Leader’s responses to Senators
The Cathaoirleach and Leader express condolences, while the Leader responds to requests concerning property tax, foreign aid, gender equality, cancer charges, the education college and the Congo.
Before I call the Leader I would like to be associated with the expressions of sympathy to the young innocent children in Connecticut and to their teachers who were slain.
I wish to be associated with the expressions of sympathy to the wife and family of the late Páidí Ó Sé who was a legend. His achievements should not be underestimated. I was at the receiving end of his might in the mid-1970s.
Comment on this
I join with the Cathaoirleach and Members of the House in expressing our sincere sympathy to all the families of the young children who were massacred in Connecticut. It was a dreadful thing to happen.
I also extend sincere sympathy to the family of the late Páidí Ó Sé, who has been a larger than life figure in the GAA over many a year.
Senator Darragh O'Brien raised the question of whether the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government consulted the county and city managers of local authorities. My information is that it did but the Senator will be able to elicit the information he requires when we debate the property tax later in the week. I am sure the Senator will get the answers to all the questions he posed this afternoon.
Senator Susan O'Keeffe welcomed the statement of the IMF. I am sure we welcome the statement on growth. Senator Mary Ann O'Brien among other Members spoke on foreign aid. Her contribution differed from that of almost all of her colleagues as she suggested we should cut our contribution. I read a newspaper report that another Member was supposed to raise a proposal that we would cut our aid by 75%. I think the suggested 75% cut is absolutely ludicrous. Our NGOs do tremendous work with foreign aid. I agree that we should have a debate on foreign aid.
I will arrange a debate early in the new year - probably in early February - with the Minister of State, Deputy Costello, on that matter. Senator Norris also raised the issue of foreign aid. He has fought for increases to overseas aid, as well as having more transparency. I also note his comments on the violence inherent in video games. It is certainly a problem not just in America but across the world. It is a matter we should look at in this House.
Comment on this
We can certainly do that. We can have a debate on foreign aid also.
Senator Keane called for a debate on closing the gender gap and the recent OECD report in this regard. Senator Kelly raised the matter of charges for cancer patients. It is a matter which should be addressed. I understand the charge referred to is not a new charge but has been in place for some time, although that is not to say it is correct. Senator Barrett raised the future of the Church of Ireland College of Education. The Senator could table this as an Adjournment matter and get a full response from the Minister for Education and Skills. Senator Mullins outlined the benefits of foreign aid, which I have already addressed.
Senator Cullinane called for more time on the Social Welfare Bill. I believe two and a half hours is more than sufficient for Second Stage. As the Leader of the Opposition stated, I insisted it was broken up and that we have separate days for Committee and Report Stages. Before, we would have taken Committee and Remaining Stages on the same day. Two and a half hours is more than sufficient for Second Stage and there will be ample time on Committee and Report Stages to tease out problems in the Bill. I do not propose to accept the amendment to the Order of Business in this regard. When we had a debate on the report of the expert group on the A, B and C judgment several weeks ago, I was told we would need four days of debate on the subject, but it did not even last the two and a half hours allotted to it. We want to be careful what we are asking for as it might be granted.
Senator Hayden raised the plight of residents in Priory Hall. I will ask the Minister of State, Deputy Jan O'Sullivan, to come to the House to give us an update on the resolution of this matter. Senator O'Donovan raised the matter of the report of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee on older people, which recommended resolving the problem that arises due to the anomaly of the habitual residency clause. The Senator should raise this matter with the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Burton, on the Social Welfare Bill. It is an anomaly that should be plugged and, hopefully, this can be done in the Social Welfare Bill.
Senator Comiskey welcomed the announcement by the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government of grants for the upgrading of septic tanks. I remember the long debate we had over several days about the septic tank legislation. The Minister said at the time he would probably introduce a grant scheme for remediation but only until the registration process was completed. He has done it now but he is still castigated for it.