Central Fund Bill, 1959—Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 117–268 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1959 ›
Senator Carter stated that while introducing measures to change the system of P.R., the Government have been busy doing good work to improve the economy. I should like to know what measures they have introduced recently to improve the economy. We are at the crossroads. Never in the history of this country was it more necessary than it is now for all political Parties to come closer together, to work in harmony in the interests of the people, to deal with emigration and unemployment. I put them before the Irish language or the ending of Partition.
Comment on this
There must be increased production in order to put our people to work in Ireland, to make Ireland a better place for Irish men and women to live in. Unfortunately, while that work remains to be done, the Taoiseach has plunged the country into a bitter political controversy in his determination to abolish P.R.
Comment on this
Your determination. You have been defeated to-day and you will be defeated in the country in the very near future.
Comment on this
We have had a great deal of P.R. over a period and, while the Senator may be in order, I suggest that he discontinue that line.
Comment on this
It is wrong to divide our people again into two different camps. We of the younger generation, who have escaped the blood and the slime of the civil war and the appalling legacy of hatred it bequeathed, are sorry that, when the Parties were moving closer to each other, the Taoiseach should have again divided this country as he did 40 years ago. That affects more than anything else the future progress and prosperity of the country. Senator Carter said that anyone who leaves is doing a disservice to his country.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I said "anyone not forced out by economic factors." I did not say "anyone". I said, "anyone who was not forced out through economic circumstances."
Comment on this
It is economic circumstances that are forcing our people out at the present time. Do Fianna Fáil want those people to stay at home and starve or do they want them to become patriots? It is all very well for people in well-paid, secure jobs to talk about patriots. We have patriots, but they have little use for patriotism, except the patriotism which in recent years has become such a highly organised and remunerative profession for followers and hangers-on of the Fianna Fáil Party. I make no apology to Senator Lenihan or anybody else for that statement because political patronage is rife in this country to-day.
Comment on this
The Party of which the Senator is a member have fostered it and they have known all about it for a long time.
Comment on this
At this hour of the night, it is well that we should try to end on a reasonable note. While it is within the rights of the Senator to say all these things, I suggest that he can probably get his case across without being provocative. I do not want another speaker after him, except the Minister.
Comment on this
We have heard a great deal about emigration, that the Irish people are being driven out of the country, that the cream of our youth are leaving and are helping the economy of other nations, while we are inviting in here foreigners with foreign capital to build up our nation. That is a daft policy. If we have £10,000,000 to spend to-day on jet aeroplanes to build up our prestige abroad and to take our emigrants abroad, I think it would be much better if that money were spent in different ways in this country in an endeavour to increase production and give employment to our people at home.
Senator Carter to-day spoke of pet schemes that were started by Fianna Fáil and which are now coming to an end. One would think that everything in this country which was for the good of the country was started by Fianna Fáil. We all know that is not true. He mentioned rural electrification. I will just deal in passing with rural electirfication which was started in 1924. The Shannon scheme started away back in 1924 and it was Deputy McGilligan, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, who started it. At that time it was referred to by the Fianna Fáil Party as a white elephant.
Comment on this
It led up to it. Were it not for the work done at that time Fianna Fáil could not have started it in 1947. Let it be remembered that they had the plans ready only then. It was the inter-Party Government that did the work and continued with the work in 1948, 1949 and 1950.
Comment on this
They are completing fewer than 20 areas at the present time than were completed in 1944. 1945 or 1946. We heard much about the White Paper. Senator Carter told us to-day that the White Paper points the way. I claim that the White Paper takes up only where the inter-Party Government left off in 1957. In the White Paper you had 15 paragraphs and five pages devoted to grass and the raising of mutton and beef. You have one single paragraph and half a page devoted to the growing of wheat. That is a big change.
Comment on this
You are converted to the Fine Gael policy. When Deputies James Dillon and Patrick Hogan preached that we should have better grass I remember what they were called. Deputy Hogan was called the Minister for Grass and those associated with him were referred to as ranchers who wanted nothing on the land of Ireland but the man and the dog. Now the people on the far side of the House realise the importance of having good grass on the land of Ireland. That is a change. It is a pity that they did not learn the importance of good grass 20 or 25 years ago. The White Paper says: "Grass is the raw material of our principal export trade, beef and cattle, of milk production and of sheep and lamb production." They realise now the importance of our beef, our cattle and our milk production. There was a time when they did not. There was a time when the present Minister for Finance had the throats of the calves slit from ear to ear and 20 years later they realise their mistake.
Comment on this
We were waiting for that. No speech would be complete without it.
Comment on this
If Senators Lenihan and Ryan would just remain silent, I am quite certain we would finish much more quickly and orderly.
Comment on this
Paragraph 18 of the White Paper states:—
"The liming programme followed in recent years has made considerable progress, with the result that we are now one of the largest users of lime per acre in Europe..."
I suppose they will tell us that Fianna Fáil started that. As a matter of fact, in 1947, as Deputy Dillon has so often stated, there was not enough ground limestone in this country to fill one egg-cup. The success of that scheme is due to Deputy James Dillon, and the inter-Party Government.
Now let me quote from paragraph 56 of the White Paper:—
"There is no doubt, however, that the bulk of our agricultural exports will continue to be marketed in Britain, and our trade relations with that country are, therefore, a matter of prime importance."
It is a grand thing to see this Party, after the havoc and destruction they wrought in this country in the past, now converted and that they realise the importance of the British market—a market they told us at one time "was gone and gone for ever, thanks be to God."
Instead of the farmers keeping cattle, the present Taoiseach told the farmers on one cold winter's day at the fair of Arva, it would be much better if they started to keep bees. He told them that the best type of bee to keep was the Egyptain bee. Unfortunately, many of the poor farmers in the country were stung and badly stung by the drones that exist in the Fianna Fáil Government and in the Fianna Fáil Party for the past 20 years. Despite the fact that they told us they would do without Britain and the rest of the world if every damn ship was sent to the bottom of the sea they now in the year 1959 realise that all they said in the past was wrong as they now realise that all they claimed about P.R. was wrong.
There is one thing certain. Fianna Fáil have been consistent in their inconsistency for the past 20 or 25 years but, again, it is a pity they did not realise the importance of the British market 20 or 25 years ago. If they did this would be a better country for all our people and we might not have the high unemployment and the high emigration that we have from Ireland at the present time.
We know that this is an agricultural country. If the people on the land of Ireland are prosperous, then the whole nation will be prosperous. We have 12,000,000 acres of fertile arable soil. We have a population of little over 2,500,000 people representing roughly five acres of land for every person in the country. Let us go back to 1947. After 16 long years of Fianna Fáil Government we had not even enough butter to feed our own people. At that time we imported butter from New Zealand and other countries.
