We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Business. - Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960— Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 189–388 of 388. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960
Enacted

No. 45 of 1960 ›

I am glad I have the chance of following Senator Quinlan. For a man who talks about charity in debate, the implication of his last statement is shocking. If I have understood him correctly, his point is that the Minister and people on this side of the House want to develop a Socialist system here and that he is the only warrior preventing a drift into Socialism. I shall not even try to contradict or deny it because it is an unworthy statement. If the Senator had a little more charity he would not have made such a statement.

I have no particular brief for the Dairy Disposal Company. I have always considered it a pity that Government Departments have to do a job that should be done by the people either through private enterprise or through co-operation. It would be unjust for me or anybody to make an attack on the Dairy Disposal Company. They have done a good job of work. It may be easy enough now to say they are "Yes-men". I cannot believe that "Yes-men" for anybody, even for a Minister, despite the fact that the Board is composed of civil servants, can do their job satisfactorily. Men faced with a job will do it very badly if they are "Yes-men". I do not think any Government would tolerate such a body. It is shocking to suggest that the members of the Board are "yes-men". I might suggest that the speaker, when making that statement, was not I think actuated by malice or else he does not understand the mind of a civil servant.

So much has been said about the co-operative movement that nobody except those who mouth shibboleths about it believe in it. There has been much talk about the co-operative movement but there has not been much practice. The real trouble is the failure to translate highfalutin theory into practical reality. That is the difference of outlook between Senator Quinlan and myself. It might also be the difference of outlook between Senator Quinlan and the Minister and possibly between Senator Quinlan and successful civil servants who have been on the Board of the Dairy Disposal Company, of which I know very little. However, they have made a success of their job and that is something.

Comment on this

I did not say they had not.

Comment on this

I suggest that the implication is clear enough. Surely any representative of that body appointed to this Board would have the interests of that particular group, of that organisation, of that area in mind and would not be a "Yes-man" for the Minister? I could not believe that any Minister, the present Minister or any Minister in any Government, would appoint a man of that sort. I hope we have not sunk that low. There is a very serious and hard job of work to be done by the Board and I hope they will succeed in their efforts.

It may be hard enough to please us all but it is easy enough for the Minister to decide on the number of the membership, the method by which they will be elected, and so on. In practice, because of the failure to translate the principle of the co-operative movement into practical reality, it will still be hard enough to get, what I should like to be achieved, a Board that has due regard to the interests of the farmer, particularly the small farmer.

I cannot help feeling that co-operative societies which trade under their name and enjoy the advantages of friendly societies very often behave in a monopolistic way. I am further aware, and many Senators are aware, of the tax reliefs available to such societies. I know of creameries that have been built in the past five years by a successful chain of co-operative societies in areas where there had not been creameries before. Here is a surprising thing. When it was found that there was a reasonably good supply of milk to a creamery the memberships were never completed, the money was handed back to the people who subscribed it and they were not allowed to become even members of a co-operative society. There does not appear to be much co-operation in that sort of thing.

If the I.A.O.S. were achieving the objects it should achieve that sort of thing would not happen. I have some personal experience of that matter. Some years ago I was engaged in negotiations on the amalgamation of creameries. Even with co-operative societies, the financial standing of the organisation becomes the dominant factor and the richer organisations in some cases know quite well how to use the big stick on the smaller organisations. While co-operativism may appear and is, in fact, a good principle, I think it is time that the people who talk so much about it should do a little to ensure that it is applied in practice.

Comment on this

This debate has, unfortunately, taken a trend where we are discussing the merits and demerits of co-operativism and the co-operative societies of this country and the Dairy Disposal Company. An action or a deed is of itself worthy merely because of what it succeeds in doing. Who does it does not really matter. I am fully aware that the Dairy Disposal Company has done excellent work and that the co-operative movement has done excellent work. Both of them, being constituted of humans, have made mistakes.

I feel that, in general, the discussion is running along lines of a rival effort to get representation on the Board of the various sections that compose the purchasing power of the dairying industry. I feel that is a bad thing. Were I to generalise on the purchasing powers of the dairying industry, I would say it is a pity that there is not a greater percentage of private enterprise involved also here. Private enterprise has the habit of reducing everything to a common denominator. Private enterprise is of itself the right line and the best line. Even though it has failed on occasions and other methods of propagating industry have succeeded, it is a good common denominator. We should not go into the vicissitudes or otherwise of the Dairy Disposal Company or co-operativism. Both of them have done a rather good job in their own particular way. It might be a good thing to confine ourselves to the section of the Bill. It would be a pity if the Seanad or members of the Seanad took sides.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Dwyer

I quite agree with the clause as it stands. The representation is, in the circumstances, quite reasonable and justified. As a matter of fact, I would say that the Dairy Disposal Company, their organisation and machinery, have given the greatest help to the marketing committee over the past 20 years. We must agree that the work of the Dairy Disposal Company has been carried on exceptionally well. It would not surprise me if they were the most successful of the semi-State boards. However, that does not prevent us from saying that we would not like to visualise the Dairy Disposal Company as a permanent institution.

The ideal of co-operativism was that the farmers of Ireland would be banded together in their own districts in co-operative societies to develop agriculture and to develop the land of Ireland as it should be developed. That is the ideal of the co-operative movement. No matter what is said, if you look around the south of Ireland, you will find that that ideal has been fully realised. Each co-operative society is developed on its own lines and in later years these societies have federated to embark on larger enterprise. That was the ideal of the co-operative movement—that it would extend all over rural Ireland. It is the only basis on which we can rebuild rural Ireland; it is the only basis upon which the people can be trained, not only to develop their resources but to develop their culture and national administration.

I remember well the year 1927 when the Dairy Disposal Company was set up. The Minister at that time did a great work for the farmers when he took over the creameries which at that time, because of their superior resources, would have destroyed co-operation. I felt that the creameries did not meet the Minister very well by refusing to take over the less successful creameries. They left them on his hands.

We are asked why the co-operative movement did not take over these societies. Where the Dairy Disposal Company creameries were set up, the farmers lost all interest in co-operation. They refused to make the necessary sacrifice to establish co-operative societies. Like people who are maintained in an institution with their food and everything else provided for them without any trouble, they refused to make the necessary sacrifice to establish co-operative societies. I know why that is so because I had a lot to do with the preparations to take over those societies and in the old days the farmers pledged their whole credit in order to establish co-operative societies and maintain them. The people to whom I refer refused to invest a penny. The Dairy Disposal Company exercised a corroding influence on all the farmers around it. That condition has steadily grown and it is harder to take over those creameries now than it was 20 years ago. They do not want to understand making sacrifices and doing things for themselves. I submit that that is an unhealthy state of affairs, which should not be allowed to continue. I would suggest to the Minister and the Government that they should take steps as soon as possible to see that these Dairy Disposal Company creameries are transferred to the co-operative movement.

Comment on this

They will not take them.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Dwyer

A programme has already being drawn up which recommends that the co-operative movement should be banded with the Dairy Disposal Company, and that advisory committees should be set up here and there for the suppliers of the Dairy Disposal Company creameries, so that in the course of time the profits would be applied towards the liquidation of the charges on the creameries and the creameries would be completely free of debt and handed over to the co-operative societies whose suppliers will have been trained to administer them. That is the only feasible way of taking them over. The farmers will not make sacrifices. The Dairy Disposal Company has been very well managed but that may not last. We should look forward to the time when it ceases to exist as a Government institution and is handed over completely to the co-operative movement.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear that Senator O'Dwyer knows something about the co-operative system and to hear him speak words of wisdom and enlightenment for the Minister for Agriculture. We all know the wonderful work done by the I.A.O.S. over a long number of years. It is unfortunate that a Minister for State should come in here and criticise voluntary organisations such as the I.A.O.S. or any co-operative movement.

Comment on this

There is nothing voluntary about it.

Comment on this

The majority of the work is voluntary and the Minister knows that.

Comment on this

It is in my hat.

Comment on this

They have done wonderful work and Senator O'Dwyer has told us about the wonderful work they have done since 1927. Remember they did that against great odds and in difficult times. They worked from 1932 to 1938 during an economic war when certain people wanted a wall built around this country and we were told that the British market was "gone and gone forever, thank God."

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Senator should put that gramophone record away.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We have roamed very much in this discussion but nobody has roamed so far as the Senator.

