We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 120–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment)(No. 2) Bill, 1973
Enacted

No. 3 of 1973 ›

Could I interrupt the Senator? There is absolutely not one scintilla of truth in the statements which were made in the Dáil that there was not any schmozzle about those two constituencies. He was right first. The constituencies did not need to be changed and I did not change them.

Comment on this

I am very happy to hear that, but I cannot understand why it has taken him until now to say this.

Comment on this

I did not think it was worth commenting on, but when someone like Senator Yeats makes a comment of that kind I thought it was only right that I should.

Comment on this

I am happy to hear this because I have been getting increasingly worried that there were no denials of any kind about it. So we will give the Minister credit then, on the basis of the 12 constituencies that he left unchanged, that he allowed us one in West Limerick. That left eight with a Coalition majority, three with level pegging, and of the ones that were changed that were not satisfactory, none had a Coalition majority.

It seems to me we have a pattern all through the thing. You have a pattern in Dublin and Dún Laoghaire, a pattern of extraordinary, unnecessary and uncalled for changes in Cork; you have a pattern in Clare-Galway; you have a pattern all through the west where areas with rising population lose seats and areas with falling population gain seats. You have the whole situation where these 21 if they had not Coalition majorities were changed drastically. It seems to me that this pattern is one of sheer gerrymandering —that the Minister has taken advantage all round of what in most cases were very small population changes to bring in extensive countrywide changes in constituencies.

One of the great advantages of economic progress in recent years has been the massive fall in the enormous emigration that used to take place— though to our great regret, there are certain areas, for example, Leitrim, Roscommon, Sligo and other areas where the population is still falling. Even there, the changes are much less than they used be and in other areas the population is now rising and the overall pattern is nothing like as drastic as it used to be in former years. Therefore, in many cases the actual changes needed were marginal. The facts do quite clearly show that in almost all cases where extensive changes were made there was a hoped for political advantage involved.

I should like the Minister to reply to a query. There is the interesting comparison of Counties Meath and Clare. The Minister stated:

A Minister for Local Government must weigh up the competing claims of all the areas and strike a balance which is fair to all. The whole spirit of the Constitution requires an even spread over the whole country without favouring or penalising any area. This is what I have tried to do; to provide fair and reasonable representation for the people of every area.

He mentioned several times, both here and in the Dáil, that he had, so far as possible, tried to preserve the existing county boundaries.

On the basis of all this, I find it very difficult to understand why, if one compares Meath and Clare, Meath which in 1971, had a population of 71,729, was given four seats; and County Clare with a population of 75,008, was given three seats. You have Clare with a population of over 3,000 more than Meath, very near the number required to have four seats, and Clare was given only three seats and Meath was given four. It may not have occurred to the Minister when he was thinking of Meath that it might be easier for him to get a quota of 20 per cent in a four-seat constituency as opposed to 25 per cent in a three-seat constituency. I do not know. Perhaps it did not. I should like to know why Meath, on the basis of population, was treated so much more favourably than Clare.

Comment on this

When replying I will be glad to give that information.

Comment on this

The Minister introduced this Bill in a rather aggressive tone. Indeed, it was a rather unusual Second Reading speech. Normally Second Reading speeches by Ministers are fairly formal affairs. They go through the sections of a Bill, explain them, perhaps make a couple of points at the end, ask us to pass it and so on. I cannot remember a speech such as this, argumentative all through, referring to events in another place. At the end of this interesting speech the Minister spoke of the impartial observers who had told him what a fine Bill this was. I really would like to know the name of even one of those observers. Certainly the newspapers, which in most cases can hardly be said to be basically unfriendly to the Coalition, have looked at this Bill, and some of them with some approval, as a naked exercise in politics and have with some pleasure in some cases, spoken of this Bill as copperfastening the hold of the Coalition on the country and as the semi-permanent ruination of Fianna Fáil. I think they are wrong.

Nevertheless, it has been the general public attitude. I know of no impartial observers, certainly no informed impartial observers, who look upon this Bill as a genuine effort to play fair with all parties or with all parts of the country. Even if I did think it was such I would have been disabused by the typically candid remarks of the Government Chief Whip, Deputy Kelly, Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, in the Dáil. Deputy Kelly was a respected Senator, a colleague of ours for several years, given to making vigorous speeches with a good deal of candour. Reading with interest his contributions in the Dáil one sees he seems to have retained this ability. He was discussing the Minister's Bill on 15th November, the day it was introduced for a Second Reading, and he let quite a few cats out of the bag. He had a fairly excellent and accurate explanation as to why the Minister had dealt with Cork in the way he did. Deputy Kelly said at column 2030 Volume 268 of the Official Report:

The situation in relation to Cork is a special one because one would expect a good Fianna Fáil vote there by reason of the fact that the Leader of the Opposition comes from the constituency.

This is an interesting sort of doctrine for Ministers for Local Government. The leader of the Opposition comes from a constituency so, therefore, it needs special attention in a constituencies Bill like this.

In Cork in 1973 Fianna Fáil won four seats for which they paid 7,591 votes each. Fine Gael won two seats at a cost of 8,071 votes each while the Labour Party did not succeed in returning anyone to the Dáil although they succeeded in winning 4,715 first preference votes. The Minister for Local Government is not St. Francis of Assisi and it would be asking a superhuman virtue on his part to permit that situation to continue.

