We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1961— Second Stage.

Contributions 219–452 of 452. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1961
Enacted

No. 6 of 1961 ›

It is.

Comment on this

It is not in order and neither is it in order for the other member of the House to interrupt as he has been interrupting. These interruptions are going a little too far.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

As I was saying before I was rudely and ignorantly interrupted, many Senators have waxed eloquent on the Constitution. It gives me and everybody on this side of the House great satisfaction to see those stout defenders of the Constitution now when I remember how they misrepresented the document in 1937 when it was put before the people, but I am inclined to wonder whether all this alleged allegiance to the Constitution now and admiration for its provisions by some of these gentlemen are genuine.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I do not like the constant reference of Senator O'Quigley and Senator L'Estrange to "your Constitution." It is not the Fianna Fáil Constitution; it is not our Constitution. It is the Constitution of Ireland enacted by the people in a free plebiscite, despite the opposition of Fine Gael and, as such, it should not be described as "your Constitution." I hope these learned gentlemen over there will take note of that and realise that in continuously referring to the Constitution, which is now the fundamental law of this country, in that disparaging way, they are not creating confidence in public institutions which they prate so much about in other parts when they leave this House.

Comment on this

Who contravened the Constitution in 1959?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senator Burke made some reference in the background in the course of a series of interruptions to the would-be dictatorship of the Blueshirts in 1934 who attempted to overthrow the Government. It is well to learn, for the record, that had this conspiracy succeeded, we might not now be able to conduct business in a State assembly of this kind.

Comment on this

The Senator would not have this type of freedom of speech, either.

Comment on this

Or this kind of blackguardism.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Senators O'Quigley and L'Estrange have referred to blackguardism. It would be very interesting and educative to the Senators to go back over the history of that period, and though I am strongly tempted to do so, I will not do it now. I shall satisfy myself with this reference to the dictatorship employed by Senator Hayes, particularly, Senator L'Estrange and others on that side of the House. They are permitted to refer to the events of 1922, to the events of 1925 and to the Blueshirts, but if anybody on this side of the House makes any reference to the attempted coup d'état in 1934 and to the successful coup d'état in 1922, he is talking politics and is accused of bringing the proceedings of the Seanad into disrepute. When we try to defend ourselves, it is all right for Senator Hayes, with unctuous effrontery, to say that the Leader of this House has no sense of the dignity of the House. But I will not be browbeaten or sit here while distortions of history are perpetrated. So long as I am here and distortions of that kind are made, I shall stand to refute them in the interests of historical accuracy and for the sake of the records. If those gentlemen want to put down a motion on 1922 or 1925 or 1934 they can do so and we shall be very glad to debate it.

According to Senator O'Quigley, the Minister carved up the country for his own purposes and those of his Party. Senator O'Quigley appears to be terribly upset by the fact that these new constituencies transgress county boundaries. During the debate on the 1959 Bill in this House, as reported at column 1051 of Volume 51 of the Official Report, he saw no harm in it and in fact advocated the system. Here is exactly what he said:

Under the new Health Authorities Act, it is proposed, with apparently no difficulty whatever, to constitute several counties and parts of counties into new health authority areas that can be administered quite well. It is expected that they can be administered quite well under the new Bill. I cannot see any reason why constituencies cannot be drawn differently from the manner in which they have been drawn up to the present time, somewhat on the same basis—not necessarily the health authority basis—but it could be done. The county boundaries and the siting of towns and so on, are not the be-all and the end-all of representation in Parliament.

This is the same gentleman who can now weep salt tears about the fact that bits of counties are added on to other counties to form new constituencies, the same thing he himself advocated during the debate on the 1959 Bill.

Senator L'Estrange might like to be reminded of what he said at that time. He will find it in column 1059 of the same volume:

That is what the Constitution says but in this Bill there is over-representation in the West of Ireland, and under-representation in the City of Dublin. I stand for parity, equal rights, and equal powers for all Irish men and women, no matter what part of the country they may be living in.

Comment on this

I still stand by that.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Now he gets a Bill which gives equal rights and an average of 20,000 voters per seat and yet he made the speech we were compelled to listen to today. Is there any end to the effrontery and hypocrisy he is capable of?

But let us come back to Senator Hayes. The Constitution of 1937, he said, was lauded to the skies and put before the people in a fraudulent manner and he had the brazen neck to compare it with the Constitution of the Free State of 1922, forgetting completely that the Constitution of that Free State was put before the people of these Twenty-Six Counties on the morning of the poll, in June, 1922. The Constitution of Ireland which was enacted by the people of Ireland in 1937 was put before the people in April, 1937, and there was public debate on it for three months before it was submitted to a plebiscite of the people. Senator Hayes must feel that we are all very stupid, that we have not lived through the period or read the history of the period.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

The Constitution of 1922 was not enacted until December, 1922.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The Constitution of 1922 was published in the newspapers on the morning of the poll.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

It was not a poll on the Constitution.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

It was not, but the Constitution was used to delude the people into breaking the pact, which it succeeded in doing. I remember in 1957 and 1958 when Senator L'Estrange threatened me with Señor Castro of Cuba. I do not hear any threats now quoting his hero of those days. They must have turned sour in his mind.

Comment on this

I referred to the Senator's efforts as being the same as those of Castro.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

His sugar-daddy is now full of gall and wormwood. We were threatened by Senator Hayes as well that we might have plenty of time to read the Constitution, but whatever the reference to Castro and the Constitution was, I am not too clear. One thing I know for certain is that the difference between Castro and the Fianna Fáil Party, which Senator Hayes attempted to reconcile by talking about one-party dictatorships, is that if ever there was a party in this country who submitted themselves to the electorate and had no hesitation in going to the people when they thought that was required, it is Fianna Fáil, and when there was any doubt as to whether or not the people still supported the Government or whether the Government required a vote of confidence in its policy, the Fianna Fáil leadership had no hesitation in going to the country.

It strikes me that the fulminations of the Fine Gael Party against this Bill are in the hope that by some mischance something will happen within the next 12 months and that in the meantime the Government will try to prolong the life of the present Dáil and keep things going for another year. Fine Gael would much prefer to have seen the Government bring in a Bill to prolong the life of the Dáil in the hope that something will happen in the next 12 months to save the already desperate position in which Fine Gael find themselves as a result of the failure of their leadership to produce the policy promised by them. I know the truth is bitter, but I sat here all evening listening to the other people——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

And never said a word!

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

——I conducted myself with dignity. I do not propose to allow the threats of Senator Hayes that if we do not conduct ourselves, the Bill will be delayed, the interruptions of Senator O'Donovan, the jeers of Senator L'Estrange or the sarcastic grin of Senator O'Quigley to prevent me if I feel I have something to say. There is no doubt that the debate in this House on the Bill from the Fine Gael side was even more shadowy than the shadow-boxing indulged in by Fine Gael in the Dáil. The effects of this Bill will be to increase the representation in the cities at the expense of rural Ireland. Fine Gael wanted it that way, apparently, and now they have got their wish.

The Government were quite rightly anxious that the life of the Dáil should not be prolonged beyond the regulation time. The dissolution is due in March next. The enactment of this measure will enable the elections to be held at the right time. The people will then get the opportunity to prove once again to the Fine Gael Party, and particularly to Senator O'Quigley and Senator L'Estrange, that honesty is the best policy.

Comment on this

The enactment of this measure became necessary when a citizen exercised his constitutional right and challenged successfully the Electoral (Amendment) Act, 1959, in the High Court. When this Bill was introduced, it seemed to comply with the requirements of the Constitution as far as could reasonably be expected from a political Party in power. The Government are to be complimented on their wisdom in refraining from appealing to the Supreme Court against the decision of the High Court. Their wise inaction also gave considerable relief to a particular member of this House! I should like to express his appreciation, even though the indirect, lengthy and literary announcement of that decision in the Town Hall in Sligo late on a Saturday night by the Minister for Health was scarcely intended to benefit that Senator politically.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

That is what one calls a good speech, Sir—no abuse of anybody.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

And nobody interrupted him.

Comment on this

I should like to commence by saying what has been said in the Dáil previously and what should be said by everybody, that this is a chapter in a book in which there may be four, five or six chapters. Certain gentlemen die hard. Fianna Fáil are like those gentlemen. Chapter 1 was the referendum to abolish P.R. I was amused to hear the Leader of the House reply to Senator Hayes and make the case that the 1922 Constitution was voted on at a time when the people might not have known about it and when it could have been allied with other causes. He went on to say that the 1937 Constitution was voted on freely after three months debate in the House and that everyone knew everything about it. He forgot that the referendum to which I refer was allied with another election—the election in which a Taoiseach who had been successful in maintaining his post for 17 years was seeking election as a President. That was Chapter 1. Chapter 2 was the 1959 Act, which was declared unconstitutional; and Chapter 3 is this Bill.

