Finance Bill, 1973 ( Certified Money Bill ): Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 1–116 of 226. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 17 of 1973 ›
Section 2 relates to a matter to which I referred last night on the Second Reading. It is concerned with the amendment of section 138 of the Income Tax Act of 1967, an Act passed six years ago when a certain level existed with regard to the pound sterling and what it could buy. We now have a situation where, six years afterwards, an amendment is introduced which is only a niggardly throwaway towards income taxpayers; it is an amendment to raise from £74 to £104 the earned income allowance in regard to a wife's earnings. It is painful even to talk about this and more painful that the Minister for Finance, in introducing his budget, should claim this as a concession. It is the only single concession, in small print, to income taxpayers. It is a very niggardly, to put it mildly, concession from the point of view of the fall in the value of money over that period. If one were to work out the precise figure at which this should operate, having regard to the fall in the value of money since 1967, one should be talking in terms of a figure of around £250 instead of £104. I am not now talking off the top of my head in this respect. In a recent survey done by the Economic and Social Research Institute, impartially conducted by Dr. Brendan Walshe, it was calculated that, in this area, a figure of £208 to £312 a year would be a reasonable figure as far as working wives are concerned having regard to the fall in the value of money.
Comment on this
At the present point in time having regard to the fact that, in 1967, a figure of £74 was fixed; so, at this stage, having regard to the fall in the value of money since 1967, we should be thinking in terms of a figure over £208, a figure in the region of £200 and £300.
Comment on this
I was just wondering what we should have been thinking of last year when it was still at £74.
Comment on this
We are talking about section 2 of the Finance Bill, 1973. What is involved in this meagre concession to income taxpayers does not even acknowledge the fall in the value of money but merely makes a throw-away gesture by raising from £74 to £104 the earned income allowances as far as married women are concerned.
There is nothing in this or, indeed, in any other section in the Bill, to indicate any recognition or knowledge of the fact that the people who count in this country are the working people and those who invest their savings. These are the people who need help if this community is to make progress. If we are going to have economic development here there must be some recognition and help as far as they are concerned. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions have recognised this and have made a submission to the Minister along the lines on which I am speaking. This is the only section that gives even meagre recognition to the category that makes this community tick.
There is no point in having a budget and a Finance Bill concerned with spreading jam thinly on the bread with an odd give-away here and an odd give-away there. What any Government should be concerned about, especially a Government elected and there, presumably, for their full term of office, planning to make the economy expand, not just this year, but next year, and over their full term in office, which they hopefully may expect to occupy. It is not enough to have giveaways two weeks before a Presidential election.
A Government genuinely concerned about the economy and future development of the country would concentrate totally on various income tax remissions in the areas of earned income relief and personal allowance. There is no point in trying to tackle the bucking bronco of inflation by doing nothing in these particular areas. All we have set out in this particular subsection is a meagre increase, nothing like the increase that would be justified in regard to the fall in the value of money between 1967 and 1973. This meagre increase is the only concession in this Bill to the huge income tax paying public. The income tax paying public were at one time called the middle classes. Income tax catches every class in the community now. If incentives are to be given to encourage people to work harder, to work overtime, to invest their savings in the expansion and development of our community, they must be in this area.
Any Government concerned about the future economic and social development of the country should be concerned about encouraging and giving incentives to those who provide the basic motivation in the community. All we have in this budget for those who work and invest their earnings is this meagre throw-away which does not even acknowledge a fifth of the rate necessary in regard to working wives. There is nothing else in regard to earned income allowance, nothing else in regard to personal allowance. Indeed, there is a negative attitude adopted in regard to people with a net income over £2,500. I shall refer to that later. This is the only concession by this Government to the people who count in the community as far as work and progress is concerned.
Comment on this
Like the Taoiseach, I find it difficult to be moved by the insincerity of the words of Senator Lenihan. The increase represents an increase of over 30 per cent on the 1967 figure. He says here that in order to meet the increase in the cost of living since 1967, an increase which took place during six years of the administration of which he was a member, the increase ought to be of the order of 250 per cent. The Senator wants an increase of £74 to £176. I am doing rough mathematics and taking rough figures. If I am correct in my assessment he wants an increase of the order of 250 per cent. In all our allegations against the Fianna Fáil Party, we took some care in making them and we never suggested for one moment that there had been an increase of the order of 250 per cent in the cost of living since 1967. That dispels the whole basis of the suggestion of Senator Lenihan. We are proposing an increase from £74 to £104. This, for the first time brings the married allowance and the wife's earned income relief to £598, which is double the amount of the single allowance. That is a gesture worth making and is something more than a gesture.
Comment on this
It is something which costs half a million pounds this year and £850,000 in a full year. This in a year in which we have increased social welfare allowances by £39 million. These benefits, both in relation to the earned income relief and the children's allowance, go in the main to the working wife who works because her social circumstances and inadequate family income require that she go out to work to supplement the unsatisfactory and inadequate earnings of her husband.
Of course, this allowance is of no consequence to the wife of the wealthy man who can employ a maid and domestic servants to look after the children and the family in the house while she goes out to work and her professional or well-to-do husband is working as well. That is why Senator Lenihan considers it as insignificant. It is of some marginal significance to the working wife——
Comment on this
——the factory worker who goes out to supplement the inadequate family earnings. If Senator Lenihan was aware of the problems affecting industry, particularly in the urban areas, he would know that a large number of our factories are working under capacity because wives are discouraged from working because of inadequate income tax allowances applicable to the earnings of wives.
We have made significant improvements in the family income, in the disposable income, of families in this country on a scale never equalled in the history of this State. As well as that, we have given this concession to the working wife. We consider that it is a worthy one and that the basis of the attacks made upon us is without foundation. The cost of giving income tax reliefs at the lower level, because the Government in power for 16 years did not give adequate relief at the lower level, amounts to £7 million for every £20 of relief that is given. That £20 is the income relieved, working out at about a net relief of between £6 and £7 for earned income. The cost of doing that is £7 million. We are now giving relief to a group in the community, most of whom work through nothing in this budget — the working economic necessity and hardship in their family area, and we feel quite justified in doing that. This is, we hope, but a small beginning of a great reform in the whole tax code which we propose to carry out in the period which I note Senator Lenihan anticipated and that is the life span of the present Government.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister's phraseology. It is a gesture of course. It is totally marginal. This is precisely my point. The idle flinging around of millions amuses me. He talks about something that could be done positively in this area which would cost £7 million when, in fact, by Government decision in order to meet election promises we have £16.75 million removed from the VAT net and we have £12.7 million brought in as a burden on the Exchequer in order to meet another promise in regard to health charges and rates. So, in order to meet haphazard election commitments we have straight away got nearly £30 million between the removal of health charges from the rates to the Exchequer and the removal of VAT on foodstuffs.
Surely within the ambit of that £30 million odd there was ample scope straight away for very immediate and urgent reforms in the income tax code, immediate and urgent reforms in regard to substantially increasing the earned income allowance, substantially increasing the personal allowance so as to guarantee an incentive to people who want to work and who want to invest. I do not think the Minister is in the land of the living. The situation has rapidly been reached in regard to income tax that it is a totally nugatory exercise for anyone to work overtime any more.