Alas, the Minister has not superhuman virtue and certainly he is no relation of St. Francis of Assisi. I think the Minister is more likely to be a remote cousin of that well known former Governor of Massachusetts, Mr. Gerry.

Comment on this

The Senator's colleague who made the long speech was not quite sure where the governor came from.

Comment on this

So far as I know it was Massachusetts. The Minister does all right, even not knowing that. At column 2032 Deputy Kelly discussed the sad situation, from the Fine Gael point of view, in North-East Galway, West Galway, Clare-South Galway, East Mayo, West Mayo, Clare, Roscommon-Leitrim and Sligo-Leitrim and he went into detail on the number of seats in Connacht and the number of votes per seat. Having assessed the situation he said:

How could the Minister be expected to maintain that situation?

In other words, the result was good for Fianna Fáil and on that basis how could the Minister be expected to maintain that situation. It is apparently on that kind of basis that this Bill has been framed.

We have had this extraordinary and unprecedented debate in this House. I am not sure if "debate" is the correct word. The word "debate" whether in Parliament or elsewhere suggests some interchange of opinions, that one side gives its views and is replied to in due course by the other side. I can only conclude that the silence of the Government side reflects essentially the knowledge that this Bill, by any normal standards of public behaviour, is indefensible. It is quite clear that in no genuine way has there been an effort to fulfil the constitutional obligations laid upon the Minister. It is a naked exercise in power grabbing.

However, the Minister has made a serious political miscalculation. We are not, of course, discussing the Minister here as a political judge. I think he is not a very good political judge. We are discussing his conduct as a Minister. For what it is worth, I can assure the Minister that he has made a serious miscalculation. His plans, particularly in the Dublin area, are very dangerous ones. A very slight shift in public opinion, a shift which I think has already taken place, would be sufficient to turn the whole ship around the other way. Politically, we are not worried. The sad thing is the damage that is done by a Bill of this kind to our political institutions and in particular to public confidence in politicians. It is a sad thing, where the public, encouraged by the newspapers, get the impression that this is the kind of thing that is expected of a new Government coming to office. It is assumed as a matter of course apparently that when the Minister goes into office he will try to scupper the Opposition in this legal way. That is bad. It is dangerous to our political institutions. This is a grimy little Bill. The Government Senators, by their attitude during the past two days have shown quite clearly their own view on it.

Comment on this

We in Waterford are delighted that after 13 years we have got back our four-seat constituency. I think that in 1969 we could have got back this four-seater with a little bit of pressure.

Much has been said about other constituencies. I am not worried because I am convinced that no matter what way those constituencies are chopped up it will not make any difference in the long run. In 1966 the farmers were protesting in Merrion Street and turnover tax had been introduced by the Fianna Fáil Party. Everything was against the Fianna Fáil organisation at that time. Nevertheless, they were successful in the South Kerry by-election. I am fully convinced that no matter what way constituencies are carved up you cannot dictate to people.

In 1969, when we had a three-seat constituency, it was against all odds that Fianna Fáil would not, or could not, get two representatives out of three. I thought when I came in in a by-election in 1966 I had no possible chance of retaining the seat in 1969. Here, again, the people made up their minds and I was re-elected. I do not mind what other Senators said here. It is the people who will make the difference and not the Minister for Local Government.

We have only heard speakers from this side of the House. I am sorry that we did not have contributions from the other side so that I could judge for myself who is right and who is wrong. There is no doubt that somebody is wrong. Listening to the contributions from this side of the House, I am fully convinced that it is the Government side who are wrong. How could I say anything else when I heard nothing from the other side? I have been a politician all my life but nobody knows what my politics are. I never discuss politics because to my mind everybody in this House and in the other House is entitled to his views.

We had a six-hour contribution by one of our own gentlemen. It would be very hard to contradict what he said but I was hoping that somebody on the other side of the House would do so and give me an insight into whether he was right or wrong. I cannot compliment or congratulate the Minister. Being in Opposition that is only natural. However, I thank the Minister for the fact that after 13 years we have got back our own again. I am convinced that no matter what a Minister will do it is the people who decide in the end.

We had the first Coalition Government. After three years there was a general election. Subsequently there was another general election. The Coalition were not defeated by any means. They just left office and walked out. I thought I would never see a Coalition Government again. Perhaps I am not the youngest or the oldest here but I heard a very prominent Fine Gael Minister for Agriculture advise the farmers at a meeting in Waterford city to hold their corn until the next year when there might be a better price for it. A very prominent Fine Gael man who had invited him to Waterford city asked the Minister: "Is that the only thing you have to offer to the people of Ireland—keep your barley, oats and wheat until the next year for the rats and mice to eat. I say I was always opposed to Jim Ryan, God rest him, but he was a decent man."

No matter what Deputy Tully as Minister for Local Government can do or what he intends to do he will not convince the people to vote for what he wants. The people of Ireland are very perceptive. I am not in the least worried about the slicing of constituencies. I am fully convinced that Fianna Fáil will not beat the present Government but I am convinced that they will beat themselves. If they last for four-and-a-half years there is no reason why we should not have the Fianna Fáil Party back in power.

In 1932 when Fianna Fáil took office for the first time they stayed in office until the advent of the first Coalition. Then after a break of six years they came back. Many people said that Fianna Fáil were too long in power. How many business people are there in the House? Why are they business people? They give service to the public and that is why they are in business. If you have a man who is not able to look after his business he will be a very short time in it because if he does not give satisfaction to the public he will not remain. Many people to whom Fianna Fáil are anathema told me they were fully convinced that a Fianna Fáil Cabinet are the only Cabinet that can rule this country. Needless to say I was glad to hear them say that. It is not my policy to offend anybody. Everybody is entitled to this view.

