We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Transport Bill, 1949—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 1–120 of 231. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Transport Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 32 of 1949 ›

This Section provides arrangements for the voluntary acquisition and operation of transport undertakings. I should like to put one or two questions to the Minister in connection with it. We have a number of transport undertakings in this country, and I should like to know from the Minister whether they will be able to enter into an agreement with Córas Iompair Éireann for the voluntary acquisition of their services or whether the provision in the section relates to compulsory acquisition.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Morrissey) Fine Gael

It will be a voluntary arrangement, I should say.

Comment on this

We are somewhat handicapped in discussing this Bill because we have not had from the Minister any details as to the present Government's policy in relation to transport. I am specially interested in a particular service and I understand that negotiations are going on at the present time for the acquisition of this service by Córas Iompair Éireann. Whether these negotiations are of a compulsory or a voluntary kind, it is very hard to know. The Bill makes provision for the acquisition of certain undertakings and such acquisition according to the Minister's reply will be of a voluntary nature. In order, however, to have a voluntary acquisition achieved, there must be certain negotiations and both sides must be quite satisfied. So far as I understand in connection with the service in which I am interested, which I do not want to name at present, the Minister has made some advances but these advances are not being accepted by the board of directors of the particular company. I want to know from the Minister if that particular company will not accept the recommendations or the advances of the Department of Industry and Commerce or of Córas Iompair Éireann what will be the result? Will the company not be acquired, apart from the fact that, according to the Minister's ideas, it is in the national interest that the company should be acquired, in order to give service to the people concerned? If agreement cannot be brought about between the board of directors of Córas Iompair Éireann and the company, what is going to be the result?

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

I should like to ask the Minister to clarify the meaning of the section, which is not quite clear to me. This section gives power, I take it, to acquire voluntarily transport services. Once they are acquired, do they have to be maintained in some form or other? If, for instance, Córas Iompair Éireann acquire a transport undertaking within the State, can it then dispense with this service without going through all the procedure provided for in the sections dealing with the closing of branch lines, etc.? As I read the section, Córas Iompair Éireann can voluntarily acquire a service of a private nature. Then does it become incumbent on Córas Iompair Éireann to maintain that as a service that cannot be dispensed with without going through all the procedure of going to the tribunal? It is not quite clear to me.

Comment on this

The importance of this paragraph in the section becomes obvious from reading it. A certain undertaking which consulted me in regard to it felt that there was no ambiguity in the clause so long as it was literally interpreted. It simply states that no private undertaking may be taken over except on terms to be agreed upon. We may take it then that it is a permissive clause, which gives power to the board of Córas Iompair Éireann to acquire a private undertaking. In other words, no private undertaking can be forcibly absorbed in Córas Iompair Éireann. That is the way we interpret it. I think Senator Hawkins has done a good day's work in focussing attention on this matter. Had he not spoken I would have accepted the clause as it is drafted and that would be my interpretation of it.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about that. This section deals with undertakings which may be acquired on the basis of a voluntary agreement. I think Senator Hawkins was concerned with the Galway-Aran service.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

There is no question of acquiring it compulsorily. It will all be a matter of agreement. As the Senator is aware that service is maintained very largely by State assistance. There is a sort of annual agreement between the Department concerned and the Galway Bay Steamship Company. I do not think he need have any fears in relation to that particular service. With regard to the point raised by Senator Orpen, any lines which may be acquired by Córas Iompair Éireann cannot be closed without going through the same process of approaching the tribunal as is necessary in the case of existing Córas Iompair Éireann services.

Comment on this

I should like to have more definite information in relation to the particular service in which I am interested. In the course of my presentation of the case, I did not mention the name of the particular service but the Minister has mentioned it. Seeing that it has been mentioned there can be no harm in further developing the case on behalf of that particular service.

Comment on this

May I ask if the Senator is going to argue the merits of the case, or the basis on which it should be acquired, if it is to be acquired?

Comment on this

No, I do not propose to go into the merits or the demerits, but I do propose to put before the Minister the importance of the service and its maintenance. I believe I would be quite within my rights in suggesting to the House that in Section 26 we are giving power to a particular board to acquire transport undertakings. It is only right when we are giving power to a board to do such a thing that we should have from the Minister a clear and definite statement as to how the undertakings will be acquired.

The service I am interested in has been carried on for quite a number of years under the directorship of quite a number of persons interested in various aspects of national life. If, by the mere passage of this section, we are going to empower the Minister or the board to acquire that service without some recognition of and making some provision for the persons who have in the ordinary way catered for this particular service—making provision for the compensation of such persons—I think that is one of the things this House should not do.

Comment on this

May I relieve the Senator's mind? We are not exactly falling over ourselves to acquire this service.

Comment on this

This service?

Comment on this

Yes, this particular service, and if it is to be acquired under this section, then it will be by agreement between the two parties. So far as we are concerned, our only interest in acquiring it is to ensure that the service shall be continued and, if possible, improved, as between the main land and the islands. We have no other interest. It is not making any money and I doubt if we will make any money out of it.

Comment on this

It is a private concern.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

While we talk about the nationalisation of transport undertakings, we must remember that this service has served the people of the islands, and during a very difficult period those people maintained that service. If, by the mere passage of this section, we are now going to give authority to a Minister or a board to take over from those people who have maintained that service through the years, without giving them some recognition or paying some tribute to their services, I say that is one of the things the Seanad should not be called upon to do.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Summerfield as to the interpretation of the section. The section provides for voluntary acquisition. It is also clear that the Bill does not provide for the compulsory acquisition of anything except the services mentioned in the Bill, that is, the present service under Córas Iompair Éireann, plus the Grand Canal Company.

I do not understand from Senator Hawkins whether he desires that there should be compulsory powers in the Bill to acquire transport undertakings. He did not make that clear. I thought at first he was in favour of that. I may say I am not.

With regard to the particular service under discussion, I am not a Galway man, but I am interested in it because it serves islands which are in the main Irish-speaking. It is a service which I would like to see preserved for reasons which have nothing to do with ordinary economic considerations. I know from experience in public life in the Dáil for a number of years that it is a long time since there were questions asked with regard to a State subsidy for this service. I do not know what the Senator wants to get from the Minister beyond what he has got, namely, further consideration for helping the people who live on the islands.

In this case there is a special interest in them—because of linguistic reasons it is desirable to continue the service. But I do not know what else the Senator wants. This service is an unsatisfactory one and has been for a long time because of economic reasons over which, I think, the people running the service have not very much control. The Minister desires to continue the service for the benefit of the people on the islands and, if possible, to improve it; but that must be done in a voluntary way, and I do not know any method by which we can make any provision legislatively for the acquisition of a private concern on more favourable terms than Córas Iompair Éireann is prepared to give.

