Education for Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2002: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–186 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 17 of 2002 ›
On a point of order, why did the Minister mislead the House at 5.50 p.m. this evening? I asked him very clearly then if this Bill would be taken in the other House tomorrow. The Minister told me it would be. I said: "So it will be in the other House tomorrow." He said: "That is my understanding." It is not being taken tomorrow. It has not been requested. The Whip's office told me a short time ago that it has not been requested and that it is not on the Order of Business for tomorrow in the other House. The Opposition Whips are not aware of it. I spoke to Deputy O'Malley from the Government side and he is not aware of its being taken tomorrow. The Minister deliberately misled this House. Could he please tell us why he did so?
Comment on this
I refute that absolutely. The Senator is trying to filibuster and stop this legislation going through.
Comment on this
I will go back to what I said. I said it is my understanding that it will be taken tomorrow. Senator Manning spoke to someone and I spoke to the Whip.
Comment on this
I will not give the Senator a categorical anything. He is telling me I misled the House and I did not. He is trying to make an allegation which is false and he should withdraw it.
Comment on this
Senator Manning has been in that mode ever since this Bill was initiated because he is trying to get cheap publicity out of it. That is all. I told him it was "my understanding" and I got that understanding from speaking to the Whip. The Senator knows as well I do that the position in respect of business is quite fluid. I said I wanted the Bill, at a minimum, to go through Second Stage so we could proceed to Committee Stage, with the opportunity to come back on the day the House sits again to complete it.
Comment on this
—and I will not stand for it. The Minister came in and told us the Bill would be taken tomorrow. I have spoken to the Whip—
Comment on this
It will not be taken tomorrow and the Minister has come in and deliberately misled this House.
Comment on this
Thank you. I have allowed you to raise the point of order. The Minister has responded to the point of order—
Comment on this
The business of the other House has nothing to do with this House. What will or will not be taken in the other House is not a matter for this House.
Comment on this
Therefore, I will not allow any further debate on the point that has been raised. I will proceed with Committee Stage.
Comment on this
With respect – the Cathaoirleach knows I have respect for him and this House – we found ourselves in a set of circumstances in which we were asked to take a Bill under undue pressure without any attempt at consultation because we were told it would be taken in the other House before the end of session. I asked the Minister specifically at 5.50 p.m. this evening. He told me it would be in the other House tomorrow—
Comment on this
The Minister is either incompetent or disingenuous. The Whips are not aware of it. The Whips of my party are not aware of it and the Whips of the Progressive Democrats are not aware of it – I spoke to Deputy O'Malley a short time ago. I was told categorically by the Whip's office that no request had been made to have this tomorrow. What game is the Minister playing?
Comment on this
I said I spoke to my Whip, not to an office or any other person. I spoke to my Whip, so that is the position.
Comment on this
He will of course. What else does he do any day? However, it is a matter for the other House.
Comment on this
The Minister is disingenuous in this regard. He is playing fast and loose with the facts.
Comment on this
Please, Senator Manning, we cannot become involved in the business of the other House.
Comment on this
Allow me a further few seconds, Senator Manning. This Bill was ordered this morning on the Order of Business and it was agreed that Committee Stage would be taken in this House today.
Comment on this
Could I intervene? As a Whip, we said that we would accommodate in every way possible the work of the House. In discussing this, we sought certain understandings. Pressure of business from the other House put pressure on here. To ensure co-operation among the Whips, despite the Houses being separate entities, a Bill's movement from one House to another is taken into consideration to accommodate people. That is well known.
This is a significant issue. If the Bill will not be going to the other House tomorrow, the rush is not necessary and people could be given time to deal with Committee Stage and its problems in a decent way. That is the significance of the matter.
Comment on this
The Chair is bound by the decision of this House on the Order of Business this morning. That decision was that Committee Stage of this Bill would be taken in this House today and I must now proceed with Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but we have been misled very seriously on this matter. We were informed that this was part of the legislation that had to be got through. The problem is that the legislation will get lost—
Comment on this
Then why did the Minister tell me that he understood it would be taken tomorrow when his own Whip's office said no request has been made? Deputy O'Malley told me specifically that no request had been made. The Minister has come in with weasel words and has said that, in so far as is possible, it will be taken tomorrow. He knows full well that it will not be taken tomorrow. Can he be truthful in the matter?
Comment on this
That is not true. A request was made, and whoever told the Senator otherwise is wrong.
Comment on this
I do not care what it said. If the Chief Whip was here, he could tell you himself. I spoke to him this morning.
Comment on this
In the other House a Deputy would not even do that, and if he did, he would withdraw it straight away. I would have thought the Seanad would have had a little more dignity.
Comment on this
Whatever about dignity, I did not accuse the Minister of telling a lie, but of telling us something that was not true. That is all.
Comment on this
We cannot agree to continue with this because we have not been told. The Minister has misled this House.
