We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 1973: Committee Stage.

Contributions 130–281 of 281. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment)(No. 2) Bill, 1973
Enacted

No. 3 of 1973 ›

When we come to West Limerick we will deal with Senator O'Brien. We will deal with the way he wished to try to handle the Leas-Cheann Comhairle of Dáil Éireann over many, many years.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would Senator McGlinchey continue on the amendment that is before the House?

Comment on this

I realise fully that Senator O'Brien is ashamed to hear the official statistics as far as population ratio is concerned, because even he could not possibly justify to the people of this land why in County Meath this Government of the socalled talents have arranged an electoral system in such a way that only 19,238 people can elect a Deputy, whereas in Roscommon-Leitrim it takes 21,119. Is that giving justice to all?

Comment on this
William O'Brien Mr. W. O'Brien Fine Gael

Of course. According to the Constitution, it is.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I would ask Senators not to interrupt.

Comment on this

Am I entitled at this stage to come to my own constituency?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

You are entitled to speak only on the amendment before this House.

Comment on this

I have enough sense and intelligence to do that. It is a pity my interrupter is not endowed with the same amount of sense.

Comment on this
William O'Brien Mr. W. O'Brien Fine Gael

The Donegal people will give you the hammer.

Comment on this

If I stand for the Dáil as often as Senator W. O'Brien has stood I think I will be elected.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Neither of those remarks is relevant to the amendment. Senator McGlinchey to continue, please.

Comment on this

I want an explanation from the Parliamentary Secretary why a difference should be made in relation to Meath, not alone in providing a four-seater to ensure the Minister's re-election but a tolerance ratio which is the minimum practically required by the Constitution, whereas in the west of Ireland and particularly in the north-west of Ireland, the tolerance ration used is the maximum required by the Constitution. It is most unjust that this Government should expect 21,102 people in Donegal to elect a Deputy whereas in Meath in order to have a safe seat for the Minister a little over 19,000 people can elect a Deputy. In Roscommon-Leitrim 21,119 people elect a Deputy whereas in his native Meath the Minister has arranged it in such a way that 19,238 people elect a Deputy. I want the Parliamentary Secretary to tell me if he considers it just that in Sligo-Leitrim it takes 21,010 people to elect a Deputy whereas in the Minister's constituency of Meath it takes 19,238.

It is quite obvious that this constituency of Meath is being gerrymandered for a particular purpose. There is no point in speaking about areas that were taken out of Meath and now put back into Meath. If in the explanatory memorandum we were to read that the population per member was almost similar in every constituency in this country, then the Minister could claim with a certain amount of accuracy that the constituencies were arranged in a manner fair and just to all. But the Minister has not arranged the constituencies in this manner. He has not been fair and he certainly has not been just to all. The discrepancies in the population per member which I have outlined are so blatant that nobody who is in any way independent of the political arena would even attempt to justify what this Government have set out to achieve.

This is particularly so in constituencies close to the Border. I am sure that when this Bill was studied by some of our Unionist friends across the Border they were delighted to see in this legislation examples of gerrymandering the likes of which they in their heyday were unable to perfect. While it is true to say that they got away with it for a long time the day came when that situation changed. I believe that if the Minister were to accept the amendments before him this evening he could help prevent charges being made in the cities of Belfast and Derry, charges of unfair practices, charges of political manipulation by people who would attempt to justify their own actions in 50 years. I think it is an error of judgment on the part of this Government that they should allow a situation to arise in this legislation which deprives the ancient and historic province of Ulster of two Dáil Deputies. Even at this late stage I would appeal to the Minister to amend the situation, and if he does I believe that there would be rejoicing in a part of this country by people who are ashamed and embarrassed by this blatant example of gerrymandering.

Comment on this

I am sorry I was not in for all of the contributions which were made on this section. This particular group of amendments is one on which in the other House I showed that the people who had put them in had not got the foggiest notion about what was being effected by the amendments.

Senator McGlinchey talked about me looking after my own seat. How many times have I repeated that I had 1,000 votes over a Fianna Fáil man and on the previous occasion I had 500 votes? Before the gerrymandering which was done by Fianna Fáil in 1969 I headed the poll at over 1,000 over the quota. I do not want to repeat this because I have said it so often I feel I am annoying Senator Yeats and I am sure he is getting a bit tired of this. This was before all this area was taken away, and before that I lost my seat.

I am a great believer in democracy. I believe that the electorate are entitled to put out of Dáil Éireann and put out of this House people who they think are not representing them properly. They are entitled to realise their mistake if they have made one and put those people back again and honour them by having them head the poll. This is what was done. I stood for election and got elected to the Dáil. There is a lot in getting elected to the Dáil. I am quite sure that the people from my constituency were satisfied. The suggestion that I put a fourth seat in there for the purpose of ensuring that I would retain my seat is too ridiculous; it is an abusive phrase which some of the Opposition Senators find useful.

May I refer to the question of the four-seater there, where, according to the way the cards have been falling down through the years, Fianna Fáil should win the fourth seat? Instead of the Fianna Fáil Opposition saying: "Look, this thing is now levelling it off." As, indeed, Senator Yeats did say in reference to Louth, they are looking behind them to see was there a reason for it being done. The reason was this, that before this constituency change took place, Cavan, Monaghan and Louth were three-seaters, but, Cavan was only a three-seater because it had a very sizeable portion of Meath —which, for Senator McGlinchey's information, is in Leinster—added on to it. Monaghan was able to have a three-seater because it had a sizeable portion of Meath-Louth, which is also in Leinster, added on to it. This is something which is apparently being ignored by the Opposition. They do not like this being brought up. They say: "You are taking away two seats from Ulster, a seat from Cavan and a seat from Monaghan". We are not, because there was a very sizeable portion of Leinster attached.

In regard to the amendment which was suggested here, I should like to give a run down on the North Meath area which I know very well as I was born and reared there. I will show how ridiculous this whole idea is. I do not blame the Senators here because they could not know what we are doing, but, it having been pointed out in the Dáil, I would expect they would not make the same mistake again here.

I was born in a village called Carlath in north Meath. The last Fianna Fáil Minister for Local Government, who divided constituencies in 1969, divided that village and gave half of the area to the west of it to Cavan and he gave the other half to Monaghan. Then he sliced off the end of the village and left the rest of us in County Meath. Quite a substantial amount of my support came from that area and he said to himself: "That has fixed him." Although they did that, I still got elected to the Dáil.

In the present proposals there is an amendment which is put in here in the name of three Senators and which in the Dáil was in the name of three Deputies. I am sorry that Senator Dolan from Cavan and Senator Brennan from Monaghan are not here because I know that they would be very interested. The proposal is that, contrary to what many of the Fianna Fáil speakers have been trying to say, the ancient kingdom of Breffni, which was Cavan and which, as was pointed out, also included the town of Oldcastle in County Meath, was to have Oldcastle included, as it was under the old system; also included were Ballinlough, Crossakeel and Moynalty. Carnaross was taken in. Then the line came to the town of Kells, which is about ten to 12 miles inside County Meath, and it then turned right from Kells and moved right along to a place called Kilskeer; then it went south of Kells to a place called Cortown up near the town of Athboy, and doubled back again towards the Westmeath border, to a little townland called Grennanstown. Why this should be beats me. How can anyone suggest it is the right thing to put the townland of Grennanstown in along with the Cavan constituency, a narrow strip up there weaving in and out between townlands? It just beats me why it was done.

