We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Appropriation Bill, 1945 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–127 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Appropriation Bill, 1945
Enacted

No. 28 of 1945 ›

When I moved the adjournment of the debate last night, I was dealing with the speech which Dr. Moorhead delivered at the Mansion House meeting, which is part of this campaign, the beginning of the protest committee which is to conduct propaganda on behalf of the demand for the publication of the evidence given at the inquiry, or the reinstatement of the board. The point in Dr. Moorhead's speech to which I was directing attention is that, while he admires the Constitution, he is appalled by what has happened in the Ministerial suppression of the board, he, too, knowing nothing about the laws enacted in this Parliament in virtue of which the Ministerial action was taken. In the course of his speech he said: "It is the kind of thing we would cry out against if it were done, in fact, by Fascist Italy or Nazi Germany," and then he turned away to demand the production of the report of the inspector. That, of course, was the watchword for the stage army on the platform of the Mansion House meeting. They all demanded that the sham inquiry should be exposed in all its hideousness by the production of the inspector's report.

Having heard the speech of Senator Kingsmill Moore, we can guess very well the source of the inspiration. Lord Palmerston once is reported to have said to his Ministers: "It does not matter what we say so long as we all say the same thing", and the members recruited for this stage army all agreed to say the same thing: "The sham inquiry is intended to report as preordained by the lawless Parliamentary Secretary for Health; why does he not produce the report of his inspector? Well, we can all make a guess"—we all know well theirs is a guess, and yet these people talk about "reckless, inconsiderate statements and action," all founded upon a distortion of the evidence—"we all know well that, in the last few weeks he would have been only too delighted to produce the report if it backed up his action; if he does not produce it the public will continue, as they are doing, to draw their own conclusions." In other words, the purpose of this Mansion House meeting, and the further propaganda that it is to father, is that the Minister, or his Parliamentary Secretary, refuses to publish the report, and continue to refuse to publish it, and the public is provided with the explanation that they dare not. Now when a man of such standing as the President of the Medical Council of Ireland can be persuaded to talk like that, it shows how dangerous this propaganda can become. All, or at any rate most of us, know about the famous dancing mania that broke out in Germany in the 14th century. The infection spread, for hysteria, remember, is an infectious disease and the Cork Street Fever Hospital functions for the cure of all infectious diseases. This infection spread through the leading cities of Germany and the delirium and the mad antics of the people were beyond all believing. They seized religious houses. Some of them dashed their brains out against the walls. That is not likely to happen in the case of these propagandists, but who knows? The Church tried to meet the obsession by exorcism but a great physician, Paracelsus, advised a cure—cold water. The cold water of truth in this case will be the cure for the Cork Street fever, which has been generated by the hysteria of which we saw some displays in the speech of our colleague last night.

Comment on this

May I ask, is that a promise that the report is going to be published and that we are going to have the truth?

Comment on this

No. It is a promise that the truth will be given. I began by reading last night the statement that the minute of evidence will be published and it will be procurable. I daresay every member of the House will get it for nothing, but in any case they will not be deterred by the charge of 2/6 from procuring it. Senator Kingsmill Moore's interjection is merely a repetition of what he knows himself to be the sophism that the report of the inspector is the principal item—I will deal with that presently —that it is the cardinal thing in the investigation. I quoted him a greater authority than he in law that that is not so. If I may turn aside from my argument to deal with his interjection momentarily, he has assured us that there is no legal obligation on the Minister to publish it. If there is no legal obligation on the Minister, what dereliction of duty is there on the part of the Minister in keeping it a confidential document, a document meant for his information and not for public circulation?

This hysteria is exhibited in its worst form by Mr. Wood, senior counsel. I mentioned him incidentally in connection with the Mansion House before, but it was to exemplify how successful this propaganda can be in speaking with two voices, one the respectable and gentlemanly voice and the other the voice of the hysterical, obsessed, patient, Mr. Wood. "I believe that this Minister," he says, "has deliberately distorted the facts. I believe that he has indulged in a sham trial. I stand or fall by the inspector's report." I pointed out that Senator Kingsmill Moore exonerates the Minister from all culpability. He looks upon him as a man deceived by a subordinate, but in the Mansion House, addressing an overflow meeting, well organised, with its platform all bound to repeat the same cry: "Give us the report," there is a different voice; there is this direct accusation. Senator Kingsmill Moore, within the recollection of the House, made his charge against the Parliamentary Secretary for Public Health. It was the Parliamentary Secretary whom he inveighed against so vehemently. But here is the direct accusation of the Minister —"The Minister has deliberately distorted the facts. I believe that he has indulged in a sham trial. I stand or fall by the inspector's report."

I would have expected that Mr. Overend would have been reported in the Irish Times. The only reference to him is that he appears in a photograph depicting him speaking into a microphone, but nothing comes out in the columns of the paper, so I do not know how he performed his little part in the play and how he rang the changes on “sham inquiry” and “give us the report”.

We have Mr. Alfred Byrne, T.D., of course, who has his part in the accusation—it reminds one of the description of the assassination of Julius Cæsar wherein the smallest of the conspirators has his dagger through the toga of Caesar. He says: "I think those in power want to get complete control by fair means or foul means and the other boards should take warning from what has been done to this particular board." The hysteria is to be spread to other hospitals and they are to join the dancing crowds of fanatics and behave with delirium like the platform orators.

We reach the very limit in the deliverances of a man who has figured before in the debates of this House, Mr. Seán Ó Faolain. He said: "The people have been brought to an unusual pitch of excitement as a result of the manner in which the board have been treated." Apparently, he thinks that the culmination of the excitement has not been reached and in that he agrees with Senator Kingsmill Moore, who is going to write another pamphlet and renew the indictment.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Senator Magennis has just specifically made a charge that Senator Kingsmill Moore wrote a pamphlet. I think he should withdraw that unless he can prove it.

Comment on this

No, sir.

Comment on this

Yes, sir, on a point of fact.

Comment on this

My words were: "Senator Kingsmill Moore is going to write another pamphlet."

Comment on this

I submit that can only be capable of one interpretation.

Comment on this

No. I quoted repeatedly from the pamphlet yesterday called Justice, and Senator Kingsmill Moore, I take it, was following up that pamphlet. I never suggested that he had written that pamphlet.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied with that.

Comment on this

The Senator's mishearing of me yesterday made him think I had said "his" pamphlet and he rose up to correct me. I see Senator Sweetman bears me out on that. However, if Senator Sweetman can improve on my statement, I will accept it and say that Senator Kingsmill Moore threatens or promises to write a pamphlet, in addition to the pamphlet from which I have quoted already.

Comment on this

That is correct. It is being printed now, but I have not got the proofs yet.

Comment on this

This tit-bit has been held back unnecessarily from the House:

"What the Minister was doing, in fact, was expropriating a hospital just as effectively as if he had sent a squad of soldiers down to Guinness's Brewery and took it over."

Only a writer of short stories and romances could have exercised his imagination so freely and, I might add, so frantically. The man who said that has no sense of responsibility and no sense of facts. These words "expropriating a hospital" are an echo of passages in the pamphlet Justice and we have heard Senator Kingsmill Moore directly on it. These seven who got, under the Act of 1936, a special college of electors provided for them, have still the idea that the Cork Street Fever Hospital is their property rightfully and that, in some way, it has been confiscated. It is clear that they have still that idea. I propose to show, from the evidence quoted in the White Paper, that that is the source of a great deal of the friction and the discord which has occurred ever since the new board began to function in 1937.