That is what Senator Hawkins wants and I do not see how in a Bill he can get what he wants. The most any of us can get is the assurance the Minister has given us, that it is the desire of the Government and, therefore, will be put up to Córas Iompair Éireann, that this service should be maintained and improved. If that can be done it is not possible for us by way of legislation to prescribe the particular conditions under which it will be done.

Comment on this

It seems to me there is a principle involved here which we should maintain. I do not think any legislation should give, even to a State company, the right compulsorily to acquire private services. If they are to be acquired compulsorily it should be by another Act as the deliberate and considered act of the Oireachtas. We are not accepting the principle that all transport should necessarily be run by the State. The reason Córas Iompair Éireann are being acquired is because of circumstances and not because of a desire to acquire private interests. While that is the policy, not only of the present Government but of its predecessor, we should maintain the principle that there will be no compulsory acquisition of a private company, of private transport or other private interests except it is done by means of legislation brought before the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

For my part I realise it is very difficult to frame questions on this section to elicit information that we would all desire to get. Even if it were possible to frame the questions I am still in doubt whether we should ask the questions at all or not. There is one particular undertaking, and I think the Minister has it in mind, about which we would like some information, but I am quite willing to concede that this may not be the opportune time to seek information in regard to it.

With regard to the Galway Bay Steamship Company, which is the one in question here, since the particular service that it runs has been mentioned, I would like to raise one or two points. The word "voluntary" has been stressed in connection with this section. We know the meaning of the word "co-operation" and I think we all quite understand that you can get co-operation in a normal, reasonable way and if you do not you can force it. Equally so with regard to this company. It is possible by a certain procedure to make the position unduly difficult. Firstly, we have to realise that the service is an essential one. It may not be a paying service, but like economic development, like some of the questions we discussed on other sections, here is a case where it will be genuinely in the national interest that, the consequences being what they may, that service should be maintained.

When the Transport Act of 1944 was before the House I made the plea that something should be done to take over the Aran Islands service. I had hopes that in due course, with the development of Córas Iompair Éireann, that service would be taken over. I still have hopes that under this legislation we will reach the stage where that service will be taken over by the National Transport Company. If negotiations are entered into between the two parties, the Galway Bay Steamship Company and the Government, it is possible for the company to indicate that this is a service that will impose a burden on them, that by taking over this service they will be handicapped in achieving the aims that we prescribe for them in Section 15, which we debated at considerable length the last evening. Then we may be able to reach the position where we could convince the Minister that, notwithstanding the attitude of the board, something ought to be done about this.

Negotiations are proceeding and the Minister or Córas Iompair Éireann will say: "We are prepared to take over this service at a price," and the price may be such, it may be arranged at such a level, that the company could not consider it at all. The price could be fixed so low that the company might say: "There is no use in going on with this matter." In that way, while we would like to see the thing settled voluntarily, it is possible to introduce an element of compulsion to the extent that you would prevent the achievement of the aim that I would like to see achieved, and that is the absorption of that service by Córas Iompair Éireann.

There is very little point in pressing the matter because time and again, on three or four relevant sections in the Bill, I have done my best to get from the Minister an indication of what he as Minister for Industry and Commerce visualises in regard to this reorganisation of transport and its development. I feel from what I have heard here and from what I have read of the proceedings in the Dáil that there is very little point in pressing the Minister for information, because he will not give it.

There does seem to be some substance in the remark of Senator Hawkins with regard to the attitude that may be adopted towards the Galway Bay Steamship Company which controls the service to Aran. A difficulty could arise due to unreasonableness on the part of the new board, if that is the board that will be responsible for the negotiations, or on the part of the Minister, if eventually it can be brought home to the Minister that he ought to take some action in regard to it.

Comment on this

I will repeat that I have no uneasiness with regard to the wording of this paragraph.

Comment on this

You can read English.

Comment on this

At the same time, because of the doubts that have been raised in the minds of some Senators, I suggest the Minister should make a statement. I know that it is like asking him to push an already open door. I ask him to repeat that the Bill does not confer and is not intended to confer on Córas Iompair Éireann the power to take over compulsorily the business of any private operator. I have no doubt about this matter at all, but it is an important matter and because of its importance I suggest the Minister should do that. Such a statement will allay the doubts that exist in the minds of some people who, perhaps, have not been here to listen to the debate and those doubts may exist in the minds of some who have even read the debate. I hope the Minister will give us a straight, simple and categorical statement.

Comment on this

If anybody had any doubt in his mind about the purpose of Section 26 he had only to turn to the Bill and read the marginal note to the section which says: "Arrangements for voluntary acquisition and operation of transport undertakings." I, like Senator Summerfield, would not have spoken on this section but for the doubts that were raised. Doubts were raised, and it is now suggested that Córas Iompair Éireann should be practically compelled to buy certain hand-picked concerns such as the Galway Bay Steamship Company. Now, I know nothing about the Galway Bay Steamship Company. I believe it is a service that should be maintained, but if the service be one that requires a State subsidy, and has required it in the past, to suggest that we should compel a company that has been reorganised because it is bankrupt to buy other bankrupt concerns seems to me to be bad economics. If you are merely to compel Córas Iompair Éireann to buy without compelling others to sell, it may be in a worse position than ever before. It was rumoured in connection with another Transport Bill it was made obligatory on the Dublin Transport Company to buy up rival concerns. That is where the obligation began and ended. It was forced to buy them up, and, since they were not forced to sell, they made their own price.

Comment on this

May I assure Senator Summerfield that there was no necessity to compel me to use simple language? As a matter of fact I do not know any other. May I say to Senator Ó Buachalla, in reply to his charge that there is no use in asking me for any information because, as he said, I will not give any, that I only regret the Senator did not discover that earlier in the debate—not that I am admitting that I am not giving information. I know very few Bills introduced into the Oireachtas which have been so exhaustively discussed as this one. May I say further that, unlike some Senators, I think I understand what is worrying the Senators from Galway. I have no desire to acquire this company compulsorily. There is no obligation on me. I am not concerned with the Galway Bay Steamship Company. I am concerned only with seeing that there is a service between the mainland and the Aran Islands. Córas Iompair Éireann can themselves provide that service without going to the Galway Steamship Company at all, or Córas Iompair Éireann or the Government can enter into an arrangement with any other company to provide a service.

Comment on this

You can get a few canal boats now.

Comment on this

I would not like to see Senator Colgan on a canal boat trying to get around Black Head. I think if he tried that he would find that it was not in Ringsend Basin he was. I have been there myself on a few occasions and I think I know something about it. I wish Senators would accept this from me that there is no desire or intention to be unfair or unjust to anybody, to any company or to any section. I understand that there have been certain talks between officers of my Department and the Galway Bay Steamboat Company. We will not exercise any pressure, unfair or otherwise, on the Galway Bay Steamboat Company, and, on the other hand, we are not going to allow anyone to exercise any unfair pressure on us. The position in connection with this is quite simple. The board of the new company, as Senator S. O'Farrell has pointed out, has nothing to gain financially by taking on this service. We are concerned about the service because we believe that the people on the islands are entitled to a decent service and we are anxious to give it to them.