Senator McGlinchey talked of Ballintra. We will come to that later on. Having done that they then decided that they would make a three-seater constituency of Monaghan also. The first thing they did, and this is rather amusing, was, to use the phrase of Deputy Wilson, to raid the ancient kingdom of Breffni and they took out Kingscourt, Shercock and three other electoral areas in the heart of Cavan.

Having done this for the purpose of arranging a Monaghan constituency of three they then went into County Meath and moved on up through Cadamstown, Stahalmog, Castletown, into Rathkenny and in some peculiar way which I have not been able to find out—I am surprised the same mistake was repeated by the Senators as was done by the Deputies—they jumped across the Gibbstown Gaeltacht and landed in a place called Donaghpatrick, which is near Navan. They took in Donaghpatrick electoral area with Gibbstown. Then they went back to Rathkenny, Stahalmog, Castletown, Nobber and Kilmainhamwood. They called this a small compact constituency of three-seats. I think Senator Yeats, if he remembers some of the comments which were made here earlier today on the question of breaching county boundaries, will agree with me that nobody who knew that area would suggest that was a reasonable thing to do. I am afraid they do not have very much respect for the ordinary way of dealing with constituencies in this country.

Comment on this

What is the ordinary way of dealing with constituencies?

Comment on this

The way in which it is being done in this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister is a superman.

Comment on this

I am just an ordinary man with a conscience and that is a change in this office.

Comment on this

It is a pity that the stenographers cannot record the Minister's smile.

Comment on this

I am giving those details because it is only fair to point out that this is the sort of proposal which is made in the amendment submitted by Fianna Fáil Senators and to point out how really ridiculous their idea is. Somebody wants to know why did I not listen to reasonable argument and why did I not offer a reasonable compromise. I do not think there is any such thing as a reasonable compromise where this matter is concerned. I have put down a very fair suggestion. Incidentally, I should like to point out that Senator Yeats has his name to an amendment which includes Balscadden in County Dublin. For a man who does not believe in breaching county boundaries it is a little odd that the Meath constituency, according to his proposal, should consist of portion of Meath, portion of Dublin, portion of Kildare, a portion of Meath added to Cavan and a portion of Meath added to Monaghan.

I believe the way I drew up the constituency was very much fairer. Nobody could suggest there would be anything wrong in making Louth a four-seater. It required an extra 2,000 people to become a four-seater; therefore it was a natural. Whether Fianna Fáil had a majority or anybody else had a majority in Louth, it would be unfair not to make it a four-seater. If I could not give a three-seater on its own to Monaghan, as I could not, and I could not give a three-seater on its own to Cavan, I thought the most reasonable thing to do was to put the two together and give them a five-seater.

I want to repeat what I said in the Dáil. Those who know Cavan and Monaghan are aware that those two counties, more than any other two counties I know in this country, have a lot in common with each other— the same type of people, the same type of land, the same interests. They are well represented in the Dáil. They are very shrewd people.

Comment on this

Why are you taking a seat from them?

Comment on this

I am sorry if Senator McGlinchey cannot understand. I do not think I should waste any further time trying to explain to him.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question? There are in Dáil Éireann three Cavan men and three Monaghan men. As a result of this Bill how many Ulster men can be elected to Dáil Éireann from Cavan and Monaghan.

Comment on this

There are many more than six Ulster men in Dáil Éireann. Cavan and Monaghan at one time had enough people living in each county to give them three representatives but under Fianna Fáil they lost more people, Cavan, in particular, than any other county with the exception of Leitrim. I hope that under a good Government, such as we have now, there will be enough people in both constituencies to allow for three and, maybe, four seats. If that situation arises, I would be delighted to see them getting their representation back. But I will not agree that we should continue to add on a bit of Leinster to the two Ulster counties for the purpose of giving an artificial representation. There will be five representatives from the two counties. Everybody in those two counties will have the right to call on one of five representatives. At present they can call on one of three.

Comment on this

The Minister prefers three-seaters in Dublin but recommends five-seaters for the rural areas.

Comment on this

I am afraid I had to be rather unkind to the Senator on the Second Stage. I do not want to be unkind to him again. But might I explain that we can give only three seats to a constituency which has 57,000 to 63,000. We have not got that number either in Cavan or in Monaghan. Is it possible to get through the fact that we could not, without breaking up a further constituency, give them six representatives, three in each? They are getting five, so they will be well represented. As I say, the Cavan and Monaghan people are very intelligent and have been sending excellent representatives to this House and will continue to do so in the other House.

Comment on this

But the Minister is taking a seat from them.

Comment on this

If Senator McGlinchey thinks that the people in north Meath and the people in west Louth who were attached to Cavan and Monaghan are not entitled to any representation, then I am taking one from them. I believe that they are as much entitled to representation in their own constituencies as anybody else. For that reason I am proposing to give four to Louth, five to Cavan-Monaghan, four to Meath and, incidentally, to give back to Meath again the portion of Meath which was taken away, not by my immediate predecessor, but by his predecessor who had the full support of the Fianna Fáil Party when he used his knife and cut up whole villages. In fact, he did better than that. There is a former Fine Gael TD in this House outside of whose door the line was drawn.

Comment on this

The same as the Minister has done to Deputy White.

Comment on this

Deputy White has not complained. I can assure Senator McGlinchey that Deputy White will be back in Dáil Éireann. If Senator McGlinchey could say the same, even with a five-seater, he would be a very happy man.

Comment on this

The Minister has stripped him of his area. He is now a streaker.

Comment on this

The Senator knows much more about streakers than I do. I will take his judgment on streakers because they would be more in his line. Therefore as far as those particular amendments are concerned I am satisfied that what happened was that the Senators did not do as they would give the impression they did. They did not get the members of their think-tank to tie a wet towel around their heads and stay up all night worrying what amendments should be put in which would help. They accepted those which were thrown out in Dáil Éireann and put them in here again. I am sorry Senator Lenihan was not here when I was describing the codology which was indulged in in drawing up these amendments. Not alone did they not wish the Cavan constituency to remain as it was, but they wanted to take a swipe up through County Meath, up by two towns on one side, and bring Monaghan up by two towns on the other, jumping across whole intervening areas.

One of the things which amused me, because I know every stick and stone in the area, was how the heck they proposed to bring voters from, for instance, a place called Stahalmog which had no connection with any other constituency unless, if the amendment were carried, it would be adjoining Monaghan and Meath. Yet they were sticking it on to Cavan. Maybe they have a magic wand to arrange such matters. If they have, they should use it at the next election in an effort to get a few extra seats.

Comment on this

We will borrow the Minister's super intelligence.

Comment on this

Do not worry about that.

Comment on this

The Minister has put people from Inisbofin into Lahinch.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence will lend his helicopter.

Comment on this

Many of you are very jealous of that helicopter. At least he is using it. Some of you fellows were afraid to go up in it.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would the Minister please continue on the amendment?

Comment on this

He was not using it when some people thought he was using it.

Comment on this

That is above my head. There are amendments down which do not make sense or meaning. Why they should have been repeated again after being exposed in the other House, I do not know. Possibly the people opposite should have had a better look at the proposals. Somebody should have told them that those amendments suggesting that you could have a three-seater in Cavan and a three-seater in Monaghan do not make any sense.

Just for good measure, let me point out that there was another little streak—to use Senator McGlinchey's word—by the people who put down the amendment, because it suggested that Louth should be a four-seater with the electoral division of St. Mary's from County Meath added in. For those who do not know the electoral division of St. Mary's is Mornington, Bettystown and Laytown. Would the Senators have the idea of giving me a nice little seat in Louth? Was that what they had in mind when they put down this amendment? I know they were looking after my interests anyway. Anybody who comes here and suggests that there should be any sort of reasonable effort made to understand this sort of thing is expecting too much because it is not reasonable and neither is it fair to the Senators who were lumbered with this list of amendments which do not mean anything.

