Social Welfare and Pensions (No. 2) Bill 2009: Committee Stage (Resumed) and Remaining Stages.
Contributions 147–301 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 76 of 2009 ›
In all fairness, I am asking a question of the Minister on the issue of the different treatment of those under 25. Was legal advice sought on this? It is a "Yes" or "No" answer.
Comment on this
I have answered all the Senator's questions at least twice.
Comment on this
The Minister has not said "Yes" or "No" to the question.
Comment on this
This section applies to rent allowance. It is another one of the slash-and-burn cuts being made by the Government, which proposes to save €2 million in this area. It has not indicated how it is proposed to save the money. The personal contribution has been increased by 85% in the past two budgets. Some 91,000 tenants benefit from rent supplement, which is an increase of 52% since the end of 2007.
It was always intended to be a short-term allowance but because local authorities are not building as many houses as before, it has become the only way for some people around the country to afford to live independently and comfortably. It was also intended for the rental accommodation scheme, RAS, to be extended but the take-up of the scheme has been dismally slow. The idea that somebody has to be 18 months on rent allowance before becoming eligible for RAS is a disincentive. How does the Minister propose to achieve this saving?
What is a bona fide tenant with regard to the language in the Bill? That is an objectionable term. The explanatory memorandum states "In order to qualify for rent supplement, a person must have been a tenant or living in homeless accommodation for a period of at least six months". There is also the stipulation that a person must be able "to demonstrate that s/he could reasonably have afforded the rent at the commencement of the tenancy". If the person was able to afford the rent at the commencement of the tenancy, he or she would not need rent allowance. It is a bit disingenuous and misleading so will the Minister clarify the matter?
Comment on this
The Department of Social and Family Affairs is practically acting like a housing authority. Much community welfare officer time is taken up with trying to sort out rent allowance, rent supplement and everything else. It was announced a number of years ago that we would have this area transferred to local authorities. It is partially transferred in the form of RAS and this should be extended. As Senator McFadden mentioned, some 91,000 people are on rent allowance and surely there should be a move to bring more people under RAS, which seems to be working quite well under the local authority system. I am sure savings would occur if that happened.
Has the intention been abandoned by the Department? Community welfare officers are not meant to deal with this area and it should, correctly, be dealt with by the local authority. If the intention has been abandoned, why so?
Comment on this
I wish to raise a point of order. I was in my office listening to the debate but I have never heard anything like the way in which the Cathaoirleach intervened to tell a Member of this House it was not appropriate for him to ask a specific and clear question germane to the debate. I understand the advice given was that the Attorney General apparently has said we are not entitled in this House to information on whether legal advice has been sought. Whatever about the content, the Attorney General has no right to rule in this House. This is a sovereign House of Parliament. We make the rules and I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach to refer this ruling and the advice given to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges because this is a further example of the way in which this House is treated with absolute contempt. It was a reasonable question, it was germane and relevant to the debate and it was ruled out of order by a series of interventions from the Chair. I rarely criticise the Chair but I am most definitely criticising what was done here tonight.
Comment on this
Will the Leas-Chathaoirleach look at the record and refer it to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges because if the Attorney General has given such advice, he must be confronted?
Comment on this
Does the Senator propose to refer the matter to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges?
Comment on this
During her deliberations on the budget, did the Minister seek advice from CWOs around the country and from strategic policy committees, SPCs, on housing and social policy? What else informs her decisions when she goes to cut a budget or make changes? How does she do this with the best intention?
Comment on this
With regard to Senator McFadden's questions, we are trying to put the regulations in this area into legislation. Under the regulations, an applicant must have been a tenant for a set period and at the time he or she took out the tenancy, he or she must have been able to pay the rent. It is not true to say they would not look for rent supplement because one might have taken out one's tenancy a year ago but only lost one's job now. We are trying to avoid people moving into expensive accommodation they cannot afford and then applying for rent supplement when they could never have afforded the accommodation in the first place. This is covered by regulation and the section provides that it is put into legislation.
With regard to the bona fides of tenants, the section provides that a tenant must have been in rented accommodation or an institution for six months. If one has been discharged from care, for example, or a psychiatric institution, one would be covered rather than having to make sure one was in rented accommodation up until then.
Local authorities are responsible for housing. They maintain housing policy but this is an unusual scheme, which was designed to be a short-term measure for those who needed support. However, it has changed considerably over the past while. The RAS is still maintained by local authorities. Housing managers have made recommendations but they are answerable to the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. The CWOs who pay out social welfare funds are employed by the HSE. The sooner the CWOs come under the aegis of the Department of Social and Family Affairs and the industrial relations issues are resolved, the better for streamlining all the processes for everybody.
