Finance (No. 2) Bill, 1968 (Certified Money Bill) :Second Stage (Resumed) and Subsequent Stages.
Contributions 113–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 37 of 1968 ›
I hope there will be a solid plank in the Fine Gael programme for the next election on the committee system. The third major dangerous tendency we see being adopted at the moment is the frightening increase in the dictatorial approach by the Civil Service. We are very conscious of this. Before I develop this theme might I say that we have in our Civil Service a great advantage to begin with, compared with other countries. By and large, owing to scarcity of comparable opportunities, we have been able to recruit a higher class personnel into our Civil Service than elsewhere, but we have not yet learned how best to use that valuable personnel.
Whether through default or otherwise civil servants in many Departments have come to regard themselves as the sole custodians of what you might call advanced thinking. There is general disappointment, in fact worse than disappointment, a sense of complete frustration at present consultation procedures used by civil servants.
Among the main offenders I list first of all the Department of Justice. It seems that every two years they present us with a brain child that has been conceived without consultation with the Law Society or any other responsible group that outrages public opinion. It then takes a tremendous force of public opinion to stop this. Public opinion has succeeded in one Bill, the Succession Bill, and I have every confidence that it will succeed in the appalling Criminal Justice Bill that is now being foisted on us.
No civilised country that prides itself in being a democratic country would tolerate present procedures in the Department of Agriculture and its relations with the main farming organisation in the country, the NFA. This is something that can be held as a principle. A Minister is expected to accept responsibility to the group he is expected to represent in the national picture. If after a reasonable time, say a year, or a year and a half, he has failed to achieve that position then it is high time, like Mr. Craig, that he, unceremoniously, be shifted. It is not the first time I have called for the removal of the present Minister for Agriculture.
In dealing with agricultural problems we have the rather facile approach that all too many take by saying that there are too many organisations in agriculture, especially the two groups contending, the National Farmers Association and Irish Creamery Suppliers Association. This ignores the fact that in every walk of life, whether it is the postmen or the teachers or any other group, we generally have a few different viewpoints and organisations and groups. Any organisation, whether they are from the trade unions, or the university or from agriculture must, before we accord them the right of being taken seriously, fulfil the criteria of a proper and adequate organisation. Perhaps one of the easiest ways of finding this out is to look at other countries and see what type of facilities are required by similar organisations in those countries: the extent of their office premises, staffing, and provision for dealing with the problems of the day. involving access to the necessary technical staff. Equally important is an examination of the democratic foundation on which the organisation is based.
If an organisation purports to represent a group then it must be democratic and it must show quite clearly the election procedure by which it is elected and we should study how these procedures have operated over the years and judge to what extent they have been truly democratic. I invite our national newspapers to let us have a factual survey under those headings of the two contending agricultural organisations in this country, the NFA and the ICMSA, so that the information will be put before the public, who can then judge the standing of each of those groups.
As regards the National Farmers Association, it can be said without doubt that their approach is as modern and efficient as the approach of the Belgian farmers, the Dutch farmers or any others. They are doing a good job and they are on efficient lines and their premises, though modest, are adequate. As far as democracy within the organisation goes one has only to look at the personalities in the organisation during the period of 12 years of its existence and find the healthy democratic fact that these personalities are constantly changing. They had Dr. Juan Greene as President in 1956 followed by Mr. Rickard Deasy and now Mr. T.J. Maher. The fact that these changes have been made in their presidency in a truly democratic manner is a healthy sign.
It is ridiculous for the Government to persist in their policy of trying to deny the NFA their rightful role in consultation and in advice on the formulation of agricultural policy. The NAC comes to mind. This has not been heard of now for the past two or three months and we hope that Irish agriculture has finished with that fiasco. There is now a new effort for 1969 called "Move", something concerned with promoting industrial efficiency and this is a highly laudable effort, but is it reasonable that the agricultural organisations and the co-operative movement should be denied representation and that agriculture is represented solely by one Fianna Fáil defeated Dáil candidate from Wexford? Surely that is not helping in any way to wipe the slate clean and to make a fresh approach as the Taoiseach recently promised. I think that the members of "Move" should show their displeasure with this politicking by inviting the NFA and the Co-operative movement to appoint representations to this body.
It is easy for the Taoiseach to talk of a fresh approach but we need some evidence of goodwill on the part of the Government and one effective way in which the Government could show this would be by the restoration of Government advertising in the Farmers' Journal. Advertising is being withheld from a paper because it “dares” to criticise Government policy. What is the difference in the issues that are being fought for regarding civil rights in Northern Ireland and the situation here? Where is the bigness, or indeed the sincerity, of the Taoiseach in wiping the slate clean if his first action is not to restore agricultural advertising in the Farmers' Journal and to do away with Government reprisals against that journal because it dares to criticise Government policy? What price the freedom of the press when such Government discrimination is practised? Surely this is elementary democracy.
I wish to refer to the development of the co-operative movement. This year the Government have given no increase whatsoever to the IAOS in the Estimate despite the fact that there is now an urgent need for rationalising the production of dairy products and that the co-operative movement is the only answer to the efficient and economic survival of our small farms.
The co-operative organisation of small farms, on the one hand, would meet the psychological needs of the local small farmer in that he would still make all the decisions on the utilisation of his farm, and, on the other hand, would enable him to carry work more efficiently, as a member of a co-operative group. Work in groups is obviously more acceptable than working alone and a co-operative group would have the service of modern machinery and could provide the necessary relief help so that the small farmer of the future would no longer be a slave to his job. If he wished to take a week's holidays, or if he needed an evening off, he could make arrangements with the co-operative relief unit to have the milking done. This is the type of development that is required to save our small farms. It means that the owner of the small farm would spend a good deal of his time working in the co-operative group. There would then be a balance between payment for his services and charges made for services rendered on his own farm, and this balance would most likely be in favour of the small farmer.
This would also provide a measure as to whether there is unused time and unused labour on small farms and, if that were found to be so, efforts would be made to remedy it by part-time industries in the local co-operative centre. Whether we are preparing to go into Europe or not, the co-operative movement is the only way for us to approach the years ahead. It is either co-operation or extermination.
We note that the amount in the Estimate for the farm apprenticeship scheme is £11,500 and when great sums of money are being spent on other forms of apprenticeship, we must ask ourselves if it is reasonable to think that training for our major industry, and the recruitment of its skilled personnel, merits only a sum of £11,500. I am saddened when I think of the intense voluntary effort and time that many of us in the 1950s put into discussion on the farm apprenticeship scheme and to see the mini-scheme that has emerged from all our efforts.
I hope the Government, even at this late stage, will look at agricultural development in the light of the 1970s rather than in the light of Party politics.
On the question of local government I must ask why the recommendation of the Conciliation and Arbitration Tribunal on engineers' salaries has not been implemented. This was a very modest award and I believe that it was accepted by most of the bodies concerned yet the order has not yet been made. Why is this so? We must realise the great contribution that the engineering profession has made to this country and we must realise, also, that most of our engineers are working here for a considerably lower salary than they could command in England or elsewhere.
I ask the Government, therefore, not to trade too much on their goodwill but to give them the elementary justice that was recommended by the Conciliation and Arbitration Tribunal.
With regard to education, I must join with the Senators who spoke previously in congratulating the Government and the Minister on the steps that have been taken, even if they are small ones, on the democratisation of education in opening up additional opportunities for the less fortunate. However in this regard not nearly enough credit is given to the devoted teachers, and to the parents who struggled against all forms of difficulties, and who were jointly responsible for the education of so many generations. Like myself most of us would not have got our education were it not for the good will and the devoted teaching of the Christian Brothers. However, there is a difference between democratisation of education and democracy in education. Many people have called for industrial democracy and I think that is long overdue but I do not intend dwelling on this here. Surely, however, educational democracy is at least as important as industrial democracy. Industrial democracy means, by and large, that the workers concerned are recognised and that their contributions are recognised and that they have their proper say in management. The same is required in education. Teachers and all those associated with schools should be recognised as people who have had long experience in the field of education and, therefore, that they have a valid and indispensable contribution to make to the shaping of education in the future, just as they have done in the past.
Looking at our university situation it is easy, as previous speakers have said, to say that there is a deplorable division in university education. I do not think that is so. There is an understandable conflict of opinion and naturally there are many conflicting ideas that are gradually being sifted but that is not something for which to apologise. But what any reasonable person should rightly deplore is the fact that the opinion held by more than 75 per cent of the teaching staff in UCD and TCD is dismissed by the Minister and his advisers as mere self-interest. Evidently in the modern age the only puresouled spirits in the academic world are the Minister, his Civil Service advisers—who never taught in a university—and the handful of academics, who see eye to eye with them.
It is appalling to think of a Minister for Education in this country flying off to New York for the sole purpose of denigrating the overwhelming majority of the staff of our Irish universities, as mere self-seekers, as Mr. Lenihan did in his recent address to the NUI graduates in New York. That is something that should not be tolerated and I asert that the staff concerned are no more self-seeking than any other group in the country, least of all the Minister and his power hungry bureaucrats.
