartily support this amendment. The question, in my mind, is whether this is the right place for it. I think it would be much simpler to make it a separate clause.
Comment on this
I beg to move: In Section 50, to delete in line 15 the words "when the Bank shall have satisfied the Land Commission that they have repaid the Society or body of trustees such deposit as aforesaid" and to substitute therefor the words "when the Bank shall have lodged with the Land Commission such deposit as aforesaid."
The Senators will remember that this amendment, and the one which follows with reference to the National Land Bank, was proposed yesterday by the Minister, and a request was made that it should be left to the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move Section 50: To add after this section a new Section 51 as follows:—
51.—The deposit when lodged with the Land Commission shall be invested by them, and the income from such investments, so far as not required to recoup the Land Commission for unpaid instalments of purchased annuities (if any) in respect of the advance made to the Society or body of trustes under this part of the Act, by whom the deposit was originally made with the Bank, shall be paid to such Society or body of trustees until the deposit is utilised otherwise by the Land Commission or repaid in whole or in part to the Society or body of trustees under the following provisions, namely:
(a) It shall be lawful for the Land Commission at any time before the advance is certified to be repaid, if they are not satisfied with the security for the same, or if the purchase annuities have been allowed to fall into arrear, to utilise the whole or part of the deposit in redemption pro tanto of the advance.
(b) It shall be lawful for the Land Commission at any time; if they are satisfied that the deposit is not required as security for the advance, to repay the whole or any part thereof to the Society or body of trustees who originally lodged the same with the Bank or to their lawful successors.
(c) Such part of the deposit as shall not have been utilised under the foregoing paragraphs shall, when so much of the advance as is equivalent to the value of the deposit remaining with the Land Commission shall be certified to have been repaid, and provided that the Land Commission are satisfied with the security for the unredeemed portion of the advance, be repaid to the Society or body of trustees who originally lodged the same with the Bank or to their lawful successors.
Comment on this
I do not rise to oppose the section, but I wish to issue a warning to the Minister for Agriculture and the Land Commission with regard to the proposition creating societies or corporations for working the land conjointly. I do not know a single one of those farms recently which has been a success.
If that is the proposal, it will lead in a few short years to another group of congests. In my native County of Kerry what has created the greatest congestion there is the fact that the owner of a small farm dies, and the farm is divided up between the sons. Sometimes the places were worked jointly, and in some cases until they were purchased under the 1903 Act they were worked as individual holdings, and in no case were they a complete success. They led to endless litigation and trouble. What has occurred all through the years is that small holdings have been split up and divided amongst half-a-dozen families. The Minister and the Land Commission ought to consider those facts very carefully when they are reviewing this matter.
Comment on this
The creation of such co-operative farming societies as has been suggested has been one of the aspirations of my life.
Comment on this
Then it is an accomplished fact; you have not lived in vain.
Comment on this
I believe they are capable of great expansion; with proper thought and education they will be one of the greatest factors in Irish rural life. The trouble Senator Counihan has referred to is brought about by the splitting up of small holdings. In the case of a Co-operative Farming Society no such thing could arise, and the conclusion he fears will be safeguarded by the rules of the Society.
New section put and agreed to.
Comment on this
I beg to move: Section 68. To insert after this section a new Section 69 as follows:—
The powers for the apportionment of an annuity, or the discharge of portion of a holding from liability in respect of an annuity conferred on the Land Commission by Sub-section (3) of Section 38 of the Land Law (IreLand) Act, 1896, as extended by Sub-section (1) of Section 67 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, may be exercised by the Commissioners of Public Works as regards an annuity charged on a holding in repayment of an advance made by the said Commissioners for the purpose of the purchase thereof pursuant to the Landlord and Tenant (Ireland) Act, 1870.
It appears that in the earlier Land Bills the Commissioners of Public Works had certain powers of apportioning annuities, and there may be a very small number of these still under their care. I take it this new section is simply meant to safeguard them as to the powers they already possess.
Comment on this
I move the following amendment: Section 69, Sub-section (3). To add at the end of the sub-section a new Sub-sction (4) as follows:—
(4) The expression "relieving congestion" means the provision of land for the relief of a person or persons having an uneconomic holding or uneconomic holdings, or for a person or persons whose holding or holdings has or have been acquired for the relief of persons having uneconomic holdings.