Why was the hospital taken over? Because, as that pamphlet truthfully records, the demands on it had grown so great that the buildings, amongst other things, proved unequal to deal with the task with which they were founded to deal. Their funds had run short, too, as was explained by the Senator, through the action of the Sweepstakes. They, fortunately, cannot accuse our Government of having stared the Sweepstakes and legalised betting.

Comment on this

Surely, betting was legalised by our Government?

Comment on this

Well, then, my memory of old days has faded out. I remember in the Dáil inveighing against the attempt to legalise betting.

Comment on this

But it was our Government did it. I was against it, too.

Comment on this

Well, I was reciting the history previous to the introduction of the Cork Street Fever Hospital Act. The charity had, notwithstanding its gallant effort, proved insufficient for the needs. The city and county of Dublin utilising it had been making contributions and they are making contributions ever since the widening of control. They pay for their service. I see that the estimate for 1945-46 for the contribution is something like £45,000. I am not quite sure of the exact figure, but it is over £40,000. They speak of "transferring all their possessions." Senator Kingsmill Moore has described the buildings as like the state of an aged body for which the informing spirit is too great. The fact is that it was necessary—desirable, at any rate—to have fever cases and infectious cases not spread over a number of hospitals, but with centralised treatment. Therefore, the action of the Government in 1936 was not an act of confiscation. There was no predatory purpose whatever in the Act and that ought to be clear.

Comment on this

On a point of fact, I do not think I ever said or even suggested that that was so. If I did, I certainly did not mean to do so. I did not say it was an act of confiscation or a predatory act. It was a voluntary act agreed to by the old trustees.

Comment on this

Senator Kingsmill Moore must share the odium of his associates in the stage army. I quoted from this speech of Seán Ó Faoláin. He says it is equivalent to sending a squad of soldiers to Guinness's Brewery and expropriating the brewery. If Senator Kingsmill Moore wishes to disown Mr. Ó Faoláin, one of his orators in the Mansion House campaign, then I am truly gratified.

Comment on this

What I said was that it was a dishonest decision to abolish the board whose property the hospital was.

Comment on this

That is a question-begging epithet. Senator Kingsmill Moore cannot expect the thinking public, the public with a sense of moderation and justice, to take his ipse dixit as against that of the Minister, who has read the report.

Comment on this

No, but I rather think they will.

Comment on this

The Senator hopes they will. That is exactly what I am accusing him of, of being the High Priest of this propaganda, of being the chief agent in spreading the hysteria. Of course, he hopes to discredit the Government. So do they all. I do not know why that should excite amusement in Senator Sweetman, but apparently it does.

Comment on this

Certainly, some of them happened to be supporters of the Government.

Comment on this

There are all sorts and conditions on the board but there was no supporter of the Government on the Mansion House platform. There were foolish men who went there to support the Government, and they were promptly squelched. The chairman of that meeting is the Chief Whip of the Fine Gael Party in the Dáil. That is the only "supporter" of the Government that I could detect, and he supported it by his opposition. These expectations of the Senator, that the public will be excited by the declamation of a frenzied clique, instead of relying upon the evidence, are rather, I think, too much of egotism. "Athanasius against the world" is the only parallel I know of to Senator Kingsmill Moore and Mr. Alfred Byrne against the evidence. I do not know what is in the report, neither does the Senator, and neither does any of them, but they are quite confident about what it will reveal. It is the old story of the Spanish Chest, the fraud perpetrated some years ago about uncountable wealth being stored in it and people fooled into making contributions to buy it, and when the chest was, by order of the court, opened, it was found to be empty. All said was to blacken the procedure of a dictatorial Government.

Notice the consilience here again between the Senator's henchmen who spoke at the Mansion House meeting and this brochure. This is a clever device; it has been used, I must say, very cleverly. Dr. Moorhead said:—

"In the Dáil the Taoiseach had stated that he was not a dictator.

A Voice: Moryah!

Dr. Moorhead: I think that what Mr. de Valera said is true. He is very fair and very just and not reckless; but I think that a good many of his subordinates are very different. Amongst other things I hope this meeting will do to-night is to put a check to the dictatorial Government that has swept over the country."

This amateur in politics, by the way, regards all the Emergency Orders under the Emergency Powers Act as dictatorial and a cause of discredit to Ministers. This is a favourite dodge. Sometimes Mr. de Valera is painted as a white plaster saint——

Comment on this

Is that a dodge?

Comment on this

If the Senator would let me finish the sentence.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

He is painted as a white plaster saint. Oh, if we could only free him from his villainous associates, the Ministers. They practise all sorts of villainies without his knowledge. Let us bring it to his knowledge and all will be redeemed. What about the Constitution about which Dr. Moorhead declared himself so proud: "I am as a citizen proud of our Constitution." What about the doctrine of collective responsibility? What a Minister does the Taoiseach does when what a Minister does is impeached or impugned. They know that very well. It is a dodge. Unfortunately Senator Sweetman is not listening to my explanation.

Comment on this

I will do my best to convey it to him.

Comment on this

It is a dodge to make it appear that there is an incompetent Government in office, that the Taoiseach who is head of the Executive Council does not know what is going on, and that Ministers are irregularly acting under the aegis of the Taoiseach emboldened by the conspicuous innocence of their chief. That will not pass muster. These people say they are proud of the Constitution, but they are ignorant of a principal item in it. Senator Kingsmill Moore and Mr. Wood are brothers at the Bar, being senior counsel, and we would expect them to know a little bit more of law than the ordinary man in the street.

Senator Kingsmill Moore demanded production of the report. Notice his comment: "You may take it from me". We are not taking it from him. At least, I am not taking it from him. I am taking it from the House of Lords, which, next to the Privy Council, is the highest authority with regard to statutes, legal arrangements and all that sort of thing. We took over all that legal system. What is the law with regard to Ministers and Inquiries? With the permission of the House I shall read it, because Senator Kingsmill Moore only read the obligation to behave decently and justly. I think when he was so eloquent upon the selecting of evidence while suppressing the remainder, that when he did profess to quote from these judgments in the House of Lords, he should have given the parts upon which this atrocious Secretary of Health relies. This is from a great Attorney-General who is reputed to be one of the greatest lawyers that England ever had, the present Lord Chancellor, who was then Sir John Simon, Attorney-General.

"The holding of local inquiries by the Local Government Board is directed by many statutes and it has always been the practice of the Board to treat the reports of their inspectors on such inquiries as confidential documents for their own use".

Yet, the Mansion House audience was told that the Government could not shelter behind its being a confidential document, that it was an ad hoc invention of this Parliamentary Secretary, one of the many things that he invented to cover his own offence of unjustly suspending the board. There it is declared by Sir John Simon as the law regulating the relation between an inspector conducting an inquiry and the Minister to whom he reports. There is an old maxim, centuries old, but its authority is no wise lessened by its age, “Qui nimis probat nihil probat”, Who proves too much proves nothing.

The Senator appealed to the psychology of the situation: the inspector saw the witnesses, saw the tremors of their bodies, the facial expressions, all the outward and visible signs of their mental state and so on, acted like the lie-detecting machines we have become so familiar with; that he is the most competent person to arrive at a judgment on the evidence that he procured and because of that we must have the report.

