Health Bill, 1952—Committee.
Contributions 1–135 of 260. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1952 ›
Under Section 2 it appears that the Bill, when it becomes an Act, will come into operation after an Order is made by the Minister. It provides also, quite properly I think, that different Orders may be made for different parts of the Act. Could the Minister say whether he has now any idea of the order in which the Bill, when it becomes an Act, will be put into operation, which part of it will come first? Has he any idea in his mind as to the order in which the different parts of the Bill will actually come into operation?
Comment on this
I am afraid I have not. It will be, I am sure, as Senators are aware, a matter for consultation between myself and the local authorities as to what particular parts of the Bill will come into operation first. I would not be able to give any indication at this stage of what these parts might be. Personally, I think that the section relating to maternity treatment and the section relating to hospital treatment will be the first to come into operation.
Comment on this
That also raises the question, which I think is relevant to Section 2, as to when the Bill will begin to come into operation. If you read Section 14, which is very general, and reflect upon the situation with regard to the dispensaries in the country and the actual physical space available, when could one expect that these general practitioner medical and surgical services would come into operation under Section 14? The Minister, surely, is not in the position that it is a question of this year, next year, sometime, never. There must be some idea as to when this would come into operation. Can Section 16, which deals with maternity treatment, be put into operation, for example, within six months after the passing of the Bill?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would also tell us whether the sections dealing with maternity will be brought into operation simultaneously all over the country. Will he, after consultation with the representatives of the health authorities, decide to make an Order that maternity facilities will be available to all those who are entitled to receive them in every health area through the country from Cork to Donegal on the same day?
Comment on this
It is possible that some of these provisions may not come into operation for all authorities on the same day. It is provided that they can be brought into operation for a certain number of authorities, perhaps a few months before the others, if the others are not altogether ready. As regards Section 14, that is only continuing what is there already. I do not think it will make very much difference at what time it is brought in because it is only continuing the dispensary and medical services as they are there at present. With regard to maternity and hospital services, I expect, anyway, that a number of local authorities will be able to put them into operation on 1st April next, the beginning of the financial year. If some of them were in a position to do it even earlier than that I would be very glad. I should like to be able to say definitely that they would be able to do that. If they are in a position to do that the necessary Order will be made.
Comment on this
Is there power here to put the Bill into operation regionally—to put it into operation, for instance, in one region first and later on in another region? I do not think the power is in Section 2.
Comment on this
If you turn to Section 22 you will see that it is made fairly clear there that it could be brought into operation for different authorities at different times.
Comment on this
The Minister said he hoped he would be able to bring the section of the Bill dealing with maternity services into operation by the 1st of April next. That is rather interesting and surprising news because the point of view held generally is that so far as maternity beds are concerned they are not anything like adequate to our means. Could the Minister give us an indication as to how he hopes to be able to bring the section of the Bill dealing with maternity services into operation by the 1st April? As far as my own area is concerned I would be very much surprised if this could be done owing to the lack of facilities.
Comment on this
Is it not doubtful whether Section 22 gives the power to which I referred? As I read the section, it deals with the regulations which will only be made when the Act has been brought into operation by Order?
Comment on this
It does give power to make an Order to bring the Bill into operation in the province of Munster but not in the province of Connaught. That would be my reading of it.
Comment on this
The Bill will be brought into operation by Order and regulations will then be made under the Order.
Comment on this
If it is brought in by Order, then by regulation it can be arranged for certain authorities to adopt it.
Comment on this
This question as to when this Bill is to be brought into operation is very important. It has been found from experience in other countries that when a Health Bill of this type is being brought into operation it is often better for many reasons to introduce it gradually. It has been the custom to introduce that part of the Bill which covers the major expenses of an individual or a hospital. In other words, they frequently bring in the hospitalisation part of the Bill first. It is easier to do the hospital side first. I should like to know from the Minister if he has any idea in his mind as to what he is going to do first about this Bill? If he intends to bring in the hospital side first, does he intend to bring that in soon?
We are up against certain difficulties. I have been associated with the staff of a voluntary hospital in Dublin since 1919 and I can claim to know something about the difficulties under which these hospitals have worked since that time. Although there have been in a few cases some small additions to the numbers of beds in hospitals in Dublin and throughout the country, we are all labouring under the same difficulties at the moment—we are very short of beds, not only in Dublin but everywhere else, particularly with regard to maternity beds. What I am going to say now holds good for all hospitals but especially for maternity hospitals.
Let us take one hospital in Dublin, the one with which I am associated— the National Maternity Hospital, Dublin. That was built and opened in 1935 and it was not completed until 1938. That hospital was built with the idea of accommodating 2,500 maternity patients per year. Last year, 4,500 patients were delivered in that hospital. It is grossly overcrowded. I think that overcrowding has a bad effect on the structure of the hospital itself in regard to wear and tear and it has a bad effect on the patients who go there. A number of these patients are obliged to leave the hospital as early as the fourth day and a number are obliged to leave on the fifth day. The same thing holds good in regard to the Rotunda and the Coombe hospitals.
In these hospitals we have tried as far as we could to get patients who live near the hospitals—people who we think will have normal deliveries —to stay at home and we send out the nurses and the staff of the hospitals to look after them in their own homes. In that way we are at the moment refusing admission to the hospitals of certain patients. Under this Bill every woman in the country is entitled to free treatment and so are people in the upper income class if they pay a guaranteed maximum of £2 in the year. Of course, that was a subterfuge on the part of the Minister to overcome a moral difficulty to which grave objection was raised. It has not overcome that moral issue. It is merely a subterfuge and pretence. From that point of view the Bill is just as bad as ever it was.
I object to the Bill because it is fundamentally wrong. I also object to the Bill because it is really very bad medicine from the medical point of view. If all these women are going to have access to hospital treatment under the Bill, they have the right to demand treatment in these hospitals which are already overcrowded. Where is the Minister going to put the patients? We will now have patients who have been accustomed to staying in their own homes and patients who went to the smaller nursing homes and paid their own way demanding treatment in hospitals so that the numbers looking for admission to the hospitals will be greater than ever before. Some of them will get in but who will suffer if they do? The poorer patient. There are a number of poorer patients who find it necessary to go to hospital because they have not the facilities in their own homes. Sometimes they apply for admission to the hospital just at the last moment and the hospitals are not able to take them in. That is going to happen in every hospital throughout the country. That is all I want to say about the maternity services.
The general hospitals, especially in the city, are overcrowded and there are not enough beds. We are going to allow in a huge number of patients who previously went to a nursing home or stayed in their own homes. They will want to be admitted to the hospitals and get X-ray facilities and all that. I want to know how the Minister intends to provide for that? Of course, it will be all thrown back on to the governors and staffs of the hospitals to make whatever arrangements they can. I think that is unfair. If this Bill is going to be implemented we are going to be swamped out with patients.
Comment on this
I do not want to confuse the different sections but it is quite impossible to get the kind of information one seeks without relating one section to another where a relationship exists.
Senator Hayes raised this matter about the commencement date. I have some experience as a member of a local authority, and when I turn to Section 16 I find the words "where the local authority shall provide". What is bothering me is that the section provides that the health authority shall provide so-and-so. Senator Cunningham has referred to the fact that people paying £2, no matter what their income may be, will be entitled to treatment. Suppose, for example, somebody goes into a hospital as things are at the moment and alleges negligence against the hospital authorities. We see cases of that kind reported fairly frequently in the newspapers. These cases go into court and sometimes damages are awarded. In some cases, a death may have resulted from what is alleged to be negligent treatment in a hospital. Suppose somebody seeks admission to one of these local authority hospitals in which the local authority is obliged to provide accommodation for those people who have paid a fee. The fact that they have paid the fee entitles them to accommodation in the hospital. If, however, as a result of a bed not being available in the hospital for a patient to be treated in time and a death occurs or a more serious condition develops as a result of the local authority's inability to take the patient in in time to give the treatment which it is obliged under the law to give, where will the local authority stand in a case of that kind? I am sure I do not know. I should like to hear from the Minister what the legal position will be so far as the health authority is concerned if the case be that it was physically impossible for it to provide the accommodation which, under the law, the Minister demands it must provide.
That is why I say that the question raised by Senator Hayes is of considerable importance—that is as to when the commencement date is to be. I pointed out on the Second Reading of the Bill that, in my county, you may have 100 people on a waiting list who want a bed in the surgical hospital which cannot be provided for them. Some of those people may die because that accommodation is not available. There is that problem to be considered. I do not know that there is such an obligation on a local health authority at present, but I am anxious to know what the position will be if this Bill becomes law. Does not that raise the whole question of the commencement date? I suggest that it does, and that it is a matter of fundamental importance.
Comment on this
Senator Baxter has mentioned the County Cavan. I think that the County Cavan is exceptional. At least, for some months back anyway, I have been coming across complaints from the Country Cavan about a long waiting list for the county hospital. I have not got the same complaints from other counties. We must not, therefore, take it that the whole country is in the position of having 100 on a waiting list so far as the county hospitals are concerned. It is regrettable, of course, that there should be waiting list at all, but even if there was a waiting list of 100 in the case of every county I do not see why everybody should argue from that that this Bill is impossible or unnecessary.
