We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an Deichiú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1986: An Dara Céim. Tenth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1986: Second Stage.

Contributions 61–165 of 165. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Tenth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1986
Rejected

No. 15 of 1986 ›

——where divorce legislation does not exist. Is there no valid marriage in any other country in Europe but in Malta and Ireland? Are Irish marriages so frail, Irish relationships so vulnerable that they need to have the legal bind of marriage tied into the constitution or they would fall apart? Re-echoing the same statement he said, and I quote: "a life long contract but one guaranteed by the laws of the land". If it is not that, does love, caring, genuine bonding to one another count for anything that you must have a legal contract that cannot be broken or amended or else marriage will dissolve and fall apart? Surely that sort of logic flies in the face of all the evidence that is available from around the world. The Senator asked what would happen if one partner left and refused to return. What kind of a marriage exists if one partner in a marriage leaves and refuses to return to the other partner? Should we send out the baliff to bring him or her back and to refasten the chain? That sort of illogic mystifies me. I believe the majority of Irish marriages are based on love and care, on a genuine bonding and on relationships that have ups and downs. But I also believe there are many people who have made mistakes in their lives and who are now tied into legal marriage contracts which present great pain for them, and from which injustice they should be allowed to be released.

Somebody writing in a newspaper recently made a point that to argue that the availability of divorce leads to broken marriages is a bit like arguing that the availability of confession leads to more sin being committed. This point was reechoed by my colleague, Senator Michael D. Higgins, when he said it is like arguing that the availability of umbrellas causes rain. It is a dramatic way of putting it, perhaps, but it is nevertheless a fact that in our society, which has always been free of divorce — but for an exceptional way on which I will touch later — we have not been free of broken marriages.

I would love to think that there was no need for a change in the law relating to marriage and that there was no need for the introduction of divorce. But I, like everybody else here, know only too well of marriages that have failed, of people and children who are under severe stress in those failed marriages, and of other people who have already established second families, having escaped from a failed first marriage. We cannot have a rational debate on the subject of divorce without putting down some initial markers. I will make a point or two on which we can all agree, whether you are in favour of the amendment or opposed to it. Fact one is that, with the best will and motivation in the world, some marriages do fail, to a point where any reasonable person will have to concede that the marriage is dead. That is an acceptable, understandable point of view that nobody could argue with.

A second fact is that the death of a marriage in many instances leads to bitterness, hostility and financial stress and can even result in traumatic consequences, particularly, for the children involved.

Fact three, the State and the Churches already recognise that marriages fail. There are a number of measures available for dealing with this. There are, for instance, Catholic Church annulments, which give the partners the right to remarry in the Catholic Church and as a consequence render the children illegitimate. There are foreign divorces, which in many cases are recognised under Irish law. These are basic facts about which there can be no great disagreement. The only thing missing from our law — and this is where the disagreement will begin — is a provision enabling people to remarry after the existing marriage has been declared dead by an Irish court. I would argue that agreeing to write that provision into our law is nothing more than facing up to reality, recognising that the facts I have mentioned have their own logic. If the Dáil, the Seanad and the Government of the day refused indefinitely to recognise the suffering that exists in failed marriages, we will rightly be accused of turning a blind eye to a serious social problem and turning our backs on the many tens of thousands — I will not get into the numbers game — of people whose only legal redress is to have the marriage that is de facto dead declared legally dead.

We in the Labour Party have argued for a very long time that people who are trapped in these unhappy situations should be given the opportunity of a second chance. But we have also argued that the poblem should be approached with care, that ultimately divorce should be available only within very clearly defined parameters, as a last resort down a long road. This is why I find the approach outlined by the Government in the Bill to be such a welcome one. It is careful and well-considered and it makes absolutely clear that divorces will only be granted as a last resort. The provisions are there. I will not read them again into the record of the House.

Reconciliation will be the key feature and judicial separations, which are a prerequisite to divorce, will not be granted unless reconciliation has been tried and has been seen to fail. The minimum period of separation — the acid test for failure — will be five years and no divorce will be granted unless the courts are satisfied that adequate provision had been made for dependants.

Many Senators, particularly Senator Robinson, referred to the legal smoke screens that people can put up, particularly, when talking about an amendment to the Constitution, because when you start to dissect comma and colon, phrase and verb, you certainly cause confusion if nothing else. Senator Robinson, in her contribution on the Second Stage, made it abundantly clear that the provisions that exist already in the Constitution leave much to be desired. Certainly they could not be defined as cherishing either all the children of the nation equally or all the women of the nation equally, or indeed, all the spouses of the nation equally. So let us be realistic in this debate. Let us address the real problem. Let us look with compassion on the real problem, and then in the fullness of careful deliberation, let us decide in compassion.

The contents of the Bill before the House are the basic ingredients of the divorce law which it is proposed to put into place. Perhaps the most important feature is that the basic requirements are being written into the Constitution itself so that only the people of the country can change them subsequently. Many people genuinely fear that the mere removal of the constitutional prohibition would leave it open to the Oireachtas to legislate in a way that they would find objectionable. The method proposed by the Government is not simply to remove the constitutional prohibition but to insert a clearly defined, rigid set of structures that must be followed. The people know in advance the sort of parameters that will circumscribe any legislation. Those parameters can only be subsequently changed again by referendum and reference to the people. That must surely allay any fears that Las Vegas or Californian type divorce would be available on demand. Because such care has been taken, I believe that the divorce law that we will introduce will be realistic and compassionate, yet restrictive and limited. It clearly sets out to treat divorce only as a solution available as a last resort. That is the way I believe it should be.

I know that there will be many views on both sides of this debate. I urge as many people as possible to consider the issue calmly and objectively. I hope that the debate will not reach the frenetic heights attained on previous social issues. It is extremely important that the Irish people who will have to live with the consequences of the decision should fully participate in that decision and fully understand the consequences of their vote. Those of us who are seeking change believe it is change for the better, modest yet realistic change for the betterment of our country. I genuinely believe that the time has come to give the people who have suffered a second chance to make it come right.

Comment on this

I am very happy to take part in the debate. Except for a few statements in recent weeks and days, the debate has, as has been asked by all parties and certainly by my party, been calm and cool. In this House we do not normally play politics. I do not intend to do so here.

As a member of the all-party committee I want to put on record, because I have not had the chance to do so before, my sincere thanks to that committee and one of the members, Senator Catherine McGuinness, who played a greater role in it than I did. Even though there were different versions of what we did and what the end result was, we did a service to the nation.

I may have got older and wiser in public life, so I understand the views on the two sides of this delicate debate. There are two sides to it. I am not too sure which side is right but I am quite clear in my own mind as to what side I am on. It is wrong to say that people like myself, who do not take the same view as some Government Senators, should be accused of being under the threat of any group of bishops or their croziers. Senator Magner's remarks, made so generally in that context were most unfair.

The values involved for us as a nation and the salvation of marriage and the family are worth almost any effort. If only those who over the past few years have been putting so much work and effort into the advocacy of divorce in Ireland could have been persuaded to put even half of that effort into the campaign to correct the real causes of marital breakdown I am quite clear in my mind that they would have made a far greater contribution to this country's future.

I do not think there is such a thing as a perfect marriage. There are ups and downs, and we have all had them. It would be foolish if it were not put on the record of the House that there will be problems. My deep worry is that if this legislation goes through people, who will be here long after I have gone from public life, may not work quite as hard as I did to make marriage work. I have as much knowledge as anybody else of the amount of work it takes. I worked in public life for the past 35 years side by side with my husband, Derry. I have a family, and I have listened with great care since this debate started this morning.

Will all the social problems of the nation be solved? Will all the marital problems be cured if the majority vote "yes" in the referendum? How many of the recommendations of the marital breakdown committee have been implemented to date by the Government? Divorce legislation is giving the right to remarry and people have said — I am not too clear about this but I am sure the Minister will answer some of the questions I ask — that one can remarry once, twice. How many times can one get a divorce in a lifetime? Where will it eventually lead to?

People who talk about the children and all the sadness this legislation will bring would want to be clear in their minds that this legislation, if and when it goes through, will correct all the sadness. Tremendous emphasis is being put on the children. I totally accept that. I want to put it on record that I accept every Senator's viewpoint. Perhaps years ago I was not as open to other people's views but serving has thought me a lot of hard lessons. I would ask people to accept my viewpoint and reservations.

Our neutral role has been referred to. If our leader makes a statement, whichever side it is on — and he is not allowed, it seems, to have his own private views — or if he gives a directive to his party, which he is quite entitled to do, it is dictatorship but, if the Tánaiste of the Labour Party or An Taoiseach, Garret FitzGerald, give the same kind of advice or directive to their parties, it is advice. I do not understand why it is "advice" when it is Taoiseach FitzGerald and Tánaiste Spring, and "dictatorship" when it is Charlie Haughey.

It should be remembered that divorce is not the remedy for marital breakdown. In my view, far from being a remedy it will serve to undermine not alone the institution of marriage but the family itself. Much emphasis has been put on the family, and rightly so. It may be noticed that I have deliberately refrained from referring to any Christian values because I believe, despite my convictions, religion should be kept in the background in a debate in Parliament. I made reference to the bishops only because of Senator Magner's remark that we, on this side of the House, were being beaten into line by croziers. I put it on the record of the House that this is unfair. Most Senators on the Government side refrained from that kind of remark.

The most recent announcement regarding the establishment of conciliation services is a case in point. It is too late and the officials to be appointed to the service are to be of a rather junior rank which, I understand, is an unprecedented low level in this State. To me, this sums up the Government's intention in this regard. I refer to the persons who are supposed to be appointed. Their rank is junior rank. I do not understand why persons of that status should be appointed by the Government.

People have the right to know the factual extent of marriage breakdown. I ask why did the Government rush through the Bill before awaiting the results of the census which for the first time had questions regarding marriage breakdown. When I filled up the form I felt that was a delicate question. One handed that open form back to a person at the door. It did not make any difference to me, but it would have made a difference to some people. It would have been better if the results of that census were known before the Government moved on this Bill.

Another example which calls the Government's intention into question is that the wording of the Bill does not mention legal separation as a precondition to divorce whereas the statement of intent is at great pains to say that this will be included in the divorce legislation which is to follow if the referendum is carried. Why not write "legal separation" into the constitutional amendment? The way it is, it is the Houses of the Oireachtas that can change it at any time. Write it into the Constitution and only the people can change it, and rightly so.

We have heard about a united Ireland and that if we vote this through, the following week the Prime Minister, Mrs. Thatcher, will give this nation unity. I have strong views on a united Ireland, but I do not understand how people in public office can make a statement that if we allow divorce down here we are going to have a united Ireland. That is not so. Senator McGuinness will be speaking tomorrow, and might not like me saying this but I have very strong views on a united Ireland. I do not think that granting divorce here will make one whit of difference to a united Ireland.

There is still confusion about Fianna Fáil's line. Let me reiterate the Fianna Fáil position which was fully and clearly outlined in our first statement on this matter when we learned of the Government's intention to bring forward this referendum. We stated that having carefully considered all aspects and implications of this proposal and, in particular, its profound effect on the position of families and the nature and quality of our society, and having also regard to many different but sincerely held views in the community on this issue, we had decided that the question should be left to the people as a whole to decide. We decided that we would not oppose, in the Dáil or Seanad, the proposal to hold a referendum. It was said here that one Senator was confused about our neutral stand. There was no plan by the Senators on this side of the House to come in, one after the other and speak one way while the Government seemed to speak the other way. If I felt differently from what I am saying I would say it, because we were given the freedom to take whatever stand we liked. Getting back to my earlier remarks about how Fianna Fáil stand on policy, I saw nobody giving wide coverage to the fact that we were free to have our own views on it.

The five-year period worries me. It states that after a five-year separation divorce will be granted. I listened with deep concern to Senator Eoin Ryan this morning whose opinion I value on a lot of things. He has been a friend of my family and of my husband, Derry, for many years and I value his opinion. He is a lawyer of distinction. When I heard him confused about when the five-year period starts, and how many "five years" can there be, and how many marriages, it worries me. The Minister of State in her speech said:

...will have to be in place for at least two years before a divorce can be sought...

She said "at least two years".

Comment on this

After legal separation.

Comment on this

After legal separation.

...will have to prove that they have been separated for five years.

I saw the words "at least two years" and I noted them. I am wondering when the five year period starts. If I have worries this is the place to voice them and, no doubt, the Minister will clear them for me.

Senator Eoin Ryan said he was not clear about the legal state regarding the legislation. I have a holy horror that the legal people are going to clean up with this legislation when it is passed. The cleaning-up will take place in the early years, if all the sadness we hear about is there. There will be a certain section of the people who will not be able to afford the type of legal back-up they will need. When we hear about possible discrimination between groups A or B, I worry that, if enacted, this legislation might only be for the well-off in our society.

Many Senators including myself, were confused here today about where the first or second family stand in relation to who will get what when this break-up takes place and when the divorce comes through. The Minister stated:

If she loses the benefit of a dwelling-house the Court will require the payment of a sufficient sum to compensate. Alternatively the Courts may require, having regard to her circumstances and those of the children, that the house be transferred to her as part of the adequate and proper provision referred to in the constitutional amendment. She will have those rights not merely as statutory rights but also as a constitutional right.

I was talking earlier today to a lawyer who understands this legislation. There will be a whole circle of courts and advice centres. We are talking here again about property, but there will be the people who have not got property. How many men in this country can afford, financially, to finance two families? These are the questions which will have to be asked.

Reference was made today to the Succession Act. Remarks were passed about the Succession Act by a certain Deputy in the Dáil, which implied that Fianna Fáil only seemed to be interested in the Succession Act of the sixties and in who would get what when all of this was dealt with. I remember the Succession Act going through this House. My husband Derry, was a Front Bench Senator at the time. Deputy Brian Lenihan was Minister put that Act through. That Succession Act went through at the time because of the sadness of cases down the country and, indeed, all over the country where mothers found themselves ending up in hospitals when property was handed over to a son or daughter. Senators from rural Ireland will understand why that Succession Act at that time was probably one of the best pieces of legislation that went through the Houses of the Oireachtas. It was absolutely necessary. What was unfortunate about the remarks of the Deputy who said that Fianna Fáil's interest seemed to be only in the Succession Act was that the those of us who remember how important the Succession Act was to people at the time can see property rights recurring here again. Property rights, would need to be quite clear in legislation.

I am confused as to how many families equal a family under Article 41 of the Constitution, if this amendment is carried. Nobody has asked that question. I am sure Minister Dukes has the answer.

I have referred to the Church of which I am a member and I am not going to refer to it again. I am a practising Catholic, but that has no bearing at all on my deep worry in regard to this legislation. If I thought that divorce was going to solve all the problems of families of broken marriages and of children of first and second marriages I would have no trouble at all in supporting it, but I do not think that it will solve these problems. I would hope that some of the values that were handed down to me can be handed on to my grandchildren. I am not being old-fashioned or antiquated. I just feel strongly that my grandchild, Jennifer, when she grows up should have some of the values that have stood me in good stead through many a though battle.

The last thing I want is advice from a Deputy like Deputy Michael O'Leary who has not even the guts to go along and marry once and then he comes along and he advises us on what we should do.

Comment on this

It would be better that the Senator would not refer to Deputies personally or to Members of the other House.

Comment on this

Thank you. He will understand it anyway. I have seen families with step-fathers and stepmothers. Some of them — but very few of them — have worked out. I have a deep concern here for the children of the first marriage. If it breaks up we hear about all the sadness and we hear that the second marriage will solve it. Very close to me I witnessed a stepmother and if that situation is going to be foisted on several families I think it is a step backwards.

Dr. Jack Dominian impressed me very much in an oral submission to the Committee on Marital Breakdown on 8 February 1984. He gave figures which should be put on the record in this debate. He said:

Since I am most familiar with the figures for Britain I can tell you that before the war there were about 10,000 divorces a year in Britain. After the war, there was a peak of 48,000 because of the anomalies of the war state. Those figures dropped to about 25,000 in the fifties and then they began to rise in about 1959-1960. They have risen ever since, with a big jump in 1971 after the new Divorce Act. Currently, from 25,000 per year in the fifties they are running at the rate of 150,000 per year. If you take men, women and children under 16 there are something like 500,000 men, women and children involved in divorce. Looking at the figures for the whole of western society something similar can be seen in almost every country. In America, the figures are very similar. One in two marriages are breaking down. In Britain it is about one in three.

You may well ask why is this happening? Why is there this great increase in marital breakdown in the whole of western society? Nobody is prepared to be unequivocal about the answers, but there is no doubt at all that during this period of time certain social factors have occurred. These are largely to do with the status of women. The emancipation of women has coincided with this period, the large increase in the number of women working has coincided, so that they do not have to stay in a household in a marriage in which they are not happy and there has been a large-scale increase in birth control and the reduction in family size. By and large it is women who are dissatisfied with their marriages. Seven out of ten petitions in Britain are filed by women. Lawyers say that this is not really for technical legal reasons. But in my clinical experience this is not the case. It is women who are displeased with the marital situation.

