We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Appropriation Bill, 1948 (Certified Money Bill)—Second Stage.

Contributions 97–206 of 206. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Appropriation Bill, 1948
Enacted

No. 16 of 1948 ›

Captain Orpen

I am asking the Minister for Finance to make available facilities in order to see to what extent our grass can be improved. I think there can be a great improvement in it. I understand, the Minister for Agriculture contemplates making better use of grass. Can we do so until we find out exactly how to do it? That is my contention. I also urge the Minister for Agriculture, if he is permitted to carry out any of these experiments, that he should have special regard to the economic aspects. I do not like always to trust to visual measurements. You want something very much more convincing than merely to say that one thing is better than another. We must measure it. The consumer is always asking for cheap food, but it is being left to the farmer to try to find out how to make food cheap. I say that we should have, possibly in our agricultural colleges or on special farms, places where we could investigate impartially which measure was doing a certain job and producing results that were most economical. As I see it, the farmer's job is to produce food. How best to do so should be the function of specialist investigators.

The Estimates for the Department of Agriculture seem to show that the cost of administration rather overshadowed the cost of maintaining technicians. It is undesirable that we should go all out to administer something that technical people are not quite convinced is being done in the best way. I suggest that we want very much more research into agriculture and very much more accuurate technical knowledge. Agricultural problems to-day are totally different from what they were 20 years ago. The farmer can only learn in the costly manner of trial and error, and mostly by error. I suggest that there is a cheaper way of doing so. Set apart qualified people who will try to determine how best a thing can be done and leave out a lot of the guesswork.

Now that we have achieved a certain amount of agricultural security for the next four years is not this the time to devote attention towards solving some of our technical problems? Having done all that, there is the immense job of putting new ideas across to the farmer. We have an advisory system but, as worked to-day, unfortunately, it usually reaches the man who least requires advice, while the man who should ask for assistance seldom does so. I suggest that we should go several steps further. We know the Minister's ideas about the administration of farms, but we want to test out any new idea before we start to administer it. The testing out of a new idea might form part of the work of agricultural colleges. The testing out of some new method might take ten years, but it would add interest to the work of an agricultural college if the students there knew they were taking part in something that might ultimately prove of immense value to the nation.

Before we can test anything we want to find out what we are going to test. It is on experimental work which shows promise that we must make tests. Unfortunately, our experimental work is extremely limited. Senator O'Brien asked for more fundamental research. I say that we are too small a country to afford much fundamental research, but money spent on applied research in agriculture—and I do not speak for anything else—would be well spent and would earn good dividends. I suggest that we must face the fact that accurate knowledge of how best to do things on our farms is insufficient. If we are to achieve the hoped for substantial fourfold increase that some Senator expected—which I thought was a very optimistic figure— and got instead a 10 per cent. increase in the next ten or 25 years, that would be worth talking about. Production has steadily gone down or has remained static over a long period.

What I feel is hampering our agriculture is an insufficiency of accurate knowledge. We have generalised knowledge and a sort of generalised leaflet, that travels wherever the post goes. That is a very dangerous thing, because farmers are apt to think that what is said in a leaflet applies everywhere. What he should know is the facts concerning his own farm. That knowledge cannot be put into a leaflet because every farmer differs, the soil differs and environment conditions differ. Hence, we have not enough peripatetic advisers. I wonder if it is always noted that if you want to reach a farmer to-day on matters affecting agricultural work in rural Ireland there is very little use in writing articles in the newspapers. I have done that myself but no farmer reads the daily Press. He listens to the radio. I do not think we use the radio sufficiently. Admittedly, if you want to speak to farmers in the summer, you may have to use the radio rather late at night but still I feel that we are not making sufficient use of it.

May I give one illustration of something we can all see in our new research station and that the Minister referred to in his opening speech in the other House? Some 25 years ago in Australia, the farmers asked for a corn drill with which they could sow fertiliser along with the corn in order to save going over the land twice. The manufacturers complied and such an instrument was made. Quite accidentally, however, it was observed that when you put phosphatic fertilisers in with the seed there was an enormous saving in the quantity of fertiliser used. It took a world war and an acute shortage of phosphates for that accidental discovery in Australia to be availed of outside that country. In our research station you will observe the economy consequent on putting phosphates close to the seed and, no doubt, you will also notice that the people who sell phosphates still say "broadcast it and put in double the quantity." It reminds me of Mr. Colman who made his money out of the mustard left on the plate.

Senators know that potash is useful to the farmer and that it is becoming a very scarce commodity. An experiment was carried out with raspberries. Half a dozen closely related raspberries were in a row. A manurial experiment was carried out in the usual way. Some show a marked deficiency consequent on having no potash, while others in the same row seem unaffected, showing, as we think, that the demand for this particular fertiliser varies in one species. Suppose that happens in an important crop, which also demands potash, such as potatoes. Suppose we can breed a potato that demands less potash than the ordinary ones we use to-day.

This whole question of fertility is bound up with our ability to buy fertiliser. The quantity that we require to restore this country to anything like high productivity is so immense that it would take years to do it. Therefore, any discovery that reduces the amount necessary to get crops growing properly is something gained. It now appears possible that, with this combined drill, we can put in a little and put it in often, and can achieve crops to-day and need not wait until such time as we can bring up the nutritional status of the land to its proper content.

It may be said that I am outside the scope of the Appropriation Bill. I do not think so. I think it is a most important matter. If we can achieve increased production within our national resources and get our agricultural requirements, not in one great quantity, but a certain amount each year, we will have achieved something that ten years ago was not thought to be possible.

I am suggesting that we want more research, more experiments and tests. I am suggesting that State funds are essential for this purpose. There is no short road. Epoch making advances occur very seldom. Mendel's paper on plant breeding was buried for 50 years. We must face the fact that we are years behind the times. From an agricultural point of view, almost any western European country is ahead of us and yet we, as a nation, depend on agriculture. What has happened is that, mistakenly, far too much has been left to the farmer to do. His job is to produce the goods, not to find out how to do something new. That is up to others. It is interesting to make a calculation. The Estimate under Research is £10,000. This includes only the seed testing and Ballinacurry. A simple calculation will show that we are spending £10,000, which represents only .25d. per acre, in research. In veterinary research we spend a matter of £21,000, under 1d. per annum. That does not seem extravagant. Admittedly, certain research has been carried on under grants to various colleges and universities. These figures show that not enough attention is paid to research.

Regarding agricultural subsidies, I would suggest that they are really consumer subsidies. Surely an agricultural subsidy is money paid to the farmers for a commodity over and above that which they can obtain from elsewhere. I do not think there are any agricultural subsidies to-day, but rather consumers' subsidies. I think it was Senator Hawkins who said that the price of fertilisers had gone up in the last 12 months. He evidently does not buy much fertilisers, as the price has gone down—or else I have paid less for them.

In a time of difficulty like this, we have to take risks. Advances are made only by the adventurous. If we are to achieve a substantially augmented output, for which we all hope, we must increase our technical knowledge and then put it across to the farmer. He will do the rest if he is guided and helped in the right manner. I have not asked for a subsidy and I do not believe in trying to subsidise agriculture, but I believe in giving it all the technical advice that can be given. I add the rider that the technical advice must have been proved to be accurate under the conditions that obtain in this country.

Comment on this

For some months past an abnormal amount of discussion has taken place on the vexed question of Partition, and I certainly do not want to add just one more to the spate of speeches on the subject, except briefly to note one peculiar omission from the flood-tide of oratory which has been let loose on this and on other lands; that is, any direct appeal of a friendly character to the majority in Northern Ireland who stand for the maintenance of the Border.