What we are providing here is that we will pay the hospital bills for certain people which are not being paid at the moment. If any Senator argues that because we are going to pay the hospital bills for people who will accept hospital treatment, for people who otherwise would not accept it, I think that is a very good argument for the Bill. It proves that there are people in this country—and I believe it to be so—who need hospital treatment but cannot afford to get it. If the fact that we are providing hospital treatment free for them will mean that there will be a rush to the hospitals well that, I think, is a very good argument that the Bill is necessary.
We have been providing additional hospital beds all the time. I have not the figures with me at the moment. I quoted them several times in the Dáil debates on the Bill and I can quote them again before the debate on the Bill concludes here. The fact, however, is that several thousand hospital beds have been provided within the last ten, 15 or 20 years, and I am quite sure that we will have to provide plenty more. We have a number of hospitals under construction at the moment, regional hospitals in different places, and county hospitals. We are dealing with that matter as quickly as we can. The same thing, to some extent, applies to maternity beds. What we are doing in this Bill is, we are providing that we will pay the maternity bills for certain women who have to pay them at the moment themselves, but we are not in any way encouraging these women to go into hospital. There is no reason why they should not stay at home. If they do stay at home we will pay their bills, and I do not see why they should not stay at home. Therefore, I do not see why the hospitals should be in any way more crowded than they are at the moment.
I would like to say that when the present scheme of hospital building is completed, that is, the hospitals that are at present authorised or under construction, we will have beds for 65 per cent. of the maternity cases in the country, and, in addition to that, 24 per cent. in private hospitals which are not under the local authorities. These two figures give a total of 89 per cent. That figure is far and away higher than the accommodation that is provided either in Great Britain or in the Scandinavian countries. We know that the Scandinavian countries are often held up to us as models of hospitalisation, but the fact is that we are going to provide more maternity beds here than they provide in those countries.
I think that the objections which are being made to this Bill, as regards the impossibility and so on of what it proposes, arise from hostility to the Bill—because we are providing these facilities. Under this Bill, we will pay the bills of certain people which are not paid at the moment.
As regards this £2 per person, I want the sympathy of the Seanad on this. I met the Catholic Hierarchy and they agreed to a certain thing. In spite of that, I am told by Senator Cunningham that it is immoral. Therefore, Senator Cunningham is not only accusing me of doing something immoral but he is also accusing the Catholic Hierarchy of conniving at something that is immoral. I cannot deal with anything like that. What I mean is that if any ultra Catholic here wants to be more Catholic than the Irish Hierarchy, well all I can say is that I cannot come up to his standard. I think I am doing fairly well in coming up to the standard of the Catholic Hierarchy. I do not propose to come up to Senator Cunningham's standard of Catholic morality. This is not a subterfuge. I believe myself that, under this provision, the women who come into it will be paying half the cost and the Catholic moralists I was dealing with said that was fair enough. They thought that was fair enough from the Catholic point of view. Senator Cunningham does not think it is fair enough. As I say, I cannot come up to Senator Cunningham's standard. I have to be satisfied with what ordinary people like the Catholic Hierarchy and myself agree is fair enough, and I have to do with this £2.
Why should the type of woman who hitherto has had her baby at home want to go to hospital? When this Bill is passed we will pay her bill for her, and why should she want to go to hospital? Why should she not continue to have her baby at home? The only explanation that I can see for the arguments that are made is that they just indicate hostility to the Bill. There can be no other explanation. Whether a woman stays at home or goes into hospital, her bill will be paid for her. If she has been having her babies at home, why should she now make a change and say that she will go into hospital for the next baby unless she has the idea of Senator Cunningham of making the Bill impossible? But common-sense people do not do that kind of thing. I do not think that the hospitals are going to be overcrowded. In any case, when our present programme of maternity hospital building is through, we will have more beds for maternity cases in this country than there are in any other country that I know of and definitely more than they have in Great Britain or in the Scandinavian countries. I think that is fairly good.
Comment on this
The Minister put forward the argument that from the time this Bill is brought into effect people who have not been able to get medical treatment previously will go to hospitals and that that is a very good argument for the Bill. He must know as well as we all know that that is not accurate. No patients at the moment are deprived of medical treatment of any kind because of expense or because of their inability to pay. They are all provided for either in hospitals, as semi-private patients or in private nursing homes.
On one occasion when I met the Minister I asked him if it had ever been reported to him or to the Department of Health within his knowledge that any maternity patient had suffered or had died because she could not find a doctor or could not get proper medical attention and he very truthfully said to me: "No, it had not," and that holds good for everything else. We have had a lot of nonsense talked in this country about people not being treated and not being looked after because of their inability to pay. I visited most countries in Europe and recently I visited hospitals in America. I know exactly what provisions are there and I can say without any fear of contradiction that as far as maternity services are concerned the people in this city are as well looked after as anywhere except for one thing and that is the shortage of hospital accommodation. They are better served by the doctors and at a lower rate; the standard of medical treatment they get is renowned everywhere. I think the same thing applies to the majority of our hospitals.
The Minister also raised the point as to why a patient who formerly had her baby in her own home should now want to go to the hospital and why the maternity hospitals should be more crowded. I will deal with that on another section of the Bill when we come to it. The Minister says that when the hospital scheme of building is completed we will have beds for 65 per cent. of maternity patients and that nursing homes will provide 24 per cent. of maternity beds. If that number is provided it is far too many in my opinion. There will always be a certain number of patients who will have their babies in their own homes and he is overestimating in this respect. I do not know how it is proposed to provide these beds in hospitals for 65 per cent. of maternity patients, where the hospitals will be or when they are going to be built. However, if they are going to be built at the rate hospital building has gone on in the past, neither ourselves nor our children will live to see them. Planning has been proceeding in this connection for 20 years. New plans are being brought up year after year and nothing is being done. The whole thing is disgraceful. I just want to say one word about the morality question.
Comment on this
I do not think the Senator can raise that now. It is not relevant.
Comment on this
On a point of order, we are dealing with this Bill in Committee and although we are supposed to be discussing a particular section it appears that there is going to be a roving commission all over the general principle of the Bill which has been accepted. Second Reading speeches are being made on a section which merely provides for the coming into operation of the Bill. I feel that the Chair should rule firmly that speeches will be relevant to the section under discussion.
Comment on this
The question at issue is whether this section makes provision for powers for the Minister which are, in fact, powers the Minister can exercise. Surely a member is in order in asking the Minister how he proposes to exercise them, when and under what conditions, and is revelant in indicating that it would be very, very difficult for the Minister to exercise these powers. I agree entirely with Senator Hearne that the Bill has passed the Second Reading Stage and that we should not have Second Reading speeches but I do suggest that the speeches so far have been concerned with powers which it is proposed to give the Minister under this section and how and when they are going to be exercised.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that there is nothing in this section which deals with the morality of the Bill?
Comment on this
I put a question to the Minister to which he has not yet replied. I am concerned as to when the commencement date of this will be. The Minister said a few moments ago that when the present building programme is completed there will be ample maternity beds in the country. He also said that he hoped that the section of the Bill dealing with the maternity service would be brought into operation by the 1st April. Does that mean that his building programme will be completed by the 1st April? If not, is he going to impose on local authorities the obligation to bring into operation the service which people are entitled to have on the payment of a consideration and, if the service is not available, where does the local authority stand? Have those people who have paid for this service and who are unable to obtain it cause for action against the local authority? This is a very grave matter.
The Minister says he thinks Cavan is unique in the difficulties it has experienced with regard to hospital accommodation for patients. May I say that we have probably spent more money out of the ratepayers' pockets in our county on the reconstruction of our hospitals than has been spent in many more counties, counties that are more wealthy? Nevertheless, the accommodation is not available. Therefore, as a member of the local authority, I am concerned as to when the commencement date is to be. The Minister may bring the Act into operation in certain areas where there is accommodation but it does not seem from anything which has been disclosed by him in his speech or from anything Senator Hayes is able to elicit from the Bill as it is that the Bill is to be brought into operation for three, four or five counties on this date while other counties are excluded. Would the Minister clarify that vital matter for me on this section?
Comment on this
I am assured by my legal advisers that it is possible to bring different provisions of this Bill into operation at different times, hospital treatment, one time; dental treatment, another time; maternity treatment, another time; and so on. It is also possible under Section 22 to bring it in at different times for different areas. Even though it does not appear that way to Senators, I am advised legally that it is possible. What I intend to do is to make an Order when I think certain counties are ready, let us say, to bring in hospital treatment. The Order having been made, the counties can adopt it at their own will. I do not say that we will allow them to delay too long but after a reasonable time we will urge those lagging behind to come along and put it into operation.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister on the Second Stage whether the provision of the Principal Act which says that regulations made under the Principal Act must be tabled and may be annulled by resolution of the Dáil or Seanad applies to this Bill, and he said it did. Is sub-section (3) of Section 3 the part he is relying on now for that; that is to say, is the Minister advised that any regulations made under this Bill will be laid upon the Table of the House and may be annulled? This Bill provides for regulations and Orders. Will Orders as well as regulations be tabled? Speaking subject to correction by the Minister—I am not familiar with the matter—I do not find any Orders in the Principal Act.
Comment on this
Only regulations, not Orders. Will, for example, repeals and alterations of regulations also be tabled?
Comment on this
Regulations and appeals, but not Orders. There are important powers of the Minister in the way of making Orders under this Bill in many places—all kinds of Orders, even the Order mentioned in Section 2, which is very important, and other which are very important for various people. It is only the regulations that will be tabled, not the Orders?
