Leader’s replies to raised matters
The Leader responds to Senators’ various requests, giving no timetable for Seanad reform, promising to pursue debates on smoking in cars and the youth guarantee, and addressing employment, crime, insolvency, hospice parking, education and cancer concerns.
Senator Bacik spoke about Seanad reform and the expansion of the University seats to all third-level institutions. This is a matter that has been raised by several other Senators. As Leader of the House, I have no indication of when this Bill will be before us. I certainly have no indication that, as reported in the newspapers, it may be here before Christmas. I have no indication whatsoever in that regard. As I hear news on it, I will certainly inform the House.
Senators van Turnhout and Daly raised the issue of smoking in cars in which there are children. I wrote to the Minister for Health last week on that matter asking for a progress report. I indicated that it was said to me that there was some legal problem with one aspect of the Protection of Children's Health from Tobacco Smoke Bill 2012, and I asked the Minister to clarify that and let me know when the Bill would be taken. After 18 months or whatever - the Bill came before us in 2012 - it is most unacceptable that this short Bill could not have been dealt with and completed in the Seanad by now.
Comment on this
Senator van Turnhout also called for a debate on the youth guarantee. The Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Burton, will be here with us all afternoon. Prior to the debate, I will ask her when she can come in to debate that issue.
Senator Norris raised the need for reform of the vocational panels. That was the subject of a couple of Bills that were before the House before the Seanad referendum.
Until Senator Norris informed me of the fact, I was not aware that the Taoiseach had held meetings with the leaders in the Lower House in respect of these matters.
Comment on this
Such meetings may have taken place but I am not aware that they did.
Senator Conway and others referred to the unemployment figures and the fact that 1,200 jobs are being created each week. That is a wonderful improvement on the position which obtained up to two and a half years ago.
Comment on this
At that rate we will have solved the problem of unemployment in 30 years.
Comment on this
Prior to 2011, some 250,000 jobs were lost in a three-year period. However, everyone will acknowledge that there is a long way to go in respect of this matter.
Senator Leyden complimented the Garda on its efforts in combating crime and called for a review of the free legal aid scheme.
Senator Hayden referred to the first case involving the Insolvency Service of Ireland and requested a debate on the matter. A number of months will have to elapse before we can examine the position with regard to debating a progress report on this issue. It would be March or even later before such a debate could be held. I agree with the Senator's call for a debate on Traveller accommodation and the standards relating thereto. I will ask the Minister of State at the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government, Deputy Jan O'Sullivan, to come before the House to address that matter at the earliest possible opportunity.
Senator Cullinane called for a further debate on reform of the House. We have engaged in many debates on this issue and what is required now is action. One of the matters to which we should probably give consideration is people who raise matters on the Order of Business and who then do not have to courtesy to remain in the Chamber for a reply.
Comment on this
Either the House or I should be able to address that issue.
Senator Brennan referred to hospice services and volunteers who transport people to appointments. Those volunteers do wonderful work and it should be appreciated. The Senator called for concessions to be made in respect of car parking charges in hospitals. I do not know who has responsibility in this regard. It is probably a matter for the hospitals themselves. I agree with the Senator that hospitals should re-examine the position. Concessions should be made in respect of those volunteers who transport people to hospital appointments.
Senators Daly and Crown referred to cancer survival rates, a matter which was the subject of a report in a Sunday newspaper. I note Senator Crown's comments in that regard and his acknowledgement that cancer treatments have improved and that the number of consultants has increased. There is, however, a need for this issue to be reviewed on a continual basis, particularly in the context of the comments made in the newspaper report in question. That report did not make for pleasant reading.
Senators Daly and Walsh referred to the "Panorama" programme on the activities of some elements within the British forces in the past. What was shown in that programme was reprehensible, as was the murder and maiming of people on all sides. That which was detailed in the programme was dreadful. I note Senator Walsh's comments on collusion between the British Army and loyalist paramilitaries in the zone to which he referred. The Government has exerted pressure in respect of this matter. There is a need for the British Government to provide the necessary information in order to give the families of the victims some closure in respect of the dreadful activities which took place at that point in our history.
Senator Mullins referred to the situation relating to the ESB and the unions. The threatened dispute is unnecessary, particularly as, according to the Pensions Board, the ESB pension scheme is fully funded up to 2018.
A couple of hundred million euro was injected in the company and its pension fund a couple of years ago. A funding plan must be agreed to restore the ESB to financial health. The House will debate the Social Welfare and Pensions (No. 2) Bill when the Order of Business concludes. Every second pension fund is in trouble. The pensions and jobs of workers in the ESB are not under threat and pay cuts are not required. I hope that, arising from the meeting between management and unions later this week, this unnecessary action will not proceed. A strike would have devastating consequences for businesses, schools, primary health centres and everyone else. I appeal for calm and common sense to prevail. Senator Sean D. Barrett has also noted that while the country is moving in the right direction on jobs, it still has a considerable way to go in that regard.
Senator Paul Coghlan welcomed the decision of the European Investment Bank to endorse a proposal to provide a low interest loan for the construction of the Luas cross-city line. This is a major project and the EIB's decision is welcome.
Senator Marc MacSharry referred to the Health Service Executive's service plan and the waste of resources in the health service. I could not agree more with him. The case he has highlighted is appalling and should not have arisen. Such practices lack all common sense. I cannot agree to the amendment to the Order of Business to discuss a specific issue. The Senator may seek to have the matter discussed on the Adjournment. I hope the House will have an opportunity to debate the HSE service plan once it has been approved by the Government. The HSE has submitted its proposals for the Minister to examine.
Senator Catherine Noone also welcomed the success of the Government's initiatives on job creation.
Senator Fidelma Healy Eames called for a debate on changes to the junior certificate syllabus. I will ask the Minister to come before the House, although the matter was debated previously. Continuous assessment has been encouraged by many educational practitioners.
Comment on this
We debated the content of the syllabus, rather than the examination.
Comment on this
I have referred to the concerns raised by Senators Jim Walsh and John Crown.