I should, of course, pay tribute to the merger in so far as it has had a tremendous impact on the university scene and has caused some real rethinking on university affairs. These can never be the same again. Even though I disagree very strongly with the tactics used by Mr. O'Malley in introducing the merger without any semblance of consultation I think it has now brought the various faculties, colleges and universities together in a spirit that is really stimulating and beneficial and offers excellent prospects for future co-operation and rationalisation.
Comment on this
I do not think that the members of any university are against rationalisation. All are interested in doing the job they have been trained to do for the betterment of this country. I would recommend the members of this House to study the document produced by the Irish Federation of University Teachers which was published extensively in the papers. It is an excellent document, very closely reasoned, and it came out decisively in favour of four co-operating universities. Of course, that is what we want. It is not a question of whether Dublin is too small for two universities. It is rather a question of whether the country is too small for three universities; one in Dublin, one in Cork and one in Galway, not to mention Limerick, whatever today's enigmatic announcement really means.
Many hold that the country is too small for three universities and what is required is that the university resources of the country shall be organised, based on four independent universities, cooperating together under a Higher Educational Authority entrusted with much the same power and duties exercised at present by the university grants committee in England in their highly successful work in rationalising their complex university system.
There is scarcely one single subject, at post-graduate level, which is covered adequately in the country as a whole between all university centres, much less is it covered adequately at any one of these centres. We all know we have been gravely deficient in resources in the past in every centre, and consequently the post-graduate work in any subject has had to be restricted to one or two facets of the subject. It so happens that most of those facets are fortunately complementary and can be co-ordinated and expanded into providing an adequate subject coverage between all institutions.
For instance, on taking the situation in the subject I know best, applied mathematics, which is quite a wide ranging subject, UCD is mainly on quantum mechanics and relativity, TCD specialises in elemenary particles and statistics, while in Cork the emphasis has been on computer based applied mathematics with applications to Engineering and Physics, and UCG could easily develop into the Fluid Mechanics centre for the country. It would consequently be easy on the above foundation for the four centres to be developed to continue to be complementary to one another so that between the four centres they would cover, not all the fields of applied mathematics, but probably enough for the country for the next 10 to 15 years. If it became obvious at any time that some other field needed to be developed, either the HEA, or more probably some existing school would see the necessity for it and would seek the necessary resources required to carry out a major faculty development. This would entail consulting the Higher Education Authority on the necessary financial resources, and thereby cause the projected major developments to be discussed, evaluated, and modified in the light of national requirements, since unless funds were given for it it would not be possible to proceed.
Every other subject, as far as I can see, would be more or less the same. At present there are civil engineering faculties in all four places, TCD, UCD, Cork and Galway. But this is only superficial duplication, because graduate and national demands in civil engineering comprise the very separate specialities of: environmental engineering, traffic engineering, structural engineering and hydraulic engineering. And in fact, by and large, the existing centres already show the nuclei of these specialisations, and it would be relatively easy to arrange that our four civil engineering faculties developed these specialities in a co-ordinated manner, to provide an adequate coverage for the country. Then, having got this rationalisation, one may ask: "Would it continue and would it not infringe on the autonomy of the university?"
In the case of any of our universities if a chair of physics falls vacant, the university does not simply advertise a professorship of the university, it advertises a chair of physics. They would be more specific in English and American universities, as they would describe exactly the branch of the subject required. That then is what we need in the future. If we agree on sharing our resources on a national basis then we obviously can and must ensure that this is not negatived by any subsequent unilateral action by any university. Having determined, say, the siting of a particular branch of applied mathematics in a certain university we would have to agree that it could not be drastically altered without the approval of the Council of Irish Universities or through the Higher Education Authority. This would mean that students in their final year, at any centre, if they displayed a very strong bent for a division of the subject which was not catered for, as a speciality, at that centre, could take their grants and go to the corresponding speciality centre, and graduate there.
I cannot understand what all the fuss is about in doing what is a relatively simple rationalising job. When it comes to rationalisation the country must be considered as a whole, not just Dublin alone. It is ludicrous to see the Minister appearing on television talking about the fact that we cannot afford two schools of engineering here in Dublin, and presenting the choice before us as either one first-class school or two third- or fourth-rate institutions. The following day he rushes down to Galway and tells them what wonderful fellows they are and promises them first-class faculties, including their Engineering School, of course. And the fact is that the UCG School of Engineering, without the slightest disrespect to it, is less viable at the moment than either of the schools in UCD or TCD.
The same applies to the all faculties whether in Cork or Galway. Unless we co-ordinate and develop our resources at national level, it means that Cork and Galway are living in a fool's paradise if they take ministerial assurances seriously that they will get the resources to develop their existing professional schools and keep them viable. We can develop first-class facets of existing professional schools, if properly co-ordinated into the national framework; otherwise our professional schools will be like the former branch lines of CIE, living in suspended animation, until the time is politically opportune for their closure. We look to the universities having broadly similar constitutions where the academic representatives constitute the majority of the board...
Comment on this
Some of us have less bishops than others.
Comment on this
When it comes to that I think we will no longer have the deplorable situation where the board wants one policy and the majority of the academic staff wants another and the board insist on its policy. Such an insistence by the board seems to me to be in conflict with the acceptance that academic representatives should constitute the majority of the board. I would also like to appeal to many of our academic colleagues who constituted a small minority in favour of the present merger. They have had a good opportunity of putting forward their point of view, they have done it very excellently, but I appeal to them now to accept the voice of the majority and go along with them.
Comment on this
Is this in fact true? Does the governing body of UCC abnegate its duty to govern UCC?
Comment on this
I am not speaking of the constitutions of the moment but of the future constitutions. Our academics will be in the majority on the future governing bodies and surely they will have the ruling voice in the future, and consequently should now carry greater weight than any outdated board.
Comment on this
The Senator has been appealing to the academics who disagree with the existing bodies to shut up.
Comment on this
You cannot leave it all to the teachers. Education is too important a matter to leave to the teachers just as war is too important a matter to leave to the generals.
Comment on this
There is also the question of our five medical faculties. I suggest that if we find we have more places in the medical faculties than we reasonably need we should make those places available to foreign students at an economic fee. If we do that we will be developing an education industry which is a type of industry to which we are particularly suited in this country. I would welcome up to 25 per cent of foreign students in our medical faculties if places were available for them, if they paid an economic fee.
Comment on this
This is what the College of Surgeons in Dublin are doing.
Comment on this
Yes, and they deserve to be congratulated on it and they have received little encouragement from the Government for doing it. If every foreign student brings in at least £1,000 per annum in fees and in living expenses, he is as valuable as a worker in a high-class industry that would require capital at about £5,000 per worker. If someone suggested an industry to provide employment for 500 people the Government would rush to give grants to such an industry. Why not look at the education industry—and in particular the medical industry— in the same way and at the same time do a worthwhile service to the outside world, and a profitable business for the nation.
The only really authoritative body that sat on university affairs in recent years was the Commission on Higher Education which took six years at its deliberations. The Report of that Commission is an excellent document, very well presented and the names of the signatories are of course appended for all to see. There are the names of Professor Carter, Professor Hutchinson and others, men of international standing who looked at our situation and recommended a solution of four universities co-ordinated by the various councils they proposed. We will find in the future that they were not far wrong in their recommendations. It is my opinion that the merger discussions have created a climate where these recommendations can be more profitably implemented so that we will have not lost anything if the Government now accept the Commission solution. I would like to see that this Commission be given the recognition that it deserves.
Then we have the question of students' grants which we debated here some months ago. While we might have liked the Government to be more liberal these grants have contributed somewhat to the number of entrants in the current year. This year the number is about 1,100 as compared with 275 last year, an increase of roughly 800. Probably 400 of that 800 would have come anyway, so that we might estimate that the actual number coming in because of these students' grants is about 400.
However, I am worried about our piecemeal approach to these matters. The Government rightly introduced grants for university students to help bright students to go to the university but appears to have forgotten that these students were the main recruitment source for the Civil Service, the ESB, the banks and the semi-State organisations. What is now the official Government recruitment policy for those bodies? Where now is the main recruitment to the Civil Service to begin? It is high time that we had a drastic change which would establish main recruitment to the Civil Service at past degree level to replace the former recruitment at the honours leaving certificate level. The new entrant to the Civil Service would benefit greatly by having spent three or four years in the university and so would be able to make an improved contribution to the Service. We need a policy on that as a matter of urgency.
