Health Bill, 1952—Second Stage.
Contributions 91–227 of 227. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1952 ›
I am sure something has been read into Senator Baxter's remark.
Comment on this
I am asking the Senator to sit down. Senator Baxter.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated that it was argued repeatedly that when this legislation was passed there would be a rush on our hospitals. As I suggested already there are numbers of people going into all our hospitals throughout the year every year who need never be there. I am convinced that one of the first things that should be attempted is an educational plan in regard to the keeping of our homes in this country, in thousands and thousands of homes where there is a necessity for education. This is being done in other countries by different means and if it were done here the Minister would have a different problem with regard to hospitals. We have reached the stage when you would need a separate hospital for all the people injured in motor-cars every day here. There is not a day when eight or ten people are not brought into hospitals.
There is an aspect of this question which the Minister must take account before this measure passes at all. There are hospitals attempting to give services which are not anything like adequate to the needs of the areas. What does the Minister do? I can speak with knowledge as a member of a local authority. There is a hospital in my county town. Our public representatives were far-seeing and independent-spirited 30 years ago, just after the State was set up, and they spent thousands of pounds on reconstruction and on the building of a new wing to our county hospital. We did that, although we are a poor people in a poor county and though many of our wealthy neighbours did not bother about hospitals at all. If we had done nothing, perhaps we would have had a large contribution to-day from the Hospitals' Trust for the erection of a new hospital. Because our own people, out of their meagre resources, built up what they have, we now find we have no space adequate to our means.
At a county council meeting some months ago, we decided to ask the Minister to receive a deputation to hear our point of view and see if something could be done. We had a letter from the Minister, a courteous letter, in reply, and the Minister wound up by saying that he regretted that in the circumstances he could not contemplate extending the current building schemes by the inclusion therein of a new county hospital. He indicated, too, that he did not think there was any point in the council sending a deputation to discuss the matter with him, but if we insisted he would receive us. At present, if an accident or an urgent case comes into that hospital there is not a bed vacant or a chance of one. The conditions are just awful. At the present moment there may be a waiting list of 130 or 140. This matter was raised at the last meeting of the county council, when someone said there were 70 people on the waiting list two days previously; but someone who had come out of the hospital that morning said there were 120 waiting. Meanwhile, the Minister is talking about all this.
I am sure that position is not peculiar to our county but obtains up and down the country. What is the use in making a pretence of improving health services and providing institutional treatment when we have not the institutions? I want the Minister to tell me about that, as I cannot see any sense in this, nor does anyone in my county. It is no better in many of the neighbouring counties. Senator O'Reilly knows that many people come from his end of County Leitrim for treatment in Cavan Hospital and there is not enough room for them. Therefore, what is it but humbug, fraud and hypocrisy to be talking about improved health services? In Cavan we find that we are put at the end of a waiting list that is going to be looked over in seven years. That is as much as we can get from the Minister.
In the administration of these new services, anyone who can make any contribution to hospital treatment for themselves should be expected to make it; and that ought to be taken account of in accordance with their means. This idea of a free-for-all scheme, giving service to people who can pay, cannot be justified. It will sap and undermine the character of our people. That is inevitable. While we may go out to-day in a robust manner and proclaim the value of this scheme, I think some of the people here will live to see the error we have committed. That is the first objection to the scheme.
I also dislike a plan for health services where the Minister practically administers the whole of them by regulations which are to be made by him or by his civil servants. The regulations are to be transmitted to the local health authority—and who is that?
Comment on this
After being disapproved of by the Oireachtas. What are those opposite going to do if the Minister brings in a regulation and puts it on the Table? They are going to vote for it, whatever they think about it. Some of those over there know what I am saying is true. Some of them have experience of local administration and know what the consequences of this Bill will be. The regulations and decisions will be passed to the local health authority. Who is that but the county manager? Senator Hearne shakes his head, but he is not without experience, any more than myself, of the administration of local affairs. I do not know how intimate his experience is now, but I assure him that I rarely miss a meeting of my own county council.
Section 48 of the Bill says:—
"The council of a county (other than Dublin, Cork or Waterford) shall by resolution appoint a consultative health committee to advise the county manager on general matters (other than conditions of employment of officers and servants, the amount or payment of grants or allowances or the making of any service available to an individual) relating to the exercise of the functions of the council in relation to the operation of the Principal Act or this Act."
There are crossword puzzles which would be more easily solved than that, but the net result is that there is to be a health authority, that can be consulted, to advise the county manager. Has anyone had any experience of trying to advise county managers? I have. They listen and listen. Someone behind me suggests that they never learn. Are they going to carry out recommendations? They may, in some places.
