Dog Breeding Establishments Bill 2009: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 161–332 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 79 of 2009 ›
There seems to one rule for one group and another rule for another group.
Comment on this
There is only one rule for everybody here. I ask the Senator to speak to the amendment, he has not spoken yet spoken to it.
Comment on this
I have. The Members opposite should listen. Perhaps I will start again.
Comment on this
I respectfully suggest that the Senator applies for the PhD to which Senator O'Reilly referred.
Comment on this
The PhD that Senator O'Reilly spoke about has been very much in evidence in the level of the Bill we have before us and in the participation of the people on the far side.
Comment on this
Gabh mo leithscéal, but I am defending myself and my party. I will not take smart remarks from anybody, especially from people who have put forward a Bill but who have no interest in creating or retaining jobs.
Comment on this
Will the Senator speak to the amendment? That point has nothing to do with the amendment.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State clearly define who is the authorised person in this context, who is eligible to be that person and give an example of the people he has in mind in this respect? Is the Government serious about the retention of 11,000 jobs in this industry? If it is, it will accept this and the other amendments put forward by Members on this side of the House as a serious attempt to improve the Bill.
Comment on this
When I served on Galway City Council we had a difficult time in this area because we had only one dog warden to deal with the issues related to dogs. We tried to get around this by involving well qualified local veterinary practitioners who had spent many years in college, but, unfortunately, we were not able to do that.
Under this amendment tabled by Fine Gael, it is extraordinary that well qualified country veterinary practitioners could not be employed in regard to this Bill——
Comment on this
That is not correct. It is only veterinary partitioners who are working for the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. Private veterinary practitioners, as laid out by the Bill, are well qualified people with many years experience as veterinarians. They have worked with dogs all their lives and are well respected by the greyhound industry and every other industry. It would not be possible for local authorities to employ those people.
It is also extraordinary that Fine Gael, which currently controls most of the local authorities is considering that it would be unacceptable to have the double safeguard of a local authority appointing a country veterinary practitioner and that country veterinary practitioner being suitable to the local authority. That is not possible under this amendment unless that person is employed by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. This amendment is nonsense. That is what is needed. This Bill will allow people who have a great deal of experience in the area of dog control to work in that area. It will allow local authorities to appoint such people. There is a safeguard in the Bill.
The Senator talked about mad animal rights liberation people or whoever who——
Comment on this
The Senator's party would know all about them.
Comment on this
——come over here from England. Does the Senator honestly expect Fine Gael controlled local authorities to employ such people? Would they not do a background search on the people they employ in regard to dog control? Of course they will. It is ridiculous to suggest otherwise. Local authorities will not make fools of themselves. Somebody described the people involved in animal liberation as terrorists and we have heard the phrase, "Stalinist Russia", this is scare-mongering in the extreme.
This is a simple Bill which allows local authorities to make that consideration.
Comment on this
There is no definition of an authorised person in this section.
Comment on this
It is a quasi-judicial function and it should not be done with people with a vested interest.
Comment on this
It allows officials of local authorities to make that designation.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has not addressed the point. There is no definition of an authorised person.
Comment on this
This amendment from Fine Gael has obviously not been thought through.
Comment on this
Vested interests should not be involved.
Comment on this
It states that "the Local Authority may designate such and so many of its officials". Perhaps the Cork local authorities, about which Members spoke, have such well qualified officials but are we talking about taking somebody from water services and putting them into dog control? This is nonsense. Many local authorities do not have suitably qualified officials. If they have such officials, the difficulty is they are already working flat out. That is the reality in every local authority.
Fine Gael is suggesting that local authority officials, who are working flat out, and Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food veterinarians, who are also working flat out and not able to cope, should be used for this purpose. The section suggests something very sensible, namely, that anybody who is suitably qualified as a veterinarian or anybody known to the local authority who is suitably qualified and has been involved in animal welfare for years may potentially be designated as a person suitable for inspections. This amendment is farcical and the section should stand as it is.
Comment on this
I listened with interest to the debate and read with interest the Minister's proposals and a lighter thought struck me. Our former colleague — I do not believe we can name people — who left the employment of this House and her political party some weeks ago because she felt her party leader was not providing for her proper employment prospects, would be a possible contender to be deemed an authorised officer under this section.
If we had dealt with section 17 in advance of section 16 and if we had deliberated on the powers of the authorised officer, which are very substantial and far-reaching, we would have tread very carefully when we debated who could take up those positions as authorised persons. As we said on Second Stage, the designated authorised persons will have significant responsibilities, significant discretion and significant decision-making entitlements. That is why it is important we are happy with the people who will hold the title "authorised person".
