We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Forestry Bill, 1945—Committee Stage.

Contributions 118–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Forestry Bill, 1945
Enacted

No. 39 of 1945 ›

If the Minister allows the Order to lapse, of course, he cannot make another Order. The application must be made to the lay commissioners and the question will arise then whether the Minister could make a second application or not in respect of the same land. I do not know that that would be so.

Comment on this

Why not? Unless it is prohibited, he could.

Comment on this

At all events, I am sure there must be some reason why the period of two years is mentioned in the Bill. No doubt the Minister has some reason of his own for that purpose but perhaps it might be better that the Minister should take possession within a reasonable time, even though he does not proceed to plant or to carry out his work on the land. At all events, it would be advisable to put the owner out of pain as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

I wonder is Senator Ryan thinking of the old maxim that you cannot imperil a man twice for the same offence. I do not see what there is to prevent the Minister applying for a second Order.

Comment on this

I agreed with Senator O'Dea.

Comment on this

I have a good deal of sympathy with the point of view of Senator Sweetman, but this proposal to complete the deed, shall we say, in six months, does not give sufficient time. I do not anticipate the difficulties that the Senator has envisaged if you are merely dealing with one individual but there may be a complication of interests, even though some of them might be of a very tenuous nature. It may be difficult to trace ownership, and so on. Many matters of that sort arise in the type of land which is purchased which is, in great measure, very often held in common and it is because of the complexity of ownership that the Forestry Department is anxious for sufficient time to decide ownership and to decide questions of the allocation of compensation.

If it is a straight deal between one or two owners and the Land Commission there would be really no difficulty about it. Of course, it is a great advance on the present legislation, when there is no limitation on any such order. Now, we are bringing in a limitation of two years. It is only because of the complication of interest that it is to be kept. I do not envisage the difficulty that the Senator envisages, if it is only one or two persons that are concerned.

Comment on this

Has the Minister got the power to withdraw? If he decides to acquire land, must he not go on with the proceedings?

Comment on this

The order made by the lay commissioners authorising the Minister to acquire lands for forestry purposes remains in force for any length of time.

Comment on this

I quite agree, but the Minister must acquire, as the law stands at present. I speak subject to correction, as it is not a branch of law of which I know quite a lot. I understand the situation is that, at present, the Minister may apply for an Order and it remains in force indefinitely. The other side can come along and, if the Minister is dilatory, I think they can force him to carry on with the job. The Minister now, for the first time, is taking power to say after the Order has been made, that he will not carry on and he cannot be forced to do so.

Comment on this

Yes, but the question of compensation would not remain outstanding and could be dealt with swiftly. If the Minister, having had the compensation fixed, wished to withdraw, it certainly could not take two years. He could do it in a very short time.

Business suspended at 6 p.m., and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

The Minister does not visualise any delay where he is dealing with one owner, but where he is dealing with four pieces of adjacent land he wants to have sufficient time to negotiate for each of the four pieces, as it could easily happen that, unless he got the whole four, the one piece or three pieces acquired would be of no use to him. He could meet my difficulty quite easily in that respect. He makes up his mind that he wants to acquire a certain piece of land, of which there are four different owners. In his explanation of that, he implied that he was going to serve the four acquisition Orders piecemeal. I suggest that, if he waited until he was in a position to deal with all four pieces together, it would not take anything like four years. It might be common property that he was going to acquire the land eventually, but that is a very different thing from an actual acquisition Order being on the stocks.

I think the Minister should make an effort to see if there is not some method by which he could avoid holding a man up for two years, by which he could avoid the owner of land being in the position for two years that he could not sell it, he could not build on it and does not know, even if he cleans the ditches or puts up new fences, whether that work will be a total loss. Once the acquisition Order is issued and the compensation fixed, no man but a fool is going to spend anything on that land. If he does, his compensation having been fixed, it will be a sheer loss to him in the event of the Minister taking it over. I think the Minister could meet the cases he has in mind, by arranging to apply for his acquisition Orders more or less concurrently. Then this difficulty would not arise. I would ask him seriously to reduce very substantially the period of two years during which an owner of land will be tied up with very great concomitant hardship.

Comment on this

There is just one point in connection with the duration of the acquisition Order, which has not been referred to by Senator Sweetman. Once an acquisition Order has been made, something further may have to be done, where the land subject to it is held with other land and both are subject to a State annuity or to some common charge. As a result, after the acquisition Order has been made, it will be necessary for the Minister to apply to the lay commissioners for the apportionment of the common charge. Section 25 provides an appeal to the appeals tribunal within two months of the date of the Order for apportionment by the lay commissioners. Consequently, it is quite possible that, in a number of cases, the two years may be used up with those preliminary matters. It would be difficult in those cases to shorten the period. It might be possible—I do not say it is, as there should be some uniformity—to shorten it in respect of lands that are not subject in conjunction with other lands, to common charges. The matter is not quite so simple as Senator Sweetman would have us believe. Perhaps the Minister, between this and the Report Stage, would explore the possibility of meeting Senator Sweetman, as far as it is possible to do so within the limits of the Bill.

Comment on this

It seems to me that Senator Sweetman anticipates a good deal of difficulty and inconvenience for the owners of land that it is proposed to acquire. There are certain compulsory powers contained in the Bill and, at some stage during the progress of the Bill through the Dáil or the Seanad, I explained the limitation of these compulsory powers—that compulsion in regard to forestry was not compulsion in its ordinary meaning. Land for forestry must be acquired almost entirely by agreement. The compulsion proposed in the Bill will merely apply to one person with some form of right who is holding up the completion of the deal when all the others want the deal to go through.

We have in this case a number of people dealing with the Forestry Department all of whom are willing to transfer their holdings to the Department. In 90 per cent. of the cases, the type of land that is being sold is practically useless for any other purpose. It will cause no inconvenience in regard to building because it is not building ground. It would be most unusual to build on land of the type envisaged as being suitable for our purposes. It would not be offered to the Forestry Department nor would there be any general agreement to give it to the Forestry Department if there was an alternative way of selling it. It is not land that is likely to be improved by fencing or work of that kind. The procedure of making an Order is swift enough. That can be done quickly and the fixing of compensation can be carried through quickly also. If the Forestry Department is dealing with one, two, three or four persons who are readily available there should be no delay, but very often the people with whom you have to deal do not live in Ireland. They may be anywhere else in the world. While it may be suggested that the Land Commission and the Forestry Department are very slow in carrying through such deals, it is our experience that the people who create the slowness are the lawyers. They do not reply very quickly to letters or they may not make out the documents of ownership properly.

Comment on this

The Minister is not suggesting that a Government Department is more expeditious?

Comment on this

I am not attacking Senator Sweetman at all. I know how efficient he is.

Comment on this

You would not mind that a bit.

