We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Bill, 1972: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–165 of 328. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Bill, 1972
Enacted

No. 16 of 1972 ›

Section 1 is concerned with definitions for the purpose of this Bill. I should like to raise one point with regard to the definition of "employee". Looking at this definition and comparing it with the definition in the Redundancy Payments Act, 1967, to which this Bill is very closely tied, I notice there is a slight discrepancy between the two. I should like to ask the Minister if there is any particular significance in the amendment which is made here.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan Minister for Social Welfare (Mr. J. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

I am not aware of any significance. If it departs from the definition in the Redundancy Payments Act, it is not for any ulterior or other motive.

Comment on this

Regarding the definition of "employee" as it relates to the scheme or to local authorities as employers, how does this affect, for example, the roadworker who may have five years' continuous employment with a particular local authority? The engineering section then finds that money is drying up and a number of notices are given for dismissal at the end of a particular period. These people do not get a week or a fortnight's notice. They are usually told on a Tuesday or Wednesday that they will cease to be employed on the following weekend as there is no money in the funds. This happens particularly at this time of the year. I should like to receive an assurance from the Minister that this type of employee will be brought within this Bill.

Comment on this

From what the Senator has said I take it this would be a lay-off, not a dismissal. "Lay-off" is also defined in the definitions, and would not break the continuity.

Comment on this

I am sorry I cannot accept that because very often a man is dismissed after perhaps three, four or five years. There is no cheque the following week or fortnight except what he receives from the labour exchange. An employer can get the same benefits and still get his pay. There is no point in quibbling as to whether a man is dismissed or laid off. When he is disemployed he is dismissed. Three months may elapse before he can be re-employed.

Comment on this

Yes. This Bill is dealing with minimum notice of dismissal. There is a vast difference between a lay-off and a dismissal. The rights a man has accumulated in continuous employment give him certain rights for continuity in this Bill. The duration of notice given to him, whether two, three, four or eight weeks, depends on the period of his employment. It also applies to his redundancy, whether he has been in continuous employment. Lay-off does not break continuity but dismissal does. If he is dismissed he has to be given the notice laid down in this Bill. If he is laid off it is a different thing.

Comment on this

I regret I cannot accept the Minister's explanation. We are referring to the interval between men being laid off and being dismissed. The fact remains that they are both unemployed. If we are to carry this to its logical conclusion an employer in an industry may quite easily say these men are not dismissed they are being temporarily laid off. Then they do not come within the terms of this Bill. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Yes. If the Senator looks at paragraph 3 of the First Schedule to the Act it states:

A lay-off shall not amount to the termination by an employer of his employee's service.

It could not be more clearly defined.

Comment on this

I had intended to raise this particular matter of lay-off and its implications in the Schedule. Now that it has been raised on this section I should be glad to have a direction as to whether I should raise the point now. It might be more appropriate on the Schedule, as the Minister has indicated, to discuss its implications there as far as this Act is concerned. We might preclude the possibility of a debate on the Schedule by continuing the debate now.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the House. If the House so wishes we will debate it now.

Comment on this

I suggest that the implication of the definition of "lay-off" occurs on the Schedule and we might have a more fruitful debate if we left this point now and had a debate on the First Schedule, if the Chair would permit that.

Comment on this

We can do that if the House is agreeable.

Comment on this

Still on section 1, if I might return to the original point I made about the definition of "employee", the Minister indicated that there was no particular significance in the change of the definition here. My problem was that section 2 of the 1967 Act defines "employee" and says that "employer" which is a defined term in that section and "employment" are to be construed accordingly. When we come to section 1 of this Act we find it says "and cognate expressions can be construed accordingly". I should like to know if there are any "cognate expressions", that is expressions cognate to the word "employee", other than "employer" and "employment"? This is why I am puzzled about the differences here. Perhaps it is that the word "employer" is not defined in this particular section. I am puzzled at two sections which are 95 per cent, perhaps more, the same having this slight difference. A change was made and one becomes curious as to the reason for the change.

Comment on this

The definitions here are only what are appropriate to the Act. If we look at subsection (2) of section 5 we will see it is a relevant matter to this whole question of lay-off and dismissal.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has underlined what I have said. When I look at subsection (2) of section 5 I find the words "employee", "employment" and "employer". If these are the only cognate expressions to the word "employee", why were these not cited, as was done in the 1967 Act? Are there some words other than in this section where we have some cognate expressions? Within a definition everything which is used in it should be clear. The words "cognate expressions" are not clear in this particular case. We are dealing here with legislation in regard to people's rights to entitlement. This may appear a niggling minor point but we must be absolutely clear about what we mean in this particular regard.

Comment on this

I do not think it is of any relevance to the Bill whether a definition requires to be given here or not.

Comment on this

I am content having raised the point. I take it it will be looked at and any necessary implications will be examined. If anything should arise from this matter, perhaps the Minister would communicate with me and put my mind at rest on this point.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us anything concerning his intentions about the coming into operation of this Bill? He provides in this section that it will come into operation on a day to be appointed. I should like to know what are his intentions and hopes on the matter.