Comment on this

One of the problems in discussing this Bill with this Minister is that, rather than dealing with the merits of the Bill, he spends so much of his time in trying to prove how much smarter he is than anyone else. Certainly we should not listen to instructions of the Minister on territorial matters when, quite recently, for the first time in all of recorded history, he has made the Aran Islands part of Galway city. However, he went into the usual rigmarole about how part of Ulster in the Republic had to lose seats because of Fianna Fáil mismanagement and so on. He produced this before with unequal lack of accuracy. The population of Monaghan has not decreased. It increased by 510 between 1966 and 1971, yet they lose a seat.

Comment on this

Go back a little further, Senator, and then you will find what happened.

Comment on this

We are dealing with the census of 1971 on which the Minister's Bill is based. He went into a long song and dance about how, as a result of Fianna Fáil mismanagement, the population of Monaghan had decreased. That is not true.

The population of Donegal—I am only going to deal with it in passing as I know it is not part of this amendment—decreased by a marginal 205. It is really a static situation. Between Donegal and Monaghan, taking the two together, the population includes an overall increase but the Minister takes a piece out of each. That is his attitude to population changes. He did the same in relation to Connacht. In areas where the population was declining and where Fine Gael was strong he left them the number of seats; but in areas such as Clare and Galway, where the population had increased or where Fianna Fáil were strong, he took seats away. It is far from being the fact that in many of the areas with which we are dealing the population has declined as a result of Fianna Fáil mismanagement or for any other reason. The Minister's arrangement of the constituencies is that there is little or no relation to the number of population. Whether it has increased or decreased, they will lose seats in accordance with the crudest political considerations on the part of the Minister.

He told us, for example, that Meath had to have four seats because it had a sufficient number of people to justify that. The county of Kildare is next door to Meath, as the Minister knows better than I do. The 1971 census shows that there are more people in Kildare than there are in Meath. Yet the Minister has left Kildare with three seats and has given four to his own constituency of Meath. Why?

Comment on this

There is a very simple explanation for that which I shall give to the Senator in a few moments.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

The preservation of Tully.

Comment on this

There are 3,000 or 4,000 more people in County Kildare than in County Meath, yet his own county of Meath gets four seats and County Clare gets only three. He told us—and it is a matter on which we agree—that, as a result of the figures in the 1971 Census, Louth had almost within a thousand or so of the number needed for a four-seat constituency. Therefore, in all justice, he said, he had to give them four seats. Yet Louth has fewer people than County Clare. He left Clare with three-seats and gave four to Louth. He was right in giving four to Louth because, as he said, in all justice they should have four seats. It would have been absolutely ridiculous to do anything else. But why in these circumstances did he take the county of Clare, with more people in 1971 than in the whole of the County Louth, and leave them with only three seats?

Comment on this

Might I tell the Senator that it was not I who first split up Clare?

Comment on this

I do not care one hoot what was done in 1961 or 1969 or any other year. It is time the Minister learned that he is a Minister of State, a member of an Irish Government. He is Minister for Local Government. He is coming into the Seanad with his own legislation which he has to defend. I do not care what any previous Minister has done or whether they were right or wrong. Clare, in the days before the beneficial effects of Fianna Fáil Government had become clear, did not have enough for four seats. The population of Clare has increased. As a result of the effective administration of Fianna Fáil, Clare now has enough population to have four seats.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I should like to remind Senator Yeats that the Clare constituency comes in the next amendment.

Comment on this

I accept that completely but the difficulty in discussing a Bill of this kind is that the Minister takes each one separately and says: "Is it not reasonable to give them three or four and so on?" Our problem is that we have to show— and, alas it is only too easy to show —that the Minister has not been in any way consistent. Where it suits him he gives a certain number of seats to a county. Where it does not suit him in other cases, such as Clare, he does not give them the four seats to which they are entitled. In Ulster, where there is a marginal decrease in population amounting between the three counties of less than 1,100, there is a loss of two seats.

Meath has been given four seats and although the Minister may tell us he is confident of being re-elected, it is a statistical fact that it is easier to get a quota of 20 per cent of the total vote than a quota of 25 per cent. One must have some relation to these simple statistical facts of life. The arrangement set out in the constituencies covered by this amendment bear no relation to population changes. They are arranged for some reason which the Minister has not yet designed to tell us. I am not clear why, if Meath had enough people to have four seats, then the adjoining county of Kildare was not given four.

Comment on this

One county had to get a fourth seat. There is a song and dance being made about Meath geting four seats. Because portion of Kildare was needed to make the West Dublin constituency and already portion of Kildare was in Meath this was the easiest way of arranging the constituencies. I thought Fianna Fáil would pass a vote of thanks as they have a chance of winning a seat there. They must not like the next fellow coming up.

Comment on this

We are not thinking of politics; we are thinking of justice.

Comment on this

Senator Yeats stated it was not the fault of Fianna Fáil that the constituencies of Cavan and Monaghan lost a seat each. I say it was. If we start with 1926——

Comment on this

We will be back to the Civil War next.

Comment on this

In 1926 Cavan had 82,500. In 1936 they had 77,000; in 1946 they had 70,000; in 1951 they had 56,000; in 1956 they had 51,000; in 1966 they had 54,000 and in 1971 they had 52,000. Fianna Fáil were in power for most of that time and the slide was going down all the time. Now they blame me because they lost a seat. If this county had the numbers of people they should have and which, please God, they will have, they will be entitled to three seats.

Let us take Monaghan as a comparison. In 1926 the population there was 65,000; in 1936, 61,000; in 1946, 57,000; in 1951, 55,000; in 1956, 52,000; in 1961, 47,000; in 1966, 45,732 and in 1971, 46,000. There is a slight change upwards there. With a slide from 65,000 down to 46,000, they come moaning here that they are entitled to more representation and that I am doing something drastic. It is too much to ask that this should be accepted as part of a reasonable debate.

I should like to ask one question. The Fianna Fáil Party have put down amendments. Would some member of that party explain what they propose to do with those amendments or how they expect they will be operated? The House is entitled to some explanation.

Comment on this

I am very thankful to the Minister because I was about to do so without his invitation. A Minister speaking in this House is expected to set an example in dealing with the matter being debated. There is no point in engaging in a hectoring, public meeting-type of debate in this House.

Comment on this

I will deal with it in my own way. The Senator may deal with his proposals in his way.

Comment on this

That is not on. It will not be accepted by rational people. The Minister has been endeavouring to debase the level of debate in this House. He raised a matter to which I want to address myself. He talked of his inability to keep the present constituency arrangements in the area under question in these amendments. He stated that this inability related to the fact that he had to go into part of the area concerned in these amendments—that is, part of Leinster—to top up the Dublin constituencies which were the subject matter of the group of amendments which we debated and on which we voted.

The Minister has invited us to explain precisely what we want and how we will go about getting it. I asked the Minister on three occasions during the debate on the previous group of amendments to make a positive contribution to the amendments put down by us in every good faith. The amendments in that group are inter-related with the amendments we have put down in this group. I will have to put it simplistically for the Minister. We must speak in words of one syllable as the Minister does not appear to be able to take a point or to answer one.

Comment on this

If the Senator wishes to go on that line I will take him on any time he wishes.