Comment on this
How are the people to be made acquainted with the Orders and what is contained in them?
Comment on this
The Order will have to be published, naturally, and sent to the local authorities, too.
Comment on this
Take Section 9, the power of the Minister to make an Order there. It gives complete power to him over hospitals to divide them in any way he pleases; to define the particular treatment which may be given in a particular hospital, or the particular treatment which may not be given in a particular hospital. All these Orders will not appear at all on the Table of the Dáil or Seanad.
Comment on this
When the Minister says they will be published, where will they be published?
Comment on this
I could not answer that question offhand. Orders will have to be published, I take it, in Iris Oifigiúil or in the daily papers. I think the principal object in publication is to make the local authorities aware of what the Order contains. They will naturally get a copy of the Order. It depends to a great extent on what the Order is, of course.
Comment on this
If I may say so to the Minister, I do not think he is right. I think Orders in Iris Oifigiúil are published in accordance with the provisions of a section of an Act, but there is no such provision here. I take it that an Order under Section 9 will be sent merely to the health authority concerned and will not be published to anyone else. It is difficult enough to keep track of all the Orders, but if they were here in the Library anyone interested could do something about them. There is a great number of Orders made here, apart from regulations, and it seems to me they should come under the same rule as regulations under the Principal Act.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us what is the usual procedure in a Bill of this kind? Are Orders usually published or are they not?
Comment on this
Orders are referred to in other Acts. Are they published normally or are they not?
Comment on this
The usual practice is to publish Orders in the daily papers. Some of them are published in Iris Oifigiúil. I am told that even that is not absolutely necessary. I think Senator Hayes is right there, in regard to Section 9. An Order of a type that concerns only one local authority probably would not be published but sent only to that particular authority.
Comment on this
I can say that so far as the Department of Industry and Commerce is concerned the practice is to publish a notice in the newspapers which no one can understand—but if you send to the Publications Office you can get a copy of the Order.
Comment on this
The Minister makes an Order and it is dispatched to the local health authority. They meet once a month. The document may be received two or three days after the meeting of the body concerned, so it will not come to the notice of the local representatives until the next agenda comes out in three weeks' time. The Order is in operation and nothing can be done about it after 21 days. Even the Minister may at times be glad to have certain things brought to his notice and to have an opportunity of withdrawing or amending an Order. There ought to be some provision made for that. The Minister finds fault with people who are raising questions about this Bill. There are so many things which are not clear in it and which none of us can understand that naturally we are questioning about them. If the Minister is able to inform us reasonably about them, it will go some way to a better understanding and appreciation of the position.
Comment on this
I am only too anxious to give the Senator any information I can, but some of the questions are rather hard to answer straight off. The general practice with regard to Orders is to have them published in the daily papers if they are of general application, but where they apply to one local authority only they are not published but are sent to that local authority. It would be an enormous task for Senators to deal with all the Orders made by all Ministers. If they all make as many Orders as I do, it would be very difficult. We make an enormous number of them every year, some of very minor importance but others of more importance. As in the case of Section 9, to which Senator Hayes refers, an Order may be a serious matter, I admit.
Comment on this
No, that one would be of particular application. It is not so easy to get over these matters. I do not know whether we could get over this in any way. I should say that it would scarcely be possible for members of either House to follow all the Orders that are made.
Comment on this
It would be desirable —I do not want to put it into the Bill —that all Orders should be found in the Library. I think that is so in the case of social welfare.
Comment on this
I cannot imagine any Orders regarding social welfare that are not of general application. They concern so many people, probably 500,000 people, and naturally should be published.
Comment on this
I was not saying these should be published but simply that they should be put in the Library. Then any member of the House can, if he likes to go to the trouble, get a copy. I think that is reasonable, that it would not cost much and that it would be worth while.
Comment on this
Should the phrase there not read: "Nothing in this Act or in the Principal Act"? Or is it quite clear that if they are construed together it does so apply?
Comment on this
That is the intention; but I believe the other wording would be better.
Comment on this
Does not sub-section (2) of Section 3 cover that point?
Comment on this
Sub-section (3) provides that "a reference in the Principal Act to that Act," etc. Then I begin to wonder what a reference in this Act means in relation to something done under the Principal Act. I think the intention is to cover all the health services as operated by the two Acts. The matter should be looked into to see if it would be necessary to add "or in the Principal Act".
Comment on this
It does not concern anything that may be covered with regard to health or hospital services, maternity, and so on.
Comment on this
This Section 4 is intended as a general saver for the patient. In itself it cannot achieve that end, as very often the patient does not know what is going on; something may be done which interferes with his principles and the patient does not know about it. It is difficult to have a saver of any kind and make certain to cover everything. There is one great omission, that is, the doctor.
There is no saver for the doctor in this and there ought to be. After all the doctors are the people who, if they decide to do so, will work this Bill and I think it is very important that the doctors should also be protected. Psychiatry has become a very important feature of the medical practice at the moment. It is a feature far more important in some countries than it is here and from the point of view of saving the doctor it is very important that there should be protection because he may be called on to carry out certain matters in accordance with the Freudian theory to which he may himself object, but there is nothing to protect him. Furthermore, the doctor may be told by the Minister—I am quite sure Dr. Ryan would never tell him but after all Dr. Ryan will not always be the Minister for Health in this country and we might have somebody who would adopt these ideas and a doctor might be told to conduct a birth-control clinic or that he must carry out an investigation, for example, of sterility in certain ways which might be objectionable although there are several other ways of doing it which are not objectionable. The doctor gets no protection under the Bill and I think a small clause which includes the doctor as well as the patient should be introduced. I think it is rather an advantage, as it were, and I think it would be on the part of the Minister a friendly gesture towards his colleagues.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Senator that if the day comes when such directions will be given by a Government it will not matter a hoot what safeguards are in this Bill or any other Bill to safeguard the doctors or anyone else because then you will have a Government in power able to enforce its will on the country irrespective of what anybody wants?
Comment on this
Senator Hearne knows as well as anyone else that there are Orders being made to-day by Government Departments and by Ministers and if the Oireachtas and members of the Oireachtas appreciated what they were doing when the legislation was being passed many of these. Orders would never see the light of day.
Comment on this
That, I say, is a complete reflection on a body established by this House, the Statutory Rules and Orders Committee, and the chairman of that is a member who sits on the Senator's side of the House. The active members who are terribly anxious to protect the people's rights are on the other side of the House, and if such Orders are being made the Statutory Rules and Orders Committee is not doing its job.
Comment on this
If some people were not as subservient as they are, there would not be power to issue these Orders at all. It is only when an Order has been issued that we hear about it.
Comment on this
If Senator Hearne's point has any validity in regard to doctors, it also has validity with regard to patients and sub-section (2) should not be in at all, and therefore no safeguards should be in. Probably, the Minister will take the line that Ministers nearly always take, that the Minister is a reasonable man who will not do anything unreasonable and everything will be all right.
Comment on this
I was not going to take that line at all. The same question was raised in the Dáil as has been raised by Senator Cunningham. I do not think it is necessary to protect the doctors. If a doctor says he will not do a certain thing, he will not do it and nobody is going to make him do it by putting something in here. That would not make the slightest difference. Senator Cunningham mentioned the carrying out of psychoanalysis on the Freudian theory. I do not know much about the Freudian theory—I did read something about it —but if a doctor is going to do these things whether we put it in here or not he will do them, and if he is not going to do them he will not do them. I think a doctor is quite well able to look after himself. That is the only answer I have.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister a question I indirectly asked him during the discussion on the Second Stage of the Bill: Is he really averse to the idea of setting up a national consultative council to help in the making of these regulations? We are assembled here to do the best we can for the health of our people but also to protect democracy, and under this section, the Minister of the day may make any regulation he thinks fit in his absolute discretion for the management and conduct of health institutions. I believe it is contrary to democratic principles to entrust such enormous— such unlimited—power in the hands of a single individual, and I suggested during the Second Reading that a consultative council should be set up which would consider any far-reaching and momentous regulations, and where a Minister disagrees with the findings of a consultative council he might submit the controversial matter to both Houses of the Oireachtas giving the arguments put forward by the council and his reasons for not accepting their decisions. I think that would be a very great help at this very difficult stage—the birth pains of the Bill—if there were a national central advisory council of some sort to deal with these regulations. I understand that regulations are always available for us, whereas Orders under regulations may or may not be available. I am referring here to regulations the Minister will make under this Bill. I feel if the regulations were made with the co-operation and assistance where necessary of the advisory body it would strengthen the Minister's hands and it would make us as guardians of democracy easier in our minds and would facilitate the initial period of the Bill. I know the Minister has several expert advisory bodies at present, but this would be a body set up for this purpose, for the drafting of these regulations, and I would be very glad to know if the Minister has any real objection to the establishment of such a council.
Comment on this
I think the Senator is advocating a reversal as it were of what is provided here. Section 41 provides for the amendment of the National Consultative Council that was there under the Principal Act, and it suggests very many amendments which give that council a fair amount of power—not to make a final decision, but of being independent of the Minister. More than half of the members are elected representatives. They meet independently of the Minister, and he is not present at their meetings. He must submit all regulations to them for their comments and if he ignores their comments their annual report will probably tell all about it. That report will be published so that members of the Dáil and Seanad will get to know what their comments were on any matter the Minister might turn down. That is where the Minister takes the initiative. The Minister makes the regulations and they comment on them. The council might make the regulations and the Minister might adopt them or change them and then—well, the difference of opinion would come out and be eligible for discussion before the Dáil and Seanad. I do not think it makes much difference except that being a Minister rather than a member of the Consultative Council, I think it is quicker the way it is in the Bill, but the net result would be much the same as far as disagreement goes.