The section puts into legislation what we have in regulation. I was asked how money would be saved. Rents have fallen significantly over the past number of months. All the evidence shows that, but they have not fallen by the same amount everywhere or for different types of accommodation. For example, rent for a bedsit has not reduced as much as that for a house. Since we last set the limits, rents have continued to reduce. I aim to save money by setting revised rent limits for new tenants and for lease renewals. We do not expect recipients to renegotiate midway through a lease. We introduced that provision in the supplementary budget last April with some success because landlords with multiple properties were happy to have a rent supplement tenant. However, there is no way the State should dictate what are the high rents. That is how we intend to save money without placing an additional burden on tenants to renegotiate midway through leases.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for her comprehensive reply and while I accept most of what she said, during my constituency work, all the people on rent supplement I meet are seeking help to go straight into rented accommodation and to apply for the rent allowance because they do not have an alternative. They try to obtain a deposit from the local authority and then apply to the CWO immediately before contacting the landlord and spending perhaps one or two weeks in the new property. I assure the Minister the people concerned are put to the pin of their collar to find somewhere to live and pay rent. I wonder whether another door is being closed and more people are being pushed out. I would like the Minister to clarify this. The section states, "The applicant must be in a position to demonstrate that he or she reasonably could have afforded the rent at the commencement of the tenancy". Rent supplement means a great deal to social welfare recipients, who could not manage to pay their rent without it and that is the bottom line.
Comment on this
Will the CWO still have authority to help applicants? When I was chair of the SPC on housing and social policy on South Tipperary County Council, I was appalled that accommodation given to tenants for which they were paid rent supplement was inappropriate to their needs and in a dangerous condition. I was worried by accommodation provided under the scheme, which was not suitable, for example, for single women with young babies or people with disabilities. They had difficulty with access having to climb two flights of stairs in some cases or having to climb external stairways. The buildings were inappropriate and poorly maintained. I stated at the SPC and at the homeless forum that if the State was helping people on housing lists, the accommodation used for RAS or the rent supplement scheme should be of the highest standard. There is no excuse for not insisting on such a standard nowadays because a glut of housing is available. Separately, if houses remain unoccupied for a while, they scream out that they are unoccupied and they are sometimes subject to vandalism, which is also an issue.
Comment on this
The CWOs will still have flexibility at local level.
Comment on this
If they were all like what I witnessed in Clonmel, they would deserve such flexibility. The CWO structure there is the model for how flood relief payments should be handled everywhere.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the CWOs in Athlone were fantastic.
Comment on this
That is a good point of order. I only mentioned Clonmel because I visited the area and they have a model for dealing with flooding because, unfortunately, they had previous experience. They knew how to handle it. The CWOs in Athlone had not experienced this previously and they responded. Where flooding occurred around the country, the CWOs are expediting humanitarian aid and so on.
I strongly believe people should be in rented accommodation for six months before they seek State aid, otherwise everybody will look for the best accommodation and only have to pay €24 a week in rent.
Comment on this
There is no local authority housing.
Comment on this
If they cannot afford it, they should not be in it and they should not expect the State to pay the rent for them. We are not a rental agency. The rent supplement is in place to support people who when they entered rented accommodation could afford it because they were in employment, but who have since lost their jobs and cannot pay the rent. It is designed as a short-term support. Unfortunately, some people have been in receipt of the support for too long and that also needs to be examined. We have to have that built-in criterion that one should be in rented accommodation for some time before one receives rent supplement; otherwise the State will end up paying hundreds of thousands of euro. We will spend €500 million on rent supplement this year while the individual pays €24. That is acceptable if someone has fallen on hard times and was genuinely in rented accommodation prior to this. However, it certainly would not be if every young person decided to seek rented accommodation and have it paid for by the State. That is why we are including conditions for the payment of rent supplement in regulations and legislation.
Comment on this
The reason so many avail of rent supplement is 400,000 people are on the live register, all of whom are entitled to rent allowance. The Minister is quite removed and disconnected in stating that. Where will they live if the local authorities do not build houses? They need support. I cannot stand over this provision; it is cold, removed and callous.
Comment on this
I am not sure the Senator understands the position. We will give the money to those who have been in rented accommodation. We will not turn down people who were previously in rented accommodation.
Comment on this
Other criteria will be added, whereby to qualify for rent supplement, a person must reasonably have afforded the rent at the commencement of the tenancy or have been residing in homeless accommodation. However, some have not and this is their first port of call.
Comment on this
They were living at home or in college or they had emigrated. We are exporting many of our people and they are returning to no jobs. Where do they live?
Comment on this
If somebody living at home wants to seek rented accommodation but cannot afford it, he or she cannot afford it. The same is true of somebody not working or working. I am sorry, but the State is not in the business of helping anybody who wants to leave home to find rented accommodation. We are in the business of supporting people who previously were in rented accommodation and are finding it difficult; otherwise we would end up paying rent for everybody in the country.