I heard speakers to-day referring to our adverse trade balance. It might be no harm to point out that in 1932 our total exports were £36.3 million. Fianna Fáil then came into power and they were in power for 16 long years of uninterrupted Government. We have been listening for the past week to people telling us here that Fianna Fáil under P.R. could not pursue a proper policy because Governments would come and go. They could not get a Government strong enough to do their work properly. Fianna Fáil were in office for 16 long years at that time. A world war intervened and the price of our cattle doubled, not due to anything Fianna Fáil did, but due to the fact that there was a war. As I have said, we exported £36.5 million worth in 1931.
Sixteen years later the price of what we had to export doubled, not due to anything the Government did, and in 1947 our total exports were £39.5 million, or an increase of £3.5 million in 16 years. If the price of our exports had not doubled we would have been exporting roughly £18,000,000 worth less than we exported 16 years before that, and this is the Government who tell us they have the plan, and that they have accomplished anything that has been accomplished in this country during the last 40 years.
It might be no harm to remind Senator Kissane, who was talking about the adverse trade balance in 1947, that the adverse trade balance left by Fianna Fáil at that time was £91,823,364. In case there is anyone on the opposite side who would doubt that I am giving the exact figure.
Comment on this
Our total exports in 1947 were £39.5 million and, when a different Government came into power, in 1948, the number of cattle on the land was the lowest on record. In addition to that the fertility of our soil was at its lowest point. That Government got to work and, due to the programme they initiated, due to the Cattle Trade Agreement that they made with the British Government—and remember they sent their Minister to make that agreement, and not civil servants, as Fianna Fáil sent over— our total exports in 1957 had risen to £131,000,000. That is a record of which any Party, or any Government, should be proud. It was effected by the inter-Party Government in which different Parties came together to work in the interests of all sections of the community, irrespective of class, creed or politics.
I shall not go through the whole list but, for example, we exported £870,000 worth of wool in 1947 but, by 1957, the value of our wool exports was over £4,000,000. In 1947 our bacon exports were as low as £50 worth but in 1957 they were worth £4,250,000. It is only a few months since the Taoiseach told us that cattle seemed to be paying better than anything else at the present time, and that the people should rear more cattle. Twenty years ago it was bees, but now it is cattle. I do not know why he changed his mind unless it was that he was stung in the meantime. At any rate, he now realises the importance of the cattle population.
In 1931 there were 4.4 million cattle in this country but, after 16 years of Fianna Fáil government, they had decreased to 3.9 million in 1947. A change of Government then took place and we had the 1948 Cattle Trade Agreement with Britain. If there is anybody in the Fianna Fáil Party who will say that if they had remained in power they would have made as good an agreement with the British Government I would like to ask him, or the Minister, is it not true that between 1939 and 1945 Britain was in the middle of a world war, and that her ships were being sent to the bottom of the sea——
Comment on this
——and that the British people were rationed to two ounces of meat per week? Fianna Fáil have always told us that Britain's difficulties were Ireland's opportunities. Was that not Britain's difficulty and Ireland's opportunity, and why did the Minister for Agriculture at that time not negotiate a trade agreement and demand a fair price from the British Government for our cattle exports?
Comment on this
They could have hit them in their pride, or anywhere else. Britain was dependent on our cattle and she would have had to pay a fair and just price. We sold our cattle to Britain at from 50/- to 60/- a cwt. when the British people were on the brink of starvation, but, due to Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, the price was increased from 70/- a cwt. in 1947 to £9 a cwt. in 1957. There is no credit due to the Fianna Fáil Party for that. In addition, the number of cattle increased in ten years from 3.9 million to 4.5 million.
The very same thing applies to sheep and yet Fianna Fáil call themselves "the Progressive Party". In 1931, when they came into power, there were 3.5 million sheep in the country but, after their 16 years of glorious government, of strong government, they succeeded in reducing that number to 2.09 million. The inter-Party Government by encouraging the farmers—not by filling ten fields with inspectors, but by giving them a fair return for their labour—succeeded in increasing the number of sheep to 3.4 million. Now, let us take pigs. We know that the small farmers are interested in pigs. The production of pigs helps them to make their livelihoods. In 1931 we had 1.2 million pigs in this country but, after 16 years of stable Fianna Fáil Government, the number of pigs was reduced from 1.2 million to 456,973.
Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, gave a guaranteed price for pigs and encouraged pig production. He introduced Ymer barley into this country, and barley for feeding pigs, with the result that in 1957 we had enough barley to do us for ten months of the year. The result was that the number of pigs increased from 456,973 to almost 1,000,000, and we know that last year we exported almost £6,000,000 worth of bacon. Nobody in the Fianna Fáil Party need tell us that all those cattle, sheep and pigs were bred and reared during the last two years since Fianna Fáil came into office. They may try to put that impression across in the city, where the people may not know much about agriculture, but they will not succeed in fooling the farmers.
Comment on this
Remember, Sir, that before you can increase pigs the bonham must be born. If it is a sow it must be kept for nine months—the period before it is born is another four months and, before the pig is reared and fed ready for sale, it is another six to eight months. That is two years, all told.
Comment on this
The Senator will address himself to the Chair.
Comment on this
The Minister, in future, must ask his questions through the Chair and the Senator must reply through the Chair.
Comment on this
We have heard a lot about unemployment and emigration. We have been told by Senator Carter that a great drive is under way but unfortunately it is a great driving away of the people from this country. Most Rev. Dr. Lucey, Bishop of Cork, put it very well in the Cork Examiner. He is a man with his ear to the ground. He knows what goes on and is not driving about in a big State car. He is meeting the ordinary, plain people of the country and knows their views.
A month ago in the Dáil when the Taoiseach was asked by a Fine Gael Deputy to state the number who had emigrated, the Deputy was informed that he could not be given any reliable information. He could not be told the number that emigrated. But now Fianna Fáil come in with prepared figures trying to prove that emigration has been reduced. That is "tommyrot". What is happening at present is that whole families are emigrating. They are locking the kitchen door. Small farmers—in some cases the father, his wife and five or six children—are going over to England. When they arrive only one person applies for a work permit and perhaps only one member of the family is registered as having entered the country whereas in fact a whole family of six or eight is involved. When the Government speak of the number of unemployed being reduced by a few thousand they should know that you cannot expect people to be registered as unemployed in Ireland when they have emigrated and are working in Liverpool, Birmingham, London or some other English city. Most Rev. Dr. Lucey in the Cork Examiner——
Comment on this
That is of no consequence. The Senator is quite in order.
Comment on this
Would the Senator indicate where the whole families are going from around Westmeath and give us some facts to support his statement?
Comment on this
The Longford Leader has carried out an examination in County Longford which showed that 930 people had emigrated from Longford town alone in the last five years.