I agree with a previous speaker in regard to the thinking behind the Fine Gael amendment. Since we began discussing the legislation some weeks ago, the main concern expressed by this side of the House and by speakers on the other side of it is that while there is something very laudable about the backdrop to the legislation and while we all support the necessity to regulate and, if necessary, shut down puppy farms, there is a fear that somehow written into the Bill are sections which could impact negatively on some of our traditional country pursuits and county sports, in particular. We must, therefore, try to be a little bit cautious in how the legislation is written.
There is a possibility of a coach and four being used in regard to the appointment of authorised officers. Not only can the local authorities appoint authorised officers but as we see with section 15(2), they can allow other organisations to appoint them. Authorised officers will not only be appointed by the local authority. The local authority can enter into an agreement with other organisations which can appoint authorised officers.
On the basis that we are talking about a position which has great responsibility and great powers, it is crucial that Members of this House and all those affected by the legislation, in particular those who must work within the rules and regulations laid down, are content and comfortable with those appointed as authorised officers. The Fine Gael amendment prescribes that veterinary practitioners only be allowed to carry out these duties.
Comment on this
It also states officials of the local authorities.
Comment on this
As with any amendments tabled, the wording may not be 100% perfect. If the Minister of State is willing to accept the spirit of our amendment, minor drafting details can be resolved.
Everyone must recognise that the way the section is written could, in theory, provide for any person to be appointed as an authorised officer. A previous speaker asked whether it was likely that local authorities would allow any person to be appointed. The answer is that we do not know but the legislation allows for that possibility. We need to tighten up on that possible cause of dispute.
As this debate has progressed, it is disappointing that we have moved further away from the starting point which was everyone's unanimous view that puppy farming should be tightly and properly regulated and that some of the scare stories we have heard should be no more. However, some of the excessive phraseology in the legislation is leading to a little difficulty in that regard.
I ask the Minister of State to consider carefully our suggestion. In response to early queries, he said there would be a review in 12 months. For this legislation to operate in a way that satisfies all and causes no further doubt as to its impact in its early stages, it is important authorised officers satisfy any doubts by virtue of their qualification and veterinary expertise.
Section 15(2), which allows a local authority to enter into an arrangement to appoint so many members of staff to be authorised persons, needs to be redrafted. I ask the Minister of State to take on board our amendment which, despite all the drama of the past half an hour, is a sensible check which will allay fears.
I accept the majority of Members want to put in place legislation which is worthwhile, workable and has no hidden agenda. Any loose sections which could be abused and misused must be amended. I ask the Minister of State to take on board what is our very reasonable amendment which will make life easier for all of us in trying to support this legislation.
Comment on this
Senator Kieran Phelan is a well-known dog breeder. I thought he was going to contribute.
Comment on this
I have two dogs at home and I am happy enough.
Comment on this
I support Senator Coffey's amendment. As the amendment makes perfect sense, I do not understand Senator Ó Brolcháin's comments. It proposes that local authorities should be able to appoint as authorised inspectors officials such as litter wardens who double up as dog wardens and are known as community wardens or by similar names in certain local authorities. Such persons and veterinary inspectors employed by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food are a wholly appropriate group of people to be employed in the inspection of dog breeding premises.
It is almost unbelievable that if passed the Bill will allow people with a direct and specific interest in this area to carry out inspections of dog breeding premises. Inspections should be carried out by someone who is independent and removed from the argument surrounding the issue. Community alert and neighbourhood watch committees do not and should not investigate crime. The proposed measure is similar.
Comment on this
I did not say it involved a crime. I stated that what is proposed would be similar to having community alert or neighbourhood watch groups involved in the investigation of crime. Senator Ó Brolcháin should read section 17 on the powers of authorised persons.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. I refer to the powers of the authorised person, which are substantial. Such persons will have the power to enter dog breeding establishments and examine with regard to any matter under the Act the operator of the establishment and anyone employed therein. These are strong powers to grant to people who may be directly involved in the process. For this reason, the amendment should be accepted.
I know many people who are involved in animal rights groups and do not have any objection to them. They are thoroughly decent and sound people. I have, however, listened to people such as this character, Bernie Wright, who represents an animal liberation organisation and whose stated objective is to end dairy farming and trout fishing. Such individuals will be eligible to be appointed as authorised persons if the Bill is passed without amendment.
Comment on this
Senator Phelan should stick to the issue of dogs.
Comment on this
Under this legislation, persons such as this will be eligible to enter a dog breeding premises as an authorised person appointed by the local authority.
Comment on this
Local authorities controlled by the Fine Gael Party would not employ such persons.
Comment on this
Does the Senator not trust the local authorities run by his party?