Comment on this
It was at least as valuable as Senator Hartnett's and would not cost half as much. At least, they would not be charged as high a fee. If I attempted to charge it, I would not get it.
Comment on this
The next time I will charge the Senator twice as much.
Comment on this
As a member of a local authority, I know that the position in the local authority to-day is—I know we are to have an amendment of this —that you have executive officers, the county engineer, the county medical officer of health and the county surgeon; but you never saw the medical officer at a meeting of the county council or had any discussion with him on health services. Generally, as far as the administration of the public health services in the county is concerned, I do not know if other members have had experience, but I am speaking of my own experience, and I am just an ordinary member of a council. I suggest that members of the council of Cavan are just as intelligent as members of the councils in Leitrim, Longford, Monaghan or any of the neighbouring counties. We can just ask a question, and it is an awkward question, but I am only telling you what has happened and what is the situation to-day. Here we are now going to be taxed, as far as we can learn, to the tune of an extra £1,000,000 for the implementation of a new service, and what part have the local representatives to play in the operation of that service? I do not know, and I am against that.
I rate my intelligence and the intelligence of my colleagues on the county council as high as the intelligence of any county manager we have got to-day, and some of them have much longer experience. There are men in my county council, I should imagine, for 35 years, anyway. Senator Fitzsimons, my neighbour and a native of the county, knows some of these people very well and I would not put their judgment, their experience or their wisdom and common sense below any county manager in any county in the country to-day, and some of them do not belong to my political Party. Those people are not going to have anything to say to the new health service other than to advise the county manager on certain matters; and he is going to have everything to say about the conditions of employment of officers and servants, and mind you, the person who has that authority is the man who has most to say about how they behave and how they are going to act. He will decide on the giving of services and the payment of grants and allowances and the making of any service available to any individual. We will not have anything to say to that at all. I cannot understand how any member of a local authority would be prepared to accept the indignity of a situation like that and assent to it in this measure. I think it is fundamentally unsound.
Comment on this
But that is the position since 1942 under the County Management Act.
Comment on this
I believe myself that we are not getting good service. That is my opinion honestly and sincerely, and it does not matter what Minister is there, that does not make any difference, because so long as you have one person in that all-powerful position where he can disregard what anybody says I am convinced that you cannot get a good service for the people of the country which they ought to get. We are getting a terribly expensive service, but it is not more efficient, and that is the position to-day. A communication came before our county council following a sworn inquiry down there and in that document it was laid down by the Minister for Local Government that the manager was supreme to the county medical officer of health and the county engineer and that they were obliged to take his direction. It did not separate that, that he was supreme only on non-technical matters. As far as I could judge, hearing it read, it would apply if my wife was to be ordered into hospital for some sort of operation. I could not ask the county medical officer of health as to what ought to be done. That was the reading of it, and similarly in regard to the county engineer even on a technical problem the manager could direct him. That is the way that local affairs are being administered to-day.
As far as I am concerned, I dislike this measure. I think that much better could have been done. I think that health is just another service like agriculture, like education, like any other of the services of the Departments of State, in which we ought to be able to agree on what was the best thing to do. The Minister has spoken about the attitude of the Irish Medical Association and he has spoken about other interests. I do not know what the other interests were. It would be interesting to hear.
Comment on this
Suppose that I am opposing it, it is not because I am a member of Fine Gael. I am opposing it on the ground of common sense and giving good reasons why I dislike it.
Comment on this
I have said already that I believe it is immoral to expect you to make a contribution towards a health service for my family if I have some means to do it for myself. I believe that. I do not know what you believe about it. Anybody here can challenge that if they want to, but I think that is absolutely sound. I think this Bill is immoral, and that the more citizens we bring in under the canopy of the State and provide them with that sort of service the lower will our moral tone become.
Comment on this
The Senator may make a speech afterwards. Senator Baxter will proceed with his speech, and if we have no interruptions we will get somewhere, especially if the Senator would take the Chair's advice and not mind interruptions.
Comment on this
That is what I think about it on the moral plane. As far as we are concerned with the practical implementation and the operation of the measure I have given reasons why, as a member of a local authority and as a ratepayer, I dislike being put into the position, as a local councillor, of being responsible for imposing on the ratepayers of my county thousands and thousands of pounds for the implementation of these services while I find myself, as their elected representative, not able to have anything to say in regard to the administration of that service. I dislike that. I think it is a reflection on every member of every local authority in the country. It is very bad for the country if we are going to have a spirit of independence in the backwoods of the land. That independent spirit cannot stand up very long while we are breaking up the backbone of character in our people and creating a situation where they are just passive, not resisting any longer. The more you go on with that the more you destroy the foundation of this State. I think that it is immoral and highly unsound and anti-national, and I do not see anything whatever to commend it.
