Higher Education Authority Bill, 1970: Committee Stage.
Contributions 146–326 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 29 of 1970 ›
Our doctors still seem to be going away. Forecasting is a very dangerous thing. We all know of the forecasters in horse racing, but none of them makes fortunes. This is a much more serious business. Let the people make up their own minds. Teachers should have some source of information. Nobody should be told which faculty they should enter. They should make up their own minds about this. If a child has a tendency towards one profession it could be a serious thing to his or her mind. If this amendment were accepted it would lower the standing of An tÚdarás and we must try to keep that as high as possible. It is not their function to forecast; it is their function to get education for the students.
Comment on this
Might I say in reply to Senator Crinion and Senator Quinlan that it seems to me that the burden of the case which is being made by them is that ignorance is preferable to imperfect knowledge. We know there is no such thing as a perfect forecast; and I think what Senator Quinlan states is true, that the difficulties of forecasting manpower requirements are very great. There are simple statements of existing fact which will allow a parent to forecast for himself. If the Minister would put something like that into the Bill it would make me happy.
We do not say there should be no weather forecast simply because it is often wrong. It would be sufficient if the Authority were able to provide the sort of figures which would enable a parent to make up his mind as to what will be the best thing for his child. He will not, as Senator Quinlan stated, come back in five years' time and say to the Authority "You misled me". If the Authority gives him simple facts which are true today, he can draw his own conclusions.
I was challenged by Senator Quinlan as to whether I would make a forecast. I could make a forecast if I had a day or so. I could make a fairly confident forecast about the employment opportunities for law graduates or for people who will have professional legal qualifications in two or three years' time, but it might not be very exact. However, I know what has been happening in the last few years and that is something which parents who have children interested in becoming lawyers ought to have an opportunity of discovering.
Senator Quinlan stated that it is up to the parents to find this out for themselves but lots of parents are somewhat at sea when dealing with educational matters. They may be in the position of trying to give their children a better chance than they got and their approach to the matter is uninformed, not through any fault of theirs. They cannot advise their children properly. The parents may not have had a secondary education and do not know the proper way of getting the information needed.
I was at the Bar for three or four years. A very high proportion of the people who took their call to the Bar either never went into practice or, having gone in, gave up practice within the first year or so because they could not make a go of it. The reason for this was the ordinary market reason of supply and demand. There just was not enough business to go round. Many of these had attended night classes, having worked hard during the day thinking they would turn into courtroom marvels, but discovered that a very long and weary plod was necessary before anything of that kind could happen.
It would have been worth while if some of these people had access to statistical information of the kind I have just given to this House. In the year 1960, of 20 people who were called to the Bar, I doubt if there are three left in practice today. The parent who, in 1960, sent his child to study law would have been interested to know that this had happened to those who had come in during 1956 or 1957. It would have been a factor which he could have weighed and could have used in order to make up his mind about what advice to give his children. I am not asking for a perfect forecast. All I am asking is very simple information which this Authority will be in a very good position to get. They should be able to tell parents or to make available to teachers some kind of statement, not necessarily a forecast, about what has been happening in recent years in regard to employment.
Did the Minister's Parliamentary Secretary not make a forecast in so many words a few weeks ago that a very large proportion of the people going into the arts faculty or into the higher diploma course were doomed to disappointment? He was quite right. No one will blame him if he were asked to quantify the number of jobs he thought would be available for these people and if he were wrong by 50,100 or even by 200. He is doing his job well merely by pointing out this serious problem. We are not doing our job unless we take notice that that problem exists and when we have a Bill before us which is ideally suited to doing something about it, such as including among the functions of this Authority the collecting and publishing of information which will allow people to make an informed guess about what their prospects are if they enter university or higher education.
Comment on this
This undoubtedly is a problem. As Senator Kelly has said the Parliamentary Secretary, adverted to it. I read in one of the Sunday English newspapers, prior to his statement, about the excessive numbers of graduates in England accepting jobs for which their qualifications are of no value. They are going to the university just to be educated, but not educated for the particular job they had to take up. The person who wrote this in the English paper was asking the Government of the time to take some steps to direct, guide or limit. Whichever is necessary, the entry of students into various facilities or disciplines in the various universities in England at the moment.
In view of this, I believe it is the duty of a Government, or an institution of that Government, or an Authority set up by that Government, to give some advice—I do not like to use the word "forecast"—in regard to what may happen within the next few years. This is the only Authority we will have that can do it. It will be the Authority that will have information from every institution of higher education as to what is happening in their various disciplines and faculties in any particular year. By co-ordinating the information they get from various higher education institutions they can make an attempt to forecast.
The wording of Senator Kelly's amendment is important. It says:
preparing and publishing forecasts of probable employment opportunity for students entering various branches of higher education.
If this is adopted, there is nothing there to blame the Authority if their forecasts are wrong. Nobody can with any certainty forecast anything. It is only on the basis of experience and trends over years. They may have valley and peak periods in certain faculties. This may be an asset too. It may be like the sale of vegetables: a year when there is a glut on the market is the time to sow for the next year because there is sure to be a shortage.
Ideas like this might be promulgated by the Higher Education Authority. There must be some body in this country who would have the function of giving to likely students of higher education some idea about the probability of their success in entering a particular faculty or discipline. That is the purpose of this amendment. The amendment is not hard and fast; it could not be. I think the Minister should consider accepting this because there is an outcry at the present time about the superfluity of certain people with degrees. As Deputy O'Kennedy, the Parliamentary Secretary, rightly said recently, this occurs mostly in the arts faculty and in the diploma of higher education.
What Senator Crinion has said is true to some extent, that there is an anomaly here. We are employing in this country foreign students while we are exporting some of our own. This is an anomaly that is occurring. Senator Honan brought out the point. I know because we have some of them employed in the Eastern Health Board, but these applied for the posts and they got them on merit.
To come back to the point, I feel there must be some source from which the parents of pupils leaving secondary schools can derive some idea of the chances for their offspring if they enter an institution of higher education. This Higher Education Authority could, for instance, forecast that in one of the universities in Dublin a certain faculty might be short. This is as far as they can go within the next four or five years. They might also say that it would be better to go to another institution, or if the person concerned lived in the midlands, that it might be better to go to Galway or Cork. I think this is the type of forecasting Senator Kelly has in mind. I support the amendment.
Comment on this
I think if we look at this amendment in the context of the whole Bill it takes on a slightly different appearance from that which appears if we look at it only in the context of section 3. Under section 6, subsection (1) of this Bill:
An tÚdarás shall maintain a continuous review of the demand and need for higher education.
It would be very difficult to maintain a continuous review of the need for higher education without examining in some way or other the employment opportunities and manpower shortages that are likely to develop in the economy in future years. Under section 6 An tÚdarás is required to maintain this review and to advise the Minister. If, keeping this particular section in mind, we turn to Senator Kelly's amendment we see that, in fact, it is hardly necessary in this amendment to put in the words "preparing forecasts of probable employment". I cannot see that An tÚdarás will be able to do its job under section 6 unless it does prepare forecasts of some type or other of probable employment opportunities for the students towards whose education it is going to propose a diversion of large amounts of public funds.
I think what we are concerned with here is whether this information should be published by An tÚdarás in a form which is useful to the public. I think that, looked at in this way, there is a great deal to be said for Senator Kelly's amendment. There would be no compulsion on An tÚdarás to publish for public consumption the advice to the same extent or in the same form as it tenders that advise to the Minister or to the same extent or the same form in which it reviews the situation itself in arriving at policy decisions.
Nevertheless, An tÚdarás should, without difficulty, be able to take part in this information, to publish this information in a form which could readily be assimilated by the general public. There are of course dangers. These have been adverted to during the debate. The main danger is an undue reliance on these forecasts, the danger that the public would get an exaggerated view of the reliability of these forecasts. But that difficulty could be avoided. As Senator Kelly has said, partial knowledge is better than complete ignorance. It should not be beyond the wit of An tÚdarás to be able to perform a public function of very great utility in this particular regard. Unless An tÚdarás is able to help the public in this regard I do not think it will be able to make very much progress with the general function imposed upon it of promoting an appreciation of the value of higher education and research. If the Minister looks on this amendment as proposing the publication in a form suitable for public consumption of information which An tÚdarás will have already gathered, he may be able to be more sympathetic towards the amendment.
Comment on this
If I recollect correctly, when Senator Kelly was speaking on section 4 he was concerned that we should put an undue burden on An tÚdarás. Notwithstanding this he now, in my view, proposes an amendment which would in relation to its functions set An tÚdarás an extremely difficult task. It will be for agencies other than An tÚdarás to engage on the highly sophisticated task of endeavouring to forecast the employment opportunities for graduates coming out of the higher education system. They will need to have the assistance of various other groups to have this information available to them.
The task of assessing need and demand for the purpose of financing institutions of higher education will of course fall on An tÚdarás as mentioned by Senator Dooge in relation to section 6(1). Advising potential university entrants will be the task of career guidance teachers in the post-primary schools. An tÚdarás, as well as the individual institutions, will be in a position to assist these teachers, but placing a statutory obligation on An tÚdarás is another matter. It is recognised that manpower forecasting is a highly sophisticated business. As I said, An tÚdarás, in this sense, will have to rely on agencies in relation to this particular matter.
I had a discussion recently with a member of the authority of an university who told me that they intended bringing in the guidance teachers from the post-primary schools, not only here but in the North also to have a discussion with them with a view to assisting these guidance teachers in relation to their own particular university. This would be a very helpful way in which this matter could be dealt with.
I accept of course that it is very desirable that the fullest information possible should be made available to prospective students in higher education regarding career prospects, but I do not accept that it would be the correct function of An tÚdarás to undertake the dissemination of this information themselves. The provision of information of this kind is essental to the satisfactory functioning of career guidance both at the level of post primary education, where such a service has already been introduced and is being rapidly extended and developed, and at the level of post-secondary education, where I consider much still remains to be done in the matter of career guidance, primarily at the stage of entrance to higher education but of course also during a student's course. The guidance teachers, for example in the post-primary system, properly assisted by the universities themselves and by the higher education institutes in general, would be in a much better position to advise the post-primary students as to what institution they should enter and also what particular faculties they should decide is best for them.