Comment on this
I do trust them. However, despite the probability that my party will be in control of local authorities ad infinitum, it is possible that another party will take control of them eventually and someone like Bernie Wright may be appointed an inspector. Senator Ó Brolcháin should read section 16. Subsection (1) states the local authority may appoint any such person, including——
Comment on this
This is directly related to the amendment. Under subsection (1) a local authority may appoint as authorised persons veterinary practitioners and any persons connected with animal welfare with whom an arrangement has been entered into under section 15(3) of the Act of 1986. Subsection (2) goes further and reads: "A body with which a local authority has entered into an arrangement under section 15(3) of the Act of 1986 may, after consultation with that local authority, appoint such and so many of its members of staff, as it considers appropriate". Under this provision, if a local authority decides to subcontract the entire process of inspecting dog breeding facilities, the subcontractor may, following consultation with the local authority — whatever that means — appoint whoever it wants to be an inspector. In those circumstances, anyone can be appointed an inspector.
The Fine Gael Party amendment is simple and straightforward and seeks to limit persons who may be involved in the inspection of dog breeding facilities to individuals employed by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food or local authorities. It would make common sense to accept it.
Comment on this
I do not propose the Senator's proposed amendment which would have the effect of excluding those connected with animal welfare from being appointed as authorised persons. It is important to remember that this provision continues the good practice provided in section 15 of the 1986 Control of Dogs Act whereby a local authority may enter into an arrangement with persons connected with animal welfare. This provision has been helpful to local authorities and has been implemented responsibly. For this reason, the continuation of the provisions of section 16 should not give rise to concern.
I restate the provisions in the 1986 Control of Dogs Act. Under section 15(3) of the Act, "a local authority may enter into arrangements with any other local authority, or with the Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or, with the consent of the Minister, with a person connected with animal welfare, for the exercise of all or any of its functions". This provision has enabled the proper functioning of the Control of Dogs Act and allowed local authorities to enlist the assistance of expert advice and assistance in their duties. I am not aware of any instances in this jurisdiction where the activities of any person used by local authorities have been successfully challenged or of any cases of abuse or misuse of the position. I am somewhat concerned, therefore, as to the reason there is such opposition to the extension of a practice that has been in place since 1986.
Senators have raised the fears expressed to them that extreme animal rights activists would inveigle themselves into being appointed as authorised officers and this would enable them to invade dog breeding establishments. This scenario is somewhat fanciful. Local authorities are well aware of the responsibilities attendant on the appointment of an authorised officer under the Bill and are likely to be careful in respect of those persons they appoint.
It should be a matter of reassurance to Senators that the provisions in the Bill have been in place in a similar form since 1986. The dog statistics compiled annually in the Department indicate that over the years, approximately half of local authorities have subcontracted significant elements of the dog control functions to animal welfare organisations, generally the Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. That so many local authorities have built up a long-term relationship should reassure Senators that they will only act responsibly in appointing authorised officers and that such authorised officers will act responsibly in the performance of their duties.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his response. The amendment is a genuine attempt to provide a clear definition of the term "authorised person". To clarify the matter for Senator Ó Brolcháin, a local authority official can be a veterinary official of that authority, accountable to that authority and fully responsible. A departmental veterinary official is already accountable to the Minister and Department for which he or she works.
The wording of the Bill is too vague. It states that an authorised person can be a person connected with animal welfare under section 15 of the 1986 Act. However, as other Senators noted, following consultation with the local authority, a member of a voluntary charitable organisation may be appointed as an authorised person. I reiterate that the majority of such organisations do great work which I admire but there is a significant risk that they will be infiltrated by any Tom, Dick or Harry given that any person may be appointed an inspector under the terms of the Bill. Such a scenario would pose a major threat to the well-established dog breeding industry.
I do not have a problem with proper scrutiny of puppy breeding establishments and the introduction of appropriate standards. The rogues who have given the industry a bad name should be rooted out. While the Fine Gael Party supports these objectives, the Bill, as drafted, proposes to give enormous powers to people about whose background and qualifications it does not provide clarity. The amendment provides a clear definition of an authorised person in requiring that he or she be a local authority official or a veterinary officer of the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. The latter already visit farms as part of their daily work. Rather than placing an additional burden on the Exchequer by appointing additional officials, as proposed in the Bill, to enter farms and places where dogs are bred, the amendment would ensure this function is captured under the inspections carried out by departmental veterinary officials. It is a reasonable amendment which attempts to introduce clarity, objectivity and fairness, all of which are important in due process and law. I am addressing real concerns about the industry. I have stated there are people involved in animal welfare organisations who have a dubious track record with regard to animal liberation and pose a threat to individuals legitimately involved in country sports, including hunting and greyhound racing. Those involved in these rural pursuits are not breaking any law; they are only doing what previous generations did. They are concerned that the Bill will affect the viability of these pursuits, in the process threatening their existence. I can appreciate their concerns, which is why we have tabled amendments to protect an indigenous industry that dates back many generations.