I have included these figures because they are frightening. Can the Minister tell us what role the present Attorney General will have if this amendment is passed. If there is a balance on both sides by those who draw up the legislation, if this amendment is passed, I would be quite happy to accept the results. People are the best judges in the end. I have seen people in similar situations and I worry about what slant the present Attorney General might put on things.

Comment on this

That is unfair to the man. He is not here to defend himself.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It would be better if names were not mentioned.

Comment on this

It was said here today that people are standing up and talking but not saying what side they are on. There are no thanks due to me for being big enough to allow everybody to have their opinion but in fairness, I am also entitled to mine. If I had made this speech five or six years ago people would say: "Tras is taking the party line". I have said what I have said, in the calm coolness of the few of us that are left here after a long day, because I feel strongly about it. If this legislation is ratified I do not think people will work as hard at marriage as people did when there was no divorce.

People today want everything soft. It is not meant to be an easy world. It is not because life was difficult for me that I take this stand but because I hope when I leave public life I will have left some standard and level of discipline for generations to come. To make a successful, good and happy marriage and it may not always be happy, one has to work at it and discipline oneself.

I am happy to have participated in this debate, I will be voting against the amendment. I have no trouble in saying what I will be doing. It is a pity the freedom which has been given to Fianna Fáil in this referendum has not been recognised more. It is sad when people decide to say they have no stand because they took a neutral stand.

If I upset my colleague from South Tipperary by my reference to the Attorney General, I apologise. I hope it will be a fair debate right to the end and let the people decide. I will accept, in total, the result.

Comment on this

Dá mbeadh gach rud mar ba chóir an domhan seo, ní bheadh gá ar bith leis an Reifrean seo. Ach ní mar sin atá an scéal agus tá pósanna i gcruachás. Tá rogha againn — deileáil leis an bhfadhb nó é a ligint tharainn. Is é mo thuairim go mba chóir dúinn déileáil leis. Tá áthas orm go bhfuil seans ag na daoine a dtuairimí a nochtadh agus tá súil agam go mbeidh síocháin ann nuair a bheidh gach rud thart.

I spoke on the Order of Business today when there was some dispute —quite a bit of agro over the fact that we were sitting until midnight. I made the intervention because in the Seanad there is no time limit on the length of contributions on Second Stage. I made the appeal that perhaps we should go for quality rather than quantity in our contributions here tonight.

As usual, I will be brief. I made up my mind that I was not going to get into any argument or comment that was made by anybody else. I have sat here for most of the day and have heard many useful contributions. Senator Honan has asked if divorce will solve all our social ills. The answer is it will not. It cannot solve all our social ills nor will it solve all our marriage ills. The question is, will it help marriage problems? I hope it will, Senator Honan also asked if it is only for the rich. There are many legal people here who can answer that better than I can. In part 2 of the Bill it says:

Where, and only where, such court established under this Constitution as may be prescribed by law is satisfied that — (i) a marriage has failed, the court may in accordance with law grant a dissolution of the marriage provided that the court is satisfied that adequate and proper provision having regard to the circumstances will be made for any dependent spouse and for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse.

That clearly says that if a person can not afford to look after one family they are not going to get the opportunity of trying to look after another one.

I want to take up the question of comparing Ireland to other countries. It is very difficult for us to pick any country and make a comparison with it because we have a different ethos and Christian outlook here. For the vast majority of people in Ireland marriage is very sacred and it is almost impossible to find a country with which we could make any valid comparison.

I welcome the Government's decision to put this referendum before the people.

It is time we faced up to this difficult issue. For my own part, I would like to see every marriage a happy and lifelong one but the reality, of course, is that some marriages are neither happy nor lifelong. While I, as a member of the Roman Catholic Church, accept that divorce, for me, is not allowed, I can not accept the argument that I, as a Catholic legislator, should impose my religious beliefs on anybody else. I disagree completely with the suggestion that, if divorce is introduced, every marriage is under threat. If I accept that claim I have to admit (1) that either every marriage is only a veneer or (2) that religion is a complete sham in Ireland. I admit neither of those.

I was glad to find that Dr. Jack Dominian, from whom Senator Honan quoted also, when giving evidence to the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown supported my assertion that the introduction of divorce would not put every marriage under threat. He said:

I have to say that if this room was filled by the Roman Catholic Bishops of Ireland and they were pushing me very hard about divorce, I would have to say, very clearly, that their fear that civil divorce would make marital breakdown worse or enhance it or facilitate it, my answer would have to be "No", it will make very little difference.

He gave that answer when he was asked for his view on the effect on marriages in Ireland if divorce was introduced. I know there may be quotations by other people which would prove differently, but he is an expert on this subject. I reject too the suggestion that our religious beliefs must be strengthened by the civil law. If we have Christian standards we should stand by them; if we have not we should not blame the civil law for our failures.

A happy marriage is a blessing that we often take for granted, but anyone who is not lucky enough to enjoy that state can live in misery. How are children affected in an atmosphere of rancour and even violence? How will those children be affected if divorce gives a break from this unhappy atmosphere? I find it hard to give a definite answer but from my own limited experience, I think children living in a violent atmosphere suffer in both long and short term.

Decrees of nullity are taken for granted by us, even though they too break up a marriage and family. Sometimes one partner is very upset but because the Church does it, it is all right. If those who get a decree of nullity marry again their future children are illegitimate. Surely we cannot allow this to continue if we have Christian values, nor should we allow the children of the first marriage, now annulled, to be classed as illegitimate. Protecting marriage partners is important — protecting children is much more important. Can there be anything more absurd than having a child registered under a father's name who clearly is not the father; yet that is what happens where new relationships take place. I know one can argue over the treatment children get where divorce takes place but I find it is very difficult to know whether they are worse off in the relationship that has broken up rather than in one that appears to be together and where they see nothing but unhappiness and maybe cruelty.

I welcome the raising of the marriage age to 18. If I had my way I would raise it to 21. Maturity is needed in a hurry in marriage and pre-marriage courses will do a lot to prevent marriage breakdowns but like the brook life goes on. I find it very hard to think that young people of today are less romantic, or foolish, than those of generations past. Senator Honan mentioned a few times how people had to work at marriages in the past, etc. They will enter marriage full of dreams of living happily ever after and, as in the past, many of those dreams will be fulfilled and some will be shattered. We are living in different times and different social conditions and with or without the introduction of divorce people will have problems in their marriages, but we cannot blame divorce if their marriages are unhappy just as marriages in the past have been unhappy.

For those who are happily married the question of divorce is academic and religious. It is easy to say we had to "work at it" but one could work all day making a hurley out of a blackthorn stick and fail miserably. So, too, partners can fail even after trying hard to make a go of marriage. Some marriages are not just unhappy; they are a form of cruelty. If the partners feel that divorce is their solution to the problem then I cannot prevent them from having that facility simply because I do not accept that divorce is permissible. For that reason I will be voting yes in the referendum to allow people the choice of divorce, if they so desire.

In conclusion, I wish to say that the Taoiseach has been more than forthright in his presentation of the facts. He has stated them openly and shown a wonderful level of tolerance, both inside his own party and towards those who hold a completely different line from him. It would be nice to think that his example and his plea for tolerance would be followed by everybody taking part in this debate, especially by those who hold extreme views, either for or against divorce, and that might apply more outside the House than inside it. Intolerant dogmatism helps nobody and Christian charity goes a long way in dealing with those who hold different views from us.

Comment on this

With Deputy Seán Barrett, Minister with responsibility for Sport in the House I must confess that I would be much more at home talking about some aspect of his responsibility such as athletics or basketball, or perhaps I could refer to the siting of the National Sports Centre. I believe that Athlone is the natural centre for the National Sports Centre and I would need no notes to speak on that subject.

We are talking about a much more important matter which is vital to the whole nation because on 26 June the Irish people will be called on to vote on an issue that will have major consequences for the present generation and for generations to come. The legislation is being rushed through both Houses of the Oireachtas as if it were in some way a crisis or major emergency legislation. We are sitting tonight until 12 midnight, tomorrow night until the same time and sitting on Saturday. About 12 months ago this House sat until 4 a.m. or 5 a.m. to deal with the Family Planning Bill. It seems that this Government see legislation as urgent and necessary for these priorities which are very much at variance with the urgent problems on the ground such as mass unemployment, punitive taxation, the crisis in agriculture and so on. This legislation does not warrant the emergency status it is getting.

The law as it stands regarding both annulment and divorce, that is divorce a mensa et toro— are based on the definition of a valid marriage as being life long. Divorce a mensa et toro allows a married couple to separate but neither separated partner can validly marry again while the other partner is still alive. The referendum next month will ask the people if they want to change that position. Do the people want to legally redefine marriage so that a valid marriage is no longer in law a life long one?

If the referendum is passed it will bring to an end the legal concept of a permanent marriage and of a permanent family home. It would be no more than a temporary arrangement that is at the mercy of one partner. If divorce is allowed, from day one, an element of defeatism enters the marriage scene. This will act firmly against the success of each and every marriage. How can we have in the future happy and secure families when the threat of divorce hangs over the head of one or other partner? It will no longer be a case of whether one wants to keep their marriage until death because their partners will, in law, have the right to seek an absolute end to it.

Experience in other countries has shown that once divorce legislation is introduced there is an increase in marriage breakdown. For example, in Northern Ireland in 1970 one in 40 marriages ended in divorce, five years later this figure had jumped to one in 26 and in 1983 it was one in 25. At present 70 per cent of divorces in Northern Ireland are granted on the basis of separation. The required period of separation is gradually being shortened so that in many European countries divorce is available after one year's separation. Divorce legislation in Britain was introduced on the basis of fault, such as cruelty, desertion or adultery. Now this is not the case. Two out of every five marriages end in divorce. In the United States one in every two marriages ends in divorce.

Divorce breeds divorce. It is disastrous for family life, for women and for children. In the United States the standard of living after divorce for ex-husbands increased by 42 per cent; the standard of living for women and children fell by 73 per cent.

The question of children is all-important in this debate. If a couple have problems, such as one or both partners being violent towards one another, what can divorce solve in this instance? If they remarry they carry their problem of being violent — or whatever it may be — with them into their next marriage. In the United States, surveys have shown that there is a clear parallel between this and a multiple divorce situation. The real suffering is inflicted on the children in such relationships as they inherit the harmful attitudes and selfish motives of the parents instead of the sound values that would be picked up from a stable marriage. In a sound marriage situation we are always making decisions about what is good for relationships. By growing in maturity we often have to change ourselves and to discard our selfish attitudes. Compare this with a divorce situation where through immaturity, the couple merely act on their feelings and in a stress situation cop-out as if they were not mature enough to see that their loneliness or delusion, or whatever it may be, is as a result of a lack of commitment to each other. If that couple get divorced then their children inherit these bad values and are themselves affected.

There have always been broken marriages in Ireland. Twenty years ago they were not talked about because, like many other Irish problems people hoped that by not talking about them, they would go away. Today the situation is different. It is good to talk about problems and to look for ways in our society to alleviate them. The crux of the matter in this instance is that suddenly we are in a panic and instead of being constructive, we have divorce as the magic answer foisted under our noses.

It has been said, and it is true, that one has to work at marriage. I have known many couples who have had problems in the past such as drink problems but they worked at their marriages. They would freely admit that had divorce been available it would have been the soft option and they might have gone down that road.

The role of the priest in this debate is important. I recall the missions we had in many parishes around the country when I was growing up, 20 or 25 years of age. The priests, whether they were Jesuits, Redemptorists, or whatever voiced fire and brimstone from the pulpits on matters of faith and morals. Happily this has changed. We now have a calmer, more relaxed and more teaching approach to these problems by the clergy.

We are told by the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown that 6 per cent of marriages are in difficulty. This is a minority grouping. Ninety-four per cent, therefore, of marriages we can assume are happy and successful ones. A new feature of Irish life in recent times is the advent of pressure-minority groupings. I am not talking about minority religions. The small number of people involved in any cause who do not share the popular or majority opinion come together as a minority-pressure group. It is strange that offending the minority syndrome is now regarded as being more of a crime than say, rape, robbery or any other serious crime. We are expected to remain silent and to permit everything so that these people can have their rights.

Many politicians have gone soft in this area. Many of our priests are gone soft on matters like this where they have a role to play. In this case, there is a need for priests to speak out boldly and clearly in defence of the family. It is their duty to teach God's law on this vital matter. Doing this, I must stress, does not and should not mean insulting people with an opposite view, nor does it mean forcing any doctrine on anyone because to do so, we all agree, would be a violation of freedom. It is the duty of our clergy to spell out the rights and wrongs of the argument, the seriousness of this problem for future generations as they see it and know it.

The cost of divorce has been referred to. I certainly cannot understand the reason for the silence from the Government as to the cost of proposals on divorce. Clearly, there are going to be huge implications for the Irish taxpayer. According to the records we have in the US, 85 per cent of men who are divorced do not pay alimony to their former wives and those women must fend for themselves. The making of divorce readily available to couples who have been living apart for five years or more will accelerate the present trends towards marriage breakdown. This, in turn, will increase the number in receipt of deserted wife's allowances and unmarried mother's allowances. The proposed amendment to Article 41 of the Constitution provides that a court may grant a dissolution of marriage if it is satisfied that certain specific conditions are met. The court must be satisfied that adequate and proper provision, having regard to the circumstances, will be made for any dependent spouse and for any child who is dependant on either spouse.

This provision will place the court in an impossible position if the person concerned is unemployed and in receipt of social welfare unemployment benefit or if the person concerned is on a very low wage. How can the court be satisfied in the case of a person who is unemployed or a person who is on low wages and where a wife has no separate income that adequate provision can be made for his spouse or his dependent children when he remarries? The court order is one thing, but can it be observed? I do not think it can in such cases. It would be unrealistic to expect a divorced husband to continue to give adequate support to his former wife and children if he is supporting a new wife and family.

It seems inevitable that, within a very short period of time, the State will have to support many divorced spouses and children as is the case in many other countries. Our social welfare budget will increase dramatically. At a time when other Government services and agencies are being curtailed, it is reasonable to ask how the Government can justify this extra expenditure. The question of pension rights is worth mentioning. If a divorced husband is in a pensionable position, on his death his second wife will avail of the pension because she is the dependent spouse. The same will apply in the case of a husband who is in receipt of a social welfare benefit because the second wife will be the dependent spouse according to the constitutional amendment.

The Minister for Justice, Deputy Dukes, in his speech in the Dáil on Second Stage made the point that as regards the spouses, it will, of course, be a consequence of divorce that a person who has ceased to be married to another by reason of the dissolution of the marriage, would not be regarded as the widow or widower of the other for the purpose of succession when that other person dies and would lose rights as a result.

It seems to me arising from that that the divorced wife will lose all her rights of her succession. She will no longer be his spouse for the purpose of the Succession Act, 1965. There are many conflicting opinions on this. Different opinions have been put forward by eminent legal people on this issue.

If the eminent legal people disagree on this, how is the ordinary person in the street to decide? The same applies to the clause in the Bill that states that the marriage has failed. There is a great deal of confusion on this matter even among those people who support divorce. What exactly does "failed" mean? Is a "failed" marriage one that has not been consummated? If a husband and wife with a small family are separated for 51 weeks of the year but come together at Christmas will that be classified a "failed" marriage? If there is no family of the union can it be said that it is a "failed" marriage? This has not been satisfactorily clarified. It has even been mentioned that the people who will decide this issue have different opinions on this matter.

If the referendum is defeated will all these extra helps for marriages that are not stable be provided? I am referring to the courts, the age for getting married, conciliation and mediation. Will the nullity laws be updated? Many questions have to be answered. Passing the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution will mean that every marriage commitment will be weakened. I fully accept that there are many difficult, sad and cruel cases. Many people will find it difficult to decide which way to vote in the public good.

We are dealing with a very important matter. There are many sad cases and many marriages that have broken down irretrievably. I would love dearly if some way other than divorce could lead them to a happier life but I firmly believe that divorce will bring far more injustices and hardships. I would love dearly to find some arrangement which would not have such devastating consequences for society and the stability of marriage and family members. It would be my observation, having considered all of these important factors, that divorce brings with it more harm than good. I believe it would have a devastating effect on the constitutional rights and the protection of every married family in this State.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before I call Senator McGonagle, the Minister wants to intervene.

Comment on this
Alan M. Dukes Minister for Justice (Mr. Dukes) Fine Gael

Thank you for allowing me to speak. I do not intend to intervene in the debate but I understand that this morning at the opening of the debate and at one or two points during the day Members of the House indicated that they had felt I was discourteous to the House in not being here this morning to introduce the debate. I can understand their feeling. The reason I was not here to introduce the debate was that I was addressing the annual conference of the Prison Officers' Association in Mullingar, a commitment that pre-dates the publication of this Bill and the timing of the debate. I apologise.

Comment on this

It happened last week with somebody else.

Comment on this

It happened last week with somebody else who was addressing the annual conference of the Prison Officers' Association. I apologise to the House for that. Looking back over the history of the last couple of years, the House might be disposed to forgive me for not being present here this morning.

Comment on this

All is forgiven.

