An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–131 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
Before we enter on consideration of the Committee Stage of the Bill the Chair wishes to point out that section 1 provides for the deletion of existing matter in Article 16 of the Constitution and the substitution of the new matter set out in the Schedule. Senators have an opportunity of debating the proposals on section 1 or on the Schedule but not on both as duplication of debate is, of course, not permissible. As amendments have been tabled to the Schedule it is suggested that the debate might take place on it and that sections 1 and 2 be postponed until the Schedule has been disposed of, following which the questions on the sections will be put formally and decided without debate.
In addition, it would be well if I indicated that Amendment 5 standing in the names of Senators Quinlan, Jessop, Sheehy Skeffington and McQuillan is out of order as it conflicts with the principle of the Bill as read a Second Time. The Senators have been notified accordingly.
Sections 1 and 2 postponed.
AN SCEIDEAL.
SCHEDULE.
Comment on this
It is suggested that amendments 1, 3 and 6 be discussed together since Nos. 3 and 6 appear to be consequential on No. 1. Is that agreed?
Comment on this
Tairgim leasu 1:
I gCuid I, leathanach 5, "dhaonraidh" a scriosadh i líne 28 agus "thoghlach" a chur ina ionad, agus "daonradh" a scriosadh i líne 31 agus "toghlach" a chur ina ionad;
agus
I gCuid II, leathanach 7, línte 14 agus 17 "population" a scriosadh agus "electorate" a chur ina ionad.
I move amendment No. 1:
In Part I, page 4, to delete "dhaonraidh", in line 28 substitute "thoghlach"; and in line 31 to delete "daonradh" and substitute "toghlach";
and
In Part II, page 6, lines 14 and 17 to delete "population" and substitute "electorate".
The case made for this Bill has been made on several grounds but the issue on which the Minister appears to rely most heavily is the issue of the relationship between the population and the electorate. He has said, and there is, of course, some force in his argument, that the distribution of constituencies carried out on the basis of population would tend to some degree to weight the distribution of seats in the Dáil in favour of the urban areas. He has overstated his case but there is a case on this matter, and on the Second Stage, I dealt with it and I accepted that there was a case. My calculations show that as between the west of Ireland, the area to which he referred, and Dublin, there is a disparity on this account of two seats and the rest of the country in between pretty well balances out, there being fractional differences between the number of seats to which constituencies might be entitled up or down from area to area but the greatest difference arises between Dublin and the west. I listed the constituencies in the west in respect of which the discrepancies were significant ranging from about .2 or .3 of a seat up to a maximum of .55, if I recall correctly. I said also that I could see the arguments in favour of either basis of distribution.
It seems to me that one can make a very good case for the present system on the grounds that it is the people of Ireland who are represented in Parliament, and if there are people in some parts of Ireland with perhaps large families, a system based on population may give legitimately more representation as there are more people with large families in such areas. Strict political theoreticians would hold, perhaps, that the purpose of Parliament is to represent the views of the electorate and that it should reflect the views of the electorate rather than those of the population. I think a good case can be made for either basis. If between these two bases, there is one which tends to favour the west and the other which tends to favour Dublin, then in that case, if people share my view that there is not much between the two systems in terms of abstract theory, I would look towards the one that favours the west. This is what the Minister has not done. He has introduced a Bill which not alone makes no reference to this matter, which not alone fails to amend the Constitution to substitute electorate for population as the basis of distribution, but which in providing a tolerance in respect of the distribution of the constituencies on a basis of population fails to permit as one of the reasons for employing such a tolerance the use of those electoral criteria. It is true that coincidentally the application of some of the criteria which the Bill includes may have this effect in some constituencies, although not in all relevant cases, of helping to restore the balance, or perhaps even going beyond restoring the balance, between the electorate and the population bases. But the Bill neither bases the distribution of constituencies on the electorate nor does it permit variations to be made with a view to achieving these things, although it does not prevent variations being made for other purposes so that it may incidentally have this effect. This exposes the dishonesty—which is not too strong a word to use—of the Minister's case, because if he felt strongly on this matter, if the sound and fury were accompanied by a comparable degree of genuine conviction, then he would have brought in a Bill which would have substituted "electorate" for "population", or, alternatively—and this is the less advantageous of the two, the less proper of the two for the purpose he pretends to want to achieve —he would have brought in a Bill which would have permitted the tolerance to be employed for the purpose of adjusting the constituencies to an electorate basis and away from the population basis. He has done neither but has come in here to justify a Bill which proposes to do quite different things, much more extensive things and in that way to get over what he tells us is an injustice.
There is no need to adopt such a roundabout way of achieving his objectives. There is no need to bring in a Bill which lays down that you can have 16 per cent tolerance on a population basis and that you can have this for the purpose of improving representation in dispersed areas. There is no need to adopt that subterfuge in order to achieve the results which he claims he wishes to achieve. It can be achieved by the simple amendment I now propose, and in putting down this amendment, I am calling his bluff and calling on him to stand by the words he used——
Comment on this
——and to stand on the principles that he put forward in regard to the electorate and to accept the electorate as a basis which will benefit the West, as against the population basis that he proposes which can only benefit the West by using this tolerance to distort representation in one direction as against another on a population basis. The proposal I make, therefore, is that we substitute "electorate" for "population", and that we substitute "register of electors" for "census of population". I also propose the deletion of the last paragraph because while I believe it is necessary so long as you work on the basis of the census of population, when we would have a long interval before the publication of the final figures, this paragraph will not be necessary, of course, if you are working on the basis of the register of electors. This is the amendment I propose. I also propose that the tolerance should be increased from the five per cent, which is the present level arising out of the Supreme Court decision of 1961, to one-twelfth or eight per cent. This is approximately half the tolerance which the Minister proposes. The reason is that I believe, and I think I can show, that with the electorate basis and with the eight per cent tolerance——
Comment on this
The Senator is discussing amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
I am referring to this point because it is necessary for me to explain these two together in order to explain the purpose of the amendment I am now discussing.
