We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 119–234 of 234. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954
Enacted

No. 35 of 1954 ›

I welcome the Bill because it restores some, at least, of the democratic rights of the people and of their representatives, and curbs, to a certain extent, the powers of the manager. It gives extra powers to the county council. I think that the Minister is to be congratulated on his approach to this Bill. We know that he visited every county in the State and heard the views of the members of the various county councils. This Bill is a result of all that. If it does not go far enough for some people, we should remember that, at least, it is the first step and that, if necessary, it can be amended by subsequent legislation.

I, for one, am in favour of the proposal to have an estimates committee. We have had one in the County Westmeath, over the last five years. I remember that between 1945 and 1950 we often met perhaps three, four and even five times before we struck the rate. In 1950, after the county council election, we set up an estimates committee comprised, I think, of nine men, the leaders of the various Parties. We come together and we discuss the estimate.

There is one thing we should remember, and it is that public representatives will very often say and do one thing in private and another in public. We have found that out. At a private meeting a man may come along and try to get a road or some other work through at a cost of perhaps £5,000 or £10,000. He will try to make a case for that but do things at the estimate committee which he would not do or say at a public meeting at which the Press were present to report what he said. The people in his area would then know about it. We find that the work can be got through much more quickly and efficiently when you have an estimates committee.

I am not in favour of the title of manager. I think that title should have been changed. He is not the county manager because he has no control over the county committee of agriculture. I think the Minister should change the title of the Bill.

Comment on this

I agree with you.

Comment on this

I understand that the county managers have an association of their own and that the Department communicates with it. If that is so, I think it is not right. I would like the Minister to tell us what standing this association has, if there is such an association. As I have said, I have been told that there is such an association.

As regards the appointment of rate collectors, I think ours was one of the councils which was unanimous in asking that the Minister should take away that power from local authorities. I think we were the only county in Ireland that did that.

I am now 12 years in public life and, no matter what anyone here may say, I believe there is jobbery, bribery and corruption in county councils and in public life. I know what I am talking about. I know that, very often, the candidate with the most money gets the position. I claim that should not be so. In my opinion there should be competitive examinations, and let the best man get the position. I am of opinion that the appointment of rate collectors should be made through means of competitive examinations. I do not know why that one appointment is still left with county councils.

There was a discussion here about temporary staff. These appointments, too, I believe should be made through competitive examinations. I think the Minister has said that in future there will be competitive examinations.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That can be done by regulation between the appropriate Department and the local authority.

Comment on this

When the Management Act was first introduced we were told that it would lead to economy and to greater efficiency. There is one thing I object to and it is that there has been the appointment of far too many highly paid officials. They have been put in positions in every county in the country. I remember the time when the work in our county was done very efficiently by the ordinary road workers, the engineers, the county secretary and some other officials. Now we have the ordinary road workers, we have gangers over them, we have a travelling ganger appointed in every county and we have various staff officers, etc. I doubt if we are getting value for the money that is being spent.

I am of the opinion that the Department of Local Government wields and holds too much power. If a county council discusses some proposal and the county manager agrees with it, why is it that we cannot get on with the work? There is great delay and schemes are held up for a very long time. Someone, speaking yesterday, mentioned the late Mr. Murphy who was Minister for Local Government in 1948. I think that the people of this country owe a great debt of gratitude to Mr. Murphy for the services he rendered as Minister for Local Government. He was Minister in September, 1948, at a time when there was not a single cottage being built in the County Westmeath. Our plans were held up in the Department of Local Government and we could not get them back. Mr. Murphy came down and said that he would scrap all the red tape and would see that the plans were sanctioned. He did, and so we were able to get ahead with the work. I think that at the present time our record is second to none as regards the building of cottages.

I think that the success or failure of this Bill will depend on the councils that are elected after the coming county council elections. One might argue also that it will depend on the people who elect them. We all must admit that it is a disgrace to see that at the local elections only 40 per cent. or 50 per cent. of the people bother to go out to vote. I think that is altogether wrong. Some Senator mentioned that in the recent past the people did not bother going out to vote because the councils had not any power. But now that the councils are getting extra power, I hope that in the coming county council elections a greater number of people will turn out, and that, as a result, the councils will be fully representative of the people.

Comment on this

Before we proceed further I would like, Sir, through you to ask that the last speaker be called upon to withdraw the accusation which he made or to substantiate it. He has accused members of local authorities of corruption without presenting to the House any substantial evidence that such has been the case.

Comment on this

And that money was divided.

Comment on this

That was a very serious statement for a member of this House to make—to make such an accusation against members of local authorities. Either he puts before the House evidence in support of his statement or he should be requested to withdraw that remark before we proceed with any further business. I think this is a very important matter.

Comment on this

I would like to say the same. I suppose I would be one of the oldest members of this House, and I happen to be a member of a local authority for over a quarter of a century, and irrespective of Party I think it is most unjust to suggest that anybody would do the like. There are about ten Fianna Fáil members, ten Fine Gael members and a couple of Clann na Poblachta and Labour members, and I can tell you that the man or woman who would offer one of those people anything in the line of money would find himself in prison very quickly. I do resent in the strongest possible manner that anybody would get up and make such a statement. He stated before, that only 40 per cent. of the people go to the polls for the local elections——

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Acting-Chairman (Mr. Kissane) Fianna Fáil

I am afraid that we cannot have speeches on this point. I do not know what jurisdiction the Chair has. Is the Senator prepared to withdraw?

Comment on this

Definitely not. I know what I am speaking about and I have no intention whatever of withdrawing this statement.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Senator did not indicate any individual against whom such an accusation could be made. That being so, I think that the Chair has not any function in the matter.

Comment on this

With all due respect to the Chair, I hold that we should not allow accusations of this kind to pass. It is a very serious accusation against the members of local authorities and, if we look back over the activities of this House, we have many precedents to guide us on this question, where accusations were made against persons who were not in a position to defend themselves here. This is certainly one of those cases. An accusation has been made against the elected representatives of local authorities.

Comment on this

On a point of fact, it was not against any individual. It was a general accusation.

Comment on this

I do not intend to give way to the Senator. The position is that if the Senator is not prepared to withdraw his accusation, then he must substantiate it.

Comment on this

The Senator has no right whatever to say what must be done.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is a matter entirely for the Chair.

Comment on this

It was a very general statement.

Comment on this

Where accusations have been made against persons who are not in a position to defend themselves, whether those persons are elected representatives or officials of any particular Department, then those statements must be substantiated or otherwise withdrawn. If we are going to depart from that now, that is a new procedure which should not recommend itself to this House. It is a most serious accusation and, to my mind, nothing more serious could be made.

Comment on this

On a point of order, this is a speech.

Comment on this

Nothing more serious could be put forward in this House than the accusation made by the Senator and it is a matter for the House, through you, Mr. Chairman, to decide what decision we should come to. I suggest that the person who made those remarks should withdraw them. If not, he should be requested to substantiate them. If not, then, well——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

As regards the procedure in the past I have not been here and I do not know what it has been, but in any case there is a very clear distinction between making an allegation against an identifiable person and making a general statement. That is, in any case, as it appears to the Chair. That being so, I think we shall proceed with the business.

