Seanad abolition process
Senator Ó Murchú supports extending debate on the abolition Bill, arguing that the proposal was introduced without consultation or a replacement plan and that limiting Senators’ contributions is anti-democratic.
I second Senator Cullinane's motion on the amendment to the Order of Business. We should not be so docile about the issue. Even if fingers were pointed at us accusing us of being only interested in our own positions, I still think that the methodology for the abolition of the Seanad is not correct. First, it was dropped like a bombshell and without consultation in the middle of a general election campaign. Second, it is clear that there is no plan to replace the Seanad in terms of scrutinising what happens in the Dáil or initiating legislation in the Seanad. No plan has been put forward.
It is evident that the media, at long last, are engaging on the issue. They have begun to realise that to get rid of a House of Parliament in the crude manner suggested is unacceptable.
Comment on this
Surely it should have been necessary to publish a White or Green Paper that set out the various pros and cons, have a debate and then allow the Government to make a decision. Let us consider the debate that has taken place in the media on the matter and the suggestion not to give each Senator an opportunity to make a contribution. The suggestion is virtually anti-democratic and is unacceptable. We should ask for more time.
I wish to discuss another matter. All of the recent polls show people have a growing disillusionment with politicians and politics. There is no doubt about that. We will add insult to injury if we posture about a bank inquiry, have a point scoring operation or adopt a cosmetic approach. We are right in being critical of the bank chiefs, particularly having listened to the tapes in recent days. If we do exactly the same and are not serious, focused and committed to a proper inquiry the public will not forgive us. It would add insult to injury to all of those people who suffer day in and day out as a result of the bank crisis, which is one of the most corrosive events in the history of the State. I appeal for urgency and request that we avoid gaining political party kudos. We must avoid all of that.
Comment on this
We are approaching the precipice on this issue. If we go over the precipice then politics and democracy will suffer.