Comment on this
The Senator is entitled to foreshadow other amendments but he should be careful not to preclude himself from discussing them.
Comment on this
It was not my intention to preclude myself from discussing them. The combination of the electorate basis and the tolerance of one-twelfth would have the effect of reducing to a small number of cases the cases where county boundaries would have to be crossed, and I think I can show there are only three cases where parts of constituencies would have to be allocatd to other constituencies in order to work within this tolerance using the electorate basis. That being the case, the argument about chopping up constituencies is diminished to the point where it is no longer important. The Minister himself has not claimed his amendment will eliminate the need for such allocation of parts of constituencies to other constituencies in all cases. Even in earlier periods when we allowed ourselves a wider tolerance with large constituencies, there were cases where parts of one county had to be attached to another. The Minister has not claimed his scheme will prevent this; he has said this will continue to happen and has said that 30 per cent tolerance would be needed in order to avoid some combination of counties. I am taking him at his word and proposing that we divide the constituency on an electorate basis with an eight per cent tolerance, and thus avoid more than a handful of county boundaries being crossed, a handful of cases in which the Minister must contemplate breaching the boundaries.
Comment on this
Would the Minister like to ask the permission of the House to include amendment No. 4 with the other amendments?
Comment on this
I think so, with the agreement of the House. To my mind, the two were put together for the purpose of achieving a particular result, and it is easier to discuss them together.
Comment on this
It is a matter for the House, if they agree.
Comment on this
There would be a separate decision but it is a question as to whether there should be one or two debates.
Comment on this
Nos. 3 and 6 are consequential. There can be a separate decision on No. 4, but the question is whether there should be a completely separate debate.
Comment on this
As I see it, No. 4 is intended to apply even if Nos. 1 and 3 fall: in other words even if the Bill still proposes that the redistribution of constituencies should be on the basis of the census, it would still be the Senator's intention to move No. 4?
Comment on this
That was not the way I approached it. My purpose in putting forward this proposal was to show that it would be possible to meet the Minister's point if you, in combination, take an electorate basis and an eight per cent tolerance——
Comment on this
The position in moving amendment No. 1 is that it is necessary to refer to amendment No. 4. If in fact we follow what has been agreed and discuss only amendments Nos. 1, 3 and 6 together, leaving No. 4 for a separate debate, the Chair will be in some difficulty in regard to repetition on the second debate.
Comment on this
I would propose, with the permission of the House, that if the amendments I have down here are not accepted, to withdraw the other, as it will cease to have any relevance.
Comment on this
The Senator does not envisage a separate debate on No. 4 if No. 1 is lost?
Comment on this
The House accordingly is now determining that amendments Nos. 1, 3, 4 and 6 will be debated together, with, if necessary, a separate decision on amendment No. 4
Comment on this
I propose, therefore, to show that on the electorate basis it will be possible to avoid the crossing of county boundaries in more than three instances, only three cases where parts of the county have to be detached and attached to another county, so long as one has an eight per cent tolerance, and to my mind an eight per cent tolerance is acceptable if it can be used only for the purpose of preserving county boundaries when there is no alternative; it is not permissible as a means of securing high representation for certain areas of the country as a matter of policy as distinct from a matter of accident. That is why I tied up my two proposals closely.
I am suggesting now that the distribution of the constituencies on an electoral basis can show the result which I claim it can achieve. I do this because I think it is not sufficient for me to assert it can be done. If I am wrong— and I may well be in error on some points—the Minister can show I am wrong, and if necessary I can make an adjustment. The following therefore is the way I would propose to divide the constituencies. I should explain that in my calculations I have had regard to figures given by the Minister in respect of the constituencies in reply to a question in the Dáil last March. It is necessary to make a slight estimation where boundaries are crossed but the margin of error is slight. If my estimation is in error I am sure the Minister will draw my attention to it and the appropriate adjustment can be made.
The electorate in the county and city of Dublin including Dún Laoghaire, is 447,000, giving an entitlement of 37.55 seats. I propose to give Dublin 37 seats. The entitlement on the basis of population is 39.7 seats. On an electorate basis instead of a population basis Dublin loses an entitlement to two seats but my proposal is that Dublin would lose three seats. So much for the allegation that we are concerned in some way to bolster up representation in Dublin at the expense of the West. That is contrary to our intention and can be achieved within the limits imposed by the Constitution and without contravening the considerations of natural justice appropriate to the method of election to Parliament.
Wicklow has an electorate of 36,700 and an entitlement of 3.1 seats which I would round down to three seats. Wexford has a population of 50,000 and an entitlement of 4.2 seats rounded down to four seats. That is five per cent tolerance and it is well within the eight per cent I propose. Carlow-Kilkenny has a population of 55,700 an entitlement to 4.7 seats and a tolerance of between seven and eight per cent would give five seats. Waterford—and this is the one case where crossing the boundary is involved—has an electorate of 43,200 and 3.6 seats due, a number which even allowing eight per cent tolerance cannot be rounded up to a sufficient number. Consequently it becomes necessary to allocate to Waterford a small section of Tipperary perhaps of the order of 3,000 electorate, giving Waterford an entitlement to 3.9 seats which I round up to four.
Comment on this
Three point nine rounds up to four with 2½ per cent tolerance. Waterford has not got sufficient unless something is attached. I propose to attach a small piece of Tipperary which would give an entitlement of 3.9 seats that can be rounded up to four with a 2½ per cent tolerance. Tipperary has an electorate of 74,800.
