Personal attacks in referendum campaign
Senator O’Brien condemns alleged lies and personal attacks by the Fine Gael press office against Senators Quinn and Crown, arguing for fairer political debate.
I do not include my colleagues opposite in this. We have a situation where genuine lies and mistruths have been told and been proven to be incorrect, where a major Government party with a 58-seat majority in the other House is able to continue to put out untruths about costs and apparent savings and where the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation says he will write a cheque for €20 million in 2016 and hand it to the Irish people. I have never heard such nonsense. All any of us have asked for, and we can disagree on any item because that is what democracy and politics are about, is fairness and truth. This campaign has been depressing. What I also found depressing was the reporting of attendance here over the year.
Comment on this
The people in the media know that in operating a Chamber like this one and the Lower House, official pairing arrangements operate. People can be sick or away on Government business but none of that was taken into account. I am sure the Leader will agree with my next point and I am not casting any aspersions on my colleagues opposite. What really disgusted me was a specific personalised attack on Senators Quinn and Crown.
Comment on this
It was despicable. I thank the Leader for his indulgence because this is an important point about the conduct of future campaigns. When one sees the Fine Gael press office issue statements personally attacking Senator Quinn who has done so much over the years and Senator Crown, a new Senator who has brought a new perspective, it is completely uncalled for. If anything, the idea of fewer politicians and saving this and that feeds the race to the bottom in politics. When the Government, its press office and a senior Minister, Deputy Bruton, act in this way, it leads me to question the respect I previously had for certain people.
I thank the Cathaoirleach for his indulgence. When we look at control, those of us advocating a "No" vote are talking about more oversight and ensuring that any Government, not just this one, is held to account in a proper way. We all agree with that. When one looks at the autocratic nature of certain Cabinet Ministers and this Taoiseach, one sees that the Government press office is able to tell RTE that it does not want any pictures of the Taoiseach at the All-Ireland final shown in case he gets an adverse reaction and is booed and he is blurred out of the picture. This is in the context of control. If this is allowed to happen, it is more akin to North Korea than the Republic of Ireland with the total control this Government has.