Comment on this

It will be as soon as possible. There are some regulations and so on, particularly under section 14, to be considered. The reference of disputes to tribunals under section 11, subsection (1), must be considered before the Act can be brought into operation. It will be necessary to make these regulations.

Comment on this

One would anticipate something of the order of six months?

Comment on this

I hope sooner.

Comment on this

Section 3 (1) (b) deals with what we might call the forbidden degrees of kindred in respect of this Bill. Here we have a number of points which I should like to raise.

We have gone out from relatively simple relationships to several degrees of kindred. We seem inclined to bring the complete deirbh-fhine of our ancestors into this legislation. We do not merely deal with the question of parents and children, we go beyond that to grandparents and grandchildren. Having taken in this very wide scope, I then find that there is no mention of the relationship of son-in-law, daughter-in-law, father-in-law or mother-in-law. When we were making out this very large list of people under this particular paragraph, which refers to employment of a particular type in which families and relations are largely concerned, these particular relationships were excluded and I should like to know the reason. If we can think in terms of an employment of a son or daughter on a farm or in a dwelling house, we could equally think of the employment of a son-in-law or daughter-in-law.

Comment on this

These are the same relationships which are provided for in other legislation under the social welfare code. There is no difference here. If you bring in in-laws, very often the boss's daughter marries an employee and it would be very wrong to deprive the employee of the benefits he is already entitled to just because he married the boss's daughter. I do not think one could argue in favour of including in-laws. There are many cases where one would think that the immediate relatives should be included.

Comment on this

This is indeed the point.

Comment on this

It is relevant, of course, to read the section which states "... and whose place of employment is a private dwellinghouse or a farm in or on which both the employee and the employer reside."

Comment on this

I am aware of that but we are concerned in subsection (1) with particular conditions of employment. The Minister indicated that this is the same as in other legislation. It is the same as subsection (3) (b) of section 4 of the 1967 Redundancy Act. On the other hand it is far wider in scope than the corresponding section of the British 1963 Act on which this legislation appears to be based.

I should like to ask the Minister, in regard to this particular problem of this type of employment, if the reference here is only to domestic work in a private dwellinghouse or on a farm. Does it apply to work on a farm and, in that case, are there any limits to the type of work?

Comment on this

I could not imagine a factory being run in a private dwellinghouse.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister. I cannot imagine a factory within a dwellinghouse but it would not be impossible to have manufacturing in a dwellinghouse; for instance, ore manufacturing could be carried on there.

Comment on this

The intention here very obviously is to exclude families or close relatives working together in a private house or on a farm.

Comment on this

Yes, but on the other hand the original intention appears to have been to restrict this to domestic service and the ordinary work of a farm. Am I right in saying that there is no restriction as it stands at present?

Comment on this

It is not restricted to domestic service or to ordinary farm work. If, in fact, there happened to be carried on in the dwellinghouse a skilled operation, or a cottage industry, the effect of this section would be to exclude members of a family taking part in such activities from the operation of the Bill.

Comment on this

I think an obvious example of what Senator Dooge is talking about would be a country public house with a farm attached. The son of the house in that case would help in the bar as well as helping on the farm: would he be included or excluded by this subsection?

Comment on this

He would be excluded.

Comment on this

In regard to both?

Comment on this

All such cases are, of course, subject to test on their merits but, broadly speaking, he would be excluded. He could possibly seek to establish that he has some specific skill that could not be found elsewhere and, even though relative, he has to be employed there. He could have a contract of service with his father and, on his establishing that he could not find somebody else for the job, he might be able to establish that he was insurable. The same thing arises with regard to insurance.

Comment on this

So far we have been concerned here with particular persons and conditions of employment. I would now like to take up the scope of the exclusion. We are concerned in this Bill with the giving of notice of the termination of employment and also with the provision of their terms of employment to employees. I should like to ask the Minister to comment on whether it is desirable to make a blanket exclusion in this regard. I know there is an escape clause which the Minister can vary afterwards, but we should be clear in the legislation on the right thing to be done at the moment.

Uncertainty in regard to their terms of employment on the part of children in rural Ireland working for their parents has been not only a cause of anxiety to many of those children but has also been the basis of much dramatic output on the stage of our national theatre. Irish dramatists have dealt repeatedly with the theme of the son and daughter working at home within the family. One can accept that such persons would not be entitled to a long term of notice if it is decided they should no longer be employed. We are talking here about employment, not just about working. We are talking about a contract—it may not be a written contract—and I wonder if we would not be doing something for the social health of such families and groups if, in fact, they were not excluded from the necessity to make the terms of employment known on request.

Comment on this

The Senator asked me to comment on this matter. I would not be in favour at all of bringing in the conditions of employment that pertain as between an employer and his non-relative employees into family affairs. This is something for which I would not like to legislate. I do not think the son should have the right to demand from his father the conditions of his employment. I do not believe we should go that far and I do not think it would help traditional good family relations. We should, however, try to give members of a family certain rights which they could invoke in certain eventualities. The same principle applies to the case of insurability. Senators know that relatives are not insurable when they are employed by their fathers or certain other relatives.