Comment on this

Let the Minister keep his hair on.

Comment on this

Be a little steady and wear that crown a bit lightly. In the previous group of amendments we had nine Dublin city constituencies, of which the Minister was not aware when replying to us at an earlier stage. He did not appear to know we were debating two sections of a group of amendments in the previous debate. There are nine three-seat constituencies in what we suggest.

We then suggested that by having one four-seat constituency in South County Dublin, one five-seat constituency in Dún Laoghaire and another five-seat constituency in North County Dublin, we would be able to preserve the identity of Dublin city and county and would not be crossing county boundaries into the area about which the Minister is now talking and on which this debate is based. I asked the Minister to suggest to me on the previous debate in relation to the other group of amendments how he could accommodate himself within the territorial unit of Dublin city and county. The Minister refrained from answering that point and we voted on the group without any comment by the Minister on what I had stated. Now we have come to this group of amendments. I will speak slowly and try to get an answer, as the Minister has asked us to comment on it. The Minister would have been able to accommodate himself within the present constituency boundary, give or take a townland here and there, if he had accommodated himself within Dublin city and county in the first instance.

Comment on this

This is not relevant at all.

Comment on this

The Minister has stated that the main reason why Kildare is a three-seat constituency and not a four-seat constituency is that part of north Kildare had to go into County Dublin to ensure that Dublin city and county were so carved up that there would be a three-seat constituency in every part other than the comfortable four-seater surrounding the Taoiseach. There is a comfortable four-seater now surrounding the Minister for Local Government in County Meath.

Comment on this

At least I won a seat there.

Comment on this

You lost one, too.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If we had fewer interruptions perhaps we could proceed. There are too many interruptions from both sides of the House during this debate. You will all have time to reply to points made. Would Senator Lenihan continue speaking on the amendment before the House?

Comment on this

It is not the Members of the House who are creating this atmosphere in the debate, it is the Minister. I will come back to the group of amendments under discussion. If the Minister, in his urgency to establish a three-seat regime in Dublin city and county, had not gone overboard in that endeavour of hatchet work he would not find himself in the difficulty in which he now finds himself in these four counties. The Minister had it quite open to him to accept the existing constituency arrangements in these five counties were it not for the fact that he had totally prejudiced himself by reason of this completely undemocratic approach in regard to Dublin city and county. Having made that initial decision the Minister found himself totally hamstrung in regard to his operations in the five counties now under discussion.

The situation at present is that in these counties there is a three-seat constituency in County Monaghan, a three-seat constituency in County Cavan, a three-seat constituency in County Meath, a three-seat constituency in County Kildare and a three-seat constituency in County Louth. The only population increase that necessitated an extra seat in that area occurred in County Louth. The Minister knows this as well as I do. The straightforward way of doing that, give or take a townland or two, was to make four seats in County Louth. Doing the minimum of violence to the other constituencies that exist at present he could have retained a three-seat constituency in County Meath, a three-seat constituency in County Kildare, a three-seat constituency in County Cavan and a three-seat constituency in County Monaghan. Why was that not done?

It is easy for the Minister to get up here and talk of townlands that we have put incorrectly in our amendments. Basically, as the Minister knows, in parliamentary practice the party in opposition put down amendments in order to get the Government to see the point of principle involved in them. I am not saying that our amendments are perfect but I would ask the Minister to consider them and come up here—as I asked him to do in the previous group of amendments—and tell us how best he can accommodate the scheme that we have by making it more rational and doing the least possible violence to the present constituency arrangements.

In conclusion, taking this group of amendments with the previous group, this is what should have been done. If he had done so, the Minister would have appeared to the public to be doing the right thing and not to be wielding hatchets.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before the Senator proceeds, I must remind him that the first group of amendments has been dealt with.

Comment on this

I appreciate that, but the Minister raised the matter.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not want any detailed discussion on the previous amendments.

Comment on this

I shall be very brief. The Minister should have approached this matter not as a person trying to fit his preconceived and grossly prejudiced political notions into a straitjacket of constituency arrangements, but in a manner where he would have to observe the constitutional requirements of 20,000, give or take a tolerance. In pursuing that objective with the least violence possible to county boundaries, he would have preserved the territorial identity of Dublin city and county and would also have preserved the existing constituencies in the group we are now discussing. County boundaries had to be breached in regard to Meath, Cavan, Louth, Monaghan and Kildare. The Minister could have preserved those three-seat constituencies and adjusted them accordingly. But he was driven into this situation because of the three-seat straitjacket situation in Dublin city. In my view the Minister is not addressing himself to what we are proposing here. I should like to hear the Minister commenting on our amendments and engaging less in political banter and political hectoring that does no justice to his case and is only an affront to the intelligence of Members on all sides of this House.

Comment on this

I have listened to Senator Lenihan giving me a lecture on what should be done. The trouble with Fianna Fáil is that they are attempting to prove that what was done the last time by their Minister was right. Would they please remember that I started off with the idea, preconceived as Senator Lenihan has said, that I knew from having been in the House when the Bill was passed that what was done was blatantly wrong and could not be allowed to continue. At the time this happened I said in the other House that if we ever got into power I would take the necessary steps to change the constituencies. I make no apology to anybody for changing the constituencies as they were left by the then Deputy Kevin Boland when he was Minister for Local Government, because I think that it was a very unfair distribution of seats from county to county.

For the information of those who are prepared to throw figures around but apparently do not want to get them back, if we look at figures in regard to County Meath, the figure in 1966 was 67,333 and in 1971 was 71,729. It is not correct to say that Louth shows the only increase. In fact in Louth there were 69,590 in 1966 and 74,951 in 1971.

Comment on this

That increase occurred under Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

The whole of the east coast increased in spite of Fianna Fáil rather than because of it.

Comment on this

It was Fianna Fáil's fault.

Comment on this

Louth was entitled to a four-seater and they got it. The only way in which Monaghan or Cavan could be entitled to retain three-seaters would be by allowing larger slices of County Meath to be added on. Even if they were added on they could not be added on in the way in which the amendments suggest. Senator Lenihan has said that you cannot blame them. I am not blaming them. This was prepared and they put in the same amendments as they submitted in the other House. But I would blame them for the fact that it was pointed out in the other House by me that this particular set of amendments just could not work. It is a little too much to dump them in exactly as they were.

Comment on this

We have a changed set and another group that you suggested in the other House.

Comment on this

What I suggested is in the Bill.

Comment on this

In the western group.

Comment on this

What I suggested is in the Bill.

Comment on this

The amendment is in line with what the Minister suggested.

Comment on this

I did not suggest anything.

Comment on this

We can quote the Minister on it.

Comment on this

Quote away!

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It can be quoted when we come to that amendment and not now. Will the Minister continue on the amendment that is before the House with fewer interruptions?

Comment on this

The constituency of Cavan and Monaghan has no breach of the boundary. The two counties are put together. They are getting fair representation in five seats. I think they will be perfectly satisfied with that. As far as County Meath is concerned, we have the whole county with a small portion of County Kildare and yet there was a suggestion that there should have been a portion of County Dublin added on to it. You should see some of the suggestions made by my predecessor when he was preparing the constituencies. He made Cavan-Monaghan a five-seater.

Comment on this

Will the Minister produce the record?

Comment on this

If the Senator wants to see it I will be glad to show it to him.

Comment on this

The Minister made a remark about me.

Comment on this

I withdrew that. Does the Senator want me to say something more about it?

Comment on this

I want the Minister to prove the statement he is making.

