We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An Bille um an gCúigiu Leasú is Fiche ar an mBunreacht (Beatha Dhaonna le linn Toirchis a Chosaint), 2001: Céim an Choiste. Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.

Contributions 195–393 of 393. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill 2001
Rejected

No. 48 of 2001 ›

Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

That is not much better.

Comment on this

—to claim that it is about a lack of confidence in the President. That was never the motivation behind this measure. As others have argued, the issue is that the people will decide constitutionally one way or the other. They will be informed of all aspects and, in reply to Senator Jackman, will know that if the Oireachtas does not enact the Bill within 180 days, it will fall.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

That will not instil confidence.

Comment on this

By that time Fianna Fáil will have satisfied the four Independents and be out of office having done the damage.

Comment on this

In response to Senator Taylor-Quinn's point, we are not taking any powers away from the Oireachtas. After the referendum the Oireachtas may decide not to pass the Bill.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

What of the voice of the people then?

Comment on this

There would be a problem.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

Of course there would. Why go down that route?

Comment on this

We are putting it before the people who will decide. Any Oireachtas which refused to comply with the will of the people would deserve to be condemned. I would condemn it roundly. However, we are not hiding this. We are saying that if the legislation is not passed within 180 days, it will fall.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

The general public will not understand that.

Comment on this

We are not taking any powers away from the Oireachtas.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

If it is done once, it will be done again.

Comment on this

Constitutionally, it is a correct, sound approach. Many of the comments made about the President are overstated. I have great confidence in her. This side of the House enthusiastically supported her nomination and election. However, any President would only refer a Bill to test its constitutionality and rarely do so in accordance with his or her private views. In this case, because the whole issue is being put to the people, they will have decided on its constitutionality, the reason there is no need to utilise Article 26 or Article 27.

Once the Bill is passed it will be subject to interpretation by the Supreme Court should anyone wish to challenge it. Any legislation we pass here is subject to interpretation by the courts if cases are made. The constitutional status of the Act is the key point. It will require that the rest of the Constitution be construed in a manner which is consistent with the fact that it is intra vires of the Constitution. The Act will enjoy the full protection of the Constitution once passed by the people after the amendment is decided.

Comment on this

Let us take this to its practical conclusion. The Minister has clearly stated that this will be put directly to the people and will be passed by the people and that the people are the ultimate decision-makers. I accept that absolutely but I must ask the Minister to get down to the practicalities. The Minister might imagine himself at the polling station in Turner's Cross. He is presented with his ballot paper. Is he also presented with the entire document, the entire Bill? No. What the people will be presented in the referendum with the words in sections 1 and 2. That is exactly what will be on the ballot paper. This is what the people will read when they go in and they will mark either yes or no. They will not have seen the Bill and they will not know what it is all about. Technically speaking, the people will not vote on that Bill because that Bill will not be presented to each voter. If this proposal is passed, this bit will go into the Constitution. There will be an election, the Government will possibly change but Bertie will be able to say that he was a good lad, he kept his promise to the four Independents and he had a constitutional referendum. He will say that the other crowd will not bring it in after the change of Government.

The Minister has acknowledged that this is unprecedented legislative practice. It is giving almost an unconstitutional power to the Oireachtas. That is the reality. It is a fundamental breach of the Constitution. I do not believe Senator O'Donovan, who has a legal background, believes the argument he made. The realities are that the people will not be voting on that Bill; they will hear that there is legislation hanging around but they will not know the fine detail. It is unprecedented and unconstitutional and should not proceed.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I have a huge respect for the capacity of this Minister and I have a certain degree of sympathy for him. Apart from saying that they should not have started on it, I will not try to make this into a party political issue. I have tried to avoid that. My own views on this have been known for a long time.

I come back again to the fact that the President knows the role of her office better than I do and the Government is saying it does not trust her to understand her role. She will have to sign this Bill. It would have been more honest to say that this Bill when enacted by the Oireachtas does not need to be signed by the President. We are telling her that she still has the role of signing this Bill but we are withdrawing her constitutional role to question whether it is consistent with the Constitution. It is possible that this Bill might contradict another section.

Let us remember what happened to Article 40.3.3º. One of the reasons for the problem was that it produced conflicting rights, not just in 40.3.3º but in terms of the fundamental idea of the right of the citizen to life. That is why the Supreme Court interpreted 40.3.3º in a way which is totally at variance with what its advocates thought it would mean because it contradicted something else in the Constitution. That is a separate issue but the fundamental issue is that I trust the President not to do something which is at variance with the Constitution. I trust the Supreme Court not to do something which is a variance with the Constitution. If it would be inappropriate for this Bill to be referred by the President to the Supreme Court to adjudicate on it, I am perfectly happy to leave that choice to the President who has to sign it. I therefore do not understand why if it is so obvious, we have to prohibit it. I think there might be a problem that their lordships might feel that some sections of this Bill were in conflict with the Constitution. I do not know.

Comment on this

How could they decide that if the people had voted?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It is perfectly conceivable to have contradictory amendments to a Constitution, to have an amendment passed which contradicts another.

Comment on this

The people have decided and the people are supreme.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It would be wiser for us to identify such a thing in advance. The Minister may well have a point. Maybe the President should not and probably would not, and maybe the Supreme Court should not and probably would not, get involved in this, but it is a pre-emptive strike entirely out of proportion to the risk to take the powers away from them, while at the same time reserving to the Oireachtas the right to ignore the people. That is the case whatever the Minister's view as to whether it should or should not be enacted.

If I am a supporter of a Government and this legislation has not been passed, I will be doing my best to ensure that it is not passed, because I will be a Member of an Oireachtas which was given that power under the Constitution to do precisely that. I will not be intimidated by people telling me things such as the Minister has said. I still believe it is wrong afterwards. If the Oireachtas is left with the right to refuse to pass this legislation, then as far as I am concerned the Oireachtas is entitled to exercise that right and nobody should pretend otherwise.

If we do not believe that the President or the Supreme Court are capable of understanding what their roles are in a constitutional democracy, if we believe that they are so capable of being wrong to the extent that we write them out to make sure of it, then our constitutional order does not stand up to much. There is no reason for that subsection.

Comment on this

There has been much talk about trust and lack of trust. Senator Ryan said he trusted the President and the Supreme Court to make an informed decision but not the people.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

He never said that.

Comment on this

The corollary of what the Senator said is that the people cannot be trusted to make an informed decision. That is political naivety or political bravery of the highest order.

Comment on this

I accept that the approach to dealing with this issue is unprecedented in the Irish Constitution. It is not unprecedented in other constitutions or in other countries.

Comment on this

We are now dealing with the de Valera Constitution, not with other jurisdictions.

Comment on this

County Clare will never forget or forgive.

Comment on this

The Constitution Review Group and the All-Party Committee on the Constitution were composed of people from all sides and included senior people from the Opposition party. It proposed a referendum and legislation as the way forward. That is what we are proposing.

Comment on this
Denis Cregan Acting Chairman (Mr. D. Cregan) Fine Gael

Senator O'Donovan is in order.

Comment on this

I think there is some confusion about the role of the President and the role of the courts. The Constitution belongs to the people and it would be utter nonsense if provisions under Articles 26 of the Constitution, allowing the President to refer a Bill to the Supreme Court, were used after having given the people their say. We will ask the people to decide in February or March and once they have decided, de facto that will be the end of the matter. We should not be confused, the people will be first to decide and having done so the functions of the President or the Supreme Court are nullified. They will have no say because if that were the case the Constitution would be—

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

The President may not necessarily intervene, but she has the option.

Comment on this

The President has no function when the people have decided.

Comment on this

There are conflicting legal opinions on this, which completely undermine what the Government is trying to do. As I said on Second Stage, based on legal advice I got, we are contravening Article 26 of the Constitution, which allows the President to refer a Bill to the Supreme Court to see if it is repugnant to the Constitution. We are undermining the Constitution. If the Government wants to refer everything to the people, why not be honest about it, abolish the Constitution and introduce a system like the one that exists in Switzerland? We could vote every week and forget about the Legislature and the President.

