We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Transport (Re-Organisation of Córas Iompair Éireann) Bill, 1986: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–159 of 324. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Transport (Re-organisation of Córas Iompair Éireann) Bill, 1986
Enacted

No. 8 of 1986 ›

Amendments Nos. 1 and 2 are similar. Amendments Nos. 3, 6 and 12 are consequential. Amendments Nos. 1, 2, 3, 6 and 12 may be discussed together.

Comment on this

Or may be dealt with separately too.

Comment on this

If the Senator wishes we can have separate decisions on them.

Comment on this

A single debate and a separate decision on them.

Comment on this

If amendment No. 1 is not accepted, Nos. 3, 6 and 12 cannot be moved. Amendment No. 2 can only be moved if amendment No. 1 is withdrawn. This is a little complicated.

Comment on this

That certainly is very complicated. I do not agree to that.

Comment on this

If you read the amendments and the section you will agree to it.

Comment on this

I will not agree to the last statement the Cathaoirleach made, that only if amendment No. 1 is withdrawn No. 2 becomes operative.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 2 has the same effect as amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

Why are we short-circuiting? What is the idea of us going through this Bill in this manner?

Comment on this

We are not.

Comment on this

I put down amendments in a reasonable manner. They have been down for some time and I find today that those new amendments are in today and they are all consequential. I would like to have fair play here.

Comment on this

If the Senator looks at amendments Nos. 1 and 2, he will see that they are similar.

Comment on this

Not on the basis that amendment No. 2 only comes into it if amendment No. 1 is withdrawn.

Comment on this

If the Senator gets into any trouble the Chair will get him out of it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 4, subsection (1), lines 18 to 20, to delete subsection (1) and substitute a new subsection as follows:——

"6.—(1) The Board shall cause two companies limited by shares conforming to the conditions laid down in this Act, to be formed and registered under the Companies Acts."

I would like to put it in the context of the position that has developed since the Second Stage debate on the Bill. As the Seanad will know, during the debate on Second Stage, members of my party expressed various concerns in relation to the Bill as originally drafted. We indicated, at that time, we would welcome the opportunity of having discussions with the Minister prior to Committee Stage. Those discussions have taken place and arising from them I am glad to say we have reached agreement on a number of matters which were contentious between us during Second Stage. The areas in which we have agreement are indicated in the amendments tabled in the name of the Minister, with one exception which arose for different reasons.

At the end of that process of discussion, some matters of difference still remained between us. These are indicated in the amendments tabled in my name. Those amendments do not represent a personal position, although I obviously support them. They are the view of my party and are tabled in my name on behalf of my party.

I hope during the course of this Committee Stage debate that we will be able to resolve the differences which remain following our discussions with the Minister. Significant improvements, in my view, in the Bill have been made with the assistance and full co-operation of the Minister. I hope, as we progress through Committee Stage, that we can reach further agreement on the matters outstanding still. As Senators in my party said during the Second Stage debate, it is clearly in the public interest, and in the interest of the workforce in CIE that that company should be made as efficient, as cost effective and as consumer-orientated as possible. That is in everybody's interest and in the national interest.

We welcome the very rapid increases in productivity which have taken place within the company since 1983. We welcome the initiative in 1983 to set down clearly the financial framework within which the company can operate. That framework makes it possible for the company to see ahead and not to be in a position where they do not know from one year to the next what financial arrangements will be made to support the operation of their transport system.

Significant gains have been made in terms of productivity, increased efficiency and in terms of the ability of the company to plan forward. The position of my party in the Second Stage debate was that we were not at all clear as to the reason why they should be subsidiary companies. The arguments that have been made for subsidiary companies are that greater transparency can be achieved in the financial arrangements for the various services offered by the company if there is a subsidiary company structure and, secondly, that more efficient management can be achieved through subsidiary company operations because of the smaller scale on which the operations are taking place.

Most of us argued during the Second Stage debate that it is equally possible to achieve the level of transparency of accounts required and the level of efficiency which is appropriate and desirable through the creation of divisions within the one company as through the creation of subsidiary companies. That seems to me to be still a case that has not really been met to any degree of satisfaction.

On the question of transparency the annual accounts of CIE are very transparent. I instanced this on Second Stage by indicating the very large numbers of accounts that are shown in the annual accounts that companies hold covering every aspect of the company's work, including refreshment rooms in restaurant cars working account, canals working account — that is now transferred to the Board of Works — international activities working account, road freight working account, vessel working account and so on. The accounts of CIE are highly transparent at the moment within the context of one company. There is no doubt that they can be disaggregated even further should that be required.

On the question of efficiency of management and questions of management being essentially more efficient through smaller scale operations, that can be achieved just as well in a divisional structure. We know of many companies internationally which are larger than CIE and which operate on a divisional structure basis. The basic position of our group is that the benefits, which subsidiary companies are intended to deliver, can be delivered within the existing single company structure just as well, but the single company structure has additional benefits which seem to us to be fairly significant, the benefit of integrated public transport provision, which is referred to in another amendment which I have down and the benefit of complementarity, sharing of resources and so on.

We recognised, during the course of the Second Stage debate that the Minister feels strongly that subsidiary companies offer a better opportunity to achieve the objectives that I mentioned. We are anxious to reach an arrangement which will be mutually satisfactory. It was in an attempt to reach that arrangement that we suggested the notion that CIE should, if the company have to be divided into subsidiary companies, be divided into two such companies rather than three, one covering Dublin city bus services and one covering the provincial road and rail services together with DART.

The rationale to the two companies idea as opposed to three is the following. Dublin city bus services are already an entity and recognised as such. They are already reasonably autonomous in terms of their operation within the company. It makes sense, if there has to be a subsidiary company structure, that Dublin city bus services should be one. Once you go outside Dublin, the argument for complementarity within the one company between provincial rail and provincial bus is very strong indeed. We are concerned with the notion, which is reflected in one of the amendments before us, that competition is expected to take place between provincial rail and bus in the future.

Obviously there will be, in the normal course of human events, some competition between rail and provincial bus. Some controlled competition is not entirely unacceptable provided it is geared towards the provision of an integrated transport service for the entire country. Competition is probably the wrong word. Separation of services would be better. Surely the outstanding point to be made is that we are trying to deliver an efficient public transport system country wide. It seems that can be best achieved if there has to be subsidiary companies through having one subsidiary company which is geared to seeing to it that provincial rail and bus operate, first of all, efficiently — everybody is agreed on that — and second, in a way where each is complementary to the other through careful planning, proper scheduling and proper resource allocation as between the two services. It seems that is better provided in one company with one management system and one board than in two. For this reason I have tabled this amendment on behalf of my party.

It is rational, in a society which is small both geographically and in terms of population to operate a public transport service in which bus and rail outside Dublin work closely together in a carefully controlled fashion, in which the decision that arises will be whether an area is better served by rail or road as oppposed to the idea that there should be two companies, one overseeing rail and one overseeing provincial bus, having as one of their objectives controlled competition between them. It is true to say that the holding company, the CIE board, would have under this Bill a responsibility to see to the affairs of all of their companies and to see that there is some degree of co-ordination between the activities of each of the companies. I would like to compliment the Government and the Minister on this. This is a significant improvement on the position as proposed by McKinsey in 1981 where he said that CIE should be abolished and there should be three separate independent companies operating in competition with each other without the benefit of a holding company board to control events and to institute proper planning.

It is for these reasons that I move this amendment. It is perfectly rational to have two companies, one company operating the public transport service outside Dublin city bus services. It will be seen in time that it is the most efficient way to do things and also the one which best meets the requirements of consumers who are at the centre of all our concerns in this matter.

Comment on this

One would have to agree with most of the sentiments expressed by Senator Flor O'Mahony on this amendment. As it is tied up with many other amendments as the Chair said I would like to have a look at it from a different point of view. I am disappointed that Senator O'Mahony could not qualify the facts that were circulated to every Senator concerning the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union and the negotiations that went on with them with members of the Government and of the Labour Party where certain promises seem to have been made. I am also disappointed that Senator O'Mahony has not mentioned NATE, the organisation representing the National Association of Training Engineers, in the Stella Ballroom at the Labour Party Conference in 1982 where certain promises and assurances were given by the Leader of his Party, Deputy Spring. "Guaranteeing" was the word that was used by a delegation that came to me to speak about their worries and anxieties concerning this Bill. I do not know what went on at the Labour Party Conference in Limerick but in the statement of that union they said publicly that clear and defined promises were made to them by the leader of the Labour Party.

It is not for that purpose that I have my amendments down. I would like to remind the House that they are aware of those promises which were made. I am surprised that the Labour Party did not come in here today to explain that matter. If a promise cannot be kept there is nothing wrong with that, but at least this House should be informed that promises were made. It is from that point of view that I make the point. They seem to be very upset about the situation in which they have been placed. I want to make that fact publicly known because that is an important fact in this matter. I wanted to talk about this from the divisional structural point of view that Senator O'Mahony spoke about, which sounds very reasonable, and the possibility of the administration from a single structure. There is no need for me to be repetitive on that point because it is something one accepts.

As regards the Minister's efforts here, I have to say, in fairness, that I do not see very much wrong with the view of going from the original proposal on report to this set up of the companies. The only problem I have with it is that it is absolutely ludicrous for the division into three companies rather than into two for the following reasons which are very pertinent. First of all, take the city arrangement. The taxpayers have spent an enormous amount of money on the DART proposal and it seems to be going to the satisfaction of the users in any event whether it is going to the satisfaction of those who are paying the piper is another question. At least it seems to be a good service. I will not talk about the cost of it at the moment because I do not have the figures as to whether it will ever be profitable.

I feel that service should have been tied in to the Dublin city bus services. The whole city and its environs should be under one administration. I know there would be huge complications as regards the right of way on the rail tracks for the DART service but I believe that it is part and parcel of the services in and out of the city just as much as the internal bus routes and the bus services of this city from a CIE point of view. One fits into the other and it is very natural and normal that they should be linked. There are probably snags but that is what we are there for. If there are complications we should be able to sort them out but once and for all we should have an efficient service in the city. That is our aim.

The Minister has not gone far enough. He will probably say to me that the complications are vast. If they are they should be resolved. There is a method for resolving such complicated matters and they should be taken in hand. We should have two rather than three companies. It is fatal to separate rail from rural bus services. That is exactly what we are doing.

Competition is the life of trade and it has certainly done a lot for CIE in recent times. I remember a time when you would get into a train in Galway city to go to Dublin and pay £19.50 or £21 if you were coming back within a couple of days. It was absolutely ludicrous. It is still that price if you are not in at a certain hour in the morning and if you are not one of those who are in before the first number of people who are getting on the train. Those days are gone. We should have a rapid, economical and good service.