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to make very serious statements without producing documentary evidence or referring to documentary evidence and talking about them here without any proof whatever?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister is in order to refer to the matter. He did advise people who wanted to see the evidence that he would produce it for them. I do not want to labour this point very much because it will stir up a lot of controversy. I should like the House——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I ask the House not to interrupt the Chair. Please allow the Minister to continue. As I have pointed out several times tonight, this is Committee Stage and Senators can reply as often as they like. It would make for a lot more reasoned debate if there were no interruptions when Senators are speaking.

Comment on this

The Minister is fairly good himself at interrupting.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am not agreeing with anything Senator McGlinchey is suggesting at the moment. The Minister to continue.

Comment on this

If the Minister would act in his capacity as a Minister, rather than acting in the capacity of a gerrymanderer——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Would the Senator please resume his seat and allow the Minister continue on the amendment?

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that a number of Senators are more anxious to shout across at me than to listen to the arguments I have made. I have told Senator Lenihan I would give him a reply. I shall make it short because if other Senators want to make a comment or want to interrupt, I do not propose to take part in a barging match with anybody on the other side of the House. I wish to say to Senator Lenihan that the amendments which have been proposed are not workable. I still believe that the proposals which I have put into the Bill are the best way to cope with the matter and I shall leave it at that.

Comment on this

A few minutes ago the Minister told us that the population of the eastern coast rose in spite of Fianna Fáil but that the drop in population in Cavan and Monaghan was as a result of Fianna Fáil. I find it hard to believe that a man who occupies the important post of Minister for Local Government would expect to get away with a statement of that kind or would expect the Irish people to believe he thinks that Fianna Fáil were responsible for the decline in population in Counties Cavan and Monaghan, while across the boundary in Meath and Louth the population rose in spite of Fianna Fáil. This is a type of propaganda in which the Minister excels. In his defence of this gerrymandering legislation he has used propaganda of this kind on numerous occasions.

I want to make an observation. A census was taken in 1971. If Fianna Fáil's effort to reduce the population in Cavan and Monaghan in 1971 and 1972, according to what the Minister has stated, rubbed off into County Louth and if the population of County Louth happened to drop during those two years of this terrible Fianna Fáil Government by more than 100 people, then in my opinion this legislation is unconstitutional. If it were to appear that in 1974, three years since the census, there is a population drop of over 100 people in County Louth then the population ratio per member would be less than 19,123, the figure allowed in the High Court decision of 1961. Whether or not the population of County Louth dropped, it is difficult to say. County Louth is a prosperous county and has expanded considerably over the last few years, particularly as a result of Fianna Fáil's industrialisation campaign, despite what the Minister has just told us when he said that it has grown in spite of Fianna Fáil.

It is interesting to note that the population ratio per Member for County Louth is 26 people per Member more than is constitutionally possible. The Minister had to scrape the bottom of the barrel to provide the minimum area to maintain four Deputies in this county. Of course it is obvious again that Fianna Fáil have two seats out of three in this county. Nobody who is in any way politically realistic could forecast an improvement in that situation. By providing County Louth with an extra seat it is an obvious bonus to the Coalition Government: quite obviously the Coalition will gain a seat as a result of this arrangement. I find it hard to accept that any political party with any sense of justice would arrange constituencies in such a way that in the smallest county it would take 19,149 people to elect a Deputy. In my native county it takes 21,102— almost 2,000 people more per Deputy in County Donegal than in County Louth.

In Roscommon-Leitrim, 21,119 people are given the opportunity of electing a Deputy. In this legislation the Minister has provided that in County Louth almost 2,000 fewer are required. The same applies to Sligo-Leitrim.

Why is it that this situation should be allowed to exist? Why is it that the votes of almost 10,000 people in County Donegal are lost? Earlier today the Minister suggested that it was nonsense to say that there was a city bias but it is quite obvious to anyone who studies the explanatory memorandum that anywhere there is political advantage for the Minister's political party the population per Member ratio is practically at the minimum required by the Constitution and where there is no apparent political advantage for the Minister's parties the population per Member ratio is practically the highest required by the Constitution.

This is discrimination against the north-western portion of this country in particular. The Minister is using his position to ensure that in Dublin city and on the east coast and in this case County Louth it takes fewer people to elect a Duputy than on the west coast. A figure of 2,000 people per Deputy fewer in County Louth with four Deputies means that 8,000 people have that advantage over their fellow-Irishmen in other parts of this country.

Again this constituency of County Louth will not go unnoticed and the Minister's manipulations no doubt in the years ahead will be the subject of comment from our Unionist friends across the Border because the Minister in this constituency of Louth has once again proved that he is the expert, the pastmaster, as far as gerrymandering is concerned.

Comment on this

A point of information, we are talking on our amendment? Just before the Minister went for his tea I was making the point that perhaps he would discuss with us across the floor our amendments and at a later stage we would deal with the Bill before us. I made a point, and it is quite unfair that it was not answered. We had made a proposal keeping Dublin city and county within that particular area. At that time no positive point was made by the Minister to show why we were wrong.

In order to bring us closer to this point we have made further amendments. All the Minister will do in reply is to introduce politics—parish pump politics—rather than discuss the actual amendments. I personally would like the Minister to tell us why our amendments are not correct. We do not seem to be able to grasp why our amendments are wrong. I thought it quite unfair that the points I made were not replied to. We have put down logical amendments. All we hear is party politics. It is as low as parish pump politics, and that is very low. For instance, Kildare has a gross population——

Comment on this
Joe J. McCartin Acting Chairman (Mr. McCartin) Fine Gael

I should like to remind Senator Killilea that he rose on a point of information. We are discussing the group consisting of Cavan, Monaghan, Louth and Meath.

Comment on this

I agree. I rose and I said on this set of amendments as well as on the previous amendments that I asked for a logical reason why——

Comment on this

I have gone into great detail explaining why I considered that the amendments before the House are completely illogical. It is an area I know very well. I would accept that categorically. Senator Lenihan said that he had put down amendments for the purpose of giving further consideration to them. The Senator has asked me to prove what was put down was illogical. I have gone into great detail, more so than perhaps I should have.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to give me a logical reason.

Comment on this

I have already done so. It would be repetition to go back over it again.

Comment on this

No logical reason has been given by the Minister to this House to show specifically why the amendments are not correct.

Comment on this

Could I ask Senator Lenihan, who is a reasonable man, is it not a fact that I went into great detail, so much detail that he was getting a bit exasperated with all the areas I covered? When I was finished the Senator, in fact, said they were not claiming the amendments were perfect.

Comment on this

In this matter, as the Minister well knows, each group of amendments is interrelated with the other. That presents a difficulty because undoubtedly the illogicality of what the Minister has done here relates directly back to the group of amendments we were discussing previously, that is, the desire to put Dublin city and county into a straitjacket of three-seat constituencies with the exception of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown. From that has flowed all these amendments which are now incorporated in the Schedule and to which we have put down amendments.

I am not suggesting that our amendments are perfect. The Minister is right in this respect. Fundamentally, Senator Killilea's point is very valid. I have made the point on several occasions that the Minister and the Government would have saved themselves a lot of public odium and disrespect if they had not so obviously set out to gerrymander the situation. For the first time in the history of the state boundaries are breached with regard to Dublin. If Dublin city and county were preserved by doing what we suggest or by some other arrangement incorporating a balance of nine three-seat constituencies, two five-seat constituencies and a four-seat constituency, then the Minister would be in a position where he would be doing the least possible harm in regard to the area under discussion. Then he could go on with the minimum amount of interference and change with the other constituencies in Leinster rather than dragging these counties, as witness the suburbs of Bray, Blessington, Celbridge, Maynooth and Lucan, artificially into Dublin in order to prop up the Government's blind prejudice to fit Dublin city and county into a three-seat constituency situation.