Comment on this

There was an attack made on them and I am going to reply. They were working during difficult years. They were working from 1939 to 1945 during a World War. I want to say that I think it wrong for a Minister for Agriculture to criticise those co-operative bodies. A month or two ago we had the Minister for Health criticising the voluntary hospitals and the Bishop of Galway, Dr. Browne, has stated recently that we are drifting too much towards Socialism. Do we want to criticise voluntary initiative in this country? That is what some people are trying to do at present. Have we heard of Horace Plunkett or of Denmark and the wonderful work that has been done there through co-operation? I think the Minister will admit that the greater part of the success of the farmers there is due to the fact that they co-operated with one another. If we had the same co-operation here and if we had a Government prepared to help those who were prepared to help themselves, instead of criticising them, we would get much further.

The Minister and those Senators on each side of the House who spoke claimed credit for the expansion of milk production etc., and the Minister blamed Senator Quinlan for not giving credit where credit is due. The Minister was inclined to claim that credit for himself. I do not think that he deserves all that credit but I will admit that a certain share is due to him for some of the work he did in 1947. Still, if we go back to 1948 we find that we had the lowest number of cows on record, we had not enough milk to supply our own needs and we imported butter from all over the world.

Comment on this

We did not import any butter in 1948, or in 1947 either.

Comment on this

We did. Bring your mind back. It was rationed.

Comment on this

Do not mind my mind, I want records.

Comment on this

It was rationed here.

Comment on this

We imported no butter.

Comment on this

We were rationed and the war was over for three years.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think the matter is relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

We are an agricultural country with 12,000,000 acres of fertile, arable land, with a population of under 3,000,000 people and with five acres of land for every person in the country. We had not got enough butter for our own needs and we had the lowest number of cows since the taking of records began.

Comment on this

We imported no butter in the year the Senator mentioned.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I wonder if the Senator would try to get back to Section 8 of the Bill, which deals with the constitution of the Board.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that the Board had the interests of the whole industry at heart. I do not see how the Board can have the interests of the liquid milk producers at heart. Senator Sheridan pointed out that they represent anything from 25 to 33 per cent. of the total producers yet they have no member on the Board to protect their interests. It is unfair that from one-quarter to one-third of the suppliers of milk are not represented on this Board. There is no denying the fact that certain aspects of liquid milk production can become the function of the Board at any time. If we refer to Section 5 and Section 6 of this Bill we see that they can.

Subsection (1) of section 5 of the Bill states that:

The Board shall, in addition to the functions assigned to it by any other provision of this Act, have the following general functions, namely:

(a) to export, or provide for the exportation of, milk and milk products of such class or kind as the Minister may from time to time specify in writing to the Board ...

Section 6 states that:

The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, from time to time by order—

(a) assign to the Board such additional functions as he thinks fit in relation to milk or milk products.

Twenty-five per cent. of those milk producers engage in liquid milk production yet they are not to have representation on this Board. There are four representatives of the suppliers of milk to creameries and one representative of each of the manufacturers of cheese, milk powders and chocolate crumb. Those people will be represented and I think it is unfair that the other 25 per cent. of the liquid milk producers have not got some representation on the Board to protect their interests.

It is only by having someone on the Board that their interests will be fully protected. We will not have the cut-throat competition which Senator Sheridan mentioned this morning if those people are represented on the Board. We know that the liquid milk producers and those who handle the milk fix their prices more or less by contract. It is done through the contract system. As Senator Sheridan told us, you could have creameries buying milk at ? or ? in a creamery area and sending it into another area where liquid milk is sold and——

Comment on this

Which side is the Senator on?

Comment on this

I am on the side of justice for everybody because remember——

Comment on this

Who is just in the case the Senator has mentioned of the——

Comment on this

If you have got this cut-throat competition you will have scarcities and gluts and so on. What we want is stability. The best thing for dairy farmers, whether they are supplying milk to creameries or engaged in liquid milk production, is stability. It is in the best interests of the country.

Comment on this

Does the Senator mean a uniform price for the entire country?

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

I take it that is what the Senator means.

Comment on this

The Senator knows that you cannot have a uniform price because milk is supplied to the creameries during the summer months when cattle are fed on grass and the skim milk is given back to the producer and in areas where liquid milk is supplied the supply must be continual throughout the year, that the supply must be kept up during the winter months.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Senator will allow me, he has got a good deal of leeway.

Comment on this

This is a Second Reading speech.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

This is either a Second Reading speech or a speech that might have been made this morning on Section 5 of the Bill.

Comment on this

No, Sir. I am making the case that instead of giving four representatives to the creameries, the Minister could easily give one to the producers of liquid milk.

Comment on this

Oh no, the Senator is not.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator will make that case.

Comment on this

I am making the case that they are entitled to representation and what I intended to say was that they should get at least one. Give the creameries three and give the producers of liquid milk one representative on that Board. I contend that in all justice they are entitled to it. It would be in the interests of stability and co-operation. It would be in everybody's interest in the end. It would be in the consumer's interest and definitely in the interests of the country.

One thing that has beaten us in the past in foreign markets is that we had not continuity of supply. That could be achieved if there were co-operation and if the farmers had full trust in the Board in future. If the farmers have not confidence and trust in the Board, there will not be the co-operation that we would all like to see the Board getting.

Comment on this

I should like to compliment Senator O'Dwyer, who spoke so well in defence of the co-operative movement. He spoke as Father Finlay or Sir Horace Plunkett would have spoken had they been here today. He pointed the way and the Minister would be well advised to take cognisance of it.

Comment on this

Actions speak louder than words.

Comment on this

I hope Senator O'Dwyer will get plenty of action.

Comment on this

I hope people will do their best to follow the path that Senator O'Dwyer suggested for the ultimate development into the full blossom of co-operation that Sir Horace Plunkett envisaged and which, to Senator O'Reilly's surprise, was the basic organisational idea behind the success of the Danish farming movement. Everything is based on that. We have a lot to learn.

Comment on this

They applied it in practice. They are practical people. That is the difference.

Comment on this

In the composition of the Board one of the most important sections of the industry is completely ignored, the Creamery Managers Association. We know the wonderful work they have done and the big part they have played in developing the many fine centres that we have got. The Minister says that they can come in under certain other provisions. He is suggesting that the producers should nominate creamery managers.

Comment on this

I did not suggest anything of the kind.

Comment on this

In the Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

I did not. I said they "could."

Comment on this

That is what I said. "Could" is what I said.

Comment on this

He did not suggest that it should be done. You want to put words into the Minister's mouth.

Comment on this

The Senator said "could."

Comment on this

That is the word I used—that they could nominate these. That is against the very idea of producer representation and if advocated in Denmark would be laughed to scorn. The Creamery Managers Association may perhaps be appointed under (c), (d), or (e) but if they are appointed they will be appointed for a specific purpose, either to represent cheese or chocolate crumb or milk powder interests and not to represent the vast bulk of the ordinary creamery milk producers. It is a grave defect in the Bill that recognition was not given to the creamery managers as a body. The election of a representative of creamery managers to the Board would improve its composition considerably.

The Minister has mentioned here that the manufacturers of cheese shall appoint a member to the Board. We need some clarification there. Cheese manufacturers comprise Mitchelstown and 13 creameries federated in the Golden Vale Society. Will they count as 13 manufacturing units or will Golden Vale, as a federation, count as one unit?

The Dairy Disposal Company is one of five engaged in the manufacture of milk powder. There are Ballyclough, Mitchelstown, Dungarvan, Urney's and the Dairy Disposal Company—in other words, three co-operatives, one private concern and the Dairy Disposal Company. The Minister says that these are to have a representative. I would imagine that in selecting a representative there would be some type of gentleman's agreement on rotation. Does the Minister envisage that when it comes to the Dairy Disposal Company's turn there would be two representatives of that company on the Board or does the provision he has made for the Dairy Disposal Company in sub-paragraph (f) mean that he would not consider it reasonable that one of their members should also be nominated by cheese or milk powder interests? Possibly they may easily go into cheese production and again would be likely to qualify under that subsection.

I am just pointing out the manner of being represented that the Minister offers to the creamery managers. It is a way that is equally available to the Dairy Disposal Company. Yet, in the latter case, the Minister makes further additional provision for them.