Comment on this

I do not intend to spend a great deal of the time of the House in addressing this subject because so many words have been spoken and written about it that the Irish people must now be well informed. It brings me back to a social study conference I was addressing — some of the colleges in Galway — where there was a mixed audience of clergy and lay people of all the Churches in Ireland. I remember very clearly pointing out that the reason I was against this Article in the Constitution, which apparently gives special consideration and position to the Catholic Church in Ireland, was that as its nature was sectarian it should be deleted from the Constitution — I am talking about the sixties.

I felt that Article would have to go eventually because of the sectarian character of the denial of access to divorce legislation, a denial that reduced the kind of civil liberty and human rights that all the children of the nation should be cherished equally and so on.

I am very privileged and I feel very gratified to be standing here when the death knell is being sounded of the denial of access to divorce legislation for those who want divorce. It is not for me to tell others my moral plan that to divorce one's partner is a mortal sin and an obscenity. I am not their judge. That is a matter for them and their conscience. The Irish people ought to be complimented that out of the struggle for independence over a short time — 70 years is a short time in the life of any nation — the elements of liberal democracy are there. We are and have been proceeding to a more open, democratic society and the good fruits will eventually appear.

I referred to the idea of nobody having a right to tell a wife she should not divorce her husband or a husband he should not divorce his wife. I am reminded of the Islamic fundamentalists, especially in Iran and some parts of the Sudan, who have no inhibitions about imposing part of their religious code on people who do not want it — even Christians. That, I am afraid, is the position as long as the denial of access to divorce legislation exists. That is an imposed sectarian situation which no liberal democrat or socialist could accept and that is the basic reason why the Labour movement and especially the Labour Party and I feel gratified that, in fact, this necessary reform is coming in. I trust it will be successful.

The purpose of the Bill is to enable the people of Ireland to decide on whether the constitutional prohibition on the enactment of divorce legislation should be removed. A grave responsibility rests on the Government, politicians, leaders of public opinion, the media and the clerical spokesmen of the various Churches to present a fair and accurate picture so that the people are reasonably well informed on the matter.

I intend to keep to the broad brush approach. I should not make the mistake of going into the details of the proposed divorce legislation, although the type of legislation must be known to the people. I am intrigued by some speakers who obviously are sincerely against divorce but who at the same time, draw attention to where the divorce legislation could be perfected. That is inconsistent. One cannot say, on the one hand, "I am against divorce for the following sincere reasons" and then go on to try to have the legislation perfected. One cannot do those two things at the same time.

I want again to compliment all the speakers up to the moment for a dignified, calm, unemotional approach to this very sensitive and delicate problem that we have and which is on the increase. Irretrievable breakdown in a marriage is a serious thing. On a matter of such sensitivity and delicacy, it is only right and proper to ask that public debate and discussion be carried out in a civilised and intelligent manner and that is being done.

False claims and exaggerated posturing should be avoided in the interest of all concerned, more especially in the interest of those people directly affected by the denial of access to divorce legislation, those unhappy people. The whole question should be approached in a compassionate and caring way and whatever way the Irish people decide, for or against, should be accepted with good grace.

It is an unfortunate fact of life that marital breakdown is on the increase in Irish society. Quite clearly, the effects of marriage failure on the affected partners and the children cannot be ignored by serious legislators. That is the crux of the problem. Legislators cannot ignore the interests of the children, say, of a second union as long as there is no divorce legislation. That is precisely why the Government have acted. The decision to introduce divorce legislation and to inform the people of the type of such legislation is a display of maturity and responsibility in accepting this twentieth century Irish nation. By that I mean the Government have undoubtedly faced the problem honestly and fairly in the interests of the common good.

I compliment the Government on the way they have conducted this whole affair. Consultation with the groups and people concerned — including the various Churches — was undertaken to obtain a clear understanding of the issues and the interests involved, but no one can claim, therefore, that their viewpoint was not heard. Nevertheless there are for and against stances on the matter. The Irish people, of course, will have the final say, the final democratic say in the proposed referendum on the constitutional amendment. When the Irish citizens vote, there certainly cannot be complaints about lack of information. The problem is to sift the chaff from the wheat. There will be proper information and sometimes misinformation and a little bit of bending the truth for political purposes. This divorce issue should not be made a political football. I am glad that it has not taken that appearance up to the moment.

The people will have received by then thousands of words of advice, spoken and written. I trust that the decision in favour of the introduction of divorce legislation will truly reflect the maturity and the wisdom of the Irish people. I am fully convinced that the question or access to divorce legislation is one that is best answered by simply saying that it is a human right. It is a question, is it not, of civil liberty as well? I am aware that the European Court of Human Rights people have decided that it does not fall within that definition. Frankly, I cannot understand this decision. The question of availing of divorce is primarily a matter for the individual or the individuals concerned. After that comes the responsibility of the legislators to see to it that the hurtful consequences for family life are reduced, if not eliminated.

The matters of succession rights are considered and the care of any children of the marriages are properly enshrined in law. That is the responsibility of legislators in any country. Initially divorce is a human problem, a matter of conscience.

The denial of access to an escape route from the unhappy environment is a denial of human rights.

Reference has been made from time to time in relation to legislation and other changes proposed in the Republic as to the effect on the people of Northern Ireland, expecially the Unionist people. Let me say quite clearly that it is a good and healthy exercise to democratise all our actions on the only proper basis — fair play and justice. It follows that every endeavour should be made to harmonise our legislation and democratic advances with those in Northern Ireland, but this qualification is necessary: harmonisation, good in itself, calls for action on both sides. The action has to be seen and the movement and full democratic dress be discernible. Having said that, I am not unduly concerned that one of the sides seem to require some assistance to progressive movement. That is the Northern Ireland side. Given time, patience and goodwill, the Northern Ireland people will move in the right direction.

On the matter under discussion, divorce, I would ask the people in the Republic to note that the Northern Ireland people have had access to divorce for many years. I have not seen any evidence of the awful calamities that some people are predicting if we have divorce in the Republic. I have not observed serious breakdown in morality or in family disorder or any other unhappy features related to divorce. Nor is divorce talked about very much in the North. Any talk I have heard about divorce arises our of the present debate in the Republic.

It is argued, and points of view are expressed from time to time, that when we are bringing in legislation, we should be careful, first, not to offend the people of the North and, secondly, to take away anything that will appear to be offensive. That is not good enough for me. Any legislation that is brought into the Republic must be good in itself. It is a secondary consideration that it might appear to be good to the people of Northern Ireland, but that does not make it a primary consideration. Of course, if divorce comes in in the Republic, that will be a good thing. It will be nearer harmonisation, but it is not to be taken that that is why we are doing it. It will help the situation. There is no doubt that, but we are bringing it in because it satisfies the common good and is socially required and necessary. I want to reiterate that. I have said this before. You cannot have a situation where the Northern Ireland people stay back and say, "when you perfect the State down there we will join you." My reply to that attitude is, "come in and help us to make it perfect. Come in and help us in an Irish Parliament to make a perfect state in the Republic or in a united Ireland or whatever new form this island is to take." That is the realism of the situation.

It is suggested from time to time that it would be good to have divorce in the Republic because as long as we do not have divorce legislation there is a major obstacle to some form of eventual unity and understanding. That is fair enough. It would be rather anomalous for the Ireland of the future to have divorce in the North, which has not upset life there, and not to have it in the Republic. It would be rather queer to say the least of it.

It is a simplistic approach, of course, but I think I have dealt sufficiently with that, under that kind of examination. Clearly, I would say that the closer we get to a position where there are fewer and fewer areas where the Northern Unionists can point to unacceptable elements in our society in the Republic the better, because we will be moving nearer to the identification of the remaining obstacles to unity and understanding. It may well be that the Northern attitude could be, "we do not care how perfect your society is, we are still not joining you". They will probably say that. They have said it. What we do here must be on the basis that it is the right thing to do. That will stand on its own merits and if it is good and we can bring about a situation in the Republic of liberal democracy, fair play and justice, eventually there will be understanding and unity on this island. As a whole. However, that must remain a matter of secondary consideration. The primary objective must and should remain the common good. It is socially necessary to have and bring about conditions of decent civilised living in the Republic of Ireland.

In the interest of the people who desperately need access to divorce legislation and in the interest of harmonisation of our legislation North and South, I commend this Bill and congratulate the Government on it.

Comment on this

Most people will accept that there are very few marriages in this country which do not experience difficulties at some time. In the vast majority of cases these difficulties are overcome and the marriages in question could, for the most part, be regarded as extremely happy and successful. Unfortunately, however, in some cases the difficulties continue, the problems increase and, eventually, the marriage breaks down. We are told that the incidence of marital breakdown is increasing. It seems to be generally agreed that this is so. The exact number of marriages which have broken down is, however, a matter which is hotly disputed. Some of the figures which have been mentioned during the course of this debate are, I feel, greatly exaggerated. The Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown referred to the unavailability of comprehensive and detailed statistics on marriage breakdown in Ireland. In their report at chapter 6, page 31 they state:

The committee has been unable to have access to any source which can delineate objectively the total number of persons whose marriages have broken down.

They went on to state that:

The committee is of the opinion that any future census should seek to ascertain precisely the incidence of marriage breakdown as manifested by separation or desertion.

This recommendation has been implemented in the recent census. We are told that the purpose of the amendment of Article 41 of the Constitution and of the legislation proposed by the Government is to tackle the problem of marriage breakdown. However, while we know that the problem exists we do not know the extent of it. Therefore, in my view, it would have made sense to wait until the exact extent of the problem was quantified before considering how it might be remedied. In introducing this measure at this time the Government were motivated to some extent at least by political considerations. The Bill to amend the Constitution is now before the House and we must consider very carefully all its implications and aspects.

It is proposed to delete from the Constitution section 3.2º of Article 41 which reads as follows:

No law shall be enacted providing for the grant of a dissolution of marriage.

It is proposed to replace the deleted subsection with a new subsection 2º which will read:

Where, and only where, such court established under this Constitution as may be prescribed by law is satisfied that —

(i) a marriage has failed,

(ii) the failure has continued for a period of, or periods amounting to, at least five years,

(iii) there is no reasonable possibility of reconciliation between the parties to the marriage, and

(iv) any other conditions prescribed by law has been complied with, the court may in accordance with law grant a dissolution of the marriage provided that the court is satisfied that adequate and proper provision having regard to the circumstances will be made for any dependent spouse and for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse.

Simultaneously with the publication of this proposed new subsection which is contained in the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1986 the Government also published a statement entitled "Statement on Government's Intentions with Regard to Marriage, Separation and Divorce". Sections 2 and 3 of that statement read as follows:

2. The purpose of this Statement is to describe in broad terms the type of divorce legislation which the Government would submit for the consideration of the Oireachtas if the proposal being put in the Referendum is approved by the people. That legislation will be designed to ensure that divorce will be available only in limited circumstances where a Court is satisfied that the marriage has failed and that the failure has continued for a period or periods of not less than five years, and that adequate and proper provision, having regard to the circumstances, will be made for a dependent spouse and for any dependent child of either party to the marriage.

3. The statement also sets out proposed changes in the arrangements for marriage and for judicial separation that will accompany the legislation mentioned in the previous paragraph.

The statement then goes on to detail various proposals for change in relation to such matters as judicial separation, the establishment of family courts and the making of financial orders. There is then a section dealing with the form of divorce legislation which the Government are contemplating if the amendment is carried. The document then outlines further proposals relating to the raising of the minimum age of marriage, the introduction of a minimum period of notice for marriage and changes in the law of nullity. It is not, however, pointed out that all these proposals for change with the exception of the divorce proposal could be implemented without any change in the Constitution. I am convinced that the whole idea was to give the opposite impression, in other words, to convey to people that the introduction of these reforms which many people consider desirable required the amendment of the Constitution, when this is not the case.

The changes outlined in relation to judicial separation, the establishment of family courts, the making of financial orders, the raising of the minimum age for marriage, the introduction of a minimum period of notice for marriage and changes in the law of nullity could all be introduced without any change in the Constitution. If the Government were genuinely concerned about the problems which these reforms would address they would have been more honest to say to the people: "These are reforms which have been recommended by the Law Reform Commission and by the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown and we propose to take the necessary action to implement them". The Government could then go on to point out that divorce legislation could only be introduced if the Constitution was changed, that is in the event of the amendment being approved in the Referendum.

I am satisfied that the other proposals were intended as the sugar coating on the pill and that they were all lumped together with divorce in the document to which I have referred for the sole purpose of swaying the people to support the proposed change in the Constitution. Those of us who are Members of the Oireachtas have received the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution Bill and the document outlining the Government statement. However, the vast majority of people in the country have not seen either document and have to rely entirely on the media for clarification of what is proposed. In every debate and discussion I have heard and in every article I have read all the proposals to which I have referred are dealt with in the context of the debate on the proposed constitutional amendment. This has created an enormous amount of confusion and I would hazard a guess that the vast majority of people have no idea of exactly what they are being asked to say "yes" or "no" to in the proposed referendum.

I believe that what has happened on this occasion is unprecedented and is contrary to the spirit of section 4 of Article 46 of the Constitution. This Article deals with the procedure for amending the Constitution. The Article in question states:

A Bill containing a proposal or proposals for the amendment of this Constitution shall not contain any other proposal.

Commonsense would dictate that the reason this section was incorporated in the Constitution was so that no extraneous material or matter could be introduced into any proposal to amend the Constitution which would compound or confuse the issue or be likely to influence the outcome of the subsequent referendum. I accept that the letter of section 4 of Article 46 has not been breached but I am equally satisfied that the simultaneous publication and issue of the Government statement was a blatant breach of the spirit of that section. It should not have happened.

The type of divorce legislation which the Government state they would introduce in the event of the amendment being carried is not very relevant either to this debate. The reason I say that is that any legislation can be amended after a very short time. I am not suggesting that the initial legislation which will be proposed in the event of the Constitution being amended will not be along the lines set out in the Government statement: I accept that it will. What I am suggesting, however, is that once the Constitution is amended it is inevitable that in due course legislation will eventually be introduced which will be as liberal in relation to divorce as the amended section will permit. I say this because it is inevitable that pressure will continue for the liberalisation of any divorce laws which the Government decide to introduce. This pressure will persist until the laws are liberalised to the maximum extent that the Constitution will permit. When that happens the likelihood is that the lobbying will then build up once again for a further amendment of the Constitution or for the repeal of the section in question.

Therefore, it is important that this debate should concentrate on the wording of the proposed new subsection and on the types of legislation which this wording would permit. Members should not allow themselves to be sidetracked into a debate on the Government statement or on the legislative proposals contained in that statement. The fact that there is a five year separation precondition in the proposed leglislation as outlined in the Government statement is really a red herring in relation to any debate on the implications of the wording of the proposed amendment. If this precondition is incorporated in the initial legislation, it can be varied or even omitted in any subsequent legislation.

The experience in every other country which has introduced divorce legislation with a separation precondition is that the period of separation has been progressively shortened. In several European countries divorce is available after one year's separation. The only thing that is absolute in the wording of the proposed amendment is that a marriage must have been in existence for five years before it can be legally dissolved. Everything else that is contained in the proposed new subsection is subject either to the discretion of the courts or to whatever legislation may be introduced from time to time. Therefore if this amendment is carried marriage is no longer a legal commitment for life but a commitment for a period of not less than five years.

For almost 2,000 years western society has accepted that marriage was a commitment by two people to each other for life. In many countries that understanding of marriage has been undermined by the introduction of divorce and the progressive liberalisation of the divorce laws. Ireland of the future, to have divorce in the country people have to ask themselves is whether they wish to discard the definition which regards marriage as a lifelong contract and to replace it with a new definition which sees marriage only as a contract for a period not less than five years. To do so would represent a radical change in the existing situation as regards marriage. Since the family is founded on the institution of marriage such a change would have enormous implications for the family. Experience in other countries has proved that once divorce is introduced it is impossible to contain. Divorce based on irretrievable breakdown or the failure of a marriage — which is the word used in the proposed amendment — means that one partner can unilaterally decide to end a marriage. The facts are that two out of every five marriages in Britain now end in divorce, and one in every two in the United States.

Senator McGonagle referred to divorce in Northern Ireland. It is particularly interesting to study the divorce statistics in Northern Ireland and how the situation there has developed since 1970. In that year the rate of divorce was one in every 40 marriages. In 1975 this had risen to one in 25 and today there is one divorce in every six marriages. In every country where divorce has been introduced the experience is that it cannot be contained and the more readily available it becomes the more frequently it is sought. Those who argue that divorce can be contained are ignoring what the experience has been elsewhere, even in the USSR. The Irish Times of 4 July 1983 outlined the situation at that time in the USSR under the heading “USSR has one million divorces”. I quote from that article.

Comment on this

That is hardly a Catholic country.

Comment on this

It is a country where there is marriage breakdown, where there was an effort made to deal with marriage breakdown through the introduction of divorce. I will read what has happened there according to a Soviet sociologist. I quote:

A Soviet sociologist has revealed that there are almost one million divorces a year in the Soviet Union and asked whether the institution of marriage was not in danger of dying.

