We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Local Government (Planning and Development) Bill, 1962—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 135–278 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government (Planning and Development) Bill, 1962
Enacted

No. 26 of 1962 ›

I should like to press the point I made on the Second Stage. Subsection (1) of Section 21 reads:

(1) Where a planning authority have prepared a draft of a proposed development plan or of proposed variations of a development plan——

They shall do certain things. My point is that there is no obligation on a planning authority to prepare a draft of a plan. Everybody knows it is possible to prepare a plan and put it through without a draft. Everybody knows that, although it is customary to prepare a draft of a deed, it is not necessary to do so. One can have the finished article in one act. There are numbers of sections in Acts of Parliament which lend support to my argument. A court would hold, I think, that if an Act intended to make it obligatory on a planning authority to prepare a draft before preparing the plan, it would say so. In Section 33 (9) it is specifically stated:

Where any such direction as is referred to in subsection (1) of this section is proposed to be given by the Minister, a draft thereof shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and the direction shall not be given until a resolution approving of the draft has been passed by each such House.

In several Acts of Parliament it is laid down that before the Minister makes regulations he shall prepare a draft thereof and lay them before both Houses of the Oireachtas. It might be inconvenient for an authority to put through a plan without first preparing a draft, but that could be done and it could be done, in my opinion, without in any way infringing Section 21 of this Bill. Apparently this was raised before and apparently the Minister has considered it, but, if there is room for doubt, should it not be put right now instead of leaving it there and inviting a decision of the court on it at some future date?

Comment on this

One of the prerequisites to the adoption or the making of a plan is paragraph (b) of subsection (1) of Section 21 which reads:

(b) they shall cause notice of the preparation of the draft to be published in the Iris Oifigiúil and in at least one newspaper circulating in their area.

Comment on this

Of the draft.

Comment on this

They must give notice of the preparation of the draft.

Comment on this

If they prepare a draft.

Comment on this

If they are to have a plan they must go through the paraphernalia one part of which is that they shall cause notice of the publication of the draft to be published. The local planning authority on whom we are relying will not be seeking loopholes to get out of having to tell the public what they are doing. I have been assured by the draftsman that it is a prerequisite of a plan coming into operation that all these things must be done.

Comment on this

I differ from the Minister. Paragraph (b) of subsection (1) of Section 21 comes into effect only after a plan has been prepared and, unless a planning authority have prepared a plan, they need not do any of the things mentioned. It may be that it is unlikely this will happen, but it is possible it will happen, and the safeguards outlined in subsection (1) of Section 21 are not really safeguards at all. There is no doubt that the things that are to be done under (a), (b), (c), and (d) need only be done if the draft is prepared. If what the Minister says is right, why does the section not say: "Before a planning authority prepare a development, they shall prepare a draft thereof" as is done in regard to all the things outlined in Page 16?

Comment on this

This specific wording was not used in the 1934 Act in regard to the preparation of a plan.

Comment on this

They never prepared any under that Act.

Comment on this

The courts held that in fact a draft was to be submitted so that the public would know what it was about, and it is not in the 1934 Act. We have had reiterated advice that this is so and that the plan cannot become a plan without a draft having been made available and known to the public beforehand.

Comment on this

Section 21 (1) (c) says:

Where the draft includes any provision relating to any structure proposed to be preserved because of its artistic, historic or architectural interest...

Where is a local authority given power to preserve any structure because of its artistic, historic or architectural interest?

Comment on this

Part IV, paragraph 5, of the Third Schedule.

Comment on this

I respectfully disagree with the Minister in his interpretation. A section like this which leaves room for argument should not be left in a Bill when it can be remedied and put beyond doubt without any expense to anybody.

Comment on this

If I saw a doubt, I would entirely agree with the Senator that this should not be so. I have not found a doubt and until it is shown to me there is a doubt, that there is a gap, I remain unconvinced, so there would not be any action for me to take.

Comment on this

We can agree to differ. However, there is another point in regard to Section 21 (1) (b) which reads:

they shall cause notice of the preparation of the draft to be published in the Iris Oifigiúil and in at least one newspaper circulating in their area.