This, therefore, is partly a matter for the authorities of such individual third level institutions. Guidance on proper lines would direct the students towards the type of course most suited to their own particular talents and ability. It will provide information in relation to career prospects and it will help to avoid or at least to relieve the situation where large numbers of students, having finished their courses and obtained qualifications of a particular type, only then realise that there are no career openings for them.
Here again I would like to emphasise that my opinion in relation to this matter is that the individual institution should undertake this type of guidance in relation to their own students. But I would like to see a situation where all of the institutions of higher education would work in collaboration and perhaps establish a central bureau for the collection and dissemination of the type of information which Senator Kelly, in this particular amendment, would charge An tÚdarás with preparing and publishing. These individual institutions, either individually or in collaboration and preferably collaborating with one another, would be the proper means by which this type of forecast should be given.
Comment on this
I have one point to make on section 3 and I should like to make it at this stage, if only to safeguard my right to raise it on Report Stage in a possible amendment. It seems to me that a feature of this section is that it in some places duplicates matter which is contained elsewhere in the Bill. I am particularly concerned with paragraph (b), where An tÚdarás is given the general function of assisting in the co-ordination of State investment in higher education and preparing proposals for such investment. If we turn to section 9 we find:
An tÚdarás may relate annual or other financial requirements of institutions of higher education to financial planning over such periods as it considers suitable.
It seems to me that section 9 is, as I thought for a while section 4 was, a section which should find its place inside and as part of section 3. It is my impression that the function of section 9 might well be met adequately by adding to paragraph (b) of section 3 the phrase "over such periods as it considers suitable." This would put the subject matter of section 9, which is of prime importance in this Bill, where it belongs in the general functions of the Bill and it would also make the wording and general progress of the Bill through its various sections much neater and tidier.
Comment on this
There are a couple of points that I should like to raise on section 3, because I think we have in this section one of the most important sections of the Bill and one that lies close to the heart of this whole matter. The first point which I should like to raise is in regard to the objective in paragraph (a), which is the question of "furthering the development of higher education." Higher education is not defined in section 1 and I should like the Minister to inform us whether "higher education" is defined in any other statute. If so, what is the definition; and if it is not so defined, how is "higher education" to be interpreted in this Bill?
We can have a common understanding that higher education is tertiary level education following post-primary education. My concern is whether all such education is included. Earlier today the Minister indicated, in regard to students, that it was not necessary to talk of students and post-graduate students since the word "student" would include post-graduate students.
We then have to ask ourselves what is the scope of the term "post-graduate student." We have nowadays, particularly among the professions, increasing emphasis on what is known as continuing education. The universities and other institutions of higher education are playing a great part in this. Those who attend courses of continuing education are not post-graduate students in the formal sense that they are registered for a post-graduate degree or are following a full-time post-graduate study in an institution of higher education. Nevertheless, they are post-graduate students, whether they are attending short courses during a concentrated period of time or whether they are attending courses on a part-time basis throughout the academic year.
It would be very difficult to separate these activities from the ordinary functions of higher education. At times it is difficult to separate them from undergraduate education. I know that in the case of continuing engineering education much of the work which is done in this respect is to give courses for practising engineers in subjects and in accordance with curricula which are now part of undergraduate studies but were not part of undergraduate studies when these practitioners graduated. It has been said—and I speak of my own profession here because it is the one I know best—that the half-life of engineering knowledge is about ten years. It means that for anyone who graduates in a given year ten years later 50 per cent of the knowledge he had on graduation is either irrelevant, useless or wrong. Therefore, it is necessary to have a system of higher education which does not merely stamp a person with a primary or post-graduate degree.
If we are to educate our professional people so that they will continued to be productive and competitive throughout their careers, then we need this continuous training. In some fields this has reached the stage where people need to be updated yearly. In certain countries in Europe those who are qualified in subjects such as nuclear energy have to return to study for about four weeks every year in order to have their diplomas stamped that they are still qualified in their particular subject. I am concerned as to whether the scope of higher education, as defined here or as defined elsewhere, would cover these activities.
Comment on this
An institute of higher education is defined in section 1 of the Bill. Those who are receiving education in an institute of higher education would be considered as receiving higher education. I do not know of any other definition in any other legislation.
Comment on this
It is an inconclusive definition that education given in an institution of higher education is higher education. Does that preclude——
Comment on this
I said that in relation to the institutions as defined in the Bill A person receiving education in such an institution would be receiving higher education. I do not know if there is any other definition in any other Act.
Comment on this
My concern is whether in line 36 of section 3 An tÚdarás is restricted to furthering the development of higher education within institutions of higher education. A great deal of the post-graduate specialist education I am speaking about might be done partly within these institutions and party without them.
Comment on this
I would say if that education were done partly within the institutions and partly without, it would come within the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
If there were a function which could equally be carried out by a professional body and inside an institution. This can happen in regard to continuing studies. While I recognise that An tÚdarás's financial function would not operate in regard to the professional body, can we take it that An tÚdarás is not precluded from furthering such studies and facilitating them?
Comment on this
On the point that Senator Dooge has raised, it seems that the conclusion to be drawn from the Minister's reply is that all teaching hospitals should be considered institutions of higher education.
Comment on this
The Senator will note that in section 1(1) the higher institutions are defined as:
(a) a university,
(b) a college of a university, or
(c) an institution which the Minister, after consultation with An tÚdarás, designates by regulations as an institution of higher education for the purposes of this Act;
We cannot assume that any particular institution, apart from a university or a college of a university, will be designated. This is a matter which will have to be examined in consultation with An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
Further to Senator Dooge's question about the definition of higher education and the Minister's reply——
Comment on this
Perhaps I might add that all medical students are registered students in a university.
Comment on this
That might get over that point. There is another point arising out of Senator Dooge's question and the Minister's reply. The only answer the Minister could give is the definition of an institution of higher education and he implied from that that anybody in an institution of higher education is receiving higher education. That was the definition the Minister gave to Senator Dooge. Anticipating the next amendment, I should like to ask the Minister how would he consider an open university that has no institution? Would it come under that definition?
Comment on this
Would I be allowed to bring that up on the amendment?
Comment on this
Further to this question of the meaning of higher education, I should like to return to a point which I made on the Second Stage. That was in paragraph (a). Here we have a reference to "further education", whereas in the remainder of the Bill we have continuous reference to "higher education and research". I should like to ask the Minister the significance of the difference in wording here.
Comment on this
Would the Minister prefer to put that in at Report Stage? It might lead to difficulty.
Comment on this
I do not think it is necessary. In a sense, it could have been omitted in the other ones. My definition of higher education would include research.
Comment on this
I am a bit worried that on the face of it we have a Bill which talks about making certain provisions in regard to higher education and research. However, when it comes to the general function of furthering development, research is not mentioned. Higher education is not defined in the Bill. The Minister says we can define it by implication as activities that are carried on in an institution of higher education. He says that his reading of it would include research. There is, for example, in paragraph (c) of section 3, and also in regard to the financial sections later in the Bill a reference to higher education and research. I am a little worried that it might happen that some other statutory body might appeal to the precise tight wording of this Bill and endeavour to prevent or hinder An tÚdarás from the promotion of research which is proper to the university.
We know that certain difficulties and disagreements have arisen between certain of our research bodies in regard to the limitation between the areas of research which would be proper to these particular bodies. I should not like if such boundary disputes would occur between research institutes, or the National Research Council, and An tÚdarás um Árd Oideachais. I should be glad if the Minister would look at this point between now and Report Stage with a critical eye, and make sure that there are no difficulties here.
Comment on this
My information is that from the legal point of view it is not necessary. I will look at it.
Comment on this
If it were not positively dangerous, I should be happier if it were included there. Through lack of funding, our universities have not been able to develop research in the past to anything like the same degree as their sister institutions in other countries. Anything which smacks at all at the continuation of the neglect of research within our institutions of higher education would be a very retrograde step. We are all grateful to the Minister and his Department for what they have done in recent years for the encouragement of research. They made training grants and post-doctoral fellowships available. There is no doubt that it has been the Department's policy to make more and more funds available for this most important activity within many of our institutions of higher education. I am worried that this Bill might use one of two alternative wordings and that it might use the one which might be interpreted as undervaluing this particular activity.
Comment on this
I should like to support Senator Dooge very strongly in this. It is even more serious than he has just spelled out. The Minister's Department are not the only Department interested in supporting research. The Department of Health support research in the medical sphere the Department of Agriculture in the agricultural sphere, and so on. This badly needs some body to co-ordinate all this and to give it direction and decide how they should best continue. If this could be put in the sphere of influence of the Higher Education Authority, it would be a splendid thing. We could then look to that body to tell us exactly how we could merge with each other and work together.
Comment on this
Senator Dooge mentioned it to me previously, but not in the House. I looked at it since then and I was informed that there was no need for it. However, I will take another look at it.
If you look at section 10, subsection (1), you will find that:
An tÚdarás shall assess amounts of State financial provision, both current and capital, which is recommended for higher education and research or for any part thereof, either in relation to current or future periods.
This could possibly overcome the Senator's difficulty.
Comment on this
I agree, but I might say it is its development function that I am concerned with here. That is not merely meeting the bill for what has been done, which is adequately done in the section, but I should hope that An tÚdarás would be taking a positive attitude towards the development of research. In some of its reports already An tÚdarás has shown its desire that centres of excellence should be established. It is impossible to establish centres of excellence in teaching without centres of excellence in research. While the phrase here might be adequate and while the addition might be unnecessary, it would reflect better what appears to have been the attitude of the ad hoc body, and what certainly should be the attitude of the new Authority.
Comment on this
In subsection (c) there is the question of promoting an appreciation of the value of higher education and research. Has the Minister formed any view as to how this might be done? This is an activity which might mean very little, but it might mean a great deal. We are agreed that we could leave it to the good sense and the specialised knowledge of the members of the new body, as to how this should be done. However, had the Minister any particular activities in mind when putting in that particular subsection?