People are becoming conscious of this and we are very rapidly developing into a situation where it will be a community of do nothing in regard to the operative section of the community, a situation where there is no incentive to work, no incentive to expand, no incentive to invest. I am repeating myself here but I believe very sincerely and positively that if this country is to make progress those are the people who are going to make this country. It is precisely those people who have got and investing people of our community.
There is no point in the Minister talking about being circumscribed from the budget point of view when he knows that the only thing that circumscribed the Government and has circumscribed the Minister in regard to his particular budget was the fact that there were election commitments unnecessarily made. There was no need to make them. I said last night that in my view they added enormously to the corrupting of our democracy and these particular election commitments circumscribed the Minister for Finance and it is around his neck and around the necks of the Government that this particular thing hangs. This was not part of our policy, it was part of their policy and by reason of their policy, and by reason of the adoption of it in this particular Finance Bill, very desirable reforms in the income tax area have been prevented from being undertaken by reason of the fact that a rates burden of £12.7 million had to be shifted in regard to health charges to the Exchequer and over £16 million had to be moved in regard to food. I appreciate that the £16 million odd is being channelled in another inflationary direction in the non-food VAT area. That is another day's work and we will have a debate on that when it comes up in the section.
The fact of the matter on this section is that this niggardly amount towards working wives is not nearly enough. The Minister knows it is not nearly enough and not alone is that not nearly enough but not nearly enough is being done in the Bill as a whole towards this particular section of the community. I take this opportunity to speak on this matter because this section represents the only concession in a Bill of over 100 sections to the income tax paying people of this country. It is useless for the Minister to come in here and say the money was not available to do this and that, that it would cost £X million to radically increase the personal allowance or £X million to radically increase the earned income allowance. I know that. We all know that. In a year, when the Minister for Finance faced a situation where he had practically £30 million to distribute in this direction were he not circumscribed and hung up on election promises in regard to the removal of health charges from rates and the abolition of VAT on food, the Minister had £30 million with which to play, to work on, with which to develop.
Practical reforms are needed in the whole area of income tax. The Minister should acknowledge that. These facts form the basis of the document submitted by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions to the Minister, a document which pointed out that a large number of our people, part-time working farmers, and those at every level of pay, are now paying income tax. Therefore, income tax is not only a matter of concern for the middle classes; it affects all classes. Most small farmers are dependent on some wage earner in their own household who again is being crucified by income tax and for whom nothing is being done in this Finance Bill other than the the meagre pittance embodied in this section.
Comment on this
I do not think I will be called on to deliver a Second Stage reply to a Second Stage speech on the third section of this Bill on Committee Stage. I should just like to say that during a period of 16 years in Government the previous administration made three nugatory, niggardly, insignificant gestures on the income tax front and now they have the effrontery to make an attack on us in a year in which, as I have already emphasised, we have made the greatest contribution to family incomes ever, not only under the social welfare code but also in the fields to which I am grateful the Senator has drawn attention.
The £12,500,000 that the Exchequer has now absorbed as a burden on the Exchequer is in relief of the ratepayer who in the main is the family ratepayer. That is a further assistance given to families and to the heads of families. The other aspect is in relation to the removal of VAT from food which is the largest item of consumption in every family budget. We make no apology for abolishing, for the first time in ten years, tax from food. This section speaks for itself. It is in relief of the wife who finds it necessary to work. It is a step in the right direction. Because we have not run 100 miles in the first nine weeks of office we have this demonstration of indignation on the part of those who have totally neglected the problems of the taxpayer during their own 16 years of office.
Comment on this
I am astonished, although I should not be astonished at anything the present Minister for Finance might state. However, even by his normal standards, I find rather astonishing his claim that during the past 16 years there have been but nugatory gestures by Fianna Fáil in relation to income tax allowances. Can he not remember that only about 12 months ago no less than £11 million was provided by Fianna Fáil in the annual budget in relief of the income tax payers? I have already mentioned this on the Second Reading in the Minister's absence, but I now remind him of it so as to encourage him to do still better in his next budget. The Fianna Fáil Government gave an extra £50 on the allowances for single people making it £299. They gave £50 relief for widows, £70 for a married couple, and £20 for child allowance, the total cost being £11 million. If he calls this nugatory and all the other adjectives he used, it gives me great encouragement as to what his all-embracing reforms are to be. We can look forward to a great future.
Comment on this
——to meet living cost increases of about 120 per cent, those who did that have no right to criticise us for not doing more in nine weeks. I have given the assurance before and I give it again that this is a field of reform in which we hope to do something very substantial, but you obviously cannot help the poorest of the poor social welfare recipients and at the same time give income tax relief to those who are earning a great deal more.
Comment on this
I cannot let the Minister off the hook as it is not only a question of nine weeks. I spent seven years in a Government debating budgets and Finance Bills and an automatic matter at every discussion prior to the presentation of a budget was what could we do for the income tax payer within the limits of what was available. We appreciated that there was a situation where a limited number of people from the non-agri-cultural sector were paying income tax, that this was a growing sector and that these were the people who mattered in the community.
Year in, year out — I have not the precise figures but Senator Yeats has mentioned last year's figures — there was a concession or a number of concessions in the whole area of income tax, particularly in the area of personal allowance and earned income. This was always a major consideration. At every Government meeting prior to the budget there would be an assessment made of what the Exchequer could bring in and on the basis of that assessment there was great attention devoted to what could be done in this direction. The Minister need not plead the question of nine weeks; that is nonsense. This could be done in a matter of weeks if the will were there, but the will could not be there as practically £30 million was willed out of the way by reason of the Government seeking to corrupt the voting public and as a result of that they regarded themselves as committed to the total strangulation of the VAT system by removing it from food and adding to inflation by putting it on non-food items and, secondly, because of the transfer of the health charges from the rates to the Exchequer. Straight away the Government had £30 million less to play with. That is the way it works out and the Minister now knows this.
There is no point coming into this House and telling people who know their business that this could not be done in nine weeks. This could have been done at once if the will had been there. Obviously nothing else is incorporated in this Finance Bill related to the income tax payers and no thought could have been given to it because the Government had strangled themselves in advance by pre-election promises.
Comment on this
In the last section we were discussing, to quote the Minister's words, "a marginal gesture towards working wives" which is the only marginal improvement so far as income tax payers are concerned. We are now discussing not an improvement but a minus so far as income tax payers are concerned. Here we have possibly the most nefarious section in the Bill. It concerns the question of family allowances which are an all important factor in cushioning people with large families against increases in the cost of living. In this inflationary age, induced to some extent by the Minister's VAT proposals in another area, we have a situation where incomes in excess of a net £2,500 are being excluded from the children's allowance provisions.
It is impossible to defend this matter.