Comment on this

The Minister says this could be invoked in certain cases. My point is that it would be invoked only in those cases in which there was something wrong and in which the good tradition, of which the Minister has spoken, was notably absent. If the Minister takes this attitude, should he not approach it by saying that such a situation of family relationship should be excluded from the definition of employment? If we are going to say that this is employment—this is what we say in the section—then it should follow the rules of employment which we are now laying down. If we wish to exclude them then it might be better to exclude them from the definition of "employment" rather than make a special case of them, as is done in subsection (1) (b).

Comment on this

I may be quite wrong, but is the position, I wonder, of adopted children covered by this subsection?

Comment on this

That is covered in the Adoption Act. The Adoption Act attributes to them all the rights to which the natural son or daughter would be entitled.

Comment on this

Does that apply to the denial of a right?

Comment on this

I am not a lawyer, but I have some very good advice available all around me.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I think Senator Sheldon has made a good point.

Comment on this

This is a point on which I would not disagree with the Minister. Still on section 3 and still on subsection (1), but moving to paragraph (c), I would like the Minister to comment on the reasons why he included local authority employees but excluded civil servants. The Minister commented briefly on this in his reply on the Second Stage, but he had not got much time available to him on that occasion. Nowadays the public service is essentially one employment. The direction in our legislation has been towards the promotion of mobility between all parts of the public sector yet here we are, in legislation, making a very distinct difference. This point was adverted to by Senator Owens on the last occasion on which we debated this Bill and I would be glad if the Minister could give us the reasons for reaching not just the decision to include one or exclude the other but, at the same time, to exclude the unestablished civil servants and to include local authority employees.

Comment on this

I may be chancing my arm on this, but the obvious reason possibly is that civil servants are already covered from the point of view of dismissal by their terms of employment and they have always enjoyed benefits that other employees did not have. Local authorities employ people at all levels, such as labourers, storekeepers and manual workers. It was for that reason it was decided not to exclude employees of local authorities.

Comment on this

I would like to intervene for a moment, if I may. It is now ten minutes past the usual time for adjourning for tea. Should we adjourn now, or should we continue in the hope of finishing reasonably early?

Comment on this
Thomas Mullins Tomás Ó Maoláin Fianna Fáil

I suggest the majority of Senators would like to get away tonight and it would convenience them if we continue until we finish.

Comment on this

Is that agreed?

Comment on this

I have no objection to continuing for the present but, if we find that the debate is going on unusually long, we might reconsider the position later.

I would like to press the Minister a little further on this. He said that the exclusion of the Civil Service is justified on the grounds that civil servants already have the rights given under the Bill. It is about 26 years since I was last a member of the Civil Service so I may be out of date on this particular point but does this mean that, in fact, all unestablished civil servants have the right of notice given under section 4 of this Bill? Is an unestablished civil servant, who has been employed for more than five years, entitled as of right to four weeks' notice?

Comment on this

I think the position is fairly clearly outlined in the Bill. Under clause (c) of subsection (1) it says: "(other than in an unestablished position)." It is generally recognised that established civil servants already enjoy better conditions.

Comment on this

The conditions of employment of civil servants give them at least what is given here in section 4 of the Bill. Is the Minister quite satisfied on this point?

Comment on this

Under section 3 (2) the Minister has got very wide powers in regard to either the exclusion or inclusion of classes. With regard to many of these powers, orders are subject to positive confirmation by this House. On the other hand, we are enacting in this measure enabling legislation of quite wide scope. I would like to ask the Minister if he has any immediate intentions in regard to inclusion or exclusion, or could he give us examples of the type of class he might, within the next few years, consider either excluding, under one of the subsections, or including under a later one?

Comment on this

I could not give any indication now. Any order made under this subsection must be laid before both Houses of the Oireachtas and approved by both Houses.

Comment on this

Is this put in as a safety clause, in case the Minister wishes to change, rather than with a view to any particular date?

Comment on this

On subsection (4) of section 3, there is another omnibus provision, not quite as wide as the one referred to by Senator Alexis FitzGerald on the last Bill. It reads:

... may include such transitional and supplemental or other provisions...

This is an interesting phrase. We might well be inclined to say "transitional and supplemental provisions necessary or expedient," in order to bring the Bill into effect. However, here we have "transitional and suplemental or other". Though the laws governing construction might say that "other" is not completely open here, I wonder why it is necessary at all? In addition, it says:

... appear to the Minister to be necessary or expedient.

We consider a thing to be necessary or expedient for some particular purpose, the purpose is not specified here. If it said it was necessary for bringing the Bill smoothly into operation or for the better operation of the Bill that would be one thing: but "as appear necessary or expedient to the Minister for any purpose" verges towards an absolute discretion in regard to necessity or expediency. Has the Minister any comment on that?

Comment on this

It is intended to apply to minor modifications, mainly transitional, of course.

