Central Fund Bill, 1941 (Certified Money Bill)—Second and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 103–231 of 231. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1941 ›
In any case, I do not think Senator MacDermot's speech will have the serious effect some people seem to think, and when this war is over, and when 999 out of every 1,000 of the people have done their bit in this country, I think Senator MacDermot will go down to history in this country as "the man from God knows where".
Comment on this
Senator Quirke's history is very weak. The "Man from God knows where" was a very noble man—a noble man who died for Ireland.
Comment on this
I am talking about another sort of man from God knows where—"The remittance man."
Comment on this
I am not talking about the original "Man from God knows where". God forbid that I should compare Senator MacDermot with that man, who died for Ireland.
Comment on this
I suppose, Sir, that if I were to allow Senator Quirke's remarks to go unchallenged, they would be taken as admitted, and so I wish to say that they are by no means admitted.
Comment on this
I did not expect the Senator to admit all that, certainly. However, to pass on to something more racy of the soil, we come to Senator Madden. Senator Madden was also amusing. He is generally amusing, but when he comes along and trots out the phrase that there are miles of undeveloped peat in the County Limerick and that the Government are doing nothing about it, it takes me back to the days of my childhood, which is a long time ago, and reminds me of a little rhyme I used to hear then: "When the devil was sick, the devil a saint would be; when the devil was well, the devil a saint was he." We need not go very far back in our history to remember the time when, if not Senator Madden, other members of his Party, were going around talking about the money that was being thrown into the bog-holes. Also, we had, if not Senator Madden—definitely, not Senator Madden himself, with regard to wheat anyhow, because he has been producing wheat himself— several other members of his Party telling us about the disastrous policy of the Government in growing wheat. I should like to hear anybody to-day having the nerve to stand up and condemn the policy of growing wheat and winning turf. However, I am glad to see that Senator Madden is interested in the thing, and I am doubly glad to be in the position of being able to tell him that something is being done about it and that he will know about it very soon, and I hope he will throw his weight into this thing as he has done in the case of various other things in his district, and that other Senators will follow his example.
Regardless of what may be done in the production of food, I believe it will be of very little use if we have not some means of cooking that food, and I believe that every Senator, when he goes back to his own district, should get in touch with his parish council and get them to work on the winning of turf and make sure that the area covered by his own parish council will at least be provided for in the way of fuel in the coming winter. Now, Senator Hayes made a few very unfortunate remarks. He starts off with a reference to recent speeches in the Dáil, and says that he saw no approach to any other persons outside the Government in this matter except a mixture of vulgar personal abuse combined with dignified appeals for co-operation.
Comment on this
Well, what can you expect from a Tipperary man, anyhow?
Comment on this
Now, that comes very badly from Senator Hayes. First, on the occasion of the last meeting we had here, in my opinion at any rate, and in the opinion of most people, I think, he departed from the ordinary rules of parliamentary debate in order to strike below the belt.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is not that a reflection on you, Sir, which ought not to be allowed?
Comment on this
Of course, Senator Douglas would come to the rescue of Senator Hayes.
Comment on this
We had Senator Douglas coming to the rescue with the suggestion of setting up a coalition Government, and I am sure that what Senator Douglas had in his mind for that coalition Government would be such a combination as Senator Hayes and Deputy Frank Aiken, the Minister for Co-ordination of Defensive Measures.
Comment on this
As a thought reader, the Senator is rather a failure.
Comment on this
This business of a coalition Government has been threshed out here time and time again. A few months ago there were a few people who believed in it, but the farther we get and the more we hear speeches like that made by Senator Hayes, in his unjustified attack on a man who is a long way from here trying to do his best to save this country from starvation or worse than starvation, the less people we will have in favour of his suggestion of a coalition Government.
Comment on this
I did not make any suggestion of a coalition Government. I shall have to teach Senator Quirke Irish, since he does not understand English.
Comment on this
Not Senator Hayes's English. Senator Hayes then went on to ridicule the appeals of the Government for co-operation, and he asks, what do we want co-operation for? Is it to carry out the policy of the Government? Surely to goodness that kind of speech will not do any good at the present time. It would be far more creditable for Senator Hayes, if he joined with others in making an appeal to those whom he represents and with whom he has considerable influence, to throw in their weight in carrying out the policy not of the Government, not of the Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil Parties, but the policy of the country as a whole at the present time. The policy which is being pursued is the policy of the overwhelming majority of the people, regardless of Party divisions and it is ridiculous for any Senator to make use of his position in this House to try to cause disunity, when unity is the one thing we need if we are to survive at all. He asks: "What is this unity for?" All I can say is that we want unity and we want the co-operation of the people to produce more food and to produce more fuel to cook that food. We want the co-operation of the people also in standing together to oppose any enemy no matter where he may come from.
Comment on this
I shall not pursue the line followed by Senator Quirke which is merely a continuation of the attitude adopted by Senator McEllin. It is a great misfortune that members of the Government Party in this House cannot realise that here we have a deliberative assembly and that no matter what political party a Senator may belong to, he has the right to express his opinions so long as the Standing Orders permit him to do so. Senators should also realise that it is not justifiable to counter these views by personal attack. I am not going to make any comment on the speech made by Senator MacDermot.
Comment on this
My view is that his speech should be met by argument and not by personal abuse and that Senator Quirke and his colleagues would stand much higher in the estimation of the House and of the country generally, if they met that case with reasoned argument. I am expressing no view on Senator MacDermot's speech, or as to whether or not he should have addressed himself to these questions but I have no doubt in my mind as to his right to do so. Whether or not he was justified in referring to these matters, he is at perfect liberty to do so. There is also the consideration, which should be overwhelming to the mind of Senator Quirke and his colleagues, that Senator MacDermot was a nominee of the Taoiseach in this House.
I know no more involved method of dealing with the problems that confront the country than that adopted by Senator Quirke. I have said to him before that his Party was the Government Party and that the Government has a big job of work before it. If you want help on any job, if for instance, you are out in the fields and you have more to do than you are able to do and you want the help of your neighbour, you do not ride down on your high horse and try to horsewhip him into helping you to sow a field of corn. In this measure for which the Minister is seeking the approval of the House, there arise a great many considerations not only for the Minister but for the House and the country as a whole. It is no use pretending that the position of the country is other than grave. In my view the position in the country is really grave. The demands which the Minister for Finance has to make are the heaviest ever put on the populace here. In my opinion the populace were never less able to carry that burden of taxation than this year. I attribute that fact largely to the policy pursued by the Government which in my judgment has been full of faults, weaknesses and failings.
I cannot at all agree with Senator Buckley when he preaches the doctrine that the Minister for Supplies and the Government generally have done everything that was possible, that there is very little room for criticism and that, on the whole, they have delivered the goods. He reproved members of the House for questioning how the Minister for Supplies did his work. We shall hope to hear from the Minister for Finance as to where the extra supplies are which came into the country, if they were obtained at all, and where is the record of the extra imports which the Minister for Supplies was able to secure for us. I feel myself that the position which confronts us now is so serious that orthodox methods of dealing with our problems will not at all meet the needs of the situation. I say that because, as far as I can see, there is no record anywhere of the success of Government policy in so far as success is to be measured by the capacity of the people of this country to bear the burden of taxation which is being put upon them by the Minister to meet the exigencies of the present situation. There is no evidence of the success of Government policy in the sense that the people are better able to carry this burden than they would have been if Government policy had been different.