Comment on this

I find a lot of biassed thinking going on. The Minister was questioned as to how creamery managers would find representation and he indicated how that could be done. He said that they could be selected in the ordinary way as individuals. In fact, at meetings of the Fine Gael Party which preceded the arrival of this Bill in the Dáil, that matter was discussed and the Party was in favour of representation on the Board for creamery managers but in a recent debate in the Dáil the Party accepted the Minister's reasoning that the creamery managers could, in fact, be selected in the ordinary way as individuals.

I know that in Monaghan-Cavan there is one man who, if he stood for election, would be elected against any farmer-producer. Senator Quinlan seems to think that that is a fantastic idea, that it is wrong, that it is against the idea of producer representation. He suggested that in Denmark such a suggestion would be laughed to scorn. I do not accept that at all. If creamery managers are the absolute snow-white workers on behalf of the cause of co-operation and on behalf of the producers, are they not individually just as good persons to have on the Board as producers? Often they know more about the business. They may be farmers' sons reared on dairy farms and then they come to know the creamery business. Granting equal intelligence and equal ability, are they not more suitable persons than any producer?

This debate has provoked what seems to be always present in Irish life, a conflict in relation to co-operation, private enterprise and State companies. I would reiterate that I think a thing is good or bad of itself, no matter who does it. I see no objection whatever to the Minister making his case that the Dairy Disposal Company should have representation. The co-operative movement should have representation. I regret that private enterprise has not a greater slice of the dairying industry because it is the common denominator. If one were to follow out the hypothetical suggestion of Senator Quinlan, whereby at some stage co-operatives were to take over the Dairy Disposal Company, if such a decision came before the Minister and if, at the same time, a sum of money came from private enterprise for that concern, I wonder what would be the right decision for the Minister to take. After all, private enterprise would pay income tax. Private enterprise would have to work in competition with the rest of the country, and if they paid less for milk, it would not be very long until attention was drawn to that fact, and it would be a simple matter of legislation to ensure they would no longer have that advantage.

At the moment, we are all following flags. Some of us are following the flag of the State concern, the Dairy Disposal Company; some of us are following the flag of co-operation, a white angel flapping its wings; and others of us are mixed up and do not know where we are. I believe the debate in the Dáil was sufficient. There is nothing we can do but accept a Board of nine members. I think the criticism Senator L'Estrange and Senator Sheridan made is valid because of the phrasing of the Bill and the Minister's refusal to accept amendments.

If one looks at the phraseology of the Bill, one sees it as possible for the Board to engage in the sale of liquid milk. As a liquid milk supplier and one of the largest suppliers to Dublin city, I can see for myself, selfishly, that at a future date that province could be invaded by the Board without further legislation. On that basis and on that basis alone, there is some case for representation. If the Board is to be restricted in number as the Minister visualises, I feel the case is not strong enough but there is that danger and there is that looseness about the provision. It is my view that this Bill is a sort of omnibus for everything and that not enough thought has been put into it by the Minister, the Department or the Parliamentary draftsman.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In subsection (3), to delete all words from and including "for" in line 57 to the end of the subsection and substitute:

"who are recognised creamery managers, or existing officials of the Irish Cream Exporters' Association, provided that in the said month the shares of the society shall be freely on offer to milk suppliers who are not already members of the Society."

The only point I wish to make on this amendment is that in all those elections, the Minister should take steps to comply with the expressed wish of the Marketing Committee, that the suppliers to the creamery would at least have the opportunity of being concerned with the elections from the co-operative creameries. What I have suggested is that there should be added a simple clause to state that the shares of the company shall be on offer to milk suppliers who are not already members of the society, that is, for one month before the elections take place.

That would provide an opportunity for those who are not shareholders to acquire shares, if they so wish, because there are certain regions in the country where I believe closed shop practices exist with regard to buying shares of co-operative societies. I have here a report of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society and in the Minister's county of Cavan, there is a group which was registered in 1928 and which has a membership of only 11, although it has a turnover of something like £350,000; in other words, £35,000 per registered shareholder.

Comment on this

That was because it went into liquidation at one time.

Comment on this

I understand that, in that region and in other regions, there are people who are anxious to become shareholders and who cannot.

Comment on this

If the Senator knew the background, he would not regard that as a useful comparison.

Comment on this

Who now holds these shares?

Comment on this

A group of creameries.

Comment on this

And that is why there are only 11 individual owners of shares?

Comment on this

I know of a case in Cork where a very prominent farmer had great difficulty in securing shares in a co-operative.

Comment on this

Those shares are held by a group of 11; they are 11 small separating stations. They are co-operatives, which means 11 shares are held by hundreds of shareholders.

Comment on this

In any case, the problem has been adverted to by the Advisory Committee. They felt that producer representation would be best achieved directly through the producers but that it was more feasible and convenient to achieve it through the co-operative societies. It was felt, therefore, that all who supply milk should have an opportunity of acquiring shares. Is there any real objection to incorporating in the election provisions a provision to the effect that during the month or some other period prior to the election, the shares of the society concerned should be freely on offer to the members of the society?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Dwyer

The shares of co-operative societies have always been open to suppliers who cannot be refused without reasonable grounds.

Comment on this

Provided the law is observed.

Comment on this

"Provided the law is observed" is a very shrewd remark by Senator Carter. The matter raised by the Senator might be looked into but I do not think putting amendments into the Bill is the best way of achieving what is intended. It might not even then succeed. There does appear to be a tendency on the part of very successful co-operative societies, when they become fairly big, to control the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, possibly the Creamery Managers Association and the co-operative societies as such, where in some cases the issued share capital can be quite small. While the Minister had a ready answer in the case of the 11 members, there may be other cases where share capital in a society is not, in practice, freely available to the members.

Since this Bill became a controversial matter, a man from the Ballinalee area visited me, a fairly shrewd, intelligent, progressive farmer. His purpose in seeing me was that he considered he might make a useful member of the Board. He is a supplier in that area of County Longford, the area from which Senators Carter and L'Estrange come. Once there were no creameries in that area, except one possibly on the Longford-Cavan border. That man feels that he is not even in a position to be a candidate for election, despite the fact that he is interested in co-operation. He played a leading part in the organisation of a creamery in his area but it appears that the parent institution, the co-operative society, while finding that there was reasonable certainty that this creamery would be successful, decided not to continue the issue of share certificates. In the case of at least one creamery, or possibly two in that area, organised in the past couple of years, it appears there is a genuine grouse because people who actually tendered money in some cases had it returned. They expected to get a certificate of membership of the society but their money was handed back, apparently, without interest and without comment.

There is something wrong there but that is a matter the I.A.O.S. should examine. If they did that, I should not be criticising them. Tribute has been paid to Senator O'Dwyer. I accept his view because I believe in the philosophical idea of co-operation and I realise that he has done more for real co-operation, applicable in practice, than many people who speak about it would do in three lifetimes.

Comment on this

Can the Minister indicate any way of getting over the difficulty?

Comment on this

Which difficulty?

Comment on this

The difficulty of shares mentioned also by Senator O'Reilly.

Comment on this

I could not agree to that at all. I do not believe it would be possible or, if so, it would be tremendously difficult. If shares were available, as it is suggested they should be, I am not satisfied that would not be open to abuse.

Comment on this

There would be a great rush to buy shares in the next month.

Comment on this

Perhaps, but I can see in certain circumstances it might not be desirable. This amendment in regard to the appointment of a particular individual is limiting. A number of the Senator's amendments limit the choice in cases where a choice can be freely made. I object to that. If I were to come forward with a proposal that where a free choice was supposed to be made, you should have all kinds of limiting conditions, means tests and so on, I should never get out of this Chamber alive. It amazes me that some of these amendments should seek to limit the right of the people who have a vote to exercise to say whether the appointee should be a creamery manager, a farmer also, a farmer only, whether he should be half-and-half or whether he should have any other interest. There is no merit in giving to people with intelligence and judgment the responsibility of making a decision and then saying: "You are not to elect a particular candidate, if he has black hair or if he has not a white head." As briefly as I can put it that is my objection to these proposals, suggesting the insertion of limiting conditions where a public type of choice falls to be made.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is limiting those who have the right to nominate to the Board by not giving representation to certain people. On the last occasion, the Minister seemed to feel some alarm that if the creamery managers got an additional representative elected directly by the Creamery Managers Association, it was quite conceivable that the association would have a majority on the Board. That could happen, but the spirit in which I made these suggestions was that if producers were to be members, I felt they should be represented by producers as such. If you took steps in that way, you would have four producer representative. On the other hand, if you expected that other representatives would come from the management side, you also had that tied up, so that you had not more than four or five from that side. The other three, as I suggested, would come from the Minister or the Agricultural Institute and the others.