Comment on this
The Seanad divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
This section amends section 246 of the principal Act and under this section, social welfare claimants must meet a habitual residence condition in order to qualify for benefits. The Department of Social and Family Affairs has argued that these criteria ruled out all asylum seekers, but in a series of cases taken by FLAC over the last two years, the chief social welfare appeals officer held that where asylum seekers had been to the country for a significant period of time, had established connections here, had children born here and attending school, or had other family members here and clearly intended that they would stay here if they could, then they could qualify under the habitual residence condition. The cases especially involved child benefit, but also the carer's allowance, disability allowance and the State pension.
Five decisions were made on 3 and 4 December. As a result of these decisions, the Minister has introduced this section. It states that persons who have applied for asylum or protection under the EU protection directive and who are still in that process cannot meet the habitual residence condition, thus effectively overturning the chief social welfare appeals officer's decision that such cases had to be assessed on their individual merits and excluding a whole class of people, regardless of their individual circumstances. Does the Minister agree that this is discrimination? Will she make a statement on it?
Comment on this
I strongly support Senator Prendergast and I am very much of the same opinion. Furthermore, the whole democratic process has been undermined by the Government's behaviour in the other House. This amendment was put on Thursday evening last and was not reached or even discussed in the other House because the Bill was guillotined.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. I am speaking on the section.
Comment on this
I am speaking about the effect of the amendment on the section. It would be ridiculous if Senators could not do so as one would then be required to repeatedly say the words "section 14". One must be allowed to discuss the——
Comment on this
I was giving a hypothetical example. This is a serious issue. As far as I am aware, virtually the entire section is an amendment. Is that not correct? If, as I believe, the section is an amendment to the Bill, I am entitled to refer to it as an amendment.
This is by no means the first time the Department of Social and Family Affairs has acted in this manner. It is disgraceful and undermines completely the democratic process of the State. One of the Minister's predecessors, the current Tánaiste, Deputy Mary Coughlan, had a decision from the Equality Tribunal which indicated a clear case of discrimination. Instead of acting to amend the legislation to address the discrimination, the former Minister amended the legislation by redefining the word "spouse" to swindle people out of the rights which an agency of the Government determined citizens were entitled to.
This is exactly what has happened in this case and it is spectacularly mean minded. What it means is that people who have applied for asylum or protection and are still in the process cannot meet the habitual residence condition. They will, therefore, be disbarred from access to even fairly minimal provision of social welfare payments. This measure will penalise children, people of pensionable age and people caring for sick children as well as causing divisions. For example, people who have been here with their families for a number of years and are still stuck in the asylum process — it is a disgrace to this country that these decisions should take so long and justice should be so delayed — will find that they will not be able to afford to allow their children to take part in school trips, outings and so forth. As a person who was involved in education and was a very good Minister for Education and Science, the Minister will not wish this to be the case.
As Senator Prendergast stated, a number of cases were taken. Asylum seekers and their representatives in the free legal aid centres, FLAC, were successful in every single case. The Minister is now reversing the decision of a properly established organ of the State.
The Department claimed that a decision by the Supreme Court in 2003 in the case of Goncescu & Others v. Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, [2003] IEHC, meant that no one in the asylum, protection or leave to remain process could be regarded as resident in the State. As a result, such persons could not satisfy the habitual residence condition. The Department’s argument was not accepted by the court because it represented a hardening of attitude.
Previously, the Department's deciding officers had relied upon the five factors or criteria set out in the Social Welfare and Pensions Act 2007 and drawn from a decision of the European Court of Justice in the case of Robin Swaddling v. Adjudication Officer, C-90/97. The five criteria are the length and continuity of residence in the State or in any other particular country, the length and purpose of any absence from the State, the nature and pattern of the person’s employment, the person’s main centre of interest and the future intentions of the person concerned as they appear from all the circumstances.
It is clear that the decisions arrived at as a result of the process by FLAC make the Minister's position undemocratic and unsustainable. I ask her to reverse her decision in this matter on the grounds that it undermines the democratic process, flies in the face of a series of decisions, defies the European Convention on Human Rights, undermines the asylum process, discriminates against children and is a reproach to all those on the Government side. I will conclude on those words while reserving the right to return to the matter.
Comment on this
This issue has been discussed. On the habitual residence clause, a social welfare appeals officer found that under five criteria certain individuals were entitled to receive child benefit on the basis that they were in the asylum trap for an excessively long time. To be fair to the Minister, this problem is not part of her portfolio but comes within the remit of the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform. It is inhumane that some people must wait for such long periods to have their asylum applications processed.
The Fine Gael Party wants the backlog of asylum applications dealt with because it is contributing to the current economic climate. People who apply for leave to remain in the State face long delays. The system is cruel, unfair and inhumane. I regularly meet unfortunate individuals in this position in my constituency office.
The Minister responded to a question I asked yesterday on whether the legislation would be retrospective. I also asked what was the potential of the ruling on schemes other than child benefit. I ask the Minister to clarify this issue.