This Bill is the result of the declaration by the courts that the 1959 Act was unconstitutional. The wording of the Constitution leaves the greatest licence to the Oireachtas to fix the constituencies in a desirable manner. Article 16, Section 2, of the Constitution says:

The number of members shall from time to time be fixed by law, but the total number of members of Dáil Éireann shall not be fixed at less than one member for each thirty thousand of the population or at more than one member for each twenty thousand of the population.

That means, when you take into account the sections following, referring to the ratio of the number of members to the population of each constituency, that the Government at any time can fix a ratio of members to population anywhere between 20,000 and 30,000. Obviously, those who drew up the Constitution made it so in order that the administrative boundaries could quite easily be accommodated. The position was that such dictates were not followed. There were changes from 1922 on, and all these changes fell to be carried out by a Fianna Fáil majority in the Houses of the Oireachtas. The position of the Opposition is extremely difficult in such circumstances. If you seek a change from what the Government have done, you may well be jumping from the frying pan into the fire.

I mean no personal offence when I say I sincerely believe that the Government, supported by the gentlemen opposite, are quite capable of fixing things to suit themselves; but if you change, you are creating a situation in which there can be wholesale change, where changes can occur in every constituency and the Opposition can be made the excuse for this. For that reason, the Opposition did not make a bid to bring about a change. But in the 1959 Act an individual did make a bid and what preceded that is well known.

The situation which had developed was that, notwithstanding that clear direction of the Constitution, the constituencies of Dublin North (Central), Dublin South (Central), Dublin SouthEast, Carlow-Kilkenny, Dublin County, Leix - Offaly, Longford - Westmeath, Wexford, Wicklow, Cork (West), North Kerry, South Kerry, West Limerick, North Tipperary, South Tipperary, Waterford, West Galway, South Galway, North Galway, North Mayo, Roscommon, Sligo, Cavan, West Donegal, East Donegal and Monaghan were unconstitutional. That was the situation in which an individual decided, notwithstanding the fact that he had not been directed to do so with the full support of the Party, to go forward as an aggrieved person. The Constitution specified that there could be a latitude of 10,000 of the population. Could anybody have been more guilty? Could anything have been more patently obvious? I am sure you cannot define that condemnation as shadow-boxing.

Another more important point arises from the court proceedings. I have investigated that point as far as I possibly could by inquiring, by reading the court proceedings and other means and there is no direction by the court as a result of that action that the deviation shall be limited—as far as one constituency relates to another—to 1,000 or less. There is merely reference by the judge to the fact that on the first occasion it had been found possible to fix the constituencies with such a small deviation from the national average. There is no direction, nor is there any question of the judge giving his opinion that it is necessary, to fix these constituencies to give a deviation not greater than 1,000.

The question then arises as to whether, if there is no such deviation, there can be gerrymandering. The case is made by the Government speakers that if the Government are completely tied down to having practically no deviation as between one constituency and another, there can be no gerrymandering. That is quite incorrect. I would explain that by saying that it would be just as if you had two horse races at a race meeting and in one race there was a favourite who was so obviously better than the other horses carrying the same weights in that race that he would win. If he were removed from that race and put into a race in which there was a much higher class of horses, he would not win and some other horse would win the race. If you have a slice of one constituency where there is say a strong Fine Gael majority and that constituency can always elect two out of three Fine Gael candidates and you remove that strong Fine Gael slice and put it into a constituency where Fine Gael require 5,000 or 6,000 increase in votes to elect two out of three Fine Gael candidates, that is dirty political gerrymandering. If at the same time— and this effort will not succeed—it was quite possible to avoid taking one of the principal towns of a county out of that county and putting it outside its administrative boundary and into another county, and that was not done, that is dirty, rotten, political gerrymandering and must be so defined.

I am referring, of course, to the removal of the Louth area including the town of Ardee to Monaghan. When I discuss that, I must discuss four counties. The Fianna Fáil Party knew quite well that they had not the chance of a snowball in Hades of getting two out of three in Kildare because Deputy Norton and Deputy Sweetman were strongly entrenched there.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

The only time Fianna Fáil came near to getting two in Kildare was in 1957 when the then Government had done patriotic and unpopular things and Deputy Sweetman was the instrument by which they were done. So, the Fianna Fáil Party, notwithstanding that there is no reason for it, decide that they will enlarge Kildare until it holds four seats, in the hope that they will get two of them, Deputy Norton and Deputy Sweetman getting the other two. They decided, at the same time, that the way to increase it was to take a bit out of Meath and Westmeath and to be sure to take a piece of Meath from the area in which the sitting Fine Gael Deputy lived. Then they felt they were lessening the opportunity of Fine Gael getting two seats in Meath.

These moves are all based on the form of races or elections of the past and there is no greater student of form than the Minister for Local Government. Then, the thing to do was to take from Louth an area that was strongly Fine Gael and put it into Monaghan. Then they hope—this is the hope—that in Louth we will not get two out of the three as we quite easily would have done and that, in Monaghan, the strongly Fine Gael slice that has been moved will merely increase the Fine Gael vote there.

That was their desire and intention but it will not be realised and I shall tell the Minister why. The move will fail because we in Louth, thank God, are blessed with the two laziest Fianna Fáil politicians in Western Europe. The other Fianna Fáil politicians in Western Europe would probably include Marshal Tito.

Comment on this

We are pretty broadly based.

Comment on this

I shall go to figures to show exactly what the position is. Senator Carter may smile, but here are figures that will prove what I say. At the time when we were most unpopular in Louth, the Labour vote was very small. It was 1,400. Fianna Fáil, in 1957, got 14,644 and we got 12,600. All that is needed there is a swing of 1,000 and we shall get that, anyway. Louth has swung as is quite obvious to me and I know Louth because I am the only one who does any work there and who resides in Louth.

Comment on this

It is surprising that the Senator is not in the Dáil.

Comment on this

I was defeated with the second largest poll in the country.

Comment on this

So was Senator Carter who told the Minister to say that. The Senator could not say it himself because he was defeated.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

I shall be back in the fight presently.

Comment on this

So will Senator Donegan.

Comment on this

We shall see.

Comment on this

Since the Minister did interject, I should like to remind him that the late Senator Moylan— God rest his soul—was defeated with exactly 50 votes more than I had.

Comment on this

That does not prove anything in your case.

Comment on this

The Minister is barking up the wrong tree.

Comment on this

Is that where you are drawing hope from?

Comment on this

My point is that it would be much easier for us to defeat Fianna Fáil, if things were left as they were in Louth. We shall defeat them anyway, but if you move——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

If you move a strongly Fine Gael portion of Louth into Monaghan and look at the figures for Monaghan, it then becomes clear that the desire was to nullify Fine Gael votes, to give Fine Gael more votes in Monaghan and to prevent them from electing an extra Fine Gael candidate. At the last election in Monaghan, the figures were: Fianna Fáil, 10,639; Fine Gael, 6,319. I have already moved the Minister to interject and I know quite well that his mind ran exactly on the lines I have indicated. He can smile and he can sneer as much as he likes. That is why he moved a slice of Louth into Monaghan. There was no need at all to do the extraordinary thing he did with Kildare. There was no need to move the entire 8,000 or 9,000 persons he needed for Monaghan, even if he wanted to get that wonderful national average he talks about.

They have now a principal town in Louth, the town of Ardee, which has its town commissioners and they have to deal with the Louth county manager. This town, as far as local administration is concerned, has to deal with the Louth County Council, but at the same time it is in the constituency of Monaghan. I know that in a country area perhaps it would not be quite so serious, but in a town of that kind things which are required by the county council can crop up. For instance, not so long ago the town of Drogheda sought guarantees for money to dredge the River Boyne from three county councils, but if the town of Ardee wanted something to further its industries, or to extend, and it sought guarantees of that sort, where would it go? Would it have the strength and support of a Deputy who was not depending on the votes of the people there? It is the only town I know of that size that has been moved from one side to another. It is quite obvious to the people why it has been moved.

