Leader’s replies to Members
The Leader responds to Members’ requests on youth unemployment, mortgage arrears, wind farms, banking regulation, HSE absenteeism, aviation and tourism, confirming or supporting several proposed debates and initiatives.
The acting Leader of the Opposition, Senator Marc MacSharry, raised the question of youth unemployment and mentioned the visit of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Joan Burton, to Strasbourg today. It is very important that we get our share of the funding voted through by the European Parliament. The matter was raised by Senator Diarmuid Wilson and others and we all wish the Taoiseach and the Minister well in their deliberations and negotiations on the funding to tackle youth unemployment.
On the issue of mortgage arrears, this is a matter which has been raised by a number of Senators. On a number of occasions I have made a request for the relevant Minister to come to the House to discuss it, but I have not yet received a positive reaction from the Department. I will continue to seek the attendance of a Minister to discuss the issue, but all I can do is ask. I will do my best to push it again and arrange for a Minister to come to the House to discuss the issues of the code of conduct, banking and mortgage arrears, as requested by a number of Senators.
Senators Ivana Bacik, David Norris, Catherine Noone and the Cathaoirleach have all expressed good wishes to Emily O'Reilly on becoming European Ombudsman. We all wish her every success in her new position.
I note the points made by Senator David Norris on the whistleblower legislation. Yesterday the issue of asylum for Mr. Edward Snowden was raised. The position is that asylum applications are not generally accepted from persons resident or present in other countries as our refugee status determination process is based on applications for asylum being made within the Irish jurisdiction. Asylum applications made at Irish embassies abroad are not accepted. Therefore, I do not propose to accept the amendment to the Order of Business proposed by the Senator.
The Senator also mentioned the report of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Transport and Communications on the issue of alcohol sponsorship. This matter has been raised by a number of Senators. The Minister of State, Deputy Alex White, indicated he would come to the House when the committee's report was published and I am sure we can arrange a debate on the issue soon.
Senator Michael Mullins raised an issue which has been submitted as an Adjournment matter regarding the use of sunbeds and the need for legislation. Senator John Crown has also raised this matter. Perhaps after the Adjournment debate we might know more about what the Government intends to do in that regard and might then address the matter.
Senator Mary M. White proposed an amendment to the Order of Business to allow her Bill on parental leave to be published. I have no problem in that regard and will agree to her amendment to the Order of Business.
Senator Cáit Keane raised the issue of the national mapping of broadband and the identification of black spots. This is a matter Senator Ned O'Sullivan raised in connection to mobile phones. There is certainly a need to act on and address this issue. If necessary, we will ask for the relevant Minister to come to the House to update us on it.
Senator David Cullinane referred to the HSE's report on neglected children. This issue was raised by a number of Senators yesterday when I responded on it. The Government is acutely aware of the neglect for decades of Irish children and has sought to take real action to address the serious inadequacies in the care system. It is only an initial report. It is on phase one of the audit and there is a lot more to be done in that regard. Everybody must realise the Government is very serious about the matter. A new model for family based multi-agency assessment and early intervention has already been trialled in two regions and is being mainstreamed in the establishment of the new child and family agency. Last summer, after the report was completed, HIQA published inspection standards for the HSE's child welfare and protection services.
The Children First guidelines have been updated and it is intended to make them statutory. The referendum on children was passed. These are positive actions in the area, but we must continue to be vigilant where the care of children is concerned. I note Senator Cullinane's points. Senator Harte asked for a debate on the future of retail banking in rural Ireland in particular. I have requested the Minister for Finance to come to the House to debate that issue. A debate on the post office network will be held tomorrow and some of the issues can be discussed then. Senator Leyden asked for a debate on volunteerism. We had that debate previously but I will see what can be arranged. He lauded Castlecoote on its success, as did Senator Kelly, who also referred to tourism in Roscommon. Many Senators praised their own towns, and rightly so. Some of them will probably be auditioning for jobs in Fáilte Ireland if anything should ever happen to the Seanad.
Comment on this
Tip O'Neill said that all politics is local.
Comment on this
Of course.
Senator Comiskey spoke about the advantages and disadvantages of wind farms. He highlighted the benefits for local communities in his area, where more than 100 jobs have been created. Senator Barrett asked for a debate on bank regulation or the lack of it. He referred to the position of officials in the Department of Finance and the need for a change in attitudes. I listened to last night's debate. I agree that some of the amendments proposed by Senator Barrett, particularly that which proposed to replace "may" with "shall", should have been accepted. However, that is a decision for the Government. I note Senator Barrett's point. I do not propose to accept Senator Ó Domhnaill's amendment to the Order of Business. He tabled a matter on the Adjournment and perhaps he may need to table a further matter if the response was not satisfactory.
Senator Paul Coghlan called for the chairmen and chief executive officers of the non-Irish-owned banks to be brought before the finance committee. I am sure the committee will arrange such a meeting. I agree with Senator Coghlan that banks must suffer some of the pain that mortgage holders and people in arrears are suffering and that banks should be brought to book at the finance committee. Senator Quinn made an excellent suggestion about the defibrillator Bill and transition year students being taught how to use defibrillators. I will bring that matter to the attention of the Minister for Education and Skills.
The question of presumed consent for organ donation was raised in the House by Senator Quinn. This has been lying to one side for a number of years. Similar legislation has been passed in Wales this week. I have inquired of the Department its intentions with regard to such legislation. I will revert to the Senator when I know when the Department intends to publish legislation. Senator Landy spoke about the pre-budget submission from the Carers' Association. I agree with Senator Landy that we should all praise the excellent work of carers all over the country. Senator Ó Clochartaigh spoke on pre-budget submissions to the Department of Social Protection. The Minister for Social Protection has agreed to come to the House when we return in September. Senator Conway praised Aer Lingus on its winter and summer services from Shannon to Chicago and New York. This is welcomed by everyone in the mid-west in particular.
There has been negative publicity in some countries as a result of the Anglo Irish Bank tapes debacle, which I am confident the Government is attempting to redress. Senator Wilson asked for a debate on youth unemployment and the €6 billion fund. Experts have said there is a need for €25 billion. In my view, €6 billion is a good start and perhaps that sum can be increased in the future. Senator Hayden called for a debate on banking. I have addressed that matter. I have asked the Minister to come to the House but I have not received a positive response in that regard. She also called for a debate on maternity services. I will ask the Minister for Health to come to the House for a debate on that subject. In reply to Senator Mullen, I have stated on many occasions that ample time for debate will be afforded to the House. As with the arrangements for the Seanad referendum Bill, I propose that ten minutes be allocated to every Senator on Second Stage and that ample time be afforded on Committee and Report Stages. I hope the debate will be conducted in a very dignified manner and that points will be made once and not rehashed a hundred times. I hope we will not have a filibuster on the Bill. I can assure the House that adequate time will be afforded to all Members to make their points. I hope that making a point once will be sufficient for everyone.
Comment on this
Ten minutes would not be ample on Second Stage.
Comment on this
That is what I am proposing and that is what will be happening.
Senator Burke asked for a debate on the level of absenteeism in the HSE and the need, if necessary, for a change in work practices. Senator Daly welcomed the news that Aer Lingus proposes to resume flights to San Francisco. This is a very important proposal. The matter was raised at the Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade. Everyone wanted this to happen and it is welcome. Senator Noone referred to the positive CSO figures on tourism and the importance of the film industry and other initiatives. These demonstrate the importance of niche activities that the Senator mentioned as being important for the tourism industry. Senator Crown referred to the death of Dermot Clarke. I extend the sympathies of the House to his family.