Comment on this
A couple of points were raised, to which I have not yet responded, including the matter of consultation. In response to a notice placed in the national press, the working group received 27 submissions from a variety of animal welfare and veterinary bodies, local authorities and private individuals. A total of 652 submissions were received by my Department following the release of the report of the working group, most of which were in favour of regulation to some degree.
On the point concerning costs and whether local authorities will be in a position to meet the financial demands, Senators will be aware that the legislation provides for a charge on dog breeding establishments, which runs from €400 for an establishment with more than 12 bitches and up to €3,000 for those with 200 bitches. There will be an income stream to local authorities which have such breeding establishments in their catchment areas.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has mentioned an income stream for local authorities. On Second Stage, former Senator Déirdre de Búrca said that, even with the proposed charges, local authorities would have a shortfall in excess of €1.6 million. I do not know how these two items can be married because, while the Minister of State is saying there will be an income stream, there will still be a shortfall. There are double standards; the right hand does not seem to know what the left hand is doing. The former Green Party Senator told us that there would be a deficit of €1.6 million, but the Minister of State says there will be an income stream, as if extra moneys will come in to the local authorities and there will not be a shortfall. We are at sixes and sevens.
Comment on this
In the context of the Minister of State's reply to my question about the cost of enforcement, I wish to quote an example. In the response to a parliamentary question Deputy Varadkar was told that the revenue accruing from the sale of dog licences in 2007 was €2.9 million, while the cost of delivering the local authority dog control service was €5.4 million. Therefore, as Senator Cummins said, there will be a shortfall. What will happen when that occurs? A local authority will arrive at a point where it will not be able——
Comment on this
That point concerns the section more than the amendment. I will let the Senator contribute on the section later.
Comment on this
I was replying to the Minister of State. However, I respect the Chair's ruling and will wait until we reach the section, if he so wishes.
Comment on this
I have one observation to make on the amendment. Given that there is a punitive dimension to the Bill with significant fines for non-adherence to its provisions, surely inspectors will have a quasi-judicial function. Since they will have to be objectively independent, a court case is possible in this regard. It does not add up. I hope the Minister of State will respond to this point.
Comment on this
On the funding of authorised inspectors and the cost implications of the Bill——
Comment on this
The amendment concerns how authorised persons will be resourced, either by the local authority or the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. The Fine Gael amendment clearly refers to staff already employed in either of these agencies. Departmental inspectors are already visiting farms; therefore, it is a matter of restructuring the system to allow for inspections of puppy farms. I am suspicious and concerned that the greyhound industry and other sectors are being used to fund this inspection regime, when, in fact, they are already being inspected and pay licence and registration fees. I am concerned that the reason the greyhound industry is included in this legislation is it is seen as a mechanism to fund the inspection regime under the Bill. I certainly hope that is not the case, but perhaps the Minister of State can clarify the matter.
Comment on this
The annual charge applies to a dog breeding establishment. That is what it involves.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Senator Ó Brolcháin mentioned the appointment of staff as authorised persons by local authority members. I do not think members of local authorities have appointed any staff to local authorities since the time of rate collectors, or at least since the time of sheep dipping committees when sheep dipping inspectors were appointed.
Section 16(2) mentions "[a] body with which a local authority has entered into an arrangement under section 15(3) of the Act of 1986". How does the Minister see this working? Will the people appointed be full-time members of local authorities, or will they be appointed on an agency basis? The Minister said when he was here that this would be self-financing in view of the extra fees that would be charged, including two fees charged to the Irish Greyhound Board along with two inspections. Does the Minister see these authorised persons being appointed on a part-time basis, or will they be full-time employees? Who will they be reporting to? Will they report to the chief veterinary officer of the local authority? This is an important point.
The Minister mentioned some agencies from which people could be appointed, such as the ISPCA. Could the Irish Greyhound Board or the coursing clubs, for example, propose people for appointment as inspectors? Senators Coffey, O'Reilly and others mentioned an important point with regard to the independence of the inspectors. All local authorities currently use their own staff, such as veterinary officers, to inspect abattoirs and so on. These people are truly independent and they should be the ones who conduct inspections. I cannot go along with the appointment of inspectors from vested interests by the local authority, whether on a full-time or part-time basis. The regulations accompanying this section should state that the full-time staff of the local authority from the veterinary section will be the authorised persons to carry out such inspections on farms.