Comment on this

At this stage, I wonder if we could get agreement to fix a time to let the Minister in? I do not think there appear to be very many speakers and perhaps we could have some indication of how many.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I think that is a very good idea. There has been a long discussion on the Bill.

Comment on this

It might be possible to arrange to sit on without an adjournment——

Comment on this

Though it has been a long discussion, there have not been many speakers.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Unfortunately, we have no means of imposing a limitation on speakers. If we had, no doubt we would apply that remedy.

Comment on this

Then we should not limit the number of speakers.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is a matter entirely for the Senators themselves.

Comment on this

I was hoping that, perhaps, we might let the Minister in if there were not many speakers at, say, 6.30 or 6.45 without an adjournment. It is not proposed, then, to continue with the debate on the traffic motion.

Comment on this

While we are prepared to facilitate the Minister in every respect with regard to this Bill, the members on the other side must have regard to the importance of the Bill, particularly in relation to those people who are members of local authorities, and I would suggest that we would have a general agreement on sitting to the usual hour of six o'clock and adjourning then, and that when we came back we could see what the position would be. I do not think it would be right to deprive any member of an opportunity of speaking, particularly persons who are not members of any Party in this House, who are Independent.

Comment on this

Senator Hawkins has quite misunderstood me. We are completely at the disposal of the House. It is entirely a matter for the House and there is no desire whatever to interfere with anybody's rights.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is understood.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that.

Comment on this

A deliberate misunderstanding.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is a matter, of course, for all sides of the House to decide. The Chair cannot decide, for the Chair cannot take away the privileges of members.

Comment on this

I think it is quite clear that there is no general agreement that we should sit until 6.30.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

We shall continue and see what the position is after the adjournment. That is the best arrangement.

Comment on this

This is certainly an important Bill and one which ought to be discussed fully, particularly by people who have knowledge and experience of local affairs. I was certainly shocked, like Senator Hawkins, at the slur that was cast by Senator L'Estrange on public representatives generally on the local councils. These people give their time and services to the public freely and spend very considerable time trying to find ways and means of serving their fellow citizens to the best of their ability. I would say, without fear of contradiction, that the percentage of members of local authorities who yield to the temptation to accept a bribe is extremely low having regard to the number and variety of people who are elected to local councils. There are men elected to local councils who have large families and no property whatever and no means of living except their daily work, and every day they attend a meeting of the council, particularly if they do not have to travel a distance and do not qualify for any substantial travelling expenses, involves very considerable loss to them and to their families. I have known cases of such men being tempted and having very sternly resisted. At least I have been so informed. I have evidence that any attempt in that respect has been very strongly spurned even by the poorest members of local authorities.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They should have gone further and had them prosecuted.

Comment on this

Yes, but in this country it is not customary to go any further in matters of this kind. They should certainly, if they wanted to have such a thing brought to an end but it is not customary. As far as my knowledge goes, I have known of only one case many years ago where one person did reveal the fact that he was offered a bribe. I have had only one experience of that and I think it is a very grave slur to cast upon these men to suggest that there is widespread corruption, bribery or—I think this was the word used—jobbery. It does not exist so far as local authorities are concerned and I do not think it was ever the real justification for the introduction of the county managerial system.

That system has a very long history. It was not introduced by Fianna Fáil and it does not serve any useful purpose to try to make any Party capital out of the matter. It was introduced originally, and probably with the best intentions by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government; it was continued by Fianna Fáil; and it is now being confirmed and continued by the present Minister. The county manager does not cease to exist when this Bill becomes law—he is re-established in his position probably for all time. At a meeting of a local authority where there are two counties under the one manager, someone asked was it the intention to abolish the county manager in this new legislation, and I answered: "No, it is the intention to multiply him by two because, instead of one county manager for these two counties, we shall have two county managers under this Bill", and I am in complete agreement.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Not unless the two parties are in agreement.

Comment on this

The two parties would certainly approve, I think, of the degrouping of the counties, because, as some Senator pointed out, the accessibility of a county manager to the ratepayers or the citizens concerned is a very important thing. If one goes into Carlow to see the county manager and finds that he is in Naas, or if one goes to Naas and finds that he is in Carlow, one is likely to be very severely disappointed; but, in addition, it is desirable that the manager should be as frequently as possible at the head office of the county whose affairs he administers. If he is administering two counties, he cannot be at the head office of both every week. So far as that is concerned, it is a step in the right direction and represents a reform.

It is not true to say that there is any substantial curbing of the powers of the county manager under this Bill. Sections 2 and 4 do to a certain extent extend the power of the local authority, but it is a very limited extension because Section 4 is not really a new section. It is merely a substitute for Section 29 of the former Act and as far as it amends the procedure under that section, inasmuch as it makes the operation of the section a little less cumbersome, it is an improvement, but it is rather extraordinary that the county councils did not avail of that Section 29 to the extent to which they might have availed of it and I feel that probably they were to a little extent remiss in not using their powers as extensively as they could have.

I think there has been a great lot of misleading propaganda in regard to the whole system of county management. Many members of political Parties have branded the county manager as a sort of scapegoat who has been singled out as the person responsible, and solely responsible, for every unpopular thing done by local authorities. Cute politicians—and there are perhaps some amongst local representatives—are very quick to claim credit for any popular things done, but it is the bold, bad county manager who does all the unpopular things. There is an old saying that, if you give a dog a bad name, it will hang him, and the county manager has been given a rather bad name and most people expected that under this Bill he would be hanged. The Minister may have seen in one of our numerous monthly journals, if he does ever stoop so low as to look at them, a representation of himself or of his Department making a bonfire of county managers' hats, symbolising the destruction of the managerial system. but the county manager will still be in use and occupying his post when this Bill becomes law. The county manager will still continue to function with perhaps all the prestige and authority he has enjoyed up to the present.

It was not to get away from bribery, corruption or jobbery that the manager was first introduced and it does not reflect to any extent upon the prestige of a county council or any local body that a county manager exists. Some Senators have expressed the view that "manager" is a bad name, but perhaps some of these were the very people who gave the manager a bad name and want to get rid of him. There is nothing wrong with the name "manager". If a small group of citizens in any parish or district form a co-operative society to transact any business like the running of a creamery or a co-operative store, one of the first things they do is to appoint a manager. It is quite natural that, if you are running any business, large or small, you must have an executive officer in charge.

Local government has had a very varied history. Since democratic local government was established in 1898, and particularly since the establishment of the State, very many changes have been introduced into our system of local government. At first, we thought we were doing a wonderful thing when we abolished rural district councils and when we abolished the workhouses and the boards of guardians—in merging all these together under the county council—but then we found that, in addition to a county council, we had to have a board of health, and because the board of health had to perform most of the business connected with local administration, it became an exceedingly busy body. The secretary of the board of health had to perform perhaps 80 per cent. of the work at present being done by the county council.