I accept the Minister's objection to that. Anyway, it has gone by the board now, as the original idea of increasing the Board from nine to twelve has been rejected. Consequently, I wish to withdraw this amendment.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments 26 and 27 may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.26:

Before subsection (2) to insert a new subsection as follows:

"( ) Each Society or Company shall be entitled to as many votes as may be specified by order by the Minister."

Amendment No. 27 is really consequential on No. 26. If we take what is in the Bill, that each society is entitled to one vote, it seems grossly unfair that a big concern like Mitchelstown should have the same representation as some small co-operative creamery. I would not go so far as to suggest proportionality, that if the turnover were ten times as much in one as in the other, one should have ten times as many votes as the other, but I think it is very unfair that they should have an equal number of votes. What I have suggested is that the Minister should retain the power of specifying by order the number of votes a society is entitled to have. That leaves him free. In the first instance, if he wishes, he can specify one vote for a society. If it is considered desirable to change subsequently, there is provision to do so. I am trying to give power to the Minister, although in my earlier amendments I was trying to take power away from him.

Comment on this

The Senator would want to provide him with a bodyguard.

Comment on this

I am very pleased to see that the Senator is prepared to give me power to make orders. I was almost convinced that was something no Minister should have the right to do.

Comment on this

Except in very limited circumstances.

Comment on this

I find now that, in certain circumstances, the Minister may be permitted to make orders. I speak jocosely. I considered this matter very carefully. Even without very deep consideration one could see the point of an organisation such as Ballyclough, Mitchelstown, Dungarvan, Loughaiglish, Killeshandra—some of these very big concern—having only one vote while a small independent separating station, for instance, would also have a vote. I could find no way out of that, and I do not think it is an urgent matter. Whether I am a supplier of milk to a small separating station or a member of the Killeshandra co-operative my interest in the price of milk and in the way in which milk products will be disposed of aboard will be as keen in the one case as the other.

If I were elected as one who had an interest in the smaller type of concern it would not necessarily follow that my capacity to play my part on the Board would be any lower simply because I happened to be associated with a smaller body. I turned these things over in my mind. I could not find it possible to devise an intelligent method of apportioning the number of votes cast by any of these individual concerns. I looked at it in the way I am trying to describe now. I decided they were all interested in the same thing and there was no conflict of interest; whoever is chosen for the southern group and for the northern group will be chosen by all the co-operatives, large and small, and will be elected on the Board to look after the interests of the producers. I think the position is safe enough.

Comment on this

Does a central creamery with a number of branches have only one vote?

Comment on this

Yes. The branches are satellites.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would answer a question about the Golden Vale Federation.

Comment on this

They manufacture separately. Each will have a vote.

Comment on this

Really, then, Mitchelstown will be swamped.

Comment on this

They would, if the Senator got away with it.

Comment on this

If the Minister does not want the powers I will not force them on him.

Comment on this

I moved amendment No. 28:

To add to the section "provided that he has not already had twelve years consecutive service on the Board."

In setting up a Board I hold there should be some positive effort made to ensure a certain amount of change in the composition of the Board. If we examine different bodies we find far more damage is done where membership continues indefinitely and I, therefore, suggest here a very mild type of rotation; a member should be ineligible if he has sat for more than 12 consecutive years on the Board. Having served three consecutive periods, he should step down for at least one period.

Comment on this

This amendment also falls in with the group as far as I am concerned, because it is a limiting provision. I object to the amendment. I think an elected representative should be allowed to retain membership. Where provision is made for an election every four years it would be wrong, in my view, to restrict on the lines suggested by the Senator. Had that provision attached to membership of the Dáil I should have been out of it 25, or 30, years ago, and I should take a poor view of that.

Comment on this

The member would be out for only one period and he would go back refreshed.

Comment on this

Every four years the Minister is in the hands of the electorate.

Comment on this

And these will also be in the hands of the electorate as well.

Comment on this

We should have rotation on all our bodies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:—

Before Section 17 to insert a new section as follows:

"The Minister may at any time remove his nominated officer from the Board".

I have been accused of being antagonistic to, or critical of, the Dairy Disposal Company. Here, I am coming to their aid in that I am advocating that they should be treated as an independent unit. If the Minister appoints one of their members to the Board, as he is entitled to do, that person should be permanent on the Board in the same way as the members elected by co-operative societies and others. Otherwise, he would be just a second representative of the Minister. It is valuable that the Minister should have one representative of his Department from the point of view of co-ordination but it is wrong that this restrictive practice, to use the Minister's own words, should be used against this particular representative. The representative of the Dairy Disposal Company should function as a full member with the same rights, duties and privileges as every other member of the Board.

Comment on this

Without having any desire to have control over the individual concerned, one has to ask oneself who else is there to select this man except the Minister? Having selected him, who is to remove him except the Minister? There is no comparison as between an elected member and the representative of the Dairy Disposal Company. The elected member must present himself to the electorate every four years. If I appoint the representative and I have no power to remove him, what will happen? Let us be consistent. Sometimes it might be desirable to change.

Comment on this

Because of political expediency.

Comment on this

It might be desirable to change and, having appointed the man, surely the Minister should have the right to remove him. If not the Minister, then it would have to be somebody else. Who would that somebody else be?

Comment on this

I am an appointee of the Minister for Education on the Board of Advanced Studies. Speaking subject to correction, I am not sure if he has any right to remove me.

Comment on this

The Minister is satisfied he can remove him if he wishes?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There is no question of removing a member appointed by the co-operative societies?

Comment on this

No, because they are elected for four years.

Comment on this

The point I make is if this company is to be represented, its representatives should be in the same position.

Comment on this

There are several reasons why a Minister who makes an appointment should have the right to remove the person concerned. We are not all saints and we do not all continue to give the type of service expected of us. Many things might arise which would necessitate the removal of a man.

Comment on this

But despite all that, the Minister can remove a man in any section of his Department.

Comment on this

There might be promotion, for instance.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

Before section 18 to insert a new section as follows:

"(1) If in relation to a nominating provision, on the nomination day in any nomination year, no person stands proposed under that nominating provision, the Minister shall appoint a person he considers to be representative of that group.

(2) The results shall be arranged in order of voting preference in each of the nominating panels, and all casual vacancies shall be filled in the order shown.

(3) If no further persons are listed in the voting results as required under subsection (2) of this section, and a casual vacancy occurs, the Minister shall appoint a person he considers to be representative of the group."

In Section 18 we have a rather complicated provision by which the Minister, in effect, takes unto himself the right to fill all casual vacancies occurring on the Board. That seems to be a very wide power and one quite unnecessary. As I suggest in this amendment, whether you adopt the straight vote system or the single transferable vote, the candidates can be returned in the order of the election—the candidate elected, then the next, the next and so on. It is quite feasible and reasonable that the second man on the panel should step up if the first man steps down. In the event of the panel running out, the amendment proposes that the further filling of the vacancy should be left to the Minister.

Comment on this

It is not worth while tying the Minister in the matter of a casual vacancy arising every four years. I do not think it would be wise to do so. When filling a casual vacancy I cannot see a Minister failing to have a look at the results of the election in, say, the southern or northern areas and, if a second candidate offers, seeing how he has fared. If two or three candidaters offer in the southern area, it may be that the second got only a fraction of the total vote. I do not think it is wise that, by acceptance of this amendment, the Minister should be compelled automatically to appoint that person. You should trust the Minister a little more than that.

Comment on this

The amendment loses much of its force due to the fact that we object to the single transferable system of voting. It is quite likely, as the Minister has said, that the second person might get only a small fraction of the vote got by the first person. That could not occur under the single transferable system and the second person would be in every respect the second choice of the group. However, that is not possible under the system of straight voting used in this Bill, and consequently I wish to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:

"( ) (a) The Minister shall cause to be inserted in Iris Oifigiúil in the next issue following the establishment day, particulars of the remuneration and expenses to be allowed to the Chairman and to the members of the Board.

(b) All changes in remuneration and expenses of the Chairman and of the members of the Board shall be similarly inserted in Iris Oifigiúil”.