We also need a Civil Service recruitment policy which will involve our honours graduates and university staffs more intimately with the workings of the Civil Service and the other semi-State bodies. We need an imaginative programme of short-term secondment to those bodies. Up to this there have been just a few cases of secondment but it is not nearly enough. I would like to feel that in most planning and development units within the Civil Service at least 25 per cent of the personnel would be on loan from outside institutions and thereby they would be able to bring the freshness of an outside point of view to bear on deliberations. Likewise, I would like to urge as I have done in the past that senior civil servants be given time to think. They should be given sabbatical leave to get away from their desk for six months or a year every five or six years to an English, American, or Irish university, or into a business, or other institution so that they could study in a changed environment and have time to reflect on what they are doing. If this imaginative scheme were introduced it would develop out Civil Service manpower in a flexible, efficient and modern way.
I have mentioned the lack of consultation in various bodies. This has come to a head in the development branch of the Department of Education and we need to look critically at that branch before it gets completely out of control. The branch arose out of the recommendation in the Report on Investment in Education, and it has emerged it has largely aborted all that was hoped for in that Report. I quote from page 153 of the Report where it says:
In our opinion there should be created in the Department of Education a new post of Assistant Secretary, the occupant of which would be directly responsible to the Secretary of the Department for long-term planning work, for considering policy matters in general and, in particular, to be responsible for directing the findings of the professional staff of the development unit into the administrative system of the Department.
It was not the development unit that was to be responsible for policy, its proper task was to provide the relevant specialist material for the administrative system. The recommendation continues:
The officer should, of course, have considerable experience in educational matters and a capacity for administration at a high level. But, equally necessarily, he would require special qualities for the new challenging task of being responsible for an educational development unit staffed by professional personnel. He should have an independent, enquiring, critical, creative mind, a thorough acquaintance with educational theory and practice, and an appreciation of the need for a quantitative approach where this is applicable. He should have the virtue of detachment of a very high degree and a lack of commitment to the status quo.
If any Senator has read the recent issue of Studies he will realise how far the development unit has deviated from these high hopes. First of all, it has become just another section of the Department. The recruitment was not carried out as suggested in this; the primary emphasis in selecting the chief officer should have been on education, requiring a thorough acquaintance with education in theory and practice. This would require having spent long periods in the actual practice of education and probably having degrees in education. These are the standards that are required in Northern Ireland, in England and in North America and in Holland for similar posts. If there is any place in which skill, experience, and involvement in educational practice and theory is required it is surely within the development branch.
I would recommend to Members of the House to read and study Mr. O'Connor's paper in the autumn issue of Studies and the comments made by various people on it. It is frightening in many of its implications. It shows that the unit is completely on the wrong track and needs to be controlled, redirected and reorganised. Mr. O'Connor makes the claim that Mr. B. Lenihan has recently announced “an agreed” proposal for a revised structure of the Leaving Certificate programme. This needs to be understood carefully because it is the kernel of the problem. It involves the pseudo consultation which takes place between this unit and practical educationalists. So, the proposals are given to us as “agreed proposals” according to Mr. O'Connor.
I have had a good deal of practical experience in this and I know how false this claim is but better perhaps to quote from Professor Denis O'Donoghue on this. He was a distinguished member of the Syllabus Committee. On page 287 of Studies of autumn, 1968, he says:
As the Senate representative on the English Syllabus Committee I was appointed to help in revising the Leaving Certificate syllabuses and examinations for that subject. Our terms of reference were acceptable; we were to submit detailed proposals for two syllabuses, an Ordinary Course and a Higher Course, the names euphemistically changed from the present Pass and Honours, which are deemed to be democratically offensive. These terms of reference guided our work in the Committee for about a year. On 4 April, 1968, however, a decision was taken by the Department which deleted the arrangement for Ordinary and Higher Courses. This decision was conveyed to the members of the Syllabus Committee on the 17th of May. We were now to start again, and to prepare a single syllabus which would serve the diverse purposes of a Common Paper and, for those students who might choose to take it, an Additional Paper. This arrangement was denounced by every member of the Syllabus Committee; we considered it a retrograde decision, calculated to reduce the amount of literature taught in the schools and to depress the standard of teaching in English. A similar arrangement for Irish was rejected by the Irish Syllabus Committee: in that case, every member of the Committee resigned. I shall not rehearse the dreary experience of the English Committee. It is enough to say that in the end the Department won; not by convincing the teachers, but by refusing to entertain any argument against the proposals. As an example of dialogue, communication, reasoned discussion, the episode was grotesque. At that stage, I resigned. I was quite certain that I could exert no influence whatever upon a Department so enamoured of its folly.
Comment on this
So apparently we are using different words altogether when we deal with Government Departments on what constitutes consultation and what constitutes an agreement. Unless we can rectify that, can we still claim to be a democratic society? What is a democracy? It is certainly not a state ruled by the Civil Service without any reference to the people concerned. It seems to me that while the people of the North are demanding their civil rights we here have equally pressing need to demand our vocational rights. I am weary of hearing vocational groups pilloried as being self-seeking and almost anti-national because they have the courage to stand up for their views against official "know-all". Evidently the faceless experts know all about every subject. That is not democracy. That is not the way we should go into the 70's. We need at this stage a complete development of the committee system, as such reprehensible pseudo consultation tactics could not be got away with if we had an adequate committee system. It could not happen if we had an Oireachtas Education Committee. We would then have Civil Service officials across the table and would also be able to question and hear experts who had experience in and whose names are known for their commitment to education. We could decide between them and steer our educational policy accordingly.
This article is most infuriating to read at times. It speaks in highly derogatory terms of the syllabus for primary and secondary schools in the past. On page 241 of the Article it says:
We have buried without regret the Primary Certificate examination. Let us now bury again without regret, the present National School Curriculum.
Again we have, speaking about examinations:
They are achievement tests, or, more accurately, memory tests, and their form is totally unrealistic, particularly in the language area.
In other words it makes a devastating criticism of the existing syllabus in both primary and secondary schools. But then who has been responsible for keeping that syllabus there? Is it not the handiwork of the Department of Education itself? The whole tone of the article is that the reformers of the Department of Education have now taken over, and that all these defects in syllabi and elsewhere are due by innuendo to the religious in these schools, to the manager, and to secondary teachers but not, of course, to the Department of Education, whereas anyone with any knowledge of trying to make a change in any syllabus knows how impossible it was to persuade the Department to do this at any time. The examinations have always been set by the Department's inspectors. If there are faults in the curriculum these faults have been largely due to the fact that the Department of Education has not listened to the progressive ideas that came up from the ordinary rank and file of teachers down through the years. Let us have change by all means but let the Department be the first to say "Mea culpa" for the deficiencies of the system and its absurdly underfinanced condition.
Like this derision by Mr. O'Connor for examinations is not well founded. Having had experience over 30 years of examinations, as man and boy, I can see it brings out the best in a student provided the examination is set intelligently. It makes the student gather his material and present it in the proper way. It is a necessary part of student development. I deplore very much the passing of the Primary School Certificate. It could have been altered and improved but getting rid of it was a retrograde step. I speak from personal experience of two daughters, one of whom sat at the end of her Sixth Class in the primary school for the last Primary Certificate and the other the following year did not have to do public examination. I see the comparison in their application to study; one felt there was an examination to be done, she studied and applied herself while the other had no public examination to face and did not make the same effort and had no need to accumulate here facts or engage in extensive revision. We should be very slow to copy too slavishly the American system. Yet it seems to be the motivating force behind the present changes.
Comment on this
Was not the Primary Certificate abolished on the wishes of the teaching profession?
Comment on this
It could have been improved. Life is one series of tests and we cannot educate children into believing that real tests need not be faced in life.
Comment on this
It was the Department listening to the teaching body. We must be truthful on these things.
Comment on this
Practically all educational authorities have rejected the new grouping system introduced into the Leaving Certificate, and see it as an effort to water down the Leaving Certificate so that any student will get through. It might reach the ludicrous stage where we might have to pass an Act of Parliament to ensure that every Irish child is born with his Leaving Certificate attached to him and having got that wonderful equipment we might then proceed to have some real educational objectives in our secondary schools. But the present position in regard to university autonomy is very disturbing, especially as Mr. O'Connor's idea is apparently to try to force the university to accept as matriculation subjects, all the subjects of the leaving certificate.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connor in his article states, concerning entrance examinations, that the National University accepts for matriculation only those subjects in which courses are offered in the university. That is a surprising statement from a man in Mr. O'Connor's position. The university accepts subjects for matriculation that involve courses of study that are comparable to other accepted matriculation subjects and are designed to benefit students coming into the university. For instance, we accept students for matriculation in many of the languages for which we do not have courses like Dutch, Hebrew, Japanese, etc. As university teachers, we must claim that we are concerned with the examinations of incoming students, that we have a right to express opinions on these, and have them respected.
I wish to refer to the position of education statistics because it unfortunately is the case that statistics can be taken and used in an attempt to bolster any case. Therefore, it is highly desirable that our educational statistics should come from a central independent body. Like all statistics, these should come from the Central Statistics Office. If the development unit wants to have a statistician for the purpose of interpreting those figures, that is their business. In fact, it is probably useful to have a statistician on it but I call for the return of the compilation of educational statistics to the Central Statistics Office.