He had to deal with housing, sewerage, health and all these very important branches of local government which involve a great deal of time and consideration and the net result was that, in effect, the board of health could not cope with the terrifically long agendas they had to deal with and it had to be left to the county secretary to perform most of that work himself. The county secretary managed the affairs of the county. The system seemed to be irregular and in that way it justified the centralising of all the executive work in the hands of one competent person. We were hoping that, with the passing of the Act, we would get some sort of supermen to perform all these functions. I do not think we did, but on the whole we did not get such a bad selection of county managers. Any of them I am acquainted with are very able and very conscientious men. In this Bill, we are seeking now, in the light of 15 years' experience, to improve the position legislatively.

Some congratulations have been addressed to the Minister for having got further with the amendment of the County Management Act than any of his predecessors, but he has not yet got the whole way. The Bill is not yet an Act, but we hope he will succeed in bringing it to completion. Two similar measures, one introduced by the Coalition Government in 1950 and another introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government last year or the year before, got bogged down in the other House and never reached this Assembly and it is to the credit of this Bill that it has got just one step further. I do not know whether it will go the entire course or not——

Comment on this

It will.

Comment on this

——but I think that, before it does, it is desirable, that it should be carefully considered by this House and possibly some amendments introduced.

Speaking for myself, I do not entirely approve of the setting up of estimates committees. I think that, so far as most county councils are concerned, they can get through their business more effectively by giving every elected representative of the people a chance of dealing with the estimates as they arise. One of the disadvantages of having an estimates committee, if it is to be elected as was originally intended in the Bill introduced in the Dáil, would be that a number of members of the county council would fail to secure election to the estimates committee and therefore would not be able to exercise to the full their power as public representatives. This would very adversely affect the independent representative who might have no person to represent him on the committee. I have a fair amount of sympathy with independents, because I was an Independent member of a county council and of the Dáil for a considerable time, and I think that once a person is elected to any public body, he should be able to exercise his rights in full, without having them curbed in any way through the delegation of the powers of a council to a small committee. I see no useful purpose to be served by such a small committee, particularly when county councils are not unduly large.

I think most county councils consist of 21 members. Some consist of 25 or 27 members but, even so long as the number is less than 30, I think business can be transacted quite efficiently. There is, of course, a certain amount to be said for having a certain routine when the estimates are being discussed in committee. If the Press is not to be present, this should be embodied in this Bill, because the right of the Press to be present at meetings of county councils is a very important one, and should not be taken away. If there are certain special circumstances, where members of the Press may not be present or should not be present, then I think it should be defined by law. Where such special circumstances are not so defined I think the Press should be present at all meetings of local authorities.

While it may be said that certain decisions will be taken in public which would not be taken in private, it is certainly necessary, in the public interest, that full publicity should be given to meetings of public bodies dealing with public money, not money which is voluntarily subscribed, but with money that is, possibly, extracted from the people. In no circumstances should there be any serious attempt to curb the right of the Press to be present at meetings of local authorities. An exception, however, could be made, for instance, in the attendance of the Press at a special meeting designed to go, in detail, into the preparation of estimates. I think that such a special meeting should be a meeting of the entire council, because leaving out members usually causes trouble.

The Minister, by way of interjection on a couple of occasions, commented upon the very large cost of summoning meetings of local authorities, particularly those of county councils. It is true that it costs a very considerable amount to convene a meeting of a county council. I think that most public representatives have a sense of responsibility and will not agree to meetings being held more frequently than are absolutely necessary. Most local representatives have other businesses, and if they had to depend upon their travelling expenses for their entire means of livelihood it would mean a very poor existence. Since they have other business to deal with, I think they are not likely to suggest that meetings should be held too frequently.

I think where there is a good deal of prolonged investigation to be carried out, as at an estimates committee meeting, there should be no question about the duration of the meeting. Officials of the county council should be prepared to facilitate the general administration by remaining for whatever time is necessary to complete the business. There should be no such thing as breaking up the meeting at six o'clock and calling a further meeting for the following week. That is one way in which travelling expenses could be saved. I am glad that the Minister did meet the representations which were made in the other House. that councils should be left free to decide this matter for themselves. Quite a number of councils would prefer that the business be transacted at a meeting of all the members of the county council.

In Section 2, we are giving local authorities power to direct the manager to inform the county council in advance of any proposals he may have to lay before them. I think that is a valuable right. The main consideration for this House is to decide how it will operate. Section 2 (1) says:

"Subject to the provisions of this section, a local authority may by resolution direct that, before the manager performs any specified executive function of the local authority, he shall inform the members of the local authority of the manner in which he proposes to perform that function, and the manager shall comply with the resolution."

That means the council can pass a resolution directing the manager to come before it with any proposal with regard to some specified executive function. The word "specified" seems to restrict the power of the council very definitely.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Would the Senator read sub-section (2)?

Comment on this

It says:—

"A resolution under sub-section (1) of this section may relate to any particular case or occasion or to every case or occasion of the performance of the specified executive function."

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Is not that the answer?

Comment on this

That means that the manager must not let any house in the county without bringing the matter before the council, if the council passes such a resolution?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is right.

Comment on this

The power is very rigidly restricted in regard to staff. The council is precluded under sub-section (3) from having anything to do with staff, as follows:—

"A resolution under sub-section (1) of this section shall not apply or extend to the performance of any function of the manager in relation to the officers or servants of a local authority or the control, supervision, service, remuneration, privileges or superannuation of such officers or servants or any of them, and any resolution purporting to be passed under sub-section (1) of this section which contravenes this sub-section shall be void."

That definitely debars the council from operating this section in regard to staff. There is a contradiction there in the Bill. Section 6 gives the council definite powers.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Over the permanent staff.

Comment on this

Is there not a very sharp conflict between these two sections? Under one, the council is precluded from dealing with all questions of staff remuneration and supervision, while in another the council is given definite power over the manager in regard to increasing or reducing staff. I think there is a contradiction there, though it may not have occurred to the Minister.

I welcome the section itself in so far as it gives the council some power in regard to the reduction or increase of staff, but it does not give them the initiative—whether it is that it was overlooked or whether this is the Minister's intention. The initiative lies with the Minister. The section provides that he may not increase or reduce the staff without the consent and approval of the council. To make that really effective, the council should have the right to raise this matter by resolution, so as to direct the manager to reduce or increase the staff, rather than wait until he has brought the matter before them. It should be open to the council to raise the matter and say: "Our permanent staff is too large and ought to be reduced."

The Minister should consider amending that particular section, to give the council power to take the initiative and to propose that the staff be reduced. Opportunities to do that arise very frequently when a casual vacancy occurs. The Minister may proceed to have the position filled right away, but some member of the council should have the right to bring in a motion to have the post abolished. That power does not exist in the Bill, as I read it. It may have been intended, but it does not appear to be there.

With regard to the appointment of the manager, I understand the position will be similar to that in the making of other important appointments, that is to say, the Appointments Commission will send down the name of the person and the council will make the appointment. It is rather strange that while nominally the council makes the appointment on the recommendation of the commission in the case of a casual vacancy, where a temporary manager is required it is the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

No, the chairman.