The prime requirement in the present budget and in our present times must be to substantially increase family incomes. The Minister may think the family allowance increases written into the budget and the Finance Bill are good but I do not think they are good enough. If there is any area in which the Minister and the Government can cushion people against increases in the cost of living this is the area in which it should be done. Instead of having an army of inspectors to enforce completely mythical price control, which cannot be enforced, instead of having Ministers introducing price control measures and then having to agree to increases in prices which they had a month before set, instead of having the Government in a situation where, with regard to increases in CIE fares and rates, the National Prices Commission announce a certain level of increases and the Government have to give a greater increase, instead of going into all this fruitless area of price control and price supervision with a massive bureaucracy involved, all to no effect as we have seen, why not be practical about it and substantially increase family allowances?
I agree there are increases in family allowances in the budget but I do not regard them as nearly sufficient. Family allowances should be increased in a straight, clean manner without any army of bureaucrats to supervise price control. Instead we have an example here in section 3 where there is a negative attitude adopted by the Minister and the Government in regard to people with an income in excess of £2,500 a year. When the next pay agreement comes the net will be spread even wider and a greater number of people will be drawn into this category. I cannot understand the Minister's thinking in this matter because, on the ordinary basic canons of social justice, how can it be justified that on one side you can have a family of ten children with an income of £2,600 a year and on the other side you can have a family of two children with an income of £2,400 a year? One category is included while the other is not. Why introduce this matter in any event?
I appreciate, and this comes back to the point I made on the last section, that the Minister by reason of election promises was circumscribed and that the election promises hung around his neck. By reason of that he had to claw back £1 million. A million pounds, as the Minister quoted in the Dáil, is the figure involved in the claw-back provision, as it is called. In order to claw back in tax terms, vis-a-vis children's allowances for people over £2,500 a year net, the Minister for the sake of £1 million — where he could have had £50 million to distribute were it not for election promises — has introduced this nefarious section leading to the type of social injustice I have just mentioned.
I should like to make a suggestion to the Minister. We in the Seanad can only suggest it by way of recommendation. It has already been suggested to him in the Dáil. I cannot understand why some attempt has not been made by him or by the Department of Finance to do it. If this has to be done and if, having regard to the electoral commitments made by the present Government prior to the election, they are circumscribed in regard to current expenditure and they had to get £1 million at the expense of people over £2,500 a year net and they have to discriminate against people with large families over that level as against people with small families under that level, why not adopt a simple grading scheme in regard to children? Why have any level at all? If we have to have a level why not grade upwards having regard to the number of children so that parents with a large family with an income up to £3,500 or £4,000 a year might qualify and have it graded downwards and upwards in that manner? Were the brains of the Department of Finance applied to that particular aspect? Was there any attention given to it? If the Minister wanted to claw back £1 million why not attempt that and thereby have some rudimentary element of social justice emerging from the decision which had to be made by reason of the pre-election commitments of the Government?
Comment on this
I should like to join with Senator Lenihan in his condemnation of this. As I said on the Second Stage last night, were it not for the fact that there are children in this nation there would not be any Parliament, there would not be any schools and there would not be any hope for the nation in any way whatever. We have to realise that any economies we may try to make down at the infant level will eventually react on us and the nation will have to pay very dearly for them later on. I wonder do many people realise the hardships that parents with families of ten, 12 or 14 children endure. It is quite easy for people to set criteria and to draw different standards between incomes but children need food and have to be fed. This is retrograde thinking. It is something that should be rectified. I would prefer to see a graded system, as Senator Lenihan has suggested. I feel that it is wrong, especially on a fundamental issue such as this, that we are niggardly in our approach to giving relief to those people who are blessed with having large families. They are the wealth of the nation but they are costly to sustain. We in Parliament should recognise the problems of those parents.
Comment on this
If there is validity in the arguments advanced by Senators Lenihan and Dolan, then they have twice the validity in attacking the Fianna Fáil children's allowance claw-back. In the statement, to which the Taoiseach referred in his reply to the Second Stage, issued by the Fianna Fáil Party five days before the last general election, Fianna Fáil acknowledged that the time had come for selectivity in the payment of children's allowances. Accordingly, their proposal was that children's allowances would be paid to only 170,000 families. That was the Fianna Fáil proposal which was contained in The Irish Press published on the Friday before the last general election. Fianna Fáil said they would pay increases in children's allowances to only 170,000 families.
We have given children's allowance increases to 319,000 families which is nearly twice the Fianna Fáil number. Therefore, I do not think I am being unreasonable in questioning the sincerity of those who attack our plan. We confer benefit on eight out of every nine children in the State because they will get the full children's allowance increases. Even wealthy parents will lose nothing but, in fact, will have a marginal gain.
Why did we choose the income tax system to deal with this increase rather than the Fianna Fáil proposal? The answer is that the Fianna Fáil selectivity proposal would have required that every family would have to apply annually to the Department of Social Welfare and produce evidence of income and qualified children. Children if they once qualified would continue to be eligible until they reached the age limit but income would have to be proved annually on yet another certificate. God knows we already have enough means tests. We have something like 16 welfare means tests in this country and Fianna Fáil propose yet another in order to disqualify nearly half of the people now entitled to children's allowance.
We could not consider that would be justified. First of all, it would impose an unnecessary burden on families and, secondly, it would also involve that army of bureaucrats that Senator Lenihan pretends to dislike. We would need to have many hundreds, to say the least, if not indeed a thousand or more additional civil servants in the Department of Social Welfare to handle children's allowances' income certificates, which would have to be assessed every year. That is the only other way in which it could be done. When Senator Lenihan asks whether brains were applied to this I want to assure him they were. It is because brains were applied that they show just how impossible in administration and how unduly costly would have been the Fianna Fáil proposal.
Under the income tax code an income taxpayer's income is recorded. His income is known and it has to be returned for income tax purposes. Each person is given such allowances as he is entitled to under the income tax code in respect of mortgage interest payments, medical insurance premiums, bank overdraft interest and superannuation contributions. All these are known, catalogued and computerised, in the offices of the Revenue Commissioners. That being so, there was a readily accessible, efficient way of dealing with this matter. It also had the humane aspect which I mentioned and that is that we are going to give the allowances to about 150,000 more families than Fianna Fáil had proposed. We feel our proposal was well justified.
I would briefly put a few questions to Senator Lenihan if he wants to answer them. Does he agree or disagree with the Fianna Fáil statement before the last general election that certificates should be introduced for children's allowances? I suspect he does agree. If he does, at what point would he introduce them? Would he introduce them at the point which was proposed at which only 170,000 families would get benefit or would he prefer — and I gather from his speech he does prefer — that they be introduced at a point at which 319,000 families would get it?
Comment on this
I gather Senator Lenihan prefers to see it introduced at the higher level that we have introduced it. I think no more need be said. He agrees with our proposal.
Comment on this
The Minister appears to be unduly obsessed with the election guarantees and statements. I said on the Second Stage last night that part of the present Government's trouble is that they made very rash commitments in regard to the whole area of estate duty, in regard to the removal of VAT from food and in regard to the removal of health charges. This is why the Government are so niggardly in regard to relief towards income taxpayers. That £30 million is being thrown away by reason of rash election promises.