Comment on this
I am accepting that amendment. That is what I have been saying all the week. I have read it and I agree to accept it. I saw it was exactly what I could accept, but I intended to suggest to Senator Sir John Keane the addition of a phrase which will not make much difference. The Senator refers in his amendment to an uneconomic holding or uneconomic holdings. I would suggest that he inserts before the words "an uneconomic holding" the words "in the opinion of the Land Commission," and it would then read "having in the opinion of the Land Commission an uneconomic holding or uneconomic holdings."
Comment on this
As you have framed the amendment of course they would be, and the only addition is that the amendment of the Minister is making it clear. Somebody must decide it.
Comment on this
Supposing there is a difference between the parties and the Land Commission, will there be any appeal to the Judicial Commissioner on that point? Does it rest entirely with the Land Commission apart from the Judicial Commissioner to decide.
Comment on this
I really think it does. If a man down the country thought that he should have been dealt with and the Inspector thought his holding was uneconomic, the Inspector would send up a report to that effect. I do not think that in practice he would ever get as far as the Judicial Commissioner.
Comment on this
It will all come up on the orders for vesting, dealt with in Clause 39. Would not the parties whose lands were being taken be debarred from appealing?
Comment on this
Appealing to the Judicial Commissioner as to whether the holding is economic or not. This is a question that could be argued quite fairly on the question of values and profits and other things.
Comment on this
I think it is better to leave it as it is.
Comment on this
I do not like the words "in the opinion of the Land Commission." I would prefer if they were left out altogether.
Comment on this
I move the following; which I think the Minister agreed to in principle:—
Section 70. To add at the end of the Section the following: "Provided always that any regulations made to carry out the provisions of this Act, in so far as they concern the relief of congestion, shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas, and if either House shall, within twenty-one days of such regulations being tabled, pass a Resolution annulling such regulations, such regulations shall be annulled; but such annulments shall not prejudice or invalidate any matter or thing previously done under such regulations."
Comment on this
This is an amendment which deals with Section 70. Now in fact that Section was not necessary at all, because there is already an Adaptation of Enactments Act passed giving the Executive Council power to adapt certain existing enactments to the new circumstances. For instance, under the old Acts, particularly the Act of 1896, which refers to the matter, in the event of a Judicial Commissioner being absent the Lord Chancellor assigned another High Court Judge to do the work. The Lord Chancellor's office is abolished and the Executive Council has power to adapt the particular Section of the 1896 Act which deals with that matter. They make an order saying that the functions of the Lord Chancellor under that Section shall in future be carried out by the Lord Chief Justice. I am sure in the new situation, when the old office is abolished and a new office created, it will be necessary to make various adaptations in the wording of the old Land Acts. For instance, when some particular functionary was supposed to do a certain thing, and that functionary was no longer in existence, it will be now in the power of the Executive Council to make orders empowering the functionary which has been put in his place to do the work. If we did not put in that Section their Orders in Council would have to be laid on the Table. With a view to making it perfectly clear I am putting at the end: "That every such order shall be laid before the Oireachtas in compliance with Section 19 of the Adaptation of Enactments Act."
Comment on this
I do not think that quite covers what Sir John Keane wants. You see these are orders of the Executive in dealing with migration and the exchange of offices. What Sir John Keane is aiming at is the rules of court. I think the regulations are too narrow of the Land Commission, because that would compel them to lay on the Table of the Oireachtas the most minute regulations. The rules of court, I think, he has in mind. I think if you provide for the rules of court that will be sufficient.
Comment on this
I thought it possible that he meant the orders, Section 70 which deals with the Orders and the next Section deals with the rules. To say that the rules which they will be making, or even to put in a provision that these rules can hold good until either House of the Oireachtas has passed a resolution against them would be an extraordinary thing to do. There is a provision like that in the previous Acts.
Comment on this
If the Seanad agrees I will. I would not agree to insert here a provision that the rules shall be laid on the Table. The rules will be laid on the Table. If there is anything wrong with the rules they will be there for everyone to see them. I would not care to insert words that either House of the Oireachtas can annul them.
Comment on this
You agree that the rules should be laid on the Table of the Seanad within 21 days of such rules being adopted by the Land Commission.
Comment on this
The Minister has offered that any orders made by the Executive Council must be laid on the Table of the Oireachtas, but he is also willing to provide that the rules of Court made in conformity with the next Section, which I think is the one you had in your mind, shall be laid before each House, but he is not willing to add the concluding portion. He is prepared to put in a provision that they are to be laid on the Table of the Seanad where Senators will have an opportunity of seeing them, but he is not willing to insert the words that follow in your amendment.