No matter what the Minister might try to do, no matter what anybody here might try to do, the people will decide whenever an election takes place. I do not know. That is up to the Minister for Local Government and the Taoiseach. I would like to thank the Minister for giving us back our four-seat constituency. To me it does not matter a damn.

Comment on this

These are my first words here today in the Seanad. I am not very long in the Seanad, but I spent many years trying to get into this House. Now that I am in, I am glad that the people who elected some of the Members here are not here today to hear what is happening. You can blame our Senator if you like for speaking for six hours, but it is a good man that can stand up here in this assembly and speak for six hours. The man who has brought this position about is the Leader of the Opposition.

Comment on this

The Leader of the House.

Comment on this

Yes. I am so used to calling it the Opposition, I cannot help it. It will not be long before I will refer to him as the Opposition again. The Leader of the House was absent all day and did not hear what happened. He walked in this evening when one of our Members was speaking. I have attended many meetings and I know a little about procedure, although I have not the intellect that some of the people here have. I am just an ordinary country man, a farmer, but here we have intellectual people and it is a disgrace to listen to the debate today. The Leader of the House walked in here this evening and interrupted a man making a speech here, and brought in his attendants with him. You were not in the Chair at the time, a Chathaoirleach. I have great respect for the Chair and for you in particular. Whoever was in the Chair did not know procedure. If he did he would have asked him to sit down.

Comment on this

The Senator should not criticise the Chair, either the Cathaoirleach or anybody who presides over the Seanad.

Comment on this

I am not criticising the Chair. I am criticising the Leader of the House. If anything irregular has happened here this evening, the Leader of the House is responsible. I have great respect for the Minister, but in this Constituency Bill the Minister has made the greatest blunder he ever made in his life. He went so far with it that he cannot stop. He went from Donegal to Cork.

Comment on this

It is a long distance.

Comment on this

Are you standing up to speak or am I? If the Senator likes I will sit down, let him speak and get up after him. They have had plenty of time all day and none of them stood up to speak. I have been in politics for 50 years. When Fianna Fáil was founded I was at the first meeting. You would not believe that I am that old. There are some people here who got into politics very quickly and very easily. Nobody can stand up here and say I am not involved in politics. No one can say that a man who has fought three elections and two Seanad elections and was a county councillor for 32 years is not involved in politics.

I have not said much here in the past 11 months in this House. What I heard this evening was a disgrace. It reminded me of an old GAA club being formed down the country, or boys who have just left school at 13 or 14 years of age having fist fights and so on. I thought when I came to the Seanad that I would be among the intellectuals. They are a disgrace and this House is a disgrace. The Leader of the House is a legal gentleman and he is to my mind the man who started it. I was backing Labour years ago—and I am still a Labour man—when some of the men here today backing Fine Gael would not give them a crust of bread. They would cut their throats. Go back to 1932 when our Government took over office, where was the Labour man? The farmers were feeding him in the cow house. They would not let them inside the door to feed them although they were working for him. Now the big Fine Gael ranchers of Ireland know what Fine Gael and Labour will do to them. Fine Gael did not want to do it to them, but they were compelled to do it to them. In the next election they will know what the big farmers will do to them.

Comment on this

The Senator has mentioned the word "election" after departing from the Bill. Perhaps he would keep to the Bill.

Comment on this

The whole thing depends on an election. None of us would be here without an election. That is what it all hinges on, getting us quickly through this Constituencies Bill in case there is a snap election. It is coming close to that. I do not want an election for four years. There must be something wrong when we want to get this put through the Seanad in Holy Week. It was never known in the history of the Seanad that it sat in Holy Week. It was not good enough to finish at 10.30 or 10 o'clock as usual. As bad as Fianna Fáil were—and they were bad enough in many ways—they never did that. When a man from rural Ireland sees a Minister for Local Government ensuring that it takes 1,500 more people to elect a Member in a rural constituency than in Dublin city, it is time to start thinking. In Dublin city you walk one and a half miles and cover your whole constituency. In my constituency alone, Carlow-Kilkenny, I have to go 60 miles to meet my constituents at one end and 70 miles in the other direction to meet them. Here in Dublin a Member can be elected with 19,300 votes and in other constituencies in the west and in parts of Ulster they have to get 21,400 votes to get elected. Is that justice or is there any honesty in it? We talk about the north. We should be ashamed to say we are in the south. The north is twice as good as we are. I went through the figures. I heard my colleague, Senator Dolan, quote them. In the three Ulster counties they are losing two seats. In Connacht they are losing two more, that is four seats altogether. Who are gaining the four seats? The Dubliners. No one can deny it. If the Minister wants to stand up and deny it he can. In my own constituency we have heard a lot about the dishonesty of the Ministers of Fianna Fáil. In this constituency two parts of my area were given away by Fianna Fáil Ministers who were criticised by the Opposition right, left and centre. There were 4,000 Kilkenny votes three miles from me and I would be here as a Minister for the last 15 years only for the change. Perhaps I am better off for not being here. In Ferrybank, Rockingham, and Marymount, 4,000 or more votes have gone in to elect Fad Browne in Waterford, or perhaps, to elect the Labour man. They took 1,000 votes in Rosbercon and gave them to Wexford. They gave us 2,000 votes in Bunclody. Perhaps the Minister does not know where Bunclody is: it is in the County Wexford. Is there any justice in taking 1,000 votes from Rosbercon and giving them to Wexford and giving 3,000 in Bunclody to Carlow-Kilkenny?