Comment on this

The people have the ultimate power.

Comment on this

Nobody denies that. Why are we embarking on something that is totally unprecedented to achieve a certain aim?

Comment on this

It is not totally unprecedented. This was done with the Good Friday Agreement.

Comment on this

Why not respect the Constitution as it stands? Why not respect the Office of the President? This will be challenged again. The Government's legal advice comes from the Attorney General, mine is from another eminent senior counsel and already there is a conflict. The Government has opened up a minefield. Having sat through the debate, I do not believe the Minister can stand over this.

Comment on this

It is crystal clear.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

The Minister agrees it is not crystal clear

Comment on this

We have had prevarication on some of the issues. What we have is opinion, not clarity.

Comment on this

Senator O'Donovan referred to the report of the All-Party Committee on the Constitution in relation to the holding of a referendum. I am a member of that committee. We reached consensus on many things, but we did not reach consensus on the need for a referendum. I support the comments made on this side of the House in relation to this amendment.

Comment on this

I reiterate—

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

You have already spoken on this.

Comment on this

There is nothing to stop me from coming in again. I reiterate the point made by Senator O'Meara. Senator O'Donovan referred to the fact that some members of our party agreed with this line. They agreed to legislation on the X case, but not to proceeding to hold a referendum. To leave that on the record of the House would have been totally wrong.

Comment on this

It was one of the options.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to the Good Friday Agreement in a passing comment. From its foundation, the Fianna Fáil Party was very slow to involve itself in constitutional politics. It did not engage in constitutional politics until it got its own Constitution in 1937. It is now showing a blatant disregard for the Constitution of which its founding father was the architect in 1937. I am concerned that it is reverting to unconstitutional matters given the cavalier manner in which it is dealing with this issue. I am surprised a Minister of the calibre of the Minister, Deputy Martin, for whom I have regard, would involve himself in this. I thought he was one of the fathers of the future of Fianna Fáil. Further reducing the powers of the Constitution and the Oireachtas is to be frowned upon.

Comment on this

I reject the arguments that this is a fundamental breach of the Constitution. It could not be and is not.

Comment on this

That is the legal opinion.

Comment on this

How can anything be in breach of the Constitution if the people have decided? Everything has to go before the people who will decide this one way or the other. In a republic, the people are sovereign. It is not a question of not trusting the President or the Supreme Court. We are developing a mechanism to ascertain the will of the people.

Comment on this

It is a mechanism to usurp the Constitution.

Comment on this

The people cannot usurp the Constitution, the people make the Constitution.

Comment on this

The President is the person.

Comment on this

The President guards the Constitution as made in the context of any future legislation that may vary with, undermine or be in breach of the Constitution. That is the role of the President. The President may refer legislation to the Supreme Court to test its constitutionality. This legislation will form part of the Constitution if passed by the people. There is no need to go through other mechanisms to second-guess a decision of the people. I will not decide this nor will the Government, but the people will. Any suggestion that it is in some way in breach of the Constitution is absolute nonsense and does not stand up. That is not a matter of opinion, it is a matter of fact.

Comment on this

That will be cited to the Minister in the future.

Comment on this

This is not exactly the same as the Good Friday Agreement, but there is a similarity.

Comment on this

The only time Fianna Fáil agreed to the 1922 Constitution was when it signed up to the Good Friday Agreement.

Comment on this

I do not want to go through the evolution of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

It came around to the Fine Gael way of thinking when it signed up to the Good Friday Agreement.

Comment on this

The 1927 general election was very interesting because it involved several Cumann na nGaedheal people coming over to the Fianna Fáil side. The same happened in 1932. The great Professor Alfred O'Rahilly, the Dowdalls etc. saw the light and came over to the Fianna Fáil side of the House. Both parties were central to the consolidation of politics in this country at a time when other European countries were taking other routes. The Labour Party also played a noble role.

Comment on this

What about the Independents?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil was not around during the Civil War although its predecessor was.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

We did not kill our fellow Irishmen because we did not agree with them.

Comment on this

I agree that it did not. The Labour Party would have been in power if John Jinks had voted the right way.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I ask the Minister to address the amendment.

Comment on this

It is no harm to have some light relief from time to time. The amended Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution only came into effect when the Government declared within a limited period that the State had become bound by the Good Friday Agreement. If no such declaration had been made by the Government, the amendment would have lapsed. That was a complex and unprecedented formula that was put to the people. The word "unprecedented" has been bandied about as if it was a dirty word, but it is not. Things happen in an unprecedented way from time to time. It happened with the Good Friday Agreement and on this occasion, two new subsections will be added to Article 40.3 if the Oireachtas, within six months, enacts the protection of human life in pregnancy Bill.

On Senator Ryan's point, it would be fundamentally undemocratic if the Oireachtas decided not to implement the will of the people.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It would have been acceptable for Articles 2 and 3.

Comment on this

No, it would have been wrong.

Comment on this

The Minister is covering himself in case he does not get back into government.

Comment on this

In terms of the Constitution and the will of the people as clearly articulated in a referendum, it would be fundamentally undemocratic to work to undermine that decision, irrespective of one's personal or political views.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

It could happen.

Comment on this

One could do it through another constitutional referendum if one wanted to, but to say one would work not to give effect to a decision of the people is fundamentally undemocratic. I would find great difficulty with legislators who would purposefully and in a premeditated way set out to undermine the will of the people. We have said all there is to say on the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

de Valera's is a fine constitution. It is a remarkably liberal document dating from the 1930s when liberalism was not a characteristic of some parties in the House, which should not force us back into that time too enthusiastically. They have issues about which they should not invite us to think. If the Minister's argument about the Bill is right, there is a question about the constitutional propriety of the process. My party raised the appropriateness of the legislation to amend the Constitution containing other matters, that is, the Second Schedule. These are constitutional issues at which the Supreme Court might feel it is entitled to look. While it may not be appropriate for it to rule on the constitutional niceties of the Bill to protect human life, it might feel entitled to look at the process of the amendment and the legislation and state that is not what Bun reacht na hÉireann envisaged as the correct way to amend the Constitution.

Comment on this

Precisely.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It might be entitled to say that after a referendum is held because a referendum not held in accordance with law would be null and void. If we did not hold a referendum in accordance with the Constitution, there would be a serious issue as to whether a decision was made by the people and, therefore, whether it was an amendment to the Constitution. It would not be outside the bounds of possibility for the Supreme Court to take upon itself the right to consider the process by which it was done and decide on it. That would not represent an interference in the activity. It would be a defence of the Constitution, which is the job of the Supreme Court. Without going through the nitty-gritty of the Bill, it could look at the process. The subsection means that an attempt by anybody to get the Supreme Court to look at the validity of the process in terms of the Constitution is being prevented. That is a fair issue because the process is new, unprecedented and different, as the Minister said. There is nothing wrong with unprecedented decisions, but they deserve to be scrutinised. This is preventing the process from being scrutinised.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It is preventing the process from being scrutinised. There is no stage where the Supreme Court can look at the process.

Comment on this

I hate when matters become repetitive, but sometimes one must repeat to get the message across. I agree with Senator Ryan. The Bill has serious implications for the Constitution and threatens the withdrawal of fundamental rights, one of which is the right of the President and the Supreme Court. We disagree on a fundamental part of the Bill. The arguments Senator Ryan made are compelling. He has given a slightly different angle to it, which is interesting. It shows the quagmire into which we are descending and it is the Minister's fault.

Comment on this

Members should read Article 26 in terms of the Bill to amend the Constitution. Article 26 states, "This Article applies to any Bill passed or deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas other than a Money Bill, or a Bill expressed to be a Bill containing a proposal to amend the Constitution. . . " We are referring to the Bill which will subsequently pass through after the people vote for it. That may not be referred to the President because the people have decided.