Comment on this

I think a six months' period would be quite sufficient in 90 per cent. of the cases but where there are complicated issues of ownership, or where complexities of any kind arise, the Forestry Department wants a maximum of two years to complete the job. That period is never likely to be needed unless in exceptional cases. It will not create an inconvenience for people who own a type of land that has no alternative market and which they are quite willing to give to the Department.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell me why the difficulties to which he referred, in regard to ownership, etc., could not be smoothed out just as easily before the acquisition Order as after it?

Comment on this

I assume naturally that before you bring matters in train for acquisition, the Order must be there. It is when the Order is made that all the difficulties arise.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to go half-way to meet me, and make the period 12 months?

Comment on this

I have a great desire to agree but it would be impossible. I do not think the Senator need worry about the time taken to deal with ordinary cases but there are extraordinary cases where, if we cannot conclude the agreement which everybody desires, we shall have to start all over again, creating all the difficulties that have arisen in regard to acquisition in the past. I do not really anticipate difficulties and I wish the Senator would agree with me.

Comment on this

Would the Minister meet me in this respect: if an acquisition Order has been made and the owner goes to the Minister and satisfies him that he would be damnified, by not knowing definitely within a very reasonable time, whether the Minister is or is not going to take the land ultimately, would the Minister meet that man by giving him an assurance or a reply before two years expire? There might be a case where a person was in the situation that he owned land, that the Minister had served an acquisition Order in respect of that land, and that the owner had got an alternative offer or that he needed to sell the land to somebody else. He might go to the Minister and satisfy him that it was essential to know there and then—when I say "there and then" I do not mean at one interview but within a reasonable time— what the Minister's decision was. The Minister says that will happen very seldom. I am prepared to accept that but in the very odd case in which it does happen, if the owner puts the matter before the Minister, will the Minister say "I will tell you within a month"?

Comment on this

It is quite easy to say that to the owner. But, again, if the owner is in a position to say that to the Forestry Department, he must have made arrangements so as to bring other owners into line. It should be as easy for the Forestry Department to bring all the owners into line as for an individual to do it. I do not want to inflict any injury on a particular owner. If we are holding up money which affects an individual, money which he can realise by an alternative sale, I think a grave wrong will be done.

Comment on this

That is the kind of case I had in mind.

Comment on this

We will take every precaution to try to avoid such a condition. The necessity for holding the maximum of two years is because of the intricacies of ownership to which I have referred.

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Under protest?

Comment on this

I reserve my right to put it down on the Report Stage when I have considered it further.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:—

Before Section 24 to insert a new section as follows:—

24. Where an acquisition Order has been made in respect of any land and no vesting Order is made under Section 26 hereof, the Minister shall pay to every person having an interest in such land the costs properly and necessarily incurred by such person as between solicitor and client and such costs shall in default of agreement as to the amount thereof be taxed by a taxing master of the High Court.

This is a small point. I am asking for it to cover a situation where the Minister applied for an acquisition Order and ultimately did not take the land. The owner of the land might, in the interval, have incurred substantial costs either during the course of the actual proceedings or in regard to the actual abstract, and I think where the Minister moved to get the acquisition Order, and, no doubt for very good reasons, changed his mind, the owner of the land who might have had to incur costs should be indemnified in respect of the money he had to pay as a result of the Minister's act.

Comment on this

This new section presupposes that in some cases no vesting Order would be made under Section 26. Section 26 itself provides that, where an acquisition Order in respect of any land is in force, the Minister may, if, in his absolute discretion, he so thinks fit, make, subject to sub-section (2) of this section, an Order under this section vesting the land in him on a specified day not earlier than one month after the making thereof. Sub-section (2) provides that the Minister shall not make a vesting Order in respect of any land which is subject in conjunction with any other land to any annual sum unless an Order has been made under Section 25 of this Act in relation to such land.

The intention of Section 26, I take it, is that in the ordinary way the Minister, when he acquires land, will make the vesting Order vesting the lands in him. In other words, he acquires land for the purpose of acquisition and the vesting Order is the machinery by which ownership is transferred from the former owner to the Minister. This new section of Senator Sweetman's presupposes that in some cases the Minister will not make a vesting Order—he will allow the acquisition Order to remain in force for two years and then expire. The question here will then arise as to what costs have been incurred by the owner in such a case.

Comment on this

Costs of negotiation about price, for example.

Comment on this

That may be, but the section, to my mind, is very wide and I think it is rather a new point in legislation.

Comment on this

So is the principle of withdrawing after making an acquisition Order.

Comment on this

My own view is this: if the Minister allows an acquisition Order to remain in force for two years without making a vesting Order—that is to say, if he allows the acquisition Order to lapse by effluxion of time, he cannot apply for another vesting Order in respect of the same land. In the Supreme Court some time ago it was held that a case stated could not be stated twice by the Circuit Court to the Supreme Court, and it is quite possible that the lay commissioners would say, and that their view might be upheld by the appeal tribunal, that this would be an abuse of the powers of the court in allowing an Order made to expire without acting upon it. Therefore, I think it is most unlikely —it would be almost unthinkable—that the Minister should obtain an acquisition Order and do nothing on foot of it.

While I am always in favour of costs, I think in this case there should be something tangible which would be the subject-matter of costs, such as I may say, the showing of title. If the person from whom the lands have been acquired had gone to the expense of showing his title to the Minister and then the Minister refused to proceed, there might be some reason for allowing him his costs, but it appears to me that the machinery under this Act is this: the Minister will vest the land and let the title be shown afterwards and the purchase money. That might be how the question of title will be solved. At all events, I think this amendment is rather too wide and nebulous and I cannot see it has any great merits.

Comment on this

The procedure is this: when land is acquired the price is fixed either by agreement or by arbitration. Now, if it is fixed by arbitration, the arbitrator awards costs to the owner of the land. Whether fixed by arbitration, or by agreement under the Land Clauses Acts, the owner is entitled to all his costs, showing title and everything else, because the Land Clauses Acts apply to every case of this nature. That is the law, as I understand it, and I think there is no question of doubt about it that whether taken by agreement or not, the costs of the owner must be paid.

Comment on this

I do not know if that is Document No. 3 which Senator Sweetman has.

Comment on this

You might rather have it from Document No. 2.

Comment on this

Section 16 of the Bill contains provision for the payment of costs which I think covers everything the Senator wishes. I think that what the Senator wants is that when the Minister makes an acquisition Order, whether the deal is complete or not, where costs are incurred by the owners of the land, the Forestry Section will meet those costs. Is that what the Senator had in mind?

Comment on this

That is what was in my mind, but I do not think it is quite what is in Section 16. This is really a technical matter, and if the House agrees I am prepared to withdraw the amendment and see if I can satisfy the Minister between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I think everything that is needed is contained in Section 16 which gives the commissioners power to pay expenses in all cases. That covers cases where we do not acquire and where we do acquire. Naturally, it would be very wrong for the Forestry Department to institute proceedings for the acquisition of land and put the owners to cost, and then afterwards not pay the costs.

Comment on this

That is what I want to prevent.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

Before Section 31 to insert a new section as follows:-

31.—Where the owners of any land acquired by the Minister for planting purposes do not agree with the price offered, the owners shall have the right to appeal to an arbitrator appointed by the Minister, who shall hear evidence from the Minister and from the owners and shall then determine the price to be paid.