Instead of adopting some sort of irrational proposal—I am not saying ours is perfect but our suggestion of the arrangement of the constituencies within Dublin and Greater Dublin would not breach the Dublin county boundaries—the Minister could then proceed to the grouping we are now discussing and with the minimum of change on the existing constituencies effect what is the only justifiable population increase which is the increase of one in County Dublin.

Comment on this

The mistake the Senator is making is that he assumes I am accepting that the existing constituencies were all right. I started off knowing that the existing constituencies were all wrong and could not be more wrong than they were. I have gone into great detail in dealing with North Leinster by pointing out that not alone do I not agree with Senator Lenihan but I have pointed out that they are not even accurate. I am sorry to have to repeat this because it must be tedious.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

I will not blame the Senator for that because it is so difficult if he does not know the area. I want it to be accepted, and the House has already by vote accepted it, that the Dublin area is 13 three-seat constituencies and one four-seat constituency. This was the principle on which we started out and that having been accepted I think it is idle to suggest that we should now go back and redebate the Dublin area and in some way try to relate it to what is happening elsewhere. I do not think it would be in order to do that.

The suggestions which have been made here in regard to this area, particularly the suggestion that a portion of Cavan be added on to Monaghan, are not acceptable in any circumstances, either by Cavan people or Monaghan people. The five-seater which is proposed in the Bill is far more attractive than the idea of having a big sweep of County Meath added on to Monaghan. I do not want to delay on this point. It is too ridiculous for words. I was born and reared in the area and I know it very well. I think it is ridiculous to suggest that from Emyvale up to Navan should be one constituency. We talk about the width from one side of Cavan to the other side of Monaghan. It is not as far as has been suggested. The fact that there are areas left out and jumped across—whole electoral areas—makes it look a bit wide.

I do not want to labour that point. To say that the Cavan people would agree that towns such as Shercock and Kingscourt as well as other smaller areas should be taken and given to Monaghan, and then to go right up round by Kells and Athboy, is not reasonable. I do not want to cut short the debate, but I do not want to take up too much time with the debate. I believe the Senators should have the opportunity of making their points, but I am not prepared to go back and discuss the first set of amendments again because they have been decided and as far as the second set of amendments are concerned I think I have explained fully. Senator Killilea has said I have not. I have gone into the greatest details to explain why this set of amendments would not work.

Comment on this

Why has the Minister changed the principle of three-seaters outside of Dublin.

Comment on this

There are two things— the Constitution and the Supreme Court decision. We have to tie the two of them in. We could have seven-seaters, or nine-seaters but without breaching county boundaries very much more we could not do better than we are doing. It is acceptable to everybody who wants to see it.

Comment on this

On the basis of three-seaters in rural areas the Minister could not do better. The Minister said that the best application of democracy is through the principle of three-seaters.

Comment on this

I said I was satisfied that in Dublin, and I gave my reasons for it, I believed it would——

Comment on this

The natural logic of that conclusion is that if three-seaters are appropriate for Dublin, surely they must be the most appropriate thing for the country.

Comment on this

Supposing there was one huge area in the midlands all belonging to one county or one city, it is possible to divide that in certain ways. When we come to a county boundary such as you have in the case of Cavan-Monaghan, I think it is more reasonable not to breach their boundaries— it is more reasonable to put the two together. When we came to Meath we could have taken a wee bit of Dublin and a wee bit of Louth and made a handy little three-seater. I do not think that would have been right. I think the proper thing to do would be to put the whole of a county with a small portion of another county added to it into a four-seater. There are four divisions in my own constituency of Meath——

Comment on this

What about Kildare and Wicklow?

Comment on this

As far as Kildare is concerned it has been suggested to take a portion of Kildare and putting it into Wicklow and portion of it into Dublin and a portion of it into Meath and the balance into Kildare. What I have done is not as bad as that. I have taken up too much time of the House——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must ask Senator Killilea not to take the Minister back to that which has already been dealt with.

Comment on this

The Minister is now discussing the meat of the Bill. I cannot apply the logic of the Minister tearing into Kildare and Wicklow on the one hand and then not daring to do it elsewhere.

Comment on this

I did not tear into any of them. Kildare could have had a four-seater but it would mean that in order to level off further it would be necessary that some of Kildare be given to some other county. Some of Dublin would have to be given to Meath in order to level it off. My object was to have the least amount of disturbance. Maybe I am wrong but my reckoning was that it was better to take one county like Kildare and to give a portion of it to Dublin, a portion of it to Kildare itself and a portion of it to Meath. Better to do it that way and have the Kildare end of it compact rather than to take a portion of Kildare and put that into Meath and a portion of Dublin into Meath and a portion of Meath into Louth and have the counties broken up into numerous areas. That was the way it was with Leitrim: it was broken into three parts, but I divided it into two only. I have had this debated at length. I had this in the other House and I have had it here. A tremendous amount of work has gone into the Bill and I am prepared to stand over the Bill as it is.

Comment on this

I would suggest to the Minister that obviously he has not answered the question. He is making plain and obvious now that the House is wasting its time, having made that statement—that it is a stone wall situation here, that it is only an exercise here to act out a charade of democracy which is totally false. I would say that the Minister is a prisoner of the two parties that he is now——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I would remind the Senator that the House is discussing Cavan-Monaghan, Louth and Meath and I think I have been very lenient with the Senators until now.

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister a question. I feel it is a useful question because it may restrict the debate here.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are discussing Cavan-Monaghan, Meath and Louth.

Comment on this

We are discussing a group of amendments and my question is related to those amendments.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If the Senator would relate it to this particular amendment.

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister a question. He criticises the amendments put forward and I am asking him if they were changed in any way would the Minister accept them.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I would remind the Senator that we are only talking about this particular amendment.

Comment on this

Could I further ask the Minister is the reason for his refusal, and his reply to me that he could not change in any circumstances, because of his complete commitment and agreement—is that the reason that we cannot have even the smallest amendment accepted or considered in this House?

Comment on this

It is a Government decision because of the fact that I consider the Bill before the House to be in order and I have heard the arguments. I can comment on the amendments before the House. No argument has been put which I would be prepared to agree should be accepted. It is as simple as that. I do not believe any argument has been made which would make me change my mind and I am convinced that the Bill as it is——

Comment on this

Even the smallest item?

Comment on this

I did change it in the other House.

Comment on this

You did in regard to East Mayo.

Comment on this

A curious situation has now arisen. For some quite considerable time the Minister has been dealing with this amendment on the basis that for reasons he set out, whether we accept them or not is another matter, appear to him to be good. He now says he cannot accept the amendment because we covered certain townlands, parishes and so on particularly in County Meath which to him do not make sense. This is the line he has been taking as to why he cannot accept this amendment. It is because it has certain, in his view, technical faults. Now in answer to the very cogent question put by Senator McGowan, he completely turns tail from this. He was asked whether, in view of his statement on this amendment, if a slightly different amendment remedying what he considers to be the faults of this one were to be brought in on Report Stage next week, he would accept it. He says: "No. A lot of work has gone into this Bill. I am not accepting anything."