Comment on this

The Minister has made the case. The first section of the Bill is an amendment to the Constitution, while the second part is legislation. It is unprecedented for a Bill which has passed its five Stages in the House to be put under the umbrella of a Bill to amend the Constitution. Article 26 reads, "a Bill expressed to be a Bill containing a proposal to amend the Constitution, or a Bill the time for the consideration of which by Seanad Éireann shall have been abridged under Article 24 of this Constitution." There will not be an opportunity for the legislative part of the Bill, which will subsequently be in the Statute Book, to be signed by the President and referred to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

The people will have decided.

Comment on this

The Minister should not give us the people argument. He is deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

The people will not decide the legislation.

Comment on this

They will.

Comment on this

The legislation must pass through the House in the same way as the five Stages passed through the other House. The constitutional amendment will be put to the people. The First and Second Schedules, the legislation, will not go through the normal process as enacted by the Constitution, thereby enabling the President and the Supreme Court to amend it.

Comment on this

My understanding is we are arguing about a gap between the passage of the Bill and the holding of a referendum.

Comment on this

No. They are talking about after the referendum.

Comment on this

After 180 days.

Comment on this

The Bill does not become an Act until after the referendum. It must come back to the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

I see.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

This is an appropriate place to raise an issue since we are ranging far and wide, including into history. The Government is presuming to run the affairs of the Oireachtas with the proposal about the Bill because it will put a Bill through the Oireachtas which it states does not have a right to amend it. That is an interesting idea. The Bill referred to in the Second Schedule will, the Minister hopes, come before the Oireachtas sometime within 180 days of the referendum. The Houses of the Oireachtas will be told they cannot amend it.

Comment on this

The people will have decided.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Why not end the pretence and write into the legislation that the Bill will have been deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas? What is the point of going through the charade of Oireachtas scrutiny?

Comment on this

That would contravene Article 15.

Comment on this

The Minister is contravening Article 26.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The Minister is contravening the spirit of Article 15 if the Oireachtas rubber stamps something because the Government instructs it to do so. I find it peculiar, but we have said enough on the issue.

Comment on this

We will have to agree to disagree. We have argued it well.

Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh na focail a thairgtear a scriosadh."

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I wish to announce a correction to the list of amendments. After amendment No. 6, the words "section opposed" should read "Schedule opposed" and the names of Senators Ryan, Costello and O'Meara should have appeared on the printed list in addition to the names of Senators Jackman, Keogh, Manning and Taylor-Quinn.

Tairgeadh an cheist: "Gurb é an Chéad Sceideal an Chéad Sceideal a ghabann leis an mBille."

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the Schedule, especially the subsection beginning: "If a law, containing only the provisions set out. . . "? I am confused about its effect. Will he explain the effect of this in plain language?

Comment on this

I have the same question. Senator Ryan has kindly explained it to me. However, given that he and the Minister have not agreed on the explanation of earlier matters, it would be wise if the Minister explained it to me as well.

Comment on this

Is Senator O'Meara referring to page seven of the Bill?

Comment on this

It is page seven, lines 24 to 32. The subsection begins: "If a law, containing only the provisions set out. . . ".

Comment on this

That is the subsection I would also like explained.

Comment on this

The subsection states:

If a law, containing only the provisions set out in . . . The Second Schedule to the Twenty-fifth Amendment . . . Act . . . is enacted by the Oireachtas, this section, other than the amendment of Article 40 of this Constitution effected thereby, shall be omitted from every official text of this Constitution published thereafter, but notwithstanding such omission this section shall continue to have the force of law.

It is self-explanatory. What will be included in the Constitution—

Comment on this

With respect, it is not.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

Subsections 4º and 5º will be included in the Constitution. The First Schedule contains the proposed text of the amendment of Article 46 of the Constitution. The proposed text to be inserted as Article 46.6.1º, in turn, contains the proposed text of Articles 40.3.4º and 40.3.5º of the Constitution. The proposed text of Article 40.3.4º provides that, in particular, the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected in accordance with the provisions of the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002. The use of the term "in particular" makes it clear that the statute envisaged by the amendment, if enacted, is not intended to be a restatement or redefinition of "the unborn" as used in Article 40.3.3º.

The existing Article 40.3.3º, as amended in 1992, will remain in place. The effect of the text proposed as Article 40.3.5º is that any Bill containing provisions to amend the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, must be referred to the people in a further referendum if, in future, people wish to amend it.

The effect of the text proposed as Article 46.6.2º is that if the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, is enacted, and amendments are made to Article 40, the amendments to Article 46 will no longer appear in the official text of the Constitution, and the amendments made to Article 40 will take effect, appearing in the appropriate place within that Article. This is because once the amendment to Article 40.3 takes place, it would be undesirable for the new Article 40.3 to appear in more than one place in the Constitution.

The text proposed as Article 46.6.3º contains a mechanism whereby, unless within 180 days – as Senators know, we discussed this matter already – a law is enacted in exactly the terms of the text seen and approved by the people when they vote on the proposed amendment, the whole of Article 46.6 will cease to have effect and the Constitution will revert to the form in which it existed before the referendum.

The text proposed as Article 46.4 states that the Bill for the law on the protection of human life in pregnancy is excluded from the terms of Articles 26 and 27 of the Constitution, which we have just debated in the previous amendment.

Comment on this

It is still not totally clear to me. Can the Minister explain the text in the First Schedule, Part 2, lines 30 to 32, which states, "but not withstanding such omission this section shall continue to have the force of law"?

Comment on this

It must continue to have the force of law.

Comment on this

The term is, "but not withstanding such omission [which means that it is being taken out] this section shall continue to have the force of law". While this may be absolutely clear to everyone else, it is opaque to me. I cannot follow exactly what that means. My concern is that we will have to explain this to people, so I would like to be sure what I am explaining.

Comment on this

I have explained that it means the same provision will not appear twice in the Constitution. That is the point.

Comment on this

I was very confused before the Minister's statement but now I do think I understand it.

Comment on this

The same happened in the Good Friday Agreement.

Comment on this

As I understand it, it is redundant—

Comment on this

—because it already exists in one place and there is no point in having it in two places. Therefore, it is not as if the substance is being left out of the Constitution.

Comment on this

The substance is very clearly in there but it is a kind of redundant clause which the Minister is tidying out of the way. I have no problem with that at all. It seems logical to me.

Comment on this

Very well read.

Comment on this

Thanks. We do things well in TCD.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will correct me if I am wrong. If this amendment to the Constitution is passed, do I take it that henceforth Article 40.3.3º will state:

The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate that right.

This subsection shall not limit freedom to travel between the State and another state.

This subsection shall not limit freedom to obtain or make available, in the State, subject to such conditions as may be laid down by law, information relating to services lawfully available in another state.

I take it the new text will then be inserted as follows:

4º In particular, the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected in accordance with the provisions of the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002.

5º The provisions of section 2 of Article 46 and sections 1, 3 and 4 of Article 47 of this Constitution shall apply to any Bill passed or deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas containing a proposal to amend the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, as they apply to a Bill containing a proposal or proposals for the amendment of this Constitution and any such Bill shall be signed by the President forthwith upon his being satisfied that the Bill has been duly approved by the people in accordance with the provisions of section 1 of Article 47 of this Constitution and shall be duly promulgated by the President as a law.

Does it stop there?

Comment on this

It stops there and that is it? That will be the new Article 40.

Comment on this

Yes, Article 40.3.3º, 3.4º, and 3.5º, as the Senator has just read out.

Comment on this

And that is it?

Comment on this

Is this, in effect, what will be presented to the people when the ballot paper is presented to them?

Comment on this

No. What will be presented to the people is the text on page 7 of the Bill. That is my understanding. The full Schedule to be presented to the people will be posted up on the noticeboards in the polling stations.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

Not on the ballot paper itself?

Comment on this

I am talking about the ballot paper. Forget the polling station, I am talking about when the people go to vote.