I am not talking about the general election. I am talking about the section of the Finance Bill that is before us. That is section 3 of the Finance Bill, 1973. I would ask at this stage, though I am certain it will be a fruitless request, that some brains be applied—they should have been applied when the matter was first raised in the Dáil — towards introducing a graded scale whereby basic social injustice would not exist, injustice such as results from a situation where people with large families on one side of the £2,500 are cut off and do not benefit from the children's allowances proposals in the Finance Bill and people with small families on the lower side of the £2,500 benefit. It is as basic as that.
I am concerned about family incomes and the importance of families, the people working and raising families in the community, the people who are making a real contribution towards society. This is so basic and rudimentary that I would have thought the Minister would appreciate what I am getting at and leave aside his obsession with election manifestos. He should feel a bit more secure now. The election is over. There is no point in talking in terms of election manifestos. We are talking in terms of a situation where the consumer price index in regard to food has risen eight times between the election and May compared with three times since February, 1972 and May, 1972. We are living in a situation where the cost of living in regard to food alone stood at 131.6 points in February, 1972, and increased to 134.6 points in May, 1972. This year the figure rose from 153.4 to 161.4 in the same period, and is probably still rising.
We are talking about a new situation altogether. The Minister should get it into his head that we are not fighting an election campaign but are talking about the people of the country who will be affected by this Finance Bill. We are talking about a situation where the Minister has written in here that a £2,500 net income is the cut off point as far as children's allowances are concerned. We are discussing a Finance Bill in which no concession is given to the income tax payer other than the niggardly concession to married working wives. We are now faced in this section with not just a zero but a minus as far as the income tax payers and general income earning public are concerned who are in this category of over £2,500 a year, a category that will be massively increased if a national pay agreement in the months ahead is based on anything like the sort of escalating inflation that the present Government are contributing to.
The Minister should stop talking about election manifestos and get down to the Finance Bill. I ask the Minister to apply his brains and those of his Department to this matter and I would suggest again: why not a graded scheme, going to any level one likes and even far ahead of £2,500 a year, but at least a scheme based on the number of children per family instead of the existing scheme where there is a crude cut-off after £2,500 a year? Why not have something of that kind which would take into account the basic social justice involved in looking after larger families? It is as crude as that. I am pointing it out in black and white terms that somebody on one side of the £2,500 with six, eight, ten or 12 in the family is cut out and people on the other side with one, two or three children are in. There could be nine more mouths to feed and because they are on one side of the barrier they are out. A graded scheme surely should not have been beyond the wit of the Minister and the Department of Finance to devise.
Comment on this
I would agree with what Senator Lenihan has been saying. The method adopted for having this cut-off at £2,500 is an extraordinarily crude, rough and ready one. It seems that on this occasion and a number of others the Government took the easy way out. Instead of thinking it through properly they adopted a rough and ready figure like this. As Senator Lenihan has pointed out, someone with a very large family in or around the £3,000 figure is clearly not anything like as well off as parents with maybe only a couple of children at around £2,500. Yet he gets none of these benefits and the others do. It really seems a very strange way of doing it.
There is one very small matter which the Minister might be able to elucidate. He just said that the income tax payer does not lose the whole of the increase in children's allowances but that there was a marginal amount left. In the Dáil the Minister said:
The reality of the situation is that of all the families receiving children's allowances only 40,000 will have to hand them back and not in toto. They will still be left a small amount of the increase.
That is all very well but when one reads the explanatory memorandum to the Bill in the third paragraph one finds at the end:
As the full amount of the increase is taken back by the reduction in allowances for income tax purposes, the reduction will not apply for surtax purposes.
Which is correct, the memorandum or the Minister? What is the position?
Comment on this
Well, £15 is the amount of the additional children's allowances this year. The maximum refund will be £14.70 so there is a gain of 30p per child.
Comment on this
The Minister has, not for the first time perhaps, been less than candid when he said in the other House that after all they were not being taken in toto, that they had a bit left. I think whatever his intention may have been the impression was certainly created that quite a bit more than 30p a householder was left.
Comment on this
Of course, in some cases the refund would not be as great particularly when you get into the marginal area, but there is marginal relief there. Nobody will be any the worse off. I think it is important, when suggestions were being made that taxpayers were being mulcted, to make it perfectly clear that nobody, even the surtax payer, will have any additional sum taken from him. What is happening is that the social welfare increase is going only to the people who are in the lower income group. I believe that that is a sustainable social policy for which we need make no apology.
Comment on this
Could the Minister explain why this change is being made. It appears that this, I do not know if you could call it a concession but at any rate state of affairs in relation to trusts in favour of children, under which when the person became entitled to the capital sum he would have to claim personal allowances dating back for a number of years, is being ended now. I wonder why is it so. Was there some kind of abuse which arose? Is it retrospective? In other words, are trusts which were made last year or the year before last under the impression that this concession would still be in existence to be effected and will the child now not get the full benefit that was expected when the trust was set up?
Comment on this
Yes, I can understand these legitimate fears of Senator Yeats and I should like to explain the purpose of this section briefly. The matter was raised in this House last year by Senator Alexis FitzGerald. It is designed to deal with the problem in which extremely wealthy people can afford to assign under a trust certain income which is accumulated for the benefit of minors during their minority. Because of this, the person creating the trust is saved tax on that money which is alienated to another and yet the minor when he comes of age can then apply for repayment of some of the income tax. The trust will pay the tax all right but when the infant arrives at the majority age he can then apply for a refund. This has enabled quite wealthy people to avoid payment of tax on money which they have assigned for the benefit of their children.
It might be arguable socially that it would be all right if everybody could do it, but when it is a device which is only available to the quite wealthy who have surplus income I think there is no moral justification for it. On a legal basis, the Income Tax Act, 1967, section 154, deals with the cases of persons for whose benefit any income is accumulated under the terms of any will or settlement contingently on his attaining a specified age, or marrying. The section provides that, after the happening of the contingency, the person may within six years from the end of the tax year in which the contingency happens, make a claim for a repayment in respect of income tax which was paid by the trustees in respect of the income which arose during the period of accumulation. The amount repayable is the amount which would have been repaid to the person concerned if the income had been his as of vested right during the years of accumulation by reference to his personal allowances and reliefs for those years. It might also be of interest to know that this particular device was noted in the British Parliament in 1969 and it was closed in the British Finance Act, 1969. The then Chancellor of the Exchequer said that he proposed to repeal the existing provisions, which we are now doing. He said:
This is an anomaly which even the most single-minded devotee of tax loopholes would find it difficult to defend.
Comment on this
I would be inclined to agree with the Minister that there is no particular reason why one should have undue sympathy with the people involved. One wishes oneself had the kind of money that appears to be involved in this type of transaction. I do not think he answered my second question as to whether it is retrospective.
Comment on this
I am sorry, I did not. It will only apply to income from this year onwards and people who, in good faith, established such a trust in the past will not be affected except in so far as income accrues from this year on. It will not apply to any past income.
Comment on this
I might say that this section may not change the law. It removes a doubt which may exist in relation to it. It was never intended that the executor or administrator of a deceased member of a partnership should not be under an obligation to pay whatever income tax was due by that partner.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not mind my saying that this whole operation is typical of what one gets in Finance Bills. Here we are deleting an entire subsection. The only result of deleting it is that the law thereby becomes clearer.