The procedure that I am suggesting in my amendment is that which is followed generally by the Department of Local Government and Public Health and by county councils when acquiring land for building or other purposes, and also by the Minister for Agriculture when acquiring land for any particular purpose. I cannot see why the Forestry Department should not pursue the same policy when acquiring land for planting. The Minister says that my object in discussing a Bill of this nature is to jack-up the price of land.

Comment on this

Not a bad idea.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will agree that it would require a lot of jacking-up before the Land Commission could be got to bring their prices up to a figure that would be regarded as just or equitable by the owners of the land they acquire. On the Second Reading of the Bill, the statement was made in this House that 529 acres of land had been taken over by the Forestry Department at 4½d. an acre. When I read the statement, I thought it was only a joke, but the Minister admitted that the statement was practically true. I think the House must feel shocked that 529 acres of anybody's land, whether it be mountain land or otherwise, should be acquired, and that practically no compensation should be paid for it.

When I read the statement I did not believe that any Department of State would be guilty of such an act. I believe the Minister's justification was that the people who owned the land said that it was of no use, and that they had not paid rates on it for a few years. We all know that for some years after 1932 there were many classes of farmers who were not able to pay their rates. I am not going to develop that point now, but, for five or six years after 1932, grazing land for any class of live stock showed very little profit.

Senator Baxter said on the same occasion that mountain land used for sheep farming was not worth more than 3/5 per acre. I think what he said was that that would be the value of the flesh of the sheep and the wool. I think I know something about the value of sheep, and of what people get for grazing sheep on mountains. I cannot allow the Senator's statement to pass without saying that it was altogether wrong.

Comment on this

What about 1933 and 1934? What were sheep worth at that time?

Comment on this

Let us take the last three or four years when the price of wool was not controlled. It was about 1/3 or 1/4 per lb. so that the 4 lb. or 4½ lbs. of wool on a sheep would be worth in or about 6/-. Those mountains are used principally for feeding ewes. You would have one lamb on each ewe. An acre of even the worst mountain land would feed a sheep. For a number of years, the price paid for lambs has been from 10/- to 12/6 each, and sometimes 15/- or 16/-. I am quoting average prices. The Senator's statement must have some effect on the Land Commission and on the Minister's advisers who are taking up land, especially when coming from an expert like Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

The Minister would, I am sure, regard the Senator as being a much greater expert than he would admit me to be.

Comment on this

I think the Senator's statement was quite wrong. I am putting myself as an expert against Senator Baxter so far as mountain sheep are concerned, and the profits to be made from them. I have bought sheep off the mountains of Kerry, off the Connemara mountains and sheep that were grazed on the Galtee mountains. I have even bought sheep that were grazed on "Hungry Hill". I have seen sheep that came off some of the Kerry mountains—two and three-year-old wethers—and they were as fat as if they had been fed on County Meath land. I am not against forestry.

What I want to say to the Minister is, that when land is taken compulsorily, the owners should be paid fair and reasonable compensation. In addition to getting what would be the market value of the land, they are also entitled to some compensation for disturbance. In those parts of the country to which I have referred, the people concerned depend on the grazing of sheep on the mountains for their principal means of livelihood as well as on the prices they get for their sheep and lambs, and the wool off the sheep. If they are to be deprived of their rights, they are at least entitled to reasonable compensation. If they get that, then the Department can plant away and satisfy Senator Baxter. I contend that no matter whose land is taken, whether it belongs to the descendants of Cromwell or of Abraham, that so long as the owners of it hold a legal title to it, they should get reasonable compensation. The Minister says he is very anxious to have goodwill in respect of the planting of land. The first essential in that regard is to get the people to believe that they will get reasonable compensation for the land to be taken over. No farmer has any confidence whatever in the Land Commission's valuing of land. I could quote hundreds of cases to prove that statement, but I do not want to go into that question now. The fact—I think that it is an admitted fact—remains that we have no confidence in the Land Commission in regard to the price they fix for land. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment, and I assure him that it was in the interest of forestry development I put it down.

Comment on this

My friend, Senator Counihan, astounds me. This new section he proposes is to be found already in Section 15. Under Section 15, the Minister must appoint an arbitrator to determine the compensation. I am only sorry that my friend, Senator Counihan, did not support me on Section 15, when I was trying to get the Minister to insert therein a provision for compensation for disturbance. If I had the benefit of his support on that section, I have no doubt whatever that the Minister would have caved in at once. Senator Counihan said that we—by which, I take it, he meant those of us in this orbit, with himself—have no confidence in the Land Commission in regard to the fixing of the price of land. So far as I am concerned, I do not want any misunderstanding on that question. I do not blame the Land Commission nor do I blame the lay commissioners or the appeal tribunal. They are only trying to abide by a completely unfair and unjust frame of words in the statute. It is the statute which is wrong with regard to the fixing of the price of acquired land and not the personnel of the bodies concerned. In view of the contingency that Senator Counihan's remark might be construed as against the personnel, rather than against the statute, which, I think, he meant, it is well that I should add that word of explanation.

Comment on this

I was rather surprised, at first, that Senator Counihan should move an amendment placing in the hands of an arbitrator, appointed by the Minister, power to determine the compensation to be paid in respect of lands to be acquired by the Minister, while Section 31 of the Bill, as it stands, provides that such compensation shall be assessed by the lay commissioners and, on appeal, by the appeal tribunal, both the lay commissioners and the appeal tribunal being independent of the Minister. Apparently, Senator Counihan was quite prepared to have the compensation assessed by an arbitrator appointed by the Minister instead of having it assessed by the lay commissioners or the appeal tribunal.

I was puzzled as to why he should put down the amendment but I think that he did so because, as he himself said, he had no confidence whatever in the lay commissioners or the appeal tribunal as the body to fix the price of land. Section 31 of this Bill provides that compensation is to be assessed by the lay commissioners, and, on appeal, by the appeal tribunal, but Section 15 places the lay commissioners and the appeal tribunal in the position of arbitrators under Section 2 of the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act, 1919, so that, whether the compensation be assessed by an arbitrator, so called, appointed by the Minister, or by the lay commissioners and, on appeal, by the appeal tribunal, the basis of compensation must be the same—that is to say, that laid down by the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act, 1919. Therefore, I cannot see that any advantage would be gained by providing that the compensation be fixed by the ad hoc arbitrator mentioned in Senator Counihan's amendment. I suggest to the Senator that he should withdraw the amendment with a good grace, because, in this case, the compensation will have to be assessed on the same basis as an arbitrator would assess it if he were appointed.

