Appropriation Bill, 1958 (Certified Money Bill) — Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 101–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 19 of 1958 ›
Now, no one interrupted Senator Lenihan when he was speaking. We would get on better if there were no interruptions. Senators may not like what other Senators say, but we have no control over that.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I think Senator L'Estrange should give the full quotation. He is taking that out of its context. He should give it in full.
Comment on this
No, no. May I protest against Deputy Corry being heard in extenso in the Seanad as well as in the Dáil? That would be too much.
Comment on this
No. I have been asked to give them. Deputy Corry said:—
"Deputy Dillon and some other Deputies passed remarks in this debate about certain statements made by me. I make no bones about this."
He was making no bones about it. Some Senators here are hiding behind it and are not prepared to admit it. At least Deputy Corry was man enough to admit that Fianna Fáil fooled the farmers of Cork and the farmers of Ireland. Deputy Corry said:—
"I told the people that they would get 82/6 per barrel for their wheat and they believed it."
He goes on further, and I may as well quote it, as I was asked what he said:—
"I would not grow wheat at Deputy Dillon's price and I am hanged if I would grow it at a lower price."
Now we have the Fianna Fáil policy from some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry continued:—
"That is my advice to the farmers ...I am taking my own steps about the matter and I am advising my own people about it."
There is Fianna Fáil policy now on the growing of wheat. At present they claim credit for everything that has gone right and they try to blame the inter-Party Government for anything that went wrong. They claim credit this year because our balance of trade was righted and the reason it was righted was that we exported £131,000,000 worth from this country. Remember that was an increase. In 1947, it was £39,000,000 and that had increased on the change of Government to £131,000,000 and, as Senator Baxter pointed out the last day, over £46,000,000 of that was for live stock alone. Surely there is nobody on that side of the House who can claim that the cattle that were exported or the sheep that were exported, or even the pigs that were exported were all born since 20th March, 1957? Perhaps some of the pigs were, but, in any case, they cannot claim full credit for it, although they are doing their best to claim it.
They also claim credit because we are more or less out of the wood financially, but the credit for that is due to the courageous, though unpopular, steps taken by Deputy Sweetman when he was Minister for Finance, when the Government of that day were prepared to put country before Party and took unpopular steps but steps which they knew would right our financial position. They were criticised in this House for doing it.
I remember some of the Fianna Fáil Deputies and Senators lamenting the fact that oranges were 6d., due to the levy and that the levy should be taken off for the benefit of mothers and young children. The levy has since been taken off oranges, but oranges are now 7d. I should like the people on the Fianna Fáil side of the House to tell us where the profit is going. The levy is off but the orange costs, not 6d., but 7d.
We all know that an economic blizzard hit this country in 1955 and 1956, that Sir Anthony Eden stated that even Britain was in mortal danger and Britain had to take measures at that time also to protect her economy. We all know that the Government of that day had, if you like, hard luck because Argentine beef was being dumped on the British market and the price of our cattle dropped as low as £4 per cwt. To-day the price is anything from £7 to £9 a cwt. Surely Fianna Fáil cannot claim credit for that, because the credit for that is due to one man alone, that is, the Minister for Agriculture in 1948, who, in 1948, made the cattle trade agreement of that year and put a proviso in it that for every increase the British farmer would get his cattle, the farmer of Ireland would get a similar increase. As a result of that, to-day, no matter what Minister may be in power, whether he is competent or incompetent, the Irish farmer will still get any increase the British farmer gets for his cattle. It is due to that fact that we exported £131,000,000 worth of produce last year and that our external accounts were balanced.
Deputy Dillon, in the inter-Party Government at that time, also started the land rehabilitation scheme and that scheme is being slowed down at the present time. Due to that scheme, over 1,000,000 acres of unfertile or bad land have been brought into production and I know people who have grown crops of wheat on land that at one time was flooded and producing nothing but heather. I know one man who is a Senator who, last year, got an average of 14 and 15 barrels of wheat off such land.
The lime scheme was also introduced. Now that scheme is also being slowed down and the price has been increased, despite promises made before the general election.
All Parties here claim that the one thing we want is increased production from the land and from the factories. When I talk about converting people, it might be no harm also to go back to Volume 81, column 1524, when we had Deputy Aiken, who is now the Minister for External Affairs——
Comment on this
I have given the Senator the volume and the column.
"We are not helpless if we use our brains. The Lord has given us resources, and we have the means at the moment, so that even if every dama ship were at the bottom of the sea, we could have twice as high a standard of living in a few years."
That is a statement that was made by an important Minister, a man who is still a Minister in the Government. If the ships were not available this year to take our cattle to Britain, Germany, France and other countries, where would this country be? Even if the ships were not available to take the 70,000 or 80,000 that had to emigrate, due to Fianna Fáil policy, where would the country be?
In any debate like this, we should give credit where credit is due. I was surprised at Senator O'Callaghan when last week he stated that we had an increase in the number of cattle in this country. He said:—
"I think it was in 1953 that experiments were carried out in North Cork and in West Limerick in connection with white scour and aureomycin was discovered to be the remedy for the disease. We know that thousands of calves, reckoned at 60,000 or 70,000, were lost in years gone by due to this disease."
I should like Senator O'Callaghan to think again because it was in 1949 that Deputy Dillon introduced aureomycin. The Minister can put his hand up as high as he likes, like Hitler or anyone else. He can say "Heil Hitler."
Comment on this
You have an overall majority and do not give a damn about the Irish people. You will be in power for another three years and can walk on them for the next three years.
Comment on this
I do not mind what way I held up my hand. I held my head up in 1935. I fought against those who stood for lawlessness and tried to break up political meetings and did not stand for democracy. If you have the I.R.A. to-day, they are only doing what Fianna Fáil taught them to do in years gone by and what the Irish Press with hate articles and hate campaigns is teaching them to do again.
Comment on this
The Senator need not go back to that time.
Comment on this
I do want to claim and I am not saying "I think" because Deputy Dillon stated it was in 1949—the Minister can ape Hitler as long as he likes.
Comment on this
If I tell you about the 1930's, I will put you in your place. If Senator Lenihan wants to know the truth about the 1930's, his father was in the Free State Army and was Fine Gael at that time and he himself a supporter of the Party on this side of the House.
Comment on this
Is the Senator rising on a point of order?