Comment on this
Senator Manning, I do not think there is any basis for that statement in that the Minister has stated to this House that it is his understanding that this Bill will be taken in the other House tomorrow. This Bill may very well be taken in the other House tomorrow. We do not know—
Comment on this
The Minister has told us that it is his understanding, but there is no factual basis to his understanding. I have been told—
Comment on this
As Senator O'Toole said, there is a very significant point to be made. Getting away from the personalities and the rows, the point must be made that every interest group involved with this Bill wants time to consider it and look at its implications. For some strange, perverse reason, the Minister wants to rush it through here tonight. It will not be in the Statute Book before the election, so why does he not do the sensible thing—
Comment on this
Senator Manning, it was decided by this House this morning that Committee Stage of this Bill would be taken in the House today. I am bound by that order of the House and I must proceed with Committee Stage. We are on amendment No. 1 to section 1. The amendment has been moved and I call on the Minister to reply to the debate thereon.
Notice taken that 12 Members were not present; House counted and 12 Members being present,
Comment on this
The focus of the definition in the Bill of a child with special educational needs is on the fact that the ordinary school programme is not sufficient for such a child. Something else is required. There may be a need for him or her to attend special classes, to avail of special education services, or both. The definition has been framed in this way to emphasise that a child with special needs will have a right to avail of these extra resources which my Department has made and will continue to make available.
Senator Henry raised the issue of behavioural problems, which are included if they are assessed needs. For this reason, the definition, as drafted, is sufficient and encompasses what is envisaged in the Bill.
Comment on this
The issue is the use of the English language. What matters is not what the Minister intends the definition to mean but what it actually means. Section 1 defines a child with special educational needs as a child who "is unable to benefit from an ordinary school programme." Whatever the intention, that means one thing only, that a child gets no benefit whatsoever. No such child exists, every child will get some benefit, even if it is only learning to distinguish basic numbers and colours. This is important because at some stage some smart lawyer is going to argue that a particular child does not fit the description of a child with special educational needs because, even though he or she has a reading age ten years behind that of his or her peers or is moderately or even severely mentally handicapped, it can be proved that he or she has learned basic addition, how to make his or her way to the toilet or how to lift a spoon.
We are talking about a child who in the first place is in an ordinary school, and trying to determine whether he or she has special needs. There will be no child in a school, however, who will not have obtained some benefit from it. The Minister talked about a situation where a school programme is "not sufficient" and something else is required. That is exactly what I agree with, but the definition in section 1 does not meet it, it does quite the opposite. My amendment would redress this by substituting the phrase "needs more than an ordinary school programme."
Senator Ormonde asked whether we would then have to define the word "more". That is what the education plan is, the plan is designed to ascertain the additional needs of a child. The issue is very simple, the potential for a legal expert to interpret the word "benefit" literally. If a child gets any benefit at all, it means that he or she cannot be defined as a child with special educational needs. There is no argument about this, unless I cannot read English.
Comment on this
I am delighted the Minister has shown flexibility and come up with an alternative. Senator O'Toole has made a good case. It is also the case that the current wording defines a child negatively. Senator O'Toole, who is a teacher, is seeing the positive aspect. In addition to the points he has made, I suggest it would be much better that a child be seen in this positive light.
Comment on this
The alternative wording I propose is: "In page 4, line 7, after "programme" to insert "to the extent that a child without such attributes can so benefit".
Comment on this
I am happy the Minister has taken the amendment on board. As matters stand, the Bill states a child with special educational needs is one who is unable to benefit from an ordinary school programme, among other things. There is no such child, all children will benefit to some extent, no matter what their level of disability. The Minister is suggesting that on Report Stage he will propose to substitute the words "to the extent that a child without such attributes would benefit". I am happy that he would say that a child who, because of their disability—
Comment on this
To the extent that the child without such attributes would benefit. I am happy to accept that wording on Report Stage. I thank the Minister. This means that no smart lawyers can determine that any particular child does not have special educational needs. That is crucial because subsection (1) would effectively have undermined the entire Bill. It is the first definition in it and the Minister's proposal is a good first step in improving this Bill.
Comment on this
There are many terms included in this section. It defines ‘disability', ‘assessment', ‘health board', ‘Minister', ‘parent', ‘school' and many other terms as they relate to this Bill. The Minister should have included health and safety in the Bill. There does not seem to be any definition of that term as it is laid down in statute. Over the last couple of years, we have read and heard much about the issue of health and safety and it should form an important part of the Bill.
Comment on this
Senator Burke is right. Health and safety is laid down separately in statute and it will apply to this Bill under the Health and Safety Acts.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1a:
In page 5, paragraph (b), line 37, after “of”, to insert “adequate and”.
I ask the Minister to accept my proposal.
Comment on this
The council must ensure that the education of a child with special needs takes place alongside the education of children who do not have such needs. This is usually described as integrated education or inclusion. I am pleased to note that the Minister has not used these words in the Bill because words go out of fashion so quickly in this territory.
Children with a disability must be educated in the ordinary classroom, provided that certain conditions are met. These include the needs of the child, the wishes of his or her parents, the efficient provision of an education for those children alongside whom the child will be educated and the efficient use of resources. The needs of the child are particularly important. Very often, a parent may prefer that their child should attend the local school, despite their learning difficulties and the fact that they may never reach the level of ordinary children. That is understandable. However, this choice would be wrong if the special needs assessment of the child indicated that he or she would do better were they enrolled at a special needs school. It is important the child is educated in the establishment wherein they can achieve their potential. Integrated education should always be based on what is best for the child.