I want to say that at a protest meeting in Ardee, I announced that I had given friends of mine in the town details of what would be done down to the last townland. I told them that it was being done and I knew it was being done. I said that from the day on which the Bill was first issued, there would be no amendment to it. At that protest meeting I said I felt it would be much better, if there had to be a change, to create a Louth-Monaghan constituency. Of course that would not suit the Government, either, because out of the six, Fine Gael would obviously get three. We would not have to struggle at all. If this Louth-Monaghan constituency were created, the position would be this. Louth has a population, or had a population, of over 69,000 people and Monaghan of over 51,000, making a total of over 121,000 and if the Minister wanted to stick to his national average, which I maintain he does not have to stick to, then if he divides six into that total, he would be very near to it indeed.

I would have desired to put down an amendment that there should be a Louth-Monaghan constituency but I went to the Leader of our Party and to a Party meeting, and so that this Bill would not be delayed, and knowing the Government would not accept that amendment, I was instructed, and accepted that instruction, not to put down the amendment. The reason I mention that is the accusations levelled across the floor by Senator Ó Maoláin to the effect that we would be very happy if this election were delayed for two years. No amendment, outside those for Dublin, has been put down expressly so that this Bill would not be delayed because, quite frankly, we are very anxious to get at them. We are just waiting for the election because I can assure Fianna Fáil— they may not know it themselves because they have lost touch with the people—that they are going to get a surprise. There is no doubt that their numbers will be very depleted not only in the other House but in this House, when the next Dáil and Seanad come to sit.

Finally, it has been said that Fine Gael have been inclined to demean the Constitution and to over-criticise the Constitution. Senator Ó Maoláin made those allegations and it is better that they be replied to. The most demeaning thing that was done to the Constitution since it was enacted was the continuance of a situation and the enlargement of that situation whereby the list of constituencies, certainly more than two-thirds, which I read out, were repugnant to the Constitution. If anybody wants the section of the Constitution where the Oireachtas is instructed not to enact anything that is repugnant to the Constitution, I will give it to him.

As well as that, the President is instructed to see that no Act goes through which is repugnant to the Constitution and to that end he puts his signature on each Act passed by the Oireachtas. Both the previous President and the present President were former members of the Fianna Fáil Party and persons who had been involved, at Cabinet level, in the most detailed work on constituencies and the political arrangements for electing the Oireachtas. They put their names to those Acts so that if Fianna Fáil want to criticise us on that basis, they have got to criticise the present President and the man who preceded him. If they wish to do that, I do not mind. We are not doing it and if they want to, they can look at the signatures placed on every Act which went through since 1937 and if they look at the redivision of constituencies in 1947 and 1959, they will find the signatures there. If they want to go further, they can read the judgment of the High Court. Those are the simple facts so that any criticism of anything we might say in that respect is direct criticism of two of their Presidents.

Comment on this

I should like to wish Senator O'Quigley and Senator O'Donovan the best of luck in their respective speeches. I have a feeling that their speeches were not directed at this side of the House so much as to the members of their own Party, those members of their own Party who were not as enthusiastic about the recent activities of Senator O'Quigley and Senator O'Donovan as they appeared to be about those activities themselves. I hope that for their sake their respective apologia are acceptable to the members of their Party but I beg leave to doubt it.

The task of arranging constituencies in accordance with the Constitution, on the one hand, and having regard to administrative problems on the other, is certainly no easy one. It is a very difficult task and I do not think anybody in this House would be foolhardy enough to say there is an ideal solution, or an ideal arrangement of constituencies. Administratively, there is no doubt that the 1959 Act was a better Act, but the court has ruled that t is invalid. We must accept that, and we do accept it. In accepting it, one cannot but regret that certain members of the Fine Gael Party went out of their way to deprive rural constituencies of reasonable representation. However, the members of Fine Gael who did that, like the majority of Fine Gael, are completely out of touch with rural problems and difficulties, which explains, if it does not excuse, their apparent indifference to the problems of rural Ireland.

Reference has been made by a number of speakers to the Constitution, and to the fact that a number of Bills introduced in the past by Fianna Fáil have been found invalid and repugnant to the Constitution. The Constitution was brought in as a guide to the Executive, and as a guide to the Legislature. It is the job of the Constitution to make sure that the Executive do not go off the rails. That is a very necessary safeguard because even the best-intentioned Government, or the best-intentioned Executive or Legislature, can from time to time make mistakes. As a matter of fact, it is true to say that the better intentioned the Government are, the more enthusiastic they are about their programme and policy, the more likely they are to do something which, although from the short-term point of view, may appear to be good, from the long term point of view, might not be wise. That is why the Constitution is there.

Certainly there is no doubt that the Fianna Fáil Government in the past have had Bills turned down, but it must be remembered that during the past 30 years Fianna Fáil have introduced an immense number of worthwhile Bills. The fact that a few of those Bills turned out to be repugnant to the Constitution is not anything of which Fianna Fáil need be ashamed. As I say, the Constitution was there to deal with that very situation. We are proud that the Constitution was there, and that it proved itself capable of dealing with such a situation.

Comment on this

The Bill was intended to look after yourselves, and you should be ashamed of it.

Comment on this

It would be a useless Constitution, a mere piece of paper, if, in all those years, it had never been invoked to say that a particular Bill was not in strict accordance with its provisions.

Comment on this

The Bill was to look after yourselves, not the people.

Comment on this

It would be merely a useless document. We are proud of that Constitution; we are proud of the good it has done over the years; we are proud of the reception it was given by the people when it was introduced, in spite of the fraudulent opposition to it by the Opposition at that time; and are proud, above all, of the fundamental difference between that Constitution and the Constitution devised by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and dedicated to his Majesty the King.

Comment on this

You were Cumann na nGaedheal at that time.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

He certainly was. There is no "seadh" or "ní headh" about it.

Comment on this

They had time to change their opinion.

Comment on this

Do you agree with it or do you not? Do not try to shelve your responsibilities.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that the Bill was intended to look after yourselves and you should be ashamed of it. It was declared repugnant to the Constitution and it was designed to suit yourselves, not the people.

Comment on this

Our courts are still functioning under the 1922 Constitution.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order! This cross-talk must cease.

Comment on this

The Senator had nothing whatever to do with that fact.

Comment on this

As much as you had.

Comment on this

Nothing to do with that fact.

Comment on this

As much as you had.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order! Deputy Ryan, on the Bill.

Comment on this

Obviously, there are many schemes which could be introduced in the constituencies.

Comment on this

"Schemes" is right.

Comment on this

If every person in this House were given an opportunity of bringing in a Bill of this kind, I am sure all of us would bring in a somewhat different Bill. There is no doubt that the majority of us would bring in a Bill which would be substantially the same as the Bill which the Minister has put before us. No matter what Bill was brought in, there would be criticism. I suppose it is too much to expect that members of Fine Gael, and in particular the Leader of Fine Gael, would not abuse the opportunity to talk about gerrymandering. Fine Gael know quite well that this Bill is not gerrymandering. They know quite well that no scheme can improve the chances of Fine Gael in the next general election.

Comment on this

The chances of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

They are determined to make cheap propaganda out of this Bill and they are making that propaganda because they have very little else to say about the policy of the Government.

Comment on this

The policy of the Government is not in question on this Bill.

Comment on this

It is easy to suggest, because a bit of County A was put into County B, when some member here thinks that a bit of County B should have been put into County A, that that is gerrymandering. The example given by Senator Donegan proved that not only were Fianna Fáil not gerrymandering to their own advantage, but, if anything, they were leaning over backwards to be favourable to Fine Gael Deputies. Strangely and astoundingly, Senator Donegan gave Kildare as an example. In the last general election, in County Kildare, Deputy Sweetman very nearly lost his seat. He nearly lost it by so few votes that it would be unfair to remind the Seanad at the moment how close it was.

Comment on this

How many? You can tell us if you want to.

Comment on this

Kildare was a three-seat constituency and under this Bill the Minister has made it a four-seat constituency, which means that Deputy Sweetman is pretty sure of his seat.

Comment on this

And Fianna Fáil will get two.

Comment on this

If a Fine Gael Minister for Local Government had expanded Kildare from a three-seat to a four-seat constituency, bearing in mind the close shave Deputy Sweetman had the last time——

Comment on this

Devil a shave at all.

Comment on this

——Fianna Fáil would have legitimate cause for suspicion that the Fine Gael Minister had done so to save Deputy Sweetman's seat.

Comment on this

Cod—he needed only 233 votes in the first count for the quota.

Comment on this

That was the constituency taken by Senator Donegan to prove that Fianna Fáil are gerrymandering to their own advantage. If they are doing anything at all, they are saving Deputy Sweetman's seat for him. Good luck to him, because he has enough to contend with in his own Party without having to worry about his constituency as well.