With all respect to the Chair, he said a lot of work has gone into this Bill, not just into this amendment, which I think carries a certain implication about discussing other amendments. We have this completely different approach now from the Minister. Until now he has been discussing these amendments so far as on the basis that they had certain faults. Now it is put to him categorically: "All right. Accepting what he says on this amendment, will the Minister therefore consider accepting an amendment which remedies these defects"? From listening to what he has said it probably could be easily done. He says he will not accept this or any other amendments. So all his argument on this amendment has been a kind of a front, an utterly irrelevant series of statements which have no relation whatever to what is really in his mind. He is happy with the Bill. It accomplishes apparently what he wants to accomplish. He is just not going to make any changes. After some hours of discussion on this amendment he now comes completely around and——

Comment on this

I went out for my tea. Senator Yeats also had a break for his tea. Having come back in again and having missed some of a very detailed discussion which I had with Senator Lenihan and with Senator Killilea on the amendment, I think it is a bit unfair of somebody who was not here to generalise. I think it is a rather extraordinary thing that somebody of Senator Yeats's experience should come along and say: "Why does the Minister not say he will accept some amendment?"

As far as I am concerned, so far I have had no argument from anybody which would convince me that I should change. If there was an argument which would make me change my mind I might. I have changed my mind on Bills before, but as of now I have heard nothing from the Opposition which would induce me to change my mind. I think that the Bill, as far as we have gone, is all right. It is as simple as that and I think adding bits on to it and suggesting what might happen and all the rest, is a little bit over the edge. We have been discussing certain amendments. They have been very fully discussed. I think those who are here are satisfied that the amendments would not do any good, would not be acceptable anyway even if they would do what they wanted. I could not accept these amendments. I am not satisfied that these amendments could be worked. I am satisfied that the sections of the Bill which it is proposed to amend are better than they would be if they were amended. I believe they are all right as they are. That is exactly what the situation is.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am now putting the question "That the amendment be made."

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 14
·
Níl 26
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question put: "That the entry relating to the constituency of Cavan-Monaghan stand part of the Schedule".

Tá 26
·
Níl 14
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

It has already been agreed that amendments Nos. 3, 9, 10, 13, 14, 16 and 18 will form a group.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 4, to delete the entry relating to the constituency of Clare and substitute the following:

Name | Area | Number of Members

Clare | The administrative County of Clare and in the administrative County of Galway the following electoral divisions: Drummin, Coos, in the former Rural District of Portumna. | Four

Woodford, Loughatorick, Ballinagar and Derrylaur in the former Rural District of Loughrea.

In this amendment it is proposed— again consistent with our earlier proposal—that as far as possible the territorial identity of County Clare be maintained, thereby justifying four seats which the county is entitled to have. Again, this is in strict accord with the principle underlying our other amendments in which we sought to have the territorial identity of Dublin city and county preserved as well. Grouped with this we have amendment No. 9 which relates to the contiguous constituency of East Galway where in our amendment we suggest five seats. This relates to a paragraph in the Minister's Schedule on page 8 in which he suggests four seats.

Amendment No. 10 in our name relates to West Galway where we suggest having three seats. This in turn relates to page 8 of the Schedule, to the Minister's proposal for West Galway of four seats. Amendments Nos. 3, 9 and 10 comprise the main amendments that we suggest, but of course, as the Minister rightly stated earlier on, any such amendments to have any rationality or common sense must be taken in relation to other consequential happenings in neighbouring constituencies. Accordingly we have amendment No. 13 which is a consequential amendment to the East Mayo constituency. Amendment No. 14 is a consequential amendment to the West Mayo constituency. These again relate to amendment No. 16 in the Roscommon-Leitrim constituency and amendment No. 18 relates to the Sligo-Leitrim constituency.

The amendments as we suggest them in the other Western counties— they are important and I will be referring to them at a later stage— are not as fundamental to our view of the overall situation as the suggested amendments in Clare and Galway. I shall be dealing in greater detail with Sligo, Leitrim, Roscommon and the two Mayo constituencies later on but initially I should like to concentrate on the first three amendments, that is amendments Nos. 3, 9 and 10, that relate to Counties Clare and Galway, taking those two counties as a unit.

Here we have a very interesting situation in that what is suggested is taking up in a constructive manner a positive intervention by the Minister in the Dáil. I refer to Volume 271, No. 9, columns 1373 and 1374. In the course of the passage of this Bill through the Dáil the Minister invited a proposition that a four-seat constituency be established in Clare. I quote the Minister in his answer to a repeated question from Deputy Loughnane. Deputy Loughnane asked the question three times in this column: "Why not a four-seater in Clare? Answer that one?" Then, of course, there are interruptions from other Deputies interfering with Deputy Loughnane's very pertinent question. He repeats it several times further down: "Why is Clare not a four-seater?" Eventually, he gets himself heard again, and he said to the Minister: "What about my crutches?" The Minister said: "We could have had a four-seater in Clare but when Deputy Molloy was drawing up his amendments he did not think this could have been done." Then the Minister makes a snide remark about Deputy Molloy's good terms with Deputy Loughnane.

Comment on this

I thought the Senator was going to read on.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that he might not be on very good terms with Deputy Loughnane. Deputy Loughnane like a good forceful Deputy comes back to his point—he ignores the Minister's remark—and says: "Why not a four-seater in Clare? The population justifies it." Then we have bantering between the Minister and Deputy Loughnane about hawks and doves in Fianna Fáil. It is very good reading indeed. The Ceann Comhairle rightly brings everybody back to the contents of the Bill, to use his own phraseology. Indeed, he proceeded in some way to reflect on Deputy Loughnane that he had asked that question many times. Deputy Loughnane was rightly getting his point home. Deputy Tully, as a courteous Minister, replied in greater detail to him at this stage at column 1374. I quote the Minister for Local Government:

It would have been possible to have a four-seater in Clare but it would have meant changing quite a lot of what had already been prepared. If Deputy Molloy had proposed something like that maybe we would have considered doing it but he did not. Deputy Molloy did not think of Deputy Loughnane when he was drawing up his amendments because he would be quite happy to see Deputy Loughnane outside the House. That is the difference between Deputy Molloy and me. I would like to see Deputy Loughnane in the House.

I should like to take the Minister up on that. So would we here on this side of the House like to see Deputy Loughnane in that House. Indeed, we would like to suggest that if Deputy Molloy, through some oversight, did not have a proposition for a four-seater ready for the Minister in the Dáil, we have done some homework on that particular aspect. That homework which we have done is now reflected in the first of our amendments which is before the House.

Comment on this

I did not like to interrupt the actual quotation, but in one remark the Senator did appear to reflect on the conduct of the Ceann Comhairle. I would be glad to have his assurance that there was no intention of doing so.

Comment on this

Not at all. My apologies to the Cathaoirleach. That was not my intention. I want to relate this exchange of views in the Dáil to the fact that we have now taken the Minister at his word. If through some oversight there was not such an amendment in the Dáil, there is now an amendment here that seeks to take the Minister at his word and puts forward a rational proposal in regard to County Clare. I know the Minister, possibly in an excess of words, sometime ago said that he thought that every detail of this Bill was the "greatest" and he was not going to adopt any changes in it. I give the Minister credit for referring to that as an excess of words. He is well enough and long enough in politics to know—and I do not intend to lecture him here—that the whole purpose of having a Committee Stage debate in a Bill is to have views put forward and to have, if possible, amendments adopted, provided they are reasonably put forward.