Provision should be made in the section and in all other relevant sections in the Bill for the insertion of this notice in a local paper. It is all right to say the local authority will invariably publish the notice in the paper circulating in the locality. That does not always happen and widely read local papers have complained from time to time that these advertisements are put in the national papers and not in the local papers. I know they are not precluded from putting it in the local paper but they are not obliged to put it in the local paper. Even in 1963 there is a great number of people in each county who do not read the daily newspapers but who read the local papers.

Comment on this

This is a matter which we did consider. In some places there are no local papers. In fact, we are standing in the heart of one such place. However, there are some other places where there would be no local paper and if such a provision were put in the Bill, it would cause confusion. That is why we have left it to the discretion of the local authority and said: "At least one newspaper circulating in their area."

Comment on this

I know there is nothing to preclude the planning authority from publishing it in the local paper. Might I suggest that the Minister, as a matter of policy, in relation to this Bill when it becomes an Act and any other such Bills, should direct local authorities to use the local paper where one is available?

Comment on this

I shall leave the local authorities to direct their officials to do that.

Comment on this

The officials are the authority.

Comment on this

Is the choice of newspaper an executive or a reserved function?

Comment on this

Some of the Senators here have a queer notion of the soft sort of people who are members of local authorities, that these executives can do what they like. They cannot do anything they like unless there is something wrong with the council.

Comment on this

As regards subsection (2) (c), what is the definition of a ratepayer in this paragraph?

Comment on this

One who pays rates.

Comment on this

Would that be to a particular planning authority or to any local authority in Ireland?

Comment on this

To any local authority.

Comment on this

Am I correct in thinking that notwithstanding Section 21, no appeal lies against the preparation of a development plan unless to the circuit court in the case of the right of way? Representations may be made and objections may be put forward and presumably the planning authority will consider them but no appeal lies to the Minister in this case?

Comment on this

This development plan is not an executive instrument and therefore there would not be any need for an appeal.

Comment on this

A directive?

Comment on this

Under subsection (3), does the Minister envisage that he will require a planning authority to vary a development plan other than for the purpose of co-ordination or for variation arising from appeal?

Comment on this

This would be primarily the reason but it does not exclude any other reason.

Comment on this

What other purposes would the Minister have in mind?

Comment on this

For instance, a plan could be submitted which was just a jumble of statements and maps which meant nothing. It would not be a plan at all and in such a case it would be returned and they would be asked to prepare a proper plan.

Comment on this

Apart from this, the Minister does not need to use this instrument in regard to planning on a regional basis?

Comment on this

Far from it. One of the reasons for it is to help such things, if it is necessary to come in and bring some uniformity of approach into this whole matter.

Comment on this

The Minister would seek co-ordination by consultative methods rather than by using this subsection?

Comment on this

Subsection (2).

Comment on this

He would just move under subsection (2) and only where one authority would be standing out as one among many would he tend to use subsection (3)?

Comment on this

I wish to refer to subsection (5) (b). Is it not possible for the Minister to impose on himself and his successors some appropriate period in regard to the giving of decisions on appeals? Sometimes an appeal is made by a hothead and it is not necessarily a sensible appeal and it takes a very long time for the Minister to give a decision. Could anything be done about that?

Comment on this

Nobody more than the Senator appreciates just what sort of matters are raised in these appeals and which necessitate the Minister consulting with other interests who are under no obligation, nor can we put them under any obligation, in relation to whatever approach we might have made. However, the bringing into operation of oral hearings should cut down very much on all this letter-writing and acknowledgements which eat up most of the time and cause the delays in these appeals. I think that will get over 75 per cent of the delay.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) provides the right of a third party to appeal. How would he appeal if he did not know that the application for permission was before the local authority?

Comment on this

By the register with which we have dealt earlier.

Comment on this

The application would go into the register. The permission would be given in two months and unless you check the register——

Comment on this

It may be that under the power given in this Bill we will prescribe that a notice must be posted on the site to the effect that permission has been given. We have given that matter great thought because that is a weakness that existed up to the present because people might not be aware until it is too late and then nothing could be done. We have gone into that pretty fully and we hope there will be no such grievance in the future.