Comment on this

This Party is not like the Fianna Fáil Party. There are not factions.

Comment on this

I am sorry in a way that Fine Gael should have descended to this ridiculous propaganda. It is quite clear that no matter how many hoops they jump through, or what else they try to do, this Bill will finally go through and a general election will finally be held. When that general election is held, Fine Gael will have to face the people and to account for their behaviour and their policy, or their lack of policy, over the past years.

Comment on this

We faced it in Sligo-Leitrim and beat you and we will face it anywhere in the morning.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

Tell us about the £100,000,000 plan and all the new jobs.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

Fine Gael have very little to say about economic policy, and they are reduced to these ridiculous long quotations from the past which we had from Senator O'Quigley about Electoral Bills introduced in 1922 and 1932 and 1942, under all of which, no matter who introduced them or what shape or size the constituencies had, Fine Gael did equally badly. They will do equally badly in the next election.

Comment on this

That is what you are hoping for.

Comment on this

We have had a fairly prolonged debate on this measure, and a variety of views have been expressed. The Minister and the Government have been accused of all sorts of gerrymandering and manipulation and so on. It was admitted in the debate on the former Bill in 1959 politicians had to consider the practicability, if you will, of rearranging constituencies, and in the course of this debate and, indeed, elsewhere, considerable argument arose about the Constitution. Most Senators will agree that the Constitution is there like a rock and that it can be invoked at any particular time by the most humble citizen.

Taking that into account, I do not think that any fault can be found with that position, but when we come to consider a Bill or indeed any kind of legislation dealing with rearrangements of constituencies, we have to take into consideration the practical possibilities of that rearrangement, and we contend now that we set out to be as lenient as possible to the rural areas. We made no bones about that both here and elsewhere and I do not think that the Fine Gael Party did, either. At least if they did, the members of the Fine Gael Party did not reveal their intentions until very late in the day.

We asserted all along that so far as the Fianna Fáil Party were concerned, in supporting the Government, we did not like the idea of breaching county bounds, and the Minister made that clear time and again. He also made clear the point about the impracticability of doing so, the hardship involved on the rural population, and indeed he stressed on Second Reading and the various Stages of the Bill and elsewhere that he did not like the idea and that it was in conflict more or less with his opinion as a practical politician. That could be deemed to be the attitude of some of the Fine Gael Party also, but, as one could rightly say, Fine Gael decided later on, when they saw maybe some advantage, to divide on the matter. Ancient Gaul divided into three parts and Fine Gael divided into two parts.

Arising then from that, we have this Bill. I think that in our circumstances no great blame can be attached to the Minister or to the Government for having due regard to that phrase "so far as is practicable." We all know what the relevant Articles of the Constitution provide, but it is not always easy to relate that mathematically and accurately to the practicalities of politics. I think I am right in saying that those who decided the issue had no regard whatever to the ideas of practical politicians and it was considered mainly in the light of conflict with the relevant Article of the Constitution. Nevertheless, I believe that practical politicans have a place in a democracy. This is a free country and we can have our point of view, too. The people, as was said earlier on, effected and gave force to the Constitution. I wind up that point by saying that, in my opinion and in the opinion of any fairminded person, no great blame can be attached to the Government for taking into consideration the difficulties involved for practical politicans.

I will refer to certain leading lights in the Opposition, and I quote from one, an ex-Minister for Local Government. Deputy O'Donnell said at column 405 of volume 177 of the Official Report:

It is most difficult to arrange such a revision of constituencies without a charge of political corruption or gerrymandering.

Apparently Deputy O'Donnell was fully aware of what was involved. Apparently Senator Donegan is not. Simply because a rearrangement had to be effected as between Louth and Monaghan, the Senator denounces the rearrangement in very strong language. I think the Senator would find many members of his own Party who would disagree with the views he expressed here this evening.

Comment on this

For instance?

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy O'Donnell would, an ex-Minister for Local Government, or any experienced Deputy. Deputy O'Donnell's statement, which I have quoted, is completely opposed to what Senator Donegan said here this evening.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell does not know the area.

Comment on this

I think he does. He had every opportunity of knowing it just as well as the Senator.

Comment on this

He lives a couple of hundred miles away from it. That is the disadvantage.

Comment on this

Most people would agree with the sentiment expressed by Deputy O'Donnell. The Minister was blamed for not seeking a decision on the 1959 Act at a higher level. There, again, the Constitution enters into the picture. The Act could be referred by any citizen or by the President on the advice of the Council of State. Remembering that only parts of the 1959 Act were found wanting, I think the Minister took the proper course in bringing in the new Bill. Considering this measure from the point of view of the work involved in our constituencies and from the point of view of the shift in population——

Comment on this

200,000 gone to England.

Comment on this

——it is obvious that we shall find it even more difficult in future to ensure that we are within the law in dealing with the practical problem of shifting populations. We are hopeful, however, that with the resurgence which has taken place under Fianna Fáil, we shall be able to correct that tendency, roll the stone back up the hill, and repopulate some of the rural areas in order to avoid coming into conflict with the law.

Comment on this

Hope springs eternal. It is deeds people want, not hopes.

Comment on this

If one wanted to argue merely for the sake of argument, then one could legitimately say that some constituencies have been in conflict with the Constitution for quite a long time. As practical politicians, that would, of course, be no help to us because it is our duty as public men to ensure that the meanest citizen can secure representation. It falls to our lot, therefore, to defend the action of the Minister in bringing this Bill before the Oireachtas in order to provide proper representation for all.

Comment on this

The pronouncements from the Opposition benches to-day bore the same conflicting appearance as did the pronouncements from the Opposition benches in the other House when the measure was being discussed there, but it was not, perhaps, quite so noticeable here to-day as it was in the other House. It almost seems as if those who do not quite agree with what is now being done have stayed away. There are, too, those who possibly feel aggrieved because what was done in the 1959 Act has now been undone. They also have stayed away.

Those who might be regarded as diehard supporters of change merely for the sake of change have not been consistent in their approach. We have the Leader of the Opposition here condemning this measure because it has something in common with other measures of a somewhat similar character brought before this House, in that, he alleges, it is brought in at the last moment. I cannot understand why Fine Gael should have any real objection to any delay. I honestly think that Fine Gael have been very anxious that there should be every possible delay so that a general election may not be held while they are in such a poor state of political health.

Comment on this

It would be welcome at any time.

Comment on this

It may be welcome to those who were unsuccessful candidates at the last general election and who hope they may put it across some of their colleagues at the next general election. A fair interpretation of the mentality of the Fine Gael Party is, I think, that they want to avoid having a general election just yet because they hope something will happen which will interfere with the growing popularity of the Fianna Fáil Government and Party at the moment.

Senator Hayes said—and this was repeated parrot-like by subsequent speakers—that it was quite practicable to frame a Bill within the Constitution. He was referring to the Act of 1959 which was declared unconstitutional by the courts. It is amazing the number of people who can come along at this stage and say: "We told you so." Looking at the records of the Dáil and Seanad, one cannot find so clear a statement. We had a statement here in this House from Senator O'Donovan at column 1032 of volume 51 which makes rather strange reading now:

I examined the figures given following replies to Parliamentary Questions. My conclusion was that in the 1937 Bill or Act and in the 1947 Bill or Act—those were the years, as far as I recollect, when there was a ten-year interval compared with the full twelve years now—taking the areas round the country, a fair effort was made, on the whole, to allocate the seats by population.

It is very strange that Senator O'Donovan should have made that statement as recently as late 1959 and should have regarded the figures then showing as a result of the 1947 and the 1937 Acts, as he says here, as a fair effort to allocate the seats by population. The maximum differential under that Act of 1947 was 6,280 odd; the maximum under the disputed 1959 Act was 6,500 odd. How Senator O'Donovan could see that at that time in that light, I really cannot understand when within a short few months afterwards, he found such fault with it as to change his mind entirely and take the action he took. I am not criticising the action but I am pointing out that, in 1959, 6,280 was a fair enough differential and a fair effort when talking about the 1947 Act, but 6,500 under the 1959 Act was so appalling that some action had to be taken.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question? According to the 1958Statistical Abstract, the population per member in Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown—this is the population of each constituency in respect of election to Dáil Éireann—was 45,153. The population in—I had better take the lowest one—Dublin North Central— was 14,120. That seems an extraordinary differential.

Comment on this

The Senator is confusing the matter to this extent, that the figures he has just quoted are based on the 1956 Census, whereas the figures in relation to the Act of 1947 were based on the preceding Census.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister is referring to 1947. The figures are 45,000 as against 14,000, a differential of 31,000.