Mr. Wood, if I may come back to him again, though I really think he was drunk with animosity when he spoke and was so carried away by his hatred of Fianna Fáil that he was not quite responsible for what he said, also stated, and it is made a headnote of by the acting editor of the Irish Times:—

"I have been appalled by the Minister's cynical disregard for what seems to me to be the elementary principle on which justice is founded—an elementary principle of justice that you shall not be condemned by a tribunal by which you have not been heard."

That was repeated to us in the debate last night. There is no such principle with regard to the conduct of the statutory business of the Minister for Local Government.

Now I shall again read from the House of Lords' report which will show you the real position. Lord Haldane said:—

"The Minister at the head of the board is directly responsible to Parliament like other Ministers."

It is not to the Mansion House, but to Parliament that he is responsible— that is not from Lord Haldane I need hardly explain. I shall be accused later on of interpolating my own views into it.

Comment on this

I hope the Senator will not hesitate to do so, as it would be very interesting.

Comment on this

But I cannot punctuate when I am speaking and the report can be misread accordingly.

Comment on this

That is a difficulty from which we all suffer.

Comment on this

No doubt. I am sure the Senator is conscious of it.

"The Minister at the head of the board is directly responsible to Parliament like other Ministers. He is responsible not only for what he himself does but for all that is done in his Department. The volume of work entrusted to him is very great and he cannot do the great bulk of it himself. He is expected to obtain his materials vicariously through his officials, and he has discharged his duty if he sees that they obtain these materials for him properly."

"Obtain these materials for him properly"; that it is the function of the official whom he appoints to conduct an investigation, to inform the Minister in the discharge of the duties of his office.

Now, my friend, Lord Shaw of Dunfermline, also stated:—

"To set up any rule that that decision must on demand, and as matter of right, be accompanied by a disclosure of what went before so that it may be weakened, or strengthened, or judged thereby, would be inconsistent with efficiency, with practice, and with the true theory of complete parliamentary responsibility for departmental decisions"

As a counsel, of whom I am sure the Senator has heard before, once said in a Dublin court: "My lord, if there is any case more than another case like my case then this case is that case." That fills the bill. Senator Kingsmill Moore tried to make it appear that the judgment was purely a decision in regard to a single person in his letter to the Irish Times published on the 24th July. But this is in the judgment of Lord Shaw, one of those great Scottish lawyers to whom everyone, no matter what his national or political prejudices may be, looks to with profound respect:—

"To set up any rule that that decision must on demand, and as a matter of right, be accompanied by a disclosure of what went before, so that it may be weakened or strengthened or judged thereby, would be inconsistent, as I say, with efficiency, with practice and with the true theory of complete parliamentary responsibility for departmental action."

Comment on this

Will the Senator quote the passage in which Lord Shaw said that in many cases it may be advantageous?

Comment on this

I will read that. The Senator will observe that it is not possible to read two things at the same time. It is like Horace's principle that when two men ride the same horse one must ride behind. "To set up any rule that that decision must on demand." Now the Senator demanded it. While he admitted that there was no legal duty to publish it, that is to say that it is a confidential document for the information of the Minister, and speaks, of course, I need hardly add, truthfully, he "demands" the publication of the report. What is a demand? A demand is not a request. It is a thousand miles away. A demand, as he knows, especially in its legal understanding, is peremptory: he claims that it must be divulged. Now, here is what Lord Shaw says on that:—

"I incline to hold that the disadvantage in very many cases would exceed the advantage of such disclosures".

That is the passage which the Senator, in his letter to the Irish Times, says “by implication declares that it might be disclosed.” But I quote the Senator himself: “Who is denying that? It need not be disclosed. There is no rule of law to prevent the Secretary from disclosing it.” Undoubtedly, by implication, as Lord Shaw says, there might be and there have been occasions on which disclosure might be made, but he says that it would be contrary to public policy—

Comment on this

No—contrary to public policy to make it an inevitable rule.

Comment on this

To make it an inevitable rule. Yes, that is so. And when a Mansion House meeting has been called and crowds of citizens come there—some out of curiosity and some to have warmth and comfortable seats and electric light for the rest of the evening—speakers take advantage of that opportunity to work off something that they have against the Government, and when they make demands somewhat along the lines advocated by the partisan advocate, then the rule must give way.

The Senator says that there is nothing against the publication of the report. I suggest that there is. It is a confidential document. It is expressly spoken of, here in what I have read out, as a confidential document, and need not be disclosed unless the advantages to be derived from ignoring the fact that it is confidential and divulging its content should warrant it. But what of the damage that might be done? Will there ever again be an inspector who will make a frank report, who will write explicitly and fully the impressions he formed of various witnesses? Will it ever again be the case that a prudent inspector, careful of his own interests, which he is perfectly entitled to consider in the matter, will make a frank, candid and full report? A hotheaded person might conceivably be in office and, regardless of the personal discomfort or various other disadvantages accruing to the inspector, might read out what the inspector had written believing that he was writing in full official confidence. I say that what Sir John Simon has said is to be pondered. There has been also a decision of Lord Moulton and of Lord Parmoor. Lord Parmoor says:—

"The only word in the statute on which a claim to see the report can be based is the word ‘public' prefixed to ‘local inquiry'. This word is said to have been used for the first time in the 1909 Act. In my opinion a public local inquiry means no more than that an inquiry should be held in the locality and be open to the public. It was well known in 1909 that the Local Government Board did not in ordinary cases publish the reports of inspectors before whom local inquiries were held. Unless an opposite intention is declared or can be inferred, a statutory form of procedure should be construed so as to conform with prevailing practice".

That is the full connotation of "public inquiry". It should be an inquiry held in the locality and open to the public, and Sir John Simon has said that the prevailing practice is to keep the confidential document confidential. There is a whole array of authorities here against publishing a report, and the only case for publishing a report is this—this is a quotation —"We believe and we are confident that it should be published, and we stand or fall by it". But because this slight body of presumptuous people undertake, by some process of divination, to say what the inspector's report contains then the "confidential" must disappear from the report and it must be published, to be interpreted as each one pleases—except the Secretary for Health.

It was meant originally for the information of the Minister or, in this case, the Parliamentary Secretary, I repeat, and it is his statutory duty to act as his judgment will determine. There is no statutory duty whatever on the Minister to accept all an inspector reports. Suppose the inspector did— I do not know whether they have ever done it—in this case behave, to quote the description by the Senator, "in a quasi-judicial character", how is the Minister or his Secretary bound by that? There is a great deal of loose thinking, apart from loose speech, and a good deal of irresponsibility, on this matter. With the exception of Dr. Moorhead, I say that there is not a single responsible speaker reported by a newspaper, not a single man with a sense of responsibility. As the Americans say, there are people who sling ink, and in this case they slung words without any sense of responsibility, while thousands of decent citizens are left under the impression that there must be something wrong or, to quote the old fallacy, that there can be no smoke without fire.

Now, I proceed to another point in my argument. I am sick of this: "Let us have the report. It was a sham inquiry." That cry was repeated here again and again. That is to say, it was a sham in this sense: not that the inspector did not do his part well—we have the testimony that he did—but that he was an innocent tool and that, unfortunately—according to this arbitrary contention—he reported the wrong way. I think that is the case made by our friend: that he was intended by the secretary to find that A was B, and the expectation was not fulfilled.