Comment on this

The Minister, in consultation with the chairman. I understood it was the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

I understand. The manager may nominate a person to fill the position, but where he fails to do so —a man may pass out rapidly and may not have had time to transact that business—I understand it is then the Minister who makes the appointment. I think that is also an oversight. If we are giving a little more power to the local authority, we should do it in regard to the filling of a casual vacancy like that. Here I would join issue with the Minister. He says the power would lie in certain cases with the appropriate person—that is, the chairman of the county council—and I say that that power, in addition to the power to elect a temporary manager, should rest with the entire council. The point may be raised that a few weeks might elapse before there is a meeting. By all means let the chairman make the appointment pending the next meeting, subject to the consent of the Minister. There is no need to call a special meeting.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

When I moved the Adjournment, the Minister and myself were, I think, in a little bit of a difficulty in regard to the question of the appointment of temporary managers and deputy managers. I take it that a temporary manager would be appointed in the case of a casual vacancy arising. In this particular case, the Minister seeks under sub-section (10) of Section 5, to attach to himself the power of making the appointment directly, pending, I assume, a permanent appointment by the Appointments Commission and the local authority. I think that in this case it would be a good gesture for the Minister to give that power to the local authorities. They could certainly be relied upon to discharge it properly.

With regard to the deputy managership, power is given to the manager to appoint his substitute, in consultation with the chairman of the county council, subject to the sanction of the Minister. In the event of the Minister's sanction not being secured, the power is vested in the Minister himself. That, of course, is probably all right except that I think the local authority should not be by-passed. I see no reason why, in the making of an appointment of this kind, the local authority should not have the right to make the decision. The Minister made the point that it would involve delay, but even that could be got over by availing of the sub-section in the Bill and allowing the manager and the chairman of the county council to make the appointment and letting it stand until the next meeting of the county council. I think that no difficulty would arise in that connection.

I do not agree at all with Senator L'Estrange that county councils are incompetent to appoint rate collectors. I think that most of us who are members of a county council would like to be relieved of the obligation of appointing those officers because it is a rather irksome duty. At the same time, we must face up to our responsibility, and it is difficult to see or to discover a feasible alternative. A rate collector is a person who, as far as the rural areas are concerned, must reside in the area where he is operating. He must be known to the people generally, and it is through the elected representatives of a county council that he can be best selected.

Generally speaking, the standard of honesty and efficiency amongst our rate collectors has been high. Nobody, I think, can say that the number who have fallen down on their allotted tasks has been greater in proportion than it has been in the case of any other type of official, even those appointed by competitive examination or through the usual Civil Service procedure. No real case has been made for taking away those powers from the local councils. but I will say again that most local councillors would like if it were possible to be relieved of the power, because if you appoint one rate collector you must disappoint, perhaps, ten would-be rate collectors, and that is something which is not very pleasant.

There has been a good deal of condemnation, partly justifiable, of the fact that since the establishment of county managers the cost of local government has increased very steeply. Whether that can be attributed entirely to the managerial system or to the expansion of local government administration and the change in the value of money is a doubtful question. It is not entirely due to the establishment of the county managerial system, but in this matter it is always a popular thing to say that there are too many highly-paid officials in counties. There are people who will also say that there are too many highly-paid officials in the Civil Service, and there are even some people who will go as far as to say that Senators are too highly paid and, in fact, that they should be abolished altogether. Such things are sometimes said in a loose and half-thinking kind of way, but if the matter is examined and carried to its logical conclusion, it will be found that there is very little alternative. There is little alternative to paying such persons as county surgeons, dispensary doctors or engineers a fairly substantial remuneration, because, in the world in which we live, we have the competition of other countries claiming the services of highly trained and qualified people.

The whole system of local government, as I said, has been under constant review over the years, and it still leaves very much to be desired. In conclusion, I would like to appeal to those who are directing governmental policy to direct their attention to the desirability of establishing something in the nature of parish councils which would give the citizens some direct function in local administration. There is a growing feeling that public representatives, whether in the Dáil or on county councils, are a sort of professional politicians, and there is quite a number of people who think that only people who are professional politicians can get elected to any public body. Therefore there are many people who feel that they should have a more direct voice in local affairs, and it is to give such people that association with local administration that I suggest consideration should be given, after this Bill is enacted, to the establishment of properly constituted parish councils and the delegation to them of some special functions in regard to administration, which may be mainly in regard to very local matters and very human matters relating to the relief of destitution, the provision of some useful employment in their own immediate districts, the improvement and development of the particular area, and matters of that kind.

Something must be done, and done quickly, to bring the ordinary people of this country more closely into local government and, through local government, into association with the whole administration of government of the country. This is particularly true in areas where a substantial section of the people are, shall I say, members of, or descendants of, the class of people who were never associated with the national life of this country but were formerly the Unionist minority. Through their local councils, such people could be enabled to take their part in local affairs whereas in most counties their chance of being elected to a county council or to the national Parliament would be very slight. The Minister should consider this whole question in addition to making this Bill as effective as possible.

I am sure that the Seanad will cooperate with the Minister in the further stages of the Bill and in seeking to amend it in whatever directions it appears to be lacking. The Dáil has done some useful work in the matter of amendments.

Comment on this

I assure Senators that I will not delay the House more than five minutes. I doubt if I would have spoken at all at this hour were it not for the statement that was made by Senator L'Estrange. I am sorry that he is not here at the present time. As an Irishman and as one of those who have been associated with the public life of this country for over a quarter of a century, I resent very much that any member of this House would make such a statement. I am satisfied that the only thing which might make me forgive him in any way is the fact that he is a young man and did not realise the serious statement he made. If he was in earnest about what he said, he should have spoken in a different manner altogether about this Bill and called for the abolition of councils, so that we would have no county councils and no travelling expenses but managers all around. Did he realise that more than half the members of both this House and Dáil Eireann are members of local authorities? I can say this much, that they are all honest men and the majority of them are here by accident because they risked their lives for the freedom of this country. They did not come into politics with any ulterior motive but for the reason that they were mixed up in the struggle for Irish freedom. I resent any young man casting that slur on those people, and I do not care to what Party he belongs. It is most unfair, and I feel disappointed that the statement was not withdrawn. After all, if it is the position that in Westmeath somebody can go around and buy votes for a fiver or a tenner, thank God that is not the position in all Ireland, and if that applies in a particular area that slur should not be cast on other counties.

As I said when I rose before, my experience of the majority, practically 99 per cent. of the people in public life in this country to-day, is that they are all honest men. I can assure you that I give the credit to the public that they are not going to elect people time and again if they get to know that they are dishonest. I want to put the point very clearly that I am sure that Senator L'Estrange did not realise the seriousness of the statement he made and the reflection he was casting, not alone on the members of local authorities but on many members of this House and the other House. If what he said was true and there were many people who believe that, we should abolish county councils altogether and have managers.