Comment on this
I agree with the Senator. That is the specific purpose of the section, which provides that the education of a child with special needs shall occur in special classes, separate schools, or other settings removed from the ordi nary environment only when that represents the best educational option for the child.
Comment on this
I also agree with Senator O'Toole. Everything should centre around the best interests of the child.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 6, subsection (5), line 24, after "appropriate", to insert "and may convene a suitable team as outlined in subsection (2) and (3) of section 9”.
The basis for this amendment is a recognition of how schools actually function. The principal of any school, regardless of its size, is under extraordinary pressure in terms of his or her work. They never have enough time to do everything that is required of them. Many principals of small schools have a full class responsibility in addition to the other tasks that come with their position. There are management, educational, functional and parental requirements with which they must deal, and that is only the tip of the iceberg. Every time we pass new legislation in these Houses, we put additional work on principal teachers in particular and the school authorities in general. The principal is the key person in any school and he or she must be the fulcrum upon which progress is levered.
Regardless of any prior knowledge of a child's abilities, each school has to produce a individual education plan for him or her. What the Bill refers to as an ‘education plan' is more commonly referred to as an IEP, an individual education plan. Each plan is child-centred. The principal may do that and it is a very intensive job of work, looking at every aspect of the child's education from the curriculum to psychological, physical and social requirements.
Yesterday I asked a fellow teacher for a response to the Bill's provision that the education plan should include the goals which any child is to achieve during any period not exceeding 12 months. He said that the idea of goals to be achieved in the course of the year has no relevance in these situations. That teacher said that if he could get a child to learn how to lift a spoon, that would represent an extraordinary achievement. That is an extreme situation but it is part of the spectrum of disabilities about which we are talking. It begins at that level. I am not suggesting that such a child would be dealt with in an ordinary school, but I need to give the example to explain the education plan.
Principals will be very angry that this is being introduced following their meeting with the Minister in regard to the various difficulties involved in their work. They are now being given more responsibility without negotiations taking place or agreement on the resources and how the work can be done. I am asking the Minister to give a commitment tonight that before the proposals are implemented there will be absolute agreement with the INTO that resources will be made available to these principals. I will return to that matter.
The reason my amendment refers to section 9(2) and (3) is the proposal that the principal can decide the best person to do the education plan is the special educational needs organiser. Section 9 outlines a whole list of support structures that can be put in place legally and on a statutory basis by the special educational needs organiser. In other words, the special educational needs organiser can bring together a team of people, including psychologists, to deal with these requirements. This is the special educational needs organiser's only duty and that person has a team to carry out the work, and rightly so. However, principal teachers in mainstream schools have many other responsibilities. My amendment proposes that what is put in place in the Bill to support special educational needs organisers should also be available to principal teachers.
I welcome the recognition in the section of the importance of the role of school principals and teaching staff. I said a great deal last night and I have much more to say about how teachers, particularly principal teachers, will feel badly put out by this proposal. Nevertheless, they will also feel there is at least a recognition of their role in this regard. Resources should be put in place to marry the two positions. Obviously, the principal teacher could delegate this responsibility but this needs to be made clear in the Act. There is a reference that this can be done by a teacher, but it should be clear that this additional function is something the principal might decide would be more appropriately done by someone else in the school, for a variety of reasons. There might be a special class teacher, a resource teacher or a visiting teacher who the principal might conclude would do the job more effectively. For that reason, it should be made clear that this function could be devolved to an appropriate member of staff.
Comment on this
Having had experience of dealing with and devising an education plan for special educational needs in special areas, I agree with much that Senator O'Toole said. We need to ensure there is a team, including an educational psychologist, a remedial teacher, a career guidance teacher and perhaps a class teacher or resource teacher. That would arise in any event. However, Senator O'Toole is correct that perhaps it should be spelt out more clearly. I would like to hear the Minister's views on the matter.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator O'Toole in this regard. Looking at it from a layman's point of view – I am neither an educationalist nor a teacher – it seems the Minister is putting unbe lievable responsibility on principals of schools, whether small or big schools, without any additional resources. Will the principal have to carry out a formal assessment of each student in the school before he can invite in teachers with special responsibilities? If a principal does not detect that a particular student has a problem, would it leave him open to litigation in the future whereby he could be sued in the courts by the family or student involved for not detecting that the student had special needs when young?
I support Senator O'Toole's amendment because this section needs to be developed further. Perhaps there could be some form of template which would include resources and special needs teachers who could visit each school. This aspect warrants debate with the leaders of the various unions.
Comment on this
It is very important to have goals. They may be simple goals or small goals but they must be agreed goals. As Senators pointed out, particularly Senator O'Toole, lifting a spoon in some instances is a goal while identifying letters and communication are goals in other cases and there are various ways this can happen. It is important that there are goals and that they are set out rather than just drifting on.
Senator O'Toole was concerned about the support services and resources, which is the purpose of the Bill. The national council for special education will have responsibility and resources to provide the necessary supports.