Senators will note that Section 19 states:

A member of the Board shall be paid out of the Fund such remuneration and allowances for expenses as the Minister, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, from time to time determines.

This will be by order and there will be no record of it on the Table of the House. I feel the proper procedure would be that the remuneration of the chairman and members of the Board, as distinct from their expenses, which might cause difficulty because they vary, should be published in Iris Oifigiúil so that we would know the remuneration of the chairman and members of the Board just as we know the Minister's official salary and the salaries of Senators and Deputies and so on.

Comment on this

This Bill follows the line adopted in seven or eight more or less similar measures. As far as the remuneration of these people is concerned, a Parliamentary Question will always bring the information required. That is the practice that has been followed and there is no reason to depart from it.

Comment on this

If the Minister assures me that a Parliamentary Question will bring the desired information, then by your leave, Sir, I wish to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I have supplied it myself on a number of occasions.

Comment on this

I wish to oppose this section because it imposes a restriction on a member of the Board. When he becomes a member of either House of the Oireachtas he must cease to be a member of the Board. That is rather unnecessary. In setting up these boards we always express the wish that the best possible board will be recruited, and then we immediately proceed to disenfranchise those people in so far as their eligibility to sit in either Dáil or Seanad is concerned. I know a certain case could be made against having these people sit in the Dáil which takes considerably more time than the Seanad, but surely if there is any substance in the claim that this is a vocational Seanad or that we desire it should develop on vocational lines, then it is only right and proper that members of the boards of various semi-State bodies and others should be able to play their part if called on without in any way detracting from their duties as members of these boards.

We are up against the problem here, and we are all very conscious of the problem, of semi-State bodies, and we shall have to do a lot of clear thinking on it in the next couple of years. We must have many of these semi-State bodies, but, on the other hand, we must be aware of what we are doing and not take, as it were, another step towards expanding the area of socialisation and nationalisation of our resources. Consequently, where it is possible for us to change from semi-State boards to non-semi-State bodies, it would be advisable for us to do so. We did it in the case of the Dairy Disposal Company.

Equally, while it is desirable that we should have some close links between Parliament and the semi-State bodies, I can think of nothing that would achieve that end better than having some permanent people on the boards, who also happened to be elected to the Seanad on one panel or another. It is rather interesting to see where the approach of the Government has varied. First of all, we have, in the Minister's Department, the Agricultural Institute. There is no restriction on a member of the Council of that Institute or even on the chief officer himself, to prevent him from being elected to this House. If such a person is elected to this House, it is only as it should be. I know the Minister will say that the Agricultural Institute is an automonous body and not a semi-State body. I grant the difference, but I do not think membership of that Board is quite comparable with membership of Bord Bainne. If a member of Bord Bainne is undesirable in this House, it is likely in the same way that a member of An Foras Talúntais would be undesirable, too.

Then, we swing to the other extreme in a measure with which the Minister was associated, the Glenamoy grassmeal measure. Admittedly, that Bill was sponsored by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but it went to the extreme that if a member of the authority set up under that Bill was even nominated for election to the Dáil or Seanad, he would thereupon have to resign. An officer of the company is under the same disability and the same clause has been invoked in the recent Broadcasting Authority Bill. There might be some justification for that.

Comment on this

There is justification there.

Comment on this

I put down this amendment to highlight the problem. I hope the day will come when the Government will accept such an amendment, and we will be pleased to find that we have amongst us members who are intimately connected with semi-State bodies who will act as a bridgehead between the two.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Quinlan on this point and, in fact, when I saw the amendment I looked up an Act that I remember, namely, the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) (Amendment) Act, 1958, which has a great similarity to this Bill. There are reasons why members of either House are excluded from membership of the Board set up under that Act inasmuch as the Minister appoints the Board. In this case, it might well be that a milk producer in the south of Ireland, a politician of either Party or an Independent politician, might be the fittest and a most excellent person to sit on this Board. In such a situation, it would be a mistake if he were not allowed to do so.

This exclusion of members of the Houses of the Oireachtas is going too far. It is now included in almost all provisions of this kind. I feel that we are being altogether to squeamish about it. There is nothing wrong in a member of the Fianna Fáil Party or the Fine Gael Party, if he is fit and able, taking such a position in some capacity, and accepting the stringent criticism which will come to him from the other side if he digresses in any way from the path of duty or the path of excellence. I feel that the automatic inclusion of this provision in every similar Act passing through the Houses of the Oireachtas is wrong, and I register myself, like Senator Quinlan, as disapproving of it.

Comment on this

It is not so many years since the Government of the day decided to insert this provision in every Bill of this kind. They must have had very good reasons for taking that decision. While I am not able to give them all now, I am perfectly satisfied it is the right thing to do. This is a small country and the couple of hundred people chosen to act here as Deputies and Senators surely are not vital to the composition of boards of this nature. However they succeed in getting there, many members of the public take a very poor view of their being there, and are very critical of any such happening. It was, I am sure, because of that growing attitude on the part of the public that the Government of the day some years ago—I do not know how many—decided upon this course. It is provided for here, and I have no doubt it will be provided for in Bills of this nature for years and years to come. I hope it will.

Comment on this

I do not follow the Minister's reasoning. He says this is a small little country and, therefore, a selection from the 200 or 300 members of the Oireachtas cannot be vital to any board. This being a small country is a good reason why certain members of the Oireachtas being members of boards could, in fact, be vital, from the point of view of their knowledge and experience.

Let us take two men. The ex-Minister for Agriculture of the Fine Gael Party, the Leader of the Opposition at the moment, Deputy Dillon, could surely, if elected—but I think he would not be elected because he is not a milk producer—make a very big contribution to this Board. The Minister sitting here to-day in Committee has convinced me that if he were out of office, he would do the same thing. Yet those two men are excluded by this provision. That is just an example, but I feel it is a proper example.

We are being far too squeamish about this sort of thing and too susceptible to criticism. We will be criticised, no matter what happens. If one were to consider how these things are operated in one of the most successful countries in the world, one has only to look at America where we find inter-relation on all sorts of boards, committees and so on of members of the Senate and members of the House of Representatives. I believe that the automatic inclusion of this sort of doctrinaire provision in Bills of this nature is bad.

Comment on this

I would only be sensitive to criticism if my conscience were not at ease.

Comment on this

I was not referring to the Minister because he is not sensitive to criticism.

Comment on this

I do not mean myself; I am saying that public men need not be sensitive to criticism, provided their consciences are at ease.

Comment on this

I agree, Of course, the Minister is not sensitive to criticism.

Comment on this

The Minister has stated that the membership of these Houses, the few hundred involved, is not fatal to the board. I agree with him on that. I should be prepared to see the second proviso stand; in other words, that a person who is actually sitting would be ineligible for appointment to a board. It is different when a person outside, sitting on a board, is appointed to one of the Houses. This is one of our real problems. The class from which we can draw membership of the Oireachtas is getting smaller and smaller. Those in salaried positions, and so on, are unable to accept. You have to be in a second position. You have to be a land-owner or in a business or in some other position before you can undertake membership of the Houses at the present allowances. Looking through the Houses, there are very few who have not got other means of support. That automatically excludes the vast bulk of the salaried people in the country. Then the cry is raised: "Why do graduates not enter politics?" They cannot afford it.

I should like a list of the members of all the boards. I imagine it would run into hundreds of our leading citizens. All these are excluded. If you wish, you might exclude them from the Dáil for a while, but there is no case for excluding them from what should be a non-political vocational Seanad and what I hope one day will reach that position.

I notified my intention to oppose this section but did not expect to get agreement. However, by raising the issues involved and keeping at them, we can ultimately bring the Government to face the task of shifting this very restrictive proviso. I would welcome the chairman of any of our State bodies. They would be ornaments to our Houses. They would be capable of valuable contributions on many legislative matters.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:

In line 16, before "such" to insert "or issue share capital for capital purposes".

This amendment is merely for elucidation as to the powers conferred on the Board. Do they extend to the issue of share capital for capital purposes by the Board?

Comment on this

This is a non-profit-making Board. It is not comparable with other bodies of this nature. We see no reason for issuing share capital. In fact, it would present many undesirable problems.

Comment on this

In a case where so many large business interests are involved, co-operative societies and so on, surely this would be an obvious means of part-financing a company?

Comment on this

What advantage would it have?

Comment on this

It would probably be more stable or less reliant on the Government rather than expect the whole thing to come from the Minister.