Comment on this
Mind you, if we could pass a Finance Bill to make all finance laws as clear it would be well justified.
Comment on this
This is also a matter which is an improvement. Senator Lenihan will be glad to know that this is a relief and has the result of increasing from one and a half to four times the amount which can be paid by way of superannuation benefits without tax.
Comment on this
This is not really a matter for us but it puzzles me because I was told that this particularly relates to trade union pensions. I think the Minister has given them what they have asked for. It seems a little mean that since no change has been made for six years since 1967 all they are asking for is an increase from £350 to £450. One wonders why somebody at one stage was not a little more generous with their pension schemes.
Comment on this
I think that is a valid point but it will be appreciated that the increase now given is comparable to or perhaps slightly greater than the increase in the cost of living since 1967. The amounts paid by trade unions have tended to be on the low side but that is because there are limitations on their funds and their subscriptions. One has to look at this in the historical sense. There are other much better superannuation and benefits in provident schemes available outside what is available within trade unions themselves. If the trade union benefit was the only benefit now available to the people, this of course would be quite a ridiculous sum but there are now many better benefits obtainable elsewhere.
Comment on this
Why are these particular groups taken out? It seems a bit airy-fairy to confine a concession of this kind just to human rights groups under the UN and the Council of Europe. There are many other bodies who should, from the point of view of tax concessions, be included in this category of charities. Let us take, for example, Gorta, which is a national organisation under the FAO. Why should Gorta not be regarded as a body suitable for this sort of treatment? This may be tied up with some conventions we have signed or to which we are committed, but it seems anomalous that we should pick out what I would regard as a very small field of voluntary activity related to international agencies while there are many other fields offering aid with which we are associated. A similar concession should be given to Gorta. I am rather puzzled and I should like an explanation from the Minister as to why this concession should be confined to the one area of human rights under conventions of both the Council of Europe and the UN.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a further point on this. I also think it very odd indeed that these anomalous, mysterious bodies, some of which I have never heard of, should be mentioned. My argument is added to very considerably by a couple of lines in the introductory speech of the Taoiseach on the Second Reading. He said:
This country has, I regret, been somewhat lethargic in its adoption and its promotion of the observance of international conventions relating to fundamental human rights and freedoms. In order to stimulate more public awareness of and direct involvement in this very important task the Bill made a special two-fold provision for tax relief.
He goes on to describe sections 15 and 22. We appear to be in a situation in which the Government are giving a tax concession to certain organisations in order that they can press upon the Government the need to sign certain conventions. Would it not be much simpler for the Government to sign the conventions to start with and forget about the tax concessions?
Comment on this
I am glad to say that the Government have decided that the UN covenants dealing with political, social and economic rights should be signed. We regret the fact that our predecessors did not see their way to make such a decision. We propose to proceed towards ratification.
Comment on this
It will. I am sorry if Senator Lenihan does not like what I am saying. I am trying to reply courteously to Senator Yeats. The point has been made as to why we should not do more. We would be happy to do more for other worthy organisations, but we thought it was timely that we should seek in some way to give encouragement to those organisations which do not get much money. We thought it might be some enticement to philanthropic people to consider some of these organisations if this tax concession were available. Unfortunately, we have a very sorry record in relation to signing and ratifying, respecting and putting into practice several international conventions concerning fundamental rights and human freedoms, not because we have individually or collectively any disinclination to do it but we simply have not done it in a formal way. We would like to see that situation corrected. The reason why we chose to give this benefit only to organisations who had consultative status with the United Nations or the Council of Europe was because we wanted to ensure that spurious organisations claiming to serve fundamental rights and human freedoms would not get this benefit. We do, unfortunately, know of some organisations who claim to be defending human rights and who, if they got their way, would trample upon the rights of most people. Organisations do not get consultative status with either the UN or the Council of Europe unless they have passed very severe tests applied by these organisations.
I was asked in the Dáil if I would name some specific organisations. I expressed unwillingness to do so and it is preferable that I should not. First of all, I am not certain of the exhaustive list of organisations who have such consultative status and there may well be organisations, including the one mentioned by Senator Lenihan, who could apply for, and qualify for, consultative status with these organisations. If and when they do, and make their application to the Revenue Commissioners, then they will get the necessary concession. This benefit, as Senators are probably aware, is already available to people who covenant money to universities or colleges for the carrying on of research and income under covenants to schools for the teaching of the natural sciences. This is a small extension of that. Perhaps over the years we can extend this kind of concession, but one must realise that sometimes to extend these concessions opens a floodgate which might prove unduly costly.
Comment on this
Arising from what the Minister said, there is no contention in this matter. I just mentioned Gorta off the top of my head; I am sure there are other organisations that would fit into the same philanthropic category. The only thing that concerned me was that we were narrowing the area of tax concession in this desirable philanthropic area by confining it merely to the human rights area within both the UN and the Council of Europe. I agree with the Minister that there are a lot of spurious organisations that carry this label and the Revenue Commissioners would find it difficult to decide between the few legitimate and the many illegitimate organisations in this category. An organisation like Gorta occurred to me straight away as an organisation under the FAO which is an agency of the United Nations and which is concerned with very legitimate practical help towards needy people when need arises. This is a very practical area of help where the label of human rights is not involved. It has become a label in many areas. Am I right in interpreting the Minister as saying that organisations which may not necessarily carry a human rights label as such, on a literal interpretation of the United Nations or Council of Europe Conventions, such organisations may apply for this type of exemption to the Revenue Commissioners?
Comment on this
They would, first of all, have to get consultative status with the international bodies. They would not necessarily have to recite fundamental human rights in their title in order to qualify for consultative status. As long as an organisation is able to prove bona fide that it is pursuing certain UN objectives, it can get consultative status. It would be a matter for proof in each case and each case would have to be dealt with on its merits.
Comment on this
But why confine ourselves in this very desirable area? I am looking for the thinking behind the section. Why confine ourselves to what the UN or the Council of Europe decide in regard to human rights validity or otherwise? Can we not decide on such desirable national philanthropic groups without tying ourselves to some human rights convention or charter which in many cases is a lot of nonsense? There is no point in claiming extraordinary credit for signing some of these conventions. Why can we not decide on what is desirable and philanthropic within the compass of our own sovereignty and treat such organisations as the Minister proposes under this section?
Comment on this
The Senator put a specific question to me so I must, therefore, answer it. I am not prepared to accept that international conventions are a lot of waffle. It is sad that they have been so regarded by so many people here.
Comment on this
The recital of the Ten Commandments may, to some people, be a waffling recital but they contain some fundamental truths. That is the position about international conventions. They are matters of truths which, unfortunately, people do not take seriously and particularly under stress. That is one of the sad things about life. I do not regard this as the end of the concessions which ought to be given to organisations of this particular kind. We are making a start this year. We think we are making it in the right direction. We will see how it works. If we consider that this is unduly restrictive and that organisations which are legitimately pursuing these aims have some administrative difficulty in getting consultative status with the UN and the Council of Europe, we will take another look at it. It may well be that we would consider other ends of a merciful and humanitarian kind, but we believe in walking before we run.
