We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Business. - Recent Actions of the Executive Council.

Contributions 1–106 of 211. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I beg to move:—

That the Seanad is of opinion that the recent actions of the Executive Council purporting to be for the preservation of public peace and order have not been justified.

It will soon be 12 years since I first had the honour to become a member of this House and, during all that period I have never felt a greater sense of responsibility in rising to address the Seanad than I have on this occasion. Hitherto I have hesitated to take part in debates which dealt with the question of public security. I have felt it was rather the function of those who had taken an active part in the deliverance, the political deliverance, of the State, who had fought together in that cause, to deal with that special aspect of our domestic affairs—that which concerned public order. I felt that I personally had no national record, as generally understood. I was far away from the Post Office in 1916. I also felt that it would be rather in the nature of presumption for one who is reputed—and I stress the word "reputed," because I do not accept the reputation—to be a West Briton to interfere in these affairs. But times have changed and I feel that neutrals have now a duty to speak.

Senators may remember the opening words of that great Irishman who, I suggest, would be called a West Briton, too—Edmund Burke—in his opening discourse on "The Cause of Our Present Discontents." Of course, it is a classic paper. He begins by saying that it is an undertaking to some degree of delicacy to examine into the causes of public disorders, and he goes on to say that there are times of tumult and disorder when our law invests every man in some form with the authority of a magistrate. I feel such an occasion exists now. We all have a duty to perform and we all are invested in some form with the authority of a magistrate at this crisis. I feel, and I hope Senators will agree, that a special responsibility rests upon this House and every one of its members at the present time far different to that of our individual responsibility as citizens. We are an integral, although a minor part, of that sovereign power to which even the Government is subordinate. The chief part of that sovereign power is now in session and it is especially our duty to voice whatever views we may have with regard to the crisis—and I say deliberately the crisis—that now faces this country. It will be my aim to open this debate—I cannot say how it will be maintained—on what I conceive to be a proper level, to lift it out of the purlieus of Party politics, because, after all, public security is not a Party question; it is, above all, a national issue; it is the basis of all government; it over-rides all material considerations and, without public security, you talk in vain of such matters as economic betterment.

I would further remark that my motion is not confined merely to the happenings of the last few weeks or, more especially, the happenings of Sunday, 13th August. My motion is, I suggest, the logical outcome of certain policies which have been pursued ever since the Treaty and it is my hope that I may be allowed to examine the origins of these policies, for on them my case rests. I use this method of discovery by motion largely at the suggestion of the Minister for Finance. When this matter was debated, incidentally you might say, last week on a Bill, one of the provisions of which was to reduce the pay of the Civic Guards, the Minister was not very informative. Perhaps he was not prepared. Among other things he told the House that he did not know what was the rate of pay given to these specially recruited and armed Gárdaí. He said that no doubt the information was in his Department, but he did not know it himself. He further suggested that if this matter were to be raised in all its aspects it should be done by motion when the proper Minister would be present. I am glad to see the Minister is present to-day. I claim that this motion is neither wanton nor is it mischievous. It is the only way we have of raising this matter in a proper, responsible way.

The origin of this trouble, I suggest, began with what was called, and what was literally described as, the "Cease Fire" in 1923, because in the light of subsequent events it seemed to be nothing more than a ceasing of fire. You might call it a truce or an armistice. It was in no sense a surrender. The organisation behind those forces that ceased fire has continued in some form or other in existence to the present day and I suggest that, although there is not open action, it is there in being and to all intents and purposes as active as it was the day after it ceased fire in 1923. The defeated army—we may call it defeated —remained in being and it exists to-day in open defiance of authority. No purpose is to be served by trying to apportion the blame, but I feel sure many of us agree that it would be better to have ensured complete surrender and the delivery of all arms even if it had meant further damage and bloodshed. I might say it is the continuance of that body in existence that is in a large way responsible for the terrorism of juries and incidents like we saw yesterday when peaceable citizens were not allowed to carry on their trade without armed interference, and other deplorable incidents of which, I think, we might almost now in the legal term claim to have judicial knowledge.

I think it is only fair to say that the late Government did do all they could to repair this initial blunder. When I say this initial blunder I mean that they ought to have made a clean job of armed resistance in 1923. It never tolerated that body, it never countenanced it, it did its best to prevent their illegal activities, to discover their assemblies, and, as we know, when 1931 came about, and that body, or some fellowship of it—because I do not profess to know the under-world of illegal bodies or assemblies—became specially active, the Government came to Parliament and sought for and obtained special powers. I do not want to repeat it, but I do suggest that these special powers have had a very strange use in recent weeks.

Comment on this

Strange abuse.

Comment on this

Or, as my friend says, strange abuse. I do not blame any parties for inconsistency. I think inconsistency must almost be regarded as a Christian virtue. It is the duty of everybody when he finds he is wrong to change his mind. But I would emphasise this. There is now no conclusive proof that coercion is an instrument of alien rule, but rather that if you are ever to have government in face of certain facts and certain people you will have to have coercion. So do not let us any longer identify coercion with imperialism, or with that kind of thing. I think it is not without humour to realise that, used in the present instance, coercion was directed against citizens whose aims are constitutional and loyal. When the present Government came into office in 1932 the attitude of the governing authorities towards these illegal bodies was reversed. They treated them with a certain supine complacency. They did not say, as some one said in the past, that Ireland could only be governed and brought to peace by 50 years of resolute government. We all know that resolute government was only applied, in the past, in fits and starts. We remember the position created, when unfortunately one Government that was resolute was followed by successors who were irresolute. I am afraid this is a case of history repeating itself.

Various reasons have been suggested for this reversal and complete change of policy. We all understand, of course, that Governments change their policy on economic and social matters and matters of that kind. But it is unusual in any settled State to find any Government completely reversing the policy of its predecessors upon such fundamental questions as that of law and order. One suggestion is that radical philosophy which says: "Trust the people and they will behave properly—they will not let you down." Others may suggest indifference, others again may suggest inability to deal with the situation, others again may sympathise with the cause sought to be revived. I am not going to suggest which of these is right, but I suggest probably it is a mixture of all. But it does seem, in their present policy, as if the Government is unconsciously following perhaps on the road of the suggestion in another sphere made by Senator Connolly at the Economic Conference that we should not be afraid to face up to methods however orthodox or unorthodox in order to solve our present difficulties. Anyhow, as a result of this policy arms are held and are openly flaunted.

Only recently the Minister for Justice was asked a question, and he never denied the truth of it, that 70 armed men took possession of a house in West Cork and carried out week-end manoeuvres there. Nothing as far as we know was done. The Minister said it was an isolated occurrence. We would like to hear if it has been possible to discover the names of any of those who took part in the manoeuvres. There is another matter. I shall be glad if the Minister will deny that there has been an armed camp formed in the last fortnight on a hillside outside this city and within 20 minutes or half an hour's motor drive from where we stand to-day. In all these matters, as far as we know, there have been no trials and no convictions. We have had the case of kidnapping in County Cork of a creamery manager which never came to trial. Then, again, we have the O'Connor case; the Minister will know what I mean by that. We can take an accumulation of instances which show that the Government's authority is weakening in political matters. With this mass of evidence I do not think it is fair merely to ask one to substantiate charges made against the Government. The fact remains that the public are uneasy and the fact remains that in all cases where the evidence bears a political aspect the ordinary rules of law would not prevail.

Now, I would like to deal with the argument advanced in defence of this policy, on the ground of radical philosophy, on the doctrine of "trust the people and they will not let you down." It is said that there have been always arms in the country and nothing much ever happened. I do not suppose the Government will put forward the argument seriously that there have been always arms in the country and that there has been very often coercion. I do not think that you can claim with pride that the possession of arms has had a very noble record. I rather suggest that it comes badly from those who resent what I might call the portrayal of the burlesque in our Irish life to put forward seriously any argument of that kind, namely, that because we always had arms it does not matter if we still have them. More seriously, I think, we should take the possible defence that the Government could put forward that the country is quiet and that it is a contrast to what it was under the old régime. I admit that judging by statistics of crime the country is quiet. I think it is a thing we should be proud of that I can stand up here and say what I do with a sense of security, and that others in the Dáil may say much harder things than I would ever dare to say and go about their business unmolested. That would not have happened 15 years ago.