Comment on this

This is a tremendously dangerous provision in subsection (2) from the point of view of the developer. The situation could arise in which the planning authority has given permission to a person to develop a sector of land. The statutory period during which somebody could object passes and he starts operations on the 32nd day. He probably will spend £10,000 or £12,000 on the development of that site. This section gives the planning authority the right to have second thoughts on this business. The Bill says they must explain why they are having second thoughts and that might be very helpful but in the last line of the subsection, it says, in addition to every other consideration, "or any other material consideration". That is a highly dangerous term, that if any planning authority, or, let us say, the manager, in interpreting the planning authority feels——

Comment on this

I wonder if Senator Carton has the original Bill before him? I feel he must.

Comment on this

I apologise: it is not the amended Bill that I have. Now that I am on the matter, has that been changed?

Comment on this

It certainly does not read as the Senator read it.

Comment on this

If a planning authority gives me permission to develop a piece of land, they can revoke it, if they have second thoughts, but I could have spent £10,000 on developing that land. Earlier the Minister made a point that the planning authority is interpreted in its absence by the manager. The manager could have some material consideration and could put me into bankruptcy.

Comment on this

He can offer to buy it. Perhaps the Minister would elaborate?

Comment on this

The decision on such matters is a reserved function. Furthermore, compensation is payable so that there is no question of making anybody bankrupt. Whatever has been spent justifiably would be payable if there is a change of heart. It is most unlikely to arise except on rare occasions.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that it is a most unlikely situation but in the other Bill, in regard to injuries to amenities, as explained by Senator Stanford—I have only learned today what amenities are——

Comment on this

Does the Senator know now?

Comment on this

I shall have to learn Greek. They have a word for it.

Comment on this

I think we will all have to learn it.

Comment on this

I should like to raise a point which arises on this and on other sections, that is, that an appeal lies to the Minister and not to an independant tribunal or arbitrator. Subsection (1) deals with the enforcement of planning control in relation to the structure which is unauthorised on the commencement of the appointed day and the subsection says that the planning authority, if they decide it is expedient to do so, and subject to subsection (9) of this section, "shall, if they are directed by the Minister so to do, serve a notice under this section on the owner and on the occupier of the structure." Subsection (4) provides that where the enforcement notice is served, any person may at any time before the day specified in that behalf in the notice, appeal to the Minister against the notice.

There you have a case where the Minister directs a planning authority to do a certain thing which affects the private individual and the only appeal the individual has against the action of the planning authority is to appeal to the very man who in the first instance may have directed that this particular step be taken. That is unreasonable. As I said earlier, I cannot see why the Minister has not provided for the appointment of an arbitrator. The money would be well spent and he would be fully occupied. A circuit court judge, or somebody of a similar standing, could be appointed to deal with these appeals.

I know that the Minister has a point when he says that if you have 30 or 40 judges all over the country dealing with these appeals you may have different interpretations of the same sections and you will not have uniformity in planning throughout the State. However, I think that if somebody of the standing of a circuit court judge or some other professional arbitrator were appointed and who would himself be fully conversant with the provisions of this Bill when enacted, he would be in a position to give decisions which would be favourable to everybody.

A right of appeal to the Minister in a matter of this sort is not acceptable to the people of the country. They are not satisfied that they get an impartial hearing. I do not mean to suggest they get a biased hearing or that the Minister would act from any ulterior motives but the people concerned simply have their cases tried by correspondence, at worst, or by an individual who is an inspector and who comes down from Dublin, at best. They do not get a decision there and then. The inspector goes back to Dublin. He reports to the Minister. It may be months afterwards before they get a reply from the Minister, in the form of a letter, saying that such and such has been decided. That never gives satisfaction and it could not be expected to do so. There is the position that you have a person appealing to the Minister against a decision taken on the direction of the Minister.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy with what Senator Fitzpatrick has said but his statement about a judge who would be able to give a decision pleasing to everybody seems a little over-optimistic. Even Solomon could not do that. I would have more sympathy with Senator Fitzpatrick if it were not for subsection (9) which appears to provide the greatest possible safeguard against misuse of any Ministerial power. It is not just a question of an order having to be made and coming into force after a certain number of days. In this case, a specific resolution must be passed by both Houses. I cannot imagine anything more designed to produce the white light of publicity and to ensure that no executive action would be taken to infringe on what it is proper to be done. It is a tremendous safeguard and much better than merely providing for appeal to some judge.