It is provided in the Education Act that the principal can delegate. The principal in the school will have an obligation to prepare an education plan for the appropriate education of the child concerned. In having this responsibility, it obviously makes sense that a principal should have access to the advice – I accept that should be made very clear – of the multi-disciplinary team in the same way as a special needs organiser where an education plan is prepared at the direction of the council. I, therefore, agree with the thrust of Senator O'Toole's amendment and I am persuaded by his contribution of the value of such an amendment.
However, with the permission of the House, I would like to table an alternative amendment on Report Stage which will encapsulate the Senator's proposal. The amendment would read, " ‘In page 6, subsection (5), line 24, after "appropriate", to insert "having regard to section 9 subsection (2) and (3)' ". This is the section which deals with the group of persons and inter-disciplinary team. This should make the proposal absolutely clear, as the Senator pointed out. It was suggested to me that this would be the appropriate amendment. I thank the Senator for his suggestion.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for accepting the thrust of the amendment. I just quibble about two of the words. Rather than "having regard" could he perhaps use the words "as outlined". The word "regard" is weak. People need to be able to point to it and say "Yes, it can be done that way". The clarity of language would make it easier.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 3 and 3a are out of order as they involve a potential charge on Revenue.
Comment on this
There is a dichotomy here which the Chair might help me resolve. It has just ruled out of order two of my amendments and unfortunately I cannot move them. They both required resources. One said that the school might recoup the costs associated with the production of the education plan and the other asked that the board of management ensure the school principal is supported by any additional staffing required. The Chair ruled them out of order.
Comment on this
There is no quibble with the Chair's ruling. The Chair is on my side on this. Last night when we asked about the resources we were told they were available. I thought I would spell that out in an amendment but when the Cathaoirleach read it he saw it would cost more money and it was ruled out of order. Last night the Minister said the resources were available, so I need him to tell me how it can cost more money? Perhaps it is a restatement of the money but it cannot be an additional cost.
The educational plan has to be put together. I have seen the work involved for the principal and what is required and we agree it needs to be done. However, I cannot see how the resources get from where they are to the school authority – the board of management, the principal, the class teacher or whoever has to do the work. If they have to convene meetings or meet parents, from where does the money come? It is not appropriate for it to come from normal school funding. I am now suspicious because I put forward an amendment in order to have clarity on the matter but the Chair thinks it will cost more money. How can that be if the resources are there?
Comment on this
I support Senator O'Toole. This is the kernel of the Bill. We were led to believe the necessary funding would be in place. This issue will arise in another section of the Bill and I hope the Minister has an explanation for it. It is unfair for the Chair to rule Senator O'Toole's amendment out of order. Funding is the kernel of the Bill. How can school principals take on considerable additional responsibilities without additional resources? Will they be provided or not?
Comment on this
Last night I explained that we are providing an enormous amount of extra resources. People are already doing these things and any resources needed will be provided.
Comment on this
I explained that in about two and a half years we have gone from €7 million a year to €70 million a year in terms of providing resources. Senator O'Toole is here long enough to know why the amendment was ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I agree that the Chair is technically correct. I must refer the Senator to section 13 which states, "The Minister shall, with the consent of the Minister of Finance, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, provide for the payment to or in respect of schools and their employees such moneys as are necessary for the provision of appropriate education to children with special educational needs." I do not want to go into the proposed amendment but listening to the Senator's concerns I propose including in that "in accordance with the provision of this Act" in order to make it clear we are talking about meeting the provisions of the Act. That is where the funds are provided.
I know the Senator is concerned that the Minister of Finance is involved. He is constitutionally involved but the key element is that it says "the Minister"– the Minister for Education and Science –"shall". It is the Minister who has the obligation and that is a legal and enforceable requirement. Beyond that the Minister for Finance must be consulted and give consent. In a case where "the Minister shall" there is not much scope for doing anything other than giving consent unless one wants to go to the courts. This provides for procedures in the courts if it is not met.
I appreciate the Senator's concerns but I think they are well met. On section 13 I will go a little further to ensure they are met.
Comment on this
I need clarification on where we stand with this section. Reference has been made to section 13 which must be referred back. I understood that when the Minister for Finance agreed the budget, it went to the Department of Education and Science and the spending of the education budget was a matter for the Minister. That is why I am worried about section 13. I think it refers to the overall amount of money and is not based on the school or the child. What I do not understand and what is not in the Bill is how the money gets to the school. What is the conduit?
Section 13 talks about the provision of appropriate education for children. The development of the education plan might happen in one school and the provision of education might be in another school. The payment of the money would not arise in the first school so the principal and school authority will be out of pocket unless there is a way to make it clear. I agree this could be dealt with under section 13 by changing the wording to ensure that expenses properly incurred by schools or school staff under the direction of the board in order to implement all aspects of the Act are covered. It would not just cover the provision of education which might be seen as a narrow view.
Perhaps we should say that expenses, properly incurred by the school or staff in the preparation or implementation of plans – which is what the Bill is about – can and shall be provided by the Minister. That could clarify it significantly so that I can point out to principal teachers that money shall be provided by the Minister for the job they are doing, without their having to face the arguments which they almost certainly would. They may never get around to providing education for a child – that may happen somewhere else – but they still have to do the work. There is a huge gap and I need to have a clear commitment that the funds will go to the proper place.