Comment on this

No, Sir, that is not quite my charge. My charge is this: that the Minister had determined to abolish this board whatever the evidence was; that he appointed an inspector in whom everybody had trust in order that it might be assumed that he was following the advice of a competent man when he so did it. I charge that he had determined to abolish this board, whatever the evidence and whatever the report of the inspector and that he did so. That is why a man of such eminence, competence and partiality was chosen—to cover the predetermined decision of the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary had made up his mind before he instituted the inquiry? Why then did he not do it before that? Could not he have done it in 1936, when the Act was being passed? Could not he have removed every one of the board who inherited "high traditions"? But he did not. We are asked to believe a great deal on the authority of the ipse dixit. I have the greatest respect and regard for the Senator but I am not prepared to follow him to such lengths as he requires. The Minister, he says, had made up his mind to abolish the board. This is Deputy Alfred Byrne again: “The Government are resolved, by fair means or foul, to get absolute control over the hospitals.” There is no proof whatever that the Secretary was determined to get rid of the hospital board or that he chose an excellent inspector for that reason. See the difficulty of administration in the presence of such criticism as this. If a Minister appoints an inspector of the highest standing, a man whose credit stands high with everyone, then his appointment is intended to cover a malign purpose. If he appoints an incompetent man or a partisan, then he appoints a tool to carry out his malign purpose. They have it either way. It will be impossible to carry on administration in this country if that is the sort of criticism which is to come from persons of high standing.

I want to touch on a couple of other matters in the evidence quoted in the White Paper. There are many things with which I should like to deal, but I have been kept so long dealing with this legal argument that I feel that the tedium must be insupportable to the House. I suggest that the weakness of the majority, of the representatives of the people on the board—and I mean by the board, the board set up in 1936—was disharmony, the utter want of ability to co-operate in the discharge of a common duty. Why? The seven representatives of the trust who, as I say, were provided with a special college of electors by the Act of 1936, had, when they took office, along with them, as colleagues, popular representatives and what the Senator called the "imbecility of three Government nominees". There was from the first a feeling of superiority, a feeling of being confronted with interlopers in the guise of colleagues. It was a natural feeling, I admit. On the other hand, the popular representatives were not, perhaps, chosen for their diplomacy. They were very frank and outspoken. The board appears from the testimony of the Senator and the testimony quoted here to have been frequently a bear-garden. On occasions, it had to suspend its meetings. Am I not right in that?

Comment on this

I think that the meetings were twice suspended, but I do not think that I quoted that.

Comment on this

You did not say that it was a bear-garden, I admit.

Comment on this

I do not think that I said what the Senator suggests at all but I believe it to be a fact. However, the Senator will not tie me down to that admission.

Comment on this

I do not want to take any unfair advantage of the Senator. It would appear that the Senior Wrangler in all these wrangles was the member, Mrs. McKean, and I should like to read to the House the evidence which the skilful cross-examination of Mr. Costello wrung from her. The number of the question is 1914:—

"You did not offer any evidence of the difficulties of the board or the difficulties you had as a member of the board in carrying on the business here a few years before this inquiry was instituted?—That has nothing to do with this inquiry."

That is a sample of her peculiar attitude towards the inquiry at which she appears as a witness for the purpose of affording her assistance.

"You heard Mr. O'Leary give evidence of the difficulties he had? —That he had?

He told us of the difficulties he was having in connection with the bloc vote on the board and matters of that kind——"

The bloc vote is what I am referring to when I say there were from the beginning parties formed. The previous witness had, evidently, deposed to that.

"He [Mr. O'Leary] told us of the difficulties he was having in connection with the bloc vote on the board and matters of that kind?—I heard him. I never saw any bloc voting. There was a bloc of votes on both sides."

I am afraid that I have not read that distinctly and that I have not been heard—"I never saw any bloc voting. There was a bloc of votes on both sides." She never saw any bloc but she saw a bloc of votes on both sides. I once heard a man passing in the street say to his companion: "The divil a one but two." She saw no bloc but she saw two blocs. She added: "There was a bloc on more sides than one."

"Do you say you never saw any signs of that?—It was on both sides."

She is not going to give the credit to one side for having maintained a steady unity of purpose. It was on both sides.

"Would it be true to say that you yourself made a charge against a certain section of the board?"

I interpret " a certain section of the board" as the seven élite.

"Would it be true to say that you yourself made a charge against a certain section of the board that, for six years, you had to suffer vilification and abuse at the hands of certain members of the board?"

"Vilification and abuse at the hands" is, of course, a slip.

"Would that be true?—It would not.

Did you ever write on the 13th November, 1942, a letter to Mr. O'Donovan in which you used these words?—Which words?

Did you write this to him—‘We, appointed members by the Minister....'"

I emphasise that. Those were, apparently, the antagonists—the seven élite and the appointees of the Minister. That is my interpretation.

"Did you write this to him: ‘We, appointed members by the Minister, have had to endure almost six years' vilification and abuse at the hands of a bitter section of the board, mainly due to our efforts to curb expenditure and improve the administration of the hospital?'— I did not think that was six years ago."

Evidently it was still a living memory; she could not believe that time had passed, so poignant was her present consciousness of it. The next question was:—

"You forgot that. Do you accept that you wrote that?—I don't think that has anything to do with it."

Then Mr. Costello asked:—

"Do you accept that you wrote that letter?—Oh, yes. And you forgot about it?—I did.

Do you now want to change your evidence that you gave to the inspector, that you knew of no bloc voting or anything of that kind and that you had not to put up with this for six years?—I say that that has nothing to do with bloc voting. I don't think it has anything to do with the last six years."

May I express my heartfelt sympathy with Mrs. McKean if, for some six years, she had to engage antagonists whose performance is of this order? But the revelation has come from an unwilling witness. She wrote a letter, but she forgot she wrote the letter. Mr. Costello, when Mr. Early, on a point of order, wanted to interpose, said:—

"I am cross-examining the witness and she has admitted writing this. I am asking her about this particular sentence. That letter was written by her. (To witness): That letter is in your handwriting?—It is not in my handwriting."

Then Mr. Costello went on to ask:—

"Do you agree that you wrote the sentence that I have read out to you? You had to endure almost six years' vilification and abuse at the hands of a bitter section of the board, mainly due to our efforts to curb expenditure and improve the administration of the hospital?' "

Then she answered:—

"That is right. I don't agree that it was in the last six years."

The witness further said:—

"I stand over that if I ever said it.

Mr. Early: I suggest that the letter be given in full.

Mr. Costello, S.C.: I am putting the one sentence of the letter for the purpose of dealing with the evidence she has given and nothing else and she admitted that she wrote that particular sentence. (To witness): You wrote that?—Yes. It was not for six years. I admit the rest of it.

Roughly six years?—Yes."

Now, that is a picture of the enmity with which this board, as constituted under the Act of 1936, conducted its proceedings.

Let me turn to another piece of evidence, of the same kind of constant friction, irremediable — no remedy could be applied to it, because the one party regarded itself as the inheritor of a proud tradition and the other antagonist regarded itself as the watchdog of the taxpayer, to secure more complete control over public expenditure and the administration of the hospital. There is evidence here of efforts on the part of the popular party—let me call it that for convenience—to have better administration. I am now looking at page 37 of the White Paper. The same Mr. O'Leary, already referred to, "in his evidence set out the objects which he and his two colleagues had in mind in putting forward their proposal". I do not propose to read the whole memorandum. If I may, I will summarise it. The medical superintendent appears, from his own evidence and from this, to have been a sort of Pooh-Bah; he was not only the medical superintendent, but the whole authority. I understand that is not uncommon in hospitals— that the general medical superintendent has, by the implication of certain duties, to look after a whole lot of things. The proposal was that there should be a layman appointed who would take over from the overtaxed and heavily-burdened general medical superintendent a lot of things which could be more competently, and in any case more constantly, attended to by an officer specially appointed for the purpose. On the ground, I think it was, that the board could not afford the expenditure, that was turned down.