Comment on this
As Senator McFadden stated, the backlog in processing asylum seekers is inhumane. I am pleased the Leader is present because last week on the Order of Business Government Senators gave us a lecture on human rights. Opposition Members were subjected to a litany of abuse from some so-called human rights experts. What does this section say about the Government's commitment and attitude to human rights? Perhaps the Leader and Minister will reply.
Comment on this
In 2008, it was estimated that there were approximately 15,000 asylum seekers or failed asylum seekers in the State. While they are resident here, such persons have a right to access public health services and free primary and second level education. Their basic needs as regards their rights to access health and education services are also met and they are provided with accommodation and a small amount of pocket money.
Comment on this
As I stated, it is a small amount. These people cost €250 million in one year alone. When the habitual residency legislation was introduced it was assumed that anyone who did not have a right to remain in the State did not have a right to habitual residency. All we are asking in this section is that it should be a precondition of entitlement to access many social welfare benefits that one is entitled to be in the State. The people who have joined us in recent years come from 188 different countries. It would be wrong if people who are not entitled to be in this country were able to build up entitlements to social welfare.
Comment on this
The Minister is completely wrong. The people in question have a perfect entitlement to be in the country. While they may not have an entitlement to citizenship or asylum, they have every entitlement to be here. I ask the Minister to acknowledge that is the case.
Comment on this
The Minister has the floor. Senator Norris can make a further contribution afterwards.
Comment on this
If someone does not have the right to reside in the State, he or she should not have the right to build up social welfare entitlements. They have access to accommodation, basic health and basic education at substantial cost. We must recognise their human rights and that is why people go through an intensive legal process. It is important this legislation sets down the precondition that must be satisfied before other circumstances are taken into consideration.
Comment on this
This undermines the independence of the social welfare appeals office. When the office makes a decision the Department does not like, the Government changes the law. This enshrines discrimination on the basis of nationality in Ireland. It is deeply divisive and only saves a small amount of money. The need to meet the criteria of the HRC means very few people who are not in need of benefits receive them. It undermines the process one goes through in the social welfare appeals office if the Government can make another law because it does not like the decision.
Comment on this
It is instructive that in all five cases cited, the chief appeals officer rejected arguments by the Department of Social and Family Affairs that the people in the asylum process could not meet the habitual residence condition, a test introduced in 2004 to prevent a feared influx of so-called welfare tourists. So-called welfare tourism has been dealt with by the habitual residence condition. The chief appeals officer found that this cannot be brushed aside completely. The Minister is trying to redefine matters.
This is all about money, as the Minister has more or less accepted. I challenge the Minister on her assertion that these people had no right to be in the country. They may not have had a permanent right but they have every right to be in the country while they are appealing. I note that the Minister is acknowledging this to be correct. It may be that we have been here a long time and the phraseology is inexact even though that is uncharacteristic of this Minister. I do not accuse her of any malice in this matter. The House should know the attitude of the Department. I do not take great pleasure in attacking the Department in a blanket sense but on this issue I feel a responsibility to do so. One can see the attitude in the fact that there was a stay put on payments during this period. The Department refused to pay, which is questionable behaviour. In the four successful appeals, where the Department of Social and Family Affairs asked for a review by the chief appeals officer, it refused to make payments that had been approved by the appeals officer until the reviews were completed. FLAC challenged this on the basis that reviews were not formal appeals and, unlike an appeal court, the chief appeals officer had no power to put a stay on the payments pending his decision and he had not been asked to do so. It was the Department, the unsuccessful party to the appeals, that had unilaterally decided not to pay and the applicants were left with no way of appealing against that decision. FLAC issued judicial review proceedings in one case to try to compel the Department to pay. However, the chief appeals officer gave his decision in favour of the applicant a few days before the hearing date and it was then settled. The attitude of the Department is to do people out of their entitlements. How much will that save? It is bad faith and this is a squalid decision. I warned the Government against the process, which appears to be particularly concentrated in the Department, of establishing public bodies, giving them a statutory remit to make decisions on matters of fairness, justice and equality and then when clear and binding decisions are made, the Government overturns them by further legislation instead of addressing them. That is appalling behaviour whatever the economic circumstances of the case.
This is not welfare tourism. What about the people who have been stuck in the process for four or five years because of our inefficiency?
Comment on this
They are on €19 a week. I apologise, I forgot the 10 cent, it is €19.10.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Norris's point that this is about money but we must reflect on the fact that this is taxpayers' money and it is not printed automatically by a money printing machine. Where stands the Irish Republic on this policy in respect of our colleagues across the European Union? Is the situation envisaged by this section the norm, extraordinary, more favourable or less favourable than the norm across the European Union? This is a policy area in which I am not an expert. The Minister can advise me whether this section and her proposals are common policy across the EU and whether they are more or less restrictive. We can sometimes get emotional and get carried away on these matters. I would like to know where we stand by international standards and particularly by EU guidelines. Constituents raise this matter quite frequently. It can cause a degree of difficulty from that great perspective of political correctness but sometimes we have a duty to reflect what constituents speak of. Where do we stand vis-à-vis our European partners?