Comment on this

They will vote on the proposed Bill to amend the Constitution, as they have done in the case of every other constitutional amend ment, whether it was the Fourteenth, Fifteenth or Sixteenth Amendment. In this case it will be the Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill.

Comment on this

Will it be the little bit on page 4 of the Bill, containing sections 1 and 2, that will be on the ballot paper?

Comment on this

I will confirm that for the Senator later.

Comment on this

Is the text on page 7 of the Bill what will be sent out in the post?

Comment on this

That will be up on every noticeboard in the polling stations.

Comment on this

Hold on a second. The Second Schedule will not appear on any posters or noticeboards.

Comment on this

It can do, yes.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am sorry, Senator Taylor-Quinn, but we are not yet dealing with the Second Schedule. We are dealing with the First Schedule at this stage.

Comment on this

I am aware of that, a Chathaoirligh, but we are dealing with a fundamental principle of what the people will be voting on. We need to be very clear about what will be presented to the people on the ballot paper and what they will actually be asked to vote on. We have now got clarification from the Minister, specifically, but the more clarification we get the more unconstitutional the proposal appears to be. It is essential that it be strongly opposed.

Comment on this

By way of clarification, I would point out that this is very similar to what occurred in the Good Friday Agreement.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

They are two different things.

Comment on this

Sections 4 and 5 of the Nineteenth Amendment of the Constitution Act, 1998, state:

if a declaration under this section is made this subsection and subsections other than the amendment of the Constitution affected thereby, and subsection (5) of this section, shall be omitted from every official text of this Constitution, published thereafter, but notwithstanding such omissions this section shall continue to have the force of law.

It is exactly the same kind of provision.

Comment on this

There is a difference.

Comment on this

Section 5 went on to state:

if such a declaration is not made within 12 months of this section being added to the Constitution, or such longer period as may be provided for by law, this section shall cease to have effect and shall be omitted from every official text of the Constitution published thereafter. . .

It is a very similar construction.

Comment on this

Yes, it is very similar but not the same. The Minister was talking about a declaration there, not about a Bill that is presented in five Stages.

Comment on this

The Senator was talking about an action that was dependent on something happening after the people had voted.

Comment on this

Yes, which is quite extraneous to the normal legislative process that is incorporated in the Constitution. The Minister was not talking about introducing a Bill that goes through five Stages in each House of the Oireachtas and which is subsequently referred to the President who, in turn, can refer it to the Supreme Court. To draw similarities is not fair because the circumstances are different.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

They are different circumstances.

Comment on this

We have argued about the fundamental point that the people are sovereign, and that is very important. It is the people who will decide on this. Only then, after they have decided, will the Act go back to the Oireachtas to be passed.

Comment on this

We would have no problem with the Act going back to the Oireachtas if the normal process could be followed, whereby be it could be amended in both Houses, passed and referred to the President. What is happening here, however, is unprecedented. It is bringing an unconstitutional role to the Houses of the Oireachtas. In another sense it is diminishing the powers of the President. Inherent within it is another Act which amends the Constitution to reduce the powers of the President. Within this constitutional amendment is another, not very apparent, constitutional amendment which considerably reduces the powers of the President.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Senator is now broadening the scope of the debate.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are dealing only with the First Schedule.

Cuireadh an cheist.

Comment on this
Division

Rinne an Choiste votáil: Tá, 27; Níl, 19.

Tá 27
·
Níl 19
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 12 are related and will be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

Tairgim leasú a 9:

I leathanach 9, líne 12, "(nó, i gcás éigeandála liachta agus i gcás ina gcreideann an cleachtóir lena mbaineann gur gá sin ar mhaithe le bainistiú leas a othair nó a hothair, in aon áit eile)" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "fhormheasta".

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 8, line 12, after "place" to insert "(or, in case of medical emergency and where the practitioner concerned believes the management of the welfare of his or her patient so requires, any other place)".

Amendment No. 9 refers to the notion of an approved place. It causes a lot of concern because an element of confusion could arise. Will the Minister clarify what he is likely to do? My understanding is that the term "approved place" will mean that the Minister, if the referendum is passed and the Bill becomes law, will prescribe by regulation or order the approved places where the procedures can be carried out. I know from work on the all-party committee that in general the major Dublin maternity hospitals are the ones which handle medical emergencies or difficulties in pregnancies from around the country. Am I right in assuming that these hospitals would be approved places? Will the Minister clarify the important matter of what is likely to happen if the referendum is passed and the Bill is enacted?

On the issue of an approved place, what happens in the event of a pregnancy related medical emergency which occurs far from an approved place? Will the Minister clarify what would happen in such circumstances? I know the legislation also deals with the issue of intent in relation to termination, medical procedure and abortion, and that is presumably to protect medical practitioners. It is not just we as legislators and the public who will be voting in the referendum who need to be clear about what is happening here. Medical practitioners will be in the front line in the carrying out of the provisions of this legislation. I ask the Minister to clarify that position.

Our amendment is designed to clarify the position, particularly in relation to medical practitioners. The wording of the amendment is self-explanatory. We seek to provide further protection in the legislation with the inclusion of the words "(or, in the case of medical emergency and where the practitioner concerned believes the management of the welfare of his or her patient so requires, any other place)". In other words, we seek to ensure that the welfare of the patient is paramount, which I think is also the Minister's intention. Until I hear the Minister's thinking on where these approved places are, I am convinced, given the way the legislation is phrased, that we need to expand along the lines of our amendment. I consider that not only necessary but urgent.

Comment on this

This is one of the areas in the Bill that causes me most concern. From a practical point of view, this is where we may run into a great deal of difficulty, particularly when we take account of the definition of the term "approved place".

Section 4 of the Second Schedule provides that a person can be a conscientious objector to what is in fact a legal procedure to save the life of the mother. When this section was discussed by the Dáil at Committee Stage, I felt that at any moment they would discuss the situation regarding haemorrhage in particular. While I agree with the masters of the three maternity hospitals that there are four to six cases a year of serious pre-eclampsia, HELLP syndrome, Eisenmenger's syndrome or a problem with another cardiac condition, it is important that we remember there are likely to be greater rather than fewer serious cardiac problems because we have made great strides in cardiac surgery in children in the past 20 years. Those children are now coming up to child-bearing age.

I cannot be the only doctor who had a patient in her early 30s who was eager to have a child, but was anxious because she had a major cardiac operation as a child and wondered what I thought. That woman's cardiologist told her he felt she should proceed if that was what she wanted. We all had to be aware during her pregnancy that it was at 20 weeks – when the unborn child is not viable and the blood volume really increases – that she might run into trouble. We had to be in a position to provide that something could be done to terminate the pregnancy, if necessary.

Having regard to the Supreme Court judgment in the X case, I would have thought that situation is all right. Judge O'Flaherty's judgment indicated that there did not have to be immediate signs that a woman's death was about to take place or one did not have to be certain that a woman's death would take place, but that if there was a real and substantial risk to the mother's life the pregnancy could be terminated. It could be aborted, even though the unborn child would not be not viable. I agree with the Minister that there are a small number of cases in this area and there may be more, but I am sure that the obstetricians will be well able to cope with them.

The situation regarding haemorrhage was not really considered by the Dáil at Committee Stage. When this area was discussed, I recall the Minister said that he would go back to his medical advisers and ask them what they thought. I am sure he did that because I do not think he wants any woman's life to be put in danger. There may be a problem in this area in that those who work in large maternity hospitals deal with women who have serious haemorrhage in association with pregnancy, childbirth or in the six weeks after childbirth. That is so common that they may have thought it was run of the mill and could be coped with, but I am not sure it can between the definition on an "approved place" and the section on conscientious objections.