The bus services feeding into that are of vital importance. The alternative to that is that we have the innovation of the luxury coaches doing their daily trips to and from the major cities and provincial capitals. They are doing it at a very low price varying between £10 and £6 and even £5 on occasions. That is the competition CIE have to look at because they are operative and they are being used by an enormous number of people whether we like it or not. There is no point trying to bring in legislation here that does not take that as a pointer. If we are going to separate rural bus and rural rail we will create more competition against something that is absolutely struggling. We should be making CIE more competitive. If they are separate companies — it is an important point and I hope the Minister will reply to it — how will the separation be made? Will there be a rapid train leaving Galway city at 8 a.m. and arriving here in town at 11.30 a.m.? Will there also be a rapid bus leaving Galway at 8 a.m. and arriving in Dublin at 11.30 a.m.? It does not sound reasonable. Third, will the local coaches start from Galway at 8 a.m. and arrive in Dublin at 11.30 a.m., all operating at varying costs?

CIE should be integrating the bus and rail services, making them more rapid, more competitive and tackling, as it were, this great new opposition that they have on the ground. CIE, from the services that they give around the country do not deserve to lose passengers. There is nothing we can do here about them if they do not shape themselves up into an efficient and competitive company and in these times and onwards offer an alternative and a better service than is on offer elsewhere in the private sector. I believe that that is an essential ingredient for the success of CIE rurally.

How, for example, in the intricacies of this Bill and the setting up of the three companies, are CIE going to divide up the properties they have around the country? Are they going to draw a white line across the railway station in any rural town and say: "That is bus; that is rail. If you cross to that side you are on the rail side, and if you cross on this side you are on the bus side". Instead of knitting the services together they are more or less separating them. There is not much logic to that. I cannot see any logic in running two parallel services from provincial cities to Dublin daily. I do not know what quantity of fuel is involved. The cost factor is not being taken into account. If the bus company is going to be separate from the rail company the bus company has to be viable. It is not going to be viable unless it offers good conditions, good facilities, speed and efficiency for long distance haulage.

At the same time we are running exactly the same service with CIE rail. What are we doing separating those two companies? Would we not be better off making a saving and giving a better offer to the passengers who chose to go by CIE, a service run efficiently and quickly and at a reasonable cost? I am not saying that costs should be lower or that they should be higher but they should be reasonable, CIE fares on trains today are absolutely unreasonable. The Minister will probably reply by saying that rail is losing money. I do not believe that the CIE structures of today can actually reveal who is or who is not losing money.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Minister for Communications (Mr. J. Mitchell) Fine Gael

That is exactly the point.

Comment on this

Yes, but if we are separating the companies to show that one or the other is losing money, then we are falling right into the trap. Surely there are structures within the framework of CIE which could accurately give us the facts. We remember the old strategies of days gone by; when CIE were dissatisfied with the rail line from Limerick to Sligo we know what happened; that line was closed. Two years prior to that CIE made a decision in their office, probably in Dublin, to close that line. They got the books out and loaded the figures and then two years later they presented the figures for that particular line and showed they were losing an enormous amount of money. Of course, it was shown by prepared accounts; I am not saying they were deceitful but they were prepared so that the light would shine down upon this great argument that was made at the time that this particular line was losing a small fortune. That was done. We know the tricks of the semi-State bodies. If we were in Government we were placed in the onerous situation that we had to defend the old tricks. Deputy Mitchell is placed in the same situation.

If we are honest with CIE and honest with ourselves we should say that there must be two companies. I am not too pushed about the holding company. Perhaps it is necessary to have a holding company, a watching company over them, but in the long term it will be proved to be ludicrous and stupid to separate rural rail from rural road, making the bus company and the rail company two separate companies. It does not stand to reason. I do not know why the Minister and the Government have made this decision. I think what they both need is assistance from each other rather than competition and that is what it is going to be.

Senator O'Mahony sort of apologised because there might be competition. It will be nothing but brutal competition. There will be a fall guy in that competitive world. Who will fall, I cannot predict. It seems from the whispers one hears around the country that it is the railways that will fall. Can we afford to let the railroads fall? Everybody will tell you the bus companies are making a profit in CIE. I do not know. I have not the figures. Other people will tell you the rail company will do well, that the bus company will fall. If the bus company falls who is going to feed the rail company? There is no imagination attached to this decision. I ask the Minister seriously at this stage to reconsider it. I think Senator O'Mahony has made the point very clear. It is a reasonable amendment. I would ask the Minister to accept it because we are only beginning this exercise. I think the public are baffled by what the Minister is doing. People are talking about this ludicrous decision to make two separate companies in the rural parts of the country. It does not seem logical.

We will be more than helpful to the Minister in any way we can because I know it is a difficult task to change such a mammoth organisation as CIE. I think this amendment should be accepted. I was not party to all the discussion that went on yesterday and the day before and on the Second Stage of this Bill. I know that the Labour Party and the Minister and the Fine Gael Party have had a lot of deliberations. I do not know whether they were cordial or not. The matter has been a thorn in the side of the Coalition Government; there is no question about that. I know they have received a few thorns in recent days and had a big one yesterday. I do not want to be political about it. I would like rather to be on the side of CIE on this issue, now that we are tackling the problem at last, and help to make CIE better for everybody including CIE. My kindness and generosity are always extended, I hope for the betterment of a good social service.

CIE has an element of a social service; that is not denied. People who think otherwise are just fooling themselves. If we do what the Bill proposes that portion of CIE that has a social service attached to it will be lost because the competition will wipe it out. I would rather see CIE basically in its rural operation attacking the market and attracting people to it, giving the comforts of their workplace to those that work in it and giving the comforts of good transport to the people who consistently used the service over the years until the alternative service became available, so as to win them back. I believe it can be done in this way. I shall certainly press this amendment.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I wanted to say that whatever about his sincerity I thought Senator Killilea would never be accused of having a short memory. I would like the House to recall the genesis of this Bill. The Fianna Fáil Government set up the McKinsey report. McKinsey made his report and in the meantime the then Deputy Mark Killilea was appointed a Minister of State at my Department.

Comment on this

Wrong.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Senator was Minister of State at my Department.

Comment on this

Wrong; it was at the Department of Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Which is part of the present Department.

Comment on this

No, it was not. Deputy Flynn was the Minister for State in the Minister's Department.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Senator was Minister of State in that Government. What did that Government decide? What memorandum was circulated by that Government — and was stopped when I became Minister? To accept McKinsey in full and break up CIE completely. Here is this patently insincere contribution from Senator Killilea today, when they proposed to break up CIE completely, to completely disestablish CIE and to accept in full the McKinsey report, how can the House expect me to accept that there is any sincerity whatever in what Senator Killilea has said? Moreover, much of what he did say would lead any logical person to the conclusion that what was needed in CIE was these three companies.

It is worth looking at the history of CIE over the past 20 years. I would point out that in every single year until I became Minister CIE's losses escalated and escalated so much so that between 1969 and 1982 the loss had gone up seven times the rate of inflation. Every year since it has come down in real terms. That situation has been brought about because of the policies I implemented within weeks of coming into office to stop the shenanigans of the way CIE was treated which is a story of the most appalling ineptitude and political recklessness. Most of the problems of CIE over the years have not been CIE's fault but have been visited upon them by politicians who have not addressed the problems sincerely and who have been expedient just like Senator Killilea is here. In the process the gap widened in those 13 years from a small loss to £109.2 million in 1982. If that had continued for another year or two we would now be talking about massive losses — £250 to £300 million.

We arrested that trend by introducing a new financial regime for CIE within months of my coming into office. We stopped the nonsense of telling CIE two weeks before the beginning of the financial year that their subvention would be as for the following year, usually a figure wishfully picked out of the air to fit in with the Book of Estimates. For instance, the figure picked out by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1982 and told to CIE a few days before I came to office on 14 December was £86 million when in fact they were about to declare losses for the year just finishing of £109 million. Yet, every single effort that CIE made to cut costs was blocked by perpetual, constant, day-to-day interference by the same politicians and then CIE were blamed. That has been changed. The financial regime which we have inaugurated is a five year projection whereby they know exactly where they stand; they know that if they beat the target they keep the money to pay off their debts, they have an incentive to work for and this has worked with dramatic effect. I never tire of repeating that everyone in CIE deserves credit for that. If I was criticising them today I know that would get headlines but the fact that I am praising them is not likely to get the same headlines but I do hope it is mentioned because it is important to people in CIE to know that the improvements have been noted.

This Bill is designed to cement that improvement, to guarantee the future of CIE and each of its components. That is what it is designed to do, to give it management closer to the ground in each case so that they can be flexible, so that they can act decisively in their own area. Senator Killilea also said this in relation to the closure of the Limerick-Sligo lines. He said that CIE came up with figures that he suggested were grossly exaggerated in order to justify the closing of that line. I cannot comment on the accuracy or otherwise of what Senator Killilea has said but it is possible within such a large conglomerate to reallocate overheads by taking very optimistic or very pessimistic assumptions. I believe that it has been at times a feature of what has happened in CIE. It has been one of the difficulties in getting CIE's costs under control. If those costs had not been got under control and had continued as they were, half, if not more of CIE would be on the scrap heap today. There would be no future for the railways and no future for the buses if the trend of 1969 to 1982 had continued any longer. It was escalating out of control.

We have achieved a turnaround in CIE's affairs without massive redundancies, without massive cuts in services which is something I was always confident of doing, having been very close to that company since my childhood. I want to reiterate that the purpose of the three companies is central to the Bill. If we did not have three companies there would be no need for the Bill. What is suggested is tantamount to saying: "Take out Dublin city services and leave the rest to CIE". There would not be a need for a Bill if that is all we wanted to do. We could have used section 14 of the 1950 Act to do that. Some people suggested we could divisionalise the company but the same difficulties would be there with divisionalisation as are there at the moment because if the board have not got clearcut boundaries of each company's activities where costs are clear, where profits are clear, where performance is clear there will always be a danger of allocating overheads optimistically or pessimistically which will not give clarity to the results and objects of the company.

We decided that the proposals of the Fianna Fáil Government and my predecessor, Deputy John Wilson, were not acceptable. We said "no" to the disestablishment of CIE, that it did not make sense because there are economies of scale that can be brought about, for instance, in centralised computer services, in joint maintenance of buses as between city buses and provincial buses and that there can be benefits for the entire group by the prudent exploitation and development of the assets of the group, something which has been disregarded for years. That is why we felt it was right to retain CIE as one group of companies. We also believed it right that there should be reorganisation of the group into three companies so as to give each of the main functions of the board its own management, its own clear objectives.