Comment on this
Technically, I agree with the Minister that unless foreign nationals have a right to be here they should not have the right to build up entitlements. I agree with the Minister in theory but in practice it is a little bit different. We are putting these cases into a backlog by not dealing with them for four or five years and in this way we are denying people their human rights. There is another series of knock-on effects arising from this. Trafficking is one example. I have become involved with the Galway Rape Crisis Centre of late and I have learned that 20% of their clients come from direct provision centres. Some 1% of Galway's population are foreign nationals yet 20% of them seek help and counselling as a result of rape and violence. Some of these people are underage minors housed in direct provision centres. This is a serious issue.
Asylum is a gift. If the Minister or I needed asylum in another country we would see it as a gift. It should not take that number of years. While I agree with the Minister on a technical point, I do not agree once this process goes beyond six months. Why is there such a backlog? Why are staff not assigned to clear the backlog in order that we do not have a living history developing of asylum seekers and refugees in direct provision centres throughout our country?
Comment on this
In response to Senator Bradford's question about equivalents around Europe, the equivalent legislation in the UK is the only example I have to hand. This requires that claimants for social welfare must have a right to reside and habitual residence. Both criteria must be met.
Some of the questions on the asylum process are more relevant to the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform. Throughout Europe it has been found that where there is a cash-based system, one is more likely to find asylum shopping. It is a terrible phrase but that is what it is known as. The more cash available, the more likely people are to come. If we were to initiate a situation whereby people could build up entitlements by virtue of them being in the country, as opposed to having a right to reside in the country, there would be a great attraction for people to come and to try to circumvent and delay all the processes. As the Senator knows, our legal system allows people to keep going back to the courts and to have judicial reviews and so on. We have seen very public examples of how people can drag it out for a very long time. With regard to some of the cases that were mentioned, the Supreme Court had previously decided that a person in the asylum process did not have residency status. The chief appeals officer took the FLAC argument, stating that the judgment in that case preceded the habitual residence condition and, therefore, did not apply to social welfare, which I accept as his finding, but it was an unusual finding to try to second guess the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
He was not trying to second guess the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
The Supreme Court indicated that it felt a person in the asylum process did not have residency status. I accept what Senator Norris has said. Such a person has a right to be in the country but not a right to reside in the country. This is the argument we are trying to protect here.
On the question of the Government making legislation, that is what Governments do. The chief appeals officer indicated in his judgment that it was open to the Legislature to bring about change if the Oireachtas wanted to exclude asylum seekers as a category. What we are trying to do here is not in any way to contravene anybody's human rights. We are not trying to interfere in any way with the asylum seeker process. All we are trying to suggest is that people who are in that process and who have not established a right to reside in the country cannot use that time to build up their right to social welfare.
Comment on this
I was perfectly correct. I was rebuked by the Leas-Chathaoirleach for referring to the amendment when we were on the section. The section is an amendment.
Comment on this
It is an amendment to that Bill put in the Dáil.
Comment on this
Therefore, it is an amendment and a section. The terms are coterminous.
Comment on this
It is an amendment of that Bill as initiated in the Dáil. The two terms are coterminous. I know what I am talking about in terms of language.
I want to address the Minister's point because there are a number of technical flaws in it. The case she referred to was the case to which I referred, namely, the Goncescu case. The chief appeals officer stated in all four cases that since the Goncescu case was decided a year before the habitual residence condition was introduced, it was unlikely that the Supreme Court was aware of any intention to introduce legislation to restrict access to social welfare payments on the basis of a habitual residence test. He said: "The facts of the matter are that the Goncescu case did not have a social welfare relevance and that the judgment predated the introduction of the habitual residence legislation." Whatever qualities the Supreme Court has, it does not possess the divine afflatus, prophetic powers, it is not the oracle of Delphi and it cannot make a decision based on something that happens one year later. That is rudimentary logic, I would have thought.
The chief appeals officer doubted the judgment's relevance to these cases and went on to say:
I do not believe there was any intention in framing the [HRC] legislation to exclude a particular category (such as asylum/protection seekers) from access to social welfare benefits. If there was any such intention the relevant legislative provisions would have reflected that intention and removed any doubt on the issue [ which they patently did not].
The advice from the Attorney General's office which was quoted by the Department said that time spent by applicants in the asylum process could not be considered as "residence" and could not count towards satisfying the habitual residence condition. However, the chief appeals officer noted that the Department had not quoted another portion of the advice which said that time spent in the State was only one of five factors. From what the Minister has said, one would almost assume that the only factor was time spent in the State but it is one of five. It is quite possible that, despite the subsequent Supreme Court decision, some at least of the other four might still be in play.