There is another major consideration. I do not think that the country can pay for these services. What are you going to do? What, I ask the Minister, is the position you are going to put me into if I have a valuation of £50 10s.? I will have to pay for my own health service and to pay for my neighbour in my rates. I do not think that that is right, and in fact I do not think that anybody could stand over that and justify it.
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Senator to be repeating himself over and over again?
Comment on this
The Chair will judge if the Senator is repeating himself, I assure you.
Comment on this
I put that to the House. I do not think any of us can stand over that. It may be that our resistance is so low that we are ready to swallow anything. I believe myself that we could have got something much better than this measure. We should have tried to get it. Even now we should try to get it. I do not know what you could do with regard to this measure. The Minister may make regulations with regard to everything in connection with our health service, and it does not satisfy me that they are to be laid on the Table of the House for annulment. That is not good enough at all.
I followed with great interest the very careful analysis of the Bill by Senator Jessop. I do not think anybody could quarrel with any comment which he made in that analysis. Some supporters of the Bill, of the measure of the ideal or of the concept may regard some of the criticism as unfair. We have heard what some members of the Irish Medical Association have had to say in regard to this Bill. There were days when, if it could be charged against them, it would be said that they were unpatriotic or when somebody would say that they were of the old ascendency, that they were out for distortion of facts, or something like that. However, not one of these charges can be made against them. I should like to make it clear that I have had no contact with them and that none of them have spoken to me on this matter.
The medical profession of this country are as fine a body of professional people as is to be found in any country in the world. They are not rich men —nothing of the kind. A very limited proportion of them may be wealthy but that cannot be said of the vast majority of them. Many of us know dispensary doctors up and down the country. We know them for what they are and for what they have been in the past 35 years. Many of them have made a notable contribution to the establishment of this State—quite a number of them in my own county. I cannot understand why anybody should allege that when these people speak they are not concerned for the health of all our citizens. I am convinced that they have spoken out of their ripe judgment and experience. I believe it would be much better for all of us if they had been listened to.
I must say that I agree with the other Senator who said that the comment by the Minister in regard to what he did when he went to the Custom House was rather unlike him. We in this House have had experience of the Minister over a number of years. We may have differed vigorously and violently but nevertheless that comment was unlike him. Suppose, for example, that he went back into the Department of Agriculture after Deputy Dillon went out of office and that he found the beet growers or the grain growers or some group of farmers in the offices of the Department consulting and debating about some plan or scheme in regard to agriculture. I wonder if the Minister would say that he ejected them. I do not think he would and I do not think he would do it either. I must confess that I did not understand him when he made that remark. I regret that that is the atmosphere in and the attitude towards this matter. I think it is bad for the future of our health services. I believe that that atmosphere has given us a document which is entirely different from what we would have got if the spirit had been different and until we get a new and a better spirit we will not get a Health Bill containing the kind of services that the country requires.
Comment on this
First, I should like to congratulate the Minister on having introduced this Bill and bringing it as far as it has been brought despite the steadfast opposition with which the measure has been faced. In the course of his generally reasonable contribution, Senator Jessop stated—I am putting a gloss on what he said, of course —in trying to explain away the uneasiness and the touchiness of the medical profession, that the doctors are bad politicians. I do not think the doctors are bad politicians at all.
In 1945, the Fianna Fáil Government made the first attempt at improving our health services. The medical profession defeated them. You all remember the Health Bill of 1947 and the opposition which it met. When the present Minister's predecessor proceeded to implement a section of the 1947 Health Act with regard to mothers and children you all saw how successful he was in his attempt to do so. How, then, can it be said that doctors are bad politicians? Not at all; they are very good, indeed. What other body in the country, what other section in the country, would have been able to hold up legislation in the way in which the medical profession has succeeded in doing so?
I am sure that the Minister must sometimes feel that he is in wonderland. For six weeks, he listened in the Dáil to a lot of filibustering claptrap from the leaders of the Fine Gael Party. In their opposition to the Bill in the Dáil, the Fine Gael Party was alone. The Labour Party and the two members of the Clann na Poblachta Party supported the Bill, together with a majority of the Independents.