Comment on this
That may be, but it seems to me that in Section 8 sub-section (1) the Minister can have his own way entirely and completely and I think that co-operation such as I advocate at this stage would be very valuable indeed.
Comment on this
Of course any regulation made under sub-section (1) will be submitted to the council for its comments and if the Minister does not adopt the council's suggestions, then that will appear in the annual report and members of the Dáil and Seanad will have an opportunity of criticising the Minister.
Comment on this
The annual report will not be available when the regulations are laid on the Table of the House.
Comment on this
I approach this matter from a different angle from that of Senator Fearon. This section is the pivotal section of the whole Bill. Under this the Minister will run the entire health services of the country. He will make regulations applicable to every health institution. I think that a health council is a valuable institution. This section empowers the Minister to make regulations as to how every health authority in the country will conduct its business and as to how every institution will be run and managed. Senator Fearon used the word "undemocratic"; I think this section is thoroughly undemocratic but there is even something more than that to it.
The Minister must appreciate the fact that under the health services the ratepayers in every county will be responsible for 50 per cent. of the expenditure on such services. Quite frankly I object to any Minister in the Custom House determining how every institution will be run and making regulations in connection with such institutions. I object to any Minister determining how the money will be spent. That is what this section amounts to. I firmly believe that there should not be taxation without representation. Under this section the Minister is taking powers to determine how money provided for health services will be spent. I think that is thoroughly unsound. But it even goes further than that. It shows a lack of confidence in the competence of our people to make any contribution as to how their affairs should be managed. I am not one of those who has so little faith in the ability of local representatives or so little faith in the future of our country as a whole that I am not prepared to say there is no one who ought to be taken into consultation with the Minister when he is making regulations as to how our health services should be run. Those of us who live in close proximity to the people and to those who man our health services—the local surgeon, the county medical officer of health and their assistants—ought to be called into consultation because it is our money that will be spent plus any grants that may come from the Minister or his Department.
I view this approach with grave concern. The Minister may tell me that this is being done to-day. We may be making regulations to-day but under this section the Minister intends to go much further than that. If all these health services are to be run from Dublin is that not a confession of bankruptcy so far as the rest of the country is concerned? Is it not a confession of bankruptcy if the country representatives here are not prepared to stand up and speak against the introduction of this entire principle? I believe that any Minister for Health can get valuable advice and counsel from those who are associated with local authorities and who know the difficulties and the problems confronting those who finance and manage these institutions. I am convinced that the Minister will help the development of health services here if he is prepared to set up some organisation or group of representatives to co-operate with him in the framing of regulations for the running of these institutions because in that way he will be in a position to call upon the experience of local people who can give valuable counsel in problems of this kind.
Comment on this
This is the most tightly drawn Bill I have ever seen. Section 8 gives the Minister power to make regulations. The Minister says that in his point of view this will be the swiftest method. It certainly will be. That is, of course, an argument for dictatorship: it is a swift method. It may within certain limits be extremely competent but the Minister also states that even if, as Senator Fearon has suggested, there was a consultative council the result would be the same: that is to say, the Minister would listen to what the council had to say but take his own line after all.
Taking Section 8 with the other sections in the Bill I think it should be made clear that the Minister will under regulations made by himself completely control the local authorities. They will have no power to make any orders, regulations or arrangements save under regulations made by the Minister or with the consent of the Minister. In that way he will completely control local authorities. He will go a long way, too, towards completely controlling all kinds of hospitals because other sections of the Bill provide that a hospital may make an arrangement with a local authority. If it does not make an arrangement with a local authority under regulations made by the Minister, then it may be squeezed out of existence.
Other sections of the Bill provide that doctors may make agreements with local authorities, again under regulations made by the Minister and not under regulations made by the local authority. Charges and everything else will be defined by the Minister. If a doctor does not make an agreement he may find his livelihood gone. The only way in which he will be able to live will be by making an agreement with a local authority under regulations made by the Minister.
Hospitals are in the same position. Ultimately patients will be in the same position because they will have to go where they are sent. Everything comes back to the Minister. While that may be swift from one point of view it will certainly lead to an extraordinary bottleneck in administration because it will fill the new building in Store Street with files. As I read the Bill, the most minute details will be decided at headquarters in Dublin and nowhere else.
This is the operative section of the Bill and the Minister gets power under it to do anything and everything he pleases. He makes provision in Section 41 for consulting a particular council but he will have made his regulation prior to that consultation and the regulation will have come into operation before anyone knows what the council thought in the particular matter.
This section will give birth to the most rabid centralisation. The Minister will have control of local authorities, of hospitals, of doctors and ultimately of patients. The section is strengthened by other sections, such as Section 22 which the Minister has already quoted. Even under Section 20, if a person has received some kind of medical appliance and that appliance has to be replaced a peculiar position will arise. If the county manager or the local authority thinks there has been negligence on the part of the person using the particular appliance it can only be replaced at such charge as may be approved of or directed by the Minister. I gather from that that the Minister will have power to decide how much Paddy Murphy in Ballyporeen will be charged for some kind of appliance if someone thinks there was negligence in the user of that appliance. I have never seen such extraordinary powers taken by a Minister hitherto. Section 8 is the section upon which this Bill is built. It gives all power to the Minister and nothing can be done about that power.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Senator is exaggerating somewhat. To some extent this Bill introduces new provisions. It is also, however, replacing provisions already in existence. We are, for instance, repealing the Public Assistance Acts and re-enacting in this measure certain provisions in those Acts. This re-enacts what was in Section 34 of the Public Assistance Act, 1939, and also Section 18 of the Health Act of 1947. So, it is only renewing a power that was already there. I think I am right in saying that if we go back to the 1939 Act that was repealing the Poor Law Act that had been in existence for some 50 to 60 years before that, it is carrying on the same power that has always been there.
Since 1947 there would appear to be more force in giving this power to the Minister than there was before, because since 1947 the Minister is paying half the costs of these services to the counties and he naturally should have some say, therefore, in how the money is being distributed.
Comment on this
When he was paying none of it and the councils were paying the whole lot he had the same control. Now that he is paying half the costs, he should have the same control.
Comment on this
That is very bad mathematics and an extremely loose and weak argument. In effect, it means that the Minister has nothing to say except that the Minister should have this power.
Comment on this
Does the Minister challenge the truth of what I say, that there are in this House representatives of local authorities who know as much about the business of managing a local authority as any Minister who has sat in the present Minister's chair or any of his advisers know? I do not think that can be challenged. They are men who are unselfish and who have given a great deal of time to building up local institutions. I do not understand the mentality. I confess I do not understand the present occupant of the office. In my long experience, I have always found him at least ready to listen to what people have to say. If, under this Bill, you are now going to draft regulations and are setting out on a new and wider field, can the Minister see any objection, before he puts regulations for the management of any particular institution into operation, to providing that a copy of the regulations would come to the responsible local authorities and that they would be asked for their comments before the regulations would be implemented? That is the least that people who are paying half the cost should expect. It would be common courtesy. If you want good administration and the aid and co-operation of intelligent local administrators, that can be attained by the Minister approaching the problem in that manner. In that way he will get intelligent assistance from members of local authorities in regard to the administration of health services in future. If the health services are to be developed and built up on the work of an inspectorial staff coming from the centre down to the local institution for a few hours in the month, the service will not be what any of us would like it to be.
The Minister ought to approach this matter from the point of view of building up in the remotest corners of the country the people who will be intelligently interested in the development of public work. There is not much point in intelligent people attending meetings of local authorities to discuss health service affairs if they have not any right whatever to make any suggestion, if all their activities are governed by regulations made by the Minister or by his staff and about which they have never been consulted until they see them being implemented. It is all wrong. It is unsound. It is bad from the point of view of developing in our people that spirit and character and will to do better which we want to cultivate so that the country may progress.
Comment on this
The Senator may not realise that in practice what the Senator has just asked for is what happens, that these general regulations are sent to the local authorities. In fact, they are given sufficient time to consider them fully and to get their comments back before the final regulations are made. If the Senator said to me: "Why not put that in the Bill?" my answer would be that I could not because it is necessary sometimes—not very often indeed—to make some particular regulation that may not be of great importance but that must be made with a certain amount of speed and it might not be possible to consult everybody about it. Generally speaking, the Senator can take it that the local authorities will be consulted very, very fully about the regulations.
Comment on this
The only additional comment I would make is that, when the Minister speaks about the local health authority, he should ensure that the machinery will operate in such a way that the members of the local health authority will see some of those regulations. We never see any of them until we come up against a problem which we find we are unable to resolve because the regulations were made without our being consulted.
Comment on this
Is not it true that the British system is very considerably decentralised and leaves regional committees considerable autonomy whereas this system is entirely centralised? That is putting it in the mildest possible way. The power is centralised in the Minister. The British, who know something about democracy in England—in England—have decentralised their system to a considerable extent, have they not?
Comment on this
I should like the Senator to compare dispassionately and carefully the British system with ours. I think he will find that that is not true.