Now, these three wrote a memorandum complaining of the administration and the inefficiency of the board, not of the seven but of the board of which they were members. We have here on the minutes of the board a fortnight later an acknowledgment of the receipt of this memorandum. Now, one of the accusations is that these three—I will summarise it again, so that the Senator need not interrupt me—were spies, agents, engaged in espionage on behalf of the Minister—he spoke of the appointment of anyone of that sort as imbecility. I would use a very much stronger word—if a Minister desired, in appointing members of the board, that their functions should be to spy and report as spies on their colleagues, it would be a despicable thing. I do not think any man or woman of honour would accept such an appointment if he or she had any reason to suppose that that was the nature of the appointment as understood by the Minister.

But because these three considered it their duty to report to their appointer, when their efforts had been futile within the board, their action is held up to scorn and it is regarded as an irregularity. Why, it was the first step towards invoking the authority of the Minister to set things right. If anyone will study this evidence, he will see there were all sorts of negligences; that these were not attacks on men of rectitude, as we have been told; that they were merely indications of irregularities that could occur even under the control of men of the highest integrity without their integrity being in any way besmirched by complaining of those facts. We have it, for instance, that the store room in which the hospital stores were kept was a glory hole.

Comment on this

May I correct a curious mistake, which is not the view of the Senator? It is not the place in which the hospital stores were kept. It is the actual shed in which, what I may call the old junk was kept. All the hospital stores were kept in a completely different building, perfectly clean in every respect. This was an old shed for the disposal of junk.

Comment on this

It was a glory-hole, specially intended——

Comment on this

The sort of thing which you and I have in our houses and which we call an attic.

Comment on this

Why is it described as a store?

Comment on this

That is just one of the many inaccuracies which I shall have an opportunity of showing later. I have dealt only with matters on documents and I have warned the House that the matter is not going to rest where I have left it. The Senator was misled and he could not possibly help it. I want to make it clear.

Comment on this

I am not trying to misrepresent anything.

Comment on this

I know the Senator is not. I am merely showing that he has been misled, as the public have been misled.

Comment on this

There is the case of the dismissal of the gate-keepers. There is, of course, a dispute as to what were the exact terms of their appointment, but we will accept the account given by the chairman of the board in his evidence A man and his wife were to be joint gate-keepers, and, like that old index of the weather, when the man is in, the woman is out and when the woman was out, the man was in. They were to be something like that; they were to share the duties of gate-keepers, but unfortunately the man was a handyman, and when he should have been discharging the duty of gate-keepers, he was fitting a fuse as an electrician, or acting as coadjutor transport officer carrying a patient from one ward to another, in this hospital for infectious diseases. He might be hurriedly called upon to drop his patient, to cease being a transport officer and to get back to the gate.

It happened on one occasion that he was doing one of his multifarious handyman jobs when an ambulance arrived with a serious case. The woman at this particular moment was incapacitated by illness and the gate remained closed. The man had to be sent for and sought after, and the delay was complained of by the doctor whose case was affected—very properly complained of. What sort of hospital was this? Were they so poor in circumstances as to be obliged to have such an arrangement? Because of this dereliction of duty on the part of the man, that, being a man, he was unable to be in two places at once, he is visited with dismissal. Under what circumstances? He is threatened by the general medical superintendent and the chairman of the board — remember that I am quoting from sworn evidence given by the chairman of the board and the general medical superintendent—and was told that if this occurred again, he would be dismissed.

That, as every man of commonsense will admit, meant that he was not to be dismissed on this occasion for this offence, but that if he repeated it, he would be dismissed. The chairman of the board dismissed him without any recurrence of the offence and defended his action, when giving sworn evidence, on the ground that, when the man was charged, he was guilty of impertinence. We want the courtly manners of the 18th century to be a possession of a joint gate-keeper. When I read that evidence, I recalled the famous French rhyme:

"Cet animal est tres méchant

Quand on I'attaque, il se défend."

This is a wicked animal; if you attack it, it will defend itself. The gate-keeper, reproached with the enormity of his offence was not polite enough, did not come up to the standard of politeness of the chairman, and it was for that offence therefore that he and his wife were both dismissed.

That shows the spirit of the management. There are so many things of that kind, apart altogether from this constant friction between two parties on the board which show that that board had to be got rid of and the public are asked to believe that there is "a monstrous miscarriage of justice"—I am quoting from the pamphlet "Justice"—in getting rid of the board. Why, in Heaven's name, was it not got rid of earlier? No such board animated by such feelings as have been revealed in that inquiry could possibly be left in charge of a great medical institution, of a hospital intended to take charge of all the fever and infectious cases from the city and county. I apologise to the House for the length and for the tedium of my speech. The tedium is not due to me and the length is due to the introducer of the matter.

Comment on this

Is maith liom gur tugadh an cheist seo os comhair an tSeanaid, biodh gur cheapas i dtosach nach ceist í a mbfiú mórán áirde do thabhairt uirthi. Tá súil agam, ó tá spéis dúisithe i muintir Bhaile Átha Cliath agus i muintir na tíre ins an gceist seo, go leanfaidh siad den spéis sin go dtí an deireadh. Rachadh sé do leas gnotha poiblí agus gnotha tráchtála pobal na tíre go leanfadh siad d'anspéis a chur ins an gceist.

I should like to say, in the first instance, that when I received a certain document described under the title "Justice," I felt, on first impulse, that I should send it to the Minister for Justice. Some years ago, there seemed to be a tendency in this country on the part of some people to indulge in a very vile form of conduct, namely, the writing and circulating of anonymous letters. A certain judge in the West of Ireland quite properly looked upon this conduct very severely and made public his intention to end it, and, I believe, in his particular circuit, did end it. However, much though I should like to have known who the author, the authoress, or the authors of this anonymous letter was or were, I consigned it to my wastepaper basket. The basket was not emptied for some days—not before the arrival of this White Paper—and I was very glad to have this document "Justice" and the White Paper by me at the same time. I do not intend to go through an analysis of this document. Senator Magennis has analysed it exceedingly well, and I think has earned the gratitude of the House for the manner in which he dealt with it.

In this matter the Minister for Local Government has very many duties imposed upon him, but in this particular case four duties stand out. One is to see to it that public moneys are properly spent, another is that he will see to it, as far as lies in his power, that there shall exist the right of all citizens to equal opportunities whether in business life or in private life. A third of his duties is to see that the sick are protected and a fourth to see that the poor are protected. If the Minister failed to carry out these duties he would deserve not alone to be censured, but he would deserve to be despised.