Comment on this

The Senator is completely misunderstanding what I am saying. Under the 1959 measure as enacted by the Oireachtas, the maximum differential emerging was 6,500 odd. The maximum differential obtaining from 1947 to date under that Act was 6,200 odd.

Comment on this

Is the Minister referring to the average differential or the maximum?

Comment on this

The maximum differential as between the highest and the lowest in both cases, the overall variation—6,280 as against 6,500. That is a very small differential. I noticed this only today but it puzzles me how Senator O'Donovan should have expressed that view on the 1959 Bill and then taken the other view later on. However, he has not claimed here as volubly as others have claimed: "I told you so." He did not say he told us this or that, or how right he was. He has not made half as much noise as those who did not take much action but stood around and, if they felt it suited them, hopped on the bandwagon and are now taking credit. If they go down the country where such a stand is not so popular, they are likely to hop off that bandwagon and disclaim all responsibility or kinship with the people who can take the credit. The claims being made here as to how right they were are being made by far more people than those who gave us warnings. Those claims are far more numerous now than were the warnings in 1959.

When the 1959 Act was going through the Dáil, it was accepted in a general way. It was a measure which, no matter what now may be said about it, secured as nearly unanimous acceptance as it would be possible to get for any such measure because unanimity on a matter such as this is beyond us. It is something which cannot possibly be expected in a democratic community and a democratic Parliament such as ours, with various Parties and political affiliations. What suits one group may be said not to suit another, but, as nearly as possible, we had agreement in regard to that Act. The Leader of the Opposition, to my recollection, accepted the Bill of 1959 and was quite happy that it was doing a reasonably good job. There were other members of the Opposition at that time who also accepted it and even went further and praised it, which on such a measure was extraordinary, to say the least of it.

There are some Senators who have not spoken in this debate and who are conspicuous by their absence, those of the Opposition Parties who felt that the measure we put through here was a reasonably good measure. There are those who now speak in general condemnation of it, who say that it is gerrymandering, that it is dirty, political gerrymandering. Cases have been quoted. One of the cases is Senator Donegan's home county of Louth. He has made the strange assertion that it was not really necessary to take away part of Louth at all.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

That is what I was about to say.

Comment on this

I said it was not necessary to take away the town of Ardee. A small slice of the country area of Louth and a small slice of the country area of Meath could have been taken.

Comment on this

I can deal only with what the Senator said.

Comment on this

I am telling the Minister what I said.

Comment on this

I was listening to what the Senator said very carefully and the Senator, in my hearing in this House, said there was no need to move 8,000 or 9,000 of the population.

Comment on this

Correct—only about 2,000 or 3,000.

Comment on this

He said it was not necessary to move that population into Monaghan. Let us see what the situation is. In the county constituency of Louth, as we have known it, there are 69,194 of a population. The Senator also said he read the High Court judgment. Whether he has read it or not, he talked as if he did and, having given that impression, I take it he can apply in some measure what was contained therein and sort out for me how 69,194 could be reconciled with the national average per seat ratio of 20,127, unless we were to have half-Deputies. We have them, metaphorically speaking, all right but actually we would have to have half-Deputies in order to go near accommodating County Louth.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

On the other hand, adjoining County Louth, we have County Monaghan. In that county constituency, there is from the last census a population of 52,064.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

They obviously need somewhere around 8,000. Obviously, again, Louth have somewhere around 8,000 too much. Does anybody suggest that, having read or even heard what was said in the High Court judgment, Louth could be left alone and that Monaghan, if it were to be brought up, could get that additional population from somewhere else?

Comment on this

Meath—7,000 extra.

Comment on this

This has also been said in the Dáil. It is quite all right to burst the boundary of some county which is not your own and with which you have no concern. Let us break into Meath and take part of Meath in order to give County Monaghan its ratio for a third seat.

Comment on this

Not the town of Ardee.

Comment on this

The Senator knows Louth like the back of his hand.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

There are few representatives in this or the other House, apart from Deputies from that constituency, who know that Louth-Monaghan boundary better than I do. I have been crossing that boundary through Ardee, Drogheda and Dundalk for the past 14 years at least a couple of times a week.

Comment on this

On main roads.

Comment on this

I have been up there on political business, as the Senator may recall. Here is a fair suggestion to him. The boundary where these two counties join is not very long. Over all, the county of Louth is not very big or wide. From east to west is quite narrow by ordinary standards. It is on the western side of the county that the boundary between it and Monaghan lies. Therefore, if we are to take any number of thousands of population from Louth into Monaghan, it must perforce come from that boundary, where the two meet. That being so, we cannot, in fairness to Louth, take a narrow front on that small boundary that adjoins the two and cut right across to the sea or go right across Louth to such a degree that it is almost splintered in two. We have taken it down the length of the boundary between the two counties and, in so doing, Ardee has gone with the rest.

If the Senator looks into the matter and looks into the position of the populations of the various divisions, townlands, and so on, that it would be possible to bring in from Louth to Monaghan, he will find it is practically an impossibility to get the figures that are there to be given by Louth and that must be got by Monaghan. It will be a practical impossibility for the Senator to bring them out of Louth, except in the sensible way of bringing them out where the two counties adjoin, without practically going to the sea or isolating some part of it——

Comment on this

Leave Ardee as it is.

Comment on this

What about the other counties? This isolated, purely parochial, political viewpoint which the Senator is now displaying, to an even greater degree than when he was talking, mystifies me. He does not seem to realise that, if I had done as he suggests, repercussions in other counties and county constituencies would then occur for which there would be no answer whatever and that the disparities which exist at the moment would have been greater if Senator Donegan had had this job to do and did it according to what he now says. If he had, he likely would have found it would be very little different from what is before the House. He can talk about it because he knows he is not in the position and that it is a fair proposition that he will never be called upon to do a job such as this.

Therefore, the sky is the limit so far as condemnation of the present measure is concerned and the sky is the limit in regard to what can be done and what could be done and the sky is the limit in regard to the allegations being made as to why certain things that are now being done have in fact come about, one of them being that, by this dirty political gerrymandered trick he alleges has taken place, we are taking out of Louth a very strong Fine Gael stronghold wherein they could have made up two seats——

Comment on this

Will.

Comment on this

——and are putting it into Monaghan, where, added to the sum total of Fine Gael support in that county at the moment, it cannot make any difference except to increase the vote of one man.

Did it ever occur to Senator Donegan that, with his successful colleague in the last election announcing withdrawal from the political scene, Senator Donegan's chances personally may be enhanced if somebody else does not come along and swipe the ground from under his feet? However, regardless of whether or not he gets to the Dáil the next time, it is quite obvious that, with his colleague departing the scene, the chance of Fine Gael getting a second seat in Louth is sheer imagination on the part of Senator Donegan.

Comment on this

We will get our second seat and with an excellent candidate and let the Minister not try to damn his chances. That is what he is up to. He is a Minister of State now.

Comment on this

Wishful thinking on the part of Senator Donegan. He knows full well——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Will the Minister be permitted to conclude his speech?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think he is.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I ask the Chair to deal with Senator Donegan.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

As far as Senator Donegan is concerned, he may have the chance now with his runner maybe an unknown and possibly a handpicked weakling of the Fine Gael Party. Therefore, he may make the Dáil the next time. Whether or not he does, it is quite obvious that Fine Gael have not a hope——

Comment on this

We will get our two seats.

Comment on this

All the groaning and wailing to the people of the area in and around Ardee will not make any conversions to Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Not at all. They will not be voting for me. The people I am talking about will not be voting for me.

Comment on this

Still, Senator Donegan and his Party are losing nothing because they have no hope of a second seat.

Comment on this

Every hope.

Comment on this

We are being more than charitable in sending in, as it now appears, a fairly substantial Fine Gael vote that will undoubtedly help to retain, if luck runs with him, the Leader of the Opposition as a member of the Dáil.

Comment on this

He is quite safe at any time.

Comment on this

Quite safe.

Comment on this

We would not like to see Fine Gael completely rudderless. They are now without a head, but, without a rudder, they would be sunk altogether and we are trying to maintain some semblance——

Comment on this

They beat you in Sligo-Leitrim.

Comment on this

That dog will wag his tail another day. Senator L'Estrange will have a hard fight to try to pull something off on another occasion.

Comment on this

In other words, the Minister has fixed it. That is the answer.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I really must protest against this organised barrage of interruptions. If these Blueshirt tactics do not stop, we shall have to take adequate reciprocal action.