In relation to the provincial bus services and the railways — both of which are very big — even with this arrangement, the smallest company will have 2,500 employees, which by our standards is very big. I want the provincial bus company to be a learn and fit body, not to compete with the railways because the parent board will see to it that the interests of the group are looked after. In order to reiterate that point I have an amendment tabled to make it clear. I want the provincial bus company to get out there and compete with other operators who are poaching business from it and be in a position to react flexibly. It is absolutely crucial from that point of view to have its own separate management. Likewise, it is crucial, if the railways are to be as efficient, as economical, as cheap as possible — that is what Senator Killilea wants — that they have their own management with their own objectives.

One of the difficulties that has permeated CIE for years is industrial relations. If you consider the size of CIE it is not surprising that industrial relations has been a problem. Decisions have had to go up to the top in an organisation of up to 20,000 people. One of the reasons for the poor industrial relations, which admittedly in recent years has been mainly — not exclusively — a Dublin city services problem, has been the remoteness of management and because there was not clear management. One of the great benefits to be gained by the re-organisation into three companies will be better industrial relations because management will be closer to the ground and more ready to deal with the unions and the employees, be more responsive to their needs and be able to make decisions more quickly.

I cannot accept the amendments because to do so would undermine the central purpose of the Bill. Whatever Senator Killilea's motives in putting down his amendment, which is a complete contradiction of the stand taken by his party in Government when they wanted to go much further, I can understand that Senator O'Mahony's motives are somewhat different. The worries expressed by the unions are unjustified. Because they are unjustified I have gone to great length to remove them, by tabling extensive amendments to ensure that, if, in the most unlikely event any of the companies ceased to function, those employed on vesting day would be reemployed directly by the board and without interruption of service and the functions of that company would be resumed by the board without interruption.

We have tabled a very extensive amendment to section 17 which clarifies beyond doubt the rights of workers and their trade unions. I have tabled amendments to provide for the presence of worker members of the board on the subsidiary companies. We have clarified the question of competition between the companies; it will have to be controlled by the main board which will bear in mind the interests of the particular companies as well as the board. Those provisions make clear beyond doubt the security of tenure of the present employment of CIE workers, whether in the railways, provincial bus services or the city bus services, or road freight, it will not in any way be affected by the re-organisation. On the contrary, the re-organisation will greatly improve the prospects of CIE and each of its component companies. Because of the new structure, because of the new financial regime, the likelihood of success is all the greater.

The future of the railways is secure certainly for my lifetime. At present carriages are being built in Inchicore, a programme commenced since I became Minister. The lifetime of those carriages, which number about 130, will be 20 or 30 years. Senator Killilea's remarks —he seems to be trying to peddle fear — that railways are going to be closed, is absolutely and totally——

Comment on this

That is not a true statement. I am not trying to peddle fear. If the Minister wants to start off with that attitude we can cut a rough deal.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is, unfortunately, a view that would have to be taken——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Killilea will have an opportunity later.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The future of the railways is secure.

Comment on this

That is the Minister's interpretation.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Killilea will have an opportunity to reply in a moment; the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Without any doubt, the future of the railways is secure. The closer specific management will greatly improve that security. As long as the railways can operate within the financial target set out for them there is absolutely no problem. I am glad to be able to record that in 1983, 1984 and in 1985 the railways, like the other components of CIE, have met their target. There has been a very substantial renewal of the rolling stock in terms of coaches and in terms of DART.

The same is true for the city services. Dublin city services have a substantially new fleet: the provincial bus services have a substantially new fleet. The renewal of CIE which this Bill seeks to cement is built not only on the financial reforms I mentioned but also on huge investment over the last number of years, going back to the time when Fianna Fáil were in office, in a substantially new fleet of buses and new rolling stock.

While I understand some of the worries that have motivated some Senators, I hope the amendments which I have tabled will allay those fears. I hope that when the Bill is passed with three companies as proposed it will provide for the brightest possible future for CIE. That is its purpose.

Comment on this

I am sorry that the Minister has started off this debate in a most acrimonious manner. I have never heard such tripe from a Minister before. He has wafted himself away on a cloud of self-indulgence and self-praise. How can the Minister suggest to this House that the motivation behind the amendments of Senator Killilea and Senator O'Mahony was different? It is ludicrous that the Minister should read into these amendments things that are not in them. I understood that we were to discuss the future of CIE, the future of the workers of CIE and to ensure that whatever changes are made will be for the benefit not alone of the company or the State but of the employees. I can guarantee the Minister a rough ride here today if he continues in the vein he started in. We are here today to work for CIE and its workers and the State. But if the Minister indulges in personal attacks in regard to the motivation of Members on this side of the House, he will be here for a long time.

A number of matters which the Minister raised are suspect because he has not in any way addressed the problems put forward by Senators O'Mahony and Killilea today. He has not given one solitary good reason why there should be only two companies as against three. He suggested that there would be more efficiency in the running of CIE and its subsidiary companies. He told us that there will be closer co-operation on the ground and that there will be better industrial relations and no competition as between rail and road. How can he assure us that the railway will last his lifetime? I did not know that the Lord had come down and given the Minister a life span which can be compared to the life span of a railway. How can he give a life span for the railway system before the setting up of the new rail board if such will be set up? Has he taken away the powers from the main board to dictate what should happen in the railway system? If a new company to run the railways is to be set up has he already decided what will happen? Does this take away from these companies their raison d'être?

The Minister addressed himself in a very short aside to the situation of the workers.

While the amendments he has brought in may give absolute protection to the workers, he did not address himself to the problems which will be associated with the splitting up of CIE for instance, lack of promotional prospects because there will be three smaller companies. There will not be the same promotional prospects within smaller companies as there would be in a bigger company.

How will it be possible to ensure that competition will not be carried on as between road and rail? The Minister did suggest that there would be no such competition because the main board would ensure that this could not happen. What is the situation on the ground? When, for example, Kilkenny are playing Dublin on a Sunday morning and the rail company decide to run a special train to Dublin and the bus company decide to run special buses, does that mean that a decision will have to be made at board level as to which of these systems will work? This is simplifying a major problem which will arise if this system of break-up takes place, particularly outside the Dublin area.

It is ludicrous to think that we can split up the bus and rail services as they are set up at present. If that is done, local management structures, which are separate, will have to be set up. You will not be able to amalgamate your global services as they are at present to a large degree. Not alone will office space have to be split up but there will have to be separate telephone lines and all the various things which today are co-ordinated and which, being co-ordinated, are cheaper to run than separate service lines. It is absolutely certain that if you split up the rural bus and rail services, you will duplicate, to a large degree, many services throughout the country. There will be no savings.

There is a chance of improving management structures down the country. I do not blame local management for the inadequacies of the transport system as it is. The management system at local level do a good job within the constraints placed upon them by the Board of CIE at present. These same constraints will be there irrespective of whether there is one, two or three subsidiary companies, because the board will still have the final say in what happens in terms of management.

One question which the Minister posed was a very relevant one. He asked whether there was need for this Bill at all. There are a number of people who suggest that there is no such need but that there is a need for re-organising the management structure of CIE and if it were altered there would be absolutely no reason for the setting up of these companies. The Minister has not shown us that there will be increased efficiency in the separation of the various services as laid down here. He did mention that remoteness of management has created industrial problems throughout the country. But he did at least admit that the majority of industrial relations problems are related to Dublin city bus services. This is quite true.

I do not think that workers in CIE down the country have any feeling of remoteness from their local shop stewards and management if problems arise or, indeed, from the worker/directors in the regions in which they work. At least, I have not heard that it is remoteness which caused industrial relations problems. I agree that remoteness of the higher echelon of management would have something to do with many of the problems that have arisen. Perhaps one of the problems of the Dublin bus service is that they are so close to the management that they can see the inefficiencies at board level clearer than people down the country.

It is ludicrous to think that one can disassemble the rural bus and rail services. There has to be co-ordination between these services in terms of pricing structures, timetabling and competition. In the past, to a large degree, we have not had this co-ordination.

At our ports there has been no co-ordination of services as between ships coming into port and the rail or road transportation system from the ports. Again, there has been no co-ordination of services from the boats to areas where divergent routes are needed. We have seen people coming into Rosslare Harbour and having to wait for a bus or train to get to Waterford and then to wait five or six hours in Waterford to make a connection to the west or the midlands. There is need for the co-ordination of the services but there is no need for the breaking up of the provincial rail and bus services. There is a need for controlled competition as between road and rail.

As was suggested by Senator Killilea, there is a need for a realisation by people in CIE that the private bus companies are providing a very good service on 99 per cent of their routes. It is not a service that is being provided, as suggested by certain Members in this House and people outside of it, by cowboys who do not pay their taxes and proper rates of wages. Ninty nine per cent of the people who operate private buses in this country operate to a stricter regime than do CIE. If one goes along the road to see the maintenance of road transport, one would find that, because of the age of much of CIE's rolling stock, their maintenance is not up to the standard that the private bus companies have to adhere to. They have to have their MOT certificates. They have to have their tachographs right. They have to have their tyres right because they are stopped every day of the week. If they are not stopped by CIE bus inspectors, they are stopped by the Garda. If they are not stopped by the Garda they are stopped by the Department of the Environment checking their tachographs and so forth.

Comment on this

I met about half a dozen beautiful new CIE buses on the way up today.

Comment on this

Yes, but, unfortunately, the problem is that they are all beautifully liveried and half full.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Lanigan to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

If we could get the Americans back over here, we might be able to fill them if they stop running scared of the people of this country. I would ask the Minister to quantify the savings that will be made in terms of cash in splitting up these services into three. I should like the Minister to quantify the savings made in personnel throughout the country. I should like to ask the Minister how physically he will change premises, how physically he will not have to set up a duplication of offices.

Finally, I should like the Minister to satisfy us in this House that there is any justification for the break-up of provincial rail and bus.

There are major problems for Dublin Bus — many of these problems have to be taken in conjunction with the road system in Dublin. We can see that the road system in Dublin can get clogged up and the Dublin bus system has to fight against many elements it should not have to fight against. Changes will have to be made in the Dublin road system to ensure that the buses can run on a regular basis without too much hindrance except the normal hindrances that would apply in any urban scenario.

DART has been mentioned. There is a need to consider DART, whether as a separate entity or in conjunction with Dublin Bus, I am not too sure. It would appear that there is — and this was not referred to here at all — a need for an extension of the DART system to other areas of the city and other areas of the Dublin suburbs. If there is such an extension, the co-ordination aspect as between Dublin Bus and DART will have to be addressed very carefully.

The genesis of the Bill was mentioned as was the McKinsey report. Former Governments have also been mentioned. If we sat down here today and addressed ourselves to the problems as they are and to the future we would be doing a better job for CIE, for ourselves and for the country than going back, as the Minister attempted to do at the very beginning of this debate.

Comment on this

I should like to echo that last comment by Senator Lanigan. I do not think there is anything useful to be gained by going back. I could accuse Senator Killilea of making a Second Stage speech which is different from what he was doing on the section. A previous Fianna Fáil Government made a decision and it is different from this now. In fairness McKinsey itself differed.