I shall not detain the House for more than a few minutes. As far as the law is concerned I am a layman and as far as this matter is concerned I want to try to simplify the issue as it appears to a layman and to give my reactions to it. I am sure the House was very interested in a good deal of Senator Kingsmill Moore's address yesterday. I think that the House at times was also bewildered and I should say, taking it by and large, that ultimately we were wearied. It would be no harm now to try to find out what were the main issues dealt with by Senator Kingsmill Moore. It would be no harm if we tried to strip these issues of their verbosity. I shall take the second case first, the one relating to the painting contract. The position so far as I have been able to make it out is as follows. An advertisement was issued inviting tenders for certain painting work. In reply to that advertisement two tenders were received, one from a firm, Warren and Sons, and the other from a firm, Jones and Sons. Warren tendered at £566 and the other firm, Jones, tendered at £944 5s. 0d. These tenders, it seems, came before the board, were opened and were examined. There was a member of that board, we have learned, who was a director of a firm of Dublin building contractors, the firm of Messrs. Crampton and Company. This man, Mr. Webb, is, I understand, an authority for that firm on painting and such work. This gentleman examined these tenders and advised the board that Messrs. Warren could not carry out the work at the price they quoted. Now, it must remembered that Messrs. Warren had to supply a bond, like every other firm, to the effect that they would carry out their work satisfactorily and in accordance with the terms of the contract and their tender. What happened? This gentleman advised the board that Messrs. Warren were not a fit firm to carry out the work.

Comment on this

That is incorrect. I am afraid it is grossly incorrect. He said that no firm could do it so as to show a profit at that rate.

Comment on this

Quite right. Messrs. Warren would not be able to do the work. No scadáin dearga for the moment. After a scrutiny of these tenders, the board decided to pick a panel of contractors and verbally to invite these contractors to tender for the work. Senator Kingsmill Moore pointed out that all these new tenders were in and around the price mentioned by Messrs. Jones and tried to impress upon us last evening that that was evidence of the bona fides of the gentleman who advised against Messrs. Warren. However, one of the new tenders was lower than that of Messrs. Jones. Still this board decided that they would give the contract to Messrs. Jones.

Comment on this

Excuse me, is the Senator intentionally misrepresenting the position? One of the contractors was a few pounds lower but it was pointed out that the painting of down-pipes was omitted, that is to say, it was higher. I wonder whether the Senator is going to make the same kind of misrepresentation which has appeared in regard to the other contract in the White Paper? I quoted the words and I do not think it lies in the mouth of the Senator to make a misleading statement like that.

Comment on this

I do not intend to make any misleading statement. If I am wrong in my statement of what I believe to be the facts of the case, when it is shown to me that I am wrong I shall make due apology.

Comment on this

I am sure you will. I just had to raise that point.

Comment on this

In due course, Messrs. Jones were awarded this contract by the board. The contract came before the Local Government Department and they refused to sanction the decision of the board. The board there and then, although it seems it was convinced that Messrs. Warren were an incapable firm, agreed to the handing of this contract to Messrs. Warren. In due course, the work was done by Messrs. Warren for the sum of £566. In due course, the work as done by Messrs. Warren was examined not alone by the people inside but by people outside and it was admitted by all parties that they had carried out the work properly and efficiently. I am not making any charge, but I could not help remembering during Senator Kingsmill Moore's address that it does happen among contractors that contracts or parts of contracts are sub-let, and when he mentioned in this House about these four or five new tenders being in or around the same figure— the figure quoted by Messrs. Jones—I could not help feeling that something strange was likely to happen.

This Mr. Webb, an authority on painting for this firm of Crampton and Co., a member of this board, must have been aware that Messrs. Warren were technically efficient and commercially sound. If he occupied that position in the firm of Messrs. Crampton he must have been aware, as Senator Quirke pointed out yesterday evening, that this firm of Warren and Sons had been engaged in and had completed satisfactorily many very important contracts. Among them were the Customs House in 1943 at £1,200; the new Industry and Commerce building at the other side of Kildare Street, for Messrs. Sisk and Co., a contract to the extent of £2,700; and the Dundrum Asylum, for the Board of Works, at a sum of £1,500. What I want to know in connection with this particular item, and what I think the ordinary business people in this city, the workers in this city and the people of Ireland will want to know in connection with this contract, is: did Mr. Webb and some members of the board know just a little bit more about Messrs. Warren than it was good for Messrs. Warren that they should know about them?

The second case—the first case in order of time—is this repairs contract. Here again, there were two quotations. It might be somewhat difficult for a layman just to find out how one tender happened to be somewhat lower than the other. However, tenders were received. One was from the firm of Messrs. Higgins, Ushers' Quay, Dublin, and the other from a firm named Hull. Higgins' tender was for £2,395, and Hull's tender was for £2,539; that is to say the first tender I mentioned was the lower by a few hundred pounds approximately. The architect of this board, examining the tenders, provided two reasons why the tender of Messrs. Higgins should not be accepted. The two reasons, as I have been able to make out, are these: first, that certain items were not included in Messrs. Higgins' tender. Senator Kingsmill Moore estimated the value of those items at between £150 and £200. The second reason was that Messrs. Higgins had not included in their figure a sum for contingencies. This sum amounted to £200. By adverting to those two facts—that certain minor items had not been included by Messrs. Higgins, and this question of the contingency items—it worked out that Messrs. Hull's tender was the lower by a few hundred pounds. Messrs. Hull's tender was accepted.

It will be remembered—it is important, although perhaps the amount may not seem very significant—that Messrs. Hull's tender at £2,539 included £200 to cover contingencies. All very well so far as it goes, but what happened? Messrs. Hull came in on the job. They got to work on the contract for which they had tendered, and without further ado they were allowed to perform many other important works and to get paid for them. They were allowed, for instance, to estimate for additional work in connection with the subject of their contract to the amount of £812 10s. 2d. Further extra work was done on a time and materials basis to the amount of £208 8s. 7d., and certain other work—pointing, to be precise—was done to the extent of £28 4s. 6d. I have not finished the list, but it was mentioned yesterday that the architect could not have been aware that this work needed to be done. The buildings were old. It was only when a ladder was thrown up and some scaffolding erected that he was able to ascertain precisely what should have been done. That was how that architect fulfilled his duties in regard to a public hospital. If those buildings had collapsed, if servants or patients or members of the public had been injured or killed, what a fine come-back it would have been on the part of the architect to say that he was not able to get up to examine those buildings and find out their condition. This firm also had paid to them the sum of £19 11s., the amount of their guarantee bond. They were allowed the sum of £107 mentioned by Senator Kingsmill Moore, because of the increase in the cost of materials due to emergency conditions. I wonder how many Senators took in just what Senator Kingsmill Moore had to say on that particular item?

These contractors, he assures us, were entitled to a 33? per cent. increase because of the change in the prices of materials, yet these public benefactors calculated their costs and their profits to a nicety and were willing to, and did, forego how much? About 23 per cent. on what was due to them on that particular item. I could not get it out of my head, when I heard Senator Kingsmill Moore, that there was something rather fishy about the item. Well, let me go on. Extra work on building amounted to £46 15s. 4d., and, again, extra work on the Beneavin Home amounted to £68 9s. 6d. I make out the total for that to be £1,290 19s. 1d., over and above the contract tendered for and awarded to Messrs. Hull. I wonder was there anything wrong with the commercial solvency of Messrs. Higgins? I wonder was their technical efficiency the cause, or the reason, why that firm was not given that contract? I, and other Senators and the public, will be very interested to know just why that contract was dealt with in the manner it was, and I think we will agree that the Minister, who would be aware of that and who would have failed to act in the way he acted, would certainly be deserving of our most severe censure.

Just one word more before I finish. Apart from all these sweets that fell into the lap of Messrs. Hull, there is a question I want to ask with regard to this £200 for contingencies. When they tendered at £2,539, that figure included a sum for contingencies, and yet, as I have shown, this firm did extra work and was paid all along the line, and eventually they got this £200 besides. I wonder where did that £200 go? I wonder is there a doubt in any man's mind as to whether that board discharged its duties as it should have?