Comment on this

As the Minister appreciates, I have no objection to "minor"; neither have I any objection to "transitional", but the section says far more.

Comment on this

It is a necessary power in this type of legislation where simple modifications could impede the better working of the Bill when it becomes law.

Comment on this

Again, we find that, although this is not as wide as the section in the last Bill we were considering earlier today, there is no time limit on this particular section. It appears to me that, if we put this in without a time limit, an order can be made by the Minister which can include other provisions which appear to the Minister to be necessary or expedient.

Comment on this

This seems to me a very wide power. The Minister states that it is meant to deal with minor and transitional matters, but the section does not say so. It says this and then goes on to widen it so much that it would not have mattered because the limitations already made are completely obliterated by the wider provisions of the remaining parts of the subsection.

Comment on this

Again, here you have the safeguard that it would have to be approved by both Houses.

Comment on this

The only thing on which I would agree with the Minister is the safeguard that it would have to be approved by both Houses of the Oireachtas. Senator Dooge remains suspicious of the word "other". He says this might be tied by certain rules. My experience is that interpretation can have pitfalls because there was one instance in which the Attorney General ruled that a motor-car was an animal under "or other"; it could be deemed to be included. There was no reference to inanimate objects but the Attorney General took it that it included inanimate objects. I would be suspicious of "other", I must confess.

Comment on this

I should like to support the argument made by Senator Dooge. This is a very wide discretion for a Minister under an omnibus clause. I do not like the way in which it could be construed. I do not think it is an adequate safeguard to provide that orders will be laid before both Houses. I anticipate that during the next few years a very large number of orders will have to be laid before both Houses simply because we are creating this type of derogated legislation in practically every statute we pass. Therefore, the review may be a much less careful one than it might be and Parliament ought not allow this sort of omnibus discretion to be given to a Minister.

We have to put in the safeguard in the legislation itself that Orders cannot be made with such general discretions. Like Senator Dooge, and on top of this argument which I make both as a lawyer, looking at the very wide wording, and as a member of the Committee on Statutory Instruments, I agree with Senator Sheldon that these words are open to very wide interpretations once they are on the Statute Book.

Subsection (4) does not lose anything by being without the words "or other". What the Minister has said he is looking for is flexibility in relation to transitional and supplemental provisions. That he has got. He has also got under section 5 the power to amend or revoke an Order. He has got a great deal of flexibility in this section and the particular wording goes further than we ought to allow because of the possibility of its giving an unfettered discretion not only for what is necessary but for what is in the opinion of the Minister, expedient. We do not accept the fact that the order must be scrutinised by the House as a sufficient safeguard because the experience has been that very often such orders are not looked at with the special care and attention they should get.

Comment on this

On the question of subsequent review by the House, I welcome the fact that many of the provisions under the important sections of this Bill are subject to positive resolution here. This is an improvement on what is happening in regard to certain other legislation.

Nevertheless, there are severe limitations to this apart from the question of the House's own ability to pay attention to all the matters that come before it in this regard. As I understand it, it is not possible to amend such an order so that, if the Minister comes forward with a provision for 20 things he wants to do, 19 of which are properly supplemental and incidental, the only alternative the House has is to vote against all 20 or accept all 20, because it agrees with 19, which are purely expedient and necessary for the purposes of the legislation agreed to by the House, but does not like the 20th, does not think it necessary and does not think it properly supplemental and incidental. The Minister should think carefully about this. The easy thing to do is to enact it the way it is here, but that is not a good thing to do. The standard of our legislation suffers very much by this. If the Minister used the words "transitional, supplemental and incidental" instead of the words "transitional and supplemental or other", I would be far happier about this section. Would the Minister think about this between now and Report Stage? I hope to put down an amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I am prepared to have to look at this. The House should consider this type of subsection, and the power it proposes giving to the Minister, in the wider context of the whole Bill. The Bill is calculated to give certain privileges to workers that have not heretofore been established legally. Anything one may do in this direction is an improvement. This is new legislation and undoubtedly it will uncover some flaws or anomalies. I will be happy to come along to bring in new legislation for the sake of small modifications that may be required. It is only wise and sensible to have a simple provision of this kind.

Comment on this

The Minister is asking for a provision as against what I have suggested. He is asking for a provision which allows him to do things that are neither transitional nor supplemental nor incidental. Those three categories should be sufficient for what the Minister says he wants to do. Perhaps the Minister would think over it and we could debate it on a subsequent Stage.

Comment on this

It looks as if the Senators are not going to give me the Report Stage today.

Comment on this

The Minister has already agreed to take the Report Stage of the other Bill on the 17th.

Comment on this

They are two separate Bills.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) provides:

The Minister may by order amend or revoke an order made under this section, including this subsection.

This is a matter of drafting. The words "including this subsection" are included so that it may be possible to amend an order which has already been made under this section. Is it necessary to include the words "including this subsection"?