Comment on this

I do not propose to put my opinion against that of Senator Ryan. My point is that, when the Land Commission is fixing the price, no question can be raised as to how they arrived at such a value. In the case of the lay commissioners, the Minister's representative states how he arrived at his valuation. The owners come in and show what the value of the land was to them. Senator Ryan says that this amendment would place the owners in a worse position than that in which they are. Even if that were so, the majority of the owners would be much better satisfied, because they could have their counsel present to question the Minister's representative as to how he arrived at his valuation. There is no such opportunity when a case comes before the lay commissioners or the appeal tribunal. That is why I think the Minister should accept this amendment. The Local Government Department and other Departments appoint an arbitrator when they are acquiring land and do not leave it to such a body as the Land Commission to fix the price.

Comment on this

If we could leave Senator Counihan to his spring lambs and return to our muttons, we should, probably, get further. His simple faith in the Minister is very touching. I wonder is that a personal compliment or is it a suggestion that politicians are far superior to independent commissioners in the matter of fixing prices. Senator Counihan referred to a number of cases in which the figure was 4½d. per acre. The whole of that 4½d. per acre was, practically, acquisition costs; the land belonged to nobody. That is how this amazingly low price for the land came about. I know, as Senator Sweetman said, that no farmer has any confidence in the Land Commission as regards the question of price. Those from whom the Land Commission acquire land always think the price is too low. Those who get land from the Land Commission are always under the impression that they are being fleeced by the annuity that is placed upon them. That is always the difficulty of the Referee. In Kerry, as Senator Counihan probably knows, it used to be very dangerous to referee a football match at one time. It seems to me that the lay commissioners and, on appeal, the appeal tribunal, being the normal instrument for fixing the compensation of such land, the Forestry Department, being a section of the Land Commission must, willy nilly, adopt the same instrument for their purpose. Where other State Departments acquire land and appoint an arbitrator, the foundation is altogether different because, with Local Government, with Defence, with Finance, it is practically entirely a question of acquiring land for building purposes, generally in an area where the cost of land for building purposes is much different and might be debatable. In this case, as I pointed out before, land acquired for forestry purposes must be over 90 per cent. acquired by agreement.

We cannot compel people to give land for forestry because we must have the people's goodwill, forestry being such a delicate plant and so easily injured. I do not know any arbitrator that might be appointed in cases like this, where there are intricacies of ownership, where there are rights of way, and matters of that sort, with which the Land Commissioners are completely familiar, and where it would be impossible to get a man with the same capacity or knowledge as they have. Even the amendment as it stands would give the Minister the right to appoint one of the lay commissioners whom Senator Counihan objects to. There really is nothing to the amendment. I could not by any means accept it. There is no injustice. Whatever argument may be made about unjust prices in regard to the acquisition of ordinary agricultural land and the fixing of price by the commissioners, there is no analogy between agricultural land and the case of land for forestry because, as I say, it is land that has no agricultural value that will be acquired by the Land Commission because general agreement has been reached by the owners of the land who are rather more anxious to get rid of it than to retain it.

Comment on this

The Minister will have the appointment of the arbitrators. It will not affect the price in any way. I think the amendment should be accepted by the Minister. He says "No" and that is the last word.

Comment on this

The Minister has divested himself under the Land Acts of various powers which are given to an independent tribunal and it would be very wrong if what has been done in the past, and which has proved to have such good results, should be changed now.

Comment on this

With the permission of the House I shall not move amendment No. 11 and I shall raise the point I have in mind on Section 32.

Comment on this

I hope I shall have the assistance of some of my legal friends in clarifying this matter of the allocation of compensation. As a layman, it seems to me an entirely simple and straightforward measure: compensation is paid for the land, on which there are certain mortgages and charges and I should have thought that the allocation of that compensation was automatic, that the highest charges would get the first draw, and so on, in order of priority. But here there seem to be complicated and, to my mind, unintelligible methods by which a judge is brought in to deal with the allocation of the compensation. It would appear to me that if there is a dispute between the parties, the courts of law in the ordinary way would deal with it. I should like generally to be enlightened by the Minister on the whole matter.

Comment on this

I think Senator Sir John Keane is right. The first mortgagee, I think, would be entitled to the money.

Comment on this

As Senator Sir John Keane says, it is rather a complicated legal matter in many ways and the only provision in the Bill which has any reference, direct or indirect, to priority as between two or more mortgagees to which an interest in land compulsorily acquired under the Bill is subject, is sub-section (3) of Section 32. That sub-section provides for the allocation of compensation in respect of an interest in vested land which was, immediately before the vesting date, subject to two or more mortgages.

It is provided that if the compensation is sufficient to discharge all the mortgage debts in full the Minister shall allocate to each mortgagee the sum necessary to discharge his mortgage debt and shall allocate any surplus of the compensation remaining to the mortgagor. In case the compensation is not sufficient to discharge the mortgage debts in full and if all the mortgagees agree as to how the compensation is to be allocated, the Minister shall allocate it in accordance with their agreement. If they do not agree as to the allocation, the Minister will apply to the Circuit Court or to the High Court, and the court to which he applies will allocate the compensation. The only case in which any question of priority of one mortgagee over another might arise is that in which the Minister applies to the court to have the compensation allocated. The court will, of course, in any such case have due regard to proper priority.

Comment on this

I take it that the only difficulty arises in the case where the compensation is not sufficient to discharge the mortgage debts in full. In that case there may be, so to speak, the question of priorities. Apparently the Minister is not prepared to take it on himself to deal with that aspect of the matter, and so the Bill provides that the insufficient compensation is to be apportioned as between the mortgagees by the Circuit Court, if the compensation does not exceed £1,000, and by the High Court, in case the compensation exceeds £1,000. Sub-section (4) provides the basis on which such allocation shall be made by the court. I should like to see in this section some provision regulating the procedure on application to the court. The section provides that the Minister may apply in a summary manner to the Circuit Court or the High Court. I think it would be desirable to refer to or have conference with the Department of Justice or the rule-making authorities as to the manner in which a summary reference should be made, say, to the Circuit Court.

This is a new procedure, as far as I know, in which either the Circuit Court or the High Court is asked to apportion compensation money as between mortgagees. It may be necessary to implement the section by providing another sub-section, giving power to the rule-making authority to make the necessary rules of court. Personally, I do not see that there is anything wrong in that and I think that is all Senator Sir John Keane desires to know.

I am not in a position at the moment to deal with the provisions of this section in respect of the method of apportionment as between the two mortgagees. That is a matter which Senator Sir John Keane, as a practical banker, would be in a better position to consider than I am. At all events, I am satisfied that, whatever the Bill provides as a basis of apportionment between two mortgagees, either the Circuit Court or the High Court will carry it out. Though it may be a satisfactory method, it may also be a costly method. I think the section also provides for costs. You cannot ask people to go to court without paying their costs. If the mortgagees were to bear their own costs, the compensation might be diminished very considerably. I do not see here any provision for the payment of the costs of mortgagees who have to go to court to get the compensation apportioned. This land is being acquired by the Minister for the purpose of this Bill. The mortgagees and the owners are innocent parties as far as that matter is concerned and I am of opinion that no person, whether he is a mortgagee or an owner, should be asked to suffer any loss by reason of the expense of the machinery set up by the Bill, either for the awarding of the compensation or for the apportionment of the compensation to which, as mortgagee, he is entitled under the Bill.