Comment on this
At no stage did I try to indicate that the right to reside was the only element. The right to reside does not at all mean that one would automatically qualify for habitual residence. It is a precondition that should be satisfied before the other circumstances are taken into account. The fact is the chief appeals officer indicated it was open to introduce legislation, which is exactly what we are doing here, and his findings do not set a precedent.
Comment on this
The Minister raised the matter of precedent. The Department rather bizarrely objected to the appeals officer referring to earlier decisions by other appeals officers and the chief appeals officer. Such decisions, as the Minister said, could not set precedents. The chief appeals officer said it was not appropriate for appeals officers to refer to "details" of previous cases in their decisions or reports. However, he agreed with the argument made by FLAC that while previous decisions were not binding in detail — this is the telling phrase — it was important to identify the underlying general principles so decisions would not be arbitrary and applicants could know the case they would have to make.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
On the new rates, I appeal to the Members on the Government side who are about to vote the Bill into law. The Minister, her Fianna Fail colleagues and particularly Green Party Members who came here with such reforming zeal two and a half years ago took office with a programme for Government that promised all things to all people.
Comment on this
The Senator should address the Chair.
Comment on this
I do not need lessons in etiquette from the Leader of the House.
Comment on this
I am entitled to speak in the House and do not need lectures from the Leader.
Comment on this
I understand the embarrassment on the other side of the House because of what they are about to do.
Comment on this
I will, but the Leader is embarrassed. The Bill is an attack on the decent people of Ireland. Schedule 1 reduces the money going into the homes of those who have not contributed to the economic decline of the country, yet the friends of the Leader and Fianna Fáil are masquerading and have the guise of someone who is getting away with it. They have perpetrated a crime on the people and have not been held to account. The Bill holds the ordinary Irish person to account. I am asking the Green Party, in particular and specifically, whether it plans to abandon the principles about which it spoke when it went into government. Senator Boyle was the very guy on the steps of Government Buildings who was nearly in tears when it had not been agreed, yet tonight he and his colleagues will be voting against the people.
Comment on this
Give them the money to count frogs.
Comment on this
I have a message for those opposite. The people will not forget them. They are going to wait for them and will pass judgment on a Government——
Comment on this
The Government is reducing the rates of payment to the disabled, those who cannot see and the mothers who depend on child benefit, as well as the income of parents struggling to repay mortgages and in some cases facing repossession. Is this the legacy that the Members opposite want? If it is, they should walk through the "Tá" lobby. If not, they should have the moral courage to vote "Níl".
Comment on this
There is no doubt we would not be introducing these cuts in social welfare were it not for the economic situation in which we find ourselves and were it not for the need to bring stability to the finances of the country. Everybody recognises the huge increases introduced in social welfare payments in recent years, including in the last budget. These increases were well ahead of inflation. Prices have now come down with the result that purchasing power is much stronger. I know this is of little solace to somebody who is taking a cut in his or her social welfare payment. We would not be doing this were it not for the fact that we genuinely have to. If we do not make cuts in social welfare, we will end up with a greater imbalance in the other two sectors on which the State is spending money — public pay and services.
Comment on this
It would do a greater disservice——
Comment on this
——to carers and people with a disability to take money from services. In fact, additional moneys are going into items such as home care packages——
Comment on this
The Government made the wrong choice again.
Comment on this
Please have some respect for the Minister who is replying. She did not interrupt any Member of the House. I want the House to show her respect. Members will have an opportunity to contribute again.
Comment on this
We made very deliberate choices to protect pensioners, older people who have made their contribution to the State. We made a very deliberate choice to ensure children in families dependent on social welfare or those families in receipt of family income supplement would not suffer the loss of child benefit. We have supported and protected pensioners and such children. We have also incentivised young people to participate in education and training to ensure they will not join the ranks of the long-term unemployed.
This legislation should be seen as part of the overall package introduced as part of the budget, with employment opportunities in the construction industry, tourism and food production, employment stabilisation measures and a PRSI exemption for employers taking on new staff. These are all part of the overall picture. I appreciate the fact that a debate has taken place in the House and the genuinely held views on all sides. However, we should also look at some of the policies of other parties which recommended cutting social welfare. Fine Gael came forward with a proposal which I acknowledge and recognise.
Comment on this
It stated it would cut payments to widows and lone parents, the farm assist payment, unemployment payments with a view to incentivising young people——
Comment on this
We should recognise there were proposals to cut social welfare from various sides of the House. We made our decisions to protect older people, the children of vulnerable families on social welfare, those in receipt of farm assist payments and to incentivise young people——
Comment on this
Older people are receiving less than last year.