In conclusion, I wish to say that the greatest work that has emerged from the development unit has been that the pressurised tactics that have been applied to school managers and to school teachers have united these in a way that is remarkable. If we have the managers and the teachers fully co-operating, I believe that there is great hope for the future and I would suggest that they continue as rapidly as possible with the formation of parent/teacher groups, or local community groups attached to the schools because these are the people who know what is involved in education. Undoubtedly all will co-operate with the Department of Education but let them insist, loud and clear, that they will not be serfs of the development unit of the Department. We commend our secondary teachers and managers and we assure them that we are aware of the contribution they are making to education and assure them of our support and understanding. We call for an investigation by the Government into the activities of the development unit and we ask them to let us have democracy not only in industry but also in education.
Comment on this
Without referring to the froth of the past two and a half hours, we shall get down to serious matters and there are a few comments I should like to make arising out of the discussions that have taken place on this Bill, with particular reference to the statements of Senator Garret FitzGerald on one or two items.
Comment on this
By the way, may I take this opportunity to congratulate Senator Garret FitzGerald on the fact that we can now refer to him as Doctor FitzGerald and to say that I am very glad indeed to be able to do so.
Comment on this
However, in spite of this distinction, I find myself compelled to admonish him. Both he and Senator Sheehy Skeffington were desperately frustrated by reason of the fact that the motion which they had down on Biafra was not discussed. I thought that the Senators might have passed me a vote of thanks instead of criticising me for the fact that the motion had not been discussed, in view of the developments that have taken place in Biafra and about which light is now beginning to appear through the clouds of press distortion that have befogged the issue during the past two years.
Senator FitzGerald is very anxious about this matter and thinks it is of vital importance that the war be brought to a conclusion. No doubt we all find ourselves in agreement with that, but anything that we could do here to bring the war to a conclusion is unknown to anybody but Senator Garret FitzGerald.
Comment on this
Senator FitzGerald probably has no recollection of a civil war that occurred in another country some time back.
Comment on this
I am talking about the civil war that occurred in Spain when a policy of non-intervention was adopted by the Government; but, despite that, large sections of the people disagreed, and the result was that on the one hand, contingents of young Irishmen joined the forces of Republican Spain while, on the other, contingents led by General O'Duffy joined the Insurgents who were led by Franco. There followed the unhappy position in which Irishmen were on different sides of the line at the battle on the Guadalquiver river.
Many Irishmen were killed in that battle and it was, indeed, a sad experience. This country gained nothing from it. But the lesson to be learned from that and from various other wars that have occured since then is that we, as a small nation, should keep our noses clean and keep out of the quarrels which arise in other parts of the world, particularly in Africa, because in Africa since the end of the Second World War there have emerged 24 or 25 independent African states. Those African States have banded themselves in a league of African nations called the Organisation of African States presided over by Emperor Haile Selassie of Ethiopia. It is their business to see to it that peace and contentment reign on the African continent. They have accepted that as one of their responsibilities without any great success but nevertheless they are the people directly concerned in the maintenance of peace.
Comment on this
I will deal with Vietnam if the Senator wishes. We should keep our noses out of Vietnam.
Comment on this
That is a completely different situation. If the Senator wants a debate on Vietnam we can have it. I am trying to make a statement. I did not interrupt the Senator until very late in his contribution when he asked questions. I do not like this business of question and answer. It reminds me too much of a pub. We are not in a pub here. However, it is the business of the Organisation of African States to look after the peace and happiness of those African nations and they would do a good job if the meddlers kept out of it, but the meddlers will not keep out of it. I am not referring to meddlers in this country but to meddlers in other countries. If those meddlers kept out, the people on that continent would ultimately solve their own problems.
Unfortunately, the Organisation of African States have not met with any great success. A recent attempt by Emperor Haile Selassie at a peace conference, at which both sides in the Nigerian civil war were present, did not succeed because of the undoubted intransigent attitude of the Biafran delegation. Since then, the veil of secrecy, a veil which constituted a curtain against news, has lifted slightly and we now find a totally different picture to the one presented by the energetic letter writers in the evening papers in Dublin and Cork and some of the religious journals circulating here. We find that the Nigerian hierarchy have decided objections to some of the things emanating from this country and some of the statements made here. We find that an international committee which inquired into the allegations of genocide on the part of the Nigerian Federal Forces, and which included Communists, Catholics and Presbyterians as well as people of no faith at all, found there was no truth whatever in the allegation that the Ibos were going to be massacred by the Federal troops when they had conquered Biafran territory.
We find also that the efforts to bring in food, in which the Irish people have been generous and in which the Irish Red Cross have played no small part, have been hampered not alone by the war situation on the Nigerian battlefront but also by the Biafran authorities. There is no use in anybody trying to paint a picture of one side being all sin and the other one angelic.
Comment on this
It is time we put an end to the nonsense that has been circulated during the last year about our intervention in the Nigerian war. If we leave them alone they will fix their own business. That is good policy. We should leave them alone.
Comment on this
That question, I am afraid, is part of the propaganda which has been issued by interested agencies. It is not based entirely on facts. If the Senator reads, as I am sure he does, some of the international papers, he will find statements there which completely contradict the bias he has in regard to this matter.
Comment on this
Another thing also which has emerged, and which is of distinct importance in this connection and in connection with the Nigerian affairs, is the statement issued by all religious houses who have missionary fathers and religious in Nigeria and Biafra insisting that no political statements were made committing their orders to do anything in relation to one side or the other and urging the people to be very careful in what they said about the situation in that country, which is regarded as missionary territory. I would therefore think we should cast our eyes around our country here and not be worried too much about Nigeria.
Senator FitzGerald wanted us to satisfy our own people that we are doing something to cope with the situation. We are doing something. We are sending as much food as we possibly can, and as much practical help as we can give. I think that is the best contribution we could make to the situation there.
Comment on this
(Longford): We could do what Mr. Burke did. He resigned from this House and went out.
Comment on this
I think it was Senator Murphy or Senator Garret FitzGerald who suggested the Minister for External Affairs should get advisers on the Nigerian war. The former Senator Burke would be very useful in that context. He would, with his wonderful knowledge of the country, be a useful man. They want us to do something. My suggestion is to do nothing more than we are doing, supplying food and clothing, which is something we are allowed to do.
Senators Murphy and FitzGerald shared the same view that there is no crisis. For once they agreed with the Taoiseach on that matter. Senator Murphy admitted in his speech on jobs and employment that the Government had made some progress in providing employment but he complained that it was too slow and that it does not meet with the situation. There is no doubt in the world about it it is not easy to provide suitable employment. The aim undoubtedly should be full employment but it is not easy to do that even under the socialist form of Government they have in Great Britain. It has not been found easy to do so.
There is one thing we can do — this is something I spoke about before— and this is something in which Senator Murphy and the members of his movement are the key figures. It is to maintain the jobs of those who already have jobs and who are working in our factories and machine shops throughout the country, by insisting that every possible way in which they can assist in the distribution and purchase of quality Irish goods will be availed of to do so.
Unfortunately, trade unionists in many trade unions seem to be under the impression that it is their duty, by their I mean somebody else's duty, to find everything for them. It does not seem to them to be their duty to do anything to help the country except to maintain their unions in such a position of strength that they operate lightning strikes to the detriment of the country and their fellow workers. They can do something concrete and the fact that they can do so can be gleaned from their complete lack of interest and esprit de corps with regard to other workers. It is necessary now to propound this and to give a scandalous case which came before a trades council in this country only recently and which shows a complete lack of interest of the organised workers in a particular industry and their union to the responsibilities and duties they have to their fellow workers to help them to maintain their jobs.
In Drogheda a couple of weeks ago the cement workers there refused to accept Irish manufactures boots and demanded through their shop stewards that English-made boots be provided for them, 5,000 pairs of them, while at the same time workers in the Drogheda boot factories were on short time. If that is not a scandalous situation and if it does not show a complete lack of appreciation of their duty to their fellow workers I do not know what does. I suggest that this has happened in other parts of the country, but it has not got publicity mainly because the local newspapers do not attend these trades council meetings.
Comment on this
What I wish to emphasise is that the organised workers of this country under the control of the Irish Congress of Trades Unions number half a million and if they were given a direction, I do not say a suggestion, by the Congress and by their union heads to buy Irish manufactured goods which are of as good quality as anything imported, there is no doubt that thousands of extra jobs would be created and maintained in this country and no boot factories would be on short time in Drogheda or anywhere else in this country.
Senator Murphy assured me that they were doing something about this. I have been around somewhat since the last occasion I brought this matter before the House and I have seen all over the place, but particularly in Dublin and its suburbs, vast displays of English made and foreign goods while there are Irish goods just as good and just as cheap available. I blame the distributing trades and the merchants for the displays given to these goods but I also blame the Distributive Workers' Union for the manner in which their members employed in these shops pick out and offer foreign-made articles to the detriment of the home produced materials. Anyone who has conducted the experiment of asking for goods will know that I am telling the truth and this extends not alone to clothes but even to beer.