The thing that astonished me when I came to inquire into this was the fact that this board seemed to meet at 8.30 in the morning. All during the emergency this board met at 8.30 in the morning.

Comment on this

Nine o'clock to be correct.

Comment on this

They met for their breakfast at the institution, then they proceeded to dispose of the business of the board, and then they got away to their business as quickly as they could. It seems to me that, in all circumstances, the board was not in a position to discharge its duty either to the Department of Local Government or to the public. I intend leaving the matter at that.

The other matters, I want to repeat, I am satisfied have been adequately dealt with by Senator Magennis, indeed, dealt with in a manner that I could hardly expect anyone to deal with them inside the time that he took. There is the other point—the very severe strictures that have been passed on the conduct of certain members of the board. Indeed, it was admitted by Senator Kingsmill Moore that certain members of that board were spied upon, that their movements were watched and traced. There was conduct on the part of responsible public representatives——

Comment on this

Would the Senator mind stating where I admitted that?

Comment on this

The Senator, to the best of my recollection, stated that certain members were known, as soon as the meetings were over, to have wended their way to the Custom House; that they were received there, but that other members would not be received.

Comment on this

They admitted that themselves at the board.

Comment on this

What is wrong, then, with Senator O Buachalla stating that?

Comment on this

The representatives themselves alleged it.

Comment on this

What I want to refer to is the attack that was made on these members. I know only one of the three members concerned with this joint report to the Minister in connection with the affairs of the board, and that man is Mícheál O Foghludha, a man who has enjoyed a very honoured position and a very honoured place in the business life of this city for how long I do not know. Not alone that, but a man who day in and day out, so long as I can remember, and I am sure for a much longer period than I can remember, never wavered and never swerved in his duty as a public representative, and above all in his duty as an Irishman. The Irish cause, whether as a political cause or as a cultural cause, never had any more loyal or any more honoured soldier or servant than Mícheál O Foghludha, and I despise the infamous aspersions that were cast, or attempted to be cast, by Senator Kingsmill Moore, on that gentleman.

I want to say one other word. There has been a lot of talk about the report. Again, I am perfectly satisfied with the reply that Senator Magennis has made in connection with it, but what I want to know is this: is there a report? If there is a report, how does Senator Kingsmill Moore know it is there?

Comment on this

It has been stated twice by the Minister's Secretary.

Comment on this

I understand that a person carrying out an investigation, if he were to make a report would make a report of a confidential nature to the Minister, and it occurred to me during Senator Kingsmill Moore's speech, in connection with this report, that he was protesting too much. It occurs to me that if there is a report, then Senator Kingsmill Moore knows the contents of that report and, if he does, how did he come by it?

Comment on this

I can state quite definitely that I do not.

Comment on this

On a point of order. In view of the definite statement of Senator Kingsmill Moore, I think Senator O Buachalla should be called upon to withdraw. According to the ordinary rules of debate, an assurance of that sort is accepted.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is the practice of the House.

Comment on this

I am sorry. What is the point?

Comment on this

So far as I understood Senator O Buachalla's last remark, he was asserting that Senator Kingsmill Moore knew the contents of the inspector's report. Senator Kingsmill Moore at once got up and assured the House that he did not. As I understand the rules of procedure of this House and any such place, when a person gives a definite assurance about something that is within his own knowledge, the assurance is accepted.

Comment on this

I have no hesitation in withdrawing but I want to point out just exactly what I said, that is, that from the manner in which he had been protesting during his speech, I inferred that he must have seen this report but, if Senator Kingsmill Moore says he did not——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

He has definitely said so.

Comment on this

——then I withdraw.

Comment on this

As an ordinary layman, I did not take very great interest in the inquiry into the affairs of the Cork Street board but when I discovered, as a result of the publication of the White Paper, certain matters of which I, as a building contractor, had some knowledge, I did take an interest in the particular part of the White Paper dealing with the tenders. Figures are not mentioned in the White Paper but Senator Kingsmill Moore mentioned figures. I took them down yesterday evening from him; they are exactly as read out by Senator O Buachalla and, as they have not been contradicted, I assume that the figures I took down in connection with the maintenance and repair contract are correct. On, these figures alone, I submit to the House there has been great injustice——

Comment on this

Would the Senator stop whispering? I should like to hear him.

Comment on this

——and something that demands more explanation than has been given by Senator Kingsmill Moore. If the figures are correct, I submit to the House that these alone would justify the abolition of the board. That is a rather serious statement to make and I propose to justify it. The original tender of Messrs. Hull was £2,539. That included £200 for contingencies. That is £2,339 for the works and £200 for contingencies.

Comment on this

The £2,539 included the contingencies.

Comment on this

That is what I said.

Comment on this

That is quite right.

Comment on this

That tender was accepted eventually and work was proceeded with. Various additional works were done and paid for on a time and material basis, and so on. I will read the items quickly—I do not propose to delay the House—which are as follows: Additional work as per contractor's estimate, I think, £812 10s. 2d.; additional work on a time and material basis, £208 8s. 7d.; pointing work, £28 4s. 6d.; guarantee bond, £19 11s.; increase under the war clause was compromised for £107; extra work on the hospital buildings, £46 15s. 4d.; and extra work on the Beneavin Home, £68 9s. 6d., making a total of £3,829 19s. 1d.

Comment on this

Will the Senator repeat the total, please?

Comment on this

£3,829 19s. 1d.

Comment on this

Does that include contingencies?

Comment on this

Including the contingencies. As I mentioned at the start, these figures are subject to correction by Senator Kingsmill Moore who has the figures.

Comment on this

They are correct according to the figures that are before me, contained in the report from the architect.

Comment on this

I am taking the Senator's figures. They make a total of £3,829 19s. 1d. I understand from Senator Kingsmill Moore that that firm has been paid £3,829 19s. 1d.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

It is something that the Senator will have to be a little more positive about than thinking.

Comment on this

If the Senator will wait a minute, I will give him all these as soon as I can.

Comment on this

If the contractors who carried out the work have been paid £3,829 19s. 1d., it is perfectly obvious that they have been paid £200 that they included in their original tender for contingencies, which contingencies have not been specified or set out. My point falls to the ground altogether if they have been paid, not £3,829 19s. 1d. but £3,629 19s. 1d.

Comment on this

Can the Senator really see the Department missing that? I cannot.

Comment on this

I can.

Comment on this

I should like to know exactly what was the figure paid to the contractor.

Comment on this

It is a perfectly fair point.

Comment on this

The letter which I am reading points out that the total is £3,829 19s. 1d.—"By payments on account of certificates, £3,000; Balance due, £829 19s. 1d." It goes on to say:—

"Under the contract a retention sum of £125 is to be withheld for a period of six months from the date of completion and subject to your board's adoption of the above figures I am now in a position to issue a further certificate to Messrs. Hull for the amount of £704 19s. 1d."

So that, combined with the retention money, would mean the sum mentioned —£829 19s. 1d.—and it was all paid, I would imply from that, on the architect's certificate.

Comment on this

Therefore, Sir, the point that I made is proved conclusively.

Comment on this

I ask again, would the Senator state exactly what has been paid to these people?