Comment on this
That is why I am putting clarification into section 13 on the point the Senator raises. It relates specifically to the provisions that are here. It is important to understand that this is becoming a demand led scheme, based on assessments. People cannot say I have a blank cheque book. It is an open cheque book, but for properly assessed needs that are in plans, it is not just demand led without responsibility. One must be responsible in relation to the provisions of this Bill.
Comment on this
Yes. I know that, which is why we have gone from having funding of €7 million to €70 million in such a short space of time.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister not to say that again. We have all heard this and we got the message. The Minister should put it in the manifesto. Let us move on.
Comment on this
In effect, that is why we have gone along that route because once the needs are assessed the money is being provided. It is difficult for people to understand because it has not been the way up to now. This Bill makes it statutory. We have been doing it administratively but this ties it into a statute so it becomes a right.
Comment on this
Once it is a demand led scheme, during a particular year one gets the budget and estimates at the beginning of the year. However, if the estimate is under the amount required to meet the assessed needs and proper development – according to the Bill – it must be provided. Hence the demand led principle.
Comment on this
How does the money get to the school principal, for instance, who has spent a month working on this?
Comment on this
That is why we have the national council. It will have the staff to work specifically with the schools. We will have staff that we did not have before, some of whom are already in Athlone working on special needs, but the staff complement will be enhanced and will have an independence of the Minister to work in that area. It is worthwhile emphasising the point.
Comment on this
Will the schools be able to claim the costs of preparing the education plan? I need to hear the answer to that on the record at the very least.
Comment on this
Surely the principal of the school will submit the claim and the demand that will be required and will know exactly the special education needs.
Comment on this
The Senator should ask the Minister what happens to those claims when they reach the Department.
Comment on this
The Senator and I know the procedures better than anyone. The Minister is saying that when the demands are met and requests are put forward, they will be honoured by the Department.
Comment on this
That is a contradiction, although I am not saying it is deliberate. Senator Ormonde said this will be done through the Department of Education and Science, whereas the Minister told me it would be done through the national special education board. This is precisely the kind of difficulty I have. These are the questions I will be asked at the conference next week.
Comment on this
The funds will come through the estimates which go to the Department. The administrative arrangements will be made through the national council, but in the meantime, before it is established, the money will be paid directly. When it is established, it will be paid by whatever is the most effective way of doing so. In the first instance, authorisation for it will come from the principal of the school, as Senator Ormonde said. It is then an administrative matter. The basic issue is that the money will be there and these elements are being recognised, including the preparation of plans and all that goes with them and the specialists will have to be available.
There is no question that this is a major change but it is a change that is long overdue. These things are happening not just because we have greater resources. We are giving the support which principals and parent have sought. That has been given as of right.
Comment on this
I want to tell a story and I would like Senator Ormonde in particular to listen and pay attention. I do not say that in a teacher-like way but it may help to guide her absolute trust in the Department – the €7 million to €70 million place.
For the past five or six years, schools have been providing payment for psychological assessments of children out of their own resources. I am giving the Minister an opening to come back with his claim regarding the €7 million to €70 million but I need to make my case. I was in a small school near Edenderry where the total funding they received from the State in one year was spent on psychological assessment. Senator Ormonde would be proud, because I told them to send the bill to the Department as it was the appropriate thing to do. The bill came back unpaid. We did it with another school and we were doing it for years until we met that nice man from the Department of Education and Science, Deputy Woods, and we asked if it would not be good to pay these people for doing this. He eventually agreed – out of the €70 million.
Now that has been put in place by the Minister and I give him credit for it. It was a progressive move so that when schools in certain circumstances have to carry out psychological assessments, they can recoup the costs. The gap between the schools deciding what they needed to do – and were required to under the Education Act – and getting paid for it was years and some of them were never paid. I want to find a place in the Bill that I can point out to doubting principals and school authorities to assure them they are not being set up and they will get the money.
I have listened to the Minister say that the money comes from the budget to the Department of Finance to the Department of Education and Science to the special education board but what I have not yet heard is how the money gets from there to the schools. All the Minister needs to say is that all appropriate and proper expenses arising out of the preparation of the plan are redeemable and can be claimed from the Department. That might be funding to do with staffing, resources or assessments – we do not need to say what they are but that they are appropriate.
Comment on this
Staff will continue to be paid by the Department and the other expenses will be met. I thank the Senator for what he said about the NEPS and its development. We have gone from having 44 psychologists to shortly having 160 when the current interviews are complete. We got approval for the end of this year to increase that figure to 200. We will have in the region of 200 by the end of this year which is a dramatic change. The target contained in the national development plan was that we would reach this figure by 2004. We are, therefore, two years ahead of schedule.
I appreciate that last year and the year before there were many difficulties, but it was hard to communicate that what was happening would not recur because the NEPS was building up and extending its regional service. As Senator O'Toole mentioned, arrangements are being made on an interim basis where the service is not yet available.
Comment on this
Would it be fair for me to interpret what the Minister has said as that the costs incurred by the school in properly developing the education plan are redeemable, provided they are properly vouched for?
Comment on this
I am not trying to pull a fast one; I just want to be able to say this to teachers, school authorities and school managements. Is that a "Yes"?
Comment on this
No, I am not. One minute ago I was being told that I was not telling the truth. I have to be very careful in the Seanad.