Comment on this
Tipperary as a whole. If the wonderful British idea of North and South Ridings is to be preserved I will have to make some more calculations?
Comment on this
Tipperary has an electorate of 74,800 and an entitlement to 6.3 seats having transferred 3,000 to Waterford. There would be two three-seat constituencies and a possibility of having to cross the North-South Ridings boundaries. Longford has an electorate of 17,300 and Westmeath has an electorate of 37,900, a total electorate of 55,200, giving an entitlement to 4.05 seats, rounded down to four seats. Kildare has an electorate of 37,900 and an entitlement to 3.2 seats rounded down to three seats, with a 2½ per cent tolerance.
Meath is another case where we have to cross the boundaries. Here we have an electorate of 39,700 and an entitlement to 3.3 seats. I have transferred part of Meath to Louth. I have made all these transfers in the direction which involves the minimum disturbance. Taking 3,600 from Meath would leave an electorate of 36,100 and an entitlement to three seats. Louth and Leitrim with an electorate of 41,800 are entitled to 3.5 seats and with the addition of 3,600 electors from Meath that brings it up to 3.8, rounded up to four seats with a tolerance of about five per cent.
Monaghan has an electorate of 28,300 and Cavan has an electorate of 34,300, a total of 62,600 and an entitlement to 5.3 seats rounded down to five with a tolerance of about six per cent. Laois has an electorate of 26,000 and Offaly has an electorate of 30,200, a total of 56,200, and an entitlement to 4.75 seats rounded up to five with a tolerance of five per cent. The Cork electorate is 204,400 and there is an entitlement to 17.2 seats rounded down to 17. Kerry has an electorate of 70,100 and an entitlement to 5.9 seats rounded up to six.
Limerick has an electorate of 79,450 and an entitlement to 6.7 seats—just under 6.7 seats—rounded up by a tolerance of about five per cent to seven seats. There would be three-and four-seat constituencies as at present. Clare has an electorate of 48,200 and an entitlement to 4.05 seats rounded to four. Galway with an electorate of 87,600 is entitled to 7.35 seats rounded down to seven with a tolerance of about five per cent. Mayo has an electorate of 71,300 and is entitled to six seats. There would be two three-seat constituencies. Sligo with an electorate of 32,400 is entitled to 2.72 seats. With a ten per cent tolerance we could avoid a boundary shift here but I have opted for a lower tolerance. The people of Leitrim are so accustomed to the constituency being chopped up that another adjustment probably may not perhaps worry them unduly. I propose to add in part of Leitrim. There are various ways of doing this, and this is only one solution. I do not claim it is the best.
Comment on this
I am speaking generally. My solution of the whole question is one only of a number of solutions. I made a general interpolation which was bad oratory. If we add part of Leitrim to Sligo this brings Sligo to an entitlement of 3.7 seats with a tolerance of eight per cent rounded up to four seats. I would call the constituency Sligo-Leitrim. Roscommon has an electorate of 36,400 and an entitlement to 3.06 seats. When we add in the remainder of Leitrim, 7,650, that brings the entitlement to 3.7 again, rounded up to four with eight per cent tolerance. This means that the Sligo-Leitrim-Roscommon area would get an extra seat. One could take a more stringent view and round it down, but I have rounded it up in each case and the result is that there is this extra seat in this area. My note dealing with Donegal seems to have disappeared but the figure here works out almost exactly at 5.93 seats rounded up by one per cent tolerance of these seats—subject to correction because the piece of paper I handed to a colleague has disappeared. I shall take any correction the Minister gives me if I am wrong there but I think it is 5.9 per cent.
There is a distribution which accepts the Minister's basis of the electorate. It gives Dublin three fewer seats than it is entitled to. It gives the West an extra two seats more than it is entitled to on a population basis and the extra seat is distributed somewhere around the country in bits and pieces. It has a bias towards rural areas. It has an eight per cent tolerance. It avoids any undue distortion and, by minimising the crossing of county boundaries, it does not entirely cut across the local loyalties anywhere. However, I may have gone wrong somewhere. My calculations had to be estimated. I have neither the staff nor the information available to me which the Minister has. I was not able to do this calculation on the basis of precise county electorate figures. I have made the best possible estimates. If I am in error in any of these estimates——
Comment on this
The Senator said he got these figures from the reply given to a Parliamentary Question in March last——
Comment on this
This is my exact point. I have already explained twice that the Minister gave figures for constituencies. Let me explain, for the third time, that I used that as a basis for calculating the electorate figures for counties by allowing for the varying ratios in each case. If I have made a significant error in any case, I am open to correction. I rather doubt if I have made a significant error.
Comment on this
I am open to disproof. If the Minister does not know how many electors there are in the counties of Ireland, he should not be piloting this Bill.
Comment on this
I gave warning of my intentions the last day in this regard. Subject to one small point, I indicated clearly the intended distribution. I did not mention Leitrim and I should have done so. The Minister's Department should have no difficulty in checking the calculations. I indicated the county boundaries I would cross and the constituencies I would keep intact.
The points are that the population system has a bias towards the rural areas and that the county boundaries should be maintained as far as possible. I commend these points to the House. I should be glad to know if there is any reason why they should not be accepted.
Comment on this
First of all, of course, the first part of Senator FitzGerald's speech in favour of his amendment consisted in ascribing to me a lot of things that neither I nor anybody else on this side of the House ever said. They were merely what Senator FitzGerald would have liked me to say but, as he and everybody in the House knows, these things were, in fact, never said.
I did not make the case that any part of the purpose of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill was to attempt the ridiculous operation of trying to equate exactly the value of every vote in every part of the country. I should expect Senator FitzGerald to engage in such type of operation. Neither I nor any Member of the Government intended to do any such thing.