The foreign Press is always inclined to make little of Ireland and to seize on any chance it can get of casting reflections on this country. I hope that the foreign Press will not take note of this and give publication to an Irish Senator making such a statement.

In my view we should have no managers. The manager should be the servant of the councillors, not the manager of the council. When I make that statement I make it with a full sense of responsibility. The position for the past 15 years has been the nearest thing to a joke one could imagine. Take, for instance, Dublin City and County. The manager of Dublin City happens also to be the manager of Dublin County. If a big case is put up at the county council offices and a big decision has to be come to, the county manager writes to the city manager, that is, he writes to himself. That is stupid and should not be allowed.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We are amending that under this Bill.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear it. Under that system the ratepayers of County Dublin have been greatly wronged, though I do not say that the manager was directly responsible for it. The Dublin Corporation encroached on County Dublin and took away 17 per cent. of the assets. They took over and built up areas around the city without giving sufficient compensation. If the county council were independent and could have fought their own battle the position might have been different. How could anybody expect that the county manager would fight the city manager? The people in Lucan, Garristown and other parts of County Dublin contributed through the rates to the development of the suburbs and, after all that expense, the Dublin Corporation come in and get those areas without a just financial settlement. The city manager and the county manager were one and the same person and what could he do? At the same time, I want to make it clear that I am not in any way detracting from the man's honour or ability.

With regard to county councils, I do not believe that there should be committees such as estimates committees, and so forth. Every councillor should have the same right and the same say. Because I live near the county council offices, I have never drawn as much as 1/- by way of travelling expenses in my 25 years as a member of the county council. The decisions of these committees have all to come before the county council and sometimes there may be great disagreement in regard to them. I hold that the setting-up of these committees is the nearest thing to waste that we could possibly have. If the people of this country are capable of electing a Government to rule them, then surely they are capable of electing men to govern them locally. The same people do the electing in both instances. As a matter of fact, they are better equipped to vote for the men to govern them locally, because they live near the candidates and know their worth and ability.

Managers are well paid and they should be good servants of the council. I believe that the county council should have full powers and that the manager should be the servant of the council. That is the type of local government we should have. This Bill will effect an improvement but not to the extent that I would like to see. As Senator Cogan remarked, when the rates are increased, the councillors can blame the manager and the manager can blame the councillors. I want the responsibility for the increase in rates put on the elected representatives of the people.

There are individuals who say that it is a great economy to have managers. I do not hold with that view. Since we have had managers, the rates in every county have practically doubled. That does not seem to indicate any great work on the part of the managers nor is it a justification for the present system. While I welcome the Bill as a step in the right direction, I feel it is not going far enough. Either we are or we are not; we should be or we should not be. If there is justification for a manager to manage a county council, then I submit we should have a national manager for the State; we should have 12 managers for the State.

Comment on this

We have those managers for the State.

Comment on this

Yes. The Ministers absorb the functions of managers.

Comment on this

But there is this one hell of a great difference: the manager of a county council cannot be removed unless some misconduct or dishonesty is proved but the other poor fellows have to face the public and may, indeed, be put out of public life altogether as a result of slanderous statements. There is all the difference in the world between the two things.

With regard to the allocation of houses, I very much approve of the present system. I am absolutely in favour of the county medical officer of health making representations but I hope it will be ensured beyond doubt in this Bill that no final allocation of a cottage or a house will take place until the names of the prospective tenants are first submitted to the councillors of the area.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That can be done. Section 2 gives that power.

Comment on this

I would ask for that, in particular. People may say that the county medical officer of health is the most competent person and I agree that he is so far as the health service is concerned. But there is another aspect of the matter altogether. If a county medical officer of health goes into a rural village, the woman of the house may make a great case and have three of the neighbour's children in the house along with her own two children so that he will think that she has five children and that, in such circumstances, she is a most deserving case for a house. The trouble is that the county medical officer of health has no local knowledge and that people, in their anxiety to get a house, will sometimes go to great lengths to get one. I am glad that that provision is in the Bill as otherwise I would move an amendment to have it inserted in the Bill.

I have already said that I believe the managers should be the servants of their county councils. I hope the day will come when complete power will be given to the county councillors. It is too bad that a man should have to travel long distances over a period of years to attend county council meetings—I say this with all due respect— and that we have the Minister to say that in my native county, within one fortnight, they spent £300——

Comment on this

In Mayo.

Comment on this

Mayo is my native county.

Comment on this

The Senator has lost his accent.

Comment on this

They spent £300. I say that every penny spent since the County Management Act has been wasted because the entire body of councillors, together with their chairman, had not sufficient power to appoint a charwoman. Is that not correct? Is it not a terrible injustice to spend and waste ratepayers' money on travelling expenses when all the power that councillors have had for the last 15 years was the power of appointing a rate collector—a power that Senator L'Estrange wants to take from them— and the power of striking a rate on the demand of the county manager. The whole thing is humbug.

I am glad and thankful that there will now be a change although I am sorry the Bill does not go far enough. I hope that, in the near future, the position will be that the people of this country will have the right to elect their own councils, just the same as they have a right to elect a Government, and that the councillors will have full responsibility.

Comment on this

So much has been said on this Bill that there is very little left for me to say in regard to it. However, I have had a certain amount of experience of public life: I was a member of a local authority before the managerial system was introduced and I have been there a few years since, even if not the whole time, so I should be able to offer a fair opinion on this Bill. Looking at the Bill in its present form one gets the immediate impression that it does not go any distance towards achieving the aims which it was promised to achieve. I think this Bill could rightly be called the City and County Management (Confirmation) Bill instead of the City and County Management (Amendment) Bill. That is my view of it, because I think it confirms everything that was contained in previous legislation. I grant that it clarifies certain points, but it confirms the others.

We are all agreed that since the system came into existence there has been a continuous rise in local taxation. That may be due to the trend of the times and, accordingly, it would be a very unfair period over which to judge any system. I think, however, a fair question to ask is whether rates would be higher or lower to-day had county managers not been appointed in 1942. Nobody, even the Minister, would care to answer that; it would be very hard to know whether rates would be higher or lower. The initial decision to appoint county managers was not one that was taken lightly before 1940. The two first Ministers who dealt with the problem of the county managerial system had actual experience of public life themselves. The President of Ireland was the first man who dealt with it as Minister for Local Government. As a boy he was elected to the Dublin Corporation and accordingly he had wide experience of what public administration was and what it should be.

At a later stage, before the system became an accomplished fact, you had another illustrious man, now dead, who came from Senator Tunney's county, associated with the introduction of the system. He was the late Mr. Paddy Ruttledge who had spent years on the Mayo County Council. He was chairman of the Sinn Fein council in Mayo and had wide experience of every aspect of local administration. These two men were conversant with the demand for new services all over the country and probably thought that the representatives of the people were not able to devote sufficient time to have the work of implementing these schemes properly carried out. The question then arose as to whether, if you had a very competent man like a manager and if you were prepared to give him a good salary, he would do the work better. That in turn brought about the question of the powers he should be given. If he were not given fairly reasonable powers, he would not take the position. That had to be taken into consideration when the managerial system was being introduced. The powers given, not very sweeping, looked justified at the time. There was very strong opposition to the first Bill both in the Oireachtas and in the local authorities and the contention seemed to be that it was necessary, if a manager was being appointed, that he must have certain powers so that he would not have to go to the Minister every day to get out of some dilemma or another.