Comment on this
That is the reason we are having this debate – we were all a little unsure until now.
Comment on this
While I still have doubts about this section, I am not going to put it to a vote because I will come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Where a parent makes a case to the council to have his or her child included in the register, it is putting unnecessary pressure on the parent. It would seem from the section that the parent has to have all the assessments carried out and give them to the council. Once the parent notifies the council, the obligation should be on the council to get the principal or whoever else is responsible – as the Minister said, the principal can delegate the responsibility – to act, in order that it will be up to him or her to provide the assessments for the council. In this instance, the section places too much pressure on the parents of a child to make sure all the assessments are carried out. The council should ask the principal to carry out the assessments.
Comment on this
While I appreciate the Senator's concern, section 5(1) states, "A parent of a child who is of opinion that his or her child has special educational needs may apply to the Council to have the child entered in the Register." Therefore, it is the parents who can apply and the organiser will be the person bringing the team together. It can equally come from the school. It leaves the options open in order that parents can be involved. The word "may" is very important in this context.
Comment on this
It is the fail safe method in order that if the parents believe it is not going the way they want, they can apply. It is an extra provision to make sure parents are covered. Parents who have concerns that a child may have special educational needs may bring the matter to the attention of the council by seeking to have their child entered on the register. It is a fail safe mechanism for parents.
Comment on this
While I appreciate what the Minister is saying, if the parents notify the council that they want their child included in the register, who carries out the assessment? Whose responsibility is it to get the assessments for the board? My reading of it is that the responsibility to make sure the assessments are carried out rests with the parents. My concern with the section is that the responsibility is theirs at that stage.
Comment on this
It is the parents in that case, but they can have them done under the NEPS system, as they do at present. It comes back to whether they want to have them done privately. They can do so, if they wish. Some parents prefer to do so. If they find there is a special difficulty, they can bring it into the system. Others will use the national education psychological service and move forward from there. In that case, an application will be accompanied by any relevant assessments and information concerning the child, as the council deems necessary to reach an informed conclusion regarding the application. It will then decide either to register or decline to do so. Where it declines, the safeguard for parents is that they may appeal the decision within one month to an independent appeals board. This confirms the vital role of parents in the new procedures. While the focus of the Bill is on the rights of children and others with disabilities, we must also support the rights of parents to determine the best route for their child wherever possible.
Comment on this
If at that stage a parent wants his or her child included in the register, would it be possible for assessments to be carried out by the principal who, in the main, has to do it himself or herself at the beginning? In some cases a parent may not be au fait with matters. Therefore, the responsibility should be taken off him or her to apply to the NEPS.
Comment on this
No. It is only a fail safe measure whereby, if they are not satisfied with what is happening, they can take this route.
Comment on this
I am unclear about the point made by the Minister in answer to Senator Burke's question about who may seek an assessment. Under the section the council may seek an assessment. Section 7 states that in preparing the special educational needs plan, the special educational needs organiser shall cause an assessment of the educational needs to be carried out. I presume, however, this does not in any way cut across the school's right, in normal terms, to have an assessment carried out.
Comment on this
I know there is a line somewhere in the Bill that states it does not cut across any other statutory rights anywhere else.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 4a and 4b are alternatives to amendment No. 4, all may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 7, subsection (1), to delete all words after "by" in line 42, down to and including "psychologist;" in line 45, and in page 8 to delete lines 1 to 5, and substitute "an educational psychologist.".
The difficulty I have with this section is that there is a misfit between the lead-in paragraph and the list below it. I have considered it a lot today since I tabled the amendment. When I look at my amendment, however, it seems to exclude certain matters, which was not my intention. My amendment reflects the point we discussed about the educational needs of a child, which are not best served by a medical practitioner, social worker or therapist. Section 6 states:
Where the Council receives a notice under section 4 or an application under section 5 the Council may, if it considers it appropriate to do so and subject to section 7(2), cause an assessment of the educational needs of the child concerned to be carried out.
The only people who can assess the educational needs of a child are educationists or educational psychologists. That was the point of my objection to the list in the section, and my amendment. I recognise, however, that while my amendment may do what I set out to achieve, it would actually change the intent of the section. The problem is that in assessing the special educational needs of a child it is also necessary to find out and explore other needs closely connected with their educational needs. One set is dependent upon the other. In other words, a child could have a medical condition which would inform or modify his or her educational needs.
What I, and I imagine Senator Burke, were trying to achieve, although I have not discussed it with him and do not want to put words in his mouth, was the inclusion of a form of words such as "other connected needs" after the word "educational" in section 7(1) because the section needs something like that. I am not trying to widen the scope of the Bill. It is just that, to determine the educational needs, it may be necessary to investigate other needs. The assessment may need something like that. As well as that, the list of people should include an educational psychologist as well as the psychologist specified or just an educational psychologist. There would have to be a reference to an educational psychologist as distinct from another type of psychologist.
I am trying to recognise that educational needs are a matter for educationalists who may be informed by other people. It is a case of how we get to the point of doing that. It is not that I want to exclude any important information which could be made available by others.
