We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Control of Manufactures Bill, 1932—Committee Stage.

Contributions 119–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Control of Manufactures Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 12 of 1932 ›

Most of my amendments were directed towards taking the power out of the hands of the Minister and I do not think the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs can expect me to agree to his suggestion.

Comment on this

Amendments 19, 20 and 21 are consequential on an amendment that was withdrawn.

Comment on this

I move amendment 22:

Section 2, sub-section (3). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) For the purposes of paragraph (c) of the immediately preceding sub-section, but not further or otherwise, the following provisions shall have effect—

(a) where the shares of a body corporate are registered in the name of a bank carrying on business in Saorstát Eireann, such shares shall be deemed to be in the beneficial ownership of a national of Saorstát Eireann;

(b) where shares in a body corporate which is a public company are transferred to a person who is not a national of Saorstát Eireann and as a result of such transfer the issued shares of such body corporate cease to be to an extent exceeding one half thereof in the beneficial ownership of nationals of Saorstát Eireann, such body corporate shall nevertheless be entitled to continue its business without holding a new manufacturer's licence for a period of six months or such longer period as may be specified by the Minister in writing."

This is another amendment which endeavours to deal with two problems that I raised in speaking on the Second Stage of the Bill. They are two quite distinct problems and I was very much puzzled as to the way they might be dealt with. When I looked at the Bill I found what seems to me to be a good way of dealing with this matter. If the Minister finds another way I am not wedded to my amendment. I want to get over this difficulty which is a real difficulty to the holding of shares in the name of a bank. It is well known that a considerable number of us are unfortunate enough to have at a bank overdrafts and the holding of our shares by the bank is a good way of giving collateral security.

The Minister, I suppose, does not want us to go into banking secrecy. I do not think any harm will be done in the way of the bank's secrets if it is confined to the banks here. But it is possible that the Minister might want to make some proviso to deal with possible evasions that may arise. But if you had to pass a Bill without making some provision such as I have here you are going to have the people who have overdrafts at present and who hold Irish investments becoming quite frightened because questions will arise as to ownership of the company. A bank will say: "We are not going to the trouble of proving this; we, as a bank, are not writing to our shareholders to ascertain their nationality and consequently we will not hold these shares as collateral security any longer." What would happen would be that it would be found that a number of Irish shares would be put on the market because they were no longer good security with the bank. That is the first part of the amendment, (a); (b) deals with another problem altogether, one which I feel sure the Minister will agree himself must be met whether he meets it my way or not. I am assuming in this case that the company is formed after the passing of this Bill, and that it is an Irish company within the meaning of the Act, that is, that 51 per cent. or more of its shares are held by Saorstát nationals. But by the selling or the transferring of a certain number of shares to a person who happens not to be a national, if this Bill stood as it was a few hours ago the company ceases to be a Saorstát company; if the shares happen to be transferred by a person living in the Saorstát to his son who happens to be domiciled in Northern Ireland it would mean that suddenly the company would cease to function here. By my amendment, if the company found that the ownership went below 51 per cent. of Saorstát nationals, the company would not be breaking the law by operating for six months, and in the meantime it could arrange first, to sell some of its shares to some other person living in the Saorstát or to come to the Government for a permit. If not, it would be found the company would have to stop business. This will happen in the case of a private company by the death of one of its shareholders who leaves his share to somebody outside this State. Over a thing like that, you would have the business of the company held up and the people thrown out of employment. No serious harm can be done during that six months' time that my amendment would give. In that time, the company must either get a permit from the Minister or arrange for the shares to be bought and transferred to somebody who comes under the Act.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot accept paragraph (a) of the proposed amendment. The position is that any person or group of persons or corporate body out to defeat the purpose of the Act could, by this amendment and operating through a bank, defeat the purpose of the Bill. That is quite possible in my judgment if we accepted this amendment. The second section, paragraph (b) of the proposed amendment, is one I am willing to accept provided the following meets with Senator Douglas's views: "Whenever the issued shares of a body corporate cease to be held in the manner stated in the said paragraph such shares might be deemed to be held in accordance with that paragraph for a period of six months after they have ceased to be so held." That is a draft that we would like to have and it covers all that Senator Douglas wants by his amendment. I suggest that, if that meets with his approval, we accept it.