Comment on this
Could I repeat my query to the Minister, that where regulations are made about which the local health authority is being consulted, the Minister would ensure that the members of the local council would be made aware of the existence of these draft regulations? It is not enough to consult somebody in an office if none of us ever see the draft regulations. I do not know what happens in other counties but I have an idea that it is very similiar to what happens in my experience. We have never been consulted.
Comment on this
Section 9 again gives the Minister complete power, not over the hospitals, but over the doctors practising in the hospitals and over the patients who may go to those hospitals. In effect, the Minister tells the doctors in these hospitals: "In this hospital you can treat this but you cannot treat that. You must not admit this patient; you can admit the other patient." That is really what it amounts to. It gives power to the Minister as to what kind of work the doctors will do in the hospitals or what kind of patients they will treat or what kind of patients they will admit and, in that way, it interferes with ordinary medical practice. I raise a very strong objection to this section of the Bill on these grounds, that the Minister is now dictating. He is not only dictating to the hospital management but he is also acting as dictator to the doctors and to the type of patients they will treat.
We understand perfectly well and everybody knows that we will not admit to a maternity hospital or a surgical and general hospital infectious cases, fever cases. Neither will we admit mental patients. We like to keep clear of all these types of cases. But the Minister here is seeking powers to tell hospitals what they can do and what they cannot do. A previous Minister for Health in this country sent instructions to hospitals in this city about the type of patients they were to treat and certain conditions which he wished them not to treat in the hospitals. He had, of course, no powers to enforce that Order and it was ignored. Now, in this Bill, our present Minister is seeking the powers that the other Minister tried to usurp and it is very undesirable. Some members of the House may not know that already there has been a certain direction in this way about hospitals and the type of cases they will treat. The Department of Health has been responsible, the Minister for Health—I do not say the present Minister—for the establishment of a State hospital in this city for the treatment of cancer. There were two already but he overlooked that and established a State hospital for the treatment of cancer, and cancer cases from the hospitals in the country are directed to this hospital in Dublin. It is a State hospital. State hospitals in the country are directed to send patients to it. The Minister may deny that that is so, but we have every evidence that they are. Those patients from the country or from county hospitals requiring special treatment by specialists in the city are economically compelled to go to that hospital. I do not think that the Minister will deny that.
Now, this kind of thing is going to progress into a lot of other branches of medicine, and a future Minister may say: "In this hospital you must not operate on this; we will send all those cases to another hospital," or "In this hospital you must do this; this hospital must not treat fractures; this hospital must be for any operations on the neck" or something of that nature. They tried to do it before in this country—a former Minister, not the present Minister—tried to direct cases and to tell hospitals what they were to do and what they were not to do. Now, that power is being sought in this Bill. I object to it very strongly and I think it should be removed.
We do not mind, as I say, limiting certain types of cases to which there are objections in hospital, like fevers, mental diseases and such cases, but we do object to these powers being given to the Minister. It will lead inevitably to trouble and heart-burnings for the hospitals and for people who wish to go to hospital. A patient may wish to go to one hospital and may be told that he cannot go there; that the doctors there are not allowed to do that kind of work. He may be told: "You must go to such a hospital, the only hospital where that type of work is done." An attempt, as I say, has been made to do that in the establishment of the State Cancer Hospital.
Comment on this
First of all, I want Senators to realise that this particular section only applies to local authority hospitals. It does not apply at all to voluntary hospitals. As far as they are concerned, I have no control over them and I am not seeking any control over them at all. As regards the cancer hospital, I was not directly responsible for that, but I certainly approve of the action taken by my predecessor. I think that, as far as the general public are concerned, whatever the doctors may think about it—perhaps the doctors are right; I do not know—whatever the doctors of the voluntary hospitals may think, they were rather critical that we were doing nothing about cancer because it appeared to them that the death rate from cancer was going up. Now, really, I think what happened was that the death rate from other diseases went down and cancer held its own, because if we eliminate all other diseases we must die from something and that was the reason why the death rate from cancer appeared to be going up. Relatively, it did go up, of course. The general public were rather puzzled why we did not do something about it, and I think that my predecessor was quite justified in setting up a special hospital.
He did try to set up that special hospital on the lines of a voluntary hospital. Now, how would one set about starting a voluntary hospital at the moment? I am quite sure that if you said to ten or 12 people: "Will you start a voluntary hospital as they did in the old times by putting a lot of money into it?" It would not be very easy to get the ten or 12 people. To start a voluntary hospital of this kind it appears to me that the State would have to find the money, and the only way you can make it a voluntary hospital is to set it up and say: "Will you take charge and run it on the lines of a voluntary hospital?" That was done. My predecessor, if you like, first of all pandered to the general clamour that something should be done about cancer. Secondly he tried to set it up on the lines of a voluntary hospital. Thirdly, he did not, neither did I, ever offer any instruction whatever to any local authority that it should send its patients to that cancer hospital. I defy anybody in this House or in any other House or anybody else to trace any instruction or any advice to any local authority or to any county manager that they should send their cases to that cancer institute. They are quite free to send them to the voluntary hospitals if they want to, and that position will remain.
Comment on this
The Minister indicates that this refers purely to hospitals in our counties, under local authorities.
Comment on this
Now, I would like the Minister to give us some illustration of what he means, what sort of institutions he is visualising are to be built up in our counties where certain classes of diseases are not to be treated and certain others may be treated. After all, I suppose that some time, some day, some doctor had to carry out an operation which had never been performed before. I do not understand what is in the Minister's mind with regard to these local hospitals. If he is going to confine their activities to a certain field I would like to have more information about it. It is not clear from the section, but we should at least know because it is vital, I am satisfied, to build up skill on the part of our medical and surgical people with opportunity and with training to our local hospitals which cannot be developed if their activities are going to be restricted in a particular way and you are going to build up these specialised services—one there, one there, and one beyond. Are we then going to think of our local hospitals as a sort of clearing house for treatment farther away? I do not know what the Minister has in view. I looked at that section and the first thing that struck me about it was that the Minister could order the kind of institutional services which were to be given. Here again, the local authority, who are going to pay half the cost, have nothing to say about it and were not going to be consulted at all. That is what I feel very strongly about.
Another aspect of it has now been revealed, and I would be glad to hear from the Minister what he visualises, what kind of treatment is going to be given, and so on.
Comment on this
Is Section 9 necessary? Surely the Minister has sufficient power under Section 8.
Comment on this
The Minister, speaking of the voluntary hospitals, said that he had no control over them. If a voluntary hospital agrees to work under this Act will he then have powers to tell them what type of work they should do?
Comment on this
About his statement with regard to the establishment of the cancer hospital which occurred just a few years ago, there were two voluntary hospitals in Dublin at the time, both specialising in the treatment of cancer, and they also did a certain amount on skin diseases. Those two hospitals were long established and well known. They refused, I think, to comply with certain specified conditions that were laid down by the Minister at that time, and he completely ignored them, and although other hospitals in this country have been crying out for years for money and could not find the money he built that cancer hospital and equipped it very rapidly; that is, he completely overlooked the two voluntary hospitals and built a new hospital.
Comment on this
This also continues powers that were there already. Senator Baxter asks in what particular case they would be used. So far as I understand, this power was there for district institutions—not, I think, fully for county hospitals. I submit this as an instance. It was reported to the Department of Health that the physician in a certain county hospital was treating open T.B. cases in the wards—a thing which was very dangerous to the other patients. Naturally, he had the patients persuaded that they were better under him than in the sanatorium. Therefore, nobody could get them to give their consent to go to the sanatorium and they continued in these wards. You may come across a crank of a physician like that. Do Senators think that we should let them do what they like? Do Senators think that we should let them injure other patients? That is really the issue. I do not think these powers will be used very often. They will be used only in very extreme cases but they may be necessary at times. That is the only case I can call to mind at the moment. That power was there always. I do not think it was ever used. It may not be used in the future.
I have often had the experience of people coming to me and asking me to do things for them. When I reply that I have no power in the matter they ask me why I do not take such power. When I come to the Dáil and the Seanad, a different view is taken because you have not in mind these sorts of cases that may crop up.
I think the view we should take is that these powers are not likely to be used but that they may be necessary. I think the case I instanced is one in which they should be used but I had not the power at the time.
Comment on this
There are a few questions which I should like to ask the Minister in relation to this section. I take it that the section refers mainly to voluntary hospitals and is intended to provide an arrangement between the local authority and the voluntary hospitals whereby they may undertake certain services. It has been suggested to me as a possibility that one of the effects of this section may be to reduce the benefits—or whatever you like to call them—of a person insured under the National Health Insurance Service. I understand that, as things are at present, a man or woman who is insured under the National Health Insurance Service can go for treatment to any of the voluntary hospitals and that payment will be made but that after this Bill becomes an Act such persons will not have these benefits unless it is a voluntary hospital with which the local authority concerned has made an arrangement. I am not sure that what I have said is correct and I should like the Minister to clarify the point.
My second question concerns sub-section (2) of this section. The sub-section provides that the Minister will approve or direct the amount which the health authority may pay to the hospital. I imagine that that will be a matter for negotiation. Is it intended to provide a sum which will provide for payment of the doctors in the voluntary hospitals where they are not being paid at present or is it intended that they will give their services free, as they do at present?
I am not quite clear about sub-section (4), which reads:—
"Any arrangement which was in force immediately before the commencement of this section and which could be made upon such commencement under this section shall be deemed to be an arrangement made under this section."