Comment on this

As far as I understand, you are correct in regard to the sum paid. I will try to get the information for the Senator, if he wants it, but the Minister has all the documents now. All I can tell you is this, that what I was reading from was a letter of the 22nd April, in which he talks about the contractor's statement of accounts—"the matters stand as tabled hereunder'—and he sets out the amount of the contract, £2,539, which included the contingency item, and I imagine that the contractor had shown the contingency item as exhausted, but if the Senator wants to find out the fact, I will endeavour to have it found out for him.

Comment on this

Now, we have reached this position—to make it quite clear to the members of the House who are not as cognisant of the manner in which these things are dealt with as I am and as Senator Kingsmill Moore is as a result of his investigations in this case —supposing no extra work was done at all and that no contingencies arose, Messrs. Hull should have been paid only £2,339.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

We have it now that the only other works as set out by Senator Kingsmill Moore that are certified and vouched for in detail are the items amounting to the various sums that I read out. We have got no reference at all, we have no mention of the architect, no claim by the contractor, as to how that £200 contingency was expended.

Comment on this

There is not, in that letter.

Comment on this

There is not the slightest indication and, if that is so, there is not a public board in Ireland and not an architect in the employment of any public board which, on permitting such a thing, should not be abolished or dismissed right away.

Comment on this

We are not suggesting it was done.

Comment on this

The only conclusion I can come to on the figure given, namely, £2,339 19s. 1d., and on the details given by Senator Kingsmill Moore, is that no indication has been given at all as to how the £200 included in the original tender for contingencies was expended. That is a matter which demands very close investigation.

Comment on this

I will try to find out about it at once, but you will notice that the Minister has the facts.

Comment on this

This amount of £200 is the peg on which the lower tender was rejected in the first instance.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Senator that if that £200 was paid in the way he is suggesting, not only should the discussion here be carried on in a different way but proceedings should have been instituted and, if he continues to allege that the £200 was so paid, he is saying that the Parliamentary Secretary did not take proceedings which should have been taken.

Comment on this

So now the lawyers are throwing up another smoke-screen.

Comment on this

I am not, but if there has been that misappropriation of public funds, steps should be taken to commence the processes of the court.

Comment on this

That is the very reason I have gone through these figures and examined them and asked the Senator who mentioned the figures first in the House whether they were correct. As a public man, there is responsibility on me to have a matter like that examined, no matter who may have omitted to examine it previously.

Comment on this

Might I suggest it is the Minister's job to give us the information now, as he has the facts, when it is being raised in this House?

Comment on this

Senator Kingsmill Moore came here briefed very fully. It was he who mentioned these figures, and out of his own mouth he must go a little further to explain away something that demands explanation, and something which, if it happened elsewhere, would have to be examined very closely.

Comment on this

And should be.

Comment on this

That is something in which there is a certain suspicion, and I am as much entitled to have that suspicion as the seven members of the board had suspicions of certain things referred to by Senator Kingsmill Moore here: for instance, the conduct of those who were described as the Minister's nominees on the board.

There seems to be a very great desire on the part of those seven members, and on the part of Senator Kingsmill Moore, to differentiate between the attitude taken by the Minister and that taken by the Parliamentary Secretary. I can say that both the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary, Dr. Ward, have personally considered every word of the evidence submitted at the inquiry, and that this attempt by interested parties to insinuate that there is disagreement is one that can be treated only with contempt.

In addition, it should be made clear to the public outside that this board includes very many people who are not implicated in this campaign at all. We must come to the conclusion, after reading the reports of the Mansion House meeting, that the desire is not so much to have a careful investigation into the affairs of the Cork Street Hospital as to use it as a stick to beat the Government. The language used by the speakers in the Mansion House tended in that direction.

Comment on this

There have been so many points raised during this debate that it would be quite impossible to deal with all of them, unless I were to make a speech of the same length as that of Senator Kingsmill Moore or Senator Magennis. I only mention this since there has been a tendency in this debate, not confined to one side, to assume, when you do not interrupt, that you therefore accept the statements made. That is a bad practice and does not imply anything of the kind and I ask the House not to assume, because I do not deal with every point, that I necessarily accept all the points made as accurate or am in agreement with them.

I would like to deal with two points made, one by Senator Magennis and the other by Senator Hearne, with which I am in complete agreement. I am in complete agreement with Senator Magennis when he deprecates attempts made to suggest that a Minister can take action for which the other members of the Government, including the Taoiseach, are not responsible. I have no use for that kind of argument; I do not believe it is true and I do not think I ever used it. I also agree completely with Senator Hearne that the Minister is just as responsible as the Parliamentary Secretary and that the Government is ultimately responsible. I have never believed, in spite of what may have been said, that the Minister left matters of such importance to the Parliamentary Secretary and did not know about them. I am sure Senator Hearne is right, and whether he is right or not, we as parliamentarians know that we must assume that a Minister who had a duty attended to it and that the Minister in this case—as I firmly believe he did—read and was responsible for the documents issued in his Department. Anyone who read the letters signed by the Minister to the Press could see that he accepts full responsibility. I wish to make that clear, for fear it would be taken that I was in favour of differentiating between the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister. Such an assumption would be very misleading and is not parliamentary practice—and I hope it never will be.

There is one other point which it is better to concede at once, namely, if it were true that a board, even if misled by their architect, had paid £200 for contingencies which did not arise and which were not deducted from payments for additional work, the board would be deserving of absolute censure. There is no question about that. I do not believe that occurred in this case, as I cannot believe that, if it did, it would not appear in the White Paper or in the letter accompanying it. Therefore, I assume that it did not occur. At the same time, I agree with Senator Hearne that, if it were so, it would be a very serious matter, indeed.

Comment on this

It is inconceivable to me that the doctor who held the inquiry would not have ascertained that fact, if it were so, but I agree with Senator Hearne that if that could be proved it would be utterly unjustifiable.

It would be very tempting to me to follow Senator Magennis. He is always interesting and sometimes brings forward points which make me think. He will forgive me when I say I do not think he was as effective this time as he sometimes is. That was due to his spending a great deal of time in criticising the action taken, not by the Minister and those with whom we are concerned in the Appropriation Bill, but by those who made speeches outside. He did not even hear those speeches. I was slightly amused when he assumed the accuracy of the newspaper reports as representing what a particular person said. I have a suspicion that, even when he sees the report in the Irish Times of his two hours' speech, he will find that, while it may not be inaccurate, it will not be representative of what he said.

Comment on this

Judging from the report to-day, it will be.

Comment on this

At any rate, I was present at this particular meeting. I was not one of the organisers, nor was I on the platform, but I was present as an ordinary member of the public. I heard the various speeches, including many points with which I agreed and quite a number with which I did not agree. The newspaper reports were obviously very abbreviated, and should not be taken as representing everything that was said. It would be extremely tempting to me to go through the report to show where I disagree or agree with what particular persons said but that would take up the time of the House unjustifiably, and there are other matters of more importance to be dealt with in relation to this problem. Accordingly, I hope I will not be misunderstood if I do not follow the general line taken in the discussion. I want to say that I deprecate what has been said on both sides of this controversy by the introduction of the name of the Society of Friends. It seems to me that members of the Society of Friends, if they are incompetent or dishonest, are entitled to be treated in exactly the same way as anybody else. The sort of idea that they should be treated differently is a completely false one. There has been another tendency to introduce some compliments paid to the history of the society with which I need not deal. I think these are irrelevant. I am not criticising what was said as I think it was well meant. I happen to be a member of the Society of Friends and I think the references are irrelevant.

Comment on this