Comment on this

On that question I would like to say a word or two. A few minutes ago, when we were dealing with another matter, I mentioned that there were three or four sections of the Bill which I considered to be of outstanding importance: that is, as far as securing an efficient and an economic transport service for the country is concerned. What I said a few moments ago about obtaining information goes still. Nevertheless, I do not want to allow the occasion of this section to pass without again making an effort to get some indication from the Minister as to what he visualises by way of a scheme or a plan or by way of a policy to achieve the aims which we all so much desire. Under Section 6 there was the question of the type of board and the retention of the right by the Minister to appoint the chairman. I wanted to know why that right was sought, but we did not get the answer. Then we had a long discussion on the general powers of the board which was equally futile. We had a long discussion on Section 15 which deals with the duties of the board and which, by the way, became specific after we had got away from the first subsection.

Section 28 deals with the question of finance. The important sub-section in this section is, in my view, sub-section (2), paragraph (b), which prescribes that the total amount of money borrowed shall not exceed £7,000,000. I do not know why the Minister put in £7,000,000. Perhaps, in view of what has gone before, and in view of the discussions we have had, it might as well be 7d. or £7 or £70,000,000 instead of £7,000,000. The words in the sub-section seem to me to have no significance unless the Minister is prepared to take us into his confidence and indicate to us what has been the result of such study as he has made of the difficulties that were there in the last few years, and of the shortcomings of the ex-chairman and of the present board, and unless he indicates to us what steps he hopes the new board will be able to take and how they are going to achieve such aims as they may have, and what he thinks those aims are.

The Minister has indicated to us the difficulties that confront Córas Iompair Éireann at the moment. Like other people, he has indicated to us the fact that the troubles of Córas Iompair Éireann arose mainly out of its running of the railway section. That is the crux. On the last day the Minister indicated to us that since 1937 not one new carriage has been built. In 1937 there was considerable uneasiness with regard to the future of the company. About that time there was a special tribunal appointed to consider the difficulties of the transport system. Almost immediately we had the great war with all the difficulties that arose out of it, especially for transport undertakings, so that if between 1937 and 1947 no new carriages had been built, one could quite understand that. I would say that as one who realises the industrial difficulties there were during the war and post-war periods. In the light of our experience, we could say that we had no hesitation in agreeing that there had been difficulties, and that we must forgive those who were not able to achieve greater results because of those difficulties.

During the last 12 months there has been a new chairman. I wonder were materials more easily got during that period than in the period before that? The personnel has been retained, the gear was pretty well intact, and it would surprise me if considerable strides had not been made in the last 12 months in the provision of new carriages. That, however, is not my point. We all know that the whole railway system requires overhaul. The carriages require to be renewed, and the rolling stock, if that means trucks and bogies of all description, requires to be renewed. In most cases they require new stock. We had indications the last day of a deterioration in the condition of the permanent way, and an indication from the Minister as to the enormous cost that will be involved in any effort to bring that up to a proper standard. We know that the stations require a complete overhaul; we know that the cabins and the signalling system have deteriorated and require to be replaced by a newer system.

There is the question of the branch lines, the standardisation of engines and so on. Does the Minister visualise that £7,000,000 is sufficient to achieve that overhaul? My point is that he must have had some idea in his mind when he decided on this figure of £7,000,000. Some technicians must have advised him, and said that £7,000,000 was the sum required to put this service right. How is this money to be expended? In what way is the service to be improved by this expenditure to the extent set down in Section 15? As far as I am concerned Sections 6, 13, 15 and 28 are the ones in which I am particularly interested. I have tried to find out whether there has been any consistent principle running through those sections. I have tried to find out from a study of them what is visualised in order to achieve what is aimed at—really good efficient and economic transport service. I have failed to find that out. This is the last time that I am going to make an appeal to the Minister to indicate to us, as the result of his studies, and of the advice that has been tendered to him with regard to this company, how he has arrived at this figure of £7,000,000, and how he thinks it is going to achieve all that we hope will be achieved. It is all very well for the Minister to say: "Well, if there is not enough in it I will come back again and ask for more." That seems to me to be the wrong way to approach this. It is of no assistance to those of us who have made a study of economic problems to tell us to try and work out, as on a chess board, the position of this and the position of that, and to relate all these things to each other in order to see what the result is going to be. Maybe I am asking or expecting too much, but in any case I feel that I should not let the section go without again making this appeal.

Comment on this

It struck me, when listening to the Senator on this provision of £7,000,000 and telling us how interested he was as one who studies economic problems, that his speech might have been more appropriately delivered on the 1944 Transport Bill when it was before the Seanad. I do not know if the Senator put to my predecessor many, or any, of the questions which he has put to me to-day when my predecessor was providing in the 1944 Act for £6,000,000 and not £7,000,000. I am putting in £7,000,000 because I am advised by competent advisers that that is an adequate sum, and because I know that that £7,000,000 will be devoted to the provision of an efficient transport system, and that its expenditure will be confined very largely, if not entirely, to the purchase and provision of vehicles which will earn money, rather than be expended upon propositions which are merely avenues for the expenditure of money. I do not know whether I can help the Senator. May I assure him that I am not deliberately withholding any information from the Seanad? I have no desire to do so but fortunately, perhaps, for the Senator as well as for myself, I am not a transport expert——

Comment on this

Nor a prophet.

Comment on this

Nor a prophet. I am neither a transport expert nor a prophet, and not having one or the other qualification, I am prepared to take advice from people competent to give it to me. I can only assure the Senator that he is not entirely right when he says that it might as well be £700, £7,000 or £700,000 as £7,000,000, as the figure was not picked out of the hat like that. Whether the Senator can accept it or not, there was very considerable attention given to the drafting of this Bill. If the Senator has failed, up to this point, to grasp the purport of the Bill, and the intention behind it, and what we hope to do with its machinery in relation to the national transport system, then I regret that I am unable to help him further. The £7,000,000 is there. I am assured that is a sum that it is thought would be required. Therefore, I do not want to ask the Oireachtas for any more or any less.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

Before Section (4) in page 25, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

No stamp duty shall be chargeable or payable on any instrument by which a transfer of transport stock is effected.