Comment on this
Mr. Austin Sheehy, Secretary of the Fianna Fáil Party, said—and it was printed in the Longford Leader—that when he was doing work for the Legion he found that, out of every house into which he went, from one to three people had emigrated and he had visited 60 houses during his work.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the Senator's attention——
Comment on this
Will Senator Carter please recognise that the Chair is speaking? I want to address myself to Senator L'Estrange and draw his attention to the fact that there is about one minute left.
Comment on this
I made no agreement and I think I am entitled to speak. If there were not so many unruly interruptions I might be able to finish.
Comment on this
I think it is the wish of the House, and that it was generally understood that the Minister, should have an opportunity of getting in at a quarter to ten. That was the understanding of the Chair.
Comment on this
Most Rev. Dr. Lucey speaking of the total population here now said there was less work and more unemployment than at an time since the famine. That is quite true. The population of the country has decreased; anyone saying that we have 4,000 fewer people unemployed or that fewer people have emigrated must realise that. If that is so, why did the Taoiseach not give the figures when he was asked to do so? There are fewer people employed to-day under Fianna Fáil. The average number of insurable people employed each week for the year ending 31st March, 1958 was the lowest for five years, 21,000 fewer than in 1957 and 36,700 fewer than in 1956. Those are facts and cannot be contradicted.
There are more unemployed. Let us take the numbers. There are 902 fewer people employed on the roads at present. The Minister cannot deny that because the figures were given recently in the Dáil. In the past, money was given by the Government under the Local Authorities (Works) Act; in my own county during the term of office of the inter-Party Government, we got from £50,000 to £60,000. That was money well spent because it helped to increase production. We know that a resolution was passed at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis last October asking the Government to reintroduce that scheme, but they will not do it because it was a scheme begun by the inter-Party Government.
Despite all we heard here from Senator Colley and other Senators two years ago about the housing programme and despite the crocodile tears they shed about people unemployed, there were 2,439 fewer people employed on local authority housing in August 1958, as compared with August 1957. We were told to-day about 1955 and about the then Government running away from its duties at that time. I would like to nail that lie because I think that at that time the Government put Party before country and that——
Comment on this
The Government put country before Party. They took courageous action and that action righted our balance of payments problem. But unfortunately, Fianna Fáil came into power and they reaped the benefit and are still reaping the benefit of the work done by the inter-Party Government.
Tomás ó Maoláin rose.
Comment on this
When Senator L'Estrange concluded, it was understood that the Minister was getting in.
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange was previously asked to stop to let the Minister in. If the Minister is not getting in, I suggest Senator L'Estrange is entitled to continue his speech and we are entitled to go on here to-night or adjourn to-night and resume to-morrow.
Comment on this
I asked Senator L'Estrange to stop for the purpose of letting the Minister in at a quarter to ten. Before the matter was mentioned in the House, I spoke to the Minister outside on the basis that as far as I could see, with Senator Quinlan and Senator L'Estrange wanting to speak, he could not get in before a quarter to ten. If the Minister is not going to get in at that time, Senator L'Estrange has been deceived and should be allowed to finish his speech. It seems to me there are two courses open to us: first, to allow Senator L'Estrange to continue his speech and then adjourn at 10 o'clock and resume to-morrow, or secondly, let the Minister in to conclude as agreed. After all, the Minister and Senator L'Estrange are on different side of the House, and how can we have two conclusions on behalf of the Government side?
Comment on this
I think it is time to put the cards on the table about this matter. I warned at the start of this debate between you and Senator L'Estrange that if Senator L'Estrange proceeded on the lines on which he was going, I would have a few words to say. I also warned Senator Hayes to the same effect. I sat here all day listening to the speeches, and if you read the Official Report, you will find that the number of speakers was heavily weighted on the side of the Opposition. Senator L'Estrange began at a quarter past nine and, even according to Senator Hayes's interpretation of an agreement, he was to be finished before a quarter to ten. At a quarter to ten, he showed no signs of finishing, and Senator Hayes then looked for another five minutes. Why should we be bullied by either Senator Hayes or Senator L'Estrange? The same thing happens every time. Senator L'Estrange is put up as a bogey man to threaten the rest of us that if we do not give way for a few minutes, the Seanad will sit all night.
Comment on this
Senator Mullins will now leave the matter to the Chair. I understood, and I drew the attention of Senator L'Estrange and the House to the fact, that the Minister was to get in at a quarter to ten and I proposed to call on the Minister at a quarter to ten. At that time, we had some interruptions. As I said earlier, I suggested that if we had no interruptions, we would get the debate concluded more quickly. Senator Hayes suggested that Senator L'Estrange should get five minutes. Senator Mullins did not protest and, in fact, Senator L'Estrange did not use the five minutes. I assumed that would conclude the debate. If Senator Mullins has a different point of view, the ruling of the Chair in this matter is that there is no agreement, that Senator L'Estrange is in possession and the House adjourns at 10 o'clock until to-morrow. I just want to know what is in the mind of the House.
Comment on this
I am not unwilling to take responsibility. I am quite prepared to take all kinds of responsibility. I have said privately to my friend, Senator ó Maoláin, that the less talk we have in the House about these matters, the better. I did not put up Senator L'Estrange to speak at all. It simply happened that Senator Quinlan was speaking and Senator L'Estrange wanted to speak. I made an arrangement with the Minister, of which Senator ó Maoláin is aware, that the Minister would get in at a quarter to ten. I am not bullying or deceiving anybody.
May I say there is no good in Senator ó Maoláin warning the Chair or the House that if a particular Senator does not make a particular kind of speech he, Senator ó Maoláin, will make a speech. The only person entitled to judge what kind of speech a Senator makes is the Chair. My intention was quite genuine all day to let the Minister in at 9.30 or 9.45. I suggested that Senator L'Estrange get five minutes. He did not even use them. If he stops now and the Minister gets in, well and good. If the Minister does not get in, then obviously Senator L'Estrange has a right to continue and we ought to adjourn and meet to-morrow.
Comment on this
It was understood here yesterday that the debate would finish on this motion to-night and that we would complete the Bill. Senator Quinlan spoke for over an hour and there were other long-distance speeches.
Comment on this
Then I suggested at twenty to nine that the Minister should be called on at 9.30. It was suggested by Senator Hayes that we make it a quarter to ten. It was understood that people would try to make their speeches short. At a quarter past nine, Senator Quinlan concluded and Senator L'Estrange began. When he began, I drew the attention of the Chair to the fact that if he continued on the line on which he was going, and which he has adopted many times here, I would be compelled to say a few words. I had no intention of speaking in this debate if Senator L'Estrange had not adopted that line. This has happened so often in regard to misunderstandings about arrangements that in future I do not propose to sit here and listen to the character assassination campaign of Senator L'Estrange without asserting my right to speak. Senator L'Estrange is always put up as the bogey-man.
Comment on this
What point is the Senator making? What does he desire?
Comment on this
I want to make one point. I am aware there is a Senator who wanted very much to speak for ten minutes to-night and he has not got in. He is entitled to just as much consideration as anybody else.