It seems to me that in cave-men style, most of the speakers have proceeded to woo the Northern maiden with a cudgel. A song popular at the present time says: "Try a little tenderness," a form of advice that might not be out of place in the approach to this difficult problem. The problem is not made easier by a certain type of oratory with which, unfortunately, we are only too familiar, and which is calculated to embitter relationships and make unity impossible except on the basis of force. All the people of Northern Ireland are our people, regardless of their religious beliefs or political convictions. We want to win them, if we can, by persuasion rather than take them by force or coercive methods of any kind, whether by Britain or elsewhere. Hence, I feel that we should address ourselves more to them and less to the world at large, a world which has troubles enough of its own without being burdened by ours, too.

We should, I suggest, try and forget as much history in this respect as possible, and induce them to do likewise, concentrating on the fact that there is here a problem for statesmanship which can only be satisfactorily or permanently solved on the basis of mutual agreement and in an atmosphere of goodwill. I know there is a temptation to go into the circumstances in which the border came about and the abuses which have developed as a result of its creation, but merely telling this story a thousand times over until our audiences have become sick and tired of hearing it, does not seem to be getting us very far. However it came, the border is there.

Let us not misdirect ourselves into the belief that we are the only people with a problem of this kind. Minority problems have been and are the bane of many countries. Quite recently the United States, acting in close association with Russia, played a predominant part in enforcing partition on Palestine, a little country about the size of Wales. Every Indian patriot must have regretted the partition of that country. In each case expediency and not principle was pleaded in justification. Even the example of the evils of Partition in Ireland was not sufficient to prevent either Palestine or India from being divided up. It must be obvious to any student of history that the hoped-for unity of both Palestine and India will ultimately come by agreement from within rather than by political, economic or other pressure from without. So-called unity brought about by force is not unity but conquest of one side by the other, and the wounds it inflicts take generations to heal. The fact that we have an unanswerable case should not cause us to lose our tempers or our patience just because its strength is not admitted by the other side to the controversy. They may believe as firmly in their case as we in ours, and men do not necessarily fight for a good cause but rather because they think it is good.

The recital of fundamental principles is a pleasing form of oratory, but we know that, in practice, fundamental principles do not always prevail, even in the best regulated societies. The American Declaration of Independence says that "All men are born free and equal and entitled to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." Ask the coloured folk of the Southern States how this high-sounding declaration of fundamental principle operates in practice. The Indian people demand freedom for India, but have not yet conceded it in practice to the 80,000,000 Untouchables. We had President Wilson's 14 points and in later years the Atlantic Charter, but everywhere men have interpreted these documents to suit themselves. To-day, the world has probably more problems unsolved than ever before in history.

Now, have we done all we might have done by way of direct approach to the leaders of the majority in the Six Counties? I would like to think that we have; and if we have I think that the appropriate Minister at least should say so, because I think it would strengthen our case. If we have not there are many matters of mutual interest that might usefully be the subject of conference and discussion between Ministers on both sides of the border, such as hydro-electric development, transport, and so on. I feel that we might even go so far as to give tariff preference to manufacturers in the North able to give us goods that we require. You would create there a number of vested interests for unity and eventually when unity does come their goods will be placed on the market here without tariffs. The more contacts we have and the more matters on which we can get agreement the more closely we draw together and the more favourable will become the atmosphere for discussing partition itself between the two parties most vitally concerned. In view of the very considerable exchange of goods between North and South it seems strange that there should be no trade or consular representative from Eire in Belfast or from Northern Ireland in Dublin.

We certainly have representatives in countries where our interests are not 1 per cent. of what they are in Northern Ireland. I know it will be said that this argument would mean giving recognition to Northern Ireland as a separate State, but surely that is rather a childish type of argument and one in keeping with the idea that by calling it "the Six Counties" we are serving the cause of unity. The sad fact remains that the Border is there and it does not matter a traneen what we call the territory north of the Border. Generally speaking, I believe the cause of unity would be enormously served if we talked less about it and worked more for it in a practical way. Many of those doing the speech-making on the subject constitute one of the biggest obstacles to the elimination of the Border. Their threats and their truculence merely stiffen the opposition to unity and give arguments of a valuable nature to its opponents. It is only the utterly defeated in war or poltroons in peace who submit to threats.

Neither of these considerations applies in the case of the Border. There have entered into the campaign on the side of unity many whose sincerity is deeply suspect, the type that always tries to fish in troubled waters wherever they may be found. Whatever their motives, they have left the position worse than they found it. I wonder how much is gained by emissaries, whether self-appointed or otherwise, going abroad to other countries to speak to the people there on this subject. How many countries give "two hoots" about it in the present state of the world? Judging by reports in certain newspapers, we were given to understand that Mr. de Valera swept the United States from coast to coast. Yet at the Democratic convention in Philadelphia a few days ago a very modest declaration on the problem, a very mild plank in the democratic programme, was turned down by an overwhelming majority. At the same time the Jews were able to snaffle both the Republican and Democratic conventions for their cause.

How much do we advance or retard the ideal of unity by indulging in statements such as made by Mr. de Valera when Taoiseach, speaking in Limerick on March 5th, 1944, when he declared: "We will have to get rid of the English language", regardless of the fact that by so doing he would deprive the majority of his own Party of any medium of expression? The present Ministers are certainly making a more realistic approach to the problem and they should be left to carry on the work without interference from self-constituted leaders, no matter how important these may consider themselves. It is a difficult and dangerous task and at any time might engender conflict if persons without authority persisted in seeking to do what Ministers alone should be entrusted with. There is one direction in which the present Government seems to be following the lead of their predecessors and in connection with which it is difficult to be happy. It is the declaration to the effect that we must concentrate almost entirely on rights with little regard for international responsibilities until such time as this, the last of our international grievances, is adjusted to our satisfaction.

That sounds a bit petulant and undignified. If each nation refused to accept any international responsibilities until the last of its grievances, vis-a-vis other nations, or the last dispute it had with any other nations, was settled we would have little or no inter-state or international relationships at all. The whole thing sounds like a specious excuse for running away from responsibility whilst claiming all our rights. I do not think we are advancing our cause by that line of action. I take it we all desire to bring unity about in a manner that will leave no aftermath of bitterness calculated to poison the wells of political thought and opinion for a generation or more. That being so, I would suggest that our Government look more North and less East or West for the ultimate solution. It may take a long time, longer than we like to wait, and it may require statesmanlike patience in order to achieve success, but if and when success comes it will be much more satisfying and more lasting than anything achieved by coercion. The present position brought about by force has failed, and any attempt to remedy it by force is equally doomed to failure.

Comment on this

Reference was made to-day to unemployment and I think some answer should be made to the criticism in that respect. I believe the system of registration has changed somewhat during the last 12 months. I understand that the valuation rate was increased by about 100 per cent., with the result that the number of people who can register for unemployment assistance is very much greater. I think the Minister might be in a position to give us some accurate figures in regard to the number of employable people who are unemployed. I was a member of a court of referees for many years, and most of the people who came before us hardly ever got a job. It is unfortunate that in every country you will have a certain number of people who are unemployable either because they are invalids or for some other reason. At any rate they cannot be made useful citizens. There is another aspect of this matter. Girls leaving their employment to be married are entitled to register and are classified as unemployed.

I think the country would be well served if we could get the total number of the really employable people registered in the exchanges, and also if we could have the number of people who hold property and who are entitled to claim unemployment assistance set out separately. We would then have truer picture of the problem we have to deal with, because unemployment is an evil in any civilised society. We must have some in a free society, but we ought to try to keep the evil as small as possible. The Opposition people and others are inclined from time to time to make capital out of these figures, no matter what Government is in, and for that reason if the method of compiling the figures could be made more realistic, it would be for the benefit of everybody and help us to grapple with the problem.

