Committee proportionality and party allowances
Senator Bradford seeks debate on committee proportionality and the legality of retaining party allowances for members removed from their parties, suggesting unused funds should return to taxpayers.
My head is a little swollen with all the words of praise I am receiving from my friends on the opposite side of the House. I am sure they are very well meant. Senator Leyden is suggesting a trip to the High Court. We will get free legal advice from Senator Coghlan. That would be much more appropriate.
On a serious matter, I missed the commencement of the debate but I am familiar with the motion proposed. The personal side of this does not concern me in the slightest but I believe the issue of proportionality as it applies to Oireachtas committees is one that we cannot remove ourselves from. I understand the make-up of the committee system reflects the balance in the Oireachtas. Unfortunately, due to events beyond our control, the balance in the Seanad has now changed. It is not as simple as saying one can replace A with B. Therefore, I would like the Leader to inform us about the actual legal position on the requirement for proportionality.
Apart from the political musical chairs, on which we can debate and reflect, I want to bring to the Leader's attention a matter that I would like us to discuss, perhaps next week. Today would not be appropriate. I refer to the financial musical chairs arising from recent political events. Through no fault of individuals in most cases, ten Members of the Dáil and three Members of the Seanad have now left their political parties. As we know, the political parties receive a substantial sum from the taxpayer in respect of their Deputies and Senators. With ten Members of the Dáil and three Members of the Seanad having left their parties, voluntarily or otherwise, some €500,000 will be handed over to political parties for individuals who are no longer members. I would like us to reflect seriously on the appropriateness, or otherwise, of that next week. We all know about the need to save money. It was pointed out as part of the Seanad abolition campaign-----
Comment on this
It is a matter I would like to have discussed in the House next week. I am not sure of the legality of party allowances being retained for Members who are no longer in their parties. It is a serious matter. Half a million euro per annum is at stake based on current figures. We will need an adjudication on that. I would like to see the money returned to the taxpayer, if possible. If it is not being spent by a political party on a member for whom it is given, it should be returned to the taxpayer. I would like us to set aside time next week to discuss that. Half a million euro is not a small sum and it appears the parties are keeping the allowance. The money should not go to the individuals concerned but back to the Exchequer. I would like us to debate that next week and ascertain the legal position.