I have some sympathy with the idea that one judge should deal with all the types of things that appear in this Bill but I think he would be fairly overloaded with work and would not have much time to practise as a judge. In regard to this section, however, I doubt if he would ever have very much to do. I am not referring to the present Minister now but Minister for Local Government in general would hardly envisage I think, a great many executive actions under this section where each one has to be passed by a resolution of both Houses. I should not imagine this would be anything except a very occasional provision.

Comment on this

I was fully conscious at all times of subsection (9): I referred to it. I merely raise this point on this section. I am making the case for the appointment of an arbitrator to deal with appeals in general and I am availing of this section to do it.

I want to make the point that you can have the case here where the Minister directs a planning authority to do something. If he does so, we may assume that the planning authority in their wisdom thought it should not be done. It was necessary for the Minister to come down on them and to say: "Serve this notice: I think you should serve it." If the Minister comes into the Houses of the Oireachtas, on a local point like that, with a resolution, it is very likely that he will get it passed. However, we have not got subsection (9) in all the other sections of this Bill which deals with appeals.

I made it clear in my opening statement that I was making my case for the appointment of an arbitrator to deal with appeals in general throughout the Bill when enacted and that I was using this section to do it. I take it that Senator Sheldon would, in the absence of subsection (9), agree with me. If he goes through the further sections of this Bill, he will find a great number of cases where the only appeal a ratepayer or property-owner has is an appeal to the Minister without the protection of subsection (9).

Comment on this

If Senator Fitzpatrick takes the wrong section on which to fight, he will not put words into my mouth as well.

Comment on this

The Senator put the words into his own mouth.

Comment on this

I do not think the enforcement section should be allowed to pass without a comment on how extremely desirable this section is and how every local authority, in particular I might mention Dublin County Council with which I associated myself, would have welcomed a provision of this type in years past. I think this is one of the very best things in the Bill.

Comment on this

On this section and on the next section, is there any provision for prosecution or penalties in respect of the contravention of an amenity order?

Comment on this

No, there is no penalty as is recognised. The penalty would be to refuse permission for development. That, in itself, would be regarded as the penalty.

Comment on this

I want to return to a point I made on Second Stage, that is, a hearing or inquiry in regard to an amenity order. Is it the position that a case can only be made in such an inquiry that the scope of the order be reduced?

Comment on this

I meant to reply to that. The Senator made this point on Second Stage and I overlooked it at the time. It is as he suspected it is. It does not extend; rather, would it be to reduce.

Comment on this

And no organisation which had a particular interest in an amenity would have any locus standi at an inquiry?

Comment on this

Not any more than anyboly else.

Comment on this

Have they any at all, or would the objection be confined? Could an organisation be represented?

Comment on this

Anybody with any interest in the mater would be entitled to be heard at the public local inquiry. Whatever the effect of their evidence might be, none of us can say at this stage.

Comment on this

This section provides for the creation of public rights of way. I entirely agree with what the Minister says that these rights of way could be created where they are absolutely necessary or reasonably necessary: I will go even that far. However, they should not be created lightly. The only provision in Section 48 against the creation of a public right of way is an appeal to the Minister, as far as I can see. I know there is also provision for payment of compensation in, I think, Section 63. It would appear that I am wrong in that and, if so, I shall hear what the Minister has to say.

Comment on this

One of the deterrents and one of the matters which will ensure that the town planning authority will be very honest and scrupulous in their approach is that they would have a duty to maintain this right of way and that would mean spending money on it if, in fact, they created it.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that any public authority would act dishonestly.

Comment on this

Not dishonestly— lightly.

Comment on this

But it is quite possible they would act high-handedly and the owner of property should be afforded some protection other than what is afforded in this section by appeal to the Minister. A right of way might be necessary to a lake or some other amenity but there might be several sites for the right of way and the owner might say: "I will offer you a right of way which will not cause me injury." A high and mighty local authority might say: "We want that particular one and we shall insist on having it." What puzzles me is that this subsection, which provides for the creation of a new right of way, gives only the right of appeal to the Minister while Section 21 which deals, not with the creation of a right of way but confirmation of an existing public right of way provides for an appeal to the circuit court. The Minister thinks it is of sufficient importance to give an appeal to the circuit court in Section 21 (i) (d) which includes the case of the preservation of a public right of way. In that case, a notice must be served on all concerned and the person on whose land that public right of way is to be confirmed—it is only confirmed; it is not the creation of a new right of way; it seems to be a right of way about which there is some doubt—is given the right to appeal to the circuit court. That is very satisfactory. But where the planning authority or the Minister, under Section 48, create a brand new right of way no such appeal is given. What is the cause for the differentiation?