The purpose of this amendment is to make a minor concession to the stockholders of Córas Iompair Éireann undertaking. On the Second Reading of the Bill I made some general observations about the relation between the amount of compensation and what I considered the amount should be, and I hope to make some further observations on it when we deal with that matter again on the schedule to the present Bill. This amendment is simply a request to the Minister to consider making a minor concession on the cost of marketing these shares and stocks when they come into the market later. These will be full Government stocks. They will not be like Córas Iompair Éireann debentures, which are simply contingent liabilities of the Government. They will be full Government stocks, giving full Government security. Therefore, I suggest that they should be treated from the point of view of stamp duty as other Government stocks are. In particular, I would draw attention to the fact that Land Bonds, which are in many ways parallel with these stocks, are free from stamp duty on the Dublin Stock Exchange. The Land Bonds have been issued by the Irish Government to people in compensation for their landed estates. These stocks are issued by the Irish Government to people in compensation for their railway shareholdings, and I really cannot see why one class of Government stock should be free of stamp duty and the other class subject to it. I would like to quote the example of the British transport stocks on this matter. The Minister has quoted the example of the British Transport Board against me in relation to other matters I dealt with on the last amendment I proposed and I do not think that he can complain if I quote it against him now. I understand that the British transport stocks, which are on all-fours with these stocks, are free from stamp duty on the London Stock Exchange, and I suggest to the Minister that he might consider making what, after all, is only a minor concession to the shareholders of the present undertaking.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I cannot accept this amendment. It may be only a minor concession that would make the stocks more attractive to purchasers and to that extent benefit the stockholders, but it might create a very dangerous precedent. I am not prepared to agree that these stocks are Government stocks in the ordinary sense of the word, and I would not be prepared to accept the amendment, because I think it would be extremely difficult to draw the line in relation to other stocks which I can think about at the moment. It would be opening the door a bit too wide. I am sorry.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 10a is a purely drafting amendment.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 10b is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I propose amendment No. 11, standing in the names of Senator Hearne and myself:—

In sub-section (2), before paragraph (e), to insert the following new paragraph:—

The board shall by special rules provide that shed and shop clerks who have had a minimum of four years' satisfactory service shall be eligible for promotion to the clerical grades of the service of the board.

I ask the Minister to accept this amendment, having regard to the facts of recruitment of labour for such a service as Córas Iompair Éireann or the transport services generally. We already know that there is a certain provision made whereby sons of employees of the transport company have already got certain preferences. What I want to achieve in this is that those people who enter the employment of Córas Iompair Éireann in a particular grade will have an opportunity, because of their abilities and service to the board, to look forward, after giving of their best services, to the time when they will be put into the category of being eligible to sit at those examinations. We have, at the present time, people who are referred to in this section as shed and shop workers. The main occupations of these persons are of a very clerical nature, and because of the fact that they enter into the service under this particular category they are not allowed to sit for any examination that might give them an opportunity of improving their positions.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

I would put it to the Seanad and to the Minister that, arriving at the stage we have reached in this country, it would be well that the most lowly person who enters into an occupation should be given every opportunity of advancement. It is in that belief that I put down this amendment, and I hope the Minister will accept it in order to give such persons in the employment of Córas Iompair Eireann or any other organisation in this country every opportunity, if they are competent, of improving their positions. I ask that they be given that opportunity.

Comment on this

I am afraid that acceptance of this amendment would create very serious reactions apart from the fact that it would be in conflict, not only with the main provisions of the section, but with the statutory position which prevailed since 1924. The clerical staffs of the principal Irish railways have been recruited by open competitive examination since about 1905. The old Irish Parliamentary Party, having opposed certain private Bills promoted by the Irish railway companies, induced or compelled these companies to give a guarantee that they would recruit at least a proportion of their clerical staff by competitive examination. I know I entered the railway service some 40 years ago by open competitive examination. The companies always retained 25 per cent. of vacancies to which they appointed existing non-clerical employees or the sons of such employees. There was no examination for that particular section; it was merely a question of appointing whoever was considered best. This gave rise to a whole series of complaints on the grounds of favouritism. It was alleged that it was not what you knew but whom you knew which decided your promotion.

The Railways Act of 1924 was the first statutory enactment compelling the companies to recruit by competitive examination. That enabled a proportion to be reserved for existing employees or their sons. It laid down for the first time the principle that this 25 per cent. would, on the grounds of common equity and common justice, be by limited competition between the various competitors. Apart from the shop and shed clerks, there are numbers of other non-clerical people, such as office assistants, office tracers, timekeepers, parcel porters and others of that type who come within the 25 per cent. category. There is, therefore, first of all the open competitive examination for which anybody who complies with the statutory conditions can compete and, secondly, there is the limited competition between the existing employees or the sons of employees.

This amendment would suggest that we should superimpose on that statutory arrangement a special class who need pass no examination but who would be simply promoted from the position of cleaner, labourer or mechanic to the position of shop or shed clerk; having served four years in that particular category, provided they were satisfactory, they would then automatically pass into the full clerical grade. That would be entirely inequitable from the point of view of other people having equally good claims. All railway companies have this type of employee. They are always attached to the headquarters of locomotive departments and running sheds. They have special qualifications because of the fact that they are around these works and sheds all the time, and the ordinary clerical staff appointed by competitive examination would feel they were being reduced in status if these particular employees were appointed in the manner suggested. As a result of trade union action we have been able to get a special agreement which lifts these people above the wages grade from which they have come, but keeps them just a shade below the competitive clerical grade.

As late as June, 1948, the Labour Court issued a finding fixing the salaries of these men. I think it would be extremely unwise for the Oireachtas, without more information, to do anything that would disrupt or break up a finding of the Labour Court made at the instigation of the unions catering for these people. Every single one of these has the right up to 25 years of age to sit for a limited competitive examination, and the railway company, as has been stated, gives them considerable facilities for attending special classes at the technical schools and in the High School of Commerce in Rathmines to permit them to prepare themselves for that form of limited competition which would bring them finally into the fully graded clerical staff. If we accepted this amendment—I know it is well meant—it would undoubtedly confer a special privilege on these people and react most unfavourably on their competitors with similar rights. In the circumstance I do not think we should accept this amendment. Certinly, I would have to vote against it.

Comment on this

I am in sympathy with the purpose of this amendment, but, like Senator J.T. O'Farrell, I, too, wonder if it is wise. Instead of doing what might appear to be justice to a small section one might create a sense of injustice in a very large section. If I could be assured that promotion is open to everybody in the railway service who can qualify for it I would be satisfied. If I thought there was a system in operation at present which would debar a man from promotion because he entered by a particular door I would be very much opposed to that system. I know that some of the best stationmasters that the railway company ever had rose from the grade of porter. I think it is still possible to go from porter to the grade of relief stationmaster and ultimately to stationmaster. I do not think there are many people in the railway service who went in at 16 or 18 years of age without an examination and who afterwards became clerks of one kind or another. I doubt if there are any of those who had any ambition to go further in the clerical grade who could not have done so had they so wished. Although I am opposed to closed shops, I think there would be danger here in taking out one small section and giving special facilities to it. I can imagine that thousands of others could claim to come in too, such as ticket checkers and parcel porters. All these have to keep returns and accounts. They have quite an amount of clerical work to do, but they are not graded as clerical workers. I do not think they would want to be graded as clerical workers. Very often a certain kind of clerical work is done by a goods porter, but that does not mean he is dissatisfied with his particular grade or that he wants to be transferred. If I am assured that the company will give promotion where it is due I will be quite satisfied with that. If it is the object to open the door merely to one or two clerks we may create considerable dissatisfaction amongst those who do clerical work but do not come within the definition of this amendment.