Comment on this
I accept that when a cut is made in one area and money is taken back, this will be difficult for those affected. It is not a situation we like to be in, but if we do not get the finances of the country right now, unfortunately, others will pay for it for a very long time. We do not want to find we are in that situation in a few years' time. In making the tough decisions now we are putting the country back on the road.
Comment on this
This social welfare Bill will go down in history as the harshest and cruellest of them all. I ask the Minister how, in God's name, she can consider she is incentivising young people in taking 50% of their payment from them. Why does she think pensioners have not been affected? She has said they have been protected. What a very nice word to use when, in fact, they have lost their Christmas bonus which amounted to a figure of 2%. As a result of the carbon tax, they will pay an extra €2.40 on a bag of coal and an extra 50 cent on a bale of briquettes, not to mention the fact that they face a 50 cent charge on prescriptions, plus all of the other cuts in optical and dental benefits.
I ask the Minister to be honest. She is glossing over the Bill and using sanctimonious sentiments when, in fact, she is being extraordinarily harsh and callous. How can she take €8.80 from carers and say it must be done for the greater good? It would have been preferable to take money from all of us here than from them, the people who are saving the Exchequer money by keeping people out of hospital and institutions. In return, we have cut their allowance by €8.80 per week. It is an outrage. If I were the Minister, I would not be saying I had done a good job.
Funding for Youthreach and VTOS programmes is being cut, yet the Minister says she is incentivising young people. This is an emigration budget which will drive young people out of the country.
We have spent a long time debating the cut in dental benefits. People do not know yet what is ahead of them. However, when they do, the Government will be criticised for the rest of its time in office for being so heartless and cruel. I rest my case. I ask the Minister not to use rhetoric that is patronising and disrespectful to the people.
Comment on this
If every penny of the social welfare budget was saved six times over, we would just about cover the level of debt of this country. The adjustment being applied in the Bill is 0.4% of the total debt of the country.
Comment on this
When people talk about who pays the price, they must remember——
Comment on this
——that the social welfare budget is being adjusted by 0.4% of the total national debt.
Comment on this
We find ourselves in a deflationary climate——
Comment on this
The one group of individuals who will find themselves better off in terms of their living standards when we next go to the polls——
Comment on this
Is the Senator happy with the changes?
Comment on this
——and no matter what Government is returned subsequently, are those dependent on social welfare payments who will find that their living standards have been protected.
Comment on this
I have one question for the Minister that deserves to be answered. The Minister said yesterday and tonight that the Government, in the context of a very tough budgetary environment, has done its utmost to protect the most vulnerable people in society. Can she explain the reason we have protected the most vulnerable by imposing cuts on them?
Comment on this
As I indicated, we have protected pensioners; there has been no change in respect of them. We have protected children in families dependent on social welfare who are in receipt of family income supplement. Those families will not experience any drop in income as a result of the cut in child benefit. We have also tried to ensure, despite the difficult decisions that were made, that we kept the cuts at a minimum for all other groups, bearing in mind the increases that have been given in previous years, particularly the increase given this year. That increase was given in anticipation of an inflation of 2.5%. As we know, however, we did not get inflation; we got deflation and whereas undoubtedly there are people who benefited more from the drop in prices than others, for example, people with mortgages benefited hugely but the price of food, clothing and energy has come down as well. People on social welfare payments and people who are unemployed——
Comment on this
Energy prices have gone through the roof.
Comment on this
People will have to switch off the lights.
Comment on this
——have also benefited from the decline in prices. Real purchasing power has also been protected for those people.
Nobody is saying this is easy but it is interesting that the very people who recommended cutting jobseeker's allowance, widow's pension and lone parents allowance, which is the Fine Gael Party, are now the ones who are objecting to that policy being introduced.
Comment on this
We are objecting to the cuts being imposed on carers and on blind people. The Minister should not misinterpret our policy.
Comment on this
No interruptions, please. Members should have respect for the Minister who is speaking.
Comment on this
The Minister is not telling the truth about this.
Comment on this
The Senator should have respect for the Minister. He will have an opportunity to speak later if he wishes.
Comment on this
To get the same savings, it would have meant putting an increased burden on some of those other sectors.
Comment on this
If we were to take the groups that the Fine Gael Party identified as the ones who should be cut——
Comment on this
——to get €730 million, we would have had to take far more from those. It was very much an effort in trying to prioritise within a social welfare budget where savings had to be made. It was not enough to try to bring in extra revenue from other areas. As anyone knows, we had to bring about structural changes in our expenditure that would last through next year and that can show we have taken the tough decisions. I accept they are tough on people who will experience a cut of €8, €8.30 or €8.50 per week——
Comment on this
People will have a cut of €8.80 per week.