Anybody who takes a drink will realise that not only in the luxury lounge bars in hotels do you find this but you also find it in the ordinary pubs. If you ask for lager and do not specify the lager you want you will not be given Harp or even Carling, which is made in Cork and Belfast. You will be given an imported lager and charged accordingly. In many cases in the luxury bars if you do specify Harp you will be told that they only had a few on ice in the fridge and that they now have none left but that they have a very nice ZHB or other lager. In my opinion the barmen's union which is looking for better conditions for its members owe a duty to the people who are going to make is possible for them to have these better conditions by buying what they have to sell. There is no doubt that the ordinary barmen could do something about this whether or not the boss is in the shop. These are points which occur to me as a result of Senator Murphy's reference to the question of employment in jobs.
He spoke also of the need for fishery protection and said that we were not doing anything about it. That is nonsense. We have three corvettes. It is all right to sneer at these corvettes as some of the newspaper columnists and pundits do but they have done tremendous work and a very satisfactory job in dealing with foreign trawlers and poaching. If the Senator has in mind that they are not enough to cover all our coastal waters he is probably right, but the cost of adding to the naval service is so prohibitive that one wonders how something could be done. The cost of repairing and keeping these corvettes in action is no small matter but when the Senator's Government, as a Coalition, was in charge of this part of Ireland from 1954 to 1957 they had to face the question of these corvettes being laid up. But they did not buy new ones. They did the same as this Government has done, they had them refitted. At that time new corvettes could be got at a reasonable price, at a price at which they cannot be got now. I would like to hear some of the speeches if the Minister for Defence came into the Dáil looking for £6 million or £7 million to buy new corvettes adequately to protect the fishing industry around our coast. I think they would be the butt of every newspaper columnist in the country, apart from TDs. It is a question of priorities, as to what must come first.
Senators and Deputies would not agree that the protection of the fishery industry should take precedence over other things they have at heart. There is a much more serious problem, as I see it. From researches I have made, and the knowledge I have of the sea and of people who go down to it, it is quite obvious that voluntary recruitment of naval personnel is a complete failure. No matter if we had ten ships, the most modern ships afloat, we will not get by voluntary recruitment the officers and men to man our ships.
Comment on this
I put it to the House that even by paying them sufficiently here they can earn more on one transatlantic trip in the Mercantile Marine, on one of these long distance trips, than they could in six months here, no matter what pay you give them in the Naval Service. I do not see how you could do it.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that that is what you should do. If an estimate came up today for debate you would have a very decided objection to spending the money in that way.
There is one other point that emerged and on which I feel I must comment. Senator Murphy and Senator McQuillan referred to it. It was in regard to exports. We were told that we should not send all our goods to the British market. We should get further markets, as if that was something new, a new doctrine. We have been trying, and every Government of this country in the past have been trying their best, to get other markets on the understanding that putting all your eggs into one basket is nonsense and dangerous. We have been trying it. The Coalition Government tried it and the Free State Government before them tried it. There are at the moment brighter prospects in some of the foreign markets which are being investigated. To think that all you have to do is send a trade delegation out or appoint a public relations officer at an embassy and give a dinner and then you will get trade is moonshine.
Comment on this
Somebody did. You have to go and get trade. No country owes us a living and no country has much time for us unless we can give them something profitable which they will find will be of assistance to their own economy. It is not so easy. We have been hearing about this new salvation east of the Iron Curtain— and reference was also made by Senator McQuillan to the Bamboo Curtain. There is no such thing. Trade figures with Japan have shown an encouraging increase and since the Taoiseach's trip there and the negotiations for a proper Trade Agreement there is every possibility that we may do good business with Japan and equalise to a great extent our balance of payments there.
Looking at our trade figures with other countries they are not satisfactory. We are doing our best. I do not see how a miracle will happen. Beyond that there are combinations of nations which are now establishing common markets among themselves. Senator Garret FitzGerald told us that the Anglo Irish Trade Agreement was not worth signing. If he examines it again, in the cold light of day and away from the shroud of political propaganda, he will see we are getting something satisfactory under the Anglo Irish Trade Agreement. If he reads the export figures, in spite of the mass of figures he juggled this morning, he will find we did a lot better than the £4 million a year he claimed we got in the Anglo Irish Free Trade Agreement.
Senator McQuillan also boasted that nobody had mentioned the question of diplomatic relations with the east European countries until he suddenly discovered it. Might I recall to him that, three years ago in the Seanad, I advocated the formation of a diplomatic mission to Warsaw in Poland and that that mission would be the focal point for trade relations with the Soviet Union, Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Bulgaria? The response to that around the country was satisfactory. There was no objection. There are great markets there. I do not see why we should not get them. I had no ideological objection against our going east of the Iron Curtain. Being inquisitive I began investigations as to why all Governments did not go for this open market that was waiting. There were 100 million people east of the Iron Curtain waiting to buy our products. Then I discovered that Irish delegations which went to Warsaw and Prague since found that there is nothing easy at all in negotiating trade agreements there. You negotiate with trade export boards and, with all due deference to Senator Murphy and his nationalist effort, I must tell him that these boards are held on a tight rein by their Governments. It is not the same sort of thing as negotiating with an employer on whom you can walk out if you feel that you do not like his terms. While we should do everything we can to get these foreign markets, let nobody be under the illusion that they are rich plums waiting to be plucked off the trees. They are not. They are difficult to get. All we can hope is that, with the passage of time and with developments in political events abroad, these countries will find it useful to trade with us rather than some of the others with whom they are trading now. The Seanad would be well advised in that case, as in the case of Biafra and Vietnam, to keep their feet on the ground.
Comment on this
In this debate we are dealing mainly with problems that have arisen from the national mismanagement of our economy, particularly, with regard to the Budget of last April. Before I come to this point I should like to follow the line on which Senator Ó Maoláin concluded. That relates to our imports. The case has been made that the volume and the value of imports to this country for some time past has disrupted our balance of trade. The point I want to make is that we have been sending trade delegations abroad and we have valuable organisations here, such as Córas Tráchtála, finding export markets for our commodities.
A group of people who have contributed to the imbalance now under discussion are our importers. They import various commodities into this country and distribute them here. Of course, the Irish consumer purchases and uses those imported goods. I feel we have reached a stage when we should say to those importers that, if they wish to carry on business and make profits from this exercise, it is up to them to do their part in making some gesture towards balancing those imports against exports. They should be told, in relation to the volume of whatever commodity it is that they are importing, that it is up to them to go to the source of those imports, and find a market there for Irish goods which can be exported by that particular importer in order to balance out with imports.
Our importers are the people who are contributing very effectively to the imbalance we are discussing now. They should be made realise that. They should be asked to balance the imports for which they are responsible by seeking exports, pound for pound, ton for ton, unit for unit. At the moment those importers sit back and say that that is a matter for the Government, for CTT, for the various Government organisations and for the Department of Finance, whose job it is to try and balance trade between this country and other countries. We can no longer leave these busy importers sitting back looking for somebody else to keep the finances of this country in order. Every importer will have to be asked by the Government and these other organisations what he proposes to do in the matter of securing Irish export markets to balance our imports. It is a suggestion which may not be useful or which has, perhaps, been tried. I feel importers have a responsibility to the nation to make some effort towards creating a balance between imports and exports.
I will come to another point which I think is a useful one to make in this House and that is to impress on the farmers of this country the importance of being associated with an effective meat marketing board. They have a golden opportunity now of doing so. It may not have been impressed upon them properly, but it is important for them to make a substantial contribution towards the efforts of Cork Marts to acquire the meat processing plant which is now for sale. I suggest that because it brings the farmers closer to the consumers, which is a very important thing these days. If they succeed in acquiring this concern, it will mean that the farmers can now follow the calf right through the period of growing and finishing, of slaughtering and eventually canning. But when it has got that far, further handling has to be done. It has to be loaded, shipped, distributed and handed across the counter until it gets to the consumer's table. But if the farmers can follow it as far as the meat packing process, they are getting much closer to the consumer than at present.
At present a farmer brings a finished, or half-finished, beast to the market or fair and his part is ended. Other problems arise when the beast is sold. The farmers who have been campaigning for a long time for the establishment of a meat marketing board would be well advised now to contribute substantially towards the fund which will enable them to acquire this ready-made meat processing establishment in association with the Cork Marts, who are apparently the sponsors of this project. I think it will be a very worthwhile step for the farmers to take. I have mentioned this in case there are farmers who do not realise the importance of a meat marketing board or a meat marketing project because the trend is in that direction. The day is approaching when it will not be sufficient for a farmer to walk his livestock off the land, say "good-bye" to them and accept the cheque in return. It will be important for him to go more of the way towards the consumer. This he can do by becoming involved in this new meat marketing project.