Comment on this
I was thinking of promoting the appreciation of the value of higher education and research among parents, for example, and also among employers. I know that the question of students was also raised today, but perhaps it would be more important if we could promote the appreciation among parents, who would be responsible for the students.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear that that is the Minister's view in this regard. I mentioned the point on Second Stage that many of the career decisions of children are influenced more than anything else by family circumstances and family views. I should like to suggest that the promotion of appreciation should be something on a completely wide basis. A special effort should be made to promote an appreciation in the places where higher education is least appreciated at the moment. Energy and money should not be wasted on preaching to the converted.
In coupling the parents with the employers, the Minister has singled out the other area where a great deal of education is needed. For example, some engineers who have graduated in this country in, say, mechanical engineering, have to emigrate, and this seems to indicate an overproduction of mechanical engineers in this country. It is nothing of the sort. It is an under utilisation. The position is that we do not produce relative to our population any more than any other country. It is just that our employers are still content to carry on, foolishly hoping to compete in the context of Europe without using the skills that are being used by their competitors in other countries. The Minister, in his short intervention, by singling out both the parents and the employers, has pointed to the two areas where this work would be most valuable.
Comment on this
I agree that appreciation should start in the home but I should like more to be done to have adult education centres set up, giving more opportunities to those who had not the chance of post-primary or formal education.
Comment on this
Before we pass section 3, I should again like to ask the Minister if he could give us some idea of the way in which he interprets the phrase "attainment of equality of opportunity". I mentioned on Second Stage that this can mean many things at different stages of development. I mentioned that there is the old equality of scholarship opportunity among the bright. We now have an equality of opportunity based on the Department's grant scheme. Does the Minister consider that equality of opportunity should go further in the near future? Does he anticipate and would he expect An tÚdarás to be thinking in the early years of widening still further the net in regard to higher education; or does he consider that it should be more in the nature of a growth much as we have at the moment but with a better distribution inside that number?
Comment on this
Within the limits of our finances, of course, this would have to be considered. Particularly, as Senator Horgan mentioned, on the technical side we would be very anxious to promote this situation. As Senators are aware, in recent years we have made very considerable advances at post-primary level where we have made free education available. I was not satisfied that this also meant equality of opportunity as is pretty obvious from my present problems in relation to the post-primary situation which I hope to overcome, given time.
Proceeding from that we have the grant system to help those who are unable to help themselves. I would see, in the future, the Higher Education Authority examining the situation particularly in relation to the technological side of education.
Comment on this
Does the Minister anticipate that the financial limitation is the major limitation in the matter of giving grants to support all those who matriculate for the university, or, does he anticipate that it would still require something more than minimum matriculation in order to qualify for a grant?
Comment on this
There are standards at the moment. I could not imagine changes beind made in that particular situation in the near future.
Comment on this
We could have the problem of defining the near future.
Comment on this
The matters arising on section 4 were discussed on amendment No. 6.
Comment on this
On a point of order, my understanding when moving the amendment on section 3 was that the Leas-Chathaoirleach, who was then in the Chair, made a ruling to the effect that he would not call Senators to order if the discussion were to slip over into section 4. It was my distinct impression that neither he nor the House intended to dispose of section 4 at that time.
Comment on this
The Chair raised this issue because clearly the matters arising on section 4 were discussed at some length on amendment No. 6. If Senators wish to raise further matters on section 4 they are, of course, at liberty to do so. The Chair would urge Senators to try to avoid repetition.
Comment on this
I should like to raise one simple matter which I did not raise when, moving the amendment, I am referring to it on this section because I may possibly have an amendment to this section on the Report Stage.
When I was examining this section after the discussion we had on my amendment to section 3 I spent some time trying to identify what precisely it was in the terminology of the section that I found unsustainable and shoddy. Eventually, I came to the conclusion that the two words in this section which are most in need of clarification, if not replacement, were "national aims." I am questioning, in the knowledge that I will not be misinterpreted and I am grateful for the Minister's remarks in this regard, if we can say in the way in which it is said in this section:
the national aims of restoring the Irish language and preserving and developing the national culture".
This is my aim. I do not doubt that it is Senator Kelly's aim. I am quite sure that it is the Minister's aim. But this does not make it a national aim. I am equally certain that it is the aim of the Fianna Fáil Party, of the Fine Gael Party and of the Labour Party, although each of these parties emphasise different aspects of the question in their approach to it. This does not make it a national aim. I even went to the Constitution where I thought one might reasonably find all national aims adequately defined. It is not so defined in the Constitution. The Constitution, Article 8 (1) merely says:
The Irish language as the national language is the first official language.
It said absolutely nothing about restoring, preserving and developing although in a certain sense this might be understood. The Constitution is the only instrument we have which was executed nationally. Even at that the manner in which it was executed leaves it open to some criticism. It was a Constitution which was adopted on a minority vote even within the area in which it was enacted. It was a Constitution on which it was not possible to ascertain the views of approximately 1½ million people to the north-east of us. While I do not think one can say that restoring the Irish language has been rejected by the Irish people as a national aim I think that we should have a sense of caution about proclaiming it as a national aim in this rather defensive way.
My final point in connection with this section refers to something that Senator Crinion said. He praised this section during the debate on the previous section because of the fact that it imposed no compulsion on people. It was something which encouraged people to endorse the Irish language rather than force them to do something about it. If we look at it from the point of view of somebody living in the six north-eastern counties of this country I doubt if they would take this reading out of it.
I believe—I have a form of words in mind which I intend to introduce as an amendment—that it is possible for us, once it has been laid down that we should include in this Bill some general statement of principle about the Irish language and Irish culture, to do this in a different way. I believe it is possible to devise with very little difficulty a form of words which, instead of imposing the Irish language and Irish culture on people living in the North of Ireland, would invite them to share it as the treasure we all believe it is.
This is really a psychological point but is one of some substance. I am not saying that this particular section will have any immediate effect in the northeastern part of the country, nor do I believe that we should be involved in any sort of horse trading of our heritage to please people when they want no hand, act or part of it. I believe that we should look around for a more positive formula, a less defensive formula than we have in this section, which instead of proclaiming something that could be divisive, proclaims something that might unite us.
Comment on this
I can think of no more positive formula and a less defensive one than that incorporated in this section. When we speak of national aims, the question is: how do we interpret these? The only way in which I can possibly interpret the national aims is by looking at the programmes of the various political parties. As Senator Horgan has stated, all of the political parties and many of the groups which are not in this House at present accept that these are national aims. Our identity depends considerably on the fact that we have our own language, our own culture and that this language and culture are worth preserving.
I cannot follow the reasoning of Senator Horgan in this matter. It has always been accepted, long before the foundation of the State, that the Irish language was the primary part of our cultural heritage and that unless we could preserve our own culture then we could no longer identify ourselves as a nation. There is no problem here so far as I am concerned.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9.
In line 9, after "education" to add "or the establishment and control of an open university".
The amendment which stands in my name and in that of Senator Dooge is to add to section 5, after the word "education" in line 9 "or the establishment and control of an open university".
I will leave out the middle part of the section and read the sentence that will be affected.
An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need or otherwise for the establishment of new institutions of higher education, on the nature and form of those institutions and on the legislative measures required in relation to their establishment or in relation to any existing institution of higher education or the establishment and control of an open university.
The first line of section 5 is "An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need or otherwise". This amendment does not intend, nor does it suggest or say, that I or Senator Dooge are looking for the establishment of an open university now or at any time in the future. It is only a covering amendment to prevent the need for regulations or legislation in the future.
Open universities, as most of the Members of this House know, are conducted through the medium of television in various countries. Those who get reception from the British television stations have already looked at and listened to the open university. I know it may be expensive and may not be practical but this is only inserted here as a function of an tÚdarás to advise the Minister on the need, or otherwise, of such a method of communicating knowledge. An open university must be construed as coming within the ambit of the Higher Education Authority although it cannot be construed as an institution unless you use the word "institution" in a different sense to the one we have been already using.
If this amendment is accepted it may be necessary to come to some arrangement with Radio Telefís Éireann. I expect this difficulty could easily be got over. There may also be some necessity to come to an arrangement with Radio Telefís Éireann on the control of any other methods of conveying instructions or knowledge which would not come within the ambit of an open university. I think this provision must be brought into this section. I do not suggest it should take effect now or even within the near future. Money may not be available and there may be other reasons why it would not be feasible. But it should be put in here. It only says that An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need for it. It does not say that it must be established at once. I would commend the amendment to the Minister.
Comment on this
The open university in England has proved very costly. If you are including in the section the onus——
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to add: "or the establishment and control of an open university". If that were included in the section the implication is that An tÚdarás should try to establish an open university here. I think England would have second thoughts about an open university in view of the overall cost. As the section stands, the Authority can advise on any particular system of higher education that is needed. I do not think there is any necessity to insert what the amendment seeks because it could be construed as implying that An tÚdarás should establish an open university. The present costs of education pose, and will continue to do so, a big budgetary problem. This proposal would only add to the cost, and put the onus on An tÚdarás to provide an open university.
Comment on this
I feel that, in as much as an open university would be a new institution of higher education, the wording of the section as it stands would cover an open university. It is not necessary, nor indeed would it be desirable, to specify in the Bill one particular type of institution of higher education while excluding specific reference to other types.
I tend to agree with Senator Crinion when he says that to single out an open university for specific reference would be to appear to give that particular type of institution an importance and a recognition for special consideration beyond what other institutions would command. I am personally very interested in the concept of an open university. Again, as Senators know, this is a concept which is a modern one and as yet has only been tested out in Britain. In our present circumstances I do not feel that the establishment of an open university could rank high in our priorities. I would fear, apart altogether from what I have said on this, that if I were to specify an open university here, it would appear as if it were a high priority, which I am afraid at the present time it could not be.