Comment on this

I beg the Senator's pardon. We are dealing here with the Bill before us.

Comment on this

McKinsey deals specifically with the number of companies, which is what this amendment is about. The consultants in 1971 rejected the idea of breaking up CIE, saying that the major disadvantages would include, and I quote:

The loss of a single national integrated transport company with the benefits it can provide to the community; the diffusion of management talent over a large number of small companies; and the duplication of facilities such as personnel, the computer, research and engineering workshops which are shared at present.

That is stated at page 58 of the McKinsey report of 1971. McKinsey in 1981 had a different view. It called for the disestablishment of CIE as an entity and the formation of a national railway company, a Dublin bus company and a national bus company. On Second Stage I put on the record of this House that the Labour Party as a political unit were opposed to the philosophy of McKinsey. We gave that at national conference and we gave public commitments to that effect. The trade unions had reservations about it and expressed them to us and, I am sure, to Senator Lanigan and Senator Killilea. They have expressed them to the Minister, that in some way this Bill might be McKinsey by some side door or back door or it could be misrepresented as it. On Second Stage I put it to the Minister that it was his duty to reassure the House here that what he was doing, particularly regarding the two or three companies, would in some way reflect the views of the trade union movement, the views of us as politicians in this House but, more importantly, just to bring it above the plane of ordinary politics, which is what all of us want to do, we collectively are expressing a reservation what people in the country have particularly regarding diffusion of the number of companies, in that one of them, which to us in rural areas is of paramount importance, that is the provincial rail service, could suffer in a three-company situation. The Minister said that was dealt with in other sections of the Bill, that he had addressed himself to this problem and that that would not happen.

In the process of our discussion on this amendment, aided by the Minister's response, we will be able to overcome that problem. We will be able to reassure people that, if finally the Minister is adamant that this is what he wants, the people in the country, the workers and the users of the transport system will know exactly where they are going with a view to a future integrated transport policy as an overall Government responsibility and response to the demands.

I asked the Minister on Second Stage what was the reason for having three companies as opposed to two companies. I listened to him now when he said that it is imperative that management be responsible for the day-to-day running of any enterprise and that there must be some element of competition, otherwise there would be no incentive to provide a better transport system than is there at the moment. If there is a little element of competition between sections, that is a healthy thing provided we do not disregard the fundamental fact that there will always be a social element in that service, particularly for the transportation of our people. I have mentioned this on Second Stage and I mention it now. It is important that all the companies, no matter how many there are — and we will agree before the day is out possibly on the numbers — have regard to social need.

Comment on this

Who will agree?

Comment on this

This House will agree, right? I am talking to the House and I hope the Minister is listening.

Comment on this

They have not agreed yet. The Senator is looking at me.

Comment on this

No, I shall look at the Chair so. It is much more attractive than looking at the Senator.

Comment on this

This is the Parliamentary process that I talked about on the last occasion. It is a very important and useful thing for us, as elected people here, to carry out. It is imperative that there is inbuilt into all of them an element of social content to which the State must address itself and be financially responsible for; otherwise half the service in the country would be closed down for economic reasons and many people who need to be transported, who cannot afford private transport, would be at a disadvantage. I think the nation has a responsibility to ensure that there is a transport system to suit the people who are in that category. All of us, irrespective of our political affiliations, have agreed on that. We have agreed that that element must be there.

I had suggested to the Minister, because I realise that you must have a management structure at different levels, that you could have an overall policy formulating company called Córas Iompair Éireann, which would have a board elected to it, as of now, including worker directors, who make a very useful input into board decisions. I suggested that that board would have an overall managing director responsible for the whole integrated transport policy for the country, that they would sit intact and would distribute down to other boards their policy and their direction of how that policy should be carried out. In that formulation I felt that there was the possibility of having a board responsible for rail and national bus with their own management, worker directors included, and that we would also have a company called Dublin Bus who would have their own board, management and policy handed down from the top board.

That gives you the three board concept which the Minister is talking about. I understood in discussions we had with all the people interested in this that that formulation of what the Minister wanted would have been acceptable. The actual terms of Senator Flor O'Mahony's amendment addresses itself in black and white to that problem and proposes that we would have just two and not three. We can have a three situation within two, if we wanted to play about with numbers or with boards or with people whom we felt should be in the business of making decisions, who would have something to contribute to the actual process of providing a transport system.

Having discussed that particular prospect, could I now put it to the Minister that to achieve the same thing he wants to achieve, to achieve the same thing we want to achieve, in this three company situation, two of the companies would have, majoratively speaking, a similarity of membership so that they would not be going off an diverging tracks.

Comment on this

Going down the same road, which would be far more serious.

Comment on this

Yes, the same road. If you get two companies going down the same road, then you have an extroardinary overlapping of services, a waste of facilities, a waste of staff and personnel, a waste of everything. If you had a similarity of board membership, it might not be possible to write that, legislatively speaking, into the Bill. If it is, let us talk about it. Let the Minister respond to what I am saying to him now because there are many processes involved in this legislation. If you accept that with separate management — who would be responsible, after all, only for carrying out the decisions of the boards, the policy of the boards — which will give the Minister what he is looking for because he feels that is the best way to achieve what he wants to achieve in this area, you would have management particularly responsible in these three areas.

May I suggest that in two of the areas, to avoid all the anomalies that we on all sides of the House visualise now, in so far as is possible, majoratively speaking, there would be the same type of board because that board would be nominated whether by the Minister or the trade union movement or whatever. If you have two separate boards responsible to two separate managements, but if they are similar at board level, then the worries and the fears that we have on all sides of the House would not materialise.

Perhaps, the Minister, in his response to that suggestion would be able to have another look at this section, if not now, then on Report Stage or something else. I am anxious that we would try to establish in the Minister's mind the fear we have, particularly those of us who represent rural areas, about a possible disadvantage that would accrue to any section of our integrated transport system by another section doing the same job but having decided advantages in doing it. That is something this House will have to address itself to.

The Minister has had available to him all sorts of expert advice from everybody, from the Parliamentary Draftsman, from the Department and from existing management in CIE. He has also had advice from the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union, from the Federated Workers' Union, from the Labour Party, at political level, at Parliamentary level, at annual conference level and at policy formulation level. This is because we have a particular interest in transport policy.

I am not suggesting that anybody else does not have, but we have a particular interest in this area and we are very proud of it. We have taken every opportunity to put on record our attitude towards a transport policy. It is on the basis of that policy in that that the Minister could achieve what we want and what he wants, that is distinct and separate management but in the case of two of the companies a similarity of the boards. They do not have to be exactly the same, but the same majoratively speaking, so that you would not have one board making decisions over another one and directing a management to carry on an enterprise down the country that would only be creating a situation clashing of interests and a waste of public finance. All the boards will eventually be looking for a subvention to meet the demand we will be making on them for a social service.

This is quite a serious matter. It is one that I want to address sincerely and with an element of understanding both for what the Minister wants to do and for what the public in general want. The public at large have an interest in CIE. As I have often said, they are very quick to condemn them when they have a strike situation, but many people are so dependent on CIE that it is important that we would realise that you cannot just legislate up here and forget the views of all the people down the country. It is very important that the views we are expressing would be done without any political haggling at one another. I accept the sincerity of what Senator Killilea is trying to do. I accept that Senators O'Mahony, Harte, McGonagle and many other members of the Parliamentary Labour Party as well as myself have——

Comment on this

And Senator Lanigan.

Comment on this

Yes. All of us have been working for weeks on this to try to reach a consensus that would settle the problems as we see them now. That is, in my opinion, the Parliamentary process. You get a Bill cleared at Cabinet who address themselves to it within whatever time factor that is available to them. Of course, if every Bill was just to come out of the Cabinet and not be amended, it would be a very extraordinary Bill. Most Bills that have come before this House in particular have benefited from their passage through this House and have been amended by consent nine times out of ten with the Minister and have been amended by the Minister listening to the case we were making. None of us wants a confrontation on this aspect of it. I feel that the formula I have put forward might meet what the Minister wants and what we want. I would certainly say that if you had a majority membership of two boards, they would be most unlikely to reach decisions to direct management to do something that would be detrimental to the responsibility held in another board. In that regard I would ask the Minister, the Cabinet and whoever else would be responsible for the composition of boards, to address that particular aspect.

The total similarity of boards, apart from the management, is the ideal. It is one we, as a parliamentary party, would approve of. It is one that I am quite certain, with explanation, that the trade union movement would accept and approve of. There is fundamentally nothing wrong with the same people with the same concept of what a transport authority is sitting on different boards with different managements, but having an overall view. As a matter of fact, I would accept that the membership of those two boards should also be reflected in the overall policy boards. I would hope that the Minister would take that into account in his response. That is how we could achieve progress in this legislation.

Senator Lanigan asked whether it was-necessary to have this Bill or was it a good thing or a bad thing. There is no doubt, from all of us who have spoken to people involved in this area, but that there was a need to address the problems in CIE. There is no doubt about that. There is no doubt but that this Minister, in his Green Paper on public transport and with his approval a few days ago to the Dublin Transport Authority, has addressed himself, with a lot of credit, to these particular areas. I would like to commend him for that.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I think the Senator knows the rules of this House a lot better than I do, but he is drifting a bit.

Comment on this

No, I am not drifting. I am requesting that the Minister who has a commitment to the overall policy of the public transport — and his commitment has already been shown by way of legislation and documents published — would listen to what we are saying on this section and address himself, if not directly to the amendments, to the suggestions I have made which would achieve the goal which we all want. It would eliminate the triplication that Senator Lanigan, Senator Killilea and Senator Mahony have spelled out if there were three separate companies. There would be duplication and waste of valuable scarce resources. There would be unfair competition because of the differences in costs of providing rail or bus transport. A board who were responsible for bus transport only, could reach a decision in isolation which would create a further demand on local authorities which they are not geared to meet but that same board, if they were running the two companies, would not reach that kind of decision. The rail board would be capable of saying, "We can provide that service because we do not have to have competition in this particular instance". As Senator Lanigan said, if there was a match in Dublin two different boards could make a decision to provide competitive transport to transport people to it. That is not how one runs a public service. That is not how a public service should be run, with one public service competing with another.

It is important that a public service should compete with the private sector. I think they can do it well and have done it well. They have also provided a service where the private sector would not go because there is no profit in it. That has happened. It is for that very reason that there is a social content in all these boards, whatever number we finally agree on. I am putting it to the Minister, sincerely and as dispassionately as possible, that he can achieve what he wants by way of board membership which would control the particular companies, and can make a decision as to the number of companies.

When other Members speak in this particular context I suggest that they address themselves to this problem. Then, possibly, we might be able to make progress.

Comment on this

I was annoyed when the Minister intervened in this debate so quickly and so ferociously by way of a great personal attack on me and on my party.