Comment on this

Who took them from you?

Comment on this

I am coming to that. I told you before that it was Fianna Fáil Ministers. We heard it in Dáil Éireann and in Seanad Éireann; I was not there but I read it in the papers and I am listening for the last 20 years to talk about the dishonesty of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It was taken out of a five-seat Wexford constituency to take a second seat from the Labour Party and well may it serve you.

Comment on this

Senator Aylward to continue on the Bill.

Comment on this

Carlow-Kilkenny is my constituency. It is down here in black and white that a Minister said there were five counties in Ireland that could stand on their own. One of them is Kilkenny. Why did he not leave Kilkenny stand on its own? I will tell you the reason if the Minister wants to know. He could not do that——

Comment on this

He could not make a show of Fianna Fáil after all their years.

Comment on this

The Minister knows as well as I do that it is because his own colleague, Jimmie Pattison, would not be elected again and that Fianna Fáil would gain two seats in Kilkenny any day of the week. That is why you did not change it. I beat him 15,500 votes the first time out of the box. He got 500 and I got just 7,000 first preferences.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not think that it is fair that the Cathaoirleach should allow a man who funked standing at the last election to heckle a man who had the guts and common sense to stand at the last election. I would ask the Cathaoirleach to use his position to protect a man who had the courage to stand in the last election against a man who had not got that courage.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I have continually throughout the day deprecated interruptions from all sides of the House. Senator Aylward to continue.

Comment on this

I have not a word to say to the Cathaoirleach. He is a fine decent man. I know that. I cannot say that about the rest of the House. It is a "show" here since 6 o'clock this evening. The Leader of the House began it. He should be ashamed of himself. I know the O'Higgins family for a long time: I know everybody here. I should like to answer some of the people that stand up to contradict me but I am not going to bring any individual into this. I would like to see some of the Senators here standing up and stating how many of them stood, how many of them were beaten and how many of them won. It is easy to get in here the soft way. Many of them did not stand. I am not condemning the Minister but the Leader of the House, who is here now, was a disgrace coming in here this evening. He upset all procedure. I have an idea of procedure but this evening's performance was like a hurling meeting where fellows who never went to school were electing a captain and a chairman and they resorted to fisticuffs. I have nothing against Senator O'Higgins but I think there is something wrong here. This Seanad should not be going on here until 1 o'clock.

Comment on this

To give you all a chance of speaking.

Comment on this

We took a vote here today and it was 28 to 18—all right, 14—and they were able to keep the whole thing going. If the Government speaker's started we would be here for a week. Why are they interrupting people when they will not stand up and defend themselves?

Comment on this

I cannot speak again.

Comment on this

I will ask the Minister one question. Why is it that it takes 21,000 to elect a rural Deputy and in Dublin city he can be elected by 19,000 in some cases? In some of these rural areas a man has to travel over 200 miles to see his constituencies. In the city of Dublin a Deputy has only to travel about a mile-and-a-half and could see all his constituency in two days. I would like the Minister to answer now while I am on my feet. When you stand up to speak we all have to sit dumb.

Comment on this

There is no question. Ask a question and I shall answer it.

Comment on this

The only answer he has is the guillotine.

Comment on this

Why is it that the three counties of Ulster are deprived of two seats? Why is Connacht deprived of two seats and Cork city deprived of one seat? Why did the Minister not leave Kilkenny one constituency? I know because your Labour man would be beaten.

Comment on this

Why did Fianna Fáil not do it?

Comment on this

I said when I began that Fianna Fáil did do it. We hear so much about the honesty of the National Coalition, if you like to call them that, the Labour crowd and Fine Gael crowd, but if they are so honest why did they not rectify the matter and let the commission do the job? If they are as honest as they are supposed to be why did the Minister have to get an extra seat for themselves in Meath and deprive Monaghan and Cavan of one?

Comment on this

I can only get one seat: they will not let me take two.

Comment on this

Meath has a population sufficient to get four and a bit of other counties in order to make sure that the Minister for Local Government would be elected. He would be elected anyway if there were only two seats perhaps. Why give people a chance to say these things? Why did you leave Kilkenny with Carlow? The reason is you wanted your own man elected again. Are Fine Gael all asleep or what is wrong with them? They cannot see further than their noses, I think. We do not care in Fianna Fáil whether you make it a three-seater or not. I would like to see the whole country in three-seaters. I would not be worried about that. Why is the constituency of the Taoiseach left as a four-seater? Why is a bit of Wicklow gone into Dublin? Why is a bit of Kildare gone into Dublin? Dublin will still have more TDs than all the rest of Ireland together.

Why not bring them out of Dublin instead of bringing them in? Why not start with Cork? Cork would have five seats. Kilkenny has sufficient for three seats and still you are afraid of your lives to leave them together. Why not give back Ferrybank and Rockingham if you are as honest as you say? Mr. Boland and Mr. Blaney took them from us. Now is your chance to prove your honesty. There is no use in laughing about it. Did Mr. Boland in 1959 do the wrong thing? The Coalition have been talking about this for so long. The Minister has an honest face. I often heard it said "Look out for the man who is smiling the whole time because he is dangerous." Is something happening we do not know anything about that we have to stay here until 1 a.m. to debate this Bill during Holy Week? Is there a crisis between you we know nothing about? Are you hiding something from us?