However, section 5, as it stands, does not require any amendment to ensure that An tÚdarás would have the authority and the duty to advise the Minister on the establishment and the control of an open university. It would be entirely premature to make a special reference in this Bill to an open university. An open university would, just as any other university, have to be established by legislation and once it had been established it would come within the scope of the functions of An tÚdarás. I feel that it would in legislation have to be given institutional status but the section covers this and I think that it would be inadvisable to make special reference to an open university.
Comment on this
It is gratifying to hear that the Minister is interested in the idea of an open university and, of course, no surprise to hear that he is somewhat worried about the cost involved. I think that the Minister is now probably worried about the cost involved in all types of education. There is nothing singular about the open university in this regard. There is a greal deal of force in what the Minister has said. It is highly probable that, as section 5 is drafted, which allows the establishment of new institutions of higher education, it will include an open university. He suggests it is undesirable that this particular type of institution should be singled out for mention.
I should just like to suggest one reason why it might be singled out for mention. Senator Uí Eachtháin mentioned earlier she hopes that, in what was being done, the question of adult education would not be forgotten. Higher adult education constitutes, in fact, the establishment of an open university or some institution of this type. I feel that when we are now making provision for the generations that are lucky enough to be born after us, in order to make higher education available on a wider scale and to a wider spectrum of our people, we should not forget when doing this to make as much provision as we can and to make it as soon as possible for those generations who received their formal education before this reform and revolution in education started.
In all our planning and education it is necessary for us to think of those people, who are every bit as deserving as those lucky enough to benefit from the relatively high expenditure on education today, and to remind ourselves that these people have not had these benefits. The provision of an open university, just like the provision of adult education at all levels, should be a relatively high priority. It would be very wrong if from a narrow economic sense we would tend to concentrate only on those cohorts who are now entering the work force. We have a duty in social justice to those who are already in the work force that we should not neglect them in our educational planning.
I further think that, even if we were to view this in a narrow, economic light, we would probably find that investment in the further education of those already in the work force might well prove economically more productive than pushing too fast in the training of those entering the work force for the first time. We would, by mentioning an open university highlight the fact that this Bill was not only providing for those who will leave secondary school and enter institutions of higher education. It would be an indication to the Higher Education Authority that the members of the Oireachtas feel that the whole of our community must be considered in our educational planning. This, as I say, is the reason why it might be desirable that we should mention this one particular type of institution of higher education as a clear indication that not only should it not be forgotten but the examination of it, not necessarily the establishment of it, should not be left off too long.
Comment on this
I am sure that the Higher Education Authority will take note of what has been said here in relation to the whole question of an open university. However, that is one thing; but to insert it here in a section is a different matter. Senator Dooge suggests that I would naturally be worried about the financial situation. Of course I certainly would, because it is a very expensive type of operation. I would be even more concerned with the appearances, as it were, of my priorities. As I have already said, I think it would overstress what would appear to be a high priority which, in fact, unfortunately it cannot be at the present time.
The question of adult education of course is a very important one, but there are many other ways and means by which we can develop our adult education. This we are doing at the present time. I am sure Senators are aware of the fact that we have an interim report from the Adult Education Committee and this is being studied as to the best means by which we can provide adult education for our people.
I accept what Senator Dooge has said that we should concern ourselves about those who are in the work force at the present time as well as those who would be fortunate enough to enter into our institutions of higher education through the leaving certificate. I would mention that through our various courses at the present time, we are concerning ourselves about this. We recognise it is essential that we should concern ourselves very much with adult education because it is generally recognised now that a man may have to retrain twice or three times in his lifetime. But I do not think that the insertion of this particular amendment in the section would help at the present time in the adult education field. For the many reasons therefore which I have given in regard to this amendment it would not be proper to include one specific type of higher education in the section.
Comment on this
I am somewhat disappointed that the Minister is not accepting this amendment, although he has expressed his appreciation of the value of an open university. Before I go on to the Minister's reply, I think Senator Crinion misinterpreted what I said. I did not suggest that an open university should be established at present. Neither did I suggest that it would be cheap. The section reads:
An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need or otherwise for the establishment of new institutions of higher education...
The advice they might give to the Minister is that it would be too dear or that there is no necessity, but the reason for putting it in here was that on the Second Stage of this Bill many people spoke specifically about adult education. At least one that I know of, Senator Cranitch, mentioned an open university. Other people mentioned adult education to a certain degree. I can recognise that the Minister had some sympathy with my suggestion that there might be some value in an open university. It is true that it may be too expensive for this country with its limited economic resources, but that fact or the fact that the Minister might not agree with it is no reason for not putting it in here. All that is asked is that An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need for it, and the Minister may say he has no money.
As regards the Minister's point that it is already included, that may be so. He is dealing with institutions. The meaning I took from his definition of "institution of higher education" was a place where education of a certain standard was carried on in a college or university or other such institution. All these were buildings. However, if the Minister accepts that it is included within this section I will not press the amendment. The Minister does say it is included in this section?
Comment on this
Yes. What I did say was that to establish a university of any kind legislation would be needed. It would need legislation to give it an institutional status.
Comment on this
No, but this is the point I am making: in any legislation that would be deemed necessary to provide an open university it would be essential that the open university should be given an institutional status so that it could come within the scope of the Higher Education Authority.
Comment on this
I will not press the amendment in view of the Minister's expressed interest in it. I understand he does not want to give it the priority which its insertion here might appear to give it. It was not my intention to give it that priority. The Minister understands that?
Comment on this
I quite understand that. I appreciate the reasons why the Senator put down the amendment.
Comment on this
It was not my intention to give it priority. The Minister has sympathy with it and will retain it in his mind. As I said somewhere else before, I presume that those people who are appointed to the Higher Education Authority will read the proceedings of both the Dáil and this House when they are appointed to that Authority and the matter will come to their attention.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear on the wording of the section that:
An tÚdarás shall advise the Minister on the need or otherwise for the establishment of new institutions of higher education...
With whom lies the initiative? Is it the Higher Education Authority which initiates this and advises the Minister, or is it the Minister who will seek advice from the Higher Education Authority? I am still not quite clear, although I tried to ask the same question in another form—what the relationship is between section 5 and the definition in section 1(c):
an institution which the Minister, after consultation with An tÚdarás, designates by regulations as an institution of higher education for the purposes of this Act;
I would like to know is there a direct relationship between them, with whom is the initiating power under section 5 and what is the relationship between the Minister and An tÚdarás in relation to this section?
Comment on this
I might say here that this would be two-way traffic if I might use common parlance. In other words, An tÚdarás could offer the advice or could be requested to give the advice. When An tÚdarás would have examined the overall position they would then have a good idea whether there was need for an additional institution, for example. Following from that, if they gave me advice and I accepted this advice, that there was a need for such an institution, then they would advise me as to the legislative measures necessary to establish it. The third point is that they would also advise in regard to any legislative measures that might be required in relation to existing institutions, for example the reconstitution of such an institution.
Comment on this
Does the section have any relation with section 1(c)? That is something that I cannot quite work out myself. Will the Minister, on the advice given under section 1 (c), act after the advice given under section 5?
Comment on this
It would be only when the institutions were established that the question of recognition or designation would arise.
Comment on this
Section 5 relates to any existing institutions of higher education. I am not quite clear whether the Minister accepts that—
Comment on this
I expect it could. As I have already mentioned, for example, the reconstitution of such institutions, like rationalisation of the university situation in Dublin.
Comment on this
What I am trying to establish is whether the Minister would accept that his powers under section 1(c) would generally follow advice given under section 5. Therefore the impetus, or certainly the advice, would come from An tÚdarás and it would be more than just a casual consultation. It would in fact be advice from——
Comment on this
We could take it, then, that the Minister would not envisage his consulting with An tÚdarás, then proceeding to designate without allowing time to elapse for them to give him considered advice.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a point which I made on the Second Stage of the Bill and I do not think the Minister referred to it in his reply at that stage. The point concerns the co-operation which An tÚdarás will have with institutions in the United Kingdom and specifically in Northern Ireland. We are moving towards a time in which we will have closer economic links with the United Kingdom through the European Economic Community. One of the many aims in the EEC is that universities and institutions of higher education should come closer together and be more flexible in their approach to exchange of staff, students, knowledge and all these other things. I should like to ask the Minister, since there is no specific reference to it anywhere, what the official attitude will be towards the universities, and especially in the North of Ireland.
I pointed out that there are already bodies in this country—I mentioned one specifically, but I think there are others—like the Royal Irish Academy which have links with the institutions of higher education in the other part of this country. These are very valuable links and they should be fostered. It is most important that An tÚdarás does not in any way operate to the detriment of links between universities in north and south. I think we should not wait to go into the EEC to strengthen these links and I should like to have some positive assurance from the Minister—I know he can say something in debate here to which we can refer afterwards and yet it has no statutory significance—that the Authority will take positive steps early in its life to work together with the northern colleges and to co-operate with them, to exchange information and to work for the general benefit of everybody in this country. He might also refer specifically to the relationship between An tÚdarás and the Royal Irish Academy which already has these very important links.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator is not already aware that grants to students here can be used by them in the universities in Northern Ireland, as can grants given in Northern Ireland be used in our universities here. That is one very considerable link. I would also envisage that An tÚdarás could have appropriate discussions with any other universities or institutions if they so desired. I have no doubt that they will do this because, in a sense, we would become parties with them in the development of higher education. I feel that they would have close links.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say what the connection between An tÚdarás and the Royal Irish Academy will be?
Comment on this
I cannot say anything about what might happen in the future. I mentioned on one occasion in the Dáil that I would agree to the designation of a particular institution and I was rapped over the knuckles by some Members for making that statement, as they could claim that I had made the statement without having consultation with An tÚdarás in relation to it.
Comment on this
I understand that point and I realise that the Minister himself cannot say at this stage what An tÚdarás will decide. I should like to know that it is the policy of his Department strengthening of the links with the educational institutions in the North should be an aim. It is all very well to say that students in the south can go to universities in the north and vice versa because the grants are applicable. This is good, but it is only a very minor step in what should be much more positive co-operation. I should like the Minister to give some thought to this because it is something about which we have not made any positive moves at all.