Comment on this
Would the Minister take into consideration in his examination of the matter, which I understand will be undertaken within the next three months, bodies which do not have consultative status with the UN or the Council of Europe but which we may legitimately decide are bodies doing equivalent or better work?
Comment on this
This is welcome of course. I know there has been tremendous and rightful agitation and concern about thalidomide children. I am glad that this matter has been met here under section 19 but I feel this is an area of social progress that should be furthered. There are other people suffering to the same or a greater degree than thalidomide children and I should like to think that they also come in for consideration in this regard. I do not know what machinery one would establish to keep this matter under review but it is a very desirable area. It is an area you cannot widen too much — I can see the problems of any Minister for Finance here — but now that we have accepted this as a matter that should be dealt with in regard to thalidomide cases we should not ignore other cases of even greater severity which arise and which should merit the same attention. What machinery should be established to do this or to ensure this can be done is another day's work, but I think this matter should be kept under constant review and attention should be continually devoted to it.
Comment on this
This is a section which will ensure that children in Ireland who are victims of thalidomide will be put precisely in the same position as children in Germany who will be receiving payments from the same fund. It is provided under Federal German law that children in receipt of capital or income from the fund will not have their incomes subjected to tax. I might also point out this section also ensures that a father is not to be deprived of the income tax allowance in respect of a child who has income from this German fund.
To deal with the other point raised by Senator Lenihan, he himself was good enough to provide the answer for me. We, of course, all have the natural inclination to go to the assistance of people who are handicapped. Most people tend to want to use the income tax system to provide that assistance. Probably it is not the best way either to recognise or to give assistance to handicapped people. It may well be better to provide the assistance to identifiable cases rather than opening the flood gates to claims under the fiscal code which may be very difficult either to prove or disprove. That is one of the great difficulties involved here. How do you, for instance, under the fiscal code deal with a malingerer? I say that without reference to any particular welfare code. The Revenue Commissioners are not qualified to deal with cases of either mental or physical handicap. It is better to deal with such cases through the ordinary welfare code and the system of family health rather than dealing with it through the fiscal system.
We are bringing in this provision for the unfortunate thalidomide children of whom we believe there may be up to 150 in the country. Most of them, if there is income tax involved, will be relieved. This will ensure that they will be in no way disadvantaged compared with their fellow victims in Germany.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister that it would be altogether impractical to help all handicapped people by means of the income tax system but he should consider looking at this from the point of view of those who have been injured, say, in road accidents and get an award in court which may be a very large sum of money. If the victim should be paralysed, perhaps the money is invested for him. He has to live on the interest on that money, but I understand that money is assessed for income tax purposes. These cases seem to me to be precisely on the same footing as thalidomide cases. They are easy to keep track of because they are court awards. The Minister should consider very seriously the possibility of adding this category of people to this section.
Comment on this
There is a slight difference. In road accident cases, where damages are paid in court, the court in assessing damages take into account the victim's liability for income tax on the award. Just as in calculating the person's likely income if injuries were not sustained they take into account what the person's net income would be after deduction of anticipated tax. The two categories are not quite on par because of that fact. It is only right that the wrongdoer should be made liable for the income tax liability of the victim. Were we to introduce a law which said that such damages or compensation would not be liable to income tax the beneficiary would not be the victim but the wrongdoer or that person's insurance company.
Comment on this
In relation to the point which the Minister has just made, the position about income tax on losses which are suffered by a person injured in an accident is going through a type of transition period in the courts. The position at the moment, as I understand it, is that the courts will allow the loss of wages to date, makes allowance for the fact that income tax would have been paid and allow the award to be somewhat smaller because of that. They do not allow it for the future for the reason that if a person is totally disabled he will have to invest the money which he gets and he would, in fact, have to pay income tax on it. Even though they may say that this man would have earned £2,000 a year for the next 20 years and he would have to pay income tax on it, the courts take the view that that should not be taken into account because the amount will be invested and income tax will be payable on the income from the investment. To that extent Senator Yeats is right in saying that possibly the Minister should look at this kind of situation.
Comment on this
I bow, of course, to the superior wisdom and familiarity with court procedure of Senator Ryan. But this matter was tested at law in England and on a decision of Gourlay v The Transport Commission it was decided that the figures ought to take the tax position into account.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to explain the rationale behind the choice of subjects which are singled out here for income tax relief. Two areas are mentioned, the area of industrial relations and the area of marketing. There is a third clause which states "any other subject which is approved for the purposes of this section by the Minister for Finance".
The subjects chosen deal with productivity, or the sort of entrepreneurial area of our national life. It makes a distinction between fundamental and applied research in universities. In the third case it is confined to universities where, quite clearly, such research could be as valuably carried out in technological colleges and various institutes. Does this mean that the Government are only concerned with helping those areas which are, in the crude materialistic sense, productive or would clause (c) admit a subject which, in the first place, would involve pure research, say, into the areas concerned — industrial, marketing or commercial — or would it also admit research into matters which are not strictly productive such as knowledge? It may be a remote possibility that some industrial organisation or commercial combine would endow research in metaphysics, in literature or in poetry or, more relevantly, in languages but it would be unfortunate if this were not possible under clause (c). Singling out these two materialistic entrepreneurial areas of research indicates a materialistic bias behind the thinking of those who framed the legislation. I should like to hear the Minister's comment on clause (c). What kind of area of research might possibly be approved? I am not suggesting they should endow a chair of polemics or a lectureship for student agitation.
Comment on this
The House will recall that the Taoiseach, in replying to the Second Stage, dealt with this point. Perhaps the Senator was absent at the time. The reason why the two specific disciplines of industrial relations and marketing are mentioned in the Bill is that specific proposals have already been made to found chairs in these two disciplines.
Subsection (c) could be used to cover the several worthy objectives which the Senator referred to but the power is reserved to the Minister for Finance to consider these proposals if and when they are made. There is no intention of confining this benefit to universities. If concrete proposals are put forward where substantial sums of money would be covenanted to or made available for other institutions of learning and research, we would not hesitate to take the necessary legislative action to bring them in. We are hopeful that we have not just turned on the green light for universities in relation to this matter this year but, perhaps, people will do some serious thinking about it and we may have worthwhile proposals for consideration in future years. There will not be any great loss by not making the provision in this Bill for any such proposals as usually it takes at least a year or two to formulate them and to make the financial resources available. I would encourage Senators to incite philanthropists to step forward and we can deal with these cases when they arise.
Comment on this
Subsection (c) provides wide discretionary powers to the Minister for Finance. Is there any right of appeal?
Comment on this
At this stage it would be inappropriate for me to indicate what my mind would be on any particular proposal. I would want to see the merits of the specific proposal but my mind is not closed; on the contrary, it is very open.
Comment on this
What criteria will be employed to check on every business entertainment and to ensure non-evasion and that there is respect for the law?