Comment on this

They have found Littlejohn.

Comment on this

If they found Littlejohn there is another Littlejohn they will not find for a long time. There are many Littlejohns they should worry about. With all due respects to the National Coalition, I am surprised at Labour men sitting here so quietly and clapping on the back the men who 20 to 30 years ago took a shilling from the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

He is now in Fianna Fáil, of course.

Comment on this

No. Excuse me. If the Minister can prove I am wrong then I will sit down.

Comment on this

He was in Cumann na nGaedheal in 1929 when this happened.

Comment on this

They cut the old age pensions from 10s. to 9s. If the Minister can prove I am wrong, I will sit down.

Comment on this

What happened in 1932?

Comment on this

I would ask Senator McAuliffe and others not to provoke Senator Aylward to further irrelevancies. I would ask Senator Aylward to address himself to the Bill.

Comment on this

Senator McAuliffe asked me what happened in 1932. There must be some other people here who can remember that year. While the Leader of Fine Gael after——

Comment on this

If Senator Aylward persists in directing his conversation to another Senator I will be obliged to ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

I might not sit down too easily now.

Comment on this

Both Senators must resume their seats. Senator Aylward to continue without interruption on the Constituencies Bill.

Comment on this

Senator McAuliffe asked me what happened in 1932 and I was replying to him. Who was wrong and who was right?

Comment on this

He was wrong to ask and you were wrong to reply.

Comment on this

In 1932 the man who made de Valera Taoiseach was Jim Dillon. Mr. McAuliffe was a Fianna Fáil man at that time and belonged to a cumann. A few more Fine Gael men in Dáil Éireann at present were too. One of them was secretary of a cumann in Laois-Offaly when I knew him. He is the man who is keeping Fine Gael and the Coalition on their toes at present.

Comment on this

I once again have to indicate to the Senator that he must address himself to the Bill. If he continues to speak of irrelevant matters in this persistent fashion, I will have no option but to direct him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

I respect the Chair, but if anybody interrupts I should be allowed to reply.

Comment on this

I have continually urged Senators not to interrupt and exhorted Senators who are speaking to ignore interruptions.

Comment on this

This did not happen all evening. There have been interruptions all evening and still the Cathaoirleach did not tell anyone to speak or sit down. I do not speak very often in this House, but I can tell the National Coalition that, if they continue the way the Minister for Local Government has started, they will need help. That is no reflection on the Minister. He is doing his job. As I said, he has a smiling face. But he may not be smiling in two years' time. We might be smiling if we are alive. I hope the Minister in his reply will tell me why the three remaining counties of Ulster lost two seats, why Connacht lost two seats and why it will be possible for a smaller population to elect a man in Dublin than in Ulster or Connacht. I ask him why he did not give back Ferrybank and Rockingham to Kilkenny? Why give us a little bit up in the hills of Bunclody 20 miles away and take 1,000 people from Rosbercon alongside Kilkenny? Why did the Minister do that? These "honest men" in the Cabinet have been saying for 20 years that Fianna Fáil did the wrong thing. Now when they had a chance to rectify the wrongs done, they themselves did worse. They divided the country to suit themselves.

Comment on this

There is a smile on the Minister's face.

Comment on this

The Minister will be smiling when he is going to the grave. I came in by the hard road. I am not trying to insult anybody here. Anyone who fought three general elections and two Seanad elections should be entitled to say a few words. Some people here think they are so smart——

Comment on this

I do not think the words are relevant to the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

Many words spoken this evening were not relevant to any matter and certainly not the matter in hands.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I must say to Senator Aylward and to the Senators on the Government side who said "Hear, Hear" that that was a criticism of the Chair and cannot be allowed.

Comment on this

This evening many words were spoken that were not of relevance at all. They would not be spoken at a rugby match. I have never seen anything to equal it in all the meetings I have attended. Perhaps I am not eligible to speak here. I am neither an intellectual nor a legal man. I did not go to University. I am not a rugby man either. I am an Irishman. We all know what happened when these intellectuals came down the country. Are we coming to the day when rural Ireland is being pushed out and urban Ireland being pushed in? Could I ask the Minister why rural Ireland, where there are three houses every mile, did not get a better representation than the cities? There are a lot of Senators and ex-Deputies here from Mayo, Galway, Donegal, Monaghan, Cavan and so on who have not protested at the higher ratio the city people have got.

Could the Minister tell me why a man can be elected in Dublin with 19,600 votes and 21,000 votes are needed to elect a man in rural Ireland? Could I ask the Minister why he did not give back Ferrybank and Rockingham to Kilkenny and make it a three-seater? Why did he not give Rosbercon back to Kilkenny and Bunclody back to Wexford? Carlow was with Kildare before, but now part of Kildare is with Dublin. Why did he not make Wexford, Carlow and Kilkenny three-seaters? Could he not have given us back Ferrybank and Rockingham and even it up with a three-seater each?

Comment on this

Does the Senator want a reply?