He further said in the Pravda article as reported in The Irish Times that:

...between 2.6 million and 2.8 million people marry each year but the divorce rate was now close to 950,000. Unless people learn to take a more responsible attitude to family life the family as a unit was doomed. The high divorce rate which in European Russia is running close to 50 per cent took a heavy social toll. Every fourth adult lived alone and millions of children grew up without a father.

The article then went on to speculate on the possible causes of such a high rate of marriage breakdown and concluded as follows:

Pravda insists that the family had to remain the basic social unit which taught children values and provided a firm basis for mutual happiness among parents. The paper said it was possible nowdays to bring up children without a father but the psychological role of the complete family was more important than ever before. The paper spoke of the official measures now being taken to strengthen the institution of marriage and prevent its breakdown. These include marriage guidance services, an increase in family allowances, a stepped-up campaign against male alcoholism, sex education in schools and sexual counselling for couples in difficulties.

In the USSR it would appear that divorce has caused more problems than it has solved. This is nothing new. The fact is that the problem which is used as the justification for the introduction of divorce, namely marriage breakdown, is greatly exacerbated by the remedy which is supposed to deal with it. The introduction of divorce will not solve the problem of marriage breakdown. It will create a whole plethora of new problems.

In any divorce situation where there are children involved, they are the ones who suffer most. There is incontrovertible statistical evidence from every country in which divorce laws operate that the children of divorced parents are several times more likely to suffer from psychological or emotional problems than children who come from a stable home environment. It is also acknowledged that in countries where divorce is available many children suffer from the fear and worry that their parents' marriage may end in divorce. This in turn can result in behavioural problems in the case of such children.

We must not forget or ignore the fact that if this amendment is carried an increasing number of children in this country will be subjected to the trauma of witnessing the break-up of their parents' marriage and the divorce and remarriage of possibly both parents. Is it any wonder that so many children elsewhere crack up in such circumstances? Will the situation be any different in the case of Irish children? While children are the chief casualites of divorce there is also much evidence that women too suffer greatly as a result.

I should like to refer to a recent study on divorce entitled "The Divorce Revolution — The Unexpected Social and Economic Consequences for Women and Children in America." This study by a sociologist at Stanford University, California, was published by the Free Press, New York. She spent ten years on her research. She sampled 2,500 court case records and interviewed hundreds of lawyers, judges and divorcees. She found that no-fault divorce, which is the type of divorce that would be introduced if the amendment is carried, is the cause of the impoverishment of both wives and children in the United States. She found that on divorce the standard of living of children and ex-wives decline by over 70 per cent while the standard of living of husbands actually improved. She also found that in the United States more than eight million women now raise children without the father's domestic presence and one-third of them are officially classed as below the poverty line.

Millions of fathers avoid payment of alimony whether they are rich or poor. From 60 to 80 per cent ignore court orders failing to pay nearly $4 billion annually. She concludes that even if all husbands paid all the money ordered by the courts 93 per cent of divorced mothers and children would still be living below the poverty line. In Ireland as in England and the United States it is women and children who will suffer most as a result of the introduction of divorce. The hardest hit will be mothers with young children. The succession rights and the legal protection in relation to the family home which spouses and children have at the moment under the Succession Act, 1965, and the Family Home Protection Act, 1976, will be considerably diluted, if not totally eroded, if divorce is introduced. These are all factors which people must take into account before making up their minds on how they will vote on the proposed amendment.

In this context I want to refer briefly to the provision in the proposed amendment that the court be satisfied that adequate and proper provision, having regard to the circumstances, will be made for any dependent spouse or for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse. I do not believe that this provision gives any worthwhile, long-term protection to the individual for whom it is intended to be a safeguard. The court in arriving at its decision in relation to what is proper provision can only have regard to the circumstances which obtain at a particular time. These circumstances could change overnight as a result of illness, accident or some other factor. Therefore I do not believe that the particular provision gives any worthwhile long term protection to the individuals to whom it refers.

In the final analysis the question we should ask ourselves is what effect the introduction of divorce would have on the quality of life in this country and whether or not society would be better or worse off as a result. It is not good enough to say that divorce will solve the particular problems of a particular individual or a particular couple, irrespective of how much we sympathise with that individual or that couple on the situation in which they find themselves. We must try to anticipate what its effects would be on society as a whole. We must ask ourselves to what extent the problems which are used as a justification for divorce could be alleviated or ameliorated by the introduction of the various other provisions outlined in the Government's statement.

I must conclude that, on balance, the introduction of divorce would not be in the best interests of our society and that the family unit on which society is based in this country would at the end of the day be worse off. I believe that the people in the referendum will support that view.

Comment on this

I welcome this Bill for a variety of reasons on which I intend to expand during the course of my contribution. I do not wish to spend my time this evening repeating a lot of what has been said by others during the day, some of which I have been fortunate enough to be here for. I think the general standard of the debate in this House has been excellent. There has been a great deal of preparation given by Members to their contributions which have been reasoned and carefully approached. I also think that the Government are to be congratulated on taking on a measure which has become one of great importance in our society in order to remedy the problems of marriage breakdown. I am prepared to accept that Senator Mullooly has to some extent got it right when he says that we do not know the numbers facing marital breakdown problems today. It is put at between 50,000 and 70,000 but certainly a considerable number of people are caught in the difficulties of marriage breakdown and it is an increasing problem. But to suggest as has been done that this is a rushed measure, that it is a measure that has been taken on for political reasons rather than for reasons that have been carefully weighed and measured by the Government of the day is, I think, to cast away the recent history of how this matter has been looked at. We have, for example, the fact that the New Ireland Forum spent some time dealing with the question of Church-State relations in regard to matters that had a bearing on the public morality area and we had, of course, the very definite views of the report of the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown which went into considerable detail in looking at the problems that we face in this area. I think it is not unimportant to remind my colleagues that this particular report came up with the unanimous view that a referendum should be held — certainly it was the majority view of the committee. Following that, we had the decision of the Taoiseach joined by the Minister for Justice here present this evening, to take the initiative in meeting the Churches and debating with them not just the issue of divorce but all the other problem areas confronting us in relation to marriage and which need to be discussed. The position is that we are now facing this measure and we are facing it at a time when it is necessary to do so.

All of these various moves from the New Ireland Forum to the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown, to the meeting with the Churches some time ago, have been in the direction of preparing the public mind for discussing the question of marital breakdown and the area of divorce.

One of the depressing aspects of the debate that took place in the other House was the extent of time that was given and the trouble to which Opposition speakers and particularly the spokesman on Justice went to deal with areas of apprehension that might be in the public mind following the debate, the economic considerations that were given a great deal of time in the course of that debate. I do not think that the economic considerations in this area are as large as some people would like to think. We have, after all, been dealing for a very long time with supports through the social welfare and tax code for split home situations, desertion and so on. These are nothing new. What is new, or certainly is growing into a very new problem, is the extent to which married couples are facing difficulties. This is being felt in every village. Certainly, it is being felt by most families and the need to come up with a remedy is all too clear. I think that it is necessary to concentrate on a little more compassion for the human tragedy that faces people in that situation, not just for the immediate couple concerned but obviously for the dependants of that marriage, the children, those who are most vulnerable in that situation. Are we to say to them that we are not as a country, or an Oireachtas able to offer them any compassion, any remedy?

This is something we have to proceed with in a courageous way and the State is doing so now. There is a well known saying: "If you want to know me, come and live with me". This is an age-old catch-phrase which is understood around Ireland. There is a great deal in it. Many of the problems of marriage arise because people did not prepare for marriage. Over the years insufficient numbers attended courses to prepare themselves for their future relationship with their spouse. I should like to quote sections from the Lenten Pastoral of 1986, Preparing for Marriage issued by Archbishop Kevin McNamara of Dublin. Dealing with the importance of pre-marriage courses it said:

Couples sometimes enter marriage with only a superficial knowledge of each other. Because they have enjoyed the period of courtship, they assume that they are suited to live together in marriage for the rest of their lives. Courtship and marriage are different, however. Courtship is wasted unless the couple use the time to make sure they have the qualities to live together in harmony as husband and wife.

It occasionally happens that a couple doing a pre-marriage course discover that they do not know each other as well as they had thought. This can sometimes result in the proposed marriage being postponed.

Further on under the heading "Warning signs" in the same Lenten Pastoral — written admittedly, before the proposals on marriage and divorce relating to this constitutional amendment were known — we read:

The prospects of a successful marriage are also put in question in other ways. As one of our Regional Marriage Tribunals has warned: "In courtship there are stop signs, accident black-spots ! Heavy drinking, heavy gambling, drug addiction, crime, violence, infidelity, tantrums, jealousy, psychiatric history — unless you want to be a martyr, take avoiding action today and do not wait until tomorrow. Do not imagine for a moment that you can change your partner in marriage."

I often wonder when I read that kind of contribution on the problems facing those, not just preparing for marriage, but those involved in a difficult marital problem, what kind of compassionate and Christian approach is embodied in the type of language that is used. There is a lack of human insight. A significant number of couples who face the difficulties we are discussing at this time feel that not just the Archbishop in question but other members of the Hierarchy who speak in this way do not understand the kind of difficulties that can arise after marriage which were not all that clear in the period before the union. It is all too evident that couples get married and later discover that one of the partners is violent.

Recently, I met a young girl who got married 18 months or so ago. She discovered not alone that her husband was violent, and was prepared to beat her up and her mother also, but that he had a history of armed robbery which she was unaware of before she got involved in her relationship with him. Mental cruelty can be spurred on by heavy drinking or drug addiction. Not all of these signs are clear before the couple decide to get married. One can be blind to the failings of the other and may not realise in time the extent of the problems which are likely to arise.

We have to show compassion for the mistakes people make and the difficulties people can get into, rather than turning our minds away from human error and offering no remedy. The proposal contained in this amendment to allow the possibility of divorce after a failure has continued for a period or periods amounting to at least five years is perfectly sustainable and reasonable. It should not be treated as opening up the country's laws to divorce on demand. That is not proposed in the legislation. In a reasonable and balanced way it recognises the human dilemma in which people find themselves. I hope there will be a positive approach to this referendum, in the debate over the next few weeks and that we will have a result which will favour a change in the Constitution in this area.

Comment on this

As a member of this House I regard my task not only as a great honour but also as a serious duty to be carried out very conscientiously. I welcome the holding of a referendum on divorce. It is only right and proper that our people should be given the opportunity to decide the matter democratically and, I hope, in a thoughtful and responsible manner. May I emphasise that all law must aim at the common good, at what is best for the majority of the people. Our Constitution does this magnificently in Article 41:

1º The State recognises the Family as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of Society, and as a moral institution possessing rights, antecedent and superior to all positive law.

2º The State, therefore, guarantees to protect the Family in its constitution and authority, as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the Nation and the State.

Article 41.3.1º reads:

The State pledges itself to guard with special care the institution of Marriage, on which the Family is founded, and to protect it against attack.

We are here this evening teasing out the various problems to enable us to get the best possible Bill to present to the people to enable them to decide. The people are being asked to remove this noble and ennobling Article totally and completely from the Constitution and to substitute a new Article which will do nothing to help the common good. It will do grave and lasting harm. I should like to highlight this point as I do not see it receiving any prominence in the debate so far.

I have been following the debate closely inside and outside the House. One thing which has amazed me is that so many have said or written so much about marriage and divorce without stating clearly what is meant by either word. I shall try to define them. First the standard and still accepted legal definition of marriage is that of Lord Penzance when he said: "I conceive that marriage may be defined as the voluntary union, for life, of one man and one woman, to the exclusion of all others." Secondly divorce — and let us be quite clear on this — it is permission from the State to remarry and, may I add, to remarry again. Those who favour divorce tell us it is necessary because of the high rate of marriage breakdown in our country. It is, of course, sad that there should be so much breakdown. But, even on the highest estimate of marriage breakdowns submitted to the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown, which was 6 per cent of all marriages, we have the lowest breakdown rate in the whole of Europe. If divorce were the answer to this problem then we should have the highest rate of broken marriages and countries that have divorce legislation should have the lowest breakdown rate. The opposite is evident for all to see. In our neighbouring island, Great Britain, the number of divorce petitions in 1920 was less than 3,000, but in 1981 this figure had risen to 200,000.

Here let me draw attention to an expression which has been attacked by the Taoiseach, by the Minister for Justice and by a lady Deputy in the other House who said that it was degrading and insulting to Irish women. The expression was that used by Deputy Woods in the Dáil when he described divorce as "a Frankenstein Monster". Those who have attacked the phrase do not know the history of divorce legislation, because this phrase is over 130 years old. It was quoted from no less a person than Lord Campbell, who was responsible for introducing the first Divorce Act in England in 1857. A few years later when Lord Campbell saw the increase in the rate of divorce, and their increases were still comparatively small, he said: "I have been sitting for two days in the divorce courts and, like Frankenstein, I am afraid of the monster I have called into existence."

The Second Vatican Council called divorce "a plague". The council's document was drawn up by bishops from all over the world and so it reflects a world wide judgment on the evils of divorce.

In spite of what the Taoiseach and others have been trying to argue, divorce legislation, no matter how limited, alters substantially what has been the universal understanding of marriage as a lifelong union. It has been claimed that a man or woman has the right to remarry. That could only be true if one changes one's basic understanding of marriage. Divorce, of its very nature, is designed to eliminate the understanding of marriage as being a union of one man and one woman for life. It is worth noting that the Royal Commission on Marriage and Divorce in England stated:

The Western World has recognised that it is in the best interests of all concerned — the community, the parties to a marriage and their children — that marriage should be one partner and that it should last for life. It has also always recognised that owing to human frailty, some marriages will not endure for life, and that in certain circumstances, it is right that a spouse should be released from the obligations of marriage. They are, and always have been, differences of view as to whether in such circumstances the marriage tie should be dissolved and the parties set free to enter into new marriages, or whether the parties should merely be legally separated without dissolution of the marriage tie.

Having noted that, even then, many were resorting too readily and too lightly to divorce proceedings, the report continued:

Unless this tendency is checked, there is a real danger that the conception of marriage as a lifelong union of one man and one woman, may be abandoned. This would be an irreparable loss to the community. There are some of us who think that if this tendency continues unchecked, it may become necessary to consider whether the community as a whole would not be happier and more stable if it abolished divorce altogether and accepted the individual hardship that this would entail.

It is the duty of the State to protect in a special way those who are most vulnerable and least vocal in our society, in this context, our young children. We are introducing many new laws to protect our children. We could have all these laws enforced and then destroy those good effects by the introduction of divorce. Our bishops remind us that "none are more deeply affected by divorce than our children" and they add "whatever laws say about marriage, parenthood at least is lifelong. Parents are forever". There is much evidence of seriously disturbed children of divorced parents.

I should like to draw the attention of the House to one further statistic which is not generally known. Most second marriages in proportion to first marriages also end up in divorce. This surely shows the destabilising effect of divorce. In all the debates I have heard in the Dáil and Seanad nobody has highlighted that aspect. That surely speaks for itself.

The Bill has been presented to take the serious effects of the economy away from the media and the people who are in serious distress at present and who would give this Government another month's life because when the referendum is over there will be four months recession——

Comment on this

Recession?

Comment on this

——four months holidays——

Comment on this

Four years of a recession?

Comment on this

——and it will bring us up to the budget of next year. There is a ploy by the Donnybrook set; the national handlers have decided that this Government must be in power, whether good or bad, for the sake of keeping Fianna Fáil from getting back into power. I have every confidence that the people of Ireland will reject this Bill.

Comment on this

This is not a Bill for the good of the family. The Minister is entitled to his opinion. He is entitled to interrupt when he wishes. I never interrupted any Minister here and will not in the future. This Bill is being brought before the unfortunate people of Ireland at a time when we have the highest unemployment level ever, the highest taxation limit ever, the highest crime rate ever. The people have had nothing but hardship for the last three or four years and are getting nothing every day but a dose of recession, cutbacks, doom and gloom, with nothing for the future. The Government are now proposing, in the form of divorce legislation, to take away the very foundation of our society, the very foundation of what makes us a great people here in Ireland.

We are the second last country in Europe not to have divorce and we should hold that position and be proud of it. The family in Ireland has got a special place and that place should be kept. Every family have their ups and downs but I would not like if my father or mother got a divorce and that I was the child who suffered. We have had problems in our home; everybody has problems. Everybody would like the love and affection of their parents and we know of the 6 per cent of mismarriages but I defy any politician or any parliament in the world to tell me of a better law than one that legislates for 94 per cent of the people satisfactorily.

The State should keep pace with the Church law because, when you are getting married, no matter what Church you are in, you have two ceremonies; you have a civil ceremony and a religious ceremony. The State recognises the priest or the vicar on that occasion as a witness to the civil ceremony. Why can the State not give a civil annulment if you can get an annulment whatever your faith?

We all know we have two or three different faiths in both Houses. We have proved ourselves to be an exceptional people in the South. We have all religious denominations working together, getting on together, in business together, in games together. In this beautiful part of the world one thing we can be proud of is the rock our family is built on. I have visited many countries. I know the disastrous effects of divorce. No profession is more plagued with divorce than the entertainment profession. In the end no one has respect for anyone. The suicide rate in divorce cases is way above that of people who try to survive and get on. We all know the early years are important I welcome the increase in the marriage age from 16 years to 18 years. It was essential. I deal with more young people, I would say, than anybody else in this House. Having massive experience all over the world, I believe this is the worst thing to have come before this House in the four years I have been a Senator.