Comment on this
I understand Senator O'Toole's approach. When a child is being assessed, the opinion of an educational psychologist is needed. The matter begins before that because someone must refer the child to the educational psychologist. In the course of an assessment it may be discovered that other aspects of the child's personality need examination and it may be necessary to defer to other expertise. That is covered in the Bill. I am delighted that a social worker is specified because he or she can say a huge amount about other needs. If the social worker and psychologist were to work together, it would allow for a broad assessment of the requirements and needs of the child involved. The process begins with the educational psychologist and moves on from there so that a wide assessment is obtained. I agree with the specification of an educational psychologist. I am not sure about specifying a medical practitioner. Will the Minister give us his views on that? I welcome the other aspects of the section.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator O'Toole that the psychologist should be an educational psychologist. The aim of our amendment is to make the assessment more of a team effort and that more than one person would be involved in the assessment. That is why we wanted to change the last line in section 7(1) to read:
.those persons shall include the following–
(a) a psychologist;
(b) a medical practitioner;
(c) a teacher nominated by the principal of the school which the child is attending;
(d) a social worker; and
(e) a therapist.
Our amendment would achieve more of a team effort by allowing for a group of the people listed in the section.
Comment on this
I agree with Senators O'Toole, Burke and Ormonde that the inclusion of the word "educational" is essential in this section. I do not see the point of Senator Burke's amendment which would change the word "may" to "shall". It may not be necessary to have the other people involved in the assessment, although it may be in some cases. The wording is strong enough to include them if they are necessary. There is no point having people involved in an assessment if they are not required. I do not go along with what the Senator said, but I agree with Senator O'Toole's suggestion that the word "educational" should be included.
Comment on this
I am happy to accept amendment No. 4b as it provides a greater focus on addressing the special education needs of a child in an assessment. Senator O'Toole made this point as well. The purpose of section 7 is to ensure a multidisciplinary approach is taken to the assessment of a child who has or is likely to develop special educational needs. This is extremely important as the response to a child's educational needs is determined not only by educational issues but also health, welfare, therapy and behavioural factors. If we were to limit the assessment to one carried out by an educational psychologist, there would be a danger that it would be inadequate and, therefore, the response could be inappropriate. The approach I have adopted in this provision ensures that a holistic approach is taken to each child's assessment and that this will inform the preparation of the education plan.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for accepting amendment No. 4b. The point we made was that it should be more of a team effort. In light of what the Minister said, I will withdraw the other amendment.
Comment on this
I support the amendment which has been conceded because it is important. I will not push my amendment because I am not happy with it and I accept the points the Minister made. However, will he consider the following before I withdraw it? My contention is that the assessment of the educational needs referred to in sections 3(3) and 6 should be done by an educationalist – someone with an educational qualification, such as an educational psychologist, teacher or whatever. I recognise the importance of the point Senator Burke, the Minister and others made about the input others could make. The Bill states that the assessment should be carried out by a list of people specified. I have an objection to that because a medical practitioner could never be seen as someone who could make a decision on educational needs.
What could be done is to drop the word "by" from section 7(1) and replace it with the words "with the assistance of" so that it would read:
"An assessment under section 3(3) or 6 shall be carried out with the assistance of persons possessing such expertise as the special educational needs organiser or the Council, as the case may be, considers appropriate; those persons may include one or more of the following–”.
That does not violate the section, recognises it as an educational issue and allows for the team effort to which Senator Burke referred and for the involvement of all the people the Minister mentioned. It would still involve an educational person and, while the section would stay silent on who would conduct the assessment, it would allow it to take place as an educational issue and allow for the team effort to which Senator Burke referred. Will the Minister consider taking that on board on Report Stage?
Comment on this
I support Senator O'Toole on this matter. It would give the section the flexibility it requires.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4b:
In page 7, subsection (1)(a), line 45, to delete “a” and substitute “an educational”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 8, subsection (2), lines 9 and 10, to delete "and shall not cause the assessment to be carried out without the consent in writing of the parents".
The Minister's advisers will be aware of my views on this and it is a discussion which must take place. I may appear to be doing the unthinkable. The Bill requires parental consent in writing before an assessment can take place. I question and challenge that for the reasons I stated earlier.
Under our Constitution, a child has the right to be educated and the parent is the prime educator and can make a choice not to exercise that right in person but to entrust that task to the educational system, in other words to ask a school to do it. Those are three distinct rights and they are not mutually exclusive. There have been situations in various parts of the world where parents, for some daft reason, did not wish their child to be educated. Under our Constitution, the Minister is also required to ensure that each child receives a certain minimum level of education and the Education (Welfare) Act was passed a few years ago to ensure that happened. Under that Act if a parent decides he or she will educate a child at home and the Minister's representative or inspector is not facilitated in evaluating or assessing the education the child is receiving, the Minister can intervene and insist that the child goes to school, where evaluation takes place as part of the normal daily classes.
The key point is that there is provision for intervention. It is not a matter of the parent's right superseding that of the child – the Constitution requires the child to be educated. It is perfectly right and proper that parents should be involved in this process. We do not want a situation to arise, as could happen, where people will decide they do not wish to send their child for assessment, and that they want their child to be at home. This is particularly liable to happen in the context of special education, where people may say they want their child to be happy at home, rather than being educated elsewhere, which may be understandable, although it is not the right thing for the child.