Comment on this

Get the Broy Harriers out again.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think they have had a fair innings now. The Minister to continue.

Comment on this

In so far as this completely illogical argument made by Senator Donegan is concerned——

Comment on this

Enough of your threats.

Comment on this

——he either does not know what he is talking about or he is talking with his tongue in his cheek. The Senator said there was no need to take 8,000 or 9,000 out of Louth.

Comment on this

You could have taken 2,000 to 3,000 in the country area.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

Before I started to attend this House and during my first few visits to it, I had the belief—I also thought it was the tradition in this House many years ago, when I was not in any House or in politics—that it was really a top-class assembly, but since the last election and looking at a few members only—and I say "a few" deliberately—it has certainly changed its character and I do not think the change is for the better. It does not matter to me if there were ten more like the terrible twins—it will not prevent me from saying what I have to say and replying to the statements made, some of which were unwittingly stupid, others just plain stupid and others made in a naïve sort of way to try to confuse still further a situation that has already been fairly well confused by their colleagues of like character in the Dáil. The High Court ruling is such—the Senator can check this with some of his colleagues who, I am quite sure, will agree—that a reduction of the population of Louth by 2,000 or 3,000 bringing it to 66,000 or 67,000 would not meet the dictates of the High Court in their interpretation of the Constitution.

Comment on this

It would.

Comment on this

Then the High Court interpretation is wrong and Senator O'Donovan has had all his trouble for nothing.

Comment on this

In order to obey the High Court decision, it was not necessary to work to a small deviation from the national average of 1,000. That was made quite clear. The only reference to 1,000 in the whole case was the reference made to the fact that on the first occasion it was possible to work within 1,000, so that if Louth and Meath gave a few thousand tomorrow, with Louth adding a few thousand more, there would have been absolutely no contravention of the ruling of the High Court.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

No speeches.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think that should be the last intervention by Senator Donegan in this discussion.

Comment on this

Senator Donegan is entirely, completely and absolutely wrong and I give him the credit of having sufficient intelligence to know it when he talks of interpretations by the Hight Court judge on the constitutional requirements in regard to this measure. It is necessary and essential to take more than 2,000 or 3,000 out of Louth. Taking 2,000 or 3,000 out of Louth would leave Louth with an average of 22,000 per seat, which would increase the national differential by a considerable number, a number which could not be justified. If it is possible to take those 2,000 or 3,000 out of Louth, it is possible to take the 8,000 or 9,000 out of Louth which has been done, taking up the balance which is necessary to leave three seats with Monaghan. In County Meath, we find they have around 6,000 of a population more in the aggregate than their three-seat ratio would give. We find in Westmeath-Longford that four seats leave us with a balance of 6,000 or 7,000. If we look at the constituency of Kildare, you will find that in the two adjoining counties of Kildare and Westmeath——

Comment on this

Kildare does not adjoin it. It does not touch Westmeath. Would the Minister look at the map?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator going to keep quiet?

Comment on this

It adjoins it now.

Comment on this

No; it is amalgamated with it.

Comment on this

What is the difference? There was a surplus in Meath which we could not tolerate. In Westmeath-Longford, likewise we could not tolerate the surplus. We could not tolerate the surplus or the deficit existing in Kildare, depending on whether it had three or four seats. We found that by adding the two surpluses in question to the existing figures in the existing constituency of Kildare, we came within striking distance of the national average and brought the other two constituencies into line. That surely is not an illogical thing to have done. We are required to try to bring about near equality of the ratio and in that instance that is the manner in which it came about and the way in which it was finally settled.

Senator Burke talked quite strongly about the situation in Waterford and Tipperary. Senator Burke apparently does not want Waterford. For some reason or another, he dislikes Waterford joining the constituency of South Tipperary. He made no bones about it. While I may not disagree with his holding his views, his likes and dislikes, at the same time, I disagree with him when he speaks about what might have been done instead. He said we could have left Waterford intact. We could, but then we would have another trip to the courts. Under the interpretation, we could not leave Waterford intact because Waterford county constituency contains, according to the census then available to us, some 74,000 of a population and for four seats, that was too low. In that situation, the idea of leaving Waterford intact goes up in smoke. I could not leave Waterford intact. It had to be interfered with. While Senator Burke complains that part of Waterford should not have been brought into Tipperary, he also implies that since it is impossible to leave Waterford intact by not taking part of it into Tipperary, he wants part of South Tipperary to go to Waterford.

He must have it one way or another; you cannot have it both ways. That is what the Senator seems to think he can have. I should like to have had it that way also. Taking it all round, if we could have looked at things that way, everybody would be more happy. The facts were there. We have to try to conform to the requirements as outlined by the courts. This we have tried to do in accepting the view of the courts. In so doing, I do not see why we should be blamed if these breaches of boundaries occur, as they must occur. There is no use in saying here or anywhere else that this did not have to be done and that the position could have been left as it was. These changes which were brought about by this interpretation were necessary. If people have a grievance in any part of the country, there is no reason why I should get the blame for it. There is no reason why the Government should be blamed for it.

In saying that, I do not want to be taken up wrongly as, apparently, I have been. I have not blamed anyone else. I am merely stating the facts. The constitutional requirement is there. The interpretation has been given by the High Court. We accepted that and have been working accordingly. As a result of that, certain county boundaries had to be breached and this has given rise to grievances. These grievances are being pushed by various people for their own ends. The blame for these grievances cannot, however, be placed upon me or the Government. I am again making that categorical statement, which I also made in the other House.

Senator O'Sullivan made a strong protest against the manner in which the boundaries of the constituencies in Cork were drawn. He protested that the city constituency boundary was being breached and that part of that constituency was being put into the county constituency. He also seems to be labouring under a misapprehension when he says that, since the total number of seats in the whole of Cork city and county are the same as in the past, there is no need for a change. This is entirely wrong. The population within the borough constituency of Cork had increased to around 112,000. That was beyond the ratio permitted, according to the interpretation of the Constitution. Therefore, we had to reduce the population figure in the city constituency and transfer part of it to the rural constituencies. That is why, although we have the same number of Deputies for the whole of Cork city and county in this measure as we had in the 1947 measure, we have had to alter the boundaries and do what Senator O'Sullivan objects to.

Naturally, it would have been much easier for all concerned if we could have left these boundaries untouched, but the fact remains that we had to do it. If people feel aggrieved about it, they should seek out where the blame lies, if there be any blame, but they should not blame me for it. Senators, as well as Deputies, are well aware of my views on this matter but these views must be subordinated to the requirements of the Constitution as recently interpreted. Members surely realise that I, as Minister for Local Government, would not create these grievances if they were not a necessary part of the scheme I had to introduce in deference to the requirements of the Constitution.

Senator O'Quigley spoke eloquently, but not very sensibly, on the Bill. He talked in a vague but somewhat disturbing fashion about the occupant of the Presidential Office. He talked about the oath the President took on assuming office to uphold the Constitution. He blandly tried to tell us that in some way the upholder of the Constitution was the humble, private citizen, his colleague, Senator O'Donovan. He was followed by Senator Donegan. While neither seemed to say what was in his mind, I had a queer feeling that their introduction into the debate of the occupant of the Presidential office was in very poor taste. This only follows up the innuendoes made in the other House by a gentleman, if the term may be applied to him, who kicked off there. What he said is being repeated here, parrot-like, by the two worthy Senators.

Comment on this

It is nothing to what Fianna Fáil said about some of the founders of the State in the past.

Comment on this

From those lips I take it as praise indeed.

Comment on this

I am sorry Senator O'Quigley is not present, but I have no doubt we will have the pleasure of his participation in the later Stages of the Bill. He said that the Constitutions of 1937 and 1922 were one and the same as far as the equality of ratios is concerned. Did he ever stop to think, if that is so, why the words were changed in the 1937 Constitution and are not the identical words used in the 1922 Constitution? Perhaps some members of the House will check the wording of the two sections dealing with this matter and ask themselves why the words were changed? Was it for the fun of it? Was it to amuse somebody? Was it to entertain or confuse? In any event, the fact remains that they are not the same. I shall leave that to Senator O'Quigley for a discussion at a later stage.

The Senator got a new slant on this idea of political gerrymandering. He says it is a trumped-up excuse to defeat certain sitting Deputies. In his own queer sort of illogical way, he went on to tell us how somebody could be weak and, if a little bit of their area were taken out, he would fall to the ground, while somebody else would be bolstered up. It shows the sort of mind the Senator has that he seems to see so clearly all the manipulations possible, but to apply those manipulations within the framework of this measure would be beyond his capacity or the capacity of anybody else.