This is important in view of what could happen further down the road. The greyhound industry in particular represents off-farm income for many farmers. There is an issue with regard to the spread of animal diseases among pigs, poultry and other farm enterprises. Diseases such as brucellosis could be carried from farm to farm. It is important the chief veterinary officer of the local authority is really in charge and that the people employed as inspectors are full-time employees of the local authority. No representatives of vested interests, whether from the ISPCA or the greyhound or coursing industries, should be carrying out inspections. The veterinary officers in my local authority area, whose work I have observed over a long period, have always been truly independent. That is the way it should be.
Comment on this
The point made by Senator Burke about the spread of diseases is of importance. Proper practice should be observed in this regard.
I will not labour the point, but I would like a response from the Minister about the possibility of a challenge to the legislation. I genuinely fear a challenge on the basis that people with a vested interest cannot act as objective inspectors. I fear that the appointment of a person from an animal rights group could be open to challenge, given that there are significant fines involved.
Comment on this
I endorse the comments of the previous two speakers. I would prefer the inspectors to be staff of the local authority, who know the area. They are professionals. We have all worked with local authorities and we know their veterinary departments. These are the professionals who should be vetting anything to do with animal welfare. No outsiders should be brought in. It should be left to the local authority; they have control and they know the area.
Comment on this
I ask those who have spoken on this Stage and earlier Stages of the debate to replace the word "dogs" with "children" and then make the same arguments. They would then be arguing that organisations such as the Irish Society for the Protection of Cruelty to Children or Barnardo's should not be concerned about children's welfare in sports, for example, unless organisations such as the Athletic Association of Ireland and Swim Ireland are also involved, because they are sporting bodies that also deal with children. It is nonsense.
Comment on this
They are not in opposition to the businesses they are inspecting.
Comment on this
The tired, trite arguments we are hearing this evening are utter nonsense.
Comment on this
They have some opposition to the businesses they are inspecting.
Comment on this
Sporting organisations are sporting organisations.
Comment on this
It is a different matter altogether.
Comment on this
Welfare organisations are welfare organisations.
Comment on this
This section and the previous section——
Comment on this
Is the Senator saying local authorities are not independent?
Comment on this
——merely confirm what is already in legislation under the Control of Dogs Act 1986. The Dublin Society for the Protection of Cruelty to Animals is already designated by Dublin local authorities. The ISPCA is designated by several local authorities. The Cork Society for the Protection of Cruelty to Animals is already designated by Cork City Council. This is standard practice.
Comment on this
All the Opposition Members are doing is scaremongering. They are trying to pretend that what has already worked in the past cannot work in the future. They should cop on to themselves.
Comment on this
The Senator should cop on to himself.
Comment on this
Is the Senator outlining what proper practice is?
Comment on this
Proper practice already exists under the 1986 Act.
Comment on this
On a point of information, surely any inspector should not be a representative of a vested interest——
Comment on this
Standard practice exists under the 1986 Act. It has existed for 24 years. Local authorities have delegated the function to people from animal welfare organisations — not animal rights organisations, not people with forms in their hands.
Comment on this
We are talking about registration and everything.
Comment on this
They are people who have the welfare of animals at heart——
Comment on this
——people whom the local authority believe have the capacity, the experience and the ability to do this work.
Comment on this
The ISPCA wants to close down the greyhound industry.
Comment on this
It wants to close down the industry.
Comment on this
They want to close down the industry.
Comment on this
If any of the Senators have a difficulty with how this is already being practised at local authority level, maybe they should have their party members table motions to that effect in the councils controlled by their party.
Comment on this
The councils give such organisations these very responsibilities. Stop the hypocrisy and time wasting——
Comment on this
The Green Party certainly is not on any of the councils.
Comment on this
The Green Party is not in the councils and it will not be.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Senator is not more concerned about the people of Cork.
Comment on this
The Government is not minding the welfare.
Comment on this
The first person mentioned in section 16 is a veterinary practitioner and there is a follow-on from that. That has been the experience to date in local authorities.
To respond to the question that there may be a challenge, I said earlier that I am not aware of any instance in this jurisdiction where the activities of any person used by local authorities has been successfully challenged or where there has been any case of abuse or misuse of the position. That is after almost a quarter of a century during which the legislation has been place. It has been effectively implemented by the local authority system.
Senator Burke raised the matter of staff. Different local authorities would have different levels of activity in dog breeding in their jurisdictions and catchment areas. Some have very limited dog breeding establishments and some may have a large number. It will be a matter for local authorities to establish the level of activity in the area and the appropriate response. It may be a part-time position in some areas and it may involve an existing officer dealing with dog welfare. A vet or an authorised officer may also be appointed on a part-time or full-time basis. It will be a matter for the local authority to establish the need to respond to the level of activity in the catchment.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. We are told the costs will be neutral to the Exchequer but will the Minister of State clarify that to the House? I quoted an example earlier relating to dog licences, where €2.9 million was raised in 2007 with a cost of operation at €5.4 million. Will the Minister of State outline to the House the cost of this and who will incur that cost?