I also admit that there is a very considerable measure of liberty in this country, compared with many other countries, and that in non-political cases the rule of law operates, but I would ask you to realise how great the limitation is, that limitation of political crime, when within the orbit of political crime you have every conceivable outrage—murder, kidnapping and all that—and if the rule of law does not safeguard you in that respect, I suggest the rule of law is very imperfect. We had only yesterday a case which I suppose has a political tinge where a foreign product was seized and destroyed. I do not know the details exactly, but there was an outrage against a foreign product by armed men. They, presumably, will be protected against the rule of law on account of its political aspect. It seems to me that such a peace rests upon a totally false foundation. Sicily was peaceful so long as the Maffia were not molested, and I would suggest this country is peaceful so long as certain armed forces are tolerated and allowed to pursue their way. I admit that in trying to reduce this matter to first principles I, perhaps, suffer from the limitations of a too rigid education in an Anglo-Saxon institution. I should not be at all surprised to hear that there is some rational defence for the two-army policy and that you can get a settled Government in the presence of a regular army and an irregular army. If that is so, perhaps the Minister will instruct us as to the technique, and we may also have the assistance of one trained in the law like Senator Comyn, who, I understand, supports the policy. In view of his activities in the past, I should also like to have the assistance in this matter of Senator Johnson.

Searching and groping as fully as I can in this matter, the only similar instance of the two army policy I have been able to discover in recent times is that of Germany. I understand they have a regular army limited by the Treaty of Versailles and that they have a political army—divided into the various categories of brown shirts, storm troops and so on. I do not imagine that the Minister will call to his support this idea of a two army policy, but there is an interpretation of this whole policy which suggests itself to a certain section, and I suggest the thinking section, of the population —that it is based upon political expediency, that, finding it impossible or being unwilling to assert the rule of law, the Government has to seek peace by the sacrifice of constitutional principles. After all two armies are more likely to provoke disorder than one. It takes two to make a fight, so that when you have only one army, even if it is irregular, it is better than to have two peaceful armies both irregular, but really, in the circumstances, the Government, having got things into the position in which they are, in a way I cannot blame them. After all peace is more important than principle and so long as the Government can maintain peace on that basis, I think we shall be glad to have it so. It shall be my aim later on to show that such a peace is illusory and cannot be maintained. Following on that doctrine, that suggestion I make of expediency, we have the extraordinary result, this extraordinary use of coercion under conditions that are brimful of inconsistencies.

I should like now to deal with certain practical aspects of this policy, of what I call peace by expediency, which I do not condemn provided it can be maintained. Repression, right or wrong, is better than disorder, but I should like if the Minister would tell us specifically why he found it necessary the week before last to reinforce the civil power, and why he did not use the Army for that purpose because, after all, in all civilised countries the reinforcement of the civil by the military power is the established practice. If it unfortunately becomes necessary for Irishmen to shoot at one another why is it better for recruits—when I say recruits I mean men enlisted within 48 hours— why is it better for them to shoot than men who are disciplined and trained to the use of arms? If I might now proceed on suggestion in the absence of information, I would suggest this: I suggest that in recruiting this special force to reinforce the civil power ordinary methods of recruiting were not followed; that Government supporters were enlisted; that the special help of a prominent member of the Dáil was sought; that these men were uniformed and given arms within at least 48 hours of their enlistment; that they were put to hold key positions in Government buildings, and that they were paid at least 10/- a week more than the regular Gárda of equal rank and status. I asked for the Minister's categorical correction of these statements and not merely for their general contradiction.

Now I pass to the consequences of what I would call this two-army imbroglio. A large section of the people believe, rightly or wrongly, that this irregular force is a party army which, when the time comes, or the Government is no longer complacent, will usurp the functions of Government and take into their hands the rule of law. I must say that many of us feel that there is a certain justification for that belief. We have an extraordinary coincidence between the claims of this body, through their Press organ, and the performances of the Government. We have the claim made that "Superintendent Neligan must go," and Superintendent Neligan goes; that "O'Duffy must go" and O'Duffy goes; that the National Guard must be proscribed, curtailed or dealt with and that is done. We have the extraordinary fact that those who hitherto held under permit arms for their personal protection are now being disarmed.

As I say, I have got no proof that fact follows from cause; whether it is a case of post hoc or propter hoc. The ordinary citizen is not logical. Perhaps it is just as well he is not. But he feels these things and he sees them. Whether his belief is right or not, I think, prima facie, he forms his views with considerable justification. That is what the Minister has to deal with— not the legalities of the situation, but how people feel. The will of the people is an extraordinarily difficult thing to gauge. Public tempers and mass tempers are not fixed things based on law but on actions and methods of the most illogical kind. The Government's job is to deal with these curious feelings that have no logical basis.

With regard to the withdrawal of permits, the stock-taking defence does seem very shallow. If the Government want to know about those arms why not let their agents see them? Why not say to A, B or C: "You have a gun with a permit, let us see it," and having seen it, is not that sufficient? Why withdraw them, and, for an indefinite period, leave these poor people defenceless? I say that there is this advantage in that policy, that it immeasurably deepens the responsibility of the Government. If anything was to happen to these people who have, by Government action, been disarmed, I shudder to think what would be the effect of the indignation on public opinion. To that extent, the Government would be definitely guilty if anything of that kind was to happen. Pray God it will not.

What is the basis of government in the last resort? We have heard a lot of talk in the past about the will of the people. I suggest that the basis of government is not the will of the people, nor is it obedience to constituted authority, but it is justice of administration. If the will of the people was to say that everybody who opposed them should be murdered, that would not be government. There must all along be justice in administration, or else it is not the will of the people. A Government which does not rest on justice cannot claim the sanctions of authority. The President himself has spoken on those questions. Speaking in the Dáil on the Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill on 3rd May, 1933, he said:—"When that is so"—that is, the removal of the Oath —"I say there is no excuse for anybody to prepare in any way for the use of force. When people are denied legitimate rights there may be some excuse for it." So government certainly depends upon allowing the people to exercise their constitutional rights. Any Government which denies these rights cannot claim the sanctions of authority.

Apply that to the position brought about by the National Guard. I do not stand here to defend the National Guard, but I say that the National Guard is the expression of conditions that the Government have created. The Government have allowed an armed force to exist in our midst. As the result of that policy the rule of law in matters political does not apply. In pursuance of that policy arms have been withdrawn from individuals. To that extent, I say the sanctions of the Government have been imperilled; that no Government could be surprised if, under these circumstances, citizens seek to protect the Constitution, to protect the right of free speech and to protect themselves. These, I suggest, are the reasons, the origins, call it whatever you like, of this force which is set up in opposition, you might say, to irregular authority. That force professes to be unarmed, loyal to the Constitution, and to seek to secure the right of free speech. It is eminently a force of which the philosophical Radical should approve. But, in seeking to justify their policy towards that force, I notice the Government give extracts from a report made last September, I think, by the former Commissioner, General O'Duffy. The Government have promised the whole report. I am subject to correction, but I do not think that whole report has been published yet. Incidentally I should like to comment on this practice of the Government in using selected documents to support their case. It is not the first occasion on which it has happened. I suggest that, if it is necessary to instruct the public on a matter, all connected documents should be published and not merely extracts from one document. If we have a confidential report by the chief of police on the aims and ambitions of one body, I think we have every right to ask for all the reports that the police from time to time have given on those armed bodies. I think it is very wrong to select reports on an institution that at least professes to be loyal and say nothing whatever about the many reports that there must have been on institutions whose aims are subversive. Even from the extract from this report we see here: "Should it at any time desire"—that is referring to the A.C.A., as it was at the time—"to adopt other than constitutional methods it can, without doubt, lay hands on a sufficient quantity of arms and ammunition to render it a very formidable insurrectionary force ..." I suggest that if we in this House desired to be unconstitutional we could very easily lay our hands on a quantity of arms.

That hypothetical thing is no justification for the action which the Government have taken. It leads almost to an element of comedy in public life when you see an armed force continue unmolested and you see the coercion which the present Government holds by its might now used to suppress a body whose aims are loyal and thoroughly constitutional. It almost has a parallel in what happened in Ulster in the years before the Treaty, when they said Lord Carson was a rebel and he said:—

"I am not a rebel; I am only taking up arms to preserve the Constitution and the Empire."

That seems to have a parallel in the action of the Government.

Comment on this

He also said he was a rebel.

Comment on this

The Senator can deal with that more fully when he takes part in the debate. So you have the position where citizens of this country cannot proceed to do reverence to their illustrious dead unless they proceed individually and by permit. They cannot proceed in organised bodies or with that demonstration that is usually associated with such occasions. It would seem strange if, in order to preserve peace, it had been necessary to prohibit, say, a ceremony like that held on Armistice Day in Whitehall. It looks as if we had reached a state of things where the observance of Treaty Day would be a more fertile source of disorder than that of Armistice Day.