Comment on this
The point of order is this: we are debating the Appropriation Bill. Surely Senator L'Estrange should restrain himself.
Comment on this
I would suggest to many others in the House, as well as to Senator L'Estrange——
Comment on this
I hope my point of view on that will be respected all round. If we have no interruption, perhaps we will get on with the debate.
Comment on this
If we have no interruptions, I will stick to what I have to say. We heard a lot of talk about false promises. We all know that the Taoiseach went around the country at the time of the last general election and spoke like a pious old preacher. He spoke about honour in public life. He spoke about lies and false promises. There is no man who has broken his promise or his word more often to the Irish people than the man who made that statement.
Comment on this
Are we compelled to sit here and listen to this after the exhibition which Senator L'Estrange made of himself last week in regard to one Minister? Are we compelled to listen to insults to the Taoiseach?
Comment on this
There is no obligation on anyone to sit and listen if he does not like to hear what is said.
Comment on this
Am I not entitled to sit here without having to listen to insults to the head of the Government?
Comment on this
As long as the Senator's remarks are in order and can be related to the Bill, the Chair has no option other than to permit him to continue.
Comment on this
Where does "in order" and insult stop? What is the difference? If this is to be allowed then we will have a bear garden.
Comment on this
I hope we shall not have, and I hope Senator Mullins will not contribute to it.
Comment on this
I shall not and have not contributed to it, but I shall not sit here and listen to the head of the Government being accused of being a liar.
Comment on this
I do not think the word "liar" was used.
Comment on this
Senator Mullins will have to sit and hear people saying things he does not like. That is a fundamental part of parliamentary debate. There is no such thing as any form of parliamentary privilege or immunity in this respect for the head of the Government, and nobody knows that better than Senator Mullins does.
Comment on this
When the allegation comes as part of a preconceived attack from the same Senator who was compelled to apologise yesterday, I think it is time to call a halt.
Comment on this
I apologised to the Chair for what I said in the heat of the moment. If I ever say anything here that I should not say I shall be man enough to come in and apologise. The Senator should apologise for some of his actions in this House.
Comment on this
Both the Taoiseach at Belmullet and the Tánaiste in Waterford took the same line on the same date. We all know it was agreed what they were to say. This appeared in the Irish Press on the 1st March, 1957, and surely Fianna Fáil Senators will believe what appears in the Irish Press:—
"The Coalition Parties were changing their tactics in this election, said Mr. de Valera at Belmullet last night.... The opponents of Fianna Fáil were wondering what new dodge they could try to prevent the people from seeing... the real issue in the election....
You know the record of Fianna Fáil in the past, said Mr. de Valera. You know we have never done the things they said we would do....
They have also told you you would be paying more for your bread."
There was a specific promise made to the Irish people and they all know that specific promise was broken.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the speaker has alleged from a quotation he has made that a promise was implied in that quotation. No such thing can be inferred from the quotation.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste said:—
"Some Coalition leaders are threatening the country with all sorts of unpleasant things if Fianna Fáil becomes the Government—compulsory tillage, cuts in Civil Service salaries, higher food prices, wage control and a lot more besides."
The Tánaiste went on to say:—
"A Fianna Fáil Government does not intend to do any of these things because we do not believe in them. How definite can we make our denial of these stupid allegations? They are all falsehoods."
The Tánaiste and the Taoiseach said those things were stupid allegations and they were all falsehoods. In a very short time after that they come in and remove the food subsidies. They have increased the price of bread and increased the cost of living despite the fact that in those two speeches they gave a specific promise to the Irish people that they would not do them.
Senator Lenihan queries what I have to say. Perhaps he would like me to remind him of point 15 of the 17-point programme which was signed by no less a man than the present Taoiseach. It was signed "Eamon de Valera" in 1951 after the general election of that year when they were trying by hook or by crook to get the votes of the five Independents. They published a 17-point programme and point 15 was that they would maintain subsidies and reduce the cost of living. That promise to the Irish people was not made in the heat of a general election from a political platform where a person may say things he might not at other times state. It was made in the Fianna Fáil Party rooms and signed by the Taoiseach himself. Nine months after making that solemn and specific promise to the Irish people he came into Leinster House and removed the subsidies.
Comment on this
They reduced the subsidies by £11,000,000 and sent the cost of living up by 15 points. We also know that further promises were made. There were to be better times for all. There is very little sign of the better times for all. The cost of living was to be brought down and it now stands at an all-time record of 146 points. Unemployment was to be reduced. A sum of £100,000,000 was to be spent to relieve unemployment, according to the Tánaiste. That plan is in cold storage and according to the Minister for Lands they never had any intention of implementing it. We were to have more homes for the Irish people but £700,000 less was provided in the Estimates for houses. They were to put an end to the depression but we know that shopkeepers, small farmers, business people, old age pensioners, widows and orphans, never got it harder to live than at the present time.
I read in the newspaper the other day a letter from the Minister for Lands in relation to the cost of living. He stated that the cost of living went up 46 points since 1947. He pointed out that the Parties on each side of the House, when they were in office, were responsible for a rise of roughly 23 points each. Let us get the figures correctly from the official statistics. In February, 1948, when the inter-Party Government came in the cost-of-living figure stood at 99 points. In May, 1951, when they were going out of power it stood at 109 points, an increase of ten points during their three years of office. Fianna Fáil came in and after the Budget of 1952 the cost-of-living figure stood at 127 points, an increase of 18 points.
The inter-Party Government came back in 1954 and the cost-of-living figure stood at 127 points. They went out in March, 1957, and the cost-of-living figure stood at 135, an increase of eight points. Fianna Fáil came in in March of the same year, and the cost-of-living figure stood at 135. They brought in their Budget of 1957 and between that Budget and other increases since, the cost-of-living figure is now 146. If you add 11 and 18, which represents the increase during Fianna Fáil's periods of office, you get 29 and if you add ten and eight, which represents the increases during the periods of office of the inter-Party Government, you get 18. Therefore, the cost of living during the Fianna Fáil reign of office increased by 29 points and during the inter-Party's term of office it increased by 18 points. As I say, those figures are taken from the official statistics and no matter how Fianna Fáil may try to contradict things, they cannot contradict what appears in those statistics. Because of that increase in the cost of living, increases of roughly 10/- a week have been given to road workers, civil servants, Gardaí and other people.