I will revert to my earlier fundamental point despite protests from the Members opposite. What happens where a local authority may not be able to provide the service as outlined? I am concerned on a number of levels about the cost. I do not mean to pre-empt the Minister of State's reply but he has the potential to ask the greyhound owners, trainers and breeders to foot the bill for this. Is that the intention? What will the cost be and will there be an annual licence fee increase? What difficulties does the Minister of State see in the administration of the scheme and could there be a case where there will be a loss of revenue to the local authority?
I would like to see the cost structure being properly outlined and explained. There must be proportionality in the process. I appreciate that the fees cannot all be outlined in the Bill but will they be reasonable relative to the costs for the industry? The Minister of State should respond to the issue as there are significant implications for the industry.
Lest the Members opposite forget after Senator Boyle's monologue——
Comment on this
I was not commenting on him at all. I said it was a monologue.
Comment on this
It is a pity he was not more concerned about people losing their jobs.
Comment on this
It was slightly longer than a tweet.
Comment on this
I am on section 16 and I will not digress. The Members opposite might cop on to themselves. I would like to put the question to the Members opposite——
Comment on this
Are you concerned about 11,000 jobs being lost?
Comment on this
Are you happy to see those jobs lost?
Comment on this
Senator Buttimer should not address the Members directly. He should speak to section 16 and the Minister of State will reply.
Comment on this
I understand that and thank the Cathaoirleach. Is there any concern in the Government that we will lose 11,000 jobs?
Comment on this
There are enough myths around the place without Senator Feeney adding to them.
Comment on this
They are myths. The Senator is scaremongering.
Comment on this
We are speaking to the section of the Dog Breeding Establishments Bill and we should stick with it.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Perhaps the Minister of State in his reply will address the fundamental issues that have been asked and I hope we will not get a typical response from the Department that fails to outline the reality. There is potential to endanger jobs and lose employment. The balance of trade, with €35 million in exports, could be affected along with the benefits that the industry brings to the nation.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for clarification on the section. He stated that it is up to each local authority, when they have gauged the number of people who have registered, to decide on the appointments with the veterinary surgeon. It can go down the other route of employing a body like the ISPCA and entering into a contract. That body may be better organised on the ground and the local authority could contract it to work on its behalf. That is my reading of what is in the Bill and what the Minister of State has said. There are two routes the local authority can travel; it can do it on its own or employ a body like the ISPCA.
Once it goes down the route of employing a body and entering into a contract, will the body report annually to the local authority? Will the body charge a fee to the local authority? How does the cost work out where the local authority farms out the work to a body like the ISPCA?
Comment on this
Will the local authority retain control even if it delegates responsibility? Will the body used report to the vet of the local authority or to the senior personnel? That is a very important issue.
Comment on this
There were a couple of points. There is an opportunity for the local authority to second or contract the services of a body. That is the position in many local authorities currently under the Control of Dogs Act and some of these were outlined by Senator Boyle. That is an existing practice.
With regard to involvement of the local authority, it is worth mentioning that there has been no challenge in this jurisdiction under the legislation I mentioned, which has been in use for almost a quarter of a century. There has been no case of abuse or misuse of a position. There is a good track record from people who have been employed by the local authority under the Control of Dogs Act. This legislation concerns the welfare of dogs, although many other issues have been brought into the debate.
I outlined the fees earlier and they are contained in legislation. It would require a change in legislation to alter the fees. Where 12 bitches are kept, the fees are up to €400. For more than 200 bitches, the figure is €3,000.
We expect that the new system in respect of dog breeding establishments will be cost neutral to the Exchequer. The provisions relating to increasing dog licence fees will only reduce the losses local authorities incur at present in the context of providing dog control services. The new charges for licence fees will raise an estimated €4.3 million. This compares with a figure of €2.8 million in 2008. The cost of the service in that year was €5.7 million. Local authorities are currently meeting their responsibilities under the legislation relating to the control of dogs from within existing resources.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 16, subsection (1), between lines 20 and 21, to insert the following:
"(a) remove without warrant any animal from premises which he or she has reasonable grounds for believing are being used for the operation of a dog breeding establishment, if he or she has reasonable grounds for believing that such removal is necessary for the protection of the welfare of such animal,”.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment. Section 19 provides for a closure notice to be served on an establishment if there is a serious or immediate threat to public health or animal welfare. Section 19(2)(b) enables a local authority to require an operator to rehouse all dogs. In addition, it provides that such removal be at the operator’s expense. Non-compliance shall be an offence. The proposed amendment makes no reference to who will pay for the removal and, therefore, it would likely fall to the local authority to absorb the costs. I am also wary of pre-empting the provisions of the animal welfare Bill which is being prepared by the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 17, subsection (2), line 29, to delete "as he or she considers appropriate." and substitute the following:
"or such other persons as may be necessary for the purpose of assisting the authorised person in the exercise of his or her functions under this section and the authorised person, member or any such other person may take with them into the premises such equipment as they consider to be necessary.".