Is it reasonable to expect men of pride and spirit, men who had done valiant service in the fight for the country's independence, who in civil war had been in opposition to those now tolerated as an armed body—I say that it is not human and reasonable to expect that these people will sit with folded arms trusting in a Government which has departed from the proved and accepted methods of sound government. Whether the Government likes it or not, such men will take steps to secure their own protection. If they cannot do so above ground they will do so by other means. They will not stand like a sheep dumb before its shearer or as the condemned man awaiting the hangman's rope. This is the rock, the rock of human nature on which the whole Government policy must stand or fall. I say deliberately that, in so far as the Government condones and tolerates illegality in one section of the people and withdraws all means of personal protection from their political opponents, to such an extent is the Government itself directly responsible for the activities by which unprotected citizens may seek to protect themselves. I do not stand here to condone or to excuse resistance to Government. I wish to state what seems to be irresistible and I do say that when Government departs from rules tried and proved by the experience of ages it enters a sphere—and Irishmen ought to know this well—where Government becomes partial and unjust and the whole foundation on which obedience rests is imperilled. We are in that position to-day. For this reason, I say that the Government is directly responsible for the movement which finds expression to-day in the terms of the National Guard.

I have little more to say. I have tried to the best of my ability to state the case clearly and axiomatically without Party bias, with full regard to the dignity, duty and responsibility of this House. It has been my aim to show that the laws of government rest on rules as inexorable as those of life or nature. I ask you to say that any Government that tries to serve two masters, one the Constitution and the other a Party junta, is doing a great and grave disservice to its country. It may buy a temporary respite by means of coercion, but in the long run it will give birth to strife and disorder, even to the most tragic of all conflicts, that of civil war. For a time such a Government may fool the people, but, as Abraham Lincoln says, "You cannot fool all the people all the time," and sooner or later, but possibly not before it is too late, ignominy and failure will be its fate and justly so, for it will have put Party before principle, it will have sacrificed national interests to expediency, it will have forsaken the hard and narrow road, shirked the truth and sinned against the light.

Comment on this

I beg to second the motion. I wish to ask the Minister a question. Is it true that, at the present time, agents provocateurs are employed by the Government and paid by the Government in certain places to provoke disturbances by attacks on men who are acting legally? I will give as a practical illustration what happened in the town of Wexford. On Sunday last a number of men were going on a parade, if you like to call it that. They were walking along the street. They were not breaking any law or disturbing the peace in any way. They were not interfered with by the forces of the State. They were not told by the Civic Guards, who were present, that they were breaking the law or interfering with anybody; but they were met by a man who had with him an organised mob who attacked these men and created a very grave breach of the peace. The man in question was associated prominently with the Irregulars during the civil war. I wish to have a direct answer from the Minister to my question. Is that man paid as a secret service agent in that place? Is he paid by the State? I have nothing else to add except that I approve of all Senator Sir John Keane has said, and I beg to second the motion.

Comment on this

Senator Sir John Keane started off by telling us that one time in his fertile career he was designated as a West Briton. I wonder what will he be designated as after his speech here to-day? I wonder for what reason did Senator Sir John Keane bring forward this Resolution? Perhaps it was, as he told us here on a quite recent occasion, to satisfy his followers. Perhaps it is his modesty which, I understand, those who are in close proximity to him tell us is such that sometimes he is impetuous and his friends find it very difficult to support him. Or perhaps it is to satisfy the appetites of the readers of the London Sunday Times, supplied with the elaborate report of the speech which we have just heard by the Irish correspondent with whom, I understand, Senator Sir John Keane has more than a nodding acquaintance. After the discussion which took place quite recently in the Seanad in reference to the action of the Government, this is, in my opinion, a very ill-judged and unwise Resolution. In so far as the Seanad is concerned, in my opinion, they should let it rest where it rested last week and, if the action of the Government is to be dealt with, let it be dealt with by the members of the Dáil who are, unlike the Seanad, the direct representatives of the people. In my opinion, the efforts of Senators would be better and more profitably spent in the interests of the country, looking, perhaps, after its financial outlook, than turning the Seanad, as it has been turned to-day, into a platform for party warfare.

Goodness knows, we have external trouble sufficient to contend with without the Seanad being asked to pass a Resolution which, in my opinion, will extend our internal troubles and create a great deal more bitterness amongst our people. Senator Sir John Keane's motion refers to the recent action of the Executive Council, and if the Senator had confined himself to the recent action of the Government one could understand it, but he has scavenged up everything that has taken place in this country for the past 14 or 15 years. With the utmost respect, sir, I thought that at one time you would have confined him to the motion. As the recent action of the Government had already been raised, I should have liked to leave the matter where it rested last week, but I shall endeavour to deal briefly and from my point of view with the recent action of the Government, and to do so I may have to go back a little to show that our latest trouble in this country has arisen by reason of a body of men, legitimately, no doubt, setting themselves up as an Army Comrades' Association, not in the least disguising the fact that they were supporting a certain political party, not disguising the fact that they were antagonistic to the Government and were endeavouring, constitutionally, I admit, to overthrow the Government and not disguising the fact that they were set up to counteract the activities of the I.R.A.. Somehow or another, for a reason which it is quite easy to understand, they made very little headway. In other words, they cut very little ice. The people looked on them with amusement and did not take them seriously.

Comment on this

That is only your opinion.

Comment on this

With respect, you can express yours afterwards, but, lo! we then find middle-aged women aping the principles of Nell Gwynn—"Won't you buy my pretty flowers," and pinning their pretty flowers on the breasts of sedate Senators, and we have also the inevitable photograph lest such a wonderful display of Irish patriotism be lost forever. Before I was knocked off my stroke by the lady Senator, I was saying that the people looked with amusement at the Army Comrades, when, lo! a star appeared on the political horizon, a Daniel come amongst them, and they elected as their chief, General O'Duffy, and changed their name, which is usually done in all decaying organisations, to the National Guard.

Comment on this

I should like to ask if there is a quorum in the House.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Yes, Senator.

Comment on this

Through you, sir, I might suggest to Senator Colonel Moore, that it is an extraordinary habit of some Senators in this House that when they make a speech they clear off immediately. Whether it is for refreshment, for air, or to receive the congratulations of their friends, I do not know, but perhaps that is the cause of the House being so thin. One could understand if the National Guard was set up to look after national principles, as in the time of conscription and when we were ruled by another power, but now that we have a Government of our own——

Comment on this

And such a Government.

Comment on this

Thank God you are not in it. Now that we have a Government of our own, in my opinion the title of National Guard belongs to the Government and to the Government alone. In my judgment, if it were only for the reason of having set up a National Guard, the recent action of the Government was justified. What is the Government of a country for? What is the National Army for? What are the Guards for?

Comment on this

That is what we want to know.

Comment on this

Would you try to keep your little tongue quiet? I assure you that if you let me alone I will let you alone and be glad to let you alone. As I was saying when I was lovingly interrupted by Senator Miss Browne, what are the Guards for? I am now going to make a statement with which perhaps a great many people will disagree. Is there a single sane man in this country who, in the highest flights of imagination, will say that the National Army are to fight or beat any of the great powers on the continent? Are the National Army not, and if they are not should they not be, the real National Guard of this country to protect it from civil and armed riot and, if necessary, to help the Gárda Síochána to protect the law-abiding citizens from the attentions of the gunman, the bully, the blackguard and the thief? I ask this in all reason: why should any body of men set themselves up as a National Guard to usurp the powers of the Government? Now if, when the late Government were in power, a body of men set themselves up as a National Guard with the set purpose of overthrowing the Government, and if that Government came to this House and asked, as they did ask, for a Coercion Bill or a Public Safety Bill, would they not get it, and would not General O'Duffy, the late Commissioner of the Guards, gallantly carry out the orders of the Executive in doing away with such a National Guard?

Senator Sir John Keane made reference to paying honour to the illustrious dead. It has become the fashion in recent years with new organisations and with decaying old organisations, with the object of keeping in the limelight, and to show their superior and superfine patriotism, to rattle the bones of the dead.

Comment on this

What about Wolfe Tone?

Comment on this

Other Senators like myself, may have received this invitation:—

"The National Guard: Office of the Director General, 5 Parnell Square, Dublin, 31st July, 1933.

A Chara,—I am instructed by General O'Duffy to invite you to participate in the parade in honour of Griffith, Collins and O'Higgins, which will take place in Dublin on Sunday, 13th August. The route of the parade, which will commence at 3 p.m., will be from the neighbourhood of St. Stephen's Green, past the Cenotaph to the cemetery at Glasnevin. A special place in the parade will be reserved for public representatives."