I read the Taoiseach's speech in relation to our economic situation. I certainly took a very poor view of the trend shown. First of all, it appears that at present our expenditure is running at the rate of £7½ million above the Budget Estimates. I feel certain that there was a trick here on the part of the Government. I cannot believe for one moment that the Department experts were not in a position to warn the Minister for Finance last April about the various liabilities we would have to meet in the 12 months from the day on which that Budget was introduced last April. It could have been forecast. Reading the speeches that were made at that time in the Dáil, one speech after another pointed out that the Minister's Budget was not adequate to meet what the programme was during the coming financial year but the Minister tried to put them off by saying that the Budget was prepared on the best arithmetical basis on which the Department could prepare it.
He said that it was prepared with a view to achieving a balance. Imagine presenting a Budget and saying that it has been prepared with a view to achieving a balance when we find in this month of December that there is a mistake of nearly £15 million. I have no doubt that the Minister knew very well that this situation would be brought to bear and that is why he made a passing reference to the possibility that circumstances might cause a further Budget to be introduced— that Budget is the one we are discussing now—but the point I am making is that it is very bad to be tricking with our economy just for election purposes.
Obviously, at that time, the referendum was in mind—in fact, people thought that a general election must have been in mind when the Government could envisage the kind of gap there would be at the end of the financial year, having regard to the terms of that Budget. At the present time, the taxpayers of this small country are contributing almost £1 million a day in taxes and with that, almost £1 million a week is being paid in interest on the national debt that has accumulated during the years.
The fact that a small population such as ours has a national debt that incurs an interest charge of £1 million a week and this, in addition to the £1 million a day that it is costing to run this little country, requires us to take a serious look at the present situation, particularly in relation to the volume and value of our exports.
As I said earlier, I took a poor view of the Taoiseach's remarks when he was offering his excuses for this Budget. He took statistics and figures for 1956 and he spoke about the volumes and values in 1956 compared with volumes and values at the present time but when he was presenting this case, he did not say that £2 in 1956 was equal to £3 in 1968 in so far as purchasing power is concerned. That would cut down very much the figures and volumes that he used to bolster up his case and the excuses he was offering for the present situation and for the need to bring in this extra taxation.
There is a trick in it still, apparently, and that is that he has decided to escalate the volume of taxation at this stage so that, when the Budget of next year is presented, he will be then able to take credit for the revenue that he expects to get from these levels of taxation during the coming 12 months in order to distribute various favours and benefits thereby creating a situation that will cause the people to believe that there is affluence and prosperity all around. In those conditions then, he will call a general election. We can assume that the general election will take place in May or June of next year when the Budget debate has been completed and when, as I say, the population in general will have been impressed by the case the Government will have made.
We must also take cognisance of the fact that, while the Government were elected with a mandate in 1965, they were put to the test very recently in the referendum when they were defeated by more than a quarter of a million votes and that many of the people who voted against them on that occasion were people who voted for them in 1965.
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt but earlier I stopped another Senator from going back to the referendum and I am afraid I must do so now.
Comment on this
Well, as I say, there are plenty of other things to talk about. I should like to say that we have been given a very clear message from the youth of this country because a large number of those are people who have been put on the register since 1959. The Taoiseach has already said he has got the message.
Comment on this
At the moment, the Chair would like to hear the Bills being discussed.
Comment on this
The other matter to which I would like to refer is the general impression of wealth and well being that the Government are trying to create when, at the same time, we realise that old age pensioners, retired pensioners, disabled persons, unemployed persons and all persons on subsistence allowances, are not getting sufficient to make ends meet, particularly, when one takes into consideration the fact that £3 today is only equal to what £2 was worth in 1956 and when one remembers too, that 30 per cent of the population is keeping 70 per cent.
Comment on this
Yes, I shall comment on that, too, because it is very true and it is a very important matter. However, what I am getting at is that old age pensioners are getting less for a week's subsistence than what some of the Fianna Fáil front benchers would spend on their lunch on a Monday.
Comment on this
If the old age pensioners spent that amount of money on a Monday, they would not have anything for the remainder of the week. The proposals in relation to turnover tax will increase the cost of housing and the cost of furnishing houses and this, in turn, will make it more difficult for those people who are trying to set up homes. That is just one example of the wholesale tax. It will hit people in a very effective manner. There were 80,000 fewer working in 1968 than there were in 1956.
Comment on this
May I interrupt the Senator for a minute? Perhaps the Leader of the House would inform the Chair whether it is proposed to adjourn for tea?
Comment on this
No, I think we should proceed or we will be here late tonight. As far as I can see there are very few other speakers and we could finish in a reasonable time if we continue now.
Comment on this
In that case I propose to finish within five minutes. I was saying that there were 80,000 fewer people earning wages in 1968 than there were in 1956, the year held up so frequently by Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach to bolster up whatever case they have to make. In addition there are almost 60,000 registered unemployed persons which gives a difference of a total of 140,000. In that time 250,000 people emigrated and if they had not the unemployment situation would be still worse than what it is.
The final point I want to make is in regard to Standard European Time. It is time that a decision was reached in regard to this matter. We should be grateful to the Sunday Independent for the opinion poll which they carried out in relation to this change of time. The result was a clear message from those who replied to the question asked by the newspaper and it was that European Standard Time is not acceptable to a very large majority of people. I mention this because the opinion poll conducted by the Sunday Independent in relation to the referendum also resulted in a very clear message being given and if the message in regard to European Time is as clear as the other message it is time for the Government to realise that the change is not acceptable to the vast majority of people. I myself am in favour of the change, I think it is better, but in view of this message which we have received it should be decided as soon as possible to revert next year to the old arrangement. I am sure those who replied to the question took into consideration the possibility that school opening hours could be advanced by one hour. The Minister for Education mentioned this already. However it was not only parents who answered the question; the people in general have intimated that they want the new time abandoned in favour of the old time. It will, of course involve certain adjustments in relation to flight timetables and in relation to various activities across the water. I will conclude on that note.
Comment on this
I had not intended to intervene in this debate but if remarks of the type that have just been made are let go unchallenged it would not be in the public interest. You, Sir, have stopped references being made to the referenda but notwithstanding that they have been made. Therefore I feel entitled to say that the people have made their decision and that will be the law. They were entitled to make that decision just as any man in his private life is entitled to do what he wishes, be it for his own good or ill. May I also say with the utmost sincerity and the conviction of my heart and conscience that I believe one day the people will bitterly resent that decision.
Comment on this
The Senator must finish on that passing reference, we will not have a debate on it.
Comment on this
We have heard other nonsense spoken by the Senator who has just used the word. He spoke about the national debt as he called it as if it were something due by the people. Obviously he has not the least idea of what is meant by the national debt. If capital assets are to be created, be they factories, buildings, roads, machinery or goods, the money for them in the ordinary way is generated out of the people's savings who in the case of ordinary companies buy debentures, shares, stocks——
Comment on this
When those assets belong to the State, whether they be State-owned companies such as the ESB——
Comment on this
——buildings or airlines, various moneys advanced to or by housing authorities, or by local authorities, the various moneys advanced by the State by way of grants to hotels or industry or to our farmers—that is the capital of this country or portion of it. A further portion of the capital consists of the moneys people put on deposit in the post office or into saving certificates. These are the items which comprise the national debt.
Comment on this
If the Senator did know he would not have referred to it as a debt, he would have referred to it as an asset.
Comment on this
If the dividends paid by the ordinary manufacturing company are to be considered a liability so too the interest paid by the Government on national loans should be considered a liability. One therefore has to be very short of arguments when statements like that are made. Short of anything else to say, motives were introduced. The Budget as introduced last April met the anticipated requirements of the country as they then were.
Comment on this
The 11th round of wage increases was only then about to be introduced.
Comment on this
In the ordinary course of events, the demand for increases by the Civil Service follow, not anticipate, the increases demanded by the unions. In this case those demands anticipated the demands made by the unions. No sensible Government would, in these circumstances, have made provision for these increases by way of estimate or otherwise because to do so would be to pre-judge the settlement which would later be made.
Those increases involved an increase of £9 million in the cost of running this country. I do not say whether the increases were too large or too small. They were increases that were introduced in the ordinary way by the negotiating machinery that is in existence. I do say that possibly increases on a percentage basis are not the most desirable type of increases, because a man who gets £3,000 and is given an increase of 10 per cent receives £300; the man who gets £500 a year and is given a 10 per cent increase, receives only £50. Unfortunately in this country and in England trade unions and all sorts of organisations are so taken up with the bribes of various sections of the community that these differentials are introduced in this manner, and as a result the lower paid workers, relatively to the larger paid workers, are being underpaid. If future increases were not given on a percentage basis these differentials could be reduced. That accounts for £9 million of this extra £15 million in the Budget.
The remaining £6 million concerns extra subsidies to our farming community. The Senator who has just spoken is a member of that community. Does he feel that these extra subsidies should not be given? If so, it would be much more honest to say so.