I take it that there may be cases where an agreement exists between a health authority and a voluntary hospital and that if it is in effect at the time the Minister brings this particular part of the Act into operation, the agreement still stands. Does that mean that the voluntary hospital would have to cancel the agreement before this part of the new Act came into effect, if they did not like the agreement?
Comment on this
I am not taking the replies in the order in which the questions were put. The Minister confirms the amount to be paid. I think that that is necessary. I feel that it is advisable to have the same uniform rate paid by local authorities to all voluntary hospitals for a particular class of patient. You would have the same rate in the general hospitals; perhaps a different rate for children and also in respect of a sanatorium. Therefore, the Minister fixes the rate. Apart from that, the local authority is quite free and the Minister has no say in the matter at all. The local authority can choose whatever hospitals they like for the purpose of sending patients to them. That is a matter for themselves.
Comment on this
Provided the hospital will accept the Minister's rate.
Comment on this
That is right. The Senator will realise that, as the hospitals are circumstanced at the present time, they can very well accept it because their deficits are paid afterwards. As a matter of fact, the question of the deficit must be dealt with some time, too. At the moment, the doctor's fee is not included. I told the members of the Irish Medical Association that if the local authorities and the voluntary hospitals thought fit to fix a sum which would include a fee for a doctor, I was quite prepared to agree to it in principle. I might have something to say with regard to the amount but I am quite prepared to agree to that in principle.
I do not see why doctors in voluntary hospitals should work for nothing. If they think they should be paid for their services that is all right with me. It is a matter for the voluntary hospitals and the Irish Medical Association or the doctors concerned, to negotiate before they come to me.
Senator Douglas asked about a National Health Insurance patient. At present—as the Senator says—the patient is quite free to go to a voluntary hospital on the panel of hospitals drawn up by the Department of Social Welfare. In fact, they include every general hospital. Their definition of a "general hospital" is very liberal: I think that it is at least one ward of five beds. If that condition is fulfilled, the hospital is put on the panel. The National Health Insurance patient is free to go to these hospitals and to get a certain subvention, over a certain period, for treatment. That will be changed. When this Bill is adopted by the local authorities, the insured person will either get free treatment, if he is in the lower income group, or he will get free or partially free treatment according to the income group to which he belongs, whether it be the higher income group or the middle income group. He will have to abide by the rules laid down in respect of these two groups and he will not have a choice of hospital unless he is prepared to pay anything over and above a certain stated sum which, at the moment, will be £3 10s. per week. Therefore, there is definitely a change as regards the National Health Insurance patient. In the first place, he will not have a choice of hospital unless he is prepared to pay a certain amount but, against that, his wife and family will, like himself, get free treatment. At the moment he can only get free treatment for himself under the National Health Insurance scheme.
Sub-section (4) is merely a clause that is in many Acts. It is a sort of transition clause. When the old Act is rescinded and the new Act comes into operation, agreements under the old Act do not necessarily lapse, but are carried on. The parties can discontinue the contract whenever they like.
Comment on this
Providing the existing agreement is not in respect of a period of years.
Comment on this
Would it not be necessary that the agreement would already have been approved of by the Minister? The sub-section states: ..."which was in force immediately before the commencement of this section and which could be made upon such commencement under this section...". Only an agreement with the consent of the Minister can be effective under Section 10.
Comment on this
I was interested to hear the Minister say that if the question of payment to doctors in voluntary hospitals arises, it is the local authority and not the Minister who will decide whether they will pay anything or what should be paid. Why does the Minister shift responsibility in this case? He takes the responsibility for everything else but he leaves the responsibility to the local authority when it comes to the question of payment.
Comment on this
I may have made a mistake there. I meant to say that if the voluntary hospital and its staffs agree. Perhaps I said "local authority" but I did not mean to say so. If the voluntary hospital and its staffs agree that payment should be made, then I see no objection to it in principle.
Comment on this
I think that the Minister recently promised, in the Dáil or somewhere else, that, in addition to the £5 12s. which is now paid by the local authority to the voluntary hospital for the maintenance of a patient, he would add 10/- ——
Comment on this
——to cover such things as were not already covered: in other words, to cover various equipment and appliances that may be used. That was also to cover the fees of the doctor. You have very big staffs in a voluntary hospital. There may be anything from 30 to 50, or more. There is a very good reason for that. Consider the position even if all of the 10/- went to the doctors. Bear in mind that these are complicated cases. A very severe operation may be involved and perhaps three, four or even five doctors may be in attendance. The doctor may, perhaps, get 2/- as a fee in respect of the patient. By the time the Minister for Finance extracts income-tax from that it is really a very small fee for the amount of work done.
At present, the sum in respect of maintenance paid by a local authority to a voluntary hospital is £5 12s. I could never understand why it is always less than the actual cost. I remember years ago it was £2 2s. a week and we knew then that it did not cover the expenses involved in maintaining the patient. After a lot of agitation, we got it increased slightly, but the hospitals are still behindhand in the amount of money they receive, because the amounts which come from local authorities, and from other organisations for that matter, do not cover the cost of the patient in the hospital. At the present day in a Dublin hospital, maintenance, which means the housing, feeding and so on of the patient, costs about £7 7s. per week, or £1 1s. per day, and if you add to that the cost of the upkeep of other parts of the hospital, the cost of drugs and appliances—there is no question of doctors' fees because we are speaking of voluntary hospitals where doctors are not paid—the actual expenditure by a hospital on behalf of these patients runs from £12 to £15 per week depending on the type of case.
Senators may think that extraordinarily high, but I can tell you that, in England, at present, the expenses of these hospitals run into £20 per week for a patient, and, in certain London hospitals, into £30 and over per week. Here the hospitals are paid a good deal less—nearly £2 per week —than it costs to keep a patient and this has kept the voluntary hospitals in tremendous difficulties. They always have deficits and are not able to spend money on the other things which are so necessary. That is what we have been crying out for for so long and now the Minister has offered an increase of 10/- to cover the cost of other appliances and doctors' fees.
The Minister has never made a distinction, so far as I know, between the voluntary hospital and the voluntary teaching hospital. These are two different things. Perhaps I might explain to the Seanad what a voluntary hospital is. A voluntary hospital is one which is run mainly by voluntary subscriptions and in which doctors operate on their patients without charge. A voluntary teaching hospital is very much the same, except that students are admitted for training as doctors. They are given lectures in the hospital and therefore a teaching hospital will require—because its men have to teach—a bigger staff. In these voluntary teaching hospitals, not only in Dublin and in England, but all over the world, there is always the biggest staff, the biggest number of specialists who carry out the most intricate investigations and who are accustomed to deal with all the most difficult cases that cannot be treated elsewhere, and therefore the cost of running a voluntary teaching hospital is very much higher than that of running a voluntary hospital. For that reason, the voluntary teaching hospital should get special consideration.
Instead of that, what is happening here is that they are being kept in a state of permanent deficit. They tried to help themselves out of that situation some years ago. They established the sweepstakes which were taken over by the Government and the money spent elsewhere. The voluntary teaching hospitals got nothing out of it and they are still in the state they were in 25 or 30 years ago. There has been very little improvement and they have been treated badly. Here the Minister proposes to continue that state of affairs. Every patient is going to cost the hospital nearly £2 per week for maintenance and if a patient requires a big operation—these operations are expensive because a lot of material is used up—it involves expense for the hospital, or if he requires two pints of blood, it means that the hospital has to pay £4 4s. for a point of blood. The Minister is not making any provision for that in the Bill.
We have been told that the other hospitals in the country are cheaper to run, but no figures have been published for the State hospitals throughout the country, so far as I have seen, and I do not know what they cost to run. I have been told, however—the Minister may correct me—that they are even more expensive still. The figures have not been published and if there is a deficit, it goes on the rates and nobody is told about it. I should like to see the figures for maintenance and upkeep of patients in the county hospitals. The reason why these county hospitals and county homes are so expensive is that they are not of an economic size. They are too small and they cannot make them an economic size without making them too big for their requirements. They were built in the wrong way.
I want to put this to the Minister in all sincerity and seriousness: If he wishes the voluntary hospitals to continue as such and if the voluntary hospitals come into this scheme, there are two things which will face the Minister and the Department and the people of the country in general. The first is that the patients must be paid for in full—that is essential. The Minister may promise that we will get money from other sources. We are paying on the overdraft in the bank and losing money in that way and the Minister may say that we will get money from other sources and that we need not bother about it, but there is another point and a point which is of equal importance: You will have to pay the staffs of the hospitals.
I do not like raising this question of money but it all boils down to finance in the end. In a voluntary hospital, a person in my position will work four mornings a week—five mornings some weeks—in the out-patient department or operating theatre of the hospital. That work is done free for these poor patients. I get no fees, no salary, no remuneration of any kind. I have certain afternoons and perhaps other mornings in the week, or part of a morning, when I can operate on or treat private patients and on that I make an income on which I am able to live. If the Minister puts this Bill through and it becomes an Act, he will be taking from the doctors in this country, doctors like myself and others in private practice, somewhere between 50 and 60 per cent. of our private patients. Remember that all farmers—farmers under £50 valuation, many of whom are much better off than I am—are all going to be treated free and all maternity cases are going to be treated free, so that between 50 and 60 per cent. of their private practice is going to be taken from doctors.