Comment on this

I think both Senator J.T. O'Farrell and Senator S. O'Farrell have stated the position very clearly. A similar amendment to this was tabled in the Dáil and I stated my views on it at the time. Quite frankly, I do not think it is any part of the Minister's function to intervene or interfere with the company or the board with regard to the recruitment, grading and promotion of its employees. All those who are employed in Córas Iompair Eireann are members of trade unions. They are fully protected. Their interests are safeguarded. No man, as has been stated, is debarred from entering for an examination. No man is debarred from promotion provided he meets the conditions laid down. In nearly every case all these men have secured promotion to their present positions from those in which they first entered the service. If they desire to go for the limited competitive examination or the open competitive examination up to the age of 25, not only are they not debarred but they get certain facilities which are not made available to those with whom they are competing, facilities which are provided, as Senator J.T. O'Farrell said, by the company. This in my opinion is a matter entirely for the company. The present limit is 25 years. I am not advocating that it should be either increased or reduced. So far as I know, that would be a matter for the board. However, in my opinion, it is not a matter for the Minister and I do not think it should be a matter for the Oireachtas to determine a question of this kind when we are discussing this legislation, particularly as I say when the competitive examination is there. There is also a limited examination as explained by Senator O'Farrell and we know, further, that all the employees of the company are members of trade unions and their interests are pretty well looked after by these unions.

Comment on this

The motive that prompted me to move this amendment was the fact that the majority of young people are frequently, through circumstances over which they have no control, compelled to leave school at the very early age of 14 and are obliged to find employment as best they can. Many of them become employees of a transport organisation such as Córas Iompair Eireann. The object of the amendment was that we might open up other avenues of employment and of promotion to these young people. However, taking into consideration the fact that we have in opposition to this amendment to-day the spokesmen of the two Labour movements in this country, I do not think there is anything more we can do about it except to hope that the various trade union organisations will cater particularly for such people as I intended to cater for by the amendment.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

In connection with this section, the rate, "for any other animal £5", does not seem quite in conformity with present-day prices for pigs, for instance. In the case of cattle, we have multiplied the rates by three, and, in the case of horses, by two. The new rate, as I say, does not seem to be in conformity with the present price of pigs.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:—

To add at the end of sub-section (2) the following words: "Provided that no exemption order shall be applied for in respect of a railway line serving a town where cattle fairs are periodically held.

I should like to point out that an abandonment order for a railway line serving a town where fairs are held means also an abandonment order for the fairs in that particular town. No buyers of any importance will attend fairs if they cannot get the cattle away by rail. In such circumstances, the farmers living around that particular town will take their cattle to the next nearest town which is served by a railway. That will inevitably mean that the trade of the particular town which is no longer served by a railway will go to the town which has captured the business of its fairs. Most people attending fairs, when they get paid for their cattle, expend a good deal of that money in buying their requirements in that particular town. That means that the trade of a town in which the fair is neglected must inevitably fall into decay.

It is an extraordinary fact that the Government of this country are trying to abolish railways while other countries are endeavouring to establish railways. I see that a British Minister has said that his ground nut scheme was a failure because there were no railway facilities to develop Tanganyika. Similarly, the Australian Government have stated that they could not develop their beef trade with England for 15 years because they will not have the railway to the northern end of the continent constructed for that period. They therefore cannot produce the beef which they require for their English trade until they have a railway to serve that part of the country. That I think is proof positive that railways are essential for the development of any country, and that no industry of importance can be developed where an adequate railway system is absent.

I should like the House to consider the position of the roads in any area where there is no railway to serve fairs. We may take it that about 5,000 cattle would be sent by rail from a fair in an area where railway facilities are available. Five thousand cattle would mean the employment of 500 wagons. The average lorry will carry about the same number of cattle as a railway wagon, and you can imagine the chaos where you would have to employ 500 lorries to carry these cattle. Can anybody imagine 500 lorries starting on the road from some of these fairs? The smallest fairs in the country, I suppose, would mean 400 cattle sent over the railways. The 400 cattle would mean 40 wagons. There are numbers of these fairs held every day. The roads are congested enough at present, but if those branch lines are closed where fairs are being held the congestion will increase tenfold in a very short time.

I do not want these railways to be kept open for passengers, but I suggest they should be kept open for the conveyance of cattle, beet, coal and other produce. The branch lines can be closed down from the point of view of passenger trains if the Minister likes, but he should very seriously consider the matter before closing down any of these branch lines for the heavier type of traffic—that is, if he wants to keep the country going. I say that lorries will never replace railway wagons for the cattle trade. What I suggest could easily be done. He need not have a big staff to every train. Every train could take its own crew for loading the cattle and it would bring back that crew. It could be done very economically if the Minister will consider it. Leaving it to the directors or the members of the tribunal—well, we know what these people are. They have not the practical experience which some of the cattlemen and businessmen have. If you leave it to the members of those boards they might be out for economy, and I suggest it would be false economy to do that. I appeal to the Minister to accept my suggestion. I know he has no intention of closing down any of those lines, but it is what is in black and white here that will count. Unless we have some definite instruction here I am certain a good many of these railways will be closed in a very short time.

Comment on this

I am very sorry that I cannot accept Senator Counihan's amendment. It is tantamount to deleting all the sections dealing with the tribunal. Let me say to Senator Counihan and to Senators generally that there is not the slightest fear that the cattle trade will be neglected by any transport company set up in this country. The likelihood is that the members of the board and the members of the tribunal will have as much knowledge and perhaps as much interest in the cattle trade as the Minister might have. It must be remembered that any national transport company, and particularly any company dealing with the railway services, must look to the live-stock trade as one of its best money spinners.

I think the Senator's fears are groundless. It will not be left entirely to the company. The company cannot close any branch lines without going to the tribunal. Any such proposal must be publicised and, whether they are local or national interests, every party interested will get an ample opportunity of making a case. The Senator is hardly fair when he says this Government is trying to close down branch lines. This Government, through this Bill, is hoping to keep the branch lines open, as well as the main lines. That is one of the main reasons why the Bill is before the Oireachtas.

We do not want to close any branch lines. I would like to be in a position to say to the transport board that I hope they will be able to reopen some of the closed branch lines. That will be determined, not by the company, but by the people who are using transport. Perhaps if there were not so much live stock being carried by road there would be fewer of the branch lines closed, and those that are open would be earning more money. There is far too much of the live stock of this country being carried from fairs and markets by roads. I agree with Senator Counihan that it would be a horrible thought that 500 lorries would be lining up at an ordinary provincial fair.

Comment on this

There would be at least 5,000 cattle at Ballinasloe fair twice a year, and if the lines were closed down you can realise the position. The smallest number would be 400 animals from any fair.