Comment on this

I think that the only possible doubt or trouble arises under sub-section (4). It seems to me that if the compensation money is not sufficient to pay all the mortgagees, then the rules for distributing the money among the mortgagees in priority are perfectly well established and do not need the intervention of a court. The rule is that the first mortgagee is paid his claim in full, together with the reasonable costs of his demand, as far as the money goes; then it goes on to the next one, if there is enough money for him, and so on, in order of time. There are certain questions known as tacking and consolidation, which very rarely arise here, owing to the operation of our Registry Act, but they arise in England. If this section is intended to give the court the decision in the case of complicated questions, I can understand that; but what Senator Sir John Keane is anxious to have made clear to him is that there is no intention, by these sections, to give to the court a discretionary power to override the ordinary rules of priority.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

If, for instance, there is £1,000 in the till and mortgage No. 1 is for £800, mortgage No. 2 for £300 and mortgage No. 3 for £100, the money would be divided up giving £800 to the first one and the balance of £200 to the second one, leaving the unfortunate third mortgagee—who has been sufficiently foolish to be a third mortgagee—with nothing. That would be the ordinary method. What Senator Keane is anxious to make sure of is that this section does not give power to invent new law or avoid old law, by means of uncontrolled discretion.

Comment on this

I wonder if it could be made clear in this way—"in case the compensation is not sufficient to discharge all of the mortgaged debts in full, the purchase money shall be distributed according to law." Then, if anybody is dissatisfied, he can apply to the courts.

Comment on this

I did assume naturally the idea that Senator Kingsmill Moore has mentioned—that there is a certain rule in relation to these mortgages, where priority is accorded. That is the regular procedure and I cannot see any reason why it should be ignored. If there is an established rule of law, it should be valid. We have a difficulty here, which we are trying to meet, where the mortgages we have to deal with in the land we acquire also cover other lands. That is why the procedure is as it is.

Comment on this

That might involve apportionment, exclusive charging, tacking and consolidation.

Comment on this

The question of costs might, in certain ways, be very detrimental to the claims of the mortgagees. I will have to examine it, as to whether we can allot certain costs, before making a definite statement about it.

Comment on this

One might eat up all the compensation in costs in a certain case. One of the difficulties is that, when the Land Commission is distributing a limited purchase money in a case where there are several superior interests in the nature of rents, they do not necessarily exhaust the purchase money in paying in full the first interest. They allot only a certain number of years' purchase to it and there is a kind of equitable distribution, partly owing to established practice and partly owing to the discretion of the judge. Senator Sir John Keane was anxious that we were introducing, in the distribution of purchase money among mortgagees, the principle of the distribution of the purchase money among superior interests in the nature of rents.

Comment on this

I should like to get certain information from the Minister. A replanting condition is attached to land. I conceive that the owner of the land and the Department may have quite honest differences as to the method of replanting. After all, forestry is not an exact science. An owner might be a little bit adventurous and might wish to replant in a certain way of which the Minister's more orthodox advisers might not approve. I feel that unless the owner is altogether extravagant in what he wants to do— after all he is the owner of the land— and provided his purpose is honest, his views should be allowed to prevail. There is a natural tendency, I believe one might say, for the Minister's advisers to look askance at the more rigid ideas of the private owner, but I do not think it fair that the Minister should have the last say as to the form in which replanting is to take place. I know that at present there are very great differences of opinion as to the rival merits of soft woods and hard woods, and in that case, when it is merely a matter of planting soft woods or hard woods, I do think that the owner's views should prevail. Similarly, there may be differences as to the various forms of soft woods.

On Second Reading I raised the question of natural regeneration. It is a practice that is very largely followed on the Continent and there is no technical reason why it should not gradually grow here. If an owner says: "I want to replant by the methods of natural regeneration" would the Minister be in a position to say: "No, I shall not allow it"? Remember the owner still presumably owns his land and presumably is trying to do his best according to his own ideas. There is another question which I think I already mentioned.

Supposing an owner says: "I want, now that there is a fuel shortage, to have quite a reasonable acreage, say ten or 15 acres of firewood coppice". I think personally that firewood coppice may grow in popularity. Firewood is a better fuel than turf, unless the quality of the turf improves considerably, for domestic purposes and there should be no obstacle placed in the way of an owner who wants to replant with firewood coppice. I feel that if there is disagreement between the Minister and the owner as to the method of replanting there should be some outside body to whom the owner might appeal.

Comment on this

In regard to natural regeneration, we have not succeeded very well in developing that type of forestry here. We have to indulge in the more costly form of rearing seedlings and planting them out. Regeneration would be more satisfactory and much cheaper if we could do our planting in that fashion. From my own layman's point of view, I think the reason that we have not adopted regeneration is that we have not sufficient parent trees of the right type. A lot of the trees standing in the country up to recently were over-mature and the offspring of old trees are not very healthy. I would very much approve of any experiments that could be made in developing forestry by regeneration and I am hoping, when we have gone a certain distance with our afforestation ideas here, that we shall experiment, and I believe successfully experiment, with the idea of forestry by regeneration. In the Bill as we have it, for the first time replanting by regeneration is provided for. It has not been heretofore provided for.

I am not a good authority on coppice. We have not had experience here of coppicing. I do know that in other countries it has been a very successful method of producing firewood and wood for various types of industries. Unfortunately in some other countries, where it provided material for a number of rural crafts and for the development of very great skill of different types in rural areas, the coppice has very much gone out. Not only do I personally see no objection to providing an area of coppice, but I think it would be a very good thing if it were provided.

In the case of a man who has a keen interest in forestry, and who has ideas of his own that do not run quite parallel with what one might call the orthodox ideas of the Department, there is room for a certain amount of give and take on both sides, but we have to introduce rules in the Bill, not particularly to deal with the man of goodwill. The rules have to be fairly clear, rigid and definite because the people we have to deal with in relation to forestry in this country, who cut down trees, are those who are anxious to avoid any kind of replanting and who are anxious to avoid putting back into the ground any of the wealth they take out of it. Where a man has the idea of replanting without the compulsion of law, where he is interested in forestry, I do not think that the rules as applied generally should be enforced against him but that there should be discussion between him and the forestry experts out of which a reasonable agreement might arise. The whole purpose of the Bill is to promote forestry and if we can get people who are ready to co-operate voluntarily with us, there is no reason why we should not meet their idiosyncrasies, if one could so regard them.

Comment on this

I think that in view of the Minister's statement it would be only fair if I said that I know of two cases in which the estates concerned are generally interested in forestry and both estates are satisfied that the Minister's Department meets them fairly.

Comment on this

I think it does.

Comment on this

At the present time it would be very onerous to press owners to replant while the cost of fencing wire is so high. That should be taken into account. I would like to ask the Department, or is the Department prepared to say, if wire is obtainable at the lowest possible price? I speak subject to correction, but I understand at the present moment that, owing to the tariff restrictions, the price of wire is substantially higher here than in other countries.