Senator Duffy referred to transport. That is an important matter from the point of view of agriculture, because if we have not got a cheap and efficient system of transport for the carriage of manures and the many other products of the land, such as cattle, wheat, beet and so on, we are not going to progress, either agriculturally or industrially. The present stock market value of every £100 invested in the railways, when they were established, is only £3 6s. 8d. I know many people who, having put £100 into the railways, now have £3 6s. 8d. worth of value. Most of them are not sorry they lost it, because they feel that they invested in what at the time was a great Irish industry, an industry which everybody said would make this country a great country. Railway building was of as much importance in its day as electrical development is in this day, and everyone who invested in the railways felt they were doing something patriotic.

Many people in the past said—and I commend this to Senator Duffy and his friends—that the people who had their capital in the railways were getting too much out of it. That capital is now gone. I lost something in it and I say, thank God it has gone, because the bogey about capital has now gone for all time. The main people with an interest in the railways now are the labour people who will have to set themselves to making a good job of it, to some extent, for themselves. We know that there are many other problems and it is for all of us to get together and solve this particular problem in a realistic spirit.

Any amount of schemes have been suggested for the farmers, but the scheme the farmer wants more than anything else is a scheme under which he will be allowed to get on with his business without too much interference from anybody. With regard to education generally, I believe the Minister for Education should bend his efforts towards educating farmers' sons and daughters into a liking for their own avocation rather than to give them an industrial or commercial bias in their education. It would be a good thing for the country, if that were done. It is a better avocation than any other, but many of the teachers and people connected with the vocational schools have suggested that other occupations are nobler and more to be sought after than that of having to work late hours, six or seven days a week, in wet and fine weather. Without the people who are prepared to be self-sacrificing enough to do that sort of work, and who believe that, in doing it, they are doing more for the nation than they would be doing in other avocations, I do not think we will have a return to the land. We may not be called on in this generation to be soldiers, but the people with an agricultural education, the people who are prepared to milk the cows on seven days a week, are the real heroes and we ought to pay them a tribute as such.

There has also been reference to valuations and I have often wondered if Government Departments are not to some extent trying to force a revaluation on the country, because it seems to me, in urban areas at any rate, that when places are revalued the valuations bear no relation whatever to the valuations of other hereditaments which seem to have exactly the same type of accommodation. It appears that so many anomalies are created that at some time a revaluation of the whole country will be forced upon us. I do not know whether that is good, because if one valuation in a town bore a proper relation to another valuation, and if the rates went up very high, it would be the same for everybody, but at the moment some instruction appears to be sent from the Valuation Office that valuations may be fixed without any relation whatever to the valuations of other hereditaments, which creates in the minds of some people a feeling of inequitable treatment. People expect from Governments just and fair treatment, so that if the Minister has any powers in this respect, I ask him to instruct the Valuation Office to see to it that one valuation bears a true relation to others in similar areas. If the Minister can meet the points I have put up, it will be to the advantage of most of the people in the State.

Comment on this

When we discussed the Finance Bill some weeks ago, I took the opportunity to point out the seriousness of several economies that were being proposed by the Government which I thought were very dangerous in view of the present situation. I referred particularly to the Army Estimates and the reduction carried out in them. The past few weeks have shown what a mistake it was to cut down the Army Estimates, in view of the present situation and the darkening clouds over Europe. In this connection, I was surprised and pained to read that the Taoiseach, in the Dáil the other day, said that all the Government's plans were based on a continuation of peace. That was very startling in view of the fact that every Government in Europe to-day is basing its plans on the inevitability of war. If we are right, they must all be wrong, but the startling thing is that, supposing they are all right and we are wrong, the time is rapidly passing. If the Government are basing their plans on the continuance of peace, at a time when the Minister for Defence should be preparing the Army and preparing a scheme of defence, at a time when the Minister for Industry and Commerce should be laying in stocks of raw materials and at a time when the Minister for Agriculture should be endeavouring to lay in stocks of food, I say that it is a very dangerous situation for the country.

Several speakers have referred to the necessity for additional subsidies and improvement in agriculture. There is one branch of agriculture which is indeed in need of very serious attention as the House will readily acknowledge, that is, dairying. It is the branch of agriculture on which our whole prosperity depends more than any other, and it is the branch which seems most likely to be almost totally eliminated within a short time. Unlike tillage and other branches of agriculture, there are in respect of the dairying industry influences at work which will be very difficult to overcome, and which, if not overcome, must eventually result in the almost total elimination of the industry.

It is too late now to go into the matter fully, but the Government would be very well advised to look seriously into the position of that industry. The previous Government did a great deal for it, but the situation has rapidly grown worse. It is a matter chiefly of labour, the difficulty of getting people to milk cows—much the same difficulty as was experienced in the coalmines of England. It is hard and badly-paid work and, naturally, people wish to get away from it.

Nevertheless, the situation is that the dairying industry is dying out year by year. It is decaying rapidly. Drastic steps will have to be taken to arrest its decay. However much we may declare against subsidies, everyone I think must admit that Irish agriculture is suffering from a deficiency of capital. How could anybody expect a businessman to carry on if he had not sufficient capital? It is foolish to think that agriculture can ever be in a prosperous state until capital is made available for it. If the dairying industry is to be revised steps will have to be taken to make capital available for it. Otherwise there can be no progress. The price which the dairy farmer gets for his produce is not at all comparable to that which people in other branches of agriculture get for their commodities. There is also the question, so far as dairying is concerned, that labour can never be enticed back to this work. It will have to be replaced by machinery. The Government should see that the provision of milking machines is subsidised. Help should also be given for their installation and management. Unless something is done along these lines the dairying industry cannot carry on.

For example, in the creameries we have every kind of machinery. Men have been highly trained to operate these machines. If dairying is to be restored advances of money will have to be made available to enable people to buy dairy cattle. It is the shortage of capital that is responsible for the fact that we have thousands of small farms on which there is family labour but no milch cows. The owners of farms have not the money to buy the cows. An advance of money to those people would enable them to get into production. There may not be the same difficulty in the case of the larger farms. The only solution for the labour problem on farms is the provision of machinery, which will have to be heavily subsidised. Machines purchased by some of the creameries in my area about two years ago have proved highly satisfactory. I hope that the Minister will look into these matters before the end of the year, so that the necessary steps may be taken to put the dairying industry on a sound footing.

Comment on this

I would be strongly opposed to saying a word of encouragement on behalf of many of the schemes that have been advocated by Senators, except perhaps the one that was put forward by Senator O'Callaghan. I endorse what he said. It is not the first time in the last ten or 15 years that both of us, sitting on opposite sides of the House, have made our contribution to debates here. It is strange that, even though we differ politically, we should advocate the same thing, or, as they say in the army: "Stand back as you were before you enlisted". I am afraid that in the last ten or 15 years we have not made that progress that either Senator O'Callaghan or myself would desire. I find here a sum of £370,000 to be devoted to university education, and £52,000 for the Academy of Higher Studies. There was more money to be spent on a shortwave station and on Constellations. With all these big sums of money before me, I think of the parish area in which I have lived all my life. We have there about 105 houses, and despite the Constellations and all the rest, in only seven of them is there any sanitary accommodation. A new university is to be erected, so that if some of the inhabitants in the homes of my parish area come to the university they will find there every amenity that modern science can provide.

Comment on this

What new university is the Senator referring to?

Comment on this

There is to be an additional building to the new university. Did the Senator not see what Professor Tierney advocated last week, and the necessity there was for it?

Comment on this

That is a very different thing from what the Senator said—a new university.

Comment on this

There is to be an addition to the university building.

Comment on this

I am glad to have that clarification from the Senator.