That is signed by "E.J. Cronin, Comdt., Secretary."

Comment on this

Did you accept?

Comment on this

That is my business and not yours.

Comment on this

I did not get one to Bodenstown.

Comment on this

I do not know what Senator Mrs. Costello's opinion, if she received an invitation, may be, but my opinion is that the issuing of that invitation to Senators was a most infernal piece of cheek and impudence —to ask Senators to take part in a party display. Just imagine expecting old and middle-aged Senators to trot through the streets of Dublin in a parade and to walk under the banners of the boys and girls of the young brigade. Why, it is enough to make Griffith, Collins and Kevin O'Higgins turn in their graves, to see their names used for party purposes. It is enough, in particular, to make Kevin O'Higgins turn in his grave, to see many of those leaders who, shortly before the unfortunate man was murdered, he dismissed from the Army as being mutineers, mar dh'eadh, placing wreaths on his grave to his memory. These are the leaders who now, as in the past, are leading the young men of Ireland astray.

[The Leas-Chathaoirleach took the Chair.]

If ever there was a time in the history of this country when the people, and particularly the young people of this country, should beware of some of their leaders, it is the present time. I remember, as I stated here once before, that some of those leaders who are pretending now that they abhor the gun, got the young men of this country into their net and into secret societies, and made them swear an oath to do deeds, dreadful deeds——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it right that the Senator should charge men with having compelled young men to take an oath to do dreadful deeds?

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

He is not charging them. He is making a statement.

Comment on this

Senator Milroy has a nasty little habit of interjection when the truth is being sent home. As I was saying—I defy contradiction from Senator Milroy or any man—these leaders led the young men of Ireland into their net, made them take an oath to do deeds of blood and fire, impregnated their young minds with diabolical designs which warped their minds and have warped them even to this day, such as the poisoning of the drinking wells of this country. These are the men who are now setting themselves up on a pinnacle of patriotism. I have spoken strongly——

Comment on this

And falsely.

Comment on this

I have spoken strongly——

Comment on this

And falsely.

Comment on this

There is always in this country a scavenger connected with every party.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator should not be personal.

Comment on this

He has described himself.

Comment on this

I have not been personal up to this. If you, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, think I have not properly described what I have described I withdraw. My answer to the resolution which Senator Sir John Keane has proposed is that the Government would not be a Government, would not command the respect of anyone if they were incapable, afraid or ashamed to deal with any dangerous organisations which may be set up in this country. If we have a Government in power, who are doing their best, as in my judgment they are, to maintain order and who are endeavouring, according to their lights, to deal with dangerous organisations, then I am strongly against the resolution proposed by Senator Sir John Keane. In my opinion, the Seanad would be very badly advised to pass that resolution of censure on the Government. I think that they would be better advised in congratulating them on their endeavour to maintain law and order.

Comment on this

When my friend Senator O'Neill quotes poetry here, I always think of the lines of Robert Louis Stevenson:—

"There is so much good in the worst of us,

And so much bad in the best of us,

That it ill behoveth any of us

To speak in despite of the rest of us."

It is only when Senator O'Neill quotes poetry that he says hard things about his brother Irishmen who happen to be in opposition. I support Senator Sir John Keane's motion because I think he has made a very reasoned statement. It is time for the people of Ireland, whether they are on the side of the Government or the Opposition, to take stock. The people on the Government side should remember that in the present position of Parliament—it is a position which I want to retain—there is necessity for an Opposition. It is the duty of the people in Opposition to do their job and to point out to the Government where they are wrong. When I try to point out to the Government where they are wrong, as I did last week, I want the Government to understand that I give that advice as I should give it at a Party meeting if our Government were in power. It would be a very good thing if people on the Government Benches would give their advice to the Government at Party meetings when they consider they are wrong. I do not ask them to give that advice here but they know the Government is wrong just as I know it and I want them to give the Government their advice at their Party meetings.

Senator O'Neill said that this thing should be allowed to rest where it rested last week. If that were done, it would rest on a very false foundation. You cannot govern a country on falsehoods or by stunts and sops. The people want something solid. To the best of my ability, I say what I mean and I always mean what I say. I raise this point now because the Minister concerned is here. I raised it last day when the Minister for Finance was here and he was not able to answer. The Irish Press took it up the following day and denied my statements. I was also treated to a sub-leader in the same issue of the Irish Press but I shall not refer to the sub-leader. I propose to refer only to the emphatic denial given in the Irish Press of Thursday, August 17, 1933, as follows:—

"Emphatically Denied: Senate Statement About Army and Gárda. Quite Untrue. (By Our Political Correspondent.)

"Emphatic denials were given in high Army and Gárda Síochána quarters last night to the allegations of Senator Michael Staines in the Senate last evening. At the outset it was stated that the Gárda Síochána had failed to find any trace of the alleged party of men waiting with stones at Cabra cross-roads to waylay members of the A.C.A. on their way to town. If the party had been at the cross roads, the Gárdaí were convinced that they would be aware of it.

"With regard to the implication that the Army had refused to man armoured cars for patrol purposes in the St. Stephen's Green area on Sunday last, Maj.-Gen. MacMahon, Secretary to the Department of Defence, stated last night that it was quite untrue. The Army had not refused to carry out any instruction; neither had it expressed unwillingness to do so. If the Government required armoured cars manned by the Army they would have been provided as a matter of course. I understand that it was part of the Government's policy to leave the entire arrangements for Sunday in the hands of the Gárda Síochána, unless it became necessary to reinforce the Gárda with military. It was in pursuance of this policy that an armoured car for patrol purposes had been worked by a Gárda crew. None of the allegations, therefore, had any foundation in fact."

Not even the one which they admit, and which was the principal point I made: "It was in pursuance of this policy that an armoured car for patrol purposes had been worked by a Gárda crew." Even that is not true, according to the Irish Press. I am sorry I have not the Official Debates, but I think I mentioned cross-roads. It does not matter, however, whether they were cross-roads or straight roads. At all roads around Dublin parties of men assembled. I gave one instance, Cabra cross-roads, where they assembled with stones, and waited to waylay buses coming to Dublin with members of the A.C.A. or National Guard. The Minister is here now and I defy him, or any Department, to deny my statement. At Kingsbridge on the same evening men who had sticks were waiting to waylay passengers coming up to Dublin. At other roads there were men who had sticks and stones waiting to waylay people. I will go further and say that I am not accusing the I.R.A. of doing so. It may have been one of the new private armies that are springing up. Dublin on that Saturday evening was as completely surrounded and as completely ringed round by men armed with sticks, stones, and probably other weapons—I do not know about the other weapons— as the Royal and the Grand Canals combined ring the City of Dublin. The only difference was that the meshes of these men were spread a bit wider, because they were outside the boundary.

As to what the Irish Press accuses me of, in connection with the Army, there appears in another part of that paper a fair account of what I said about the Army. In a sub-leader that I do not want to quote, because it is not worth replying to, it is stated:

"After the Army had said it was not their job to man the cars, the Civic Guards were asked to supply men."

I would like to say that I had no intention whatever of suggesting there had been a mutiny in the Army, or that the men in the Army would mutiny. If the men in the Army or the Civic Guards mutinied, I would be the first to condemn them. There is no use in trying to slip stuff like that across me. Probably if I had used the words "Department of Defence" instead of Army I would have been more correct. I expressed what was in my mind. The Department of Defence is different to other Departments. The Department of Justice deals with the police, the courts and other matters. The Department of Defence deals only with the Army. I do not see any difference in having used the word "Army" instead of "Defence." I did not want shamelessly to insult—as I am accused of doing—the members of the Army. The point that I really made was that it was the duty of the Government, governing at the will of the people, to govern for the benefit of all the people, and not for a section. I said that it was a very bad policy to ask an unarmed force like the Civic Guards to man an armoured car to terrorise the citizens of Dublin on that particular Sunday. I agree, if it was the opinion of the Government of the day—whatever Government it was—that armoured cars were necessary, they should be put on the streets, or sent to the country, or to any place they were required in order to protect the lives and property of the people. But, when that is done, these cars should not be manned by members of the Gárda Síochána; they should be manned by members of the Army, who are trained in the use of armoured cars, and trained in the use of the guns on these cars.

Senator Sir John Keane referred to quotations from police reports. I agree with the Senator's remarks that private police reports should not be published. It has become a habit of the present Government to do so. It was not the rule previously. As it has become such a habit I would ask the Minister, when he gets the report of the Cabra cross-road business, to let the House see a copy of it. I notice by to-day's Irish Press that the Minister has already reports of the A.C.A. parades that were held all over Ireland last Sunday.