For example, I came up against a case this year in which a student from Queens University was to transfer to Trinity College for a year. It had nothing to do with the Department of Education—they cannot be blamed— but for certain technical reasons, which to me were absolutely ludicrous, this man was unable to transfer. There were all sorts of silly regulations in the way of an exchange. These transfers can only do this country a great deal of good and I should like to see a positive move being made in the direction of links between institutions of higher education in the south and those in the north.
Comment on this
I could say I am informed that many of the advisory bodies under the Royal Irish Academy and committees subject to them have representatives from both north and south.
Comment on this
On the section which provides for the establishment of new institutions of higher education— in other words new universities as time evolves—I should like some indication from the Minister of his thinking on that. At the present time there is a feeling among many of us that it would be better not to allow existing institutions to get too big and that it would be better, if the need arises—as it must arise in 15 or 20 years—for developing other centres, to go ahead with that freely and to use the machinery of the Higher Education Authority, and we hope the Council of Irish Universities will be set up under that, to ensure that we evolve a system of co-operating independent university centres.
If the existing centres grow too big— and already at least one of the Dublin centres is reacing that stage—it might be well to consider the provision of arrangements by which first-year classes could be taken elsewhere, something on the junior college style in America, or even to get back to the despised type of junior colleges that were recommended by the Commission on Higher Education. In any case we should consider anything that would take the pressure of numbers off the existing ones and prevent the growth of too large centres. In Cork we are very conscious of this because at the moment, like other centres, we are engaged in evolving a plan for the future. A plan must take account of the physical side and the resources available, and our thinking on that is that we would welcome a ceiling, not very much greater than our present number, of something of the order of 5,500 or 6,000 put on our centre as an absolute maximum.
After that we would welcome the creation of other centres to provide for whatever is required. That applies equally to the development of the Limerick Institute towards which we have no antagonism whatsoever and to which we offer the greatest cooperation. We want to ensure, however, that existing centres are brought up to some minimum level before we embark on other new ventures.
Comment on this
I am sure the Senator will appreciate, now that we have gone a very considerable distance towards establishing An tÚdarás in statutory form, that it would not be right for me to anticipate what advice they are likely to give me in relation to these matters.
Comment on this
Surely the Government have some ideas as to whether they favour the growth of very large centres or whether they would prefer to have a number of smaller co-ordinated centres?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
Before section 6 to insert a new section as follows:
"In relation to its functions in this Act An tÚdarás shall consult with the relevant institutions of higher education including the students in these institutions."
Senator Jessop in unable to be present and has asked me to move this amendment on his behalf. I move this amendment with conviction because I think it would be an important statutory obligation on An tÚdarás to consult with the institutions and, in particular, with the students in relation to the general function set out in section 3 and other specific functions. Under the wording of the amendment, as drafted, this would not tie An tÚdarás down in any way. Neither would it put an undue burden on that body. It would be part of a dialogue with the Higher Education Authority and these institutions and would promote a sense of participation in the development of higher education in this country by the students concerned.
The Minister might well accept this amendment as an important contribution to the development of higher education. He may be of opinion that the Higher Education Authority will, naturally, consult with these institutions and with the students concerned. We have put a great deal into this Bill rather specifically. We have spelt out various functions and aims, including the national aims in relation to the restoratin of the Irish language and culture, for the Higher Education Authority. We have also spelt out the way in which the Higher Education Authority will act, the way in which they will co-operate with the Minister and their exact functions in this regard. It is, therefore, appropriate and important that a statutory duty of consultation should be placed on the Higher Education Authority as outlined in this amendment.
Comment on this
I think Senator Robinson has already answered this question in the manner in which I feel it should be answered. I could not visualise An tÚdarás being able to perform its duties without consulting with the various institutions of higher education. It is implicit throughout the Bill that An tÚdarás must consult with the relative institution of higher education in relation to its functions under the Bill. One could not imagine how An tÚdarás could possibly fulfil its various functions, and particularly its specific functions, without having consultation with the institutions concerned.
With regard to the inclusion of students in these consultations, I feel that An tÚdarás must have freedom to consult with any relevant interest. If we were to specify the interests with which they must consult the list would be endless, unless we were to confine the discussions to one or two interests. I cannot see any reason for accepting this amendment because it is quite obviously implicit that An tÚdarás could not possibly function without consultation with the institutions concerned. On the other hand, I am equally convinced that if we were to add, as in the case of an open university, a particular body to this section it would mean that we would have to continue to list all those institutions with whom the Authority should consult. That would result in an endless list and for that reason I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not agree that imposing a statutory duty on the Authority to consult the institutions and students in the institutions would be regarded as satisfying the requirement of consultation with various interests or the rquirement of seeking expert advice or assistance elsewhere. This is one of the good things about the ad hoc body. It came into the universities and sat in open session in consultation. This was greatly appreciated. I am sure the Minister will say this is implicit in the Bill and I would agree with him. However, there are many other things which would have been implicit if we had not written them into the Bill.
Section 6 reads that "An tÚdarás shall maintain a continuous review of the demand and need for higher education." One could say that this would have been implicit in its functions if it was to function as a Higher Education Authority and yet we are spelling it out in the Bill. Although it would be implicit that there would be a duty on the Authority to consult there is great value in making it statutory on it to do so. It would be of particular value to include the students because the Minister is reluctant to give the students statutory status on the Authority, but if he imposed a duty on the Authority to consult with students it would go a long way to alleviate the students present feeling of being left out and being cut off from the planning and work of the Higher Education Authority.
Comment on this
I should like to support this amendment. I think it is, in a sense, a poor second to the amendment which was defeated earlier in the day. I should like to draw attention to what I feel might be some of the unhappy consequences of failing to make this matter explicit. In doing so I would remind the Minister that, even though the Higher Education Authority did, as Senator Robinson has said, go into the colleges, it was not the happy type of perambulation that it might have been. If I remember rightly, in Cork there was considerable misunderstanding between the members of the as hoc Authority and the student body about the nature and functions of the Authority as well as about its desire to meet the student body there.
If we do not make this duty explicit it opens the possibility for the Authority, however well meaning it may be—it may choose some excuse such as lack of time—to avoid the kind of consultation we are talking about. If the Authority is left free to avoid such consultation and if it avoids such consultation suspicion will gather strength that the members of the Authority are acting as plenipotentiaries for their institutions. This is a situation which I know the Minister is anxious to avoid. I believe that by inserting this new section in roughly the same words as Senator Jessop has presented it the Minister would enhance the credibility of the Authority and avoid any possible implications about the conduct of its members.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot accept what Senator Horgan says. There may have been some misunderstandings but, of course, there will always be misunderstandings. Time will give the opportunity of ironing out these matters. I have already pointed out that, in my view and, I think, in the view of most people, it is clear that An tÚdarás could not perform its functions without having consultations with the relevant institution of higher education.
With regard to the student aspect of this matter, if we were to decide that there should be consultation on a statutory basis the question would arise as to what students would be met, how they would be selected, if the general body of students would accept them, and so on. I am not making this a particular issue: I am simply saying that it is quite obvious to me that An tÚdarás could not perform its functions without consulting with the relevant institutions. Therefore I can see no reason why we should include this amendment in the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In subsection (2), line 12, to delete "overall".
I think amendments Nos. 11 and 12 should be taken together. They are basically designed to tidy up the section. I understand that, as originally presented in the Dáil the section read roughly as I should like to see it amended. In its present form, the section is ambiguous about the ministerial function with regard to the provision of student places within the higher educational system. The provision of student places to be made within the higher educational system— in other words, the slice of the national cake that is to be made available for higher education—is a political decision and therefore a ministerial decision. It is right that the Minister should be given the power of taking a broad decision along these lines, as the section would enable him to if my amendment were accepted. The last three lines:
...having regard to the need to maintain a reasonable balance in the distribution of the total number of students between the institutions of higher education...
seems to me to introduce in ambiguity. Does it confer on the Minister the right to decide how many students should go to any particular institution of higher education? It is quite wrong to give the Minister that right. The right to do this is specifically reserved to An tÚdarás, in section 10, subsection (2) of the Bill. As it exists at present, subsection (2) of section 6 is either superfluous to the Bill, as a whole, or even in direct conflict with subsection (2) of section 10.
Comment on this
As the Senator has already mentioned, when this Bill was first presented to the Dáil, it did not have in subsection (2) the words which the Senator wishes, by this amendment, to delete. These words were added to the subsection as a result of an amendment proposed on Committee Stage— not by me—and agreed to after a rather full debate. The words which this amendment proposes to delete were inserted in the subsection through the amendment which I accepted and which was agreed to during the passage of the bill through the Dáil. I consider it to be an essential portion of the function of An tÚdarás that in making their recommendations to the Minister as to the overall provision of student places to be made within the higher educational system, they should have regard to the distribution of the total number of students between the institutions of higher education. This also includes non-university institutions. Perhaps there is a danger in dealing with this Bill, particularly in the Seanad where there are so many academics— and I do not say that in any derogatory sense—in that we tend to think to institutions of higher education as universities only. There are other institutions which provide courses leading to technological qualifications of the type which serve urgent requirements of the community and of the economy. In considering this subsection, we must keep all the institutions of higher education in mind, and not the universities only.
The Senator is worried about the Minister having the power to make the arrangements in relation to the students. Not only would the Minister not have the power, but it would not even mean that An tÚdarás would arbitrarily decided what number should be accepted in any particular institution, or how these number would be distributed as between the faculties in the institution. It would be an element of the general function assigned to An tÚdarás under section 3 (b), that is, "assisting in the co-ordination of State investment in higher education and preparing proposals for such investment". I had originally been of the opinion that these words were unnecessary in this subsection, since they appear in almost precisely the same form in subsection (2) of section 10. So I suppose I have the same qualms as Senator Horgan had. Nevertheless, in the light of the arguments that were advanced in the Dáil, and having given the matter the fullest consideration. I am now satisfied that subsection 920 of section 6 has been improved by their addition.