Comment on this

What are you afraid of? Why, when there is no need for it, should any county boundary be split and voters put into another county? Everybody has a pride in his own county. I have a pride in my own parish, in my own townland. I would not vote for a man who put me into another county. Could the Minister not have left the boundaries as they were? For instance, in the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny, Kilkenny is a three-seater constituency. Why not take part of Paulstown and Graiguenamanagh, which is on the border of Carlow, and make two three-seaters? Could the Minister not have left us Kilkenny and given Waterford their own part back and left it as it was? Perhaps he had other reasons. That is no good to the local people who were born and reared in South Kilkenny who have to go in with Waterford. I know the reason—he wanted to save a seat for Labour. We are not all as green as we look. I will conclude by wishing the Coaltion the best of luck. I hope they will be here for four years, but I am afraid they will not.

Comment on this

That is why they are rushing it.

Comment on this

Even if the constituencies are made three-seaters or four-seaters or five-seaters, Fianna Fáil will be back after the next election.

Comment on this

Many hours have been spent in the Dáil discussing the title of this Bill but as a rural Senator I am more interested in the rural areas than in the cities. I think the five hours that have been spent in discussing this title have been completely useless. The title of this Bill, in my opinion, should be—something that was introduced into Ireland recently—the "Streakers Bill". This Bill is denuding the rural population of their proper and justified representation in Dáil Éireann. The title should be—and I say it without fear of contradiction—the "Streakers Bill". A Minister who comes from a rural area should have had more consideration for the rural areas and should have given them more concessions in his constituency Bill or "Streakers Bill" similar to what he has given to Leinster and within the Pale, as we know it in Dublin.

I appreciate the Minister's difficulties. He is a Labour Minister in a Coalition Government. I look over at all those Senators who listened to all the accusations that have been made against the Minister today by this side of the House. Not one individual on that side of the House had the courage to stand up and defend him. It is a very poor reflection on them. What can the Minister expect from his colleagues in the next few months when they failed to stand up and defend his actions in this House for the past two days—apart from their lousy interjections? For example there was the callous interjection about 1932. When this country, in 1932, was left starving and penniless after a Cumann na nGaedheal Government the Fianna Fáil Government took over. In order to bring the people back to maturity and to give them ability and strength the free beef scheme had to be introduced. The poor old pensioners lost their ten shillings a week. There was the first introduction of the dole. I do not want to dwell on this too long but merely to reply to Senator McAuliffe who was not a member of the Fianna Fáil party at the time. When he saw he could get no further he left it.

Comment on this

Would the Senator continue on the Bill?

Comment on this

I do not intend to travel around the country for five or six hours. I do not intend to go around Monaghan, Cork, Waterford or other places like them. I am going to dwell on my own native county of Mayo. The only amendment brought in by the Minister to the Bill was brought in to make sure that the Parliamentary Secretary would well and truly retain his seat. We had a tradition in what was then known as West Mayo of returning two Fianna Fáil candidates. The peculiar thing about the last election was that, when the first preference votes were counted in West Mayo, Fianna Fáil had 300 votes more than the Fine Gael Party but, under proportional representation, we returned one candidate and Fine Gael returned two. It was the first time in the history of West Mayo that that happened.

The Minister for Local Government in his original Bill handed over to West Mayo—I have the map here— Crossmolina North, Crossmolina South, Deel, Kilfian South and Kilfian West and Lacken North. In that area Fianna Fáil have in the region of 1,500 votes—of course we are not bothered with the Labour Party in Mayo—and Fine Gael have 600 votes, but the boys got together in a sort of cominform—I would not call it a coaltion because Labour do not come into our area at all—and told the Minister that he was now assured of two Fianna Fáil seats because he was handing them over at least 900 votes. Of course, after the recent budget and the increased prices, there is no Fine Gael vote in that part of the country now. They are finished there.

Comment on this

Which budget is the Senator talking about? Deputy Molloy had the same proposal as I had.

Comment on this

I am not talking about Deputy Molloy.

Comment on this

He had the same proposal as I had.

Comment on this

The Minister said in the Dáil on various occasions, and I will quote him if he wishes, that Deputy Molloy as Minister for Local Government had a Bill drafted. Deputy Molloy challenged the Minister on several occasions in the Dáil, and I will quote his words if the Minister wants me to, to prove his statement but he has never done so. Does the Minister know what he is known as down in our county, and does he know what John Reilly knows him as —the man they expelled from the Labour Party for castrating the itinerants and putting them onto Tory Island—he is known as "Slippery Jimmy". The Minister can put up with that.

Comment on this

I will put up with nothing from you.

Comment on this

I have the floor. The Minister will get plenty of time to reply to me if he wants to. If the Minister interrupts me I will reply to him—and no better man. In the constituencies of East Mayo and West Mayo Mr. Tully discovered that he was handing over a majority of 900, and we already had 300 No. 1 votes more than the Fine Gael Party, the boys got together and said: "That is wrong. We will have to get around Jimmy and he will have to change that".

Comment on this
George E. Russell Acting Chairman (Mr. Russell)

The Senator must refer to the Minister as the Minister and not as Jimmy Tully or anything else.

Comment on this

I humbly apologise to the Minister.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

He will refer to the Senator as the Senator.

Comment on this

I know how the Minister will refer to me if he gets the chance. I know what he has already called me.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would the Senator get back to the Bill?

Comment on this

The Minister handed over 900 of a majority to West Mayo but the boys, as I said, got together and they informed the Minister that he was making a hames of the job, that they would lose Myles Staunton and that Fianna Fáil would get two seats. What did they do?