Comment on this

The Senator is quite right in calling them the A.C.A.

Comment on this

The National Guard.

Comment on this

The Irish Press is calling them the A.C.A.

Comment on this

The Irish Press called them the A.C.A. but they have changed their name, and in accordance with that it gives the different names in brackets.

Comment on this

The Irish Press insists to this day in referring to the Free State instead of to Saorstát Eireann, and to the Free State Government.

Comment on this

Is not that right?

Comment on this

It is right, but why not use the Irish names? I do not think my friend Senator Comyn should interrupt me so much.

[The Cathaoirleach resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this

Thanks very much. I never wanted to say all I have said, but I have repeated for the information of the Irish Press what I said on the last day, and I have given them a little more information. The Irish Press is the Government organ, and the Irish Press can put what I have just said to-day in their Kapp and Peterson and smoke it.

Comment on this

While Senator Staines was speaking I regret that too many Senators left the Chamber, probably to have a smoke. They could have waited to listen to his speech and to the speech made by Senator O'Neill in answer to the remarkable statement read for this House by Senator Sir John Keane. That speech of Senator Sir John Keane to which we have listened is the most remarkable tribute that could be paid to the Parliament of any country. Who can say after that speech that we had not in this country tolerance for our opponents, and that we do not respect freedom of speech when in the Parliament of this country a man is allowed to say what comes to his mind? The motion before the House is in a rather narrow compass. It reads: "That the Seanad is of opinion that the recent actions of the Executive Council purporting to be for the preservation of public peace and order have not been justified." When I read that motion I expected that Senator Sir John Keane would have delivered a speech of a somewhat different character, that in fact he would have spoken to the motion. But what did he say? He said that the "Cease fire" order represented merely the defeat of the Irish Republican Army, but that their spirit was not crushed. In that he is correct, for

"Freedom's battle once begun

Bequeathed from bleeding sire to son

Though baffled oft is ever won."

But Senator Sir John Keane wished that the Party which for the moment prevailed should make, as he described it, a clean job. He said that in the Seanad of this country—that they should make a clean job. What was the meaning of a clean job? That the Free State Government, the Saorstát Government, to adopt the correction of my friend Senator Staines, should not be satisfied with peace in this country, that they should go on with the war of repression until the last man who swore an oath to defend the Irish Republic was exterminated in his own blood. That is what it means. He went on further to say that in his youth, I suppose in the time when he was breathing what he calls philosophic radicalism, an English statesman said that all that Ireland needed was fifty years of resolute government. That was said in 1890 or thereabouts, and Senator Sir John Keane deplores that the British did not persist in the fifty years of resolute government. He said that in your Parliament to-day and you listened to him with the decorum, reserve and patience which is an honour to this House. He went further and said that instead of giving fifty years of resolute government, of repression, of coercion and of starvation to the people of Ireland, that the British were resolute only in spasms. They were resolute first and then irresolute. I have taken the words down here. He went on then to compare the British system in this country with the system which we have to-day. The Government are blamed by Senator Sir John Keane not for being resolute but for being irresolute. His complaint is that some camps, some tents are erected on top of some hill near Dublin. I know nothing of the camps that are erected near Dublin but I agree with Senator Sir John Keane that this country is peaceful. I hope he will agree with me that notwithstanding the economic war, the most deadly war which a foe could imagine, this country is prosperous in many respects.

Comment on this

Well surely!!

Comment on this

Oh! oh!

Comment on this

We have enough to eat. Thank God we have enough to eat.

Comment on this

The Senator is only thinking of the legal profession.

Comment on this

That is all that appears to be prospering.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Order. This is only Senator Comyn's opinion, and he must be allowed to express it.

Comment on this

I say it is our opponents who are the belligerent people and the intolerant people. We are the patient people. We listened to Senator Sir John Keane without interruption. The harvest last year was bountiful. The harvest this year surpasses last year's harvest in a miraculous degree. I ask Senator Gogarty if that is not so? This year's harvest surpasses last year's in a miraculous manner. Senator Sir John Keane loses patience with me. I see that he cannot endure any more of the truth. He is going from the Chamber—he is gone. Now the Senator's complaint is not that the Government is strong in its action but that the Government is weak. What would the Government do if they had the benefit of Senator Sir John Keane's advice? I will tell you what they would do. They would not, of course, recruit 300 or 400 Gardaí. No, they would call out the military. That is what he is saying. The late Government did not make a clean job of the men who struggled for the liberties of their country. The English in their 50 years of resolute government did not make a clean job of the men who withstood them. The present Ministry did not act properly because they did not call out the military and have the streets of Dublin swimming in blood. Senator Sir John Keane said that, and he was listened to with patience in the Parliament of this country. That is the greatest tribute that could be paid to this House.

Comment on this

May I intervene to say that I never said anything of the kind that the Senator is alleging? I realise that there must be latitude in debate, but here I am accused of saying that I wished to see the streets of Dublin swimming in blood. I never used these words.

Comment on this

It is in the recollection of this House that Senator Sir John Keane advocated the calling out of the military to stop the parade on that Sunday.

Comment on this

I am surprised that the Senator should stop me in my speech, but when the report is read it will be found that Senator Sir John Keane suggested the calling out of the military forces. It was also suggested here a week or two ago that they should be called out. I put it to this House that the Government adopted a much wiser policy. The military forces of this country should not be used against the people of this country or against any section of the people except in cases of extreme necessity. Notwithstanding what has been said, and the parade that has been made, there is no extreme necessity at the present moment. The civil forces constituted to preserve order have been sufficient. Dublin was a calm, a peaceful city on that Sunday, but if Senator Sir John Keane's advice were taken it would have been guarded by military from end to end.

What is the Senator's complaint? His complaint is that the Government have not suppressed another organisation which purports to be organised on the basis of force. It has not suppressed the I.R.A. The I.R.A. were in existence during the period of office of the last Government—ten years. They were not suppressed. I think they never will be suppressed until the object for which they were instituted is achieved.

Comment on this

They are the Government.

Comment on this

Senator Fanning says they are the Government.

Comment on this

Obviously they are, according to your own statement.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that.

Comment on this

They are the supreme authority.

Comment on this

In my judgment the I.R.A. will not be suppressed until the objects for which they were instituted long ago, when we were all united, are achieved. They have their roots in the past; they have their roots in the sentiments of our people.

Comment on this

The Senator will get his commission then.

Comment on this

And they even have the secret sympathy of Senator Miss Browne. What does Senator Sir John Keane say? He says that the failure of the Government to suppress one irregular army is due, perhaps, to the indifference, to the inability, or to the sympathy of the Government. I wonder was it due during the last ten years to the sympathy of the late Government? Perhaps it was. Perhaps in the late Government there were men who had some sort of a lurking regard for the men who held on to the principles that they for certain reasons, temporary I hope, abandoned.

We come to the latter part of the Senator's speech, which deals rather in a flimsy way with what I thought was the resolution before the House. The Government have taken reasonably strong action. They did suppress or proclaim the parade which was to be held in Dublin on Sunday week. They did proclaim parades which were in substitution and which were advertised for the following Sunday. General O'Duffy, having yielded to the Government on Sunday week, issued a statement that he would have parades at churches on the following Sunday. I am sure he thought better of it. There were no parades to Mass or in the churches, or towards the churches or near the churches on the following Sunday. I am glad that General O'Duffy, whatever his motives may have been, abandoned that idea, because whatever our differences may be, we ought not to go under the shelter of sacred things in any disputes which may arise in this country.

Why was this organisation prevented from making this display? The reason is perfectly clear. If the Government had not intervened to check this second army—to use the correct expression which has been used by Senator Sir John Keane—if the Government had not interfered to prevent this demonstration, it would have failed in its duty. Any why? Here is an organisation under the supreme command of a man who, in regard to this very organisation, the A.C.A., made a report which I will read for the Seanad. Senator Staines is right when he says that the A.C.A. is the same as the N.G.—they are the same thing. Here is the report:—

"The majority of Cumann na nGaedheal T.D.s and ex-Army officers throughout the Saorstát are also organising.

"There is no doubt that a considerable number of individual ex-Army officers are in possession of revolvers, and even rifles, held surreptitiously as souvenirs of the pre-Truce period. Further, many ex-National Army men, when leaving the Army in 1923-25, brought arms with them.