In many counties there has been cooperation between the council and the manager and, in these areas, things have gone on well and the system has become popular for that reason alone. When it became possible for us in this country to elect our own representatives on the old district councils and boards of health we had won our first step towards freedom. From the time when Irish nationalists were first elected on these councils, the councils were a fighting force up to 1920 when we had the honour of electing republican councils throughout the country. There seems to be a fear nowadays that the wrong type of person would become elected to local authorities but I should like to point out that such an eventuality would be very rare because a man must be up to a certain standard before he can pull sufficient votes; his credentials must be reasonably good if he is selected again and again by the people of his area to represent them. It is very hard to fool people because, when they go behind the screen in the polling booth, they are very wise as to where they will allow their pencil to drop first.

I think that the right line of approach to the problem of local administration would be that the local representatives would set out the policy of the council and that the manager would come along then and implement that policy. I think really that is the system we want. The council could devote a sufficient time to planning their policy and the manager would be their key-man to put that policy into operation. I think everybody would like that the system would be based on those lines if it could be so worked.

There definitely is a difference of status as between the public representatives and the managers and I think it is that difference that leads to the amount of friction that exists. Allowing that managers in general are good and just men—I am not going to say a word against any of them—the man elected by the popular vote has always to look before he leaps, unlike the manager. The elected representative must think of the day of reckoning, be it five years, as it is now, or three years hence. When the period between local elections was three years, the councillor hardly had time but now he has plenty of time to make repentance between elections. It should be the duty of the local representatives to provide the services and it should be their duty only, because they are the people who have to pay for the services themselves, and who are able to measure up the value of the services by the impost they put on themselves and their neighbours.

Naturally the manager is in a different position; he is like the manager of a big firm because his mentality is that any moneys spent on improvements are well spent. The manager can always feel that he can put down the cost of the work to the credit of the rate-paying community. That difference between the local representative and the manager will never be reconciled. From the point of view of Government Departments— the Local Government Department in this case—it was always much easier to have a manager at hand to carry out the decrees of the Department from time to time. Possibly the local authority would be inclined to adjourn decisions on such decrees from meeting to meeting. Possibly they would put them on the long finger or in abeyance for a considerable time, but while the manager was there the decrees of the Government would be carried out more speedily.

I referred already to the upward trend of local taxation. Side by side with that, the people from all counties say that the personnel of county council staffs has been trebled. That seems to be the position. I am afraid we have travelled too fast in that direction. I would like if the Minister could see his way on Committee Stage to insert a provision in the Bill whereby all vacancies arising in a council staff would, in the first instance, be reported to the next meeting of the council and that the manager could take no action until they took a decision on it. There might be no necessity to appoint a person directly to fill the office. It might be possible to have amalgamation or to transfer somebody to the vacancy, to exchange clerical officers, to promote people from the foot of the ladder. It is only fair to the representatives of the people that such vacancies should be reported to them in the first instance and, if they consider that the post can be filled from existing staffs, there is no reason why it should not be done. The matter must come before the Minister eventually and if the council are wrong and the manager is right, the manager can be very sure of a fair decision when it reaches the Minister. If the council are wrong, their decision is not final because sanction must be sought from the Minister.

I do not think there is any provision in the Bill in connection with that matter. I would be very pleased if all vacancies were, in the first instance, brought before the local authority and that the manager would take no action until he would get the decision of the local body. That is essential. In plain language, the people who pay the piper should call the tune. It can be boiled down to that. The Minister has gone a certain distance but, if he would introduce a sub-section that would cover that matter, it would be very useful.

The question of setting up estimates committees has been referred to by most speakers and I shall deal with it very briefly. My personal opinion is that it is for the county manager and the staff to prepare the bill of costs and for all the members of the council to start from scratch and to examine them and to make the best job they can of them. By all means, if they consider it is too high they should bring it down to a figure they would consider reasonable and which they could recommend to the people who elected them to take charge of affairs for them. An estimates committee might be very useful as a buffer between the manager and the majority of the council who would not be on the estimates committee but it might not necessarily tend to the better examination of the bill of costs when it is presented at the beginning of every financial year. Members of the estimates committee would probably stand over what they decided on the committee and, human nature being what it is, members who were not on the estimates committee, and who would be disgruntled on that account, might wish to find fault with everything the committee suggested. In fairness to everybody, the best way is that the entire council should get the estimates as prepared by the manager and staff and should all start on an equal footing in discussing the costs to the best of their ability.

In respect of new works, these will have to have approval of the council before they are undertaken. The Minister excludes works of repair, maintenance and that sort of thing.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Yes. Supposing a slate came off the courthouse and you had to call a meeting of the council to employ a temporary man to put it on.

Comment on this

That is the unfortunate thing—it is something that is imposed on us. If it were one of our own institutions we would stay up all night to put it in order.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We cannot call a meeting of the council. Take the council chamber.

Comment on this

It is not our chamber at all.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Take the city hall.

Comment on this

That is separate also. The courthouse is away on its own.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is all the more reason why somebody should employ a temporary man to put a slate on it.

Comment on this

If, in the opinion of the council, it was better that works of repair and maintenance should be carried out, would it not be right that the council should be in a position to make that case against the manager? Assuming it was our famous courthouse for example, if the manager could say: "There is so much for that," we could not do anything about it. Between this and the Committee Stage it may be possible to extend this somewhat.

I hope that whatever changes are made by the Bill will be for the better and that we have reached the stage where everybody will be satisfied that the members of the council can go in with their heads up in the knowledge that they are the people entitled to declare policy and that the managers are appointed to carry out their decrees.

Comment on this

I want to make it clear that I do not agree with the county management system. It is undemocratic and not necessary in this part of our country any more than it is necessary in the other part, the part that is occupied by the British people still, against our will. In that part we have not the county management system and the people elected there are able to carry on their affairs without any dictatorial officials. I will not be satisfied until we have an end put to county management and a return to the old, purely democratic system of local government. That is my personal view. This is one of the few ways in which we have departed from the British system of government. It is a pity that we became less democratic than they were in doing so.

I support the Bill. I think it can be a very good Bill and gives very important concessions to the local authorities, if I read it correctly.

Section 10 (4) says:

"At an estimates meeting of a local authority or at an adjournment thereof, the local authority—

(a) may by resolution amend, whether by addition, omission or variation, the estimate of expenses,"

As far as my knowledge of local government goes, and I have been a member of a local authority for ten years, at the present time if the manager submits an estimate and the council does not agree, the manager can ultimately force the council to accept.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That is not true. The council must strike the estimate, no matter what opinion the manager has.

Comment on this

The manager may then, if he is dissatisfied, make an appeal to the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Not under the County Management Acts.