Recently a certain man was appointed Chairman of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. We hear much in this country about people holding two positions and about emigration but here was a position that could have been given to some poor man who might have to leave the country, or it could have been given to some man who had no other job, perhaps a graduate coming from the university who might have to leave for England in a week or a fortnight.
What happened in this case? The appointment was given to a man who had left his previous job with a pension of £800 a year. The previous chairman of this body had £800 a year. The Minister does not give the new appointee an increase of 10/- per week despite the fact that he has a pension of £800: he gives him an increase of almost £10 a week, £400 a year, bringing the salary up to £1,200. He also has the £800 pension, a total income of, roughly, £2,000. Then the Government appeals to the workers and to other people and says: "You must be satisfied with 10/- a week. We can do nothing about emigration." Yet, we have one man getting £2,000 a year. He is well paid for his work.
As we are discussing the cost of living, it is no harm to state that, as far as we are concerned on this side of the House, the inter-Party Government during its two terms of office from 1954 to 1957 never increased the cost of the essential commodities of life by even one penny piece. Senator Lenihan shakes his head and when he does that I shall give him figures to prove it.
Comment on this
The inter-Party Government came in in 1947 and the price of the loaf was 6½d. They went out in March, 1951, when the price was still 6½d. Fianna Fáil put the price up to 9d. in the 1954 Budget. When the inter-Party Government came back they did not interfere with the price but, according to the people on the other side of the House, they took a slice of the loaf. I do not know about that; I thought it was as big as ever. When Fianna Fáil came in they put the price of the loaf up to 1/1½d. an increase during Fianna Fáil's time in office of 7d.
Flour was 2/7 a stone after three years of inter-Party Government in 1951 but when Fianna Fáil came in it went to 4/5. The price was not increased until the change of Government last year when in the Budget it was put up to 7/6 per stone, an increase of 4/10 per stone under Fianna Fáil. Yet they will say that they have always tried to keep down the cost of living. Sugar was increased from 4d. to 7½d.; butter was 2/10 in 1951 and in the 1954 Budget Fianna Fáil increased it to 4/2. The inter-Party Government came into office and brought down the price by 5d. to 3/9 but Fianna Fáil was not satisfied with that and increased it in the Budget before last to 4/4, an increase of 1/6 per lb. I claim that those four essentials of life, especially for poor people, are commodities that Fianna Fáil have taxed and increased in price more than anything else.
Unfortunately for many of our people at present there is a new brand of butter and it is called "Three Nones"—none yesterday, none to-day and none to-morrow because poor people cannot afford to buy it.
Comment on this
All these things were done despite the promises made by the Taoiseach and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Yet we had the Taoiseach stating in the Dáil on February 26th that there was no evidence that the cost of living was increasing. Is the present Government losing all contact with the plain people of Ireland? Are they living on the moon? Their vote decreased by 4½ per cent. in South Galway.
Comment on this
And in the constituency here in Dublin where they got 61 per cent. of the vote in the general election they got only 26 per cent. in the recent by-election. Despite the fact that they won the seat, the total Fianna Fáil vote was only 6,014 against a vote for the combined opposition of 11,569.
Comment on this
Because it was a by-election they won the seat but if it were a general election there would be a different result from those figures and nobody knows that better than Senator Ó Maolain.
Comment on this
We hear much about the confidence people have in Fianna Fáil, but if one goes to the Sunday Independent of June 1st, 1958, we find:—
"‘People are tired of Fianna Fáil' says Fianna Fáil delegate.
"‘People are fed up with Fianna Fáil for charging 4/4 to the working man for butter and telling him that the children's allowances will make up for it,' Mr. M. Hartney, Limerick City, told East Limerick Fianna Fáil...."
Comment on this
Again, I have to correct the Senator. Will he now read the letter which Mr. Hartney sent to the Sunday Independent and which was published the following week?
Comment on this
I do not know what letter Mr. Hartney may have sent when rapped on the knuckles by the Taoiseach or by Senator Mullins——
Comment on this
I am asking the Senator to read the correction which Mr. Hartney sent to the Independent and which was published by that paper.
Comment on this
I cannot compel the Senator to read any letter.
Comment on this
Senator Reilly is not likely to improve the possibilities in regard to letting the Minister for Finance reply at 10 p.m. I thought that was the idea. Senator L'Estrange is not preventing that very desirable result but it seems to me that the Senators opposite have entered into a conspiracy to keep the Minister for Finance here.
Comment on this
I cannot permit the Senator to speak again.
Comment on this
The Seanad is not going to be used to misrepresent private individuals who have no opportunity to reply.
Comment on this
There will be an opportunity for the Senator to speak on another occasion but he has already spoken in this debate. I cannot compel Senator L'Estrange to make the kind of speech which Senator Mullins would like him to make.
Comment on this
I think the Chair stated "as near to ten o'clock as possible", but all the interruptions are only bringing fresh material to my mind.
Speaking before the last election the Tánaiste said that unemployment and emigration were the acid test of policy. The Fianna Fáil Government, he said, measured the effect of its work by these standards. If they are to be measured on these standards the result is very, very poor. In 1956 when the inter-Party Government was in office, in the month of July the number unemployed was 49,297. In the corresponding month of July this year the number of people unemployed is 52,971.
We all know that emigration reached an all-time record during the past year. It is reckoned that between 60,000 and 70,000 people have emigrated, and even Senators on the other side of the House have deplored the fact that the doors of small farms were being closed and the people were emigrating. That emigration is taking place, despite the promises made to the people by Fianna Fáil, both before and during the election.
There has been a great deal of talk about confidence returning. In the past, trade union leaders have been quoted when they were Fianna Fáil members of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union, whenever they criticised the inter-Party Government. I now wish to quote from the Irish Times, of 25th April, a speech made by Mr. Walter Beirne, secretary of the organisation, who stated:—
"...the Government had promised to treat unemployment as a matter of urgency and to give it priority during the last general election but the unions had been disappointed. This month they had 78,500 unemployed and there was not a solitary ray of hope from end to end of the Minister for Finance's Budget speech."
That is what the leader of one union thinks of this Government. Mr. Beirne added:—
"The conference should show the disappointment that the trade unions felt at the Government's failure to implement its election promises, and at its failure to put forward any solution to the unemployment problem."