Comment on this
Let me be quite clear. If the Minister does not get in now to conclude the debate, the House will adjourn at 10 o'clock until to-morrow.
Comment on this
Senator Carter is not in order unless he raises a point of order.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. Senator Carter must resume his seat. That is not a point of order. It may be a question of explanation or something else, but it is not a point of order. The Chair is the judge in this, and the Chair is doing its utmost to be impartial, whatever may be thought to the contrary. What does the House think?
Comment on this
May I say to Senator Ó Maoláin in the calmest possible way that he is quite deceiving himself when he thinks that anybody put up Senator L'Estrange. I put up nobody and I have no bogeyman. All of us have to practise self-denial. But I should like Senator Ó Maoláin to be clear about this. He has absolutely no right at all to warn the Chair that if somebody in the House speaks in a particular way, something will happen. He just has not any power to do that.
Comment on this
Or to intimidate it. Nobody could be filled with more goodwill towards the Minister for Finance than I am; nobody could be filled with more desire to conclude this debate than I am. I wanted Senator L'Estrange to conclude his speech for a particular purpose. If that purpose is not accomplished, then Senator L'Estrange can go on. We can go on with the debate to-night, or adjourn until to-morrow. I do not mind which we do. If the Minister gets in now, well and good; but if he does not, Senator L'Estrange may continue his speech, so long as the Chair allows him.
Comment on this
Would the House be agreeable if I call on the Minister to conclude the debate and let us pass on?
Comment on this
Without abandoning one iota of my rights in this matter, in deference to the Minister, who has sat here all day, I am prepared to waive my objection in this case.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes asked me earlier how long I would take to speak and I said about three quarters of an hour, but I had not heard Senator L'Estrange at that time.
Comment on this
Before the Minister commences, I shall ask the House to hear the Minister as the House should hear him—in silence.
Comment on this
I do not intend to deal with all the misstatements which Senator L'Estrange made because that would take me until daylight, and it would take too long to unravel them. There are two or three points which I wish to make clear. Senator L'Estrange probably thinks he is being smart and offensive to me by talking about the slaughtering of calves. I always like to have the opportunity of explaining what happened. I was Minister for Agriculture. I was not in favour of slaughtering calves and it was not our policy to slaughter calves, but we were fighting an economic war with Britain and getting a poor price. The farmers in the South of Ireland, who always slaughtered the inferior calves, slaughtered more calves than previously. In order to compensate them to some extent, we gave them a bounty on calf skins. The economic war ended because the farmers stood by us. They fought that war successfully to a conclusion and we won the economic war, while Senator L'Estrange and his friends were going around in blue shirts trying to get the farmers to give in. I have nothing to be ashamed of, but if I had worn a blue shirt I certainly would be ashamed for the rest of my life. I would be ashamed to have put on a blue shirt and to have tried at that time to get the farmers to go against the Government. That was the issue and that was what the Blue-shirts tried to do, but the farmers stood by us.
Another point which the Senator made was that we were now all in favour of grass. We are not. We are in favour of producing all the crops we can and whatever Deputy Dillon may get credit for, he certainly cannot get credit for wheat growing here. In 1931, when we were in opposition, we introduced a motion advocating that wheat should be grown in order that we could supply ourselves with bread. There was a Cumann na nGaedheal Government in office and they opposed it. They said that millable wheat could not be grown and they issued a pamphlet to that effect. When we came into the office, we introduced the wheat scheme which was opposed by Cumann na nGaedheal. On one occasion, Deputy Dillon said that he would not be caught dead in a field of wheat, but we succeeded in getting millable wheat grown and, as a result, we were able to keep neutral during the 1939-45 war. That we remained neutral may have been no concern of Deputy Dillon, but it was the concern of the Irish people. Certainly we could never have done that but for the wheat policy. It was absolutely a Fianna Fáil policy and there was no other Party in favour of it.
We advocated also that we should grow barley and oats for feeding stuffs. I remember arguing in the Dáil with the members of Fine Gael—I am not sufficiently well up in history to know when they changed their name from Cumann na nGaedheal—and that Party were always against us on the question of growing barley and oats on the grounds that we would lessen the amount of land for live stock. We argued that there would be sufficient land for live stock and I remember quoting a very famous survey by Lord Bledisloe—I always remember the name—which showed that where good tillage was carried out, it would increase, and not decrease, the pasture that would be available for cattle; it would increase the produce from pasture because pasture would be improved as a result of tillage.
I mention that to show our argument all the time was that you could carry the live stock as well. Why now should we have a Senator like Senator L'Estrange—who we know has no great regard for the truth——
Comment on this
——trying to fasten on us a policy that we never had, a policy of trying to do away with live stock. The Senator talks about raising pigs, but if you look at the figures each year from 1947 to the present time, you will see that when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture——
Comment on this
——the figures for pigs were down. Look at it for yourselves and you will see that was the case all the time.
Comment on this
That was the case all the time and why should it not have been the case? When he came into office in 1948-49 he would close the Border one day and the next day he would open it, until the farmers became fed up and went out of pigs entirely.
Comment on this
I listened to 35 minutes of untruths from Senator L'Estrange and he should listen to me telling the truth.
Comment on this
It is the truth. Another thing which Senator L'Estrange quotes every time I come into the Seanad and——
Comment on this
Senator L'Estrange will conduct himself for the rest of the debate; if not, I shall have to ask him to withdraw.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I do not think any man in this House, whether he is a Minister or otherwise, has the right to say that a Senator told untruths for 35 minutes.
Comment on this
I have risen on a point of order and I am not going to have people barrage me out of making the point of order.
Comment on this
I have raised a point of order, Sir. I do not think that any man in this House, Minister or otherwise, has any right to say that somebody told untruths for 35 minutes. I certainly shall not listen to it.
Comment on this
That is how it appeared to me, anyhow. Senator L'Estrange says that it is a lie. Now Senator O'Donovan——
Comment on this
May I suggest that Senator L'Estrange should be quite satisfied? He can be quite satisfied that he has got under the Minister's skin.
Comment on this
Senator Hayes said the same thing before. It is very good technique for Senator Hayes to have a man here to say things which he himself would not like to say. Senator L'Estrange said something which he says every time I come into this House. He talks about production in 1947 and 1957, the number of cattle in the country, exports and so on, and he does not advert to the fact that there was a large scale war being fought, a desperate war for us. We imported no feeding stuffs, and no fertilisers and as a result, we could not get production from the land. There were no seeds being imported, so that production was down for that reason also. We had to depend entirely on our own production to feed our own people. We got nothing into the country and had to rely on what we produced ourselves.