Comment on this
We hear much today of demands by the farming community. I personally feel that it is time our farmers realised that, like many other sections of the community, they are entrepreneurs. They are not a social service. They are there with capital assets to be used to the best advantage as the man in the small shop, the man who runs a forge, the carpenter in his own workshop, has to use the capital assets he has to the best advantage.
I was shocked today to hear Senator McDonald say the farmers are worse off than they were 10 years ago. Farmers are no fools. The cost of capital assets can be measured by the income that comes from them, and any person with common sense today knows that the price of any farm is at least twice or two-and-a-half times the price it would have been 10 years ago and people will not buy something at that price if the income has not gone up.
I was rather shocked when I heard the Senator say that while last year he got £18 per ton for potatoes, this year he was able to get only £8. In fact, I was so shocked that I put through a phone call to the country, and I would now tell him if he is selling his potatoes in County Laois at £8 a ton he can take them up to Mayo and sell them at £18 or he can take them down to Kerry and sell them at £14. Why must we have this constant whining and complaining which is undermining the pride of our farmers? As one of the most noble sections of our community they deserve better leadership than they are getting from people who make comments and remarks of this kind.
We have also been told that it is the fault of the Irish Government that the pound sterling has been devalued. How could we boost up the pound sterling any more than we could boost up the French franc? We must realise that Ireland, being a small nation, is greatly dependent on the economic strength or the economic weakness of England. At one time England was the workshop of the world. She imported raw materials, manufactured them and sold them all over the world, thereby paying for those materials. She was able to buy capital assets abroad; and, further, she was able to make loans to foreign governments.
England today is tied to the iron frame and because it has to import what is tantamount to one-fifth of its national product in raw materials, it is no longer the wealthy empire that it was. For England to endeavour to live at the standard and at the rate at which she had been living may be a brave Churchillian gesture of defiance, but it is a gesture of defiance in the teeth of the hard economic facts of life. England is living above her means, and wages and other rates of pay have outrun her income. This depreciation has hit not only England but most countries of Europe with the exception of West Germany. At the moment the French franc is struggling for survival. As long as the pound sterling is under pressure, and as long as there is no confidence in it, the pound sterling will depreciate progressively. It was an irreparable mistake on the part of England and there was no option on our part. It was merely putting a cloth over an ulcer to hide it. For a few months, it boosted exports but England then found, because of prices of raw materials and demands for increased wages which were not matched by parallel increases in productivity, that she was unable to export at those prices.
In all those circumstances, our little country, which is so likely to get economic pneumonia if England gets an economic sneeze, has done very well. We have done very well because —perhaps in contrast to the Labour Government of England that has tried to soothe all sections by no policy or by lack of policy—our Government at no stage has refrained from stating the bald facts of economic life. Let me say, too, in this regard that if the sectional interests of our community would pay a little more consideration to the sectional interests of other parts of our community, we might be able to get nearer to that happy state of affairs which does not at present exist while the non-organised—the old age pensioners, the itinerants on the roadside and some other sections—are so neglected. But we have sections—and all their various cries and disputes are supported from the opposite side of the House—who are pushing, petulant, presumptuous, selfish and who have no interest in any other sections of the community so long as they get what they want.
Comment on this
That is the sort of situation which, on occasion, when the euphoria disappears, shows up the economy in its true perspective. Personally, I feel that, in the hard world of economics today, where so many strong currencies are fighting for survival, we, for our part—though perhaps, if one could be as wise in foresight as by hindsight, we might possibly be more, but, taking that into account, —have done exceptionally well and our Government is to be congratulated.
Comment on this
I want to apologise for the inability of the acting Minister for Finance to remain here and to reply to the debate. One of the reasons concerns the difficulty of keeping both Houses of the Oireachtas going. The Minister for Finance proper will be back after Christmas, please God. On his behalf, we want to thank those who have sent messages of goodwill and hopes for his recovery. I can assure the House that he is very well and that he will be back with us very soon. In saying that, I apologise for the inability of the Taoiseach, who is acting Minister for Finance, to be here this evening and to sit in and listen to what was indeed the very wide scope of this debate which ranged over everything from post office boxes and vending machines to higher academics in third level education, through agriculture, through high finance—the lot. I hope Senators do not expect me to reply in any detail to all the matters that were raised——
Comment on this
——if they expect to get home for Christmas. The debate was, of course, essentially on the second Finance Bill. The Appropriation Bill was thrown in for good measure. It gave Senators sufficient ground, I suppose, for a good wide scope of debate, I do not think many Senators seriously challenged the real fundamentals of what is popularly known as the "mini-Budget". Some questioned its timing. Some attributed improper motives to what the Government did. However, I do not think anybody seriously challenged the wisdom of doing what we did and the corrective measures that were taken and their extent. Possibly some criticism was made for propaganda reasons—that we knew all along that this course was necessary but staved it off until after the Referendum and then took the necessary action.
Anybody with any experience of Government must agree that no Government at any time looks upon the introduction of a Supplementary Budget as a popular exercise. Our experience of other Governments is that the tendency is to postpone the evil day until the position becomes so serious that a crisis looms up and then the necessary corrective action creates a serious recession with subsequent gloom and despondency and leaves many scars on the economy before we emerge from the ordeal. I trust the House will accept my sincere belief that the only motive which prompted the Government to take action of this type at this time was that of the national interest. We could have done a number of things. We could have ignored the position. On the other hand, we could have taken more drastic measures or we could have taken less drastic measures.
The Government acted carefully, on the best advice available, taking into account all the economic indicators. Actually, the measures taken were designed to be the least hurtful possible and were taken at this time in the hope that they would put us right if a crisis should come. If we had not taken these steps, we should be faced with an even more serious situation next year. I think we are all agreed that that is the position and, being so agreed, we must also agree that the action was both timely and correct.
I do not think the Government can, with justice, be accused of deriving pleasure from the bringing in of a Supplementary Budget. Indeed, we could argue that the steps we took in respect of relief to farmers also were taken only after the referendum. In 1958 our GNP was £601 million. Last year it was £1,148 million. The percentage of our gross national product for social welfare payments was 5.5 and last year it was 6.31. That is a considerable increase. To get down to more basic figures—and this includes contributory and non-contributory social welfare payments—in 1958 the social welfare figure was £33.4 million. This year it will be £81.5 million. Those are figures which no one can repudiate or denigrate. No one can say that is not a decent advance in the field of social welfare.
Senator Garret FitzGerald said it represented an increase in rate only and not in expansion of the service. That is completely wrong. I do not want to go into the whole field of social welfare but it is one I am interested in very deeply. Remember it was in 1961 only that we brought in contributory pensions. Remember it was only last year that the Occupational Injuries Act came into effect. Remember that the Minister for Labour—and this is a very important social welfare payment—brought in the redundancy payments. Apart from that, every single facet of the social welfare scheme has been improved. On the contributory side the requirements for qualification have been eased. We have extended the six months period for disability and unemployment benefit to 12 months, and it is also possible for a recipient to qualify for a further six months in the meantime.
We have also introduced the free electricity scheme and the free travel scheme for old age pensioners. I wrote into the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act—and it was not provided for in the Budget—a scheme making a beginning towards paying extra to the recipient of an old age pension when it is necessary for a daughter to abandon insurable employment to take care of one of the parents. I admit it does not go very far but it is a good beginning. If a person has to abandon insurable employment and cannot get benefit because she is not available for work, the father or mother or both get an extra £2 5s a week. I have not asked the civil servants to work on that for me as Senator Garret FitzGerald suggested. I am operating my own scheme with the approval of the Government.
In preparing a blueprint for the progressive expansion of social welfare it is not advisable to publish it in the form of a White Paper because it would immediately create a demand for its implementation. Those are some of the things which we have before the Government for approval and which we propose to do. I will have to introduce the required legislation and I would hope in the near future to introduce legislation for the further extension of our social welfare code. It is hardly necessary for me or any member of the Government to defend this Budget on the grounds of what we are doing for social welfare because we have only to ask people to look back on our record and see for themselves. If we make as much progress in the next ten years as we did in the past ten years our social welfare payments will compare favourably with those in any other country. That is the greatest guarantee of our future in that respect. Last year if we had been guided by the increase in consumer price index we would have been giving 2/- instead of 7/6d. In 1965 we gave 10/- and every year we hope that tendency will improve.
Comment on this
The Government are imposing additional taxation on these people and not making any provision for it.
Comment on this
It is not possible to start giving increases in a mini-Budget because most of them require legislation, an alteration of the stamps, the printing of new stamps and the publication of new forms. Every time we give an increase we have to print a new set of forms and prepare books and so forth. I should really like to give a good increase every two years and not have to have those difficulties. The contributory class will get an increase on 3rd January when the new stamps will be available. It cannot be done at the time the Budget is introduced. We have to wait until the following January but the fact remains that we have more than made up for any increase that has taken place.