We know, in fact, that even when the members of the Government were making those promises, they had no intention of fulfilling them.
When we talk about confidence, and about what people have to say about the Government, it might be no harm to quote from the Nenagh Guardian of Saturday, March 1st, 1958. A Fianna Fáil convention was held in Nenagh on Sunday, 28th February, at which Mr. Roger Williams, Cloughjordan, said:—
"Last year they had Mr. Lemass in Nenagh and he told them the object of the Government was to relieve unemployment, and he said: ‘Let us get cracking.'"
This was a Fianna Fáil delegate.
"They had waited for the Government to get cracking and the results had been very poor. There were almost as many unemployed to-day as there were 13 months ago, and in addition, 50,000 people had emigrated. That was very bad cracking, said the speaker. The delegates he spoke to were disgusted with the way things are going."
That does not show a happy family.
Comment on this
It is free speech all right, but it does not show you are living up to the promises you made at that time.
Recently, the Minister for Lands was quoted on page 15 of a magazine called Development as saying: “Moreover, our people do not suffer from the adverse effect of over-full employment.” I wonder is that the attitude of the Government of today? Do they want to see 60,000 or 70,000 people unemployed the whole year round so that the millers—the men over whom the Minister shed crocodile tears the other night—and all the big combines in this country, may get slave labour? Is that what the Minister for Lands stands for at the present time? Is that the whip they want to hold over those people? I am surprised that the Minister for Lands, or any Fianna Fáil Minister, should make such a statement.
We have heard a lot of comment about what the Government were to do, and about their plans for providing full employment. There is no doubt that when Fianna Fáil were in opposition, they were great people. They had plans for this, that, and the other —just let them get back into power— but when they did get back into power, we heard very little about their plans and what they intended to do to fulfil the promises they made to the Irish people. We have heard a lot of talk about what they have done in regard to the building of houses. I got figures on that from the Secretary of the Department of Local Government and I hope these figures will not be queried. I admit that no houses could be built during the war, but the war ended in 1945. In the years 1945, 1946, 1947— and I will give Fianna Fáil the year 1948 because they could argue they had the plans—only 1,515 houses were built. The inter-Party Government came into power then, and, in the next three years, 12,229 houses were built.
Despite all we have heard about 1956-57, there were 5,561 houses completed and built. Senator Colley shed crocodile tears during this debate last year about the poverty and unemployment among people who could not get work building houses in the City of Dublin, and said it was due to the inter-Party Government. Despite that, in 1957-58, only 3,559 houses were built, 2,000 fewer than in the year 1956-57 for which the inter-Party Government was so much criticised.
The very same applies to the number of houses built by county councils under the Labourers Acts. In the four years after the war, when cinemas and dance halls were being built throughout the country and when licences and permits were being given to build them —there was one built in Mullingar—631 houses were built. That was between the years 1945 and 1949. There was a change of Government then, and, in the next three years, 8,191 houses were built by the county councils, 24 times as many as were built in the previous four years of Fianna Fáil Government. In 1956-57, 1,617 houses were built and last year, under Fianna Fáil, despite the great leadership that we hear about from Senator Lenihan, only 1,261 houses were built, a drop of 400.
A question was asked in the Dáil recently as to the total amount of loans made under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act during the last five years. The figure for 1953-54 was £3.6 million; for 1954-55, £3.9 million; for 1955-56—the year we were criticised so much—the figure was £4,450,859; and in 1956-57 that fell to £2,897,000.
The Taoiseach recently stated in the Dáil that it was obvious that what we ought to seek is that which gives the best return, and at the moment it appeared that cattle gave the best return. When Senator Baxter spoke last week on this subject, Senator Lenihan took him up on it. As reported in the Official Reports of Seanad Éireann, Volume 49, column 971, Senator Lenihan said:—
"We had a further instance of statistical juggling from Senator Baxter in relation to our external balance problem."
I think it was Senator Lenihan himself who was juggling with statistics when he tried to prove that the greater part of that increase was due to some miracle Fianna Fáil achieved since 20th March, 1957. In 1957, our national income was £477,000.000. There was an increase of £19,000,000 over 1956——
Comment on this
Yes, "hear, hear". It was due to the increased export of cattle, of carcase beef, of sheep and of pigs. It was due also to the increased price which cattle fetched on the British market. There is no credit due to anybody on the far side of the House for that.
Our gross agricultural output—and these are the figures I want to get at— was £196,000,000. It had increased from £177,000,000 in 1956. That was an increase of £19,000,000. There is where your figure of £19,000,000 comes in— and remember that the Party on the other side of the House, the Government Party, could do nothing in those short years because those cattle and sheep were all born before Fianna Fáil came into office.
Industrial progress showed no change in total volume compared with 1956. We also note that the terms of trade are in favour of the Fianna Fáil Party. They have been in luck in that regard, because, in the past year, the cost of our imports dropped by six points and what we are getting for our exports, especially cattle, has increased enormously. As I have already said, the price of cattle increased by almost £3 per cwt.
We know that 1957 was a record year for production and exports from this country. It vindicates the policy the inter-Party Government pursued while they were in office. Our total exports were £131,000,000. Our exports of wool, for example, increased from a mere figure of £870,000 to £4,000,000 in 1957. Bacon exports increased from a mere £50 in 1947 to £4,250,000 in 1957. When the inter-Party Government were in office, the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, and Senator Baxter and I appealed to our farmers to produce more pigs. I remember that Deputy Dillon stated that if we could produce another 700,000 or 800,000 pigs for export, at £15 or £16 apiece, it would right our financial difficulties. The farmers answered the call and we exported to the tune of £4,250,000 worth of bacon.
We also exported £45,700,000 worth of cattle. When Senator Lenihan accused Senator Baxter of juggling with figures, he should have taken into consideration the extra £4,000,000 worth of bacon and the extra £6,000,000 worth of beef, fresh and chilled, exported last year. He should have taken those figures into consideration. Instead, he tried to bring out in this House that there was an extra £9,000,000 of industrial exports——
Comment on this
The Senator said it was due to industrial exports as a result of the courageous policy of the Government.
Comment on this
The Senator should quote me correctly. On a point of order, Senator L'Estrange has misquoted me. Indeed, he is misquoting from the Seanad Official Reports which he has in his hand.
Comment on this
There is nothing about industrial production in the sentence the Senator was quoting from.