Comment on this

I do not think the country ever sanctioned expenditure for an Academy of Higher Studies. I never heard a case made for it on any political platform, or that the expenditure incurred in connection with the various schemes for education, or the universities, ever received popular favour in any quarter in rural Ireland. I think that all this calls for serious consideration on the part of the Government, and that if the taxpayers in the rural areas are to maintain their position there must be, to my mind, a reduction on this class of expenditure.

There is a bit of a racket going on in the country at the moment. Attempts are being made to see that labour on the land is to be paid at the same rate as labour in industrial concerns. If labour is to be held on the land, then we must see to it that there is a levelling up all round. Those of us who derive our means of livelihood from the land are not in a position to provide theatres and picture houses for those who work on the land. These amenities are available for industrial workers. As I say, there should be a levelling up in respect of income-tax, because it is out of their profits that the employers in the cities and the towns have been able to provide these things for their workers. I think the time has come when we should go slow. We have many types of schools in the country and millions of pounds are being spent on education. You have competition among students to get into the universities and to remain in them in after life as professors. I think the Government should examine these things very keenly. Attempts to improve the condition of the rural community have been very few. It must be remembered that in the Act of 1903 it was held out to the farmers that in the year 1959 all rents would cease. I wonder what is the position now. I do not say that this Government can do it at once, but it would be an ideal solution. Not a great deal has been done to keep our rates in keeping with the rates across the water or across the Border. These are matters that weigh against us.

It has been stated in the other House with a great deal of truth that for the past two years the sum of £2,000,000 was deducted from the barley growers and presented to Messrs. Guinness and their shareholders by way of the fixed price. I wonder if it would be possible for the present Government this year— I know they are doing it next year—to give us something like the market value and something that the brewers would give for barley. It would be a very great advantage. There is the necessity to produce cheap food, but there are certain products that are really luxury products. A good price for barley will not increase the cost of living.

Comment on this

Will it not increase the cost of beer, which was a luxury a few weeks ago?

Comment on this

No. I have a very definite answer to that. It will not. Ten shillings per barrel would make a great difference to the barley-producing communities and it has been withheld, and it was not denied in the other House that it was withheld. It was stated by Deputy Sweetman that £2,500,000 has been deducted over the past five or six years from the fixed price. If I am not mistaken, the Minister for Agriculture stated that he would be very pleased to get 700,000 barrels at 55/- a barrel. If the present Government could do something along those lines, it would be a great help.

In a debate not so long ago the question of racing was raised and the question of an extra tax on betting. I question the wisdom of that. The price of beef, mutton, pork and other products affects the consumer. That does not apply to racing. A properly-run stud farm is a great employer in the rural community. The money that is devoted to the development of racing helps the rural community. It may be said that that might lead to too much gambling, but people do things that might be worse, having regard to the amount of money involved and the amount of employment created. It has been suggested that the Government should see to it that the National Army should get more to do in association with racing and perhaps control it altogether. Of course, that is a matter that needs some little consideration, but it is a matter that might be explored with possible advantage to the community.

In connection with the agricultural community in general, I would impress upon the Minister the desirability of increasing the agricultural grant. At one time derating was advocated from various political platforms, but when the people got into office nothing further was done about it. The idea has been created amongst the people that the Government is a Dublin-run concern, the same as the last Government, and that the last Government was the same as the first, and so on. There is evidence of enthusiasm in regard to this matter now, and if we can get Deputy Dillon going on it he may do something to see to it that the old farmers and labourers on the land will be the aristocrats of this country, as they would be entitled to be by tradition, their names being on the tombstones for 600 or 700 years. They are satisfied to live without limousines and detached villas. In many cases they are living in the same house where their ancestors were born. The people in rural Ireland can be made happy and contented if some consideration is given to their position.

I should take this opportunity of expressing the gratitude of my county council to the present Minister for Local Government for the assistance he gave us the other day. We will owe a greater debt of gratitude when we get the Shannon scheme that has been so long delayed. I would impress upon the Minister that every penny of relief in the rates on land, in a community where the population is stationary, will be money well spent.

Comment on this

It is inevitable that the debate on the Appropriation Bill is of a somewhat unsatisfactory character, particularly in the Seanad, where we have only one Minister who can, if he likes, deal with the other Departments, but probably will not be prepared to accept responsibility for the administration of the various Departments. For that reason I had almost decided not to take any part in the debate but there were one or two remarks made which I do not think I ought to let pass. I think Senator O'Dwyer is completely wrong if he thinks the nations of Western Europe are basing their present economy on war. There is intense fear that there may be war. From anything I can read and the contacts I have had, and I have been on the Continent this year and have met quite a number of people in responsible positions, the conviction is that no country in Europe, small or large, is in a position in which it could base its economy on war and that if there is to be a war, it can only be done by united action and by united preparation. It is easy to talk about Joseph and the time of Pharaoh, and it is easy to talk about preparing for a war which may or may not come, but is there any Senator or Minister that has the remotest idea of how that war might come or what our position might be in it? Is there any Minister or any person in public life who knows, if there is war to-morrow— and the only thing people are afraid of is a war between Western Europe and the East—how it will affect us? Can you even make a guess? Can you say you could, or ought to be, or should be, or would be neutral?

If we are going at this particular stage to adopt what, not only Senator O'Dwyer, but certain other Senators on the opposite side have in various hints indicated they think should be the policy, to proceed on the basis that there is certain to be a war within the next few months, what it simply means is, we are going to destroy the possibility of the rehabilitation of this country by adopting a war basis. I think that kind of panic would be fatal and I do not believe that if Fianna Fáil were in power to-day they would adopt it. I may be wrong in that but I do not believe they would. A responsible Government, while keeping its eye open and saying very little of what it may see in the way of danger, must endeavour to see that in the meantime the ordinary people can carry on on as decent a standard of living as they can, that business will be maintained, particularly, that agriculture will be developed to the greatest extent and as quickly as we can—and everybody knows it cannot be done very speedily. That is the commonsense preparation because it is a preparation to enable people to live. They will live better with such a preparation, if there is peace, and if there is war they will not be very much worse off for the fact that that was the policy.

If, on the other hand, you adopt a war mentality, go on spending, spending with little regard to what effect it will have on inflation or the cost of living or anything else, then we are making calamity certain. I am extremely glad that there has been no indication, at any rate, so far, that that is going to be the policy of the Government.

I do not want to make little of the danger of war, but I do not believe that it should be regarded as in any sense inevitable, but, if there is a danger, that danger to a large extent is due to disunity, difficulty of co-operation and uncertainty. Thanks to some extent to what is commonly called the Marshall Plan, thanks to the fact that there is now a fair amount of co-operation between the 16 nations, there are very good grounds for hope that the war which I do not believe anyone on either side of the iron curtain wants, can be averted. Certainly I think it would be lunacy for us to start now basing our economy on the assumption that there is going to be a war in the next month or two.

Senator Summerfield was very much concerned about the shortwave station and he assured us that if we read the debates—I take it he means in the Dáil and in this House—we will see the case that was made, I think he was in America when we had the debate here and I hope he will read the debate and see whether he agrees with the case that was made. I have a strong suspicion that he will not be impressed. Of course, you can make a case for a shortwave station. The question is, can you make a case for spending money on a shortwave station when you have decided that in the national interest there should be a policy of economy?

Senator Hawkins started the debate. The Minister paid us the compliment of making a short speech, on the assumption, I presume, that if we had not read the Estimates and had not paid attention to the discussion on the Departments, there was nothing he could do in half an hour to enlighten us. I thought he was extremely wise, on this Bill, to make a short speech, and I took it as a compliment to the House. Senator Hawkins went simply on the spendthrift line. If it was the speech of a private person, it would be the speech of a millionaire—we should go on spending on all the things we liked to do.