Senators have referred to what has been achieved by a policy of self-sufficiency. Will somebody show us how far the policy of self-sufficiency has strengthened us to meet the problems that confront us now? Looking at agriculture what do we find? I suggest that the Government's policy in regard to agriculture has weakened the whole fibre of the nation, reduced its power to pay, reduced the national income and left it to-day much poorer than it would have been, had the policy which some of us advocated in this House been pursued. We find from a table supplied by one of the members of the Banking Commission to that body, Professor Duncan, who, I think, was supported by another economist, Dr. Kiernan, that in 1929 agriculture accounted for 52.3 of the national income, in 1931 for 42.2, in 1933 for 29.4, in 1936 for 38.5, in 1937 for 39.9, and in 1938 for 40.5. In 1931 the figure was 42.2 and in 1938 it was 40.5. That surely contains evidence of the failure of Government policy despite the pursuit of the policy of self-sufficiency. That shows that the agricultural industry, on which the whole structure of national economy is based, had a lower net income in 1938 than when the Government came into office. That lowering of the agricultural income has had very serious consequences for the nation at a whole. There is no use in saying that you can build up the industrial arm when you are weakening your agricultural arm day by day. It seems to me that the situation which confronts us now is one in which we are going to have more and more taxation of people whose income is becoming less and less. In the first place, our income, as far as one can observe, will be lower. The return of our agricultural community this year may not be much more than 50 per cent. of what it was last year. One cannot see just at the moment what it may be but, as far as exports are concerned, they are at a standstill at present. The failure of our Minister for Supplies, and the position with regard to our supply policy as a whole, is so appalling, when you know the conditions in rural Ireland, that one just cannot see the light at all.
This foot and mouth disease—which, apparently, the Minister for Agriculture has not got under control—has brought trading in the agricultural industry to a complete standstill and on top of the fact that our exports are nil at the moment, we have had the statement now from the British Minister of Agriculture to the effect that, even if the foot and mouth disease were finished to-morrow, they will drastically reduce the imports of store cattle from Ireland, because they will not feed them over there. The result of that is that no one can calculate what our income from cattle will be this year. Clearly, the income of the agriculturists will be very much lower this year than last year.
In addition to that, on account of the supplies position, there will be an unemployment problem of such a magnitude that even now I do not believe our imagination can carry us to a realisation of its possible limits. With a position like that coming upon us so swiftly, one cannot be other than perturbed as to what plans the Department has to meet such a situation. It seems to me that the question which the Minister has to answer is, "What will be done to raise the national income to a level at which it will be possible for all our citizens to have three meals a day and as much left over as will make the contribution to the Exchequer of the dimensions which the Minister demands?" That is the problem, put bluntly but briefly. Unless the Minister has some plan other than any that has been disclosed up to the present, the country will have to face as grave a situation as any faced by any other country in Europe at the present time.
As far as supplies are concerned, the Department does not at all appreciate the consequences of the shortage. Even in the matter of agricultural production, it does not seem that the effect of the foot and mouth disease has been appreciated in regard to the amount of supplies which will be available for human consumption. I saw a fair yesterday in my home town. There were not less than 600 or 800—possibly 1,000—young pigs in that town, from eight to 14 weeks old. I imagine that not more than 150 of them were sold and the balance were taken home to small farm places which have been accustomed to keeping more live stock than they were able to find or produce food for on their farms. They are now facing a situation that no supplies are available to be purchased and if they can keep them at all they are to be kept by feeding to them food which probably may be essential for the maintenance of human life here. That is part of the problem up and down the country.
That will have other consequences as well. It seems that, by July next, possibly one bacon factory will cure all the pigs that the country produces week after week, and hundreds—perhaps thousands—will be unemployed as a result. That situation is being accentuated day after day in a way which the Minister does not realise. We may as well face the fact that, despite anything Senator MacDermot may say about the line that ought to be pursued by this nation, the majority of the people assented to a policy of non-belligerency. While there are individuals here and there who have different views about it, I have no hesitation in saying that the consensus of opinion is that non-belligerency should be maintained. In its maintenance very great problems will have to be faced.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Senator, but I wonder if he wishes to imply that I have argued to-night in favour of belligerency. I was arguing really in favour of non-belligerency, as opposed to rather unfavourable neutrality.
Comment on this
I am not going to cut off into that line of debate. As I see things, we will have internally here rather disturbed conditions for ourselves, for various reasons. Incomes will fall; for some people incomes will be cut off, and for a great many people food will be short; for some it will scarcely be procurable and for all, even with money to buy, it will be difficult to get. We should face up to this situation and see that whatever burdens have to be borne shall be shared equitably. If the Government fails to do that, government itself is failing. A few people may have to go hungry, but if the number of hungry people reaches mass proportions it may not be possible to keep them quite. I am quite convinced that, with imagination and courage on the part of the Government and co-operation on the part of the people, it is possible to organise a proper exchange of services, in order to employ many who are not employed to-day. Co-operation is only possible, however, when you are in support of the policy that is being carried out and when you have confidence that the people who carry out the policy are the best who could be got.
It is possible to give incomes to people who have none. It is possible to increase the national income and, accordingly, increase the capacity of our people to bear burdens which national government and non-belligerency impose upon them in these days.
I would like to hear from the Minister what plans, or what effort he himself, and his Government, are making towards the carrying out of such a scheme as that, because, obviously, it is imperative —it is absolutely essential. I have stated my views very frequently in this House. As far as Government Senators are concerned, I might as well be talking to the statue of Queen Victoria outside, but I am quite convinced that if my arguments had carried weight and had received the support of Government Senators to which they were entitled, we could have enough food in this country to keep our people from being hungry and to feed our animals as well. I am quite convinced about that. I know what I can do myself, and I know what my neighbouring farmers can do, if they know they are going to be paid for their work.
I have heard other Senators say that they do not believe in that method of guaranteeing prices, yet in the same breath, almost, they ask for increased prices for certain commodities which is exactly putting in other words what I asked for. There is a shortage of supplies in this country to-day. Men have talked about wheat. I put this to the House: I have always held the view that we could grow wheat. I know equally well that there are great tracts in this country that cannot grow wheat, and that there are other areas that can grow it, but not economically, and that in the country generally you cannot pursue a successful policy of wheat-growing unless you have cattle at the same time to keep your land fertile, not alone by the bounteous use of farmyard manure, but by the addition of fertilisers as well. In my opinion, we ought never to have embarked on what the Ministry regarded as this extensive wheat policy of theirs. Mind you, I have not found fault with it generally, but, if we had not embarked on it, the possibility is that the supplies of wheat in the country last autumn would have been much greater than when we were growing a greater proportion of our needs at home. I think it is a distinct possibility that we would have had a greater stock of flour in store if we had to import it, because I am satisfied the importers did not do it owing to the restrictions and regulations you had to impose to carry out your policy.
It is my view, after a great deal of thought and consideration, that the only way to ensure that we get the maximum quantity of food produced from our own land is to tell the farmers that they are going to be paid decent prices for their work. You cannot go to the farmer, any more than to anyone else, without telling him at the beginning of the year, as precisely as you can, what he is likely to get for his produce at the end of it. If you put a Minister into his post, a civil servant, a banker or a road worker, you will find that they would not go very far until they were told what they were going to get. Every man likes to know what price will be available for his time, and the farmer is the one man who is not being told by the Government. I have put up that consideration before and I stand by it. I know the consequences of it in Northern Ireland. It has had amazing results.
It may interest the Minister to know that in 1939 or in the beginning of 1940, the Six-County Government asked for 200,000 additional acres under tillage. Prior to asking that, they announced guaranteed prices, not only for wheat, but for oats, potatoes, barley, flax and for milk as well. Six-County farmers are being paid ¼ to ? a gallon for their milk, while, for the last four or five months, our own farmers have had to be content with 6d. or 7d. a gallon. The result of the Six-County Government's policy in asking for 200,000 acres and telling the farmers the prices they would pay, was that they got 260,000 acres. In the Twenty-Six Counties, Ministers were talking about 1,000,000 acres and they did not get 300,000 acres under the plough. I say we would have got it if we took the same steps as the Northern Government. To-day, we would not have to slaughter immature pigs because of a shortage of feeding stuffs for them—we would have the food.