I recognise that 94 per cent is a good percentage. I do not know of any legislation that has come before the House since I became a Senator that has had such a high success rate as Article 41 in our Constitution. The men who are dead and gone who have framed that Constitution have been commended at meetings I have attended over the past fortnight of all political shades and opinions. A member of the Government, who comes from Athlone, differs from the Minister, the Taoiseach and his Cabinet on this matter. I trust that the decent electorate of Longford-Westmeath will give a massive no vote to this in the referendum. I have never been too far wrong in elections over the past 20 years.

Councillors of all political persuasions have talked to me. Perhaps some of them thought I was a more liberal type politician, or a politician of the so-called media world. Many of my friends in the media thought I would be in favour of this. On occasions like this, I speak for the people I represent. I represent the family. As the father of a family I could not, in all conscience, support something because the media were for it. A certain minority speak very loudly in our society. I call on the silent majority to let themselves be heard, apart from the ballot box. At certain times looking at different articles in the media you would wonder whether you were living in America or in London.

We have seen massive victories in the European elections for Fianna Fáil, and the massive victories in the local elections for Fianna Fáil, and all these discredited journalists are on about the same thing: divorce must come; it is an absolute necessity because everyone is being crucified in their marriage and most marriages are not working. Most marriages are working.

I welcome the referendum. I am confident that the people will reject it. When it has been rejected we should update the State laws in line with the Church laws. I look forward to the Minister's reply to the question: if the Church gives a religious annulment why cannot the State do the very same thing? There are other aspects of this which have been teased out in the other House. What will it cost the State? I heard that the Minister said — and if he wants to correct me he may — £20,000 per divorce.

Comment on this
Alan M. Dukes Minister for Justice (Mr. Dukes) Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

If a couple living in a local authority house — and many of our people are living in local authority houses, or a house with a mortgage, which 90 per cent of us are all living in — get a divorce, one of the parents will stay in the house and the other parent will have to get out. When one parent finds another partner and possibly remarries — and 70 per cent of them remarry — the State will be faced with having to house all these people again. We all know the cost of houses. It can be £35,000 to £40,000 depending on which local authority area you are in. These are the expenses the State will have to meet. This is going to cost the taxpayer. If we have not got the money to maintain our roads, which we all know are in a deplorable state at the moment, where will we get extra money to house those people? If you take 70 per cent of 60,000 or 70,000 people that is 40,000 people to be housed and 40,000 houses at £40,000 each amount to quite a sizeable sum of money. These are the arguments people are making to us as county councillors. How will the Minister finance this luxury for this 6 per cent for whom he is bringing in the Bill?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I should like to conclude by saying I am glad a referendum is being held. I hope that, for the future welfare of our country, the electorate, like me, will vote no to divorce.

Comment on this

I will try to avoid going down the road, pot holes and all, that Senator Cassidy went down. I disagree with his comment that the decision to hold this referendum was taken at the whim of some handler or some set from some part of Dublin or otherwise. This debate is an indication that it is much too serious for a whimsical throw away remark like that. This is an area of human misery. What, if anything, can the State do about it? The debate the public want to hear from us is whether or not it is the right thing to do. We would all dearly love to live in a society in which marriages did not break down. Thank God the vast majority of marriages do not break down, 90 per cent or more. That is an indication of the stability of Irish society. Of those 90 per cent or more that are still intact, none of us knows or presumes to know how many are in difficulty. Many people make an effort for the sake of their children. No matter what legislation is introduced in any area of social legislation, we must have regard for the rights of children. In the few words I will say on this Bill I will try to deal with the concerns I have particulary about children and their rights in the existing situation of marriage breakdown and how, in fact, this Bill can address itself to the problem. In the ideal society — if we were to call it ideal — of course, Senator Cassidy, only mature and responsible people would marry.

Comment on this

At 18 no one can be mature.

Comment on this

I presume people of 18 are now mature. The Senator is in show business, as he said so he should know.

Comment on this

Entertainment is the word.

Comment on this

Entertainment is right. There are people who are mature at 18, thank God. Marriage vows would be honoured until death by either partner. Alcohol, violence and all the inadequate personalities would not threaten the very basis of marriage.

Comment on this

Perhaps that will be included in the next Bill.

Comment on this

In the ideal society these things would not happen and mature people would not allow all these other things to happen. But, unfortunately, in the real world that we are living in, some people marry too young and they marry for the wrong reasons. They make decisions of another nature, which pre-empt a decision about marriage at the appropriate time and they marry for the very wrong reasons. The Catholic Church, rightly, advises against that kind of forced marriage nowadays, because it is the wrong reason to get married. That is why the Catholic Church — and many theologians — talk about a proper preparation for marriage and the fact that there should be proper notice to the Church authorities. In the real world, we have the problem of alcoholism, violence, immature personalities which all undermine this marital harmony we wish for and marriages, unfortunately, break down. What has changed, of course, is the attitude of the parties to a broken marriage. A generation ago — that is not so long ago — there appeared to be absolutely no alternative to an unhappy marriage but to grin and bear it and women, because of their economic dependence on their husbands, and because of their having usually large families, seemed to have no choice whatsoever. The fact that the couple remained together despite the miseries that may have been experienced by one or both partners, did not mean the marriage had worked. But many of them survived such marriages for the sake of children.

What has changed in recent times is that the parties to unhappy marriages are willing to part and are unfortunately prepared to form second relationships and have second families. That is the tragedy of our country. A public reprepresentative, meeting constituents every week in rural Ireland and in urban areas will know that that is the real problem. In spite of the Catholic Church, the Protestant Church and all other religious teaching, people still enter into illegitimate, immoral relationships, which have proved to be stable in cases, and have produced children. But it is still immoral. In addition to being immoral, it also creates other problems. It is illegal. These kind of relationships are outside the law and it is because of that — and perhaps only because of that — that sections of this Bill will rectify that situation. I do not know if that is a good or bad thing. I want to be clear about our understanding of these informal unions. The children are illegitimate. That is a horrible word, we do not like talking about illegitimacy. We are going to do something about describing children of these unions in a different way in another piece of legislation but at present let us talk about the illegitimate children of these unions.

The spouses, do not have, for example, the protection of the family home legislation. Dependent partners and children have no legal right to maintenance; a woman living with a man outside of marriage cannot obtain a barring order in the event of violence to her or her children. Illegal and immoral as it is, she still has no protection whatsoever and if that illegal union breaks up and the man deserts her, she is not entitled to deserted wife's benefit or allowances. If her partner dies she is not eligible for a widow's pension. Neither does she or the children have any succession rights to her partner's property. As the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Marital Breakdown pointed out, not only is the law being brought into disrepute in this area but the situation is also harsh, unnecessary and unjust to the parties in such relationships. That is the sort of legal morass we have to try to sort out. It is a pity that we have arrived at that stage in Ireland, a Catholic country, that we have to sort out that situation. I would dearly love to say that every marriage was happy and peaceful and content, producing families who went on to better things than their parents. That went on for a long, long time but stresses and strains have changed all that.

Senator Honan in her very considered contribution to this legislation talked about the attitude of the Church. She was not going to put on the record — even though she is a believer like myself — the attitude of the Catholic Church. I have no apology at all for putting it on the record. I believe in the Catholic Church. I am a practising Catholic.

Comment on this

I said I was, too.

Comment on this

I want to put it on the record of the House that I am defending the right of the Catholic Hierarchy to teach their flock the proper, moral teaching about marriage, that sacramental marriage is indissoluble. For me that is the Catholic teaching and I accept it. But this Bill is not talking about sacramental marriage. This Bill is talking about legal marriage for which the Church acts as an agent on behalf of the State and registers it in law.

Senator Cassidy suggested a civil annulment. There are Catholic annulments and civil annulments, expensive as they are. If you have a Church or State annulment, you are, in fact, deciding that the marriage never took place. What does one do then? What does the woman in that situation do? The State and the Church might have decided that the marriage never took place. That woman is disowned of any rights she might have had. Even in a miserable marriage, before the annulment, she would have been legally entitled to succeed to property and so on. But in the case of annulment, none of those rights applies. One is left high and dry, out in the open with no rights to home, to a pension, to children's allowances or to anything because the marriage has been deemed never to have taken place. That is the problem. To defend the religious teaching of the Church presents no problem whatsoever. I believe that Catholic marriages are morally binding and whether divorce is introduced, there can never be another Catholic marriage or a sacramental marriage again in the Church. Perhaps Catholics would want to know that. They cannot after a divorce be married again in their Church, although I believe it has happened that the Catholic Church has been involved in the marriages of persons whose first marriages were annulled by the Church. That is stretching it a bit too much and I disagree with that.

Comment on this

That is where charity comes in.

Comment on this

Right. The Labour Party have had a policy on this issue for a long, long time and not because it was popular. It was unpopular for a long time to have these views in Ireland. The only reason our party ever had a policy on this was not because we were anti-family or anti-marriage as I think all of us involved in the party have proved but — because we had a certain sense of compassion and understanding for the problems that, unfortunately, befall marriages of all religious denominations today. This is not just confined to the Catholic Church. We would not be human if we did not have problems. Christ was very compassionate. We have been told that He forgives all sins.

I have not heard any Church authority saying yet that if somebody actually votes for this or avails of the legal rights that this might confer, that in some way they would be excommunicated from the Church. Perhaps if it is that immoral, that is the line that should be taken. Then I would wonder what the people would think about it. Over the years the electorate in Ireland have proven themselves by their decisions to be a very considered electorate. They have changed the Government at times and rightly so. They have voted yes and no in referendums. We have often questioned them afterwards. They are questioning now the voting `yes' for entry into the European Community. That required a referendum and an amendment to the Constitution. Many people say they should not have done it, but the reality is at that time they considered it the right thing to do. I respected their view. At that time I did not even agree with it, but I respected it.

People's minds are becoming confused by listening to all of us. We have had an excellent debate; apart from a few little skirmishes here and there it has been an excellent debate and rightly so because it is a very important and sensitive area. It is very important to me personally. I believe in what I am doing. I believe in the institution of marriage, but there are some elements of doubt being spread around by people. I do not know for what reason. Senator McGonagle made an excellent contribution. He mentioned the North. If it is beaten the people from Northern Ireland will point to us as being in some way sectarian. If it is won I would say that it will not make any difference. I do not think it will influence them one way or another.

Comment on this

I think you are right there.

Comment on this

I do not think it will. They know exactly, and they will use it against us if we do not make the change, and if we make the change it will not make any difference to them. In that context you cannot win. Senator McGonagle was right. Either you do it for the sake of doing it, if it is right or you do not do it at all.

Naturally, the Government in their compassion would not have run off in haste, as they have been accused of doing, into a referendum, if they did not realise that there is a problem there. The problem of marital breakdown will not be sorted out by this referendum. There will still be marriage breakdowns. All it will sort out is the legal right to remarry and will give a legal status to all these other unions that have taken place. That is what is it all about. It is not the fact that anybody is anti-family or anti-marriage or anything else. The Minister who is present has been quoted, and in fairness to him it must be said that only part of the reference has been quoted. In a speech that he made, he said and I quote:

As regards the spouses, it will, of course, be a consequence of divorce that a person who has ceased to be married to another by reason of the dissolution of the marriage, would not be regarded as the widow or widower of the other, for the purposes of succession when that other dies and would lose rights as a result.

Everybody stopped there as if the first marriage is going to be disowned — the first marriage is over and the spouse has had no rights whatsoever. The Minister has been quoted out of context several times in the House today, and continuing he also said:

As part of the proposals outlined in the Statement which accompanied the publication of this Bill a Court granting a divorce will have new powers to make orders as to the ownership of property of the spouses. This will enable the Court to make some compensation for loss of expectations on the death of the other spouse, if that is appropriate. It is, of course, a normal feature of the standard form of separation agreement usually entered into by enstranged spouses that each renounces his or her succession rights on the death of the other. This is the case in practice even though it is not recognised, or perhaps realised by many of those who comment on issues raised by the Bill.

That is the total context of what the Minister said in his speech. If people quote they should quote it all. I presume the Minister in the latter part of his speech is referring to Schedule 2, 2º (4) (1) of the Bill itself and this is being written into the Constitution:

the court may in accordance with law grant a dissolution of the marriage provided that the court is satisfied that adequate and proper provision having regard to the circumstances will be made for any dependent spouse and for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse.

That is the section which reaffirms what the Minister has said and which is in the Constitution. So there is no danger whatsoever to people in previous relationships.

Comment on this

Which is or which will be?

Comment on this

That is, as I read it, will be the Constitution. Senator Mullooly made a comment that legislation would always be amended and updated and made as liberal as possible in line with what the Constitution will allow. Either we are satisfied with this constitutional amendment or we are not, because no law can be enacted that is not in keeping with it. It cannot be made liberal or less liberal or anything. This is it. I have some questions to ask. Nobody can ever be satisfied, because the Minister has available to him and to the Government, the highest legal opinion in Ireland. That is why I have reprimanded Senator Honan for casting a doubt on the Attorney General for what he might do, "this one in particular" was the way she put it.

Comment on this

One of yours. I am just worried about it.

Comment on this

I thought that was unfair and I defended the Attorney General because he is not here. He holds a constitutional office and if he is not here to defend himself, we should leave him alone. The Senator need not be one bit worried.

Comment on this

You have other occasions when you have need to be more worried than you have today.

Comment on this

Could you refrain from personalities.

Comment on this

I will leave it alone. I will just say that I am as happy about the calibre and the standing and the validity of the existing Attorney General as I am about any previous one and much more so. His advice was available and other legal advice was available about the exact words, how it would affect people and what would happen. I am saying that Deputy Cooney is entitled to his opinion. We are in a free country and he can express his views. We are all expressing our views. You expressed your views.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Could you refrain from personalities?

Comment on this

I should have mentioned the Minister, Deputy Cooney, and I defend his right to free speech as well. You are quite right. There are several people in Fianna Fáil and who had been in Fianna Fáil before. Let us all accept that people can state their views.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Both sides of the House have had enough lee-way on this now. So please continue the Bill.

Comment on this

I have a few questions I want to ask the Minister because he has advice available to him, that I do not have available to me. Let us presume a husband deserts his wife with two or three children for five years and goes to live in England. Suddenly we pass this legislation here. One would say immediately, that he would probably file for a divorce. The reality is that at present, although he is an Irishman, if he is resident in Britain, he can get a divorce over there which, unfortunately, our State recognises. It recognises the divorce of people domiciled in another country. That is an extraordinary situation. Somebody could have disappeared for five years — I will not name the town in case Senator Cassidy might think I was alluding to his own town — but still live in Ireland. Because the constitutional amendment is carried he could suddenly file for a divorce. His deserted wife has already suffered the stigma of being a deserted wife with three children. He can now start to petition for a divorce to regularise this other extraordinary relationship.

I would like to know what right the woman who is left at home has in that instance. Has she the right to say: "Why should I let him have his freedom? I stayed at home and reared the children and now he wants his freedom to regularise his new union. Have I any say in it?" Is this why we are going to legislate that there must be a legal separation for two years? If we are to have an obligatory legal separation for two years as part of the legislation, the Minister might tell me why it was not put into the constitutional amendment. In a legal separation, at least you have to have agreement between the two partners that there was a separation. I would not like that it might be found to be impracticable for some reason and that the person who was left at home with the responsibility had no right to object to the other person having his or her freedom legally. I have been asked these questions and it is my duty to ask them. Whether the amendment is passed or not, the rights of children are paramount, and children must have some legality in this situation, a legality children of other unions do not have at present.

I have absolute confidence in the Irish electorate. They are genuine people. They will ask a question if they are worried about something. I have asked several people whether they are voting for or against this and it is amazing how many different views there are on it. People you would expect to express the view expressed by Senator Cassidy are the people who say they will vote for it. Whatever the result is, let us welcome it. We should not be scoring points. This is too important. The people should have their say, make their decision, and let us abide by whatever the decision is. Let us not take advantage of the decision whether it is negative or positive. It would be great to have a decision by the people on an issue like this which has been talked about for so long. Only this Government had the courage to give them an opportunity to express their views.

Comment on this

I would like to speak on the amendment. I am glad to see the Minister here. We were disappointed he was not here to move the Bill this morning especially since the Government side are saying this is very important legislation. I was also disappointed with the way it was introduced. I want to quote from Volume 365, column 1445 of the Official Report of the Dáil on 23 April where on the Order of Business, Deputy Haughey, Leader of our party, said:

You will recall, A Cheann Comhairle, that yesterday morning, I raised with the Taoiseach the parliamentary programme until the summer recess. Let me return to that matter and ask the Taoiseach if, in view of the many reports in the media this morning, it is the intention of the Government to bring forward legislation in this term to amend the Constitution?

The Ceann Comhairle told him he was not in order.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am sorry to interrupt you, Senator, but the business of the other House is not appropriate to this House and you cannot quote from the other House.