The Senator also has an amendment to delete the word "overall" I do not see that the word "overall" would make any difference to the meaning of this particular subsection. Subsection (1) charges An tÚdarás with the maintenance and continuous review of the demand and need for higher education. It is a corollary to it that in subsection (2) An tÚdarás is required to recommend to the Minister to overall provision of student places to be made within the higher educational system. The word "overall" has a definite purpose here, and I cannot agree to the proposal for its deletion. Taking the country as a whole, An tÚdará would decide on, say, providing X number of arts student, Y number of medical students, and so on, for the whole country, in the context of the demand and need. Otherwise, it would appear to relate to individual institutions.
Comment on this
Maybe I misheard the Minister, but I thought I hears him say he considered that the word "overall" did not make any difference to the section and, secondly, that it had a specific purpose in the section, and not specifying what that specific purpose is. If it has any purpose it is to emphasise, in an age in which higher education is so often taken to mean university education, that it is to cover all forms of higher education. However, this is a word which is superfluous to the Bill. The Minister said that it had a specific purpose, but he did not tell us what it was.
The other point I should like to make is in connection with the word "recommend" in "An tÚdarás shall recommend to the Minister." My understanding of this phrase is that recommendation to the Minister is followed by action by the Minister. What sort of action does the Minister envisage himself taking on foot of recommendation made by An tÚdarás under this section? Does he not run the risk while taking action under this section of conflicting with the activites of An tÚdarás under section 10 (2)?
Comment on this
There are two separate issues here. One is the overall provision for students and the other is as to how they might be distributed between institutions. These considerations govern, to a large degree, the total Bill to be presented for higher education as well as the breakdown in the matter of the amounts to be provided for individual institutions.
Comment on this
On section 6, I should like to ask the Minister what is the particular force of the word "continuous" in subsection (1)? We miss, this evening, Senator West, who is a mathematician and who might have a particular definition of "continuous." To my mind the plain meaning of the word "continuous" is "without interruption", in contrast to a word such as "continual" which means "at frequent intervals". I should have thought that perhaps the subsection might read.
"An tÚdarás shall maintain continually a review of the demand and need for higher education".
This would meet the ordinary intent that they should follow changes in the demand and the need for higher education with whatever frequency is required for the purpose of carrying out their functions. To me the word "continuous" has the meaning "without interruption". I am wondering if we would not legally be putting on them a burden of reviewing every week and every day. We have a mathematician in Senator Quinlan.
Comment on this
That is correct. "continuous" means "without interruption".
Comment on this
I do not know if he lawyers can tell us if the word "continuous" means something different in a Bill than it does in plain speech.
Comment on this
The general idea here was that a five-year plan would be drawn up and that a continuous review of this plan would be maintained so that it could be modified from time to time. Evidently the legal aspect of it is that the word is correct in this particular situation.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Minister would make the specific query.
Comment on this
My information is that this is what it really means. Having drawn up the plan they would keep it under review.
Comment on this
If we are talking have of a five-years plan which is reviewed every year, every six months or every quarter I think the word "continuous" indicates a higher degree of continuity than is intended.
Comment on this
The point is that at any stage they can modify this five-year plan. Therefore, for that reason it would have to be under continuous review.
Comment on this
I am afraid to us that is a discreet process and not a continuous one.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that, as Senator Belton said earlier, one of the points of section 6 is similar to the point which he and I have been trying to get the Minister to recognise with our amendments in regard to giving the public some idea of the longterm prospects for employment. I should like to ask the Minister if he envisages that, so far as the continuous review of the need for higher education is concerned, the Authority would publish their views or findings in regard to this need?
A "need for higher education" is not a very lucid phrase because both subjective and objective constructions of it are possible. An individual may experience a need for higher education as a perfectly valid one in regard to his own individual development. I presume that is not what is meant here so much as the national need for higher education or for people with higher training. If that is what the Minister means it might be no harm to say so.
Comment on this
I feel that the Authority would make reference to the assessments that they make in their reports in relation to need.
Comment on this
If they would then circulate that to the kind of people who are likely to be interested in it, it would go a long way towards meeting the point I was arguing earlier.
Comment on this
Following the point raised by Senator Kelly I should like to get something more precise on the need for higher education. I questioned earlier the feasibility of forecasting, but the recognition of need is a different thing. The need is something that is present or something that is likely to arise in the next few months. It is a recognition that the economy may, for example, be short of technicians or chemical engineers or some other identifiable group of person. In a system as open and as unpredictable as ours we should be always on the alert to recognise need where it arises and to make provision for suitable short-term courses to supply that need. In other words, as I put it on Second Reading and I want to put it to the Minister again, we should treat graduates in the same was as we treat redundant workers.
Graduates or technicians, the products of any stage of our educational system, have got a training and are equipped to do a job. But if the job is not there and if we can retain them for a job that is there, then the onus is on us to do that in fairness to the young people concerned and also for the benefit of our economy. Therefore, I should like to feel that An tÚdarás, in recognising a need, should have some machinery for action quickly by either acquainting the Minister of this need or by setting up or suggesting courses necessary to bridge that gap.
It is only by flexibility that we can get the most out of the educational process. It is a long process, generally involving three, four or five years of training. Therefore, we will have to have continuous assessment and continuous re-training. Obsolescence in the sciences is within five or seven years—Senator Dooge can check the figure for me— the period in which the technologist should be subject to retraining. This is a function of our institutions, but it is a function where co-ordination is necessary and where it could legitimately be the responsibility of the Higher Education Authority to ensure that our technologists and technicians are provided with adequate retraining facilities at suitable intervals.
Comment on this
I recognise the various problems put forward by Senator Quinlan. The question of need is an assessment of the requirement of the nation in various fields of activity as it relates to the employment of graduates and others in the higher education fields. I do not wish to go into the long statement I made on another amendment. While the Higher Education Authority would need to take this into consideration it would basically be a matter for the institutions of higher education. A number of the problems could be overcome if we had our post-primary guidance scheme fully developed. I have already replied at length to this matter which is raised now by the Senator.
Comment on this
The Minister misses the point there when he states this is the responsibility of the individual institutions. It is not. The provision of additional short term courses or refresher courses is an onerous task. All these cost money. It is not a particularly high level activity and not the type of activity into which the institution concerned would be very anxious to divert their resources. Yet it needs to be done in the national interest. On the other hand, you do not need four or five of those courses going on at the same time. Once you identify a need there should be money provided for any stop gap measures that are necessary to get over that need, and I would envisage An tÚdarás recognising the fact that we need so many additional technicians trained in this way.
This might require some special degree training. A six month course in a particular line of subjects might produce ten or 15 people urgently needed by Irish industry. Surely such activity should be paid for separately? The institution that undertakes to give the course is doing a national service and the bill should be presented to the Government for payment. It is not something they will rush into on their own account.
Comment on this
I could see that this would be a situation where the Higher Education Authority would consider any such proposals which would come before them and, should they regard the proposals as reasonable, they should make money available.
Comment on this
I think the initiative should come from an tÚdarás.
Comment on this
If you take all the pass B.A.s we are talking about at the moment and the fact that we are short of several hundred technicians, I cannot see why a technical crash course at a good level for six months or a year would not be provided so that these people would emerge in six months or a year as technicians to fill a need in Irish industry.
Comment on this
I would say that this should be provided in a technological college rather than in a university.
Comment on this
Yes, but here we are discussing all the third level institutions and recognising that.
Comment on this
In recognising that, the Minister might have said in the first place that it was a pity those people had not to a technological college.
Comment on this
That was one of the reasons why I said that, if we had fully developed our post-primary guidance system, many of those who went to university might have been directed, to their benefit, towards technological institutions.
Comment on this
Guidance in our context is largely guidance to a job.
Comment on this
No, it is not. That is a mistaken conception of what our post-primary guidance means.
Comment on this
Unless we have the jobs available within the economy at the end of their training period the guidance will be of no avail. Even if we have guided them to their first aptitude and if jobs are not available, surely we should be eager to retrain them for their second aptitude, if our economy needs that? Most of those people are capable of filling one job ideally and another job 95 per cent correctly. The higher their IQ the more careers they can fill. That is the main fallacy in our whole approach here. We rely too much on the concept of guidance. If we had an economy with full employment and all sorts of diversified openings it would be all right; but in our system flexibility has to be the keynote. The tasks we have laid on AnCo for industry should not be any different from the tasks we would lay on the Higher Education Authority in regard to the products of our third level system. They are entitled to some measure of consideration by the State when at the end of their period of training, through no fault of their own, they find themselves without a position in our economy. If they can be retrained for some position, they have a moral right to that retraining.
Comment on this
The Senator's idea is very good, but I should hate to see retraining immediately a person qualifies say, for a B.A. degree and knows he cannot obtain a position. It would be a dangerous precedent to retrain these people immediately. It would mean rushing people into some other position which they had no intention of taking up originally. You could end up with a lot of square pegs in round holds. I feel that they need some time to see if they can get fixed up.
We have been speaking about the arts faculty but the arts faculty to my mind has always, been a higher grade of general education. It may have been for teaching, but you see at the present time arts graduates in every field, in industry, in teaching and so on. I feel that they should at least try to get the degree, because a person is more likely to make a success of what he has been aiming at over the years than if he goes into another course once he graduates. It is admitting defeat straight away. Let him try, and maybe as time goes on retraining might be possible. I feel it would be a dangerous precedent to start off by burdening An tÚdarás with something like that.
Comment on this
In this I was looking simply from the standpoint of the economy. In other words, we have got to try to ensure that all the various positions in our economy are provided for by our educational system. Where we identify lacks, such as the lack of technicians, than if the regular process of providing them is not capable of providing them fast enough and in the quantities we require, obviously there are other ways and means of doing it. We should be able to follow the same line as in redundancy.
One other point I wish to stress is the great fallacy of our system where a person is trained for a particular task If we could only get the quality of spirit into our graduates I would not mind if everyone in the country had a degree, because at that stage he would recognise that a degree was just a general training that equipped him to go out and do a job better than if he did not have that degree.