The national income, and certainly the agricultural income, would be much higher, and you could bank on that, than you know it is to-day. That problem is still there, and it will continue to confront us until we give stability to the industry of agriculture, and until the farmers can produce more and put more people to work on the land. We must raise the national income of the farmers, stabilise the economy of the country generally, and give the confidence to agriculture which it has not enjoyed for a great many years.
Along with the work of providing food, I agree with Senator Quirke that we need to provide fuel. In the past, we have been exporting for the purpose of importing and coal was one of our large imports. Apparently, we are not going to get adequate supplies in the future, and some of what is coming in is not as satisfactory as it is required to be. It is true to say that there is fuel in abundance in this country. I do not think you can wait on the machine-made fuel, or on the kind of organisation the Government has set up. The way to do it is to get, now, every man who can handle a sleán in the country out to do his share. In my opinion, men able to cut turf are just as essential for national defence as men with guns and, perhaps, even more so. I believe it would be well worth the while of the Ministry to take a census of the position, to see how many men in this country can cut turf or use sleáns—aye, even to transfer them from one county to another, and put in others to fill their places for the time being, to provide us with the fuel the country may require and may not be able to get before next year.
But, it should be borne in mind that if you are going to get turf cut, it is no good starting on the 29th June. I do not know whether the Minister knows that, but it is very important. I think you could put many thousands of people on the work of providing fuel for ourselves which Scottish and English miners provided for us in the past. Somebody may ask where is the money to come from. Perhaps the Minister would tell us something about the Report of the Banking Commission? Is anything being done about it, or is there any other plan for providing money more cheaply than the present bankers who are charging 5 and 6 per cent.? I think that the dangers many people have foreseen in inflation are not anything like as bad as the dangers of starvation, and I would rather run the risk of inflating a bit—employing more people and providing the means by which they could exchange their goods and services and take the risks—rather than sit still and do nothing.
What terrifies me most is that the Government are not half enough alarmed about the situation that confronts us. I do not want to be an alarmist. I know all sorts of things have been said in this House and outside this House about the case I make but I prefer to be a realist and to face up to the facts. It is much better. If you try to evade the issue it is only piling up greater danger. It would be much better for the Government, as I have said, to adopt all the unorthodox methods, to get on with the job and to get people working than just to sit and wait and hope for something to turn up. In these days, with turmoil and upheaval in men's minds, in the present world situation, the situation is one which I think the Government would be very unwise to permit to develop here. Auxiliary bodies or well-meaning citizens outside or any group of people cannot do this. Only the Government, with its power of organisation, its power to make money available, and its power, if it will exercise courage and imagination and display the spirit necessary to win co-operation, can get these things done. The work is there to do, plenty of work, and I suggest if the Minister wants to find the money which he requires he will be able to do that only by taking extraordinary steps to increase the national income this year. If he does not, it is going to drop to levels that will stagger him.
There is one further point I want to make before I conclude, and that is in regard to the appalling danger which, I think, threatens the country due to the foot and mouth disease. Personally, the consequences of the spread of this disease stagger me. The restrictions extend now to an area in my own county, the poorest area in my own county. I have been talking to people who are within that area who cannot move any of their stock, who cannot move hay or straw or anything like that even within the area. It happens to be an area in which the food available for man or beast is limited at all times. What is going to happen there after another month if the restrictions continue is beyond me to answer. The food supplies for the cattle will be completely used up. The land will not be providing anything until right into the month of June. I think that is a situation which the Minister ought to examine with a view to seeing what can be done about the problem. These things cannot be left unattended to.
With regard to the spread of this disease, I do not like to say it, but I have the feeling that some of the farmers are altogether too lackadaisical with regard to taking the necessary measures to having the disease stamped out. Unless the farmers do everything possible, go to all extremes and are prepared to subject themselves even to what might be regarded as injustices, in order to stamp out the disease, the consequences for this nation may be very terrible. Where farmers are negligent and where farmers do not take all the necessary steps to have the evidence of the disease immediately reported so that it may be tackled and dealt with with vigour and energy, my view is that these people are doing the community and the nation a grave injustice and that action ought to be taken which would ensure that farmers will in no case cloak the presence of disease and get away with it. I do not know whether this has taken place or not but it is most extraordinary that the disease is spreading from one part of the country as it is, enveloping, slowly but dreadfully, one province after another. If it goes on for two or three months more, if our exports continue to be restricted, if our supplies continue to fall, as they are falling, day after day, the food problem for the citizens of Dublin will become more acute than they can anticipate at the moment because farmers down the country will be using up all sorts of food, even the potatoes and other foods, which they probably ought to be keeping for their families and for the people in towns and cities who will not have food for themselves. I would like the Minister to draw the attention of the Minister for Agriculture to that point. I think a statement with regard to the responsibility of farmers in that matter ought to be made so as to give all of us encouragement and to make us feel every effort is being made, not only on the part of the Ministry, but by the farmers as well, to grapple with this disease, for if we cannot overwhelm it, it will overwhelm us.
Comment on this
As the hour is getting late and as various aspects of this subject have been discussed at very great length here this evening, and as I am sure the Minister will require all the time now available to deal with the various points raised, it is not my intention to dwell very long on the matters under discussion. However, there are certain aspects of the Bill before us this evening to which I would like to call attention. The Bill affords an opportunity to discuss practically every aspect of Government policy from the League of Nations to the law of diminishing returns, but, I think, although that discussion was of an extremely widespread and varied character, it did disclose that there was a crisis in the future before the country and a very serious crisis at that. Some of us in this House are extremely concerned for a certain class in the community and if the statements we have listened to here this evening from responsible Senators indicate clearly and closely what that position is likely to be, then I say the situation is serious and will require very great consideration from all of us. I think, in addition, we will require a very full statement from the Minister here this evening in regard to what the Government has in view by way of plans to meet that situation.
A blockade has been referred to. Unquestionably, the action of both belligerents in this war is having a very serious effect on our industries as a whole. A statement made by Senator Goulding, I think, is to be taken notice of, which was to the effect that nobody should be allowed starve in this country in the approaching crisis. It is a serious situation if Senator Goulding is of opinion at the present moment that there are people who are likely to starve in the near future. The chairman of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce recently—I hope I am quoting him correctly; I have not got the statement by me—but I think he said that within six or nine months we would have 250,000 unemployed in this country. That is a serious statement. References by employers of industrial workers are made daily in the Press in regard to raw materials. If the source of our industry, namely our raw materials, which have to be imported, is cut off, then unquestionably there is going to be created a very serious industrial, financial and economic position for the country as a whole. It is probably statements of that character that influenced the minds of Senators this evening when they spoke about an approaching or impending industrial crisis and of the dire consequences, economically and socially, which they anticipated would flow from the position which was about to be created. I am sure the Minister and the Government are sensible of this approaching crisis, and I think we are entitled on this Bill to know precisely and explicitly what the Government propose to do in view of the circumstances which we understand are approaching. I notice that the Estimate for Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Assistance is down this year as against the sum provided last year. If these are the only methods by which the Government proposes to deal with the economic difficulties which are anticipated, then I think we can conclude here and now, that this method is no solution, and cannot be looked upon as satisfactory to meet the difficulties ahead of us. I presume, therefore, the Government have other plans, and I say that we should be told in the debate on this Bill what these plans are.