It is easier in private life, and certainly easier in business, to spend, but if we spend and cannot get the money we go bankrupt. That does not operate with the State. Times do come when judicious spending is wise. There are also times, during a period of rise in prices and a certain amount of inflation—and particularly if there is an excess profits tax, which is calculated to tempt people to spend, so that they will not have to pay taxes— when there will be a good deal of spending which will be unnecessary. At some point you have to stop and then you have the extremely unpleasant task of deciding what is essential and what has to be cut, and it is inevitable that there will be differences of opinion.

I have been present during the majority of debates in the last ten years on the Appropriation Bill and the Finance Bill. Both sides of the House, but mostly the Opposition, have asked for retrenchment, but we never had a hope under the old Government that it would happen. We have now a new Government that has to face an enormous bill, and we are assured that they are making an effort to get reductions in expenditure and taxation. We should give them our most sympathetic support, not only by making speeches but by trying to influence people in business or with whom we are associated, to curb unnecessary expenditure for the next year or two. It seems to me a policy the Government has a right to demand and one which we should be ready to carry out.

Senator Hawkins mentioned a case where a certain type of boots had been increased by 8/1 and a certain type of material by 5/- per yard. He did not give us an idea of the particular type in either case. If he tells me that someone was charging 5/- a yard more for material I will take his word for it, but if he brought that forward with a view to indicating that Irish manufacturers are unnecessarily increasing prices, I say that is an insult to them and that it is not a fact.

Comment on this

I did not make such a statement.

Comment on this

The impression that would be given by such a statement, if it got a lot of publicity, would be to make people assume that materials running from 5/- to 15/- have been increased by 5/-. I know something about the textile industry and say that any such increase is not justified, nor do I believe it has taken place—except perhaps in an isolated case, which may be explained and is not typical. I do not doubt the Senator's word, but if he suggests that textiles generally have risen it is not true. I am not suggesting that if they had risen the Government would have had anything to do with it, and I am not claiming anything in their favour for its not being a fact. There has been, and there is at present, a tendency to decrease in most clothing prices and I would not like to go from this House with an idea to the contrary. There may be some luxury materials worth £5 a yard, where there has been a 5/-increase, which would not be material. In cotton, woollens and probably rayons, the prices in Britain have increased. We are able to import considerably more and the British price in most cases is considerably cheaper than that at which they can be bought elsewhere. The net result is that, even in import goods, the price is lower. It is better in the case of Irish manufacturers. In many cases there has been increased production, and unless there is a slump in decreased production prices will have a tendency downwards. On the other hand, if a serious slump were created artificially or through political action, you would not necessarily get prices down—except through some firm nearly bankrupt having to clear out—as the cost per article would be higher. I am convinced that prices have dropped and will drop still further. I am not sure, but I hope it will be a gradual drop, as that would cause less dislocation and better chances of a healthy position than otherwise.

Senators Concannon and Burke referred to valuations. Whatever the relationship of the Valuation Office to the Department of Finance, I am satisfied that the officials have a very high standard. They are, generally speaking, men of a conscientious type who will endeavour to carry out with absolute fairness, as between one person and another, the general instructions they are given and the policy that is being adopted in the particular year. The fact remains, however, that there are few subjects on which there is more dissatisfaction and —more or less inevitably, because of our present system—few things where there is such inequity. I know of a case where oldish premises were condemned by a local body. The firm found it difficult to get money to rebuild and when they managed to borrow the money they found the valuation doubled because they had rebuilt the same premises a little smaller than before. The answer was that the old valuation was very low and there had to be a revaluation on a somewhat higher basis. The fact is that that firm feels it has a grievance. The same applies to individuals where a certain amount of alteration involves a revaluation. I still think it is done fairly, as between any two people in similar circumstances at the same time, and I do not believe there is any ground for the belief that there is not a very high standard. However, it works out that you have people paying on similar premises double the rates, and that causes intense feelings of injustice. If you introduce a general revaluation Bill, there will be a yell and a howl from almost every quarter. We will all be scared. I will be scared myself as to the effect on me, though I am not at all certain that we have not reached the stage at which, if we could get a general agreement, it would not be the commonsense and proper thing to do.

Senator Burke wanted different instructions to be given by the Minister. That would not help. If the instructions were to value on a lower basis, it would suit me very well if I happened to get the valuation; but if I had been valued last year and found it was coming now, I would have a grievance. Nothing but some general form of revaluation would do. I find resentment coming from all quarters—Dublin and elsewhere—and some of the increases have been very serious. The case given by Senator Mrs. Concannon is one with which we all have sympathy. It might be an isolated case, but I do not think it is. I do not know how the Minister can deal with it, but it was a matter that should be raised.

I have a great deal of sympathy with the point of view taken by Senator O'Farrell. I have advocated a policy with regard to Partition on somewhat similar lines, and perhaps in a little more detail. I am not sure if he was quite consistent when he said he raised it on the Vote for the Department of External Affairs, but that is only a minor detail. There has been a great deal of talk and there have been campaigns of very doubtful value, in my honest opinion. Those of us keenly interested in this subject would probably be very well advised to say very little about it—at any rate for six or nine months. We have a new Government and we know their view. There is no fundamental difference between any of the Parties as to what we would like to achieve. Instead of agreeing with Senator O'Farrell in that he hoped the Minister would say something more to make the position clear, my advice, if I had any influence, would be to say extremely little. Make your attitude perfectly clear and do not say much about your policy, as too much talk could easily do harm. While I am in agreement with Senator O'Farrell and think that, sooner or later, it is the line we have to adopt, I do not think a new Government, in the interests of unity, should be pressed, nor would it be advisable for it to make any hints as to the line of policy, for six, nine or 12 months.

For the first time for a long time, I feel we have turned the tables and that a genuine effort is going to be made to reduce expenditure on things which, however desirable, are not essentials, so that there may be a better chance of spending more on what everyone admits to be essentials. We must accept the position that we will have to do without some things for a few years in order to get our economy on a proper basis and, therefore, I believe that the efforts of the Minister should get every support.

Comment on this

I wish Senator Douglas would make it clear that when referring to Senator O'Farrell he was not referring to me, as I do not share my namesake's ideas regarding the Border and I do not approve of the rattling of the Orange drum here in this House.

Comment on this

I protest against such a remark and ask that it be withdrawn. I consider that the remarks of Senator O'Farrell are offensive and are not usually used in this House and should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I did not catch clearly what Senator O'Farrell said.

Comment on this

It is clear to everyone in the House. He protested against the rattling of the Orange drums, suggesting that Senator J.T. O'Farrell did that. I protest against that view.

Comment on this

That is the interpretation his speech conveyed to me. It is not the first time he rattled the Orange drum, and I understand——

Comment on this

Is this going to be permitted or not? You are in the Chair, and I protest against this.

Comment on this

Senator Duffy is not in the Chair, so he cannot give a ruling.

Comment on this

I protest again against this thing. It is an insult to this House and it should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Will not the Senator's protest go on the record?

Comment on this

If you rule that way, there is not much use in my carrying on. If that is your ruling, I will have to obey it, but it is not the practice of this House.

Comment on this

I do not see why Senator Duffy should attempt——

Comment on this

Where is this going to end? I want you to rule on something, Sir.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We will hear Senator O'Farrell.

Comment on this

On what?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

On what I think is the point of order upon which I am asked to rule.

Comment on this

I protest against that. You have nothing to hear. You are called upon to rule.

Comment on this
A Senator

Order.

Comment on this

There will be no order unless there is some ruling by the Chair. I protest against this misuse of the House.

Comment on this

I regret if my reference to Senator O'Farrell could have been taken to mean Senator Séamus O'Farrell. I will try to use Senator J.T. O'Farrell's name in full in future. I was referring to the speech made by referring to the speech made by Senator J.T. O'Farrell.