Comment on this

He just asked what your policy was.

Comment on this

The Senator is the last man in this House who should talk about anybody knowing anything about policy. He got his teeth pulled out of the Fine Gael Party on numerous occasions.

Comment on this

I will tell you one thing. I have quite a number of teeth left.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Killilea to speak, without interruption.

Comment on this

We know the Minister's policy from his history. Since he came in here today he has been praising himself for all he did for CIE. We know the price he got for the Irish Spruce last week. We know what he did to Irish Shipping. If I am correct, I know what the Labour Party are afraid of in this Bill. It is that the same thing might happen to some of those companies. I want to take Senator Ferris's point but before I take that point I want to ask the Minister a straight, honest and honourable question.

Comment on this

Tell us your policy.

Comment on this

I know why he did that. He was trying to weld you all together to put you against us. I want to refer to a letter which was sent to every Senator in this House and, I suppose, to every other public representative. It was sent on 30 April 1986 from the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union. In the first page there is a paragraph I want to read to this House because to me it is very important. It has not been answered and nobody on this side of the House seems to know what is going on. I would like if this matter could be cleared up for us. I quote:

We are opposed to the concept of splitting up the company. Here it is absurdly clear that any of the proposed three new companies which would be registered under the Companies Act can be liquidated.

We know that the Minister is renowned for his capabilities in such fields. The wording of the Bill conflicts with the promise — and this is what I want to emphasise — made by the Minister for Communications to an Irish Congress of Trade Unions' deputation at a meeting on 29 October 1985, and confirmed subsequently by letter dated 8 November 1985. I would like to hear the content of that letter. I think that is very important.

I want to follow through on Senator Ferris's point because I have already spoken on this. Senator Ferris, I am afraid would compromise himself out of a pit of snakes. I want to take his argument, separately from the matter of the fixing of the particular boards with the appropriate people who would fall into line — and no better man than Mr. "Fix It" himself sitting beside the Senator to set those up. The Senator would want to follow that argument through. I think the point has got to be made that if we take the All-Ireland Final and even if we do not care which counties are involved transport to the match from major towns in the counties concerned would be needed. We must follow the argument through because this is where it is important. The bus company and the rail company want to do business on the match weekend. They are running on a parallel road to Dublin. The senior board may decide that the rail company are providing the transport and that the bus company may not be involved. Who is going to compensate the bus company for the loss of revenue for that weekend?

Comment on this

Who compensates the private sector?

Comment on this

Nobody. If, consistently and persistently, the senior board state the rail or the bus company shall provide the transport, whichever one they select, and say to them: "you do that", or "you do this" the other company will not be allowed to provide transport if we follow through the argument of Senator Ferris who wants to set up two companies with the same people on their boards. If there is a bias in that company — and the Minister might not be able to help it — and they say: "Let rail do it," all this time the bus company would suffer a loss in revenue. Who compensates them? They have to get compensation because under this legislation they can be told not to become involved. One of them has to stay at home. It would be nonsensical to have the two of them travelling to Dublin from the same market place.

Comment on this

What is happening now?

Comment on this

We are talking about this Bill and the three companies. There is no reasoning to this point of view. Therefore, it shows the illogical proposal of having the rail and bus companies separated rurally. They should be complementing one another and be all thrown in as one major force to run an economic service to Dublin. The reason why the private companies are doing well is that one can travel from Dublin to Galway in a luxury coach for £7 on a daily or weekly ticket. Can anybody in this House, including the Minister, tell me the cost of travelling to Dublin by CIE on a weekly return ticket?

Comment on this

It is £7 on a day return on Thursday.

Comment on this

What about if you want to go on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday or Friday? I know how they operate. If you are in in the morning at 7.15 and one of the first 40 or 50 people at the rail line you will be lucky enough to get to Dublin for £5. But if you are 41st or 42nd you pay £21. People do not have to get up at an extraordinary hour if travelling by luxury coach because you telephone them the night before, book a seat and for Galway to Dublin or Athlone to Dublin. It is a provincial service and you know what you are paying and can secure a seat generally speaking, it is a "flea market" situation. If you are in time, good luck to you, and if not in time, hard luck to you. This is no service. Let CIE be a functional organisation where they say "We offer a service with certain extras in it for a certain price". Let them become competitive. Let them become competitive as a unit against private enterprise. I am sure they will be successful and we wish them luck. The reason why we have this Bill here today is that every day the number of private enterprises coming into this city are growing at a rapid pace. Let us ask why. Value for money is the reason. Nothing else.

I want to refer to the point made by Senator Lanigan concerning the allegations made about cowboy operators. I do not see anything cowboyish about them. The Minister brought in legislation last week and the first people to welcome that legislation were the express coach people to the city of Dublin. I have seen the articles in our local papers, that welcome it. Their services will now be under the guidance and, I hope, under the tight security of the Department of Transport. All the nonsense about the operators being cowboys should be stopped. They are all reasonable people trying to do business. One cannot blame them, but that does not mean that we cannot assist CIE to make them a very fine company too. That is what we should be doing.

Senator Ferris's argument goes way out because somebody has to make a decision as to who does that business at weekends. Otherwise we have duplication. Otherwise we are going to have two companies running two services to Dublin, with the total numbers not being utilised at all. It is nonsensical. If one follows it through, the day will come — may be a long time before Deputy Mitchell passes out of this world, to quote his own phrase — when some major decision will be made that the bus service is not going so well and that as the figures are beginning to show a loss, as was done in the old times, it should be cut out or liquidated. Then we will have problems. That can happen. We have listened to the Minister, Deputy Mitchell telling us about the wonderful job that he has done in CIE since he came to the Department and about the financial state that he has created, as if it were alive and going well. I do not deny that the Minister has done a little, but he should not let the cap fall down over his eyes. The Minister has done a lot of bad things to. Bombardier in Limerick is not successful. The Minister cannot wink out at that company from under his cap. The Minister should not stand up here and bestow laurels on himself.

We have seen his performance in Irish Shipping as well.

Comment on this
An Leas Chathaoirleach

Back to the Transport Bill, please.

Comment on this

It is a bad sign to see a person clapping himself on the back. The Minister should be careful. He is in a tight position here. He has got this situation slightly wrong and would be far better off giving his attention to it. I do not think he has followed it through. Senator Ferris has not followed his point through either. I believe that we cannot have those two companies leaving the same market place and serving the same destinations. If they are going to be viable they have to be competitive. If they are going to tackle the private enterprise people, who are competitve, they have to be even more competitive. Certainly, we are not going to have three of them viable doing all that.

I, personally, believe that the private buses will stay in operation unless the Minister does something, because they are offering a magnificent service. Senator Ferris asked: "What about the poor people if they had no CIE to travel on?" They would not be able to travel. If they are not old age pensioners they cannot travel by CIE unless they are up at 6 o'clock in the morning, standing outside the station for the bargain that Senator Higgins was talking about.

Comment on this

That is not true. I am reluctant to interrupt, but the private buses leave Galway at exactly the same time as the train, 8 o'clock in the morning. I get the train twice a week at 8 o'clock.

Comment on this

If Senator Higgins were in poor circumstances and did not have free travel on CIE——

Comment on this

I do not have free travel. I am not an old age pensioner yet.

Comment on this

What would the poor people do without CIE? The only people with whom they can afford to travel today are, in fact, the private luxury bus people with their express bus service because the amount of money it costs to travel from Galway to Dublin——

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The private buses will not take people with free passes.

Comment on this

I know that, but I am talking about a poor person who has not a pass. The only people who have passes, as you know, are old age pensioners.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

No, there are invalidity pensioners and others.

Comment on this

If you were a DPMA person who was on the bottom line, who had to come to Dublin tomorrow morning and had to pay for the ticket, who would you choose to travel with?

Comment on this

They can get a free travel pass from the health board.

Comment on this

Can they? It is a valid point. Going back to the point made by Senator Ferris, that if a person on DPMA had to travel to Dublin and did not have a facility from his health board, who would he travel with, I will guarantee this House today that he will go on the express private bus service. Why? Because CIE is too expensive. Secondly, what are we trying to do now? We are actually helping to make CIE a strong and viable company, which will have competition to keep them alive and keep them going well. CIE need both the buses and the rail to do that. That is the reason why I think that the point put by Senator Ferris, as a compromise, has not been followed through. It is very important that the end result has got to be taken with the beginning. If I could see viability coming from Senator Ferris's suggestion, I would go for his compromise, but I am afraid I do not. When it is followed through to the very end it does not have the intention that it had at the beginning. The intention at the beginning sounds fine, but when it is followed through it does not have the realism it should have. It does not have the factuality that is needed. That is most important at this stage before we go down a certain avenue. I do not think we could follow it because of that reason.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Fine Gael Senators have been here since 11.30 a.m. and no Fine Gael Senator has been called in this debate yet. It is now two hours and twenty minutes into the debate.

Comment on this

You will have a long day.

Comment on this

We might have a long day but I wonder what system is used.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I appreciate that but it is not a case of one party or another where I am concerned. There were not very many speakers since we commenced at 12 o'clock today. I should have given way to the Minister, rather than to any other Senator.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am anxious that I answer the points being raised by Senators. There have been fairly long contributions by both Senator Killilea and Senator Lanigan, and also a constructive contribution by Senator Ferris.

Comment on this

What about Senator Ferris?

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I did not mean to infer that the contributions by Senators Lanigan and Killilea were not constructive. I am appreciative of their interest in this Bill.

Senator Lanigan took exception to my first contribution. I am sorry if I vexed him, because I know Senator Lanigan is normally a very constructive and reasonable man, as is Senator Killilea but it is a little hard to take, in the light of this document, dated September 1982 to the then Fianna Fáil Government, where it is stated that the Minister for Transport was seeking the authority of the Government to prepare a plan for the creation of a separate Dublin bus company by 1 January 1984 at the latest, and the creation of a separate national railway company and a separate national bus company by 1 January 1985 at the latest. The then Minister for Transport was seeking the termination of road freight and sundries activities then owned by CIE by 1 January 1985 at the latest. That was their plan — total disestablishment of CIE — very strongly argued in this very large document from Deputy Wilson, the then Minister. It is only fair that I should point out that fact. In Senator Killilea's own speech——

Comment on this

On a point of order, we are talking about a Government document and one particular page of it and one particular sentence on that page but if we are to be fair I think that the Minister must start at page 1 and continue to the end to get the whole context of it. The Minister cannot leak part of the document without leaking it in full.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

An t-Aire, without interruption.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am giving the essence of what was proposed by the then Fianna Fáil Minister to his Government.

I also want to highlight the fact that at Second Stage Senator Killilea welcomed the Bill. At no point that I can recall did he refer to the two-company, three-company issue.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Not in my recollection but I stand to be corrected.

