We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business (Resumed)

Garth Brooks concerts and licensing

Summary

Senators debate whether Garth Brooks should perform the three concerts already licensed or all five, the economic consequences for Dublin, possible Government intervention and the need to complete licensing earlier.

The Garth Brooks fiasco has been well aired in the media but the reality is that permission has been given for three concerts and it is reasonable to expect Garth Brooks to perform the three concerts. People will be disappointed if he does not perform all five concerts. I believe permission should have been given for all five because many businesses in Dublin are struggling and such business would be welcome. The Government should intervene where possible to try to prevail on Mr. Brooks to perform the three concerts for which permission has been given. There might be a role for the Irish Ambassador in the United States to make an approach to support Peter Aiken, who I understand has travelled-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We cannot have a debate on the issue.

Comment on this

Hang on. I understand Mr. Aiken has travelled to the United States to use his influence to try to persuade Mr. Brooks to perform the three concerts.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Senator calling for a debate on this issue?

Comment on this

I ask the Leader to determine the approaches the Government could make to Garth Brooks and his management people in the United States to encourage him to perform the three concerts for which permission has been given.

Comment on this

The Senator should ring him.

Comment on this

A structure might then be put in place to allow him fulfil his other two engagements at a later date.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it part of the Seanad's remit to promote music promoters?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Conway is requesting information from the Leader. I call Senator Walsh.

Comment on this

Is it our place to promote musical promoters? Is that part of our raison d'être ?

Comment on this

We are trying to figure out what the Senator's raison d'être is first.

Comment on this

I concur fully with what Senator Noone said with regard to the licensing arrangements. It is an anomaly that tickets can be sold many months in advance of an event and that the determination of the licensing is done within weeks of the event taking place. That has led to a significant problem in this instance. Given what has happened in this instance I suggest that the licensing regime be examined so that it would be completed much earlier in the process and prior to the selling of tickets.

It struck me as odd but reflective of our undemocratic system of local government that one highly paid official makes these decisions and the elected members who went before the public a few months ago are sidelined regarding it. It begs the question of strengthening our democracy across the system, and in particular at local government level. The Minister came into this House many months ago and spoke about the new arrangements that would apply and the strengthening of local democracy but in its first test we see that it does not jump the fence, so to speak. Nothing has happened to improve the democratisation of politics.

There is a need for an appeals system to be in place within a structure such as this one where decisions are made. I urge the Leader to encourage Ministers to accept the legislation Fianna Fáil has brought forward in the Lower House, which would provide an appeals system in such instances that would allow these matters be dealt with.

For those concerned that two concerts might not take place, perhaps the Leader would consider inviting Mr. Brooks to come to this House. We could have an evening's entertainment with him on one of the evenings that he cannot sing at Croke Park.

Comment on this