When the Minister was asked on Tuesday, 27 November what would be an approved place, he said the Minister would make an order that would list hospitals so approved and, on foot of amendments being brought forward, the Oireachtas would have the opportunity to affirm these orders. We got more information from the Taoiseach on what would be an approved place. In a reply to Deputy Noonan he said, the term "approved place" is intended to be applied to hospitals under responsible management, possessing adequate expertise in the area of obstetrics and gynaecology and in the treatment and prevention of life-threatening diseases arising out of or complicated by pregnancy.

I mentioned women with HELLP syndrome. For the benefit of other Senators, this is a condition where a woman has very high blood pressure and her condition is so serious that she suffers haemolysis of her red blood cells. That affects her liver and kidneys which start to shut down. This is a dire situation. The last such case I read about in medical literature was of a woman who was approximately 20 weeks pregnant when this happened. It was totally unexpected, but she had access to University College Hospital, Galway, where she was treated very properly. There is some time in such cases to get the woman to hospital. These are not the type of cases about which I am concerned.

I am concerned about the Taoiseach's definition of an "approved place", having regard to the contracting nature of the maternity services. Even during the Minister's term of office quite a number of hospitals with maternity units have been closed. For example, we have all been involved at some level with the debate that has taken place in the North-Eastern Health Board on the closure of Monaghan and Dundalk hospitals. That decision was right because there was not an adequate number of staff in those hospitals to provide the level of service pregnant women require. The Minister was right to support the report which recommended that there could be midwife led services there, but that will not come under the Taoiseach's definition of what is an approved place. I presume we must go by the Taoiseach's definition, given that no one else has given one.

There is a contraction in maternity services and a serious deficit of midwives around the country. There is also the problem in the lack of obstetricians. There are major problems regarding medical insurance in these areas. Given these problems, we face serious problems in dealing with woman who suffer haemorrhage in association with pregnancy.

As to why they are important, the maternal mortality rate has dropped in all western European countries and we, in the medical profession, have been advised not to quote cases because they are too easily identified. In a bad year we might have three cases of maternal mortality. Naturally, if they are discussed in a maternal mortality report, everyone will know who the woman was. We have stopped doing that for at least the past ten years.

I was involved in producing maternal mortality reports years ago. It is only 30 years since there may have been 30 such deaths in a year. Major improvements have been made, especially since, with the advent of contraception, there has been a decrease in the number of older women having a large number of children. The most likely women to die were older women with large families. Thankfully, there has been a great diminution in the number of women dying during pregnancy. That is due not only to improved obstetrics care but also to the fact that women have more of a choice about whether they become pregnant. If women have had an illness, in many cases they are unlikely to try to become pregnant again. I can remember hearing of women with rheumatic hearts in maternity wards in this city. They were lined up for death. All that was ahead of them was cardiac failure and while the baby may have been born and may have survived, its mother would have died.

We are advised always to refer to the Report of the Confidential Inquiries into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom. These are excellent reports produced every three years. They reveal that haemorrhage is a major cause of direct maternal deaths. The rate has varied between about 10% and 20% over the past ten years. The unfortunate thing is that many of these cases were unexpected. The cases do not always include all those in early pregnancy as some of the deaths are due to spontaneous abortions which are not reported as many did not happen in maternity hospitals. There may be even more than we know – the results of the confidential inquiries and the general health statistics always differ, with the greater number of deaths recorded in the latter.

What women have these haemorrhages? A large number of them are older women and many are women who have had poor maternal care or are not known by the hospitals. Unfortunately, a number of them are from ethnic minorities while others are women who have concealed their pregnancies. This is increasing in this country rather than decreasing. It is a problem that will not go away. This is one of the great difficulties about excluding everywhere that does not have obstetric or paediatric care from the list of approved places. I suggest we would be wiser not to have approved places.

We have some idea about identifying cases that might be at risk in this country. Due to the decrease in maternal mortality in recent years efforts have been made to bring forward reports on near miss maternal mortality and I know the Minister has supported this. The following is cited from a letter which appeared in the Irish Medical Journal in March 1992:

Sir, We wish to introduce the term near miss maternal mortality (NMM). This is defined as a serious maternal morbidity directly or indirectly due to pregnancy, arising in pregnancy or within 42 days of delivery necessitating transfer to an intensive care unit (ICU) or coronary care unit (CCU). The NMM rate is calculated per 1,000 deliveries (including abortions, ectopic pregnancies and hydatidiform moles).

I want to make it clear that abortions in this case are spontaneous abortions. They are not therapeutic abortions, although those that take place before the child is viable could be described as that. They can happen after spontaneous abortions. This is really risky because when someone is 15 to 19 weeks into pregnancy she may have had very little contact with the doctor or hospital. These are a very vulnerable group. That letter was from 1992 and I am sure the Minister or his advisers will have seen a recent letter in the same journal from the University College Hospital in Galway that raised this issue again. They pointed out that there are still no statistics on near miss maternal mortality available and that they should be provided. The major hospitals in the Dublin area are certainly trying to produce this and I applaud the Minister's encouragement of that as it is extraordinarily important.

A recent near miss maternal mortality survey carried out in the Coombe Hospital gives some indication of conditions. Dr. Bridgette Byrne was the consultant in charge and Dr. Carmel Sheridan was one of the registrars who worked on it. The survey ran from January 1999 until October 2001 inclusive. It was very well done. It was important that it should be a prospective survey as there is no point in carrying out a retrospective survey. In the period, 21,170 women delivered babies. Of that number, more than 50 were near miss maternal mortalities, that is about one in 400. It is many people. Haemorrhage was the major cause of near miss maternal mortality, with 31 women suffering from it. This does not include those who with post-partum or caesarean hysterectomies also suffered serious haemorrhages.

There were eight instances of eclampsia which is associated with high blood pressure and kidney problems. That is a much smaller number, yet it is for them we are catering in our approved places. There was a case of failed incubation – that was an anaesthetic problem – and amniotic fluid embolism, which is totally unexpected and nothing could be done about it. There was also a case of diabetic ketoacidosis. That can be a problem, which involves dealing with diabetics, and I am sure the hospital was able to care for the person. There was also a case of respiratory failure.

The big group were the 31 who suffered haemorrhage. How much bleeding did these women have? The near miss maternal mortality criteria was taken from a protocol from Pretoria, South Africa, which was agreed some years ago and is considered to be very useful. It asked if the woman had to have more than five units of blood. That would involve the replacement of a woman's entire blood volume. It is quite a bleed, and there were 31 of them.

Suppose this were to happen in a rural area. I do not know if the Independent Deputies who are pushing this have been assured that approved places are to be provided in each of their constituencies. I would like to know what is going to happen to someone who starts bleeding in Goleen. Bantry has no obstetrics unit and it will not be an approved place. I do not think the Minister should build one there – that is not what I am asking. If this happens I suggest that Senator O'Donovan should become a conscientious objector, head for Castletownbere and let Deputy Healy-Rae deal with the matter. By the time the woman would reach Cork she would be very ill. She may have bled for quite some time before anyone got to her.

Comment on this

She would not be treated on the side of a hill and one would not propose that. That is the core point.

Comment on this

Amazingly some women could be treated there. If a woman had a spontaneous abortion, up to about 18 weeks, she could be treated. I worked in the Rotunda Hospital and we used to go around the district before these women were admitted. We dealt with them in houses. I recall being with a woman in a room at the top of Parnell Square while her husband shone a light on her from the next room because they were living in poverty. She lay on a mattress on the floor while the registrar and I dealt with her. She was not admitted to hospital.

However, it is not correct of the Minister to say no one will be able to do anything.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

We will run into serious danger because of this provision even though the Minister does not want anyone to run into serious danger. I am dying to see what Deputy Fox will do when people in Glendalough ask her to get a woman to Dublin in an ambulance when the snow is on the ground and the ambulance has to pass Loughlinstown Hospital because it has no obstetrics or paediatric care, the Blackrock Clinic, although in these circumstances the woman would be taken in, and St. Vincent's Hospital until it arrives Holles Street Hospital. That is a serious situation. Something should certainly be done for her in Loughlinstown but it will not be an approved place.