Comment on this

That satisfies me, so long as it is put on record but I have been accused before of making statements which my namesake had made, and the views in which I did not share. One was made in Cork recently.

Comment on this

Might I ask again if you, Sir, are going to rule whether offensive remarks made about members of the House in a most irresponsible manner are to be permitted without protest from the Chair?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Offensive remarks are not permitted in the House.

Comment on this

Are they withdrawn then?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The question is whether the remark made by Senator O'Farrell is to be construed as an offensive remark.

Comment on this

I am suggesting to you that it is most offensive to Senator J.T. O'Farrell to say that he was beating the Orange drum here. That is most offensive, and, on his behalf, I am protesting. If you are willing to let that kind of thing go I am helpless, and so is the House.

Comment on this

I suggest that Senator Lynch be asked to continue his speech.

Comment on this

The Chair has got to rule and say "yes" or "no." This "codology" cannot go on. The Chair must say whether it is permitting these remarks or whether they must be withdrawn. They will not go by default so far as I am concerned.

Comment on this

Is the Senator intimidating the Chair?

Comment on this

I am asking for a ruling and surely that is not too much to ask from the Chair.

Comment on this

You are demanding it.

Comment on this

I am, and I am entitled to demand it; that is what the Chair is for.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator's protest will go on the record. Beyond that, I cannot go.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the attitude of some of the Senators here and especially the Labour Senators who have supported the Government and have tried to justify the savings proposed. There was reference here to the saving of £85,000 in respect of mineral development. I come from the vicinity of the coalmining district of Arigna where coal has been mined for the past 100 years and in my time I have seen that industry having many a struggle for its existence. In 1918-1920 a light railway was built through the Arigna valley for the transport of coal and in 1924, during the time of Cumann na nGaedheal, I saw that light railway lifted and coal mining fall to practically nil. In fact, the output of the coalmines in the years 1925, 1926 and 1927 was around 20 tons per week.

In 1934, when the beet factories were established and a market provided for the slack, it was the first ray of hope for the Arigna coalmining industry. We then had the sugar company going to Arigna and arranging for 100 per cent. of the slack to be sent to the beet factories and we saw employment in the mines increased and conditions and wages improved. The employment went up from 25 or 30 men, who were employed for two days a week prior to 1934, to 200 men in the years 1934-1940, as a result of the policy of the then Government and a market found for the slack by the establishment of the beet industry by the then Minister for Industry and Commerce. In 1940, when coal could not be imported, employment increased from 200 to 600, and, for the first time, Irish railways used Irish coal. The Irish railways ran skeleton services from 1940 to the beginning of the present year on Irish coal when coal was imported into this country.

A deputation from the area met Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass, and the former Minister for Industry and Commerce told the members of the deputation that the same protected market as they had from 1934 to 1940 would be provided for them and that Irish industries would be made to use all the marketable coal that would be produced and that these 600 workers would thus find good employment. To-day, however, the Irish railways are not taking one lb. of Irish coal. Irish coal is used in only one instance at present and the quota within the last month has been cut by 100 tons a month. I claim that if this sum of £85,000 were spent on the development of the Arigna coalfields, we could employ 1,000 men at good wages. We have for the past several months been applying to the Department for the paltry sum of £6,000 to help a coalmine which spent £20,000 in bringing in electric current and providing electric coal cutters.

Comment on this

The £85,000 was not for the development of a coalmine, but for exploration looking for new minerals.

Comment on this

It was to facilitate the existing coalmines in further development.

Comment on this

You could not get a shilling for that out of the £85,000.

Comment on this

We could get grants for improving the roads from the Department of Industry and Commerce, and we got them before.

Comment on this

Where are they in the Estimates?

Comment on this

They are not in the Estimates. Is that not the important thing?

Comment on this

It is very hard to understand Labour's attitude. They are now supporting a Government which is throwing trade unionists out of employment and forcing them to seek employment in Britain, where they can hew coal to be imported into this country by the inter-Party Government. The Labour Party stands for that and the cause of Labour has been lost because of the giving of offices to the Labour Party.

Comment on this

The Senator had not got one word to say for the past seven years when they were going away in thousands. They were leaving at the rate of 50,000 a year and he had not got a word to say. He was dumb like the rest of them.

Comment on this

We had plenty of employment and development.

Comment on this

Where—in England?

Comment on this

I hope that the protected market that the Arigna coalfields have with the sugar company and the railway company will be maintained. In that mountainy area hundreds of men were thrown out of employment by the abandonment of hand-won turf production. The first happiness I ever saw these people enjoying, the first comfort that ever came into their homes, was wiped out by one scrape of the pen and then it was suggested that it was the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce who abandoned hand-won turf production. The sooner the Labour people forget the leaders who forgot the cause of Labour and sold the pass on them, the better.

I have been a member of a local body for the past 20 years, and I have the greatest respect for any man who will do anything to eradicate the tragic disease of tuberculosis which has wrought so much havoc amongst our people. An auxiliary mental hospital was built in our time at a cost of £150,000 and we built a county hospital at £107,000 which is second to none in Ireland. We installed a staff and a surgeon there who have done more to save life than any other institution.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

If I am out of order, there are many others who have been out of order.

Comment on this

I want to say that I have not got the faintest idea of what the Senator is saying. He has not referred to any county or to the part of Ireland he belongs to. He has referred to a hospital I never heard of, because he has not said where it is, and I fail to follow the debate.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The Minister for Health went down there and opened it——

Comment on this

Castlerea, County Roscommon. He opened this temporary sanatorium and there had to be cutting of tapes and the blowing of whistles. Having been entertained at the expense of the ratepayers of County Roscommon, he went to Galway, and later we find this heading in an English paper: "The Same Beds and the Same Soup as in 1847." That is what he says about our county homes.

Comment on this

The soup must be stale after 101 years.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt you.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to interruptions.

Comment on this

I believe that if that is read in countries abroad, it will give the impression that we are nothing but unchristian savages.

Comment on this

Would the Senator answer one question: Is that an Irish or an English edition?

Comment on this

It does not matter.

Comment on this

It is the Catholic Herald.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Deputy Lynch will proceed to address the Chair and not pay attention to interruptions.

Comment on this

I regard that as an indirect attack on the religious Orders who run 90 per cent. of our county homes and I am convinced that it is an effort to sow the seed about which we were warned day after day which will seek to destroy our christianity.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Senator would not read a copy of that paper for 1924 or 1925 and see what it said about himself.

Comment on this

With regard to the Department of Agriculture, I have had some experience of the Minister in charge of that Department. I was on local bodies with him for a few years and from what I know of him I believe that the Department will not be long a Government Department, but a Department run by Jimmy Dillon.

From what I know of the Department to-day it will be run for the benefit of the rancher. We had experience of that here to-night. Those are the people who will dictate policy to the present Minister for Agriculture and not the Ministers of the Government. As Senator O'Callaghan said, there have been many wrongs inflicted on agriculture in the past 200 years, but the greatest wrong ever inflicted on it was when the present Minister was installed as Minister for Agriculture, the man who believed that the manhood of Ireland should have been on the battlefields of France and on the battlefields of Russia during the critical days instead of producing food for our people at home.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It would be better if the Senator confined himself to the business before the House.