The purpose of this amendment, as was explained to the House both in introducing the Second Stage of the Bill and in reply, is to give reasonable scope to avoid the injustice that was done to large sections of the population in numbers of counties. The last revision required by the decision of the High Court on the 1959 revision was strongly objected to by a number of Deputies from the Opposition Parties who represented the areas concerned and, I may say, was objected to quite as strongly by Members of the Fianna Fáil Party as well. Because of this type of injustice, described by Opposition Members as "disfranchising" of the people concerned, described as the "butchering" of counties and of constituencies, described as the "ruthless dismemberment" of them—because this would have to happen all over the country on this occasion—the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill was, in the main, decided upon. Senator FitzGerald knows that as well as everybody else. He will not be able to find any instance where it was stated that anything else was the objective.
It is, of course, a fact that I countered the opposition to the Bill by pointing out that the resultant position from the enactment of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill would be that the rural vote in general would, for the first time, more nearly approximate to the value of the urban vote in general but that was quite obviously merely a by-product of the Bill. There was never any suggestion that it was part of my objective, or of the Government's objective, to attempt anything so ridiculous as trying to equate exactly the value of every vote in every part of the country. It was because we agreed with the majority view and, as I believe, with the unanimous view of all Deputies—I think all Deputies in the House but certainly all Deputies whose constituencies were in any way affected—that what happened in 1961 was unjust to the people concerned, we decided to comply with the demands that were made at that time for an amendment of the Constitution to provide a limited amount of scope for avoiding such injustices in the future.
The Opposition—who, apparently, purely and simply because this was proposed by Fianna Fáil, decided to oppose it—adopted the unscrupulous and obviously unjustifiable argument that this breached the sacred principle of one man, one vote although they must have known, because the figures were available to them, that this was not so.
Comment on this
If the Senator wishes to make a counter argument he may do so later.
Comment on this
I pointed out that, in fact, the present position which the Opposition want to retain resulted in conferring on the vote in the built-up areas in general a greater differential in regard to electing a Deputy than would the proposal and that while the situation resulting from that would be that votes in all parts of the country and in every constituency would not immediately be equal, still the overall result would certainly do no more than to equate the value of a rural vote in general with the urban vote in general. But I never conceded that there was any democratic requirement to ensure that every vote in every constituency would be of equal effect with every other vote. The whole basis of my argument was that far from it having been just on the last occasion to require that a part of the electorate of County Louth, for instance, should vote in Monaghan, it was inflicting an injustice on them. Deputies for County Louth, and Senator Donegan, as he then was, endorsed that view. It was quite clear that so far as the public representatives were concerned, they believed there was no gain for democracy in doing this and the people of the Ardee area who were transferred to Monaghan would not have felt in any way discriminated against if it took fractionally more Louth votes to elect a Deputy than it would Monaghan votes to elect a Deputy in the constituency of Monaghan.
That was no part of the objective of the Bill which was to avoid doing these unjust things both to the people, to their public representatives and to Party organisations.
Senator FitzGerald has argued that there is something to be said for giving a differential voting power to people with families. There may be, but there is not any way of identifying people with families and allocating some fractionally increased value to the votes of these people. There are single people in the cities as well as in the rural areas; there are married people with and without families both in rural and in urban areas; and apparently Senator FitzGerald thinks that this voting power should be given on the basis of the total population as ascertained by the census which is taken on one particular day of the year. Of course, the difference in the percentage of the total population that the electorate comprises in different areas does not arise solely from the proportion of children in the population in these areas. It also arises from other reasons such as the fact that there may be temporary residents on the night of the census in different areas. I pointed out that it is not just the fact that families in general may be larger in urban areas that gives rise to this. There is the question also of residents in hotels, patients in regional hospitals, children and their mothers in maternity hospitals in Dublin, and so on, and Senator FitzGerald thinks that all these should contribute——
Comment on this
He assumed that the only factor operating was that families were larger in the urban areas and in accordance with that, he sees it as something desirable that every vote in the urban area should have more effect in electing a Deputy than every vote in a rural area. I do not agree with that, and as I said, I think, and the Government think, that it should be sufficient to have reasonable equality in this matter and that there should be a certain amount of scope allowed in order to avoid such anomalies as the breaching of county boundaries and so on. I want to refute the suggestion that it was ever part of the objective that this should be achieved but it does so happen that in the application of the proposed maximum divergence for the purposes laid down in the Bill, the overall result will be that it is much nearer to equating the overall value of the rural vote in general with the urban vote in general.
In other words, the position in that regard, if the Amendment is passed, will be much nearer to this alleged principle of one man, one vote than the position the Opposition have been trying to hang on to. Nobody disputes that if you base the scheme of constituencies on strict parity of the number of electors per Deputy, you will, in fact, achieve equality in the value of a vote in every part of the country, but you will not avoid doing these unjust and anomalous things that had to be done in 1961. A certain permitted divergence from the national average will also be necessary. Senator FitzGerald apparently concedes that and is prepared to agree to half the maximum divergence we proposed. I do not know where he got his figures and as far as I could see he admitted that he guessed them, but quite a number of county boundaries would have to be breached if the revision were to be based on the electorate and unless there was a divergence of almost the same as we have suggested as the divergence for a revision based on the census figures.