Comment on this

So far as the appeal to the Minister is concerned and protection from the high-handed council, the first great deterrent is that it would cost the council money and I do not think that in our time we shall see local authorities spending money where they might save it, by putting the right of way where the owner did not want it. That might be a good case for putting it there, but not merely doing it for the sake of annoying the person who owned the land.

The creation of a new right of way is being dealt with in the same way as the acquisition of land. A compulsory purchase order for the purchase of land for certain purposes such as housing is dealt with in the same way.

Comment on this

Why do you give an appeal in Section 21?

Comment on this

That is what I am asking myself. I was probably talked into it.

Comment on this

I think Senator Fitzpatrick should not lightly give way.

Comment on this

I will be steamrolled out.

Comment on this

That is a way of giving way. I would not have much faith in what the Minister apparently considers a deterrent, that is the expenditure the local authority would be called on to bear in maintaining the right of way. In the case of such public rights of way as do exist, I am not aware that the local authority spend money on them: certainly a great many have no money spent on them. I think the planning authority might insist for their own convenience in going a particular way which might be a great inconvenience for the land owner. The Minister's view is that it would be a good reason, if they would save money. I would not be prepared to accept that. A right of way can be a great nuisance. It is not a matter of what is trampled on but all sorts of side nuisances arise. Fences get broken because somebody is in too much of a hurry to open a gate. Rights of way create more trouble, practically, than anything else. I think Senator Fitzpatrick is right and that there should be a better right of appeal in this case.

Comment on this

I do not agree.

Comment on this

I divided Donegal.

Comment on this

If I had my way I would not, but divided or otherwise, it is still there and so are a great many of us. I think Senator Sheldon has taken me up incorrectly in my reply to Senator Fitzpatrick. When the latter made the point that a local authority might act high-handedly and at the same time save themselves money by going the most inconvenient but the shortest way through a man's property I said that might be a very good reason why they would so so. I did not mean it would be a good reason for upholding the council on appeal. If, on appeal, it was shown that it was unreasonable to interfere in this way with a man's property, that it would upset him or cause him undue hardship and if he came along and said that the council could go another way to which he would be quite agreeable, even if it were three times as long and as costly I think it would be a most unreasonable council that would propose to do this and it would be a more unreasonable Minister who would condone their proposal to spoil a man's land and break it up unreasonably while he was ready to offer an alternative site.

Comment on this

Section 48 says:

Where it appears to the planning authority that there is need for a public right of way...

That is a very strong word, "need". I have heard of so many people especially cranks, who, if they can avoid allowing scenic walks through their land, or access to the seashore, will do it unless the right of way can be proved by prescription or otherwise. This presupposes it cannot be proved by prescription. Does the Minister consider "need" is too strong? "Need" means that it is necessary but necessary for what? Necessary for a scenic walk? Yes. Necessary to get to the seashore? Yes. But it is "need" unqualified. Does the Minister think the word is too strong?

Comment on this

I should say that I would read it from the beginning: "Where it appears there is a need..." That is not quite as strong as if we take the word "need" in isolation, as was put to me just now.

Comment on this

What that means is that the planning authority have considered it. They have come to a conclusion. It appears to them that there is a need. "Need" is a very strong word and it might possibly negative the whole section. That is what is bothering me. This is one of the most important sections of the Bill—I cannot say it is the most important, but it is a very important section.

Comment on this

This is to avoid any necessity for interfering with a person's private property and the fear has been expressed that that might arise. That is the idea of obliging a local planning authority to be convinced, to be persuaded, that there is a need, and that is fair enough.

Comment on this

That will be fair enough if they are to be persuaded that there is to be a need, but need for what purpose? You have to prove need in the abstract, prove that it is necessary that they get this. In many cases despite inconvenience, a local authority cannot do certain things. They must do something costing £500 where they could do it simply by entering on a man's land. If they take a hump off the road, for instance, they cannot dump the rubble on a man's land. Do they need the land for amenities, a scenic walk or a visit to the seashore? However, I was just pointing this out but if the Minister and his officials are satisfied, I am happy. I think, however, there is a grave risk.