Comment on this

I often quoted before from reports in this House——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

You cannot quote Deputies, but you can quote Ministers.

Comment on this

I am sorry I did not understand. I will give the Taoiseach's reply to that question. He said:

I have stated publicly that following consultations with the Churches I will be coming to the Government to present my conclusions. The Government have not taken any decision on the matter in question.

After further questions he said:

I have made no statement, other than the announcement I have just made.... I will not anticipate a decision of the Government in a matter of this kind.

He went on to say:

The matter is still under consideration. There are difficulties arising from problems of abuse and we are endeavouring to reconcile those problems with the importance of providing this facility.

Less than one hour afterwards the Fianna Fáil Party were informed through the Taoiseach's office that the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1986, would be printed and circulated that evening. The Taoiseach treated the House with contempt by not letting the House know he intended to introduce legislation, especially when the media had already made the announcement.

Comment on this

The Senator is criticising the Taoiseach for informing the Opposition at the earliest possible moment that a decision was made. It is a little bit impolite to say the least of the Senator to do that. The fact that the Opposition were informed immediately a decision was made is something in which he should rejoice. It is the proper courtesy to be extended by the Taoiseach to the Opposition.

Comment on this

The Minister might think that, but I think otherwise. The media knew the night before.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As I have already stated, the business of the other House is not appropriate to this House.

Comment on this

We have late sessions tonight and tomorrow night. The last time we had a late session was for the debate on the Family Planning Bill. I raised an Adjournment matter at 4 a.m. after that debate.

Comment on this

It is not the first time the Senator was up at that hour.

Comment on this

This is supposed to be legislation on a social issue but there are more important issues which we deal with, and we do not sit this late. Fianna Fáil have already shown their good faith in this matter by accepting the Government's decision in a non-political way. It is definitely a matter for the people and should not be made a political issue. It is regrettable that, in the course of this debate, a number of Coalition Deputies made it a party political point scoring issue and engaged in personal attacks. Can they not see that they are leaving themselves open to the accusation——

Comment on this

Did the Senator not hear Senator Cassidy a few minutes ago?

Comment on this

I am finding it very hard to hear. When are we going to get the new amplification and speaker system here? I brought this up yesterday. I am finding it impossible to hear what is going on.

Comment on this

Senator Kiely did not hear Senator Cassidy.

Comment on this

I am delighted I am of the same opinion as Senator Cassidy. I appeal to the Government parties to desist from these attempts to gain party political advantage from this issue. It should be above politics. It should be conducted in the responsible way it deserves to be treated.

The amendment has many important aspects and implications for the position of families and for the character and quality of our society. As citizens, we will have to weigh up many vital considerations in order to decide where the balance of the public good lies. Many sincere and conscientious views are held on this subject and are deserving of respect. While the timing of the referendum might have been better chosen, rushing through this legislation is not fair to the debate. There was a question on the census form about marriage breakdown and it would be appropriate to have the referendum after the results of the census are published in the autumn.

The issue going before the people will be whether marriage should remain permanent and indissoluble as a firm basis of family life and of society or whether it may be dissolved if certain conditions are met. The decision either way will affect the nature of marriage for everyone and not just those at present caught up in breakdown situations. If this amendment is passed it will mean that the partners in a marriage which may not be going well but which could be remedied, will be seeking a divorce. There is something in the amendment which will facilitate such cases.

Opinion polls are conducted on many issues as an indication of how people are likely to vote but they are not always correct. I hope they are right as far as the performance of the Government is concerned but I hope they are wrong on this issue. It is only after the referendum is held that the wishes of the Irish people will be known. The referendum is likely to take place on 26 June and Irish voters will once again have an opportunity to show the world they are going to keep our traditional values intact. There is no need to follow the trends of other countries. Ireland can continue to protect marriage and family life and, therefore, benefit the common good. We Irish are proud of our independence as a people, of our character and ability to be able to stand up against the world, and yet years after others elsewhere introduce something, we go for it and do it even after those who introduce it now realise they were wrong. Who is asking the Government to bring this in — a tiny minority? I wonder if this minority, using the power of the media, are going to be able to bring divorce proposals forward again and again by using the argument that since we are the only remaining country in Europe which has not yet introduced divorce, we have an obligation to do so as soon as possible. If that is the reason this country finds itself debating this topic it is unfortunate and reprehensible.

Experience in other countries has shown that once divorce legislation is introduced there is an increase in marital breakdown. In Northern Ireland in 1970 one in 40 marriages ended in divorce: in five years the figure jumped to one in 26 and in 1983 it was one in 25. At present, 70 per cent of divorces in Northern Ireland are granted on the basis of separation. This required period of separation is gradually being shortened so that at present in many European countries divorce is available after one year's separation.

Divorce legislation in Britain was introduced on the basis of fault such as adultery, cruelty or desertion. It can no longer be controlled because the condition of irretrievable breakdown is satisfied by one person deciding to live apart. Two out of every five marriages in Britain end in divorce. In the United States one in every two marriages end in divorce.

Irish people should not be fooled into believing that divorce legislation once introduced in Ireland will not follow the same trend as it follows in other countries. As sure as night follows day, it will. No matter what way it is controlled that trend will follow.

Is this what the Irish people want? A "Yes" vote in the referendum will open the door to the granting of divorce on a very liberal basis. Many people will be confused into believing that in voting "Yes" in the referendum they are voting to alleviate hardship in certain cases. This is not so. Passing the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution will mean that every marriage commitment is weakened. In the forthcoming referendum people will be voting to change the legal concept of the permanence of their own marriages or the future marriages of their children. This is very serious, before voting people should seriously consider the experiences of other countries and the likely probability that Ireland will follow the same road if this amendment is passed.

There is a lot of talk about the children of the first marriage. Under the Succession Act, 1965, children of the first marriage lose their constitutional protection under Articles 41 and 42 on the dissolution of the marriage and their inheritance rights would derive only from the Succession Act.

To go back to the case of a divorced wife who is in the situation of being a dependent spouse during the marriage the new wording in the Constitution proposed in the referendum states:

The court may in accordance with law grant a dissolution of the marriage provided that the court is satisfied that adequate and proper provision having regard to the circumstances will be made for any dependent spouse and for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse.

These words sound reassuring but what do they mean? For a divorced wife they could mean the difference between the standard of living to which she was accustomed or a life eked out of social welfare. In such cases the estranged dependent wife can use her renunciation of legal succession rights as a barring factor to obtain more generous maintenance terms. In the case of a divorce, the wife would have no bargaining power as she has no succession rights. However, the Government's point seems that the court will have the possibility of compensating for loss of succession rights. The passing of the referendum will not give this power but only later legislation.

No matter what improvements are made in the enforcement of maintenance orders we know that in practice many spouses will be left solely dependent on social welfare. The social welfare system is over-burdened at present. I am sure the money in the Exchequer at present is hardly adequate to meet social welfare payments. If this legislation is passed, there will be little hope of removing VAT from hurleys in the next budget.

Comment on this

That will never happen.

Comment on this

The DIRT tax will be increased from 35 per cent because the social welfare bill will be very much increased. Apart from its humanitarian aspects that development will have major financial implications for the Exchequer in the cost of the social welfare benefits.

Under the Family Home Protection Act, 1976, one spouse cannot sell the family home without the permission in writing of the other. In a case where the husband is the owner, the wife is protected from having the family home sold over her head. It seems clear, however, that a divorced spouse who was not the owner of the family home would lose his or her right to block the sale even if still residing in it. These are serious implications that will arise on the passing of this legislation for the family and wife of the first marriage. The first marriage is the marriage everyone, including the Minister, would like to see continuing. Whilst we agree there are many cases of hardship which we would like to resolve, the passing of this legislation will make it possible for people who have marital problems to opt out of marriage. It would be like trading in a car. The woman might go for a man with better means and have a better time. There is a danger that that could happen.

Comment on this

It is a fact. This is a serious matter.

Comment on this

It might not happen in Kerry or Limerick.

Comment on this

It is too serious to compare it with second-hand cars.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Kiely to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

The Government are bringing it to that level. It is the men they will be treating like second-hand cars. There is a danger that this legislation will lead to something like this. It could have serious consequences for the social make up of this country.

I would like to quote from the proposed amendment to the Constitution which states:

Where, and only where, such court established under this Constitution as may be prescribed by law is satisfied that—

i. a marriage has failed,

ii. the failure has continued for a period of, or periods amounting to, at least five years,

iii. there is no reasonable possibility of reconciliation between the parties to the marriage, and,

iv. any other condition prescribed by law has been complied with.

Could it happen that in a year's time a condition could be prescribed by legislation which would make divorce more readily available under the terms of the first three paragraphs?

Comment on this

Not without further changes to the Constitution.

Comment on this

I would like an explanation of paragraph iv. It is very vague. Will it make things more liberal? This worries me and I am sure it worries many other people.

I hope this legislation will not be passed. This Government will be remembered for introducing two measures: making contraceptives readily available throughout the country and making divorce legal. It will be a sad day for Ireland if this happens at a time when unemployment is rampant. This legislation is unnecessary at a time when there are more pressing problems such as serious crime and increased taxation which the Government should be tackling.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I will not take very long because at this stage one is recycling many of the arguments that have been made in this House previously and in the other House. At the same time, there is a certain amount of justification for regurgitation of some arguments. While one respects the right to silence of individual Senators, individual Deputies, or public representatives, on such an issue this is one of the occasions when one would be inclined to withdraw that right. It is vitally important that every public representative pins his or her colours to the mast, points their supporters in a particular direction either pro or con, and has the courage of his or her convictions to stand up and say precisely where he or she stands on this issue.

The debate, by and large, has been an enlightened one in both Houses. I compliment the two partners in Coalition on having the necessary political courage, in the face of what was seen to be trenchant opposition from the combined mass forces, in some cases, of Church and would-be State authorities, to go ahead with legislation which is vital to underpin the family, family breakdown, irretrievable breakdown, the social hazards and the social malaise which have crept in and are so prevalent in society today.

One is amused by some of the arguments coming, in particular, from the Opposition. One of the arguments made by Senator Kiely, which is one of the facile arguments we always get at times like this when we have difficult legislation before us, was: why do the Government not address themselves to the pressing needs of the country? Just as I reminded Senator Kiely and his colleagues on the occasion of the passing of the Finance Bill, the Government have more than addressed our difficulties. There is tangible proof and statistical evidence that there have been significant breakthroughs in underpinning the main fabric of the economy and getting the components and nuts and bolts of the economy into relatively good shape in order to maximise the benefits of the present upswing in the international economic scene.

There is the other facile argument: why do the Government not address themselves to crime? It has been proven that the tide has turned in this regard and that crime is on the decrease in this city. The unemployment pattern has taken a downward swing. In the past two months we have managed to have a real decrease in the underlying levels of unemployment. Ploys, diversionary tactics, satellite arguments, and peripheral arguments like those are an impediment to getting to the core of the real argument and which is that we have a social, moral and political obligation——

Comment on this

Unemployment has increased.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathoirleach

Senator Higgins, without interruption.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——to solve the real problems that confront us.

Senator Kiely mention that the traditional values of the nation would be undermined, that they are intact at present. Surely all of the evidence trotted out in this House, the Committee on Marriage Breakdown, in the media, phone-in programmes and women's programmes substantiates in considerable detail the conviction of this Government and the people in general that there is a crying need to do something about this problem.

We have the old argument of financial implications. I would respectfully suggest that when dealing with trauma, human suffering, human degradation, cruelty, marriage breakdown and the consequences thereof, financial considerations are of secondary importance. In the face of what we saw as the collective mobilised weight of certain politial parties and the trenchant opposition of the State, it took considerable courage to go ahead and put this referendum before both Houses, to get it out to the people and let them finally decide.

Comment on this

Without any political interference.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

We have a moral obligation to face up to our duties. It shows a certain amount of cowardice if we have to be always prepared, nudged, elbowed and goaded on by the Supreme Court and that in itself is an indictment of us as legislators.

I am from a part of the country where roaring liberals are not very welcome. I do not represent that type of constitutency. I come from an area that is basically a conservative area and where we would like to think that the traditional values to which Senator Kiely would have us adhere so steadfastly are by and large kept. Yet in such a rural, conservative community one sees marriage breakdown and the consequences thereof. One sees irretrievable breakdown, the uncertainty caused, the doubt, the children involved who are unsure of their status, the grim financial circumstances, most of the suffering and cruelty, etc. It is evident in every townland in rural Ireland as well as every city.

Comment on this

I feel you are exaggerating.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I am not exaggerating. It is there. I am aware of it. I am sure it is prevalent in rural Limerick as it is in Mayo.

Comment on this

It is in Limerick.

Comment on this

Does Senator Belton know Limerick?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

It is callous on the part of legislators that we do not face up to our obligations. Those of us who are lucky enough to have stable marriages should not, because of our stability, deny people who are in unstable situations a chance of having a second opportunity of marrying. It is taking "I am all right Jackism" to extremes, and unforgivable extremes.

The reasons for marriage breaking are manifold — alcoholism, physical and mental cruelty, desertion. Irrespective of the reasons, the results are there. I am not enamoured, as most people are not, of the argument that nullity is the answer for everything. I subscribe to the view put forward by many people in the other House, in this House, and by Senator Ferris that nullity is no answer or remedy. Nullity presupposes that no marriage existed in the first place. It is a gratuitous insult to people who have been married for 10 or 15 years, who have worked hard at that marriage, who were, for a period of time, reasonably happy but who for reasons perhaps of their own making or not suddenly found themselves in situations where incompatability arose, to be told their marriage never existed in the first place. I, like Senator Kiely and every other speaker, wish that this did not happen, but it does happen. Those of us who find ourselves in secure, stable situations should be all the more grateful, accommodating, compassionate and understanding in our determination to ensure that the necessary facilities to allow people disengage themselves from these types of situations should be advanced, put forward and made available.

I as a member of the Catholic Church, and adherent to the basic tenets of the Catholic Church, pay tribute to the Church for the manner in which it has undertaken its role in relation to marriage, matrimony and underpinning and servicing matrimony before, during and after marriage. In this regard there has been a considerable degree of neglect by the State. Were it not for the Church and for many of the services provided by the Church, either pre-marriage counselling, post-marriage counselling, mediation services, shelter groups etc., there would be a much higher incidence of marriage breakdown. At the same time it is the primary duty of legislators to legislate for the common good.

Like the speakers on the other side of the House I fully endorse the protection of the family and the family unit. I do not subscribe to the view that there is going to be an avalanche, torrent or a whole series of applications for divorce decrees in the event of this referendum being passed. We had the same hysterical, emotional arguments put very forcefully to this House, to the other House and to the media generally by the Church in relation to the family planning legislation. I venture to suggest, without having any statistical evidence, that if one were to monitor or to quantify the number of additional condoms introduced into this country or sold by chemists across counters, the grim forebodings of the Opposition and the Church in that regard have not been borne out.

I am not anxious for divorce. Basically I do not like divorce. I think that divorce is a remedy that should be made available. It is a civil right that should be there. It is an option that should be made available to people. I do not see the introduction of this measure as making divorce compulsory, as would seem to be the general thrust of argument from the Opposition benches. This is about people's ability to take charge of their own lives. When people are talking about legislation they should address themselves to the facts. One of the earliest arguments put forward by the opponents of this measure was that it was too liberal, there was no fault divorce and it was almost creating a situation where we were going to have divorce on demand. As the Minister has pointed out, without adequate refutation or rebuttal from anybody, this is the minimum we could introduce. This is probably the most restrictive form of divorce one could have. There will be a five year waiting period. This means a couple will have to be married for at least five years before they can even contemplate divorce. It will also be introduced in two stages. First, there is the judicial separation and, second, the dissolution decree. It cannot be shortened other than by an obligatory five year waiting period.

I am somewhat appalled by the critics of our courts system etc. who say that our judges cannot be trusted in relation to exercising their discretion. The Judiciary have stood the test of time. The basic values of society have been well addressed by them. By and large the judicial system has served this country well.

I welcome, in particular, the introduction of family courts. I urge, as Deputy Shatter urged in the other House, that the judges and members of the Circuit Court who are chosen to perform this task are people, who will have a special sensitivity and the necessary skills to handle the subjects and the delicate area in which they will be dealing.

When one looks at the other remedies and supportive measures that are being introduced in relation to property, custody, maintenance payments etc., I cannot for the life of me share in the slightest apprehension of the people from the Opposition benches who say that this will destabilise marriage, will undermine the fundamental unit of society and will wreak havoc on Irish traditional values. I am very happy with the values and safeguards that are enshrined in this legislation.

The divorce provisions in other countries, give the lie to the allegation that the form of divorce envisaged in the Bill is more liberal than that which operates in other jurisdictions. Other jurisdictions, by and large, are far more liberal in that regard. For example, in some American states there is only a two day waiting period. In Sweden there is a two week waiting period. In Germany the basic requirement is a general consensus in relation to failure, plus a one year waiting period. In the Netherlands there is the condition of irretrievable breakdown and divorce, in some cases, is permitted in the first year of marriage in certain circumstances. In Finland, both partners agreeing, there is the introduction after a six month waiting period. In Australia the court can refuse a divorce petition if the judge feels that reconciliation is possible in the case before him. Otherwise there is a one year waiting period.