Comment on this

The Minister was not here for all of it.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is right to put on record that Fianna Fáil were disestablishing CIE, breaking it up and closing the road freight. This Government said: "No, there are good reasons to retain CIE as a group for reasons of co-ordination."

Senator Lanigan mentioned that promotional opportunities were being reduced because people would be working in smaller companies. That is not so. I have specifically provided that promotions and transfers can take place within the group. Secondly, I have provided that there would be a common pension scheme for the group to underline the unity and cohesion of the group.

Some other points made by Senator Killilea seem to ignore some of the amendments that will be dealt with later by the Seanad, for example, the amendment about winding-up and competition. For instance, we say in the amendment with regard to competition:

In relation to competition between services of the companies, the companies shall have regard to the overall interest of the Board and in any conflict between the companies the Board shall decide the issue with due regard to its overall interest and the interests of the particular companies concerned.

With regard to Senator Ferris, I feel very strongly that the company has to be structured into three companies. I am prepared to consider suggestions as to having a certain commonality of membership of the boards concerned. I would be prepared to consider something in that direction.

Comment on this

May I ask one further point?

(Interrruptions.)

Comment on this

Senator O'Mahony.

Comment on this

I am deeply shocked to hear that it was the intention of the Fianna Fáil Party before they left office to disestablish CIE and to set up three separate transport companies in its place. That is a shock to me, given the attitude that the party is adopting in this Committee Stage debate. Senator Killilea was highly critical of the Labour Party and their performance in relation to this legislation. I can say two things there——

Comment on this

I was not critical.

Comment on this

——one, that the Labour Party are doing this business effectively on this legislation in consultation with the trade unions and in consultation with the Minister who is piloting the legislation through the House. Secondly, any deficiencies which Senator Killilea can see in the position of the Labour Party are at nought compared with the idea apparently put forward by their Minister, Deputy Wilson, in 1982 to totally destroy CIE. However, I would like to confirm what the Minister said about the very significant improvement in the performance of CIE since 1983. There is no doubt in anyone's mind who has looked at the experience within the company since then but that there have been major changes and improvements in productivity and that there has been a very substantial improvement in industrial relations, particularly in the Dublin area. There has been a very substantial improvement, too, in the company's ability to plan forward because of the new financial framework. I think the Minister is absolutely right in that. Credit is due to him for that. A great deal of credit for that improvement is due in no small way to the commitment of the unions to make the company work. They have shown that, over the period I referred to, by having a very low level of industrial disruption compared with past history. I have no doubt that the main interest of the trade union movement in relation to this Bill is to see to it that the company not just survive but develop and attract more and more of the business which is going to the private bus operators. The unions have an interest in that company. They want to see it develop but they have a right to express certain concerns about the measures proposed in the Bill. Where those reservations are real, then they must be taken account of by all of us.

The question I posed at the beginning as to why a divisional structure was not put in place has not been adequately answered. A divisional structure would serve the same purposes in relation to management efficiency, personnel relations and financial transparency as the three subsidiary company structure would serve. I do not understand why it is impossible to have a divisional structure in a relatively small company by international standards when it has been achieved successfully in many very large multinational corporations. However, we have gone beyond that in the debate. The Government are committed to a subsidiary company structure of some kind.

We are aware of course that the holding company board will have, by definition, a responsibility to co-ordinate the activities of the subsidiary companies. In the Bill we had two primary sets of concerns and as a result two primary sets of objectives. I would like to spell these out as carefully as possible. The first objective we had, during the Second Stage debate and in the discussions we have had with the Ministers, has been the security of the employment of the workforce who would be transferred from the statutory company, CIE, to the subsidiary companies set up under the Companies Acts. We wanted to ensure that the transfer from the holding company of people to the subsidiary companies would of itself lead to no diminution in the security of employment and conditions of service which they now have within the main board. As a result of our concern in this area, we suggested to the Minister a set of proposals which we asked him to consider for incorporation in the Bill. These proposals to a very considerable degree have been accepted by the Minister because he recognised the validity of the case we made and they have been put down in the form of amendments. The principal one is amendment No. 17 (7) which reads:

If any of the companies is wound up, the functions of the company shall be exercised by the Board, and the Board shall accept into its employment without interruption of service all officers and servants employed by the company in consequence of subsection (4)...

That is the subsection which tranfers the workers from the holding company to the subsidary company. That is the principal amendment which the Minister has accepted. This amendment secures the jobs and conditions of service of the workforce under the new system as opposed to the situation as it is now.

There are other amendments which I will not mention at this stage. They are concerned with the central first theme that we have had in our discussions which is to ensure that the security of employment of the workforce would not suffer any diminution as a result of the new arrangements. The second set of objectives we had is to——

Comment on this

The Senator is moving away from the amendments.

Comment on this

The second set of objectives in our discussions and in our amendments is to secure an efficient and integrated public transport service operated under the aegis of CIE. That is why we have made the suggestion for two companies — two companies would secure integration between rail and pro vincial bus services. It is also why we made the suggestion in our amendments Nos. 10 and 11, where we talk about seeing to it that the companies operate an integrated transport service.

Comment on this

We will get to that, Senator.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that amendment No. 1 in my name is part of this strategy of securing an effecient integrated public transport service which links with amendments Nos. 10 and 11. They must all be seen as a sign of our concern to try to get both an efficient system but also one which integrates the various services into one national system. No reasonable argument has been put forward as to why, in the case of the provincial rail and bus services, there should not be simply one company. The case has not been made as to why there should be more than one company if we are concerned with this notion of an integrated public transport system where rail and bus services are used to complement each other in a planned way throughout the country in a manner which is consistent with the financial framework within which they have to operate.

Comment on this

I would like to make, very briefly, a contribution to the debate on this amendment. I am disappointed that the amendment is not drafted the other way, that instead of having three companies, we decide to have four companies. One important portion of the CIE framework has been totally ignored in this debate. It is a section which has been completely and wrongly downgraded over the years. It is the intention that the road freight section should be incorporated into the rail section. What is wrong with the road freight section is that it was always considered to be an adjunct to the railway operation rather than an independent operation in its own right. It is considered always to be an addendum to the operation of the rail freight service rather than competing with the ever increasing number of road freight operators. The construction proposed by the Minister provides for the re-enforcing of the role for the road freight section. The road freight section consigned to that role is inevitably doomed. It cannot continue to provide a service which consists primarily of — or which at least a significant proportion of its service is bringing goods to and from the railheads. That is an incorrect assessment of what the proper position and role for the road freight section. I would have been much happier if there were four companies instead of three, one to deal with road freight, the others dealing with rail, bus and the Dublin city services.

There is one reason I would like to put forward which has not been mentioned here, as a reason for changes being made. Some people seem to think there should be no changes. It is quite obvious that each of the political parties have different policy viewpoints on CIE. It is obvious that in so far as Fianna Fáil have a policy, their policy would be to break up CIE and to develop the functions on to totally separate independent companies. That would appear to be the latest policy they expressed as indicated by the Minister. It would appear that the Fine Gael policy——

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister is the one to tell Senator O'Leary what Fianna Fáil policy is.

Comment on this

If Senator Killilea will not tell us what it is, we will have to depend on the Minister. If Senators Killilea or Honan wish to tell us what the policy is we will cancel what we have said, say, "yes, they have a new policy". In the absence of any statement of policy in spite of repeated invitations expressed forcibly from this side of the House we have not been told that there is any different policy. We can assume that that policy is at least, if not the present policy, the last policy they had on the matter. The Bill probably represents a compromise between the Fine Gael Party policy and the Labour Party policy. The Fine Gael Party would have been for a greater degree of devolved power and the Labour Party would have been for less.

Some change in CIE is necessary because of the dynamic of change. Change in itself in large organisations which have got into ruts is a good thing. As Members of the House will know that change in itself was developed by the Chinese communists into a political philosophy of its own. The dynamic of change has, in fact, a function to play. I have seen very many examples in business where people in large organisations centralise operations for a few years, then decentralise them and then centralise them again. Very often people may also say why change every few years. In the process of changing, a dynamic is created which is for benefit to the organisation. Prior to this Government and the Minister for Communications coming on the scene — I do not wish to give him all the credit — CIE were in a position where no change had taken place in the organisation over a long period of time. As a result the company were going steadily downhill.

In my view, it is not necessary that each and every change should be perfect. The fact that change takes place creates within that organisation a new awareness and a sense of achievement which is very important. I am not worried whether the structure is two, three, four, five or six different companies so long as it remotivates the people who work in CIE because it is a most difficult task, to be working in a national company, who are providing a social service which cannot be valued and as a result depending on a substantial subvention from the State demotivates the members of that organisation in a very serious way. This demotivation is what must be tackled periodically by Ministers and by those in authority in organisations such as CIE. It is because of the dynamic of change that changes are necessary.

I consider the proposal put forward in the Bill as a good one, leaving aside the question I raised about road freight for a moment. The idea that rail and bus are providing similar services is too narrow a viewpoint. The rail service does and always will provide a substantial freight element which is almost totally lacking from the bus section. To consider rail as being only a passenger service in function, is not to give its proper importance. Therefore, to think that one can automatically conclude that the bus and rail services are providing the same service along different highways to the same parts of the country is to misunderstand the real function of the bus and rail service. Overwhelmingly, the bus service provides and continues to provide a passenger service. The rail service must go far beyond that and should be encouraged to do so.

In addition, the rail and bus services should be encouraged to be in competition with each other. I do not see anything wrong with two State companies being in competition with each other. It is ludicrous to think just because a company is a State company that it cannot go into competition with another company which also might happen to be a State company. From time to time they should compete for passengers. It is only by the people exercising the choices which competition provides, that those in authority within the areas of organisations which are the subject of those choices can gauge how they are responding to the needs of society. To give the same example as was given by a number of Members on the other side, if one is talking about the choices which are being presented in the event of an All-Ireland final with people travelling from Kilkenny and as to whether they should travel by rail or by road. I do not see anything wrong with giving people the choice. I do not see anything wrong with both services being run by the State, through State sponsored bodies of one kind or another. If on one occasion one of them loses money because they are not providing the service that is a signal to that organisation that it has to get its act together so that a better service would be provided the next time Kilkenny are playing in an All-Ireland final. We must not be afraid of the word "competition". We must not automatically assume that the word "competition" has no part to play in State organisations. It has a part to play and we should encourage that kind of thinking within State organisations.

Having said that, I am delighted we are discussing this amendment in such depth. The Seanad, and indeed both Houses of the Oireachtas, are places in which to discuss these matters and to come to reasoned and sensible conclusions — compromise where possible — and if not, the inevitable conflict of votes must take place. I would hope that this is not a one-off exercise but that we can look forward to a similar attitude of mind and an independence of mind when it comes to other issues. I must recognise that on the only occasion that I had to put that to the test, Senator O'Mahony certainly was not found wanting in that regard. Other people were. More independence of thought within the Houses of the Oireachtas is a good thing in the long run and something which Governments even though they are uncomfortable about it, should encourage.

