We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Seanad independence and influence

Summary

Senator O’Donnell argues that Ministers must listen more seriously to Senators’ warnings, amendments and independent views.

I commend all those who stood for Parliament. What happens within the Labour Party and other parties in terms of changes in Ministries and elsewhere is not my call and I am not here to criticise. However, Ministers will in future have to take heed of what Senators are saying, particularly some of the Independent Senators who are fortunate enough not to be required to display abject loyalty, whether morally, intellectually, emotionally or politically, when it comes to decisions.

Comment on this

The Senator is not bad at it.

Comment on this

I know that one is either on a team or not on a team, and I completely agree with the Taoiseach in that regard. However, Ministers have come into this House and ignored warnings from Senators across all parties, Government and elsewhere. They have ignored disagreement expressed by Senators, as well as amendments, judgments and suggestions from Senators. Everybody in the House speaks about the one or two amendments we got through but what about the hundreds or thousands of amendments that were ignored? I have a feeling that since the Seanad was given a reform agenda by the Irish people we have been ignored even more.

I offer some examples of how we have been ignored across all parties. The respite grant for carers should never have been cut. The cuts to the funeral grant and the telephone grant should never have happened. The cutting of community workers' portfolios should not have happened. Upward-only rent reviews should never have happened. There has been a lack of attention to means testing as opposed to universality across medicine, education, health and social welfare. The Seanad has a great deal to offer across all parties and none. I would go so far as to suggest to the Government that some Senators should be considered as junior Ministers. I say this from the perspective of a politically independent Member.

Comment on this