Comment on this
I should like to deal with another question, mentioned by Senator Prendergast, namely, the eradication of bovine T.B. Nobody can exaggerate the urgency of this task. It has been repeated over and over again that it must be done immediately, but it does not seem to be sinking in that, unless we make a terrific effort to clear our herds completely of T.B. by 1961, we could be hit by the worst economic disaster that ever struck us. We have to guard against a big switch-over in Britain. The British farmers might themselves produce more beef. We all remember the time when Britain had to import 90 per cent. of her eggs. At present, she produces 80 per cent. of her eggs. The same might happen as regards beef.
There are certain people who have tried to sabotage the scheme for the eradication of bovine T.B. When some farmers in the south announced that they would not co-operate, we appealed to them to co-operate, in the interests of the nation. We pointed out to them that, even if they were hitting themselves, in one sense, they should co-operate in the scheme in the interests of the nation.
I come now to the question of veterinary surgeons. From what I read in the Press last week and from what I heard Senator Prendergast say this evening, our veterinary surgeons are looking for the same conditions as obtain for veterinary surgeons in England and Northern Ireland. I should be behind the Minister in any action he might take to see to it that these gentlemen do their work because it is national work. They, or anybody else, should not be allowed to hold up the Minister or the country to ransom. Nobody in the Twenty-Six Counties gets the same facilities, terms or wages as his opposite number receives in Britain or in Northern Ireland. Our farmers are not getting it for their produce. Neither do members of the medical association. No professional people in this country are getting the same terms as their opposite numbers in Britain or in Northern Ireland. I do not see how the veterinary surgeons can claim it. I do not think they are entitled to it. An appeal should be made to those people to go out and do their duty. If our cattle are not free from T.B. by 1961, we could have one of the biggest depressions that ever hit us. It is imperative that the Government do everything in their power to ensure that this vitally important work goes ahead smoothly.
Comment on this
I take it the Senator is prepared to give the Minister an opportunity of speaking?
Comment on this
No agreement was come to. I said I wanted to speak. I might be finished now but for the way I was interrupted from the other side. However, I shall try to finish within the next ten minutes. I would point out that there was no agreement on my part.
Comment on this
I want to know if it was not understood from Senator Hayes that there was agreement that the Minister would get in not later than 10 p.m.
Comment on this
Yes, it was agreed to aim that the Minister would get in at 10 p.m. It was indicated that at least two persons behind me wished to speak. Senator L'Estrange said he would speak for an hour. If he had not been interrupted, he would have finished long ago.
Comment on this
I have not. I rose to speak at nine o'clock. I took a note of the exact time I started.
Comment on this
Would it not be simpler to allow Senator L'Estrange to finish his speech now and to let the Minister get in? We shall finish the whole business by 12 o'clock, anyhow.
Comment on this
I think Senator Hayes is a little naive in this matter. I was listening to this arrangement. It was not mentioned specifically that Senator L'Estrange should deliver a diatribe for an hour. I have been sitting here all day and I put it to the House that I am as much entitled to speak as Senator L'Estrange.
Comment on this
There was no agreement that he should monopolise the debate and keep us here until midnight.
Comment on this
If I understood it properly, he said he would end in ten minutes. In my view, he should end now.
Comment on this
We heard a lot about what the Fianna Fáil Government would do, if they got back, to restore employment and stem emigration. After a year's inactivity, the following steps were taken to create more unemployment and stop emigration: in regard to the Local Authorities (Works) Act in my own county council alone, they lost £60,000 this year; Fianna Fáil reduced the farm buildings scheme and the water supply scheme by £140,000 in this Estimate; they cancelled the double byre grant which was given as an incentive in regard to the Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Scheme; and they cut the figure for new school buildings by £174,000.
Comment on this
They cut the Gaeltacht housing grant by £27,000 and they cut the ground limestone scheme by £22,000 and imposed a freight charge of 4/- per ton. That is quite correct; that is not wrong. They cut the price of wheat by 12/-.
Comment on this
Forestry development and improvement was cut by £130,000. They effected a decrease in the total moneys for forestry of £36,000. They cut the urban employment schemes by £60,000. They abolished food subsidies to the tune of £9,000,000, but showed no corresponding reduction in expenditure. These are the great achievements of Fianna Fáil. These are the things which will relieve unemployment and end emigration.
In conclusion, I want to ventilate a matter which I think is of serious public importance. It is of particular importance to the Seanad. Recently the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated in the Seanad that tea merchants who did not become members of Tea Importers, Limited, would suffer no disadvantage.
Comment on this
I think this is gross misrepresentation. We have had all this threshed out in the House to-day by at least three speakers from the opposite side.
Comment on this
I will quote from the debate, column 444, Volume 49:—
"Mr. Barry:... What precise difference will there be between tea merchants who do not join this company and who import tea from the East and who have to import it through the company machine? What precise difference will there be in the advantage or disadvantage that will accrue to them?
Mr. S. Lemass: None that I know of."
Let me quote from column 448:—
"Mr. Barry: Would the Minister indicate in figures, so that I could understand, what disadvantage it is to those who do not become members or shareholders?
Mr. S. Lemass: They suffer no disadvantage."
Comment on this
The Chair wishes to draw the attention of the Senator to the fact that these matters were dealt with yesterday in detail by Senator Barry. There is no point in having a repetition.
Comment on this
And also to the fact that the Senator was to finish his speech at 10 o'clock. It is now five minutes past ten.
Comment on this
This is one of the greatest examples of Tammany Hall methods we had in this country.
Comment on this
I will stand over it. Those people are asked to pay 3d. extra for every lb. of tea. If that is not a racket, I do not know what is.
Comment on this
I do not intend to devote very much of my time to the speech made by Senator L'Estrange. There are just a few points I should like to mention before I go on to more serious matters. I listened to the speech by the Senator on the Vote on Account. If anybody had the courage to do a little research, he would find that he has now made the same speech again. It does not impress me very much. It does not impress anybody. He spent an hour giving figures which were mostly wrong and always misapplied. They do not mean anything.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the figures are not wrong. Any figures I gave are taken from official statistics.
Comment on this
We will deal with some of them. The Senator takes up this brief which I have heard in the Dáil three or four times about some unfortunate fellow who made a speech at a Fianna Fáil convention at Nenagh. It was not behind closed doors. We are not like Fine Gael. What was said went into the Fine Gael dossier. I have heard it so often in the Dáil that I know it almost by heart.