The Minister must have read, as I did, a letter which appeared in the Irish Times of Monday, August 3rd, 1953, signed by J.F. Falvey, Hon. Secretary, The Irish Medical Association, 10 Fitzwilliam Place, Dublin. The letter itself is dated 31st July, 1953. The last paragraph of that letter reads as follows:—
"No amount of vituperation or misrepresentation of the medical profession on the part of the Minister will help in the present dispute. The Minister is well aware, and the public should know, that the Irish Medical Association's objections to the Health Bill are based on the principles of Catholic social philosophy, which are unshakable and unbreakable."
That, no doubt, was written with the authority of the body of which Dr. Falvey is the honorary secretary.
The Minister came into the House to-day for the Second Reading of this Bill. He heard a very pleasant after-dinner speech by Senator Barniville, who lightly criticised the Bill in a jocular way without ever touching on a specific point and stating that, at a later stage, he would have some criticisms to make. He said very little about the Bill in principle. I should have thought that if Dr. Falvey were correct, Senator Barniville would have told us specifically the unbreakable and unshakable principles which the Minister's Bill contravenes. I was disappointed. Of course, I did not feel that Senators Fearon and Jessop would speak with the same authority on that subject as I expected Senator Barniville to speak but, nevertheless, they are distinguished members of the Irish Medical Association. Both of them made what I can truthfully describe as reasonable criticisms, for the most part. One could not help feeling that, at times, they felt themselves under an obligation to voice the views of the Irish Medical Association but that there was very little conviction behind the voice.
Senator Fearon told us about the doctor-patient relationship. He gave us the very interesting viewpoint that, because of the complexity of modern medical techniques, so much of the work has to be done in the laboratory that the old relationship between the doctor and patient could no longer exist.
Senator Jessop dealt very carefully and very specifically with many aspects of the Bill. In the course of his remarks, he said that this Bill is a reasonably satisfactory one. He put it side by side with the British health service. I think that is a useful thing to do. I am sure that the Minister and his Department will profit from the experience of the medical profession in Britain in running the health scheme there. I want to make this clear beyond nay or yea, that when Senator Baxter states that the British health scheme is an insurance scheme, he is talking through his hat.
Comment on this
Does the Senator remember what Senator Hayes said— that the interrupter must take what is coming to him? So be careful.
Comment on this
I have read a letter from Mr. Aneurin Bevan and a letter from the present Tory Minister of Health in Britain to the effect that the scheme is a free-for-all scheme and that no contribution, good, bad or indifferent, is exacted from those who participate in it. If Senator Baxter spent some of the time he spends here in regaling the House in reading Hansard in the Library, he would discover that when the British public health service was being introduced, it was made crystal clear that it was a free- non-contributory scheme. The fact that he now interrupts and pipes "nonsense" will not succeed in altering the facts.
Comment on this
I am not giving way. If the Senator wants to interrupt he can do so, but I am not giving way.
Comment on this
I had a clergyman in the House this evening who paid 6/- per week to ït as an insurance.
Comment on this
Senator Baxter should really keep to his theology.
Comment on this
And Senator Hartnett should keep to the Bill.
Comment on this
When the White Paper was published, the kept organ of the Senator, the Standard, stated in an editorial that there were no ethical objections whatever to the provisions of the White Paper.
Comment on this
I never take a copy of the organ—I always borrow it.
Comment on this
If I am wrong I can be corrected by a subsequent speaker. I am positively stating that that appeared in an editorial in the Standard.
Comment on this
The Senator is not able to give the quotation?
Comment on this
I am not able to give the exact quotation. I sometimes have to read the Standard for professional reasons——
Comment on this
The Senator should not raise the point when he is not able to give the quotation. That has been the practice.
Comment on this
All I can say is that I read it in the Standard. If Senator Baxter says it did not appear, I will have to accept that.
Comment on this
As I was saying when Senator Baxter interrupted me——
Comment on this
This is the man who was crying for the protection of the Chair when Senators on this side were trying to educate him.
Comment on this
If the Senator would educate the House on the Health Bill, it would be much better.
Comment on this
I, in turn, claim the protection of the Chair. The British health service, as I think I have stated, is unquestionably a free service. I have no doubt that, as Senator Jessop has said, there are abuses of that service, but he told us that the doctors are not dissatisfied with it, although they miss the opportunity of giving the same kind of personal treatment as they formerly gave. I think I may link that up with what Senator Fearon said. Would I, as a layman, be correct in suggesting that nowadays the business of the general practitioner is to segregate the serious diseases from the trivial and that, if he suspects that a man is suffering from a serious disease, he sends him forward for diagnosis to a general specialist and that the patient then goes forward further to the specialist dealing with that particular kind of disease, if it has been so diagnosed? It is understandable that general practitioners may feel a little baulked in not having an opportunity to try their own skill to the same extent as they did before medicine became as complex as it is to-day.