The Minister has made no promise to pay the doctors in any voluntary hospital for the work they are going to do for the patients. If he does pay them, I wonder have you any idea of what it will run to? Remember that in the voluntary hospitals we get all the difficult cases that cannot be treated elsewhere. A county surgeon will deal with a great deal of the ordinary run of surgery cases. He will remove an appendix, for instance. In that case the patient will be able to leave hospital in seven or eight days and it will not cost very much but he has got neither the equipment, the staff nor the technique to deal with difficult cases. He has no way of dealing with difficult cases. We, therefore, get all the difficult and obscure cases in the voluntary hospitals. One of these cases may require the attention of three or four specialists before they can come to a conclusion as to the best line of treatment for that patient. That may involve extensive investigation in the laboratory. Then it may be discovered that the patient may require a big operation in which you will have, not one or two doctors, but perhaps five or six or even seven doctors participating. That all adds to the expense.
Unless the voluntary hospitals are put in a position in which they can maintain and continue that type of work, there will be nobody to do it. That type of work will disappear. The voluntary hospitals at present are doing the most technically difficult work in the country. They deal with all the most difficult cases; they treat all the cancer and brain cases. All the most difficult operations are carried out by the voluntary hospitals. If you have not staffs with the requisite skill to do that work, it cannot be done in this country and the patients requiring such treatment will either have to cross the Border and go into the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast or go to England or to the Continent to have the operations carried out there. There will not be anybody to do that work here because if the income which doctors at present receive from certain patients is taken from them, the doctors will not be able to survive. The senior doctors will, perhaps, be able to survive for a while, but they cannot carry on indefinitely. The young specialist who is trying to establish himself will have no private practice and he will not be able to live. These young men will leave the hospitals or they will not seek appointments in them. We shall be left without staffs for our hospitals and we certainly shall not have in these hospitals the best brains in the medical profession, because they will not work under these conditions. The Minister has got to face that fact. The voluntary hospitals, as such, will disappear unless he faces that fact.
This is a question of tremendous importance for the future of medicine in this country, because the standard of medicine depends on the voluntary hospitals. Go anywhere you like, visit the voluntary hospitals and you will know from them the standard of medicine in that country. The Minister has to accept the responsibility for the prospect which now faces this country and all those who vote for this Bill must share that responsibility. I appeal to the Minister, in all sincerity, to give this matter his earnest consideration, because it does involve the future of medicine in this country. I ask him, and all those who support this Bill, not to destroy what is left of what is good in the country.
There is one other point that the Minister must face. That is that he must not, if the voluntary hospitals agree to work this Bill and come in with him, attempt to interfere with the autonomy of these hospitals. It has been the experience in other countries that if you have State interference and State control the value of the work done in the hospitals is considerably dimished. We do not want that to happen here. We are very jealous of our hospitals and of the work done in them and we do not want any interference. It is essential that there must be no interference. I am sorry that I have to mention England again but after all I am compelled to do so as this Bill is rather a poor copy of the English Act—an inferior copy. There are many good things in the English Act as well as bad things but there is not very much good in this Bill. However, in England, the former Minister of Health, Mr. Aneurin Bevan, realised the value of the voluntary hospitals and he gave them complete autonomy. The voluntary hospitals there carry on their work under their governors as they always did. They make out an estimate of the amount they require for a year or for some specified period and they send that on to the Department from whom they obtain the necessary funds. I have been informed —I do not know how accurate it is— that the Governors of the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast are given a sum of £1,000,000 every year for the running of the hospital.
The Minister has got to face this question of expense. He will tell me that he does not want to interfere with the voluntary hospitals but he is interfering with them under this Bill very considerably. This Bill will interfere with them and unless some justice is provided for the hospitals in this Bill the hospitals will eventually disappear and the standard of medicine in the country will fall.
Comment on this
I suppose it is up to me to reply to Senator Cunningham, even to his sneering references to this Bill as being a poor copy of the British Act.
Comment on this
It is not a sneer: it is true. I do not want to sneer. I am quite sincere.
Comment on this
It makes matters worse if the Senator says he is sincere in that statement. There might be some hope for him if he spoke with his tongue in his cheek but he is hopeless if he says he is sincere in that statement. Where did I say that 10/- a week would cover medical expenses as well as other things? I never said any such thing. When the Senator started his speech and referred to the 10/- I interrupted him to point out that I had merely said "10/-, for instance", but he had prepared his speech on a certain basis and he made it in spite of me. He wanted to make these unfair points.
Comment on this
I interrupted the Senator in the course of his speech to say that I merely gave that as an instance but the Senator ignored it. He had his speech prepared and he wanted to establish that I stated that the 10/- was intended to cover other services as well as medical services. I never said any such thing. This destructive criticism of the Bill is not helpful in any way and it is not going to make the Bill any better. I suppose the Senator does not want to make the Bill any better. I suppose that is his attitude and the attitude of the Irish Medical Association but now that the Bill is becoming law, I think they should change that attitude and try to make the Bill better. They have been beaten and they should recognise it.
Comment on this
I do not speak for the Irish Medical Association. I speak for myself only.
Comment on this
Even if the Senator is speaking for himself only, I appeal to him to try to improve the Bill rather than to try to ridicule it.
Comment on this
If that is the position why does the Senator come here at all? Why does he not stay away? Why does he come in here and try to hold up the Bill to odium?
Comment on this
I am anxious to show why the Bill is so wretched and bad. It is only a remnant of an old Bill; it is wretched.
Comment on this
This is a Bill that was first introduced in 1945. That shows that it is not a copy of the English Bill. You cannot have it both ways. If it is a remnant of another Bill introduced here, it is not a copy of the British Act. I said that I was quite prepared to provide for paying doctors in voluntary hospitals. Somebody then asked how much. I said: "For instance, 5/- or 10/-." I did not know what it was. I say definitely that I am quite prepared to have this examined by any impartial investigator, to ascertain how much the county hospitals and local services are costing per bed per week and that we will give the same to the voluntary hospitals. They may say that they have better services and that sort of thing, but we may not all agree with them that they give better services.
Comment on this
I did not say that we had better services, but that we had more intricate cases to deal with and that makes it much more expensive.
Comment on this
Voluntary hospitals ought to put up some little element of voluntary service, because the men in the county hospitals do not claim to be giving voluntary services; they admit that they are paid for their services. If we pay the men in the voluntary hospitals at the same rate they ought to be satisfied. I am prepared to abide by that. We will take the medical costs in the county hospitals per bed per week and offer the same to the voluntary hospitals.
Comment on this
You want a little more. Senators know now how hard it is to deal with the Irish Medical Association. Another thing which the Senator said has been often misrepresented in spite of the facts being stated so often. It is true that the Sweepstakes were started to benefit the voluntary hospitals. But a Bill was put through this House and the Dáil in 1933 and I went to the trouble of reading the debates on that Bill very carefully. There was no objection to that Bill; nobody in any Party objected to it. That Bill gave the Minister power to distribute those funds to both the voluntary hospitals and the local authority hospitals. The reason why Senators and Dáil Deputies agreed to that is that the income from the Sweepstakes was far and away more than was expected when the original Bill was brought in. The Minister was asked if he would not agree to a certain proportion being fixed. He said he would not and it was not pressed. The proportion suggested, I think, was two-thirds. In fact, when the present programme of building is completed of all the hospitals which have been approved of by the Minister for Health, including the new St. Vincent's Hospital, two-thirds of the proceeds of the Sweepstakes will have been given to the voluntary hospitals. I have stated that over and over again and it is true, but people like Senator Cunningham get up and try to give the impression that the voluntary hospitals practically got nothing out of the Sweepstakes funds. Those are the sort of statements which are being made by Senator Cunningham and members of the Irish Medical Association who are trying to give the impression that the Department of Health—whatever Minister is there— is not giving a fair show to the voluntary hospitals; that the Minister is always favouring the local authority hospitals. There is no truth in that.
No Minister for Health tried to interfere with the voluntary hospitals. They are finding it hard to make ends meet. They must blame somebody and they blame the Minister for Health. The Minister has done his best for them. All these grants are going to them. They get what is considered a fair amount from the local authorities for their patients, but they are not able to make ends meet and the Minister for Health comes along and makes up the deficit. But the Minister for Health here is only an Irishman; he gives them whatever they want. But the Minister of Health in England is an Englishman. He is a gentleman, according to Senator Cunningham, and he says: "Boys, what do you want and you will get it?". The Englishman gets all the praise. He does not do it in a different way from the Irishman, but he gets all the praise. The poor Irishman says: "What do you want? You will get it," but he is only an Irishman. That is the sort of criticism you have about this from Senator Cunningham and members of the Irish Medical Association.
Senator Cunningham complains that there is nothing in the Bill to enable the Minister to give more help to the voluntary hospitals. There is not, but of course we only bring in a Bill to give us power to do the things we want to do and power which we have not already. I have any amount of power to give money to the hospitals and I do not want any legal power to do it; I only want the money. Therefore, it is not necessary to put it into the Bill. What more money can we give them? If I come along at the end of the year and ask them: "What did you spend?" and I give that, what more can I give them? Surely I cannot say: "There are a few thousands for yourself," if that is what the Senator expects I should do. They are getting all they are spending at the moment and we cannot give them any more.
I ask Senators—because I suppose there may be innocent men among them—not to listen to the story that the Minister for Health is hard on the voluntary hospitals. They get anything they want. In fact, I have offered to give them more to pay their staffs. The position will be then that the voluntary hospitals, if you pay their staffs, will be getting the deficits paid as well and I do not know what else we can do for them.