Comment on this

As regards paragraph (a) of the amendment, which the Minister says he cannot accept, I am afraid this is another case that we have seen where the Government say "Well, accidents must happen. We will carry on our policy; the people who will suffer from our policy are people that we are sorry to see suffer, but they will have to suffer." There is not a shadow of doubt that what Senator Douglas said is correct. There are plenty of shares, personally held in the names of banks as security in an Irish business. It is the banks who are carrying on their business in Ireland and undoubtedly the Bill as it is without this amendment throws a great disqualification on these shares. I really believe that the Minister is resolved on this. He is putting this disqualification on shares not knowing what the effect will be at all. I am a bank director and I carry a lot of overdrafts and securities in my head and if you ask me to-day what is the effect of the Bill on the lending power of the bank and what arrangements would a bank have to make by reason of this Bill I could not tell you and I do not suppose anybody could tell you. The danger is there, and a good many Irish people with money in Irish businesses will find themselves in a difficulty. I suppose this Bill only applies to new businesses.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

I recognise that. If you have a Bill with a blot of that nature, and if you want new businesses to be supported by the banks, surely you should make the shares a first-class security to the banks to any extent? If this section is a disqualification of the shares of a new company that should be accepted by the banks, you are doing a real harm to the new industries. The banks want to see new industries as well as the Minister, and for that reason I think he should seriously consider the question. It is only because he wants to go along a certain line that he will not deal with the danger.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly what would happen with new businesses would be that they would have the worst chance of getting banking accommodation because of the nonacceptance of the amendment, and holders of shares will probably not be able to borrow on them as easily as they should be. It is a distinct disqualification. I strongly support the amendment because it will make the business of promoting new companies better, so far as they are likely to get the accommodation they need.

Comment on this

My feeling about this is that the points we see now are only trivial ones and that others will emerge with experience. No a priori will ever reveal the snags in legislation at the moment. I believe the Bill will only work by being unworkable, in the sense that things will be allowed to drift, and it is only when some political pressure or pull is in operation——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I resent mention of "pull" and the whole attitude of Senator Sir John Keane on this Bill. As in most other things, undoubtedly what he suggests is that it is a Government of politics and pull. I have stood about as much of that as I am going to stand.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I think it would be better if we kept to the section.

Comment on this

I think there is no necessity for being continually offensive

Comment on this

I withdraw. I believe this Bill is capable of being used by certain people for putting pressure on the Government.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

We are dealing with the section now.

Comment on this

I am keeping to the section and my remarks are germane to it. I think the Minister understands how the danger of shares being held by banks will really arise. I suppose he means people who wish to disguise their nationality, shareholders who will get their shares held by the banks as their nominees. I can see a much easier process which would be perfectly within their power, and that is to get a person born in what is Saorstát Eireann, who lives in England, and who has got no affiliation here, to hold these shares. As far as I can see he will be able to do so. I would like the Minister to deal with that point of view.

Comment on this

The point is that we want to know who are the real owners of businesses here. The suggestion that the operation could be carried through by banks on the lines suggested would defeat us in knowing the ownership. Senator Douglas knows that. Senator Sir John Keane and Senator Jameson know that the purpose of the Bill could be torpedoed by such a proceeding. We want to know who owns the shares. If, say, the Bank of Ireland, the National Bank or the Hibernian Bank want to buy fifty thousand shares in an Irish company they can buy them and there will be no objection. They will not have to be licensed. If a bunch of Frenchmen, Italians or anyone else go to the Bank of Ireland to buy fifty thousand pounds' worth of stock in an Irish company in order to get control in the name of the bank, how are we to find the ownership? The secrecy of the banks is well known. We are facing up to realities. If the Seanad does not want the Bill they should have thrown it out. I submit that it is indecent to go on with an amendment like this after passing the Second Reading. I again protest against the attitude exhibited continuously by Senator Sir John Keane. I resent it. I feel that I have as much credit and honour in this country as regards resentment to political pull and to the suggestion of jobbery as anyone. I have been in politics since I was 17 years of age and no one could ever point a finger at me for any political job. I hope Senator Sir John Keane's record is equally clean.

Comment on this

I am sorry that the Minister has allowed resentment at some other remarks to be an opportunity to make the charge that this amendment should not be put down unless I wanted to defeat the purpose of the Bill. That statement is neither accurate nor fair. The position is that this amendment is put down because of a real problem, one which may seriously hurt subscribers for shares, or the possibility of getting subscribers for shares in Irish industries in the future. This is another case of an amendment where it is almost impossible in the open House to get down to brass tacks and to find whether you can get a way out to deal with it. The Minister says there is a possibility of evasion in the section. He thinks the banks here would allow some foreigner to come in and borrow money from them, saying "Will you put these in your name?" I agree that that could happen. I do not agree that it is likely to happen. I say that a way could be found to prevent that happening without exactly accepting the amendment in my name. A way could be found if we could get together.