Basically, I would subscribe to the thesis of many people that good divorce legislation can actually support matrimony and this legislation will be proven to have this effect. From the point of view of making a rational comparison with our own situation, the best comparison would be with countries which have most recently introduced divorce and which, basically, have the same Catholic ethos as prevails in this country, for example, Spain, Portugal and Italy. In Spain, where divorce was introduced in 1981, there is a two year waiting period or a five year waiting period if the divorce is being disputed by one or other partner. A phone call to the Spanish Embassy, a general query as to what the incidence of divorce was in Spain since its introduction in 1981, elicited the reply that it was low. In Portugal, where divorce was introduced in 1974 and liberalised in 1977 there was — as will happen in this country because there is a backlog, the evidence is there from the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown whether or not one accepts the validity of the statistic of 70,000 — a rise immediately but, hopefully, our experience will be that of Portugal, that there will be a subsequent fall. Again, it is the general consensus in Portugal and it would be acknowledged by Church people there that it has not undermined or destabilised society or marriage.

In Italy the requirement is that if there are irreconcilable difficulties, divorce is permitted. Where there is a disputed divorce there is an obligatory seven year waiting period. If there is agreement between the partners the period is five years.

The greatest possible laboratory example of divorce in the situation in which we find ourselves is the Northern Ireland situation. This is the one irrefutable argument in relation to giving people the necessary assurance that we are not going to have an epidemic or a deluge of divorces in this country when the legislation is enacted. I would take issue with some of the statistics trotted out by Senator Kiely by which he showed that there is an escalation of the numbers of people suing for divorce. An examination of those figures shows that among the Catholic community in the North of Ireland there is not anything like the ratio of divorce as pertains in other countries or as pertains in the North of Ireland among the Church of Ireland community or the Protestant community. I would venture to suggest that these people swing the same hurley and have the same values and the same traditional basic interests as Senator Kiely and his Limerick people. Senator Kiely spoke in very emotional terms about that — that there is very little basic difference in terms of values, culture or interests between the people of Crossmaglen and the people of Clones. The Northern Ireland experience, which is so reassuring for all of us who might have anxieties or worries in that connection should give us the necessary encouragement to proceed with the referendum.

Comment on this

Is the Senator disputing the figures?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I am disputing the figures in relation to the Catholic minority in the North. One of the answers given by the Hierarchy in this regard is that because of the type of siege mentality in which the minority community find itself there is a feeling that if one sues for divorce, one is letting the side down. I do not subscribe to that view.

It is the duty, obligation and the right of the Catholic Hierarchy and the Catholic Church to instruct. I have no doubt whatever but that they will do so. I take a certain amount of courage, comfort and consolation from the opening words of the Bishop of Clonfert on the "Today Tonight" programme the day this referendum was announced. Hopefully they will be followed by the vast majority of churchmen. He said that the position of the pulpit should be used and not abused. In fairness, to date, happily, that has been our experience.

But just as it is the Church's obligation and duty to look after the welfare, the morals, the values of their flock, equally, it is our duty and obligation as legislators to consider the mental anguish and cruelty with compassion and to legislate honestly and fairly without fear or favour. This legislation does that.

One can justifiably ask, as Senator M. D. Higgins asked in the House today, what happens if the result of the referendum is not positive and what happens to the children of marriages that have been nullified? He asked what would be their property rights and what is their status and standing. As a legislator, it is my bounden, duty and obligation to go without fear or favour before my electorate, to point out to them the facts in relation to this issue, to point them in a particular direction and, having done that, to allow them to make up their own mind on it. I sincerely hope that the proposal to have a referendum is carried.

Comment on this

I was here for the Minister's speech this morning and for some of the other speeches and I listened very diligently to them. I was not very anxious to take part in this debate not for any particular reason. It is an issue for the people. The people should be mature enough to make up their own mind on it.

I compliment the Members of this House for the dignified manner in which the debate has been conducted throughout the day. Sincerely held views have been expressed from all sides of the House, views supporting the amendment, views against the amendment and I would not question the sincerity of any of the speakers. We are all in public life, many of us for a long number of years and we have many objectives in life. We have political objectives. We have political ambitions. We have social objectives and moral objectives and we try to help the community irrespective of what party we belong to in the best manner possible. That is why I would not like to seem to be crossing swords on this issue with some of my good colleagues in the House. I have made many friends since I came here and I do not intend to cross swords with anybody here tonight.

Comment on this

Even though we cross swords we can still be friends.

Comment on this

I know that. I want to briefly place on record my views on the referendum based on my experience and on what I feel will be best for the people of the country. First, I want to place on record my full approval for the manner in which the Fianna Fáil Party handled this matter. The party leader's speech in the other House was a very constructive one and a very fair assessment of the situation. I am happy that I am not under a party Whip to have to make a decision that would be, perhaps, against my better judgment or against conscience. I am happy to be free to express myself as to what my personal feelings are on this matter. As I have stated, it is an issue to be decided by the people. It is their decision. It is their choice whether we have divorce in the country or not.

I do not intend to go into any of the technicalities of the Bill. Many Members have discussed various technical aspects of it. Some of the technicalities are beyond my comprehension, technicalities that will have far-reaching effects on many of the families involved if the legislation becomes law.

I view the Bill in the light of my experience, as I have stated already, and as a public representative since 1967. In that period I have served as a member of a local authority, the Vocational Education Committee, library committees and health boards. I have been a member of many visiting committees to hospitals, some of them psychiatric hospitals. In my experience in dealing with the many social problems that exist in society, I have seen marriage failures and I have known the reason for many of these failures. In many of the cases I have known, I am fairly convinced that the same problems would arise in a second or even a third or fourth marriage. The people concerned had failed to recognise the problems of the situation they were in and then failed to take the necessary steps to rehabilitate or combat the problems prevalent to their way of living or to the situation in life in which they found themselves.

There is no doubt that the people have become the victims of a fast moving world where pressures are becoming increasingly intolerable to bear for many people. It is only realistic to recognise that fact and to understand that these pressures can have a detrimental effect on marriage in certain areas. Some people are built with strong wills and have the capacity to cope, other people just have not got that strong will or even the capacity to cope with situations. Yet, I know from experience, that many cases of seeming marriage failures or discord have been totally healed. I am glad of this fact. I have seen some cases where there seemed to be no solution whatever, yet with some help and advice, and communication, the situation was reversed. I know families who seemed to be a hopeless position and are now living happily together. I am proud of this fact. Had divorce been available at that time, I have no doubt whatever that husband and wife would be living apart. I asked a young boy what his feelings were on the divorce Referendum. He said that he would be for it. I asked him would he like if his father was living away X number of miles from his native town and away from his mother and his reply to me was: "My God, no way." I know that that family had experience of great difficulties a number of years ago but they had the will. They got the inspiration and with help they gradually came back together and are now part of a happy family unit.

The clergy have been criticised, the Church has been criticised, pro-divorce groups have been criticised, anti-divorce groups have been criticised. Let us be fair on this. The role that the Church has played in trying to help preserve the family unit should not go unnoticed during the debate. High praise should be given to the Churches for the role they have played. The various social bodies and councils should be taken into account for the work they are engaged in. The greatest source of failure of all with regard to marital breakdown is the lack of communication.

I speak regularly in the House about family businesses and how we should protect the family business, how we should endeavour to preserve the family business. My concern here tonight is for the preservation of the family as a unit. We are all concerned about the preservation of the family unit. This is my personal view. At approximately 9 o'clock this evening I had a telephone call from a person with a young voice. I said "Michael Lynch speaking" and he asked: "Where are you from"? I said: "Leinster House" and he said: "Sorry, wrong number". Being conscious of the debate that was taking place in the House tonight, and throughout the day, I tried to have a short conversation with this young person. He kept on apologising that he had telephoned the wrong number. It reminded me of the innocence of youth.

I sat down in that office and asked myself where do people go wrong? At what stage of life do all these problems arise and for what reason? Is it a gradual development or is it a combination of social depression or social depravity coupled with an acceptance of dominant outside influences? I fear that the day may come when we will have children in this country who will experience, not just their first, second, but their third or maybe even their fourth set of parents, which has happened in other countries. I am very concerned about that.

I would much prefer to be here discussing ways and means of trying to help to alleviate many of the problems in relation to marital breakdown. There are many problems and many situations where marriages are seemingly on the rocks but with goodwill and the necessary help the problems could be resolved. As I see it, for the very good and strong marriages, legislation, whether for or against divorce will have no impact whatsoever. For the weaker marriages, it could tip the scales towards a way out, the handy way out, which is not always the right way. Certainly, it would not be the right way in this instance.

The Taoiseach in his speech remarked that the legislation would stabilise the marriage structure. For me that is impossible to comprehend. With all due respect to what sincerity was behind that statement, I just cannot figure out how that could be.

I, in conscience fear greatly the consequences of this amendment if it is carried. There are many questions that I could ask. There are many questions that should be answered before the Bill leaves this House. Perhaps, some of them have been asked by other speakers here. For instance, who will pay the legal fees and for the legal aid and what will be the cost to the State? We should not always put money before people. I am not doing that but these are questions that will have to be answered. If this legislation is carried, they are situations that will have to be faced up to. It is quite possible that the Minister could be back with a supplementary Budget to cover the cost to the State. The taxpayer will have to carry the can as usual.

Comment on this

That is all behind me.

Comment on this

What constitutes a failed marriage? I could ask many questions on this issue. I have known of cases where families have apparently separated and yet come together once a year for Christmas. Could those marriages be regarded as failed marriages? I have expressed my views on life as I see them and on the family unit. I am fearful that this amendment could erode the family unit. On the day of the referendum, I will be personally voting against it.

Comment on this

I should like to say from the outset that I support this Bill and the various recommendations it entails. It is quite clear at this stage that we have a significant degree of marriage breakdown in this country and that we, as politicians, have a duty to put some order and reason into the confusion that has resulted from that level of breakdown. We have separations, both legal and otherwise, barring orders, marriages dissolved by decrees of nullity and also church annulments. Some of these procedures allow remarriage, thereby causing difficulties for children of the first marriage who are deemed illegitimate and both partners lose maintenance and succession rights vis-à-vis each others' estates.

Some groups argue that the current proposed divorce legislation, even though very restrictive, will in some way undermine existing marriages. I believe, that though this may be a very sincerely held view, it is both an insult to and an act of no confidence in the thousands of stable and secure marriages in the country. Family tradition and a strong marriage bond is rooted in the Irish culture. I am convinced that a very restrictive form of divorce legislation will not seriously affect us. In the context of this debate Ireland has been compared to such places as Las Vegas and California. It has been inferred that marriage breakdown and divorce in these areas will simultaneously arise in this country. It is nonsense, I feel, to compare the cultural traditions of either a place like Las Vegas or California with the cultural traditions and family ethos of Ireland.

On the actual wording of the legislation, I feel that separation and failure prior to a decree of divorce being granted should be clearly clarified. The Minister and the Minister of State, Deputy Fennell, have done that in their speeches on Second Stage in both Houses. However, before the Bill leaves this House the issues should be clearly and precisely clarified, especially in relation to separation. There seems to be some ambiguity as regards length of time, what a period of five years involves. Could two people living together for five years claim they were separated because they may not have been sharing the same bedroom or maybe because they had some differences? I feel that this whole period of five years is not clearly enough defined. There should be a definition of when the five year period is deemed to have begun and expired.

The basic difference between legal separation and divorce has been mentioned several times in this House today. It simply is that divorce confers the right to remarry. This is both a compassionate and humanitarian approach to adopt. there are now thousands of second unions in the country which are stable and happy. In many cases there are children of these unions. These are family units but do not have any legal status whatsoever. The report of the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown states that such stable but non-marital relationships may create an element of insecurity which can lead to further breakdown and trauma for the couple and the children. The joint committee report also states that the number of second relationships will increase and that the number of children which result from such relationships will increase too. For this reason I feel it is very important to update our laws on marriage. Otherwise, as has been stated, our legal system with regard to marriage breakdown and family law could fall seriously behind.

I welcome the establishment of the new family court system which will deal with judicial separation. These new courts will be much more sensitive to the feelings of the couple involved and will be less formal and confrontational than the normal court setting. The family court will play a key role in recommending mediation and will attempt to bring about reconciliation. The case Senator Lynch referred to could be dealt with by the family court. He mentioned a marriage that was on the rocks and that if divorce was available at the time it could have broken up but, because the couple involved made an effort and worked hard at it, they became a very compatible couple. These courts could fulfil that type of function. A divorce decree can only be granted when the court has decided that there is no reasonable possibility of reconciliation.

Furthermore, the court makes various financial orders to ensure that the interests of a dependent spouse and children are adequately protected and provided for. The court will be very important and the people who are appointed to the courts will have to be suitably qualified in family law. Apart from that, they should have immense experience in dealing with family law. These people will have to be skilled and understand the whole psychology of the matrimonial relationship.

I welcome the proposal that in future the minimum age of marriage will be 18 years. I have always been concerned about people getting married at a very young age. They are frequently financially insecure and are also emotionally and psychologically immature. That is not to say, of course, that these marriages have never worked in the past. In fact, some people who were married at a young age have very successful marriages but, generally speaking, people who get married at a very young age are under more pressure. Such marriages are often due to pregnancy, which is not the best basis for a marriage. Research has already shown that marriages involving young persons are more likely to break down than marriages between persons of more mature years.

I am also somewhat disappointed that detailed consideration has not been given to education for marriage and pre-marriage preparation. The State must do everything possible to prevent or minimise the extent of marital breakdown, I have emphasised, again and again, in this House the importance of education — sex education and, in the case of marriage, relationship education. This would have a very important bearing in the preparation of people for marriage.

I would also like to refer to the report of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown. In Chapter 3 it dealt with education and I refer to section 3.11. Throughout the deliberations of the committee there was a constant emphasis on the importance of being prepared for marriage. Many submissions which were received by the committee pointed out the need for a structured approach to educating people for marriage so that, in so far as possible, all persons who marry are aware of the duties and obligations, rights and liabilities which are directly involved. In section 3.13 it was pointed out that the committee were aware that some of the problems which gave rise to the breakdown of marriage are present before the marriage. The committee stressed the need for an education process to reduce the element of uncertainty so as to promote awareness, reflection and mature consideration by all parties.

I believe education has a key role to play and in a submission to the committee it was pointed out by Dr. Jack Dominian, a clinical psychiatrist with a central Middlesex hospital, that education for relationships should be an essential part of education in schools and that students should be taught about personal relationships, about trust, communication, affection and understanding. These traits provide the basis on which a successful marriage can be built. I appeal to the Minister and to all concerned to emphasise the need to set afloat in the schools and the curriculae a relationship educational programme that would prepare people in a better manner for marriage. I am convinced that within the present educational system we need an integrated and specific programme geared to the preparation for marriage.

Deputy Hussey, the former Minister for Education, dealt with this on a number of occasions and at the time she was very concerned and committed to implementing such a programme, but, unfortunately, recently the same commitment seems not to be there. It is important to reconsider the immediate implementation of a proper relationships educational programme in our schools. Choosing a partner and getting married is the single most important act in one's life. It, therefore, requires adequate and serious preparation. This brings me to the question of providing direct pre-marriage guidance immediately prior to a marriage. The provision of such pre-marriage courses is rather haphazard at present. In some dioceses it is compulsory for Catholics to attend, but this is not universal.

The State plays no role whatsoever in the direct provision of pre-marriage courses. The State will have to fund adequately the existing agencies in the fields and also establish, where necessary, non-denominational courses for those who wish to avail of them. The compulsory aspect has to be handled very sensitively. The State should create a climate for pre-marriage courses where people entering marriage would feel inadequately prepared unless they had completed such a course. I appeal to the Minister to refer to this when he is replying and inform us of any intentions his Department may have of setting up State-sponsored, pre-marrriage courses. Any such courses could include the following: an understanding of the nature of marriage, the importance of communication, responsibilities and obligations within marriage, an awareness of human sexuality, family planning and family law and finance.

It has been mentioned here already by Members from all sides of the House that the best basis for a happy marriage is a happy and secure family background and childhood. At present, the three factors which cause most stress in families are unemployment, poverty and the abuse of alcohol. If we as a nation could eliminate these, we would have a fair degree of success in preventing marriage breakdown, and minimise the necessity for divorce. I am quite pleased and happy with the efforts being made by our Government to alleviate the problems mentioned above. Hopefully, the new liquor laws will ensure that, as a nation, we can become less dependent on alcohol which is the root of many of our social problems, especially within marriage.

Several arguments have been put forward against the introduction of divorce — I must say very sincerely by Senators from the other side of the House. It has been pointed out that the 50 year ban has served us well in producing the lowest marital breakdown figure in Europe. I feel confident that, following the introduction of divorce, we still will have, and continue to have, the lowest marital breakdown rate in Europe. Some speakers pointed out that divorce seems to produce more problems than it solves. For example, according to some Senators it increases emotional problems, litigation, social security payments and demands on the welfare services. Again, divorce may contribute to these problems but certainly unresolved marital breakdown can have similar effects.