We, on the Opposition side, bring forward amendments which we think are highly necessary and they are continually dismissed by Ministers on the ground that, while they might improve the Bill, they are not strictly necessary. I ask the Minister are the words "including this subsection" strictly necessary in this case?

Comment on this

It enables the Minister to amend or revoke this subsection.

Comment on this

No, it does not.

Comment on this

It certainly does not.

Comment on this

An order made under this may be superficial.

Comment on this

Are the Government and the Parliamentary Draftsman allowed to put in superficial phrases which are used as an argument against Opposition amendments? When we feel that these amendments are matters of substance they are dismissed on the grounds that we should not put anything into a Bill which is not necessary.

Comment on this

I can see the need now for having that there. If it were not there there could be certain orders that one could not revoke.

Comment on this

This is my difficulty because, if we look at the Redundancy Payments Act, 1967, the phrase is not there. Either the phrase is unnecessary, in which case it should be neither in the 1967 Act nor in the 1973 Act, or it is necessary, in which case it should be in both the 1967 and the 1973 Acts. I ask the Minister either to strike this out of the Bill or, if it is necessary, then we have the 1967 Act as an example of legislation in which this was not done.

Comment on this

I do not think we should strike this out. "Including this subsection" is necessary there. If a Minister revokes an order under that subsection he revokes an order he has already made. If he wants to amend or revoke that order, again these are the words which enable him to do it.

Comment on this

The Minister is now arguing that the words "including this subsection" are necessary. If we look at section 4 (6) of the Redundancy Payments Act, 1967, to which this Bill is tied, that subsection reads:

The Minister may by order amend or revoke an order made under this section.

The words "including this subsection" are not included. Is it then necessary to amend the 1967 Act?

Comment on this

This is a separate Act and, however much it may be designed in accordance with the other Act, it is a separate piece of legislation. With due respect to Senators with a better knowledge of the law than I have, those three words are essential.

Comment on this

My argument is an argument for consistency rather than an argument of the law.

Comment on this

They may be superficial but they do no harm.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister remembers that when dealing with Opposition amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In subsection (4) to add to the subsection the words "provided that nothing in the order shall have the effect of reducing the amount of notice to which any employee is entitled under subsection (2)".

As it stands the section indicates merely that the Minister may vary the amount of notice. Accordingly, the Minister could by order reduce the minimum period of notice under subsection (4). I propose the subsection be amended so that it reads:

The Minister may by order vary the minimum period of notice specified under subsection (2) of this section provided that nothing in the order shall have the effect of reducing the amount of notice to which any employee is entitled under subsection (2).

Comment on this

Which subsection?

Comment on this

The amendment is to subsection (4) which refers back to subsection (2).

Comment on this

Subsection (4) of which section?

Comment on this

Section 4, amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

The Senator is dealing with the first amendment?

Comment on this

Yes. The amendment seeks to ensure that any order made by the Minister under subsection (4) can only have the effect of increasing the notice to which an employee is entitled. By the full process of legislation we are passing this Bill into law. There are two main principles in the Bill one of which is enshrined in Section 4. An employee is entitled to notice and as of this date we consider the amount of notice to which an employee is in general entitled if he falls within the included classes is what is given under subsection (2) of section 4. The Minister provides in subsection (4) for a variation of this. It would be inappropriate that he should vary this notice downwards, or reduce the entitlement of any employee by order even though that order has to come before the Houses of the Oireachtas for approval by positive resolution. We should provide that that subsection cannot be used to reduce the entitlement of an employee by making the amendment as suggested.

Comment on this

The words proposed by the Senator in the amendment are unnecessary unless we overlook the whole spirit of the Bill. The word "various" means in this case invariably an upward adjustment. The whole spirit of the Bill is to ensure that the minimum is observed and that any adjustment should be upwards. It is written into the Bill that the terms of a contract which would make for lesser period of notice would be invalid. The terms of the Bill must prevail in spite of any contract which may be entered into. This is something the Senator argued about in relation to my three words in the previous section. Nobody would cause this section to be changed in the belief that there would be a reduction in the minimum as laid down in the Bill. This is taking a sledge hammer to kill a fly.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

No one is taking a sledge hammer to kill a fly: it is just the addition of half-a-dozen words proposed in the amendment to make the intention clear, which is in accordance with the spirit of those who have proposed this Bill to us. I strongly support this amendment. It is wrong for any Minister to have power to reduce the minimum period provided for in this section. The Minister states that he does not wish it, so let him not take it.

Comment on this

There is no reference to the employer who is also entitled to notice. The Senator is implying that workers need protection against the Minister and the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

No, I am merely stating we should have legislation which is in accordance with what is desired to be the law which the Minister tells us is his wish. It should take appropriate form which would seem to be that which is suggested in the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

There is no difference of opinion here about the spirit of this legislation. The whole purpose of the Committee Stage of a Bill is to convert spirit as agreed on the Second Stage into letter as determined on Committee Stage.

I am concerned with the letter of the law of subsection (4) of section 4. I intended to put down a very simple amendment which was to change the word "vary" to "increase". If the Minister would accept that I would be happy. My only worry is that the Minister might wish to amend subsection (2) not by increasing the amount of notice but by reducing the service required in order to attain a given amount of notice.