Comment on this

It is not designed as a profit-making concern. What purpose would it serve from the point of view of issuing shares?

Comment on this

If the whole effort had been made through the co-operative movement, then obviously the share capital, in the main, would have been put up by the co-operative movement, just as the share capital is put up for various co-operative enterprises, cattle marts, and so on. The fact that it is non-co-operative would not preclude it from paying whatever is the legitimate——

Comment on this

Where you have shareholders, do they not own the concern? If it were possible to do that, would it be desirable that this Board should be owned and controlled by shareholders?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

In pages 17 and 18, to delete subsection (4).

This amendment is to delete the section that limits the amount of subvention to the export of dairy produce which the Government should give. This is intended to be a governor on the engine that produces dairy produce. When an engine comes to a certain capacity, a governor does not allow it to go any further. In support of that, I would say that the whole demand for dairy produce here, with the exception of cheese, has been proved to be static. Whatever improvement we may get in cheese will be rather small. Therefore, if we have a static home demand and if the position is that we drink or consume a certain number of millions of gallons—let it be X million gallons— and we export a small amount, the levy, being one-third of the cost of exporting that small amount divided over that X million gallons of milk at home, shall be small and shall reduce by a small amount the price of milk paid by the consumer. If we expand our exports, while the demand at home is static, relatively the charge upon X million gallons of milk at home is increased and the price of dairy milk is reduced. Therefore, if we have expansion, the situation here is that the price of dairy milk is reduced and when the price of any farmer's crop reduces, he moves over to something else.

Our farmers are mainly mixed farmers. While a farmer may be a dairy farmer, at the same time, he has other avenues for his energy and production. Therefore, if the price of dairy milk is reduced, then the heifer that might have been mated is not, but instead is sold as beef and the declared policy of the Government to increase the number of dairy cows to 1,500,000 does not succeed.

I would refer to the necessity for a long-term plan for expanding dairy produce, as referred to in the conclusions of the Advisory Committee on the Marketing of Agricultural Produce report on dairy produce. I would refer the House to paragraphs 8, 9, 10 and 11. It is very important that we should read these paragraphs.

Let me quote:

At this stage we should like to refer to the need for a long-term plan for the dairy industry in this country. It seems to us that it is essential to evolve an overall national policy for the industry and that this should be done by the milk producers, the Irish Dairy Produce Board, recommended by us later, and the State. The fundamental point to be decided is whether this country should be an exporter of whatever temporary surplus of dairy produce may arise from time to time or whether the country should be a long-term and regular exporter of dairy produce. If it is the intention that the country's export trade in dairy produce should continue to be merely the export of whatever fluctuating surplus may arise from year to year, there would be little point in altering radically the present marketing arrangements. This applies particularly in the case of butter, the marketing arrangements for which, in our opinion, have operated reasonably satisfactorily in disposing of the occasional temporary surpluses that have arisen.

They now proceed to draw the conclusion:

We consider, however, that proposals for the future marketing of Irish dairy produce should be based on the assumption that the country must have an increasing volume of such produce to export and our report must be read in that light. A significant increase in the volume of exports of dairy produce cannot be brought about rapidly and we believe that a definite long-term plan aimed at increasing milk output and providing a steady flow of dairy products for export must be evolved. In formulating such a plan it is important that the following two points should be borne in mind. In the first place, the plan should be a long-term one which will be maintained over a reasonable period irrespective of temporary developments. Secondly, the producer must be assured that any increase in efficiency and productivity resulting from his efforts will be reflected in an improvement in his standard of living.

I do not want to quote Paragraph 10 but I should quote Paragraph 11 which draws further conclusions:

We must say that our views in regard to the dairy industry are at variance with the general trend of the section on dairying in the White Paper, which appears to consider dairying outside the context of the wholly artificial nature of world trade in dairy produce. Furthermore, the dairy industry here cannot be considered on its own and the dependence of the cattle industry on it must be taken into account. If the arguments in paragraph 33 of the White Paper are accepted as general policy, it seems to us that the conclusions of this report will be largely negatived.

The desire of the Government is to give the appearance of going on with the recommendations of this report, but at the same time to adhere to their own conclusions as adumbrated in paragraph 33 of the White Paper on dairying. The Advisory Committee also digresses from the views of the Government as stated in that section.

In their general conclusions, I should refer the Seanad to conclusion 20 on page 36 of the report of the Advisory Committee on the Marketing of Agricultural Produce in the Summary of Recommendations.

Comment on this

Are we on Section 33?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Section 32, amendment 35.

Comment on this

There the Advisory Committee say:

An annual grant for the purpose of supporting exports of dairy produce should be made to the Dairy Produce Board, the amount to be determined in annual negotiations about November of each year between the Board and the Department of Agriculture and the Board to be allowed to support exports of certain other dairy products as well as butter.

These people say that we must proceed on the basis of an expanding dairy industry and that each November we should look at what are the requirements of that industry and go further in the realisation that we have a constant surplus to export at any time and that we can get better prices and can dispose of our losses. The Government in their White Paper do not adhere to that view. In my opinion, they tried to put the governor on the engine. The result will be the ordinary grasshopper policy for agriculture that we had in this country— the swing of the pendulum. The price goes up when production goes down and vice versa. That is the old supply and demand idea which governs all transactions, but it is not allowed to govern transactions in the marketing of agricultural produce in any civilised country today.

The position is that the prices of agricultural produce are all artificial. In fact, there are supports which we cannot too freely afford, but, at the same time, there are stated policies and aims and a desire to get somewhere, in the hope that when you have got to that point you can market your produce more advantageously and dispose of losses. The Government, in paragraph 26 of the White Paper, state:

The objective of policy will be to increase cow numbers progressively to at least 1,500,000 by 1964. The retention for breeding of an additional 50,000 heifers per annum would enable this objective to be attained without undue disturbance to the farming economy or to the export trade, though the progress of the Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Scheme, involving the slaughter of considerable numbers of cows before the end of their normal life, will for a time be a complicating factor. It is important that these additional cows be bred for beef rather than milk production, as beef can be sold abroad competitively, whereas butter, our most important milk product, cannot—a situation which seems likely to continue for some time. A considerable proportion of the additional cows should be outside the main dairying areas.

From that, I deduce that the Government want to have this governor and do not want an expanding export drive in dairy produce. You cannot sell the goods if you have not got them.

The first thing I want to say in relation to the ordinary breeding of cattle is that single suckling and multiple suckling became rather popular three or four years ago. This year and last year, there was not a great profit either in single suckling or multiple suckling. Therefore, what are we to do with our cows, the whole basis of our cattle industry and therefore this country's prosperity? If we are to digress from the breeding of young heifers, we are destroying our main agricultural export. Even though industrial exports have passed the cattle export trade slightly in money value, it must be remembered that industrial exports involve us in a considerable amount of imports of raw materials before we export the finished product. I hold against the Government and against the views stated in the White Paper. We must proceed in the realisation that this country has to market the milk products so that we may have the calves at a price that will give some extra return to the dairy farmer.

Let me quote from paragraph 33 of the Government White Paper which was mentioned in the Advisory Committee's recommendations:

Where a subsidy has to be paid, the benefit to farmers from increased production and exports is, to the extent of the subsidy, achieved only by a transfer from the community at large, of which the farmers themselves are a considerable part. If, according as production increased, unit costs were reduced, enabling milk products to be marketed abroad with gradually declining aid from public funds, the improvement in farmers' incomes would be more soundly based and, ultimately, the whole value of the increased output would accrue as a net national gain. The need for a change in this direction is made more evident by the prospect of an expansion in the breeding herds. An annual increase of 50,000 cows (paragraph 26 above), accompanied by an annual increase in yields even of only 10 gallons per cow, would, at the end of five years, quadruple the amount of milk surplus to home requirements. On the basis of present export prices and subsidy arrangements, this would entail an Exchequer subsidy of some £10,000,000 to £12,000,000 per annum. A potential liability of this magnitude cannot be undertaken. Both for economic and financial reasons, the primary objective of grasslands policy must be to secure an increase in the output of meat rather than of milk, since even on present production costs meat can be sold abroad without State aid.

The Government, therefore, do not agree that the breeding herds in the milking areas should be increased. I feel that is a terrible digression from a proper agricultural policy. I feel that even if there is the increase mentioned in Paragraph 33 of the White Paper, if things were to continue as they were, in the order of £10,000,000, that great load that could fall upon us would be largely negatived by the extra opportunity we would have of marketing our products in an orderly fashion.