He also told us—I trust I am not misquoting him—that the people, generally speaking, were satisfied with the British health service, but there is one thing which may be taken as a guide as to whether the people are or are not satisfied—the enthusiasm of all the British politicians for the British health service. During the last election, the struggle which occurred between the British Labour Party and the British Tory Party in claiming the authorship of the particular health scheme was positively unseemly. Nobody could have been more enthusiastic about the British health scheme than the British Prime Minister, Sir Winston Churchill. It is unlike politicians, as Senator Baxter well knows, to claim the credit for a measure which is unpopular with the people. I do not think that will be gainsaid.
Then again Senator Jessop referred to a case within his own experience of an English person over here who succeeded in getting treatment which would have been considerably deferred if he had been in Britain. I am sure that is one case, but may I, as a lay member of this House, say that I know of my own experience of at least 15 cases of persons who have gone across to Britain to receive treatment, free treatment—immoral though it may be —under the British health service? I am sure the Senator can recall a number of doctors who went across to have their own ailments treated in Great Britain—for what reason I have not got the faintest idea, but Senator Jessop may have.
Senator Jessop also told us that his experience of the family doctor was that he did not press for money. I am not suggesting for a moment that the doctor should not press for money. The general practitioner works very hard —probably harder than any other section of the community and it is only proper that he should be paid, and adequately paid, and, if possible, promptly paid, for his services. The point is: can people in the middle income group continue to pay him? Are they able to do it, or will they hesitate about calling him in and say:
"If it is going to cost me 10/6 or a guinea, I will take a chance. The child may be all right in the morning"? Then, of course, it may not. It would be a more convincing tribute to what happens in the out-patients' department of our hospitals if the tribute were given by somebody from the Dublin slums rather than by a distinguished medical professor.
I have no doubt that any of us in this House would receive excellent treatment. That is the very way of human nature, but very often where you have two-tiered medicine, treating patients who pay and patients who cannot pay, there will inevitably be a distinction between the treatment meted out to those who pay and that meted out to those who cannot pay. As I say, I have no doubt that we in the hospitals, as Senators, would be exceedingly well treated, but I would wish—if I may repeat myself—to have that tribute paid by Biddy Mulligan or by some very poor fellow from the slums of Dublin. It well may be that it could be paid—I am not saying it could not—but it would carry more conviction with me coming from that quarter.
As far as I can see Senator Jessop is the only person in the House who made anything like a reasonable speech. From Senator Hayes you had the usual vapid platitudinising which comes out of his mouth like ribbon out of a tape machine but Senator Jessop dealt with the matter otherwise. He says you will have people demanding attention because it is free. He says that happens in Britain. If it happens in Britain who is at fault but the doctor? He told us the story of the woman in hospital whom the doctor pronounced to be fully recovered and who says: "No, doctor, I am not. I am going to stay on for another week." Surely, if the doctor is a man he will go down to the office and say "Mrs. So-and-so is leaving to-day. I have decided that we have done everything for her that we can do". It is unfair to paint the doctors as if they were imbeciles. They are quite capable of handling a situation of that kind.
I think a lot of these things are variations of the Irish Medical Association arguments. I have here a document issued by the Irish Medical Association. It is entitled: "The White Paper on Health Services." It has a sub-title: "State Medicine is Bad Medicine." These are the arguments of the Irish Medical Association, which none of their members put in this House to-day. Apart altogether from the overriding, unshakeable and unbreakable principles of philosophy, there are these quotations: "What does the White Paper offer? Treatment only in public wards of hospitals." What an affrighting thought for people like Senator Baxter. What is wrong with treatment in public wards of hospitals, and if there is anything wrong whose responsibility is it? If there is anything degrading or anything which it not up to standard with regard to treatment in public wards of hospitals the responsibility rests on the medical profession and nobody else.