In my reply to the Second Stage debate, I pointed out that there were a number of other reasons why it was not considered desirable to change from the census as a basis for the revision of constituencies. The Government considered this question of basing it on the electorate rather than on the population, but we came to the conclusion that it was preferable not to amend the Constitution in that way because even if representation were based on the electorate, a tolerance of much the same order would be required, and there did not seem to be much to be gained in that way. As well as that, there is the fact that the census is compiled on a national basis by the Central Statistics Office and in a much more scientific way, with a much more elaborate organisation, than is the register of electors. It carries much greater authority. The census figures are generally accepted as being both accurate and reliable, whereas anybody who has any connection with political activity knows that there are many complaints with regard to the compilation of the register of electors. It is quite clear that the standard of accuracy in compiling the register of electors varies considerably from place to place. The same elaborate organisation for compiling the register of electors which operates in the census of population is not available.
Comment on this
And it is not within the wit of man to devise a better system?
Comment on this
It is, and, no doubt, the expenditure that would be involved is a matter of no consideration to the Opposition.
Comment on this
The census is taken only every five years while the register of electors is compiled every year.
Comment on this
That being so, it is eminently reasonable to set up the elaborate organisation and incur the expense necessary for the compilation of the census, but it would hardly be reasonable to keep a similar organisation there permanently for the compilation every year of the register of electors.
Comment on this
But that is what would have to be done.
Business suspended at 6.5 p.m. and resumed at 7.15 p.m.
Comment on this
I was pointing out that I had not, at any stage, said that any part of the objective of this Bill was to ensure that every vote in every constituency would count exactly the same towards electing a Deputy and that it was not in fact in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill that we were dealing with the principle of one man, one vote, that that principle was not in fact relevant to the Third Amendment Bill but that it was very much involved in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. It may be that that was what was confusing Senators on the opposite benches. They may have mistaken my insistence on the importance of the principle of every vote being treated the same but that was in connection with the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. What I did explain in regard to this particular Bill was that even if that is accepted, it is quite clear that the position after this amendment is passed will be that the value of a rural vote in general will more nearly approach the value of a vote in an urban area.
I noticed in Senator FitzGerald's approach here today that he is tacitly assuming that the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill will be passed and assuming that the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill will not be passed. As I understand it—I admit it is not an easy thing to understand the minds of the Opposition Parties— but as far as I can understand, they are in fact opposing both of these electoral reforms and we are recommending both. The Opposition obviously realise or are admitting that one at least of these will be passed. I think it must be obvious to them and it will become increasingly obvious that both will, in fact, be passed. After all, that is what they are advising, that neither should be passed. We are advising that both should be passed and I think it is reasonable to assume that it will be either both or neither. The Opposition apparently have now come round to assuming that the Third Amendment Bill will be passed and I think it will not be very long until they also appreciate that the Fourth Amendment will be passed with it.
However, for the purposes of his argument on this particular amendment, Senator FitzGerald has been assuming that the Third Amendment will be passed but that we will still have multi-member constituencies and on that basis, he contends, I think, that only seven counties will be affected if his amendment is accepted. On the other hand, in the more likely event of both amendments being passed, 11 counties would be directly affected. There would be 11 counties in which it would not be possible to avoid breaching county boundaries and of course in many of these cases another county would also be affected.
Comment on this
Is the Minister counting two counties in the case of a transfer here?
Comment on this
No; I am talking about 11 single-seat constituencies, that in the event of there being single-seat constituenices and the distribution of seats to be on the basis of electorate with a maximum divergence of one-twelfth, then there would be 11 counties in which it would not be possible to avoid breaching county boundaries, considering those counties on their own.
Comment on this
These would be counties which would lose population to another county?
Comment on this
No; in some cases they might have to get population. They would have to be adjusted with another county.
Comment on this
The point I am trying to make is when the Minister talks of 11 counties, does he mean that where people are transferred, say, from South Tipperary to Waterford he is counting both South Tipperary and Waterford or only the county that loses population.
Comment on this
It is possible that in some cases the two might be counted because what I am doing is dealing with each county separately, and I am saying that on the basis of treating each county separately, there would be 11 counties in which the allocation of seats could not completely respect county boundaries. Most of those cases anyway would be involved in adjustments with another county. Senator FitzGerald found a smaller number of counties was affected because he was dealing with the improbable situation of one amendment being passed and the other not, and he was assuming the traditional grouping of parts of counties and he avoided it in that way. I want to point out that there is no reason for assuming this. It is much more reasonable to assume that either both amendments will be lost or both passed.
There is obviously no advantage to be gained by changing from the traditional basis for deciding constituencies on the basis of the census. Senator FitzGerald's proposal is to start out by basing it on equality of votes and then deliberately moving away from that, whereas our proposal is to base the actual revision on the present basis of the census which has always been used, and, as I have shown, the operation of the maximum divergence that we propose would, in fact, move more towards equality of voters.
I was interested in the actual manner in which Senator FitzGerald approached the allocation of seats in accordance with what would be the position if his amendments were accepted. To the Dublin area he proposes to allocate 37 seats and to the western area, the counties of Donegal and Clare and the Province of Connacht, he proposes to allocate 31 seats. In other words, he proposes an increase of three seats in the Dublin area and a decrease of two seats in the western area.
Comment on this
An increase of three on the present representation in Dublin. Even on the present basis if no change were to be made and on the basis of the assumption that we make, that the High Court decision indicated that a divergence of five per cent was permissible, if that were applied to the electorate in the Dublin area the minimum number to be allocated would be 36. If it were applied to the western area, the western area could retain 32 seats as against the present 33. The absolute minimum that could be allocated to the Dublin area under the proposals in the present Bill, if it were enacted, would be 35, so that Dublin must get an increase of one seat at any rate and the increase would, in fact, probably be more. Therefore, it is quite clear, or it is likely at any rate, that the absolute number the western area would get under the present Bill would be 32 and they would be entitled to 32 if the present conditions were applied to the electorate rather than population, so there is no need for going to the less accurate and less reliable register of electors rather than the census.