I am sorry the Minister did not find some proviso that would prevent anything outside the number of shares that a bank could hold. He ignored that entirely and accused me of putting down something that I should not put down after agreeing to the Second Reading. The Minister has not dealt with the real problem. There are not many wealthy people in this country, unfortunately. Most of us put our money into Irish businesses. We cannot do business unless it is possible from time to time to be able to use such securities. If individuals here are to be placed in the position of putting their money in British securities that is all right. The banks will be able to take them. If you put your money into Irish industries there must be an examination of the holding of the shares and the banks will not facilitate you. It is putting the banks in an unfair position. It means that when anyone goes to the Irish market to try to get people to take shares they will be put in an unfair position. There is a way out, but not by my accusing the Minister or by ignoring something. It has to be carefully considered to see if there is not another way. I put down the amendment acting on my own initiative. I sat down during the week-end to try— and it was not an easy task—to draft amendments in the short time that was available. I do not pretend that I found a way out. I put down the amendment because I believe there is a difficulty, and in order that members of the House might find a way out if the Bill is to become law. If we got together, a way would be found. To simply reject the amendment and to leave shareholders in the position that they will not be able to go to the banks and to use shares collaterally the same as English shares are used, is the point the Minister has not dealt with.

Comment on this

What is to prevent ownership of the shares being cloaked and lost in the name of some person who was merely born in Ireland but who does not live here at all? A person who may live in Italy or Timbuctoo can be made the nominee of shares of any syndicate or group who want to disguise their identity. Would the Minister deal with that?

Comment on this

I shall deal with that. The fact of the matter is that there is nothing in an Act of Parliament that cannot be got round by a crook. He may be a crook, grade A, or he may be a guttersnipe, but it takes a crook to get round an Act of Parliament. You can have dummy directors——

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that legal evasion is crookery because it goes on every day?

Comment on this

To me it is crookery.

Comment on this

It goes on every day in relation to income tax.

Comment on this

My standards are different from those of Sir John Keane, evidently. The point is this: are we going to accept it as a fact that because a bank is operating here as an Irish bank, they can operate shares in any way for any person who is a national or otherwise? Does this open a way for non-nationals, people whom we do not want in manufacturing industry here to operate through a bank? Senator Douglas raised two points on that issue. He raised the point that the banks would not do that. Senator Douglas trusts the banks. So do I. I believe we have probably in our banking system here men according to their standing of supreme integrity, perhaps unequalled in any other country in the world; but how are they going to operate if some group outside tries to purchase through them £50,000 worth of shares in a company here? We have been told that the Minister is not the person to show discretion, that a Commission must do all this. I hold that this Bill has got to be applied like every other Act, from a human point of view, intelligently, honestly and with discretion. I hold there is no alternative. Senator Douglas also raised the question of security. I assume these shares will rank as security just as the shares show security to the bank. The shareholders can raise loans in the bank if their shares as collateral show value to the bank and in no other way. I cannot see the point that the Senator pursues so ruthlessly, this question of having the banks in a confidential position to defeat the object of the Bill. I cannot see that it can be argued that they could not defeat the object of the Bill if they wished. I admit that in many ways a Bill admits of evasion, but I have stated that people who evade Acts of Parliament deliberately for profit are crooks, and I stand over that. That is why I cannot accept paragraph (a).

Comment on this

I heard Senator Douglas say that this will handicap people who wish to deposit their shares in the banks for the purpose of getting assistance from the banks for a period. If I follow his argument, it means exactly this: that persons, nationals of this country, will hold shares in a company, and when they want to get shares in another company they deposit their existing shares with the bank——

Comment on this

What is the object of depositing the shares in the bank?

Comment on this

As security to borrow money.

Comment on this

Supposing they deposited their shares in the bank for the purpose of borrowing money, does the bank become the shareholder?

Comment on this

That is the point. I am very glad Senator Farren raised this, because that is the difficulty. I do not think that the Minister appreciates the difficulty that I see, and in his last reply I do not think he saw it.

Comment on this

I fully appreciate the difficulty.