Denmark has been mentioned at least half a dozen times today. The Danes are now claiming a large portion of the British market for dairy products, and, as a by-product of the export of dairy products, they have claimed a large portion of the bacon trade in the British market. I feel that the Government in putting this limiting factor there are deliberately setting the governor on the engine, saying that if exports increase, the prices at home will diminish and if the farmer is dissatisfied with the price of his milk, he will as a result keep less cows. He will not keep that extra heifer. Instead of having 1,500,000 cows which have been mentioned as a target, we will have less. I feel that the Government want this pendulum and I feel that in November of each year, there should be a meeting between Bord Bainne and the Minister, and, in consultation with the Minister for Finance, a sum should be voted which would run the dairy industry for the following 12 months. That would be a fairer and better solution because it would allow for expansion. I feel that if the dairy industry does not expand, agriculture generally will contract as well as the dairy industry.

I do not know where we are to get our store cattle for export, if we do not get them from the dairy industry. I know there was a great move towards single-suckling and multi-suckling calves and in the first years, these beef calves did make a good price but as the number increased in relation to the demand, they made bad prices and single suckling calves in this year, when beef was making a fair price, made as low as £27. What is the choice for the farmer? Does he keep his good heifer and make it into beef, or does he keep her and milk her and rear calves and sell the surplus milk? We are not changing the situation in the dairying industry one iota.

A few years ago, the Government instituted the one-third, two-thirds system and as a result there was a reduction of one penny in the price of dairy milk. Following that, there was a dry summer and there were no exports and the Government took credit for the fact that there was an increase of 1.3d. in dried milk. That again is the pendulum system which has operated in all Irish agriculture over past decades. If the Government want that system, they could not have devised better machinery than the system whereby when exports increase, the price of milk at home decreases.

I feel this section should be deleted and that the Minister should meet Bord Bainne in November each year and plan the general policy of the Board for the next 12 months. That would give some incentive to the farmer to increase his breeding herd in the dairying areas. The Minister knows that in these areas there is a 40 per cent. incidence of bovine tuberculosis. How does he propose to increase the breeding herds in those areas, if he does not give some support? If he does not give this support, it will produce the grasshopper farmer and the pendulum and will not help the dairying industry. That is my case on this section. I am supported by the Advisory Committee in my views, so that I am not completely out on a limb.

Comment on this

One thing which happens in a deliberative Assembly which I always think should not happen to the extent that it does is repetition. Senator Donegan made this speech on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

The very same speech. It was made in the Dáil. The reports to which he referred have been quoted and I dealt with that quotation when I was concluding the Second Reading discussion and I said then that if a Senator wanted to be really objective and fair, he should read on and could provide himself with more information. I dealt with Paragraph 33 of this document known as Economic Expansion. I dealt with the times and circumstances in which that document was prepared. It was prepared at a time when, as the Senator admits himself, beef was very costly, was a very good trade and was very profitable. It was prepared at a time when the Taoiseach, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, and I went to Britain as a result of the challenge of the New Zealand Government. We were obliged to go there to deal with our export position, as far as butter was concerned.

On the conclusion of the Second Reading debate, I tried to deal with that matter in an objective way. I proceeded to read Paragraph 34 of Economic Expansion from which the Senator has quoted. This is what Paragraph 34 said:

However much policy may be tilted towards having beef rather than milk products as the marketable surplus, any increase in cow numbers will result in an increase in milk production...

This document makes it clear that the policy aim was to increase cow numbers. The steps to be taken towards that end are also outlined in the document.

The paragraph continues:

and it is urgently necessary that production costs be reduced so as to enable the increase over home needs to be economically exported. The improvement of grasslands will help directly both by reducing feeding costs and by enabling better feeding methods to be introduced. Care will be taken to ensure that the best breeding stock of the main dairying breeds will be available in the dairying areas both at the artificial insemination stations and at the premises of private breeders; this will enable further improvements to be effected in the dairy herd. The scientific investigations necessary for a determination of the comparative merits of the Friesian and Shorthorn breeds will be pressed ahead. Farmers will thus be able to decide for themselves whether to go Friesian or Shorthorn and the State will endeavour for its part to introduce the best sires of both breeds and to improve the existing breeds by progeny testing.

That document was prepared as an indication to the public of the objectives which the Government was striving to achieve. It does not follow, of course, that even if you did deliberately say to the farmers, "go in for beef rather than milk" that they would do so because naturally that would be determined by the profitability of one as against the other.

Much as I detest repetition, even when it has to come from me, I want to say now that when this document was being prepared, because of the circumstances of the time to which I have referred and because of the danger of our whole attitude being misrepresented by paragraph 33, from which the Senator has quoted, I was personally responsible for paragraph 34, in order to show the farmers that we were not in any way prejudiced against milk and milk products, that we knew the difficulties of handling a surplus to our own requirements, that we were not prejudiced against them and we were indicating here the steps we were taking in order to enable them to produce so as to simplify marketing.

I said also here, in reply to the criticism on the last occasion, that you cannot misrepresent this Party as far as the milk producers of the country are concerned. You may try as much as you like. I am not saying that the price which is paid for milk here is very attractive by comparison with other countries, not by any means, but I am saying in the Seanad and I shall say it anywhere, before any audience, that this Party does not have to be in any way afraid or ashamed to go before the farmers, in comparison with the performance of any political Party, and have this scheme contested.

The fact that we are here as a majority Government, the fact that this Party has been in office with two breaks since 1932 is proof, if you are dealing with men and women with reasonable minds, that we have retained the support of the people. Even when out of office we have been able to secure almost 50 per cent. of the support of the people. We have been able by our own activities, by our own achievements, by the policy that we pursued, to secure and to retain their confidence and I would say that we never held it so firmly as we do today.

Comment on this

You never got 45 per cent. of the farmers.

Comment on this

What about the last bye-election?

Comment on this

Go to the country. What are you waiting for?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order.

Comment on this

We shall not be like some of those who preceded us. We shall not have to be almost lifted out of office.

Comment on this

You will have to be lifted out.

Comment on this

I do not like to have to deal with this very politically minded Senator from County Louth. I have been in politics for a very long time and I would not have been in them for so long if I did not have some liking for politics but I really do dislike having politics on every plate that is put before me. I like to get some ease from politics now and again. I do not know whether the Senator regards that as a tribute or a criticism but I do not know of any Senator except his running mate, Senator Quinlan, who is so politically minded as he is. There is no harm in that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister recollect the time when he spoke for six hours and never used a political argument?

Comment on this

It is said that I can be tremendously interesting if I am in the mood.

Comment on this

Never more interesting than now.

Comment on this

Do not lose too much sleep about us. As far as our relations with the country are concerned and especially my relations with the farmers, they were always good.

Comment on this

What about the Minister for Local Government?

Comment on this

In the case of the farmers, especially milk producing farmers, I suppose I have the best record of all of them. You could not do damage to my name as far as they are concerned.

Comment on this

Not any more.

Comment on this

The Minister is putting bad thoughts in my head.

Comment on this

Coming to the end of the Bill I had reluctantly to make these remarks so that Senator Donegan would be given some ammunition with which to take up the running after me. I did not like to leave him there. He is associated with these amendments and if he had to say his part and do his piece, it would be very dry if he had to cover the ground covered by Senator Quinlan. I intervened as a matter of convenience. I hope that the Senator has got some useful notes on which he can play a new tune.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Could the Leader of the House indicate what the arrangements are?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think there is general agreement that we should finish this Stage. As a matter of fact, the understanding I had was that we would finish the Committee Stage by 6 o'clock and I think we should endeavour to do that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Then we shall go ahead.

Comment on this

At what time will the House rise?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

When we finish the Committee Stage of this Bill, at 6 o'clock.

Comment on this

We are not going to be coerced into rushing. I will not have that.

Comment on this

Despite how the farmers love the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Agreements should be kept.

Comment on this

I have no objection to an adjournment for tea.

Comment on this

We ought to do that or postpone the debate till Tuesday.