Comment on this

Wire is much cheaper than it was.

Comment on this

It would be unfair altogether to insist on immediate replanting, I agree, because the price of wire is so high. The Department has made many efforts within the past few years to get wire at such a price that it would not be unfair to ask him to put up wire. But at the present time it is very scarce in the country.

Comment on this

And the Department have always extended the time in consequence.

Comment on this

I move:—

To delete the section.

I have put this amendment down to get clarification. On the face of it, it seems to be most unjust that a person who owns land should be liable to a contribution of this kind. I cannot see what it is. Perhaps the Minister would develop it and say what he has in his mind by this contributing condition?

Comment on this

Wherever there is a clearance of land under licence there is a replanting condition attached. That imposes certain commitments, which may be called penalties, on the owner of the land. In some cases where land is cleared under licence, the owner may desire to utilise the land for purposes other than the growing of trees. He has taken a certain amount out of the land. He has reduced the area of forestry and we feel it only just that he should be placed somewhat in an analogous position to the man, who after clearing his land had to make certain contributions to State forestry development in replantation. Therefore, we propose to put on him compensatory conditions so as to put him on the same basis as the man who had to replant. I do not think it is unfair.

Comment on this

What would the contribution be like?

Comment on this

It appears to me that there are three different cases. The first is the man who owns land suitable for replanting, applies for and gets a felling licence subject to replanting. But the trees he is replanting are grown on his own land and are inuring for his own benefit and not for that of anybody else. Then you come to the case where there is land not suitable for replanting and I do not quite understand why if the land is not suitable for replanting because of some factor over which the owner of the land has no control that he ought to be asked to pay for something that is going to inure for the benefit of somebody else's land. That case was not met by the Minister at all.

Then, there is the third case that was met by the Minister, where a person applies for a licence to cut and the land might be suitable for replanting, but the owner, in the Minister's words, wishes to use it for something else, and in view of his wishes the Minister is prepared to allow him to use it for some other purpose provided he contributes to the cost elsewhere. In that case there is a specific decision taken by the owner of the land. The option is left to the owner and I would not have the slightest objection to giving the Minister a section that would cover that third case. It is the second case I object to.

Comment on this

I wonder if the Senator would make that clear again?

Comment on this

The first case is a simple one—the owner has trees on his land and applies for a felling permit. He gets the felling permit provided he will plant trees on his land and these trees inure for the owner's benefit. That is dealt with under Section 41, and then we come under Section 42 to two different types of case. The first is the case where the owner of the land has trees and applies for a permit to cut them. The Minister decides that the land in the possession of that owner is not suitable for replanting. The Minister, under this section, has taken power to exact tribute from that owner before he will let him cut.

It does not appear to me to be reasonable that the Minister will have the power to exact tribute from a person who owns trees where that person has no land which is suitable to replant. The third case is the case made by the Minister in reply to Senator Sir John Keane. That is a case where a man has trees on land which he wishes to cut and which land is suitable for replanting but the owner wishes to use the land for something other than replanting.

I entirely agree in that case if the owner wishes to use land for some purpose other than replanting when the land is suitable to plant, it is perfectly fair to exact a tribute from him because he has the option either of paying or of replanting, but I fail to see why the Minister should take power to exact tribute from a man who has no land suitable for replanting, and therefore in so doing the Minister is taking from him money to enable some other person to plant trees and to reap the profit from those trees when they are planted and grow to maturity.

Comment on this

Does this limited felling licence apply to persons who planted trees at their own expense without getting a grant and who now wish to fell them? Suppose I have undertaken a scheme of afforestation. I put my money into it. The trees have grown and matured. I am entitled to sell them as matured timber, it being a legitimate use of my land. I apply and get a licence. Why should there be any further conditions put upon it? If I do not wish to use the land for forestry the Minister has certain powers. If he is not going to use them, and I wish to use my land for other purposes, why should I not have the right to use my land if I want to? Why should I have to pay a fine to the Minister?

Comment on this

I wonder if it is accepted by the Seanad that there should be a replanting clause?

Comment on this

Certainly, as far as I am concerned anyway.

Comment on this

If we are to have forestry and preserve what we have and develop what we need, we must try to hold the land which is under forestry for forestry purposes. It is not at all unfair then that the man who is going to cut down the timber shall be asked to replant. The second man has an afforested area. He gets a permit to clear the land. We desire that he shall replant, and he suggests that he proposes to use the land for other purposes. It is his own land, but he has taken away, in the felling of the timber, a certain national asset, and if he is not going to replace that asset the fine that is put on him is to be utilised to try to provide elsewhere the asset which he has destroyed. I do not think it is unfair.

Comment on this

Provided the Minister leaves the option with the owner of the land.

Comment on this

Option in regard to what?

Comment on this

Provided the Minister only exacts the money if the owner has first got the opportunity of replanting and says that he is not going to do it.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

If the Minister will put that in the section, I will be in agreement with him.

Comment on this

I have been considerably worried as to whether this portion of the Bill is not going to defeat its own ends. I have talked to people as to what the effect of it has been on their minds. There are a lot of people who would be willing, at their own expense, to indulge in a certain amount of afforestation, provided that, if they put their money into land, they were to have control of it themselves, and should be allowed a discretion as to thinning and felling, and that they should be allowed to take the profit of the matured trees just as the farmer who creates a national asset by putting wheat into his land is allowed to take the profit of the matured wheat without being forced by a Government Department to make a particular usage of the same land each year.

I believe that these are some of the provisions in the Bill that are going to defeat themselves and that are going to stop planting. I think it is a radically wrong principle that if a man has expended his own money on forestry that he should not have control over the growth of the trees, the selling of them and the use of the land. In the case of a man who has applied for a grant, a grant which is provided in connection with the planting of his land, the position is quite different. There the State has given something and is entitled to impose conditions. Nobody can complain about that, but if a man has done planting himself and has asked for no money—if he has done it as a hobby, from a commercial point of view or to beautify his place—I cannot see why the State should cash-in on his individual expenditure and care. I cannot see why, because a man has done a thing which will benefit himself, something which will add to the beauty of the landscape or that will produce climatic advantages, he should be forced, because of his foresight and expenditure, to toe the line.

Surely the right thing would be that if the State wants land it can acquire it under the earlier provisions of the Bill. It should not, however, penalise a man who has acted on his own initiative. In earlier parts of the Bill it will be found that people may be deterred from starting planting schemes because, when the time comes for thinning and for acting on their own discretion or on the advice of their experts, they cannot thin without going to the Minister for a licence. I have heard people say that if they have to go trotting to the Minister's Department every time they want a licence to cut out weakly trees in order to let the others grow, they will not undertake planting at all. I am rather afraid that the amount of regulations which are being put into the Bill will defeat the end in view. I hesitated to express a view on this matter until I had ascertained what the reactions of this Bill were on certain people I consulted.