This amendment would alter section 17(2) in order that it would read:
When performing a function under this Act, an authorised person may, subject to any warrant under subsection (4), be accompanied by such . . . members of the Garda Síochána or such other persons as may be necessary for the purpose of assisting the authorised person in the exercise of his or her functions under this section and the authorised person, member or any such other person may take with them into the premises such equipment as they consider to be necessary.
There are two aspects to the amendment. The first is the idea that once an authorised person is entering a premises, he or she might be accompanied by certain other individuals who might be necessary for assisting him or her in the job he or she is obliged to do. The second aspect is that the authorised person and those accompanying him or her should be allowed to bring onto such premises any equipment that is deemed to be necessary.
I listened with great interest to colleagues' impassioned contributions on the subject of authorised persons and bodies with which local authorities might enter into arrangements which might, in turn, nominate authorised persons. It is clear that there is a long-established practice of involving third parties or agencies with a track record in the field of animal welfare. What is important is that we should not involve those with a negative agenda of a generalised and prejudicial kind in respect of the establishments or owners thereof which they are supposed to be inspecting or visiting. Once a local authority has responsibility for nominating authorised persons of a particular status and as long as there must be an authorised person on the premises, the necessary protections are in place. If an issue were ever to arise in that regard, the Minister and the Houses would have the capacity to deal with any mischief that might arise.
Once an authorised person is going onto a premises, he or she must be in a position to do his or her job. To fulfil his or her duties, an authorised person might be obliged to bring cutting equipment, for example, onto a premises. If the legislation is to have any meaning or efficacy, then provision should be made in respect of the possible scenario to which I refer. An authorised person might also be obliged to bring with him or her individuals who would be technically deemed not to be authorised. In that context, would veterinarians not employed by the Department or a local authority, those employed by the emergency services or whomever be considered, in technical terms, as being unauthorised?
This is a reasonable amendment, particularly in light of the fact that anything which occurs on a premises would take place under the watch and in the presence of an authorised person. On that basis, I hope the Minister of State will accept it.
Comment on this
The proposed amendment is unnecessary as section 17(2) does not limit the number of other authorised persons that can accompany an authorised officer in performing his or her functions. Furthermore, the legal advice is that it is not necessary that it be stipulated in the section that such persons may take equipment with them. I do not, therefore, propose to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Will the Senators claiming a division please rise?
Senators Rónán Mullen and Joe O'Toole rose.
Comment on this
As fewer than five Members have risen, I declare the question carried. In accordance with Standing Order 70, the names of the Senators dissenting will be recorded in the Journal of Proceedings of the Seanad.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 19, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following subsection:
"(7) A person who fails to comply with an improvement notice or a direction of the District Court under this section shall be guilty of an offence.".
I am hopeful of a much better turnout in support of this amendment. It seems, as a matter of public policy, that a responsible political party, particularly one which has the luxury of supporting such amendments from the Opposition, must support an amendment that would simply have the effect of promoting respect for a decision of the District Court and an order for improvement.
Section 18 establishes the procedure for improvement notices but fails to establish any offence for failing to comply with such a notice. The implied threat may be that failure to comply will result in a closure notice but that may be seen as draconian in the specific circumstances. Therefore, such a closure notice might be revoked on appeal. Therefore, it seems that, for this legislation to have proper effect and be properly applicable, it would be more effective if there was an equivalent of what we find in section 19(2)(e) which states a closure notice may contain the statement, “If the operator of the dog breeding establishment concerned contravenes the closure notice, he or she shall be guilty of an offence”. Section 19(7) provides that a “person who contravenes a closure notice or a direction of the District Court under this section shall be guilty of an offence”.
Sauce for the greyhound is surely sauce for the pup. I would have thought that, if it was appropriate to include such a provision in section 19, it was also appropriate to include it in section 18. Why is it that a person who fails to comply with an improvement notice or a direction of the District Court will not be guilty of an offence but that a person who fails to comply with a closure notice or a direction of the District Court in that regard will be? In view of the need for consistency, apart from anything else, the amendment cannot be rejected. Surely those who have difficulties with aspects of the Bill and what it requires by way of a regulatory inspection regime cannot have a difficulty with the rule of law, a decision of the District Court or a requirement that people comply with whatever orders are made. I propose the amendment on that basis and I will ask for a vote on it.