"I have, however, been informed, as already reported to the Minister, that certain members of the organisation hold extreme views, and would be prepared to urge the use of force in pursuit of their policy."

And going on further:—

"It is certain, however, that Mr. Jerry Ryan could, should the occasion arise, muster a fair number of the arms taken from Templemore Military Barracks during the mutiny."

And further:—

"Should it at any time desire to adopt other than constitutional methods it can, without doubt, lay hands on a sufficient quantity of arms and ammunition to render it a very formidable insurrectionary force and a source of extreme danger to the peace and stability of the country."

I will ask Senator Sir John Keane, with his philosophic radicalism, to put himself in the position of the Government of the day. That Government is informed by an able man—General O'Duffy is an able and efficient man—"Here is a force which has arms, which has political support, which has in its ranks men of ability, members of the Dáil, probably members of the Seanad"—I make no accusation.

Comment on this

Senator O'Neill, for example.

Comment on this

"Men with an organisation behind them, fully armed men who could, if they chose, by force become a danger to the community." The gentleman who made that report, for some reason best known to himself, becomes the spokesman and the leader of that body which is rebaptised the National Guard and, under its new name and under its new control, it puts forward a programme and a policy. Is that programme a constitutional programme?

Comment on this

Is that policy constitutional?

Comment on this

I did not ask Senator Milroy because, although he is a great lawyer, he is not a trained lawyer. But I ask the philosophic radical, Senator Sir John Keane, is that a constitutional policy? Senator Sir John Keane will not answer. The position the Senator takes up is this. I want an answer from Senator Keane as to what he thinks should be the policy of the National Guard, viewed from the standpoint of philosophic radicalism.

Comment on this

Is this a purely hypothetical question or is it one to which the Senator wants an answer? If he wants an answer I may say that I consider the policy of the National Guard as announced in its charter is thoroughly constitutional, and as thoroughly in accord with radical or liberal principles.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear that from the Senator. That shows that the Senator, who by his speech to-day has shown himself to be a frank and fearless man, and a courageous man is, also, an honest man. Here is a body that Senator Sir John Keane would describe as constitutional. Here we have a man at the head of 50,000 men, according to his own words, who are brigaded, organised into parishes, and parishes organised into constituencies, and constituencies organised into a national force. He says that this national force is 40,000 strong, but that he hopes to have it 100,000 strong and with an auxiliary force as well.

All this reminds me of what was done by an Irish prince many years ago, who had been turned out of his clan somewhere near the county in which Sir John Keane lives. He went over to the Romans in Britain and told them it was a danger for them to have any army adjacent to their frontier or any free people in contact with their dominion. "One legion and a few auxiliaries will be enough," said he, "to conquer the disunited Irish." Does Senator Sir John Keane want a repetition of that kind of thing? Does he want three armies brigaded, organised and armed, led by military men with war experience? We may surely ask where are the arms that have been in this country for the last 15 or 17 years? Where are the arms that were taken from the barracks and where are the 40,000 rifles?

Comment on this
Senators

They are in the dumps.

Comment on this

I am not talking about the arms in the dumps. These arms are held by men who love their country. The last Government, in ten years, was not capable of getting these arms, and the present Government would, I think, be quite incapable of finding them. But the present Government are determined to allow no unauthorised arms with people if they can lay their hands on those arms, and I am glad to see that the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad says "quite right too."

Comment on this

I did not. I asked why do they not get the other arms.

Comment on this

The only arms the Government took up were from persons who had permits for them, including myself.

Comment on this

The Government are going to collect arms in this country from persons not authorised to have them so far as they can get those arms. I believe that to be the policy of the present Government. I believe, also, it was the policy of the last Government and I believe it should be the policy of any Government to get control of arms and ammunition and get them under the authority of the State for the time being. The policy of the Government is one thing, the power of the Government is another thing. The Government I am sure will do all it can to get control of all the arms in this country so that we may have one Government and one people—I hope a united people—and one army doing the business of the country, and one police force to preserve order in this country. That is what this Government desires. That is the thing which I think the Govern-have set out to accomplish.

Now, how have they proceeded to deal with the situation? They declared that they would not allow an assembly of armed men last Sunday week; that they would not allow them to collect together with arms. Potentially they are armed men, for actually they can be armed. They had the arms if they wished to appear with them and they could have appeared with arms on Sunday week. Were the Government right in the action they took? I think they were. I think in the present state of this country—and we are an excitable people——

Comment on this

You are a perfect specimen.

Comment on this

I am glad Senator Fanning regards me as a perfect specimen of an Irish Nationalist. I shall return the compliment to him and say that he is a fine type of a Tipperary man although most Tipperary men do not agree with him in politics. Why should the Government allow an excitable people to come together in great numbers with military formation and probably armed—at least they might be. There is no sort of comparison between a demonstration of that kind and the demonstration to which Senator Sir John Keane referred at the Cenotaph at Whitehall, because at the Cenotaph you have a united people paying homage to the memory of their illustrious dead. Here we are a disunited people. There are two irregular armies and these two irregular armies might have met. Perhaps Senator Sir John Keane would want a third irregular army also present, in order that there might be a triangular fight. The Government did the proper thing. They got three or four hundred civilians, put them into uniform, and asked the police from the surrounding districts to come in and keep order. That was absolutely perfect both in good policy and good sense, and it succeeded. No blood was shed; no disturbance took place. The most that could be said was that while the police were drafted in from Kingstown——

Comment on this
Senators

Dun Laoghaire.

Comment on this

I was trying to follow the mind of Senator Sir John Keane. It is Kingstown to him. It is, of course, Dun Laoghaire to Senator Fanning, myself and people like us. The only thing that could be said is that an unfortunate fellow who, I suppose, had not 2d. in his pocket, took occasion of the absence of the police from Dun Laoghaire to break a window, go in and rob the poor box. That is all that happened.

Comment on this
A Senator

Will the window not cost £50?

Comment on this

Three Senators made the complaint that by reason of the measures taken to prevent disturbance in the City of Dublin last Sunday week a window was broken in Dun Laoghaire, the poor box was robbed, and the man was not caught.

Comment on this

And the Dun Laoghaire police were walking about here doing nothing.

Comment on this

I am very pleased to say that the Dun Laoghaire police had no very onerous duties to perform on that day. The day passed off quietly and calmly, as did the following Sunday when parades were announced at every parish church at Mass. I say again that I am glad, whatever the motive was, that General O'Duffy or his associates did not avail of the Sacrifice of the Mass for the purpose of making a parade of any organisation. I hope as long as this dispute lasts—and I believe it will not last very long—that we shall keep as far away in our disputes from the shelter of holy things as we possibly can. That is what the Government have done. They have found it necessary to put into force a statute which was passed by the late Government in this Parliament with the approval of Senator Sir John Keane and also with the eloquent support of Senator Milroy.

Comment on this

I never said a word about it.

Comment on this

Oh, you did.

Comment on this

Look up the report.

Comment on this

Senator Milroy was silent on that occasion, but since then how many times on the public platform has he supported the action of the Government? That statute was there. That statute has been put into operation. I hope that it has been put into operation only as a method of precaution, because when it came before this House I denounced it, and denounced it in very unmeasured terms.

Comment on this

Do you denounce it now?

Comment on this

Do I denounce it now? I am very sorry that the occasion should arise for putting into force, even as a precautionary measure a single line of that statute.

Comment on this

Has it arisen?

Comment on this

There are things in that statute which I hope will not be resorted to by this or any other Government. Senator Milroy, who is so keen, asked me has the necessity arisen. He knows what has arisen. Senator Sir John Keane has said that there is one army in this country, an authorised army under the control of Parliament. There is another army, according to Sir John Keane, an unauthorised army which had its existence long back in the past. There is coming into operation a third army, according to Senator Sir John Keane, which is to be a second irregular army, which is to be in opposition to the first irregular army.

Comment on this

I never said that. The Senator should not put these words into my mouth.

Comment on this

Senator Sir John Keane ought not to interrupt me.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

If you make a very bad mistake, Senator, in quoting what he said, he is perfectly entitled to correct you.