The breaching of county boundaries is regarded by Senator O'Quigley as a softening-up process so that we can bring about confusion in the minds of the people to enable us more readily to change the Constitution. Again, it is a fair example of the way his mind works, if I can say it is a mind and that it is working.

Comment on this

Is it in order, Sir, for the Minister to refer in this manner to Senator O'Quigley's mind and how it is working?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

You are becoming very thin-skinned.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think the Minister meant it maliciously.

Comment on this

Facetiously.

Comment on this

Thank you very much.

Comment on this

I take it that the reason according to Senator O'Quigley, that we took this softening-up process he talks about, was to bring about a change of mind in the people so that the Constitution might be changed. That, certainly, is a new angle and we shall give him credit for that in his absence but you do not bring about a change of mind or get the public to change something, as any politician will surely have found out by now, by confusing them. You merely confirm them in their beliefs. Fine Gael learned that lesson a long time ago and have used that tactic when it suited them. Now they want to allege that, to attain certain ends and desires, the Fianna Fáil party are trying to confuse the electorate and bring about a change of mind to get changes made that otherwise the people would not allow to be made, suggesting that the minds of the people are such that we can mould them as we desire, confuse and bamboozle them to such an extent that they will not know what they are doing.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil succeeded very well.

Comment on this

If Fine Gael fall for that point of view it is little wonder that they have treated the people as they have done. That they should attribute the same motives and methods to Fianna Fáil is not our fault but it is not a very good effort from them now.

Somebody should "tell off" Senator O'Quigley about it and warn him that it is better to let sleeping dogs lie, that possibly what he says will react on themselves as many of these things do, and there is little in the way of political trickery that they have not taken part in down the years.

Comment on this

There is nothing they can learn in the North from you about gerrymandering.

Comment on this

I should think that gerrymandering would be much more applicable to the way the Senator talks when he is on his feet. That he is still meandering there is no doubt because he has not said all he intended to say and it is only when points are brought to his mind by somebody else that his recollection is sparked off and he jumps up with some new suggestion.

Let us take the suggestion about gerrymandering. The House has heard Senator Mullins quote members of the hierarchy of Fine Gael, the Leader of the Party, the ex-Minister for Local Government and also the present leader of the Labour Party who, while making these charges of gerrymandering in regard to this measure, hastened to contradict themselves by indicating in varying terms that gerrymandering could not be done in this part of the country because the circumstances in which it could be operated do not exist. Better than that, come statements from Senator O'Quigley. He says we have been and are gerrymandering in this measure. He waxes eloquent in trying to show how wrong the 1959 Act was and how base were the motives for what we are doing in the 1961 Bill and he says it would certainly mean the loss of four seats to Fianna Fáil on the western sea-board. Has anybody in his sane senses ever heard of gerrymandering bringing about a loss to the Party employing it? I shall make a present to the Opposition of the remainder of the argument. They can go home, work it out and tell us about it on the Committee Stage.

Another suggestion that could come only from Senator O'Quigley, when worked out, leads to a strange situation. He says we should have amended the 1959 Act rather than repeal it. He says we wanted to wipe it out so that it will never be known that it existed. He says we should amend it and that only the parts of it that were declared unconstitutional should be removed but he did not tell the whole story. The amending Bill would have to amend Section 6, replace Section 7, extend Sections 8 and 9 and add Section 31. Subsection 4 and the Schedule have been declared unconstitutional. What would we have then? We should have merely Section 1 which was the definition Section and Section 2 which states the number of members, 144. That is the sensible contribution on which Senator O'Quigley spent so much time this evening.

If we had done what he suggests we would be left with the number, in words or in figures, 144. That would not have made a lot of sense but it would be almost as sensible as his final remark when he said there should be made available to the members of the House the population figures for the townlands in order that sensible amendments might be framed for the Committee or other Stages of the Bill. There are 51,000 townlands in the country and I do not think, outside the imagination of the Senator, that very many others in the House would want to have thrust upon them the figures that would be involved in meeting that request.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

He meant that where Senators wanted to put down an amendment the figures for particular townlands in limited areas would be made available to them.

Comment on this

That was not what I understood.

Comment on this

We are not responsible for the Minister's understanding.

Comment on this

I can scarcely be responsible for Senator O'Quigley's imagination or ignorance of how many townlands there are or what he really wanted.

The general pattern of the discussion has been anything but conclusive. It was as inconclusive as it was in the Dáil or as it was in 1959. A week or so ago there was the effort of the Opposition Parties to get on the bandwagon. The trouble is they do not know which bandwagon was going in the right direction. They do not know whether to claim credit for the new measure brought before the Oireachtas or to discredit those responsible for bringing the matter before the courts. They want it both ways. They want to have a one-horse race and back him each way. That may be very desirable but it is scarcely possible to get any bookmaker who is "mug" enough to lay the odds.

The laymen of Fine Gael do not know where they are going or whether to claim credit for this measure. It is not a popular measure, as I am in a position to know better, perhaps, than anyone else. I would advise Fine Gael not to back that horse if they want to gain votes. They had better try to blame somebody and that seems to be the line they were adopting this evening. They must make up their minds either to place the blame on somebody or take credit for the measure. They cannot have it both ways. They cannot cod all the people all the time. That is what they have been trying to do in regard to this measure throughout the various proceedings that have taken place in the past 12 months.

The suggestion has also been made —just to show how when a stupid statement is made by somebody and followed up and repeated and repeated, people finally begin to believe it—that my constituency of Donegal was divided in order to suit me and to get rid of Deputy Sheldon. When the 1959 Bill was before the House, the charge was made that there was no change being made in Donegal at all, both constituencies being left with the same number of seats, East Donegal retaining its four seats. The charge then made by Deputy O'Donnell, a county man of my own and ex-Minister for Local Government—and a man who, I believe, should know what he is talking about politically, even about East Donegal, but who apparently does not —was that Deputy Sheldon's seat was being maintained for him by Fianna Fáil as a payoff for the support he gave to Fianna Fáil on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and other measures during their term in government.

A few weeks ago, on this measure, another Front Bench Fine Gael Deputy got up and made the charge that we are now reducing East Donegal to three, that we are ditching Deputy Sheldon, that that is the designed purpose of the change of boundary which is designed to suit the Minister for Local Government. That has been repeated here and if it is repeated often enough it is likely that some people will come to believe it. I just want those who might in some way have regard to that statement, to look at the charge made by Deputy O'Donnell in relation to the matter in 1959 and to read the charge made by Deputy Sweetman and repeated by a Senator of the Fine Gael persuasion here this evening. Having read both of those, and realising the close ties that must exist among the members of the august Fine Gael Party, they will surely come to the conclusion that somebody at some stage was not being very truthful and that if they are untruthful, unscrupulously on this, they are as likely to have been untruthful on other aspects of this measure and to measure their statements on this matter in the light of that conflict of expression.

Comment on this

You have not got East and West Donegal now; you have North-East and South-West, going across the mountains. The Minister told us last year that they could not be crossed.

Comment on this

Another matter which I should like to bring to the attention of this House is that time and again it has been said that I stated that the 1959 Act had a rural bias. I want to correct that. I have never said it had a rural bias. I said it appeared to have a rural bias, or it may appear to have a rural bias. I have never categorically stated that it had and I have corrected that on several occasions in other places and I am correcting it again now for the record. There is something else which I want to correct and which I have already corrected, but which I might as well not have corrected because it has been repeated by the same person. There was an interjection by Senator O'Quigley this evening when Senator Lenihan was speaking, and he said that during the debate on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Act, I had said that if it got through, Fine Gael would have had it.

Comment on this

The Minister said it.

Comment on this

I want to tell the Senator that he is telling an untruth and I have challenged this matter——

Comment on this

The papers published it.

Comment on this

I have got the matter corrected in the Official Report and I want it recorded that I have shoved it down the throat of the Senator who has used it. At the time the notetaker's notes were impounded and inspected and I want it withdrawn and I want it put on the record of this House——

Comment on this

The papers published it.

Comment on this

I do not give a damn what the papers published. I am not coming in here to be told twice on a matter that has been corrected here and in the Dáil, and I am not——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order! The matter is entirely dead.

Comment on this

The matter is not——

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

The matter is not dead.

Comment on this

The charge has been made here this evening and I am challenging this House to see that this type of thing does not happen again, particularly when I have corrected the same Senator before and challenged this matter in the Dáil and I am not going to be blackguarded again.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Order!