For all those reasons I support the Minister's proposal. However, I am disappointed that the road freight section is being consigned to a position where it has become a mere service adjunct to the rail network rather than a service seeking to enter into competition with the other road freight operators in the country which would be a healthy way in which to revive interest and support for that lagging arm of the CIE organisation

Comment on this

If a traveller from rural Ireland were listening to this debate, and it is about one company outside Dublin or two, they would come to the conclusion that it would not matter very much provided they could travel at the lowest possible fare. It is not as simple as that. There are more subtleties to it than tweedledum, or tweddledee.

When we in the Labour Party are advocating one company outside Dublin, an integrated rail and road system, we are not indulging in tweedledum or tweed-ledee politics. We are trying to assist this nation and its people in the matter of having a good transport system. It is only right and proper that I should compliment the Minister on what he has been doing in the past two or three years in this arena by way of introducing efficiency measures. This Bill, broadly speaking, is welcome — even though we have reservations as an ongoing process adding to and supplementing what he has been doing for the last two or three years in CIE. Having said that, by way of approval I should go on to say that it was not too difficult because the situation was so bad that the Minister could not have failed even without the knowledge of efficiency measures, job evaluation and good management, which also means, that there is probably room for improvement yet.

This Bill must be taken as an experiment. It is not only going to be subject to change after the passage of some years but it is subject to change even now. The Minister seems to be satisfied when he insists that two companies outside Dublin — which are called three if one is outside Dublin because of the separateness of the identities of rail and road outside Dublin — will lead to efficiency. It depends what you mean by that. I do not know any canon law in economics that points to separateness of units of production, distribution or services which indicates clearly that the separateness of the identities leads to efficiency.

On the other hand people ask, what is efficiency? Some people say that efficiency is measured by profitability. That is rubbish. That is not the only measure of efficiency. It cannot be the measure of efficiency in an arena where one requires, and the people and the labour movement insist on, social service. Even though one is not making a profit it can be efficient, and probably is in many instances. Efficiency should not be measured by profitability first. Efficiency is measured by good industrial relations and good management which involves them in their relationship with their workers. Efficiency should be measured by the consensus between worker and management as to a job being done in the shortest possible time and, if it is production of some commodity, the quality not suffering thereby. In this case it is a service.

Nobody knows better than workers when a service is efficient; from time to time, they even know better than management. The distance that workers are from management in that context means that management are not getting the brain power of the worker applied if there is a remoteness. This has already been referred to. They are not getting the benefit of the workers' brains. I know from 35 years experience as a trade unionist, as a work study engineer involved in the building industry, and construction industry, the engineering industry, the ship repairing and the clothing and textile industries that, nobody can tell a worker about the quickest and best way to do anything at the work bench, on the road or anywhere. If management lose contact with the worker, they have lost the contribution in that manner.

Motivation with workers is most important in the context of good management and efficiency. That is what the Bill strives after. That is why I am complimenting the Minister, in broad terms, on the provisions of the Bill. I am still wrestling with the ideas put forward in trying to explain to us why he insists on two companies outside Dublin rather than one. It is not clear to me. If my argument is based soundly, and if three are as good as two, and two are as good as three, why does the Minister not adopt the attitude of saying let us have two companies rather than three, that is, one outside Dublin? The lay person outside would say: "It is a good idea to have rail and road integrated. "Notwithstanding what Senator O'Leary has said about freight from my experience, having sat on the Northern Ireland railway tribunals and having looked after the County Donegal railways in my time and knowing something about integrated rail and road services, I can say that it is potentially as efficient to have an integrated rail and road service outside Dublin as it is to have two separate companies.

It has been said by somebody that the operations must be transparent. We want to see who is losing money and who is making money. What is the point of seeing who is making money and who is losing money? I can understand the point of watching who is efficient and who is inefficient. The profitability yardstick again is being used to determine this. If company A loses money and company B is making money, it is assumed that company B is more efficient than company A. It is assumed that company A is inefficient because they do not make money and company B is more efficient because they make money. It must be said that one cannot have efficiency without making profit, especially in the field we are talking about, the necessity of providing a social service. Efficiency depends on good management and the relationship with the worker getting the proper motivation and getting the contribution that only a worker can make in that context. That is efficiency. Seeing who is making money or losing money is not a sound basis on which to endeavour to establish, through legislation, the three companies complex. That could have been done with one company and there could be two divisions. It is only an accountancy problem.

The question of competition then comes into it. Of course there can be competition. Nobody has suggested for one moment that because one company governs an integrated rail and road system, there cannot be competition. Why not? That is what efficiency means. If competition is a contributory factor towards making anything competitive and, therefore, efficient, there is nothing wrong with that. I say to Senator O'Leary that there is nothing inherently wrong with competition. What the workers would be worried about — and what we would be worried about — is that competition would produce a net result of cutting back, cutting down and eliminating at some stage the size of the company or the company that was not making money. It could be claimed that because it is not making money and is a drain on the State it should be shut down.

I am one of the people from the North who called for the nationalisation of the old railway system between the two countries for two reasons. First, the people required a social service. It was not being provided very efficiently. That was done many years ago. Second, it would add to the co-operative element that was required between North and South. We were involved collectively in the trade union and labour movement. Then to our dismay we found that not only did they cut back but they eliminated parts of the railway system from Derry to Dublin. They did not eliminate the Derry to Belfast line. They were going to but were warned that they should not do it. One has to balance between what the people require and efficiency and profitability, which is not a very useful yardstick when you look at it.

The second argument put forward by the Minister in defence of the three companies is that of the remoteness of management from the workers. That is a sound basis for any argument. If the remoteness is to be put out of the way and the closeness of management and workers brought together, that is a good thing. What he has failed to do is relate that to the idea that the remoteness would disappear just because there are two separate companies. How does the remoteness disappear just because there are two companies rather than one? Surely the closeness of management to the workers, with all the contributions that workers can make is brought about by intelligent management, day-to-day decisions, no procrastination, trying to understand the motivation of the labour force, and moving all the time in a positive direction rather than negative, and good management.

Why can that not be done in one company outside as well as two companies outside Dublin? I cannot see the strong argument that I am looking for in support of three companies, that is two outside Dublin. I keep repeating that. I cannot see it, but I heard the Minister say today that he was taken with Senator Ferris's suggestion, and thinking about it positively, about the same personnel occupying two company board seats. I would like the Minister to repeat that for us today, because that might be the basis on which we would have a look again at our amendment to see if possibly we could accept that situation, because the unnecessary and unwanted competition that might bring about bad results might be resolved in that manner. I thought I heard him say that but I would like him to say it again clearly for us, that he would have second thoughts about that.

Comment on this

We are not using this disagreement between us as a political football. We are trying to be helpful in the interest of a good transport system for the people, and in the interest of the consumers' social needs and so on.

Comment on this

I have been listening here for quite some time to the debate on this amendment. My concern about the stance of the principal party opposite is of course, greatly increased this week. I begin to wonder about the state of mind of the party opposite. They are developing a certain restlessness, a certain total lack of conformity in relation to a series of matters which just do not encompass this amendment. I had the extraordinary experience in the last 48 hours of watching their total change of mind in relation to the building of a road near St. Patrick's Cathedral. They developed suddenly a conscience about the architecture and the history of the city of Dublin which had never been part of their concern previously. Here we have relating to the McKinsey report back in 1981.

Comment on this

I would not mind the conversion. I welcome their conversion on Monday night last. It they began to explain themselves in any fashion that would lead you to believe that they had given the matter any great thought, then one's perspective would be quite different.

Comment on this

The thoughts that come out of my mind in relation to this matter are how they can possibly deal with the questions that have been posed by the Minister in relation to the McKinsey report. They have not said that they, as a party in Government in 1981 and 1982, were not committed to the total disestablishment of CIE. They do not seem to treat that statement.

Comment on this

We are discussing the Committee Stage of a 1986 Bill introduced by Deputy Mitchell, Minister for Communications.

Comment on this

They do no concern themselves with the fact that not only was this the position taken by the party in office in the 1981-82 period and by Deputy John Wilson, the Minister at the time, but it was equally part and parcel of the development——

Comment on this

We would like to hear the Senator's thoughts on the Bill.

Comment on this

I presume I have floor and I am entitled to speak without the constant barrage coming from Senator Lanigan across the floor. It is not simply a matter of commitment in a general way in relation to transport we are talking about. We are talking about the commitment of the party opposite to the McKinsey report, which is very much embodied in the drafting of this legislation with one major difference, which the Minister and the Government sought to incorporate into this Bill by way of the holding company and the co-ordination that that holding company would give towards retaining many of the features of CIE as we have known them through the years, and also giving the new companies that are to be set up under this Bill, the possibility of identifying new growth areas individually. The Minister mentioned earlier the kind of growth areas that could be seen in the development of the provincial bus company in relation to dealing with much of the slack, very little competition that CIE have afforded the private bus companies throughout this State in recent times, and of course, they could be much more alert to this in the future.

I believe we are going through a period in which many of the large statutory bodies are being looked at as being too large, maybe requiring a more modern and a more dynamic approach. We have seen, in the course of the last year, this House debating the establishment of a new local authority structure. The trend in that area has been, of course, to reduce the scale of our local authority system, the Dublin area being changed from two major local authorities to four.

We have in this area a work force of the order of 20,000 people. I can understand what the Minister says in relation to the remoteness that must give the company in handling a workforce of that scale. There is a lot to be said in the creation of a new environment within the company. Why not, if we are establishing two companies, go ahead and establish the three and allow those three to have a much greater chance of identifying the role they play within the board structure of CIE and their holding company rather than continue for the vast majority of the people who will come across CIE, the very same structures and the very same type of organisation at local level that we have known to date?

We would, by not accepting the force of argument there is in the direction of three companies, be allowing most of this State to continue as if the state of organisation in CIE were, at this point in time, perfectly satisfactory and that there was no need for change. The need for separation of services is not simply one of making the Dublin bus system separate from the rest. That argument should apply to the rest of the country and attempt, in this new reorganisation of CIE, to bring the management and staff within the companies, each to identify with a new company, to open up not just competition between themselves but competition with other providers of services in the country resulting hopefully in not just a series of annual returns of CIE, which have been encouraging in recent years — the Minister gave them a much more ordered approach to the finances that would be available to them — but also an opportunity to identify and to develop these companies individually, in the same way that we have managed in the course of the last couple of years to deal with the first step in reorganising CIE's structure with the CIE hotel group, showing the first signs of successful out-turn on their financial operation running as a separate entity.