Comment on this

I am finished now, a Leas-Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this

A good deal has been said already this evening about higher education. One Senator said he would prefer to have the money spent providing bath tubs in country clubs. I believe in spending the money on both if there was an equal demand for both, but I would emphasise one thing, and that is that higher education does not stand or fall on material results. I want to emphasise that and I want to refer to another aspect of education especially which has been ignored up to the present and which has been an undoubted asset that has been paying dividends to us for 2,000 years. I am referring to literary education, education for clear thinking and human living. We live in an age of propaganda and unless we are educated in a literary way to deal with propaganda we will go down as a national entity. Political propaganda, commercial propaganda and ideological propaganda is aimed at us from all sides, and the only way we can counter it is by good literary education. Our life to-day is full of examples of the dangers of half-education. Take one example: a great many people of this country know of the word "Milton" and "Wolsey," but they do not know that the man in the first case was a great poet, and in the second case a great cardinal, who, perhaps, made a mistake, as some of us think. That is the result of commercial propaganda. I could give examples of far more serious things facing us and only higher education can make us fit to counteract them. The farmers have been mentioned here very often which is only right in the legislature of a country so dependent upon the farmer. But if we educated the farmer better in literature we would not be so much in need of cinemas or dance halls, although I am more in favour of dance halls than some of the elderly members of the Seanad, who dislike these forms of activity. But the farmer will take down a book and read it instead of playing pitch and toss at the crossroads. In this country we are fortunate in possessing a magnificent literary tradition and the fact that we have our own legislature to-day is largely the result of the literary contributions. If the poets of Ireland had not written what they wrote I do not believe that we would be here to-day. We have our modern poets and novelists still maintaining our independence in the highest possible way. It was the word as well as the gun that won for us the independence we have. I need hardly remind you of two literary men whose names were mentioned here this evening, Thomas Davis and Patrick Pearse. If you prefer bath tubs to these, if you prefer bath tubs to the institutions which trained men like Thomas Davis and Patrick Pearse, you know, gentlemen, how to vote, but I do not think you will.

Comment on this

There are just two points I would like to raise, and one is in connection with the dairying industry. A good deal of money has been spent on premiums and so on, both by the Department of Agriculture and by the county committees on improving the progeny of the dairy cow. So far the results obtained have not been very gratifying. Now that larger feeders are getting out of cows the country will be more dependent than ever on the small milk producers, those people who milk their own cows, the people of the West in particular. I think that the dairying areas, particularly in the West, will be very important in the future. Notwithstanding the fact that schemes have been in operation for the last 35 or 40 years, the results achieved to date are not gratifying and definitely I think that this is largely attributable to the fact that heifer calves are not being retained in the country. Until the Department devises some scheme whereby heifer calves, the progeny of good dairy bulls and cows, are prohibited from export and retained in the country this position will continue. I would like to tell the Minister for Finance that any money spent in this way in preventing the export of these heifer calves will be well spent and will result in much better-type cows within the next ten or 15 years. Now, to come to the question of unemployment, I think that every Party realises that the giving of money to able-bodied men is a most undesirable thing. I think that there will be general opinion that if these people were usefully employed it would be much better. Speaking for the West, where there are a great number of small farmers registered as unemployed during the winter, I think that a great many of them could be employed on drainage schemes or in planting the countryside. There are large tracts of cut-away bog not far from where I live which are no use for anything except for planting. I have no hesitation in saying that men would be much better employed on schemes like these than drawing the dole, as it is called in the country, and such a policy would be welcomed by everyone. I do not stand for victimising anybody. I think there are other people and that, no matter what their political opinions or convictions may be, they are just of the same opinion. I think it would be much more desirable to have people usefully employed than to be drawing the dole.

I would like to support Senator Lynch in so far as the Arigna coal is concerned. I would ask the Government to be as sympathetic as possible to the working of that industry. The district is a poor one, in which there is not much employment. The land there is not very productive and hence I would ask the Government to be as sympathetic as possible to that industry. While I would not like to go as far as Senator Lynch did with regard to the county homes, I do want to say, as a member of the Roscommon County Council, that the members of it, ever since we got a native Government and irrespective of what Government was in power or the political Party to which they themselves belonged, were always unanimous in their desire to do all they could for the poor people in the county home. The county manager and the boards of health that we had there from time to time spent what they thought was within reason and within the capacity of the ratepayers to bear in order to make it as comfortable as possible for the poor people. If further improvements can be carried out to the county home, nobody will be better pleased than the members of the Roscommon County Council to do that.

Comment on this

I want to open my reply with an explanation to the Seanad on one point, although I do not think there is any misunderstanding in regard to my attitude. Certain critical comments were made that I did not enter into a long disquisition on details of policy. I had always understood that policy, in so far as it had a special relationship to finance, was developed in the finance quarter of the year on the Financial Resolutions and the Finance Bill, that in the period immediately following, when the detailed Estimates are under consideration, Departmental policy, inside the framework of the more general policy discussed on the Financial Resolutions, came under review, and that in the end there was the Appropriation Bill, which was merely a gathering up of the fragmentary Estimates and the putting of them into one piece of legislation. I do not know that it has ever been the habit to have a reiteration of policy on the Appropriation Bill. It was not the practice when I had anything to do with the Government before, and I find no examples to the contrary in the period in between.

I take it that the statement which comes from Fianna Fáil Deputies and Fianna Fáil Senators—that the Government have made no declaration of policy—is their way of getting over an awkward moment. It may be their aim that if they persevere in making this claim that, out of sheer boredom, one may be again driven into dealing with it. I doubt, however, if anybody who has followed the debates in the Dáil can have any doubt on that point after reading what was said on the Vote for Agriculture and the Vote for Industry and Commerce, as well as the winding up speech of the Taoiseach last week. I doubt, I say, if after all that anybody can have any doubt as to what the general line of policy of the present Government is. If people want any information on any separate point they can ask about it. But as far as the general lines of policy are concerned I abide by what was said by my colleagues on important Estimates.

Senator Hawkins complained that unemployment and emigration had been caused. I am entitled to challenge him for figures. It is easy to produce the records and they do not bear out his statement. There was an upswing in unemployment amounting to several thousands before the last Government left office. The Senator knows, probably as well as anybody else, and if not, might have taken the pains to find out, the numbers that may be affected by the change. He knows very well that a change was made, and that people of certain valuations were allowed to register as unemployed— people who, no matter how destitute they might be before, were not allowed to register. If the Senator will get some view of the increased numbers who in that way were permitted to go on the unemployed register, he will share the surprise of most people that whatever increase the registered figures show, they have not been much greater than what there is.

I come back to the challenge made in this House and before that in the Dáil. We are told that the one great change made which is causing unemployment is that in relation to turf production. We set up a special committee to deal with that matter. We brought forward certain moneys to develop certain schemes, and we have not been able to find enough people to work these schemes. I put the challenge again to Senators—to go to their respective counties and try to pack the register with all the people whom they will try to get, people who were alleged to be turf employed and are now unemployed. I have made that challenge before and I make it again. There has been very little attempt made to meet me on it.

It is significant that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Department of Finance, when opening the Brosna scheme recently, indicated that there was a certain need for men to work on that scheme. At a later stage he was able to say that he required 400 men and could only get 100. I wonder why it is that there are not others going to that scheme. Senator Hawkins attempts to make the case that it is because there is no provision made by way of hutments or catering. That would certainly be a peculiar reason in the case of a drainage scheme. I do not think people are so delicate, particularly if in search of employment which they need, that they would halt because there was not some sort of a hutment to provide refreshment for them during the day. In the Dáil, the Parlimentary Secretary indicated that the turf board had offered co-operation on certain of these matters and had not been able to find people who required that co-operation.

Senator Hawkins also spoke of what he called a reduction in the Vote for the Office of Public Works. According to him it has been curtailed and is the cause of great unemployment. Again, I say that the figures do not show that. I want to come to the root of this matter and say that there has been no significant cut in the Vote for the Office of Public Works. For years figures have been paraded on that Vote, but no attempt was made to spend the moneys. It was not possible to spend them. The Office of Public Works has to depend on two things: (1) materials for building, and (2) men of the building operative type. For years there has been a scarcity of both and that is not over yet. If the Senator will undertake an investigation himself he will find that the issues in respect of the Office of Public Works have been very much lower than what appear on the face of the Estimate. In fact, I feel that the charge can be levelled against me that I am pretending to get economy by the deliberate action which, in fact, would accrue to me in any event if the practice of the last few years was adhered to. But there has been no lack of employment caused by any curtailment in the Vote for the Office of Public Works.