Someone suggested that there would be a tremendous increase in the price of houses because of the high percent increase in the wholesale tax. It was suggested that the price of a house would go up by £200, £300 or £400. I do not think five per cent on the wholesale tax will increase the price of houses as much as that when you consider that the labour content of housing is 60 per cent and the raw materials are 40 per cent. Most of the raw materials are exempt from the wholesale tax so I cannot see how it should have a serious effect on the price of houses. It would not be a fraction of the £300 or £400 which someone suggested.
Comment on this
I mentioned a figure of £100 or £200 and I hope it is not correct.
Comment on this
I do not anticipate any such thing. There is not much competition in building because it is going well. There is not one unemployed skilled man in Ireland today. Thanks be to God it is that way. There was a time when there was emigration but today this increase should not have a serious effect on housing.
I do not think we should set out merely for the purpose of propaganda to frighten people about what this is going to mean in every field. There was a lot of criticism of our Trade Agreement with Britain. We cannot win so far as this Opposition are concerned. Whenever the British market is not going right we are told we are not giving enough attention to it and when it is going well we are told we should be looking for alternative markets because Britain would throw us in the ditch. We have no illusion about markets. No economist has come up with the perfect answer about markets for anything we export. You can plan your economy to the best of your ability.
You can estimate, plan, prepare, set certains targets, but you cannot plan the other fellow's economy. You cannot plan the economy of the fellow to whom you are going to sell your goods and we sell two-thirds of what we export to Britain, As I said to somebody here to-day if a weaver in Donegal is selling his tweed at 24/- a yard in Britain and if the Government try to compel him to sell it in Japan at 11/-a yard he will not be too happy. In a free economy people sell in the market where they get the best price and those who say: "Why depend on the British market so much? Why not find alternative markets?" must surely know that the people who are producing goods sell them where they get the best price.
The Trade Agreement with Britain must not have been the dismal failure some people would like it to be shown as and it must have been well worth our while to come to the aid of our exporters when you consider that our exports to Britain have risen from £158.3 million to £215.9 million last year. This is a colossal figure and herein lies the greatest hope for our future expansion. All the economists, elementary or otherwise, will tell you we export or die and we are exporting, continually increasing the volume and value of our exports, even with competition becoming keener and keener. This is the greatest possible hope.
I thought the way Senator Garret FitzGerald slipped over that in his propaganda speech was beautiful. He said the Civil Service was running the country and the Government were not even pushing them and the Government were bereft of ideas and imagination. Of course we had an overwhelming increase in our economic growth this year but that was an accident, that just happened. Whenever anything good takes place it is an accident and whenever anything bad happens it is due to bad management by the Government. I suppose that sort of thing went down when we first got native Government 40 or 50 years ago but the people and the legislator have come a long way since and I think that old argument has worn thin. I also think the claim that other things could be done at no extra cost does not count any more and the people who go on making those statements are not enhancing their own chances for the future one bit.
Senator Sheehy Skeffington is a great man for protests and the marches.
Comment on this
He is in favour of this sort of thing and everybody is to an extent. I did not say he marched but he has that sort of social outlook with regard to aggressive elements who want to protest about everything.
Comment on this
Keeping the Government on their toes.
Comment on this
Yes, this is becoming the modern thing all over the world. Indeed our people are only copying what they saw in Tokyo or somewhere else. However, I was at a debate in Jury's Hotel the other night. The different parties were represented there and the Professional Services Association. Senator O'Quigley was there and he made a very nice speech but virtually entirely propaganda. What he said was—and this is playing up to those people absolutely—Government of the people for the people and by the people is not something that takes place on one day and one day only. He meant election day. He said: "When we get into power this will be every day". In other words they would be guided, and I think he spelt it out absolutely, that they would be guided by all the pressure sections who come along the pavement or knocking on the gates of the Dáil with particular reference to the farmers of course. Neil Blaney, the cruel Minister for Agriculture, is tramping on the farmers and not permitting them to have any dialogue. This was the sort of statement he made which does nothing but generate ill-feeling that does not really exist. I do not care who is the Government of this country in years to come——
Comment on this
——if they have regard for the preservation of democracy as we know it. I am Joe Brennan but the Minister for Social Welfare is another thing and his job must be carried on in the best traditions of a decent democracy. I hope that no Minister at any time would abrogate his authority to anybody in the street. I think when the people go out in a democracy at election time and return a Government—and God knows there are short enough spells between elections—that Government should be the Government until the next election and not be swung from day to day by pressure groups. Who knows anyhow whether the 15 people who walk up to knock on your door or demonstrate on the street, decently or otherwise, are representative of the vast majority of the people? The best a government can do is take notice and use their own judgment as to where the case is just. It may only be a sectional case. Perhaps if you accede to it you will trample on other people in the country. A government has overall collective responsibility for all the community and for anybody to assert that they should be guided entirely by all these pressure groups, good, bad or indifferent, is merely playing up to every little weak spot in order to try to get support and don't we know that you can go too far with that sort of thing when you are merely trying to get to government.
Comment on this
I have been in the Dáil for 18 or 19 years and during that time there were seven or eight elections. Each time an election was due across the House you could hear: "Go to the country" and we went to the country and we came back.
Comment on this
They could do everything but win elections. We can go to the country and I will bet my life we will whack you again.
Comment on this
If the people want to vote for you they will vote for you and if they do not they will not. It is as simple as that. The people will make up their own minds. This thing of shouting "Go to the country" every time is no good. Stop talking about elections now and again and get down to business and go out and win an election for a change. Then we will know where we stand.
Comment on this
Your crowd will not want an election in Wexford. Sir Tony does not want an election in Wexford. He is the last person who will ask for it.
Comment on this
The greatest thing that ever happened was that the referendum threw you fellows into the one camp.
Comment on this
One person interjecting at a time is all right but when everyone interrupts together it makes no sense at all to me.
Comment on this
I think I have covered some of the points. I did not attempt to cover all of them but I did want to have a bit of a whack at this propaganda racket. We are all human. I said I did not care who is the next government and somebody disagreed with me. I do care. We will do everything possible to ensure that we are the government again but if we are not we will not cry on the opposite benches. I sat on the Opposition benches before and I watched a sorrowful government sweltering for a few years.
Comment on this
It did us no harm at all. In fact it only created a criterion by which we can compare what we did afterwards with what was done before. Out of 46 years, Fine Gael and Cumann na nGaedheal before them, were 16 years in power. We have not been all the time in government. There were nice intermittent breaks to give the people a chance to see here and there the alternative.
Comment on this
One thing I do not think anybody referred to and I thought it was unique. The mini-Budget and the motion of no confidence were debated, virtually, together. Simultaneously the Government announced the National Loan and it was oversubscribed. That was unique. I do not think a National Loan was ever announced in the Dáil during a no confidence motion or simultaneously with a supplementary Budget debate. In the midst of that, we announced a National Loan.
Comment on this
Yes, but the economy which we were taking action to correct was the matter at stake. "National" is the operative word. We filled the loan.
Comment on this
There will be no more of this disorder, particularly from some of the sources. I am rather shocked.
Comment on this
Senator Murphy will stop interrupting and be decorous.
Comment on this
That was something unique. I thought it was a demonstration, if demonstration were needed, that the man-in-the-street and the small investor as well as the large investor had absolute confidence in what we had just been doing and in the economy generally. There could not be any greater demonstration of faith in the action we took on the subject immediately under discussion. If the statements and gloomy forecasts made by the Senators here had any semblance in fact, that loan would not have been filled.
Comment on this
We had not to take nearly as much as we hoped to get for public investment. We took less than we announced we were taking in order to ensure that the private investor would get his full share.
Comment on this
You had to take it yourself if nobody else would.
Comment on this
By comparison with any loan ever raised it was an absolute success. As the Senator says, his Party supported the loan, as they always do but I think they were quite disappointed that it was successful.
Comment on this
I want to finish on a quieter note. I had great interest in sitting here for the last few days listening to the speeches.
Comment on this
If Senator Rooney interrupts again I shall have to ask him to leave. He is not contributing anything of any importance with that sort of nonsense.
Comment on this
He was provoking me to a very important statement. I am here only as a representative of the Minister for Finance. I hope the House tolerated what I have said so far. I was certainly interested in listening to Senators giving their views. They certainly went over the whole spectrum of national policy and far beyond the things that I thought might have been mentioned. One might say I learned a lot. I also might say, without being derogatory—I learned nothing. I had hoped that I would see some things shown in a new light. There was merely a repetition of the debate we had in the Dáil, perhaps ranging over a wider field. A very eminent Churchman in this country recently said something about the absence of sincerity in public statements. Until we get to the stage where we can say exactly and sincerely what we believe to be true, I do not think the public will take the cognisance that they should of what we say. That applies particularly to the people who are struggling to become the alternative Government. Thank you.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Now.
Agreed to take remaining Stages to-day.
Bill put through Committee, reported without recommendation, received for final consideration and ordered to be returned to the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Appropriation Bill has been sent from the Dáil and as agreed I shall now put the questions.