Comment on this

He says these shares will be just as good and that they will be full value as security. I am assuming that they will be value for a reasonable amount. Assume that I hold shares in a company which is brought under the Bill and in which 51 per cent. or 52 per cent. of its capital is held by people who are Saorstát nationals under the terms of the Bill. For the sake of argument, let us assume that 2 per cent. or 3 per cent. of these shares are mine and I want to borrow money on them for any purpose. I take those to the bank and I transfer them into the name, we will say for the sake of argument, of the Bank of Ireland. When I do so, if I am challenged as to whether my company is a Saorstát company or not, I have to prove that the majority of the shareholders of the Bank of Ireland, 51 per cent. of the shareholders of the Bank of Ireland, which then becomes a holding company under this Act, are Saorstát nationals. I say that the bank would decline to go to all that expense for the sake of the £200 or £300 which I required as a loan. They would have to do it at the time I was challenged, and in two months' time the position might change. That is what I want to avoid. That would definitely make it harder for people like myself to subscribe for shares of companies that are started here, because I would not be able to borrow money on those shares. I believe there is a way out of this difficulty.

I propose to have this amendment inserted now, but I do not want to insist on the amendment further than the Report Stage if we can get some other way of dealing with it. I think there are ways which would avoid serious abuses, such as providing that a certain percentage of shares might be held in the name of a bank or some other method which would meet my objection and avoid what the Minister is afraid of. It is suggested that we cannot do this as the Minister fears that the banks might be given power to evade the Act by holding shares for somebody else. I think he would find that it would be a long time before you will get the banks to do anything of the kind. Even if they were approached by some other company to do so, I feel the company would be turned down ruthlessly. As to the argument that there is a big risk involved, I say the risk is less harmful than would be occasioned by the loss of borrowing facilities to the shareholders. If it were a question as between the two, I would prefer to run the other risk. At the same time, I think a way can be found out of this difficulty which will meet my point without running the risk which the Minister says is involved. The Minister has got his legal draftsman and I think he could find some way out of the difficulty. With regard to paragraph (b) I am satisfied with the alteration which the Minister proposes. It goes further than I asked.

Comment on this

May I ask a question in regard to paragraph (a)? A person goes to the bank to borrow money on his shares. The shares are transferred to the name of the bank. Is that not selling the shares to the bank?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

The position with regard to that is that it is in law a transfer to the bank, but the bank merely holds them as collateral. As long as there is proper security the bank will hold these shares. While in a legal sense you have sold to the bank, you have not parted with them entirely. Unless something happens affecting the value of the shares and that you have not got better security, the bank will not decide to sell them. The bank would not sell them to anybody else. If the bank gets a notice with regard to a shareholders' meeting, it sends it on to you. It sends any papers which it gets, and the dividends, on to you.

Comment on this

If I transfer shares to the bank, for the purpose of getting a loan, does not the bank, in law, own these shares?

Comment on this

They have the right to sell them if you do not pay off your debts.

Comment on this

What I want to know is, supposing I have shares and I come to a bank and want an advance on these shares and transfer them to the name of the bank, is the bank the legal owner of these shares?

Comment on this

Not unless they are transferred in the books of the company.

Comment on this

They become legally the property of the bank. That is why it is necessary to do this to give the bank the security. Actually, banks do not sell these shares except they are obliged to realise their securities and they pay you your dividend. They do not want to hold on to the shares themselves.

Comment on this

I should like to make this point. Where does the danger lie if these shares are transferred to the bank? The voting power then lies with the bank. They have got their voting power and there is no danger.

Comment on this

Is it not the fact that the actual transfer of the shares does not take place in the books of the company and therefore the beneficial ownership of the shares in that particular company still rests in the person who is on the books of the company as the owner of the shares? The actual ownership of the shares, from the company's point of view, rests in the holders of the shares. The transfer is a potential transfer——

Comment on this

No, no.

Comment on this

—capable of being executed by way of the shares as collateral on credit issued by them and is not collectable until they come to collect the debt.

Comment on this

The shares must be transferred in the books of the company into the name of the bank.

Comment on this

If they are not transferred into the name of the bank my amendment will not operate. That is why I put this down. If they are not transferred for any reason, then it may not arise at all. It is only where they are transferred that the difficulty arises.

Comment on this

The bank appears as the owner in the company's books.