The only change that has been made, and I put it to the Senator that it is a good change, is that in so far as materials and labour suffice, there is a deliberate policy of directing these to houses, particularly houses of the local authority type, and, secondly, houses of the type that come under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act. We much prefer to have whatever labour and materials there are devoted to these two things rather than to some of the multitudinous things that were scattered through the Vote for the Office of Public Works. The Senator again rolled out all that has been said in the debates on these matters since the Dáil opened on the 18th February— about the farm improvements scheme, the farm buildings scheme and what the Minister for Agriculture said, that when he came into office he found 24,000 applications under the farm buildings scheme, most of which had not even been opened.

Comment on this

It is only fair to the Minister for Agriculture to say that he withdrew that statement and apologised for having made it.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement was misconstrued.

Comment on this

He was misinformed.

Comment on this

It is a fact that there was a very big number of applications under the scheme which had never been attended to and could not have been attended to. I wonder if there was a vote with regard to priorities, would not the vote be cast for devoting whatever labour and materials that may exist to slum clearances and to local authority housing or small dwellings rather than to cowsheds.

Comment on this

I suggest that if the Minister and the Government are prepared to make the case that slum clearance and other items should come before the farm buildings scheme and the farm improvements scheme that they should make it and not be making the ridiculous and uncalled-for statement that there were applications in the Minister's office which had not been opened.

Comment on this

There were numerous applications unopened.

Comment on this

And the same staff was being maintained?

Comment on this

I am not making any criticism of the fact that they were not opened. What would be the good in opening things when, clearly in regard to farm building proposals, the most that could be done was to send a reply saying that there was no possibility of these being reached within a year or two.

Comment on this

If the same staff was being maintained in the Department would it not seem to indicate a lack of courtesy?

Comment on this

I am not referring to a lack of courtesy but to the substantial number of applications that were put in. If courtesy is brought in I have not any criticism of that at all. What I have said is not meant in that way, but it is the criterion of how impossible it was to get these schemes attended to, and that is all.

The Senator pretends to be confused with regard to housing, and whether the rate of interest will have any adverse effect on housing. When speaking on budgetary matters earlier I did try to establish the principle—it is one on which there ought to be very little disagreement—that the rate at which the State can borrow ought to be the rate at which the State is expected to lend. I did say in the financial statement in the early days of May that, if that had any serious effect on housing then it was going to be alleviated by an increase in the subsidy, and later I said it would be alleviated in full. Does anybody want anything plainer than that?

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government would like to have it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government has been so informed. I had at least three conferences on this very point, and there is no confusion in his mind. I make the statement again in case there was any confusion before in answer to Senator Hawkins, who has been complaining that he does not know the position in regard to interest rates for housing.

Senator Hawkins made another statement with regard to the Brosna drainage, to the effect that different machines have been ordered from those previously ordered. There were certain types of machines on order. They were not coming fast enough. Other machines were ordered. Only for that, the drainage would not have been done. There is no defect in any of the machinery put on to that job.

Comment on this

I have not suggested there was a defect.

Comment on this

Why does the Senator complain of a change in the machinery? I certainly have a note here to the effect that "there were not the same results being secured."

Comment on this

I wonder where the Senator gets his information. The information we have through those who are attentive to this matter is that the machines are in no way inferior to the ones that were previously ordered. Surely for those who are pressing forward to have employment, it is a bit captious to make the criticism that other machines were ordered and then to suggest that there are not the same results being achieved. I have already said that it is never the practice to provide any housing or catering facilities in connection with drainage workers and there is no evidence that any facilities of that type are demanded by those who are inclined to go and work on the Brosna drainage.

The Senator, I think, also made complaint with regard to the type of people going there. The workers are drawn from the unemployed register. When that register is exhausted other people, small farmers in the neighbourhood, are employed. There is no question of confining employment on the Brosna to people who were previously employed on turf, but I have asked, and I will continue to ask, that people who register ought to say whether or not they were previously on turf schemes, so that we can have the statistical information in respect of this claim that is made that serious unemployment has been caused through anything that has been done in connection with turf.

I do not know if the Senator's remarks about £4 an acre had relation to the Brosna. I take it that it had not?

Comment on this

Because there is no question of any deduction in connection with the Brosna drainage. There is the other deduction. It is open to a land owner to say whether he will take a field drainage scheme or not. If he does, he has to estimate is it worth his while paying £4 an acre. He will get a scheme done for him, no matter what it costs. If he does not think it worth while, he will not pay the £4.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether it has been calculated that the cost of field drainage averages £16 an acre?

Comment on this

Certainly. The Brosna drainage will cost over £20 an acre, but the other, field drainage generally, will go very much above £4.

Comment on this

He will get £16 worth of work for £4.

Comment on this

A man looking at his land may say it is not worth paying £4 for it. The field drainage is not intended to meet every case and certainly not the case that Senator Hawkins dragged out as if it was a typical one of the man whose son had a poor bit of land in the neighbourhood of a bog.

Comment on this

He must employ labour that was originally employed on the production of turf.

Comment on this

It does not mean that he has to employ that labour immediately beside the bog. Let there be no mistake about this: When we are providing schemes of this type, which are going to improve land, which will lead to greater production, we are not going to bring the employment to the people. They will have to move a bit to get it. All turf work was not done by people working a perch or two away from their own place. They will have to put themselves at least to a little bit of trouble to get work if work is being provided. The Senator says that business is depressed. I have not seen any signs of it. I have been looking for it. I have some hopes that business will become depresed. Otherwise we are going to go on as we are. Does Senator Hawkins hold that we are at the ideal situation or that we were at the ideal situation, say, last autumn or the early part of this year and that no change could be made but one that would be for the worse?

Comment on this

One has been made.

Comment on this

One has been made. If it is a movement downwards in regard to prices it will be for the good. I suppose the Senator will recognise that there is a situation of some degree of inflation in the country. Apparently he thinks any move away from that is bad. I do not share that view and I am going to ask this House not to share that view. Senator Douglas has talked here about a deflationary movement, which may lead to a slump. Nobody wants that and a watchful eye will have to be kept against that, but there is a situation in between which is a desirable one. Senator Douglas has said he hopes any movement downward in regard to prices will be gradual. That is my own hope, but I have had some conferences with various people in the business world recently. Some people have been good enough to meet me at my request to discuss things like prices and costs, and, while the discussions I had with those people were conducted mainly in the atmosphere of privacy, I am not breaking any secrets when I say the general conclusions these people gave me as theirs were that prices are coming down, that materials that they buy have come down and most of them have told me that, if it were not for the tourist-buying that is going on at the moment, there would already have been a noticeable fall in prices. That, I suggest, is desirable. If that is what the Senator believes to be a depression then we have different terms for the situation.

Comment on this

May I say that this Bill must be law by the morning of Wednesday 4th, and if we were to take it next week, as had been arranged, we would have to meet on Tuesday? Tuesday follows a bank holiday. It has been, therefore, thought that we should finish the Bill to-morrow, taking the other stages to-morrow. I think there is agreement on that. It would be for the convenience of members. We shall have to meet next Wednesday for other business, including perhaps the motions on the paper, so that business to-morrow would be the conclusion of the Second Stage and the other stages of the Bill. Perhaps we could take the motions in my own name which, I think, are not contentious after the Second Stage of the Bill, and before the other stages.

Agreed.

Comment on this