I think then that there is no need for this and that, in fact, what we are proposing is more desirable and will be more effective in avoiding the breach of county boundaries either in the unlikely event of the present system of multi-member constituencies being maintained or in the more likely event of the single-seat system being introduced. In either case under what we propose it would be possible to avoid the breach of county boundaries. Under Senator FitzGeralds's proposal, he himself admits that in the multi-member constituencies, I think, seven counties would be affected and at least 11 would be affected under a system of single-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment, the reason for which was summed up very well by Senator E. Ryan in column 1591 of volume No. 65, No. 15 of the Official Debates of Wednesday, 17th July, 1968:
In these circumstances, it is quite legitimate and only proper and just to try to have some difference between city constituencies and county constituencies to redress this balance and to provide that it will require something in or about the same number of electors to elect a Teachta Dála in a city constituency as in a remote rural constituency.
We are all in agreement on that and what we are asking the Minister and the Government is to put it down in the Bill. In other words, if the Government insist that in the basis of representation one large determining factor will be the number of electors per Deputy and if it is the desire to have this the same, then why not make that change in the Bill? It is obviously wrong to write into the Bill a scheme based on population and then to go round with all the various and nefarious suggestions that were quoted trying to show that, in effect, tolerance would only succeed in redressing the balance and you would have the same number of electors per Deputy in Donegal as in Dublin. It seems totally wrong, if that is to be the basis, to play around with population figures and not to deal with the figure concerned, that is, the number of electors.
On the other hand, if the Government wish to say that all in the population are equal when it comes to representation and that the child counts just the same as the adult, if they hold that viewpoint, the representation should be based on population as given in the Bill. But the Government seem to be trying to get away from that and I suggest that just as the figures quoted by the Minister show that by applying the tolerance he would have roughly the same representation of electors in Donegal as in Dublin, he should do that for all the other counties as well and then the muddle that is created will be self-evident.
In the amendment which I am sponsoring at a later stage, I am seeking to make the basis of representation slightly lower than that produced by Senator FitzGerald and to make it based on those over 18 and then, of course, based on figures that have come from the population statistics and, due to the fact that these population statistics are taken only every five years, then it seems reasonable that a slightly lower limit of 18 would mean that at some stage you would have the vote going down to 18——
Comment on this
No. We are not discussing amendment No. 2.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied that amendment No. 2 does not need very much separate discussion. The principles contained are essentially the same.
Comment on this
We must wait until we dispose of the other amendments.
Comment on this
I want to support Senator FitzGerald's amendment.
Comment on this
If his amendment is carried, I will withdraw mine.
Comment on this
That may be done without dealing with amendment No. 2.
Comment on this
As Senator Quinlan was good enough to cite me in support of his proposals, I want to make it clear that a study of the ratio between electorate and population in all of the constituencies shows quite clearly that in almost all cases it takes more of the electorate to elect a Deputy in the rural areas than in the city areas. Consequently, I would support any proposal that would redress this in a general way.
Comment on this
But, of course, the point being made that this should be done simply by substituting "electorate" for "population" only meets one of the problems that have to be dealt with in framing suitable constituencies and entirely disregards the other problem, the problem of convenient areas of representation. For that reason, I think the Third Amendment as it stands is a much better way of dealing with it because it deals both with the question of the ratio between electorate and population and with the question of suitable areas of representation. Consequently, I think that, as it stands, it is a much better way of dealing with both than trying to segregate two or three problems and trying to deal with them separately.
Comment on this
Deputy Ryan's speech on the Fourth Amendment would be helpful on that measure but has no relevence to this measure, which is separate from the Fourth Amendment and which could conceivably be passed when the Fourth Amendment will certainly be rejected by the people. Therefore, I do not know quite how to bring it into focus in this debate. Convenient areas of representation is not the issue which the Minister was pressing with us.
Comment on this
It has been referred to, certainly. Are we to take it, therefore, that all these columns that I have here of the Minister dealing with the electorate and county boundaries are to be disregarded, that this was just a smokescreen by which we were supposed to be blinded and that behind all this what is wanted is not, in the Minister's words, to make it possible to keep the rural Deputy, in general, equal in value to the Deputy in the bigger cities but, instead, to do far beyond that and to give far bigger representation in order to provide convenient areas of representation? Either it is the intention that the Deputies should be equal, in which case the areas of representation will be more inconvenient in rural than in urban areas—and that is what is implied in everything the Minister has said—or, in fact, the intention is to provide a different ratio of representation, even on an electorate basis, in the west. That is what the Bill makes possible. It is what the Minister has throughout tried to persuade us is not the intention. He said most specifically, at column 1204:
...mentioned in the Bill, will do no more than in general equate the value of a rural vote to that of an urban vote—if it even does that.
Comment on this
"In general"—that is global—for the country as a whole, not for the west versus the east or the east versus the west. The Bill, in fact, entitles him to go far beyond that. It entitles him to transfer five seats from Dublin to the west, whereas all that is needed to achieve the objective stated is to transfer two seats. If we are to give convenient areas of representation which means giving to the west or rural areas more seats in relation to population than the rest of the country, that would do very much more than “in general, equate the value of a rural vote to that of an urban vote—if it even does that.”
The fact is, the Minister has throughout tried to cover up the fact that the purpose of this Bill is to eliminate the principle of one man one vote and he has introduced this red herring of the electorate, which we have now exposed totally, and this red herring of county boundaries, in order to cover up the fact that his intention is not simply to give fair representation on an electorate basis, on which we are all agreed and which he is now rejecting when I propose it, not simply to prevent, and I quote him I think, "wholesale breaching of county boundaries" but, beyond either of those two objectives, which are reasonable objectives with which we sympathise and would entirely support him in achieving, he wants to distort the representation in order to give extra representation to some parts of the country against others on the grounds of the character of the areas and regardless of the number of people living there.