Speaking, I think it was last July, I asked a similar question as to what was proposed to be done in the event of this country's trade being cut off from Great Britain and of our incapacity to export our ordinary goods in order to maintain our economic life. The difficulties I felt we were then approaching are nearer now, and debates here and similar debates elsewhere show conclusively that there is not a section or a class of people in this country, rich or poor, which is not seriously alarmed by the approaching difficulties.
I would like if time were available to pursue some of the economic theories and arguments propounded here by certain learned Senators who are supposed to be extremely skilled by reason of their profession to deal with economics. Professor Johnston spoke upon the subject and endeavoured to propound the solution that we should have greater production of agricultural goods in the country so that they might be exchanged for coal and other materials required by the industries of this country. If greater production would meet the situation why, I ask, has the present situation arisen? Surely, if Senator Johnston reflected that the great difficulty with regard to supplies is largely a question of transport then even if we had greater production of agricultural goods we would be up against the same difficulty of transport because of the difficulty of getting raw materials to keep our industries going? Therefore, it seems to me utterly fallacious to talk on these lines or to propound a remedy along these lines.
The Senator also suggested that the Minister for Finance should go easy with taxation. I think he meant that if we come up against the law of diminishing returns the Minister will get less in taxes and consequently will only worsen the position. He also suggested in that portion of his speech that we should increase production. If increased production is not exported in exchange, it is to be presumed it is meant for internal consumption. There will be more employment if industrial supplies are cut off? It is difficult for some of us to see where the money is to come from to purchase this production. I think however we ought to have a statement from the Minister when he speaks as to how it is proposed that the supplies produced are to reach people who are not in a position to purchase them because of the fact that they are unemployed. Senator Baxter also stressed that aspect of the problem and called for more and more agricultural production to raise the national revenue. These are all high sounding phrases. I would like to know what they mean in actual practice.
If our foreign trade is cut off, and our imports of raw material restricted, how are we to secure that this consumption of agricultural produce is to come into the hands of those who are denied their ordinary means of livelihood if unemployed. It seems to me that increased production on the land and little or no production in urban industry would give you a very unbalanced economy in this country. If that is the case how do you propose the economy would be balanced so that those not in a position to purchase by virtue of being unemployed shall be able to purchase the ordinary necessaries of life? In other words how are you going to provide, in the words of Senator Goulding, that those who will starve because they have not got the means of livelihood will be kept from starving?
That is briefly the impression this debate has left on my mind. All the factors in the case have been stressed and perhaps overstressed. There were tentative phrases and solutions as to where we might go outside orthodox methods. It seems to me if the problem cannot be dealt with by ordinary laws of political economy or ordinary financial methods some other methods must be adopted if the people are to receive the fuel, the food and clothes, etc., necessary to their material existence. Some Senators have spoken tentatively upon these aspects of the case but I think they have not gone sufficienly far to satisfactorily state how that problem could be surmounted, or to state what plans they had in mind. I trust that when the Minister comes to deal with the Bill now he will let us know what is proposed to be done by the Government because, unquestionably, that is the kernel of the situation. No matter what may have been said about the League of Nations, the Censorship, and all the other semi-relevant matters that were dealt with here this evening the important thing is that there is an economic crisis developing in this country. That has been the outstanding feature of the debate. What is proposed by the Government to meet that economic crisis now or in the future?
Comment on this
This debate has dragged on rather late and I shall not delay the House very long. I only wish to draw the Minister's attention, as other Senators have done, to the items where a decrease has been made in the Estimate. Under three or four headings we have this occurring, particularly in regard to housing grants, unemployment relief grants, unemployment insurance, land division, and the Forestry Department. I think that all those I have mentioned are so closely linked or connected with the giving of employment that it is rather unfortunate that there should be a reduction. So far as the housing grants are concerned, at the present time many people, tradesmen and craftsmen of various kinds, are being knocked out of employment, and I would urge on the Minister and the Government that they should face this question boldly. We have the raw materials of building, as it were. We have the cement, the slates, the timber; we have the land, and we have huge numbers of people looking for employment, and even with a threat of invasion hanging over our heads we should face the position boldly and do all we can to create employment at the present time, not alone in building but in other directions. I think that local authorities and private individuals should be encouraged to go ahead with building Last year, I think, we were promised a more extensive and comprehensive Housing Bill. I hope that when that Bill comes along later, greater facilities will be given to building societies and greater grants given in urban areas. In cities like Galway, as everyone knows, we have a number of tradesmen being knocked out of employment. These people have big commitments, in regard to rents, rates, insurance, and so on, and they cannot be very well fitted into other types of employment.
As regards the Forestry Estimate, the only reason I mention it is that we spend a good amount of money on this Department each year, and while it is very essential and very useful to have a certain amount of forestry in the country I fear that we are not making proper use of the trees we have. There is no firm, or at least I think there is only one firm in this country, that has proper plant for the treatment of our native timber, for the seasoning and drying of the timber under circumstances that would make it of the best use. That is a thing that could be undertaken by the Forestry Department. I think that 300 acres is the smallest acreage they will take, but when it comes to the cutting of these trees there they should have one of these plants for the seasoning, drying and proper treatment of the timber.
Various appeals have been made to the Minister for Finance in connection with loans for farmers, but if it were possible I should like the Minister to consider the position of our local authorities and the position of the people in the cities. In Galway City, as many Senators know, the rates are 32/6 in the £ at the present time, and if there could be any means of making cheap loans available, so that the local authorities there and in similar cities could redeem the loans purchased at high rates of interest, it would ease the position, considerably. I do not know whether it is possible or not, but something will have to be done towards relieving the people in our cities at the present time.
The Minister, speaking on unemployment relief work, said that there was, I think, £1,000,000 being allocated for that this year and that if schemes were put up the money for these schemes would be forthcoming. We would all agree with that, but like other Senators I think we shall have to tackle this question of fuel very seriously. It is estimated, I think, that something like 2,000,000 tons of turf will be required this year. That is a big proposition. It is a big proposition to supply our towns and cities, and the Government should set up the necessary machinery immediately. As a matter of fact, I think that a county commission for works of production like that should be established and that that commission should have the duty of taking over our idle bogs and lands that are not in cultivation, and should also have the job of providing the ways and means of work for unemployed people who are anxious to work. Now, that cannot be done by people who know nothing about turf. You have got to start making arrangements about the 1st April, and continue from that on. I do not believe that this work should be left in the hands of the Land Commission or the Turf Board. They have a certain amount of lands and bogs under their own charge, but I do not think this matter should be left in their hands. Neither are we going to solve the problem by issuing an appeal to parish councils and similar bodies to do it. You must go out immediately and organise this thing, and not only organise the cutting and saving of the turf, but organise its distribution and sale to the people also. You cannot depend on the ordinary coal merchants for that. I believe that you will have to set up a purchasing body in each of our towns. At the present time, I understand that in Connemara there are some thousands of tons of turf—that is probably an exaggeration, but so I have been informed—lying there since last year. If that turf is not purchased immediately from these people you cannot ask or expect them to cut more turf this year. You may appeal to them but they will not do it. The Government should make arrangements immediately to purchase this turf, either through the Army or through some purchasing board which could be set up to take the turf off the people's hands and give them some encouragement to cut turf for the coming year. If you give them that encouragement I believe they will do all you want, but if you do not, then they will not cut more turf.