That is why what I have put down in this amendment may appear unduly long. The intention behind the wording of the amendment is to allow the Minister to increase entitlement either by increasing the degree of notice to which a person is entitled or by reducing the period for which he would have to be employed in order to be entitled to a given degree of notice. If the Minister wishes to bring into the Bill the intention of only using this in order to improve matters I suggest we should either, on this Stage by agreement or on Report Stage, strike out the word "vary" and insert the word "increase".

Comment on this

I should like to support this amendment. We are not quibbling about words; it is a matter of substance. I appreciate the Minister's view of the word "vary" in this context may be an inevitable varying upwards but the word is not confined to that interpretation and would not be viewed in that way.

During the Second Reading debate in the Seanad on 19th December, 1972, as reported in the Official Report at column 1377, the Minister explained some of the bargaining which took place to fix the minimum terms. This did not seem to be as untouchable as it might. I quote:

Any criticisms Senators may have of the Bill and any amendments they may contemplate putting forward may be based on the fact that they may think the week's notice is too short on the lower end of the scale. Employers may think the eight weeks is too long at the top of the scale. We tried to get an optimum that would be reasonable.

For that reason there is some substance in the fact that the word "vary" might well mean that some future Minister might give in to pressure from employers that at the top of the scale the notice was too long and "vary" might well mean a change in the terms.

I support this amendment as I would not like to see the word "vary" on the statute book in this context even though I accept the Minister's assurance that as he sees it "vary" will inevitably mean a varying upwards. This is a minimal and intelligent amendment on Committee Stage to achieve the purpose about which we all agree— that any amendment ought to be an amendment upwards but that the word "vary" has that possibility of not being an upward change.

Comment on this

I have an open mind on the matter but I think it is ridiculous in view of the provisions already in the Bill for bringing orders before the Houses of the Oireachtas. An employer is also entitled to get notice. This refers to employees only. If Senators insist I am prepared to change the wording but it would show a lack of faith in the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

We make many acts of faith in regard to what Ministers do. If there is clear agreement that this subsection would not be invoked except to increase the entitlement of the worker then the subsection should say so. I would be grateful if the Minister would yield to our scruples in this regard. If I withdraw the amendment the Minister can perhaps consider the best way to amend it between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will do that.

Comment on this

I would just like to say that some of the subsections of section 4, notably subsection (3), refer to the First Schedule. Perhaps the matter could best be debated on the Schedule.

Comment on this

Section 5 relates largely to the Second Schedule of the Bill. We reserve the right to discuss this Schedule.

Comment on this

Just a question here: section 6 is concerned with the right of the employer to notice. I should like to ask the Minister in this particular regard what is the sanction of the employer. If the employee does not give the requisite notice of one week, I take it that in every case wages would be owing to the employee from the employer. I take it that what is likely to happen in such a case is that the employer would withhold wages in lieu of the one week's notice which had not been given. I should like to ask if this section entitles him to do so and if this section has the effect of making it impossible for an employee to recover as a debt wages due; if we are creating a right on the part of the employer to be given at least the sanction of withholding wages up to an amount equivalent to the notice which has not been given.

Comment on this

I should like clarification on this matter from the point of view of an employer. We are concerned very much here with the notice which must be given to employees. There is another side to the story for which there is no legislation. Many employers may train people for long periods. They spend time, money and effort on this. Then one day they find their employees have gone. Wages are not held over for a week. If employees are paid by the week there is a custom in some firms that a person's wages are not paid and then he is paid the second week's wages. Employees are now paid by the week to a greater extent. The employer has no redress whatever in law or elsewhere to come back at an employee for any loss he may suffer as a result of the employee walking out without notice. While we must ensure that all workers are safeguarded, employers are not all ogres. They need a certain amount of protection also. If they are not covered under this Bill I should like to see an Employers' Rights Bill coming in. It is long overdue.

Comment on this

I did ask whether the section does create an entitlement on the part of the employer to withhold wages as a sanction for non-receipt of notice from the employee.

Comment on this

The employee may have been paid on Friday and may have taken up other employment on Saturday. In that case there is no money owing. The question of breach of contract arises. It is up to the employer to take whatever action he can under the contract.

Comment on this

What would the Minister define as a contract? Usually one does not have a contract signed and sealed in many of those cases. I do not think we should beat about the bush in this particular case. This does happen. An employer can insist on the employee giving him six weeks' pay?

Comment on this

One week's.

Comment on this

Yes, one week's. The question has not been answered.

Comment on this

Under this Bill the employee has to get notice of his conditions of employment. He is aware that he is obliged to give a week's notice to his employer on leaving. In regard to Senator Farrell's point regarding an employee who has been undergoing training to improve his skill and then walks off, this is a very common thing. The employer would be stupid not to have a contract providing that when the trainee has reached the full pitch of his or her skill he or she will serve for a certain term of employment. It is a loosely knit arrangement if there is no contract to ensure that there is a reciprocity on both sides.

