We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Savita Halappanavar inquiry

Summary

Senators urge restraint over the Galway tragedy, support awaiting the expert and hospital reports, and stress the need for fair treatment of medical professionals.

I compliment the Minister for Health on the measured manner in which he responded to questions on the tragic death of a young woman in a Galway hospital. He cautioned us all to be temperate and sensitive in our comments at this time. Anybody with an ounce of humanity would take on board his advice. He said that he was privy to certain information that he was not privileged, at this stage, to divulge. He also said that he doubted that there was a question of religious ethos involved in the decisions taken. He further stated, which I thought was significant and we should listen to him, that the medical staff at the hospital are entitled to due process. Two investigations will take place and we should not try, in the absence of all of the information and based on the privilege that we have, to in some way influence the outcome.

I wish to comment on a separate and important issue, with the indulgence of the Chathaoirleach. The Palestinian people are crying out for justice.

During the 12 months leading up to the American presidential election, their suffering went off the radar completely. Given the opportunity, small though it may be, we should speak out for justice for all people who suffer or are coerced. It is not acceptable that a nuclear power, with arms at its disposal can bully in the worst meaning of the word a small nation of people. This country has always taken a robust stand, and the Tánaiste and leaders did it in the past. When a body such as Trócaire that is working on the ground, has staff who are prepared to put their head above the parapet on behalf of those people, it is disingenuous to intimidate and silence them. That is not our history. We have never done that in the past and we should not silence them now.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Ó Murchú on both issues.

I ask people to be careful when speaking on the tragic issue in Galway. In regard to maternity services, the number of deliveries has increased from 54,000 to 74,000 per annum. Ireland has the lowest perinatal mortality rate and the lowest maternal mortality rate in Europe. In fairness to doctors and nurses, everyone is on tenterhooks with the direction of the public debate. We need to be fair to everyone in dealing with this issue. We must exercise caution. We should await the outcome of the inquiries rather than commenting in public on the way the issue is being dealt with. Doctors and nurses are very concerned about the way this matter is being dealt with in the public domain. Everyone in hospitals works very hard at all times to protect the patients under their care.

I visited Gaza four weeks after the attack in December 2008 and January 2009. I referred to it about six weeks ago in this House when I stated that once the American presidential election would be over, hostilities would increase. That is now coming home to roost. That is what happened in December 2008 and January 2009. We need to be more decisive. I agree with Trócaire on this issue. This matter has gone on unchallenged for too long. We will see an increase in hostilities again because of the forthcoming elections in Israel. We cannot afford to stand idly by. Gaza is an area of land similar to an area from Cork city to Youghal measuring ten miles wide by 35 miles long. Some 1.5 million people are locked in that land mass. That is how it has remained for a long number of years. The situation has remained unchallenged. We should not be afraid to say enough is enough. What is happening is not right and should not be tolerated.

Comment on this