Comment on this

As it is at the moment. That is what I want to be very clear on because, if that is the case, we appear to have been misled in the county council to which I belong. The information we had was that, if the manager and his officials make up their minds that a certain amount of money was necessary to enable the manager to run the county, he had to get that amount.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

As the law stands, he can compel the council to adjourn for a period of seven days. They can strike and they only strike.

Comment on this

If he still felt that he had not the required amount of money, what is the position?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There is no provision whatever in the Management Acts for that.

Comment on this

I am a member of the Carlow County Council. I do not know that there was any occasion on which I and the group I represent were not supporting the manager but the rest of the council were discussing matters and the argument became real when we came to the final point and the manager was making up his mind as to whether or not he could accept the amount the council were prepared to give him.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The manager does not strike the rate. The council strikes the rate.

Comment on this

Yes, but I want to get it clear in this Bill because I was not at all clear on it. Sub-section (4) of Section 10 says that the local authority:—

"may by resolution amend, whether by addition, omission or variation, the estimate of expenses."

In other words, the council has complete power to decide what money is needed to run the county. That is all right. Now let me refer to Section 11 (5) because this is the one I am worried about. I remember, when speaking in the Dáil, the Minister said he would send a memorandum to the local authorities when this Bill was finalised to explain to them what their powers were because he thought that when interviewing the chairman and the vice-chairman, not the members, of the various councils, many of them did not appear to know what their powers were. I do not appear to know what the powers of the council are either. Sub-section (3) of Section 4 says:—

"Where, as respects any local financial year the manager is of opinion that the proper performance of the functions of a local authority requires the expenditure of money or the incurring of a liability in respect of any particular purpose in excess of the expenditure for that purpose specified in the estimate of expenses for that year, he may prepare and submit to the estimates committee of the local authority——"

I presume if they have one, and if not I suppose it goes straight to the council.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

What copy of the Bill has the Senator got?

Comment on this

Maybe I am wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I am afraid the Senator is quoting from an old draft Bill.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) of this other copy says:—

"Where, as respects any local financial year the manager is of opinion that the proper performance of the functions of a local authority requires the expenditure of money or the incurring of a liability in respect of any particular purpose in excess of the expenditure for that purpose specified in the estimate of expenses for that year, he may prepare an application for the authorisation by the local authority of the excess expenditure and may submit the application—

(a) in the case of a local authority having an estimates committee, to the committee, and

(b) in any other case, to the members of the local authority."

The sense of what I am saying is not affected. The point I want to get clear is this. Sub-section (4) says:

"Where an application is submitted to an estimates committee under sub-section (3) of this section, the committee shall consider the application and shall then submit it, with their recommendation thereon, to the members of the local authority."

The change was merely a drafting one and does not affect the sense of what I am saying. What I want to know is, are the council completely free to decide the recommendation or not?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Of course.

Comment on this

It is not stated there.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I do not wish to develop this into a Committee Stage debate, but would the Senator go back to sub-section (1) of Section 11?

Comment on this

The Senator does not appear to have read the correct Bill.

Comment on this

I did, but I brought the wrong one. I apologise for that. However, as long as we are clear on that I am satisfied. I do not agree with this county management business at all. I think local authorities should be completely free to handle their own affairs. I have ten years' experience on a county council and I always had the feeling that, if we decided we were going to cut a particular estimate for roads or for anything else, eventually the manager could demand that it be changed or modified and that we would be put out of office if we insisted on doing what we considered necessary. If that power is given back to the local authority it will make a great difference.

There are one or two other things to which I have always objected. One is the fact that the manager must be the only person to deal with personnel.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Temporary or permanent?

Comment on this

Permanent.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That cannot be done now.

Comment on this

As regards their conditions of employment, and so on.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Industrial Relations Act will regulate that.

Comment on this

To some extent. There appears to be a difference in procedure as between urban authorities and local authorities. In the local authorities when the council recommends to the manager that the workers should get an increase, they can make the manager recommend that increase to the Minister but in urban councils that is not so. In Ballinasloe and Carlow, for instance, the councils in both cases recommended to the manager that he should recommend to the Minister that the workers should get an increase but the manager consistently refused. To my mind, if the representatives of an urban council unanimously agree that the workers are entitled to more money there should be some way of getting that recommendation to the Minister for his sanction.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It need not go to the Minister; the manager may do it.

Comment on this

I know, but in these two cases he refused, and there is no way out of it.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Minister is trying to keep out of local affairs as much as he can.

Comment on this

In these cases the application was for more pay for these workers to bring them in line with the local authority workers, as their work was comparable and, as I said, the manager refused. I think this is one of the cases in which the local authorities should have power to decide for themselves, that is, in regard to the pay of their workers.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I should like to thank the House for the very constructive manner in which the Bill has been received on all sides. From what I have heard, I look forward to most constructive amendments being put down. I feel that I will get them from all sides of the House. I invited them in the Dáil and I was disappointed with the number of amendments that were put down. However, I look forward to something else in this House from the very interesting contributions I have heard.

The first speaker from the opposite benches, my friend Senator O'Sullivan, tried to introduce a political note into the discussion when he said that he was glad to see Senators supporting the Government now in favour of the county management system. It is but right to remind him that the Opposition are the converts. I do not wish to go into a political argument, but it is just as well to have the facts. Away back in 1929 the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government decided to introduce a City Management Act for Cork City. If my recollection of reading the debates serves me right, it was bitterly opposed by the present Opposition. Again, a year or so later a further Bill was introduced, a Bill to appoint a city manager for the City of Dublin and, again, that Bill was opposed by the present Opposition. But as Senator Kissane, I think, pointed out, after eight years Fianna Fáil saw the wisdom of the action of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government and they introduced the County Management Act in or about the year 1939 at the outbreak of the war; when they saw executive functions of local authorities mounting up; when they saw that local authorities could no longer deal with these executive functions which were then mounting up and would continue to mount as a result of the outbreak of war.

That Act was not perfect and, when the inter-Party Government took office in 1948, the first thing they did was to instruct their then Minister for Local Government, the late lamented Tim Murphy, to prepare an amending Bill. It was never suggested that that amending Bill should repeal the County Management Act, merely that it should amend it. Unfortunately, before the then Minister had time to put the Bill through, he died; his successor, Deputy Keyes, proceeded with the Bill but, before it reached this House, he went out of office. The present Opposition came into power and the first thing Deputy Smith did as Minister for Local Government was to introduce an amending Bill.

Now I have been very fortunate. I have had an opportunity of studying the working of the County Management Act since 1940 in my capacity as a lawyer, and more particularly still in my capacity as a lawyer to a local authority. I have also had the privilege of reading the Bill introduced by the inter-Party Minister for Local Government, Deputy Keyes. I have had an opportunity of reading the debates on that Bill. I have had an opportunity of reading the Bill introduced by the present Deputy Smith; and I have had the opportunity of reading the debates on that. But I was not satisfied and I set out to consult local authorities, the people who were actually working the County Management Act, all over the country to find out what they wanted.