Comment on this

You must refer to the long title of the Bill when dealing with this. If you go back and read it you will see that it brings this in.

Comment on this

If you are happy, that is all right.

Comment on this

Section 56, subsection (1) (a) provides that compensation shall not be payable:

In respect of the refusal of permission for any development that consists of or includes the making of any material change in the use.

I can appreciate that where the development consists entirely of a material change in use, compensation should not be paid. Indeed, that is largely in line with what the existing code provides, but it is provided here where a proposal includes making any material change. It is possible that this change of use might be a small portion of the total proposal but it appears from my first reading of the section that the prohibition is absolute and that no proportional payment of compensation can be made. One way out of it would be—I do not know if it would be possible under the Bill—that two separate applications could be made for development. Where the development consisted of an addition to a structure, plus a change of use, could it be the subject of two applications, one of which was excluded for compensation by the section and the other possibly included?

Comment on this

It is conceivable.

Comment on this

If it is not possible, the slightest element of change of use in a proposal cuts out compensation.

Comment on this

"Material" comes into it. In addition, I would suggest that section 58 provides certain discretionary powers. It is open to the Minister in respect of his functions under Sections 56 and 57 to depart from that which is said in Section 56 and to arrange that compensation shall be payable although Section 56 would seem to exclude it.

Comment on this

I was worried by the absolute nature of the exclusion as it appeared to me.

Comment on this

Section 58 waters it down.

Comment on this

We can rely on the Minister's generosity under Section 58 then to overcome Section 56?

Comment on this

It is the usual thing to expect.

Comment on this

Section 63, subsection (2) says:

A claim under this section shall be made within (but not after)—

(a) six months after the time when the order creating the public right of way commences to have effect.

If this is a right of way through a farm to a beach or river and the order is made, say, in September, I submit that more than six months would have elapsed between then and the following summer so that the amount of inconvenience or of compensation based on the inconvenience caused by the public would not be known for at least a year. To protect the rights of the individual farmer, the period should be at least 18 months so as to give the new situation time to be fully tested. Would the Minister be kind enough to have a look at that?

Comment on this

In fact, discretion is given to the circuit court to allow a longer period than six months with that very possibility in mind, where six months would not be sufficiently long to show what the real damage was and where compensation based on the six months as laid down in the first part would not be real compensation because it would not be known what the compensation should be. Therefore the circuit court is empowered to extend the time within which such a claim can be made, if it thinks fit.

Comment on this

Does the Minister realise that Section 21 allows an appeal to the circuit court as does Section 63 also. He thinks the question of compensation for a right of way sufficiently important to go to the circuit court?

Comment on this

Not at all; that has nothing to do with it. The Senator, with the happy knack he has, makes it appear that this is one and the same thing. The circuit court is not dealing with planning policy. It is deciding only whether or not the time which should be allowed an appellant should be extended in order better to make his case. No planning policy is concerned so it is quite easy.

Comment on this

It is a right of way all the same.

Comment on this

Can an individual apply to the circuit court later than six months?

Comment on this

May he apply after six months have expired?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

No; he must apply within six months and make a case why the court should extend the time in which he might fight his claim.

Comment on this

Surely a person can be quite willing to give a right of way and then after the public have misused it, take exception to it. He may not ask the court for compensation on the first day.

Comment on this

He cannot give his blessing today and renege on it tomorrow.

Comment on this

The public do not always appreciate a right of way. In a place where they get access to a river, they may leave gates open and give cattle access to crops so that considerable damage is done. When the farmer gives the right of way, he has not time to try out the arrangement. He will not know until after the first summer season whether the public are causing damage.

Comment on this

He would not know for 20 years if somebody unreasonable came along then and caused damage and you would not expect an extension for 21 years. One is as sensible as the other although that is an extreme case. When a right of way is created or is allowed to develop without any rights under the Bill at all, you may find trouble and damage years later which you could not possibly foresee, damage caused by virtue of your approach to the matter many years before. Had he known that would be the situation, he probably never would have allowed a right of way to develop, but we cannot just wait around to see if people will change in their attitude or the users of the right of way become a menace. We cannot just wait for that development. If there is any point in this suggestion that he may be satisfied within the six months but grow dissatisfied within 12 months, then he should give notice to the court that he may suffer a change of mind in 12 months, and let the court decide.