Naturally, we were down in stocks, but, by 1948, the country began to build up again. Senator L'Estrange says that was due to Deputy Dillon and it always reminds me of those who attribute everything to Stalin and say: "Stalin did that." Look at the O.E.E.C. figures for Europe and you will find that, from 1947 to 1957, we were practically the lowest country in Europe, so far as improvement was concerned. We have not done as well in production as other countries from 1947 to 1957. We have not done as well in exports or any of the things that Senator L'Estrange mentioned as the achievements of Deputy Dillon. In all these countries in Europe where they have done so well, some of them have done twice as well as we have and a few, but very few, have done worse. In these countries that did so well from 1947 to 1957 they had no Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture or no Fine Gael Party to back him up and they certainly had no Fianna Fáil Party in 1947 to make the trouble to which Senator L'Estrange refers.
Is it not time to drop all that talk about 1947 and 1957? From 1939 to 1945 we had the biggest war ever in this world and Fianna Fáil, to the admiration of the people of this country, held out neutral, a thing the other Parties did not expect we could do. Naturally we were in very low water economically in 1947. Senator L'Estrange also spoke about the big adverse balance of trade. The very day the ports were open we imported all we could. If we imported goods to the value of £130,000,000, that was a sign of a good Government. Every Government was trying to get things in then not send them out. I remember going over to England and asking: "What will you give us?" That was the trend of negotiation all round and the countries that imported a lot were those where you had successful government. Therefore, the figure quoted by Senator L'Estrange for big imports in 1947 was a credit to the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
Any figures I have, I got them from the official statistics and I did not get one iota from Hume Street or anywhere else. I did not have to get them from Mount Street.
Comment on this
With reference to 1956, Senator L'Estrange and others who stand behind Deputy Dillon talk about the Suez trouble. The Suez trouble had no influence whatever on this country. It could not have had any influence on this country when it had no influence on England, and the English economists have said that it had no effect on them. The Opposition talk about Suez to cover up their mistakes of 1956 and ignore the last war as if it had never taken place at all.
We ought to get down to a better basis of comparison than that. If you take the economic indices for 1956 and compare them with those for 1955 and 1956 you will get a true measure of the incompetency of the Coalition Government. Senator L'Estrange spoke about the agreement of 1948. He did not tell us that it did any more than was done in 1938.
Before the 1948 agreement was made, when our store cattle went over to England they had to be kept two months before they were slaughtered for the benefit of the British market, and the earmark put on them meant that they were cut by 5/- per cwt. Deputy Dillon said when going across that he intended to cut that 5/- per cwt. and he had it cut, I think, to 4/-, but he gave away a month's waiting period which was a very good bargain from the British point of view.
Comment on this
No, only 1/-, and the cattle had to wait three months in England instead of two which was a very bad bargain from our point of view. That was the only thing achieved by Deputy Dillon. We have been told that everything we produce in this country had free access to the British market. We always had that but how did it work? About three months after the period I speak of, there was a by-election in Donegal. At this time we could not sell our oats and the Government had to bring in a tariff on oats, a thing which Deputy Dillon was against in respect of any agricultural produce. We know what happened after that. Turkeys could not be sold. They would be taken all right but at very low prices. The same applied to eggs and poultry and that concession given by Britain to take all our produce was worth nothing except where Britain needed it, as in the case of cattle and sheep which they always needed and which we hope they always will need. I have not time to go through all the misstatements made by Senator L'Estrange so I shall leave it at that. However, I hope that the next time he speaks he will not repeat them because it will mean I shall lose a quarter of an hour or 20 minutes correcting him.
Comment on this
The Minister is completely wrong. I got my information from the official statistics. If the Minister can prove that one statement was wrong——
Comment on this
If the Senator will allow me I shall prove at least one misstatement with regard to my own town.
Comment on this
Several Opposition Senators including Senator O'Brien and Senator Burke criticised our proposal to treat the fertiliser subsidy as a capital item. Let me first of all quote from the White Paper which says:—
"To bring about a rapid expansion in the use of phosphates on grasslands is one of the main objectives of the Government policy. It is not proposed to rely only on exhortation and advice. The Government will make available a sum of £1.75 million each year for the next five years to reduce the price of phosphates and thus encourage farmers to use them more extensively."
I wish to draw attention to the fact that in drafting this White Paper we had in mind—and nothing has occurred to make us change our minds in that respect—that it would be a temporary and intensive subsidisation of fertiliser. For that reason it has been treated for the time being as a capital investment. If it should be found necessary or advisable by a Government, say, in three or four years' time to make this a more lasting subsidy, then there would be every reason why it should be treated as current expenditure. However, at the end of five years, having got the land into better shape and the farmers having developed the habit of using more fertilisers, it would be necessary either to drop the subsidy or, if we were to continue it, to find it out of current expenditure.
Senator Baxter said that the phosphates would be used especially by the larger farmers. I do not agree with that. During the war when we were getting very little fertiliser into this country—we had a very small quantity some of which we mined from our own resources and some of which we got on a very limited quota abroad —the greatest clamour for fertiliser was from the small farmers of the West of Ireland. They pointed out to me that they could not go on producing their potatoes and oats unless they used more fertiliser. There was not the same demand at all from the large farmers.
Senator Baxter also spoke about changing Section B of the land drainage improvement scheme to a fertiliser scheme and said that this would mean that fertilisers would be used by the larger farmers. If we were to take a census of the fertilisers used under this scheme and a census of the land improved under Section B of the land project, we would find that much more money was spent by the large farmers under the land project than under the fertiliser scheme. As a matter of fact, so far as my observation goes in my own county, and the county in which I now live, every farmer I saw who took advantage of the B scheme was a big farmer. It was not suitable for the small man so it was the big farmer who took advantage of it. It cannot, therefore, be contended that in transferring this money over to the fertilisers, we are doing a disservice to the small farmer.
Senator O'Donovan referred to paragraph 137 of the White Paper which sets out the four factors which are to be borne in mind in considering the extent to which external reserves should be drawn on to finance any gap in investments from available sources. The Senator said he disagreed with our conclusions, that is, so far as I have taken a note of his suggestions. He expressed some criticism of the remarks in the White Paper concerning these external reserves and, so far as I could follow him, he thought if we had a different monetary system, we would be better off.
Comment on this
No. What I wanted to put forward was simply that as a piece of currency theory, this was just tripe.
Comment on this
I must say in the system as it is, I do not see that any objection can be found to these conclusions. I was giving the Senator a bit of the benefit of the doubt in saying that perhaps he had another monetary system in mind. Personally I do not believe—perhaps the Senator does—that any miracle would be worked by another monetary arrangement. Our economic ills will be settled by more production, not by more money, whatever way the money could be got and, therefore, I cannot see that miracles can be worked by a change in our monetary system. As things stand at the moment, more harm than good might be done by making any change.