What will Deputy Gildea do for people in Ard ara? Will he attempt to cross the mountain passes to reach Letterkenny or will he travel to Sligo? Both journeys involve long distances and that coastline is well populated as people are encouraged to live there. Others are advised to travel to Derry where they will not have the problem of meeting a conscientious objector. This is serious.

I do not like another aspect of the approved places, namely that they will only be used for what is a legal procedure. Nothing new will be made legal. An inference can be drawn from this provision that some doctors may be doing things they should not be in other places but that is not happening. The intention of the provision is to prevent people from carrying out socio-economic abortions.

Comment on this

It is hardly to give the best medical care.

Comment on this

It is all about safety. I will argue the point later.

Comment on this

Very often the best thing is to travel to the centre of greatest expertise but when one is travelling between Goleen and Cork one is dealing with another scenario. I do not ask the Minister to establish an obstetrics unit in Bantry. I read the health strategy to establish whether the proposed medical helicopter would be introduced but it has not been provided for and, therefore, such a helicopter will not be available to fish these women out.

I would not be concerned about this except that I have seen dreadful bleeding, involving 50 units of blood. The cases mentioned involved five units. However, I spoke to the consultant involved and greater amounts of blood are involved in these cases. At least in places like Bantry the medical personnel would be able to group and cross match blood and request it. This provision is fraught with danger but none of my colleagues will not conduct socio-economic abortions on women.

It is nine years since the X case and there has not been one case in which the suicide ground was used so that someone could have an abortion. The only case that was mentioned in the press was the 13 year old child who had been raped and was threatening suicide. An approved place is unfortunate. Senior managers may have said to the Minister not to worry because they can cope with everything, but I am not sure that will be case. The Minister will be aware of the old expression "over my dead body". I do not want anything to happen that will be over any woman's dead body and I am quite sure the Minister also does not.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

The atmosphere in the Chamber indicates this issue was not dealt with in the Lower House with the same clarity and detail demonstrated by Senator Henry as she arrived at the nub of the issue. She has outlined real life situations using her medical expertise and know ledge. I ask the Minister to re-examine the amendment. Perhaps Senator Henry will table the amendment for Report Stage so that he will have time to go through it. Fine Gael would have examined the concept of approved places but we wanted reassurance that the necessary expertise would be available in the approved places.

On Second Stage Senator Henry said she was concerned about women in remote parts of the country who might be at risk. She mentioned Goleen and Wicklow and I refer to west Limerick, north Tipperary or west Clare. The Senator is saying lives can be saved by adopting a broader interpretation. This needs to be spelt out clearly and a great deal of work needs to be done on approved places. She is absolutely correct, as we read day in day out about the shortage of midwives in large urban centres, that rural areas should be examined in this context. People take it that everything is fine because childbirth is natural, but Senator Henry graphically explained what happens when one comes across a relative or friend who experiences complications and an immediate decision must be made regarding the life of the mother.

I am extremely supportive of Senator Henry's amendment. Extensive logical and practical information has been put to the Minister regarding this issue. He has said "no" to earlier amendments but he has time to take into account Senator Henry's professional understanding of the plight of women in such cases, particularly where women have survived but are at risk. I implore the Minister to take the amendment on board and consider it before Report Stage.

Comment on this

Senator Henry's contribution was one of the finest I have heard on Committee Stage in my time in the House

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The breadth and depth of knowledge she displayed must be seriously considered. An approved place is ill defined in the legislation but her point is that no matter how it is defined it will not cover certain circumstances which could result in a fatality. She provided statistics on the incidence of haemorrhage among women, which could happen in a maternity hospital or as a result of a serious accident. There is a wide set of circumstances which could give rise to a medical condition that would need to be treated in an emergency where an approved place might not be easily accessible.

The Minister has the option of the Labour Party amendment or that of Senator Henry. She has proposed the deletion of "an approved place" so that all circumstances that might arise can be dealt with through a reasonable response. Our amendment would leave the reference to "approved place" in the Bill on the general understanding that it would be a hospital with obstetric and paediatric and neo-natal services, etc., but would provide for the following caveat, "(or, in cases of medical emergency and where the practitioner concerned believes the management of the welfare of his or her patient so requires, any other place)". What we are saying is that "approved place" will not cover all circumstances and that the Minister should accept an amendment which would deal with emergencies.

Notwithstanding any examples given, whether it is Goleen or the fastness of Donegal, there could be circumstances arising in Dublin, with the current traffic congestion, where it would take just as long to reach an approved place, wherever that may be. It is unsatisfactory that we must deal with this definition of "approved place", that is, "a place in the State approved for the time being by order as being suitable", without having a clear idea how many of these places will be approved, where they will be and what the services will be in these approved places. It is left up in the air and it is confusing.

I would suggest that there are serious practical problems which must be addressed here and we would like a positive response from the Minister. He must remember that what we are talking about is a procedure that, even within the context of the terms of the provision here, will be an emergency. The Bill states, "in the reasonable opinion of the practitioner, necessary to prevent a real and substantial risk of loss of the woman's life", and therefore we are dealing with approved places only in the context of emergencies and immediate action being required.

One is talking about special circumstances with which one must deal all the time. That is a highly important point. It is not about the run of the mill medical procedures. These are exceptional circumstances in every single case we are talking about. That must be taken into consideration.

I understand we are taking amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 11 together. In the other amendment, where we are proposing to delete the last clause of section 1(2), that is, after "a real and substantial risk of loss of the woman's life" to delete the words "other than by self-destruction"—

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

We are not taking amendment No. 11 with these amendments. We are taking amendments Nos. 9, 10 and 12.

Comment on this

There is enough in those.

Comment on this

That is fine. I thought it was a little out of kilter with the others.

Comment on this

It is being taken separately.

Comment on this

I want to support my colleagues who have put forward these various amendments, but in particular Senator Henry. I agree with the praise which has been given to her. The Minister must really listen carefully to what has been said because it was said so simply and without heat but clearly and factually from firmly grounded personal medical experience. The examples she gave were admirable also because they indicated the difficulty of people having to travel long distances and the risks to which their lives might be exposed in this area.

There is a suspicion around the House that, for political reasons, no amendments will be accepted in the Seanad. We are well used to this but it is a violation of the designated role of this House under the Constitution for such a position to be adopted, even informally, and we all know that it happens.

This is a compassionate and caring Minister. I need not remind him that he is Minister for Health and Children and that his responsibility is not to the political convenience of the Government or any particular party. His responsibility is clearly the welfare of patients. That is paramount, however much trouble it might get the Minister into with some of his colleagues if the Bill must be returned to the Dáil.

It seems to me that a very serious problem indeed has been drawn to our attention. If it goes through without an amendment of this kind, as I read the Bill, a doctor in an emergency who performs a therapeutic routine in order to save the life of a patient may in fact be guilty of a criminal offence.

Comment on this
Mary Jackman Mrs. Jackman Fine Gael

He will if he is not in the approved place.

Comment on this

I want the Minister to tell me if that is the case, that a doctor saving a woman's life on the side of the road or in another kind of hospital, which does not have all the facilities which the Taoiseach thinks they should have, is guilty of a criminal offence, that the Minister is criminalising the saving of life. He cannot accept that.

What about it if the Bill must return to the Dáil? That is where it must go. At the end of the day our responsibility is to the welfare of the patient.

There is an argument, as there is with regard to home births, etc., that it is better to have these emergencies dealt with in a place where there are facilities of the best kind available. In an ideal world that is so, but the amendment in the names of Senators Ryan, Costello and O'Meara makes it perfectly clear that this is in the case of emergencies.

Emergencies are not neat. That is part of their character. They are untidy, unpredictable, unexpected and one must act on the spur of the moment. If one has the medical expertise that will allow him or her to save the life of another human being, is it appropriate that because of technical considerations this act should be deemed by the State under this legislation to be criminal? I cannot believe that to be the case.