There were many economic factors favourable to the situation last year and which brought about a balance in foreign trade. In fact, they give more than a balance. They give a favourable balance. The Senator claimed that was all due to the foresight of the inter-Party Government. If it was, they did it without knowing it. They certainly did not know about it when they went to the country in confusion to fight an election with despair. They went back in very much smaller numbers than they went out. To suggest that a Government of that kind had planned all this favourable trade for 1957 is going too far altogether with the joke.
There is one thing that I never let pass in regard to the Fine Gael propagandist, that is, the slaughter of the calves because I suffered more at the time. I was then Minister, fighting the British Empire and their allies the Blueshirts.
Comment on this
The Blueshirts as well as the British Empire. We had to fight the Blueshirts who were allies of the British Empire.
Comment on this
I must say that I always wonder and marvel at the cheek of the Fine Gael people who can mention the slaughter of calves at all or anything about the economic war—a Party that claims to be national and who sided with our enemies when we were fighting the economic war and did their best to defeat us. They should not say anything more about the matter now. They should keep silent.
The same Senator talked about our maintaining a lawful Government. We had to adopt very strong measures at the time to maintain lawful Government against Fascist Blueshirts. Indeed, the Leader of the Party at that time, Deputy Costello, boasted he would be in the same position before long as Hitler was in Germany and Mussolini in Italy.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange should be satisfied because he has vexed the Minister and the whole Party opposite. He has got under their skin.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes may be annoyed because Senator L'Estrange let him in for it by talking about the economic war and the Blueshirts. He should not have mentioned them. Senator Hayes has the sense to know that these things should not be mentioned.
Senator Baxter said that we now all admit our errors in agricultural policy in the past. I hope we do. When I became Minister for Agriculture in 1932, the agricultural policy at that time was to raise live stock on grass and imported feeding stuffs and to feed our people on imported grain, imported fruit and mainly imported vegetables. That has all gone now. Now we all believe we can grow wheat, feeding stuffs, fruit and so on in this country. If Senator Baxter is sincere in saying that we are all admitting our errors of the past, it is something to be proud of.
A number of Senators, beginning with Senator Baxter, spoke of the trouble with the veterinary surgeons in the Department of Agriculture. I think Senators should leave that matter alone. Why should they assume the Minister is wrong and should give in? Surely no sensible Minister would adopt an attitude like that, unless he had some reason for doing so? One Senator asked me to speak to the Minister for Agriculture. I have discussed the matter with the Minister for Agriculture. I know the position and I am not inclined to ask him to go a step further.
Comment on this
Well, it would be better not to talk about it then. It is simply mischievous talking about a thing like that. It is only giving the veterinary surgeons concerned a bit of encouragement to hold out when they feel that Senators are behind them and so on.
Senator Baxter talked about the Free Trade Area. He more or less found fault with the Government for describing this country as an undeveloped country economically. He went on to say he did not think we should try to be like the developed cities in England and the Continent. He gave the impression—I do not know whether he meant it or not—that the Government would like to see the cities of this country the same as the cities in England and the Continent, not only economically but culturally and morally as well.
Senator O'Brien, dealing with financial matters, said that I should try to resist as far as possible Supplementary. Estimates, unless they had a productive purpose. I agree with that. I certainly would resist as far as possible any Supplementary Estimate, unless it has a productive purpose—I should say any sort of substantial Supplementary Estimate or new Supplementary Estimate. Of course, there are small amounts that must be met—amounts not provided through an oversight or where there was some change, not so much in policy, but in circumstances during the year. Generally speaking, however, I certainly agree with Senator O'Brien.
The Senator went on to say that, in the first four months of this year, the balance of payments had deteriorated. He understood the policy of the Government was to keep trade balanced. I stated in the Dáil, and I should like to state here again, that the policy is to keep it balanced, but we are not too keen on building up a surplus. We feel that painful methods will have to be adopted for that purpose. It is not necessary that it should be done. As long as we can keep it balanced, almost balanced or a little over-balanced, we will be satisfied to carry on and try to build up our economy on that basis.
The Senator concluded by saying that, in this matter of bringing in economic specialists to advise us, in the long run, they might not be as useful as the family physician. I quite agree with that. I think if we do bring in foreign advisers, we will probably get the family physician to advise us again before adopting any suggestion given to us.
There are one or two remarks I want to make on Senator O'Donovan's speech. He talked about the amount of sterling we had and of the case made to have it available for trade. He said that the whole sterling area has much less, in proportion, than we have, although, as he put it, they probably have 50 per cent. of the trade of the world, while we have much less than 1 per cent. That is the very reason why we have more proportionately than they have. If you had the whole of the world trade, you would want none; if you had half, you would not want very much; but when you go down to a very small proportion such as we have, you want a bigger proportion of foreign exchange in order to keep things right.
Senator O'Donovan referred to a scheme brought in by the Agricultural Credit Corporation before the inter-Party Government went out and he said it was unworkable. That is true. I had nothing to do with that. That scheme was brought in by the previous Government and the details were worked out by the two Ministers concerned, the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance. It has proved to be almost unworkable. However, we may be able to make some changes in that scheme in the near future.
The Senator went on to talk about the amount of business the Agricultural Credit Corporation is doing, which he makes out is extremely small. He concluded his remarks on the Agricultural Credit Corporation by saying that, if the new chairman appointed by me does the job as well as I forecast, then he would certainly congratulate me on my choice. This matter was also raised by Senator L'Estrange. I do not want to dwell on it very much except that I want to make it perfectly clear again that when I said in the Dáil I was not satisfied with the amount of work the Credit Corporation were doing, I said I was not blaming the board for that, that I was blaming the policy being pursued, for which of course the Ministers are responsible, and blaming the procedure which had been laid down for the board.
Since then I have been accused of finding fault, as it were, with the board and staff and I would like to make it clear that I had no such intention. As I said in the Dáil any shortcomings there may be are due to procedure and policy and when I was speaking in the Dáil I gave as a reason for appointing the new chairman that he had administrative experience in agricultural credit and banking and that the knowledge would be useful in implementing a new policy which the Minister for Agriculture and I had been discussing and which we hope to put before the board in the very near future. That did not take from the qualifications and experience of the board, the managing director and the staff.