Comment on this
A Senator

And Myles said that about Henry Kenny. He said: "Henry has plenty; give it to Myles".

Comment on this

What did they do? The Minister gave them back. If he had left it as it was I would be one of the TDs in the next Dáil. Of course, he knew what he was doing. That is what he thinks about me.

Comment on this
A Senator

Senator O'Toole is not here to contradict that statement.

Comment on this

I am not worried whether Senator O'Toole is here or not. The Minister gave them back to East Mayo and took my little area out of it completely because I was the danger man, the strong man. Then he makes a big jump and goes from Crossmolina up as far as Hollymount, between Ballinrobe and Claremorris, and he picks an area there. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary told him: "That is a strong area of mine. You know Myles beat me the last time by a few hundred votes but I want to get back the next time as Parliamentary Secretary" and the Minister for Local Government handed over this packet of Fine Gael votes to West Mayo from East Mayo. They kept a bit of Lacken, Belderrig, Ballycastle, Kilfian, Letterbrick and all those areas. That is a strong Fianna Fáil area so no matter what happens in West Mayo the next time, Fianna Fáil will have two seats and the Fine Gael fight will be between the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Henry Kenny, a man for whom I have great respect and who is a great friend of mine, and Deputy Myles Staunton. Under the circumstances Senator Lyons and I will be on the long road canvassing for the Seanad because the Minister made sure that I would not get into West Mayo because he was told I was a very dangerous man in that constituency. I heard people talking today of travelling——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Killilea spoke already and he might keep quiet for a while.

Comment on this

I heard a Senator speaking today. He made a very good speech and I compliment him on it. He talked about going from Ballyshannon to Ballintra, a distance of 12 miles, and he crossed over constituency boundaries three or four times. I should like to ask the Minister who drew up the constituency boundaries for him. How will a Deputy for West Mayo—the Fianna Fáil Deputy I am speaking about, of course, will be in the Castlebar area and the other one, Deputy Denis Gallagher, will be in the Achill area —get to Kilfinan, to Ballycastle, to Lacken South, without going through the constituency of East Mayo?

I do not want to talk about helicopters at this stage because the Minister has done about 6,000 miles by helicopter and the Littlejohns and the rest of them went out by helicopter. I do not want to talk about helicopters at all because you would have to get permission now to fly a kite in case you might tie a prisoner to the tail and take him out of Mountjoy Jail.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If the Senator persists in interrupting, I shall have to ask him to leave the Chamber.

Comment on this

It is no use interrupting me. You could tell Senator Killilea to keep quiet, but I do not think it would have much effect on him.

Take East or West Mayo, leaving Poulacapple—anyone who looks at a map will see it is the next village to America—and travelling to the Galway boundary you come within 1½ miles of Tuam. On the other hand, if one leaves Lacken South and travels to Keem Bay in Achill, it is roughly 155 miles. To leave Lacken South, or Belderrig, or Kilcummin Pier and travel to Keem Bay in Achill is a distance of at least 120 miles. It is absolutely cruel to think that a man who represents that area has to get practically 22,000 votes, whereas a man in Dublin, who can have a constitutional around his constituency in the morning before breakfast, needs only 19,123 votes to be elected. I do not know what to call it—"Tullymandering", "Coalitionmandering" or whatever it is—but it is an absolute disgrace, an insult to the intelligence of the rural population.

I know there is urgency about this Bill. I have discussed it with some gentlemen outside the House today. They have admitted that there is urgency. That is why the Leader of the House, who gave us all a lecture on religion during the Contraception Bill, thumped his craw and said: "There, but for the grace of God, go I".

Comment on this

I am talking relevantly on the Bill. He came in to ask us to sit during Holy Week and until 1 o'clock tonight to discuss this Bill. Where is his piety now? Where is Pontius Pilate now? Craw-thumping. The Senator had to take his place at the Order of Business. He was Pontius Pilate then, too, when he refused to move it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Garrett.

Comment on this

I should like to know the reason this motion was moved tonight that we sit until 1 o'clock to discuss this Bill. I should like to compare the piety of Holy Week with what happened on the Contraception Bill introduced here a few weeks ago, when we got a lecture on religion, on pious attitudes, on morals from the Leader of the House. Does he realise the position regarding confession in rural areas during Holy Week? Of course, it does not matter a damn; piety comes in only when it is useful. For instance, in my home chapel this evening there are confessions from 1 o'clock to 3 o'clock for Holy Week. I am not allowed to be there to go to confession. I will have to travel to Ballina perhaps, not that I shall have a hell of a lot to tell. But when I look over there and think what they have to tell. God forgive me I will not be judge or jury, I will let them condemn themselves.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Could we leave the piety for a moment and come back to the Bill.

Comment on this

I never left the Bill at all. I did not leave the Bill nor the Pill. I am still on both of them.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair must be the judge of that.

Comment on this

Maybe. I am not disputing the authority of the Chair. I obey the Chair equally well if not better than many Senators on both sides of the House. I think I have been always fairly respectful to the Chair. Has the Acting Chairman seen what was done in Donegal around Ballyshannon?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair should not be involved in any discussion. Let the Senator make his own case.

Comment on this

It reminds me of something; I will not say what. It is a very sad reflection. To what lengths will people go in order to gain advantage? I know that the Minister for Local Government, who is a member of the Labour Party, is not very much interested in East or West Mayo, because it is Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael there. A certain urban councillor of the Labour Party attacked the Ballina Urban Council and made a statement at an urban council meeting concerning itinerants.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would the Senator kindly return to the Bill?