I realise the difficulty of the Minister in altering the Bill now. I did think, however, that I should bring this point of view before the Minister because there is still left in Ireland a certain objection to being ordered about. As I have said, there are a great many people who, if left to themselves, would indulge in small or medium schemes of afforestation, but who will not do so if, as soon as they put down a tree, that tree is for all intents and purposes to be taken out of their control and subjected to a mass of forms and regulations, and if they are to be put under the control of people here in Dublin.

Comment on this

I quite agree with the general views expressed by Senator Kingsmill Moore, but I do not think the Minister much minds that. I think he would be quite glad if all private forestry came to an end and that the whole matter was vested in the State. I do not say that he has got any sinister purpose in these regulations. I do agree with Senator Kingsmill Moore that every discouragement is being given to people not to embark on the adventure of private afforestation.

I do not see how this section is going to work. Perhaps that is due to the fact that I am rather ignorant of how the present system works. If I want to fell an area of land, and that there is a certain portion of the area which I do not want to replant because I do not think it is worth while planting it—and moreover if I fell it—I am liable to have a contribution attached. I take it the idea is that I would apply for a felling licence only in respect of the area that I think is worth felling— the area that I wish to replant. The effect of that will be that the portion that is not worth planting owing to the fact that trees have never thrived there, or that the land is not good, will simply remain useful perhaps for game purposes, but useless for afforestation. Trees will not thrive where you have a bad sub-soil or where the land has not been drained. In such circumstances, what is going to happen? If the Minister is satisfied with a situation like that, well and good. I do not think it is desirable, because it might be possible, by draining the land, to use it for other purposes.

As regards the contribution, it is surely unjust that the Minister should be the sole judge of what it should be, and that there should be no appeal. If the principle of a contribution is to be accepted there should be some machinery by which the Minister will not be the sole judge—to give whatever sum he likes, and that the owner is to have no means of appeal. I think the Minister should reconsider this section between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am afraid Senator Kingsmill Moore has got the House back to a Second Reading debate. He has attacked the principle of compelling people who cut down trees to replant but that principle has been accepted over a long period. It would be, I think, entirely impracticable to make that principle apply only to people who have got sums for planting trees. I think it would be impracticable also to confine it to people who had planted trees at their own expense. Surely, if my father had trees they are as much mine as if I had planted them. By the same token, my father did not leave me trees. Perhaps that is why my views are what they are. In any event, I do not think you could make a distinction between the trees which a man plants himself and the trees his father planted, or indeed his predecessor in title planted.

I think Senator Kingsmill Moore would acknowledge himself that the analogy between wheat and trees, in fact, does not exist. A tree is quite a different thing from a wheat crop. It takes a long time to mature. Wheat, of its nature, must be cut down, or else it rots, whereas if you cut down trees you are depriving people of something that is an asset. The arrangement by which trees must be planted is a sound one.

On the other question raised by Senator Sir John Keane's amendment, if the section has the meaning which the Minister says then the Minister is in complete agreement with Senator Sweetman, and if that were made clear then there is nothing at all between the Minister and Senator Sweetman or, indeed, I think, between the Minister and Senator Sir John Keane. That is to say, if a man has trees on his land, wants to cut the trees and, apart from the question whether the land is suitable for replanting or not, wants to use it for something else and agrees with the Minister, he should, presumably, make an agreed contribution. It might be more satisfactory if, instead of the Minister being sole judge, somebody else could be made judge but the matter is one that may occur very often and about which there may be not any dispute. If we are to have a Forestry Department at all, we must give it certain powers. Nobody is more in favour of individual liberty than I am but one of the ways of restricting individual liberty is to advocate it too strongly.

I think that Senator Kingsmill Moore will agree with that. The further you go in the advocacy of individual liberty, the more you are preparing yourself for grave restrictions of that liberty. Better to strike a middle course. If the Department is reasonable in its treatment of owners, then I think that the replanting condition must remain. The question of the contribution is different. The Minister appeared to think that the section applied only to cases where the owner, without any regard to the suitability of his land for replanting, wanted to use it for something else, and would agree with the Department as to the contribution. If the Minister were right in that, no difficulty would arise.

Comment on this

I did realise that I was making a Second Reading speech. I did not raise the matter on the Second Reading because the principle had, more or less, been accepted. I tried to show, in this instance, that, while the principle itself was open to certain objections, these objections applied with extra force to a section such as this. It is too late, I grant, to criticise the principle, though I realise that it has gone too far.

Comment on this

I regret that my business does not bring me to the Seanad oftener. I continue to make discoveries every time I come along. How Senator Hayes could have had the heart, after so many years in the Chair in the Dáil, to say that he was in favour of individual liberty, I do not understand.

Comment on this

I am in favour of ordered liberty.

Comment on this

I am completely in favour of the individuality of which Senator Kingsmill Moore so highly approved. But individuality is very often expressed in this country in a sense of grievance, when no grievance exists. Senator Sir John Keane's latest speech represented that particular type of individuality. There is a regulation in France that no land which has ever grown trees can be utilised for any other purpose. I think that that is very wrong, that it is an indefensible regulation and that we should not support the idea here. But we are talking about forestry and Senator Kingsmill Moore is talking about plantations for scenic purposes—woodlands and so forth.

I do not visualise any individual going into large-scale forestry in this country, though I sincerely hope people will do so. Senator Sir John Keane seems to think that we wish to prevent, by regulation, a person from so doing. We really want to be helpful and all our regulations are intended to be helpful. Senator Kingsmill Moore says that a person will not plant trees because he must go to the Minister for authority to fell them. Surely, we are not so dictatorial or so unwise as to prevent a man from carrying out the usual thinnings and clearances that have to be undertaken under proper methods of sylviculture. We have taken no powers to prevent any man from felling matured trees on his land. We cannot include men who cut shelter-belts on small acreages of land or men who cut down timber planted for scenic purposes with those who have been felling in a large way in connection with forestry. It is quite possible that certain land which has grown poor timber is unfitted to grow real timber and there is no reason why we should continue to utilise that land for forestry purposes. The Forestry Department would be the last people in the world to plant timber on land unsuitable for producing it commercially. Most people seem to be under the impression — particularly enthusiasts — that the Forestry Department should undertake, anywhere in the country, the growing of trees, irrespective of whether they become, at any stage of their growth, of commercial value. Our concern is the growing of commercial timber, not scenic timber and not timber on land that will not produce commercial timber. We are often told that we are not in earnest about forestry because we will not accept certain types of land and plant it, knowing that it will produce only stunted, gnarled and useless stuff, suitable, at best, for firewood. The Department has designed a method of helping those interested to undertake forestry by giving a grant of £10 an acre for planting. I can see no man—even if he were a very prominent banker—undertaking forestry without making application for that £10 grant.

In offering that grant we are trying to be helpful, and the individuality that expresses itself in a sense of grievance is not a helpful type of individuality to have introduced here. Possibly, our history has as much effect on one side of the fence as it has had on the other. It is quite reasonable to ask a man who has clear-felled an area of forestry to replant under the conditions that we desire, and we provide him with £10 an acre.