Comment on this
I am trying to generate support for Senator Mullen. His request seems reasonable and would ensure consistency throughout the Bill. I am interested to hear the response of the Minister because I do not see how he can argue against what Senator Mullen is seeking, namely, compliance with the law. I leave it to the Minister.
Comment on this
I am afraid the tail will not wag the dog on this side of the House. We cannot support the amendment.
Comment on this
The effect of the proposed amendment, while well intentioned, might be too draconian. The Bill has been carefully drafted to provide for an escalation of measures. It is not envisaged at this point that non-compliance with an improvement notice would constitute an offence. Rather, it would be a matter for the local authority to move towards enforcement of the notice by making an application to the District Court to have the establishment removed from the register under section 18(d). It is thought that the threat of removal from the register would have the desired effect on the operator.
It is my intention that local authorities would build a relationship with dog breeding establishments operating in their functional areas to ensure implementation of appropriate welfare standards. We must allow breeding establishments the space to implement the measures outlined in the improvement notice. Section 18(2)(c) provides for a stated period in which the improvement notice must be implemented. The notice can be appealed to the District Court within seven days of serving the notice. If the notice is ignored, the local authority can progress to a closure notice under section 19. A person who contravenes a closure notice will be guilty of an offence. Therefore, I do not propose to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I am disappointed with the Minister's response and although I like some of the people involved I am likewise disappointed with the response of the main Opposition party. It seems to be bad public policy to deliberately turn down an amendment that would have the effect of providing that a failure to comply with an order of the District Court would be an offence. As the Minister said on section 18 and the improvement notice, it is not just a matter of what an authorised officer may decide, it is a matter that may end up before the District Court in the event of the improvement notice being appealed to the District Court and the District Court might make an order in favour of what the authorised officer decided.
I have great difficulty with the decision to not provide that it would be an offence to fail to comply with the order. What seems to be happening reminds me of the famous phrase from scripture that the meek shall inherit the earth, but the Government's approach in this case is "the meek shall inherit the earth if that is alright with you fellows". The Government does not seem to have the courage of its convictions on the Bill if it does not require that in the event of non-compliance with an improvement notice a person would be guilty of an offence and that a District Court order should be required. On that basis I regret that the Minister will not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
An improvement notice is issued by a local authority. A balance has been struck. A dog breeding establishment can appeal the decision to the District Court. Then there is the threat of removal from the register. It is intended that each local authority would build up a relationship with dog breeding associations. In most cases they are responsible bodies. The ultimate sanction of the court order is available. The amendment is too draconian and what is in the Bill is more balanced.
Comment on this
Does the Minister believe that a person who fails to comply with an order of the District Court should not face any sanction by way of being guilty of an offence? Does he consider it acceptable that a person would fail to comply with an order of the District Court?
Comment on this
It is not an order of the District Court, it is an order of the local authority.
Comment on this
It may become an order of the District Court if the matter is appealed to the District Court. Does the Minister not think that if the District Court upholds the improvement notice the person should face sanction from the law if he or she fails to comply?
Comment on this
The improvement notice is a notice from the local authority, it is not a notice from the District Court. At that stage no decision of the District Court has been taken.
Comment on this
An issue has arisen that the Minister——
Comment on this
I seek further clarification on this point. It is clear from the legislation that two scenarios could arise; I propose that failure to comply with an improvement notice would be an offence. The legislation provides that the person may appeal the improvement notice to the District Court. The implication is that the District Court, as is clearly laid out in the legislation, may affirm or revoke the notice. The legislation as drafted does not provide in this section that where the District Court makes a decision on the improvement notice that has been the subject of an appeal that it would be an offence at that point to fail to comply with an order.
I will happily withdraw the amendment if the Minister gives me a commitment that he will either bring forward or accept an adjusted amendment, which would at least require that it would be an offence if a person fails to comply with an order of the District Court on an improvement notice. I accept there is a distinction between a failure to comply with an improvement notice order from a local authority or from an authorised officer. If you will pardon me mixing my animal metaphors, a Leas-Chathaoirleach, it is a horse of a different colour to suggest that it would not be an offence for a person to fail to comply with an order of the District Court.
Comment on this
I appreciate the point being made by the Senator but I do not wish to see failure to comply with an improvement notice turned into an offence. It is not an offence. The information I have outlined has been provided by the Parliamentary Counsel but I will ask them to have a second look at it.