I visited every local authority in the country and one of the first things that struck me was that the improvement in the management system was not so much a question of adding to reserved functions; what they wanted was more reserved functions and less executive functions. They never sought the abolition of county management, with one solitary exception which I shall not mention. I thereupon incorporated the request of the majority of the local authorities in the present Bill and when I came before the Dáil I invited, on the Committee Stage, amendments from both sides of the House. I accepted a number of amendments. The only amendments I refused to accept were amendments from the present Opposition, which I found Deputy Smith incorporated in his Bill, but which they now wished to propose for the purpose of obstruction. Those were the only amendments I refused and I will welcome any suggestions Senators may wish to make on this Bill.

A considerable amount of play has been made on Section 16 of the Bill. It has been said that Section 16 will nullify the powers given under Section 4. I think it is but right that I should now reiterate what I said when introducing the Second Reading of the Bill here. First of all, let me point out that the law governing surcharge is laid down in Section 61 of the Local Government Act, 1925. This is the law at the moment governing surcharge. The Section sets out that certain officers of local authorities must warn local authorities of the result of their actions provided their actions are unlawful actions. Unfortunately it goes further than that; it says who the person is who must warn the local authority and it describes him as the "responsible officer of a local authority" and the responsible officer is defined in the Act as meaning "the secretary, clerk. resident medical superintendent or other chief executive officer of such local authority".

That was a first-class definition and an excellent definition in the days of the old local government system; but when the county management system was introduced that section should have been amended to include county managers. That is what I am doing under Section 16—that and nothing else. I am merely bringing the law up to date and in line with the county management system. I have added Section 16 which sets out:—

"(1) Where a proposal is made at a meeting of a local authority to do or effect any act, matter or thing—

(a) which constitutes a reserved function or is mentioned in a resolution under Section 4 of this Act——"

——a reserved function, not an executive function——

"(b) in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made out of the funds of the local authority, or a deficiency or loss is likely to result in or to such funds."

Let me give the House an example. Suppose a local authority decides that they will accept a tender for houses which is not the lowest tender; suppose they accept a tender which is £100 per house higher than the lowest tender—that is quite a lawful act. They are entitled to accept if they have made provision. But sub-section (b) says: "in consequence of which an illegal payment is to be made out of the funds of the local authority, or a deficiency or loss is likely to result in or to the funds." There is an onus there cast upon the prescribed or responsible officer as defined under the Local Government Act of 1925; but, in order to bring local government legislation up to date, we must now include the manager,

"(or, in his absence, such other officer as may be designated by the manager) and he shall object and state the grounds of the objection, and, if a decision is taken on the proposal, the names of the members present and voting for and against the decision and abstaining from voting on the decision shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting."

That is the wording of the old section of the 1925 Act. I am merely bringing the law up to date and it does not contradict in any way the powers given under Section 4.

It is necessary that I should stress that the question of warning does not arise where the local authority are proposing lawful expenditure outside the provision made in the estimates, such as the repair of a road which was not included in the road works scheme. I think someone mentioned that particular point. Once the request is made by the members and the work can lawfully be carried out and the council authorises the expenditure, the manager must carry out the work. Once it is a lawful act he must do it and, so long as the money is provided, it is not illegal.

Most of the arguments advanced here are arguments which could more advantageously be made on the Committee Stage. I have taken a note of them. If I can meet them in any way by ministerial amendment I shall be glad to do so. On the other hand, I would like to see Senators themselves putting down amendments.

I want to emphasise one point with regard to the employment of temporary employees of a local authority. It has been suggested that the council should have some say in the appointment of temporary employees. Supposing some slates came off the council chamber, would it not be ridiculous to suggest that a meeting of the council should be held for the purpose of appointing John Brown to put three slates on the council chamber? Supposing, on the other hand, that a doctor drops dead or is taken seriously ill, a locum must be appointed. I understand that locums are appointed at the rate of two or three per month in local authority areas. Would it not be a drastic state of affairs if we had to leave a dispensary denuded of a medical officer while the council were coming together and arguing and deciding as to who should be the locum tenens appointed to fill the vacancy?

Comment on this

Has the position ever occurred that a dispensary has been left vacant because of the local authority not coming together to make an appointment?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The local authorities have nothing whatever to do with it. The Senator knows as well as I do that when a doctor takes ill or is called away, say, to visit his sick mother a couple of hundred miles away a locum has to be appointed. Theoretically, he appoints the locum with the sanction of the county manager, but if you have to call together the county council——

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister is not quite right——

Comment on this

The Senator will please permit the Minister to conclude without interruption.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Again, one can imagine a case of a permanent assistant engineer who is taken suddenly ill. A good deal of road work is going on in the local authority area and, at the moment, the managers have power to appoint temporary engineers, but it would be a shocking state of affairs if, in counties like Mayo, Donegal or Cork, the entire council would have to be called together involving travelling expenses of £60 to appoint a temporary engineer for a fortnight or three weeks. That is all I wish to say on temporary appointments of staff. We have given the councils under this Bill full control over increases in permanent staff, and not only that, but over increases in the salaries of permanent staff. I think we have gone a long way towards reaching democracy so far as local affairs are concerned.

Much criticism has been made of the estimates committee proposals. I do not want to say very much about it. In Senator Hartney's county, when I visited it, I was told by the deputation, the councillors who saw me there, that their difficulty was this: "We do not know," they said, "anything at all about our finances until we read in the county manager's orders that he has done such a thing." Or: "We do not know anything about our finances until the end of the year when we see the estimate presented." This impressed me. Several councillors in other counties said: "We would like to know something about our finances and how they are going on." I decided it would be a good thing to set up a small committee to examine the finances of the local authority from month to month or, if they wished, from quarter to quarter, from half-year to half-year or at the end of the year. If they wished to prepare the estimate they would have at their disposal all the officials now at the disposal of the county manager in preparing the estimate.

I was impressed in the Dáil by some Deputies who said: "We do not want that," and I said: "After all, this is to be democracy, and, if you do not want it, we will not give it to you. I will make it optional." I do not think I could be fairer than that. But I was disappointed to hear from Deputies about how difficult it is to procure members to sit on estimates committees. Like Senator Sheehy Skeffington, I was never a member of a local authority but for over 30 years my father was a member of the county council, of the board of health and of the mental hospital committee. These bodies met once a month and to get to the council meetings and back took him three days—a day travelling, a day there and a day coming home. He gave exactly six days each month to the work of the local authority and not one solitary penny of expenses did he get where gentlemen are now getting £5 and £6 per day for each day they attend these functions. I am disappointed to hear that even at that we will not get men to man the estimates committee. I do not believe it. I am satisfied that if we give power back to councils, the power which I propose giving them under this Bill, we will get men to do these jobs voluntarily, merely for their out-of-pocket expenses, and in that way we will go a long way towards cutting down expenses.

I wish to thank the House for the manner in which Senators received this Bill and for their most constructive criticism. I look forward, as I said earlier, to having their amendments on the Committee Stage and we shall discuss these amendments in the same friendly spirit as we have discussed the Bill on the Second Reading.

Comment on this