If we could get that across we need not worry about redundancies or we need not worry about graduates who cannot get positions in their exact line when they are prepared to go and tackle other lines. Indeed, we can see, if we look at our graduates from various faculties, that the greatest successes have been those who have gone away completely from what they were trained to do and used their talents in the general scope, simply concealing the fact that they had degrees but going and having the confidence in themselves that they have got additional training to equip them to face a challenge, wherever that challenge came from.
Comment on this
Section 7 states:
An tÚdarás may annually or at such other intervals as it may determine...
I take it that what is meant there is longer intervals than annually. We shall be looking for monthly or six-monthly reports. I would suggest that we put in "or at such longer intervals as it may determine". "Such other intervals" seems to suggest that they will be down every week looking for the accounts.
Comment on this
While it could happen on some occasions that they would require information in a shorter time than a year, usually I would say, it would be annually or longer periods. But it could happen that on some occasions it would be shorter.
Comment on this
Yes, But, on the other hand, we do not want to encourage unnecessary interference by An tÚdarás with the institutions with which it is connected. It seems to me that a statement of financial position etc. at less than yearly intervals is unreal.
Comment on this
It could happen on at least some occasions, but broadly speaking I would say that it would be annual.
Comment on this
I hope this does not encourage programming too far ahead, which of itself can be very stultifying for institutions. I know we are supposed to be almost two years ahead and it is very hard to anticipate what would be the main requirements in two years.
Comment on this
Yes, but is it not a fact that all this programme budgeting is like manpower forecasting, just about as deceptive?
Comment on this
The experience in the United States, where this originated. has been that now they are beginning to see the fallacies and pitfalls in this and it seems that we are about to rush into it.
Comment on this
Surely we ought to be able to learn from whatever mistakes they made in the United States?
Comment on this
If we can learn that such a thing is not very practicable and has its pitfalls and that it should not be unduly relied on, if we can learn that lesson, well and good, but the euphoria there is about it at the moment does not seem to suggest that we have learned that basic lesson.
Comment on this
I should like to express a completely opposite point of view to Senator Quinlan, lest it be taken that he is expressing a point of view which might be common in the universities From my experience, I should like to say to the Minister that it certainly is my view of feeling in the universities that, particularly where scientific departments are concerned, where budgeting for equipment, technical staff and so on is concerned, the university departments are crying out to have their budgeting and financial arrangements spread over a longer period than an annual basis. They are anxious to get up to three or five years. I am rather astonished at the argument put forward by Senator Quinlan.
Comment on this
I think the Senator misinterpreted me. They are anxious to spread over a number of years, but on the other hand they want to be able to make adjustments and corrections without having to wait two years until the period for adjustment comes up again.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) states:
In making assessments under this section in respect of institutions of higher education, An tÚdarás shall have regard to the accommodation capacity for students of each institution and to the maintenance of a reasonable balance in the distribution of the total number of students as between institutions.
I take it that this again will call far some national policy on size. We have not got that yet. When does the Minister expent to be in a position to give some guidance on that? It will have to be done because overall plants for all the institutions are being prepared at the moment. The Higher Education Authority is anxious to have those, and an overall plan commits an institution to a certain size plus or minus 15 or 20 per cent. I think is rather vital that we should have a national policy on that very shortly.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the effect of subsections (1) and (2) taken together is easily read between the lines. What it means is that the Authority is to assess the amounts of money which the various colleges are going to get. These assessments will have regard to accommodation and maintaining a reasonable balance in the distribution of students as between the institutions. When the smoke clears away what that really means is that a college will be told: "We cannot let you have more than £X for the servicing, let us say, of the faculty of arts. That in turn means, if I am not misinterpreting the section, that the college as usual will have to bear the odium of telling the public, "We are very sorry but we will have to axe our intake by one half or cut it down by two-thirds or not take in any more new students this term or this year or introduce a cyclical system," or something like that.
In other words, unless I misunderstood the sense of the section, the point is that the Authority by having regard to these factors, which of course are important factors in making its assessment, is putting the ball squarely in the colleges' court so far as taking politically unpopular decisions is concerned. No one in a university minds taking unpopular decisions. Academics would not be worth a damn if they were not better able than the ordinary layman to do something which did not demand general approval. But it seems to me that there has been too much of this in the past. When University College, Dublin, or some other institution makes a decision and when the pickets arrive at Earlsfort Terrace and the rows start and the sit-ins and representations and all the rest, the Government stay quietly in the backgorund, although it is of course ultimately with the Government that the responsibility for these things rests.
I am not saying that the responsibility means the blame. Obviously there is a limit to the amount of money at the Government's disposal, whether recommended by the Authority or not. But in the past the position has been that decision taken by UCD have been taken not for the convenience of the people who work there as teachers but simply because the place could not take any more students, and still they claim to be functioning properly as an institution of higher education.
My feeling about this section is that it will mean these unpopular decision will be left with the universities and that nothing is to be done to help them to make these decisions or to make them easier to sell to the public. That is all part of the same complex of problem I adverted to here earlier when I asked that the Authority should be given the function of trying to head students off from courses which were either over-crowed or which led to professions which were likely to be overcrowded.
Comment on this
I should simply like to raise on this section a question that was raised earlier on in the definition section, or section 3 paragraph (a). Again the words used here are "an institution of higher education". I would again ask the Minister if he believes this is an adequate way of referring to what I referred to elsewhere as a process of higher education and research?
Comment on this
Senator Kelly spoke about the difficulties that the universites have in relation to this matter of funds. He mentioned that the Government do not take any of the odium of it, that they stay in the background. I do not think it can be said of me since I became Minister that I have been very far in the background when it came to taking decisions, popular or unpopular. It rather amuses me to find members of universities complaining that they are left carrying the can. I think every can that was ever made finally ended up in the Minister's hands. At least I will say in relation to this that in the future under An tÚdarás we will not have every institution operating off their own bat. We will at least have a co-ordinated effort. This in itself will be a very worth while change from the present position. An tÚdarás will be able to take an overall look at the situation, they will be able to assess the overall needs and we will be operating in a much more co-ordinated fashion than at present.
Comment on this
I see in subsection (1) mention of higher education and research. How can this be reconciled with the activities of the Science Council, which has a very definite role in encouraging scientific research and gives very sizeable grants for such work to departments in the various colleges.
Comment on this
I am informed that there is a very definite liaison now between the Science Council and An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
An tÚdarás is at present and ad hoc body, but has it any jurisdiction over the Science Council or does it in any way pass any judgment on the budget of the Science Council?
Comment on this
It has no jurisdiction. As I say, there is a liaison between the Science Council and An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In line 41, before "require". to insert "reasonably".
I will be brief about this. I have already mentioned the gist of my point in the debate on the Second Stage. It would be no great concession for the Minister to make if he were to accept this amendment, the purpose of which is to insert the word "reasonably" before the word "require". The section as it stands reads:
An institution of higher education shall supply to An tÚdarás all such information relative to the institution as An tÚdarás may require for the purpose of performing its functions.
That seems to me to put the Authority in a strong position to say: "We require certain information. Whatever you think about it does not matter. The fact is that we think we require it and you will have to hand it over to us. If you do not you will be in breach of your duties under the Act."
It appears to me that there is a range of information at the disposal of an institution such as a school or a college or university about personal matters which is in most respects private information and relevant only to strictly academic matters affecting an individual. A point might be reached at which the Authority for reasons not of a discreditable kind but of a kind which we in this House would not today approve, could look to a university or a college or other institution of higher education and ask for personal details about teachers or students in those institutions, going beyond what the Authority would require for the discharge of its functions as we now understand them and as they are being represented to us by the Minister.
It would be no harm therefore if the Minister would agree to insert the word "reasonably" here so as to give the universities or the colleges some elbow room. I do not anticipate conflict, but there is no harm in trying to put the parties on level terms if there is to be conflict. It would give them some elbow room for saying: "Your requirement in this instance is not reasonable. We do not think it is reasonable that in order to fulfil your functions you should have information about the private arrangements within a department for teaching a particular member of our staff or the view we have taken perhaps in disciplinary matters in regard to certain students or things of that kind.
These are matters which are by no means waving indiscriminately the flag of university autonomy: I think that is overworked. These are things which are within the proper scope of university autonomy and I should be sorry if this Bill were to lend any countenance to an Authority which would seek to breach that autonomy by interfering or by requesting information not really necessary for the proper discharge of its work.
Comment on this
In my reading of it, if "reasonably" were put in there it would take away the whole effect the section would have. It would leave it open to people to say,"We consider it unreasonable" and to refuse to give information that would be required. It would be taking power away from An tÚdarás and giving an excuse to faculties to refuse to give information. It relates to section 7 also and it is one word which could have a bad effect on this Bill and would do a lot of harm. On that account I think it would be taking away power from An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
Senator Crinion, not for the first time this evening, has been good enough to say that the amendment which I put forward would defeat completely this or that or the other object. In this case his argument is based on an assumption which he and his party have been unwilling to make in regard to the Authority itself, that the institutions of higher education here will take leave of their senses and behave in a disruptive way. There is no reason to suppose any such thing. I do not for a moment imagine that any conflict will arise in the kind of atmosphere which exists even at the present day between the institutions of higher education and the State, or that the relationships and the degree of fact shown by the latter towards the former over the last few years had not been perfect. I do not anticipate any great conflict. I do not see why Senator Crinion should assume that the universities or the institutions of higher education will be looking for an excuse to refuse to supply information. They will not be looking for an excuse not to supply information which is reasonably required for the purpose of enabling the Authority to carry out its functions.
The point about this section as it stands is that it seems to allow the Authority to say, "We think it is necessary for performing our functions and no matter what you think we insist on getting this information"—even though it may relate to something which in the reasonable view of you or me or anybody else could not be relevant or central to the Authority's job. We certainly had a polite debate so far today—not like other debates in recent times—and I am sorry to have the sensation of beating my head against a stone wall so much with this Minister, who I know is genuinely interested in providing a decent educational structure so far as he can do it.