Comment on this

He is perfectly entitled to interrupt me if I misrepresent him, but I have taken it down in writing, and have not altered one word of what Senator Sir John Keane said. If there is one regular and two irregular armies in this country, is that not a position of danger? What would be the result of the existence of two bodies of organised men led by experienced commanders? What would be the result when each of these irregular armies were in competition with each other? That between them both, if they are allowed to continue, they would drown the voice of constitutional Government in this country. I am asked again, has the necessity arisen. I submit the necessity has arisen from the statements made by the leader of the second irregular army. In the first statement which he made he declared his dissatisfaction with parliamentary government. I think in that he was probably unwise and showed that he was a man of very little political experience. From time to time generals have subverted Parliament, but in the course of history, as far as I have read it, I have not known an instance of a single man proclaiming his intention of subverting Parliament who has succeeded in his design. The men who have succeeded in doing that, the men who have succeeded in turning out Parliaments, are men who first professed to be the servants of Parliament and who, when they were strong enough, turned their forces on Parliament. That was the conclusion at which I arrived when I read the first statement of that gentleman.

I then read what purported to be a corrected statement. Here is the corrected statement. He says he was misrepresented. "I was misrepresented when I referred to the new system in a previous interview." This is the system which he proposed to substitute for the system of parliamentary government. "It was construed to mean that I wanted a dictatorship. What I meant is a change from the present system to the most democratic Parliamentary system. There must be a Parliament"—that is a great concession from General O'Duffy—"but for the good of the country the present system of parties and politicians requires to be changed." You will be all changed. You will be put into the mincing machine and come out sausages. "The proposed change will mean the abolition of parties and constituencies and, instead, we will have representation for agriculture, labour, science, education, engineering and other vocational walks of life. I have already explained the system."

What is the meaning of that? That the people through their representatives elected in the ordinary way shall not have control in this country but that an experienced military man with 100,000 men at his command will call a few farmers, a few manufacturers together and get advice from them. That is a system of government for which the Irish people will not stand. They will not accept the overthrow of parliamentary government by military forces. It is said that parliamentary government is a foreign institution. That I deny. I say that, amongst Northern peoples, the first Parliament that was ever held was held in Ireland, on the Hill of Tara. That was the meeting of the chieftains from the various parts of the country. There was, at one time, as you know, 500 bishoprics in this country.

Each bishopric represented some sort of clan or family. In later times there were as many as sixty or seventy or eighty clans, each having a Government of its own. The representatives of each clan met in Tara and made the laws and decided the policy of this country. Therefore, I say that before there was a Saxon Heptarchy, before there were seven Governments in England, not to speak of one Government, there was a Parliament in this country. Parliament is an Irish institution. Its roots are deep in the history of this country. I hope also that they are deep in the affections of this people. I hope that the Irish people will not endure the existence of a new military force without any tradition behind it, without that sentiment of nationality behind it which inspired the Irish Republican Army and the other armies that preceded the Irish Republican Army—the Fenians, the men of '48, and Whiteboys, if you like, the Wild Geese, and all those men who in their day rose to defend the liberties of their country, hoping to achieve the independence of their country, dying one after another, sinking in failure. The Irish Republican Army, with the tradition of these men behind them, rose. They were the greatest men that ever lived in Ireland. I have said before in the Seanad that when they were united in 1921 they were the greatest men that ever lived in Ireland. I have seen men face the firing squad unflinchingly and while they were standing up to the guns other men were allowed to look through the windows and to see them fall. After that I saw and spoke to some of the men who were for trial and execution and with a valour, a manhood, a resolution unsurpassed in the history of the world, I heard these men say: "I can die as the other men died yesterday morning; I saw them die and I can die like them." We were all united then. I should like to give a little cameo of the things that are past when you were all united.

Comment on this

What about the men who pleaded their American citizenship and funked the firing squad?

Comment on this

Not a single interruption was made when Senator Sir John Keane was speaking, and the Senator has been continuously interrupted, especially by the liquor interests.

Comment on this

Perhaps if Senator Fanning were informed that he would be allowed to make a speech later on he might keep his mouth shut.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

If Senators ask questions they must expect dissent.

Comment on this

It is to the credit of the Senators on these benches that they listened with so much patience to Senator Sir John Keane. I ask them now not to blemish that by being impatient with interruptions by my friend, Senator Fanning. I hope he will make a speech. I was giving the members of the Seanad a little glimpse of the days when they were all united and I still say that they were the best men that ever lived in Ireland. Some of these men——

Comment on this

Are under a ban now.

Comment on this

Some of these men are alive. You cannot dispute facts. The I.R.A. have their tradition and it is impossible for any Government to suppress the Irish Republican Army until Ireland is united and free.

Comment on this

We have listened to a very long, sometimes impassioned, frequently very irrelevant speech, from Senator Comyn. He is often humorous in this House with very great effect. This, to my mind, was not an occasion on which the kind of humour in which he indulged was worthy of him or of this House. His effort to criticise or disagree with the statement made by Senator Sir John Keane was perfectly fair. But when he chose to try to suggest that Senator Sir John Keane had advocated the use of the Army, or the use of any force or suggested that he wished the streets of Dublin running in blood——

Comment on this

I never said he wished it. I know very well that Senator Sir John Keane does not wish any injury to this country.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

The whole matter was very indistinct, and I think we had better leave it to be read in the Official Report.

Comment on this

What I wanted to say was this. If I understood the object of this motion, it was to give an opportunity to the responsible Minister to make a statement on the present situation which would, we hoped, make, not for anything such as was attributed to the Senator's speech, but for the peace of this country, both in the near and far future. It seems to me that any speeches that may be made in this debate which are calculated to stir up bad or bitter feelings, either at the present time or with regard to the past, are not only to be deprecated but, to my mind, at the present time are definitely unpatriotic. Anything I should like to add to this debate is for the purpose of dealing with certain matters which, I think, are important to this issue, and for the purpose of suggesting to the Minister for Justice that a carefully-worded statement at the end of this debate, not for this House but for the country, might go a very long way indeed towards removing a great deal of the very genuine uneasiness which is prevalent in the country at present. Senator Comyn wound up his speech with references to certain heroes who had died for this country. I have nothing but reverence and respect for men who gave up their lives in the past, but if I have one absolute conviction it is, that at the present moment what this country wants is men who are willing to live for this country and not men who are willing to give up their lives or to kill somebody else. If we could get a band of men and women who would say: "Come what may, I will not kill any Irishman," I believe there might be some chance of an end to the kind of thing we have read in the newspapers during the last two or three years.

Senator Sir John Keane suggested that peace was greater than principle. He quoted it in a satiric way. I have been told by many of my friends of different Parties that I stand for peace in preference to principle. I am going to confess here that I would go a very long way in breach of what seemed to be principle to bring about peace. But the difficulty is that you cannot get real peace by departing from principle. You may try; you may get it for a fortnight or a month or even a year, but it does not last. It seems to me that any Government responsible for peace and order in this country, whether it be Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal, Labour, General O'Duffy, or any other possible Government, will only get peace by applying the best possible principles that they can find, and applying them absolutely without fear or favour to every section of the community. I spent a portion of the night before last reading the debates in this House and in the Dáil in connection with the Constitution (No. 17) Act, when it was passing through the Oireachtas. I found a great deal that was instructive. I read it, principally, because I wanted to revive my memory as to the attitude I, personally, took on that occasion.

I think that, if there was any Act of recent years passed by this House —even those members who voted for it—with the greatest reluctance, it was that Act. I stated at the time that, much though I loved peace, I was not prepared to refuse those powers to an Executive Council which considered they were the only possible way by which order could be maintained. But I further stated, and I am still absolutely of the same opinion, that methods, whether used by this Government or the last Government, such as are set out in the Constitution (No. 17) Act, can never be more than temporarily successful and will not give you permanent peace, whether you are dealing with National Guards, I.R.A., or anybody else. I am of the same opinion to-day, and if this Government satisfied me that the only way in which they could maintain order in this country was by using, as they have now set in force, the provisions—all of which are in force now—of the Constitution (No. 17) Act, I would not vote against them in a motion of this kind, because there are even greater things than peace and, while we are governed as we are at the present time, the Executive Council of the State is responsible for the lives and properties of the people under their care. We can advise them, and we can criticise them, but we cannot take that responsibility from them.