That is what the Bill enables him to do. It is stated in the Bill that that is the criterion to be applied in determining constituencies. Throughout this debate and the debate in the other House the Minister tried to throw up a smokescreen when talking about the electorate.
Comment on this
For the purposes of the Official Report, will the Senator give the reference?
Comment on this
The reference is column 1204 of volume 65, No. 11. The Minister, in the course of his remarks, said he was endorsing the principle of one man, one vote on an electorate basis. I stood up to challenge him and the Leas-Chathaoirleach rightly ruled that I could make my point when my turn came. I make it now. I quote the Minister's opening speech:
I do not think that city voters expect or want to retain such favourable treatment and I trust that Senators will endorse the principle of one man one vote of equal value which is inherent in the proposals in the Bill.
Comment on this
At column 1206, when the Minister was dealing with the Third Amendment. He did not deal with the Fourth Amendment until later.
Comment on this
The Minister is getting confused. He overworked himself last week.
Comment on this
The Minister is maintaining that the purpose of the Bill is to achieve the one man, one vote principle on an electorate basis. He told us the Bill will do no more than to achieve this even if it does that. This was to avoid the wholesale breaching of county boundaries. I have proposed an amendment to achieve these two aims. I have smoked out the real intention which is, not to achieve the principle of one man, one vote on an electorate basis, but to go far beyond it, regardless of the wholesale breaching of county boundaries.
I am glad my amendment has had this effect. It is quite clear now where we stand. It is quite clear what this Party is in favour of: giving fair representation to every part of the country as far as possible and, within limits, in favour of the West. We believe it can be done within the reasonable tolerance of three or four seats. The Minister seeks to go beyond that to enable him to gerrymander the whole country so that people in some areas will have 40 per cent more representation than people in other areas. These are the figures; that is the mathematics; that is the purpose of it.
Comment on this
That is the power the Bill gives to the Commission. It requires them to achieve convenient areas of representation related to the population contrast and the ratio of population per square mile of the constituency. It gives them the power and, by implication, the encouragement to exercise it—it is, perhaps, even a legal requirement—to give up to 40 per cent more representation in some parts of the country than others, to give representation two and a half times as great as that required on a population basis in order to equate the electorate, which the Minister said was the objective, in order to equate the value of a vote in the city to a rural vote.
As the Minister said:
I trust that Senators will endorse the principle of one man, one vote of equal value which is inherent in the proposals in the Bill.
Our amendment, if adopted, would make one man, one vote on an electorate basis inherent in the proposals in the Bill. It is not inherent now because the Bill requires the Commission to go far beyond that, giving perhaps two and a half times as much representation to people in some areas as in others, giving people because of their place of residence, 40 times more representation than people in other areas.
The Minister throughout laid great stress on this electorate principle, until exposed, until smoked out, until I presented him with the figures which I challenged him to deny, which was that this principle can be implemented within a tolerance of eight per cent, which I think is acceptable, that this can be achieved, breaching county boundaries in only three cases. There were only three cases where parts of counties would have to be put on to other counties, those three counties being Meath, Tipperary and Leitrim.
The Minister has made no reply to my point. I have given him the figures, constituency by constituency, but he has sedulously avoided dealing with them. All he has to say is that this is a guess on my part. It is not a guess, any more than any projection on solid material is a guess, any more than the Government's own work in relation to the economic programmes, in relation to their capital programme and in relation to any other calculation of that kind is a guess. In fact, it is less so here because I am concerned not with projecting into the future but simply using data in respect of the constituencies in calculating the variation between population and electorate.
The number of cases where there is divergence between county and constituency is relatively small. There are only at present seven cases where portion of one county attaches to another county. The number of population concerned is small. Therefore, the degree of error possible in such a calculation —even one carried out thoughtlessly— would necessarily be small. In any event, as the divergence between those ratios is in most cases between neighbouring counties very small, even if the job were done crudely, the degree of error would necessarily be small. I am quite prepared to be corrected. The Minister has in his Department information on the electorate in every county. If I am wrong to any degree, he will not hesitate to challenge me. If he does not do so, I can take it that my point is proven.
The Minister has said that I said the only factor affecting this distortion was the question of the number of children in a family. I did not say anything of the kind. This is the main factor. There are other factors, such as people in hospitals, but as between constituencies this is not a major factor. Nevertheless, what I was saying — the Minister misquoted me here—was that a case could be made for the population basis on the ground that it gave effective extra representation for families. I did not endorse such a case. In fact, I opposed it by putting down this amendment to say it should be on an electorate basis, accepting the Minister's theory which he does not believe himself. The Minister accuses me of favouring extra votes for families and proposing this. I merely said such a case is arguable: I do not argue it. I accept the Minister's theories about electorate, but he will not accept them when they are proposed. He dodges away from his theories because this does not give him an excuse for this distortion of the population which he thought, if he got away with it, it would give him. He did admit in his remarks that my proposal is much nearer to one man, one vote. It is not much nearer to it: it is one man, one vote.
Comment on this
The Minister said the proposal was much nearer to one man, one vote. I think the record will confirm that. If the Minister doubts me, I will not press this. As regards his arguments for not accepting the electorate, I never heard anything less convincing. He said this was considered by the Government—the first time we have been told that—but that the census was more scientific and carried more authority than the electoral register figures. This is indeed true to some degree. But I would not have thought that the difference is of any significance, as the electorate who vote are the electorate on the register. It seems odd that the register is good enough for people to vote on but not good enough to distribute seats on. It is a remarkably illogical non sequitur.