Comment on this

What redress has an employer in this case? An employee can claim, if brought to court for breach of contract, that he has no money or no property. The employer is just wasting his or her time pursuing the matter.

Comment on this

This Bill is intended to provide for minimum notices not to arrange contracts for people who will not make them themselves or who cannot enforce them. We cannot expect to tie up the employees in every conceivable situation. We are simply providing the legislation that they at least get a week's notice and in certain cases as much as eight weeks' notice. We do not propose writing into the Bill all sorts of terms of employment that may be enforceable. I cannot say if there is anything in the Bill which would cover the situation where the employee has no money and the employer cannot get compensation.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say if in the case of an employer whose employee walks out on him at a time when there is one week's wages due to that employee, such employer rings the Minister's Department and asks the question: "Am I entitled to withhold that one week's payment in view of section 6 of this Bill?" what answer will he get?

Comment on this

He will get the usual Civil Service answer that it depends on the merits of the case.

Comment on this

We might as well pass to section 7 because the point overflows from section 6 to this section. The Minister has not raised any objection to this question of the withholding of payment. Would the Minister object if section 7 were amended to allow the employer to withhold? Section 7 subsection (1) states:

Nothing in this Act shall operate to prevent an employee or an employer from waiving his right to notice on any occasion or from accepting payment in lieu of notice.

This allows either of them to waive the right to notice. It allows the employee to accept payment. A simple amendment here would allow the employer to withhold payment. Would the Minister have any objection if this section read:

Nothing in this Act shall operate to prevent an employee or an employer from waiving his right to notice on any occasion or from accepting or withholding payment in lieu of notice.

This would give a statutory right to the employer to withhold payment. It would, miraculously, allow the Minister's Department to give a definite answer to a question.

Comment on this

No, I think the question with regard to withholding the payment does not make sense, whatever about the legal phraseology. If somebody walks off and there is pay owing to him, he will not be paid for the time he did not work. Payments are made weekly in 99 per cent of the cases. In no case would there be a week's pay owing, unless the employee walked off before his pay-packet was handed to him on Friday. Most likely the employee goes to other employment after he is paid on the Friday. There are no wages owing to him.

Comment on this

Not everybody is paid weekly.

Comment on this

Most are.

Comment on this

Many are paid fortnightly.

Comment on this

Section 7, subsection (1), the right to waive notices, is a very necessary and convenient subsection. An employer and employee frequently find themselves in the position where the employee is taking up new employment next day. Both of them agree on this matter. We must have provision for this. I do not think it is necessary to include in that section the right to a week's notice.

Comment on this

Apparently it is necessary, if the position is not clear under section 6. We may have an employer who is anxious to do the right thing. He will be anxious to save himself money in respect of a person who has left him without the proper notice. The conscientious employer might only wish to do this if it was his entitlement. We are leaving the employer in the position that he does not know what he is entitled to do. The Minister is right in saying that the practice would be that the money would be withheld in most cases where it was possible to do so because of the manner of payment.

Comment on this

Is it right then to say that he is entitled to withhold payment in respect of the week where there may, in most cases, be nothing due? This also seems silly.

Comment on this

I said withhold, not recover.

Comment on this

But there may be nothing to withhold.

Comment on this

Agreed. He has an entitlement to withhold but this is not possible.

Comment on this

In any case he would withhold if possible.

Comment on this

I think we are discussing it on the basis that no employers have a conscience in regard to such matters and some of them have.

Comment on this

There is no penalty specifically written in for the employee not giving notice. One can easily see the difficulty of enforcing such a penalty.

Comment on this

We should leave that matter as it is.

Comment on this

For the moment.

Comment on this

Section 8 is something which we should all like to see here. One of the difficulties which would occur to anyone reading the section is the question of what is misconduct. Chapters of the history of industrial relations are devoted to the determination of what is misconduct on either side. If we look back to section 1 we have no definition of misconduct. Is the question of misconduct now a matter which would be determined by reference to the Redundancy Payment Appeals Tribunal under section 10?

Comment on this

Yes, in the first instance, and possibly to the High Court, if necessary, afterwards.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that this is the most suitable body for determining this particular matter?

Comment on this

It certainly could not be argued that a definition of misconduct should be written into the Bill because it would be impossible to define. One cannot argue that an employer must be left with no redress if he finds an employee with his hand in the till, or doing something which is gravely prejudicial to his employment or his employer. This is contained in every Act in relation to employment. Misconduct does not carry with it any special privileges. If an employer finds an employee is guilty of serious misconduct he has this redress or if an employee finds that an employer is guilty of some offence he also has the right to walk off the job. We must have this provision in the Bill. It can always be argued that it will be abused, that some employer will pretend that an employee is guilty of misconduct, but those who are familiar with the appeals tribunal will agree that they give a fair hearing in all cases. If the people concerned are not satisfied they have the right of appeal to the High Court.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that we should delete the section. I only wanted to prove the particular scope of misconduct. I yield to Senator Alexis FitzGerald.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Would it help the Bill if we added the words "entitling the employer or the employee to terminate the contract"?