Senator O'Brien expressed disappointment at the 2 per cent. rate of increase in production, and said it would not solve our problems. He said it would be less than the rate secured in Europe generally. I agree that is quite true, but there is nothing to prevent us from getting an increase and we certainly will not object if the target is too low. In other words, if we achieve more than we expect, if we get a higher increase than 2 per cent., naturally we shall be very glad. We came to the conclusion, in drawing up this White Paper, that it would be better not to put up targets we could not attain, because people are then disappointed, and it would be better really to exceed our target rather than not reach it. For that reason, we were, perhaps, somewhat conservative.
I am afraid, on the whole, Senator O'Brien's criticism of the White Paper was rather depressing. I should have expected from an economist making an objective statement something different from what he gave expression to here yesterday evening. We expect, as we state in the White Paper, to double our production inside of 35 years. Well, of course, anybody may say to me: "Why not treble or quadruple it?" Why not? If we can, of course, why not? We are just giving an estimate of what we can do with our present resources.
We were not taking into account, I think, in that, what private enterprise may do, and we are making conditions for private enterprise, if you like, as favourable as we possibly can, by giving as Senators know, concessions in taxes on exports, concessions to people who start industries here. I want to make it quite clear that whether they are native or foreign, they will get these concessions. As a matter of fact, foreigners may not get exactly the same concessions as our own people at home, but they will get concessions in any case. If we get a return from private enterprise, we expect to do better than two per cent. per year.
I should also like to say that we have had general approval and general welcome for this White Paper. It has been very well received on the whole. I do not want to give the impression that I am in any way disappointed or annoyed with any criticism that may be made. Naturally, a certain amount of criticism could be made of any document that might be produced. What I am disappointed in, perhaps, is that when a person like Senator O'Brien offers a certain amount of criticism, we get nothing by way of an alternative to any of our proposals. It would be very welcome indeed if we could get some alternative from some of our critics.
Generally speaking, this White Paper lays down targets of production. It does not even give an estimate of what the employment may be, but if there is more production, employment will naturally follow. On the agricultural side, let me say that I do not believe there will be any increased employment certainly for the first five or ten years during which this White Paper is operating, because if you take, and they have already been quoted here, the figures of our employment in agriculture as compared with England or Sweden—two examples which rather coincide, where conditions are much the same as our own or at least quite near to our own—we would have to be producing about twice as much as we are producing at present, on the existing employment, to give the same return to those engaged in agriculture. Naturally, our people will look for a better return because that is what I suppose emigration means—if they are not getting the same conditions here as they can get elsewhere, they go. Therefore, they will look for the same return.
We must face the issue that our production will be very much increased before the present force engaged in agriculture will be increased. On the other hand, the fact that we increase agricultural production will give a fillip to our economy generally, because the farmers, the farmers' sons and the farm labourers, who we expect will do better as time goes on, will have more money to spend and the spending of that money will, in turn, I hope, promote industry.
On the industrial side, we hope to get increased production. In our efforts to increase production, we must see that it is efficient. We cannot produce very much more for home consumption, so the extra production must be for export; and when we go into the export market, we have to compete against the world generally. That means that we must be efficient in our methods, in order to capture the export markets. The future there lies in developing our resources as quickly and as efficiently as we can, so that we will have a bigger volume and range of goods and services capable of being sold against all competitors.
Although we have not given any estimate as to how that will affect unemployment and emigration, if we succeed in getting production going in that way, I think that employment will follow naturally, and then emigration will, of course, go down. I am not claiming, and I do not want ever to be quoted as claiming, that we have solved unemployment and emigration by this White Paper; but if we achieve what we are aiming at in the White Paper, we at least are dealing with unemployment and emigration as effectively as they can be dealt with at the moment.
Senator O'Donovan also quoted another figure, to the effect that between 1951 and 1954, when Deputy MacEntee was Minister for Finance, expenditure went up from £75,000,000 to £115,000,000.
Comment on this
I have not checked on the figure. I have accepted that figure from the Senator. I remember one figure, because at that time I was Minister for Social Welfare and Minister for Health. I know that during those three years I was responsible for taking £15,000,000 of that. Actually, when leaving office in 1954, our expenditure on Social Welfare and Health had increased by £15,000,000 from 1951. Therefore, if the expenditure by Deputy MacEntee went up by £30,000,000, half of it at least went on Social Welfare and Health.
Senator O'Donovan raised another point. I said in the Dáil that the Book of Estimates was with the printer. Senator O'Donovan pointed out, since he came in, that it was not with the printer but with the Department of Finance. That only strengthens my case, that I had nothing to do with the preparation of the Book of Estimates. I certainly had nothing to do with it, if the book was not printed when we came in; and I thought I had made my case when I showed it was with the printer, and that I had done enough. Now I am told by Senator O'Donovan that it had left the printer. I certainly had nothing to do with the preparation of the Book of Estimates. However, I am not going into that, as it would take too long. I said that when challenging statements made by Deputies Costello and Sweetman with regard to the amount by which the Estimates should be reduced for 1957-58.
There was a lot of talk here about unemployment. I shall take the employment figure, as I think it is a better figure to take, since unemployment and emigration are so intermixed. Anyone might easily get a favourable unemployment figure by more emigration, or an unfavourable unemployment figure by less emigration. Therefore, the employment figure is the better one to take. I take the employment figure for transportable goods industries, which is the one taken very often as an index of economic recovery. In that particular year, 1958 over 1957, the figure went up by 2,000. It is not very much, I admit, but it showed a definite trend. It had come down by 6,000 from March, 1957, when we took office. Obviously, we came in on a downward trend; and, as Senator Carter said here, a Government cannot stop a trend very quickly—it takes some time. That figure probably went down and down until June or September, and then it began to rise again. We are now on the upgrade, at any rate, and that is a more hopeful sign.
One Senator here expressed his doubts about the amount of money which will be available for agriculture by way of credit. We mention a figure in the White Paper—I think somewhere about £7,000,000. As a matter of fact, we found that the commercial banks—and we did not have this figure at the time we were preparing the White Paper—between October, 1957, and October, 1958, had increased their advances to farmers by £3,000,000. They went up from £16,500,000 to £19,500,000. I was asked in the Dáil if that meant that farmers were hard up after the bad harvest and that they had borrowed for that reason. That was not the reason, since the farmers' balances in the banks had gone up slightly at the same time, I think. Anyway, we all know that the joint stock banks now are generally issuing schemes, every day of the week. One bank is issuing one scheme and another bank has a different scheme; and the general trend now is that bankers are inviting farmers to come in and ask for money.
It is a great change, it must be admitted, over a period of two years. When we came into office, the banks were taking in loans; there was a credit squeeze; and they were pressing for money. People were coming along and saying: "For goodness' sake, talk to the bank and ask for a little more time." It is a very good economic trend that credit should be available now so easily. It is not there for everybody, of course, but at least it is more readily available than it was two years ago. I suppose we can claim, as other Governments have claimed in the past—though we do not often claim things for ourselves— that we have brought the country from despair to hope and confidence.