I am old-fashioned enough to believe that no case whatever can be made for two, three, four or any number of armies, other than one, in any State. I can think of many arguments in this country for having none, but I cannot think of any argument for having more than one. I am not going, however, to throw any jibes or criticism against this Executive for what is called leniency. If they could have got, or could still get, an acceptance by all sections of political opinion in this country of the principle that there should only be one armed force responsible to the elected representatives of the people, and that the elected Executive, for good or evil, are, for the time being, the only people who can govern —if that could be achieved, it would be worth taking some risks. But what I do say, and I say it, having thought it out carefully, is, that you cannot get that unless you are prepared to apply exactly the same principles all around. The motion before us to-day suggests that the recent actions of the Executive Council, purporting to be for the preservation of public peace and order, have not been justified. What are the recent actions? We have only a limited amount of information, gathered from the rather unsatisfactory speech of the Minister for Finance in this House last week and from the public Press; but I take it that the recent actions mean the action of the Executive in putting into force the Constitution (No. 17) Act, their action in proclaiming certain parades that were arranged by the National Guard for a Sunday a short time ago, and their action in creating a new special armed section of the Civic Guards. I will deal with the last first, but I do not want to deal with it at any length except to give it as my conviction that it was a gross and very regrettable mistake to create a new armed and uniformed section of the Civic Guards and, if it be true as has been stated, to put them into armoured cars and use them in that way in the City of Dublin. I cannot see a great deal of difference, from the moral point of view at any rate, whether they are called soldiers or police, if they are going into armoured cars with the purpose of firing on the citizens. I cannot make nice distinctions of that kind, but I will say that it was a definitely retrograde step, because, since the establishment of the Civic Guards, we have been in the position until now of being able to say to the public that a Guard in uniform, going about the streets, was not armed. I think it is most unfortunate if we are not to remain in that position in the future and, though I appreciate and sympathise with the desire not to use the army against the citizens, I say that that would have been a lesser evil than to have created an armed force as part and parcel of the Civic Guards. I am not going into other questions involved in it except to give that as my personal opinion. I believe that, by their action of bringing into operation the Constitution (No. 17) Act, the Government have done a very considerable amount of damage to the whole situation, including the position of trade, aided and abetted—I do not mean in collusion with—by the English Press, who are always too ready to make a mountain out of a molehill as far as this country is concerned. We have had something very much like a panic and we have had people of all kinds believing that during the last four or five weeks some sudden situation of potential danger to this country has arisen—something which was not so four or five weeks ago—and that the Government have been forced suddenly to create a new force and bring this most drastic legislation into effect.

I ask the Minister here either to give the lie completely to the statement that anything occurred of any serious danger to the peace of this country, or to tell us straight out—I believe it would be far better to do so—what it is that caused these panic and sudden actions on the part of the Government. The Minister may have a great deal of knowledge that the ordinary man in the street has not got. As far as this is concerned, I am only in the position of the man in the street. I am aware of the fact that, for a considerable time, there has been a certain number of men who carry arms—to what extent I do not know—who were declared by the last Government as an illegal organisation but which declaration was withdrawn shortly after the coming into power of this Executive. I have no reason to believe that the situation has changed or changed suddenly. But it may have, for all I know. The only other information we have as to a changed situation has been the position of the National Guard. Following the debate last week, I made it my business to obtain a copy of the paper setting out the constitution of that body. I know nothing as to what other aims and objects there may be in the National Guard. If their aim or object is a coup d'état—which I do not believe —or if it be to usurp Parliament, I have no sympathy with that object, but, taking their aims and objects as I see them and read them, I find a great deal with which I am in entire sympathy— the promotion of a spirit of service in the country, and so on. I find other things of which I have doubts, but I see nothing whatever to justify the panic action and the bringing into force of the Constitution No. 17 Act. There may be other information, but we have not got it, nor have we had it suggested in any way. Senator Comyn on the last occasion said—I have his exact words; I will not take any risks:—

"The most dangerous political idea which I have heard in my experience is this—I have seen it published—that one gentleman in this country has declared that Parliament is outworn, and that he is the man to deal with the government of the country. Now any person that challenges the authority of Parliament is a potential danger to the country, and that one statement alone would be sufficient in my opinion, to justify the recruitment of the Civic Guard."

Do not let us live in a fool's paradise. I believe in the Parliamentary system. I have believed in it ever since I took an interest in political affairs, but I am not big enough fool to believe that everybody believes in it. I know and we all know if we read politics at all that in every country the parliamentary system is on its trial. We know that there are many people who would like to see some other system of government. The parliamentary system will succeed only if it is able to produce executives which are scrupulously fair in their dealings and which are prepared to protect the life and property of all individuals alike.

Senator Sir John Keane stated that he thought the movement which is represented by the National Guards was the natural outcome—I think those were the words he used—of the general policy of the Government with regard to other armed forces. I do not know how far that is true but what I do say is that if there be any truth in it, and I think there is a good deal, you are not going to suppress any movement which is growing out of the feelings of suspicion or the feelings of doubt in the minds of a large number of people by forcing it to change its name or by passing the Constitution No. 17 Act and declaring it illegal, on the grounds that it has other aims than appear on the surface, without producing proof. I would suggest to the Minister that he would find it very profitable indeed to read both his own speech and the speech of the President when the Constitution No. 17 Act was going through the Dáil. I am not going to read them here but I would remind the Minister for Justice that he, in particular, emphasised the fact that you could not suppress opinions simply by declaring an organisation illegal and that in so far as it represented real opinions you would only spread it and drive it underground to break out in a new form. I forget which of them it was, but either the President or the Minister for Justice made an appeal to the then Government in which he asked them to remember their own position a few years before and the advice they had given to other young men as to the need for organisation and the desirability of organising for what they considered a good purpose. I need not go into the details, but I should like to say the same thing to the members of this Government. It may be very interesting to them and to all of us that they have adopted an Act which they denounced, but I do not place any importance on that. One could make lots of political capital by taking their past speeches but they are now in a responsible position and they are taking the machinery which was there and which they evidently considered it right to use. For that I am not condemning them, but I do suggest to them that if they are going to be the Government of the country, they will have to apply exactly the same principles to the National Guard as they are prepared to apply to Republicans who disagree with them and who may threaten violence or may not threaten violence.

I should like to ask the Minister— and with this I will sit down—if he would tell us and tell the country exactly what is the Government policy with regard to parades irrespective entirely of what the particular organisation may be? It would appear from certain statements made by the President that the Government policy is that drilling may take place but not in uniform and not with arms —that the Government is determined not to allow drilling in uniform and with arms in public places. I have stated it very badly because I do not quite understand what the Government policy is, but I suggest that in view of this extraordinary situation that we have now the Minister should state exactly what is the principle which will be applied presumably to all persons. Is the wearing of a badge a uniform? Would the National Guard if they wore badges instead of blue shirts meet with the approval of the Government, at any rate so far as drilling is concerned? I am not trying to make points; I am simply trying to get the position made clear because I believe that the attitude of a great many persons like myself towards these organisations and towards the National Guard will, to a large extent, be determined by whether we are satisfied that they are getting the right to express their opinions and the right to organise but not the right to arm. If we are satisfied that they get that from the Government and if we are satisfied that no other body is getting the right to arm which is denied to them, I think they will get very little support indeed in any schemes for the creation of a third army. But there is the danger that if the impression gets abroad that one policy is good for one section of armed men and another policy for another section of what Senator Comyn calls potentially armed men, you are going to have this country divided as between one section supporting one group of actually armed men and another section supporting another group of potentially armed men. I cannot think of anything worse for the future peace of this country.

It was almost amusing to hear the speeches of Senator McEllin and Senator Comyn and to compare them with certain Cumann na nGaedheal speeches a short time ago in support of the Constitution No. 17 Act. Senator Comyn to-day said that "it is only the opponents of our policy who are turbulent." Cannot we get out of that attitude that it is only those we disagree with, those who are against us, who must be wrong? Does everyone not know perfectly well that on all sides there are irresponsibles? Do we not know perfectly well that it is in the interests of every person to stand for ordered government, whether it be Cumann na nGaedheal or Fianna Fáil, to prevent coups d'état or anything of the kind, and does not everyone of us not agree that if all parties would accept as a question beyond doubt that only one army can be permitted it would go almost 80 per cent. towards solving the difficulties in this country? Is it not well worth while trying for it? But you are not going to achieve it by creating the impression that there may be one army to-day, two armies to-morrow and three the day after and that some will get one kind of treatment and others another kind of treatment. I appeal to the Minister to recognise, as I recognise, that men who love their country may be planning to arm, but that the fact that they love their country does not give them justification for creating an armed force against the Government of the country and against Parliament. I would appeal to him to see if he cannot make a speech—not one which is difficult to understand and interpret like the speech we had from the Minister for Finance—and I do not blame him because it was sprung on him suddenly on another subject— but to make a statement that will give confidence not only to his own supporters but to those of us who do not support him politically but who would like to support him in maintaining order. Give us a statement which will give confidence: that every section is going to get the same kind of fair treatment and that they are going to put down all armies in this country, and that whatever means they adopt the same means will be adopted to the one as to the other. If that is done there will be a chance that out of this situation which is full of difficulty and danger we may get something which will make towards the future peace of the country.

Comment on this