This thing of relying on the parish councils will not do. You may have a good parish council in one place, and that depends very often on having an energetic parish priest and energetic, efficient people at the head, but if you have not something like that there is very little to be got from the parish councils. I was all for parish councils at first, but I am rather beginning to change my mind as I go along, when I see some of these parish councils carrying on in the same way as some other organisations, and expecting the Government to do everything for them. I think it would be better to put somebody in control in each county, either the county commissioner or somebody else, and give him full authority in the matter of organising food production and the provision of employment. There are plenty of unemployed who would do the work all right if the work were there for them.
We have had a number of appeals being issued from time to time for increased food production, but there is a type of person, I think, who has been left out with regard to that appeal. In many of our towns and cities there are people in possession of holdings of land, and while all our appeals go out to the farmer, I think that we have forgotten the type of person to whom I am referring. In some places they may not have sufficient land to bring them under the Compulsory Tillage Order, and in other cases they would find some other excuse, such as that it was dairy land and so on, but these people have a certain amount of land and they are not doing what they should do. Some of them are not even producing enough for themselves and their families, although they have sufficient land to enable them to do so and also to have something left over for the poor.
I should like to associate myself with Senator Sir John Keane in what he said. I think that his suggestion with regard to communal feeding in our towns and cities deserves serious consideration, and something will have to be done along that line as the position which the Senator foresees is almost upon us at the present moment.
Comment on this
Many points have been discussed in this debate, but I think there is one thing that merits our attention more than anything else, and that is the question of food production from the land. It is 12 months ago now since it was discussed here before, and it was pointed out how necessary it was that the food required to feed our people should be produced from the land during the past year. I am afraid that has not been done and, worse than that, I very much doubt if enough will be produced this year to feed our people during the coming 12 months. That is the one great task which lies before the country. The one great task that lies before the country is to see that food sufficient to feed the people is produced. That in my opinion is more vital than industrial production, fuel production or defence. The question of producing sufficient food transcends every other problem in the very real blockade that has come upon us. If there is an abundance of food produced in the country, it will be an easy matter for anybody to distribute that food in such a way that nobody need starve. Though other industries may fail, one thing that can be made certain is that nobody need starve. If there is not sufficient food produced on the land, it does not matter what money remains in the country or what industries are working, people will have to go hungry. What is still worse, if we go short of food we may not be in a position to maintain our neutrality. The essential point, therefore, is to see before it is too late, as it soon will be too late, that sufficient food is produced within the country. For that reason I think the Government should spare no effort, no matter how drastic, to see that the Tillage Order is enforced and that credit is provided to enable seeds, machinery and in fact every available facility to be placed at the disposal of farmers.
Another point that I should like to put before the Government is that, notwithstanding increased tillage, there has been scarcely any additional employment provided in rural districts as in recent years much of the tillage is done by machinery. There is, in fact, great unemployment in many rural districts and I think, therefore, that unemployment assistance should be given at least to married people during all periods of the year. I know that in some cases unemployment assistance has been abused very often but in the case of married people it is very seldom abused because they cannot afford to remain on the dole if any work is available. I think also the time has come when the Government should seriously consider the question whether agricultural labour should not be subsidised. The position at the moment is that the price of agricultural produce, especially such of it as is exported, does not afford a living wage and, of course, a labouring man cannot work without a living wage. It seems to me that the Government will have to consider the question of giving a subsidy to cover the margin between what is an economic wage for the farmer and what is a living wage for the labourer. As I have said before, the real problem, however, is to produce all the food we possibly can on the land during the next few months.
Comment on this
I agree with the last speaker, and with other Senators who have spoken in a similar strain, that one of the most urgent problems, if not the most urgent, now before us is the production of food. I was glad to hear several Senators emphasise that. Senator O'Dwyer, Senator Johnston, Senator Baxter, Senator Madden, Senator O Buachalla and Senator Quirke all agreed on that point. I think the Government has done all that it could reasonably be expected to do in the way of urging the importance of this matter on the country and particularly on landholders.
For many months past, I have listened occasionally to radio talks by the Taoiseach, by the Minister for Agriculture, by the Minister for Supplies, and I have seen frequent speeches by other Ministers and, indeed, by other members of the Dáil and Seanad of all Parties, reported in the newspapers putting before the community as a whole the urgency of this problem. I do not know whether any further urging or appealing to the landed community, rich or poor, is likely to have any greater effect but, nevertheless, perhaps it should be persisted in up to the last hour that it is possible to sow food of any kind for man or beast with the possibility of reaping it in the harvest of this year.
I do not think that there has been any neglect in that matter. Long before Christmas speeches were made by Ministers. There have been special reasons since then for greater pressure being brought to bear on the community as a whole by everybody responsible—and primarily the Government is responsible in this matter —to get the country to realise the urgency of the matter and how essential it is that everybody who has land should cultivate it to the fullest possible extent so that every variety of foodstuffs for which people can get the necessary seeds and manures should be produced. The greatest difficulty probably will arise over the matter of wheat. Nobody knows at this moment whether we will be able to produce enough wheat for our needs this year. Different opinions have been expressed. Some in authority have expressed doubt on the matter, but even now I understand, although I am no authority on agriculture, there is still time for the production of spring wheat. I hope that the advice given by so many responsible men here to-day and which has also been given by the various members of the Government, from the Taoiseach down, will be heeded by those who have it within their power to grow food of all kinds, particularly wheat. I hope they will see to it that no opportunity will be lost while there is yet time for the sowing of wheat.
I was interested in a couple of references of a personal nature that were made in the early stages of this discussion. Senator Hayes, I think, made a veiled reference to something that took place in the Dáil last week. Possibly the same thing was in the mind of Senator Johnston when he referred to the fact that he hoped I was in a mild mood. I think I am nearly always mild. I am one of those people who are referred to as being like a dangerous animal—when he is attacked he defends himself. I defend myself, perhaps not with all the dignity that I am told ought to surround my office and myself in that office. Perhaps I am at fault, but who is it that does not err sometimes? I defend myself— if not in the choicest language always— and that cannot be regarded as a grave error. I do not think I ever showed bad temper in this House. I often get hard knocks here and, probably as long as I continue as Minister, I will again; and I do not object to that, but I try to give as hard as I get. And if the other fellow gets a good one in, I give him credit and say it is one up to him, but some time or other, if not immediately, I will give him a good welt if I can. I have given a few and I have reason to know that they have left their mark—maybe some of them have left their mark on me, too.
Comment on this
That is not a new interpretation of the Golden Rule?
Comment on this
Well, I am a human individual, very human. I listened with the greatest interest to the debate here to-day. I got much advice and I was asked for a great deal of advice. I was requested by many to expound theories and plans and programmes, but I think I will forgo the pleasure of developing plans and programmes in any detail, or at great length, to-night. Probably, I will be coming here again, if God spares me for the next few weeks, and will have to meet this House and debate—and defend, probably—the formal propositions of the Government in the way of the annual financial Budget. It is usual for the Government spokesman to outline the financial programme for the year and all that that connotes, when the Budget is introduced. It is now in preparation and, as Senators here have reminded me, we are passing through an unsettled and difficult situation. It is not an easy time for any Minister for Finance. Senator Baxter recognised that fact and said he would not like to be in my shoes.
Comment on this
It is a hard and a difficult job. We are not living in normal times. Senator Counihan would like credit provided for farmers in liberal measure by the Government and would like to see the farmers "made prosperous and contented." So would I, but who is going to achieve that? Senator Hayes recognised the fact that if the Archangel Michael came down and was Minister for Finance, with all the whole financial powers of the 32 Counties at his control, he would not make the farmers prosperous and contented to their own satisfaction.