Senator O'Brien talked about a reduction of taxation, as did other Senators. I am not clear on what the Senators have in mind. When they talk about a reduction in taxation, they might mean, for instance, that we should do with less money than we had last year. Or they might mean that some tax should be reduced, by taking something off beer or income-tax, and in that way taxation would be reduced. It is possible that we might reduce the incidence of taxation by reducing income-tax or by reducing the taxes on, say, beer or tobacco, and at the same time, collect more money. If the country were on the upward trend and money were coming in better, we would collect more money.
The revenue, as Senators know, in 1958, was on the same tax level as in 1957, but the revenue yield itself was much better. I do not know how much better for this year yet, but I know it is going to be better. If the tax incidence were not increased or, better still, if the tax incidence were reduced, even though more money may be taken in for expenditure, the Government which could do that would be doing fairly well. Of course, I am not in a position to say that anything either way can be done in the Budget which is coming along at the moment.
Senator Murphy said the Government had become complacent about unemployment. Nothing could be further from the truth. As a matter of fact, I think we have always that figure in front of us, as regards unemployment and emigration; and every economic step which we are taking is taken with a view to absorbing the unemployed and cutting down emigration. We do not come along and say we are going to employ 150 men here or 100 there, but we know that, if the methods we are adopting succeed, employment will follow.
Senator Barry started off by saying that he would not talk Party politics. I always get suspicious when I hear someone saying that. However, I think it would have been better for Senator Barry to have talked Party politics than start attacking one Party after the other. He tried to kill confidence generally in politicians and that is a very bad thing to do. Cynicism is the easiest thing in the world for anyone to practise, but it is very damaging.
The Senator who spoke next said that the coalition's first care is agriculture, while Fianna Fáil's first care is always industry. I do not think that is true. In another part of his speech, he said that expenditure had gone up by £6,000,000 since we came into office. If you take industry and agriculture and put his statement to the test, you find that in those three years—the third Book of Estimates is before you—agricultural expenditure is up by £3.35 million during that time; Education is up by £1.8 million; Social Welfare is up by £2.6 million. That is more than the £6,000,000 he spoke of. On the other hand, the Industry and Commerce Vote has gone down very much—more, actually, than the amount of the food subsidies which were taken from that Vote. There is no support then for the statement that the Coalition Government always put agriculture first while the Fianna Fáil Government always put industry first. We keep both before our minds all the time. I hope the coalition did too.
Senator Stanford, and other speakers, made a comparison—it is a type of comparison I dislike very much— between the amount of money spent on education and the amount provided for some other services. These speakers talked about our spending £5,000,000 on a transatlantic air service while only £100,000 was provided for something else. One can draw any number of comparisons like that. Is it the idea that we should not spend money on, say, a transatlantic air service, shipping, or some other scheme until certain other things are done first? It is possible the country needs other things, but we must at all times preserve a balanced economy. When we devote £5,000,000 to developing a transatlantic air service, that is capital development. We are assured by the experts—I myself know little or nothing about it— that this service will be a paying proposition. If it is, well and good. We put in £5,000,000 and on that £5,000,000 we get interest.
Senator Stanford talked about giving more to the universities. The sum he mentioned was, if you like, a comparatively small amount—£20,000, £30,000 or £40,000. There is no reason, of course, why we should refuse to have a transatlantic air service in order to give this money, if it is necessary, to the universities. But one must preserve a certain proportion. The type of argument advanced is founded on the pedagogic approach. People making the comparison say: "You can give all you like to a transatlantic air service but you cannot give £20,000 to this or £10,000 to that." I admit a Government has to put up with that sort of criticism; it is all too common. But the argument is not well founded.
Senator Donegan accused us of establishing this service because the coalition scrapped it. I think it would be truer to say the coalition scrapped it because it was our idea first. Indeed, I think the coalition made a grave mistake in scrapping it, but they set out in 1948 to prove that we had been an extravagant Government. They stopped the transatlantic air service, and the Bray Road scheme. I could never understand why the Bray Road should be regarded as a Fianna Fáil road while the Naas Road was not. But that appears to be the coalition reasoning. I saw three people killed on the Bray Road and, when I cannot leave Dublin before half past ten, I wait until after 12 because I do not want to be killed on the Bray Road. Apparently the coalition did not care who was killed on it so long as they could call it a Fianna Fáil road.
Senator Stanford talked about capital expenditure on our universities. That is a different matter, but there is a limit to the amount of capital one can find. It is much easier for a Minister for Finance, on the whole, to supply capital rather than current expenditure because he may not get the revenue to meet current expenditure. With capital expenditure, however, he will have a pretty fair idea as to whether or not the proposed expenditure will recoup itself and therefore it is much easier for him to find capital expenditure. If the committee inquiring into the matter make a recommendation in relation to University College, Dublin, and if the Government agree—the Government naturally must agree—things will be done.
Senator Stanford referred to our attitude towards Trinity College. I cannot speak with any familiarity on all the little details—this is the bailiwick of the Minister for Education— but I know some of the principles he has in mind. I know that many factors were taken into consideration in deciding the amount of the grant to each of the four colleges. Number of staff as compared with the students was one; another was the growth in the number of students—how many new students since the last grant was given. It would obviously be unfair to give the same percentage grant all round because one college might have had no increase in the number of students and another might have had a very big increase. All that had to be taken into account and that brought one down to the average grant per student. The amount was not fixed, of course, but there was a comparison made.
There is also a different standard of remuneration in the colleges. That had to be borne in mind. All these factors were taken into account. I do not know how they were weighted, but they were all taken into account before the money was apportioned between the four colleges.
A question was asked as to why Maynooth was not included. I would advise Senators to let Maynooth look after itself. There is no doubt it can look after itself. The same advice applies in relation to the religious authorities in charge of these auxiliary agricultural colleges.
Comment on this
Would the Minister please explain? How can they look after themselves?
Comment on this
I am merely saying that Maynooth is a very efficient organisation. It has a very efficient governing body. They are well able to look after themselves. I do not think they want any interference.
Senator Baxter said that there can be no hope of reducing taxation unless there is increased production and increased employment. Our income from taxation was higher in 1958 than it was in 1957 so, on Senator Baxter's formula, there must have been more people in production and more people in employment in 1958 as compared with 1957. That is a fairly good indication of the position. When people are productive and when people are in employment they spend more on goods which are taxed and in that way revenue increases.
I do not think it right for Senator Baxter to say that the problem of emigration is not receiving the attention it should. Perhaps he is right in a way because, no matter how much attention it gets, I agree it would not be too much. At the same time I should not like it to be taken that we are ignoring or neglecting the problem. We certainly keep it in the forefront as far as we possibly can. The White Paper clearly indicates our aims for increasing production. If we succeed in that, employment will follow. When employment follows, emigration will be reduced. I am not finding fault with Senator Baxter for his criticism, but what we would really like are concrete suggestions. Apart from what we have tried to do ourselves, we have not got any useful suggestions from others as to how we could increase employment. We have certainly got no feasible suggestions. We should be glad to get them.