Comment on this
——but it should be seen in the context of the increases that were given, the decreases in prices and the fact that when it comes to the most vulnerable, the very young and the very old, we have protected those as well.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister to some extent and as we approach the finality of this Bill I have no doubt that if the Fine Gael Party was in government I would be sitting on this side of the House opposing the measures it would introduce in a social welfare Bill because our party has shown clearly that social welfare should not be touched. The Minister said that if we did not touch social welfare we would have to cut public sector workers or services harder. That is not true. As I said, €50 billion of US debt has been bought up by Irish individuals and investors in recent months. There is wealth in this country. The Minister had many other opportunities to increase the tax take to offset the cuts she has to introduce. It is not just a case that there are three areas — social welfare, the public sector or services. There is an area where we could have found the money to offset the decisions the Minister is taking and the Government is implementing. We should be honest about that. I have tried to be as honest as possible, and the Minister may have had a difficulty with what I have said, in terms of this debate. There are difficult decisions that the Government has to take but there are people who are earning huge amounts of money. There are people in the public sector earning €500,000. That does not make sense. We could have hit those people harder. It is not about punishing people who have wealth, who have taken risks and done well for themselves. It is about the ability to pay.
In his contribution Senator Boyle——
Comment on this
I am talking about what it relates to.
Comment on this
In regard to Schedule 2, let us put it in perspective.
Comment on this
I am getting down to it. Schedule 2 itemises the cuts to which young people will have to adhere, the benefits that will be drastically cut. We should put those in perspective and not muddle it up in a spin of 0.4% of 1% of national debt. We should be clear on this. A young person who has worked building the economy for the past year and a half and who has paid taxes and PRSI will see the benefits to which he or she should be entitled reduced by more than €104 as a result of the decisions that will be taken here in a few minutes. It is not 0.4% of 1%; that is the real effects of the cuts that will be implemented today with the passing of this Bill.
These are difficult decisions. The Government has decided to support them but we should be honest and admit that these measures are drastic. What is being introduced in this Bill is utterly disgusting. I do not want to name individuals in the Green Party. It is in government and it supports the Bill. It is a minority party. This is not about the Green Party or its members. What is being done here is ridiculous. The cuts the Government is implementing are not minor adjustments that will bring people back to levels they were at a few years ago. It was a long time since young people, many of whom are married as I mentioned earlier, were only supported by the payment of €100 in this State. That is the third worst social welfare payment for an individual in the EU 15. It is ridiculous. If members of the Green Party have decided to vote for this, they should be honest about what they are doing. This legislation is disgusting. I mentioned earlier that this legislation is usually one of the worst items of legislation to come before the House. It should be the worst but, unfortunately, it is not because we have had worse this year. This is what is sickening about it.
In terms of the 0.4% of the 1% of debt, in a few months we will come to the House and pump billions of euro into the banks. It will be the billions of euro we have taken off the 20 year olds, blind people and child benefit recipients that will go into the banks. That is absolutely terrible. That is only one part of the jigsaw. The Minister should be honest about what the Government is doing. Choices were made although other choices were presented to the Government. We presented choices, costed by the Department of Finance, on where revenue could be created. I refer, for example, to wealth tax, standardising tax relief and the introduction of PRSI ceilings. All those options were available to the Minister. Our proposals were not about the public sector, services or attacking social welfare recipients. That is absolutely disgusting and it should not be happening. I do not agree with the Fine Gael proposal but the Minister should acknowledge that other options were available. The Minister decided to ignore them. There are other ways out of the problem but the Minister decided to ignore them for a reason I will never understand.
Comment on this
Not particularly, because I always seem to have to repeat everything I say to the Senator and then repeat it again. What the Government was faced with was taking money out of expenditure and the three areas of expenditure are social welfare, public pay and services. It was not enough just to try to increase revenue. That is part of it, and that is what we did in the previous budget. The income levies, which people viewed in a progressive manner, have had that effect. The more one tries to hit at the income of people, the more one gets into diminishing returns. A total of 4% of people will pay approximately 50% of income tax next year. We doubled the health levy to find that €105 million less has been realised. There is no way one can achieve €4 billion of savings by heading after a small group of people because it would not give the required results. That is why we were faced with trying to take money out of expenditure. As in any small or large budget, if one does not have money coming in, one cannot have it going out. One has to bridge that gap. That is precisely what we are trying to achieve. We are trying to reduce the €400 million per week that we are borrowing. That is in the best interests of the entire country. It is in the best interests of young people that we try to return to a situation where employment is available and there are incentives for people to invest in this country and to ensure we can hold on to the 1.9 million jobs we have. It would be very easy for us just to focus on those people who have lost their jobs. They have to be the focus of this Department in particular and they have to be supported but there are still 1.9 million people working and they need to be supported as well. That is the type of balancing we had to do in the budget. It is difficult. This is not a situation we want to be in but it is for the greater good of the country.
Comment on this
A vote was called when I was about to ask the Leader when Report Stage would be taken, which should not have been called at that point.
Comment on this
This is a very bad way to handle business to go straight into the next Stage.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?