Comment on this

I am not questioning the Senator's figures. I am agreeing with him on that. That was one of the arguments which I used to the former chairman of Córas Iompair Eireann when the question was put up of closing down all the branch lines. Having some knowledge of what happens at a fair in a provincial town, I asked how you would clear a fair where it might take anything from 12 to 20 railway specials—cattle wagons —to clear it. I have often seen it. I was told it could be done easily by road. I did not accept that then and I do not accept it now. If you had 500 lorries to send out to a fair to clear it, or 400 or 300 or 200, and if it were physically possible to clear the fair with that number of lorries, while they would be clearing it nobody else could use the roads. Again, the roads would not last under that sort of traffic for 12 months. Our roads were not designed or constructed for that type of traffic. This country cannot do without a railway service. It will have to be accepted also by the community that, if they agree that we must maintain, in the national interest, a railway service, the community must pay for that service either by using it or subsidising it.

Comment on this

Before any line is closed down must it have the sanction of the Minister?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Will the Minister be consulted at all?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If the Minister was consulted I would be satisfied, but if it is left to the tribunal or to the directors I think it is a hopeless proposition.

Comment on this

I am sorry I cannot agree with the Senator there. I would prefer that these matters would be settled by a completely independent tribunal. I cannot visualise any board, much less an independent tribunal, that would be so completely negligent of the national interests, much less the transport interests, as deliberately to take a decision to close lines that would paralyse certain of our provincial fairs or markets.

Comment on this

In the case of branch lines already closed down for some years, will the people get an opportunity of appealing to the tribunal that will be set up?

Comment on this

In relation to branch lines that have been closed down, that matter will be examined by the board. Speaking for the Government, let me say that so far as we are concerned it would be our wish that every branch line that could be economically run should be run. It cannot be emphasised too often that whether a branch line will remain open or be reopened and maintained depends upon the community in the particular district concerned. People cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

Will the community get an opportunity of appealing to the tribunal?

Comment on this

In the case of lines closed.

Comment on this

They will get every opportunity of making their case and, if there is a case for reopening, the lines will be reopened.

Comment on this

Lines closed already, but closed in accordance with the law as it then stood—that is, on the authority of the Minister—so that they are legally closed.

Comment on this

I know, Sir, that in a few cases in the past, certain branch lines in the West of Ireland were closed down, and when the people locally protested against the proposal to close them down, they were assured by the company that adequate substitute services would be provided. Now, whatever may be said about adequate substitute services, as far as passenger transport is concerned, the substitute service provided for the transport of live stock was not adequate. It meant a very considerable loss to the people who produced the live stock and anyone who happened to visit fairs serviced by road transport could see that there was a difference, in so far as the value of the stock exposed for sale was concerned, compared with those sold where there was a railway. I can fully appreciate Senator Counihan's doubts on that matter, because I have had the experience of promises being made of adequate substitute services that were not fulfilled.

Comment on this

Are we to take it from what the Minister has just said that it will be purely a matter of economics as to whether a line is to be kept open or not? He stated that if people were prepared to use the lines they would be kept open. Would that not apply generally? The position we find ourselves in is that the railway system is not a paying concern. It has not been for many years. The community has not been using it, but why specify a community in a certain district where the lines are running at a loss? Why should they be told, that unless they are prepared to make the railway line in that particular area an economic unit, it will be closed down?

Comment on this

No, no.

Comment on this

That is the impression I got. I think it would be unfair to ask the Minister, but I think the general public would like to be assured. This tribunal, I take it, will be divorced absolutely from the Minister and the company. They will be independent people who will have no concern with the company. What will influence those people as to why a line should be closed down? Will they take into consideration, not alone the economic conditions, but also the national interests and, if necessary, local interests. After all, we people in the city are fairly well served. The people in the towns are fairly well served, but people in villages throughout various parts of the country, and in backward places, are vitally dependent on the railways. I suggest, that the tribunal ought to consider it from the point of view of the general amenities of the community, social and otherwise, as well as taking into consideration the economic position of the line. A point has been made as to lines already closed down. It should not be forgotten that many of these branch lines were closed down, as a matter of policy, during the emergency when they could not be kept open. They did not get an opportunity of justifying themselves, from the economic standpoint, as well as from the point of view of utility to the people concerned. If you get the opportunity they should be reopened. Let the tribunal deal with them separately. They should not be left closed simply because they were closed during the period of the emergency. I suggest that the Minister should seriously agree, that there are other factors to be taken into consideration in connection with the branch lines, than economic factors, There is the question of keeping people on the land and keeping them in rural areas. These are all bound up with the railway system. After all, the railways are part of the very lives of these people, and it is a very serious matter to shut them down. I do not, at all, like the idea of this independent tribunal. There is much to be said possibly for its being independent, but it means, in fact, that it is responsible to nobody. It is not responsible to the Minister, and the Minister has delegated certain powers to the board. This independent ad hoc tribunal is to be put there without responsibility to anybody and, I suppose, whenever it makes a recommendation to close a line, invariably, the line will be closed. I think the whole thing is lop-sided. These people have no responsibility to anybody. They may take factors into consideration that the company would not take in, if they deal with the thing on its merits.

Comment on this

Of course, I did not say at any time that unless a branch line was fully economic, and paying its way, it would not be kept open or reopened. If we are to apply that test, every branch line would be closed down, because none of them is economic. We have the obligation to see that they must come as near to the point of being economic as possible, and I think it is a bit late in the day to be talking now about responsibility to nobody, and of the Minister shedding his own responsibility, and so on. May I ask Senators again to refer to what is contained in Sections 14 and 15, particularly Section 15. There are certain obligations laid down for the company. In the first place, the company cannot even apply before the tribunal for the closing of a particular branch line, without adverting to the obligation which this Act will impose on it. The tribunal, in investigating any request which is put before it, in relation to a branch line by the board, must itself advert to its responsibility under Section 15 of the Bill. I do not know whether it is quite fair to say that this is a sort of ad hoc tribunal, that is set up without responsibility to anybody, and that it can come to any decision it likes irrespective of its effect, from the point of view of the national interest, or the local community. One might as well say that the Supreme Court of the country is in the same position. This is a board which will be established for a specific purpose, and it only comes into operation on a request being made to it. It must hear both sides, and that imposes the obligation of adverting to the policy laid down in the legislation which will emerge from the Oireachtas here, and of coming to an independent decision. Frankly, I think, it is quite wrong that matters of this sort should be determined by a Minister. I think it is quite wrong, and there is no use in pretending innocence or anything else. Ministers, Deputies and Senators are open, in respect of all these matters, to extreme political pressure and influence. There is no question about it. Ministers of all Governments, and Deputies and Senators of all Parties, would be in that position. I think it is entirely wrong that matters such as these should be determined or could be open to the suggestion that they should be determined, by the amount of political pressure or influence which can be brought to bear on the members of any particular Government at any particular period of our history. I think—again I have to remind Senators to try to keep it fixed in their minds—that we are not now dealing with a private board or a board that will be antagonistic to the national transport policy of this country. This organisation is in process of being acquired by the State. A board selected by the State will be appointed to run that organisation in the interests of the State. We ought to keep that constantly before our minds. That board will be charged with that responsibility and that board alone. That is what they will be required to do. If the board flagrantly or if the tribunal flagrantly flouts the wishes of the Government or of the Oireachtas expressed through the Government or a Minister, then, there is a way of dealing with it. I do not think that is likely to happen, but I do suggest to Senators that it is a very very fair way of imposing certain obligations on the company, by giving, shall I say, a railway slant to the whole of our legislation, an indication that the railway system of the country must in the national interest be maintained here.