One point made by Senator Cunningham was that the Minister has not distinguished between the voluntary hospitals and the voluntary teaching hospitals. I do not think we could. What distinction can we make? We pay the deficits and what more can we do? I suppose that is all we can be expected to do. The voluntary teaching hospitals may have a little more expenditure. If they have, they are getting it back by having the deficits paid. As far as their staffs are concerned, they at least have some income, because the voluntary teaching hospitals—Senators may not be aware of this—collect fees from the students and those fees are distributed to the staffs for lectures. That, of course, is quite correct and I am not objecting to that. The men who give these lectures get some small remuneration. I am not sure what it works out at, but they get some small remuneration per student. Therefore, they are somewhat better off than the voluntary hospitals which are not teaching hospitals. I do not know what distinction the Senator wants made between the voluntary hospitals and the voluntary teaching hospitals. From looking at their bills, it would seem that the teaching hospitals have more expenses and the deficits are bigger, but if they are bigger they are being met and that is all we can do.
Comment on this
A mere layman is hesitant about entering into this discussion, but people who speak on behalf of the ratepayers, who, in turn, have to bear the cost of sending patients to Dublin hospitals, must be concerned about the arguments over this section. I must confess that I cannot commend the Minister's speech. I think it was the most unhelpful contribution he has yet made. I must say that Senator Cunningham put his case reasonably, and he had a case. The Minister points out that he has offered to give the voluntary hospitals the same amount per patient as is given in local authority hospitals. Senator Cunningham indicated his concern because of the new section in this Bill to which we will come in a few moments and to which I have put down an amendment, and which in his judgment, apparently, and the judgment of those associated with him would change the character of the work in the voluntary hospitals and reduce very considerably the incomes of the practitioners there and, of necessity perhaps, not only alter the personnel, but alter the approach of young men who would enter into the profession if the opportunities were sufficient to encourage them to do so.
I do not intend to deal with the situation under Section 15 until I come to it, but Senator Cunningham has raised the issue now and cognisance must be taken of that. He made reference to the payment of doctors in voluntary hospitals and his reference brought to my mind an experience of our local authority at a recent meeting when a managerial order made reference to the appointment of a house surgeon in the local hospital and the failure to obtain such a person. We were actually proposing to pay him the magnificent sum of £150 per annum, but he could not be procured at that money. For a figure like that, I do not know what sort of a person you can expect to get. After all, it is important to maintain the self-respect of our young professional people and that is the figure which was determined by the Minister's Department. We are deprived of the services of the county surgeon because of this figure. If a figure like that enters into the costings in a local authority hospital and if these costings are put against the costings in a voluntary hospital in Dublin, obviously it will be to the disadvantage of the voluntary hospital in Dublin.
The whole problem of building up health services in this country has been raised by the speech of Senator Cunningham and the Minister. It does not matter how you juggle with words and it does not matter whether you are cross or pleasant in making your statement about it, the truth of the matter is that the building up of health services in this country to the level desirable by the Minister or Senator Cunningham is going to cost an enormous amount of money—much more money than the country has available to spend on the building up of a health service. While Senator Cunningham is concerned about the contribution of local authorities to send patients to voluntary hospitals in Dublin, those of us who spend money on behalf of the local authorities and who have to put upon the rates the liabilities that accrue because we must send patients to the voluntary hospitals in Dublin have to be concerned about that aspect of the case too.
There is no use whatsoever in the Minister's showing displeasure at the case made by Senator Cunningham. In my opinion Senator Cunningham's case was very reasonable. He was seeking an understanding of a situation which exists and there is no use in the Minister showing displeasure. The fact is that this Bill will not be worth the paper it is written on unless we can provide millions and millions of pounds more for health services than we have ever provided before. Where these millions are going to come from none of us can say. It does not matter whether Senator Cunningham hopes to get the Minister to decide that many more patients should be free to go into the voluntary hospitals and pay for the services which they get or whether the Minister is going to provide that these people are going to be treated free. There is a certain amount of money which we can afford to spend on health services in any particular year—a certain amount of the national income— and there will be considerable impoverishment if more than that is spent in that particular way. That is the real problem and nothing which the Minister will say or do in this Bill will solve the difficulties which will confront him and all of us when the Bill is implemented.
Comment on this
The Minister tried to get annoyed over what he said was the comparison I made between him and the former Minister of Health in England, Mr. Bevan. I made no comparison whatsoever. I merely stated certain facts concerning the method of paying money to hospitals here and elsewhere. I think the Minister understood that very well. He knew I meant no reflection whatever. I never mentioned Mr. Bevan being a gentleman or otherwise and I never mentioned the Minister being a gentleman or otherwise. I do not take all that very seriously.
This is a very serious matter and there are a few statements which the Minister made to which I must reply. He said that the voluntary hospitals were getting all the money they needed and that when they were in debt he paid off the debt. The accounts of the hospitals are very carefully checked and the items which are purchased are very carefully checked. If there is an item purchased in respect of which the Department or the Minister does not agree, then they will not pay for it. The voluntary hospitals at present are in the position—and the Minister will bear me out in this—that when they require certain apparatus or require to extend a room, an operating theatre or a laboratory they must apply to the Department of Health first. If they spend the money without doing so and put it on the deficit for the year it will not be paid. I can quote numerous instances of my own experience. I am the governor of one hospital in the city and I am on the staff of another and I know we are waiting for a certain apparatus in our hospitals for at least two years and the Department of Health will not sanction the purchase. The Minister may gloss over these things. He said he is giving the voluntary hospitals everything they want. They have not got it.
We have been agitating for years for all the necessary things. They do not do me any good to have them but they benefit the patients and give us better facilities for teaching students but the Department of Health wants to keep down expenses and we do not get them. The Minister also said that two thirds of the money has been given to the voluntary hospitals but only one voluntary hospital has been built in Dublin out of the sweepstake money. How many hospitals have been built in the country? There were local subscriptions for these also. Why have we been kept waiting 20 odd years?
The Minister also said that we get fees from students. That is true. The students pay fees to the hospitals for their teaching and these fees are divided according to the arrangement that existed years ago amongst certain members of the staff. These fees do not amount to very much and for that reason we have never bothered to change the system. The men who do most of the teaching are surgeons and physicians because it is they who deal with the major subjects. They get the fees which do not amount to much. I teach two days in a hospital and so do my assistants and all the other voluntary surgeons and physicians, but we do not get one penny for that. So much for the fees.
The Minister, again, asked for some explanation of the difference between the voluntary hospital and the voluntary teaching hospital. I tried to explain it. The voluntary hospital has not got the same expenses as the voluntary teaching hospital because in the voluntary teaching hospital you have specialists of the highest degree. They get all the difficult cases and it costs for each patient more on the average than it does for a patient in a voluntary hospital or in a State hospital, and from the point of view of investigation it costs a great deal more.
We get the difficult cases, the cases that are bad risks for operations. The patient may require three or four pints of blood, certain apparatus may be required, and all that has to be paid for and it costs a great deal more than it costs for the removal of a simple appendix. We have a lot of that difficult work to perform because the patients are sent from the country where facilities to deal with them do not exist. That is why the voluntary teaching hospital is much more expensive to run.
Furthermore, we require laboratories where students can be trained. Of course, they get most of that training in the universities, but we require a little more room from the point of view of teaching also. I hope I have made it clear why a voluntary teaching hospital is more expensive to run. This is a most serious matter and it affects the whole future of medicine in this country.
Comment on this
In dealing with this amendment, I think I should say a few words on it and on amendments Nos. 2, 5, 6, and 7. Perhaps I could put the matter shortly this way, that there was some doubt as Section 14 was cast as to whether aural appliances and aural services were both free as, of course, they should be under Section 14 because it is the section which is to continue to give free services to the lower income group, known at the moment as the public assistance group. We want to make it clear that they are entitled to free services of all kinds. These amendments propose to make it clear that they are entitled to aural appliances as well as aural treatment. There was some doubt, and hence these five amendments—1, 2, 5, 6 and 7—propose to put aural treatment and appliances on the same level as ophthalmic but not dental. The effect of the five amendments for the lower income group will be that there will be free treatment for the ear and free appliances. As regards the middle income group, where they are entitled to specialist services they will be entitled to free advice but not necessarily entitled to free appliances. There may be a charge made for the appliances. That, briefly, is what these five amendments mean.
Comment on this
As regards the amendment to sub-section (1) of Section 14, I read it in a completely different way from the Minister. I read it to mean as including aural, as far as treatment is concerned, but excluding aural as far as appliances are concerned. It is significant that you put in the word aural, as provided in the amendment, and leave it out in the last sentence of the sub-section where there is reference to appliances. I suggest, therefore, that you are excluding appliances. There is the danger of putting in the word aural in one place and leaving it out in the other.
There is the general principle to be borne in mind that the more you define the more danger there is of excluding. I looked up the dictionary and found that aural appertains to the ear and nasal to the nose. Nasal treatment would be excluded because it is not mentioned. I mention this to show that there is a possible danger in this arising from the general principle which is fairly well recognised. Eye treatment and dental are being described as medical. If a person gets a pain in the ear must he, in the first instance, go through the ordinary doctor? I am doubtful of the wisdom of adding this word in these amendments and then excluding it in the last sentence of sub-section (1) of Section 14. I think that under the amendment, as it stands, aural appliances would be excluded.