Comment on this
I was interested in Senator Counihan's suggestion and had a private chat with him earlier. He is a good propagandist and an enthusiast in his subject. He tried to get a promise from me, even before I heard his plan outlined, that I would be sympathetic. He will not mind me saying in a kindly way that he is a sympathetic kind of fellow and one likes listening to him. He makes a good impression, but it does not follow that, sympathetic as I may be towards his projects, the Minister for Finance will promise right away that the suggestion which the Senator thinks would make the farmers happy and contented will be adopted. I was pleased to hear Senator Sir John Keane give his conditional blessing to the proposition of a committee as proposed by Senator Counihan but, as I said to Senator Counihan outside, I wonder if the Minister for Agriculture has been convinced that the scheme is a good one. After all, he is the Minister whose duty it is to look after agriculturists and I think one ought to convince him first. If that can be done, I promise to be sympathetic.
I do not know what has happened between the Minister for Agriculture and himself, or whether the proposition has been formally put before him, but that is the first fence to jump and, if his horse is able to get over that and comes along to me, I will not turn it down without due, serious and—as I promised him and as I say to the Seanad here—sympathetic consideration. I do not promise that I will be likely to go within a long distance of anything that would seem to make the farmers as a whole prosperous and contented. We were told here to-day that this Government had not succeeded in increasing the productive capacity of the country. We tried hard and did succeed in some directions. Even in many directions we did not succeed to our own satisfaction. We did not get much help in some directions from many of the Senators here, nor from Senator Baxter, nor Senator Hayes— I do not know about Senator Douglas.
Comment on this
I never worked on the land, and do not be throwing that at me. I do not know anything about it except what I learned as an ordinary common-sense, and, perhaps, more or less educated person, but, as to work on the land, I cannot speak with anything like or near the authority of Senator Baxter. But, it is a fact that we tried hard to get more tillage of every kind in this country, and it is also a fact that some Senators, and Senator Baxter's Party as a whole, did their damnedest to stop us getting extra tillage in certain directions. I do not think anybody can deny that. We tried to get extra wheat grown, and we succeeded largely. We have not succeeded in getting enough. We would be in a much happier position to-day if we had succeeded, first of all, in being able to get people to keep the cultivation they had of the various things they grew on the land, and to give us in addition the extra tillage we wanted, particularly in wheat. Senator Baxter knows how fun was made of that wheat policy by some of his leaders. Deputy Dillon threw all the scorn he could on it. Many a time I have listened to him during general elections and by-elections around the country making these speeches, and, after all, he is an important man in the Senator's Party, and he was not alone.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not know that what determines the farmer in what he will do is the price that he will be paid and not election speeches?
Comment on this
On that one point, the price paid for wheat, I heard the Minister for Agriculture say in the Dáil during the last few weeks that in the many county committees of agriculture that he visited and met since Christmas in connection with this tillage campaign, not one farmer said that he was not getting enough for wheat and nobody repudiated that in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am not going to go into that matter now. The Minister made that statement in the Dáil and there was not attempt to repudiate it. He stated that in answer to Deputy Belton, who wanted 50/- a barrel. As I have said, we would be in a much happier position to-day if there had been greater support for the wheat campaign. It is not much use going back on it and I would not do so if the thing had not been adverted to several times here to-day. If we had a great deal more wheat we would be certain of bread to eat anyway.
Comment on this
I agree. We ought to have more potatoes. There will be good prices, I am sure, for potatoes, oats and barley.
Comment on this
The question of supplies in general and the Minister for Supplies came in for a great deal of criticism, not always too complimentary, to-day. I do not intend to go into the question of supplies or to defend the Minister in his policy. That was debated at great length in the Dáil recently and it might interest Senators, particularly Senators Baxter and Hayes, to hear that I have it from a colleague of mine in the Government, that immediately after the debate in which Mr. Lemass defended himself on his policy of supplies, two members of the Fine Gael Party told this colleague of mine that they never heard Lemass make a better speech and never did he defend himself with better effect or more convincingly. They said they were disappointed that the speaker of the Front Bench who followed Mr. Lemass did not recognise that fact. That was the impression Mr. Lemass's speech made on me.
Comment on this
Yes. I said after he had spoken: "Lemass has wiped the floor with those who criticised him."
Comment on this
I am not so simple and nobody ever took me in this House or anywhere else for a fool. I am just as ready to tell Mr. Lemass so if I thought he failed as I would be to tell him that I thought he had been a success.
Comment on this
I would not get up in the House and criticise him, and you would not expect that from me.
Comment on this
I have a note here —I think it is from Senator Hayes' speech—regarding the fall of France. I heard the Minister for Supplies that night in the debate tell the House that we got several shiploads of wheat after the fall of France, as a result, probably, of the fall of France. Wheat that was going to other parts of the country was diverted here. I could not say how many, but I know that ship loads came. I would want to be a walking encyclopædia or several encyclopædiae rolled into one, if I were to attempt to answer many of the questions that were levelled at me during the course of the debate to-day. There are very few Ministries that did not come in for notice and, as I said about the Minister for Supplies, it was not always complimentary. I do not pretend to be able to answer in detail many of the questions that were put up to me. The Army and the Minister for Defence were criticised by Senator Hayes; perhaps more the Minister for Defence than the Army, and I think he was referring to the gentleman who was Minister for Defence before he became the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures. He seems to be a kind of bête noire with some of the Senators here, may be Senator Hayes in particular. He did a good job as Minister for Defence and I hope he is going to do a better one now in America in his capacity of envoy there to get us supplies.
Comment on this
It will not all depend on him, but we have a very sympathetic people in the United States. The people of the United States, in general, have always been sympathetic with this country, not alone the Irish there, but the people of the United States in general, and I am sure he will be warmly, courteously and helpfully received there. In that connection Senator Hayes made reference to the fact that the President of the United States had stated that he was not aware officially that the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures was going to the United States. All I can say is that everything that the protocol lays down that should be done on such an occasion was attended to properly. And more than that, I know there were conversations with the American Minister here who knew, long before the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures left our shores, all about his visit. The American Minister was kind enough, long before, to write and supply the Minister with letters of introduction recommending him and recommending his mission, and I know that the Minister here was as courteous and as kind and as helpful as a man could be, though I do not know what official dispatches he sent over the wire or otherwise to his Government. I am satisfied he did his duty officially, fully as competently and as well as could be expected of him or any other man in his position.
Comment on this
Our Minister in the United States, likewise, was fully informed both by telephone and by cable, long before the event and, to my knowledge, had formally notified the Secretary of State of the United States of the intended visit by the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures. What more could be done?
Comment on this
Both Senator Hayes and Senator Baxter dealt with the question of co-operation with the Government. I have spoken on this subject more than once and I, personally, and speaking on behalf of the Government, have stated that the Government is anxious for co-operation. I have been assured by Leaders of the Opposition that co-operation will be given, but if I am to take the word of Senator Hayes, and more particularly Senator Baxter, such co-operation is not likely to be forthcoming. Senator Baxter said co-operation is only possible when you are in favour of the policy and when you have confidence in the persons who are carrying out the policy of the Government. If we do not go any further than to listen to the speech of Senator Baxter to-night, how could we expect him to believe in the policy of the Government? He does not believe in it; he has never believed in it. I know that Senator Hayes is even more emphatic. I have heard him say so many times over—not alone more emphatic in his disbelief in the policy, but more emphatic in his want of confidence and belief in the capacity of the individual members of the Government, probably individually and collectively. I think I am not wronging him in saying that. If then I am to take Senator Baxter's statement, co-operation is finished. There is no chance of getting it. He does not believe in the policy and he has no confidence in the individuals.