It was so obvious to me that the managing director and staff had knowledge and experience of agricultural credit and banking that it never occurred to me to mention the matter, and indeed it was far from my mind to cast any aspersions on them in that respect. I was too well aware, over the years, both when I was Minister for Agriculture and since, of the ability of these gentlemen, of the managing director and the staff, and of their experience, and I might add, of their loyalty and industry, to say anything derogatory in reference to them in that particular position.
Senator Lenihan said that what we need is risk capital and that is exactly the right way to put it. I have expressed the opinion, both in the Dáil and here, that there is no shortage of capital for desirable projects—in fact, I think what we lack are the desirable projects. That is one of the reasons why I have expressed a wish for foreign capital to come in. It is not that we need the foreign capital but foreign capital coming in will probably bring projects with it and bring the knowledge, experience, technical requirements and so on that we need to start new industries here. I think we have got general agreement on that point and I need not stress it any more.
Senator Lenihan said we should try to regulate our taxation code so as to encourage risk capital coming in. Well, we have been doing that as far as we can. Senator McGuire also spoke about taxation and he stated that there was not a very favourable atmosphere for the building up of industries, one of the reasons being our taxation code. I do not know if very much fault can be found with it. After all you have practically the same type of taxation in all countries where industries have been built up and I do not know if we can blame the taxation very much for any slowness in the building up of industry here. We have been offering incentives in our taxation code to new industries to come along, especially of the export type. It is not true to say that an industry cannot build up reserves on account of the taxation because after all they are only taxed on profits and only part of their profits is taken.
Senator Lenihan went on to talk about drainage and he appeared to think that arterial drainage would take 100 years to finish. I cannot say how many years it will take, but it will certainly be nothing like 100 years. Senator Lenihan is a young man and I am quite sure he will see the end of it in his time. With regard to his proposal for a national drainage authority, that has been advocated by many people. There may be something to be said for it but I must confess I never went into it very deeply and I never examined the merits or demerits of it but I certainly shall take the opportunity of doing so.
I mentioned already Senator McGuire's reference to the atmosphere with regard to industry here. He went on to say that the Government had put too much weight on industry. I presume by that he means taxation. He may mean restrictions as well but he probably means taxation. As I said already, I do not know if we can be accused of putting too much weight on industry. He then went on to talk about whether industry could stand any more or not. I was rather interested in his view on that matter.
At the present time if we take production in general we are just getting through, as it were. We may not have a deficit in our balance of payments this year but we certainly will not do much better. We are not going to have a very big surplus. We are barely accumulating enough savings to put into capital investment so that we are actually using up the whole volume of our current production. We are using up everything that is coming in in current production to satisfy existing consumption at home and if anything throws that out of balance it is going to be bad. We could not have more consumption. People cannot consume any more goods or services. If they do they will put things out of balance, unless we produce more. Therefore, Senator McGuire is quite right when he ended up by saying: "Let us get going, produce more and then we can all be better off." We are not in that position and we must be very careful with the economy as it stands and not strain it. If we were to spend more at present, by making money available in any way, it would mean that capital would be reduced and that would mean the future would be mortgaged, as it were, and we would not be as well off in three or four years' time as we should be if we carry on as we are and build up from our resources.
Senator Quinlan talked about technical civil servants, such as meteorological officers and agricultural officers, and he thought that they were not being treated as well as administrative officers in the Civil Service. That is a very old contention which goes on between the technical men and the administrative men. There are, of course, arguments for and against. It must be admitted that some of the administrative men are at the top but it must also be admitted that a great number are below the technical officers and perhaps when the matter is regarded in that light, things are fair enough as they are.
There is one thing on which I would like to make a comment. The Senator talked about an agricultural officer here having 1,000 farmers to look after, whereas in Denmark the agricultural officer has only 300. That is not the point. The point is that an agricultural officer here cannot look after a farmer unless he is invited to do so; and I think the fact is that the same proportion of farmers here have not invited the agricultural officer to look after them as has been the case in Denmark. If every farmer here had invited the agricultural officer to look after him, we would need more agricultural officers, but I do not see the use of putting more of them into any county if they have no work to do. They cannot make the work; they must wait until the individual farmers invite them to come. That practice is growing and the farmers are gradually falling into line; they are consulting the agricultural officers and I presume that, in time, we will reach the same position as obtains in Denmark and those other countries which are always being quoted.
Senator Stanford spoke in general of the country's ills and he said that three quarters of our ills are outside the control of any Government. There is no doubt about that. In fact, he may be putting it too low when he says "three quarters". The Senator said that there are many things which we could solve for ourselves and that no Government could solve for us. He wound up by asking for a "cease fire" between Parties. Well, there would need to be disarmament also.
Comment on this
That reminded me of what the great Abraham Lincoln said at one time: "In this great democracy of America, every man can curse the President, but the President must be allowed to curse back."
Senator Miss Davidson spoke of waste. I quite agree with the Senator that there is a great deal of waste, both public and private. If I could do anything to eliminate waste, I should be very glad to do it; and now that it has been drawn to my attention I shall certainly see if we can have a campaign of that kind. I was not able to check up on the point Senator Davidson raised about the auction but I think the auction which was held by the Garda was not altogether as bad as might appear at first sight. For instance, I am told that the bicycles are practically all stolen bicycles which were found by Gardaí and which no one claimed. I do not think that the bicycles came out of the Garda stores. The same thing applies to a lot of the other things mentioned; it was mostly lost property or stolen property. I admit that there were tunics and so on, as mentioned by the Senator. I do not know whether they were secondhand or not. I shall inquire about that. The one thing which puzzled me was the sale of truncheons.
Comment on this
I do not know why they got rid of the truncheons. However, I shall inquire about that. Senator Ó Donnabháin asked why veterinary research was excluded from the activities of the Agricultural Institute. I am not sure about that point. This institute has been under discussion for so long that I hardly remember now what the first proposals were. I think the point was made that the Department of Agriculture has a branch or sub-Department which is always called the Agricultural Research Department; and probably it was thought better to leave it there where it was. At any rate, the Department has a very big number of veterinary surgeons; and I suppose it was felt that it would be as well to leave veterinary research there—for the moment, at least. It is always easy to make a change, if it is considered necessary to move veterinary research into the Agricultural Institute.