It is disappointing to me to find that every time I propose an amendment— or any time any Member proposes an amendment—first of all that a screen of "flak" is thrown up by Senator Crinion, telling us that the thing would completely defeat the purpose of the Bill, and then the Minister dive-bombs in to tell us that the whole thing is being looked after anyway and that we must not worry because his own intentions are the best. That is not the way to deal with amendments. I ask the Minister to try at least to meet some of the amendment that we on this side are putting forward since we have no intention of making political capital out of them.
Comment on this
I should like to support this amendment very strongly. It seems to me that the whole Bill is an attempt to give expression to two separate kinds of relationship: the first, that which must and should exist between the Government and An tÚdarás and the second that which must and should exist between An tÚdarás and the various institutions which it serves.
In this section as drafted—I do not know if I am prejudging the issue too much—in what seems to me to be the Minister's refusal to accept a very reasonable amendment we have the kind of authoritarianism which has become evident recently not only in Government but in many of hour human institutions, and which in this Bill has acted in several sections to tie An tÚdarás too closely to the strings of the Government.
I believe that in drafting this section the Minister has put himself in the position of An tÚdarás and said: "If I were in charge of An tÚdarás, if I could be the whole body corporate myself, what kind of powers would I like to investigate the working of the institutions of higher education?" The present climate being what it is, it would not surprise me at all that the Minister considering himself in the role of An tÚdarás, would like to give himself such wide powers, because it would be a natural extension of an authoritarian point of view. I wonder whether this authoritarian point of view is shared even by the present ad hoc members of An tÚdarás and whether it would be shared by people who would be appointed to An tÚdarás in the future. I should like to think that it is not and it would not and that the Minister, by accepting this reasonable amendment, would give at least momentary set-back to the increasing authoritarianism that is inflicting all our institutions.
Comment on this
We all believe that the members who will appointed to An tÚdarás will be reasonable and I cannot for the life of me see where they will request information that will not be necessary.
Comment on this
I fully support Senators Horgan and Kelly on this. It is a complete reversal of the roles again, giving this authoritarian power to An tÚdarás. I think the word "reasonably" should be put in, as required in the amendment, and there should also be a provision here in case of conflict. If an institution says, "We consider that this demand is unreasonable" then there should be a court of appeal on this. I should be quite wiling to leave that court of appeal with the Minister, but there should be an appeal on this. I hope on Report Stage to move an amendment to that effect.
In many Bills we say, "The minister's decision shall final", or "an appeal to the Minister", and in a case like this I admit it would be very unusual to have to occur, but it is safeguard which the institutions under An tÚdarás should have. If they say that a request is unreasonable they should at least be able to say that they can refer it to the Minister to see whether he opposes it for not. I think this is one very useful function which the Minister could perform.
Comment on this
I have been in the House for a comparatively short number of years but I have had the experience of seeing people running down to the Library to get a dictionary to tell them what "and" and "may" and "if" and all the rest were concerned with.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Senators all today. If we put the word "reasonable" in we would have to set up another court of inquiry to decide what the word means. The word "reasonable" could mean one thing to me and another thing to somebody else. I presume that the people to be nominated to An tÚdarás will be sensible people who will not be likely to look for information which they know they are not likely to get. If the universities say to them: "We do not think it is reasonable to ask us for this information" it will be a matter between the two of them. To put in the word "reasonable" would, in my opinion, mean that the members of An tÚdarás would have to make tracks to the libraries again.
If we have any faith in An tÚdarás, and I believe it will fulfil a very important function, I cannot see why we should be splitting hairs over what is reasonable and what is unreasonable. You would eventually have to appoint some other superior body to decide what is reasonable and what is unreasonable. You could go to the faculty of medicine one day and they might consider something was reasonable while the next day you could go to the faculty of arts who might consider the same thing was unreasonable. Each of them would have their own interpretation of what is reasonable.
If this body is to do an important job—and remember it will be an expensive body—and if we have not enough confidence in it I should prefer to see the whole idea scrapped. If they are to fight with the universities as to the meaning of the word "reasonable" we might as well put the whole idea out of our minds.
Comment on this
Perhaps I should first of all assure Senator Kelly that there was no collusion between myself and Senator Crinion in relation to this debate. If senator Crinion wishes to make a contribution, that is his business. Whether he waits to make that contribution until I have made mine or makes it before me is also his business.
Senator Kelly said the universities are reasonable groups of people and would not act unreasonably. It is equally true to say that An tÚdarás will also be a reasonable body and will not act unreasonably. The ad hoc body has shown itself, in its operations since it has been established, to be a very reasonable body which has done a very worthwhile job. If I have not accepted amendments here it is simply because I did not feel the amendments would improve the Bill. If I felt they would have improved it I would have accepted them. If, however, I feel those amendments will not improve the Bill the duty is on me to ensure that the Bill remains as it is.
Nevertheless, the discussions which took place on the various aspects of the Bill were very useful and they will be very helpful to the members of An tÚdarás when that body is established in statutory form. In regard to this amendment I must say—as I have said before and will probably have to say again—that An tÚdarás will act in a responsible manner and will not be unreasonable in the information they will require from institutions under this section.
It is rather surprising that Senators have shown great concern that, on the one hand, An tÚdarás should have quite a wide amount of autonomy and authority and, on the other hand, they seemed to assume that there should be legislative powers to ensure that An tÚdarás will not act unreasonably. As has been mentioned here, the word "reasonably" as proposed in this amendment would result in bad law in that its interpretation would vary widely between on institution and another and between on individual and another. If only for that reason I would find myself having to oppose the amendment. I should also have to oppose it because it bears the implication that An tÚdarás requires to be constrained statutorily in order to fact reasonably. I do not think this should form part of the Bill.
Comment on this
I am sory to have interrupted Senator Honan a moment ago. He spoke about confidence in this Authority. I would certainly like to have confidence in this Authority and what we are trying to do here is to provide the country with an Authority in which we can have confidence. Our objection to this Bill is not an objection so general as to justify us voting against it on the Second Stage, and accordingly we did not vote against it. Our objections to it are that the Authority is not so constructed as to warrant confidence. The debate here today has shown that the Authority will be not just a buffer— it perhaps may be a buffer between the Minister and the universities—but an entirely subservient buffer and one which perhaps will relieve a Minister of some of the political odium which otherwise might attach to a Minister at some time in the future.
We had a debate this morning about academic members during which the Minister would not yield an inch to the suggestion that there should be a hard core of at least seven out of 18 people in full-time academic jobs with a full-time commitment to a university. We did not make even an inch of headway in the long debate this morning on that point. In the provision in regard to the designation of new institutions as institutions of higher education, we had a long debate on that too and again not an inch was yielded. I realise the Minister has good intention in this regard but the Government are prepared to leave us with an Act which will make it possible for the Minister to designate by regulation an institution an being one of higher education over the heads of, and in the teeth perhaps of, unanimous disagreement of the Authority. Let us be clear on this point: that is the law we are to get.
When you put those facts together with the fact that the Government are empowered also to hire and fire all the members of this Authority, it can be seen, as I have described it, as a potentially subservient body. I am then asked to have confidence in such an Authority. I should like to have confidence in an Authority and what we are trying to do here is give the country an Authority in which they can have confidence. An authority which may be a catspaw of the Minister for Education is not a body in which I would have much confidence, particularly when I look at the record of the Minister for Education in the last few years in regard to their proposals for university education and in regard to their attitude towards the only advice which they got from people qualified to give such advice.
I am reaching the stage where I have very little confidence in the Authority we are about to set up. I protest against this touch-me-not attitude towards this authority. We cannot require anything of them. We cannot make any assumptions that are adverse to them in 50 years' time. We cannot require anything ofthem explicitly. we cannot suppose that the Authority may ever go wrong or that a Minister in charge of that body may ever go wrong.
Why not? Why are we not allowed to suppose these things? We are making law, and the letter of the law is what people look at. I wish to say to Senator Honan, in regard to the question about the dictionaries and looking at words, I have always noticed that the people who are the hardest on lawyers, and on law, are the ones who are the quickest themselves to chop a straw, when they have to chop one and to split a hair, when they have to split one.
That is what law is about, I am sorry to say. I know that people make their living out of it and that they are an unpopular profession. However, the only way in which civilised society can continue is by having rules which are incorporated in a permanent form, in black and white, which are as clear as they can be made, and which would enable people to see what their rights are under them. That the idea of putting the word "reasonably" here was to make this now very sweeping section unworkable—as Senator Crinion appeared to think—is simply completely wrong.
Comment on this
In my view it would be much better law to refrain from inserting the word "reasonably" in this section. it is incorrect to suggest that this body would be anything but an autonomous body. It has proved itself over a considerable period to be an autonomous body and to act as an autonomous body. This is accepted by practically everybody. In relation to this particular section it has been very largely worked out between An tÚdarás and the universities as to the manner in which this information will be sought. We could leave it to An tÚdarás and to the universities to work it out.
Comment on this
I do not want to hold up the House. May I take from what the Minister said that section 11, as it now stands, has been arrived at after consultation with the universities and is acceptable to them?
Comment on this
The point I am making is that the manner in which information will be sought has been largely worked out between the universities and An tÚdarás.
Comment on this
Has the Minister got any representations from anyone in the universities about this section 11?
Comment on this
As a member of the senate, the standing committee, the governing body of University College, Cork, and its academic council, I have never heard anything whatsoever about this, and I doubt it completely. The ad hoc Authority has no statutory position.
Comment on this
My information is that there have been consultations between the HEA and the authorities in the various universities in relation to the manner in which information will be sought.
Comment on this
There have been consultations in regard to presentation to financial account and so on, but section 11 goes far beyond anything relating to financial accounts.
Comment on this
I am simply giving the information I have, and that is that the consultations have taken place in relation to the manner in which this information will be made available.
Comment on this
That is what we are worried about. It puts the Authority in a position to demand all types of information on academic affairs.
Comment on this
We are not worried about the financial side, we are more worried——