I do not expect the Minister to be totally supportive of my proposition in this regard but I ask him to make a significant response which will have regard to the constitutional position. In a situation where the Minister or his representative believes a child should be assessed but a parent says "No", the rights of the child should prevail in the same way as in the Education (Welfare) Act.
Comment on this
To some extent, Senator O'Toole has answered his own question. There are several vehicles for doing what he refers to, including the provision for the State to intervene under the provisions of the Education (Welfare) Act. In this Bill, the State could go to court, if required, but we may make it more explicit and I will consider that when the Bill goes to the Dáil. It requires some consideration and I will look at the issue.
Comment on this
I accept that. There are causes célèbres in this regard, including a case in north Kerry and one in Leitrim, where the Minister's Department has been in and out of court in an effort to get children to attend school. I am not advocating any hasty action. I appreciate there are constitutional issues and I am not a lawyer. However, there is a question of a child's rights being recognised as the core issue. I am prepared to withdraw the amendment on the basis that the Minister is prepared to consider this and bring forward an appropriate wording which also values the parent's involvement. I do not wish it to be seen as any diminution of the parental contribution. It is, rather, a proactive approach in favour of a recognition of the child's rights. Naturally, there should be consultation with the parents but if, in the final analysis, there is a view that an assessment should take place, then it should go ahead.
Comment on this
When the register is compiled, it will include all the matters referred to in subsection (2) (a), (b), (c) and (d), as set out in the Bill, including the nature and extent of the child's disability and the name and address of the parents and the child. The register will contain a great deal of information in that regard and I believe it should only be accessed in limited circumstances. It should be treated as privileged information which not everybody can access. The Bill does not appear to specify clearly how this confidentiality will be safeguarded. We are in an era of litigation and there could be negative consequences for a child or a family or it could militate against a person getting a job – it could have various connotations for the child concerned. I ask the Minister to explain where in the Bill this privacy is to be maintained.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5a:
In page 10, subsection (2), between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following new paragraph:
"(h) The teacher to be consulted with regard to the setting of the goals which the child is to achieve as part of the education plan.”.
This relates to a core element of the Bill. It involves setting up an individual education plan for a child with a disability. In order to deal with the child's special needs, whether it involves autism or whatever, an assessment is required. It could involve a child who is already in a school classroom or it might be a child who is presented for enrolment at a school and the school principal considers an assessment necessary to ensure the child can benefit to the greatest extent from attendance at the school. The next step is to set up the education plan. I am sorry if I appear to draw out the point but it has to be contextualised.
The education plan will have to look at the nature and degree of the child's disability and how that disability affects his or her educational progress. It continues to the question of educational performance and looks at the precise educational needs, based on earlier consultation with a psychologist or whatever professional guidance is required. The next point is the goal to be achieved by the child over a period not exceeding 12 months. Those are all very important matters and they could relate to a child who is already in the school concerned. I believe that, after eight, the teacher should be consulted with regard to setting the goals the child is to achieve as part of the education plan. It is crucial that the setting of the goals should involve a teacher input and, as the Bill stands, it is unclear if that will happen.
I accept it is the Minister's intention to have a teacher consultation but that is not written into the Bill and that could cause problems in the event of court proceedings. I would welcome the Minister's response.
Comment on this
I agree with most of Senator O'Toole's comments. I believe the matter of goals is already detailed in section 9. I do not particularly like the idea of goals in the context of dealing with people with disability as it may be seen as too great a step for them. I also wish to raise a point in relation to the 12 months provision in this section. Should we specify 12 months when the goals which a child should achieve—
Comment on this
I am of the view that it is really a matter for the school or the council to decide what must be included in the education plan. There is a list of matters contained in section 10(2) referring to the education plan. It is not exhaustive and other matters may be included. If the amendment was to be accepted, there would be a risk of the legislation becoming too prescriptive. On the question of the principal or a teacher nominated by the principal, this is already included in section 9(3)(b).
Comment on this
I do not disagree with that point. Perhaps I have not explained my position clearly. Section 10(2)(g) states the plan will include the name of the school which the child is to attend. This recognises that it could be a different school. It could be any school. The child will arrive at the school with a set of educational goals without any consultation with the teacher in the school who will be dealing with him or her. That is the difficulty I have with it. It is a matter of recognising how this will work on the ground. In terms of the preparation of the plan, if it is all happening in the same school, this issue will not arise, but if the child is going to another school, it will.
Comment on this
I cannot see that happening. If a child is assessed in one school and sent to another, there will have to be a correlation between the teams of each respective school regarding the consultation process. That will happen. Section 9(3)(b) refers to “the principal of the relevant school, or a teacher nominated by the principal of the relevant school to be a member of the team”. What Senator O'Toole fears will not happen.
Comment on this
I agree with the sentiments behind what Senator O'Toole suggests, but the Minister has pointed to the words in section 9(3)(b) “the principal of the relevant school, or a teacher nominated by the principal of the relevant school”. I hope the principal could nominate a teacher from the school where it is suggested the child should attend, particularly if he or she is moving from mainstream education to a special school. In such a case it is important that somebody from the special school is involved in the preparation.