Comment on this

The Minister is seeing something wrong in this amendment that does not really lie there. The bank will be dealing with a customer —an Irishman—and they will have to satisfy themselves that he is an Irish holder of Irish shares. I cannot see how the bank will deal with anybody else. If he is not an Irishman, the bank will look upon the matter as suspect, and surely the first question they would ask is: "Are these shares in your name, and are you an Irish citizen, and are you one of the people who own these fifty-one or fifty-two of a balance of shares?" He will have to satisfy the bank that he fulfils all these requirements. Otherwise the bank would know that there was a danger. I really think the Minister has not looked into this enough. I am afraid that he thinks we are up to some mischief or another.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

We are not really at all. What we are trying to do really is to see that banking accommodation can be given to holders of shares in these new Irish companies that he is trying to establish, and to make it easy for the banks to give that accommodation.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Supposing a big English bank, such as the Midland, or some of the other large English banks, were to operate in the Saorstát, might not something be effected there?

Comment on this

What we really want to know is this: We feel that we want to know who are the beneficial owners of the shares of any company operating here. This amendment would prevent our knowing that, and I therefore must oppose it.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Shall I put the amendment in toto, or what does the House suggest we should do?

Comment on this

It is in two sections.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the House to decide. With regard to (b) I am quite satisfied with the wording proposed by the Minister, and if the House will allow it I am prepared to take that separately.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I will put the substituted section, as read by the Minister, which is to add a new paragraph as follows:

(b) Whenever the issued shares of a corporate body cease to be held in the manner stated in the said paragraph such shares might be deemed to be held in accordance with that paragraph for a period of six months when they have ceased to be so held.

Comment on this

With regard to paragraph (a), I think it would be better to put it. Since the Minister takes the attitude that nothing can be done, I have no other course.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

The position then is that the second portion of the amendment is as substituted by the Minister and that the first portion of it will stand as on the amendment list?

Comment on this

A point has just occurred to me. On reading this over again, I think I can see a possible way out. I have got here in the amendment "that such shares shall be deemed to be in the beneficial ownership of a national of Saorstát Eireann." Perhaps wording could be arranged to the effect that such shares shall be deemed to be so, provided a certificate is obtained from the bank that they are in the ownership of a national of Saorstát Eireann. All a person would have to do then would be to get a certificate from the bank that he was, in the bank's opinion, a national. That would meet what I want and I suggest that it might be a way of dealing with it. This attitude, however, of the Minister, that he cannot have it at all, leaves me no option but to insist on the amendment in its original form.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the amended form as suggested by Senator Douglas, that is that a certificate from the bank should be obtained.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

We will leave it over then for redrafting until a later stage?

Comment on this

I accept it in principle.

Comment on this

I will withdraw that portion of the amendment then.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I think it would be better to allow the whole amendment to stand over till the Report Stage.

Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment 23:

Section 2, sub-section (3). After the word "who" in line 18 to insert the word "knowingly."

There are several amendments of a similar character. This is an amendment which I think is reasonable. If you look back over a number of similar Acts where regulations had to be carried out and returns to be made, perhaps you will remember that the word "knowingly" had to be inserted by this House on a number of occasions, and generally it was accepted.

I believe there was an amendment in the Dáil to put in the word "wilfully," but I understood that the Government were unwilling to introduce the word "wilfully" because it was difficult to prove that a person wilfully made a false statement. I want to provide something that will enable the court to acquit somebody who may quite inadvertently have made a return which was inaccurate. I think there will be no difficulty in distinguishing between people trying to evade the Act, and those trying to carry it out but who find some difficulty. The very difficulty we find about fixing responsibility and things of that kind is all the more reason for inserting a word like "knowingly."

Comment on this

It strikes me that if this amendment were accepted it would enable any person who wanted to fight a claim to plead that he did not know the regulations. Who is to prove that he did?

Comment on this

This is a matter of a prosecution before a court, and it is entirely for the court to be satisfied whether he knew or not. We had a good many cases here before and they were discussed. If it was a case of the Minister expressing an opinion it would be a different matter, but judges are not in the habit of accepting a man's statement that he did not know. All the circumstances of the case would be taken into consideration. What I want to avoid is the rigid obligation to fix a fine in a perfectly genuine case. If anyone acted as a company secretary or had to make returns he would soon find out how difficult it is. Many of us have to make income tax returns and the officials always make a clear distinction between putting in a false statement and putting in such a statement inadvertently.

Comment on this

I am advised by our legal adviser that there is no necessity for the word "knowingly." If the case goes to the court and these words of the Senator are put in, criminal intent may have to be proven. I understand that that is the legal position so far as the court procedure is concerned. Therefore they object to the word "knowingly" being put in, as it would give a considerable amount of trouble.