The next extract is: "Birth of your children in public maternity wards." Think of the number of people whose children are being born in public maternity wards. Is there anything wrong with it and, if so, why was the protest not made long ago? Ought they not have clamoured with the Customs House to put an end to this iniquitous situation in which the poor are obliged to have their children in public maternity wards? I go on: "Private treatment? Yes! If you pay for it yourself." That seems reasonable. If you want private treatment it does not seem unreasonable to be required to pay for it. "Your health and sickness recorded by the local authority in its files." That is another extract and it is the kind of thing that gets a person's back up. As the Minister pointed out in his opening speech there has not been much protest about the people who received their medical treatment hitherto under the dispensary system. I never heard any protest against what the poor had to suffer under the dispensary system. Furthermore, records are kept in all hospitals and if there are nosey parkers who are curious about other people's ailments they can stick their noses in the files in any hospital. There are even charts over the beds. "Your doctor ordered around by lay officials." This is where the hypocrisy and, if I may say so, the humbug of the Irish Medical Association comes in.
Senator Jessop made a very interesting point to-day. He told us that he had experience of serving on local appointments commission committees for the purpose of selecting applicants for posts in the mental hospital service. He told us that questions were put to them as to what they knew about the farm and that some applicants from England were horrified that a medical man should be required to have any responsibility for the hospital farm. It is quite wrong and unconscionable that a medical man should be required to be an administrator. The doctor is there to exercise his professional skill. He may be a first-class doctor, a brilliant surgeon or a superb psychiatrist and at the same time a very rotten administrator. There is no reason why the two things should go together. They cannot have it both ways.
I think it has always been the policy of the Department of Health that work of that kind should be done by lay officials and that the doctor should stick to his medicine. That has been resisted by the Irish Medical Association on the grounds that they were being pushed around by the officials and that they were not going to be pushed around any more. Certainly it is an interesting example of having it both ways. I continue to quote, Sir: "The red ticket goes—and the ‘coloured card' comes in its place". Of all the hypocrisy and humbug in the world that takes the biscuit. Did they protest against the red ticket or the poor law system under which the poor got their medical treatment? Never until 1945. They write it down here as if they always had been the champions of the rights of the poor.
I want Senators to take in the next quotation very carefully. I think it is really good. It is: "And, inevitably— wire-pulling and political influence in access to ‘benefits'." It just suggests wire-pulling and political influence "in access to ‘benefits'". I do not know what that means. I have not got the White Paper. I cannot refer to the paragraph which they must have had in mind in some strange sort of way for the purpose of distorting it, but people in glass-houses should be very careful not to throw stones. It would be interesting if one were to inquire as to how the appointments in certain hospitals and medical services not made by the Local Appointments Commission are made and who makes them, and whether there is any wirepulling or any influence. Of course, there is influence exercised in these matters. There was at least one speech made here to-day which I could have forecast to the last syllable practically, because it conforms with the analysis of the Health Bill which was issued by the Knights of St. Columbanus to its members.
Comment on this
To which Senator's speech are you referring?
Comment on this
I am referring to a document circulated amongst the Knights of St. Columbanus.
Comment on this
To the speech of which Senator are you referring?
Comment on this
If the Senator does not lay it on the Table he cannot quote it. Is the Senator quoting from this?
Comment on this
Yes. Here is an organisation—I do not know what medical qualifications its members have—which has made an analysis.
Comment on this
It is a private document. Do you want to give it publicity by putting it on the Table?
Comment on this
On a point of order. If the Senator is prepared to place on the Table of this House a document that he alleges came from a certain organisation he is within his rights.
Comment on this
I am asking if he wishes to put it on the Table.
Comment on this
There seems to be a suggestion that he is not within his rights.
Comment on this
If it is not to be laid on the Table of the House it cannot be quoted.
Comment on this
It is written by a correspondent of the Standard.
Comment on this
Is is going to be laid on the Table?
Comment on this
Certainly. I am quite willing to lay it on the Table. Most Senators on that side of the House have seen it.
Comment on this
It is definitely going to be laid on the Table of the House?
Comment on this
On a point of order. In accordance with the rules and orders of this House if a Senator purports to quote from a document which he says has emanated from an organisation which he names and further is prepared to put that on the Table of this House, then the Senator is entirely within his constitutional rights.
Comment on this
I agree. I want to find out definitely from the Senator if he is prepared to lay it on the Table.
Comment on this
Interrupters must take what they get. You know who wrote it.
Comment on this
The Chair has to deal with interrupters and will deal with them.
Comment on this
I am merely quoting Senator Hayes who said that it was parliamentary practice that interrupters must take what is coming to them. I do not know if you were in the Chair at that time.
Comment on this
Would the Senator now proceed to deal with the Health Bill?
Comment on this
Maybe I am being a little too disparaging; I suppose it is in some ways an encouraging thing to see an organisation such as the organisation to which I have referred taking such a keen, close interest in the health service.