I hope that we will be supporting the Minister in this area as the amendment does not have the guts of a decision that goes far enough in order to grasp at the problems CIE have. If we do not take on the full range of what is incorporated in the McKinsey report, although with one major improvement the Government have seen to by way of the holding company, we will not grasp the serious difficulties CIE have. Let us not be worried about white lines, stations and provincial towns around the country. Those kinds of organisational difficulties can be overcome.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister a question. He quoted today from a Government memorandum concerning supposed legislation that was on the agenda for the previous Government. It is only appropriate that that document now be made available in the Library so that all Senators may read it or failing that the statement should be withdrawn. I do not think it is quite fair that the interpretation of a Government memorandum should be left to the interpretation of one person. It is appropriate now that that document be made public by way of being placed in the Library.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am very sorry if Senator Killilea is embarrassed by the revelation of the document. I thought it was necessary in this case to highlight what I consider to be the insincerity of the Fianna Fáil stand in this House today.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not think that answers my question. My question is quite relevant and quite specific. There is a former Government memorandum being selectively interpreted by the Minister here today. We have a right as individual elected Senators in this House, if he can interpret it and produce it here in this House, to have it made available to us in the Library. I am asking the Minister if he will make the document available in the Library.

Comment on this

If the Minister quotes from a document, that document must be made available but so far as I know he did not quote from it.

Comment on this

He did.

Comment on this

I was not here at the time.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I quoted from a summary of the document on the decision sought by the then Minister for Transport. I challenge Senator Killilea to get Deputy Wilson to deny the accuracy in detail of what I quoted.

Comment on this

That is not relevant to the question I have asked. The Cathaoirleach made a ruling that if the Minister, quotes from a document——

Comment on this

If the Minister quotes from a document he should make it available.

Comment on this

If he does not make it available where do we stand?

Comment on this

If he quoted from the document he should make it available.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make the document available? After all, it was a Government memorandum. He is selective in that he read two paragraphs from it. He illustrated to us that it was a huge document of many pages. We would like to see the remaining pages of that document.

Comment on this

The Senator is only entitled to see the portion the Minister quoted from.

Comment on this

Is it normal standard for a Minister to quote a memorandum circulated to a previous Government or indeed any Government publicly in the House?

Comment on this

Perhaps not. I am only concerned with this case.

Comment on this

This case has highlighted this particular aspect of it. The Government memorandum has been produced here. It has been shown to us here in this House as though it were a document of a most sincere content. It has been used here today for political purposes and one section of it has been read out by the Minister. I ask the Minister either to put up or shut up on this matter, either to make this complete document available in the Library or else not to refer to it in this House anymore. Individual interpretations by any Minister, from any political party are not relevant to the facts we are talking about.

Comment on this

Senator Michael D. Higgins.

Comment on this

It is not enough that we just leave it there. The question has been asked.

Comment on this

I can go no further.

Comment on this

The document has to be produced to the House.

Comment on this

I do not know if the Senator was here at the time, I was not here. I have that disadvantage.

Comment on this

I was here. The Minister quoted from the document.

Comment on this

If the Minister quoted from it he is entitled to produce what he quoted.

Comment on this

He is not entitled to. He has to.

Comment on this

He quoted from the document.

Comment on this

Can we have the document?

Comment on this

Will the Chair ask the Minister to produce it for us?

Comment on this

I am informing the Minister of——

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will consider the request. I would have to take advice on whether I should produce it and perhaps consult Deputy Wilson. Suffice to say that I quoted from the summary of the memorandum inaccurately that part of the decision sought which deals with the breaking up of this company. I want to repeat that the proposal was to disestablish CIE completely, to have a separate Dublin bus company, a separate provincial bus company, separate railway company and to close down road freight completely. I want to know from Senator Killilea whether he denies that.

Comment on this

How can I either deny or agree with what the Minister is saying because he is talking about one paragraph in a document which, in my opinion, was practically an inch thick and which I estimate to be about 100 pages. One can pick from any document any selective paragraph and give it one's personal interpretation but that is not adequate. It is a horrendous decision of the Minister to walk in here today and claim now, as he is claiming, that he has to seek legal advice. Did he seek legal advice when he walked in here today?

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

He is saying now that he wants to seek advice. He is seeking advice after the act. I do not think we should go any further here until we allow the Minister the opportunity to get advice to see if he is going to circulate this document. If he is not going to circulate it I will ask the House to have him withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

Will the Senator resume his seat please?

Comment on this

I am asking the House to adjourn to give the Minister the appropriate time to produce the evidence.

Comment on this

Will the Senator resume his seat? I have asked the Minister to produce a copy of what he quoted from the document. I was not here at the time so I am not too clear on what he quoted. If the Minister quoted then he must produce the document. The Minister has said he will look into that.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I propose that we adjourn the House until such time as the Minister produces the document or otherwise. I do not think the debate can continue until we see this document.

Comment on this

I would like to summarise because at this stage we have gone through many of the different arguments in favour of the amendment and the response to it. I very much support those who say that what we all want is the best possible Bill, as it will govern public transport, to come out of our discussion. In that sense I can accept the contributions which have been made either in this discussion or at different stages on different sides of the House.

I want to argue, however, slightly at variance with some of the contributions that have been made by some of my colleagues in the House in relation to the desirable effects of competitiveness on the affairs of CIE, which are suggested might ensue, following the company having been divided into three companies. I was interested in the two different versions of McKinsey between 1971 and 1982. The second McKinsey report came before the drafting of this document which occasioned some discussion a few minutes ago. In the 11 years between 1971 and 1982 the change in McKinsey's thinking was very significant. In 1971 they were arguing that the loss of integration, which presumably they felt capable of defining, in the early seventies would be a loss from the break up of CIE into several different companies.

They equally were able to address themselves to the question of diffusion, the effect it would have and the lack of economic yield from the duplicating of certain services and facilities in relation to a number of areas including personnel, computing, work shops and so on. In 1982, however, when the commissioning masters changed a difference in emphasis could be detected but the variation and the thinking was never really explained.

Very briefly in favour of this amendment in the name of Senator O'Mahony I would like to just develop what I think happened between 1971 and 1982. What happened was external to the consultants and external indeed to CIE to some extent. An atmosphere grew up in the country which was decidedly anti public service and which was decidedly anti semi-State and it argued in a rather vulgar way for accrued profitability as measured by commercial performance.

When you try to look at the concept of transparency and its origins you will find the concept of transparency is lurking in there somewhere within this as a kind of methodological aid towards achieving and seeing commerical profitability. All of us know, in relation to transport, that since the State was founded, all of the transport Bills that have come before this House and the other House have always, even if it was not believed, paid lip service to the social goals of transport. I spoke about this on Second Stage and I will not stray from appropriate Committee Stage discussion. I referred to the fact that there was a constituency that might not be a voting constituency but one that was non-car owning and that you could see the shift in different country's transport policies as they move from catering for people who are non-car owning to people who are predominantly car owning and the implications that will have.

We have to be careful in this regard even if we accept the best intentions of the Minister. I know there are many people who feel that the Minister cannot be replaced, that a better person for the job would never be found. There are other people who feel that this could take place. Be that as it may it is very unlikely that he will be the Minister in charge of the operations of transport for ever. I have to address myself to the circumstances in which, externally, an atmosphere will develop in which people will be anti-public transport.

I see it happening already. There are Senators who are not present in this House. I notice that the new grouping from the Progressive Democrats who are comprehensively against public subventions of State and semi-State bodies have not come into the House to argue their case today. The fact is that we live in an atmosphere in which people more and more are really going in two directions. People are complaining about high levels of taxation, about Government expenditure and certainly on the case of those who have and those who are in a position to pay tax is being expressed increasingly. It is being manipulated by political groupings who are offering the public the concession of cutting back on public expenditure, be it in relation to health, to transport or to any other area.

We have to consider therefore that if you believe in public transport and in the delivery of an adequate range of public transport in a major urban area such as Dublin and then in the rural areas through bus and rail, what company structure can best stand against a changed atmosphere in which people want transparency? Why do people want transparency? I have listened with great care to the speeches that have been made developing this concept. I hear people saying, for example, that transparency will enable the employees in a company to be motivated by profitability levels, that it will enable people to know where achievements have been made and so on. What you are really saying, when you translate this one way, is that when you take the drag off in many ways, for example, the burden of rail away from provisional buses, perhaps the buses will spring into profitability and this will easily be seen.

That is one translation. The other translation is that you simply want to know how performance is being measured against stated goals, but you can do that within the existing structure of CIE without any reorganisation into a corporate structure altogether. To go back and follow the first translation a little further down the line I see that in an atmosphere so hostile as we are in now in relation to public expenditure that to separate out the rural rail services and the freight and passenger services would be to leave them at an extraordinary and unnecessary level of frailty in relation to future survival.

At this stage I want to say a couple of other things in relation to the bus side of the operation. Let us say that you move away from an integrated bus and rail service in provincial areas. What will you then have? The provincial bus can choose indeed to go into competition with private buses but now we have encountered a problem here. Many private buses, let us be clear about this, are operating outside of both the spirit and the detail of the Transport Acts in this country. Equally, they are motivated entirely by returning a profit. I listened to my colleague from Galway talking about how they provide that service but I think that even he would agree that they provide a service in areas that will return profit without having to carry the obligation of providing a general service to other less densely populated areas.

Are the buses to enter into competition with an entity that does not have the same purpose as the original purposes for which we established a provincial bus or is it that the goals of the provincial bus service have been changed? I believe we are coming closer and closer to saying that we are really speaking about the single criteria, the primary criteria, in relation to provincial transport being a matter of profitability. You turn it around the other way and suppose that even in the spirit of the Transport Bill we want, over and above everything else, to be efficient, goal oriented and profitable in as much as is possible but that at the same time the ultimate purpose of transport legislation is to provide things which are both profitable and also things that are necessary. Every Minister who has ever presided over this area has had to address the fact of what is necessary but not profitable. If that is the case you have to turn around again and ask if it has any logic at all to be setting the two instruments by which you are delivering these services into competition with each other or having the competition of what was CIE bus now being defined in terms of its market relationship to private buses.

I have heard the argument which has singularly unimpressed me that there are rail people and bus people. This is as meaningless as to say that there are people who are ice cream people and lollypop people in a sweet shop. I do not accept it because what you can have within CIE — I have been a defender of them and their consumer services — is a wide range of management expertise some of which is delivered into specialisms.

Comment on this

Can the Senator give me a moment? The Minister wants to make an announcement.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

In deference to your ruling, for the information of Senator Killilea and the House, I will make available the relevant extract from the memorandum I quoted from.

Comment on this

We are only getting an extract from it.

Comment on this

That is all.

Comment on this

Were those proposals accepted by Government?

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

They were circulated by the then Minister in that Department.

Comment on this

Anybody can send a memorandum to Government. Were they accepted by the Government of the day? It is a very important question.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

They were accepted by the Minister of the day.

Comment on this

I have no control over that.

Comment on this