Comment on this

Whether the land is suitable or not?

Comment on this

Oh, no. I have been very clear on it. It is quite right, where a man has clear-felled a forest area and wishes to utilise the land for other purposes that, having deprived the nation of a certain national asset, he should make a contribution to try to rebuild that national asset. In Section 56 of the Bill there is an appeal to a referee. The Minister does not take it upon himself finally to assess compensation and the only case, so far, where we have insisted on, or tried to insist on, a compensation clause, is in the case of a man who wishes to clear a large area of forestry, who expresses his intention of avoiding any replanting conditions, and who says he never wishes to see the land again. We must try to make him be a little bit helpful. I think the Senators should accept the section without amendment. I think it is quite reasonable.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to allow this question of the contribution to go to the Referee under Section 56?

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

Is it covered by the Bill at present?

Comment on this

Section 56.

Comment on this

Sub-section (6), paragraph (c)—does that do it?

Comment on this

It does it the wrong way.

Comment on this

I do not wish to take up the time of the House now. I am not satisfied but I am prepared to press no further if I have that assurance.

Comment on this

I will be quite clear on it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I wish to make one point on the economics of the Minister's remarks. He says that you cut down trees and, if you do not replant, you deprive the nation of an asset. Surely if you put that land to agricultural purposes, which would be far more productive than any forestry would be, you would not be destroying a national asset but creating a more valuable asset. It may be an academic point but I cannot accept the Minister's contention that you destroy an asset by turning a forest area into agricultural land.

Comment on this

I am afraid it is an academic point.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister could answer one question which would save me considerable thought. Does the Minister accept the point of view that an owner should only be asked to contribute money if he wishes to avoid the replanting condition?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister satisfy himself between now and Report Stage that the section is phrased to cover that, because I am not absolutely clear that it is?

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

As I understand the situation in regard to this section, the owner of land serves his application for a felling notice and the Minister must serve his refusal to that notice within 21 days. If nothing happens within 21 days the owner can cut away.

Comment on this

If the Department does not notify the owner within 21 days.

Comment on this

If the Department does not notify the owner within 21 days, he can cut away. If the Department does notify the owner within 21 days, the Department must have a reason for so doing.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Under sub-section (2) of this section the Minister cannot make a refusal based on preserving an amenity without consulting the district planning authority. How can he, therefore, consult the district planning authority and get their decision within 21 days? It appears to me that the situation might quite easily be that an owner would make application, the trees being mature, but the Minister may think that they had scenic value. Shall we take, for example, the trees at Torc Mountain in Killarney. The Minister may take the view that that timber was commercially mature, was old, dying, but that it was desirable, from the scenic point of view, to hold it until such time as other timber had come along. The Minister must do something within 21 days but the Minister cannot refuse the permit from the scenic point of view except with the consent of the district planning authority. I do not see how he could get that consent within 21 days and, therefore, I think his refusal might be set aside, and I am particularly anxious from the tourist angle that the refusal should not be set aside. It is a technical point and if the Minister would look into it between now and Report Stage I would be quite happy.

Comment on this

Of course, the point is, a man makes application for a permit to fell certain trees in a particular area; the Forestry Department examines the map, sees exactly where the trees are. If they believe as a result of their examination of a small-scale map that there is necessity to inquire into the matter, they can get a large-scale map and have a look at it. That is what I would do. They would then notify the gentleman who applied for the permit that he was not to cut the timber without permission. Then they would have it examined. They would have time enough to go to the planning authority then. The question of cutting mature timber in those places has been raised. We really cannot prevent the cutting of mature timber, and while it would be very right from the tourist point of view, the scenic point of view, to preserve such timber, it can only be preserved for a limited period, and there are certain provisions in the Bill which impose on the planning authority certain commitments with regard to it.

If the work in Killarney had not been carried out, the trees would have fallen in a very short time and the condition would be far worse than it will be now, when there is a settled scheme of felling instituted and a replanting proposition to preserve the scenic amenities there. It should be quite easy, I think, to arrange with the planning authorities. As a matter of fact, I have had some experience in that during the past year where trees have been preserved in one particular area. I do not see any difficulty in it. We do not have to get in touch with the planning authority immediately. An examination of the map gives us the information as to whether it is necessary to do so or not, and if we believe from an examination of the map that the amenities should be preserved, we can prevent the felling of the trees until we make a thorough examination into the matter.

Comment on this

On behalf of Senator O Buachalla, I move amendment No. 13:—

In sub-section (2), page 51, to delete lines 51 to 55, inclusive.

Perhaps the Minister would accept the amendment and save me all the trouble of saying anything more about it. Where the Minister orders hares to be destroyed, if they are not destroyed, he can send his men in to destroy them. Then, in lines 51 to 60, he can charge the cost to the owner of the land. Section 58 provides for rabbits and other vermin and the same clause in that section was deleted in the Dáil, but evidently, by mistake, it was not deleted in Section 60.

Comment on this

I will accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I have been approached by a well-known person in the world of sport, who says that, if these two sections are passed, there will be no more coursing in Ireland. He suggests the following amendment —of course, I am not proposing it now, but I am asking the Minister to consider it—"If the owner or occupier can prove to the satisfaction of the Minister that the land is being used as a hare preserve, for the purpose of supplying the recognised hare coursing interests, he may grant a certificate of exemption, even though the land is infested." That may seem reasonable, from the point of view of coursing as an industry, and certainly hares that contribute to the sport should be preserved. I would ask the Minister to consider that aspect of the whole question.

Comment on this

I have no desire to destroy an industry or a sport. It would look more like a sport to me always if the hare could turn back and bite somebody, but that does not happen. However, hares have a habit of keeping out of a place where they are unwelcome. They are migratory. If they are permitted in forests or in the vicinity of young forests, one has to choose between hares and forestry. My choice would be forestry, where we have it at present and let the hares find somewhere else. I have not the least belief that this section will destroy coursing, any more than the destruction of Pekinese dogs in Dublin will destroy greyhounds.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister would think over this, as perhaps I have taken him rather by surprise. This matter was not raised in the Dáil and it seems rather important. The Minister may say he has never been approached by the coursing interests and that they are not concerned. There is nothing to prevent the Minister thinking it over. He may ask some of his sporting friends if they are satisfied about this. It looks to me as if it might have an effect on the provision of hares for coursing.

Comment on this

The Senator does not surprise me at all. What surprises me is that no one ever referred to the matter before. I expected much more of a row about it. I really do not anticipate the difficulty that the Senator or his adviser anticipates. Naturally, the people in a sporting district are concerned with that and not with anything else. I am concerned with forestry, particularly in this Bill, but I would not like to do any damage to any other industry. However, as I say, there is a place for forestry in this country and that is not the place for hares. There is certainly a lot of other land where there will be hares. As a matter of fact, the hare which is not a forest or mountain hare is a far better hare for coursing purposes.

Comment on this