Comment on this

If my recollection serves me right this Government is in the same position as the old one was when we were dealing with the same thing. We were told it would not do any harm and we put it in. Nothing happened. If the Minister tells me that this would do harm I will not press it.

Comment on this

It would raise legal difficulties.

Comment on this

Reserving to myself the right to bring the amendment up again on the Report Stage I ask leave to withdraw it now.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

We have now completed half the amendments to be dealt with at this stage. It is twentyfive minutes to eleven o'clock and if we propose to finish to-night we will have to go on until 12.30 or 1 a.m. I think this might be a suitable time to adjourn until to-morrow.

Comment on this

I want to move that we adjourn now.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

If we are to finish we would have to sit, as I say, until 12.30 or 1 o'clock. If we do not intend to finish to-night it would be better to adjourn now and take the rest of the amendments in Committee to-morrow.

Comment on this

I have been the slave of this Bill this week working until past 12 and 1 o'clock each day. If the House decides to adjourn till 11.30 a.m. to-morrow I should like to make an appeal that we should finish the Bill to-morrow.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Not finish the Bill?

Comment on this

Finish the Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Yes, but I do not think that we could take any further stages to-morrow in the circumstances.

Comment on this

Could we not continue and finish the Committee Stage now and take the Report Stage to-morrow?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

There are 25 or 26 more amendments.

Comment on this

Let us continue until 11 o'clock.

Comment on this

Can we have no understanding as to what the Seanad really intends to do about this Bill, because I think we have only been playing with the matter?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I should like to know what the House intends. My own feeling is that we have made some very important amendments already. There is a number of amendments that Senator Staines wants to consider and to make changes in, so that he can bring them up on Report Stage. I think if we go on to-morrow and finish the Committee Stage it would be unfair to take the Report Stage to-morrow.

Comment on this

Can we get any idea when the Seanad, in its wisdom, will consider the advisability of putting the Bill through?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I suggested, at the beginning of the morning session, that in the event of the Committee Stage being carried we would probably have to put off the Report Stage till next Wednesday. That is what I suggested, but, of course, it is for the House to decide.

Comment on this

As far as I, personally, am concerned I am not prepared to rush these amendments to-morrow. I shall come here on Wednesday and give all the time I can. I do not claim to be the slave of the Bill, but I do want to do what I can to secure its necessary amendment.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

The Minister has given a great deal of his time and attention to this measure, but to take the Report Stage to-morrow when there are so many amendments would be quite unreasonable.

Comment on this

I hope the House realises that the Dáil has to meet next Wednesday to ensure the passage of the Finance Bill. It costs a very considerable amount of money to bring the Dáil back. Then the amendments to this Bill will have to be dealt with, which will mean a further meeting of the Dáil.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I pointed out all these difficulties this morning.

Comment on this

If it is the opinion of the House that we cannot take the Report Stage to-morrow I suggest that we meet on Monday.

Comment on this

Monday is a bank holiday.

Comment on this

Could we not meet on Saturday?

Comment on this

I suggest this House meets to-morrow at 11.30, completes the Committee Stage and adjourns until next Tuesday, to take the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am in this difficulty. I withdrew certain amendments and want to get some legal opinion on them. The Minister has his staff and his legal opinion. I would have to put these amendments down again and I may not be able to have the necessary opinion by Tuesday. I could not arrange to have them by to-morrow in any event. The best I can do is to have them by Tuesday.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

We will go on now until 11 o'clock and then we can start talking about this matter again.

Comment on this

I move amendment 24:—

Section 2, sub-section (3). To delete all after the word "exceeding" in line 21 down to the end of the sub-section and to substitute therefor the words "twenty pounds in the case of a first offence and fifty pounds in the case of a second or subsequent offence."

I think the object of this amendment will be pretty clear without very much discussion. I think that £50 is too much for a first offence and £10 for every day of a continuous offence is far too much. There are many people who may have been born outside the country who will find themselves coming under this Act, who did not realise that they did come under it, and who will inadvertently change their method of business or alter their business, and they may commit quite trivial offences. My suggestion is that there should be a fine of £20 for the offence and £50 for the second.

Comment on this

We accept this amendment. Of course, it is perfectly obvious that fines are placed at a maximum amount but that often 10/- and 25/- fines are imposed where there are £20 and £50 penalties.

Comment on this

I move amendment 25:

Section 2, sub-section (4). After the word "section" in line 25 to insert the words "and prima facie evidence of such offence has been given.”