Comment on this
But I do not expect that the Senator, even in that statement of his that I took down carefully, expects us to take him 100 per cent. seriously, because I think that he realises the seriousness of the situation that this country is facing——
Comment on this
——and which is facing the Seanad and the Dáil and the people as a whole as well as the Government. We do not know what is going to be in front of us this year or maybe next year. We cannot tell. Senator Baxter himself stressed the seriousness of the situation and questioned whether the Government fully realised it. I think we are not entirely devoid of imagination but while we do realise that we are facing, and that we are going to face still more, a serious situation, maybe it is that we do not fully realise all that may be in store for us. I hope the worst that some of us can imagine will, with God's help, be spared us, that we will not have to face some of the things that maybe are in Senator Baxter's mind and are in my mind and the minds of other members of the Government. But even if the worst does not happen, the situation for us as a people, the situation of the Government having the responsibility, is likely to be a heavy enough burden to carry. The Government would like co-operation but it can only carry out to the best of its belief the policy that it stands for and believes in, such as it is. It may not be worth much according to some Senators, but there it is.
There has to be a Government. That Government has to be selected by certain rules that are laid down in our Constitution, and the Government that is in office, which happened to be in office when this world crisis arose, is a Government that was not elected in a haphazard fashion. Senators here, even those who are most bitterly hostile to the Government, admit that the Government has been duly and properly elected, subject to all the constitutional rules and regulations and the various statutes that lay down how the Government is to be elected. That has happened on several occasions. It has gone before the people and the people have expressed their will. For good or ill, this Government is there and it has the confidence of the people. It has secured that and it retains it and whether Senators are pleased with the Government, in its policy or in its personnel, they have for the time being to put up with it and make the best of it. Nobody asks Senators in the Opposition to change their views; it would be foolish to do so; nobody expects that of them. I do not think the words Senator Baxter used in describing what may happen were exaggerated—not according to my ideas of what may be in store for us—and in this grave crisis I think the Government is entitled to expect such amount of co-operation as will help to see the country safely through the grave dangers and difficulties that may face us before many months are over. Senator Hayes said that co-operation implies work on two sides. I agree. But he cannot expect that the Government is going to somersault politically in this stage of its history, in this time of crisis——
Comment on this
——and scrap all that it has said and done so that it may get the helpful co-operation of Senator Hayes and his Party. I have just said I do not expect anything of the kind from Senator Hayes' Party but we do nevertheless expect such co-operation and help and suggestion, including criticism, including, if you like, any amount of criticism. I do not resent, and no person in the Government is foolish enough or should be foolish enough to resent, criticism. Certainly I do not. Senator Hayes said we have not made ourselves self-sufficient.
Comment on this
There is. Self-sufficiency is a relative term. I do not know even if the Government were in office for 100 years that it would succeed in making this country completely self-sufficient. Possibly the countries nearest to that position are France and the United States. I am sure in proportion to their population and means that they have to import, at least in the case of France, millions of pounds' worth of materials of all kinds. They did their best to reach a well balanced economy in France. We are many miles away from being nearly as self-sufficient as France or America. Probably we could never succeed in being self-sufficient because we have not the natural resources. Nevertheless, we stand for self-sufficiency. This Government has already gone quite a good way along that road. We would now be in a very sad way indeed, with regard to certain materials that we require, but for our policy.
Comment on this
I said complete self-sufficiency. I qualify it with these important words "complete self-sufficiency." We cannot have that.
Comment on this
He lived a long time ago. I do not know whether it is in that connection that someone talked about muddled thinking to describe our policy. But could anything be more muddled than the thinking of the Front Benchers in the Opposition Party who signed a report in 1929 stating that wheat could not be grown in this country. The late Minister for Agriculture, Mr. Hogan, Lord rest his soul, was one of the signatories and the others were Deputy McGilligan, who was then a Minister, and Deputy Brennan, who is also on their Front Bench.
Comment on this
Do you mean that the report stated that wheat could not be grown economically: grown without a subsidy?
Comment on this
The Senator should get the report and study it. That was the substance of the report. It was used as propaganda to prove to the country that the growing of wheat was a farce, and could not be accomplished.
Comment on this
Was it not also proved to the country that we could reduce current expenditure by £3,000,000?
Comment on this
Oh, as usual, the Senator wants to run away from the question of wheat and draw a red herring. Why did he raise the question of wheat? Now he is getting what he asked for.
Comment on this
I do not think I said anything about wheat. I do not want to deny anything I did say.
Comment on this
It was raised in connection with the question of self-sufficiency and muddled thinking, and, I think, to bring in wheat is relevant with all respect to the Senator, and particularly to bring in that report which he does not like.
Comment on this
It will be quite welcome. Senator Hayes wants me to get on to a subject where I will not tread on his toes, but I am not going to follow his red herring. Senator Sir John Keane talked about communal feeding and recommended that efforts should be made to see that in the likelihood of certain eventualities here people would not be left without good and cheap food. I happened to meet the Parliamentary Secretary to the Department of Defence, during the interval, and I knew that he had been charged with responsibility in connection with A.R.P. and other services and that he had been dealing with the question of communal feeding. He assured me that the setting up of communal kitchens had been the subject of examination by the Department, and also by the Department of Local Government for the past six months. The Department of Defence has ordered, and I think has secured, a number of field kitchens. Efforts are being made to secure other equipment of that kind to meet such an emergency as the Senator has in mind. The Parliamentary Secretary has had committees set up and meetings have been held. I have here a copy of a report of a meeting held only a few nights ago where a number of these people— doctors, social workers, and dieticians representing a variety of such organisations as Senator Sir John Keane had in mind, discussed the matter raised by him. I wish to assure the Senator that it has not been lost sight of.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister think that these functions would be more properly the work of the Department of Local Government and Public Health? It seems rather an anachronism that they should be entrusted to the Department of Defence.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Defence is charged with A.R.P. work and, in that connection, he was brought up against the question of the supply of food in emergencies, but on the question of the supply of food he is in close and intimate touch with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, the Department of Local Government and Public Health, and the various local authorities—in Dublin, at any rate, and I think in other parts of the country—on this very subject, and they are all cognisant of what is being done and the debates that have taken place, and they have representatives on the committee.
Senator Sir John Keane asked about relief in kind. It is possible, legally, to give relief in kind and, from time to time, that system is adopted, and has been adopted, by different local authorities. Many Senators discussed the question of unemployment and reminded us that, bad as it is now, it is likely to be worse in the months to come. In that connection, Senators called attention to the fact that on the Vote for employment schemes, and on other Votes that are set out in the Book of Estimates, there were such reductions in the amount provided as would lead to a serious reduction in the numbers of people likely to be employed this year as compared with last year. Now, I do not believe that there will be one man less employed on the employment schemes because of the reduction that was made in that Vote. It was not for that purpose that reduction was made, but I was informed that it was expected that on the 31st March, this year, nearly £600,000—that is my recollection of the figure, and I know that it was well over £500,000 anyway—would be handed back, would not have been spent, and that a similar amount, although not quite so large, was handed back last year. I said: "Why swell the Estimate, and why put in figures there that would make it appear to be a large and generous figure for employment schemes, when that money is not likely to be spent before the end of the financial year? Give me a figure that you will spend and I shall put it in"; and that is the figure that is there.