It has been pointed out that divorce, when introduced, would have a snowballing effect. As I mentioned already, this is an insult to those people who are already married. It has been pointed out also that if it is introduced the nature of marriage will have changed; no longer will it be a lifelong commitment. I feel that for Catholics the law will not have changed; if I get married within the Catholic Church that lifetime commitment is still there. It has also been pointed out that divorce undermines family life, damaging especially the more vulnerable women and children and families. The converse can be true, that a marriage which is not working can have even more undesirable effects.

Senators in favour of the Bill have agreed that it is unjust and unfair and lacks compassion to prevent people, some totally without fault, from re-marrying. It was also pointed out that children suffer more when unhappy marriages are kept going by legal rules. This morning Senator Ross said we are out of step with Northern Ireland, and indeed, with most western democracies and many other countries. The fact that divorce is available to Catholics in Europe should entitle Catholics in our country to have the same privilege. After all, we are in the same Common Market at the moment.

It has also mentioned that the unavailability of divorce limits personal freedom by enforcing one religious viewpoint. Minority religions allow divorce in this country. Marriage breakdown is due to the collapse of a relationship and is not its cause. Both arguments, for and against have been very well put in this House. I do not doubt for a moment the sincerity of those people who have opposed the amendment here tonight. However, the arguments put forward by various speakers in favour of divorce certainly convince me of the need for the amendment.

I should also like to refer to the position of the Catholic Church. I fully appreciate the position of the Catholic Church and the right of the Catholic bishops to speak out on this very important issue. The Catholic Church's insistence that the family unity be preserved and protected has also been recognised and appreciated by this Government. No one individual in this House disagreed or would disagree with the above sentiment. However, the amendment itself is a reasonable and moderate one and should be supported on compassionate and humanitarian grounds.

Finally, I should also like to pay a special compliment to our Taoiseach and Leader for bringing forward this very important and vital legislation. He has displayed immense courage in doing so. He has again displayed the great characteristics of true leadership.

Comment on this

I am glad to get an opportunity to make my contribution on this Bill. As I said this morning, I am disappointed that we are sitting at this late hour and proceeding in this manner because really I do not think there is any necessity for it. Another week would make no difference in my view. If it would, this should have been thought of in time so that we could deal with the Bill in the ordinary way. By taking it in this manner, the spotlight is more or less taken off areas like unemployment and other problems the Government should be dealing with.

Comment on this

They are dealing with such problems.

Comment on this

I sincerely hope they are. The point I am trying to make is that we could deal with this Bill in the ordinary way. While it is important and I know it is necessary to deal with it in as short a time as possible, nevertheless it is undignified and unnecessary to bring it forward in this way.

My contribution will be made in no particular sequence. I just jotted down some notes as the ideas came to me. I will go into the areas I feel are important. I have already explained my position: it is on the record of the House. I stated that regarding marital breakdown I could not envisage any satisfactory solution which did not include divorce in certain limited and extreme circumstances. At the time my point of view got considerably exposure, principally by Gulliver in The Sunday Press. I am sure everybody is aware of my point of view. I have the same point of view still. This Bill meets the criteria I laid down and that I would expect. Therefore I will be voting “yes”.

I want to say also my particular line — I will not say causes me embarrassment — makes me feel somewhat uncomfortable in so far as I am making the same case as Members on the other side of the House. However, I have always felt there are some matters which are above party political considerations.

Comment on this

The Senator is to be congratulated on his integrity.

Comment on this

There are some matters that are above party political considerations. There are areas where people should not be constrained by party politics and once that is conceded it follows that this is one area that would fall into that category because of its importance and sensitivity. I want to thank my party for allowing me to give my individual views: they are solely that. It is rather unusual for parties to take this line and I am glad to have the opportunity to put on the record of the House my personal views in this area.

I have no exaggerated notion regarding my competence to express views or opinions that would be helpful. When the report of the Joint Committee on Marriage Breakdown came before this House I spoke for about two-and-a-half hours on three occasions. I remember at the end of that time one of my colleagues asked me if I had contributed or if I intended to contribute. I am under no illusion that I made any outstanding contribution or original comment on that occasion. I am still in the same position. I have nothing original to say. I have no special insights but at my stage in life I can look into my heart and, while I do not like what I see — I have a fairly good picture of my shortcomings — I feel that, from my experience, both personal and in the society in which I grew up, and due to my special concern, my sympathy, my love and, above all my intellectual honesty in those areas, what I have to say will have some relevance.

It has been a struggle to come to this decision as I am sure it has been for every other Member of the House. It is a very grey area but we must make our stands and determine whether we are coming down on the side of black or white. I have been consistent at least. I do not wish to claim that consistency is necessarily a virtue because often there are changes in a situation which would lead one to a change of mind. There could be circumstances which could make deviation necessary and where it would be correct. Those who have thought deeply about this subject are not easily changed. I could not be changed regarding my viewpoint in this situation. In most cases I would have doubts in coming to a decision but I am perfectly satisfied and happy that my decision in this regard is the correct one.

My reasoning is very simple; maybe too simple. I am leaving the legalistic end to the lawyers. I am looking at it from the simple viewpoint of a layman. Marriage is for happiness, above all. All those who enter into that state do so in pursuit of happiness. Happiness in marriage is very often bought at a very great price. I do not know how we could put a figure on that price: I do not know if it would be possible to measure it in that way. I would determine the value from the other side, from those who are not prepared to pay the price. I would like to give a few examples. The alcoholic who refuses treatment is not prepared to pay the price. I do not want to be unfair to alcoholics. They have a big problem and I suppose a stage is reached at which they are not responsible. Nevertheless, for some time along the line there must be the voice of conscience or some other voice within an individual saying that this is the wrong choice if a man leaves his wife at home looking after children while he goes out and spends money on drink, money that should be spent on the family and the home. He spends the time he should spend with his wife and family in the pub. He comes home in a silly state. That man is not prepared to pay the price. The husband who abuses his wife is not prepared to pay the price. He is not prepared to make the effort to control his emotions. The criminal who is in prison for a long time or the gambler are not prepared to pay the price. In this week's edition of my local paper The Meath Chronicle there is a letter from a young woman whose marriage has broken up. In one part of it she stated:

I think it is hysterical and misleading for the anti-divorce lobby to say that divorce causes marital breakdown. What usually causes marital breakdown is mental cruelty, physical cruelty, alcoholism, infidelity, desertion.

They are the areas I have mentioned in a different sequence. I suppose somebody who has gone through that trauma and experienced the pain and pangs of that situation is in a better position than I to determine the correct sequence. Nevertheless, drink is one of the great curses in this country. I am not against drink; I am against the abuse of drink and therefore I would regard that as the number one problem. There are other areas of serious neglect or defect within a marriage. All of these are unwilling to pay the price. It is too high. In every instance there is a minimum price to pay. When we say marriage is for life we are really saying to all those selfish people "Do whatever you like, your spouse must put up with you for life." That is wrong. It is giving freedom to those who do not play the game. I do not agree with that. While I am not saying every wife in any of those situations should get divorced, what I am saying is that because the spouse is not playing the part that they should play divorce should be available to them.

If I employ someone I expect them to come on time, to be diligent, to have an interest in the work and, if not, I let them go. Marriage is for life. It is the most important relationship and it seems extraordinary that there are no rules of behaviour. We only need love to initiate a marriage and seemingly love is not considered to be needed to maintain it. I do not agree with that. Life is very difficult in a marriage situation where there is love; it is impossible where love dies; but what is it like when love turns to hate? We can visualise that situation. We know families with that problem. There are cases where couples try and fail. They make an honest attempt. There is such a thing as incompatability. Couples can drift apart. People develop in different ways. Mature people make sacrifices for the family. If a marriage has broken down, failed, as it is termed in the Bill, for five years, the choice of divorce should be available.

There are people within the stresses of a relationship who have not the capacity to grow in love. How many I do not know. It is related to the stresses of modern living. This has been developed at some length by other Members. It is going to increase. This increase in marriage breakdown is to a large extent a function of the improvement in the standard of living, so that has its drawbacks. When we are young we are all naive, and many people learn the hard way. When I was young I felt that, if somebody fell in love, worked hard, got the material comforts, and had everything that was needed, happiness would follow. It is a big jolt to realise that we are wrong. Many people have found that happiness was in the striving, not in the achievement. When they got there, they had everything the wanted but happiness seemed to evaporate.

Because my marriage is stable and because I am married to a wonderful girl, I have no right to condemn where there is marital failure and say "You cannot start again. You did not try hard enough. You made your bed and must lie on it." I do not believe that. When I come across a spouse, young or old, left forever, do I lecture that marriage is for life or do I feel that a caring God would understand and allow a fresh start? Divorce is objectionable — and I am sure everybody in the House would share that view — but this limbo is far more so in my view. People marry for a sexual relationship and they are denied this in a broken marriage. The Catholic Church forbids sexual intercourse outside marriage. We live in a predominantly Catholic country, so 90 per cent of the problems that arise involve Catholics.

This raises another issue which again has been dealt with. I favour a pluralist State. The tenets of one particular faith should not be implemented in legislation or the Constitution. We should acknowledge freedom of the rights of other religions. Their choice should not be bounded by another belief, a different religious outlook.

Catholics loyal to their beliefs may not remarry after divorce. Catholics loyal to their beliefs may not use artificial contraceptives according to the teaching of the Church. I am not saying they should not. I am stating the fact. Many of them do and in conscience can do it. I am sure they are right. I believe in other countries where divorce is available the problem is no different with regard to Catholics. Catholics get divorce at the same rates as other religions. If the same happens here — I am not saying it will happen here, but there are others who say it will happen here — then we are denying this choice not just to members of other religions but to those of the majority religion who would not be inhibited. We cannot say that these members of the Catholic faith remain faithful when they have no choice in the matter. Looked at in another way, the Church is using the State through its laws to enforce its doctrine. This should not be. The Catholic Church, I believe, has the right to lay down rules and insist that they be observed by those with that particular religious conviction. I believe it does not have the right, or any other religion in a majority situation, to have any of its rules enforced by Constitution or statute.

I said before, as did many other Members, that tolerance and pluralism are very important with regard to the rights of minority religions and many people would not be categorised in a religion at all. On many occasions in the past I have deplored the fact that all over the country we are losing the small Protestant churches. It is terribly sad in my area to see those churches being knocked and got rid of. It is not just a religious loss; in my view it is a cultural loss. I remember in the past — and other people have commented to me on the situation on Sundays when people of both denominations went to their churches regularly. In the old days they would pass by at the same time on a Sunday in the trap to service. Those who lived near the churches heard the hymns being sung and the service. It is terribly sad that that is no more.

I feel we have a place in our country for those people. I say to the people of that religious persuasion, and all religious persuasions: "We have a place for you". But that should be shown in a practical way. A very practical way to state it, and to state it very clearly, is to show that we have a place in our Constitution for those people, not just in relation to Article 44 but in relation to the civil rights of those denominations. Most of the objections against legalising divorce are based, I feel, on religious convictions — not all but most of them. To make those values mandatory in Statute is the antithesis of pluralism.

Desmond M. Clarke in The Church and State, which was published by Cork University Press in 1984, had this to say in that regard:

The fundamental inspiration of pluralistic legal systems is that the rights of minorities are valued just as highly as the rights of majorities, and that the legal system should refrain as much as possible from enforcing values which are patently religious. Apparently, the Catholic Hierarchy in Ireland does not believe that most of the values they support are purely religious. They think that these values are supported by reason. But this is usually the case with any religious group. Religious believers often assume that "reason" supports their belief, even in the face of obvious dissent from rational people who share different religious views.

The test of whether a belief is religious or not is not what its supporters say about it. Rather, if accepting some belief systematically coincides with being a member of a Church, then such a belief ultimately rests on religious faith.

The Catholic Church's teaching about the morality of contraception is a clear example of this. I would state quite categorically that the teaching in regard to divorce is a clear example of this, it seems to me. Then the author goes on to deal with the rejection of religious liberty and of pluralism, as usually understood. It makes for different problems, which he goes into later. He states that:

The overruling of free choice of those who disagree with us by legislation is often justified by paternalism.

Further on in a later chapter he argues that:

Except in special circumstances paternalism cannot be morally justified because it undermines the essential presupposition for any moral system, which is the autonomy of individuals.

I am deeply sorry that we have failed in passing on the values we inherited. I am sure everyone else in this House feels the same. I am no different. In my youth we had a more docile society, though inhibited in many ways. Some of the values at that time I would question also. But it would not be appropriate to deal with that in making my contribution on this Bill. But there was not the same emphasis on these values. Sex outside marriage and the stigma attached to the unmarried mother has all changed. At present we have girls as young as 16 years of age becoming pregnant. We have people cohabiting and rearing a family without being married. But at the same time I feel that society is more understanding of the people in this situation, and very rightly so. In my view that is a very good and very proper thing.

As I said, most of these problems are related to the stresses of modern living. It is the price of progress. I feel that it is wrong that we should bury our heads in the sand when it comes to dealing with those problems. Of course, some stresses spring from a conflict of values. To give one instance, children are taught, as we were taught, religion in schools. They are taught the commandments, I am sure, the same way as we were. I am sure in particular with regard to the area of sex there is the same emphasis on the sixth and ninth commandments as when I was going to school. Children are taught in this way what is right and proper. Then they come back into their homes and turn on the television to watch Dallas or Dynasty where, I believe — I do not watch those programmes, I do not have time — married people are jumping into bed with different partners. This is indicative of a good time, so what choice these children can make I do not know. Certainly if I was taught one thing in my religious classes at school and saw a far more attractive and immediate concept on television I would not have the strength to make the proper choice. I do not blame any of those people who are not able to make the choice. I do not want censorship, yet I am concerned about the effect of these types of programmes on the youth.

In other areas also we have got this problem. I am a member of the Joint Committee on Women's Rights — a hard working committee, and on 14 May we met a group from the Rape Crisis Centre dealing with the problems associated with rape. These programmes were discussed and I can say the members of the Rape Crisis Centre, were the most impressive group that I had the pleasure of meeting at any of those meetings. With regard to Dallas and Dynasty they stated that those films showed people getting into bed and nothing more, but children have their own imagination and any intelligent child does not believe that those people are getting into bed for a rest. The Rape Crisis Centre also talked about video nasties and their widespread availability portraying sexual violence and pornographic material. This debases the human being, especially women. I will quote from their statement in relation to video nasties:

Video nasties are a brutal, horrific, ugly and debased representation of human relationships and sexuality. Their current popularity raises serious questions about the direction in which our society is headed. How can people sit down and watch gross violence and bloodshed and rapes and brutally explicit sexual humiliation as a form of entertainment and pleasure.

Where is our society going? But apparently that is the reality and there is no point in sticking our heads in the sand.

People have said to me that I support divorce. Nothing could be further from the truth. I do not support divorce. I want people to live in married bliss, living together in a Christian way, husband and wife working hard to satisfy and compliment one another and bringing up their children properly. I support everything that is good in marriage, above all happiness. But I also support a means of escape for those trapped in broken marriages.

I note the intention to increase the age for marriage to 18 years. I thought that was already decided. I agree with that. It is hard to know what the proper age for marriage should be. In one sense I believe that young people are resilient, flexible and adapt to new situations quickly; older people very often can be set in their ways but nevertheless most problems are related to marriages of young couples. They are not aware of the power of their own or their spouse's emotions and therefore it is a mistake to marry too young. Before marriage there should be a proper marriage guidance course and counselling and I want to congratulate all of the Churches who organise such courses. I also want to congratulate the clergy and the volunteers who have given their time and patience to such courses. It is necessary to inform people and certainly in this area ignorance is not bliss and ignorance can never bring bliss.

Over 30 years ago I remember going to Navan to a rally which was addressed by Fr. Peyton, the family priest. There was a large crowd at that rally and his motto was that the family who prays together, stays together. At that time the family rosary was recited in most Catholic homes. I wonder how many homes recite it now, but that is not my point. Fr. Peyton made a point which has always remained with me. He stated that when two people get married they have picked one another out from all the billions in eternity. Whether their meeting was providential or accidental they have been brought together and they should make every effort to make their marriage work. They should show responsibility rather than run away from the problem.

That lovely picture has always stuck in my mind. It is still true but in spite of the best attempts, in spite of sacrifice, we have breakdown. The saddest demise of all must be the death of love — so much hope, expectation, everything that is beautiful in life, in particular for young people because they have life before them to enjoy, to bring happiness to one another, and then there is the death of love. There is the loneliness, the emptiness, the despair and the lack of communication.

In the planning laws there is the clause which is referred to as the withering clause. It never seems to me to be quite appropriate for planning legislation. The withering clause would certainly be very appropriate in the area of marriage and marital breakdown when love withers away. Love needs to be nourished and tended. It is a very tender plant. It needs proper soil.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As it is midnight, would the Deputy Leader of the House say when it is proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

It is proposed to sit at 10 a.m. on Friday, 23 May 1986.

Comment on this