Comment on this

Of course Senator L'Estrange in his meanderings around the country and in his charges of gerrymandering, made comparisons and said it was as bad as the Quisling something-or-other of Northern Ireland. That is scarcely understood by the Senator who made the charge. I am sure if he did understand it, he would be a little less hasty in making such a charge. He will realise that this type of charge, no matter how groundless it may be, when made here will undoubtedly earn him some notoriety and will undoubtedly be used by those people whom he has mentioned, as a defence for themselves in the future. Possibly that is the purpose behind the Senator's charge when he talks about Ballaghaderreen being sent into Mayo to suit Deputy Flanagan, and North Mayo being fixed to suit the Minister for Lands, and Louth being fixed in order that the Minister for External Affairs should be all right.

Surely Senator L'Estrange, even at this stage, would have the common decency to think of what he is saying and of how baseless and groundless those charges are, to consider the facts and figures and to realise that these changes are made because they had to be made. If they are not acceptable to everyone, they are certainly not of my making or design. They are there as changes which we must make. I should like to say this and I say it most emphatically. There are all sorts of veiled suggestions, all sorts of charges both here and in the Dáil, that all the various boundaries were drawn and penned by the various Fianna Fáil Deputies——

Comment on this

So they were.

Comment on this

——who had special meetings in the Custom House and burned the midnight oil. I want to tell this House that there were no grand meetings held and no midnight oil burned. What is more, if I were to publish the list of representations I received, there would be some very red faces on the Opposition benches, so far as boundaries are concerned—representations made without their Party's knowledge. I shall not publish them because of the fact that any Deputy or Senator for that matter, who wanted to bring to my attention any particular item, any particular fact in regard to local knowledge that I could not possibly have, was quite welcome to give me that information in order that I might be enabled better to do the job I was charged with in bringing in a Bill that would make commonsense where boundaries or new divisions had to be made.

With regard to the boundaries and new divisions which had to be made, let there be no mistake about it, there would be many red faces if we were to publish the representations, and the personal representations, that were made. There was no hiding behind the bush about it. Certain changes were suggested to me about the manner in which the lines could be drawn—there was no tongue or tooth put in it—for the benefit of certain members of Fine Gael. Let us have no more of this talk that this matter was born out of some unique sort of clandestine meetings which had some sinister purpose behind them to suit Fianna Fáil, and that everything could be so arranged that even though we were rejected by the people, we would still be the Government.

The people will have the Government they want under this Bill, just as they had the Government they wanted under other Bills over the years. If it is a Fianna Fáil Government the next time, as I have no doubt it will be, Fine Gael should not try to belittle that success or imply that Fianna Fáil had not that success by saying it was brought about or engineered in any manner. The next election will presumably be fought on this Bill, if it becomes an Act, and when the Government are formed, from whatever Party, they will have been duly and properly elected, and will represent the wishes of the people throughout the entire country. That Government, as I say, will more likely be Fianna Fáil than Fine Gael. One would not need to be a prophet——

Comment on this

What about Sligo-Leitrim ?

Comment on this

——or a gambler to lay fair odds that it will not be a Fine Gael Government who will take office after the next election.

Comment on this

Do not be too sure.

Comment on this

Fine Gael should not try to undermine or belittle in advance the work that was done. It may be that the mud they sling now, or later, by allegations of a gerrymandering electoral scheme brought in by the Fianna Fáil Government, will be to the detriment of the country. Seemingly, it is the avowed purpose of Fine Gael, if they cannot achieve Government office themselves, to make it impossible or as difficult as possible for whoever gets there, regardless of the consequences to the national wellbeing.

There are just one or two other matters that have been mentioned here to which I am called upon to give some reply, if for no other reason than to give certain members of the House some better knowledge of some of these matters for the next Stage of the Bill. Senator L'Estrange seems to be under the impression—which I should correct for him—that the Minister for Local Government was responsible for the 1959 Act. That Act was the responsibility of the Oireachtas and that should be clearly——

Comment on this

I said the Minister and the Government.

Comment on this

He said "the Minister" and now that is amended to "the Minister and the Government". I am merely putting on record that the 1959 Act was enacted by the Oireachtas, not by the Government, or the Minister for Local Government. It might also be better to put on record that the reference by Senator L'Estrange to 1937 and the Economic War does not seem to me to ring true either.

Comment on this

If the Minister reads the full statement, it will ring quite true.

Comment on this

We will not have to impound the statement, either.

Comment on this

No, because there will not be any false charges made here by unscrupulous people as have been made on the other side of the House here and in the other House.

Comment on this

That is a false statement. Fianna Fáil Deputies and Senators were in the Custom House with the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is Senator L'Estrange to be allowed to make that statement again?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Senator will allow me. Senator L'Estrange has been interrupting a great deal tonight. I think he should cease now and allow the Minister to complete his statement.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think Sir, if I might suggest it, that you should go further than that. Senator L'Estrange has accused the Minister of a falsehood. I think he should be made to withdraw that accusation.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think the Senator should accept the Minister's statement that there was no burning of the midnight oil in the Custom House.

Comment on this

I cannot accept that statement. Fianna Fáil Deputies and Senators knew the proposed changes in Westmeath a fortnight before the Bill came out.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator must accept the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

I cannot, when I know that Fianna Fáil Deputies and Senators knew exactly the changes to be made before the Bill came out.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I cannot hear the Senator on this matter because the Senator must accept the Minister's word about it. The Minister has said there were no Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party with him burning the midnight oil.

Comment on this

They were there. Where did they get the information?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

Is the Senator to be allowed to get away with that again?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

He must accept the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

I cannot accept it. Fine Gael Deputies and Senators knew the changes to be made.

Comment on this

What does that prove?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

Fine Gael Deputies and Senators knew from Fianna Fáil Deputies and Senators.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator may not make continuous statements about this matter. He must accept the Minister's word that Fianna Fáil Deputies were not closeted with him at midnight.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Professor Hayes Fine Gael

There is no other way to work the system we are trying to work. If the Minister makes an explicit statement on his own word about his personal conduct, that should be accepted. If he says it did not happen, there is no other way of dealing with it except to say: "I accept that". I am sorry, but there is no other method.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it the Senator is accepting the Minister's word?

Comment on this

I am sorry but I cannot.

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I think that without any further discussion he should be asked to leave the House. He will not now accept a ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator will have to withdraw from the House.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Deputies and Senators had that information and someone must have told them. I will withdraw because I believe it to be true.

Comment on this

The Senator is looking for the headlines. He thinks he is at a meeting of the Westmeath County Council.

Senator L'Estrange withdrew.

Comment on this

Having disposed of that little episode, I think the last interjection by the Senator before he left the House is one to which the answer is, as I have already said, that there would be red faces in the Fine Gael Party if all the representations were to be published. He says he cannot accept my word and has left the House rather than accept it. He says he cannot accept it because Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Deputies and Senators knew what was to be in the Bill two or three days before it appeared and someone must have told them. If we take that with what I have said about red faces, of course someone told them.

However, I think it only fair to say in regard to the measure before the House and which we hope will, in fact, without much more delay or ado, become the law so that an election may take place within the specified period not exceeding five years from the election of the previous Government, with all the various grievances— and grievances there must be in this type of matter—taking it all in all, and taking everything into account, the grievances are not greater in number than one would expect in the circumstances. I do not think they are any greater than they would be, regardless of who might have been charged with drawing up the Bill.

It is easy to stand up here and say this could have been done, that could have been done, or the other could have been done, with any particular constituency. Listening to the speakers here, one would think there were innumerable permutations and combinations and that there were hundreds and thousands of choices, so far as constituency boundaries are concerned. The fact of the matter is that, when one gets down to the problem, there are really very few combinations and permutations from which to make a choice. In all sincerity, I say that the combination of constituencies we now have, and their boundaries, available within the framework of our Constitution, is the best combination that we, or anyone else, could get. I do not think anyone else would do any better. Even if someone else did come up with something that appeared to be better, he, too, would find himself faced with innumerable grievances.

With the knowledge and experience I now have, I have no hesitation in recommending this Bill to the House. I admit there are grievances and I admit that in some areas those aggrieved have cause but some areas were bound to be affected, and some areas were bound to have grievances. The suggested remedy of drawing the boundaries somewhere else is not the answer. Where there are grievances, there will naturally be opposition to this measure. I believe this Bill conforms fully and completely with constitutional requirements and, at the same time, gives rise to the least number of grievances in the least number of places. I recommend this Bill to the House.

Comment on this