That brought us on to bovine T.B., which was first raised by Senator Ó Donnabháin and then by Senator Sheridan and again by Senator Prendergast. It is undoubtedly one of the biggest problems we have; and I think everyone is alive to the fact that it is an extremely urgent one. Senators may accept it from me that the Department of Agriculture are doing everything they possibly can to get on with the job. They appear to be reasonably satisfied that they will be through in time with clearing the thing up. I must admit that, when one talks about 1962 and about what has been done already and how long it takes to do it, it looks as if the Department may not get through in time. However, they appear to be satisfied that they can get through in time with this job.
I do not know about the point of incentive mentioned by Senator Sheridan in this connection. Possibly it is true that the British gave an incentive of £2 per beast per year. That, of course, would be a very big amount of money here but I admit that if it were necessary we would have to face it. Senators must admit that at present we are giving a fairly big bonus. For every animal that is rejected we pay the market price, and, of course, we have to sell that beast afterwards, for whatever purpose it may be suitable. It may be suitable only for use as meat meal, or it may not be suitable for anything but the hide, and so on. On the average, we get back only about half the amount we paid for it. That is the subsidy mentioned in the Estimates at present; it is fairly heavy and will be getting heavier as time goes on.
The Senator said that the agricultural industry was more worthy of support than any of these "newfangled" industrial projects. We all admit that and act on that assumption. I gave figures the last time I was speaking and I do not wish to delay the Seanad by repeating them now. Those figures showed that the amount spent on agriculture in the way of subsidies, grants and so on, was far and away bigger than the sums spent on other industries. Therefore, the Senator is not only right in what he says, but everyone agrees that he is right and everyone acts accordingly. The Senator wound up by saying that it is much easier to keep a market than to regain a market which has been lost. There is no doubt about that, and we all have to agree with that.
Senator Ó Maoláin talked about An Bord Fáilte, on which I think I will not comment at the present time, as I do not know much about An Bord Fáilte. I should say a word or two about the Senator's advocacy of something to instil a spirit of nationality into the children in the schools. I agree that something of that kind should be done, but how it is to be done I do not know. I have taken a note of the point about the 21st birthday of the Constitution. I think that has probably been adverted to already but, if not, we will see about it.
Senator Tunney, in speaking about the subsidised turf for certain classes of social welfare recipients, gave very interesting figures and made a very good case for a review of the whole position. I shall ask the Minister for Social Welfare to look at it and shall send the Minister a copy of Senator Tunney's speech.
Senator Ó Siochfhradha made a plea that some of our Departments might become wholly Irish. I do not know if that is possible; it would be a great thing if it could be done. I can only take a note of that also and see if there is any hope of having it done now or in the near future.
Senator Tunney also referred to the allocation of health cards, which is a matter in which I was very interested, having been responsible for the Department of Health at one time. I always felt that county managers were rather restrictive in the issue of cards, but when it came to making inquiries of any county manager, he always satisfied me with figures that he was not too restrictive at all. This is a matter that the Minister for Health is watching all the time.
As regards the Senator's plea for a P.A.Y.E. system of collection of income-tax, the Income-Tax Commission, I believe, will report in due time on that proposal.
On the question raised about tea, I had time only to glance through the various publications last night. I found that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in talking of the treatment of shareholders and non-shareholders, said that they would be treated on the same basis as far as freight, insurance and landing costs are concerned. That was repeated several times. There is no doubt about that. But he did state that, in addition to this charge, the non-shareholders would be charged an agency commission. It is only common sense that they would be because, when the Minister put this scheme before the Government—I remember this part of it all right—he said there would have to be some inducement to the tea importers to take shares in this company and, if there was no difference whatever between the shareholders and those who did not take shares, why would a man take shares, why would he tie his money up there? It was obvious that there would have to be some difference. If the commission charged is too high, there is an appeal to the Fair Trade Commission. It is exactly the type of case the Fair Trade Commission would deal with and they would be able to give their decision as to whether the amount charged was too high or not.
I have said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce said several times that there would be equal treatment as regards freight, insurance, landing costs, and so on, but he did, as I say, make the distinction that the non-shareholder would have to pay an agency fee.
Comment on this
Yes, that is right. On 21st May, 1958,—Volume 49, No. 5, column 450—the Minister for Industry and Commerce, replying to Senator Barry, said:—
"What the Senator will be charged will depend on the services which the Senator requires. If the Senator requires this company to act as his agent, presumably they will charge an agency fee. Alternatively, he may buy the tea himself anywhere he likes—in Timbuctoo or anywhere else—and the company will act as shipping agent and will recover for the service of shipping the tea in bulk to him only the proportionate cost of the freight."
So, the agency fee was undoubtedly mentioned. I have not studied in full what Senator Barry's case is, but if it is that this person—I am not sure if he was talking about himself or somebody else—was charged an agency fee where it should not have been charged, that is one matter or, if he was charged too high an agency fee, in that case, if he thinks it worth while, he should apply to the Fair Trade Commission to investigate the matter and they, as I have said, have full powers to adjudicate in a case of this kind. I think that would be the remedy.
Comment on this
Senator Barry's case is that a trader has to pay £18 a week now, where he had to pay nothing before and is getting nothing for it. That is his case. Whether it is true or not, I do not know.
Comment on this
That may be, but Senator Barry made the case that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had given an undertaking. Whether Senator Barry is right in that or not is another matter. The Minister certainly did not give the undertaking there that no agency fee would be charged. In fact, he said an agency fee would be charged to a non-shareholder.
Comment on this
In my contribution to the debate, I asked the Minister if it were true that an offer of financial help had been made by Britain.
Comment on this
I am sorry; I am glad the Senator reminded me about that. No such proposition was made; the British have never suggested any such thing. If they did, I suppose we would be inclined to accept it, although I want the Senator to understand that we are not delaying this by one day for want of money. If the Department of Agriculture said to us: "We can go quicker if you give us another £500,000", we will say: "You may have your £500,000."
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation on this stage, I fear that a reference of mine, when I was speaking at an earlier stage of this Bill to-night, to a certain aspect of the affairs of the Arts Council might be taken as a personal reference to the chairman of that body. The particular words I have in mind are "stupid and incompetent". Should what I say be correct, will you please allow me to withdraw that reference?