It is not correct to say that we have stopped land improvement. We have stopped Section B of the scheme because we felt there was a good deal of waste under it. I shall not go into the figures now because it will not help my case, or prove anything, just to show that a huge sum was paid out, and not always to the best advantage. Any Senator can say: "Stop that, and put a limit on the amount." As far as I could see, the scheme appeared to me to be essentially wasteful.
I think Senators generally have believed that Government Departments do not do things as well as private enterprise will do them. I think a farmer who is spending a certain grant on reclamation will make much better use of it than the Department of Agriculture. If it is done under Section A, where the farmer gets a certain grant and puts a certain amount to it himself, he will see that the work is done to better advantage. Therefore, I think we will get better work under that Section.
To talk about reclamation in Bangor Erris is not a comparison. That was done as an experiment—to do a certain amount of research on reclamation of that kind and see what good use it could be put to. It may be very expensive indeed. We are trying to find out if it is economic for the ordinary farmer to do it commercially. We have not learned enough yet to be able to pronounce on that.
I agree with Senator McGuire: I think we all agree that we have, maybe, to add to our plans now for the development of industry—particularly because we have now reached the stage of practically supplying our own needs in most of the things we want. To have any sort of substantial increase in industry means that we must go into export. In turn, that means that it must be very much more efficient and better organised. I think we have offered any inducements we can offer to people who propose to go into that sphere of activity.
As Senators know, we are remitting income-tax on export profits and also giving certain grants and loans to people to start industry, and so on. We cannot, from the financial side, be expected to do any more. I think Senator McGuire said we were not perhaps advertising our wares sufficiently in that regard. That may be. However, we can have a look at that, too.
I do not want to enter into the point made about decentralisation. There may be a good lot indeed in what Senator McGuire says, namely, that for an industry to be efficient, it must be able to compete against industries in other countries and that it should, therefore, get everything possible in its favour and should be allowed to go wherever those engaged in it think is the best place to go. In a case like that, they are not finding any great difficulty. It was all right, in starting small industries in the past for the home market, to try to direct them to the smaller centres in order to give a bit of employment here and there. They probably could carry on all right.
I should like to assure Senator Donegan that I myself got an invoice for fertilisers and, as he points out, superphosphate is down, I think, at £12 10s. per ton and then, underneath, is written "Subsidy £4; net £8 10s." Senator Donegan wanted to know if that is put in by the Fianna Fáil Government for political kudos. I do not think so. I think it is put in by the Department of Agriculture in order to go as far as they possibly can to see that the subsidy is passed on to the consumer. I think it is a safeguard in that way for the consumer.
Senator Donegan also said that the abolition of the food subsidies is still having its effect. He talked about the increases in the costs of local authority institutions which stem from that and says that the same thing applies to revenue here. Whatever about the revenue, this applies to expenditure: when I say to him that the current expenditure as forecast for 1959-60, is lower actually than that which he had in 1958-59, it means that there is no point whatever in his case.
Senator Donegan says it is difficult for farmers to know what they got for their wheat last year. I should love to deal with that question, but perhaps it is getting too late. They got more than they were promised because 90 per cent. of last year's wheat was unmillable. No promise was ever made to any farmer that unmillable wheat would be taken from him. I think I can say, in respect of every scheme by every Government, that the prices were fixed for millable wheat. Last year, 90 per cent. of the wheat was unmillable. It was taken from the farmers as an ex gratia gesture by the Fianna Fáil Government. Therefore, the farmers got more than they were promised. I shall leave that to my colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, when he is dealing with the motion on the Order Paper.
I am grateful to Senator Donegan. He said he would defend the Government against a group movement for more for old age pensioners. He said it would cost £1,000,000 and that the Government find it very hard to get £1,000,000—which is very good and kind of the Senator. But when they said to him: "What about the £5,000,000 for transatlantic air services?" he probably said: "There you are. We did away with that and they are putting it on again." I do not know if he really defended this Government very strongly.
Senator Sheehy Skeffington spoke about penal reform. Nearly all the leaders of Fianna Fáil and some of Fine Gael were in jail in their time. While he was speaking, I asked myself why we do not take more interest in it. I think it is that, from our experience, the penalty of being in jail consists of 95 per cent. loss of freedom and that the conditions there do not matter so much. Being away at all is the really hard part of it. I suppose that is why we have not taken great interest in these penal settlements, wherever they may be.
To abolish the means test for old age pensioners would cost £2,500,000, but I do not think I could agree with doing that. I am speaking very academically now, I can assure the House. If I had £1,000,000 to spare and the Government told me to devote it to the old age pensioners, I would give it to the existing old age pensioners rather than abolish the means test. Those who have no means whatever could probably do with a little more and those who have not the old age pension have means and are not so terribly badly off as the others.
I do not agree, either, with Senator Sheehy Skeffington about Irish. He says we should regard it as a live language and have an oral examination. I regard it not only as a live language but as an official language. Therefore, I do not see the necessity for an oral examination. We do not have an oral examination in English, for instance. Why should we have it in Irish if it is to be put on the same footing as English? I do not think I have anything else to deal with on the points put up to me.
Comment on this
Could the Minister elaborate on why the State agricultural schools must get preferential treatment compared with the private agricultural schools?
Comment on this
I know that what the Senator says is true, that the State schools are getting very much more than the private schools, but I am afraid I would have to get notice of that question to be able to give a more intelligent answer than I am in a position to give now.
Comment on this
Perhaps it could be raised on the Appropriation Bill. I do not think that there is anywhere a better investment for £250,000.
Comment on this
I was Minister for Agriculture for many years and I think that, generally speaking, the religious orders running these auxiliary schools largely got what they thought they should get. I do not say that they got all that they asked for. Nobody ever does.
Comment on this
They are doing excellent work. I also return to the case of Maynooth College. They are really hard hit.
Comment on this
I promised Senator Dowdall that I would give her the reference to a statement by Mr. Verolme. I went to the trouble of looking up the reference. It is in the Irish Independent, Saturday, January 10th, 1959, on the main page. It is at a news conference that Mr. Verolme held. This is the note:—
"Asked why he had come to Ireland, Mr. Verolme replied: ‘I have not come to make money. I have been plagued by your ambassador and your Government to come'."
I used the word "badgered". That is the only point on which I should amend that reference. Senator Dowdall is quite wrong in suggesting that my reference was not correct.
Comment on this
On this stage I wish to remark that the Minister appealed for suggestions with regard to emigration and unemployment and said that he had not received any in this debate. I devoted three-quarters of the time at my disposal to showing how the land is the key to both these problems.