Comment on this

I am speaking the Labour Party's attitude——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would the Senator please refer to the Chair and return to the Bill? We are not interested in what an urban councillor said.

Comment on this

I think you should be.

Comment on this

This was the O'Reilly's method of contraception. The Labour Party in East Mayo—keeping to constituents and leaving out the urban councillors—happened to have one member elected to a public body. He said at a meeting of that body: "All the itinerants in the Ballina area should be castrated and put on to the Aran Islands".

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That has no reference to the Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if the pollution ratio per member is a determining factor——

Comment on this

That is what I was coming to.

Comment on this

——in this Bill would it not be in order for Senator Garrett to say that any move to prevent an increase in population in County Mayo could seriously affect this Bill in the future? If a member of the Labour Party advocated the castration of itinerants this would, in fact, have a very strong bearing on the population ratio of Mayo in the future.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It the Senator wants the ruling of the Chair, "No".

Comment on this

No. We can put the people on the Aran Islands or on Tory Island. The result of that statement was that he was automatically expelled from the Labour Party. It would seem the Minister for Local Government, as a member of the Labour Party, has no interest in East or West Mayo because they have no hope whatsoever of getting a Labour candidate elected to an urban council or even a parish council in either East or West Mayo.

In the last election we had the most wonderful spectacle that ever took place in the history of this country under its present Constitution. When a Labour candidate in the East Mayo constituency—the constituency I live in—decided that the figaries of the Garda Síochana, plus the Returning Officer, were not in order—I would not, of course, mind him saying that, it is the practice of the Coaltion to say those things——

Comment on this

On a point of order, this matter is still before the Supreme Court. It is sub judice.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact it is not.

Comment on this
Alexis Fitzgerald Mr. Alexis FitzGerald Fine Gael

The fact is that it is.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator should come back to the Constituency Bill now.

Comment on this

If you are afraid to hear about Kennedy and the Labour Party, go back to West Galway where Senator Higgins comes from.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Senator Garrett, it is not a question of the Chair being afraid. The Chair is ruling.

Comment on this

West Galway and Galway and Clare have been tied up in many and various ways. I humbly apologise to Senator Higgins. Mark you, I did not say "O'Higgins," because I was warned here about three weeks ago on the contraception issue not to mix his name up with that of Senator M.J. O'Higgins because the two Senators were at extremes on that issue. I am very, very sorry to have to inform the Minister now, who is a member of the Labour Party, and all the other Labour Party people, that it is on the cards that, instead of making a safe seat for Labour in West Galway, or for Senator Higgins——

Comment on this

Instead of making a safe seat there, I want to inform the Minister now that Senator Noel Browne has decided that he will probably be a candidate in that famous West Galway constituency and he will shake the daylights out of Fine Gael and Labour in that constituency and the Labour Party can say "goodbye" to a Labour seat west of the Shannon. They have said "goodnight" to it for many a year, but they can now say: "Goodbye, good luck and cheerio".

Comment on this

Sure, Senator Browne is a member of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Oh, no he is not. He might be a member of the Labour Party but he is not a member of the Parliamentary Labour Party. He is on his own. He is a fine respectable gentleman who has the courage of his convictions and stands up and says what he has to say and that is that. He is not a "Yes" man. That is why he is not liked.

Comment on this

That is why he sits over here.

Comment on this

Certainly it is. All the good people sit on this side of the House.

Comment on this

For the moment.

Comment on this

We have dealt with West Mayo fairly well. I do not mind taking a canter across the bridge at Crossmolina and travelling on towards the eastern side of the county, which comprises Ballina, Foxford, Swinford, Charlestown, Ballyhaunis, Claremorris, Kiltimagh—the lot. One can start in Lacken North and tour along for about 100 or 120 miles to within a mile-and-a-half of a little place called Irishtown, and then from the butt of Nephin right along to Ballaghaderreen, Frenchpark, Loughlynn, Ballinlough, and you travel at least another 100 miles. I want to know from the Minister is it accepted by him and by his draftsmen that a man who covers a constituency of that length and breath requires practically 22,000 votes to elect him? Compare him with a city Deputy who can travel his constituency on his walk in the morning before he has his breakfast. This is absolutely unfair and the Minister, coming as he does from a rural area, should have more respect for the rural areas. I appreciate his difficulty. He has, in my estimation, done the best he was allowed to do. Looking over on my right at the Minister, who has been an honest, hard-working man ever since he left the cradle—I should say he has been as honest as he was allowed to be—in drafting this Bill he had to deal with conservatives, capitalists, socialists, lords, ladies and leaders——

Comment on this

Leaders of Opposition.

Comment on this

When I want Senator Halligan's help I will ask for it. I have plenty of ability myself. I do not have to ask the Senator for anything.

Comment on this

Forty minutes.

Comment on this

Senator Halligan's estimation of time completely surpasses his intelligence because I have not been even 40 minutes on my feet.

Comment on this

Will the Senator continue on the Bill?

Comment on this

The Bill is a genuine endeavour by the Minister to satisfy the various groups that make up the two parties who form the Government. He has done a fair lot to satisfy them. When the 1968 Bill was being debated the most castigated man was the former Minister for Local Government of the Fianna Fáil Party, Mr. Kevin Boland.

Comment on this