Their appeal must be based on the railways rather than on the roads. In order to safeguard the community against even a national transport board we are appointing an independent tribunal. I think there is no better machinery than that for ensuring that the national interest and the local community interest shall be safeguarded and that matters will not be determined, or decisions taken, purely as a result of political influence or political pressure.

Comment on this

Earlier to-day the Minister presented himself with a bouquet. He assured us that one of his great qualifications was simplicity in stating what he had in his mind. I think it must be clear to him now, and clear to the Seanad, that that is a qualification he does not possess. His whole trouble has arisen because of a lack of clarity and because of the inconsistency that has been running through the Bill and through Section 15 to which he has specifically referred. He sets out in sub-section (1) of that section that the board must provide an efficient economic and properly integrated transport service. The trouble is to find out what do the words "an economic service" mean. I have tried to find out whether they mean that the board is to be a profit earning institution, but when I raised that question there was a chorus—in fact two choruses—on the other side of the House, one to the effect that it was to be a profit-earning institution, and the other that it was not. I could not find out either from the people on the other side or from the Minister what was intended.

The second thing is this question of national economic development. The Minister sees now the views people are taking on that. We indicated to him the difficulties that were going to arise out of the interpretation of the term "national economic development." He did not indicate to us what he has in mind about that, and we are left in the dark as to what he thinks. I suggest that he cannot get away from his responsibility of informing us of what he has in mind with regard to this matter of national economic development. He talked about reasonable conditions for the employees and that, of course, must involve cost. He then went on to other things, the needs of the public, of agriculture, commerce and industry and said that these must be attended to. Senator Counihan, and those for whom he speaks, do not understand what that means, nor does anybody else.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Then we come to sub-section (2) of Section 15 which says——

Comment on this

I thought we were discussing the amendment that is before the House, but this is a Second Reading speech which the Senator is making.

Comment on this

We are discussing an amendment to Section 55. The Minister, in the course of his reply, made certain remarks, and referred Senators to Section 15. He spoke to some extent on that section.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister simply made a passing reference to the section.

Comment on this

He referred to the responsibilities of the board as imposed by Section 15. I want to mention now that sub-section (2) of Section 15 provides that:—

"It shall be the duty of the board so to conduct its undertaking as to secure, as soon as may be, that, taking one year with another, the revenue of the board shall be not less than sufficient to meet the charges. properly chargeable to revenue."

In other words, this board is to be a business board. This board will have to pay its way, and is going to have regard only to such services as will enable it to carry out that duty of paying its way. How that is going to be done is what is worrying Senator Counihan and many other Senators, especially when they consider what is implied in sub-section (1) of Section 15. It must be clear now to the Minister that his Bill is creating a great deal of confusion in the minds of Senators and in the minds of the public.

Comment on this

Apparently, it was not a difficult task to create confusion in the mind of the Senator. He has been completely confused from the first moment the Bill came to the Seanad. I do not know whether the Senator is completely confused, or whether it is part of the tactics that he has chosen in the debate on this measure, that is, to pretend that he is confused. He has accused me of a lack of clarity and a lack of simplicity. He regrets that I have not seen fit to develop in detail what I mean by national economic development. I would like to discuss that, particularly in relation to some speeches that have been made by some of his colleagues within the last few days, and of some articles which have been written in a newspaper which I am sure he reads, and how helpful these are to national economic development. I would like to go into the question of how helpful it is to the national economic development of this country to have a deliberate campaign of sabotage of the credit of this State in advance of national loans, but this is not the place to do it. I wish it were, and if it were, I can assure the Senator that I would have no reluctance whatever in entering into a full discussion of that.

Comment on this

We are not an argumentative body here.

Comment on this

So I was informed before I came here, but I am afraid that I have had reason to change my mind altogether about that. I can only assume it is so because the Senator is so happy to be sitting behind Senator Ó Buachalla instead of in front of him.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think we had better get back to the amendment.

Comment on this

If the Minister is anxious to have a full discussion on that we will give him every facility for it.

Comment on this

As far as sabotaging the national position of this country is concerned——

Comment on this

To talk about sabotage comes very badly from the people who organised the Blueshirts in 1932.

Comment on this

As far as sabotaging the national position of this country is concerned, the first person to cast any doubt on the credit-worthiness of this country was the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

May I remind Senators that it was not I who introduced the subject of national economic development here. It was dragged in as a red herring for some purpose which I do not know.

Comment on this

Is not that expression in the Bill?

Comment on this

Of course it is, and it is a pity the Senator did not discuss it on the appropriate occasion.

Comment on this

In Section 15 we find the words "the encouragement of national economic development."

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to have a full-dress debate on the past we will give him every opportunity for it.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, I was not the first person to introduce it. The Minister introduced the words "the encouragement of national economic development," and he does not know what they mean.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We had better get back to the amendment.

Comment on this

It is a pity we ever departed from it.

Comment on this

In the last six months when they had Bills in this House, the only people who engendered heat here were the Ministers who came here.

Comment on this

I resent that remark.

Comment on this

It is a fact.

Comment on this

It is not a fact.

Comment on this

A question has been raised about the validity of the reference to Section 15. Section 54 provides that "in exercising their functions the tribunal should have regard, amongst other matters, to Section 15." Therefore, it would be impossible to discuss the functions of the tribunal without referring to Section 15.

Comment on this

That is so, and I should say to Senator Hearne that was the only reference that I made to Section 15. I should say, too, that we are a long way now from the closing down of branch lines in places where fairs are held. I think I answered Senator Counihan's point on that. I think—at least I hoped—that I had assured the Senator and satisfied him that I was fully conscious of the point he was trying to make. I tried to assure him that his fears in regard to that were entirely groundless and, having made myself as clear as I possibly could, I thought we had finished with the amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

Better not.

Comment on this

It is withdrawn.

Comment on this

He is withdrawing it.

Comment on this

Let the Senator speak for himself.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new subsection as follows:—

Before making an exemption order under this section the tribunal shall submit the terms of the proposed order to the Minister for Industry and Commerce who may direct that such modifications in the conditions as he considers necessary to meet the reasonable needs of the public in the districts covered by the order be inserted therein.