I said in the Dáil, and I repeat it here, that the question of the unemployment situation, and its likely development in the months to come, is under close examination at present. One man, a Parliamentary Secretary, has been told off to deal with that matter, and he has a committee working with him, giving all its time to the question. I anticipate that before long certain schemes will be put before us, and if these schemes are such that we find that they are realisable and practicable and will give employment, as far as it can be found, for certain types of people, money will not stand in the way, within our resources. In this connection, Senator Lynch, Senator Johnston, I think, and other Senators stressed the fact that certain types of men will be thrown out of employment—some have been thrown out of employment already—such as skilled tradesmen and craftsmen, and that it will be difficult to deal with them. It will be difficult, and at the moment I do not see how they are going to be provided with employment. That is a situation we are up against. At the moment, I cannot see how highly-skilled craftsmen, who have spent their lives in certain trades, are going to be put on other work, whether of a skilled or unskilled type. You cannot expect these men, any more than you can expect clerks, commercial travellers, or people of that kind, to go out with a pick and shovel. They will not do it, and you cannot expect them to do it; but that is the problem. I said before in the Dáil, and repeat it now, that they cannot be allowed to go hungry. The Government stands over that, and we shall have to find some way of dealing with the problem, but, hungry, they and their families cannot be allowed to be.
I was glad to hear the tributes paid to the Army, by Senators McGee, O Buachalla, and others. I believe that the Army that was there before the crisis, and the largely increased Army that is there now, as well as the Local Defence Force and the Local Security Force, deserve our confidence. They deserve every credit, particularly the new men who have come along and volunteered or offered their services to help the nation in its time of difficulty and defend our shores, if necessary— offering everything they had, most of them. The men who were already qualified, the older officers and noncommissioned officers, who were able to take these raw recruits and untrained men and make such excellent military material out of them, as I understand they have succeeded in doing, deserve our sincere thanks.
Peat is another matter that was referred to by several Senators. That was another matter about which this Government got a lot of criticism. There has been very considerable development, and a lot of money was spent—I believe it will be found to have been spent usefully—on the development of bogs, but I do agree with the several Senators who stressed the fact that it will be necessary for every individual who has a turbary anywhere to work that turbary to the fullest possible extent this year and to start work from the earliest moment the weather will permit so that he himself, and the country as a whole, may have the necessary fuel to pass us over this year. Our supplies of coal have been very short in recent months and, as I think one Senator reminded us, the coal we have got has not been anything to boast about—some deliveries of it anyhow—and even at that it is pretty stiff in price. That is so, but we cannot complain about that—at least, we can complain all we like about it, but we cannot remedy it. That is the situation: we cannot remedy it. As a matter of fact, I think that those who supply us with coal would be quite happy to give us more coal and better coal if they were able to do so. That is my opinion.
Comment on this
On the question of blockade, I might as well deal with it now. I think it is not correct to say that the statement made by the Taoiseach was misleading. As the Minister for Supplies said, and as the Taoiseach himself said, we are, in effect, the most blockaded country in Europe. In saying that, I would not charge, and I think I would not be correct in charging, either of the great belligerents with attempting to squeeze us economically, consciously or willingly—blockading us from supplies that normally should reach us. They have not done that, to my knowledge.
Comment on this
Our ships have been sunk, but ships of all nationalities have been sunk, have they not? We are blockaded, in fact, and seriously blockaded. There are many things that we badly need here and we cannot get them; we have not got them, and probably will not get them. We are blockaded in that sense, and while, as I say, I do not believe there is a deliberate attempt on the part of the belligerents to blockade us, blockade is a very serious thing. We are not being blockaded in that deliberate way, but the effect is the same.
Comment on this
We have been informed that certain areas of the seas around our coasts are mined and that they are dangerous areas for ships to pass through, but we are a very small and insignificant little country. The greatest nation in the world, America, has not dared to send her ships into that blockaded area.
Comment on this
And the Minister's colleagues have announced that if we had a mercantile marine most of our ships would have been sunk by now.
Comment on this
Not deliberate against us any more than against any other nation which has ships in that area. This is a very ticklish and dangerous subject. There are people in the country who would like to get responsible people—may I say, myself and others—to make statements on one side or the other that could be used and placarded for propaganda purposes against one side or the other. I am not going to be led into anything of the kind. I have my views and my sympathies. They are very strong views. I have sympathy with all brave peoples who are suffering, who have had to make such horrible sacrifices and who have been crushed. I know, and everybody in this country with a knowledge of our history ought to know, what oppression and aggression mean. I have sympathy particularly with small nations, but we are in a very ticklish position, a very dangerous position. We have declared neutrality. Though that neutrality is not liked by many people in the Dáil and in the Seanad, we, all of us, ought to walk warily, watch our step and, particularly, watch our words so that we shall not give cause for offence to one side or the other and involve ourselves and our country in very serious consequences. Senator MacDermot evidently dislikes neutrality.
Comment on this
If I may say so, with all respect, I do not think the Senator's speech helps matters. Honestly, I do not. I do not object to a man criticising censorship; I have done it myself, but which of us, Senator MacDermot, Senator Hayes, Senator Baxter or Senator Quirke, if we were in the same position as the Censor, could satisfy everybody? Could you satisfy anybody? I think that you would satisfy very few people. I would satisfy very few people, I know, if I were in charge and I think the same applies to Senator MacDermot. I think Senator Hayes would be more ruthless even than I.
Comment on this
I am afraid I am keeping the House unduly long. I read with interest the long letter of Mr. Wylie to which Senator Johnston referred. I seldom read long letters, and I very rarely read speeches, even my own. At any rate, I glanced at the Times on the morning the letter was published. I usually just run down the news and the births, deaths and marriages. That is the sum and substance of my reading of the newspapers. If there are any splash headlines about politics, I read the matter to which they refer.
Comment on this
I have to read the financial notes whether I like them or not. I have to keep in touch with them and they are not always the most interesting part of the newspaper. I had to put aside Mr. Wylie's letter, but I took it to bed and read it over carefully.
Comment on this
It kept me awake long enough to read and to ponder over it. I would agree with Senator Johnston in describing it as very good Sinn Féin policy—a policy of self-reliance. If only more people would read it, and if they would not alone think but act on the lines of self-help and self-reliance of the type suggested in that very interesting letter, I think the country would be very much better off than it is. There is too much harping on the Government all the time, too many questions such as: "Why did not the Government do this, that, or the other?" Goodness knows, there are many things which should be and which are not done, but there are a thousand and one other things which could be done by citizens for themselves which they will not do. There is too much waiting to be spoon-fed. I should like people to read that letter again. I hope that Mr. Wylie himself will not stop at the writing of the letter.
Comment on this
Good. I hope something practical comes out of it. It will be a good example to many other citizens. I was interested in Senator Johnston's recommendation that the State should guarantee supplies of milk and potatoes to the extent of £3,000,000. I was all the more interested when, later on, he went on to warn the Minister of the awful consequences of increasing taxation. How are we going to spend £3,000,000 and the many hundreds of thousands recommended by other Senators, good and all as the schemes may be, without increasing taxation?
Comment on this
You could not do that. Suppose you paid 2½ per cent., that would be something within reason, but look at what £3,000,000 at 2½ per cent. would cost. That must be paid by the taxpayer—not alone the interest but the sinking fund to wipe out the loan. There is nothing you can do in that way that will not result in some additional taxation on the people.
I should like to say a good deal more but the hour is late. I shall conclude by thanking you for the debate, which interested me. I can sincerely say that I profited by it. I shall gladly remember the advice given to me. Suggestions made from all sides were, I believe, prompted by an anxiety to be helpful. I should like to have an opportunity of referring to the remarks of many other Senators who spoke, but I shall preserve the notes which I have taken and I hope to have an opportunity on some occasion in the future of referring to them at an earlier hour.
Comment on this
There is just one question which I should like to raise. Everybody spoke of the importance of securing as big a harvest as possible from the land, but nobody said a word about the equally important harvest of the sea. Herrings saw us through many a year, and I hope that, when the May herring fishing comes along the fishing will be encouraged, and that adequate provision will be made for curing plenty of herrings and other fish.