Comment on this

I do not think that would improve the matter.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

This is a matter of ascertainable law.

Comment on this

This is the type of point which I was going to develop. I should like to refer the Minister back to the equivalent section in the 1967 Redundancy Payments Act, that is section 14. The Minister has indicated that the Redundancy Payments Tribunal is an appropriate body to determine whether or not there is misconduct. They would already determine this matter under the Redundancy Payments Act. But this Act, in section 14, goes into much more detail in regard to the definition of misconduct than does section 8 of the Bill before us. It says:

...if his employer, being entitled to terminate that employee's contract of employment without notice by reason of the employee's conduct, terminates the contract because of the employee's conduct....

It then gives three conditions. It goes on in subsection (2) to refer to the effects of this particular condition when strikes occur.

There is no dispute about a person being found with his hand in the till being guilty of misconduct but some employers consider going on strike as misconduct. It should be necessary to give protection in regard to this.

If it was thought necessary in the 1967 Act to spell out the question of misconduct in the detail which takes up a half-page of the Act, then we need something more than a single word or phrase in section 8. One is struck by the difference between the very short reference to misconduct in section 8 of this Bill and the rather long reference to misconduct in section 14 of the Redundancy Payments Bill.

Comment on this

The Redundancy Payments Act does not attempt to define misconduct either.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

No, but it links it up clearly with the question of entitlement to terminate the contract of employment, in the case of such misconduct.

Comment on this

It excludes certain situations specifically from the particular provisions of the section.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

I could imagine somebody arguing this matter and drawing attention to the fact that the Act of 1967 could be looked to. The fact that the language in the 1967 Act is not in this Bill would mean that the kind of misconduct to be examined might be of a different nature from that which would entitle the determination of the contract. This section is, of course, in the English Act and this is how it has come into ours.

Comment on this

The section of the 1967 Act relates to strikes only.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Yes, but it uses the language "being entitled to termination of the employee's contract of employment" in subsection (1).

Comment on this

It says:

Nothing in this Act shall affect the right of any employer or employee to terminate a contract of employment without notice because of misconduct by the other party.

All this infers is that if a person is aggrieved and feels that there is not justifiable misconduct, he has the right to appeal in the first instance to the tribunal and subsequently to the High Court.

Comment on this

I should like to follow up Senator FitzGerald's point. If, in fact, we use the simple definition in this Act and the more complex definition in the 1967 Act, would not this tribunal, which spends most of its time dealing with questions under the 1967 Act, be very concerned with the fact that the Oireachtas has used the word "misconduct" unadorned in this Bill before us? It will see before it a reference to misconduct which is very different from the reference to misconduct in section 14 of the 1967 Act, take notice of this difference, interpret accordingly, and say that something which might not be misconduct under the 1967 Act, because of the limitations put into it, could well be taken as misconduct under this Bill when enacted.

Comment on this

An employee who had at least two years employment would be appealing under the Redundancy Act rather than under this Bill because that is the Act under which he would suffer the greatest penalty if there was wrongful dismissal.

Comment on this

He might win his appeal under the Redundancy Act and lose it under this one.

Comment on this

He would be much more concerned under the Redundancy Act because his lump sum, weekly payments, and the question of his continuity of employment might be at stake. In this case the period of notice——

Comment on this

An entitlement to payment in lieu?

Comment on this

The same tribunal would be dealing with it as deals with the redundancy definition of misconduct.

Comment on this

I do not think we should take the attitude that we can console a person by saying to him that he has one of his rights when he is looking for two.

Comment on this

He would be most likely to plead under the other Act.

Comment on this

Would he not plead under both? If he was summarily dismissed for misconduct——

Comment on this

Contrary to what the Senator is saying, the fact that the absence of a more clearly set out definition of misconduct here would give rise to the feeling that a lower standard is required, I take the opposite view. The other Act will be likely to be cited as the one which lays down "misconduct" if—and I do not believe for one moment that it does—it in any way defines "misconduct" any clearer than it is defined in this Bill. The only thing it does is to point out about strikes.

Comment on this

It refers to strikes in subsections (2) and (3) but in subsection (1) it refers to the termination of a contract because of the employee's misconduct under the condition that the employer is entitled to terminate without notice by reason of misconduct. This is either defined in a contract or is in some way a right which an employer has under general conditions of employment. I think there is a real difference in subsection (1). If we look only at subsections (2) and (3) we can say this is a question of strikes—this in itself is significant—but I think we must look at all three subsections of section 14 of the 1967 Act.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

Also may I add, this Bill will apply to a category of employment to which the Redundancy Payments Act will not apply at all.

Comment on this

That is correct. A person having two years continuous employment would not come under the Redundancy Act and he would still be entitled to his week's notice under this Act. I still think that the section is adequate. One could argue for a week over this but we must have the section. Senators will agree that one cannot define misconduct.

Comment on this