I would have no difficulty in modifying my amendment if the Minister does not like the electoral register for this purpose—the register his Department is responsible for drawing up— and taking instead the census of the population over 21 or, and I will endorse Senator Quinlan's amendment, of the population over 18. If the Minister has this confidence in the census, as distinct from the figures prepared in his own Department, I am prepared to accept that. The argument that you cannot use the electorate on the ground that the electoral register figures are not reliable does not stand. Let us take the census figures for people over 21, or preferably over 18, if Fianna Fáil are not afraid of the 18 to 21 age group, and we certainly are not. We would wholeheartedly support any proposal to franchise them because we know who would benefit at this time. The argument that the data are not available for this purpose is spurious and untrue. The data are available here from the electoral register or if the Minister prefers, from the census. I suggest the electoral register because it seems convenient and more relevant to an election because it is the people on the register who can vote. The fact that there may be more people entitled to vote if they are registered—the marginal error is small—is irrelevant for this purpose but if the Minister thinks it is important it can be done on the basis of population.
Would the Minister tell me on what grounds he is rejecting the electoral basis we propose? He gave no grounds in the course of his remarks and I can recall no other statement that he made relevant to this point at all. He has said that this principle of the electorate is an important one and he has asked us to endorse the principle of one man, one vote, of equal value, based on this concept of the electorate in a constituency. Then, once we accept that, he says: "No, that is not what I mean; I meant something else, something quite different on this issue." I think we should vote with the Minister on this and give him what he asked for. If members of his Party go the other way—they do not always agree with him—then the country can see who is in favour of an equitable system of election, one man, one vote, and to give a different ratio of electorate to population, and see who wants to rig the constituencies to their own advantage and who is not prepared to stand over his own statement, his own speech, his own endorsement of the system.
The Minister also said that our calculations are based on the assumption that the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill will be rejected. I must admit that is an assumption that I tend to favour and the most realistic one to work on in the light of the present state of public opinion, but in fact our calculations do not depend on this, because within the county area, the figures I have given for three, four, or five seat constituencies are within the Minister's tolerances and I have checked carefully to make sure that is so. The Minister, in the course of his speech the other day, named precise figures for the tolerances in three, four and five seat constituencies and I think he will find all my proposals fall within these limits. There is no quarrel between us on that. Therefore, if the constituency I propose is within these limits and it is divided up pro rata, we can see that there will be no problem about boundaries within the constituency being broken up by electoral divisions.
Comment on this
If the constituency is divided pro rata, then the individual one-seat constituency will be within the limits imposed.
Comment on this
The Minister has frequently used electoral divisions, especially in city areas, and broken them into units in which there may not be a population of more than 200 and has departed from traditional boundaries and established new boundaries arbitrarily which bore no relation to any past or present administrative division. There is therefore no significant problem and all the figures I have put forward are within the tolerance limits imposed and there should be no problem about subdivisions of this kind. In nearly every case, the tolerance involved gives ample leeway so that it should be possible to break up an electoral division if the Minister decides to do so. The Minister's statement that my calculations are based on the assumption that the Tolerance Bill would be rejected is as untrue as the rest of his arguments which I have refuted.
To recapitulate some of the things the Minister said: he said that if the widespread breaching of county boundaries was to be avoided it was obviously necessary to allow the population per member in constituencies to deviate to some degree from the national average. I have made a proposal which meets his point of view on the electorate and the breaching of county boundaries, since I do not think anybody could reasonably hold that three small pieces of three small counties being involved could be regarded as widespread breaching of county boundaries when it relates to less than ten per cent of the whole. Clearly the Minister is thinking of more than that. I have met him on that since my proposal would avoid it. The proposal also meets him on the question of the electorate which is a valid point on which he has now turned turtle and it would ensure that the balance throughout the country would in fact favour rural areas because my proposal gives Dublin less than it is entitled to on an electorate basis and gives the rest of the country more than it is entitled to on that basis.
Having met the Minister on every point other than his desire to have freedom to introduce a major distortion of his representations between the different parts of the country and totally undermine the principle of one man, one vote, I now propose that he accept the amendment, and if he does not do so, I think it will be our duty to vote for this amendment which meets all the Minister's wishes, but from which he has now run away like a frightened rabbit when he finds that he has been caught out in his attempted confidence trick.
Comment on this
——or to increase the value in some cases. The intention, as he knows, is neither of these things. It is to give a certain very small amount of scope to avoid inflicting on people in certain parts of the country the injustice of uprooting them from their own county or constituency in which they have always been and transferring them into another county or constituency. To avoid the injustice of having to do this at five-yearly intervals, moving them around——
Comment on this
It is not at twelve-yearly intervals because the Constitution says: "...at any time——"
Comment on this
Then, let us accept this amendment, and go back to the Dáil and then propose to delete that next time, and we can keep going back and forward between Dáil and Seanad, which is what Senators opposite would like, to keep on introducing revisions of constituencies, bringing them to the Dáil and the Seanad and then submitting them to the Supreme Court and allowing Senator O'Quigley to get some income from wrangling over them, then bring them back here and by a process of trial and error——
Comment on this
Senator O'Quigley was not in the Supreme Court on that case.
Comment on this
The intention of this Bill is to prevent injustice, in the main, the injustice of breaching county boundaries. As I pointed out, it is by a process of that kind that we move towards the general equation of the value of a rural vote with the value of an urban vote. That is inherent in these proposals, part of what they will do. It is not the objective of the Bill. The Bill is introduced as I showed, in response to demands made from all sides of the House when this injustice was inflicted on people in 1961 in a number of cases but not on a terribly widespread scale. It was sufficiently widespread to arouse from people who were affected——
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.