Comment on this
The matter does not arise until a taxpayer puts in a claim for a tax allowance on entertainment expenses so inspectors are not required to sit in every luxurious restaurant to see who is dining and wining too well. The test will be generously interpreted by the Revenue Commissioners so as not to exclude genuine entertainment expenses which arise in the ordinary course of business or in the promotion and maintenance of business contacts. This matter has been abused to the extent of taking out to dinner and providing holiday facilities for one's friends and rivals in the same line of business not for the purpose of generating trade but to have a high social life at the expense of the taxpayer. If the well-to-do can get their entertainment at the expense of the Revenue Commissioners, the general taxpayer must foot the bill.
Comment on this
I welcome this provision. For too long the taxpayers have been exploited in this regard. One can see business executives at 4 o'clock any evening in city hotels recovering from their wining and dining. Not alone are they wasting the time of their firms but, as the Minister has said, they are exploiting the taxpayers. I feel that any steps that are taken to alleviate this are steps in the right direction.
Comment on this
This appears almost to give freedom to exploit not only the lands of Ireland but also our coasts. Are we not being too generous with assets which will be exhausted?
Comment on this
The intention of this section is to do the very reverse of what the Senator contemplates. We are bringing within our tax net profits which may be generated on the Continental shelf in the development of our marine resources. Such profits would not now be caught and we are providing in this section that they will be caught in the future.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that the raising of this from £500 to £1,000 will prevent abuses?
Comment on this
This penalty is all right for the purpose of discouraging evasion. It is a penalty which is only imposed after court proceedings are taken against a defaulter and the court is satisfied that the person has been guilty of default. In a case where a person has inadvertently or, perhaps, on medical grounds omitted to make returns they would not be caught. It is only used by the Revenue Commissioners when they are are satisfied that there is wilful default or negligence.
Comment on this
Perhaps the question I am about to ask would be more relevant on the section dealing with the increase in value-added tax. Am I right in saying that as a result of the budget two increases in the price of beer have been proposed, one in this section and the other in the proposals to increase value-added tax?
Comment on this
The answer to the question is in the negative. We have indicated that the excise duties on beer, spirits and tobacco will be reduced on the 3rd September. The VAT element will then come in and the overall figure will remain the same.
Comment on this
I do not think it was necessary to impose this tax at all. It was part of the only little comfort that the less privileged of our people had. While we may be gathering in revenue, we are depriving them of a certain amount of enjoyment. Because of the five-day week nowadays and the amount of leisure time people have at their disposal, that type of legitimate enjoyment should be encouraged rather than discouraged.
Comment on this
The net yield is £4.68 million, which is not something that can be lightly thrown away.
Comment on this
I am only dealing with the extra taxation. The net yield from this addition is £4.68 million. I do not know whether the Senator will be encouraged or discouraged by the knowledge that the consumption appears to be rising rather than declining since the budget. There has, in fact, been quite a significant increase in tobacco consumption in recent years despite the efforts of the State to discourage people from it for health reasons.
Comment on this
There seems to be various lines of thought on this. At one end of it through the medium of television we are encouraging people to indulge in tobacco and here, in the Dáil and Seanad, we are trying to prevent them by adding on extra taxation. My contention is, especially in regard to plug tobacco and a particular type of cigarettes, that they are an essential part of life at present. It is wrong to continually add on tax to cigarettes and tobacco in particular.
We all know that in rural areas pensioners and elderly people enjoy a smoke. Even in other countries they enjoy smoking, too. The Indians enjoyed their pipe of peace. A contented community is very important. Weighing them down with taxation on commodities is unjust. They do not go to the races or go on foreign holidays. Many of our rural people enjoy their pipe of plug tobacco. Each year it has become the tradition to increase the taxes on tobacco. It is time that a halt was called to it. We have lots of talk about cigarette smoking causing cancer, and doctors agree and disagree about it. It would be much better if we, at some stage, got away from those so-called traditional avenues of taxation and let the people enjoy themselves. After all, we are in this world to enjoy ourselves in a reasonably healthy manner. The rural man or the small income man is entitled to enjoy his cigarette or his pipe of tobacco. Extra taxation should not be imposed on the less fortunate and the lower paid income group year after year. The higher income group smoke cigars.
Comment on this
I do not wish to get into a theological argument with Senator Dolan on the Finance Bill but I would have thought we were in this world not for enjoyment but to win enjoyment in the next. If I were assured that one would obtain universal peace in Ireland by the removal of tax from tobacco, I would certainly remove it. But I do not think there is any social, political, or moral evidence that peace would be obtained by the removal of tax from tobacco. I said earlier that I have an open mind. If any conclusive evidence of this can be produced, I will certainly yield.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the increase he is responsible for is the greatest increase imposed on cigarettes in the last 20 years? If it is the greatest in the last 20 years it is possibly the greatest ever.
Comment on this
The answer is "no." I am trying to get to the figures. Certainly in percentage they are less than has often been imposed. When I get the figures I will produce them.
Comment on this
I do not know why it is necessary to use percentages. We all know you can play around with figures to suit each side. The facts are that non-tipped cigarettes have been increased by three new pence a packet. We have had budgets in the past that were described by the Minister's party, when in opposition, as "cruel budgets" but which carried increases of only a few pence on the packet of cigarettes. An increase of three new pence, which in old money is equivalent to 7½d, is — I speak subject to correction on this, and no doubt I will be if I am wrong — the greatest increase ever imposed by any Minister for Finance in any budget in the history of this State.
A few minutes ago the Minister stated that even with this increase the cigarette consumption appears to be on the increase. There was a time cigarettes were considered a luxury. Today cigarettes could be, for many of us, an absolute necessity. Whether cigarette smoking is good for us or bad for us should not be a consideration in this budget. In this section the Minister is imposing the greatest increase ever in the history of the State on this necessity of life.
Comment on this
I inadvertently said that the figure was not greater than any imposed in the last 20 years. I was thinking of the total increase in duty on beer, spirits and tobacco when I said that. The total figure is a lot less. In relation to cigarettes the increase is, all right, three pence this year, but in relation to the amount of money now being spent on cigarettes, and the total price, the increase is not significantly greater than has been imposed in the past. We live in a different day and age to ten or 20 years ago and I think percentages do matter because they indicate what people are prepared to spend on a commodity.
To quote the words of the immortal Deputy Haughey, he said on one occasion that the old reliables always come up smiling no matter what you impose upon them. A Minister for Finance naturally succumbs to the temptation to use them. It appears that the old reliables, even in relation to tobacco, are still smiling after the budget this year and in fact the consumption is on the increase.
Comment on this
I think we are rapidly reaching the saturation point. Tobacco has become much too dear. The question of cigarette smoking from the medical viewpoint is another matter. The Minister could get over that by removing the tax on ordinary pipe tobacco and encouraging the people to smoke a pipe rather than cigarettes. I would not like to see the youth of this country prevented from enjoying a smoke if they felt like it. It would be much better than have them going on drugs. These are problems which we have with the youth at the present. I would not encourage people to start smoking. But in regard to those who are addicted to it and those who got a certain amount of enjoyment out of smoking all through life, it would be wrong in their old age to try to force them to abandon such practices and try convert them overnight. The Minister should seriously consider this matter especially in regard to plug tobacco and pipe smokers.