Comment on this
The Knights of St. Columbanus. Senator Baxter will tell you all about them.
Comment on this
I am asking what proof is there to support the allegation the Senator makes that this document comes from the Knights of St. Columbanus? Who knows he has not produced the document himself?
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled in this matter. The Senator will see it.
Comment on this
The Senator is prepared to lay this on the Table of the House. It can be seen. Let there be no further discussion on it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. In my humble submission the fact that someone like Senator Hartnett is prepared to lay a document on the Table of the House is no proof of anything.
Comment on this
The Chair must accept his word and cannot do any more.
Comment on this
Senator O'Higgins has not interrupted.
Comment on this
He put a question which was not an interruption.
Comment on this
With respect to the Chair, may I say that Senator O'Higgins walked into this House and immediately proceeded to challenge a ruling that had been given by the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair did not hear it. Senator Hartnett.
Comment on this
The marginal notes to this Bill are interesting, showing the deep interest that is being taken. First we have criticisms of Bills. Then it says:—
“Christian Social Principles. | Is the Bill, then, unobjectionable from the stand-point of Christian social principles? To answer this we must consider some of these principles for a moment.”
It then goes on to deal with the fact that the end of man is supernatural, that such an end implies the perfection and happiness of man. Then it tells us: "Man cannot by his nature attain perfection in isolation," and then—I am skipping because it is very wordy:—
"The State exists for the sake of the persons who comprise it. Its end is the common good. Its function is to furnish the environment that men need to secure their needs on earth and to develop their faculties and personality to the full."
I do not want to bore the House, it has been bored enough already this evening, but it quotes other countries:—
"Other Christian countries have solved the health problem without such a service. In France and Belgium, medical welfare is provided through the State-assisted co-operation of employer and employee. In Ireland we have many outstanding examples of such co-operation without State encouragement. About 50 per cent. of Irish firms have some type of medical welfare for their workers. Many provide benefits also for the workers' dependents, as well as pension and social schemes. Far from being encouraged by the State, these are being discouraged——"
Senators will note that—
"—first by the State compulsory social welfare insurance—and now by the present scheme, which these firms and their employees will have to pay for in increased rates and taxes, although they do not need its services."
Then there is a boost for Portugal and Spain. It says that their health services are operated by the vocational groups. It does not give any further details. "Holland's by voluntary organisations, one Catholic, one Protestant and the third non-sectarian." We have not got the non-sectarian group in this country. The document continues:—
"Impoverished Italy is organising insurance schemes to which employers and workers contribute. When these are fully organised it is proposed to hand their administration over to vocational groups.... Even socialist England—"
and then the old error appears—
"retains the principle of insurance. In order to find a precedent for a State medical service on the lines now proposed we have to pass beyond the Iron Curtain."
Is that not really contemptible—not a single medical objection, not a single reasonable social objection but claptrap for the purpose of misguiding some of the innocent members of that organisation, if such there be, and that to have emanated from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office.
Comment on this
Does the Chair understand that that has emanated from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office?
Comment on this
This document emanated from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office?
Comment on this
I do not mean it is an official document, coming from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office, but I stand over what I said.
Comment on this
The Chair can hardly accept that explanation.
Comment on this
I would like the Senator to state in plain language what he means. Surely if it emanated from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office it must be an official document.
Comment on this
I am repeating it, Sir. I say it is not an official document.
Comment on this
The Chair and Senator Hartnett will deal with this matter. I do not know that it is a clear explanation. If it emanated from the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office it is surely an official document. The Senator must withdraw the remark.
Comment on this
It was written by a person in the Parliamentary Draftsman's Office.
Comment on this
The Senator is worsening the situation by bringing another individual into it.
Comment on this
Simpliciter, I withdraw. To conform with the ruling of the Chair, I am withdrawing.
Comment on this
May I say that if the Chair has any power to do so it should order that Senator Hartnett's remarks should also be deleted from the report.
Comment on this
Senator Hartnett has withdrawn this. This makes it clear it is not official. The Senator may proceed.
Comment on this
Beginning with Senator Hayes, Senators right down the line have emphasised the cost involved. The medical men with a great deal more reason have emphasised the cost of the scheme. Of course, the scheme may prove costly, but if anybody in this House had a child who was ill unto death and he had £200, £300, £800 or £1,000 in the bank, would he not spend it to save that child's life? Can the State do less for the children of the nation, whom we promised—or those who died for us in 1916 promised—to cherish equally? I do not see why the cost should be brought in, particularly by some of the Senators opposite. When the White Paper was published last year, I came in here and—a trifle irrelevantly, I confess—in the discussion on the Appropriation Bill I congratulated the Minister for Finance on having made the money available for the services outlined in that White Paper. I remember Senator P.F. O'Reilly standing up and saying: "Yes, I have the White Paper here and these are certainly excellent proposals, but the fact is that the Minister will never put them into operation".