Comment on this

I cannot do that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

There was an understanding that we would finish the Committee Stage of this Bill at 6 o'clock and then take Senator Prendergast's motion. We have made several endeavours to take Senator Prendergast's motion and if this effort fails, I cannot see when it will be taken.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If we are to take Senator Prendergast's motion, it is only fair to the Minister who has been sitting here all the time that we should have a tea adjournment.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not want this debate to be prolonged as it was on other occasions until nine or ten o'clock on footy points. If understandings are arrived at, they should be honoured.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I have noticed that matters have been disposed of more rapidly in the last hour. The Leader of the House thinks Senators may get second wind during tea time.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It is quite possible.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think the feeling of the House is that we should have a tea adjournment.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

The Minister, in replay to my contribution, said many things and I analysed them pretty fairly. He said that the White Paper, which in my view did not predispose towards expanding our economy, was prepared at a time when beef was profitable, when the present Taoiseach and himself were in London trying, as he said, to combat the challenge of the New Zealand Government on dairy products on the British market. That seems to be an admission that what I suggest is true. He went on to quote paragraph 34 as if it were a complete apologia for paragraphs 33 and 26 and he almost challenged me that I had not continued to quote him. Of course I am quite prepared to quote the entire White Paper if he wishes but I do not think it would be either necessary or in order.

Taken in conjunction with the statements he made that the recommendations contained in the White Paper were made at the time mentioned and when the Taoiseach and himself were in London, one must read the first words of paragraph 34—the paragraph the Minister quotes as an apology for Government policy in this regard—as something that proves rather than disproves my contention. I quote:

However much policy may be tilted towards having beef rather than milk products as the marketable surplus, any increase in cow numbers will result in an increase in milk production and it is urgently necessary that production costs be reduced so as to enable the increase over home needs to be economically exported.

I could continue but I think in the interests of brevity it is not necessary. The paragraph refers very properly to the necessity for improving our dairy breeds and so on but when you take the first sentence I think you must immediately accept that the Government's policy was to move our cattle policy away from the dairy end towards the beef end.

I have pointed out on the Second Reading that in fact production of beef, while most necessary and suitable in part of the country and suitable for our economy and was built up because farmers' houses had larger farms around them and that sort of thing, it is at the same time a kind of cattle rearing that produces the lowest income per head. I think it true to say that if you are going to ask the people in dairy areas to restrict their activity you are, in fact, following a contracting policy rather than an expanding one and that is wrong.

This section refers directly to the levy on dairy milk and the position when this enactment becomes law is that the levy will remain law until it is repealed. It is therefore a perpetuation of the milk levy and is designed, like other levies on agricultural produce—notably the levy on wheat— to control production as the governor on the engine controls its speed as I described in my first statement on this matter.

Senator Quinlan and I were grouped together as running mates. I did not discuss this section, or any part of this Bill, with Senator Quinlan at any time. The identical amendments were tabled from Louth and Cork, with no prior exchange of any kind. It may be said that "fools seldom differ" or "great minds run in grooves". There is absolutely no question of Senator Quinlan and I being running mates.

Comment on this

I wish to make a few observations to reinforce what Senator Donegan has said. I stand here, as I have always stood, as an Independent representative, and I will defend that position against attacks from any side. I have frequently been criticised by my friends on this side and frequently by my friends on the other; I am glad to say I have found friends on both sides. I conceive it to be my duty on a Committee Stage like this to give whatever views I can as a result of the study I have put into the measure. I do not expect my views to be accepted in whole, or even in part, but it is my duty here to put forward my views. I make no apology for being concerned because of the inroads that are being made into our national life by the creation of groups of citizens who cannot take any part in the public life of this country. That is a very ominous development. It is one we must watch.

With regard to independence, I wish that we here would grow up a little and regard Committee Stages as so much give and take. I look back with extreme pleasure to the first occasion on which I tabled amendments here. It was the Committee Stage of the Agricultural Institute Bill. I had 25 amendments down. The Bill was piloted through the House by the President, who was then Taoiseach and Head of the Government. It was a magnificent debate. Not the slightest imputation was made against any speaker and we wound up that debate, having done a good job on the Committee Stage. One of my amendments was accepted. As I see the position here tonight, there is not the slightest intention to accept any amendment. We have found ourselves up against closed minds the whole way through. I want to register the strongest possible protest against this method of handling a Committee Stage and the only effective way I can see of registering my protest at this stage is not to move all the remaining amendments standing in my name.

Comment on this

We do not wish to go into the Division Lobby on this amendment but we do wish to be recorded as dissenting.

Comment on this

Will the Senators who wish to be recorded as dissenting please rise?

Senators Donegan, Quinlan, L'Estrange, O'Quigley and Carton rose.

Comment on this

The Senators will be recorded as dissenting.

Comment on this

I have consulted the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) (Amendment) Act, 1958, in relation to the establishment of a Board such as this. I find that the wording is that the Board shall provide itself with such offices and premises as it considers necessary. According to Section 5 of this Bill, all sorts of things are covered, such as shops, showrooms, bureaux. I regard the provision as highly suspicious and as absolutely unnecessary.

Comment on this

The Minister's approval is vital and that approval is an assurance which should be appreciated fully by the Senator.

Comment on this

I fear I cannot accept the Minister's approval as a complete answer. Under subsection (2) (g) of Section 5, we find that the Minister's approval is not necessary at all. They can have anything they like—bureaux, shops, showrooms.

Comment on this

They can undertake none of these activities without my approval.

Comment on this

There is nothing to that effect in the Bill.

Comment on this

What property is involved here? Could the Minister also tell me what amount of money is to the credit of the Dairy Produce Price Stabilisation Fund?

Comment on this

I could not say. The property would be butter and butter boxes.

Comment on this

It is mainly that kind of thing?

Comment on this

Yes. I would not know the amount of money at the end of the year. It is only when all these accounts are straightened out that I would be able to give that information.

Comment on this

Regulations and orders are to be made and laid before each House of the Oireachtas "as soon as may be." Could the Minister give some general information as to the period in which normally regulations and orders will be laid before each House of the Oireachtas?

Comment on this

I would not have a clue, to tell you the truth.

Comment on this

This brings us back to Section 6, about which we were talking earlier. Senator O'Reilly spoke at some length this morning. What he had to say was subsequently endorsed by the Minister—that the great safeguard about the addition of duties and functions to the Board lay in the fact that regulations and orders made under the Act would have to be laid before each House of the Oireachtas. Therefore, there was a great deal of fuss, bother and pother about the thing, since Parliamentary control was being retained under Section 63. The Minister is the person who will be responsible for laying these regulations before the House "as soon as may be" possible. I now ask him what is his intention—would it be within seven days, a month or three months?—and the Minister says he has not a clue. That is not a very satisfactory way to ask us to defer our opposition to Section 6. It makes more urgent the amendment of Section 6 along the lines I indicated this morning.

Comment on this

My note here says "This is a routine provision." I do not suppose that question was ever directed to me previously. An order is made and it cannot be published until it is printed and a date is given on which it becomes operative. I would never have known there was any doubt about such a document being made available to the House, had I not heard some Senator say that, as a result of the activities of a Committee of this House, it was discovered that that was not so in all cases. In all the cases I know, once the document is ready for tabling, the date is mentioned and all is in order. It was because some Senator mentioned to-day that that was not the practice in all cases that I was hesitant about giving any assurance on a subject about which I knew very little. The matter never arose with me during my time as Minister.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Minister's position. I do not expect him to be able to explain everything in the Bill. We had a fairly lengthy debate on Section 6 and Senator Ryan said— and the Minister subsequently approved of what he said—that the safeguards in relation to an addition to the functions of the Board lay in the fact that these regulations were available.

Comment on this

They have to be.

Comment on this

Of course they have to be. What I am asking is how soon, because our experience has been that it may be as long as six months. That is a fair length of time. I am asking the Minister is it his intention that they will be laid upon the Table at the earliest possible date they are available?

Comment on this

Not only is it our intention but it is the practice of my Department to do that.

Comment on this

Unfortunately my experience has been—and I do not say the Minister's Department is particularly at fault in this respect—that regulations were not laid on the Table as soon as they might have been. No difficulty arises in regard to printing because, as we all know, many regulations are stencilled, and are available for purchase in the Government Publications Sales Office in stencilled form. So far as printing is concerned no difficulty need arise, but the Minister should be able to tell us that his interpretation of "as soon as may be" would be a week after making the regulations.

Comment on this

Next Stage?

Comment on this

Next Tuesday.

Comment on this