Comment on this

I suggest the period should be extended to 12 months. That would give him a better opportunity of gaining experience.

Comment on this

I am wondering rather about the machinery of it. Does the Minister envisage that anyone making, or proposing to make, a claim will have to decide on the damage? Does the Minister think six months will be a long enough period in which to determine the damage or should the person concerned immediately make some sort of claim to the court? I am not a lawyer, but what will happen is that anyone who is the owner of land over which a right of way is sought will probably claim to the circuit court. This could lead to the circuit court being overloaded because of the shortness of the period. I think a full year is a reasonable period in which to expect anyone could reasonably know what his claim would be.

Comment on this

It would also be to the advantage of people to go before the six months are up. If they go during that period, they are likely to have more effect, whereas, if they allowed the situation to go on developing, they would probably get next to nothing.

Comment on this

I am inclined to think a claimant could go to the circuit court after six months.

Comment on this

A claim could be made to the circuit court at any time.

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

Then all you people can advise. I have my view. If they have the right to go after the six months, that is all right, but do not say I did not warn you.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's intention that there could be no claim after six months?

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say that a claim must be made within six months.

Comment on this

That is to meet the person who does not find out about this in time.

Comment on this

It seems to me a claim could be made at any time.

Comment on this
Eamon Kissane Éamon Ó Ciosáin Fianna Fáil

That is all to the good.

Comment on this

This may have very far-reaching results. Generations later a claim could be made if some sudden rush came.

Comment on this

I will take anything.

Comment on this

In view of the speed with which we are progressing, I shall have to preface my remarks now by saying, as Senator Fitzpatrick does, "It would appear": it would appear that there is under this section a complete prohibition on compensation under two enactments. Is that correct?

Comment on this

I do not think we go quite that far. Payment of double compensation for the same loss is all we are getting at; it need not necessarily be under two Acts.

Comment on this

It does prohibit double compensation in the case of compensation for the totality of the same matter. I wonder could there not be a case in which something was done which might be partially the subject of compensation under one code and partially the subject of compensation under another? What would the position be if the partial compensation under the non-planning code had already been paid? Is there then a prohibition under this section on the payment of the remainder of the compensation under the planning code?

Comment on this

Could the Senator give an example?

Comment on this

I cannot think of an example offhand.

Comment on this

It seems to me these would be two different happenings and they would not, therefore, be caught by this; in other words, there would not be two lots of compensation in respect of the same thing. There might be compensation in respect of separate parts of what could be regarded as the same thing. If that were so, they could in fact get compensation from two different sources, but not for the same thing.

Comment on this

The Minister says you cannot be compensated in respect of the same thing. Could they not be part of a thing?

Comment on this

Then they would be the same thing.

Comment on this

The two things could be both parts of a larger thing.

Comment on this

That would be three things.

Comment on this

The section, as it stands, seems rather absolute. It says "in respect of any... thing". What I am worried about is that one could be compensated in respect of one aspect of a thing under one code and compensated in respect of another aspect under another code. I feel the section is rather tightly drawn and there might be cases of hardship.

Comment on this

It is probably necessary to have it that way.

Comment on this

There are very many points, indeed, which could be raised under Section 82 but at this hour of the night, I have no intention of raising them. There is, however, one matter I should like to put to the Minister. Is it his intention when he has recruited his planning staff, to separate this staff into two groups, one group responsible for planning and technical services and the other group a planning inspectorate to hold the various inquiries under the Bill?

Comment on this

That is the likely course.

Comment on this

From the point of view of how the various hearings would appear to the public, I would urge the Minister that the officials who act as ministerial inspectors for the purpose of these particular inquiries should not at any time be in technical consultation with the planning officers of the local authority. That would be very desirable. It is the practice in Britain that there is complete separation of staff between those who act as planning advisers to the Minister and, on the Ministerial inspectors for the purpose ties and the housing and planning inspectors. From the point of view of public relations, I urge on the Minister that as soon as the staff is large enough to divide, that division should be made. said something. We shall bear that in

Comment on this

Now the Senator has mind. It is right that it should be so, but I would not like to undertake not to use one and the same person for the moment. I do not think we will and I do not think we will have to.

Comment on this