It is quite evident from the discussion on this Bill that there are many pitfalls in it. The sub-section sets out:—

Where a person is charged with having committed an offence under this section, the onus of proving the matters or any of the matters mentioned in paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d), (e), (f), (g) and (h) respectively of sub-section (1) of this section shall lie on the person so charged, and until the contrary is proved it shall be assumed that none of those matters is applicable in relation to the act alleged to constitute such offence.

I think that very unfair, and the object of the amendment is to insert the words "and prima facie evidence of such offence has been given.” That will ensure that there shall be prima facie evidence, at least, before a man is charged, and that the onus should not be placed on him of proving his innocence. Amendment No. 26 works in with it:

Section 2, sub-section (4). To delete all after the word "charged" in line 28 down to the end of the sub-section.

And I think the Minister ought to accept both amendments.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Sufficient for the day is the evil thereof. No. 25 will be enough for the moment.

Comment on this

I think the amendment is unnecessary, because the Minister would have to prove that the person had committed an offence. With regard to the second one, it merely amplifies and explains the earlier words throwing the onus of proof on the person charged. I am not very much wedded to it, one way or the other, but I think the drafting of the section as it is is quite all right and will meet the purpose.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, I would urge the Minister to accept the first one, because there are people who, reading this, have been rather worried about the position and it would make it much clearer. Probably the Minister's advice is right, but I am inclined to think that the strict reading of this means that, if a person is charged, it is sufficient for him to be charged with an offence under the Act, and the onus of proving that he is exempt is thrown on the person charged and it might mean in some cases a considerable amount. I am perfectly certain that it will be the intention of any reasonable Government to give prima facie evidence, but there is nothing fundamental in it. It would, however, clarify the position and I do not see any harm in it.

Comment on this

I do not see how the Minister could give prima facie evidence. I am not a lawyer, but I think there is considerable difficulty in the Minister giving evidence.

Comment on this

It is not the Minister; it is the State Solicitor or whoever brings the charge.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister would really be expected, according to the strict terms of the Act, to do it. I am advised legally that it is not necessary, but if the House insists on it, of course, the House will insist upon it.

Comment on this

Senator Brown is not well and I am sorry he is not able to be here. He was the only person with whom I discussed this, but I gathered that the procedure, in effect, would be that a charge would be made, not by the Minister personally, or even by his Department, but through the ordinary operation of the law, at the instance of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and, if you put in the words "and prima facie evidence is given,” it means that the judge, before asking the defendant to accept the onus of proof provided in the Act, will simply satisfy himself that a prima facie case has been made. The onus of proof will then be on the person charged. If you do not put them in, they would have to come down with full evidence prepared immediately. That might mean a considerable amount of expense and, for that reason, I think we should put these words in.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 15
·
Níl 11
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move amendment 26:—

Section 2, sub-section (4). To delete all after the word "charged" in line 28 down to the end of the sub-section.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Senator Staines really understands the meaning of the amendment. It does not alter the effect of the sub-section; the effect is just the same. If the Senator is very keen on having the words deleted, well and good. They merely amplify and explain earlier words.

Comment on this

I think the Senator would be well advised not to press the amendment.

Comment on this

In the circumstances perhaps it is as well to withdraw it.

Comment on this

We are not worried whether the amendment is pressed or not.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 27:—

Section 2. To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(5) Where a body corporate is charged with having committed an offence under this section, it shall be sufficient for such body corporate to prove that it has received statements from the requisite number of its shareholders that they are nationals of Saorstát Eireann within the meaning of this Act and no body corporate shall be held responsible for any inaccurate information supplied by its shareholders.

I do not know that this amendment is satisfactorily worded. It tries to meet a possible difficulty. As the Bill stands, the person who makes a return could be held responsible. I do not know whether such a person should be held responsible for the information which he gives. I want to provide that if a body corporate gives the information it should be quite sufficient for them to prove that they got that information direct from their shareholders and they should not be held liable for any possible mis-statement as to the place of birth of their shareholders.

Comment on this

We feel that our hands should not be tied if any question were raised as to whether replies of shareholders could be accepted as complete proof in all cases of whether or not a business was owned by nationals. For that reason we feel that this amendment might, on occassions, perhaps not very frequently, tie our hands in getting the information desired and, in the circumstances, it cannot be accepted.