During the Second Reading and on the Committee Stage of this Bill, we have had much discussion on this point, but I must say that inside the last five or ten minutes we have certainly got from the Minister more information than we had ever obtained during the two or three days that the Bill has been before the House. Speaking the last night on the Committee Stage, I directed the attention of the members to Section 22, which made provision that where the board is empowered to make certain by-laws that the by-laws made by the board must have the approval of the Minister before they become effective. With that I expressed my agreement. We have been discussing the setting up of a board and I will admit this at the outset, that probably some of my contributions on this particular section would have been more appropriate on Section 54, because Section 54 provides for the setting up of a tribunal. We have not had from the Minister, either in this or the other House, any idea about the personnel of the new tribunal, or how he is going to choose the personnel or what are the qualifications necessary for the Minister to appoint a particular person. When we examine the Bill in detail, we find that it makes at least three provisions. One of them is that we must have a board. The board is to be composed of not more than seven persons, and not less than three, but on top of that we are going to have a tribunal, and we are empowering the tribunal to carry out very definite functions. The most important of these, so far as the rural community are concerned, is in relation to the closing down of branch lines. We have had from the Minister here to-day, and in the Dáil, and on several other occasions, an expression of opinion that it would not be right to expect that any undertaking, whether it be national or otherwise, would engage in a service that would not be a paying service. But when we come to ask ourselves the question what the Bill proposes and what are these things in the Bill, the answer to that question very definitely is that we are setting up a board to give to the people of the country a particular service. We are asking them, too, to the best of their abilities, that they would try to ensure that that service would pay year by year, but while we are asking them to do that particular thing, and placing them under that particular obligation, we are also prepared, at the same time, to make provision, in the event of their failure to accomplish what we would wish them to accomplish, by saying that the Dáil and the Seanad, in the name of the Irish people, are prepared to make certain contributions to maintaining this general service. Having admitted that much, and having come to the conclusion that the maintenance of a rail system is of very grave national concern, one of the things we must maintain, we must, if we are prepared to pass this Bill, also accept that, side by side with the importance of the main lines there is a matter as important, if not more important, to the rural community, in which the members of this House must certainly and should be most interested, the question of the branch lines, the importance of which is borne out by the fact that in times gone by, when it was a question of establishing a branch line, or the maintenance of a particular line, the local council, taking into consideration the importance of that particular service, were prepared to levy on the ratepayers a charge in order to maintain that service. The provisions of this Bill, I might say, arise from the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce saw fit to appoint, what he termed at the time, an expert in railway business and organisation, a person whom he thought would be capable of giving him advice. And what do we find? We find in paragraph 226 of the Milne Report the following:

"The paramount consideration in investigating the question of closing branch lines should be whether their retention is necessary or desirable in the public interest. They are part of the national system of highways, and if they provide convenient access to outlying districts their retention may be well justified, even if the railway is unable to earn sufficient revenue to cover the full cost of providing and maintaining the tracks and the service of the particular services."

The Minister appointed the particular expert and I have directed the members of the Seanad to his report. We also find in paragraph 231:

"In all circumstances it is considered that any proposal to close branch liness solely on the grounds that they are at present unprofitable, should be rejected."

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

"It is recommended that, before any such branch line is closed, there should be a public inquiry and that the governing consideration should be whether the retention of the branch as part of the country's highway system is necessary or desirable in the public interest."

We have, as I have already pointed out, made provision in Section 54 for the setting up of a tribunal. We have not got from the Minister any indication of what the personnel of this tribunal is going to be, but we know that it is going to have an overriding authority over the Transport Board, that they are the persons who will decide, that this House and the other House are placing in the responsible position of deciding, whether a particular service should or should not be closed down. It is true, of course, that that decision will not be arrived at without certain formalities being gone through. It is quite evident, regarding the composition of this particular tribunal, that we have not yet got from the Minister on any stage of this Bill in this House or the other House, any clear idea or indication as to the personnel or qualifications of the people who will have the right to decide such important national issues. We do know that once they make a recommendation to the board the board must carry out their decision. As representatives of the people who provide the money, we believe and are convinced that it is essential in the national interest that a rail service should be maintained. If that service is to be maintained I think there should certainly be an appeal to the person charged with responsibility, namely, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. In the 1944 Act there was a provision under which certain formalities had to be complied with before a branch line could be closed. An inquiry had to be held.

The Minister is, after all, responsible and he should answer to the Dáil and the Seanad if any member seeks information. Ultimately he must answer to the people. He is charged with responsibility for sanctioning the closing down of a branch line. At least that was the position under the 1944 Act. Of course at that time we were dealing with a private concern and the only person who could give effect to Government policy was the chairman. With the passage of this Bill we shall find ourselves in the position of having nationalised the railways. Not alone is the Minister appointing the chairman but he is also appointing the board. I am sure that he will fully investigate their qualifications to take charge of such an important concern as this. Under Section 22 he further arrogates to himself responsibility for looking over the day to day activities of the organisation. I refer to the by-laws. He will examine such items as the time the trains should leave Westland Row for Galway.

Comment on this

That is not a by-law. That is a time-table.

Comment on this

The Minister must do that under this section.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Senator should not confuse time-tables with by-laws.

Comment on this

For Senator O'Farrell's information, the Minister may under the powers he confers on himself make by-laws for all or any of certain things; he may make by-laws for regulating the times of the arrival and departure of vehicles or craft.

Comment on this

But that has nothing to do with time-tables. That is dealing with general principles.

Comment on this

If Senator O'Farrell wishes to intervene I am quite prepared to give way to him.

Comment on this

Keep to the section.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes pointed out in the early stages of this Bill that it was what was in the Bill that mattered and not what was in the Minister's mind.

Comment on this

You made a tremendous effort to find out what was in my mind.

Comment on this

Senator O'Farrell is an expert and he acts as adviser to the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not claim to be an expert on anything.

Comment on this

I have drawn the attention of the House to the fact that the Minister is taking on himself the responsibility of deciding what time the trains should leave Westland Row for Galway. After all, Galway is only a small place; the fact of the matter is that the Minister is taking on himself that responsibility. But there is another responsibility he is not prepared to take. Senator Counihan—I am sorry he is not present at the moment—mentioned Ballinasloe fair. He pointed out that it is one of the largest fairs held in the West of Ireland. I am interested in another area served by a branch line. Now the Minister has not seen fit, for one reason or another, to give us any indication of the personnel of the proposed tribunal which will be charged with the responsibility of closing down branch lines. My amendment is a reasonable one. I am sure if it was left to a free vote of the House the present difficulty would be solved. At one time we hoped there would be freedom in this House.

Comment on this

There has always been a free vote in this House and there always will be.

Comment on this

The Senator cannot stomach that. It takes a little digesting.

Comment on this

After our experience last Thursday, it is a little difficult to believe that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not discussing free votes.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes borrows the answers to his own questions. I remember being elected to this House in 1938. At that time the present Minister for Education was the leader of what is now the Government Party.

Comment on this