Comment on this
There is, of course, a special rebate for the home produced pipe tobacco and particularly for the hard plug. The rebate is not being interfered with in this budget.
Comment on this
It is excise duty on certain stocks.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to enlighten me — I am an amateur as far as tobacco and smoking are concerned — as to what these extra ingredients might be. What are they composed of? Where are they made? Where are they obtained and why are they included in tobacco for export? To where do we export the tobacco?
Comment on this
Under the present law, that is the Tobacco Act, 1842, a tobacco manufacturer may not use any material other than tobacco and water in the manufacture of cigarettes. The purpose of this restriction is to prevent the adulteration of cigarettes at the expense of the revenue. Recently a proposal was made for the establishment of a factory in Ireland to manufacture cigarettes for export consisting of a blend of tobacco and a synthetic tobacco. The purpose of this section is to enable this industry to get under way, but the product will be for export only. Therefore, it has not any revenue significance as far as we are concerned, but it has got the possibility of developing in Ireland a new cigarette. As time goes on and experience is obtained in relation to the attitude of smokers to the new cigarette and to the extent of the knowledge relating to its health hazards or possibilities, then the matter can be examined so far as the home market is concerned. It means we have immediately available to us what could be a significant new industrial enterprise.
Comment on this
I just made the inquiry because I was interested to know what material would be included in this. It was news to me to know that we are going to enter into the cigarette export market. What I am interested in, apart from the revenue, is whether it could be that we are endeavouring to try something out on the dog. Are we sure that this type of operation will not be injurious to the health of the people, irrespective of where they live? In a matter that would affect the health of the people of any nation I do not think we should contribute to it in any way if it involved any danger whatever, even if it meant some employment for our people. I should not like to see anybody in this country engaged in such an activity. I am not saying that it might have that effect but if it should we should be clear on it before we give our blessing to it.
Comment on this
I am glad to say that I have the same reservations, being a person concerned with human rights and fundamental freedoms, as might be recognised from other sections in this Bill. I am most anxious that we would not try out anything on the rest of mankind that we would not be prepared to risk ourselves. Investigations were made into the health consequence and there is no reason to believe or to anticipate that there are any greater health hazards in relation to the use of the particular synthetic fibre which will be used than already exists in relation to tobacco plants and, indeed, the possibilities are that it may be very much better.
The proposal of the manufacturers in question at the moment is only to engage in the export market. They have not made any proposal to use the product here and, therefore, for the time being we are not making any new approaches in the matter. The exemption will allow cigarettes to be manufactured for export and if and when the proposal comes to make the commodity available on the Irish market we can have a look at it in that situation.
Comment on this
The Minister is again much too elaborate and I do not say this with any disrespect. I should like to know if he has any information regarding this type of cigarette being used in any other civilised country and what effects it has had on the consumer. Was it through kindness that these people came in here, or do they intend to use us to try it out on the rest of mankind? I should like to be perfectly clear on it because I should not like to see the good name of our country defiled in any way. It may be a genuine, sincere effort. If it is, I welcome it wholeheartedly but I should like to know if the Minister has any information on it.
Comment on this
First of all, I speak as a convert from the habit of smoking and most of my travels have been in the non-smoking period, so I have not yet tested the commodity myself. Secondly, it is a totally new experiment and I am not aware that it is yet being marketed commercially anywhere. The proposals of the manufacturers are to manufacture here and to export to Britain where it will shortly be available on a commercial basis. Seeing that there are, on the neighbouring island, much larger samples of people from different walks of life, I think their intention is to carry out a consumer research of the operation. If the market takes to it, then we could be well on the threshold of a considerable industrial development here. Why they chose Ireland, I do not know but, of course, we have tax incentives and grants and other facilities to encourage industrial investment in Ireland and this is one of the consequences of it. It could not get off the ground unless we were to amend the law in this respect and that is what we are doing.
Comment on this
I wonder if there is a licence duty on the import of tobacco as well as an excise and customs clearance duty. In the case of beers there is a licence duty, an excise duty and a customs clearance duty. As I understand the new regulation under the whole of Part II — I am sorry to deal with in in retrospect, but I am talking about tobacco as well as beer and spirits — is there no longer a licence duty for imported beer and is there for tobacco?
Comment on this
I am afraid all items could be allowed on the section——
Comment on this
There is a customs duty on imported tobacco but where such tobacco is used for processing here and then re-exported it may be imported duty free.
Comment on this
If I were to deal with all the items which were not put under these statutory instruments, there would be no recess this year. If you like I will run down through the particular instruments involved.
Comment on this
I do not mean that the Minister should name them individually but could I have some idea as to what they relate to.
Comment on this
The Imposition of Duties, Excise Duties, Firearms Certificates Order, 1972: this order increases the excise duty payable on firearms certificates. There is the Statutory Instrument 220 of 1972, the Imposition of Duties, Customs and Excise Duties and Form of Tariff Order, 1972. The effect of that was really to bring the customs requirements in this country into conformity with those of the EEC. It came into operation on 1st January last. The Imposition of Duties, Customs Duties and Form of Customs Tariff Order, 1973, had a similar effect in relation to the EEC on certain kinds of paper, building materials, of asbestos, cement, hinges, for motor vehicles et cetera. There was another Imposition of Duties Customs and Excise Duties and Form of Tariff Order in 1973, which extended the scheme of tariff preferences for developing countries. The Imposition of Duties No. 203 Customs Duties and Form of Customs Tariff Order, 1973, also adopted EEC common customs tariff nomenclature and removed the duties on newsprint and on motor vehicles, fan belts of Northern Ireland origin and made a certain number of consequential changes. The Imposition of Duties No. 204, Customs Duties and the Form of Customs Tariff Order, 1973, provided that the rates of customs duty be applied to certain goods of Northern Ireland or UK origin; and the Statutory Instruments No. 83 Order of 1973 dealt with beer, spirits, tobacco, hydrocarbon oils and wine. It removed certain minor protective elements on the customs duties of beer, spirits and recognised medical preparations, tobacco and hydrocarbon oils in the case of imports from other than EEC countries. The reason why it was done was that the cost of collection was greater than the revenue would yield.
Comment on this
I do not think it is involved in any of these orders. I said "building materials of asbestos cement," but that, I think, would not involve timber.
Comment on this
In this section it is proposed to increase the exemption limits from £7,500 to £10,000. Most of us would agree that the main factor contributing to the defeat of Fianna Fáil in the last election and the success of the National Coalition Government was a clear, firm and categorical promise by the Coalition parties, as they then were, to wipe out death duties. It is, therefore, disappointing for many people who believed the Coalition parties' promise was an honest one to learn that the limit has been increased by only £2,500. In recent years the value of land has escalated, particularly with the advent of the EEC, so that this provision will give no extra help.
A year ago land which would have been valued at £7,500 would be valued at £10,000 today. In providing this increase the Government are only making a gesture in this increase to give the impression that they intend honouring the most serious election promise made last February. I should like to ask the Minister if it is the intention of the Government to honour this election promise and, if so, when.