It seems to me that the Minister could not possibly have heard a clearer argument in defence of an amendment of this sort put forward by this side of the House. I will certainly be strongly supporting this important amendment. The Minister and his advisers would only gain credit for taking action in this regard to ensure the welfare of the patient, the ordinary citizen of Ireland. That, not political convenience of any kind, is what must be paramount.

Comment on this

Anybody who has listened to the incredibly compelling argument put forward by Senator Henry could only support her amendment. It is utterly compelling. She has made the case. She has the expertise which, unfortunately, none of us has. We are lucky that she is here to participate in this debate. Others of us have expertise and experience in different areas of an immediate nature which relate to this proposed Bill, but the almost heartrending plea and argument that Senator Henry is making cannot possibly be ignored.

Once more we are back to theory as opposed to practice. This is a theme which runs right through this Bill. We can not afford to ignore realities in relation to women's life and health. If we ignore this amendment, this is what we are doing.

I cannot add any more to the argument that has been put forward by Senator Henry in terms of compassion for expectant mothers. I would earnestly entreat the Minister to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

This section gives us a definition of approved place. It states clearly that it is one "approved for the time by order as being suitable for the purpose of this section". Therefore the Minister will be empowered to make an order to designate an approved place. The Minister can choose to designate as few or as many as he or she so wishes and therefore in a sense we are literally at the whim of the Minister. One individual can make a decision in whatever manner he or she chooses. How will the Minister decide what is an approved place, where it will be located and the details of such a place?

The subsection further restricts the right to life of the mother if she does not have access to an approved place. Article 40.3.3º states that the State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn with due regard to the right to life of the mother and guarantees in its laws to respect and, as far as practicable, by its laws – not by orders – to defend and vindicate that right.

The number of places approved may increase or diminish a woman's right. It may vary depending on what part of the country she lives in, the climatic conditions at any given time and the distance she may reside from an approved place. The inclusion of the words "approved place" will restrict a woman's right to life. Senator Henry made a compelling case, which impresses me as I am from a rural area, on near miss maternal mortality in the survey. Of the 50 women included, 31 suffered from a serious haemorrhage. She also gave examples of localities.

The Minister wants to be responsible as we are discussing a situation where a normal, natural miscarriage occurs and the woman needs medical attention. If she does not get to the approved place to receive the proper medical attention, she may lose her life. As Senator Henry said – we are fortunate to have someone of her medical expertise among us – five units of blood was the criterion applied in the survey, a considerable amount.

Comment on this

Is the Senator referring to the Coombe Hospital's survey of women who came under its care?

Comment on this

It was produced at a meeting the other night. It refers to those women, of whom there are about 7,000 each year.

Comment on this

It is a startling and convincing figure. The Minister must consider the information supplied by Senator Henry and consequently accept this amendment. There is a danger in including the words "approved place" as they will put at risk the lives of women living in isolated rural areas which are medically disadvantaged.

As Senator Henry stated, the recently published health strategy did not provide the helicopter which many of us had called for. In west Clare it is over 50 miles from Loop Head to Ennis. Limerick or Galway, 90 miles away, may become the approved place. This is a serious situation which must be reviewed, not just because of the information laid before us, but also because of the constitutional protection. Will women be discriminated against because of where they reside?

Comment on this

This is a good discussion, but the emergency about which we are talking is acute and sudden blood loss. The fluid lost can be replaced on the side of the road. In rural Ireland most general practitioners carry plasma expanders and fluid. The first thing to do is to stabilise the patient and reverse the shock. She is then taken to a hospital for proper and adequate treatment.

The other reality is that women in Ireland are voting for high-tech maternity units. District hospitals are closed and children are no longer delivered in nursing homes. Mothers go to the Rotunda, the Coombe and Holles Street because they feel certain that they will get the best possible treatment if anything goes wrong. If the Minister was to designate a hospital which did not have full obstetrical support – the minimum in any unit is two obstetricians on full call – he would be guilty of and encouraging malpractice. The public, especially ladies, would turn on him. In the Bill he must ensure appropriate treatment is given in appropriate units.

Comment on this

The Labour Party amendment would provide for an exclusion of requirement that procedures be carried out in approved places in an emergency and when the medical prac titioner believes that the welfare of his or her patient requires it. Senator Henry's amendment would remove the requirement regarding an approved place in section 1(2) and its definition in section 1(3). This would permit the procedures to be undertaken in any location, not just those approved by the Minister or the Oireachtas.

I want to make it clear that the Oireachtas will ultimately approve the places as I brought forward an amendment to this effect in the other House with the support of other parties. This means that orders to give effect to approved places will have to be voted on by both Houses, which is not the normal way to introduce orders and regulations which require a motion to nullify them. It will not be one person's decision, although the Minister will make the proposals. We envisage they will include major maternity and acute hospitals.

When this started I sought advice on this specific point from the masters of the three major maternity hospitals. As a lay person, I asked about emergencies.

Comment on this

Did the Minister specifically ask about haemorrhage as it is extremely common?

Comment on this

I did not but, with respect, these are the people who are aware of the complications. It is generally agreed that they gave clear, solid submissions to the Oireachtas committee. As this issue was raised on Committee Stage in the other House, I sought medical advice from my own chief medical officer. I discussed it again this morning. As Senator Fitzpatrick said, the first priority where a woman is haemorrhaging is to stabilise and then move her to a centre where she can get the best of care. What the masters said to me was that in these rare and exceptional cases, about which Senator Costello spoke – exceptional does not equate to emergency – they would bring in other medical practitioners to help and discuss the case. Cardiac, liver, renal or a range of other functions could be involved where the life of a mother is at risk because of pregnancy. All would involve a multidisciplinary team approach to her care in order to decide the best course of action.

The major issues discussed and the major medical conditions which would constitute a real and substantial risk to the life of the mother were pre-eclampsia or Eisenmenger's syndrome or cancer of the womb. It is said that these would be diagnosed in the normal way. Immediate action would not be required. There would be three or four such cases in any given year. These are the conditions where the woman concerned would be brought to a tertiary level centre. Her condition would be assessed and monitored over a period of time. It is in that context that decisions are made as to whether a medical procedure is necessary to save her life that would have the effect of ending the life of the unborn in her womb.

There would be a great issue of safety if we were to delete the words "approved places."

Comment on this

Because one would then be opening up the idea of taking chances. I accept the validity and the motivation of the excellent contribution of Senator Henry, but it is equally valid to argue the other side of the coin. The position on mortality rates has improved dramatically in recent years. The position on maternal mortality rates has improved in the last 30 or 40 years because of advances in medical practice and in terms of the environment in which women give birth. It did not happen by accident. Other socio-economic issues are also a factor. There is a very strong argument on safety grounds for putting in place a framework and controls in terms of where the medical procedures in question should take place. There are also strong arguments on the other side of the coin, but if one was to delete the words in question, one would leave the situation wide open. One may leave it open for individuals to carry out illegal abortions. That is one consideration.

The chief medical officer and others are very strongly of the view that there is a very strong safety dimension to this issue. Even the Institute of Obstetricians makes the point about the need for multidisciplinary teams of doctors who would invariably be involved before a medical procedure would be carried out that would end the life of the unborn in the event of a real and substantial risk to the life of the mother. The situation is by no means black and white.

I have been advised that there would be ample time to treat the conditions in question in terms of appropriate facilities where the highest level of medical expertise could be brought to bear on the situation. The legal side is equally important. Section 1(1) states that "abortion" means the intentional destruction by any means of unborn life after implantation in the womb of a woman. Subsections (1) and (2) are not simple alternatives to each other, but must be read together. We are talking here about intentional destruction. The absence of one element under section 1(2) does not automatically mean that an abortion is being committed under section 1(1). There is an inference that if a doctor intervenes in an emergency and because of his intervention the unborn human life is ended, that automatically constitutes an abortion. It does not. There has to be deliberate premeditated intent to terminate the life of the unborn in the first instance.