Comment on this
He put enough of them to satisfy me and if it satisfies me that is enough.
Comment on this
The Senator has been shifting his ground so many times that it is not hard to please him.
Comment on this
Senator Hartnett should be allowed to continue.
Comment on this
So much for Senator O'Reilly's attitude. At the time when the Coalition was in power——
Comment on this
We are dealing with the Health Bill.
Comment on this
Surely I am entitled to deal with the antecedents? Everyone else has done so. At the time when the Coalition was in office and the then Minister for Health was introducing his mother and child scheme, Senator Baxter was an enthusiastic supporter of it.
Comment on this
A whole lot of men are impossible, if the Chair is any judge.
Comment on this
The Senator should be allowed to proceed with his speech. Senator Baxter got his opportunity. Senator Hartnett has to get his, and I hope he will be allowed to conclude without further interruption.
Comment on this
If the Senator has finished, may I continue? People want an improvement in the health services. In the Dáil, the Fine Gael Party said: "We do not worry about the cost, we do not care how much it costs." This was on the Committee Stage, after they had heard talk about a certain letter. They did not care how many millions it cost, the health of the nation was worth it, but they said this was a thoroughly bad scheme in its conception and they were going to oppose it root and branch, section by section, word by word. Now they stand up and talk about the cost. Senator Baxter drearily goes on and on—the cost, it will cost the people of Cavan so much. Even if somebody does profit under the scheme, someone who has been improvident and who has spent his or her money improvidently, should their children suffer because of that? Are the sins of the fathers to be visited on the children? Is that the social outlook of persons like Senator Baxter? I trust not.
With regard to the nurses, Senator Hayes, who was always a good politician, held forth on the treatment which was being accorded to the nurses. He said there was nothing in the Bill for the nurses. He must know that the nurses in local authority hospitals have better conditions in every way than those in other hospitals. No one will deny that. I join with Senator Hayes in paying tribute to the nursing profession. I would like to see them get better and better conditions and I am sure the Minister will try to ensure that.
I am sorry that Senator Barniville, in what I have already described as his pleasing, after-lunch discourse, should have attacked the permanent officials. I was glad to see that was rectified by Senator Jessop, who paid the highest possible tribute to their courtesy and efficiency. Of the two viewpoints, I prefer to accept that of Senator Jessop.
With regard to dispensaries, the physical condition of the dispensaries in many cases is undoubtedly very bad; but that is the responsibility of the local authorities. It is the business of the local authorities to see that they are improved and to bring pressure to get whatever grants they can to see that they are improved, instead of trying to make capital out of their bad condition.
Senator Jessop dealt with what the Minister said in the Dáil regarding his treatment of the doctors to whom the Custom House had been handed over by the then Taoiseach and Minister for Health, Deputy John A. Costello. Senator Jessop fairly stated that though the newspapers reported the Minister as saying merely: "Get out", the records show that the Minister had said: "I did not say that to them impolitely and I thanked them for their services; I told them it was my job to produce the scheme and not theirs." The Irish Medical Association, in the letter a paragraph of which I have already quoted, again selects one sentence of the Minister, "Get out", and leaves all the rest out—though they must have known what was on the record, as Senator Jessop knew. I think they must have decided to make a selection with regard to that matter.
Surely any democrat in this House must support the attitude of the Minister. Remember what was said at that time, remember what was said in the Dáil, by the then Taoiseach and Minister for Health, that he said to the Irish Medical Association: "Go and produce your own scheme and come back to me in a stated period of time with it." What would happen if every section in the country could get treatment of that kind? What would happen if the industrialists, whom I hear talking here about the heavy incidence of income-tax on their business, could be put in by the Minister for Finance to the office of the Revenue Commissioners and told: "Settle it up for yourselves, boys." Suppose the farm labourers were brought in to the appropriate Government Department and told: "Now, fix up what you want in the way of working conditions and pay, I will put it before the Dáil and have it approved." Would you not say that the Minister who acted in that way was, at the least, a very bad democrat? There is no reason why one section of the community should be preferred to another in matters of that kind. It was preposterous, it was outrageous, that that should happen when a controversy was going on between the Government and people outside. I move the adjournment of the debate.