Indeed, the Minister, on the occasion of the last group of amendments through his own personal knowledge and involvement in the area concerned was able to point out in what respects our amendments fell down on the practicality of having them applied to the county of which he is a Deputy. Here we suggest is an amendment which on every aspect of viewing makes sense. Here is an amendment that proposes to keep the entire county of Clare as a constituency and in addition to that a few townlands ideally contiguous to it which in fact I know from my personal knowledge of this area are in reality part of Clare—the townlands of Woodford, Loughatorick, Ballinagar and Derrylaur in the former rural district of Loughrea. That particular part of County Galway, adjacent to Gort and Loughrea—as anybody in the House is well aware—has always been associated with County Clare. Since the formation of the State that part of County Galway has been in and out of Clare constituencies. Apart from 1969, it was Clare-Galway; on prior occasions North Clare was in with South Galway; part of South Galway at one stage included that part of North Clare. Therefore over the years—this is where the tradition and the precedent comes in—that small part of County Galway in the Gort-Loughrea area has been in and out of both constituencies, Galway and Clare.

Here we have a very rational amendment. It gives the whole county of Clare its four seats. It is slightly short of justifying four, so these few townslands on the border of Clare, that are as much related to Clare as to Galway, are added to it to make four seats. It is a very clean, rational suggestion. If there is any sincerity and any meaning in having a Committee Stage debate in a House of Parliament, it is one that should be adopted. If not adopted, it requires to be answered as to why it is not being adopted. Taking the constituency of West Galway, there has been total violence done to the territorial and administrative integrity of the county of Clare. Taking West Galway one can see the extent of what has been added in from County Clare to mutilate completely that county in the interests of giving West Galway the completely artificial four-seat constituency. I am sorry to see that the Member of the Seanad who had possibly hoped to be a beneficiary from this arrangement, has not seen fit to be present here to discuss this particular form of mutilation involving County Clare's incorporation in West Galway to make four seats in West Galway, and hopefully a fourth seat for the Labour Party. I say "hopefully", as I do not see the particular Senator who has a vested interest in this particular matter on the Labour Party benches at the moment.

Comment on this

There are two of them: one of them belongs to the Senator's part of the House.

Comment on this

Both of them have the utmost confidence.

Comment on this

In West Galway's four-seat constituency we have the most massive piece of mutilation that is involved in the Schedule. A third to a half of the list of electoral divisions referred to in the West Galway Schedule are made up of a huge part of north-west Clare. The electoral divisions of Abbey, Carran, Castletown, Derreen, Drumcreehy, Gleninagh, Lisdoonvarna, Mount Elvar, Noughaval, Oughtmama, Rathborney and the former rural district of Ballyvaghan are gone into Galway. Ballyvaghan, in total, is gone into Galway and all the electoral divisions in it.

Similarly, in the rural district of Corofin we have Ballyeighter, Boston, Corofin, Glenroe, Killinaboy, Kiltoraght, Muckanagh, Rath, Ruan—the whole rural district of Corofin on top of the rural district of Ballyvaughan. Into the town of Ennis itself, which is well down in the county of Clare, more than halfway, parts of the former rural district of Ennis town, the capital town of the county, are now removed into this West Galway abortion of a constituency. Dysart and Templemaley are in the former rural district of Ennis, added into a constituency that is already stretching to beyond Clifden.

Finally, the whole of West Clare: the rural districts of Ennistymon, Ballagh, Ballyea, Ballysteen, Cloghaun, Clooney, Ennistimon, Kilfenora, Killaspuglonane, Killilagh, Kilshanny, Liscannor, Lurraga, Magherareagh, and Smithstown. Right down into the heart of County Clare, the town of Ennis and the whole of more than half the western coast of Clare and practically all the north-west of Clare, is added into the West Galway constituency to make a four-seat constituency.

I have already shown that in our amendment we can keep the identity of County Clare together. I am seeking to keep an attitude here that what we are discussing are the amendments. This is not Fianna Fáil talking in its interest and we shall not complain or moan about the Government parties looking after their interests. We are concerned about rational amendments that would be adopted by any judicial or quasi-judicial commission or tribunal, who would look at the matter fairly and openly and decide that we must keep a population balance under the terms of the Constitution, having regard to the Budd decision on foot of his interpretation of the relevant Article of the Constitution. We must keep that balance. It is part of the Budd decision and must be maintained within the overall balance of having regard to county boundaries. In other words, one does not breach county boundaries unless one has to. That is the effect of the Budd decision. There must be a population of 20,000 per Deputy, with a reasonable tolerance each way. Otherwise, county boundaries should be maintained and retained. The objective should be to maintain county boundaries, to preserve traditional loyalties and associations and geographical relationships as much as possible. Where that is impossible, the county boundary must be breached.

The Minister's monstrosity in regard to West Galway, in which the whole of north-west Clare is taken away from the county, stands out in stark contradistinction to our proposal to maintain the whole of County Clare, with a few small townlands in South Galway contiguous to it, as a four-seat constituency.

I now proceed to the other side of our argument. In answer to what the Minister has suggested in regard to West Galway we come back to the Minister's beloved three-seat constituency. He has done violence both ways in that he has introduced an artificial four-seat constituency in West Galway, adding to it well over a third of County Clare. He has made an artificial constituency stretching from near Ennis to Clifden in the interests of keeping Clare down to a three-seat constituency and in the interests of having West Galway a four-seat constituency. Our amendment suggests that we do the exact reverse, and this is what the Minister called on us to do in the Dáil, which we are now doing, that is, to preserve County Clare in its integrity as a four-seat constituency, with the few townlands from Galway mentioned, and that we maintain what is, by and large the present West Galway constituency, which has always been the West Galway constituency, with adjustments here and there over many years, as a three-seat constituency. Therefore there is the present three-seat constituency arrangement, which has existed for a long number of years in West Galway, based on the two defined segments of that constituency, which are the city of Galway and its hinterland and Connemara. Why artificially make that a four-seat constituency, by lumping in with that the whole of north-west Clare? This means reverting back to a three-seat constituency in Clare, where the county on its own practically warrants a four-seat situation. There is nothing gained. All there is under the Minister's proposal is a four-seat constituency in a totally artificial new West Galway and a three-seater in a totally mutilated Clare.

Under our proposal we have a four-seat constituency in a complete County Clare and a three-seat constituency in West Galway. That has always been so. If that does not appear to be a logical presentation to the Minister, I do not know what is. In the Bill we find a totally ludicrous position.

All logic would lead one to having a four-seat constituency in Clare and a three-seat constituency in West Galway. Only obscure political advantage would lead a reasonably intelligent man like the Minister to any other conclusion. The natural state of things is reversed: instead of a four-seat constituency in Clare and a three-seat constituency in West Galway we have a four-seat constituency in West Galway and a three-seat constituency in Clare, and violence and mutilation have been done in the process to the two counties concerned. I will be coming back to this tomorrow with the Minister because he has asked us to come out with positive proposals in the course of this debate. He may have been on strong ground in parts of County Meath but he is on very weak ground in trying to explain this one. I believe we are on very strong ground——

Comment on this

I will take you on tomorrow.

Comment on this

Might I mention for the convenience of Senators that it is proposed to sit at 10.30 a.m. tomorrow. It has been agreed that we should conclude the Committee stage of this Bill tomorrow and that the Report and remaining Stages should be taken and concluded on Tuesday of next week. It might be of convenience to Senators who want to make arrangements to know that that has been agreed.

Comment on this

It depends on how well behaved everybody is.

Comment on this

I understand that there is agreement. It is intended to interrupt business tomorrow after lunch in order to take the motion dealing with the regulations for the local elections.

Comment on this