Comment on this

Has the Minister no other suggestion that would meet the difficulty? This affects existing companies. If you look at the Bill you will find that questions can be addressed to existing companies and they may be obliged to supply information. You are putting a very big charge indeed on some of the larger companies here and their secretaries when you ask them to supply information with regard to the nationality, the place of residence or the place of birth of their shareholders. Take Messrs. Guinness as an example. Such a question might be addressed to them. They are a public company and it is well known that their shares are held all over the world; there are large numbers of shareholders in Ireland and in other places. The Minister possibly will want to know the position with regard to Messrs. Guinness.

I cannot help the feeling that you are almost putting them in an intolerable position in making them responsible. I cannot think of a way out of it at the moment but there is probably some way. I see now that the Minister is afraid that some dishonest people may take advantage of it and have an arrangement to give a false statement. But is the safeguard any good? Because if he will go on to a section later on he will find that the Minister has power to address any shareholder in a company direct and to ask him his nationality. All I am wanting to do is to safeguard the secretary of the company. The secretary must give the address and the names. If he does not give them the Minister can get them anyway in the office. If there is a suspicion in the mind of the Minister that evasion has taken place he can address a question to the persons concerned and if he doubts the answer he can challenge that person in the courts with regard to the information.

Comment on this

Frankly, I cannot see how Senator Douglas argues that I can take up with any company such as Messrs. Guinness. Everything in this Bill applies to the licensing.

Comment on this

What about section 10?

Comment on this

On the question of licensing the sections of the Bill are in the main referring entirely to those companies that are going to come on in the future.

Comment on this

Not at all. The position is that Section 10 provides for putting the question to the manufacturers. My point is that this is in relation to companies now existing or afterwards. A large number of the questions apply to existing companies and fairly large companies may have these questions addressed to them.

Comment on this

In the absence of fraud, this section is unnecessary, but the amendment of the section proposed by Senator Douglas would facilitate fraud on the part of the Secretary of the company. I am sure Senator Douglas does not intend that. It would be quite possible for a fraudulent secretary to say that he had received information from the shareholders although the reception of that information may be in pursuance of a pre-arranged plan. That is the reason why I think Senator Douglas's amendment is not reasonable and does not carry out the intention he has in his mind. If there is any fraud the secretary is protected by the Bill as it is.

Comment on this

Am I to take it as Senator Comyn's opinion that, suppose a secretary sends in a false statement or an inaccurate statement with regard to the nationality of a person, and then if he goes to the courts and says that that was the information given, the court will hold that he has not committed a technical offence under the Bill?

Comment on this

I would say not.

Comment on this

Well I have the greatest respect for Senator Comyn's opinion but I have the greatest doubt that what he says is the case. I should like to draw attention to Section 10, paragraph 4, with regard to fraud. Senators will find there that "the Minister may, from time to time, serve a notice in writing on any persons who hold any shares in a body corporate carrying on a business to which this section applies requiring such persons within twenty-eight days after the service of such notice to send to the Minister a return...." I suggest that that is a safeguard to the Minister against fraud. If the company sends in the names, these names can be checked at the company's office, and if the Minister has any doubt about the accuracy of that information he can take steps in court and he can prosecute them for giving wrong information.

Comment on this

I submit again that whilst the companies can be asked for information under the Bill just as they are asked for a good deal of information to-day there is no intention in this Bill to interfere with any company operating before June 1st, 1932.

Comment on this

They can be asked?

Comment on this

They can, but they do not require a licence at all so long as they are operating before the 1st June, 1932. The circumstances that Senator Douglas suggests could happen should not in fact happen.

Comment on this

May I put a problematical case? A company is in existence on June 1st and it decides to go into another line of business, a very probable thing to happen. The Ministry is to find out whether they are entitled to do that under permit or not and questions are sent to the company. The company must give that information. If that company happens to hold any shares in any subsidiary company, another matter may arise at any moment. The question will arise whether the company is a national company. The company would have to get information that it is; they would have to get a statement, if you like, in writing. What will happen in the larger companies is that the secretary will send out a questionnaire to each shareholder as to whether the person was born in the Saorstát. I do not want to have fraud in any way but here is a difficulty that must be faced.

Comment on this

It raises the same question as the amendment dealing with "knowingly."

Comment on this

I would suggest that if Senator Douglas withdraws this we might meet it by a sub-section of Section 10 or we might consider that we might accept it up to a certain point. I should like in the morning to go into it as regards whether we can accept it in that form or whether it can be appropriately met under a sub-section of Section 10.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

That amendment is adjourned to the Report Stage.

Comment on this