In the very unlikely event that a case would be of the sort which would be taken, the rebuttal presumption is enshrined in the Bill. The Director of Public Prosecutions would have to initiate the case in the first instance. There are very strong barriers or obstacles to those who might want to take a range of cases against doctors in any given situation, but it is not as simple as that. There would be many hurdles to jump before a case ends up in court. We do not want to reach that position because we do not want medical practitioners in a situation where they have to save the life of the mother to be looking over their shoulders. This is the first Bill to give legislative certainty to medical practitioners in intervening to save the life of a mother. While they have been doing so up to now, they themselves have said they feel they are acting in an uncertain legal environment and are anxious that it be cleared up.

Given the strength of the arguments made, I will look at the matter again overnight. I wish to make it clear that I am not promising anything. We will have a final discussion on Report Stage tomorrow.

Comment on this

I am not so worried about a doctor being sued. I do not think that will happen. My concern is that someone will do nothing because they will be afraid to act in a dire situation. Senator Fitzpatrick is correct. General practitioners could do an enormous amount, but might be in a situation where they would be forced to terminate a pregnancy if they encounter someone with a serious bleed 16 weeks into pregnancy. Senator Fitzpatrick points out that a GP would try to stabilise the patient, but bleeding during pregnancy is another kettle of fish. Confidential inquiries into maternal deaths in the United Kingdom note that Dextran should be avoided for fluid replacement because of its possible effects on haemostasis. In other words, it can lead to a situation where the bleeding will become worse. It is suggested that intravenous crystalloid and artificial plasmatic expanders such as Haemoceel should be used. I do not know of any GP who is going around with intravenous crystalloid and artificial plasmatic expanders in his or her bag.

Comment on this

What is the Senator's point? If she says GPs cannot do it, who can and where?

Comment on this

They might be in a position to act with a miscarriage, a spontaneous abortion, that is not complete. I should mention that 31 cases—

Comment on this

In the context of the Bill, that would not equate to an abortion.

Comment on this

I am not worried about a doctor being sued. I am worried about him or her doing nothing in an emergency. I am worried about the woman losing her life because the doctor cannot get her to an approved place. The figures I mentioned from the Coombe Hospital survey do not cover early or ectopic pregnancies. They were excluded.

I am delighted that the Minister will look at the matter again overnight. I am not trying to be difficult. I do not think there is one Member in this or the other House, one member of the Government, anyone, who wants any woman's life to be in danger. I do not think people will get smart and try to do things in peripheral hospitals. It is vital that patients are moved to tertiary level hospitals. Doctors are warned not to deal with cases with which they cannot cope. They must be moved quickly to ensure expert care. I am not asking the Minister to establish peripheral units. I am merely pointing out the danger that a doctor not in an approved place may do nothing. We are constantly warned that time is of the essense where there is bleeding, particularly in obstetrics.

I ask the Minister to look at the matter again. I do not think people will deal with cases with which they cannot cope as they will only invite litigation if they do. The Minister does not want a woman to be in danger, nor does Senator Fitzpatrick. None of us does.

There is a piece at the end where one can be a conscientious objector to carrying out one of these procedures. The procedure is a life-saving one for the mother. A woman could arrive in a very serious condition at a peripheral hospital and meet a junior doctor. The doctor may have to verify if the hospital is approved. Having discovered it is not, he might announce he is a conscientious objector. It would not be possible to blame him. The medical council guidelines warn about such cases. The senior medical practitioners have to try to take responsibility for dealing with the most difficult cases. However, there may be nobody senior available.

At the last two meetings of obstetricians and gynaecologists, this topic was raised repeatedly and people from the peripheral hospitals were extremely anxious about it. The Minister's definition of approved places appears to be expanding on the Taoiseach's definition, but it is still very loose. Because the Minister is making orders, we could leave out approved places and if people start getting smart, the Minister could say it is outrageous and do something about it.

Of course women want to be looked after in the best places, but there is much evidence from the British figures and now from the Coombe survey which is rather alarming. If we consider ectopic pregnancies and spontaneous—

Comment on this

Did the Coombe survey cover people treated at the Coombe Hospital?

Comment on this

No, they eventually turned up at the Coombe. It has not been published yet, but I am grateful to the people who carried out the survey and spoke to me. Although most of these events were managed in a maternity hospital, management outside these perimeters occurred in selective cases. This is the problem. They did not manage to get them to the hospital, even the Coombe. This is a matter of life and death. Nobody, especially the Minister for Health and Children, who may have to look after the children that are left, wants to enable this. I am grateful that the Minister has said he will consider this. We have nothing to lose. The medical profession is very honourable. I hate the suspicion people have that the medical profession will try to do abortions.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister's open approach to this issue. He has clearly listened to the concerns that have been raised. I look forward to hearing what he has to say tomorrow, having thought about it overnight.

Based on the last comments by Senator Henry, unfortunately over the past 20 years a degree of fear has entered into the general relationship between pregnant women, or women who intend to become pregnant, and the medical profession. We are debating the issue of legislative certainty for doctors on the one hand and the need to ensure women's lives are protected in every context. From listening to the masters of the main maternity hospitals who addressed the All-Party Committee on the Constitution, it is clear their day-to-day concern is to always ensure the pregnant woman is protected and kept in the best possible health.

When we pass legislation, we have a responsibility to ensure there are no loopholes left and there is the greatest degree of certainty possible for doctors and of course patients. That is the root of our concern over the issue of approved places. The more I hear about this, the more concerned I become. In his response the Minister said the approved places in general will be the major maternity and acute hospitals so there will not be a shortage of approved places. However, there will be a list of approved places and this will not include every hospital in the country. Once the list is published and passed by the Oireachtas, they will become the only places women can go in the certainty that, in the event of a medical procedure being required that would result in ending the pregnancy, this will happen. That is why we tabled the amendment and in the light of the Minister's response, I believe it is still necessary. The Minister has said the deletion of the words "approved place" would result in not having any hospital that could carry out such a procedure.

Comment on this

Not just a hospital, but anywhere.

Comment on this

The procedure could be carried out anywhere and clearly that is not the intention of the legislation, which should give legislative certainty for doctors and patients in cases of medical emergency. In light of what the Minister has said, our amendment is necessary to address our concerns and those of the Minister.

As mentioned in passing by the Minister, it is the intention of this legislation to ensure that illegal abortions are not carried out. In other words, the Minister relies on the judgment of the medical practitioners in the major maternity and acute hospitals to determine whether a particular medical procedure is required, which would result unintentionally or otherwise in the ending of the pregnancy. We are placing our trust in those hospitals to implement the legislation and the constitutional amendment if passed by the people. We should be clear about what we are putting into law.

I welcome the Minister's open attitude and in responding tomorrow, I ask him to try to give us more details about where the approved places will be.

Comment on this

The Minister indicated approved places would be existing maternity hospitals. If that is the case, I remind Senator Fitzpatrick that Loop Head is 200 miles from the Rotunda Hospital. It is 70 miles to the maternity hospital in Limerick and 90 miles to the maternity hospital in Galway.

Comment on this

Will women really want to go to these hospitals?

Comment on this

No, not at all. One of the Minister's predecessors, Deputy O'Hanlon, withdrew the maternity service from Clare in 1987 or 1988 and the women from there were so vehemently opposed that they marched on the streets. They have no choice but to go to Limerick because no other facility exists.

I share Senator Henry's concerns about the fears that may exist concerning general practitioners. It is possible to envisage GPs in Carrigaholt, Kilkee or Kilrush finding that under section 2(1) they have to carry out a medical procedure at an approved place in the course of which or as a result of which human life is ended. In such a case a GP would have to decide whether to take a chance and put her on an ambulance to Limerick or Galway. A GP who carries out a procedure in a surgery or the patient's house may be prosecuted as having engaged in criminal activity.

Tugadh tuairisc ar a ndearnadh; an Coiste do shuí arís.

Comment on this